Video transcripts, November 19, 2026
Video transcripts
76 of 76 videos with a full transcript
Why Retail Investors Are Divided Over Anthropic’s $1.4 Trillion IPO full transcript
0:00 I think that's a huge
0:01 misconception in modern time
0:04 where retail has all this
0:05 hype because they can get in
0:07 at IPO price, and are we
0:08 really getting someone
0:10 else's trash, or are we
0:11 getting treasure.
0:12 For me to hold a position
0:13 like that? The macro
0:15 conditions need to be
0:15 favorable and I see them
0:16 starting to worsen. So it's
0:18 not for me at this time.
0:19 But if you gave me half off
0:21 the IPO tomorrow, would I
0:22 take it? Probably.
0:23 I just drained my Roth IRA
0:25 account, and I'm taking out
0:26 money from my own Roth IRA
0:28 and taking $12K from my Roth
0:31 IRA to put into this
0:33 Anthropic stock. Because I
0:34 really see, as someone who's
0:36 in tech, that this
0:38 technology is going to
0:40 drastically improve over
0:41 time, and they're just
0:42 getting started.
0:43 I'm planning to eventually
0:45 buy Anthropic, just not at
0:46 the IPO price.
0:48 Anthropic, the company
0:49 behind Claude, is set to
0:50 go public with a possible
0:51 valuation of roughly $1.4
0:53 trillion, and its revenue
0:55 has been growing at an
0:56 incredible pace.
0:57 The company is giving
0:58 individual investors a
0:59 chance to get shares at the
1:01 IPO price. But there are
1:03 some very different opinions
1:04 about what those shares are
1:05 worth.
1:21 Anthropic could attract
1:23 roughly $250 million in net
1:25 retail buying on its first
1:26 day, according to Vanda
1:28 Research. That's more than
1:29 twice what it recorded for
1:30 SpaceX's IPO earlier this
1:32 year.
1:33 There's a good chance that
1:34 the demand for Anthropic
1:36 could be doubled that. So
1:37 that would be far and away
1:38 the largest amount of net
1:40 retail buying of any stock
1:42 that we've seen in our data
1:43 on the first day of its
1:44 listing.
1:45 Vanda says there's another
1:46 clue. Retail investors have
1:47 recently been selling stocks
1:49 like Micron and AMD,
1:50 which could mean they're
1:51 freeing up cash for the IPO.
1:53 Sources told CNBC's David
1:55 Faber that Anthropic will
1:56 likely price its shares
1:57 above its original target of
1:59 $70 to $78.
2:01 Up to 20% of the
2:02 offering could go to retail
2:03 investors. Dan Shetty,
2:05 a 27 year old AI product
2:06 lead, is excited about the
2:08 chance to get in alongside
2:09 some of the biggest names in
2:10 tech.
2:11 This Anthropic IPO isn't
2:13 just for Google and Nvidia
2:15 to invest in. It's for the
2:17 common man, common woman to
2:19 put some of their own money
2:20 and profit from this
2:21 AI boom as well.
2:23 But if the retail traders we
2:24 spoke with, Shetty was an
2:25 outlier.
2:26 There's also a fair amount
2:27 of investors that express
2:28 skepticism around the
2:29 financials, the size,
2:31 the valuation. Retail is a
2:32 much more disciplined group.
2:34 They're much more
2:34 systematic. They're much
2:35 more strategic, I think,
2:36 than a lot of investors give
2:37 them credit for.
2:44 At a potential $1.4 trillion
2:46 valuation, Anthropic is
2:47 asking investors to bet on
2:49 extraordinary growth.
2:50 Anthropic revenue has
2:51 exploded, going from $41
2:53 million in 2023 to $33.2
2:56 billion in the first nine
2:58 months of 2026.
3:00 By October 2026,
3:01 Anthropic was generating
3:03 revenue at a pace that would
3:04 bring in roughly $81 billion
3:06 a year. But the company has
3:08 also committed to spending
3:09 enormous amounts on
3:10 computing infrastructure in
3:11 the years ahead. That means
3:13 investors would pay roughly
3:14 $17 for every dollar
3:16 Anthropic is on track to
3:17 bring in annually,
3:18 and investors are
3:19 increasingly questioning if
3:20 that spending will actually
3:21 pay off.
3:22 A lot of it comes down to
3:23 scrutiny over how much money
3:24 they're spending on AI.
3:26 Investors want to see
3:27 that those investments are
3:28 turning into tangible
3:29 returns, into tangible
3:31 revenue.
3:31 Russ Faigen, who discusses
3:33 investing on social media
3:34 under the username "Invest
3:36 with Russ," is skeptical
3:37 about the IPO even though
3:39 he's an avid user of
3:40 Anthropic product.
3:41 I love Claude. Like, I use
3:43 Claude every day. I think
3:44 it's a great platform.
3:46 I would love to own some of
3:47 Anthropic. I just am not in
3:51 a rush to get in on day one
3:52 based off the valuation.
3:54 Joe Pak, a former macro
3:55 portfolio manager,
3:56 thinks there's a lot of
3:57 future growth already built
3:59 in to that price.
4:00 The risk that you have is
4:02 the financial conditions
4:03 deteriorating before you
4:04 start to grow into those
4:06 figures where it's
4:06 justified. For me,
4:07 it's about asymmetry.
4:09 And I think at the current
4:10 valuation, you don't really
4:11 have it.
4:22 The SpaceX IPO earlier this
4:23 year has become a reference
4:25 point for investors looking
4:26 at Anthropic.
4:27 And depending on who you
4:28 ask, it's either a reason to
4:29 buy or a reason to wait.
4:31 If you're looking at SpaceX,
4:33 which went public earlier
4:34 this year, you might think
4:34 to yourself, well, hey, if I
4:36 was excited for SpaceX at
4:38 this valuation doing this
4:39 much revenue, I should be
4:41 twice as excited for
4:42 Anthropic.
4:43 SpaceX set its price ahead
4:44 of the IPO at $135 a share,
4:47 and it opened at $150.
4:49 It briefly climbed above
4:50 $200, then fell below the
4:52 opening price a few weeks
4:53 later.
4:54 I started to get skeptical
4:55 in general of IPOs and what
4:58 we saw with SpaceX IPO.
5:00 Just the other month,
5:01 $135 a share was the
5:03 offering price, and then it
5:04 dipped 20% below that.
5:06 And considering how SpaceX
5:08 sits at the convergence of
5:09 all those technologies and
5:11 it still dipped below.
5:12 I'm not willing to
5:13 participate in like the
5:14 SpaceX IPO, but I'm more
5:16 willing to participate in,
5:18 like, the Anthropic IPO
5:20 because they're like very
5:21 safety first as a company.
5:22 What the SpaceX IPO did was
5:24 just shine a light on the
5:25 importance of getting retail
5:28 appetite into that listing.
5:30 And so this almost provides
5:31 a bit of a blueprint.
5:32 SpaceX shows how investors
5:33 experiences can vary
5:35 depending on when they buy
5:36 in. Through mid-November,
5:38 IPO investors saw positive
5:39 returns, outperforming those
5:41 who waited to buy at the
5:42 first traded price of $150.
5:51 That presents another
5:52 question for potential
5:53 investors: when is the
5:54 right time to get in?
5:55 On the one hand, they see an
5:56 opportunity. And on the
5:58 other hand, they see this
5:59 worry that they're going to
6:00 be the bag holder when the
6:01 bubble pops.
6:02 I think of my father who
6:03 invested in Microsoft during
6:05 the dotcom bubble.
6:07 He divested from that stock
6:09 and it was such a silly
6:10 thing to do. And I don't
6:11 want to tell my grandkids
6:13 that I didn't invest in
6:15 Anthropic, and I didn't
6:17 invest in OpenAI during
6:18 the AI bubble.
6:19 My audience members are
6:20 always in a rush to get in
6:22 on IPO day, and especially
6:24 now that retail investors
6:25 can request shares directly
6:27 through their brokerage, i
6:28 think the hype has gone,
6:29 you know, has gone tenfold.
6:31 However, in reality,
6:32 like if you look at the
6:33 numbers, it's almost never
6:34 beneficial to get in at IPO
6:36 price on IPO day.
6:38 But not everyone is rushing
6:39 to buy on day one.
6:40 Some retail investors are
6:42 hoping that patience could
6:43 pay off.
6:44 From my experience,
6:45 IPOs are a tricky,
6:47 tricky game. Plus, I think
6:48 there's going to be a lot of
6:49 lockup periods expiring
6:50 where early investors and
6:52 employees will cash out,
6:53 creating a good buying
6:55 opportunity and window.
6:56 I didn't get an allocation
6:59 to the Facebook IPO.
7:00 But I ended up buying it the
7:03 first day of open.
7:04 I got burned pretty quickly.
7:06 It's very difficult as a
7:08 retail investor to actually
7:10 get an allocation in these
7:11 blockbuster IPOs.
7:13 Often you get maybe one
7:14 share in the base case is
7:15 you don't get any at all.
7:17 So it's a bit of a catch 22.
7:18 If you do get a lot of
7:19 shares, it probably means
7:21 that the institutional bid
7:22 was weaker.
7:23 We're now in an environment
7:24 where actually the sector
7:25 has been beaten up quite a
7:27 lot for the last six weeks
7:28 or so. And so the general
7:30 sentiment is quite low.
7:32 I think we're starting to
7:33 see that closer scrutiny
7:35 from from retail and not
7:36 just in AI, but just
7:37 broadly speaking.
7:38 I would say that I'm leaning
7:40 towards patience, right?
7:42 Anthropic will be public for
7:43 a very long time.
Home Listings Soar Nothing's Selling 11/19/26 full transcript
0:00 With a CNBC Your Money Minute, I'm
0:02 Jessica Edinger. Home listings piled up
0:05 in October, but stubborn sellers aren't
0:08 really slashing prices.
0:10 >> We're seeing some price cuts, but if you
0:11 look at the national figures, we're
0:13 still up year over year.
0:14 >> That's CNBC's Diana Olick. Prices were
0:17 up. Sellers are trying to still get more
0:20 for their homes than the comps around
0:22 them. No seller wants to be the first in
0:24 the neighborhood to have their home go
0:25 for less.
0:26 >> The southern markets, the pandemic
0:28 driven markets where prices are now
0:30 coming down a bit, but nationally you're
0:32 still seeing prices higher year over
0:34 year.
0:34 >> Active inventory in October was up.
0:37 That's code for there were more homes on
0:39 the market in October than in the same
0:41 month last year. In fact, 7% more. But
0:44 that didn't matter because sellers were
0:45 still priced too high and pending home
0:48 sales plunged 16% last month. The group
0:53 that's balking the most at high home
0:55 prices, waiting it out till owners bring
0:57 them down,
0:59 first timers.
1:00 >> We're seeing a drop in the share of
1:01 first time buyers, you know, of course
1:03 they're the ones who struggle the most
1:05 on affordability.
1:05 >> And where you are seeing prices come
1:07 down a little, it's really not much when
1:09 there's so much uncertainty for would be
1:11 buyers.
1:12 >> You know, you're seeing these prices
1:13 come down a little bit, but not from the
1:15 heights that I mean, we're so much
1:16 higher than we were even four or five
1:18 years ago. And we always say, you know,
1:20 you buy the house, you date the rate. So
1:21 as you say, you refinance the mortgage,
1:23 but we're in a situation now where we
1:25 don't know a couple of years from now if
1:27 you're going to be able to refinance
1:28 into a better rate and whether that
1:29 house is going to be affordable for you.
1:31 We're already starting to see
1:32 delinquencies tick up.
1:33 >> Lots more on the housing market is at
1:35 cnbc.com and that's where you can sign
1:38 up for Diana's free Property Play
1:40 newsletter. I'm Jessica Edinger, CNBC.
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella: Cyber defenses and infrastructure upgrades are all at a premium now full transcript
0:00 We do seem to be at a time of an amazing
0:02 confluence. It's whether it be United,
0:04 the NSA, uh, Schwab, Chase, Apple
0:07 Services. Seems like that everyone's
0:08 kind of testing their systems and maybe
0:11 that's causing a problem. If you were
0:13 the ZAR of AI in this country, would you
0:15 say perhaps we need to avoid a national
0:17 meltdown? Yeah, it's sort of there are
0:19 two things that are happening. Um, first
0:21 is the patch velocity because the thing
0:24 that AI has done is is allowed us to
0:28 find these bugs and fix these bugs. But
0:31 that means you've got to then patch them
0:33 and that creates instability. And I
0:35 think a lot of the what you're seeing is
0:37 a little bit of maybe old infrastructure
0:40 with new patches and instability. The
0:42 other one that's also happening
0:43 simultaneously which I don't think has
0:45 yet hit us but we see a lot of the cyber
0:47 activity right. So now the floor for
0:51 anyone to be able to do nation scale
0:54 type of attacks has come down a lot
0:56 because you can just go send a telegram
0:58 message to one of these arch harnesses
1:00 somewhere and it keeps attacking. It's
1:03 persistent. So these two things
1:05 unfortunately means our cyber defenses
1:08 our infrastructure upgrades are all at a
1:10 premium. Well, I regard your company as
1:12 you said, ignite, I think it's you are
1:14 the the dial tone of the world. So when
1:19 something like what happened to my
1:21 outlook last week, how do you make sure
1:24 the dial tone never goes down?
1:26 >> Yeah. And and so first of all, we take,
1:28 you know, real uh that responsibility of
1:31 being dialed and even running an email
1:33 service for the world and it was a great
1:35 reminder for us last week. Um and so
1:37 therefore all of the architectural
1:39 learnings, the operational learnings are
1:42 the things that we're going to take from
1:43 that. And in fact, we just put out the
1:45 incident respon. It was one of those
1:46 crazy perfect storms where there was a
1:49 latent bug that got sort of found only
1:52 during a particular traffic pattern. And
1:54 of course, we should have, you know,
1:55 done the testing before. We should have
1:57 figured out how to have the bulkheads
1:59 such that you didn't have a global
2:00 outage and what have you. So therefore,
2:01 we're going to take all that, harden it,
2:03 but yes, ultimately we want to stand
2:05 behind offering that dial tone, and that
2:08 means we have work to do.
2:10 >> Don't miss a second of MadMoney. Follow
2:12 Jim Kramer on X. Have a question? Tweet
2:15 Kramer #madmentions.
2:18 Send Jim an email to [email protected]
2:21 or give us a call at 1800743cnbc.
2:25 Miss something? Head to
2:27 madmoney.cnbc.com.
Mad Money 11/18/26 full transcript
0:01 My mission is simple, to make you money.
0:04 I'm here to level the playing field for
0:06 all investors. There's always a bull
0:08 market somewhere, and I promise to help
0:10 you find it. Mad Money starts now.
0:17 Hey, I'm Kramer. Welcome to Mad Money.
0:19 Welcome to Cray America. Other people
0:23 make friends. I'm just trying to help
0:24 you make some money here. My job is not
0:26 to entertain, but to teach. So call me
0:29 at 1800743 CNBC or tweet me at Jim
0:33 Kramer.
0:34 You don't need to own Nvidia. Sure, the
0:38 interim CEO Klet Crest was brilliant on
0:40 Mad Money last night. The numbers
0:43 weren't good. They were fabulous.
0:46 But it doesn't matter because the market
0:48 like the tribe and survivor has voted
0:51 Nvidia off the portfolio island and it
0:54 ain't got nothing for you. On a mixed
0:56 day where the Dow fell 561 points,
0:59 estimate to climb 23% but the Nasdaq
1:02 managed to gain42%.
1:04 We saw what happens when the stock
1:06 market doesn't know what to do with its
1:08 one-time darling, the stock that was for
1:10 a while, a brief moment, the largest
1:13 company on earth. It begs explanation.
1:15 So we when that happens, what do you do?
1:17 You go metaphorical in order to
1:19 depersonalize a situation that is badly
1:22 and sadly need of depersonalizing.
1:26 Let's imagine a restaurant, something I
1:27 know about. I own two of them. The
1:29 comparison should make things more
1:31 digestible.
1:33 First, when you walk in, we place the
1:35 menu in front of you and you peruse it.
1:36 See what looks interesting. What pops?
1:38 After a bit, the waitress comes over and
1:40 while you are trying to decide, the
1:41 waitress always says, "Would you like to
1:43 hear the specials before you order?" He
1:45 doesn't want to hear the specials.
1:46 First, she tells you the chef has
1:48 something truly amazing tonight. The
1:50 largest initial public offering ever.
1:52 Anthropic. The waitress talks about how
1:54 it's going to be more than a trillion
1:56 dollar company. That it's the most
1:57 important artificial intelligence
1:58 company ever. The one that's pre has
2:01 hyperrowth. Can figure everything out
2:03 for you with its clawed product. Perhaps
2:05 the best growth since Microsoft. Maybe
2:06 better than that. The chef says it may
2:08 be the best dish ever. It's so
2:11 spectacular, she says. You may have to
2:12 put your order in and put it in now in
2:15 order to be sure to get some because
2:16 why? Cuz it's pit piping hot. It's
2:19 sizzling.
2:20 That sounds so exciting that you almost
2:22 can't resist. Almost. Almost though
2:24 because you've been coming to bar San
2:26 Miguel for a decade and you always order
2:28 the same thing. You love the Nvidia
2:30 here. It's the best semiconductor
2:32 option. The one that runs the super
2:33 intelligence efforts of our nation and
2:35 others. It's incredibly profitable with
2:37 amazing growth. A rare combination. You
2:40 wouldn't have Anthropic or Open AI for
2:42 that matter without Nvidia. So you tell
2:45 her, "Uhuh. I want the signature dish."
2:48 And with that dismissal, the waitress
2:50 calls over the manager. Now, the
2:52 manager's been busy seating people with
2:53 this whole time. Most of them glum
2:54 because a lot of patrons have been
2:56 losing money. Chips and salsa? No. Chips
2:59 and losses?
3:01 The manager hustles over and immediately
3:03 says before even saying, "Hi, have you
3:05 put in for your anthropic yet? You're
3:07 incredulous." Gez, you think maybe I
3:10 just go for the anthropic, but in that
3:12 split second before you commit, you ask
3:14 about your old friend Nvidia.
3:18 The manager size, looks down at his
3:21 shoes.
3:23 Then he says, "The Nvidia you love is
3:25 gone.
3:27 It was run by Jensen Wong, the founder
3:29 and perhaps one of the world's most
3:31 famous business people. Jensen built an
3:33 incredible business, but he has just
3:35 resigned from the company he built." But
3:37 you come back and say, "How much could
3:39 the dish have changed? Aren't the
3:41 ingredients the same?" The manager more
3:43 emphatically this time shakes his head
3:44 and says, "This company is nothing
3:46 without Jensen. He was the company. He
3:49 built it and he took it with him when he
3:51 resigned."
3:53 Why did he resign, you ask? The manager
3:55 says he resigned because the board of
3:57 directors hired a tough law firm that
3:58 didn't like he was carrying on with a
4:00 client who bought a lot of equipment and
4:02 was rumored to be a Chinese spy. Oh, and
4:04 he was also having an affair with his
4:06 vice president of healthcare. You're
4:07 confused, baffled.
4:09 Why does that matter? Isn't he supposed
4:11 to sell semiconductors? Sure, it's not
4:14 great that he was a sleepless
4:15 subordinate, but he was making so much
4:17 money for shareholders. THE CUSTOMERS
4:18 LOVE THEM. SO DO THE SUPPLIERS. HOW CAN
4:20 THE board of directors listen to a law
4:22 firm and get rid of a guy who's making
4:24 so much money and is loved by everyone,
4:26 a few more than others. Who do these
4:29 directors think they are? The manager is
4:31 already thinking about how to get the
4:32 next table to put in for anthropic. But
4:34 he's patient. He says, "Yes, it does
4:36 seem odd, the affair with the
4:37 subordinate." That can be explained
4:38 away. And so can the situation with the
4:40 woman in Singapore because she seemed to
4:41 have have a real business. And how was
4:43 he supposed to know she was a spy? Spies
4:44 don't let you know they're spies. Even
4:46 the president didn't know if she was a
4:48 spy. Well, then does he come back, you
4:51 ask? Yeah. The manager says he he he
4:54 he's honored to come back, but they also
4:57 have this interim CEO who's terrific,
4:59 and they're conducting a search for a
5:00 new CEO, possibly an outsider.
5:04 And you say, "That's ridiculous. He's
5:06 the best. He wants to come back." There
5:09 was no real investigation and the stock
5:11 will go up if he's reappointed. The
5:13 board's not doing its job. The company's
5:15 owned by the shareholders for heaven's
5:17 sakes. At that point, the manager's
5:18 patience has run out. He says he's got
5:20 to go. He has to get more people in
5:22 anthropic before the kitchen closes. But
5:24 as he departs, he says that the board
5:26 does have to consider things like things
5:28 like ethics, maybe in things like
5:31 national security, too. ARE YOU SHOUTING
5:33 HIM? THAT'S NONSENSE. THE BOARD DOESN'T
5:35 KNOW WHAT IT'S DOING. I BET HE COME BACK
5:36 TO RUN IT. I READ THAT HE APOLOGIZED
5:38 TWICE. JUST TAKE HIM BACK. GET THE DARN
5:41 STOCK UP. THAT'S THEIR JOB. THE waitress
5:43 looks down. Things have gotten awkward.
5:46 You sigh and you say, "All right, fine.
5:48 I'll take the anthropic, please." She
5:50 writes it down, walks away. Quickly
5:52 though, she comes back with a somewhat
5:54 pained expression. Unfortunately, she
5:57 says, "While we were talking, the price
5:58 of Enthropic has now gone up. It's
6:00 hotter than she thought."
6:03 The table table huddles. Hey, maybe we
6:06 have to sell some of our Target or TGX.
6:08 Both of those reported incredible
6:09 quarters are way up. Hey, maybe it's
6:10 time to let go of some Disney is finally
6:12 running. H how about some of those cyber
6:14 security companies? Maybe we got to hold
6:15 those. Let's just sell some healthcare.
6:17 It's getting slaughtered. Better take
6:18 the law. See you later. you, man. Get
6:20 some banks. Goodbye, Bank of America.
6:22 It's all very bewildering experience,
6:24 isn't it? But it is very much a real
6:27 life one. So, here's the bottom line.
6:29 People want a company with a permanent
6:31 CEO and they want Jensen Wong. They
6:33 don't care what the heck he did. They
6:35 don't want to wait for Colette Crest and
6:37 the board as they complete a search for
6:39 a new one. But if nothing's happening in
6:41 Nvidia and nothing seems to be
6:42 happening, all things being equal, they
6:45 would rather just get some Anthropic.
6:46 And if they don't get any, if Anthropic
6:49 is so hot that they can't have any for
6:50 dinner, well, you know what? They'll
6:52 take the fish tacos with some chips and
6:53 guac. And why not margie to drown our
6:55 Jensen sorrows?
6:58 >> Joseph in New York. Joseph.
7:02 >> Hey Jim, I've been watching Met Money
7:04 since I was 6 years old with my dad and
7:06 I really appreciate all that I've
7:07 learned from your show over the past
7:08 decade and a half. My question was six
7:11 years old. All right, but it's got it's
7:13 like a farm wine. Go ahead.
7:16 Yeah, it's so I've been watching you a
7:18 long time now, man. My question to you
7:20 today is do you think Shake Shack is a
7:22 good stock to hold until I retire in 35
7:24 years?
7:24 >> Really interesting question. I'm glad
7:26 you asked it. We got cross disciplines
7:27 here. It tells us 60 times earnings, but
7:28 we really like to work with Rob Lynch. I
7:30 have to say that there's so many
7:31 restaurant stocks are doing right now.
7:32 I'm going to say take him past some
7:34 shake shacks. I actually think you can
7:35 go back to Brinker even even up here and
7:38 Texas because prices are finally coming
7:40 down. It's going to work. Okay, listen.
7:42 So man money tonight. Not only is
7:43 Microsoft one of the world's most
7:44 valuable companies is one of the most
7:46 important ones too. So I'm going to sit
7:47 down with the CEO to hear about the
7:48 latest out allergies, whether you should
7:50 panic, the data center buildout and
7:52 more. Then Palo Alto Network is on the
7:54 move after reporting earnings. I'm dig
7:56 into the quarter with the CEO. I like
7:57 that acquisition too. Of course, all
7:58 your calls rapid fire in tonight's
8:00 edition of the lightning round. So stay
8:02 with Kramer.
8:14 Don't miss a second of MadMoney. Follow
8:17 Jim Kramer on X. Have a question? Tweet
8:19 Kramer #madmentions.
8:22 Send Jim an email to [email protected]
8:25 or give us a call at 1800743cnbc.
8:30 Miss something? Head to
8:31 madmoney.cnbc.com.
8:46 After a tough start to the year, the
8:48 stock of Microsoft, Big Chust Holding,
8:51 is now up over 20% the past 6 months.
8:54 And when the company reported late
8:56 October, we got to see how it is still
8:58 growing. Take its Azure cloud business,
9:00 which jumped a staggering 48% to $33.2 2
9:04 billion. Now, yesterday's Ignite
9:07 conference, Microsoft made the case that
9:09 co-pilot is where we'll all get our work
9:12 done. And of course, last Thursday's
9:14 Outlook outage was a reminder of how
9:16 much we already rely on Microsoft.
9:18 Earlier today, we sat down with Suchin
9:19 Adele, Microsoft's chairman CEO, to find
9:21 out where this multi-rillion dollar
9:23 company, the dial tone of the economy,
9:26 is headed next. Take a look.
9:31 We do seem to be at a time of an amazing
9:33 confluence. It's whether it be United,
9:35 the NSA, uh, Schwab, Chase, Apple
9:38 Services. Seems like that everyone's
9:40 kind of testing their systems and maybe
9:42 that's causing a problem. If you were
9:44 the zar of AI in this country, would you
9:46 say perhaps we need to avoid a national
9:48 meltdown?
9:49 >> Yeah, it's sort of there are two things
9:50 that are happening. Um, first is the
9:53 patch velocity because the thing that AI
9:56 has done is is allowed us to find these
9:59 bugs and fix these bugs. But that means
10:03 you've got to then patch them and that
10:05 creates instability. And I think a lot
10:07 of the what you're seeing is a little
10:09 bit of maybe old infrastructure with new
10:11 patches and instability. The other one
10:13 that's also happening simultaneously
10:15 which I don't think has yet hit us but
10:17 we see a lot of the cyber activity
10:19 right. So now the floor for anyone to be
10:23 able to do nation scale type of attacks
10:26 has come down a lot because you can just
10:28 go send a telegram message to one of
10:30 these RTK harnesses somewhere and it
10:33 keeps attacking. It's persistent. So
10:35 these two things unfortunately means our
10:38 cyber defenses our infrastructure
10:40 upgrades are all at a premium. Well, I
10:42 regard your company as you said, ignite.
10:44 I think it's you are the the dial tone
10:48 of the world. So when something like
10:51 what happened to my outlook last week
10:53 happened, how do you make sure the dial
10:56 tone never goes down?
10:57 >> Yeah. And and so first of all, we take,
10:59 you know, real uh that responsibility of
11:02 being dialed and even running an email
11:04 service for the world and it was a great
11:06 reminder for us last week. Um and so
11:08 therefore all of the architectural
11:10 learnings, the operational learnings are
11:13 the things that we're going to take from
11:14 that. And in fact, we just put out the
11:16 incident report. It was one of those
11:17 crazy perfect storms where there was a
11:20 latent bug that got sort of found only
11:23 during a particular traffic pattern. And
11:25 of course, we should have, you know,
11:27 done the testing before. We should have
11:28 figured out how to have the bulkheads
11:30 such that you didn't have a global
11:31 outage and what have you. So therefore,
11:32 we're going to take all that, harden it,
11:34 but yes, ultimately we want to stand
11:36 behind offering that dial tone and that
11:39 means we have work to do.
11:40 >> But one of the things that I think is is
11:43 so admirable that you want to do is it
11:45 crossurposes with what people are
11:46 thinking happening. You want to keep the
11:48 human at the center of it all and I love
11:50 that attitude. It's so great and it's
11:52 clear. Okay, there's no there's no
11:55 there's dignity to it that I like. Uh
11:57 you want to make sure the products are
11:59 designed to amplify human intent. You
12:01 want to make sure that they don't
12:02 threaten or take us over. People feel
12:05 that they will take us over. How can we
12:08 get rid of how do how do we take that
12:09 out off the table? I think that it's the
12:13 design question of our times because I
12:15 feel that we won't have permission quite
12:18 frankly if we introduce technology that
12:22 takes human dignity and human agency. In
12:24 fact, the Pope's encyclical had it
12:26 right. Right. He kind of said that which
12:28 is you know if you don't want to have
12:30 technology that truly empowers and makes
12:33 sure that human agency is at the center
12:35 why would we want it as a society so and
12:38 by the way I'll give you a practical
12:39 example so take what happened in
12:40 software engineering right initially
12:42 when the coding agency started becoming
12:44 popular people were saying what happens
12:46 to software engineering guess what
12:47 software engineering is back in full
12:49 force with a level of abstraction a new
12:52 operating point we're not doing exactly
12:54 the same thing we did in the past we
12:56 have a new tool
12:57 Not a god, a new tool to use. So that
13:01 >> not a god,
13:01 >> not a god. A new tool to use to do
13:05 highly ambitious things. And I like that
13:07 which is I want human ambition, human
13:09 intent, and human agency to remain, but
13:11 we're building tools, not gods.
13:13 >> But we are told that they sometimes
13:15 they're not in alignment. You know,
13:17 you're not talking about having the
13:18 smartest kid in college or grad school.
13:21 You're talking about someone that people
13:23 think could be our our overlord.
13:25 >> Yeah. No. So one of the challenges of
13:28 these scaling laws see the way in fact
13:31 when I went and first met all the open
13:33 AI folks and said hey let's go bet on
13:36 this scaling laws the idea that you put
13:39 more compute and better data and better
13:41 algorithms and you're going to get
13:43 intelligence sort of was not unproven
13:45 it's an empirical law we talk about it
13:46 as if it's a law it's an empirical
13:48 result that's held true like the Moors
13:49 law
13:50 >> the unfortunate thing is the
13:52 capabilities are climbing and
13:55 exponentially But alignment is nowhere
13:57 to be found. Right? And the mechanistic
13:59 understanding of exactly how do these
14:01 things work is also not there. That's
14:04 why I believe one of the other things
14:06 you have to do simultaneously is build a
14:09 trust system outside of the intelligence
14:12 system. Right? You can't give authority
14:13 to the intelligence. You have to
14:15 separate that out. And so that's a lot
14:16 of what we did even at the conference
14:18 this week at Microsoft was to make sure
14:20 people understand how to architect these
14:23 systems such that you can use the
14:25 capability but at the same time treat it
14:27 essentially like insider risk and very
14:30 capable machines except you need the
14:33 trust system to be outside
14:34 >> and do you think that the 30 million
14:36 people who pay for co-pilot know that
14:38 they're in that world? I think it with
14:40 co-pilot in fact that's the beauty of it
14:42 right which is what we did is we said
14:44 first of all you have all the form
14:46 factors you have chat you have co-work
14:48 you have autopilot you have all the
14:50 models you want cloud you want open AI
14:52 or our own models you can route across
14:54 all of that you also then have this
14:56 trust infrastructure built in so that
14:59 you don't have to really you know we
15:02 separating out the authority uh from the
15:05 intelligence and that gives you the
15:06 peace of mind
15:07 >> okay now I'm trying to understand
15:08 something that seems counterintuitive.
15:10 Copilot has the it's the operating
15:12 system for work. Again, I like the
15:14 simplicity and elegance of the way you
15:16 speak and the way you think. I do worry
15:19 that it's a that you say that things now
15:21 can be plugged in. And I said, "Oo,
15:23 Salesforce can be plugged in. That's
15:25 terrific. I've I've used the product,
15:27 but then Salesforce stock goes down big
15:29 as if somehow a plugin is bad for for
15:32 one Salesforce and good for you." But
15:35 that's not true.
15:36 >> Yeah. So I think that I think the world
15:38 is trying to readjust
15:40 uh to what is an agentic sort of value
15:43 capture versus what was the thing that
15:45 was built for the human web for example
15:47 talking about Salesforce or Dynamics
15:49 it's it's interesting all my meeting
15:51 notes Jim are in one note right they're
15:54 all prepared I've like 30 years of my
15:56 life I would read them and prepare for
15:58 meetings now guess what my agents are
16:01 using my one notes to prepare for me and
16:04 they are talking to whether it's CR RM
16:06 from Salesforce or Dynamics more so than
16:09 I ever used a CRM system. So these
16:11 headless CRM systems I think are going
16:14 to be terrific and they're going to be
16:15 the most useful back back office or you
16:18 know system of record that these agents
16:21 will use. So the consumption will go up
16:23 and people will have to have new
16:24 business models. So for example in
16:26 dynamics now a lot of our business is
16:28 not about seats, it's usage,
16:30 >> right? But that says to me we have to
16:33 have a we don't want a razor. We don't
16:36 want to make it so that that people
16:38 they're one side of it or they get cut.
16:40 I mean for just you have done layoffs
16:42 but when I hear what you describe I say
16:44 I need more people because if each
16:46 person can have a thousand agents my my
16:48 company is going to be lean and big are
16:52 the people who get laid off not part of
16:54 the equation. Why is the table of
16:57 employment wrong for that kind of
16:58 agentic world?
16:59 >> Yeah. No, I think we have to have one of
17:02 the hard things that all companies have
17:04 to do is reconfigure how work workflow
17:09 and the work artifact. Right? So if you
17:10 think about a news AI first startup, how
17:13 does it look? The founder is there, the
17:15 founder has a token budget, then they
17:17 hire the next employee, that employee
17:20 has a token budget, they pull the token
17:21 budget and then hire an employee and
17:23 then it's constructionist all the way.
17:26 >> Guess what? An incumbent like us, we are
17:28 going to look the same way, which is we
17:30 will have to go from what was the
17:32 original team size to different sizes
17:35 with token budgets and do more. So we
17:38 have to turn our strength in human
17:42 capital into scale benefits with really
17:46 the same level of token consumption that
17:48 even an AI native startup is. And that
17:50 process is not linear like all change.
17:53 It's not easy. It's not instantaneous,
17:56 but it has to be done.
17:57 >> So, it's done on the fly and at the same
17:59 time, you have to take Azure, which I
18:03 remember I saw you many, many years ago
18:04 and you told me it could be an $18
18:06 billion business. I was cru I was cruel.
18:09 I said, "Yeah, okay, that's very funny.
18:12 How big is Asher and how fast is it
18:13 growing?"
18:14 >> Yeah. I mean, we crossed I mean, believe
18:15 it or not, we've crossed a hundred
18:16 billion dollars.
18:17 >> Billion and I I doubted you at 18, which
18:20 really shows you how how much foresight
18:22 I have. 100 billion. And this the pace
18:24 of this growth is extraordinary.
18:26 >> Yeah. In fact, if you think about it,
18:27 right, we were a big player in the
18:29 server business.
18:30 >> Sure.
18:30 >> And rightfully so, people were skeptical
18:32 that hey, you're you know, will you ever
18:35 make any first of all, will you have
18:36 traction in the cloud and will you ever
18:38 make any money because you had 98% gross
18:41 margin and high share in server and this
18:43 is going to the cloud and what's going
18:44 to happen?
18:45 >> The biggest thing that I've learned from
18:47 that is the TAM, right? Most people
18:49 think of everything being so zero sum
18:52 and what have you except
18:53 >> you know in digital technology the more
18:55 the determinant of long-term prospects
18:58 are is the total addressable market
19:00 bigger like you know we kind of had a
19:02 server called link before which we sold
19:05 to a few people except teams is a
19:07 subscription that everybody who has
19:09 office has right right so that ability
19:12 and the same thing is going to happen
19:13 again Jim with agents I mean I think
19:15 about it right GitHub is a great example
19:18 right Yeah, there was you know software
19:20 devel I mean if I look at the number of
19:22 all these coding agents where are they
19:24 showing up they're showing up on GitHub
19:25 and it's exploding and of course we now
19:27 have that means we have to rebuild Azure
19:29 and which we are for the agent era as
19:31 opposed to the human web era
19:33 >> well as we know how co-pilot's doing
19:35 GitHub very exciting product really
19:36 terrific in the last quarter Azure but
19:38 we've got so much more to talk about
19:40 with Sergeant Nadella Microsoft chairman
19:42 CEO after the break
19:45 >> stick around Kramer's tackling
19:47 Microsoft's place in the AI ecosystem
19:50 with the company's CEO. Next
20:06 for the break, I showed you part one of
20:08 my interview with Microsoft chairman CEO
20:10 Saja Nadella. But there was much more we
20:13 had to get to. Take a look.
20:17 S I'm reading this book and I'm reading
20:19 it because of you and it's excellent. I
20:21 read Lords of Finance before that. But
20:23 this is about the Rothschilds. Actually,
20:25 it's about it's about Jay Cook who's
20:26 from Philadelphia. But we spent way too
20:28 much money back then and we lost
20:30 fortunes and everyone looks back and
20:32 says why did we ever let that railroad
20:34 boom bust happen? Do we have a data
20:37 center boom bust right now?
20:40 >> Yeah. So, it's a fascinating book. It's
20:43 good and it's got a lot of parallels. I
20:45 mean I think you know whether it is this
20:47 Leakut's book or even Corleta Perez's
20:50 book and I think all of these I think
20:53 point to fundamentally Jim at least my
20:56 lesson learned is you have frontier
21:00 let's call it infrastructure at some
21:02 point just becomes infrastructure
21:04 >> so the question is you know how do you
21:08 really play both parts of it right one
21:10 the economic sort of lesson for me is
21:13 you got to be careful when the
21:14 infrastructure is being built out as the
21:16 frontier where there is everybody's
21:18 rushing and so that classic mistake is
21:20 overbuild or railroads to nowhere in the
21:23 Pacific Northwest I think he was
21:24 building or that all happens but the
21:28 interesting thing is what happens after
21:29 the infrastructure gets built out this
21:31 happened with the fiber in the dot it
21:33 happened in railroads I think same thing
21:35 will happen with AI so when I think
21:37 about the GDP of the world I am so
21:40 positive about the world's GDP because
21:42 of all this infrastructure we are going
21:44 to have an economic boom. uh there may
21:47 be sort of some turbulence in between
21:50 but there is going to be GDP growth
21:52 that's broad and that will mean new
21:53 industries like the railroads made CPG
21:56 possible made retail possible made
21:58 manufacturing as we know possible so
22:00 >> and that can be this big so that's why
22:02 we have money in anthropic have that big
22:04 open AI investment these are these are
22:07 chits in a game that you think could be
22:09 very profitable
22:10 >> actually more so I am sort of thinking
22:12 all of this whether it's the models or
22:14 the hyperscalers we're just the
22:16 infrastructure and we have to sort of do
22:17 it in a smart way and at the end the
22:19 limit all the prices for this is just
22:21 going to be compute right and I hope
22:24 they make a two-way market in it they're
22:25 talking about it
22:26 >> so let's say we the railroads
22:28 >> but the point is what real economic
22:30 value is getting created on top that is
22:33 economywide right so when one of the my
22:35 framings Jim is people talk about the
22:37 frontier uh model I like to talk about
22:39 the frontier economy I want the United
22:42 States to have a frontier economy that's
22:45 growing going a minute real GDP growth 5
22:47 7 10%. Which is broadspread right when
22:51 that happens then the citizens of this
22:53 country will benefit the communities
22:56 will benefit we will have the political
22:58 economy permission to build more unless
23:01 we create that virtuous cycle. This is
23:03 really does feel like a rail railroad to
23:06 nowhere.
23:07 >> But at the same time you know who taught
23:08 me that same view was Jensen mom.
23:10 >> Yeah. uh you know he wants to come back
23:14 but there are structures correct I mean
23:16 you can't just say you resign and come
23:18 back if there are issues that a board
23:20 says uh-uh
23:22 >> well I mean Jensen let's face it was a
23:24 singular founder I mean he's been there
23:28 and uh and he just he did a fantastic
23:30 job building a great company and by the
23:32 way I you know I know Colette she worked
23:34 at Microsoft for a long time she's a
23:36 terrific person Ian Bach Nick Parker who
23:39 worked with us there to my So we are all
23:42 fantastic people at Nvidia and we are
23:44 very thrilled to be partnering with the
23:46 company Jensen built with the people
23:48 that were at Nvidia and then of course
23:50 it's the Nvidia board will decide what
23:52 happens next.
23:53 >> Now uh I don't have a lot of favorite
23:55 CFOs. You mentioned one Klette then
23:58 there's another one Amy Hood I've known
24:00 for many many years. I was cheering on
24:02 the last conference call because I have
24:04 a huge position in Microsoft my travel
24:05 trust for many many years cheering that
24:08 she talked about staying within the
24:10 operating cash flow that you have free
24:12 cash flow but then some wag said to me
24:14 no Jim you see they had some projects
24:16 delayed she would have gone over she
24:18 would have been like everybody else
24:20 that's not true though is it
24:21 >> no so what Amy and I are trying to make
24:25 sure that we do two things one is we
24:28 recognize the secular nature of this
24:31 trend. So therefore, we're going to
24:32 invest. We're going to invest on what is
24:34 the long lead aspects of it, right?
24:36 Building out, getting the land, getting
24:38 the power, in fact, building the cold
24:40 shells. Then the second part is we want
24:43 to also make sure we match demand,
24:45 right? You don't want the shortterm
24:47 stuff like chips.
24:49 >> You want to match demand better and even
24:51 there match even the diversity of a
24:54 business, right? Just selling to one or
24:55 two customers is not a business in my
24:57 opinion. Now hypers scale
24:58 >> I know you said that that's a very good
25:00 point because some do
25:01 >> and and it may be good for them right so
25:03 for Microsoft right which is we are a
25:06 hyperscaler that is really about serving
25:08 the longtail infrastructure business and
25:11 having an application business so
25:12 therefore I want us to be patient uh I
25:15 want us to be long-term and also be
25:18 smart about matching demand and supply
25:20 where we can versus sort of
25:21 secondguessing the secular trend the
25:23 secular trend is clear
25:24 >> but is that why you're willing to use
25:26 the so-called neocclass allows for for a
25:29 let's say a a minority of your business
25:31 but still a great deal because they
25:33 charge a lot they charge 30% more than
25:36 if you build your own comfortable with
25:37 them but what happened was we were short
25:39 supply right so in order to match demand
25:42 we had to go procure right you know we
25:44 build we lease we rent all three will
25:47 always be options but we start that
25:49 route right which is we build for the
25:50 long term we lease and then we rent
25:53 >> all right so let's talk about this big
25:54 blue wave it isn't it possible possible
25:58 to make the data center be the best
26:00 friend of a town that is bereft a town
26:02 that I I have a house that's 10 minutes
26:05 I'm not going to mention town because I
26:06 feel so bad about it but it lost its
26:08 employer big one and the town has big
26:10 trouble much bigger than any individuals
26:13 can handle and I keep telling people if
26:15 we only had a data center and people
26:17 keep telling me you don't know how evil
26:19 they are but aren't they the solution
26:21 for some towns that would not otherwise
26:23 come back
26:24 >> it's a great point you make see I think
26:26 the thing that we have to do is we have
26:29 to win the hearts and minds and the
26:31 votes one community at a time. At the
26:33 end of the day, it's not about even a
26:35 narrative that I can tell you, but it is
26:37 about the reality that communities feel.
26:40 The best example, in fact, I would love
26:42 for you to come visit this place,
26:44 Quincy, Washington, because the place we
26:46 had, this is the place where we now have
26:48 the best town.
26:49 >> Yeah. This is a place in Washington
26:50 where we've been operating a data center
26:52 for 20 years. So, it's good longitudinal
26:55 data.
26:56 >> Okay.
26:56 >> Right. where the property taxes have
26:58 gone down, right? The uh the uh overall
27:02 tax benefits that have come in have all
27:05 gone to building a new school, a new
27:07 city center, lots of the facilities that
27:10 this, you know, the people in the
27:11 community love. Uh and that t and oh, by
27:14 the way, the wages, the average wages of
27:16 the people who are employed there is
27:17 what twice the what was the wage average
27:19 wage before. So, we've created long-term
27:21 employment. Most people think, oh, these
27:23 are transitory jobs. They're
27:24 >> right. People say once it's open they're
27:26 gone. Like there's a
27:27 >> way a data center never stops building.
27:28 You're continuously refurbishing, re
27:31 modernizing, building and what have you.
27:32 And so I feel that more of this
27:35 longitudinal data being understood by at
27:38 a local community level and more
27:39 importantly we celebrated 20 years in
27:41 the community and the community
27:43 celebrated with us. This is a story that
27:46 look the government no longer has the
27:49 money to do this and we have to
27:51 recognize that and there's nothing
27:53 between the government and private
27:55 enterprise that's going to take its part
27:57 but private enterprise has to be
27:59 responsible
27:59 >> 100% right and that's why I think even
28:01 our commitments right whether it's not
28:03 making sure that we're not increasing uh
28:05 the electricity prices on the community
28:07 if anything it should go down right the
28:09 water consumption our training our
28:11 employment guarantees these are the
28:13 things that you have to do and and again
28:16 they just can't be just things I say
28:18 they have to be felt and that's where we
28:19 have a good example of it.
28:21 >> Okay. Now, one of the things I've done
28:22 right in my life, I like to think I've
28:24 done some things, is I brought in uh
28:26 Microsoft the Goldman Sachs for the IPO
28:28 and it was a good it was one of these
28:30 deals that was done incredibly right.
28:32 Advice to people who want to participate
28:35 say in an anthropic or want to deliver
28:37 the anthropic deal to the public or open
28:40 AI because there's a right way and a
28:41 wrong way and it can't be just let's see
28:44 what happens. Well, I mean as an
28:47 investor whether you would invest or
28:49 like I think that I think as an
28:50 individual investor if you are a
28:53 believer that in the long run AI is
28:56 something that's going to create
28:58 broadspread economic growth you can go
29:00 long on it and then individual firms I
29:03 leave it up to your investor that's what
29:04 I be telling people if it let's say it's
29:06 at 100 you might look back 10 years from
29:08 now and if you bought it at 120 uh you
29:11 won't tell the difference between 100
29:13 and 120 it looks like this but then it
29:14 looks like this. I think you're very
29:16 very right.
29:17 >> And you can always buy MSFD.
29:19 >> Yes, you can. Why not? I think these are
29:21 great companies. But the stock that I
29:22 have the most in my chap has is yours.
29:26 Satcha Nadella, Microsoft chairman CEO.
29:28 Thank you sir so much.
29:30 Coming up with Americans on edge about
29:32 tech glitches. Kramer's investigating
29:34 the risks with the top brass of PaloAlto
29:37 Networks. Next,
29:47 >> today amid the ongoing and scary
29:49 concerns about rolling outages and tech
29:51 disruptions, the cyber security stocks
29:53 were among the biggest winners. That
29:55 includes Kramer fave and travel trust
29:56 holding Palo Alto Networks, which was
29:58 the second best stock in the SP 500
30:00 today, 10% gain. After the close, the
30:03 good news kept coming as Palo Alto
30:05 turned in its latest quarterly earnings
30:06 report. blew away the consensus numbers.
30:08 Company also announced an acquisition
30:10 $4.5 billion all stock deal to acquire
30:13 applied compute. That's a private
30:14 company that specializes in post
30:16 training and inference of open weight
30:18 models. Don't worry, we will go over
30:19 what that means. And now here to discuss
30:21 all this is Nesh Aurora, the chairman
30:23 CEO of PaloAlto Networks. Mr. Roer,
30:25 welcome back to Mad Money.
30:27 >> Nice to see you again, Jim.
30:29 >> Okay, so Nikesh, I went over this
30:31 report. I did not see a line from the
30:32 report that I didn't like and some of
30:34 your most important ones like next
30:36 generation uh recurring revenue well
30:38 ahead of expectations. Give us some of
30:40 the highlights because there are many to
30:42 choose from.
30:44 >> Look Jim, what has happened is that the
30:46 mythos moment about 6 months ago has
30:48 become an inflection point for cyber
30:50 security. You've seen even the last two
30:52 weeks that we've seen all these outages.
30:54 We've seen some AI assisted cyber
30:56 attacks. So the pace of cyber activity
30:58 is only going to increase. And what
31:00 customers are realizing this moment is
31:01 that this approach that they had of
31:03 spray and prey is not going to work.
31:05 They're going to have to go consolidate
31:07 into platforms. They're going to have to
31:08 make sure they get the best players in
31:10 the market to come support them because
31:12 this is no longer child's play. And
31:13 we're seeing that across the sort of
31:16 portfolio and space. We saw phenomenal
31:19 growth in our firewall business,
31:20 hardware and software. We saw amazing
31:22 growth in our sassy business. Our eye
31:24 security business is off the charts. Our
31:26 automated SIM AI sock business is off
31:28 the charts. Our identity business is
31:30 driven by age mostly observability grew
31:32 4x in the quarter. So across the board
31:35 literally everything is working well and
31:38 it's really an execution issue and ask
31:40 do we have the capacity to execute as
31:43 fast our customers want us
31:44 >> and I think that I saw the cyber arc
31:46 deal it looks like that you have
31:48 extended that so many people take the
31:51 whole platform once they get in and take
31:52 cyber arc.
31:54 Now Jim, I'm really proud of the Palato
31:56 team for what we did with Cyber Arc and
31:59 the Cyber Arc team because we closed
32:01 this deal in February of last of this
32:03 year this year and we're just in
32:05 November. In that time period, we've
32:07 been able to integrate them, rebrand
32:09 them, accelerate the pace of innovation,
32:11 and we start to cross-ell across the
32:13 platform between Palo Alto and them. Not
32:14 just that, you know, we took a margin
32:16 dip in February. We're back to record
32:18 margins and we've been able to take
32:20 their business and literally almost get
32:22 close to doubling their margins in the
32:23 last six months. really really excited
32:25 about what we were able to achieve with
32:26 that team.
32:26 >> And you have to be excited about this
32:27 acquisition tonight. Applied compute
32:29 which to me I want you maybe you can
32:31 help explain but this is potentially
32:34 three what $3 billion in a couple of
32:36 years.
32:39 >> Well Jim this is 40 chess. Jim, look, if
32:42 you think about where AI is going, I
32:44 have come to the conclusion that we
32:46 cannot observe AI from the outside and
32:49 provide our comfort, the trust and
32:52 security capabilities around AI from the
32:54 outside in. It's just very hard. As
32:56 you've heard, models have rogue agents.
32:58 Rogue agents start misbehaving
33:00 mid-flight. It's very hard to understand
33:02 what the agents are doing if you're not
33:03 in that infrastructure. Now the only way
33:05 you get in that infrastructure is when
33:07 you're training AI, you got to make sure
33:08 you're training security AI at the same
33:10 time. So we're hoping that with the
33:12 applied compute acquisition, what these
33:14 people do is they help train openweight
33:16 open source models for enterprises. We
33:18 want to be able to train security at the
33:19 same time. So when your when your
33:22 application is working and if it starts
33:23 to misbehave, we already know what good
33:25 behavior should look like. So we're able
33:27 to stop bad behavior mid-flight. If you
33:29 do it afterward, it's not going to work.
33:31 >> That's amazing. That's amazing. and this
33:34 proven technology, right? I mean, every
33:35 you've obviously tested it. It's been
33:37 the company's been in business. You've
33:38 seen it in action.
33:40 >> So, Jim, we started to look for a
33:43 company that would train our models
33:45 because we decided we need cyber models
33:46 which are frontier LM capability models,
33:48 but we need openweight models because I
33:50 want to be able to look into them.
33:51 Closed models don't allow you to look
33:52 into their chain of thought. I want to
33:54 look into them. And when we looked at
33:56 the landscape, there were many companies
33:57 looked at and this was the best team we
33:59 found. Our research is obviously from
34:01 OpenAI and Tropic and other places where
34:03 they've got together and they were
34:04 providing elite service to companies
34:06 like ours to help us get frontier LLM
34:08 like capability. We said wow can you do
34:11 this for us and said hey why don't you
34:12 come work with us and that one thing led
34:13 to another they said yes we see the
34:15 vision we see what this needs to be and
34:17 rather being one player out of 10 in the
34:20 industry serving compute we want to be
34:22 the one player with Palo Alto that
34:23 delivers secure comput and security
34:25 capabilities. Well, let me ask you
34:26 question. I mean, tonight though, this
34:27 is a company that's going to raise $200
34:29 billion an uh Anthropic. It's a fabulous
34:32 company. You and I both know that
34:33 they've got so much cash in their
34:34 balance sheet. Why didn't they uh buy
34:38 applied comput?
34:41 >> That's a great question for them, but
34:43 they already have a closed model which
34:46 uh they have uh extreme success in. I
34:49 think what we're trying to do is we're
34:51 trying to serve the enterprise use cases
34:52 where enterprises want a little more
34:54 control on the model that they deploy
34:56 internally when they want to put their
34:58 own proprietary data. They want to do
35:00 cancer research. They want to do
35:01 logistics. They want to be able to
35:02 control the environment, the domain, the
35:05 model and they want it to be secure and
35:07 know the enterprises are about getting
35:09 edge cases right.
35:10 >> So what's the total addressable market?
35:12 What's the total addressable market
35:13 there?
35:14 >> It's huge Jim. I think there's be
35:16 hundreds of billions of dollars of
35:17 openweight open source delivery that's
35:19 going to happen in the market. Every
35:20 NeoCloud that you see out there that's
35:22 building compute is getting ready to
35:24 serve open source openweight models. So
35:26 imagine those models have to be served.
35:28 We're going to be the ones training the
35:30 models. They're going to be the ones
35:31 serving the model.
35:32 >> Okay. So now I going to go to you
35:33 because you're a calm head in a
35:35 difficult time. Uh patch patchopalypse,
35:38 patch apocalypse, whatever you want to
35:40 call it. You know, people must come up
35:42 to you. People probably stop you in the
35:43 super never mind the supermarket. People
35:45 probably stop you uh while you're
35:47 playing tennis. I don't know. And they
35:48 say, "Listen, I'm panicking. I I got I'm
35:52 really worried. What do you say to these
35:53 people?" Because the the number of blue
35:56 chip companies and government agencies
35:58 that have been hit. No, no one thinks
36:00 it's a coincidence.
36:02 >> Well, Jim, actually what's happening is
36:04 there two things happening
36:05 simultaneously. One is, as you know, the
36:07 mythos like capability is now common
36:09 place. So you can get an open source,
36:10 you can point an open source model at
36:12 your company's infrastructure and it's
36:13 going to find vulnerabilities. And the
36:15 bad actors have figured this out. Uh we
36:17 just announced a piece of research where
36:19 a small group actually attacked 19
36:21 companies simultaneously because of
36:23 using AI which would have taken them a
36:24 lot more if they had they had a lot more
36:26 resources. So that capability has become
36:28 commonplace. You're seeing that
36:29 happening. That's kind of do that's
36:32 causing some of the outages but not all
36:33 of them. There's a second effect which
36:35 is happening which is interesting. We're
36:37 now discovering vulnerabilities at seven
36:39 times the pace that we used to one year
36:41 ago. Right? So you just every IT team is
36:45 delused with tons of vulnerabilities
36:47 that they have to patch. And it's not
36:49 just their problem. It's like every
36:50 vendor saying, "Hey, I found mine. Can
36:52 you patch my software?" They don't have
36:53 time to test. They're out there patching
36:55 and saying, "I don't want to be
36:56 breached." And that patching that
36:57 they're doing at rapid pace is causing
36:59 these outages because they are not sure
37:02 what the collateral damage of a patch is
37:04 because they didn't understand what the
37:05 patch was. So, they're going to have to
37:06 slow down. You cannot patch before you
37:08 test. This is going to go on for the
37:10 next 12 to 18 months, Jim.
37:11 Unfortunately, I don't have a panacea.
37:13 >> All right. Now, and how about uh the
37:14 agents that Anthropic tells me to be so
37:17 worried about as people frantically try
37:19 to get shares in the company.
37:22 Look, um I think agents are going to be
37:26 more prevalent in the consumer space
37:28 first than in the enterprise space
37:29 because enterprises are going to be very
37:31 careful about letting agents lose in the
37:33 enterprise because in the end all CEOs,
37:35 all enterprise management teams are
37:36 responsible for the actions of AI that
37:38 they deploy. We can't blame somebody
37:40 else. We can't say the dog ate my
37:42 homework or AI did it. It's not okay.
37:44 We're accountable to our boards, our
37:45 audit committee. So enterprise are going
37:47 going to do a careful job at deploying
37:49 agents. We will help them with applied
37:51 compute and security from Palo Alto. In
37:53 that context, I think you're going to
37:55 see a much more sort of prevalent usage
37:57 of agents in the consumer space as we've
37:59 already seen the likes of Muse, DOT,
38:01 Grock, etc. are going to have agents.
38:03 We're going to see it there.
38:05 >> Does anyone ever get caught who does
38:07 this stuff in the cash?
38:10 >> Sometimes they do. Sometimes they do.
38:12 You know there was uh a group in the UK
38:14 which was uh recently uh caught and
38:18 arrested because they were called
38:20 scattered spider and their expertise was
38:23 trying to hold people at ransom which is
38:24 generally not a good thing. Um and they
38:26 were caught but very often these are
38:28 nation spawn nation state sponsored
38:30 events which is very hard to go find
38:31 them where they originate from. Very
38:33 often they're in jurisdictions which are
38:34 hard to reach. Very often it's very hard
38:36 to trace where they came from. So there
38:38 are a lot of complexities involved in
38:39 trying to trace where these attacks
38:41 begin and who to hold accountable at
38:43 some point.
38:43 >> And last question I have be when I think
38:46 about what you're doing uh and what
38:49 you've accomplished. I remember when you
38:51 did platformization and people did not
38:53 they laughed. How else are you able to
38:56 do it but platformization?
38:59 >> Well Jim uh this is this quarter was a
39:03 resounding sort of endorsement of our
39:04 platformization strategy. We did 170 of
39:06 those which is the sum more than the sum
39:09 total of what we did in Q1 last year and
39:11 the year before. So clearly that's an
39:13 approach that's working.
39:14 >> Uh look people had never seen the idea
39:16 of platform. So they were they were
39:18 obviously skeptical. Now they realize
39:20 that you've got to go with a common
39:22 approach. You got to go with a single
39:23 vendor. So that's kind of working. I
39:25 think you're going to be talking about
39:26 this in three to five years with applied
39:27 compete with what we're doing.
39:28 >> Well, will you be there two to five
39:29 years or is it time for a brand new
39:31 challenge?
39:33 Jim, I'm having a great time at Palto
39:35 where there's tailwinds in cyber
39:36 security as you know.
39:37 >> All right, I'm going to leave it at
39:38 that. I think that makes sense. That's
39:39 Nikeshar, chairman CEO of Palo Alto
39:41 Networks after an unbelievable quarter
39:43 and amazing acquisition. Thank you,
39:45 Nikesh.
39:46 >> Thank you, Jim.
39:47 >> Money is back in the break.
39:51 >> Coming up, he's the fastest mind on Wall
39:53 Street, so we're putting him to the test
39:55 with your help. Bring on the lightning
39:58 round next.
40:20 It is time for the lightning round.
40:24 Bye bye bye.
40:26 my steps to grab some land sound and
40:29 then the lightning round is over. Are
40:31 you ready? Ski D. Let's go to Elliot in
40:34 Illinois. Elliot.
40:36 >> Booya. Jim, second time caller here. How
40:39 you doing?
40:40 >> I'm doing well, Elliot. How about you?
40:43 >> I am great. I think Peter Beck is a
40:45 great CEO and Neutron is a huge driver
40:48 of this stock. What do you think about
40:50 Rocket Lab, Chillman?
40:52 >> You know what I have to tell you? I look
40:53 I first of all I'm drawn to the rocket
40:55 business which means I like SpaceX but
40:57 you know what I would take this rocket
40:59 lab has gotten too cheap I to kept my
41:01 eye on it and I think you have a good
41:02 one. It's a spec. Let's go to Nathan in
41:05 my old home state of Pennsylvania.
41:06 Nathan,
41:08 >> hey Jim, it's been a while. Great to
41:10 catch up with you. Hey, this company
41:13 should almost change their name to uh
41:15 arm in the leg. That's how bad it's been
41:17 for investors. So assuming the CEO stays
41:20 on board and has got an alternative to
41:22 Nvidia, what do you make of the stock of
41:24 ARM Holdings?
41:25 >> Uh, it's Renee Hos. He's done an
41:27 unbelievable job if he can get extra
41:29 supply from Taiwan Semi. He is going to
41:31 blow the numbers away. So therefore,
41:33 it's worth owning. Let's go to Jim in
41:36 New York. Jim,
41:39 Jim, how are you?
41:40 >> A lot of you. What's going on?
41:42 >> Great. Uh, Amphanol AP time to buy or
41:47 time to It's a fiber fiber connection.
41:50 If you want fiber optic connection at
41:51 this point, just go by glowworm, which
41:53 is the technical name for GLW, which is
41:55 Corning Glass. It's better than Let's go
41:57 to Phil in Florida. Phil,
42:02 >> Jim Kramer, I'm a long time listener. I
42:05 just want to be entertained and maybe
42:06 make some money.
42:09 >> My stock has signed an 11.6 $6 billion
42:12 7-year contract with a possibility of
42:14 nine more billion with Antropic
42:17 Anthropic. Revenues may double in 2027
42:20 and may double again in 2028, although
42:23 they do have considerable debt. The CFO
42:26 Thomas Leon
42:28 uh purchased 30,000 shares at $2.5
42:31 million a week ago.
42:32 >> Dr. Thomas Leightton, that's a I think
42:34 the stock I could not believe the stock
42:36 has come down after we had him on the
42:38 show. I thought the stock was going to
42:39 rip to 120. You said it goes the other
42:41 way. It's up a lot today, but I would
42:43 still pull the trigger on AKAM.
42:46 Oldie but goody. Now, we're going to go
42:48 to to Rob in South Carolina. Rob,
42:52 >> hi Jim. My question uh concerning the
42:55 recent AI anxiety on Wall Street. I'm
42:58 looking to diversify to a company that
43:01 provides the materials for computer
43:03 chips to be read. Their client list is
43:06 Taiwan, Semi, Apple, Amazon, Intel. The
43:11 company is Quinty. The stock symbol is
43:14 Q. Just
43:16 >> this thing is vastly misunderstood. It
43:18 is the materials for all semis, not just
43:20 for data center for heaven's sake.
43:21 That's why it is a bye-bye buy and
43:23 that's why my travel trust owes it. And
43:25 I wish that we could buy more, but we
43:27 have a ton of it. And that, ladies and
43:29 gentlemen, THE CONCLUSION OF THE
43:31 LIGHTNING ROUND.
43:35 THE LIGHTNING Round is sponsored by
43:37 Charles Schwab.
43:41 >> I like to say there's always a bull
43:43 market somewhere and I promise try to
43:44 find it just for you right here on Mad
43:46 Monday. I'm Jim Kramer. See you
43:48 tomorrow.
43:51 >> All opinions expressed by Jim Kramer on
43:53 this podcast are solely Kramer's
43:54 opinions and do not reflect the opinions
43:56 of CNBC or its parent company or
43:57 affiliates and may have been previously
43:59 disseminated by Kramer on television,
44:00 radio, internet, or another medium. You
44:02 should not treat any opinion expressed
44:04 by Kramer as a specific inducement to
44:05 make a particular investment or follow a
44:07 particular strategy, but only as an
44:09 expression of his opinion. Kramer's
44:10 opinions are based upon information he
44:12 considers reliable, but neither CNBC nor
44:14 its affiliates or subsidiaries warrant
44:15 its completeness or accuracy, and it
44:17 should not be relied upon as such. To
44:19 view the full MadMoney disclaimer,
44:20 please visit cnbc.com/madmoney
44:22 disclaimer.
Elon Musk: No one can really replace Jensen Huang, 'don't think he is disloyal' to the U.S. full transcript
0:02 MYSELF INTO TROUBLE QUITE,
0:03 QUITE A LOT ON, ON X FORMERLY
0:06 KNOWN AS TWITTER AS, AS
0:07 EVERYONE KNOWS. SO, SO, BUT
0:10 YOU'RE NOT GOING TO FIND ME
0:11 SAYING ONE THING PUBLICLY AND
0:13 ANOTHER THING PRIVATELY. I SAY
0:14 THE SAME THING. SO, YOU KNOW,
0:16 JENSEN IS AN OLD FRIEND OF MINE.
0:18 I THINK HE'S I WOULD CALL
0:20 JENSEN LIKE, YOU KNOW, MICHAEL
0:23 JORDAN, PERHAPS AT HIS PEAK
0:25 LEVEL, YOU KNOW, IN TERMS OF
0:26 WHAT HE MEANS TO A TEAM. AND I
0:29 DO I DO THINK IT'S IT'S YOU GOT
0:33 TO THINK LONG AND HARD BEFORE
0:35 YOU TAKE SOMEONE LIKE, LIKE,
0:36 LET'S SAY A CHICAGO BULLS, YOU
0:38 KNOW, MIDDLE OF YOUR MIDDLE OF
0:39 YOUR SECOND SEASON AND YOU'VE
0:41 GOT, YOU'VE GOT A WINNING
0:42 STREAK THAT'S JUST GOING TO
0:44 HAPPEN. AND THEN YOU PICK
0:45 MICHAEL JORDAN OFF YOUR TEAM.
0:47 DOESN'T SEEM LIKE A SMART
0:48 DECISION TO ME. YOU KNOW, I
0:51 THINK WHEN YOU WHEN YOU THERE'S,
0:54 THERE'S NO ONE THAT CAN REALLY
0:55 REPLACE JENSEN. I MEAN, HE DOES
0:59 THE ROLES OF LIKE SEVERAL
1:00 PEOPLE. I MEAN, HE'S MANAGING
1:01 SUPPLY CHAIN. I MEAN, YOU SEE
1:03 HIM EATING, YOU KNOW, STREET
1:04 FOOD IN KOREA AND TAIWAN WITH
1:06 CRITICAL SUPPLIERS. HE HAS LONG
1:08 TERM RELATIONSHIPS THAT HAVE
1:09 BEEN BUILT UP OVER DECADES. HE
1:11 UNDERSTANDS HIS TECHNOLOGY
1:12 INCREDIBLY WELL. HIS TEAM LOVES
1:15 HIM, LOVES HIM. AND MANY OF
1:18 THEM ARE THERE BECAUSE OF HIM
1:20 AND HAVE HAD HIGHER OFFERS TO
1:22 GO ELSEWHERE AND HAVE TURNED
1:23 THEM DOWN BECAUSE OF PERSONAL
1:25 LOYALTY TO JENSEN.
1:28 >> SO DO YOU THINK THAT.
1:29 >> YOU REALLY THINK YOU NEED TO
1:31 THINK LONG AND HARD BEFORE
1:32 KICKING SOMEONE ELSE LIKE THAT
1:33 OUT, YOU KNOW, SO SOMEONE LIKE
1:35 THAT OUT, IT SEEMS. YOU KNOW, I,
1:40 AND I KNOW THAT THERE'S LIKE
1:42 BEEN, YOU KNOW, HE'S HE'S
1:43 CERTAINLY MADE SOME MISTAKES
1:45 HERE, BUT I DON'T THINK HE'S
1:49 DISLOYAL TO THE UNITED STATES.
1:51 AND, AND YOU KNOW, I JUST I'VE
1:54 BEEN CLEAR. I THINK IT'S LIKE,
1:56 IT'S LIKE MICHAEL JORDAN OF
1:57 YOUR TEAM WHEN YOU WHEN YOU'RE
2:00 ON A WINNING STREAK AND IT JUST
2:02 SEEMS, DOESN'T SEEM IT DOESN'T
2:04 SEEM LIKE, LIKE A GOOD THING
2:05 FOR SHAREHOLDERS AND, AND YOU,
2:09 AND YOU HAVE TO BALANCE THE
2:10 GOOD THAT SOMEONE DOES AND
2:11 BRINGS RELATIVE TO THE BAD, YOU
Elon Musk: Everyone I know thinks Jensen Huang should have stayed on as Nvidia CEO full transcript
0:00 MARTIN SCRIPT WHERE YOU'VE GOT
0:02 A MAJOR CHARACTER THAT YOU'RE
0:03 INVESTED IN AND SUDDENLY
0:04 THEY'RE THEY'RE GONE. IT'S,
0:08 IT'S QUITE SHOCKING.
0:10 >> DO YOU THINK LONG TERM THAT
0:13 HE WILL. I MEAN, DO YOU THINK
0:15 THAT HE. HAVE YOU SPOKEN TO HIM
0:16 ABOUT THIS PERSONALLY?
0:18 >> YES.
0:19 >> AND AND WHAT DID HE TELL YOU?
0:22 AND WHAT DO YOU WHAT DO YOU
0:24 THINK HAPPENS?
0:25 >> I DON'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENS
0:26 NEXT. OBVIOUSLY, THE THE
0:28 DECISION IS UP TO THE TESLA, UP
0:29 TO THE DECISION IS UP TO THE
0:31 NVIDIA BOARD, OF COURSE. AND
0:35 THEN PERHAPS, YOU KNOW, THE
0:38 NEXT LEVEL OF AUTHORITY ARE THE
0:40 SHAREHOLDERS. BUT THE
0:40 SHAREHOLDERS WOULD WOULD HAVE
0:42 TO YOU KNOW, I THINK LIKE THE
0:44 CURRENT BOARD WOULD EITHER NEED
0:45 TO CHANGE THEIR MIND OR
0:47 SHAREHOLDERS WOULD NEED TO VOTE
0:48 THE BOARD OUT AT THE
0:49 SHAREHOLDERS MEETING, WHICH IS
0:51 THE THAT'S THAT'S PRETTY RARE
0:52 FOR THAT TO HAPPEN. SO. BUT BUT
0:58 REALLY THE THE BOARD IS IN
1:00 CHARGE OF THE COMPANY RIGHT NOW.
1:01 SO THAT'S, YOU KNOW.
1:05 >> YOU'RE WITH THE PRESIDENT.
1:06 HAVE YOU TALKED TO HIM ABOUT IT?
1:08 >> WELL, I MEAN, I DON'T THINK
1:10 WE SHOULD MAKE THIS THE JENSEN
1:12 INTERVIEW. NO I KNOW YEAH. WELL,
1:15 I THINK THE PRESIDENT HAS
1:16 VOICED PUBLICLY THAT HE THINKS
1:20 JENSEN SHOULD HAVE STAYED AS
1:21 CEO. AND CERTAINLY
Elon Musk: If I could rewind the clock, I would have spent less money on U.S. midterms full transcript
0:01 SO BUT BUT THIS THIS IS THIS IS
0:03 A AT THE END OF THE DAY, THE
0:05 THE NVIDIA BOARD DECISION. SO
0:06 IT'S WE'RE NOT ON THE BOARD.
0:09 >> RIGHT. LET ME ASK YOU ABOUT
0:10 YOU. I WANT TO GET INTO ALL OF
0:12 YOUR COMPANIES AND SPACEX AND
0:15 TESLA AND EVERYTHING ELSE. BUT
0:16 WE DID SAY AT THE TOP OF THIS
0:20 THAT YOU WERE OBVIOUSLY
0:22 INVOLVED QUITE HEAVILY IN THE
0:24 POLITICS OF EVERYTHING IN THE
0:25 COUNTRY, IN TERMS OF SUPPORTING
0:28 REPUBLICANS IN THE MIDTERMS.
0:29 THEY LOST. AND I JUST WANTED TO
0:31 GET YOUR REACTION TO TO THAT
0:34 LOSS AND WHAT YOU THINK THE
0:37 IMPACT WILL BE ON THE COUNTRY,
0:39 WHAT YOU THINK THE IMPACT WILL
0:41 BE ON YOUR BUSINESSES? WE NOW
0:43 HAVE A BLUE GOVERNOR IN TEXAS,
0:46 WHICH IS A FIRST IN A VERY LONG
0:48 TIME. WHAT DO YOU THINK?
0:51 >> WELL, I THINK FIRST OF ALL,
0:53 THE NEW GOVERNOR ACTUALLY, I
0:54 THINK IS, IS GOING TO BE A
0:58 QUITE MODERATE, I THINK I DON'T
0:59 THINK SHE'S SORT OF A FAR LEFT
1:01 GOVERNOR, AND AND BASED ON
1:06 EVERYTHING I'VE HEARD ABOUT HER,
1:07 I THINK I THINK THINGS WILL BE
1:09 FINE IN TEXAS WITH GINA AS
1:11 GOVERNOR. SO. I THINK I THINK I
1:17 THINK THINGS WILL BE FINE ON
1:18 THAT FRONT. YOU KNOW, I DO
1:20 THINK THAT IT'S GOOD TO HAVE
1:23 SOME BALANCE OF POWER, YOU KNOW,
1:25 LIKE NOT HAVE THE, AS A GENERAL
1:28 RULE, HAVE NOT NOT HAVE THE
1:30 PRESIDENCY, SENATE AND HOUSE
1:31 ALL BE OF THE SAME PARTY. SO MY
1:36 GOAL I DID MENTION THIS ON, ON
1:38 X WAS, WAS THAT, YOU KNOW, I
1:41 THINK WE WANT TO HAVE AT LEAST
1:42 ONE OF THE, YOU KNOW, ONE OF,
1:44 OF EITHER THE PRESIDENCY, THE
1:46 HOUSE OR THE SENATE BE OF THE
1:47 OTHER PARTY. SO, SO YOU SAID,
1:50 WHAT WAS MY ACTUAL GOAL HERE,
1:51 WHICH FAILED, BY THE WAY,
1:53 OBVIOUSLY WAS TO HAVE THE
1:55 SENATE BE 51 REPUBLICAN IN 29.
2:03 BUT OBVIOUSLY THE REPUBLICANS
2:05 WERE ROUTED IN THIS IN THIS
2:07 ELECTION. AND THE MONEY I SPENT
2:09 WAS I THINK I FEEL I FEEL
2:12 PRETTY FOOLISH ABOUT HAVING
2:13 SPENT SO MUCH MONEY AND NOT
2:15 SEEING MUCH FOR IT OR OR MAYBE
2:18 IT WOULD HAVE BEEN MUCH WORSE
2:19 WITHOUT THAT. BUT. BUT IT
2:24 CERTAINLY SHOWS THAT, YOU KNOW,
2:26 AMERICAN ELECTIONS ARE NOT JUST
2:28 ABOUT MONEY. YOU KNOW, THEY'RE
2:29 OBVIOUSLY YOU CAN PUT A LOT OF
2:31 MONEY INTO AN ELECTION AND HAVE
2:33 AN EFFECT THAT IS RELATIVELY
2:34 MINOR. AND I THINK THAT THAT
2:35 WAS THE CASE HERE. SO I
2:39 PROBABLY IF I COULD REWIND THE
2:40 CLOCK, I WOULD HAVE SPENT LESS
2:42 MONEY AND
Elon Musk on his compensation if Tesla were to merge with SpaceX full transcript
0:00 SO MANY AREAS OF CONVERGENCE
0:03 THAT THAT DIDN'T EXIST IN YEARS
0:05 BEFORE AND ARE INCREASINGLY
0:08 SIGNIFICANT TO THE FUTURE.
0:10 >> I GOT A HARD QUESTION FOR
0:11 YOU. WE ASKED READERS IF THEY
0:13 HAD QUESTIONS FOR YOU, AND ONE
0:14 QUESTION THAT CAME BACK A LOT
0:15 WAS THIS. IT RELATES TO THE
0:17 MERGER OF SPACEX AND TESLA, AND
0:19 RELATES TO THE IDEA THAT AT
0:22 TESLA, YOU HAVE A PAY AWARD
0:23 THAT'S TIED TO OPERATING
0:25 TARGETS, BUT THAT IF A DEAL
0:26 HAPPENS, AT LEAST HISTORICALLY,
0:28 YOU WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO
0:30 CAPTURE THAT COMPENSATION. AND
0:32 THE QUESTION THAT THEY THEY
0:33 ASKED MULTIPLE TIMES WAS GIVEN
0:35 THAT THAT WAS DONE ORIGINALLY.
0:37 SO YOU COULD CONTROL TESLA AND
0:39 THAT YOU NOW HAVE FULL CONTROL
0:40 OF SPACEX. WHETHER YOU THINK
0:43 YOU SHOULD GET OR NOT, THAT
0:45 THAT PIECE OF COMPENSATION, IF
0:47 A DEAL IS DONE.
0:50 >> WELL, I DON'T THINK I SHOULD
0:51 BE COMPENSATED WITH WITH, WITH
0:53 ANY, ANY KIND OF AWARD JUST FOR
0:55 DOING A MERGER. THAT WOULD BE
0:58 UNREASONABLE AND NOT RIGHT. I
1:00 MEAN, I THINK THE RIGHT THE
1:01 RIGHT WAY TO THINK ABOUT ANY
1:03 DEAL IS WHAT DID THE PARTIES
1:04 INTEND AT THE TIME OF DOING THE
1:06 DEAL. AND YOU SHOULD AND YOU
1:08 SHOULD KEEP YOUR DEALS AND STAY
1:09 TRUE TO YOUR WORD. AND SO IF
1:12 YOU KNOW, IF THE, SAY, TESLA
1:15 STOCK OPTIONS THAT WERE
1:16 CONTINGENT UPON TESLA EXECUTION,
1:19 I SHOULD NOT RECEIVE THOSE
1:21 STOCK OPTION AWARDS SIMPLY FOR
1:23 MERGING WITH SPACEX, BECAUSE
1:24 THAT IS NOT
Elon Musk: More areas of overlap between SpaceX and Tesla than before full transcript
0:00 MAGNITUDE MORE BANDWIDTH TO
0:02 CONNECT TO, TO SERVICE THE
0:05 SUPERINTELLIGENCE AND THE VAST
0:06 NUMBER OF ROBOTS THAT WILL
0:07 EXIST IN THE FUTURE.
0:09 >> YOU PROBABLY CAN'T TALK TOO
0:11 MUCH ABOUT IT, BUT OBVIOUSLY
0:12 THE BIG NEWS IS ABOUT THE
0:14 POTENTIAL OF A SPACEX AND TESLA
0:16 MERGER. AND I WAS JUST CURIOUS
0:17 WHAT YOU WOULD THINK IF IT
0:19 DOESN'T HAPPEN. I THINK
0:20 EVERYBODY THINKS IT EVENTUALLY
0:21 WILL FIND A WAY TO HAPPEN. BUT
0:22 IF IT DOESN'T HAPPEN, HOW MUCH
0:25 MORE CHALLENGING YOU THINK IT
0:26 WOULD OTHERWISE BE TO OPERATE
0:29 THESE BUSINESSES SEPARATELY
0:31 DOWN THE LINE?
0:35 >> I THINK EITHER PATH IS
0:37 POSSIBLE. IT'S JUST THAT
0:39 THERE'S MORE AND MORE AREAS OF
0:43 INTERACTION OR OVERLAP WITH
0:44 SPACEX AND TESLA THAT THAT
0:46 DIDN'T EXIST BEFORE. SO IF
0:47 YOU'D ASKED ME FIVE YEARS AGO,
0:49 DO I EVER THINK THERE'S ANY
0:50 PURPOSE IN SPACEX AND TESLA
0:52 GETTING TOGETHER? I WOULD HAVE
0:53 SAID NO. AND PEOPLE DID ASK ME
0:55 THIS. AND I SAID, I CAN'T THINK
0:57 OF WHY THAT WOULD MAKE SENSE.
0:58 YOU KNOW, THE WORD SYNERGY IS
1:00 OVERUSED AND MISAPPLIED AND,
1:02 AND, YOU KNOW, VERY OFTEN, LIKE
1:05 THE NUMBER OF MERGERS THAT
1:06 ACTUALLY WORKED OUT WHERE THE,
1:08 THE COMBINED COMPANY IS WORTH
1:09 MORE THAN THE SUM OF THE, THE
1:12 PRIOR TWO COMPANIES IS, IS
1:14 RELATIVELY UNUSUAL. WHAT WE ARE
1:17 SEEING IS THAT IS THAT IS AI
1:19 AND ROBOTICS OR SCI AND
1:21 ROBOTICS IS WHAT'S WHAT'S
1:23 CAUSING CONVERGENCE HERE. SO.
1:28 YOU KNOW, BOTH SPACEX AND TESLA
1:30 HAVE MAJOR AI SOFTWARE GROUPS.
1:33 OBVIOUSLY, THE TESLA AI
1:34 SOFTWARE GROUP IS PRIMARILY
1:36 FOCUSED ON REAL WORLD AI WITH
1:38 TESLA SELF-DRIVING AND WITH THE
1:39 OPTIMIST ROBOT. SPACEX HAS SORT
1:43 OF THE LARGE MODEL AI STUFF.
1:46 AND ON THE ON THE AI SOFTWARE
1:49 FRONT, BOTH TESLA AND SPACEX
1:51 HAVE ADVANCED CHIP DESIGN
1:54 GROUPS. AND IF YOU LOOK INTO
1:56 THE FUTURE, IT'S ORBITAL
1:58 COMPUTE IS REALLY GOING TO BE
2:00 WHERE THINGS SCALE TO, TO, TO
2:01 VERY, YOU KNOW, OR LIKE IN THE
2:04 FUTURE, THE AMOUNT OF
2:06 SUPERINTELLIGENCE COMPUTE
2:07 THAT'S IN SPACE WILL ROUND UP
2:09 TO 100%. NOW REMEMBER THESE
2:11 WORDS BECAUSE THAT SOUNDS LIKE
2:12 A PREPOSTEROUS THING TO SAY,
2:15 MEANING THAT I THINK
2:18 SUPERINTELLIGENCE COMPUTE WILL
2:19 BE LESS THAN 0.4% OF COMPUTE.
2:22 THEREFORE, ORBITAL COMPUTE WILL
2:23 ROUND UP TO 100%. AND I THINK
2:25 THIS IS A RELATIVELY EASY
2:27 PREDICTION TO MAKE, AND IT'
Elon Musk: If we turned off StarLink the entire Ukrainian front would collapse immediately full transcript
0:01 YOU KNOW, CALL IT TEN, 15 YEARS
0:02 AGO. SO THIS IS THIS IS NOT IN
0:06 ANY WAY LIKE SOME EXTREME
0:08 IDEOLOGICAL VIEW.
0:09 >> I'VE GOT A SEPARATE
0:11 GEOPOLITICAL QUESTION FOR YOU
0:12 BECAUSE IT CAME UP A COUPLE OF
0:13 TIMES TODAY. AND ACTUALLY
0:14 PALMER LUCKEY, WHO WAS HERE,
0:16 OFFERED A FASCINATING DEFENSE,
0:21 ACTUALLY, OF YOUR DECISION.
0:23 YOU'VE TALKED ABOUT IT ON X,
0:24 BUT I DON'T THINK YOU'VE TALKED
0:26 ABOUT IT PUBLICLY. CAN YOU
0:29 EXPLAIN TO EVERYBODY YOUR
0:31 THINKING AND ALSO JUST
0:33 PERSONALLY HOW YOU FELT ABOUT
0:34 IT AROUND THE SITUATION WITH
0:37 STARLINK AND STARSHIELD IN
0:39 UKRAINE AND THE IDEA OF
0:41 THROTTLING IT AND WHAT REALLY
0:42 HAPPENED, BECAUSE I DON'T THINK
0:43 THAT THE PUBLIC REALLY KNOWS
0:45 THE TRUE STORY.
0:48 >> NO, MOST PEOPLE IN THE
0:49 PUBLIC JUST BELIEVE THAT, YOU
0:50 KNOW, THE PERSON ON TV OR THE
0:52 ARTICLE THEY READ AND THEY AND
0:54 THEY JUST THEY HAVE A SOMEWHAT
0:57 SURFACE REACTION TO, TO THAT.
0:59 BUT I THINK IT'S PROBABLY BE
1:02 ACCURATE TO SAY THAT THERE IS
1:03 NO PRIVATE INDIVIDUAL WHO HAS
1:05 HELPED UKRAINE MORE THAN I HAVE.
1:08 I MADE SURE THAT STARLINK WAS
1:10 IN UKRAINE, PRE-POSITIONED
1:12 AHEAD OF THE RUSSIAN INVASION.
1:15 AND WHEN RUSSIA INVADED THE
1:17 DISABLED, ALL COMMUNICATIONS,
1:18 ALL CELL TOWERS, ALL FIBER
1:20 CABLES, AND ALL AND EVERY
1:22 SATELLITE COMMUNICATION SYSTEM,
1:23 THERE WAS ONE SYSTEM THEY COULD
1:24 NOT DISABLE, AND THAT WAS
1:26 STARLINK. AND IF THEY HAD NOT
1:29 HAD STARLINK, THEIR ENTIRE LINE
1:30 WOULD HAVE COLLAPSED BECAUSE
1:31 THEY HAD NO COMMUNICATION
1:32 SYSTEM AND RUSSIA WOULD HAVE
1:34 WON. NOW, DOES THAT SOUND LIKE
1:36 A PRO-RUSSIAN ACTION TO YOU?
1:39 >> SO THEN TELL US WHAT
1:40 HAPPENED AFTER.
1:41 >> OBVIOUSLY, IT'S A RHETORICAL
1:42 QUESTION. SO, AND EVEN TO THIS
1:46 PRESENT DAY, STARLINK IS
1:48 PROVIDES THE BACKBONE OF
1:50 COMMUNICATIONS FOR UKRAINIAN
1:52 MILITARY AND FOR AND FOR
1:55 UKRAINE MORE BROADLY. AND IF WE
1:58 WERE TO TURN OFF STARLINK, THE
2:00 ENTIRE UKRAINIAN FRONT WOULD
2:01 COLLAPSE IMMEDIATELY. SO THIS
2:04 IS, I THINK, AN ACTION THAT CAN
2:06 ONLY BE ONLY BE DESCRIBED AS
2:08 INCREDIBLY SUPPORTIVE OF
2:10 UKRAINE. NOW, NOW, NOW, FROM
2:13 THE BEGINNING, I'VE SAID THAT
2:14 STARLINK IS A CIVILIAN SYSTEM.
2:17 IT IS NOT MEANT TO TO BE USED
2:19 FOR OFFENSIVE DRONE STRIKES
2:21 THAT KILL PEOPLE, THAT THAT IS
2:25 THAT IF YOU IF YOU WANT TO DO
2:27 THAT, YOU NEED TO DO STARSHIELD,
2:28 WHICH IS A SEPARATE SYSTEM THAT
2:30 IS CONTROLLED BY THE US
2:32 GOVERNMENT. BUT DO NOT ASK ME
2:34 AS A PRIVATE INDIVIDUAL TO MAKE
2:36 KILL DECISIONS THAT SOMETIMES
2:38 RESU
Elon Musk: I'm not MAGA full transcript
0:01 PRISON, YOU KNOW, NOT THE OTHER
0:04 WAY AROUND. I MEAN, WHAT
0:07 COUNTRY ARE WE LIVING IN HERE?
0:09 >> BUT DO YOU THINK THAT THIS
0:11 EXPERIENCE, THOUGH, CHANGES
0:12 YOUR THINKING ABOUT. BEING
0:16 INVOLVED IN POLITICS ONE WAY OR
0:17 THE OTHER? MEANING GIVING MONEY
0:19 TO ONE PARTY OR THE OTHER, IN
0:20 PART BECAUSE INVARIABLY, IF YOU
0:22 SUPPORT THE LOSING PARTY,
0:25 POTENTIALLY THE WINNING PARTY
0:26 IS THEN GOING TO I MEAN, PEOPLE
0:28 TALK ABOUT WHETHER THERE'LL BE
0:29 HEARINGS AND YOU'RE GOING TO
0:30 HAVE TO GO TO WASHINGTON. LIKE
0:32 I, I JUST WANTED TO KNOW AS AS
0:34 SOMEBODY WHO'S LEADING THESE
0:35 COMPANIES AND THINKING ABOUT
0:36 ALL THIS, HOW, HOW YOU THINK
0:37 ABOUT IT.
0:39 >> NO, MY MOTIVATIONS WERE VERY
0:41 SIMPLE, WHICH IS JUST TO, TO
0:42 SORT OF HAVE LIKE ONE, ONE OF
0:47 EITHER THE HOUSE, SENATE OR
0:50 PRESIDENCY BE REPUBLICAN IN 29
0:53 AND NOT HAVE JUST A SORT OF IN
0:57 THE WORST CASE SCENARIO, A
0:59 SUPERMAJORITY OF, OF, OF
1:02 DEMOCRATS. I'M NOT IN FAVOR OF
1:04 SUPERMAJORITY OF, OF
1:05 REPUBLICANS EITHER. YOU KNOW, I
1:08 THINK WE HAVE TO HAVE SOME
1:10 CHECKS AND BALANCES HERE AND
1:11 THAT THAT WAS IT REALLY. SO.
1:17 YOU KNOW, I THINK IDEOLOGICALLY
1:19 QUITE MODERATE, ALTHOUGH, YOU
1:21 KNOW, I DON'T THINK I HAVE LIKE,
1:23 YOU KNOW, ANY, ANY KIND OF
1:25 EXTREME POLITICAL VIEWS. AND
1:26 YOU'VE KNOWN ME FOR A LONG TIME.
1:28 I MEAN, CAN YOU THINK OF SOME
1:29 EXTREME VIEW THAT I HAVE.
1:31 >> I HAVE KNOWN YOU FOR A VERY
1:33 LONG TIME. I THINK IT'S FAIR TO
1:34 SAY THAT YOU HAVE SAID THINGS
1:36 OR REPOSTED THINGS ON X, WHERE,
1:37 YOU KNOW, YOU GOT INTO AN
1:39 INTERESTING INTERVIEW WITH
1:40 ZANNY FROM THE ECONOMIST, WHERE
1:42 YOU GUYS WENT BACK AND FORTH
1:44 ABOUT SOME OF THE, THE THINGS
1:46 HAPPENING IN EUROPE AND THE
1:47 LIKE AROUND IMMIGRATION THAT,
1:49 THAT, THAT PEOPLE DID THINK
1:51 WERE FAR OR EXTREME. I KNOW YOU
1:53 DON'T THINK THEY'RE EXTREME.
1:56 >> YEAH. I DON'T THINK THEY'RE
1:58 EXTREME. LIKE, LIKE WHAT.
2:01 >> I.
2:01 >> I THINK, WELL, LOOK, I THINK
2:03 IN THE US, PEOPLE IN THE US,
2:05 SOME PEOPLE IN THE US MIGHT
2:06 THINK THAT SOME OF THE, THE
2:08 MAGA STUFF WAS EXTREME. AND IN
2:09 SOME OF THE STUFF IN EUROPE
2:11 AROUND IMMIGRATION AND THE LIKE,
2:13 THERE'S SOME PEOPLE WHO WOULD
2:14 THINK THAT. AND THAT'S WHY I'M
2:15 ASKING YOU ABOUT IT.
2:16 >> NO, NO, BUT YOU CAN'T JUST
2:19 SAY BROAD BASED. OH, MAGA
2:21 WHATEVER. I MEAN, I'M NOT MAGA.
2:23 WELL, AT LEAST I'M NOT LIKE,
2:24 I'M NOT SURE WHAT MAGA
Market Close: Mixed Day For Stocks, Rate Hike Warnings, Nvidia Stock Comeback Fizzles 11-18-2026 full transcript
0:02 I'm Peter Shack now CNBC. The stock
0:04 markets attempted a comeback was mostly
0:07 unsuccessful after a promising start to
0:09 the Wednesday session. The Dow was
0:11 negative from the opening bell and the
0:13 S&P 500 and Nasdaq finished well off
0:15 their best levels of the day. The Dow
0:17 fell 561 points to close at 50,198.
0:21 The S&P 500 closed a quarter percent
0:23 lower or 17 points after being up 4/10
0:26 of a percent earlier. The Nasdaq rose
0:28 4/10 of a percent or 102 points. That
0:31 makes five straight losses for the S&P
0:33 500, its longest losing streak since
0:35 June. Interest rates were at the
0:37 forefront of Wall Street's concerns with
0:39 Fed Governor Christopher Waller saying
0:40 more rate hikes are needed.
0:42 >> I'm very concerned about inflation. It's
0:43 kind of headed in the wrong direction
0:45 and it's spreading out. It's not just
0:47 concentrated a few categories. That's
0:49 one of the concerns is when inflation
0:51 starts spreading out and it's not just a
0:53 one-time level shock for something else.
0:55 So that's got me really concerned about
0:57 inflation and so I think we need to get
0:59 a lot more I mean inflation's been above
1:01 our target for over five years.
1:04 So if you really want to get it down,
1:05 you've got to start taking more
1:06 aggressive actions.
1:07 >> But Ellen Hazen, chief market strategist
1:09 at FL Putnam says rate hikes shouldn't
1:12 derail the stock market's progress.
1:14 >> I think that the Fed has got to raise in
1:15 December and everybody knows it. It's
1:17 not going to derail the tech trade. It's
1:19 not going to derail the market in
1:20 general. I will say that we've seen the
1:22 whole curve move up this year, right?
1:24 Long end because of higher deficits and
1:26 short end because of inflation and the
1:28 Fed and the middle of the range because
1:30 of a hyper scalars and all that debt
1:31 issuance that they're doing. So that is
1:34 is in the market, but I don't think that
1:35 raising 25 or even 50 in December is
1:38 going to cause a market dislocation on
1:39 the equity side.
1:40 >> The minutes of the most recent Fed
1:41 meeting released Wednesday afternoon did
1:43 nothing to dispel the notion that rates
1:45 would be rising. Nvidia finished the day
1:47 down about 3% after starting out higher
1:50 following an upbeat earnings report. CEO
1:53 Colette Kress says the outlook for the
1:54 chip maker's business is upbeat despite
1:57 the recent surprise departure of former
1:59 CEO Jensen Huang.
2:00 >> Important
2:01 >> that we have been seen is just again a
2:03 continuous growth in terms of the demand
2:05 that's out there. But we also have been
2:08 working in terms of our supply. So an
2:10 increase in supply working with all of
2:13 our different suppliers, whether that be
2:15 focusing in terms of what we need in
2:17 terms of chips, what we need in terms of
2:19 advanced packaging or memory, all of
2:22 that is also coming together.
2:24 >> shares gained about 4% after its sales
2:26 rose by the most in 5 years during its
2:29 latest quarter. Lowe's was up about 1%
2:31 following an upbeat earnings report and
2:33 recovering from earlier losses as
2:35 investors shrugged off warnings about
2:36 higher costs. Among the stocks we'll
2:38 watch in the day ahead and Thropic,
2:40 which will make its Wall Street debut
2:42 Thursday following the pricing of its
2:44 IPO on Wednesday evening. Cybersecurity
2:46 firm Palo Alto Networks reported better
2:48 than expected earnings after Wednesday's
2:50 closing bell. And Walmart with the
2:52 retail giant scheduled to report
2:54 earnings before tomorrow's opening bell.
2:56 We'll be getting the Labor Department's
2:58 weekly report on jobless claims, which
3:00 remain near multi-decade lows. That'll
3:02 come out on Thursday morning. And the
3:04 Conference Board will be releasing its
3:06 index of leading economic indicators.
3:08 Peter Shankman now, CNBC.
Anthropic is a company that can go public in a market like this: Notable Capital's Jeff Richards full transcript
0:01 DIMON LAST WEEK. HE SAID THEY
0:03 WANT TO TRY TO UNDER PROMISE
0:05 AND OVER DELIVER.
0:05 >> SCOTT. YEAH, I GUESS GOOD
0:07 LUCK WITH THAT, I SUPPOSE. KATE.
0:08 THANK YOU. THAT'S KATE ROONEY.
0:10 NOW WE BRING IN NOTABLE
0:11 CAPITALS. GEOFF RICHARDS HE'S
0:12 AN ANTHROPIC INVESTOR IN THE
0:14 PRIVATE MARKETS. GOOD TO HAVE
0:15 YOU. WELCOME BACK. GREAT TO SEE
0:16 YOU. I FEEL LIKE EVERY LITTLE
0:18 INCREMENTAL STEP TOWARDS THIS
0:19 BIG DAY WE VISITED WITH YOU. SO
0:21 WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS NOW IS
0:22 IT'S RIGHT HERE.
0:23 >> WELL IT'S A IT'S AN AMAZING
0:25 DAY. I THINK, YOU KNOW, IT'S A
0:27 LOT OF FOLKS OVER THE LAST FEW
0:28 WEEKS ASKED ME, WHY WOULD A
0:30 COMPANY TRY TO GO PUBLIC IN
0:31 THIS MARKET? IT'S BEEN CHOPPY.
0:33 WE HAD THE ELECTION, WE HAD
0:34 NVIDIA, ALL THE ISSUES THERE.
0:36 AND SEEMS LIKE A LOT OF PUBLIC
0:38 MARKET INVESTORS HAVE BEEN SORT
0:39 OF IN RISK OFF MODE THIS YEAR.
0:41 YOU KNOW, THE Q Q, Q IS UP WHAT,
0:43 SEVEN 8% ON THE YEAR. SO NOT
0:45 EXACTLY A BUBBLE IF YOU WILL.
0:46 BUT I THINK THE ANSWER TO THAT
0:48 QUESTION IS ANTHROPIC IS A
0:49 COMPANY THAT CAN GO PUBLIC IN A
0:51 MARKET LIKE THIS. IT'S A SUPER
0:52 STRONG COMPANY. I THINK THE S-1
0:54 SURPRISED A LOT OF PEOPLE TO
0:55 THE UPSIDE AND THEN TO WHAT
0:57 KATE WAS SAYING. KRISHNA IS A
0:58 FANTASTIC CFO AND AS A AS A
1:00 PUBLIC MARKET INVESTOR, WHAT
1:01 YOU WANT IS TRUST IN A COMPANY,
1:03 TRUST IN THE NUMBERS, TRUST IN
1:04 THE OUTLOOK AND CONFIDENCE IN
1:06 THE NEXT 2 OR 3 YEARS AS THEY
1:08 GUIDE FORWARD. AND I THINK THE
1:09 COMPANY HAS BUILT A LOT OF
1:11 TRUST OVER THE LAST FEW WEEKS.
1:12 >> WHEN DID YOU FIRST INVEST?
1:14 >> WE INVESTED IN THE SERIES D
1:15 WHEN THE COMPANY WAS AROUND
1:17 $800 MILLION. REVENUE RUN RATE.
1:18 >> WOW. SO A LONG TIME AGO.
1:20 YEAH, THE GROWTH HAS BEEN
1:21 REMARKABLE.
1:22 >> THEY CERTAINLY EXCEEDED OUR
1:23 EXPECTATIONS.
1:23 >> WHAT WERE YOUR EXPECTATIONS?
1:24 >> YOU KNOW, WE THOUGHT THIS
1:25 WAS A GENERATIONAL COMPANY. WE
1:27 THOUGHT BOTH OPENAI AND
1:28 ANTHROPIC HAD A CHANCE TO
1:29 CAPTURE JUST AN INCREDIBLE
1:30 MARKET OPPORTUNITY THAT WAS
1:31 GROWING. I THINK THAT REALLY
1:32 CHANGED IN Q1 OF THIS YEAR,
1:34 WHEN CLAUDE COWORK AND CLAUDE
1:35 CODE CAME OUT AND THE NUMBERS
1:36 REALLY STARTED TO SPIKE, WHICH
1:38 YOU SAW IN THEIR FINANCIALS.
1:39 AND WE SAW IT ACROSS THE
1:40 ECOSYSTEM. YOU AND I HAVE
1:42 TALKED ABOUT THIS BEFORE, BUT A
1:43 LOT OF PRIVATE AI COMPANIES,
1:45 YOU COULD SEE THE SORT OF
1:47 RAMIFICATIONS OF WHAT WAS
1:47 HAPPENING WITH ANTHROPIC IN THE
1:50 INFRASTRUCTURE NAMES, PRIVATE
1:51 COMPANIES THAT WERE INVESTED IN
1:52 LIKE VERCEL AND DATABRICKS, AND
1:53 COMPANIES LIKE FIREWORKS AND
1:54 BASE TEN ALL SAW THEIR NUMBERS
1:56 SPIKE. SO REALLY, 26 HAS BEEN A
1:59 GAME CHANGER FOR AI ADOPTION. I
2:01 STILL THINK WE'RE EARLY IN THE
2:02 ENTERPRISE. AND YOU SAW THAT IN
2:04 THEIR IN THEIR S-1, THEY HAVE
2:05 11,000 CUSTOMERS SPENDING OVER
2:07 $100,000 A YEAR. BUT IN THOSE
2:09 CUSTOMERS, THEY'RE LESS THAN 1%
2:10 OF THEIR SPEND ON SOFTWARE. SO
2:12 A LONG WAY TO GO FOR THIS
2:13 COMPANY. AND IF YOU THINK ABOUT
2:15 ENTERPRISE BUYING CYCLES, IF
2:16 YOU THINK ABOUT ENTERPRISES
2:17 USUALLY TAKE 6 TO 9 MONTHS TO
2:19 BUY NEW
2:20 >> TECHNOLOGY. MOST OF THEM
2:21 BECAME AWARE OF THIS IN Q1. SO
2:22 WE'RE NOW JUST GETTING INTO A
2:24 PHASE WHERE A LOT OF MAJOR
2:25 COMPANIES AROUND THE WORLD ARE
2:26 PROBABLY STARTING TO LOOK AT
2:28 IMPLEMENTING.
2:29 >> WHAT'S MOST IMPRESSED YOU?
2:29 YOU THINK? I MEAN, WE'RE JUST
2:31 LITERALLY TALKING RECENTLY
2:32 ABOUT A RUN RATE GOING, YOU
2:34 KNOW, $10 BILLION GROWTH OVER
2:39 ONE SEQUENTIALLY. WHAT'S MOST
2:40 IMPRESSED YOU ABOUT THE WAY
2:41 DARIO HAS TAKEN THIS COMPANY
2:43 FROM THEN TO HERE?
2:45 >> I THINK THAT THE THE
2:46 FINANCIAL STRENGTH OF THE
2:47 COMPANY WAS SOMETHING THAT
2:48 PEOPLE DIDN'T UNDERSTAND OR
2:50 APPRECIATE BEFORE THEY FILED
2:51 THE S-1. THERE WERE A LOT OF
2:53 NAYSAYERS, DOOMSAYERS. IS THE
2:54 AI TRADE REAL? ET CETERA. ET
2:56 CETERA. AND YOU KNOW, AS YOU
2:57 AND I HAVE TALKED ABOUT, THE
2:59 DATA THAT EVERYBODY WAS WORKING
3:00 WITH WAS REALLY THE SEMIS, THE
3:02 HYPERSCALERS MORE THE SUPPLY
3:03 SIDE AND QUESTIONING THE DEMAND
3:05 SIDE. SO WHEN THIS COMPANY
3:07 FILED ITS S-1, I THINK THAT NOT
3:09 ONLY WERE PEOPLE IMPRESSED WITH
3:10 THE GROWTH RATE, WHICH I THINK
3:11 WAS EXPECTED, BUT THE FINANCIAL
3:12 STRENGTH OF THE COMPANY, THE
3:14 BALANCE SHEET, RELATIVELY LOW
3:15 BURN OVER TIME MARGINS, PEOPLE
3:17 COULD SEE A PATHWAY TO STRONG
3:18 FREE CASH FLOW. SO I THINK
3:20 THAT'S JUST SOMETHING THAT
3:21 WASN'T APPRECIATED IN THE
3:22 MARKET FOR FOLKS THAT DIDN'T
3:23 UNDERSTAND THE PROFILE OF THE
3:24 COMPANY.
3:25 >> HOW ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT
3:26 THE IPO SORT OF ITSELF? I MEAN,
3:28 IT'S A LITTLE BIT OF A JUGGLING
3:30 ACT, RIGHT? I MEAN, YOU WANT TO
3:31 AND KATE WAS JUST TALKING ABOUT
3:33 THE POSSIBILITY OF UPSIZING THE
3:34 OFFERING ITSELF. YOU WANT TO DO
3:36 THAT. YOU STILL WANT TO HAVE A,
3:37 YOU KNOW, GOOD DEMAND PROFILE
3:39 ON, ON DAY ONE AS WELL. HOW ARE
3:41 YOU LOOKING AT THAT?
3:42 >> YEAH. I MEAN, YOU NAILED IT.
3:44 FIRST OF ALL, I THINK THE
3:45 BANKERS HAVE DONE AN AMAZING
3:46 JOB BECAUSE THIS WAS NOT AN
3:48 EASY ONE TO DO. IT'S THE
3:49 LARGEST IPO IN HISTORY AND SUCH
3:51 A SEMINAL MOMENT IN THIS
3:52 INDUSTRY. I GUESS WHAT I WOULD
3:54 WHAT I WOULD THINK ABOUT IS
3:55 LIKE COMPANY PEOPLE WANT TO OWN
3:57 A STOCK LIKE THIS FOR THE
3:59 FUTURE. WHAT IS THE OUTLOOK
4:00 LOOK LIKE? WHAT ARE THE NEXT 2
4:01 TO 3 YEARS LOOK LIKE? AND
4:03 YOU'VE SEEN SOME FORECASTS FROM
4:04 FOLKS, YOU KNOW, ANALYST
4:05 REPORTS WON'T COME OUT FOR A
4:06 FEW WEEKS, BUT FOLKS ARE KIND
4:08 OF WHISPERING 500 TO $800
4:10 BILLION IN REVENUE IN 2030,
4:12 WHICH IS, WHICH IS JUST GROWTH
4:13 WE'VE NEVER SEEN BEFORE. AND
4:14 FRANKLY, THERE'S NO PUBLIC
4:16 COMMENT WHEN YOU'RE TALKING
4:16 ABOUT A COMPANY TODAY THAT
4:18 WOULD GO PUBLIC AT AROUND, CALL
4:19 IT TEN TIMES FORWARD REVENUE.
4:20 IF YOU THINK ABOUT CLOUDFLARE,
4:22 PALANTIR, CROWDSTRIKE, SOME OF
4:23 THE NAMES THAT PEOPLE MIGHT PUT
4:24 AS A
CME Group CEO Terry Duffy on the CME Group Tour Championship, prediction markets full transcript
0:14 >> WELCOME BACK TO POWER LUNCH.
0:15 I'M DOMINIC CHU HERE IN NAPLES,
0:17 FLORIDA, WHERE WE ARE JOINED
0:18 RIGHT NOW BY CME GROUP CEO
0:20 TERRY DUFFY. TERRY, THANK YOU
0:22 VERY MUCH FOR BEING HERE ON
0:24 CNBC WITH US TODAY.
0:25 >> WELL DOM, THANK YOU FOR
0:26 BEING HERE. I APPRECIATE IT
0:28 VERY MUCH.
0:28 >> WELL THIS IS THE SEASON AND
0:30 THE REASON WHY YOU'RE HERE
0:31 BECAUSE THE SIGNAGE TELLS IT.
0:32 YOU ARE THE TITLE SPONSOR OF
0:34 THE LPGA SEASON ENDING TOUR
0:35 CHAMPIONSHIP AND HAVE BEEN FOR
0:36 YEARS. CORRECT. WHAT IS IT
0:38 ABOUT THIS EVENT THAT MAKES YOU
0:40 SO KEEN ON BEING A PART OF
0:42 WOMEN'S PROFESSIONAL GOLF?
0:43 >> WELL, I THINK THAT YOU CAN
0:45 JUST SEE IT IN EVERYTHING THAT
0:46 WE DO AT CME. AS YOU KNOW, I
0:48 ANNOUNCED THAT I'M GOING TO BE
0:49 RETIRING AS CEO COMING UP NEXT
0:51 YEAR. AND LYNN FITZPATRICK IS
0:52 GOING TO BE MY INCOMING CEO.
0:53 I'M VERY BIG IN WOMEN IN SPORTS,
0:55 WOMEN IN BUSINESS AND EQUALITY
0:58 ACROSS THE BOARD. SO THAT'S,
0:59 THAT'S ONE OF THE THINGS THAT
1:00 WE REALLY LOVE ABOUT THE GAME.
1:02 WOMEN'S SPORTS HERE AT THE CME
1:04 GROUP TOUR CHAMPIONSHIP.
1:05 >> IT'S IT'S ONE THING TO WANT
1:07 TO BE A PART OF WOMEN'S SPORTS,
1:08 BUT IT'S ANOTHER THING TO PUT
1:10 UP THE BIGGEST PRIZE PURSE AND
1:12 THE SINGLE BIGGEST WINNER'S
1:14 CHEQUE IN PROFESSIONAL WOMEN'S
1:16 GOLF. WHAT EXACTLY IS IT ABOUT
1:17 THIS PARTICULAR EVENT THAT
1:19 MAKES YOU FEEL AS THOUGH IT IS
1:20 WORTH THE KIND OF INVESTMENT
1:21 THAT CME GROUP?
1:22 >> WELL, AS I AS I SAID A
1:24 MOMENT AGO, I BELIEVE IN
1:25 EQUALITY. AND I DON'T BELIEVE,
1:27 YOU KNOW, WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
1:28 TALENT THAT'S OUT HERE ON LPGA
1:30 TOUR, IT'S JUST EXTRAORDINARY.
1:31 AND I BELIEVE THAT WOMEN SHOULD
1:32 BE COMPENSATED THE SAME. SO
1:34 WE'RE TRYING TO DO OUR PART IN
1:35 THAT EVENT. SO PAYING 4 MILLION
1:37 TO THE WINNER OF OUR EVENT IS
1:39 PROBABLY LARGER THAN MOST OF
1:40 THE MEN'S AVERAGE TOUR EVENTS.
1:42 NOW, SOME ARE BIGGER, BUT THIS
1:43 IS A VERY LARGE EVENT AND I
1:45 THINK THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT.
1:46 >> WE WERE HERE TWO YEARS AGO.
1:47 I THINK WHEN YOU GUYS EXTENDED
1:50 YOUR SPONSORSHIP, YOUR TITLE
1:52 SPONSORSHIP OF THIS EVENT INTO
1:54 2027. THIS IS 2026, ONE YEAR
1:57 LEFT. ANY THOUGHTS TO WHAT
1:59 YOU'RE GOING TO DO BEYOND 2027?
2:01 >> YEAH, I THINK RIGHT NOW
2:02 WE'RE GOING TO SIT DOWN. I'M
2:04 GOING TO SIT DOWN WITH LYNN,
2:05 AND WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A
2:07 DISCUSSION ABOUT OUR BRAND AND
2:08 OUR BRAND MARKETING AND HOW
2:09 WE'RE GOING TO PROCEED AND WHAT
2:11 SHE HER VISION IS. AND, YOU
2:12 KNOW, WE'VE YET TO COME TO A
2:14 CONCLUSION YET WE HAVE THIS
2:15 YEAR. AND OF COURSE, WE HAVE
2:17 NEXT YEAR BEFORE WE HAVE TO
2:18 MAKE THAT DECISION. BUT RIGHT
2:19 NOW, IT'S BEEN REALLY GOOD FOR
2:21 CME. WE'VE BEEN DOING IT FOR A
2:23 LONG TIME. AND WE'LL SEE HOW IT
2:24 PROGRESSES ONCE I HAVE THE
2:26 CONVERSATIONS WITH LYNN.
2:26 >> SPEAKING OF WHAT'S GOOD FOR
2:28 CME AND WHAT'S GOOD FOR THE
2:29 BUSINESS OVERALL LYNN'S COMING
2:30 IN. YOU'VE SET THE STAGE OVER
2:32 THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS. THE CME
2:33 GROUP NOW IS FACING A VERY NEW
2:35 LEVEL OF COMPETITION IN TERMS
2:36 OF ITS BUSINESS DEALINGS, ONE
2:38 OF WHICH IS PREDICTION MARKETS,
2:39 THE OTHER OF WHICH IS SOME OF
2:41 THESE NEW PLATFORMS THAT ARE
2:42 GETTING INTO TRADING AND
2:43 EXCHANGE OPERATIONS. WHAT DO
2:44 YOU THINK THE COMPETITIVE
2:45 LANDSCAPE NOW LOOKS LIKE FROM
2:46 YOUR MIND, GIVEN ALL OF THOSE
2:48 VARIABLES?
2:48 >> WELL, FIRST OF ALL, THERE'S
2:49 A COUPLE OF DIFFERENT THINGS
2:51 THERE. I'M PREDICTION MARKETS.
2:52 I THINK THERE'S A LOT GOING ON
2:53 THERE. AND AS YOU SAW MAYBE IN
2:55 THE RECENT NEWS, EVEN THE CFTC
2:57 IS FINALLY REALIZING THAT THEY
2:58 NEED TO TAKE DOWN SOME OF THESE
3:00 MENTIONED MARKETS ON
3:00 PREDICTIONS THAT THEY ARE WHAT
3:02 THE PRESIDENT WILL OR WILL NOT
3:03 SAY. THESE ARE SUSCEPTIBLE TO
3:04 MANIPULATION MARKETS UNDER CORE
3:05 PRINCIPLE THREE, THERE'S BEEN
3:06 5000 SELF CERTIFICATIONS DOWN.
3:08 YOU CAN'T TELL ME THAT ONE OF
3:09 THEM ISN'T A PROBLEM. SO
3:11 THEY'RE FINALLY STARTING TO
3:12 REALIZE THIS. AND YOU KNOW,
3:13 ELECTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES,
3:14 THEY SAY. AND I THINK WE'RE
3:16 STARTING TO SEE SOME OF THOSE
3:17 CONSEQUENCES. SO THEN WHEN YOU
3:18 LOOK AT SOME OF THE DEFI
3:20 PLATFORMS, I THINK WHEN YOU
3:21 LOOK AT THE REAL MONEY, LOOK AT
3:23 HOW DEFI GOES ON THE BLOCKCHAIN,
3:24 WHAT IT DOES OR DOES NOT DO, I
3:26 THINK THE REAL MONEY GETS A
3:28 LITTLE NERVOUS WHEN THEY LOOK
3:29 AT THE GUTS OF THOSE PROCESSES.
3:30 SO WHEN YOU LOOK AT CME YOU
3:32 KNOW, ROUGHLY $105 BILLION
3:34 EVERY SINGLE DAY A MARKET
3:36 EFFICIENCIES. THAT'S WHAT REAL
3:37 MONEY IS LOOKING FOR. RETAIL
3:38 MIGHT BE LOOKING FOR SOMETHING
3:39 DIFFERENT, BUT REAL
3:40 INSTITUTIONAL MONEY IS LOOKING
3:41 FOR THOSE EFFICIENCIES. AND
3:43 THAT'S WHAT WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO
3:44 CREATE. AND WE'RE CONTINUING TO
3:45 BUILD ON THAT EACH AND EVERY
3:46 DAY.
3:47 >> WE ARE SEEING NOW PREDICTION
3:48 MARKETS, COMPANIES BY BROKER
3:50 DEALERS AND GETTING TO MORE
3:52 TRADITIONAL TRADING ACTIVITIES.
3:53 IS THAT GOOD OR BAD FOR THE
3:55 MARKETS OVERALL.
3:55 >> I DON'T KNOW. I MEAN,
3:57 COMPETITION IS GOOD IF THEY'RE
3:58 GOING TO BUY A BROKER DEALER. I
4:00 THINK IT WAS A SMALL
4:01 ACQUISITION YOU'RE REFERRING TO
4:02 KELSEY I THINK IS WHAT YOU'RE
4:03 REFERRING TO. LISTEN, I THINK
4:05 THEY HAVE A LOT OF DIFFERENT
4:06 THINGS GOING ON RIGHT NOW. AND
4:08 THEY'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
4:09 THEIR FOOTING. I MEAN, THEY'RE
4:10 TALKING ABOUT VALUATIONS OF $65
4:11 BILLION OFF COMPUTE FUTURES.
4:12 THEY HAVE ENLISTED THEM YET.
4:14 I'VE HAD AN APPLICATION AT THE
4:15 CFTC NOW FOR MONTHS THAT'S BEEN
4:17 HELD UP FOR WHATEVER REASON, ON
4:18 COMPUTE FUTURES. SO, YOU KNOW,
4:20 I'D LIKE TO SAY MY COMPUTE
4:21 FUTURES ARE WORTH
4:22 65,000,000,002 TO MY MARKET CAP,
4:23 BUT THAT'S KIND OF A JOKE. SO
4:25 WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS ON
4:26 SOMEBODY'S PLATFORM. SO YOU SEE
4:27 PEOPLE LIKE THAT TRYING T
The Investment Committee discusses the state of the AI trade following Nvidia's earnings full transcript
0:00 THE MARKETS AS WE GET STARTED
0:02 HERE. KEEP AN EYE ON THE DOW AS
0:04 WELL. LOOK AT THAT. IT'S 250
0:05 POINTS ABOVE 50,000. SO IT'S
0:06 GETTING A LITTLE BIT CLOSE.
0:08 WE'RE WATCHING ALL THAT. AND
0:10 YES WE'RE WATCHING NVIDIA AS
0:12 WELL. THEY DID HAVE THE BEAT.
0:13 THEY HAD THE STRONG GUIDE. AND
0:15 WE DO AT THIS MOMENT HAVE THAT
0:17 ALL HANDS MEETING AT THE
0:18 COMPANY'S HEADQUARTERS NOT TOO
0:19 FAR FROM HERE IN SANTA CLARA.
0:21 SEEMA MODY HAS BEEN FOLLOWING
0:23 THAT. AND SEEMA THIS IS GOING
0:25 TO BE SO CLOSELY WATCHED THIS
0:28 MEETING BEFORE. WHAT'S BEEN
0:30 DESCRIBED AS A DIVIDED
0:31 WORKFORCE.
0:32 >> OH FOR SURE. NVIDIA'S
0:34 INTERIM CEO, COLETTE KRESS
0:35 SCOTT HAS A TOUGH TASK AT HAND,
0:38 DELIVERING A MESSAGE OF
0:39 CONTINUITY AND MOVING FORWARD,
0:40 JUST AS EMPLOYEE CALLS TO BRING
0:42 JENSEN WONG BACK GROW LOUDER.
0:44 WE'RE TOLD JENSEN WONG'S PUBLIC
0:46 STATEMENT YESTERDAY, HIS FIRST
0:47 SINCE RESIGNATION, QUOTE, FIRED
0:49 A LOT OF PEOPLE UP. THE
0:50 INTERNAL PETITION AND THE STAND
0:52 WITH JENSEN POLL GETTING MORE
0:53 SIGNATURES THIS MORNING. MANY
0:55 OF THOSE EMPLOYEES EXPECTED TO
0:56 TURN UP AT NVIDIA'S ALL HANDS
0:58 MEETING, WHICH DOES BEGIN
1:00 MOMENTARILY AT NVIDIA
1:01 HEADQUARTERS. TWO EMPLOYEES
1:02 TELLING ME THEY FOUND THAT
1:04 NVIDIA'S NEWLY APPOINTED CHAIR,
1:06 HARVEY JONES, COMMENTS ON THE
1:07 EARNINGS CALL LAST NIGHT
1:08 SLIGHTLY FRUSTRATING. WHY TAKE
1:10 A STRONG STANCE ON NOT BRINGING
1:12 JENSEN WONG BACK WHEN THE
1:13 INVESTIGATION IS STILL ONGOING?
1:15 IT ISN'T CLEAR IF COLETTE KRESS
1:17 AND EXECUTIVES WILL TAKE
1:18 QUESTIONS FROM THE AUDIENCE.
1:19 THEY TYPICALLY DON'T DURING
1:20 THIS ALL HANDS MEETING, SCOTT,
1:22 BUT WE WILL KEEP YOU UPDATED.
1:24 >> YEAH, I'M SURE YOU WILL.
1:25 SEEMA, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
1:26 THAT. WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE
1:28 OWNERSHIP ON THE DESK. I DO
1:29 WANT TO GET INTO THAT. SEEMA
1:32 COVERED ALL OF IT. GUYS, YOU
1:33 HAD SAM ALTMAN. I'M NOT SURE IF
1:35 ALL OF YOU HEARD THIS THIS
1:36 MORNING WITH ANDREW AT DEALBOOK.
1:38 HARD TO IMAGINE AN AI INDUSTRY
1:39 WITHOUT JENSEN. THE STREETS
1:40 WEIGHING IN ON THE BACK OF THE
1:42 EARNINGS, GOLDMAN REITERATES A
1:43 BUY. JP MORGAN RAISES THE PRICE
1:45 TARGET TO $230. DAN IVES SAYS
1:49 DEMAND DID NOT RESIGN. MORGAN
1:51 STANLEY TRIMS THE TARGET A
1:52 LITTLE BIT. JOSH, HOW ARE WE
1:54 FEELING TODAY AFTER EARNINGS?
1:57 >> WORSE. THE NUMBERS ARE GREAT.
1:59 NOBODY THOUGHT THEY WOULDN'T BE
2:00 GREAT. THAT IS NOT THE PROBLEM
2:02 WITH THE STOCK. THE OVERHANG IS
2:04 THE PROBLEM WITH THE STOCK. AND
2:05 I APPRECIATE HOW MISS KRESS
2:07 SIGNED OFF BY SAYING WE GOT
2:08 THIS. AND I THINK, YOU KNOW, AS
2:10 A SHAREHOLDER, WE ABSOLUTELY
2:12 DID WANT TO HEAR SOME
2:14 PROJECTION OF CONFIDENCE. BUT
2:16 THE INTERVIEW WASN'T GREAT. I
2:17 THINK EVERYBODY UNDERSTANDS
2:19 SHE'S NOT THE ANSWER. IN THE
2:21 INTERMEDIATE TO LONG TERM.
2:22 THERE'S GOING TO BE A NEW VOICE.
2:25 I DON'T LIKE WHAT JENSEN DID
2:28 SUGGESTING LIKE, HEY, I'LL JUST
2:29 COME BACK. I KNOW I RESIGNED
2:31 FIVE DAYS AGO, BUT LIKE, I'M
2:33 HERE IF YOU NEED ME, THEY WILL
2:35 GO BACK TO HIM. IF THE STOCK
2:37 FALLS UNDER 100, I DON'T I
2:39 DON'T SEE HOW THEY GET THE
2:40 VOTES. QUITE FRANKLY. THE THE
2:42 MAJORITY OF THE SHARES, THE
2:44 SHARES ARE VERY WIDELY
2:45 DISPERSED. THIS IS NOT A
2:47 SITUATION WHERE YOU HAVE AN
2:48 ACTIVIST IN HERE WHO OWNS 10%.
2:50 YOU'RE NOT GOING TO GET
2:51 VANGUARD AND BLACKROCK TO DO
2:53 MUCH IN TERMS OF LIKE REMOVING
2:55 BOARD MEMBERS FOR ENFORCING THE
2:57 COMPANY'S POLICY. SO IT'D BE
2:59 VERY DIFFICULT FOR HIM TO COME
3:01 BACK BARRING SOME SORT OF AN
3:03 EMERGENCY. AND AS A SHAREHOLDER,
3:04 THAT'S LIKE NOT THE IDEAL
3:06 SCENARIO. SO I DO THINK IT
3:09 COULD BE A CLEARING EVENT WHEN
3:10 HE TESTIFIES PUBLICLY AND
3:12 PEOPLE SAY, OKAY, THAT'S ALL
3:13 THERE IS, I COULD LIVE WITH
3:15 THAT. SO THAT'S REALLY, I THINK,
3:17 THE FIRST TIME I MIGHT BE ABLE
3:18 TO COME OUT AND SAY, I FEEL
3:20 LIKE WE'VE SEEN THE WORST, BUT
3:22 WE'VE GOT SOME DAYS AHEAD UNTIL
3:24 THAT HAPPENS. AND SO I DON'T
3:26 THINK THAT THE LAST 90 DAY
3:29 QUARTERLY REPORT RUNDOWN IS
3:31 REALLY THE THING THAT WAS GOING
3:33 TO PUT A FLOOR UNDER THE STOCK
3:35 NO MATTER WHAT. I'M GLAD THEY
3:36 HAD A GREAT QUARTER. I'M GLAD
3:38 THEY GAVE GREAT GUIDANCE. BUT
3:39 THE OVERHANG OF ALL THE OTHER
3:40 STUFF IS STILL TOO MUCH FOR ME
3:42 TO FEEL REALLY CONFIDENT HERE
3:43 WITH THE STOCK AT 152.
3:45 >> THAT'S THOSE ARE SO MANY
3:47 GOOD POINTS, ROB.
3:49 >> I'M VERY GOOD.
3:50 >> AT THIS. MAKES YOU ARE, YOU
3:52 ARE. THAT'S WHY WE LOVE YOU.
3:53 THEY SAY THE STOCK'S CHEAP
3:55 RIGHT. IT'S TEN TIMES FORWARD
3:57 EARNINGS. THEY HAVE A MOAT.
3:59 THEY'VE GOT THE NEXT COUPLE OF
4:00 YEARS. BAKED DEMAND IS
4:02 OBVIOUSLY STRONG. NO ONE
4:04 DISPUTES ANY OF THAT. BUT IT IS
4:06 THE OVERHANG THAT THAT JOSH
4:07 TALKS ABOUT. IT'S THE
4:08 UNCERTAINTY OF EVERYTHING THAT
4:11 MAYBE SUPERSEDES EVERYTHING
4:12 ELSE. HOW DO YOU SEE IT?
4:15 >> LISTEN, I THOUGHT THE THE
4:17 EARNINGS CALL WAS A STEP IN THE
4:18 RIGHT DIRECTION TO SHOW DEPTH.
4:20 I KIND OF AGREE WITH JOSH THAT,
4:22 YOU KNOW, THERE'S GOING TO BE
4:23 THIS OVERHANG FOR A BIT. BUT
4:26 JUST LIKE MARKETS, MARKETS
4:27 CLIMB WALLS OF WORRY WITH A
4:29 SLOW REMOVAL OF THOSE NEGATIVES.
4:32 SO YOU HAVE SENTIMENT THAT HAS
4:33 TO GET POSITIVE. AGAIN, YOU
4:35 HAVE A REGULATORY OVERHANG, YOU
4:37 HAVE POLITICAL HEADLINE
4:39 HEADLINES THAT ARE OUTWEIGHING
4:41 REALLY STRONG FUNDAMENTALS
4:42 RIGHT NOW. BUT IF YOU IF YOU
4:44 CAN KIND OF DISTANCE YOURSELF
4:46 FROM THE NOISE AND YOU LOOK AT
4:48 THE STRONG RESULTS, YOU LOOK AT
4:50 THE CONFIDENT OUTLOOK, YOU LOOK
4:51 AT SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT
4:53 WERE ADDRESSED, NO LONGER
4:55 SELLING ANY PRODUCTS TO CHINA,
4:58 MORE VISIBILITY INTO WHERE
4:59 FINAL SALES WILL GO. WE'LL
5:01 FOLLOW THE SPIRIT OF THE X, YOU
5:04 KNOW, THE EXPORT ROLES, NOT
5:07 JUST TO THE LETTER OF THE LAW.
5:09 THEY ADDRESSED OR AT LEAST
5:12 CLARIFIED CIRCULAR FINANCING.
5:14 THEY TALKED ABOUT CUSTOMER
5:17 GUARANTEES AND HOW THAT HAS TO
5:18 ONLY KICK IN ONCE CAPACITY IS
5:21 DELIVERED. DEMAND REMAINS
5:23 HEALTHY. THEY SAW THE
5:25 HYPERSCALER REVENUE ROSE 25%
5:29 SEQUENTIALLY. IT'S THE BIGGEST
5:30 JUMP IN SEVERAL QUARTERS. AND
5:32 YET YOU HAVE THIS OVERHANG. AND
5:34 SO I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S GOING
5:36 TO TAKE A CLEARING EVENT TO
5:38 BRING BACK JUSTIN JENSEN. IT
5:41 COULD END UP JUST BEING THAT
5:43 THE NOISE THAT'S IN THE COMPANY
5:45 RIGHT NOW, THE NOISE AMONG
5:47 SHAREHOLDERS, THE FACT OF HOW
5:49 IMPORTANT HE IS TO THE BUSINESS
5:52 MIGHT BE THE CATALYST THAT
5:55 BRINGS THAT BRINGS HIM BACK
5:57 ONCE DUE PROCESS, OR IF DUE
5:59 PROCESS PROVES THAT THERE WAS
6:01 NO WRONGDOING HERE. AND SO, YOU
6:04 KNOW, ONCE YOU GET THROUGH THE.
6:06 >> HEY, ROB. HEY, ROB.
6:07 >> YEAH.
6:07 >> THERE THERE ARE LEVELS OF
6:09 WRONGDOING. AND THE THING THAT
6:10 HE IS NOT DENYING IS THE AFFAIR
6:12 WITH THE DIRECT REPORT. SO YOU
6:14 EITHER HAVE CORPORATE
6:15 GOVERNANCE OR YOU DON'T. AND
6:16 I'M, I'M A HUGE FAN OF JENSEN'S
6:19 AND HE'S MADE ME MORE MONEY IN
6:21 THIS STOCK PERSONALLY THAN I. I
6:22 THINK I'VE MADE IN ANYTHING
6:24 ELSE, MAYBE OTHER THAN APPLE, I,
6:26 I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE A DO OVER
6:28 WHERE NONE OF THIS HAPPENS. AND
6:30 HE'S STILL SITTING IN THE SEAT.
6:31 BUT THE REALITY IS YOU CANNOT
6:34 REMOVE BOARD MEMBERS WITH A
6:36 VOTE BECAUSE THEY'RE ENFORCING
6:38 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND DOING
6:39 THEIR JOB. SO THE NO WRONGDOING
6:42 PART AS IT APPLIES TO CHIP
6:44 SALES IN ASIA THAT WEREN'T
6:47 SUPPOSED TO HAVE HAPPENED. THAT
6:49 WOULD BE GREAT. I AGREE WITH
6:50 YOU. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE I
6:52 DON'T KNOW ABOUT EXONERATED
6:53 BEING THE RIGHT WORD, BUT I
6:54 WOULD LIKE TO SEE IT COME OUT
6:56 THAT THERE WASN'T ANYTHING
6:57 NEFARIOUS. HE JUST HAD BAD
6:59 JUDGMENT WITH AN AFFAIR PARTNER.
7:00 BUT THE OTHER PART IS THE PART
7:02 THAT I THINK MAKES IT REALLY
7:05 TOUGH FOR THE BOARD TO SAY,
7:06 OKAY, WE HAVE A POLICY, BUT IT
7:09 DOESN'T APPLY TO THIS ONE
7:11 MAGICAL MAN.
7:12 >> OR IN.
7:13 >> YOU THINK WE THINK OUR
7:15 POLICY.
7:16 >> YOU FEEL LIKE THEY CAN
7:17 CHANGE THAT POLICY IF THE STOCK
7:19 DROPS BELOW $100 A SHARE?
7:21 >> YEAH, I DO, BECAUSE IT'S AN
7:23 EMERGENCY.
7:23 >> THE DOUBLE STANDARD. IN THAT
7:25 CASE.
7:26 >> I'LL TELL YOU WHY, BECAUSE I
7:27 THINK THAT'S WHEN THAT'S WHEN
7:29 THINGS GET MORE DESPERATE AND
7:30 PEOPLE ARE WILLING TO BE MORE
7:31 CREATIVE. AND SO WE HAVE IT'S
7:33 NOT DESPERATION. LET'S TAKE A
7:34 STEP BACK. JOSH, UNFORTUNATELY,
7:36 TAKE.
7:36 >> A STEP BACK. LET'S TAKE A
7:38 STEP BACK. GIVE ME A CHANCE
7:39 HERE. WE'RE FRIENDS HERE. LET'S
7:40 TAKE A STEP BACK AND MAKE SURE
7:43 THAT WE LOOK AT WHAT THE JOB OF
7:45 THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS IS. AND
7:47 IT'S NOT ONLY TO ENFORCE POLICY,
7:50 IT IS TO ACT IN THE BEST
7:52 INTEREST OF THE SHAREHOLDERS.
7:53 NO, I'M BY NO MEANS ADVOCATING
7:56 THAT THIS HAS TO HAPPEN NOW,
7:58 BUT I THINK YOU DO HAVE TO LOOK
8:00 AT WHAT IS IN THE BEST INTEREST
8:02 OF THE COMPANY, BECAUSE AS A
8:04 SHAREHOLDER, THAT'S EXACTLY
8:06 WHAT I WANT TO HAVE HAPPEN. AND
8:08 I'M NOT SURE THAT RUSHING TO
8:11 JUDGMENT ON THIS TOPIC IS THE
8:14 RIGHT ANSWER. SO THAT WE GET TO
8:17 DESPERATE MODE AT BELOW $100
8:18 PER SHARE, WHICH I DON'T THINK
8:20 IT'S EVER GOING TO REACH. IF IT
8:22 DOES, THAT'S A DISASTER
8:23 SCENARIO. HOWEVER, THAT
Brookings’ Michael O’Hanlon on China trip: I hope Trump holds the line on chips full transcript
0:01 BEEN CLEAR. SO WE'LL WATCH ALL
0:02 THESE SESSIONS OVERNIGHT TO SEE
0:04 IF THERE'S ANY INDICATION OF A
0:06 DIPLOMATIC BREAKTHROUGH. KELLY,
0:07 BACK OVER TO YOU.
0:08 >> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. WE
0:09 APPRECIATE IT. OUR NEXT GUEST
0:11 SAYS THE MOST CONSEQUENTIAL
0:12 OUTCOME OF THIS MEETING IS
0:13 LIKELY A RENEWED DEAL ON
0:15 TARIFFS, CHIPS AND RARE EARTHS.
0:17 LET'S BRING IN MICHAEL O'HANLON.
0:19 HE'S DIRECTOR OF RESEARCH FOR
0:20 THE FOREIGN POLICY PROGRAM AT
0:21 BROOKINGS. GOOD TO SEE YOU,
0:22 MICHAEL. WHAT KIND OF DEALS DO
0:24 YOU EXPECT ON THOSE FRONTS?
0:26 >> NOT HUGE. OBVIOUSLY, WE HAVE
0:29 THE NEED FOR AN EXTENSION OF
0:30 PREVIOUS UNDERSTANDINGS OF
0:33 LIMITING THE AMERICAN TARIFFS
0:34 AND PROLONGING OR CONTINUING
0:36 CHINA'S WILLINGNESS TO SEND US
0:38 RARE EARTH MAGNETS, AMONG OTHER
0:39 THINGS. AS YOU KNOW, THIS IS A
0:41 DELICATE GAME OF, YOU KNOW,
0:43 THREAT, COUNTER THREAT, BUT
0:44 BEING DONE WITH SMILEY FACES
0:46 AND BRO HUGS, AS WAS JUST
0:48 DESCRIBED. BUT NO ONE SHOULD
0:50 MISTAKE THAT. THERE'S OBVIOUSLY
0:51 VERY SERIOUS, YOU KNOW, MUTUAL
0:54 LEVERAGE HERE THAT'S BEING
0:55 APPLIED. AND THAT COULD BE
0:57 APPLIED MORE SEVERELY IN A LESS
0:58 FRIENDLY WAY IF THINGS WERE TO
1:00 GO SOUTH. AND WE ALSO HAVE, YOU
1:02 KNOW, THESE ARE ALSO BEING
1:04 EXTENDED MONTH BY MONTH, TWO
1:06 MONTHS BY TWO MONTHS. SO IT'S
1:08 SORT OF NECESSARY TO PUSH INTO
1:10 THE NEW YEAR. THAT'S WHY I
1:11 PREDICT THAT NOT BECAUSE I
1:12 EXPECT A BREAKTHROUGH OR A
1:13 FINAL RESOLUTION OF ANY KEY
1:15 UNDERLYING ECONOMIC OR
1:17 STRATEGIC ISSUES. BUT BECAUSE
1:19 THE ECONOMIC ISSUE REQUIRES
1:21 SOME ATTENTION RIGHT NOW.
1:22 >> WHAT DO YOU THINK IS GOING
1:24 TO HAPPEN WITH CHIPS AND VIDEOS
1:26 AND OTHERWISE?
1:27 >> I HOPE THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:29 HOLDS THE LINE. YOU KNOW, THE
1:30 UNITED STATES HAS A VERY STRONG
1:33 ADVANTAGE OVER CHINA IN
1:35 ADVANCED CHIPS IN CHIP MAKING
1:37 AND THE WESTERN WORLD WRIT
1:38 LARGE. OF COURSE, THE ADVANTAGE
1:39 IS REALLY QUITE IMPORTANT. I'M
1:41 NOT SAYING WE ALWAYS HAVE TO
1:42 BEAT CHINA TO EACH AND EVERY AI
1:45 APPLICATION, BUT GIVEN CHINA'S
1:46 AMBITIONS TO BRING TAIWAN BACK
1:48 INTO THE FOLD AND ITS
1:50 ASSERTIVENESS MILITARILY IN THE
1:51 WESTERN PACIFIC, IT WOULD BE
1:53 DANGEROUS FOR CHINA TO FEEL
1:55 THAT IT CAUGHT UP OR EVEN
1:56 GOTTEN AHEAD OF THE UNITED
1:57 STATES IN AI. SO I THINK IT'S
1:59 IMPORTANT THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP
2:00 TRY TO MAINTAIN THIS FRIENDLY
2:02 RAPPORT. I APPLAUD HIM FOR THAT.
2:03 I THINK IT'S GOOD THAT HE AND
2:05 XI JINPING GET ALONG WELL, AS
2:06 LONG AS IT DOESN'T LEAD TO A
2:08 SOFTENING IN SOME OF THE KEY
2:10 AREAS OF TECHNOLOGY CONTROLS,
2:11 WHERE I THINK IT'S CRUCIAL FOR
2:13 OUR NATIONAL SECURITY, THAT WE
2:14 STAY AHEAD.
2:15 >> DON'T THEY HAVE A LOT OF
2:16 LEVERAGE OVER US WITH RARE
2:18 EARTHS?
2:18 >> YES. AND THAT'S WHY THE
2:20 ECONOMIC AND TECHNOLOGY
2:22 CONSTRAINTS HAVE TO BE APPLIED
2:23 VERY CAREFULLY AND SELECTIVELY.
2:25 IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT WE SHOULD
2:27 BE SOMEHOW, YOU KNOW, TEARING
2:28 APART THE WHOLE RELATIONSHIP.
2:30 AND, YOU KNOW, THE WHOLE
2:32 RELATIONSHIP IS STILL VERY,
2:33 VERY INTENSE WITH A LOT OF
2:35 TRADE AND ESPECIALLY A LOT OF
2:37 CHINESE EXPORTS TO THE UNITED
2:38 STATES. AND SO IN THAT SENSE,
2:39 YOU KNOW, I THINK IT'S
2:41 IMPORTANT THAT WE STAY SPECIFIC
2:42 AND TARGETED IN THE TECHNOLOGY
2:44 CONTROLS. AND IT'S PRIMARILY ON
2:46 LITHOGRAPHY MACHINES USED TO
2:47 MAKE CHIPS, AS WELL AS THE HIGH
2:49 END CHIPS THEMSELVES. THAT
2:50 REALLY ENABLES US TO MAKE SURE
2:52 WE STAY AHEAD OF CHINA IN AI.
2:55 IT DOESN'T REALLY HOLD CHINA
2:56 BACK FROM A LOT OF GOOD AI
2:58 APPLICATIONS OR ECONOMIC GROWTH,
3:00 BUT IN NATIONAL SECURITY TERMS,
3:02 IT PREVENTS SORT OF A WINDOW OF
3:04 OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CHINESE,
3:05 WHERE THEY MIGHT FEEL THEY
3:06 COULD GET AWAY WITH AGGRESSION
3:07 IN THE WESTERN PACIFIC.
3:08 >> MEANWHILE, YOU SAW THE PRIME
3:10 MINISTER, MARK CARNEY, KIND OF
3:11 GRINNING THERE ABOUT HOW WELL
3:12 IT'S GOING WITH CHINA. I THINK
3:14 I HAVE HIS LANGUAGE, HE SAID. I
3:16 CAN REPORT THE TRADE
3:17 NEGOTIATIONS ARE GOING
3:18 EXCEPTIONALLY WELL. WE REACHED
3:19 AN AGREEMENT. WE REDUCED
3:20 TARIFFS ON OVER 90% OF TRADE
3:22 IRRITANTS. THEY'RE VERY
3:23 PROFESSIONAL. THEY'VE MOVED IN
3:24 A VERY LINEAR FASHION AND IT'S
3:26 ALL VERY RATIONAL MOVING
3:27 FORWARD. I MEAN, THOSE ARE AND
3:29 I BELIEVE THEY'RE GOING TO PUT
3:30 JUST A 6% TARIFF ON CHINESE EVS
3:33 NOW, WHICH I WOULD EXPECT TO BE
3:34 FLOODING CANADA. I DON'T KNOW
3:35 HOW IMPORTANT THAT IS TO OUR
3:37 MARKET, BUT WHERE DO YOU EXPECT
3:39 IT, THE TARIFFS BETWEEN THE
3:40 U.S. AND CHINA TO GO OR TO BE
3:43 COMING OUT OF THESE MEETINGS?
3:45 >> WELL, A COUPLE OF THINGS.
3:46 FIRST OF ALL, YOU KNOW, I'M
3:47 GLAD THAT THE CANADIANS ARE
3:49 BUYING A LOT OF CHINESE EVS,
3:50 BUT THERE IS A NATIONAL
3:52 SECURITY RISK BECAUSE THOSE ARE
3:53 ESSENTIALLY MOVING SENSOR
3:54 PLATFORMS IF THE CHINESE CHOOSE
3:56 TO USE THEM THAT WAY. I DON'T
3:58 WANT TO SOUND ALL PARANOID AND
4:00 ANTI-CHINESE, BUT BECAUSE OF
4:01 THE CIVIL MILITARY FUSION IN
4:03 CHINA, ANYTHING, THEY'RE
4:04 PRIVATE COMPANIES OR THEIR
4:05 STATE COMPANIES PRODUCE FOR
4:07 CIVILIAN MARKETS CAN BE
4:08 INFLUENCED BY MILITARY
4:10 CONSIDERATIONS AND INTELLIGENCE
4:11 GATHERING CONSIDERATIONS.
4:12 SECOND, AS MUCH AS I ADMIRE THE
4:14 CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER, HE
4:15 SHOULD KNOW THAT CHINA HAS BEEN
4:17 STEALING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
4:19 FROM THE WEST AND DELIBERATELY
4:21 UNDERSELLING WESTERN PRODUCERS
4:23 TO STEAL MARKET SHARE. HE
4:25 SOUNDED A LITTLE TOO FRIENDLY
4:26 FOR MY TASTE, I GOT TO TELL YOU.
4:28 IT'S JUST WE WE SHOULD TRY TO
4:30 GET ALONG WITH CHINA. WE SHOULD
4:31 BE BUSINESSLIKE, WE SHOULDN'T
4:32 BE CONFRONTATIONAL, BUT WE
4:34 SHOULD BE FIRM. AND WE SHOULD
4:35 UNDERSTAND THAT THE PROBLEM
4:36 THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP, IN HIS
4:38 OWN WAY, IS TRYING TO ADDRESS
4:40 IS REALLY OF CHINESE MAKING.
4:41 AND I DON'T APPROVE OF
4:43 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S TACTICS IN
4:44 MOST CASES. BUT AGAIN, I
4:45 WOULDN'T GO OUT OF MY WAY TO
4:47 COMPLIMENT THE CHINESE FOR
4:48 THEIR OVERALL ECONOMIC POLICY.
4:50 AND FOR THAT REASON, I THINK
4:52 THE UNITED STATES IS GOING TO
4:53 HAVE A FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT
4:54 APPROACH, WHETHER IT'S
4:55 PRESIDENT TRUMP OR HIS
Palo Alto Networks CEO offers his solution on tech outages full transcript
0:10 >> WELCOME BACK! YESTERDAY'S
0:11 TECH OUTAGES AT APPLE AND
0:13 MARRIOTT, TO NAME A FEW, ARE
0:14 JUST THE LATEST IN A STRING
0:16 UNITED AIRLINES, JP MORGAN EVEN
0:18 THE NSA HAS BEEN AFFECTED OVER
0:20 THE PAST WEEK, AND IT ALL COMES
0:21 AHEAD OF PALO ALTO'S EARNINGS
0:23 THIS AFTERNOON. AND THAT STOCK
0:24 AND A LOT OF THE CYBER STOCKS
0:26 ARE HIGHER TODAY. MACKENZIE
0:27 SIGALOS HAS THE KEY NUMBERS TO
0:28 WATCH FOR IN THAT REPORT.
0:30 FINALLY THE CYBER NAMES ARE
0:31 CATCHING A BID. YESTERDAY THEY
0:32 WERE SELLING OFF. AND NOW WE
0:34 SEE PALO ALTO NETWORKS POPPING
0:35 SOME 7%. AND I WILL SAY IN THE
0:37 FACE OF MULTIPLE OUTAGES OVER
0:38 THE PAST WEEK, NIKESH ARORA HAS
0:40 SAID THAT HE HAS A SOLUTION BUY
0:42 HIS PRODUCTS. SO THE CEO OF
0:44 PALO ALTO NETWORKS IS WARNING
0:45 THAT AI IS MAKING IT EASIER FOR
0:47 HACKERS TO TARGET MULTIPLE
0:49 COMPANIES AT ONCE. AND HIS
0:50 SOLUTION IS REAL TIME THREAT
0:52 DETECTION. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT
0:53 HIS COMPANY SELLS. SO TONIGHT
0:55 WE FIND OUT WHETHER CUSTOMERS
0:56 ARE BUYING IT. SO SHARES
0:58 SURGING AHEAD OF THE PRINT. BUT
1:00 AT MORE THAN 75 TIMES FORWARD
1:02 EARNINGS, EXPECTATIONS ARE HIGH,
1:04 ESPECIALLY AFTER MAKING WHAT
1:06 SOME $28 BILLION WORTH OF
1:08 ACQUISITIONS SINCE LAST YEAR.
1:10 THE KEY NUMBER TONIGHT IS NEXT
1:12 GENERATION SECURITY RECURRING
1:14 REVENUE. THAT INCLUDES ITS AI
1:16 PRODUCTS AND AGENTS THAT
1:17 AUTOMATE EVERYTHING FROM
1:18 DETECTING THREATS TO THEN
1:19 RESPONDING TO ATTACKS. MORGAN
1:21 STANLEY EXPECTS IT TO BEAT AT
1:23 THE HIGH END OF THE GUIDE AT
1:25 NEARLY $10 BILLION, RAISING THE
1:26 FULL YEAR OUTLOOK, THOUGH AFTER
1:27 JUST ONE QUARTER WOULD BE AN
1:29 ESPECIALLY BULLISH SIGNAL.
1:31 COMPANIES ARE ALSO MOVING AWAY
1:32 FROM THE PATCHWORK OF SECURITY
1:34 VENDORS TOWARD FEWER PROVIDERS,
1:35 AND KEYBANC EXPECTS SECURITY
1:37 BUDGETS TO GROW MORE THAN 20%
1:38 NEXT YEAR. WITH PALO ALTO
1:40 POSITIONED TO CAPTURE MORE OF
1:42 THAT SPENDING FROM SOME OF ITS
1:43 RIVALS. AND THEN THERE ARE
1:44 ALREADY SIGNS OF INCREASED
1:46 DEMAND. AND MORGAN STANLEY'S
1:47 LATEST SURVEY, MORE THAN HALF
1:48 OF RESELLERS PICKED PALO ALTO
1:50 AS THE TOP WINNER FROM THAT
1:52 SHIFT. BUT CORPORATE BUDGETS,
1:53 THEY MOVE SLOWLY. SO MUCH OF
1:54 THAT SPENDING MAY NOT SHOW UP
1:56 IN REVENUE FOR SEVERAL QUARTERS.
1:58 ALL RIGHT. WELL, I MEAN,
1:59 EXPECTATIONS ARE HIGH NOW. SO
2:00 BOTH FOR HIM AND IF HE WERE TO
2:02 LEAVE, I YOU KNOW, THIS IS I
2:04 DON'T THINK ANYBODY SERIOUSLY
2:06 THINKS THE CEO OF PALO ALTO IS
2:07 GOING TO BECOME THE NEXT CEO OF
2:08 NVIDIA. BUT AT THIS POINT, YOU
2:10 DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE COULD
2:11 HAPPEN. SO I GUESS SOME
2:12 REASSURANCE THAT THE BUSINESS
2:14 ITSELF IS STRONG AND THAT THEY
2:15 WILL BENEFIT AND NOT HAVE
2:16 CUSTOMERS SAYING, WHAT AM I
2:17 PAYING ALL THIS MONEY FOR
2:19 CYBERSECURITY IF IT CAN'T FEND
2:20 OFF THESE ATTACKS? AND THERE IS
2:22 THIS DYNAMIC WHERE YOU SEE A
2:23 LOT OF COMPANIES THAT ARE
2:24 PATCHING PROBLEMS THAT THEY
2:25 DIDN'T KNOW EXISTED, AND THEY
2:27 ARE SO ANXIOUS TO GO FROM
2:28 HAVING A DOZEN VENDORS AND
2:29 CONSOLIDATING DOWN TO A FEW.
2:30 AND THIS IS WHERE PALO ALTO
2:32 NETWORKS HAS AN ADVANTAGE. AND
2:34 YES, YOU HAVE NAMES LIKE A
2:35 GOOGLE THAT HAS MANDIANT UNDER
2:36 ITS UMBRELLA AND WIZ THAT IT
2:37 ACQUIRED. AND SO THEY HAVE
2:39 THESE CYBER DEFENSES. BUT YOU
2:40 ALSO HAVE COMPANIES THAT DON'T
2:41 WANT TO BE BEHOLDEN TO THEIR
2:43 ONE OF THEIR ONE OF THEIR CLOUD
2:45 LANDLORDS. AND SO THERE IS
2:46 SOMETHING BENEFICIAL TO HAVING
2:47 THIS, THIS THIRD PARTY THAT'S
2:48 MODEL AGNOSTIC, THAT'S ROUTING
2:49 TO EVEN OPEN SOURCE MODELS THAT
2:51 MIGHT BE MORE COST EFFECTIVE.
2:52 AND THIS NARRATIVE IS GREAT.
2:53 COMING OUT OF WASHINGTON, D.C.
2:55 YOU'VE GOT A LOT OF PEOPLE
2:56 TALKING ABOUT TRYING TO PUSH
2:57 FORWARD AI LEGISLATION THAT,
2:59 YOU KNOW, HISTORICALLY HAS BEEN
3:00 GOOD FOR THOSE CYBER DEFENDER
3:01 NAMES. YOU SEE MORE, YOU SEE
3:03 MORE REGULATION COME INTO THE
3:04 SPACE,
DHS Sec. Mullin and DNI Jay Clayton testify on worldwide threats at House hearing full transcript
4:35 It is a violation of House rules and the rules of this committee to engage
4:40 in personalities regarding other members or to question the motives of a colleague. Chair will
4:44 enforce these rules of decorum at all times and urges all members to be mindful
4:48 of their remarks. The witnesses are here this morning voluntarily and I would encourage my
4:52 colleagues to engage with them respectfully and productively on the topic of today's hearing. I
4:57 would also like to remind our guests that verbal outbursts are a violation of House
5:01 rules. Continued disruptions will result in law enforcement removing those responsible from the room. I
5:06 now recognize myself for an opening statement. Good morning and welcome to the Committee on
5:12 Homeland Security's annual hearing on worldwide threats. This year marks the 25th anniversary of the
5:17 September 11th terrorist attacks. That tragic day forever changed our understanding of the threats facing
5:22 our country and continues to guide our work today. Earlier this year, I led a
5:28 bipartisan delegation to Ground Zero to commemorate this anniversary. meeting with the families and
5:33 first responders who gather each year is a powerful reminder of why we must never
5:38 forget and the importance of our work to secure the homeland. So the Homeland Security
5:43 professionals who work every day to keep us safe, we commend you and thank you
5:48 for your service. Our witnesses today are Department of Homeland Security Secretary Mark Wayne Mullen,
5:53 Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, and FBI Deputy Director Chris Ferreira. Thank you all
5:58 for being here and for your service. Committee has consistently held this annual hearing with
6:04 the same panel of witnesses for over a decade. The DHS secretary, the FBI director,
6:09 and National Counterterrorism Center director. Mr. Joseph Wierski, who has been serving as acting director
6:13 of the National Counterterrorism Center, was scheduled to appear today, but he was formally nominated
6:18 to the director role by the president only a few days ago. Committee has made
6:23 an exception and waived his participation this year, given his confirmation hearing before the Senate
6:28 Intelligence Committee this afternoon. We look forward to continued collaboration with Ms. Zawierski following his
6:33 confirmation. We are very pleased that Director Clayton was able to attend today to ensure
6:38 strong intelligence community representation. We appreciate him offering his insights and expertise on this important
6:43 topic. I am disappointed that Director Patel chose not to appear before the committee today.
6:48 Today's hearing date was first provided to Director Patel in August. There was no surprise
6:53 or last minute request and despite repeated attempts over the span of several months between
6:58 then and now to find any date when he could testify, the director made clear
7:03 that he had no intention of appearing. Director Patel's refusal to testify marks a significant
7:07 departure from well established committee precedent. Both the director Patel's immediate predecessors participate in this
7:12 hearing several times. Christopher Ray, for example, appeared before this committee for this annual hearing
7:17 six times during his tenure. Last year, an exception was made for the FBI director
7:22 to offer an alternative FBI witness to participate in this annual hearing. Given the separate
7:27 challenges, the committee experience was securing the availability for former Secretary Noem. However, the committee
7:31 has been clear in its direct communications to the FBI and through its historical record
7:36 that this is a hearing where the FBI director is expected to participate on behalf
7:40 of the Bureau. Our focus on world-wide threats transcends politics, and the director should be
7:45 here to brief Congress. I do want to thank Deputy Director Rea for
7:50 being here. It is very important that you're here and I appreciate your testimony
7:56 today. Since becoming chairman, I have made congressional oversight a priority. Once it was
8:02 clear that Director Patel would not be attending, the committee decided to allow Deputy
8:08 Director to participate so members could ask the Bureau some questions. To be clear,
8:14 the committee's issues are not with Deputy Director Rea and I thank you for
8:20 your years of service also to the FBI as well as with our national
8:26 security. Since becoming chairman, the committee has received testimony from well over a dozen administration
8:31 officials from across the department, including leadership at CBP, TSA, ICE, CISA, USCIS, the Coast
8:37 Guard, and more. Today's hearing gives Congress and the American people an opportunity to directly
8:42 hear from those responsible for our security about the threats we face and the resources
8:47 needed to address them. In the aftermath of 9/11, our mission and mandate was clear:
8:52 prevent another terrorist attack on American soil. 25 years later, the threats to our
8:58 homeland have grown more complex. Cyber attacks, emerging technologies, foreign adversaries, and transnational criminal
9:04 organizations have fundamentally changed the security landscape. Border security has also become a major
9:09 national security priority. Over the last two years, the Trump administration has established an
9:15 incredible record of success in strengthening border security, dismantling transnational criminal organizations, disrupting the trafficking
9:20 of illicit drugs, and keeping the American people safe, all of which was bolstered by
9:26 generational investments made by congressional Republicans to reconciliation. Despite these successes, our work is far
9:31 from over. We must continue adapting to emerging threats and stay ahead of our adversaries.
9:37 Foreign terrorist organizations continue to encourage attacks against the United States, while China, Russia, Iran,
9:43 and North Korea pose serious threats to our government and critical infrastructure. As artificial intelligence
9:49 advances, so do threats posed by malicious actors. We must ensure our cyber defenders have
9:55 the tools and capabilities to keep pace with increasingly sophisticated attacks. Just last week, disruptions
10:01 from email to airline travel. While there is no indication that these incidents were caused
10:07 by cyber attacks, they underscore the importance of securing our networks and strengthening their resilience.
10:12 Ahead of this summer's FIFA World Cup, this committee worked with Congress and the Trump
10:17 administration to enact the Safer Skies Act, allowing trained and certified state and local law
10:22 enforcement to conduct counter drone operations for the first time. The World Cup and America
10:28 250 celebrations presented significant security challenges, and I commend all of our witnesses for their
10:33 leadership in securing these events. Our committee's special task force, special events task force spearheaded
10:37 by the former chairman of this committee, Congressman McCall, took the lead on those important
10:42 engagements and oversight work throughout this Congress. On that topic, I do want to take
10:47 this opportunity to recognize former Chairman McCall for his leadership and steadfast service on this
10:51 committee and his commitment to national security and public safety over his entire career. and
10:56 it will be missed by this body when he retires at the end of this
11:00 congress as we look ahead to next congress i remain committed to working with all
11:04 my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to advance priorities that will ensure that
11:09 dhs has the resources authorities and personnel needed to carry out its no-fail mission to
11:13 be clear there will be policy disagreements as there always are committee republicans will continue
11:17 to support dhs and all of our law enforcement partners that said this committee has
11:21 proven over the years that despite political differences we can still work together when it
11:25 comes to our shared goal of protecting the american people I look forward to continuing
11:30 that partnership in the years ahead, and I once again thank our witnesses for their
11:36 participation here today and their dedication to public safety. I now recognize the ranking member
11:42 of the gentleman from Mississippi, Mr. Thompson, for his opening statement. Thank you very much,
11:47 Mr. Chairman. Good morning. I welcome our witnesses and colleagues to the committee's annual hearing
11:53 on worldwide threats to the homeland. Let me indicate that my Democratic colleagues at
11:59 a caucus meeting since we were not in charge. We couldn't postpone
12:04 this hearing like we did last week. I'm okay with postponing it.
12:10 We understand. So we'll go forward. Elections are going on as we
12:16 speak. I appreciate the chairman holding the hearing for this committee. It
12:21 marks the 25th anniversary of the September 11th attack this year.
12:27 So much has changed since 9/11 and the Department of Homeland Security
12:33 was established to prevent another large-scale terrorist attack on American soil.
12:39 Unfortunately, under President Trump, administration officials have weaponized DHS to carry
12:45 out the president's extreme political agenda and use their official positions
12:50 to enrich themselves and their friends. In doing so, they've taken
12:56 DHS away from its original mission and made our country less
13:01 safe. For many years, these worldwide threats hearings provided Congress and
13:07 the public with an opportunity to hear directly from the Secretary of
13:13 Homeland Security, FBI Director, and National Counterterrorism Center Director about the threats
13:19 facing our nation. I support the Chairman's concern that the FBI Director
13:24 is not here at this hearing and is so unfortunate. notwithstanding
13:30 the current FBI witness. However, only one of those witnesses is here
13:36 for this hearing today. I'm glad Secretary Mullen is here because we've
13:42 many questions for him about how the president has turned the department
13:48 against the American people and used it as a personal political cajole.
13:54 I also want to thank and ask the Secretary about the Department's
14:00 failure to respond to democratic oversight inquiries. Dozens of our oversight letters
14:06 have gone unanswered despite our legitimate, legislative need for this information. After
14:12 the recent election, Secretary Mullins reached out to me for the first
14:18 time since his confirmation nearly eight months ago. While I appreciate your
14:24 very belated gesture, Mr. Secretary, what I need you to do is please answer
14:30 the letters that we've provided your office with, and I know you have a
14:36 response, and we'll talk about that. I hope you'll commit today to providing the
14:41 information and documents we requested without further delay. Our oversight is critical
14:47 because even 25 years after 9/11, threats to the homeland persist.
14:53 Over the past week alone, We've seen a major outage at
14:59 Microsoft, an FAA outage that resulted in a nationwide ground stop, and
15:05 outages at major banks. Whatever the cause, Americans are looking to the
15:10 administration for answers and assurances that the critical infrastructure they rely on
15:16 every day is safe. They haven't forgotten it. Instead, the president responded
15:22 to the ground stop saying, I don't take any responsibility.
15:28 Secretary Mullen, you went on TV to make statements and
15:34 offer hunches based on evidence or formal reviews, but on
15:40 conversations you've had with people you refuse to name. Speaking
15:46 about the administration's handling of the situation, you said, and
15:51 I quote, this is what the leadership of President Trump
15:57 looks like. Thank you. On that, we agree, Mr. Secretary. The
16:03 so-called leadership of the Trump administration consists of refusing to take responsibility, shifting
16:09 blame to the others, and putting your own interests above the country. While
16:15 Americans were stranded in airports across the country, with many sleeping on the
16:21 floor at their gates, the Secretary boarded a luxury jet flew to
16:27 a college football game and visited the private suite of a company
16:33 that DHS had awarded a $2.2 billion contract. For the Secretary of
16:39 Homeland Security to do that during a crisis was not only irresponsible,
16:45 Mr. Secretary, but also incredibly tone deaf. Meanwhile, President Trump's reckless war
16:51 on choice with Iran has been escalating Reports of Iran developing
16:56 plans to detonate a dirty bomb in the nation's capital are alarming, and
17:02 the public needs to be able to trust that their government is focused
17:08 on keeping them safe instead of living large on the taxpayers' dime.
17:14 These are serious issues, and American people deserve to have serious people solve them. Frankly,
17:20 I do not believe that person is you, Mr. Secretary, but in just a few
17:26 short months, the committee is going to make sure that you do the job you've
17:31 been hired to do. If not, you'll need to go away of your predecessors. But
17:37 at least you showed up. which is more than I can say for
17:43 FBI Director Kash Patel, who has again declined to testify at this hearing. For
17:49 over a decade, FBI directors on the administrations of both parties appeared before this
17:54 committee to give their assessment of threats to the homeland. While I appreciate
18:00 the Director of National Intelligence was added to the panel late
18:06 yesterday, Director Patel's absence for a second consecutive year limits the
18:12 committee's ability to conduct effective oversight at this hearing. Director Patel
18:18 is shirking his responsibility to appear before this committee just
18:23 as he has shirked his responsibilities leading the nation's premier federal
18:29 law enforcement agency, allegedly drinking so much that he's been unable
18:35 or difficult for staff to wake him up even during high-profile
18:41 terrorist incidents and investigations. Mr. Chairman, you should take it as
18:46 an affront that the director finds time to spend taxpayers' dollars flying
18:52 to his girlfriend's concert go VIP snorkeling at a Pearl
18:58 Harbor Memorial site, celebrate with hockey teams, and intimidate
19:03 journalists for reporting what he doesn't like, but has
19:09 no time to testify before this committee. He also
19:14 answered, he also hasn't answered our oversight letters. Committee
19:20 Democrats have sent six letters to the director over the
19:26 last year and a half with no substantive replies. Those
19:32 letters include questions about the scaling back of FBI counterintelligence
19:38 activities and investigations into government corruption and domestic terrorism.
19:44 Also, nearly a year ago, we requested a briefing from
19:49 FBI and DOJ on their implementation of President Trump's National
19:55 Security Presidential Memorandum 7, countering domestic terrorism and organized political
20:01 violence. This memorandum drastically redefines what domestic terrorism is in
20:07 order to justify the Trump's administration's effort to stifle dissent and
20:13 investigate anyone or any group they don't like. In July, at
20:19 a classified briefing, an FBI counterterrorism official told members that they
20:25 would be briefing the committee, quote, "soon." My staff has followed
20:30 up on more than a dozen occasions and last month I sent a
20:36 letter to Attorney General Todd Blanch and Director Patel demanding the promised briefing.
20:42 Still not a peep from either agency in response. If there is nothing
20:48 illegal or improper about what the agencies are doing, then there should be
20:53 no problem being forthcoming with the committee and the public. Their silence
20:59 speaks volumes, but it's no surprise. The Trump administration's agenda for
21:05 the last two years has been weaponize the government, politicize DHS,
21:11 shift the blame, line their own pockets, ignore oversight. Congressional Republicans
21:17 have let this outrageous behavior go on unchecked. But the administration's
21:23 free pass is about to come to an end. Earlier
21:28 this month, the American people overwhelmingly voted for accountability for an end
21:34 to the Trump administration's chaos, violence, and vitriol for a government that
21:40 works for the American people rather than for special interests, for Congress
21:46 to use its authority to conduct oversight of an administration that has
21:51 rejected the rule of law. Come January, this is what Democrats
21:57 intend to deliver for our constituents and for the country: accountability. Mr.
22:03 Secretary, we look forward to receiving the responses you owe this committee
22:09 so that we can do our legislative work and to having you
22:15 before us early next year. Accountability is coming. Mr. Chairman, in
22:20 closing, I want to thank members who will not be returning next
22:26 Congress for their service. To Representative Thanahar, Goldman, Johnson, and Green, your
22:32 work on this committee has helped secure the homeland, uphold our values,
22:38 and hold this administration accountable. We look forward to following your contributions
22:43 to this great country going forward. I'd also like to indicate that
22:50 Mr. Correa has a health situation he's dealing with and that's why he's not with
22:55 us today. So Mr. Chair, thank you and I yield back. Thank you and we
23:01 all wish Mr. Correa a speedy recovery. He's a great asset to this committee. Other
23:06 members of the committee are reminded that opening statements may be submitted for the record.
23:12 I would like to now formally introduce our witnesses. First is the Honorable Mark Wayne
23:18 Mullen. He serves as Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security. Prior to his appointment,
23:23 Secretary Mullins served in both the United States Senate and House of Representatives representing the
23:28 state of Oklahoma. Second is the Honorable Jay Clayton. He's the Director of National Intelligence.
23:32 Prior to his appointment, Director Clayton served as United States Attorney for the Southern District
23:37 of New York, as well as the former Chair of the U.S. Securities and Exchange
23:42 Commission. Third is Mr. Christopher Rea. He's the Deputy Director of the Federal Bureau of
23:46 Investigation. Mr. Rea previously served as Assistant Director of the FBI's New York Field Office.
23:51 thank all the witnesses for being here today pursuant to committee rule 8c i ask
23:57 that the witnesses please rise and raise their right hand do you solemnly swear that
24:02 the testimony you will give before the committee on homeland security of the united states
24:08 house of representatives will be the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth
24:13 so help you god let the record reflect that the witnesses have answered in the
24:18 affirmative please be seated i now recognize secretary mullen for five minutes to summarize his
24:24 opening statement Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Ranking Member Thompson, for this hearing today. I
24:30 will address some of the stuff that Ranking Member Thompson threw out. I want to
24:36 say this right off the top. I have the utmost respect for the 270,000 employees
24:41 that work inside DHS. Our mission is awesome. We get to protect the homeland. And
24:47 as Mr. Thompson had alluded to earlier, our creation was to keep mass terrorist attacks
24:53 from taking place in the United States. We've done that for 26 years successfully. Even
24:59 though I've only been part of it for 239 days, it is something that I
25:04 take as a great honor to be part of. I also like to deal in
25:09 facts. I believe that this committee has an oversight job and I believe in that
25:14 with all my heart. I served in the House, I served in the Senate, and
25:18 I believe Congress does have a role and I want you guys to have a
25:22 role. But we need to deal with facts and not make political points. Unfortunately, Ranking
25:26 Member Thompson, I did reach out to you in good faith. I wanted to have
25:31 a good conversation with you and in 15 seconds, unfortunately, you came after me and
25:35 I And I said, sir, I was just reaching out to make contact with you.
25:40 You said, I've reached out to you multiple times and you haven't responded once. And
25:46 we went back and looked. And as of today, Congress, the House has been in
25:51 61 days. Out of 61 days that you've been in session, 36 letters have been
25:57 signed and sent to me by your office. We responded to 21 of those letters.
26:02 That's more than every other day. We're trying to do our job. We're trying to
26:08 respond, and we want to be respectful to that. But when you come in here
26:12 and you start making political points by holding up posters that are completely inaccurate, one
26:17 being the statement that I made about President Trump's leadership team. As you know, if
26:21 you listened to the hearing you would have saw, or the interview you would have
26:26 saw, that I was referring to the fact that we had a complete ground stoppage.
26:31 And within a matter of hours, we had the airspace back open. We had an
26:36 issue with old technology and FAA. The president assembled the team. The whole of government
26:40 went to work, every aspect of it. There wasn't one cabinet member that had jurisdiction
26:45 or had direct contact with this that wasn't involved. And we were able to put
26:50 the planes back in the air safely. We landed over 4,000 planes when the
26:56 ground stoppage went out because of the communication and didn't have one single incident.
27:01 That in itself is a great success. And then you want to bring up the
27:07 fact that I took my family and my great nieces to an LSU game that
27:11 was scheduled for weeks prior to that because I wanted to be a good uncle
27:14 and take my little niece who has never been to an LSU game and she's
27:18 a huge LSU fan to a game. We had discussions at 10 o'clock Saturday morning
27:23 Should we cancel it? We had deep conversations about it. And it came in that
27:27 if we cancel something with the airspace was completely open, it could bring confusion because
27:32 I was meeting the governor there, I was meeting other people there, that would show
27:37 maybe distrust that we're not even willing to fly. There was a lot of stuff
27:42 going on in the news saying, is it safe to fly? We were saying our
27:48 skies are completely open. On Saturday alone, 36,000 planes flew and flew safely. Before I
27:53 took off, the airspace had been open for almost 24 hours. I paid because when
27:59 I travel on a personal business, not official business, even though I'm required, and you
28:04 know that, Mr. Thompson, to take the the government supplied plane because of the continuity
28:09 requirement I have and be in communication 24/7 365 days it's been 239 days and
28:14 there hasn't been a single day off I'm required to take the plane I'm also
28:18 required to reimburse the government for that which I did I'm also required to pay
28:23 for the tickets to which I did but the hypocrisy from you and from the
28:28 members that want to make a big deal out of it I go wait a
28:33 second I know this game I said over there You guys would have done the
28:38 same thing, but you would have called it a campaign event. You would have paid
28:42 for it with your campaign funds, or you would have reached out to the state
28:47 university and got the tickets for free. You know that. Your colleagues know that. And
28:51 you guys would have went to the same suite, and this person would have donated
28:56 to your campaign, and you would have said, it's a campaign event, yet you have
29:00 oversight of them. The gentleman I went into a suite, I didn't reach out to
29:05 him for the tickets. I reached out to the state for the tickets, tell them
29:10 we're going to reimburse. They put us in the suite. I'd never met the company.
29:14 I'd never met the team or the gentleman. I'd never had a conversation with them.
29:18 They've been doing business with the United States Coast Guard for 40 years, well before
29:23 DHS was even stood up. And yet there's some type of funny business going on
29:27 here. But you guys call it campaign related. I paid for it personally. This hypocrisy
29:32 has got to stop if you actually want to look at oversight. I'm willing to
29:38 work with everybody. I have nothing to keep from you. I want you to do
29:44 your job, but I'm not playing games. Thank you, Secretary Mullen. I now recognize Director
29:50 Clayton for five minutes to summarize his opening statement. Good morning, Chairman, Ranking Member, members
29:56 of the committee. Thank you for having me here today. Like this committee, the agency
30:02 I lead, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, was established after September 11th.
30:08 Congress created the ODNI out of the lessons learned from that tragedy
30:14 to strengthen our nation's security by improving integration across the intelligence community.
30:19 The dedicated women and men of ODNI remain committed to that mission
30:25 today, and I am proud to work with them. Twenty-five years after
30:31 9/11, the United States continues to face a heightened threat environment, both
30:36 in the homeland and to our interests abroad. While I cannot get
30:42 into any classified details of the threats here today, those threats have been fully briefed
30:47 to the Gang of Eight and the Intelligence Committees. I may pause in my responses
30:52 to your questions because I want to be able to give you as much information
30:57 as possible, but you must understand that some of the information I have is not
31:02 appropriate for this setting. I'm going to address a few key threats we are seeing
31:08 around the world that are relevant to this committee. Terrorism, Iranian lethal plotting and
31:13 cyber attacks. I'll start with terrorism. Our NCTC Director Wierski, as the
31:19 chairman mentioned, typically testifies at these hearings. He has been nominated for
31:25 Senate confirmation for that position. I'm proud of the women and men
31:31 that he leads who work 24/7 watching out for the homeland, watching
31:37 around the world to prevent another 9/11. Post 9/11,
31:42 the work of NCTC and the rest of the Intelligence Committee,
31:48 along with the agencies we interact with, has degraded the capabilities
31:53 of global terrorist organizations. We've improved our ability to detect and
31:59 disrupt terrorist plots, and we have implemented defensive measures that deter
32:04 terrorist aspirations. Nevertheless, a diverse range of terrorist actors, from individuals
32:10 inspired by ISIS and al-Qaeda to networks enabled or exploited by
32:16 adversarial states pose a persistent and evolving threat to American
32:21 lives. Next, I want to briefly discuss the threat from
32:27 Iran. We remain committed to detecting, deterring, and combating the
32:33 Iranian lethal plotting outside the United States and inside the
32:38 United States. These threats have substantially increased. Our women and
32:44 men abroad, our women and men here in the United
32:50 States, are under greater threat. But based on what we know today,
32:56 after a great deal of digital diligence, these are separate service outages associated
33:01 with maintenance and technical changes. They are not a coordinated or state sponsored
33:07 attack. The intelligence community continues to monitor and stay alert to any possibility
33:12 of malicious cyber activity threatening the U. S networks and our law enforcement
33:18 partners. Let me note that superintelligence
33:24 is reshaping the cybersecurity landscape. It is sharply increasing speed, scale, and
33:30 sophistication of offensive and defensive cyber operations. And it's not just cyber.
33:35 This goes to national security, it goes to the battlefield, and it
33:41 goes to commerce. Superintelligence is changing the way we do business, the
33:46 way we fight wars, and the way we combat terrorism every day.
33:53 In closing, I want to say that the threats I just discussed represent a small
33:59 sliver of the threats facing our nation. But it is clear that our foreign adversaries
34:05 are more sophisticated and more determined than ever to bring harm to the American people
34:10 and our way of life. I want to mention FISA 702. It should not expire.
34:16 It is the single most indispensable tool we have to protect both Americans in the
34:22 homeland and our troops abroad. This is the same authority that we rely
34:28 on to provide early warnings to this body of foreign threats, members of the administration,
34:34 and members of Congress. No other program can replicate the speed and effectiveness of FISA
34:39 702. Letting it expire would simply be a mistake. Thank you for having me here
34:45 today. Thank you, Director Clayton. I now recognize Deputy Director Rea for five minutes to
34:51 summarize his opening statement. Chairman Gaborino, Ranking Member Thompson, and members of the community, first
34:57 of all, thank you for allowing me the opportunity to appear before you today. But
35:02 probably more importantly, let me take this opportunity to thank you for just your service
35:06 in general to our country, not only as a member of Congress, but as a
35:11 member of this committee. Obviously, it's no secret the threats facing our nation are more
35:16 complex, they're more interconnected, and they're more global than ever before. from foreign terrorist organizations
35:22 and hostile intelligence services to transnational criminal networks and cyber criminals
35:28 operating across borders and adversaries that are constantly adapting. But the
35:33 FBI is meeting those threats head on. We are delivering delivering
35:39 historical operational results and remain focused on our most important mission,
35:45 protecting the United States of American citizens. Counterterrorism remains
35:50 one of our highest priorities. The threat from foreign terrorist organizations,
35:56 homegrown violent extremists, and individuals inspired by extremist ideologies continues to
36:02 evolve. In the past 21 months, the FBI has arrested nearly
36:08 1,300 terrorists, conducted over 1,300 counterterrorism disruptions, and seized 430 illegal
36:14 firearms in counterterrorism investigations. Just last week, a joint investigation by
36:20 FBI New York and Washington field offices resulted in the indictment against three
36:26 Iranian-backed operatives for their alleged involvement in nearly 20 terrorist attacks and attempted
36:32 attacks across Europe and the United States. That includes an alleged plot targeting
36:38 a base housing our American military personnel. Unfortunately, these threats do
36:44 not stop at our borders. Neither does our mission to identify, disrupt, and
36:49 dismantle the networks behind them. We're also aggressively confronting foreign intelligence threats.
36:55 Our counterintelligence efforts have resulted in 167 arrests. That's
37:01 a 53% increase in the previous 21 months and
37:06 499 disruptions targeting espionage and other foreign hostile activities.
37:13 In cyberspace, our adversaries are exploiting emerging technologies, cryptocurrency,
37:18 and international networks to target American businesses, critical infrastructure,
37:24 and hardworking American families. Our Cyber Division has delivered
37:29 557 disruptions, 368 arrests, and 544 indictments, while seizing
37:35 more than $278 million in cyber criminal funds.
37:41 Perhaps most importantly and impressively, we're seeing extraordinary results through Operation Blackout. This
37:47 is the FBI's global mission to disrupt, dismantle, and demolish cyber scan compounds
37:53 around the world. This operation has led to more than 17 billion, billion
37:59 with a B, in seizures, hundreds of arrests, and thousands of trafficked workers
38:05 freed. We've also presented more than prevented more than 11,000 Americans from losing
38:10 625 million in cyber enabled fraud schemes. These aren't just numbers. These are Americans whose
38:16 savings, livelihoods and futures we protected. And we're not slowing down anytime soon. We're expanding
38:22 our international partnerships and taking to the fight directly to the criminal organizations responsible.
38:28 Our national security mission goes hand in hand with our responsibility to keep American communities
38:33 safe. Nationwide, as you all are familiar, the murder rate has decreased nearly 30 points
38:39 in the last 21 months, and the FBI, along with our state, local, and federal
38:44 partners, has contributed to that progress. We made more than 71,600 violent crime
38:49 arrests, seized more than 4,600 kilograms of fentanyl, and that's enough lethal
38:55 doses to kill 350 million Americans. And just last week, I joined
39:01 our Justice Department international partners to announce the results of Operation Tornado,
39:06 the largest coordinated enforcement action ever conducted under our Joint Criminal Opioid
39:12 and Darknet Enforcement Initiative. That operation resulted in 354 arrests, 5.7
39:18 metric tons of drugs seized, 209 legal firearms seized, and 230
39:23 million in cryptocurrency and illegal proceeds. I'll close with FISA 702
39:29 like DNI Clayton did. This remains one of our most important national
39:35 security tools, allowing us under statutory safeguards and recent reforms that we have
39:41 made to collect critical foreign intelligence targeting non U. S. Persons located overseas.
39:47 That's why the FBI fully supports President Trump's request for reauthorization of FISA Section
39:53 702. Members of the committee, the threats facing our country are real and our
39:58 adversaries are relentless. But so are the men and women of the FBI. Thank
40:04 you. Thank you deputy director members will be recognized by order of seniority for their
40:10 5 minutes of questioning as a reminder. I will be strictly keeping to the 5
40:15 minute rule to ensure all members have the adequate time to ask questions of today's
40:19 panel. I now recognize myself for 5 minutes of questions. Secretary mullen. Thank you for
40:24 being here and I want to thank you. Your. Your work as head of the
40:29 Homeland Department since you took over and I've only been chair for over a year
40:33 now. It's night and day compared to how this committee was treated previously and I
40:38 want to thank you. The you have your department. You oversee a lot of different
40:42 things and it's a very best department. You very important job and. I believe our
40:47 partnership, I see it as a partnership. We've worked together in a lot of things.
40:52 I want to thank you for that. I'll start talking about my favorite subject, which
40:57 is CISA. And when you were back, when you were here in June, you testified
41:01 that CISA needed roughly 600 new hires. In September, CISA's acting director stated about 250
41:07 selected candidates were still waiting on security clearances before they could start work. Can you
41:12 provide us an update on how many employees have actually started CISA since June and
41:17 how many remain in the clearance process and when the agency will be at the
41:23 level that you have said it needs to be at to fulfill its mission? Thank
41:29 you, Chairman. I don't have those numbers with me right now. I'll have to get
41:33 back to you on those, which we'll be happy to do that. I will tell
41:38 you that we're able to meet our mission right now because of new technology that
41:42 has come in. Our CISA director, we hope, will be confirmed. Our incoming CISA director,
41:47 hopefully, will be confirmed before the Senate leaves. I believe it's on track to do
41:51 that. Our mission is broad. And we constantly meet threats and work with threats, work
41:57 with industries. Anytime they asked for assistance, were able to respond during FIFA. You saw
42:03 Cisa was able to stand up information centers, knocks all across the United States, work
42:08 with 11 cities, work with municipalities, federal, state and local. We were able to coordinate
42:14 and it all came through Cisa. We had one incident in Miami that happened
42:19 about 4 o'clock in the morning. Because of CISA's coordination with the local municipality
42:25 in Miami, we were able to locate the threat and I don't want to
42:31 say eliminate because that sounds like we took somebody out. We were able to
42:36 neutralize what the threat was. And it wouldn't have been possible without CISA recognizing
42:42 the traffic online to be able to see it. I need to go back to
42:48 FISA 702. That played a critical role at that time. When we deal with
42:53 real threats, which we deal with every single day in CISA and all throughout
42:59 our other 21 components, every minute counts. And we have a partnership that we
43:05 work closely with DNI where we have INA that is embedded with them every
43:10 day. FBI, we work with them every single day. And without Pfizer 702, we
43:16 go from being able to do things in minutes or hours into days or
43:22 weeks. That is a danger to the American people. They're real threats, there's real
43:28 bad actors, and they move at the speed of light today. um and i
43:33 i can't say this enough sysad plays a critical role in everything we do because
43:39 almost all communications uh all traffic we see goes through a device and without sysad
43:45 being able to be there to meet the need it's it's it's we would we'd
43:51 be dark And I'll say this one more time, too, Chairman. We're able to meet
43:56 those needs today, but we want to grow our capacity and be able to do
44:01 that. It does take time. But it also takes a long time to get people
44:05 cleared to have a TSSCI and above level. Not everybody can pass those background checks.
44:09 No, absolutely. And we have to work with industry because our pay scale is much
44:14 lower than what the industry is paying. Thank you very much. And if you can,
44:18 if you can have your team get back to us on those numbers and where
44:22 they are, we will turn as well as I hope and I'm sure they're already
44:27 looking at it with the rise in AI developed attacks, hiring those personnel that had
44:31 that expertise and not being stuck in the positions that existed as they were before.
44:35 In my 45 seconds left, Director Clayton, you ended your statement by talking about
44:41 why FISA 702 cannot fully expire. Can you please, just in 40 seconds, I'm
44:46 going to cut myself off, talk about that. What we do every day is
44:52 protect the American people from foreign threats. FISA 702 allows us to collect on
44:58 foreign actors outside the United States who are looking to do us harm here
45:04 at home. That collection is done in a way that is extremely protective
45:09 of the rights and interests of U.S. citizens. It is a collection that we are
45:15 very proud of, and I'll just give you one stat. Over 60% of the critical
45:21 information in the President's Daily Brief comes from the FISA 702 collection. Thank you very
45:26 much. I now recognize the Ranking Member for five minutes of questions. Thank you very
45:32 much, Mr. Chairman. Deputy Director
45:37 Redd, can you, for the committee, name
45:43 the FBI's listing of the most dangerous
45:48 domestic terrorist organizations? I think, Ranking Member,
45:54 I think that is a very nuanced question. I think all terrorist organizations are dangerous.
46:00 I think that ebbs and flows as well as current events pass. I will tell
46:06 you on my end, probably the single most thing that keeps me up night as
46:12 the Deputy Director is the threat from homegrown violent extremism. Uh, that is something as
46:17 we've seen some of these attacks land in the last several years, they have been,
46:23 they have been from the homegrown violent extremists. These are the loan offenders. They get
46:28 radicalized on largely online. They don't even meet a terrorist face to face. Um, makes
46:34 it very difficult to infiltrate them, whether it's so your testimonies that lone wolves, part
46:39 of that domestic terrorist threat. Yes, sir. The homegrown violent extremists. So are there any
46:44 organized organizations to your knowledge? That would fit that domestic terrorist. Oh, for domestic for
46:49 domestic terrorism. So so we look at domestic terrorism under three prongs in the FBI
46:54 in order to predicate a case. There's three things that have to be present. One,
46:58 there has to be an alleged violation of a federal criminal law. There has to
47:02 be some sort of use of violence or threat of use of violence. And there
47:07 has to be an ideology. When those three things exist and that ideology, no matter
47:12 how grotesque or no matter how heinous, for example, think 764 nihilistic violent extremists, when
47:17 those three things are in place, then we properly predicate a domestic terrorist. Can you
47:23 give me three of those organizations that meet that test right now? I would
47:29 say 764. I would also say Antifa off the top of my
47:34 head, those two organizations. But again, we don't deal in the organizations
47:40 when we're predicating those cases. We use those three prongs to predicate
47:46 domestic terrorism. Well, help me out. Are any right-wing organizations in this
47:51 country that meet that test? Yes, sir. Please name one. Yes. Again,
47:57 the organization itself, I don't want to go, I don't want to
48:02 paint a broad brush here. There are right-wing organizations, right-wing first protected organizations,
48:08 just like there's left-wing first protected organizations that have people seeded into those
48:14 organizations that meet those three prongs. Just name me one. Just name me
48:20 one. As a domestic terrorism organization? Right. There isn't There's no right-wing organization,
48:26 to your knowledge, in this country that meets the domestic terrorist threat. There are people
48:32 inside of right-wing organizations, just like there are people inside of left-wing organizations, that meet
48:37 those three prongs to predicate a lawfully- I'm just trying to come up with a
48:43 name of an organization. If you're saying that organization doesn't exist, then just please say
48:49 that. Again, we don't deal in the organizations. We deal in the people
48:55 in those organizations. But you said Antifa. That is an organization that has
49:00 been designated by the President of the United States as a domestic terrorist organization. No,
49:06 I'm asking for the FBI's designation, not the President's. We don't designate terrorist organizations. We
49:12 open domestic terrorism cases based on those three prongs. Thank you so much. Are you
49:18 aware of any instance where the President has directed the FBI to investigate or not
49:24 investigate anyone? Absolutely not. So when it comes to investigation into Tom
49:29 Holman taking a $50,000 bribe, was the FBI directed by the president or
49:35 anyone else to drop the investigation? Our job as an investigative agency
49:41 is to gather facts, whether it's Tom Holman or any other subject. We gather facts.
49:46 We put together investigative reports. Did you do it? Did you do it? Did you
49:50 do it? I'm not going to comment on the existence of an investigation or not
49:55 existing investigation. It would be inappropriate. Mr. Chairman, I ask unanimous consent to enter into
50:00 the record. A whistleblower disclosure that alleges that the president and DOJ directed
50:06 the FBI Los Angeles field office to open an investigation into ICE
50:11 and CBP protesters demonstrating at federal buildings in Los Angeles. That objection.
50:17 I yield back. Right. Member yields back. I now recognize the former
50:23 chairman of this committee, gentleman from Texas, Mr. McCall, for five minutes
50:28 of questions. Thanks, Chairman. And this will be my final question. hearing
50:34 after 22 years of service in Congress and on this committee and as
50:40 chairman of this committee. Prior to that time after 9/11, I was a
50:46 Department of Justice federal prosecutor, chief of counterterrorism, national security. I want
50:51 to thank all three of you for your service. And over the years, having
50:57 Homeland, the Intelligence Community, and the FBI working together has stopped so many threats
51:03 from hitting this country. And when I first became chairman, the Boston bombing occurred,
51:09 the rise of ISIS and the caliphate, and all three of your organizations stopped
51:15 95% of the threats, the 5% we know about publicly. But I just
51:21 want to commend you for that. And I agree with you on 702. I'm probably
51:27 the only member that in Congress that actually applied for FISA warrants. I know how
51:32 critical they are. I know you can't get into the details in the open hearing
51:38 space. I would encourage members to go into the classified space with House Intelligence Committee
51:43 to learn. Because to me, it's political malpractice for Congress not to reauthorize FISA warrants.
51:49 I want to start with you, Mr. Secretary. First of all, let me
51:55 commend you. 36,000 planes being grounded. Yes, it was chaotic, but you know
52:00 what? Nobody died. And I want to thank you for that. The chairman
52:06 talked about CISA. We've seen a lot happen in a couple of days,
52:12 whether it be the FAA computer glitch to the NSA communications being shut
52:17 down. That concerns me greatly. It sounds like these are more technical glitches, but I
52:23 worry about a foreign adversary, Director Clayton, as you talk about, because we're under threat
52:28 every day from them. Iran, China, Russia, North Korea. And I think you've answered the
52:33 question about CISA, but I would encourage you, as the guy who actually created and
52:38 authorized CISA into law, how important it was. We were going to put it under
52:43 the NSA. We decided to put it under a civilian agency. You have 600
52:49 people we need to hire. I would urge you to get CISA at full
52:54 steam because the threats haven't gone away and CISA needs to be in full
53:00 force. I want to ask Director Clayton about this latest threat from Iran. I
53:06 happen to be under indictment in Iran after the Soleimani targeting. I was a part
53:11 of that with the White House and I'm on that top 10 list. And I
53:17 hear sleeper cells and assassination teams. But there was a report recently about an Iran
53:22 dirty bomb. I know how vulnerable the southwest border is. Smuggling a
53:28 dirty bomb would be a relatively easy thing to do. Can you comment
53:34 on this particular threat and where are we with that? Thank you. And
53:40 thank you for recognizing that we do face a heightened threat from the
53:46 Iranians' lethal plotting against Iran. our citizens at home and abroad. I'm
53:51 not going to talk about specifics of intelligence, but Director Rea in his
53:57 opening remarks noted about, I would say, and this is an indictment, so
54:03 I feel free to comfortably talk about it, a gentleman indicted in New
54:09 York for an Iranian-sponsored plots inside the United States. And not only did
54:14 they seek to plot against U.S. citizens while in custody, correct, sir?
54:20 continued to seek to plot against interests of the United States abroad. That demonstrates
54:26 a network capability that is very sophisticated, global, and one that we need to
54:32 combat seriously and with all the tools we have available. And so it sounds
54:38 aspirational, the motive an intent to do this. I don't know if the capability
54:44 is there, but perhaps we can talk in another space on that. Lastly, NCTC Director
54:50 Joe Kent testified 18,000 known or suspected terrorists entered the country under the Biden administration.
54:56 To me, those are all ticking time bombs. That frightens me. That keeps me
55:02 up at night. Secretary Mullen, can you address that issue? I know there have
55:07 been a lot of deportations, but it seems to me when you're prioritizing deportations,
55:13 that's got to be your top priority. It absolutely is that and
55:19 locating the missing children that was led into the country with
55:25 fake sponsors. So as of today, underneath the Trump administration, we've
55:31 removed 2,705 terrorists or suspected terrorists that were let in underneath the current or the
55:35 previous administration, President Biden's administration, and most of them gave, actually all of them gave
55:40 false names. We ran into them actually while we're serving other warrants. But I just
55:45 want to put that in your head. Since President Trump has been in office January
55:50 20th of 2025, 2,705 terrorists were moved out of this country that were inside wanting
55:54 to do harm to them. I'm getting gout with that one. 18,000. They did just
55:59 move votes to 1215, so we're definitely going to keep people on to the five
56:03 minutes, everybody. I'm okay with that, too. Now that votes have been moved, we need
56:08 to keep everybody on schedule. I apologize. And with that, I recognize the gentleman from
56:12 Rhode Island, Mr. Magaziner, for five minutes of questions. Thank you. Secretary Mullen, how many
56:17 ICE agents are on the streets today who have not had full completed background checks?
56:22 Our ICE agents have all been back through training. We have moved our training as
56:27 we... I'm not asking about training yet. I'm asking about background checks. That's including the
56:32 training. Full completed background checks. That's including the background check. Every ICE agent we have...
56:37 in service right now have had full background checks. That's in service. Now, some of
56:42 them are administrative leave until they get the final background check. The reason I ask
56:46 is that on July 13th in Biddleford, Maine, a man named Johan Guerrero was shot
56:51 and killed by an ICE agent in front of his wife and his three-year-old daughter.
56:56 And Mr. Guerrero had just pulled out of his driveway to go to work and
57:00 was not the person that ICE had been looking for. And the ICE agent who
57:05 killed Mr. Guerrero, David Brouillette, had been hired and put on the street before his
57:10 full background check was completed and in fact his background check was still not complete
57:15 when he killed mr guerrero on july 13th if that background check had been completed
57:20 it would have shown that mr brulette had severe mental illness had been diagnosed with
57:25 bipolar disorder and hospitalized for it multiple times that both of his ex-wives his mother
57:30 and multiple former employers found him to be violent and unstable but the trump administration
57:34 made him a nice agent put him on the street with a mask and a
57:38 gun before the full background check had been completed so i just want to be
57:42 clear about this it's your testimony that today just a few months later every ice
57:46 agent that is out there on the street today has had a full completed background
57:50 check That is correct. And the ones that aren't have been put on administrative leave
57:55 until that happens. And I want to throw this out there too. Can I make
57:59 a statement here? And I don't mean to occupy time. We just recently arrested an
58:04 individual from a state that was a state trooper that was also had supposedly went
58:08 through the background check and was a state trooper in a state that was arrested
58:13 because they were illegal. Yeah, so listen, I don't have a lot of time here,
58:18 so let's talk about training because Mr. Brouillette was also put on the street and
58:22 authorized to use lethal force without completing the standardized training. In fact, He was put
58:27 on the street after completing just an online course. He didn't even do any of
58:32 the in-person training in Georgia. Now, I understand that you have changed policies. You've restored
58:37 the full 13-week in-person training. Has everyone who is out there on the street today
58:43 completed the full 13-week in-person training? Yes, and those that haven't have been put on
58:48 administrative leave. Plus, we added additional training. And so the 13 weeks doesn't just stop.
58:53 We continuously do continuing education. How many people had been put on the street who
58:58 hadn't had the full training? that had been that had not I would have to
59:03 get back to you on that number, right? Because there were there were some people
59:06 like Mr Brouillette who just did online only there are others who did just eight
59:10 weeks. Unfortunately, Congressman, there were some decisions that were made before I was secretary that
59:14 we were having to undo and we we are we're bringing the full faith just
59:18 like I said when I appreciate that. But I just how have you had time
59:21 in just the less than a year that you've been in office to retrain all
59:26 of these thousands of people who didn't receive adequate training before? So we're in charge
59:31 of FLETC too. Currently right now we have 517 classes going. We had a lot
59:36 of work to do. I've been in office, as I said, 280 plus days. And
59:41 the agency was eager to get back to the way they used to do business.
59:46 We stood up extra classes with FLETC. We also have taken classes and put them
59:51 in the state to where the ERO offices are. We had a full push and
59:56 we were able to do it and do it in a very effective way. Let
1:00:01 me ask you on a different topic then. You oversee CISA, the nation's premier cybersecurity
1:00:06 agency. When did you learn that NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wang may have been compromised by
1:00:11 a Chinese spy agency? We weren't privileged to that information at all until it
1:00:17 was broke. - So that's surprising to me. I mean, 'cause it's been reported that,
1:00:22 you know, Secretary Rubio knew months ago, Lutnick, that the president knew apparently over a
1:00:27 year ago. But you're the Homeland Security Secretary. You oversee the nation's premier cybersecurity agency.
1:00:32 Why weren't you read in on this? You should have been. The way that I
1:00:36 understand it is because this is a spy outside of just our network, and they
1:00:41 were handling it in different agencies. If it was a direct threat to the homeland,
1:00:46 I would have been read in on it. I would just suggest respectfully that China,
1:00:50 one of our greatest cybersecurity adversaries, having access to these advanced AI chips is a
1:00:56 direct threat to our homeland, it's a direct threat to our cybersecurity. Does it concern
1:01:01 you that Secretary Letnick apparently resisted efforts for so long to rein in these export
1:01:07 control, these exports of chips to China. Because I know Secretary Rubio, others, Mr. Clayton
1:01:12 have said that it was something that they had disagreed with. Do you disagree with
1:01:17 it as well? This wasn't something I'm dealing with. It's outside of my lane. Those
1:01:23 that are dealing with it, but I'm not ready. I say it should be something
1:01:28 to deal with. Gentlemen, time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Mississippi. Mr.
1:01:33 Gesser, five minutes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. In less than a week, we have seen
1:01:38 Microsoft services go offline, a nationwide ground stop, disruption within our major banking institutions, disruption
1:01:44 of U.S. national security communication infrastructure, and earlier this week, United Airlines had a nationwide
1:01:49 system outage. So the people that I serve back in the great state of
1:01:55 Mississippi, some of those individuals are concerned about the fact that we have had these
1:02:01 numerous outages that have occurred in such short proximity to one another. I was texting
1:02:06 this morning with Max Luter from Tylertown, Mississippi, a Navy veteran, small business owner, and
1:02:12 he asked me a question about are these outages related in nature? And I
1:02:18 told him that that is a great, great question and that I was going to
1:02:23 have a panel of experts in front of me today. And I would ask you
1:02:28 that question, starting with you, Secretary Mullen, are the outages that we've seen within the
1:02:33 last week, do you have information that they are related? And then also a second
1:02:38 follow-up question, do you believe that they pose any threat to national security? We have
1:02:44 seen nothing that would indicate that they are related. We have reached out to industry
1:02:50 and there's been no online traffic that CISA has seen. I will pass this to
1:02:55 Jay because Jay is working with the agency too and he's leading this because of
1:03:01 INA, which is our intelligent analyst, is embedded with D&I. Director Clayton. Thank you. Your
1:03:07 constituents are right to ask those questions. As the Secretary said, after doing
1:03:13 a great deal of due diligence inside the government with the private sector, with people
1:03:18 in the private sector whose job is cyber security, we have no indication that these
1:03:24 incidents are related, that they're coordinated. We also have no indication that they're a result
1:03:30 of a state-sponsored malign actor. Mr. Reagan. Thank you, Congressman. And let
1:03:36 me foot stop exactly what my colleagues here on the table said. We have our
1:03:41 cyber action teams, our cyber experts have been engaged from day one on all of
1:03:47 these incidents very heavily. And I want to be very clear on this. At this
1:03:52 point, there is no indication whatsoever that there is any cyber malicious activity related to
1:03:58 any of those incidents. Now, on. Obviously, we're going to keep working with our private
1:04:03 sector partners in an abundance of caution. But at this point, there is no indication
1:04:08 of any cyber malicious activity. I want to revert back to a question Mr.
1:04:13 McCaul brought up about the media reports about possible Iranian actors that they are
1:04:19 developing plans to target senior Trump administrative officials by the use of a dirty
1:04:25 bomb or by chemical weapons. These reports, of course, raise serious national security concerns.
1:04:31 We know that under the previous administration that there were millions of individuals who
1:04:36 entered the country illegally. Mr. McCall brought up that there were
1:04:42 over 18,000 known or suspected individuals on the terrorist watch list. We
1:04:48 know that there were 1,500 Iranian nationals who were apprehended, that 700
1:04:54 of those Iranian nationals have been released into the interior. And so
1:05:00 my question, as my time runs short, is are You
1:05:05 individuals, are you concerned about the possibilities of sleeper cells operating within our borders? And
1:05:11 if so, are we taking the necessary steps to identify, monitor, and disrupt those potential
1:05:16 threats before those actions are put in place? And I know you've got to do
1:05:22 a very broad overview that we can't go into the details in this setting. But
1:05:28 starting with you, Secretary Mullen, are we concerned about the possibility of sleeper cells? And
1:05:32 if so, are we taking the necessary action to make sure that those individuals are
1:05:36 unable to carry out their mission? So this is what the Department of Homeland Security
1:05:41 was stood up for. Is it a concern? Of course. Are we fighting it and
1:05:45 stomping it down every single day? Absolutely. Absolutely. Our men and women are completely dedicated
1:05:50 to it. They showed it even when they were shut down for over 120 days
1:05:55 last year. They still showed up for work and still carried out the mission. We
1:05:59 have great partners with DNI, great partners with DOJ, and we work in a cohesive
1:06:04 manner to go after every one of these threats. Director Clayton. I'll go quickly and
1:06:09 echo something that... Deputy director Ray mentioned, which is the evolving technique
1:06:15 of using online forms to radicalize people that are here in the homeland. That's not
1:06:21 theoretical. It's real. We saw it in New York. We've seen it in other cases.
1:06:27 It demonstrates why we need to be vigilant. I'll be real quick. Obviously, it's a
1:06:33 concern for us having read that reporting now every day for a decade. I will
1:06:38 tell you a lot of the reporting is largely aspirational, but that does not mean
1:06:43 we do not take it seriously. We have revamped our Iranian threat. mission center to
1:06:48 help combat that threat. And we've had a lot of wins that are in the
1:06:52 public ether on lethal plotting as it relates to lethal plotting against dissidents and gentlemen's
1:06:57 gentlemen's times expired. I'm sorry. I now recognize the gentleman from New York, Mr. Goldman
1:07:02 for five minutes. Thank you Mr. Chairman. This is also my last hearing and I've
1:07:07 been grateful for your leadership and Ranking Member Thompson, excited to see what he will
1:07:13 do taking over the majority because there are a lot of questions that we have
1:07:18 asked over the last two years that have not been answered. We're in a crisis
1:07:24 moment right now and Mr. Clayton I want to focus on the NSA outage
1:07:30 from a couple days ago. Is it your testimony today that the
1:07:35 technological problems that the NSA faced on Monday were from internal software
1:07:41 and technological upgrades? We have no indication that they have come
1:07:47 from external threat actors or state sponsors actors. So no indication. It's a pretty binary.
1:07:53 It's either external or internal, right? So if you have no indication that it's external,
1:07:59 is it your testimony that it is from internal upgrades? My understanding, and look, I
1:08:04 want to be... as responsive as possible, but we also need to protect that
1:08:10 agency. Anytime you're talking about patching, upgrading, you want to speak-- Are you talking about
1:08:16 patching or upgrading is really the question. I am-- sir, I am talking about the
1:08:22 suite of things that you do as a routine matter to upgrade your systems, patching,
1:08:27 upgrading, replacing hardware, doing those things. Anytime you are going to do those things, you
1:08:33 take systems down, you bring them back up, In that context, we have
1:08:39 no indication of any foreign threat actor or any coordinated cyber. That's fine. But
1:08:45 is that why the system failed? Because of those internal patches and upgrades?
1:08:51 The issue we are dealing with, as far as we can tell, and we've done
1:08:56 a lot of due diligence, is exactly that type of routine. You and I have
1:09:02 known each other a long time. You're a very smart person, and you're clearly not
1:09:07 answering my direct question. No, I'm actually answering the question in the most appropriate way
1:09:13 I can. During those issues, was there any vulnerability of our classified systems to
1:09:19 while those systems were down to malign actors uh who may or may not want
1:09:24 to that's it that is a terrific question because as you make adjustments and upgrades
1:09:30 one of the things that you ask yourself is when i'm doing this is the
1:09:36 threat I don't have time for the long answer. I'm sorry. I appreciate it. I
1:09:41 know you're doing this in good faith, but it's a little bewildering to me that
1:09:46 the Secretary of the Department of Transportation is doing a Hill tour asking for more
1:09:52 money to upgrade the FAA systems after when he has billions of dollars to do
1:09:58 that that he hasn't used after a nationwide ground stop and for some reason
1:10:03 we are supposed to be grateful to the incredible team that President Trump put
1:10:09 together to get back online all of our flights even though 18,000 flights were
1:10:15 cancelled and there's been no clear explanation for why that ground stop Our constituents,
1:10:21 the American people, are looking at a series of dramatic and systematic failures in
1:10:26 the government, in the private sector. Mr. Clayton, you're right. Yes, they should be
1:10:32 asking these questions. But is it your testimony today that the American people should
1:10:38 believe that the series and sequence of events over the last week is purely
1:10:44 coincidental? We we I'll go as quickly as I can. I know your
1:10:49 time. We have no indication that these events are related, but let me let me
1:10:55 answer something that the American people should know, which is the speed of compute and
1:11:00 the level of capability of applications that use that compute is increasing substantially. which means
1:11:06 legacy systems that were old six months ago in a year are a lot older
1:11:11 than they were then. Which is why the FAA and the Department of Transportation should
1:11:16 have put a little bit more of their money into the underlying infrastructure so that
1:11:21 these additional AI and technological upgrades would have a foundation. I don't have much time.
1:11:26 I did want to get to one thing, which is, let's be real, all three
1:11:31 of your agencies perhaps not Mr. Clayton, have decimated the cybersecurity personnel that this administration
1:11:37 entered office with. CISA is way down because the president didn't want election fraud to
1:11:43 be uncovered. The FBI has fired numerous cybersecurity agents because they may or may not
1:11:49 have served a subpoena in the Mar-a-Lago case. You all have an obligation to restore
1:11:54 that. And Secretary Mullen, I didn't have time to get to your declaration that you
1:11:58 believe in oversight. I have sent six letters to you. I have asked for meetings.
1:12:02 You haven't responded to a single one of them. It can't just be that oversight
1:12:07 exists for the party and the administration. And I do hope you don't force the
1:12:11 majority to go to subpoenas. And if you do, that you comply with those subpoenas
1:12:15 in the next term. I yield back. Thank you, gentlemen. Can I respond to that?
1:12:20 - Mr. Chairman. - I'm sorry, unfortunately. Maybe in somebody else's timing, they'll give you
1:12:24 a second to, but I gotta stay on schedule here because everybody wants to ask
1:12:29 questions. I now recognize the gentleman from Florida, Mr. Jimenez for five minutes. Thank you
1:12:34 Mr. Chairman and Mr. Secretary Mullins, thank you for being here and I know that
1:12:40 some of my colleagues on the other side of the aisle are upset that somehow
1:12:45 you haven't responded. I'm a little bit more upset that your Democratic predecessor actually sat
1:12:50 in that chair and told us for years that the border was secure. So, you
1:12:55 know, thank you for that. At least you're sitting there. Mr. Clayton, Director Clayton, on
1:13:01 the issue of the dirty bombs, is that a new issue? I mean, I'm not
1:13:07 going to talk about a specific matter of... I'm not talking about that. I'm talking
1:13:13 about is the threat of a dirty bomb, is that something new? Something that just
1:13:18 came up like, you know, two weeks ago? There are a suite of threats.
1:13:25 that are that we refer to as you know civilian mass destruction threats or whatever
1:13:29 you want and they have been around for a long time this actually they have
1:13:34 been because you know when i was mayor of miami-dade county one of my biggest
1:13:39 concerns was that a dirty bomb would be floated up the miami river and exploded
1:13:44 in the middle of my city that was 10 years ago all right and so
1:13:49 who was i concerned about iran Isn't that amazing? Ten years ago I was worried
1:13:54 about Iran. Not because we started a war with them, because they've been at war
1:13:59 with us for about 47 years. And so this threat from Iran is not something
1:14:04 new. They've always been threatening us and they've always been trying to find a way
1:14:08 to harm us. And so I think that this revelation, if true, just indicates why
1:14:13 Iran should never have a nuclear weapon. If they can do that with a dirty
1:14:18 bomb, which is pretty simple to make, etc., and detonate, could you imagine if they
1:14:23 got their hands on a real nuclear weapon what they would do? And so, you
1:14:29 know, I find that very interesting. Everybody, oh, my God, it's because
1:14:35 of the Iran war. It's not because of the Iran war. They
1:14:40 want to destroy us. They've said death to America for 47 years.
1:14:46 I think it's time we take them seriously. So, Mr. Araya, if
1:14:51 there were an employee of General Motors that fit your three definitions
1:14:57 for domestic terrorists, and you would label that individual a domestic terrorist, would you label
1:15:03 General Motors a domestic organization? Okay, and so, you know, I think that the fact
1:15:08 that, you know, what the ranking member was trying to get to you, and I
1:15:13 understand you very, very well that you designate people unless the president designates an organization.
1:15:19 And that's why you couldn't name a right-wing organization because there are people inside
1:15:25 right-wing organizations that are domestic terrorists, correct? That is correct, yes. But not the
1:15:31 organization itself. Just like I'm sure there may be somebody working for General Motors
1:15:37 that may be a domestic terrorist, but General Motors is not a domestic organization. Mr.
1:15:43 Mullins, one thing, the one thing I do disagree with the administration on is immigration
1:15:49 enforcement. And I haven't been quiet about it. I've been telling people for a long
1:15:53 time. I have no problem with closing the border. I have no problem with deporting
1:15:58 criminals. I have no problem with gang members, terrorists, etc. Or people with active deportation
1:16:03 orders. I just think you've gone a little bit too far. So is that your
1:16:07 policy or somebody else's policy that you're implementing? Our policies that we implement are based
1:16:13 on statute of laws that Congress passed. I've said this multiple times. Our job is
1:16:18 to enforce laws, not make laws. If Congress wants to change that, they can. Our
1:16:23 policy right now is to go after the worst of the worst. But every time
1:16:28 you go after the worst of the worst, you also have what we call collateral
1:16:33 criminals. So when we arrest someone that's on a warrant, most of the time they're
1:16:37 not by themselves. There'll be two or three individuals with them. The 2,700 terrorists that
1:16:42 we have found, all of them weren't known. We were serving a warrant on someone
1:16:46 else when we found them and they were giving us the wrong name. When we
1:16:51 did biometrics on them or we did more in-depth look into their travel, we were
1:16:55 able to find out that, oh, wait a second, these guys should never be in
1:16:59 this country. So our enforcement every day is worst of the worst. But when we
1:17:05 encounter someone here illegally, I am required to find out who they are because we
1:17:09 cannot have national security if we don't know who's in here. And I would encourage
1:17:14 Congress, if you want to change my laws that I have to enforce, the statutes
1:17:19 that I go through, do it, and I'll enforce those too. I'm not picking and
1:17:24 choosing which law I enforce. Fair enough, but one of the things that I do
1:17:29 have concern about is that there are some people who are here legally under temporary
1:17:34 protective status that the administration later took that away. Okay, and that's the problems that
1:17:38 I have. And so, you know, my time is up and I'll leave you back.
1:17:42 Thank you very much. Gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentlelady from Illinois, Ms.
1:17:47 Ramirez, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Chairman. Well, hi, Secretary. I want to
1:17:51 ask you a pretty direct question. Are you comfortable in your seat right now? Yes
1:17:56 or no? I absolutely love my mission. That's great. Well, Secretary Mullen, I have sent
1:18:01 10 separate oversight inquiries to the Department of Homeland Security that have gone unanswered. You
1:18:05 were just mentioning that you respect and understand oversight, but I have them here. Five
1:18:10 of them have been actually under your tenure about conditions at Campbell County and in
1:18:16 value detention facilities, data sharing agreements with TSA, your department's use of shot gloves and
1:18:22 less lethal weaponry. And even though the department seems to not have time to respond
1:18:27 to Congress's congressional inquiries, you seem to have time to respond to me on X.
1:18:34 Your most recent post suggests that the Department of Homeland Security and its agents are
1:18:38 keeping Americans safe. So I want to talk about that. When Martin Lagunas pointed his
1:18:44 firearm in Carolina Molina's face, a licensed mental health professional and US
1:18:50 citizen, was he keeping Americans safe? Or when Charles Exum crashed into
1:18:56 the vehicle of Marimar Martinez, a United States citizen, a teaching assistant,
1:19:01 and shot her five times, was he keeping her safe, Americans safe? When
1:19:07 Border Patrol agents Matthew Sulek, Michael Turner, Oscar Mesa, Andrew Tarapore, Joseph Brennan,
1:19:13 Martin Davalos, and Alexander Mills crashed into the vehicle of Diane Figueroa, a
1:19:19 United States citizen and a paralegal, pointed the weapon at her, pulled her
1:19:25 out of her vehicle by her feet, pinned her face down and utilized
1:19:31 excessive force as they detained her. Were they keeping Americans safe? Now,
1:19:36 when Border Patrol agents Enrique Camacho, Angel Nieves, Ricardo Moreno deployed tear
1:19:42 gas on a public road near an elementary school while children were
1:19:48 playing nearby, were they keeping Americans safe? You know, there's a lot of
1:19:54 examples how this government is not keeping people safe. And many of those threats are
1:19:59 coming among your rings. They don't respect the civil rights of our neighbors and the
1:20:05 rule of law. They're terrorizing our communities and they're acting with impunity. According to ISIS
1:20:10 enforcement and removal operations, your own numbers to this committee in July, while they've opened
1:20:16 53, now let me say it again, 53 internal investigations, only one agent, has been
1:20:22 held accountable through temporary suspension. So Secretary, do you have an update on, since that
1:20:27 last report, how many agents that have violated the rights of or harmed our neighbors
1:20:33 have been in fact accountable? All cases that are supposed to be under investigation
1:20:38 are still under investigation. You talk about not keeping our country safe. So any cases,
1:20:42 anyone accountable? Anyone else suspended? Anyone removed? They're under investigation. They're investigated outside of ICE
1:20:46 when they're under investigation. I'm not able to comment, but when they come up and
1:20:50 we get recommended actions. Let me reclaim my time. Let me reclaim my time because
1:20:54 it was about specific numbers and you can't report on that at the moment. I
1:20:58 would love to talk to you about numbers. Let me reclaim my time. It's my
1:21:02 time. Last time I told you when you came not to get comfortable in the
1:21:07 seat because we do need accountability. Well, I want to take it back. I do
1:21:11 think you should get comfortable because there are so many unanswered questions and next Congress,
1:21:16 things will look a little different. And I hope to chair the oversight subcommittee here,
1:21:20 a committee that I've spent now four years doing oversight on. And when I do,
1:21:25 you are going to spend a lot of time in that seat. I will be
1:21:30 bringing to you and your staff Questions for you to answer in this committee on
1:21:35 the use of federal funding to reward campaign donors like GEO Group and CoreCivic, the
1:21:41 grand contracts to friends and family members, the illegal and unconstitutional surveillance of the American
1:21:47 people by DHS and its contractors, the illegal neglect, the medical neglect, the miscarriages and
1:21:53 abuses in detention centers, Stephen Miller's calls to ignore habeas corpus. DHS agents do
1:21:59 process violations with impunity, the rapid spread of 287G agreements threatening the safety and
1:22:05 stability of our communities, the defunding of FEMA, of CISA, of Coast Guard and
1:22:11 TSA just to support this president's mass deportation campaign, the politicization of FEMA's mission,
1:22:17 the incompetence of you and your department to protect us from cyber attacks and so
1:22:22 much more. We have to uncover the corruption and you are absolutely right. It is
1:22:27 the responsibility of this committee to do oversight and we will do just that in
1:22:33 the next Congress and I cannot wait to see you again. With that, Mr. Chairman,
1:22:38 I yield back. I now recognize a gentleman from Texas, Mr. Pflueger, for five minutes
1:22:43 of questions. Thank you. I've got a lot of questions. Secretary Mullen, did you have
1:22:48 maybe 30 seconds of response on any of the oversight letters? Yeah. Listen, if we
1:22:53 didn't respond, I apologize. That's not a reflection on us. I said that we'd be
1:22:58 very forward leaning as much as we can on public affairs. Sometimes the letters aren't
1:23:03 directly, we may not have direct oversight of it. So if it's something that DOJ
1:23:08 is investigating, we have to refer it to DOJ. If it's something that the IG
1:23:13 is investigating, we give it to the IG because I can't respond to all of
1:23:18 them, but we'll try. And I apologize greatly for that. Mr. Goldman, I have tried
1:23:23 to reach out to you. In fact, just recently on Veterans Day, because -- and
1:23:27 the number I have for you, I apologize, it's not right. But I just wanted
1:23:32 to thank you for your service. I reach out to all veterans that serve in
1:23:36 Congress, regardless of what side of the aisle you're on, because I still respect it.
1:23:40 So I will apologize for that. That's a reflection of what we do. I'll ask
1:23:45 a couple of questions about are these threats still threats to the
1:23:51 United States of America? AQ, ISIS, Iran, IRGC, their proxies,
1:23:57 the CCP? Are these threats still viable threats? And I've got questions to follow on
1:24:01 that. I'll start with Doug. They are absolutely a real threat. We combat every single
1:24:06 day. I just want to throw out one statistic. Just by the cartels. Cartels are
1:24:11 into human trafficking. They're the ones that trafficked the 416 It was 478,000 kids that
1:24:16 were lost underneath the Biden administration. We've only found roughly 160,000 kids, which you can
1:24:22 imagine the other 300,000, what conditions they might be in. Just underneath the Biden or
1:24:28 just underneath the Trump administration, we've apprehended 8 million or 8 billion kids. 8 billion
1:24:34 lethal doses off the streets that was shipped in by the cartels.
1:24:39 That's equivalent to kill the entire population of the United States 21
1:24:45 times or 90% of the entire world population. That is a major,
1:24:51 major threat. Because of President Trump's push on this, we have brought
1:24:57 overdoses down by 46% because he has authorized us To do what?
1:25:03 Do our job. And we're able to do it. You've done a tremendous job of
1:25:08 upholding the laws. And despite what we're hearing over here, sanctuary cities continue to be
1:25:12 a problem. These threats continue to persist in our country. They use an open border
1:25:17 as the most... uh, open avenue to threaten our country. Director, um, is it clear
1:25:22 how many illegal immigrants are still in the United States and of that number? Do
1:25:26 we have any idea? And for anybody on the panel, how many of those are
1:25:31 affiliated with Al Qaeda, ISIS, Iranian threats or their proxies, cartels, the CCP and any
1:25:35 other threat that may be out there? Congressman, I would refer those numbers to immigration
1:25:41 on DHS. Obviously, we're DOJ, but what I can say is due to the border
1:25:47 being shut and the job that DHS has done as it relates to enforcement, a
1:25:53 lot of our counterterrorism cases in the past that had folks that were illegal into
1:25:58 the country and we couldn't get to a 2339 charge or a substantive terrorism charge,
1:26:04 before we weren't able to do anything except continue to watch them, continue to make
1:26:09 cases on them because they would never get kicked out of the country. Now, under
1:26:14 Secretary Mullen and DHS, we're able to use DHS to enact those immigration authorities. And
1:26:18 when we know we have a bad act, or a bad terrorist in the country,
1:26:23 and we can't get to a substantive charge, we're able to immigrate, we're able to
1:26:28 use those authorities and create a disruption and ultimately... How many elected officials do you
1:26:34 have in sanctuary cities throughout the country that directly oppose the enforcement of federal statute?
1:26:39 Elected officials? Yeah, that are out there lamenting and talking about opposing it and not
1:26:44 following federal statute. I don't know. I know there are outspoken politicians regarding that.
1:26:50 Again, my job is to oversee an agency to keep America safe through investigation.
1:26:56 Secretary Mullen, when it comes to some of the campaign promises that were made,
1:27:02 by Democrats, especially DSA-associated people that want to defund ICE, people in this room, in
1:27:07 fact, that want to defund ICE. Tell me about the effect that has on the
1:27:12 morale of the 27,000 employees of DHS. Well, it's actually moved from defunding ICE to
1:27:17 defunding Department of Homeland Security, which is absolutely crazy to me, because we protect the
1:27:22 homeland. All 22 components enforce the laws that Congress passed. And as I've said multiple
1:27:27 times, Congress can change those laws. And if they can change the laws and get
1:27:32 the president to sign it, we'll enforce those laws. But to be mad at us
1:27:37 for simply doing our job, I don't understand it. Our job is to protect the
1:27:41 homeland. That means we're going to protect your backyard just like I protect my backyard,
1:27:46 and we do a good job at it every single day. Thank you. You're back.
1:27:50 Gentleman yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Michigan, Mr. Tanadar, for five minutes
1:27:55 of questions. Good morning, Secretary Mullen. To fulfill President Trump's mass
1:28:01 deportation agenda, DHS carried out a hiring campaign to more
1:28:07 than double the number of ICE officers and agents. To
1:28:13 get as many new officers into the field as quickly
1:28:19 as possible, DHS took shortcuts. slashing training time
1:28:24 in half and eliminating much of the required testing
1:28:30 for officers. These shortcuts put public at risk and
1:28:35 had serious and even deadly consequences. For the record,
1:28:41 Mr. Secretary, I'll appreciate if you'll answer these yes
1:28:46 or no questions. Yes or no, During the hiring surge,
1:28:52 did ICE remove or reduce firearms training for new recruits? Sir, if you were here
1:28:58 earlier, you would have heard me answer a lot of these questions. We restored training
1:29:04 back to the full 13 weeks, and we're going to continue to do that. Just
1:29:10 yes and no, sir. I wasn't here during that time. Yes or no. During the
1:29:16 hiring surge, did ICE remove or reduce use of force slash decision making training for
1:29:21 new recruits i wasn't here during that time sir i've only been in office since
1:29:26 march all these decisions were made prior to me coming into office i'm sure you
1:29:30 reviewed those decisions when you took the job sir we changed a lot of things
1:29:35 when we came in i would i mean i can't answer for previous administration you
1:29:39 want to ask questions with my tenure there i'll be happy to answer all those
1:29:44 yes or no at any point during the hiring search did ice reduce on the
1:29:48 job training for ice Officers. Once again, that was before my time, sir. I would
1:29:53 love to answer questions about my tenure. I think you know when I came in
1:29:57 office. So we can answer all those questions moving forward. I can't answer for a
1:30:01 previous administration or a previous secretary. When you took the job, did you speak with
1:30:06 any of the previous administration? As I said, we restored our training back to what
1:30:10 it was going to be, and I made that very clear when I came in
1:30:14 front of your committee the first time. Well, sir, I proudly represent Detroit, Michigan. And
1:30:19 we have some of the finest barbers in the United States. And our barbers
1:30:25 go through more training than your ISO officers. Do you know that? I've never
1:30:31 been a barber, but I know the service industry and apprentice license for electricians,
1:30:37 plumbers, and heating and air is roughly three to four years. I can talk
1:30:42 about that. Let me switch to another topic that has been on the minds
1:30:48 of my constituents this past week. Secretary Mullen, can you give me your
1:30:54 best guess as to why systems across the country keep breaking? And now
1:31:00 this is happening on your watch. You can't punt this or blame this
1:31:06 on the last administration. First, outlook went down and work grinded to a
1:31:12 halt. Then the FAA implemented a ground stop nationwide. The second time since
1:31:17 9-11 attacks They have done that. Major banks across the country
1:31:23 experience widespread disruption. And recently, the NSA's classified network went down. Secretary
1:31:29 Mullen, what the hell is going on? What is your department doing
1:31:35 to look into these recent failures? And do the American people have
1:31:40 a reason to be suspicious of the administration's answers that everything
1:31:46 is fine. - It's unfortunate that you just got here because we've answered
1:31:52 this question multiple times. I don't think your staff is doing you any
1:31:58 justice because they would change your questions. But I'll let Jay answer that
1:32:04 question. - We are in an environment where the rate of patching, the
1:32:10 rate of upgrading of systems is increasing. That is the result of advancements
1:32:16 in compute, and in applications we should expect that as people are patching and
1:32:22 as people are upgrading systems i say it this way every any one of us
1:32:27 who's worked in a large organization has heard the system's going to go down at
1:32:33 five o'clock on friday it's scheduled to come back up at two o'clock in the
1:32:38 morning on saturday so i only have 20 20 seconds left okay so i have
1:32:44 another question for the secretary uh secretary is Your commitment that all ICE
1:32:50 officers hired during the hiring surge will grow through the full 13-week in-person
1:32:56 training. Would you commit to that? Yes. Thank you. Well, the part of the training
1:33:01 they haven't already completed. There were some that they completed, the parts that they added
1:33:06 to it. They will go through all the training and continuing training throughout the year
1:33:11 as long as I'm in office. Thank you. I yield back. Gentleman yields back, and
1:33:15 I recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Luttrell, for five minutes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
1:33:20 Mr. Secretary, gentlemen, good to see you. Mr. Secretary, Houston, Harris County is... and I
1:33:25 hate to say this out loud but it's the worst it's considered the worst city
1:33:31 in America when it comes to trafficking. We sit on the I-10, I-45 corridor and
1:33:36 35 runs through there too. We're missing you threw some numbers 100,000 300,000 still missing.
1:33:41 What is the department by with and through the other organizations that you're partnered with
1:33:47 doing to not only currently combat human trafficking but to rescue those babies that are
1:33:52 still missing? This is something I take extremely personal because with six kids
1:33:58 I just can't imagine the horrific conditions that some of these kids are dealing
1:34:04 with. We've already out of 160 plus thousand that we've recovered, 7500 of them
1:34:09 were in direct trafficking. We just recently found one in Oklahoma that was in
1:34:15 a vehicle. She was 17. And when I say recently, this is two weeks
1:34:21 ago. We'd been looking for her. She was trafficked from Arizona. She was
1:34:27 in a vehicle with six adults that were all legal, male adults. And
1:34:32 we found her in Oklahoma driving down Interstate 40. You can imagine the
1:34:38 horrific things she had to go through. And it frustrates me because we're
1:34:44 even seeing sanctuary cities and states that are refusing to work with us
1:34:49 to find these kids, refusing to work with us. if we
1:34:55 can agree on one thing it would say hey let's go find these
1:35:01 other 300 000 because you can imagine the harder they are to find
1:35:07 there's probably a reason for it and it breaks your heart what's even
1:35:13 worse as an alarming rate they're aging out meaning once they get 18
1:35:19 they fall under the complete different jurisdiction and it's much harder for us
1:35:24 to find we need to have every law enforcement agency working on trying to
1:35:30 find these kids that were lost underneath the Biden administration. They were given to sponsors.
1:35:36 It's not even an argument. You can't even argue this anymore. It's a fact. They
1:35:41 were given to sponsors that were unvetted. Some sponsors had taken as many as 40
1:35:47 kids. 40 kids. I don't know. I have six. Six is a lot to raise.
1:35:52 40 that you're a sponsor of in four years? Who was the oversight? People should
1:35:58 go to jail over what happened here. But our first responsibility is to locate these
1:36:03 kids. And it is our mission every day. We have partnered with outside organizations to
1:36:09 go around what sanctuary cities won't allow us to do. So they'll allow these outside
1:36:14 organizations to do it. We're having to pay them to go do it. But it's
1:36:19 worth every dollar we spend for every single kid. And we're finding roughly at this
1:36:25 rate, It slowed down some because of cooperation, the harder they are to find, but
1:36:30 we're finding roughly 4,000 kids to roughly a month. I can think some other places
1:36:35 I'd rather send those people than jail, but I digress. You and I would probably
1:36:40 agree on that. Mr. Ray, Mr. Clayton, this might land on top of one of
1:36:46 y'all. And this goes to Mr. Thompson's point about domestic terrorism. Give me some rope
1:36:51 on this one, okay? And domestic chairmen could be an individual,
1:36:57 not less an organization. My question, which most likely may not be able
1:37:03 to answer in here, you guys are both familiar with Hugging Face Attack,
1:37:09 correct? An individual's capability to create an army of AI agents and an
1:37:15 attack profile creates an organization. And if you have tens of thousands of
1:37:21 generated, and I'm a fan of artificial intelligence and super intelligence, whatever you
1:37:27 want to call it, but it's the good and the bad here.
1:37:35 Looking downstream, how do we protect ourselves from an AI-generated
1:37:41 army that can be programmed to be a terrorist when
1:37:47 we move at the speed of government and they do
1:37:53 not? Let me say multi-pronged effort, but one of the
1:37:59 most important prongs is to have the best technology because
1:38:05 this is not geographically bound within the United States. There
1:38:10 are people developing super intelligence technologies and developing applications. I say that just so everyone
1:38:15 knows it's not just China, Iran, North Korea, and everybody that's attacking us. There's somebody
1:38:20 living out there's probably somebody across the street right now listening to what I'm saying.
1:38:25 Just like we have to lead in aerospace for defense, we have to lead in
1:38:29 computing technology and applications technology for defense in the cyber arena. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
1:38:35 Thank you. Thank you. And I'll just schedule you. So with votes being called at
1:38:39 1215, we will keep the hearing going. So if you have not questioned yet. or
1:38:44 if you're not having questions by the time it's coming, I would suggest you get
1:38:48 there for votes right at 1215 and come back because we are going to keep
1:38:53 this hearing going. Ms. McIver, can I borrow one second of your time? No, she's
1:38:57 not in time. Is there an official question? Yes. What is it? Can I get
1:39:02 those answers from those guys on the record? No. Okay, thank you. There you go.
1:39:06 Unless Ms. McIver would let them, but I now recognize the gentlelady from New Jersey,
1:39:11 Ms. McIver, for... Thank you Chairman and thank you ranking member Thompson for
1:39:16 holding this hearing today. Secretary Mullen, we have a lot to discuss. Last Friday,
1:39:22 due to extraordinary circumstances, a communication outage resulted in only the second national ground
1:39:28 stop since 9/11. Truly ridiculous. You and Secretary Duffy criticized Congress for failing to
1:39:34 prioritize investments in our nation's aging air traffic control infrastructure. but in 2021 congress
1:39:40 passed the bipartisan infrastructure law providing 25 billion dollars for aviation infrastructure including 5
1:39:46 billion specifically for faa facilities and equipment since mr secretary if i'm not mistaken
1:39:51 you were a congressman um during that time when that bill was considered how
1:39:57 did you vote on that legislation oh you know what i remember i'll tell I'll
1:40:03 tell you how you voted. You voted against it. Last year, the one big beautiful
1:40:08 bill gave another $12.5 billion to the FAA. The administration now says it needs another
1:40:14 $50 billion on top of that. An infrastructure failure like the one we saw last
1:40:19 week grounding all US flights and having the administration say they don't know what the
1:40:25 issue is exposes how vulnerable our country is to sabotage. Under your leadership, we look
1:40:30 like a weak target. Secretary Mullen, would you support fixing our air
1:40:36 traffic control system by redirecting some of the funds from
1:40:41 ICE? Well, by statute, I limited on what I can spend those funds
1:40:47 on. So I guess that's a no. You know what is happening under your leadership.
1:40:52 Historically high deaths in ICE custody. To date, 65 people have died in ICE custody
1:40:58 underneath this administration. Mr. Secretary, the last time you were before this committee, I asked
1:41:03 you, had you ever visited Delaney Hall in my district? You said no. Since then,
1:41:09 two more people have died at Delaney Hall. So I'll ask you again, have you
1:41:14 taken the time to visit Delaney Hall, a detention center that is under your umbrella?
1:41:20 Yes or no? Absolutely, I have. And the facility, as you know, because you've been
1:41:26 there, is in way better condition than your state penitentiary. No, it's not. Reclaiming my
1:41:32 time. I'm currently asked. I'm reclaiming my time, Mr. Secretary, please. As you know,
1:41:38 I am facing 17 years in prison from this Trump administration for my work at
1:41:43 Delaney. Do you even understand why I've been sounding the alarm about Delaney Hall for
1:41:48 so long? Do you understand that? No, I went there and visited the facility. It
1:41:53 was in very good condition. We provide twice as much medical attention to our detainees
1:41:58 than the state does. Reclaiming my time, Mr. Secretary. It's interesting. ISIS, reclaiming my time,
1:42:03 Mr. Chairman. Reclaiming my time. ICE's own investigation, Mr. Secretary, found that nearly 80%
1:42:09 of people who died in custody in the first year of Trump 2.0
1:42:15 died after receiving poor medical care. That is ICE's own investigation. This includes
1:42:20 failure to provide emergency care and adequate treatment of chronic conditions and failure
1:42:26 to respond to suicide risks. Someday, extremely soon, history is going to judge
1:42:32 you for what you are doing. Your collaboration with Stephen Miller, all of these
1:42:38 deaths. Do you have any regrets or reservations for the leading role you are
1:42:44 playing in this administration's immigration agenda? I'll never apologize about enforcing our nation's laws. Not
1:42:49 about even killing people. No apologies for that. We're not killing people. You are killing
1:42:54 people. You are killing people. That's your opinion. No, no, you are killing people. We've
1:42:58 been the whole entire country watching you kill people. I got the numbers right here.
1:43:03 I'm reclaiming my time. This is my time. I'm reclaiming it. With that, Chairman, I
1:43:08 yield back. General Leidy yields back. I now recognize the gentleman from Alabama, Mr. Strong,
1:43:12 for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Chairman Garbarino and Ranking Member Thompson, Chairman McCall,
1:43:18 and I thank all of our witnesses for being here today in your service to
1:43:23 our country. What I have noticed is much of this debate would never have occurred
1:43:29 if President Joe Biden would not have allowed the invasion of 25 million illegal aliens
1:43:34 at the southern border to come into America. Secretary Mullen, before I get into my
1:43:40 questions, I want to commend you and President Trump for your leadership and commitment
1:43:46 to securing our southern border and strengthening our nation's homeland security. For reducing illegal
1:43:51 border crossings to combating drug trafficking, human trafficking, and criminal cartels, your efforts are
1:43:57 making a real difference in keeping America safe. First off, I want to talk
1:44:03 about a place that's very important to my community and the people that I
1:44:09 represent in North Alabama. Redstone, Arsenal, and the greater Huntsville community are home to
1:44:15 a remarkable concentration of military, intelligence, and federal law enforcement capabilities supported by a
1:44:21 robust defense industrial base and a strong network of industry and academic partners.
1:44:26 As outlined in the administration's 2026 National Defense Strategy, the threats
1:44:32 facing our homeland are becoming increasingly complex, from foreign adversaries developing
1:44:38 advanced technologies to persist threats of terrorism. Addressing these challenges requires
1:44:43 strong coordination across our nation's security agencies and continued investment in
1:44:49 American innovation. The Department of Homeland Security has not been turned
1:44:55 against the American people as previously stated. Secretary Mullins, the day you
1:45:01 were confirmed secretary, you immediately authorized the latest technology be deployed to
1:45:07 defend against counter UAS from every, for every state hosting a FIFA
1:45:13 event. You deployed counter UAS for America 250 events in record time. Secretary
1:45:19 Mullins, I'm proud you have engaged in college football games. I chaired an
1:45:24 Emergency Management Technology Committee meeting right here where you sit. And on any
1:45:30 given weekend in the Southeastern Conference, nine to seven stadiums have more than
1:45:36 90,000 fans in attendance with with even more thousands around the stadium and
1:45:41 we need to be defending these large gathering operations. You think about it,
1:45:47 I will continue to advocate that counter UAS be deployed to large venues
1:45:53 throughout America. As each of you know, we have the technology to intercept,
1:45:59 drop, block, do forensics on drones. Much of this technology is from my
1:46:04 district in Huntsville, Alabama. Deputy Director Rea, I was with you, Dan Bongino, at
1:46:10 another America 250 event where the FBI foiled an effort to assassinate members and
1:46:16 others in attendance. Please tell your agents thank you for what they're doing for
1:46:22 the American people. Deputy Director Rea, can you speak to the importance of Redstone
1:46:27 Arsenal and the broader Huntsville community to the FBI's mission and the opportunities you
1:46:33 see for continued growth and collaboration there? Well, first of all, Congressman Strong,
1:46:39 I would be remiss if I didn't thank you personally for your support, not only
1:46:44 Redstone Arsenal, but in the FBI and really federal law enforcement intelligence in general. So
1:46:49 appreciate that. You mentioned it earlier. I think one of the biggest strides that we
1:46:54 made in the last 21 months, not only with the FBI, but with the Department
1:46:59 of Homeland Security and our federal partners, is in that fight against counter UAS. All
1:47:03 you have to do is look at a YouTube video and see what's going on
1:47:08 overseas with explosive payloads. put on these UASs. 21 months ago, I was very concerned
1:47:14 about that technology coming over here to the United States. And I am still concerned
1:47:19 about that threat coming here to the United States. However, in the last 21 months,
1:47:24 based on a multitude of things to include the standing up the National Counter UAS
1:47:29 Training Center, where we are deputizing state, local and other federal authorities to give them
1:47:34 the same the same technology to not only mitigate to not only detect but mitigate
1:47:39 all across the country and increase that throughput. We are much better postured against that
1:47:43 threat than we were 21 months ago and I appreciate your support and I appreciate
1:47:48 everything you've done to help us in that effort. Congressman Thank you. Secretary Mullins, from
1:47:53 DHS's perspective, how important is collaboration with national security community in North
1:47:59 Alabama to identifying and addressing emerging threats to the homeland? We couldn't
1:48:05 do it without the cooperation. It is vital for state, local, federal
1:48:10 cooperation. It's the only way we're going to effectively combat it. Thank you.
1:48:16 And again, I want to thank you for what you did to immediately from the
1:48:21 first day you took office, you deployed counter UAS to FIFA, which was equivalent to
1:48:26 what seven Super Bowls going at the same time at 11 different locations, America 250
1:48:31 and the Olympics is on the horizon. Never quit. We'll never relent. Mr. Chairman, I
1:48:36 yield back. Gentlemen's time is expired. I now recognize the gentleman from Puerto Rico, Mr.
1:48:41 Hernandez. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. 25 years ago, after 9-11, this country created the Department
1:48:47 of Homeland Security to keep Americans safe. Now, let me be clear. I believe
1:48:53 in enforcing the law. We all want those who break it to face consequences,
1:48:58 but immigration law can and must be enforced without violence. Let's take a cold
1:49:04 look at the facts. In Chicago, masked agents raided an entire apartment
1:49:10 building. In the middle of the night, U.S. citizens and children were
1:49:16 pulled out of their beds and zip-tied for hours. Since these enforcement
1:49:21 operations began, immigration officers have fired at people in at least 29
1:49:27 incidents. At least seven people are dead. Renee Nicole Goode, Alex Preddy,
1:49:32 Silverio Villegas Gonzalez, among others. Agents have tear-gassed. police officers, protesters,
1:49:38 children, and clergy. Officers have been told to identify and run checks on
1:49:44 people whose only act was filming them. So let me say it plainly.
1:49:50 We are here to talk about threats to the homeland. When the government
1:49:56 enters an apartment and sipties children and citizens, the government is the threat.
1:50:01 When the government opens fires on our streets and families have to bury
1:50:07 their dead, the government is the threat when the government tear gases
1:50:13 children and clergy the government is the threat when the government puts a
1:50:19 citizen in a database simply for holding up a phone the government is
1:50:25 the threat when the government shoves a pregnant woman as they did in
1:50:31 puerto rico the government is the threat meanwhile the threats that this department
1:50:37 was built to stop have not waited The department's own cybersecurity agency
1:50:42 has reported a vacancy rate of about 40% across key mission areas. Every hour
1:50:48 and every dollar spent on raids like the ones in Chicago, Minneapolis, San Juan,
1:50:54 and Caguas is an hour and a dollar not spent on those threats. I
1:50:59 represent more than 3 million American citizens in Puerto Rico. Many of us speak
1:51:05 Spanish at home, on the streets, at work, Our citizenship does not depend
1:51:11 on our accent, our last name, or the color of our skin. When ICE operations
1:51:17 came to Puerto Rico, I asked for one thing: that the law be enforced without
1:51:23 violence, with compassion, and with respect for human rights. That is not too much to
1:51:29 ask. That is the minimum. Mr. Secretary, the American people deserve a department that protects
1:51:35 them, not one they need protection from. Mr. Secretary, these incidents raise
1:51:41 serious questions about accountability within your department, and the American people deserve answers
1:51:46 about what happened, who was responsible, and what action DHS has taken. Mr.
1:51:52 Secretary, what is the status of DHS's investigation into the killings of Americans
1:51:58 Renee Nicole Goode, Alex Preti, and Ruben Ray Martinez? I cannot talk
1:52:04 about ongoing investigations, but I can't talk about the angel families that's been lost by
1:52:08 the hundreds at the hands of illegals that were let underneath this administration or the
1:52:12 previous administration. Does that justify the killing of innocent people? It never justifies anybody. And
1:52:16 why do you have to bring up the comparison? That is very disrespectful to those
1:52:20 victims. I'm just saying in your mouth, you should probably talk about the angel families
1:52:24 that the illegals that were let underneath the Biden administration have killed. You don't talk
1:52:28 about the killing of any person in the United States. No one should. We are
1:52:32 against the killings of every person. We are for peace. We are for justice. Biden
1:52:37 administration. What is the status of the HSS? I claim back my time. What is
1:52:41 the status of the HSS investigations into the killings of Lorenzo Salgado and Johan Sebastian
1:52:45 Durán Guerrero? Answer still the same. Why is the status of the shooters in those
1:52:49 cases? Are they still working? Still in the investigation, and anyone that was involved in
1:52:53 a shooting is no longer... How long will this investigation take? I'm not doing the
1:52:57 investigation. A lot of it is being done by... You don't know how long the
1:53:00 investigations your agency is conducting? Once it goes into investigation, that's... Are you pressuring the
1:53:04 relevant agencies to conduct the investigations faster? Because we don't want people who are potentially
1:53:08 guilty of murder conducting investigations in this country. I'm not involved in the investigation at
1:53:11 all. I've already said that. So don't put words in my mouth. I never put
1:53:15 any words in your mouth. By saying in my pressuring when I already said I'm
1:53:19 not involved in the in the in the Are you indifferent towards the investigation being
1:53:22 solved? Am I what? Indifferent towards the investigation being solved? I'm not involved in it
1:53:26 at all. You're not involved in it, so you don't care about the results of
1:53:30 the investigation. Will you commit to providing the committee with the investigative files of those
1:53:33 cases within the next two weeks so we can carry out our constitutional right of
1:53:37 police? I'm not in charge of the investigation. Do you have any files related to
1:53:41 the investigation? I'm not in charge. I have nothing to do with it. I don't
1:53:45 know how many times I got to repeat myself. Nothing to do with the investigation.
1:53:49 You do not provide any information for the investigation. I don't know how many times
1:53:52 I can repeat myself. I don't know if you're having a hard hearing, but I've
1:53:56 said this multiple times. Gentleman's time has expired. Gentleman's time has expired. I now recognize
1:54:00 a gentleman from Arizona, Mr. Crane, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
1:54:04 Thank you, gentlemen, for showing up today. I want to say thank you, Mr. Secretary,
1:54:08 for bringing up these angel families. You know, it's interesting. they never bring them up
1:54:13 they don't care about them they don't care about the hundreds of thousands of kids
1:54:18 you know that you've sat through enough of these hearings it's just so interesting how
1:54:22 they don't care about american citizens that have lost their lives to the millions that
1:54:27 the biden administration let in um mr secretary we've obviously had a pretty tough week
1:54:32 uh but technology outages within federal agencies and the private sector microsoft faa workday
1:54:38 chase wells fargo united airlines nsa apple and the national weather service i know
1:54:44 the administration has said repeatedly there is no evidence that these were cyber attacks
1:54:50 Secretary Mullen, I know you've been in DC for a long time as a former
1:54:54 member of Congress, Senator, and now in your current role. I wanna ask you, have
1:54:58 you ever in all of your years in DC seen this many technology outages during
1:55:02 this short of a period of time? Absolutely not. And we're actually convening a phone
1:55:07 call with industry because my personal opinion here is it'd be helpful as we're moving
1:55:12 forward that maybe the industry that's doing the upgrade could inform their customers that it's
1:55:17 going to take place. I mean, when we upgrade our phones, right, it gives us
1:55:22 a warning and says, hey, you're due for an upgrade. And when you upgrade it,
1:55:27 you know your phone's going to go offline for possibly two minutes. With the amount
1:55:32 of patching work because of the aging infrastructure we have, it's probably time for the
1:55:36 industry, and it's the industry, we're not pressuring the industry to do it, we just
1:55:40 want to have a conversation and say maybe we should start communicating because What happens
1:55:45 online is a tremendous amount of fear and we can understand it. I think all
1:55:50 of us can understand it, but there's no cause for it. Jay, I'm sorry, I
1:55:56 keep calling you by your first name. The director, I know, but I consider you
1:56:01 a friend, but the director has mentioned about this and about what's going on in
1:56:06 the technology world. I think it's helpful for him to say it again. well I
1:56:12 I appreciate that but I'm get as you guys are I'm getting a lot of
1:56:17 text messages phone calls about these issues and I think one of the concerns is
1:56:21 how quickly and how many of these outages we've seen from the 12th to the
1:56:26 I believe the 17th so in a span of five days when we've never seen
1:56:30 that That coupled with Mr. Clayton, your testimony about the rise of super intelligence and
1:56:36 how just a lone hacker himself with some of these advanced tools can now become
1:56:42 that much more of a threat. It just seems, you know, really frightening to a
1:56:47 lot of people that there might be some there there. So how can you guys
1:56:53 with confidence sit here and tell us that, hey, There's nothing to, you know,
1:56:58 these aren't cyber attacks. These are actually just a bunch of patches and, you
1:57:04 know, old networks. I think you're correctly outlining two different things. What we're seeing,
1:57:10 and the American people are right to say, hey, you know, You in government,
1:57:16 you in industry, what's going on? We have gone out to each one of those
1:57:21 individuals. We've used our tools, and we have no evidence that this is a coordinated
1:57:25 cyber attack or state-sponsored activity. Thank you. Thank you, sir. That said, you make a
1:57:30 very good point. The pace of technological advancement is increasing. It's increasing where we have
1:57:35 access to it at the government. It's increasing in the private sector, and it's increasing
1:57:39 outside the United States. Thank you. We need to be prepared for that. - I
1:57:45 appreciate that. Secretary Mullen, why has the no taking off shoe policy
1:57:50 still been in place at the TSA? We're evaluating
1:57:56 technology every single day, and we feel like what we're doing right now is keeping
1:58:01 the American flyers very safe. We've never put anyone at risk at all. That's our
1:58:06 number one job at Department of Homeland Security is protect the homeland. There's been multiple
1:58:11 reports that's come out on this. I understand it. I've talked to the IG personally
1:58:16 in a skiff, addressed his concerns. In fact, we addressed three of the four concerns.
1:58:21 The fourth concern is has nothing to do in my opinion with the security of
1:58:26 it but i will tell you uh congressman we would never put anybody at risk
1:58:30 we were just any doubt thank you sir and to follow up on that i've
1:58:34 i've been briefed that i got the classified briefing from the ig on that it
1:58:38 was very concerning i'd like to talk with you sometime off the record about that.
1:58:42 My following question, Secretary Mullen, I find it interesting that Democrats are coming after you
1:58:47 for these outages and also your own voting record when they voted against DHS funding
1:58:52 on January 22nd, March 5th, March 26th, and June 9th. I'd like to hear your
1:58:56 comments on that. Thank you. Unfortunately, every time we go dark, which we did for
1:59:02 120 days, it damages our ability to do our job and protect the homeland. I
1:59:06 don't know why the Department of Homeland Security is even controversial. We should all agree
1:59:10 with protecting our communities, and that's what we do, and we do a good job
1:59:15 at it. Thank you. Gentlemen, the time has expired. I now recognize the gentleman from
1:59:19 New York, Mr. Kennedy, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There's no
1:59:24 question that our constituents feel less safe today and troublingly It's the Trump administration that
1:59:29 bears responsibility for that. Through DHS's misguided, deeply flawed priorities, you've built out a
1:59:35 mass detention system, unleashed rogue immigration agents in our communities, and left families and
1:59:41 neighborhoods living in fear. And yet, despite widespread public opposition and Donald Trump acknowledging
1:59:47 himself, his policies were, in his own words, too tough. This administration has shown
1:59:53 no signs of slowing down. Secretary Mullen, do you agree with Mr. with
1:59:59 President Trump that this administration's policies were too tough? Yes or no? Thank you. Every
2:00:04 single day we go after the worst of the worst and underneath the President Trump's
2:00:10 leadership, we've been able to take 2705 terrorists off our streets. That was Leonard to
2:00:15 buy administration. We've been able to remove 20,690 gang members off of our streets and
2:00:21 countless murders and child predators. We was able to find 166,000 kids. that were lost
2:00:26 during the Biden administration. You're able to take record numbers of drugs off the streets
2:00:30 and bring down overdoses by 46%. So my point is that we're going after the
2:00:35 worst of the worst every single day, and we're doing a good job at it.
2:00:39 Mr. Chairman, put that up at four minutes, please. Reclaiming my time, yes or no,
2:00:43 do you agree with the president that his own policies are too tough? Underneath my
2:00:48 tenure, the president and I had a conversation right off the bat, and he said,
2:00:53 let's go after the worst of the worst, and that's exactly what we're doing. Okay.
2:00:58 So the worst of the worst include more than 70% in a recent letter to
2:01:03 me from you. Thank you for finally responding after three months, but... seven over seventy
2:01:08 percent of the detainees at the batavia federal detention facility have never been have never
2:01:13 been convicted of a crime yet they're detained um are they the worst of the
2:01:18 worst as i was stated earlier which i know you had other things to do
2:01:23 and he wasn't in the committee i said that we when every time we serve
2:01:28 a warrant we have what we call criminal um or or collateral criminals which are
2:01:32 illegals that are with the person or serving the warrant on it is our due
2:01:37 diligence to find out who they are which is why we've been able to find
2:01:42 the 2 705 terrorists and and nation reclaiming my time we have 50 of the
2:01:47 people we deport mr secretary claiming my time and and i was voting for a
2:01:51 new speaker of the house because the american people have spoken against these failed policies
2:01:56 of dhs and this administration That's where I was. And I'm here. I'm asking
2:02:02 you simple questions. Yes or no, you seem like you can't answer that.
2:02:07 Well, here's what I know. You're expanding an ICE detention facility just south
2:02:13 of my district in Batavia, New York, at $17 million of taxpayer funds.
2:02:19 And at the same time, I find this single award construction contract that
2:02:25 has been put forward for a billion and a half dollars, one and
2:02:31 a half billion dollars to detain people that no one in good faith would
2:02:37 consider the worst of the worst. You know, a billion and a half dollars
2:02:43 this contract is for. I was just at the Batavia ICE detention facility last
2:02:49 month. Have you been there? Secretary Mullen? No, I have not. Okay. Well, what I
2:02:54 can tell you is that this is not a facility in need of a billion
2:02:59 and a half dollar facelift. When people are starving in our country, when gas prices
2:03:04 are skyrocketing, when people can't afford the daily cost of living, and we're going to
2:03:09 spend a billion and a half dollars on a facility in Batavia, New York? that
2:03:14 no one wants or we don't need. And the only reason that you're even considering
2:03:19 an expansion is because 70% of the people that are there again in your own
2:03:24 words have never committed a crime. These are not the worst of the worst. This
2:03:29 is a failed policy of this administration and the American people have had enough quite
2:03:34 frankly. And so With that, Mr. Secretary, I'm very concerned about the
2:03:40 direction of your policies, of DHS in general, and that's just the
2:03:46 tip of the iceberg. How, in good faith, can you spend a
2:03:51 billion and a half dollars on an ICE detention facility? in Western New
2:03:57 York. Congressman, I agree we probably shouldn't have to spend the money, but because of
2:04:02 sanctuary policies over your governor, they're not allowed to cooperate with us and we have
2:04:06 to detain them. We'd love to work with you guys in your state prisons or
2:04:11 your state jails. We can save all that money, but because of your sanctuary policies,
2:04:15 you're not allowed to work with us. In fact, right now inside your state penitentiaries,
2:04:19 you have 18,746 detainers that we're asking you to hand over that are murderers, child
2:04:24 predators, rapists, drug dealers, and and yet you guys will not work with us on
2:04:28 it so if you want to help you want to save the taxpayer dollars let's
2:04:32 do it have your governor in the sanctuary policies 72 of the detainees have never
2:04:36 committed a crime that's not the worst they did they enter the country legally that's
2:04:41 not the worst of that's not what the president of the united states promised when
2:04:45 he was campaigning years ago he said we're going to deport the worst of the
2:04:49 worst is what he said and that was a lie that was an aberration and
2:04:52 that was a lie to the american people and you know it and the people
2:04:56 know it and that's why we have a new congress coming in i yield back
2:05:00 gentleman yields back i now recognize the gentleman from new york secretary mullen where are
2:05:04 the worst of the worst right now We're catching them or they're being shipped back.
2:05:10 Are they in our state prisons? Most of them, yes. Why can't you get to
2:05:14 them in the state prisons in jurisdictions like New York? Because they won't honor the
2:05:18 detainers and they're going to release them back on the streets. And that's what's happened.
2:05:22 Is that a choice that's being made? A thousand percent choice by the sanctuary policies.
2:05:27 Who's making that choice, Mr. Secretary? Elected officials that have chosen to choose criminals over
2:05:31 law-abiding citizens. Thank you, Mr. Secretary. Switching gears a little bit, Director Clayton, good to
2:05:35 see you. You're the Director of National Intelligence, the nation's top intelligence officials?
2:05:41 One of them. The 18 or so entities report to you? Yes, they
2:05:46 do. Do you believe in coincidences, Mr. Director? I believe in exploring coincidence.
2:05:52 That's a good answer. My constituents and I, we believe sometimes in coincidences,
2:05:57 but maybe sometimes not. And I'm a little worried that what's happened this
2:06:03 last week are a little beyond coincidences. Thursday, Microsoft 365 went down. Friday,
2:06:09 a nationwide ground stop. Monday, United Airlines grounded flights. Also Monday, Chase and
2:06:15 Wells Fargo experienced banking disruptions. And yesterday, we learned of a network disruption
2:06:20 at the NSA. Five major disruptions in less than a week. Five
2:06:26 different explanations. All while America is engaged in conflict with Iran, Russia is
2:06:32 illegally, unfairly fighting Ukraine, and China is growing increasingly aggressive. You've said before,
2:06:37 Mr. Director, that there's no indication of a coordinated cyber attack, but have
2:06:43 our intelligence agencies affirmatively ruled out a connection, or have you simply not
2:06:49 yet found one? Like I said, very right to ask.
2:06:55 It's your constituents are right to ask the questions that we have asked to give
2:07:00 me a very high level of confidence that there's no coordination and no state sponsorship
2:07:05 around. These are they are different causes. First of all, in those we have then
2:07:11 looked inside the government inside the private sector. You know what are the TTPs? What
2:07:16 are the techniques, tactics and procedures that have been used? in the past for that
2:07:22 type of activity? Do we see any of them here? We do not see them.
2:07:27 Director, when you and your folks are analyzing these five and more instances, are you
2:07:33 analyzing them independently or are you comparing the TTPs on one to the other? Both.
2:07:38 Great. Secretary Mullen, we've heard explanations involving faulty routers, software defects, and routine maintenance. The
2:07:43 director says he's confident, but on a scale of 1 to 10, how confident
2:07:49 are you that these five incidents are a result of technical failures and not
2:07:55 a sophisticated adversary exploiting vulnerabilities that may resemble ordinary failures? I've said this publicly.
2:08:01 I'm 98% confident that this has nothing to do with our adversaries hacking or
2:08:07 going after our systems. I saw the FBI deputy director nodding his head earlier. I
2:08:12 think he might have something to say. I would make that same assumption. I mean,
2:08:17 we have people, our cyber experts are out on scene with a lot of these
2:08:21 companies in an abundance of caution. And again, to footstomp it, we have seen no
2:08:26 malicious activity as of today. We are going to continue. We are going to continue
2:08:31 working with DHS, working with the DNI to be a to be 120 sure but
2:08:35 as of right now again no malicious cyber activity jump back in quick because i
2:08:40 don't need to answer the question you got 10 seconds let's be clear you are
2:08:44 also right there are foreign malign actors who would seek to do us harm that's
2:08:49 okay so so broader broadly speaking you've done the diligence you've done the investigations you've
2:08:53 gone through the protocols you haven't found anything what's your gut say just a coincidence
2:08:57 five in one week while we're fighting iran while china's getting aggressive russia and ukraine
2:09:02 Does your gut say just a coincidence? It does. And let me tell you why.
2:09:07 It's an informed opinion. And the reason it's informed is we are engaged in a
2:09:12 substantial increase in upgrades. The number of patches, the number of upgrades that we're undertaking
2:09:16 in the public and private sector. Thank you. Let me get back to my last
2:09:21 question before my time expires and the chairman gavels me out. 25 years ago,
2:09:27 we had horrific attacks on this nation. Nearly 3,000 Americans were murdered that day.
2:09:33 And for the years afterwards, the nation contemplated how the hell did that happen?
2:09:39 And one of the four key takeaways was a lack of imagination. That
2:09:44 there was other things about lack of communication and coordination, some duplicative services that were
2:09:50 stovepiped. But one of the key four takeaways was a lack of imagination. Folks didn't
2:09:55 figure out that 19 civilians could hijack planes, use those cruise missiles to attack innocent
2:10:00 people here. I would ask you this. Can you have, make sure that you and
2:10:05 your folks are having the largest imagination possible to ensure that this isn't just a
2:10:10 coincidence, that this is a coincidence. Can you ensure that you are imaginative, you're using
2:10:14 opposition research and everything else to ensure that this is not nefarious? Let me give
2:10:19 you one example of the types of things we do and I expect we will
2:10:24 do here. We call it red teaming. We say, okay, let's say we wanted to
2:10:28 do this and not be detected. and make it look like it wasn't coordinated and
2:10:33 try to establish all of that. That's the kind of exercise that our experts at
2:10:38 the FBI and the like will go on, and I think we should be doing
2:10:42 more of that. Thank you, gentlemen. Appreciate it. Gentleman's time has expired. Votes have been
2:10:47 called. Just to let you all know, one vote, I believe. I now recognize a
2:10:51 gentleman from Virginia, Mr. Walkinshaw, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. One
2:10:56 of the most serious threats we face is cyber attacks targeting the technology systems and
2:11:01 the critical infrastructure that Americans rely on every day, our water
2:11:06 systems, our hospitals, our banking networks. And those threats, those attacks
2:11:12 are exploding. They're not growing, they're exploding. And the recent tech
2:11:17 outages are not coincidences. And they are connected to cybersecurity. Because
2:11:23 organizations, businesses, government agencies are frantically patching systems to close vulnerabilities that
2:11:29 advanced AI can exploit at a speed and scale unlike anything we've ever seen.
2:11:34 This week, the FBI warned that hackers are using autonomous AI tools to target
2:11:40 governments and businesses in the United States. Is that true, Mr. Deputy Director? We
2:11:46 put out a flash message on that. Yeah, thank you. We are under attack.
2:11:52 We're under attack. But at precisely the moment that these threats were growing,
2:11:57 The Trump administration gutted CISA, the agency responsible for helping protect us against those
2:12:03 attacks. And Mr. Secretary, respectfully, it is not true that the gutting of CISA
2:12:09 had no impact on its ability to accomplish its mission. Don't ask me, ask
2:12:15 its former director, its former director in this administration. He said, quote,
2:12:21 the reduction in personnel has limited CISA's ability to fully
2:12:26 support national security imperatives and administration, Trump administration priorities. Mr.
2:12:32 Secretary, at the beginning of this Trump administration, approximately 3,400
2:12:37 people worked at CISA. In June, you testified before this
2:12:43 committee that CISA had approximately 2,200 employees, but needed 2,800
2:12:48 employees. Is that correct? Is that consistent with your previous testimony? Some of those, I
2:12:53 believe that is, I don't see the testimony in front of me. Some of those
2:12:58 numbers have changed because... I understand. And the chairman asked you this question earlier. You
2:13:03 didn't have it. Maybe you have it now. How many fully onboarded employees does CISA
2:13:07 have today as we sit here? As I told the chairman, I'll get... All right.
2:13:12 Mr. Secretary, you've been here for hours. And earlier you said a member's staff wasn't
2:13:16 serving him well. If you wanted to tell us that number today, any number of
2:13:22 those people behind you could have given you that number. Either they're not serving you
2:13:28 well or you don't want to tell us how many onboarded employees. Reclaiming my time.
2:13:34 Reclaiming my time. Reclaiming my time. Mr. Secretary, let's be clear about what happened. The
2:13:39 Trump administration inherited a CISA workforce of 3,400 people. They fired and pushed
2:13:45 out more than a thousand cyber defenders at precisely the moment the
2:13:51 cyber threat was exploding. You came before us and said correctly that
2:13:57 you needed hundreds of those employees back. So I have a simple
2:14:03 question for you. Was it a mistake in 2025 For those employees,
2:14:09 the thousand plus CISA employees that you now need back, was it a mistake for
2:14:13 them to have been fired and pushed out? Yes or no? I wasn't there when
2:14:18 that was made. I don't know the reasoning behind it. So I'm not going to
2:14:23 talk about why someone was let go when I wasn't involved in it. Well, none
2:14:28 of them were let go for cause. They made a decision to push out a
2:14:33 thousand people at CISA. Well, actually we do. They made no claims. You now say
2:14:38 you need them back. You saw that file? If it wasn't a mistake, why did
2:14:42 you tell Congress you needed hundreds of them back? Not them. I didn't say those
2:14:48 employees back. I said we're hiring new people. We need to bring experts in. The
2:14:53 new employees that have been onboarded at CISA recently, are any of them among the
2:14:58 thousand plus who are pushed out and fired? I don't know that information. I don't
2:15:03 know. You have no information about CISA's workforce when you come before this committee today.
2:15:08 As our cyber threat facing the American people is exploding, you don't have basic information.
2:15:13 If you need 2,800 and you have today somewhere between 2,200 and 2,800,
2:15:19 you don't know. If you need 2,800, you don't have them all today, what work,
2:15:24 what critical work that you seem to believe, correctly, I agree, needs to be done
2:15:29 is not getting done while those positions are vacant? What work is not getting done
2:15:33 that you would like to see done at CISSP? I think, I don't know if
2:15:37 you were here earlier because I wasn't on the ground. I was. Then you heard
2:15:42 me say we have not missed a mission. We're very mission- Then why do you
2:15:46 need them? We need to address the emerging threats. The threats don't exist today. The
2:15:51 threats always involving. They're always moving and we're always trying to catch them. Thank you,
2:15:57 Mr. Chairman. I yield back. Gentleman yields back and I recognize the gentleman from Tennessee,
2:16:02 Mr. Ogles for five minutes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you to the witnesses.
2:16:07 I have the privilege of serving as the chairman of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Protection
2:16:12 Subcommittee and I thank the chairman. You know, obviously the last few days have been
2:16:17 very trying for you gentlemen and your respective agencies and quite frankly, stressful for the
2:16:21 American people. And so let's jump the pond for a moment. Look at the last
2:16:26 three weeks. You look at India where you have the crafty Falcon, the crypto wallets
2:16:30 were raided. North Korea hit Binance $6.3 billion over a 20-minute operation. November
2:16:36 16th, you have the JavaScript code through Optimizely hit again roughly 178 organizations.
2:16:42 And now you look at headlines from PolyMarket and specifically Yahoo Finance saying
2:16:48 that AI will make the next 12 months a slaughterhouse for crypto security.
2:16:54 So as American people hear those headlines, see those headlines, obviously they're concerned in the
2:16:59 context of the last few days. So I'll start with you, Director Clayton. Talk to
2:17:04 the American people. Reassure them that what we're seeing today isn't orchestrated per se, then
2:17:10 also that we're watching overseas what's happening, what's occurring. So we see the resources being
2:17:15 deployed by North Korea, by China, by Iran, Iran, et cetera, against our allies and
2:17:20 what may be coming if we're not ready. Thank you. Thank you for the opportunity
2:17:25 to do that. As we've all talked about and with the processes
2:17:31 that we put in place, what we have seen over the last 10 days is
2:17:37 not an orchestrated attack by a foreign malign actor. We do not have any indication
2:17:43 that it would be. But your question about what's going on in cyberspace globally is
2:17:49 an excellent one and one that we are keenly focused on. Computing capabilities, the overall
2:17:55 processing is increasing exponentially. The applications that then run on that computing technology,
2:18:01 they are increasing in terms of their sophistication. In that environment, our digital
2:18:06 infrastructure is becoming increasingly outdated and needs to be upgraded. The better we
2:18:12 do that, the better America will lead in commerce, in defense, in
2:18:18 national security, and all the things that matter. This is a dramatic change
2:18:24 that's going through the technology infrastructure around the globe, and we need to
2:18:30 lead it. Mr. Secretary? Sir, I would agree with what Jay is saying
2:18:36 in this. He has definitely stepped up to meet the moment, and he's
2:18:41 leading the charge here. Sir, thank you for the opportunity, and I couldn't
2:18:47 agree more on the the breadth, depth, and scale of our cyber attacks is increasing
2:18:52 in general from state actors and from criminal actors. In fact, one of the things
2:18:58 we've done recently under Director Patel's leadership, probably one of the biggest reorganizations at headquarters
2:19:03 that we have done is we've completely re reorganized our cyber branch. We have made
2:19:09 that a branch before it had fallen under another branch. We made it. We've taken
2:19:14 the entire cyber mission, intelligence investigation, our capabilities and our cyber security of our own
2:19:19 systems. We've we've we put those under one accountable executive in order to streamline, enhance
2:19:25 our investigations and stay ahead of this emerging threat. The other thing we've done is
2:19:30 we've also done a lot of of operations and initiatives, not only offensively, we did
2:19:36 Operation Riptide earlier this year, that resulted in over 200 arrests, the freezing season over
2:19:41 23 million. So we did that offensive capability in order to stay ahead of the
2:19:46 threat. We also launched Operation Winter Shield, which was a defensive initiative, again, that we
2:19:52 worked with the private sector where we reached out to something like 600 different private
2:19:57 sector companies in the critical infrastructure space in the matter of about 60 days. And
2:20:02 we work with our partners at CISA and the DNI to increase their cyber hydrant,
2:20:08 work with them to harden their networks. And so we are dumping a director Patel
2:20:13 has been very, very, very aggressive in staying ahead of this cyber threat based on
2:20:19 the American public's concern and based on what the DNI and the secretary have said.
2:20:24 Thank you, gentlemen. You know, Mr. Chairman, and you know, got 30 seconds or so
2:20:29 left. I mean, I think it's important for the American people to understand is that
2:20:34 under this president, these agencies inherited a mess. They've spent the last each of their
2:20:39 tenure fixing what was broken. Meanwhile, we are under global threats day in and day
2:20:45 out. And yet, America is safe. The bad actors don't have to be right every
2:20:50 time. They have to be right once. right these guys have to be right every
2:20:55 single time so thank you all for your service god bless america i yield
2:21:01 back i thank the gentleman the chair recognizes the general a from new jersey
2:21:07 miss mahea thank you mr secretary while dhs initially abandoned plans to convert a
2:21:13 roxbury warehouse into a detention camp in roxbury new jersey it has It has since
2:21:18 reversed course. Can you please share a timeline for this conversion and a timeline
2:21:24 for its anticipated opening? We were wanting to not have to do that.
2:21:30 We're trying to work with your governor. Timeline only, sir. I'm just saying, we were
2:21:35 trying not to have to do that because of the circumstances working with your governor.
2:21:40 It forced us to. We're still putting it out for bid. Once we get the
2:21:45 bid complete, we'll let you know. Got it. So you don't have a timeline. Has
2:21:50 any work, any conversion work begun at the facility? No. Right now, we're still looking
2:21:56 out and trying to figure out what is the best approach forward. So should I
2:22:01 take that as a no? We haven't started full construction, no. We're looking at what
2:22:06 we need to do for the bidding. So full construction means partial construction has begun?
2:22:11 No, full construction means that all we're doing is putting it out for bid right
2:22:16 now. Let me ask this again very clearly. Has any work to convert Roxbury, the
2:22:21 Roxbury warehouse, into a detention camp? Has any work begun? Ma'am, don't call the
2:22:26 detention camp. Sir, has any work begun? Okay, reclaiming my time. May I ask,
2:22:32 according to a court order, any conversion work is restricted pending an environmental review.
2:22:38 Has that review been conducted? As I said, this is part of the bid
2:22:44 process, so we're still taking it. So that's a no. And I said, we're
2:22:50 putting it up for bid and that's part of it. - Sir, it is such
2:22:53 a clear question. Has there been an environmental review conducted? Yes or no? - We're
2:22:57 still going through all the requirements right now. - Okay, so that's a no. I
2:23:01 don't know if it's been completed. Okay, that's I don't know. That's a
2:23:07 fair answer. Okay, so let me ask. I again, I had admitted that
2:23:13 they had detained 14 individuals at Roxbury on September 4th and September 8th
2:23:18 for processing. Can you share? Have any detainees ever been brought inside of
2:23:24 the warehouse? Ma'am, I'm not familiar with it as they have. I
2:23:30 don't know. Okay, so you don't know. Do you know if your officers, ICE
2:23:36 agents, anyone under your jurisdiction, are they informed about any court decisions about a
2:23:41 facility like Roxbury, i.e., would they know that there is a court order saying...
2:23:47 this uh facility is that communication would be with acting director and i don't
2:23:53 know if he's okay may i ask since september 8th have any detainees been
2:23:58 brought to the site either inside or outside during any moment of your tenure
2:24:04 Ma'am, if you'd like, I can take that and get it back to you. Oh,
2:24:09 I would love that. I would love that, actually. Can you, may I make a
2:24:14 request? Will you commit to submitting to this committee, to my office, and to the
2:24:19 state of New Jersey, your timeline for the conversion, your timeline for the environmental review,
2:24:24 and your timeline, anticipated timeline for an opening of this facility? What is statutory required
2:24:29 of us, we will do. Okay, you just said that you would share information, and
2:24:34 now I'm asking for three pieces of information. You said that you would share the
2:24:38 information on the environment. You asked me questions about operations. I said that I can
2:24:42 take that and get back to you. The questions you're asking now, I said that
2:24:46 I will take those that the statute required of me to report those to you.
2:24:51 I will. Okay. So what I am requesting for this committee, the state of New
2:24:55 Jersey, and my office, is for you to inform us on when that environmental review
2:25:00 will take place. Are you able to share that information, yes or no, at this
2:25:04 point or at a future date? - Let me get back to you on that.
2:25:09 - Okay. - I'd be happy to. - Now let me shift a little bit.
2:25:14 So you said that you do not cherry pick laws. May I ask, do you
2:25:19 believe that citizens and non-citizens alike have due process and equal protection rights according to
2:25:24 our constitution? ma'am our immigration policy is policy that that's not what i'm
2:25:30 asking i'm asking i follow that policy i'm trying to understand your understanding of
2:25:36 our constitution are you aware do you believe that citizens and non-citizens alike have due
2:25:42 process and equal protection laws afforded to them according to the 14th Amendment of our
2:25:47 Constitution. Yes or no? American citizens have unique rights that are given to them. That's
2:25:53 not what I'm asking, but it's okay if you don't understand, if you do not
2:25:58 have awareness of our Constitution. That's totally okay. It's shocking, but it's I'll let that
2:26:04 pass. Let me ask New Jersey passed a law barring ICE agents from using
2:26:10 a big being mass when they're carrying out operations and yet officers agents persist.
2:26:16 Is that cherry picking laws adherence to laws? General ladies time is policies that
2:26:21 Congress sets. If you want to change your policies, you want to change your
2:26:27 laws. So you ignore state law. ma'am i enforce the laws that by immigration
2:26:33 you ignore state law this time has expired uh the gentlewoman miss biggs is it
2:26:39 uh is recognized thank you mr chairman and thank you to each of you gentlemen
2:26:44 the service what you do for our country um you know i've just been sitting
2:26:50 here kind of listening and it's really appalling to me at how members on the
2:26:56 other side want to put illegals over our American citizens and
2:27:01 I find it kind of disgusting. But thank you for the
2:27:07 service that you do. Anti-American radicals are converging on our campuses
2:27:13 and in our streets. In the 25 years since 9/11, the
2:27:19 United States has faced violence from radical leftists and Islamist extremists.
2:27:25 raising concerns about cooperation between these movements. Their sources of funding
2:27:31 and support also deserve scrutiny, including potential links to foreign governments
2:27:36 such as Iran and China and to organizations funded by George
2:27:42 Soros and Nabil Roy Singham. The alliance elements of the radical
2:27:47 left and the Islamist extremists, it's not new. A decade
2:27:53 ago, the Soros-funded Open Society Foundations were already funding organizations
2:27:58 affiliated with Linda Sorosauer, who has connections to the Council
2:28:04 on American Islamic Relations and Extremist Figures. Likewise, Nabil Roy
2:28:09 Singham's network fuels both groups of radicals as well. The
2:28:15 House Ways and Means Committee is investigating foreign link funding involving
2:28:21 organizations connected to Neville Roy Singham. And in July, the committee
2:28:26 announced subpoenas to Breakthrough News, Tri Continental and the People's Forum
2:28:32 as part of that investigation. These cases show how
2:28:37 layers of grants and intermediary organizations obscure who is
2:28:43 paying for political messaging and organizing Secretary Mullen or
2:28:49 Director Clayton. or Director Rahu, I would love to have
2:28:55 your input on these. My question is, what is DHS doing
2:29:01 to uncover these networks and identify foreign influence aimed at destabilizing
2:29:06 American society? Thank you, Congresswoman, for the question. This is what our 80,000 badge
2:29:12 officers throughout DHS does every day, and we couldn't do it without direct coordination with
2:29:18 our state and local partners. This is why sanctuary cities and sanctuary states are so
2:29:23 dangerous. Because it creates a melting pot and a safe haven for this type of
2:29:29 activity because they realize that we're getting no cooperation from the people that are patrolling
2:29:34 the neighborhood daily. And yet we're still able to do our job. It's frustrating, though,
2:29:40 because we're tasked to do the job and protect the homeland. But yet we
2:29:46 fight the very people that written or that wrote the law
2:29:52 to do that. It's frustrating when sanctuary politicians are able to
2:29:57 just ignore federal law, ignore what law-abiding citizens actually do want
2:30:03 and protect their constituents. And it puts the American people at
2:30:09 risk. Thank you. - Ma'am, thank you for that question. Related
2:30:15 to, I believe what you're also referring to is the president's NSPM 7 memorandum on
2:30:21 anti-authorities and anti-government rhetoric, violence and the like. And I can tell you, we have
2:30:26 moved a lot of that space under Director Patel's leadership. We have stood up what
2:30:32 we are calling the Joint Mission Center that's housed out of FBI headquarters. It's us
2:30:38 and about 10 different agencies to include DHS, And we have taken different
2:30:44 pieces of our of our organization because that thread encompasses our criminal folks, our
2:30:49 CT folks, as you mentioned, influence our CI folks, as well as our cyber folks.
2:30:55 And we put them all under the same roof to act as a clearinghouse. And
2:31:00 we process leads, we put leads out, we connect the dots, particularly when it comes
2:31:05 to the funding, because we know there's funding behind some of these violent protests, some
2:31:10 of these violent acts that you're seeing. out in the media right now that we're
2:31:15 seeing in some of these cities and we're pushing those things out to our JTTFs
2:31:19 who are the actuating arm of that particular mission center. I just want to throw
2:31:24 out, I can't talk specifics about cases and confirm, deny, confirm or deny cases on
2:31:28 those individuals you mentioned, but I do want to talk about some stats that we
2:31:33 have that we have done in a very short time under the JMC.
2:31:39 Right now, roughly, we've got about 2,766 anti-government/anti-authority cases. That's up about 22%.
2:31:44 We've actually issued, in conjunction with our partners at Department of Justice, 220
2:31:50 indictments. That's up about 70%. 155 judicial complaints with DOJ. That's up 66%.
2:31:56 And so all that to say, we are taking that threat very seriously.
2:32:02 We're getting some massive wins in that space and we're going to continue to work
2:32:06 that aggressively to keep our country safe. Thank you. The gentlewoman's time has expired. I
2:32:10 now recognize the gentleman from Colorado, Mr. Evans, for five minutes of questioning. Thank you,
2:32:15 Chairman, Ranking Member, and thank you, of course, to all of the witnesses for coming
2:32:19 out today. My first question is going to be to the Secretary. Good to see
2:32:23 you again. border security we've talked about what a disaster it was under the
2:32:29 four years of the previous administration we've talked about how we've secured the border which
2:32:34 was the number one thing i heard from my constituents two years ago we've secured
2:32:39 the border the last two years but unfortunately now we're starting to see um reporting
2:32:44 coming out about caravans and cartels uh anxiously awaiting the new congress to be seated
2:32:49 so that they can hopefully go back to business as usual in fact We saw
2:32:53 reporting of a caravan leaving from the southern Mexico area November 10th and 11th, coming
2:32:58 north to the United States, hoping to take advantage of the new Congress. And what
2:33:03 they hope is a relaxing of the border security measures that I think everybody in
2:33:09 America wants to see. And so the first question to you is, can you comment
2:33:14 on uh any intel uh or other reporting about how cartels and caravans
2:33:19 are hoping to exploit um potentially relaxed border uh security procedures in the
2:33:25 next congress Under the previous Biden administration, the cartels turned human trafficking into a multibillion
2:33:31 dollar industry. And they're selling, unfortunately, very vulnerable people a bill of goods that
2:33:37 they can't deliver. They will not be allowed to enter the United States underneath
2:33:42 President Trump's watch. Our border is secure and it will remain secure. Fortunately, we have
2:33:48 pretty good cooperation with Mexico right now. And Mexico has assured us that they will
2:33:52 not make it to our southern border, their northern border. They also realize that if
2:33:57 they do, they'll have an immigration issue on their hands because we're not letting them
2:34:02 in. It's completely closed. So for anyone that's thinking about joining one of these caravans
2:34:07 and allowing the cartels to extort dollars from you, you're wasting your money. It's not
2:34:11 going to happen. You're not coming into the United States safely. unless you do it
2:34:16 the proper way, and that's following our immigration policy that Congress set. - Thank you,
2:34:21 Secretary. Deputy Director Wray, thank you for coming today. And thank you for the work
2:34:26 that you and everyone else in the FBI does. My background, I was a cop
2:34:31 for 10 years, and so worked with you guys on some bigger cases. Question to
2:34:36 you is around overdoses and violent crimes, specifically as it regards sanctuary jurisdictions. I hail
2:34:42 from Colorado, where unfortunately we are both a sanctuary state with sanctuary municipalities within the
2:34:48 state. And we can see the data around the impact that's having on public safety
2:34:54 nationally in your comments. You talk about how violent crime down, overdose down nationally. But
2:34:59 in Colorado, the Common Sense Institute, which is a bipartisan think tank that actually has
2:35:04 the former Democrat district attorney for the city and county of Denver on their public
2:35:09 safety portion of the think tank. Common Sense Institute says 1,600 Coloradans are dead today
2:35:15 that should have still been alive had Colorado merely followed the national declining trend
2:35:20 in overdose deaths. But overdose deaths continue to go up in Colorado. Same thing
2:35:26 with violent crime. Nationally violent crime down in Colorado, Denver specifically, murders are up
2:35:32 30% compared to just this time last year. And so the question to you is,
2:35:37 do sanctuary jurisdictions contribute to higher crime rates and higher overdose death rates? I think
2:35:43 to your point, Congressman, we have seen little pockets of areas where the violent crime
2:35:48 rate has actually gone up. I think like nationally, as I referenced before, we're largely
2:35:53 down about 10% violent crime. The murder rate the last 21 months has been down
2:35:59 30%. A lot of our wins in that space, in addition to our renewed focus
2:36:05 in the FBI on violent crime, A lot of our wins in that space comes
2:36:10 from our relationships we have with our state, local, and other federal governments. And so
2:36:14 if there's not a lot of support in a specific city for their state, local,
2:36:19 and federal governments, then that makes it very difficult for us, obviously, as a task
2:36:24 force or those agencies in general, to continue with the national decline of violent crime.
2:36:29 - Thank you for that. Director Clayton, last question to you. Again, I was a
2:36:34 cop for 10 years, so I know to get a warrant, you need probable cause,
2:36:39 which means you have to have enough information to be able to articulate probable cause.
2:36:45 So speaking to FISA, that's how we get that original information that starts off a
2:36:50 FISA request. We know the statutory authority for FISA 702 lapsed in June, 2026. And
2:36:55 so even though the program is operational through 2027, through a one-year extension. Have your
2:37:01 agencies experienced any significant or notable disruptions in collection? To date, in
2:37:07 terms of collection, we have not seen a material decline, but there
2:37:13 is a substantial. If those authorities lapse, the providers, and let's be
2:37:18 clear, they provide us with information about foreign persons outside the United
2:37:24 States. The providers are unlikely to feel comfortable continuing to provide that information. Thank you,
2:37:30 and I'm out of time. You'll be back. Thank you. The gentleman's time has expired.
2:37:36 I now recognize the gentleman from Texas, Mr. Green. Mr. Green, you're recognized for five
2:37:41 minutes of questioning. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I thank the witnesses for appearing today, and
2:37:47 I have been monitoring this hearing for the edification of persons who have commentary about
2:37:53 those who do not know what has been said.
2:37:58 Secretary Rubio, who is also the Director of National Security, I believe, has
2:38:04 indicated that there is zero evidence that the outages are connected. You know
2:38:10 what I speak when I say outages. I think zero is a pretty
2:38:16 strong statement. So I'd just like to get your commentary. Do you agree
2:38:22 with Secretary Rubio? And I'll start with you, Mr. Ray. Zero?
2:38:28 Thank you, Congressman. As I've stated before, if you don't mind, a yes or no
2:38:33 would suffice. And if you say anything other than yes or no, I'll just take
2:38:38 a yes. We, we, we have taken your answers. Yes, we are. Okay. Let's go
2:38:43 on to Mr. Clayton. Based on all the work we've done, we have seen no
2:38:47 evidence to that effect. Thank you, sir. Appreciate your answer. Mr. Secretary. Appreciate you showing
2:38:52 up two hours and 40 minutes late. If you want to, excuse me, would you
2:38:57 ask him to hold for a moment, please? I'm not late. I've been
2:39:03 monitoring this hearing. I don't have to sit here. And you would know that I
2:39:08 don't have to sit here. Excuse me, Mr. Chairman. It's my time. I don't have
2:39:14 to sit here and watch you perform. I don't have to do that. I can
2:39:19 look at you on television. And that's what I've been doing now that you've been
2:39:25 properly chastised. Let me go on. Do you agree with the secretary?
2:39:31 Like I said, if you've been watching it, you do. I was watching. I missed
2:39:36 you. Do you agree? Do you know the question? I take it then you're 98%
2:39:40 confident that there is no affair. Is your answer? Yes. I take it as yes.
2:39:45 Okay. Very good. Now let's go on to the next question. He's also said there
2:39:50 is no imminent threat of a possible Iran dirty bomb plot. No imminent threat. Do
2:39:55 you agree with that assessment as well? That's a question that hasn't been asked. Well,
2:39:59 I don't have to. Mr. Chairman, since it's my time uh would you kindly restore
2:40:04 some of my time given that i've had to have this uh this uh well
2:40:09 we'll just do that i feel like i've talked to you guys before about this
2:40:13 what we'll do is you ask the questions you can't tell them how to answer
2:40:17 it if you'd like and if if you want to reclaim your time please do
2:40:21 suspend the clock right now okay please please uh that's how we're gonna but that
2:40:25 does do you agree that um he can't uh tell me how to attend meetings
2:40:32 You do agree with that, don't you? We can ask the questions. Okay. All right.
2:40:36 And then he'll answer them. But again, you ask, he'll answer. Okay. Well, Mr. Chairman,
2:40:40 let me just say this. For the record, let's let the record reflect that I've
2:40:45 been viewing this meeting, this hearing, and that I don't have to be here in
2:40:49 his company. Quite frankly, I don't enjoy being in his company. But I can come.
2:40:54 Okay. Well, I'm going to tolerate him as long as I have some agreement. Okay.
2:40:58 I'm going to tolerate him as long as I have. Yes. Okay. Okay. Let's okay.
2:41:02 Okay. We have two minutes and 20 seconds left here. Let's if you get questions,
2:41:06 please. Secretary, if he reclaims his time, please again, but No directing on how he,
2:41:11 you asked the question, no directing the witness on how to answer. Let's get through
2:41:17 this. We're almost done with this today, and I appreciate you both being here. This
2:41:22 is a very important hearing, and I'm glad that you all made the time to
2:41:27 be here. Thank you. All right. Now, let's try it again. Do you agree with
2:41:32 the assessment that Iran is not an imminent threat in terms of a dirty bomb?
2:41:38 plot. Yes. Okay, I appreciate you saying that because my suspicion is that the president
2:41:44 is looking for a reason to take kinetic action against Iran. And if he can
2:41:49 conclude in his mind, as he's concluded, by the way, that he won the election,
2:41:55 that he lost, that DEI was the cause of an accident out at the airport.
2:42:01 If he can conclude in his mind that he'll take us back into Iran with
2:42:06 kinetic activity, which is another way of saying war. The
2:42:12 president has not come to Congress to get congressional authorization for his wars.
2:42:18 The president has to be impeached for that. He has to be. He
2:42:23 must be. If we don't impeach him, every president after him will assume
2:42:29 that you can take this country to war without consulting Congress. I believe
2:42:35 that notwithstanding his behavior since, if he goes on to become a saint,
2:42:40 he still has to be impeached. Because if a person robs a bank,
2:42:46 and he decides he's going to return the money he still has to
2:42:52 be prosecuted so the president must be impeached and any members who contend
2:42:58 that he shouldn't be impeached they are aiding and abetting the president's behavior
2:43:04 and it's sinful now quickly for you mr secretary um alex pretty
2:43:10 No information about a verdict in that case. Are there any charges being filed? Once
2:43:14 again, if you were monitoring, you would have known that I said this was a
2:43:19 preliminary investigation. Well, you don't have to tell me about if I had monitored. I
2:43:24 heard you. I want you to answer me. Now, you did what I asked. I'm
2:43:28 going to ask you again another question. You do know that Mr. Perez was arrested
2:43:33 within 10 days after he was accused of assaulting an officer in Austin, Texas. Do
2:43:38 you know that? Not commenting about an ongoing investigation. Well, you don't
2:43:44 comment on very much to hide yourself, but let me just say this. You want
2:43:49 to disguise your commentary, but Mr. Chairman, let me close with this. We have not
2:43:55 heard anything in terms of what's happening with Alex Preddy. Mr. Perez was charged
2:44:01 in nine days after being accused of assaulting an officer. It's been more than
2:44:07 nine months with Alex Freddie. Secretary has talked about how somebody ought to be
2:44:13 arrested. Mr. Secretary, you ought to be arrested. The gentleman's time is expired. I
2:44:19 hope you enjoy your forced retirement. I'm enjoying it more than you know. You
2:44:24 will know. The gentleman's time is expired. I now recognize the gentleman from California, Mr.
2:44:30 Fong, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you to the witnesses
2:44:34 for being here. Mr. Secretary, I want to thank you for your leadership. Cybersecurity and
2:44:39 our cybersecurity needs and challenges are now front and center. And I appreciate and I'm
2:44:44 grateful that you highlighted in your comments the need to grow CISA's capabilities. And I
2:44:49 want to thank you as well and your team for working with me on my
2:44:54 bipartisan bill that I've introduced, the Bridge AI Act. This bill would authorize CISA to
2:44:59 create a pipeline and bring private sector AI professionals into the agency to advance its
2:45:04 mission of safeguarding U.S. critical infrastructure. As you know, the private sector has a lot
2:45:10 of talent and expertise that we love to bring into CISA to enhance America's security.
2:45:15 Wanted to get your perspective on this type of legislation and how we can make
2:45:20 it easier to bring the best talent into public service. Congressman, I spoke with Congressman
2:45:26 Ghanimer on this. I think this is a very forward-leaning bipartisan bill that we need
2:45:31 more of. This gives us exactly the flexibility we need to compete with industry and
2:45:36 bring in the best that we can into CESA and pay them competitively. -
2:45:41 Yes, I appreciate Congressman Geithner's partnership on this. It is bipartisan legislation. And
2:45:47 so certainly look forward to working with you on trying to get this
2:45:53 implemented. Earlier this year, I held a round table, Mr. Secretary, with Chairman
2:45:59 Garbino, brought him into my district, brought him to California. We gathered representatives
2:46:05 from CISA, hospitals, military bases, utility companies, a local government. Certainly all the
2:46:11 infrastructure, when we talk about rural communities, are all targets to cyber attacks. And certainly
2:46:17 the increase in cyber attacks over the years have grown exponentially. I wanted to get
2:46:23 your sense of how how we can work with you how what congress can do
2:46:28 to assist these rural entities in modernizing their cyber security networks are there additional authorities
2:46:33 that you need additional resources so that we can we can enhance rural communities as
2:46:38 well as urban communities as well our rural communities because a lot of times a
2:46:43 lack of funding especially in very rural areas like where i live they lack a
2:46:48 tremendous amount of funding it's going to take a partnership to do that but there
2:46:53 is there is some authority that we're going to need but we're
2:46:59 probably going to talk about that in a different setting and and they're asking for
2:47:04 it i recently met with the um with the fraternal order of police and and
2:47:10 they were asking for specific authorities met with the sheriff's associations they were asking for
2:47:15 it too but we're going to have to it's going to take legislation and hopefully
2:47:21 we can do it in a bipartisan way. Great. As any way we can help
2:47:25 to bring AI tools to give it to the good guys to protect us from
2:47:30 the bad guys. We certainly look forward to that work. The biggest problem that we
2:47:34 have on this too is some of the stuff we need to send them requires
2:47:39 a clearance and it requires a system for them to be able to access it.
2:47:43 Very few municipalities and counties have that type of facility to access it,
2:47:49 and most of them don't have the clearances. Even we have sheriffs that don't
2:47:55 have the clearances that they need to be able to get access to that.
2:48:02 That's an important piece, and we want to work with you on that. The
2:48:08 question to the Secretary, as well as to Dr. Clayton, in April, the White
2:48:13 House warned that the PRC, their entities are conducting industrial-scale development a
2:48:19 distillation in American frontier AI bottles copying our capabilities without permission. Every
2:48:25 advanced American lab that's making that that make AI capabilities are now
2:48:31 being reproduced in these models and then released and used openly in
2:48:36 the world. including criminals, terrorists, hostile governments, Russia, China, Iran, North Korea, to
2:48:42 name a few. How quickly are you both seeing frontier cyber capabilities reach PRC models
2:48:48 and the actors who use them? And what does that mean for the time American
2:48:54 defenders have to fix vulnerabilities before they're exploited? Let me put it this way. America
2:48:59 is still in the lead. We need to remain in the lead. You bring
2:49:05 up an important point that Americans should recognize, and that is that industrial espionage, whether
2:49:10 it's state sponsored or private sponsored, is a threat. There are people who are seeking
2:49:16 to steal our trade secrets, seeks to steal our exquisite compute. It's something that we
2:49:21 work very closely with the FBI to combat. But it is a reality. And this
2:49:27 is about worldwide threats. One of the worldwide threats to America is industrial espionage. I've
2:49:31 run out of time. The threats are real. And we appreciate the work that you
2:49:35 guys do. Thank you. Thank you. And I recognize the gentleman from Tennessee, Mr. Van
2:49:41 Epps, for five minutes of questions. Thank you, Chairman Garbarino, for continuing to hold these
2:49:46 hearings on worldwide threats to the homeland. And thank you, Secretary Mullen, Director Clayton, and
2:49:50 Deputy Director Raya for joining us today. I'm deeply grateful for the services you all
2:49:55 provide to this country. It's an honor to serve on this committee dedicated to stewarding
2:50:00 our country's security. We know that the threats facing us today are more varied and
2:50:05 complex than ever before. The cyber domain grows increasingly competitive and difficult to defend. Our
2:50:10 critical infrastructure is vulnerable to attacks from the other side of the planet. Our young
2:50:15 people are being radicalized online. Biological, technological, and ideological threats evolve faster every day. During
2:50:20 last year's Worldwide Threats Hearing, I discussed emerging AI threats. Today, that threat is still
2:50:25 a priority. Foreign cyber actors continue to use AI tools to threaten our cyber infrastructure.
2:50:31 Part of our responsibility is to ensure the federal government safeguards our critical systems from
2:50:36 these threats while also clearly delineating how AI can be used across our systems to
2:50:41 make them stronger and more efficient. Director Clayton, leading American AI developers
2:50:47 have activated heightened safeguards on their most capable models because they cannot rule out that
2:50:53 those models could meaningfully help a novice build a biological weapon. In September, Anthropic
2:50:59 disclosed five cases since December in which users tried to get around
2:51:05 its safeguards on dual-use biology involving highly pathogenic avian influenza orthopoxviruses and
2:51:10 toxins. Open weight models offer no such protections once downloaded. Does ODNI
2:51:16 assess that terrorist groups or other non-traditional actors are actively seeking to use
2:51:22 AI to acquire chemical or biological weapons capabilities? And how has the intelligence
2:51:28 community adjusted its collection to detect it? Thank you, and I commend you
2:51:33 for the context in which you placed that question. American frontier model developers
2:51:39 are at the forefront. That capability is very important to national security for
2:51:45 many of the reasons that you just mentioned. That is not isolated work.
2:51:50 They are ahead. They are working with us seeking to develop this capability in what
2:51:56 I would say is irresponsible and controlled environment. That does not mean that people around
2:52:02 the world are following those same rules. It's one of those reasons why we need
2:52:07 to be out in front. so that we can be out in front of those
2:52:12 who would seek to develop similar technology, seek to have similar compute, and not use
2:52:17 it for good. Like we have demonstrated, the United States has demonstrated through every technological
2:52:22 development that our leadership is good for the world, and we need to keep doing
2:52:26 that. Thank you, sir. Director Raya, the terror threat landscape in the U.S. is increasingly
2:52:32 shaped by emerging nihilistic violent extremism or NVE. These decentralized online groups are primarily run
2:52:37 by youth and minors who promote cycles of victimization and coercion, including self-harm extortion and
2:52:43 mass attacks. I'm very concerned about what this is doing to our youth. At the
2:52:48 federal level, how is the FBI approach to investigations and prosecutions tied to NVE groups,
2:52:54 since most are minors with prosecutorial limitations? Thank you for that. Thank you for that
2:52:59 question, Congressman. I, as yourself, is very concerned about that threat, and the FBI is
2:53:04 concerned about that threat. That is a threat that we have pushed a lot of
2:53:09 resources into. It encompasses, obviously for us, it is considered a domestic terrorism threat. groups
2:53:13 like 764, the comm, which I know you're familiar with, but it also has a
2:53:18 crimes against children aspect to it because it's targeting one of our most vulnerable populations,
2:53:23 our children. So what we have done at the FBI is we've created the NVE
2:53:29 fusion cell and we've taken experts from our domestic terrorism folks and experts from our
2:53:34 crimes against children folks and we put them in one room in order to create
2:53:39 that synergy to investigate those cases so we've seen a lot of wins in that
2:53:43 in that space recently but as you said a lot of these are minors and
2:53:48 as you know the federal system is not set up for minors so we rely
2:53:52 a lot on our state and local uh partners uh in not only disrupting those
2:53:56 uh individuals but also um uh also in getting some type of jail time and
2:54:01 making sure they're held accountable. In extreme circumstances with some of our older children, we
2:54:06 can go to the attorney general and prosecute on a federal law, but that is
2:54:11 something that doesn't happen that often. That's something we continue to work on. We're going
2:54:16 to continue to push a lot of energy into, and we're going to continue to
2:54:21 keep our children safe because that is a priority of this administration and of our
2:54:26 director. In the final 15 seconds, any comments on counter UAS? I know you've made
2:54:31 comments on that. I have a long question, but anything you'd like to add? Yeah,
2:54:35 earlier I was explaining to Representative Strong here, we have made a lot of space
2:54:40 in this last 21 months, and we are much better postured now combating as a
2:54:44 country, state, local, and federal, we are much better postured now combating that threat than
2:54:49 when we were just 21 months ago. Right. Thank you gentlemen. Chairman, I yield back.
2:54:53 Chairman Eilts back. I now recognize the gentleman from Pennsylvania, Mr. McKenzie for five minutes.
2:54:57 I just want to say it was a real pleasure having you on the committee.
2:55:01 We're going to miss you. You were a great asset to this committee. So thank
2:55:04 you for all your hard work. thank you well thank you mr chairman it has
2:55:10 been a pleasure to be a member of this committee and appreciate your leadership
2:55:15 and mentorship during my time here on the homeland security committee to our panelists
2:55:21 we talked at length about the challenges that the government through the faa the
2:55:27 nsa and other entities in the private sector have been facing with these outages over
2:55:32 the past week or so. You've given pretty detailed answers about the things that we
2:55:37 can rule out that they are at this time not believed to be related, that
2:55:42 they are not a state sponsor of terror, that there was no malicious activity. I
2:55:47 do have some follow on questions though, that Director Clayton, you talked about the challenges
2:55:52 that we face in upgrading our systems, doing patches, upgrades, et cetera. Is it possible
2:55:58 that AI or SI is exploiting those opportunities that it sees when
2:56:04 an upgrade or a patch is being added to a system to
2:56:10 go in and attack at that point? We've talked today, and I
2:56:15 think it's very important, very important question that we've talked about computing
2:56:21 capabilities, applications capabilities. Think about... people using scanning to identify vulnerabilities
2:56:27 in systems. This is some of the things that cyber malign actors
2:56:33 do. Their ability to scan is increasing. We need to use the
2:56:39 increased compute and the increased capabilities to combat that scanning. That is
2:56:44 going on. That has been going on inside a number of our
2:56:50 sophisticated financial institutions and others. So we are meeting this threat, but it's
2:56:56 something that we need to continue to do. I certainly agree with you. We
2:57:02 need those defensive capabilities against those malicious activities. But I guess my question is this.
2:57:07 Do we think that the outages are a result of the patch being done or
2:57:13 the upgrade being done internally? Or is it somebody taking advantage of the change being
2:57:18 made? I see the question you're asking. It's probably a question the American people are
2:57:23 asking. It's a very good question. We have no indication that... A nefarious actor is
2:57:28 saying, oh, they're in the process of patching. Therefore, we're going to take it, take
2:57:33 advantage of that. We have we have scanned for that. We've looked for that with
2:57:37 the FBI, with the private sector. But you are you are right. One of the
2:57:42 things about patching is you have to anticipate that during that process, you know, people
2:57:46 will scan and the like. These are things that. We've been dealing with, we're going
2:57:51 to be dealing with going forward. And the American people should understand that we are
2:57:56 in the process of upgrading our systems. I'm looking around this room and I'm seeing
2:58:01 different systems from many different decades. Some of them actually a combination of decades.
2:58:07 when you have combinations of old and new equipment on a particular network that makes
2:58:11 upgrades and things like this challenging we're going to go through this challenge but i
2:58:16 think we're going to come out the other side stronger than any country in the
2:58:20 world okay uh more just at a high level uh not any related
2:58:26 to any of the specific outages that we've seen are we seeing increased
2:58:31 usage of state sponsors of terror or our adversaries utilizing ai to try
2:58:37 to attack or exploit our systems
2:58:44 I think that's something we have seen instances of that. We are concerned about that.
2:58:48 I would classify more. We're more concerned about that. I think you're familiar. We issued
2:58:53 a flash related to that here on Friday. And that's something we are going to
2:58:58 work very closely very expeditiously and very aggressively when it comes to that particular threat
2:59:03 factor. In fact, I think you may have been here, but I'll repeat it again
2:59:08 because it bears repeating. We did a complete reorg of our cyber branch, and we've
2:59:14 taken our investigative parts of our cyber capabilities, we've taken our cyber capabilities, we've taken
2:59:19 our cyber intelligence, and taken our OCIO and our cybersecurity. We've all housed them together
2:59:24 under one accountable executive. So SI attacks from SI, it will continue to be something
2:59:28 that we focus on in the future and try to stay ahead of that threat.
2:59:34 right thank you in my final 30 seconds i would just like to say thank
2:59:38 you to the secretary for your leadership of the department the changes you've made around
2:59:43 training which you've talked about at length here your continued work to track down those
2:59:48 children that were lost or not being tracked properly starting from the last administration so
2:59:52 want to commend your efforts there and would just encourage continued efforts to improve TSA.
2:59:57 I've introduced a number of pieces of legislation here to improve our TSA operations for
3:00:01 all travelers, but also specifically for families. And so just want to again, thank you
3:00:06 for all your work and look forward to seeing even more great work coming out
3:00:10 of the department going forward. Thank you, Congressman. You're you're not going to miss the
3:00:14 political theater, but you're going to miss the friendship around this place and you're going
3:00:18 to be missed as well. Thank you. With that, I yield back. Gentleman yields back.
3:00:24 Ranking member has a UC. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr.
3:00:29 Chairman, I action animus consent to enter into the record testimonies,
3:00:35 letters, and statements from democratic forums held in New Orleans, Houston,
3:00:41 Austin, Newark, Bidford, Maine, and Washington, D.C., this conference. Mr. Chairman,
3:00:46 I also action animus consent to to enter into the record letters we've sent to
3:00:52 the secretary and the FBI director of which we have not received answers. Without objection.
3:00:56 Gentlemen, the members of the committee may have some additional questions for you all, and
3:01:01 we would ask that you all respond to these in writing. Presumed to Committee Rule
3:01:06 7E, the hearing record will be held open for 10 days, and I want to
3:01:11 thank you all for being here today. This is a very important hearing, and your
3:01:15 attendance shows that it's that important. Without objection, this committee stands adjourned.
Squawk Pod: Nvidia’s Q3, President Trump in China, & Tech Outages 11/17/26 full transcript
0:00 Bring in show music, please.
0:04 >> This is Squawk Pod and I'm CNBC producer
0:07 Cameron Costa. On today's episode, an
0:10 unprecedented meeting between Presidents
0:13 Donald Trump, Xihinping, and Vladimir
0:16 Putin. Former US Ambassador to China,
0:18 Nicholas Burns, on what it means for the
0:21 war in Ukraine. For those three leaders
0:24 to be talking about the fate of Ukraine
0:26 with President Silinski not at the
0:28 table, I think is a real problem for the
0:30 United States. You know, we've ended all
0:31 military and economic aid to Ukraine.
0:34 Frankly, we're acting more like Putin's
0:36 lawyer these days than Zalinsk's lawyer.
0:39 >> And Wall Street and Main Street are
0:41 gearing up for Anthropic's historic IPO.
0:45 Billy Gford's head of private companies,
0:47 Peter Singlehurst, has put a billion and
0:49 a half of his clients money into the
0:51 company.
0:52 >> I think inevitably there's going to be
0:53 multiple different model makers. What
0:55 makes Anthropic special is that focus on
0:57 the enterprise. It's an existential
0:59 focus that they have on serving
1:00 enterprise customers and also safety.
1:02 Like safety really matters for this
1:04 company because it matters for their
1:05 customers.
1:06 >> And tech outages are worrying some
1:09 folks.
1:09 >> I don't want to say it's panic buying. I
1:11 want to say it's like pulling some stuff
1:12 forward that we're going to use anyway.
1:14 CNBC's Aean Javvers joins us.
1:17 >> I think you just have to kind of bake
1:18 into your expectations that there are
1:19 going to be a lot more outages uh in the
1:22 months and and years to come until we
1:24 get to some equilibrium point.
1:27 >> All that and so much more today,
1:29 Wednesday, November 18th. Squawk Pod
1:32 begins right now.
1:35 >> Stand Becky by in 3 2 1 Please.
1:41 >> Good morning everybody. Welcome to
1:43 Squatbox right here on CNBC. We are live
1:46 from the NASDAQ market site in Times
1:47 Square. I'm Becky Quick along with Joe
1:49 Kernan.
1:50 >> Nvidia, we're all waiting reporting
1:52 better than expected third quarter
1:54 results and strong guidance. Revenue
1:56 more than doubled uh from a year uh to
1:59 about $116 billion and that was above uh
2:03 when we were talking about it yesterday.
2:04 Also the guidance uh for the fourth
2:07 quarter was we had numbers yesterday we
2:09 were talking about that was also above
2:10 interim CEO uh Colette Crest joined Mad
2:14 Money with Jim Kramer last night in her
2:16 first interview uh since Jensen Wong's
2:19 departure.
2:19 >> Important thing that we have been seeing
2:21 is just again a continuous growth in
2:24 terms of the demand that's out there.
2:26 But we also have been working in terms
2:28 of our supply. So, an increase in supply
2:31 working with all of our different
2:33 suppliers, whether that be focusing in
2:35 terms of what we need in terms of chips,
2:37 what we need in terms of advanced
2:39 packaging or memory, all of that is also
2:42 coming together.
2:43 >> And we're still hearing the same thing.
2:45 NVIDIA chair Harvey Jones says the board
2:47 does not intend to bring Jensen Wong
2:50 back. Uh though Semaphore reports some
2:52 board members do want Wong to return. By
2:56 the way, Colette Crest shot that idea
2:58 down with Kramer yesterday, too, when he
3:00 asked her about that. Um, said that's
3:02 not our intention at this at this point.
3:04 >> Who knows whether she speaks,
3:05 >> right?
3:07 >> We've got third quarter results that are
3:08 just out from Lowe's. Earnings coming in
3:11 at $310 a share. That includes a 34%
3:15 positive impact from tariff refunds.
3:16 It's a little unclear if analysts
3:18 included refunds in their estimates or
3:20 how much of a refund they put in. That's
3:22 the difference between a beat and a miss
3:24 when you compare it to the $2.88. an 88
3:25 cent estimate. But if you were looking
3:27 at revenue, revenue did come in at
3:29 $22.76 billion and that was slightly
3:31 above expectations. Comtore sales were
3:34 up by 1.8%. That is a really pretty
3:36 significant jump. The street had
3:38 expected an increase of just a tenth of
3:40 a percent. Gross margins 33% that was
3:43 roughly in line with expectations. And
3:45 Rose Lowe's is now raising its fullear
3:47 earnings guidance to $12.25 25 and also
3:50 raising its fullear sales guidance to
3:52 the range of $92.5 billion versus their
3:55 earlier guidance they had given of
3:56 around $92 billion. Stock right now
3:59 indicated up by about 2%. I did speak
4:01 with u Marvin Ellison the CEO at Lowe's
4:05 and he talked about a lot of the things
4:06 that they're seeing in the sector at
4:07 this point. He did say the same thing
4:09 that we heard from Home Depot the day
4:11 before that the do-it-yourself segment
4:12 is under some economic pressure and
4:15 headwinds that are out there. But he
4:16 says in the meantime they're really
4:17 pleased with what they're doing and said
4:19 that Lowe's is stealing market share as
4:21 well. Uh Home Depot told us they were
4:23 stealing market share. I asked uh Marvin
4:26 Ellison where they're stealing the
4:27 market share from and he said look it's
4:28 really a big misnomer that we operate as
4:31 a duopoly um Lowe's and Home Depot. He
4:34 said between the two of them they still
4:36 make up less than 30% of what he says as
4:38 a 1 trillion dollar tangible addressable
4:40 market in the United States. It's really
4:42 fragmented market. pointed out that
4:44 there's garden centers, hardware stores,
4:47 companies that sell patio furniture, all
4:49 of those really fragmented um uh sector
4:52 that's out there, and those two
4:53 companies are stealing market share from
4:55 all those other places. He said Lowe's
4:57 has underperformed historically, but he
4:59 said now we're just running a better
5:00 business. And he did say it it's not
5:02 unusual and not unexpected to be able to
5:04 see both Lowe's and Home Depot
5:06 outperform. Um in terms of the bright
5:08 subouts that they saw at this company,
5:09 he did say appliances really pleased
5:11 them at this point. they've got this new
5:13 thing where they can hook up next day or
5:15 in two days or in some cases even be
5:17 able to deliver some of these appliances
5:19 same day and he said that's helping them
5:21 win in that area. And he addressed AI.
5:23 You know, yesterday we heard from Home
5:25 Depot's CEO talking about their AI agent
5:28 that's out there. Well, they have an AI
5:31 agent that I think was the first one out
5:32 there. It went out in March of 2025.
5:34 It's called Milo My L. It was built on
5:38 an OpenAI platform. And he said that
5:40 when customers use this um a this agent
5:44 that they have, Milo, um online, it
5:48 winds up being conversion rates that are
5:50 really significant. He said the
5:51 conversion rate triples when people can
5:53 ask Milo questions about what to buy and
5:55 what to do it. When their associates in
5:57 the store use it, he says they see 200
5:59 basis point improvement in customer
6:01 satisfaction. They can track which
6:03 associates are using this AI agent,
6:05 which ones aren't. the ones who are come
6:07 off being much smarter and more
6:09 knowledgeable about the products that
6:11 are there and as a result it does
6:12 improve customer satisfaction. He said
6:15 um and and Joe that's kind of
6:16 interesting just this idea of all of
6:18 these non- tech companies that are
6:20 implementing AI, how does it work? Does
6:22 it pay off? Is there a value ad for
6:24 these things? When you talk to these two
6:25 companies, there definitely is because
6:27 they see customer sales and customer
6:28 satisfaction going up as a result of
6:30 this. um he he talked about how when
6:34 they're answering questions and they're
6:36 answering millions of questions at this
6:37 point um the agent gets smarter and
6:40 smarter over time and that's kind of the
6:42 virtuous cycle that you can see with
6:44 these AI agents. So, you know, you've
6:46 got all these concerns about AI agents,
6:48 what they're knocking out in other
6:49 places, but the companies that are using
6:50 them and continuing to use them are
6:52 seeing some um real tangible effects
6:57 that are improving some of their numbers
6:58 on this. And I I was thinking about it,
7:00 you know, all these small companies that
7:02 are out there, these small stores that
7:04 do it, who they're stealing market share
7:05 from, it's a problem where big companies
7:08 have continued to got get bigger over
7:09 the last 20 years. AI is probably going
7:12 to extend um that very same cycle
7:15 because the smaller companies can't pay
7:16 for some of these AI agents to be doing.
7:18 >> Hard to believe it's only 30%. and and
7:21 we've always sort of
7:22 >> I I have there's a mom and pop hardware
7:26 store near I
7:27 >> I always go to those where we go and and
7:29 and you do feel a little bit uh mixed
7:32 about uh you know as progress rolls
7:35 forward in these
7:36 >> there's rollups that happen and
7:37 everything but I'm surprised there's
7:38 still 70 so that's where they steal the
7:40 market share from again from these poor
7:42 moms they can't
7:45 >> that's progress uh I guess but um
7:48 >> well when you can get something
7:49 fulfilled day of when for servicing the
7:51 pro like that. It's it's tough. But I it
7:54 did make me think we should talk to some
7:55 of these small business owners and and
7:56 see the impact that's happening there
7:58 just in terms of what he's seeing from
8:00 the overall consumer with the economy
8:02 that's out there. He said their cons
8:04 their consumers do continue to be valued
8:06 driven. But he also pointed out that
8:08 twothirds of Lowe's revenue is
8:10 non-discretionary purchases like if a
8:12 refrigerator breaks or if the roof leaks
8:13 or if the hot water heater goes out. Um
8:16 and those are purchases they have to
8:18 make. He also said that all of the
8:21 historic demand drivers, you know,
8:22 they're waiting for things to turn. All
8:24 of these all of these um uh home
8:26 improvement companies, home equity,
8:29 there's a ton of it that's built up out
8:31 there. Personal disposable income
8:32 continues to go up. And the age of the
8:34 home, he said, is that the oldest in
8:36 history. It's like 44 years old is the
8:38 age of the average home at this point.
8:39 So, he said all those things are moving
8:40 in the right directions. They do think
8:42 that there will be a point where all
8:44 that pent-up demand, he said based on
8:46 their surveys, they think there's about
8:47 $40 billion in pent-up demand for big
8:49 projects that has have not taken place
8:51 and consumers are waiting to see.
8:52 >> So these agents that that get smarter as
8:55 time goes by that that's not quite
8:57 >> what what your experience has been.
8:59 >> No, that's not No, that's not RSI.
9:01 Recursive self-improvement. No,
9:03 >> no, this is just as you answer
9:05 questions, the models get smarter,
9:06 right? They're training themselves.
9:07 >> So that's still coming. Not here yet,
9:10 >> right? I'm just trying to figure out how
9:12 long we have
9:14 >> before.
9:14 >> Yeah.
9:15 >> End of days.
9:16 >> Yeah. Before they don't need us anymore.
9:18 >> The final thing I'll say from um Marvin
9:20 Ellison is that he does think that they
9:24 can lay out in December when they have
9:26 their analyst meeting. They're going to
9:27 lay out how they think they can grow
9:28 irrespective of the macro economic
9:31 environment. And that's the same message
9:32 we heard from Home Depot. But you're
9:33 right. I I was surprised by that. less
9:36 than 30% of the market number between
9:38 those two because we do play it off like
9:39 a duopoly. It's going to be this one.
9:41 >> They do. So, irregardless of that.
9:43 >> Yes.
9:44 >> You said irrespective. I think that's a
9:46 good one.
9:47 >> I wrote irrespective.
9:48 >> That's fine.
9:48 >> I literally wrote irrespective.
9:50 >> Because if you're going to use if you
9:51 don't want to use regardless,
9:53 you got to go right from regardless to
9:56 dis
9:56 >> irregardless toive. No, you got to go to
9:58 disregard regardless. Yeah. Double
10:00 negative.
10:00 >> Yeah. Yeah. To get back to regardless. I
10:03 think that's what we that's what we
10:04 decided.
10:06 Missouo has a no doubt uh that customers
10:09 have started panic buying more
10:11 essentials in the wake of multiple US
10:15 >> guilty
10:16 >> tech outages. Missou bumping up is
10:18 >> its price target uh on Costco shares uh
10:23 to $1,150.
10:25 >> Joe asked me my address again yesterday
10:28 because we were texting back and forth
10:29 and he wanted to you can't me take my
10:33 water. You can't
10:35 >> cuz he's going to beat me up for it.
10:36 >> Okay. So, you're not going to out me
10:38 completely. You can tell. I don't care.
10:40 >> I'm about to out myself. I'm about to
10:42 out myself.
10:42 >> You can out yourself. I You asked me if
10:44 I have a bunch of water. I said, "No, I
10:45 have a Glock."
10:46 >> Yeah.
10:47 >> And all my neighbors are stocked up. So,
10:50 what's your address?
10:50 >> It's a joke. And then I And then I ask
10:53 you for your address. A Glock and a
10:54 thousand rounds. So, um
10:56 >> I I don't want to say it's panic buying.
10:57 I want to say it's like pulling some
10:59 stuff forward that we're going to use
11:00 anyway,
11:01 >> right?
11:01 >> Like toilet paper and water. Although I
11:03 did go down a rabbit hole yesterday on
11:05 the internet about things you really
11:07 need to buy.
11:08 >> Do people in
11:10 >> stockpile wipes? You know those moist
11:12 wipes?
11:12 >> I did order baby wipes. Unscented baby
11:15 wipes.
11:16 >> Those work. Those work.
11:17 >> Not not for wipes, but for you know it's
11:19 good to have some wipes around.
11:20 >> I don't know. Toilet paper.
11:22 >> That's your shower, too. If things
11:23 really go down,
11:24 >> toilet paper needs to be a lot of times
11:26 only a shower is going to Right. Well,
11:28 what I will warn you is the rabbit hole
11:31 I went down yesterday is okay. One of
11:32 the first things that stops if there's a
11:34 grid outage or something for a few days.
11:36 >> Yeah.
11:36 >> If the electricity goes down, and I
11:38 remember this from just weather events.
11:40 The reason we originally got a generator
11:41 was because the power was out for like a
11:43 week.
11:44 >> Exactly. A gener is a godsend.
11:47 >> But it it one of the things they point
11:49 out is if the electricity goes out to
11:51 the water plants and to the pumps, you
11:53 can't flush your toilets. And dissentry
11:56 can be a big problem if you got three or
11:57 four days. So they're promoting the idea
11:59 of buying those portable toilet, you
12:01 know, the
12:02 >> the the buckets that are toilets with
12:04 things in them.
12:05 >> That was the rabbit hole I went down
12:06 last.
12:07 >> Awesome. That's
12:09 Oh,
12:10 >> they're like rushing us along. I don't
12:12 know why.
12:12 >> Uh Aiman's waiting.
12:13 >> Maybe we're sharing.
12:14 >> Aiman. Yeah, I think maybe maybe we are.
12:17 Maybe Aean can uh can weigh in on some
12:19 of this. I think it's the one thing that
12:21 maybe Europeans were smart about those
12:24 squirt things, you know,
12:25 >> the days. Yeah, those are Yeah, those
12:27 are nice.
12:28 >> The only thing that in certain instances
12:30 >> and then you don't need wipes, right?
12:32 Apple and the NSA, the latest
12:34 organizations to be hit with tech
12:35 problems. The Trump administration
12:37 continues to say that the recent outages
12:40 don't stem from a coordinated cyber
12:42 attack. Aean Javvers joins us with more
12:45 on this, but boy, the coincidences keep
12:47 piling up at this point. Aean? Yeah,
12:50 that's right, Beck. I don't have any uh
12:51 particular toilet related thoughts this
12:53 morning for you guys. Uh but we did have
12:56 Jay Clayton, the director of
12:57 nationalities share with you don't want
12:59 to share with us. That's fine. That's
13:00 fine. You're all
13:01 >> I mean, I might share with you, but I
13:03 don't want to share with the I might
13:04 share with you, but I don't want to
13:05 share with the whole world
13:06 >> with our tens of you and I, you know,
13:08 that'd be one thing,
13:10 >> right? But there's a lot of people
13:11 watching and so
13:12 >> now you're left to our imaginations to
13:14 wonder if you're into
13:15 >> bed letting us dangle. Yeah.
13:17 >> Please don't. Please don't. I have that
13:19 image in my head now.
13:20 >> Uh let's talk about let's talk about
13:23 Jake Leightton. Uh he's the director of
13:24 national intelligence. He was on CNBC
13:26 yesterday with some re reassuring words
13:29 about all of this for markets and for
13:32 the general public. He said first of all
13:34 what we're not seeing here is a cyber
13:36 attack. He said there's no nation state
13:38 that's been behind all of this. uh and
13:41 he did offer an explanation which is
13:43 that AI is moving so quickly and
13:45 exposing so many vulnerabilities that
13:47 people are really having to rush to
13:50 patch those vulnerabilities quickly and
13:51 it's that patching activity which may be
13:54 causing a lot of these outages as people
13:56 patch quickly and unintentionally create
13:59 other problems. Here's what he said
14:00 yesterday on CNBC.
14:02 >> Many people are patching their systems.
14:05 They know that their legacy systems have
14:07 vulnerabilities. They're outdated. They
14:09 don't work well with new systems. It is
14:12 time for an upgrade across our digital
14:14 infrastructure. And as you patch and
14:17 upgrade your systems,
14:19 taking them down and bringing them back
14:20 up, there are things like this that
14:23 happen.
14:23 >> And we did get a similar statement from
14:25 Mark Warner, the ranking Democrat on the
14:27 Senate Intelligence Committee. So,
14:28 there's sort of bipartisan agreement in
14:30 messaging uh here in Washington about
14:32 what's causing all of this. Uh, and to
14:35 put a a finer point on it, we saw a note
14:37 from CISA just yesterday, guys, about a
14:40 bug that's been discovered in Java,
14:42 which is a a very very common
14:45 programming language. Uh, and CISA is
14:47 recommending that this patch be done
14:49 immediately. They say SISA strongly
14:52 urges organizations to immediately patch
14:54 the recently disclosed Oracle Java
14:56 vulnerability and they name the
14:58 vulnerability and say and offer some
15:00 instructions on how to patch it. So
15:02 these things are happening much more
15:04 frequently now uh as AI tools, more
15:07 sophisticated tools are scouring
15:10 existing systems and finding these
15:12 vulnerabilities that human coders maybe
15:14 didn't find over the years. Uh and now
15:16 there's this accelerated rush to patch
15:19 all those and the patching itself is
15:21 causing some of this disturbance. So
15:22 that's the good news. The bad news is,
15:24 you know, this is going to be a long
15:26 process. There's decades and decades of
15:28 accumulated vulnerabilities out there
15:30 and the speed of finding them uh is
15:33 going to be much quicker. The time to
15:35 patch is going to be much less.
15:36 Companies are going to have to really
15:38 move very very quickly here. All of that
15:41 is going to be expensive and all of that
15:43 probably you'd have to imagine is going
15:46 to lead to a lot more outages. Guys,
15:48 >> yeah, Aean, I I I I hear what they're
15:50 saying. They don't want to create a
15:52 panic and say that it's a cyber attack
15:53 on these things. But if it's coming from
15:55 AI and these outages go down, you still
15:58 have the huge concern that Americans
16:01 have to figure out what to do. You know,
16:02 there have been warnings that have gone
16:03 out. I think in Germany, they're telling
16:04 you to prepare for up to 10 days of
16:07 outages. In the UK, it's 3 days. Um,
16:11 >> and and those are the type of things.
16:12 You know, they'll tell you even that now
16:14 some military bases are trying to be
16:16 able to be prepared to to plan for 90
16:18 days without the grid, no matter who's
16:20 doing it. If it's AI, if we're doing
16:21 this to ourselves, we are incredibly
16:24 reliant on these systems. And at this
16:27 point, the patches are coming faster,
16:29 the updates are coming faster. You know,
16:31 instead of doing a hundred of these
16:33 updates a year, company may do thousands
16:34 of these updates a year. And that's a
16:37 lot of vulnerability that we maybe
16:39 didn't realize we had before.
16:42 >> I think that's right. And that's what a
16:43 lot of the AI experts have predicted is
16:45 that there would be a wave of
16:46 vulnerabilities discovered by AI as that
16:49 scour as AI scour these existing
16:52 systems. And that's exactly what we're
16:54 seeing. And I think you just have to
16:56 kind of bake into your expectations that
16:57 there are going to be a lot more outages
16:59 uh in the months and and years to come
17:01 until we get to some equilibrium point
17:05 where AI has now patched as many of
17:08 these flaws as it has discovered. But
17:10 between now and whatever X date that is,
17:13 you're going to see a lot of sort of
17:16 rough going as companies realize that
17:18 they have these vulnerabilities and try
17:19 to do something about it
17:22 under the surface here and and uh I mean
17:25 we're f I'm friends with Clayton. All
17:26 right. I I love him. But
17:29 you know, Mullen told you something and
17:31 you're like h and Sean, the other
17:35 secretary, transportation secretary told
17:37 you something.
17:39 Yeah.
17:40 >> Aren't you glad Jay is in that job?
17:42 >> I am.
17:43 >> Right now. And and when and when he says
17:45 it, I'm like, I feel he's got a lot of
17:48 of credibility.
17:52 >> Cheese will be next.
17:53 >> Coming up on SquawkPod, former US
17:56 ambassador to China, Nicholas Burns.
17:58 President Trump's trilateral meeting
18:00 with Xiinping and Vladimir Putin. Plus,
18:02 the impact of the Jensen Hang scandal on
18:06 chip sales in China. I think given
18:08 everything that's happened with Nvidia
18:10 over the last two weeks, there's almost
18:12 a unanimous view in Congress, led by
18:15 Republicans, that we have to shut down
18:17 all chip sales, advanced chip sales to
18:20 China. The Nvidia board said at their
18:22 earnings poll yesterday that they would
18:24 not sell them. I can't see that now as a
18:27 possibility, and it shouldn't be a
18:28 possibility.
18:32 >> This is SquawkPod. Here's Joe Kernan.
18:35 President Trump, if you don't know yet,
18:37 arrived in China for the second leg of
18:38 his overseas trip. It was kind of it was
18:40 kind of cool. Uh Becky, um watching
18:44 President Xi walk down the red carpet to
18:48 get to to the
18:49 >> to the stairs
18:50 >> to to where the stairs were. That that's
18:52 unusual for President Xi. And it uh I
18:56 don't know. Uh sometimes I think he of
18:58 course maybe it's a couple of you know
19:00 the the critics or the left would say
19:02 it's a couple of dictators you know ping
19:04 around but it is an example of how it is
19:07 an example of how how he he might be
19:08 viewed differently than some some of the
19:11 factions in this country. Earlier the
19:13 president posted on social media that he
19:16 had struck a trade deal uh with the
19:18 Philippines that would benefit American
19:20 farmers and the US energy uh industry.
19:22 Tomorrow, President Trump's expected to
19:24 meet with she and Russian President
19:26 Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the
19:29 AsiaPacific Economic Cooperation Summit.
19:33 Potential topics on the agenda, the
19:36 Ukraine war, uh the Iran war, AI as well
19:40 as nuclear weapons are all there. the
19:43 three superpowers in terms of uh nuclear
19:47 capabilities.
19:48 We got a lot of them left, you know, as
19:51 people.
19:51 >> Yeah.
19:53 >> Am I ready to worry more more about AI
19:56 than than nuclear? No. Am I ready to
19:59 worry about warm weather more than um
20:05 increased, you know, having warm, wet,
20:06 cold, dry years?
20:07 >> I'm more worried about AI than I am
20:09 about climate change.
20:11 >> Yeah. been nice. Did we not have a great
20:14 fall? Was it not really nice? Huh? Would
20:16 North Carolina Would that be the end of
20:18 the world to have their weather up here?
20:20 And No, I'm kidding. I just I'm tweaking
20:23 people. They go crazy, but they're not
20:25 they're not around as much anymore.
20:27 They're they're uh I think they're
20:29 depressed. They're depressed cuz it's
20:30 not on uh might be top of mind again in
20:33 June.
20:36 >> Joining us right now is Harvard
20:38 University professor Nicholas Burns.
20:40 He's a career foreign service officer
20:42 serving six presidents, both Republican
20:44 and Democrat. Most recently, he served
20:46 as US ambassador to China in the Biden
20:49 administration. He's also served as US
20:51 ambassador to NATO. And uh Ambassador,
20:54 tell us what you think is most
20:56 important, what's happening here, what
20:58 we should be watching.
20:59 >> Uh Becky, I think the bilateral meeting
21:02 between President Trump and President Xi
21:03 is going to be important. The two sides
21:05 are trying to work out a tariff truce so
21:08 they wouldn't raise tariffs on each
21:09 other for the next 12 months or so, but
21:12 also a supply chain truce so that would
21:14 prevent China from taking rare earth uh
21:17 off the table out of the US market. And
21:19 they've had a lot of difficulty over the
21:21 past year and agreeing to it. Scott
21:22 Besson's been taking the lead for the US
21:24 and I think it's the right two goals,
21:26 you know, to establish so that they
21:28 don't decouple the two economies,
21:30 establish some ground rules that will
21:32 enable trade and investment. Whether or
21:34 not they can get that, hard to know.
21:36 China is withholding most of their earth
21:38 supply to the American economy, which is
21:40 a big problem. So, I'm looking I'm
21:43 looking for that. Uh the other issue
21:45 here, of course, is the trilateral
21:47 meeting among President Trump, President
21:50 Xi, and President Putin. And there's a
21:52 serious issue here that the president is
21:54 going to raise and that's China's
21:56 unconstrained nuclear weapons uh
21:58 buildup. It's the fastest rising nuclear
22:00 weapons power in the world. And they're
22:02 not talking to anybody about it. And I
22:04 think President Trump is right to raise
22:06 the issue of nuclear weapons. He won't
22:08 get very far because I think President
22:10 Trump and excuse me, President Xi and
22:12 President Putin are going to stick
22:14 together on that.
22:16 >> U right to raise the issue. um what is
22:20 the ultimate goal and and how long do
22:22 you think that plays out if you don't
22:23 think he's going to get very far in this
22:25 meeting? What do you think he can
22:27 accomplish over the next two years?
22:29 >> The Chinese have resisted for many many
22:31 years any discussions with the United
22:34 States or any other country about their
22:36 nuclear weapons buildup. You know, the
22:38 whole history of the last 60 years, uh,
22:40 for the most part has been the nuclear
22:42 weapons powers being more transparent
22:44 with each other, agreeing to reductions
22:46 in strategic nuclear weapons. Until
22:48 recently, that's now now gone with the
22:50 Russians as well. And so, you do want to
22:53 hold the Chinese to be accountable. So,
22:55 this is the first head of government
22:57 meeting where it's going to be raised.
22:59 And I think that is important. The
23:01 problem with the trilateral meeting, at
23:03 least in my judgment, is the symbolism
23:06 of the three of them getting together
23:08 and who's not at the table. Uh,
23:10 President Trump said that he wanted to
23:11 raise Ukraine with uh with Shee Shinping
23:15 and and Vladimir Putin and to try for
23:18 those three leaders to be talking about
23:20 the fate of Ukraine with President
23:22 Zinski not at the table, I think is a
23:24 real problem for the United States. You
23:26 know, we've ended all military and
23:28 economic aid to Ukraine. Frankly, we're
23:30 acting more like Putin's lawyer these
23:32 days than Zalinsk's lawyer. And it's
23:35 certainly in the long-term interest of
23:37 the United States not to see Russia
23:38 succeed in in destroying the Ukrainian
23:41 nation state. So, I think that's a real
23:43 image problem. This is going to be a
23:45 short meeting among the three leaders.
23:47 The photo op is going to be the center
23:49 of it. And the symbolism of of them
23:51 together without without Ukraine,
23:53 without the Japanese prime minister
23:55 who's who's being intimidated right now.
23:57 They're trying to intimidate by by
23:59 Xihinping and Putin. Also a problem. So
24:02 I think allies are worried about this
24:04 meeting and I think that the White House
24:06 should have structured it differently.
24:08 We were talking earlier, Mr. Ambassador,
24:10 what what's going to get us first? U
24:12 nuclear or or AI? Um
24:16 both dangerous. There's a there's a
24:18 concern that that um given this Jensen
24:20 Wong situation that we've seen play out,
24:24 Jensen
24:25 I think wanted to sell chips to wanted
24:28 to get around the export control. I
24:30 think the president at times almost
24:34 seemed like he was going to look the
24:35 other way or from what his own commerce
24:38 department had had decided uh because he
24:42 I think he thinks it might be in the
24:44 best interest. He's a big proponent of
24:46 of what he calls SI. Uh and this could
24:49 be a bargaining chip over there that
24:52 that he can use to get something else.
24:54 Do you think he should uh he should come
24:57 to some agreement with with President Xi
24:59 about getting the high-end Nvidia chips
25:00 that to get something else that that he
25:02 wants or or would that be even more
25:04 dangerous than the other thing he wants?
25:07 >> I think this is the elephant in the
25:08 room, Joe. Um, you know, four years ago,
25:10 President Biden, with a lot of
25:11 Republican support, shut down the sale
25:14 of all American advanced semiconductors
25:16 into China really because we don't want
25:18 the People's Liberation Army to get our
25:20 most sensitive technology and to
25:22 militarize, you know, new weapons to
25:24 compete with our military. We don't want
25:26 the Chinese private sector to have a leg
25:28 up on our private sector in the AI race.
25:30 So I think given everything that's
25:33 happened with Nvidia over the last 2
25:34 weeks, there's almost a unanimous view
25:37 in Congress led by Republicans that we
25:40 have to shut down all chip sales,
25:42 advanced chip sales to China. The Nvidia
25:44 board said at their earnings call
25:46 yesterday that they would not sell them.
25:48 I can't see that now as a possibility
25:51 and it shouldn't be a possibility.
25:52 >> What if President Xi promises to
25:54 cooperate with us on the safety of uh I
25:56 mean I can't even say that with a
25:57 straight face. Yeah, I mean we need to u
26:01 we need to tread lightly. I I would
26:03 think but they they don't like they they
26:05 have a stated intention of how they want
26:08 the future to play out in China.
26:10 >> Well, they do. Look, I think it's
26:12 important that the two countries, the
26:13 two leaders actually talk about uh AI.
26:17 We certainly want human beings to be at
26:19 to be in control of nuclear weapons, not
26:22 AI systems. President Biden and
26:23 President Xi agreed on that two years
26:25 ago. So I think the beginning of a
26:27 dialogue and and Bessent Scott Bessent
26:29 is going to be the leader on the
26:30 American side is a good thing with
26:31 China, but I wouldn't trust that China's
26:33 going to up, you know, hold to any deal.
26:36 Xiinping has a track record of promising
26:38 American presidents he'll do this or
26:40 that and then reneging on the promise.
26:42 So we've got to be really careful here
26:44 and very hard-headed.
26:46 >> Ambassador Burns, we want to thank you
26:48 for your time today.
26:51 Still to come on SquawkPod, the IPO of
26:54 the year, possibly of all time,
26:57 Anthropic. What we're expecting from
27:00 tomorrow's debut with Bailey Gford's
27:02 Peter Singlehurst. He's invested a
27:04 billion and a half dollars in the
27:06 company on behalf of his clients. I
27:08 think the real story here is that growth
27:11 and value creation that's happening in
27:13 the private markets. We saw it with
27:14 SpaceX as well, where you're seeing
27:16 trillions of dollars of value being
27:18 created in private markets. And to do
27:19 growth equity investing properly in this
27:22 era, you have to be doing it in both
27:23 public but also in private markets to
27:25 ensure that investors are capturing that
27:27 full range of upside.
27:33 Welcome back to Squawk Pod. Toward the
27:35 end of this morning's Squawk Box, Becky
27:37 Quick left set to go on assignment. Stay
27:40 tuned for more on that later this week.
27:42 And CNBC's Mike Sani stepped in at the
27:44 NASDAQ to help us cover what could
27:47 become the biggest IPO story in history.
27:52 >> Anthropic is expected to price its IPO
27:54 tonight ahead of its highly anticipated
27:56 public debut on the NASDAQ tomorrow.
27:58 Joining us now is By Gford, head of
28:00 private companies, Peter Singlehurst.
28:02 The firm has invested about $1.5 billion
28:04 dollars into Anthropic on behalf of
28:06 clients. It's good to see you. Thanks
28:08 for joining us here. Um, so you invested
28:11 uh was it in summer of 2025? Is that
28:14 about right? So at the time I think that
28:16 round was it below 200 billion I think
28:18 in market cap. So is there a correct
28:21 number? Is there an optimum market cap
28:24 you'd like to see it debut at that both
28:26 kind of recognizes the potential of the
28:28 company and makes it a a a good
28:31 performing stock as a public company?
28:33 >> I think ultimately as investors we focus
28:35 on what companies can do over very long
28:36 periods of time. uh we're wanting to own
28:38 companies for five 10 years plus. We try
28:41 to do that both privately and then into
28:42 the public markets as well. I think
28:44 ultimately what matters for anthropic is
28:47 not what the valuation is going to be in
28:48 the IPO. What matters is can they
28:50 continue to develop frontier models. Can
28:52 that translate into high levels of
28:54 revenue growth and profitability. These
28:56 will be the things that really matter. I
28:57 think ultimately those are the
28:59 determinants of success, not what the
29:00 price is on the day it opens. Most of
29:02 the financial performance as revealed in
29:04 the filings I think has come as a bit of
29:07 an upside surprise just in terms of the
29:08 economics of the business the growth
29:11 rates the scale that it's achieved. Uh
29:13 obviously big questions though remain
29:16 longer term about whether the frontier
29:18 models will continue to acrue uh you
29:21 know the real benefits or at least have
29:23 a big profit share as AI uh develops in
29:27 the future and then obviously the
29:28 commitments to the cost of delivering on
29:30 those models. So how are you framing
29:32 those issues?
29:33 >> So so so we have a a strong hypothesis
29:35 that value will continue to acrue to the
29:38 frontier models. Undoubtedly there is
29:41 going to be wide proliferation of models
29:42 that are good enough. Um and indeed an
29:45 anthropic has their own versions of
29:47 those models, the haiku models. But when
29:49 you look at technological evolutions,
29:51 what you normally see is the vast
29:54 majority of of revenue and profit
29:56 acrewing to those companies that are at
29:58 the leading edge. You could look back at
29:59 the mobile era where most of the value
30:01 accrewed to Apple despite and Android
30:04 becoming ubiquitous. We believe that's
30:06 going to happen in AI as well and we
30:07 think anthropic is the best place to
30:09 remain at the frontier and therefore
30:11 recruit.
30:11 >> So this is this another kind of winner
30:13 takemost sector of technology. In other
30:16 words, the other model makers are are
30:18 going to be disadvantaged versus
30:19 anthropic.
30:20 >> I think inevitably there's going to be
30:21 multiple different model makers. Um what
30:24 makes anthropic special is that focus on
30:26 the enterprise. there's an existential
30:28 focus that they have on serving
30:29 enterprise customers. Um, and also
30:32 safety, like safety really matters for
30:34 this company because it matters for
30:35 their customers. If you are an
30:37 enterprise and you're letting AI agents
30:38 into your environment, you're going to
30:40 really care about safety. It's part of
30:42 their competitive advantage and it's one
30:43 of the core reasons that we own it. I I
30:45 feel as if with the market cap now
30:48 getting into the zone of a trillion and
30:49 a half, whatever it actually ends up at
30:51 plus or minus, it creates a pretty clean
30:54 comparison with Meta, which is at
30:56 exactly that market cap. So Meta 2027
31:00 numbers, it's going to have more than
31:01 300 billion in revenue, 90 billion in
31:03 net income. Obviously, it's spending a
31:04 lot of its cash flow to build, but I I
31:07 wonder how you think about that with a a
31:09 somewhat more mature business that's
31:11 also feeding off the same trends at a
31:13 similar market cap to one which is now
31:15 at like an $80 billion revenue run rate
31:17 annually.
31:18 >> I think the meta comparison is a really
31:19 interesting one because the story that
31:21 really sort of comes out to me from that
31:24 is the difference in the value at which
31:26 these companies are coming to the public
31:27 markets. You know, Meta IPOed in 2012 at
31:30 a valuation about onetenth of the value
31:33 that Anthropic is is coming to the
31:35 public markets at. I think the real
31:37 story here is that growth and value
31:39 creation that's happening in the private
31:41 markets. We saw it with SpaceX as well
31:44 where you're seeing trillions of dollars
31:45 of value being created in private
31:47 markets. And to do growth equity
31:48 investing properly in this era, you have
31:51 to be doing it in both public but also
31:52 in private markets to ensure that
31:54 investors are capturing that full range
31:55 of upside. that would seem to mean that
31:58 there isn't quite as much left for the
32:00 public investor once this is out there,
32:03 right? I mean, Facebook came public 100
32:05 billion as you said, it's even less than
32:06 a tenth of what Anthropic is going to
32:08 come at in 2012. Um, does that change
32:12 the the dynamic in terms of whether it's
32:14 fruitful to buy growth companies as a
32:16 public investor?
32:17 >> I think there are two stories of growth
32:19 equity investing over the last 15 years.
32:21 The first is this private for longer or
32:23 kind of bigger faster dynamic, but the
32:25 second is that public companies have
32:27 become bigger than anybody thought they
32:29 could become if you go back 15 years
32:31 ago. And so that's made growth equity
32:32 investing still a viable and prosperous
32:35 way to invest in in the public markets.
32:38 >> Again, it's these two dynamics that are
32:40 really important. I think for anthropic
32:42 there's still so much growth that's
32:44 happening and we believe this is going
32:45 to be an exceptional growth stock into
32:47 the public market
32:47 >> and presumably you will continue to hold
32:49 it uh once we price through and all the
32:51 rest.
32:52 >> We're long term.
32:53 >> All right. Uh Peter, thank you very
32:54 much. Thanks for coming by.
32:56 >> That's it for SquawkPod today. Thank you
32:58 for listening and be sure to tune in to
33:01 CNBC all day tomorrow. We'll have
33:04 coverage of Anthropic IPO from early
33:07 investors to retail perspectives.
33:10 Squawkbox is hosted by Joe Kernan, Becky
33:13 Quick, and Andrew Rossorgan. You can
33:15 catch them live for three hours straight
33:18 if you tune in to CNBC on weekday
33:21 mornings starting at 6 Eastern. You can
33:23 always get the best bits from that TV
33:26 show right into your ears if you follow
33:28 SquawkPod wherever you're listening now.
33:31 We'll meet you right back here tomorrow.
33:33 Have a great day.
33:35 >> We are clear. Thanks, guys.
AI chip export controls targeting China gain bipartisan momentum after Nvidia scandal full transcript
0:00 Jensen Huang's reported
0:01 affair with an alleged
0:01 Chinese spy has increased
0:03 pressure on Congress to
0:04 protect American AI
0:05 dominance. Amid the Nvidia
0:07 scandal, three export
0:08 control bills are gaining
0:09 momentum on Capitol
0:10 Hill. The bills previously
0:12 stalled, but are now seeing
0:13 bipartisan support.
0:14 One or all of the proposals
0:15 could be attached to the
0:16 National Defense
0:17 Authorization Act.
0:18 The NDAA authorizes defense
0:20 funding and is considered
0:21 must-pass legislation,
0:23 but has met some resistance
0:24 from Democrats this year
0:25 amid concerns over the Iran
0:27 war. As negotiations play
0:28 out on the Hill, these are
0:29 the bills I'm watching.
0:36 The AI Overwatch Act would
0:37 require Congress to review
0:39 the sale of advanced AI
0:40 chips to American
0:41 adversaries like China and
0:42 Iran. It's backed by an
0:43 unlikely duo: Massachusetts
0:45 Democratic Senator Elizabeth
0:46 Warren, and Indiana
0:47 Republican Senator, Jim
0:49 Banks. Both urged Congress
0:50 to pass the legislation
0:51 after the Nvidia scandal
0:53 broke. They also called on
0:54 the Commerce Department to
0:55 close export control
0:56 loopholes and ensure that
0:57 advanced AI chips aren't
0:59 going to China's military.
1:01 Then there's the Chip
1:01 Security Act. It would
1:02 require the Department of
1:03 Commerce to verify the
1:05 location of advanced AI
1:06 chips and ensure they don't
1:08 end up in unauthorized
1:09 regions. Finally,
1:10 the Match act would block
1:12 the sale of semiconductor
1:13 manufacturing equipment to
1:14 adversary countries.
1:15 The bill advanced out of the
1:16 House Foreign Affairs
1:17 Committee in April, but it
1:18 never got a vote on the
1:19 House floor. Florida
1:20 Conservative Representative
1:21 Brian Mast, who leads the
1:22 committee, told reporters
1:24 that similar proposals have
1:25 gained momentum lately.
1:26 He said the Trump
1:27 administration gave marching
1:28 orders to stop advanced
1:29 AI chips from being smuggled
1:30 into China. That's a
1:31 departure from December
1:33 2025, when Trump authorized
1:35 the sale of Nvidia's H 200
1:36 chips to approved customers
1:38 in China. Before he
1:39 resigned, former Nvidia CEO
1:41 Jensen Huang lobbied
1:43 Congress and the Trump
1:44 administration against
1:45 banning chip sales to China.
1:46 He'll now appear before
1:47 Congress on December 1st,
1:49 and some Democrats have said
1:50 they'll conduct probes into
1:51 him next term. Over the next
1:53 few weeks, China hawks and
1:54 the tech industry will be
1:55 watching to see. Will this
1:57 Congress make export
1:58 controls one of its final
1:59 acts?
Markets Midday: Stocks Turn Mixed, Rate Hikes Ahead, Target Shares Rally 11-18-2026 full transcript
0:02 I'm Peter Shack now, CNBC. Stocks are
0:05 mixed and off the best levels of the
0:07 session with market sentiment initially
0:09 helped by an upbeat quarterly earnings
0:11 report from market bellweather Nvidia.
0:13 The Dow is down 446 points at 50,313.
0:17 The S&P 500 14 points lower or 210 of a
0:20 percent. The Nasdaq Composite holding on
0:22 to a quarter percent gain or about 57
0:25 points. Nvidia, by the way, is down more
0:27 than two and a half% after trading
0:29 higher earlier. Investors may be giving
0:31 additional weight to comments by Fed
0:33 Governor Christopher Waller, who told
0:35 CNBC that a half point rate hike could
0:37 be necessary at the next Fed meeting.
0:39 >> I'm very concerned about inflation. It's
0:41 kind of headed in the wrong direction
0:42 and it's spreading out. It's not just
0:45 concentrated a few categories. That's
0:47 one of the concerns is when inflation
0:49 starts spreading out and it's not just a
0:51 one-time level shock for something else.
0:53 So that's got me really concerned about
0:55 inflation. And so I think we need to get
0:57 a lot more I mean inflation's been above
0:58 our target for over five years. So if
1:02 you really want to get it down, you've
1:03 got to start taking more aggressive
1:04 actions.
1:05 >> We'll have more insight on the Fed's
1:06 thinking this afternoon when the minutes
1:08 of the most recent policy meeting are
1:10 released. The anthropic IPO will price
1:12 tonight with shares of the AI company
1:14 beginning to trade tomorrow. Peter
1:17 Singlehurst, head of private companies
1:18 at investment firm Belly Gford, says the
1:21 pricing and market value of Anthropic is
1:23 not where investors should be putting
1:25 their focus.
1:25 >> I think ultimately as investors, we
1:27 focus on what companies can do over very
1:28 long periods of time. I think ultimately
1:30 what matters for Anthropic is not what
1:32 the valuation is going to be in the IPO.
1:34 What matters is can they continue to
1:36 develop frontier models? Can that
1:38 translate into high levels of revenue
1:40 growth and profitability? These will be
1:41 the things that really matter. I think
1:43 ultimately those are the determinants of
1:45 success, not what the price is on the
1:47 day it opens.
1:47 >> If you've been worrying about the
1:49 proliferation of techreated outages
1:51 recently, cyber security experts say a
1:53 coordinated cyber attack is not a likely
1:56 possibility. Kevin Mandia is CEO of
1:58 cyber security firm AMD and he says
2:00 fears that AI is helping hack computer
2:03 systems are overblown.
2:04 >> AI is not the surreptitious hunter on
2:07 the internet yet. It is loud. It does a
2:09 lot of things that don't make sense. It
2:11 leaves a trail like a tank through a
2:13 corn field. So right now they've got
2:15 this right. This is not a cyber attack
2:18 that's coordinated. They would know by
2:19 now. It would leak by now and everybody
2:22 would know. It's just heightened
2:24 diligence, heightened concern because of
2:27 a lot of folks fear of AI.
2:29 >> Two new reports out today are painting a
2:30 weak picture for the housing market.
2:32 Housing starts did jump in October, but
2:34 permits fell, indicating slower future
2:37 building activity and pending home
2:39 sales. A look at home sale contracts
2:41 signed but not yet closed fell 4.7% to a
2:45 record low. Shares of retailer Target
2:47 are up about 6% after Target posted its
2:50 best sales growth in 5 years. And Take 2
2:53 Interactive shares are jumping about 7
2:55 and a half% ahead of tomorrow's release
2:57 of the widely anticipated Grand Theft
2:59 Auto 6 video game. Peter Shack now CNBC.
CoinShares CEO Jean-Marie Mognetti: AI is sucking out every marginal dollar away from crypto full transcript
0:09 >> WELCOME BACK. KEEP YOUR EYE
0:10 ON BITCOIN DOWN 20% IN THE LAST
0:12 MONTH, AMID A MIX OF LONG
0:14 POSITION LIQUIDATIONS AND SOME
0:15 SELLING PRESSURE AHEAD OF
0:16 ANTHROPIC IPO TOMORROW. OUR
0:18 NEXT GUEST OVERSEES ONE OF THE
0:19 WORLD'S LARGEST DIGITAL ASSET
0:21 MANAGERS IN THE WORLD. HE'S
0:22 TELLING INVESTORS THIS IS NOT
0:24 DOOMSDAY FOR CRYPTO. JOINING US
0:26 HERE AT POST NINE IS COINSHARES
0:28 CO-FOUNDER AND CEO JEAN-MARIE
0:29 MOGNETTI. JEAN-MARIE, WELCOME.
0:30 IT'S GOOD TO HAVE YOU.
0:31 >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
0:33 >> SO WE'VE BEEN WATCHING THESE
0:34 PRICES AND THERE'S ALL KINDS OF
0:36 EXPLANATIONS. THERE IS
0:37 ANTHROPIC, THERE'S HACKS,
0:39 THERE'S RATES. IS ONE MORE
0:41 RESPONSIBLE, YOU THINK, THAN
0:42 THE OTHER?
0:43 >> WELL, LOOK, FIRST TIME LAST
0:44 TIME YOU HAD ME HERE BITCOIN
0:46 WAS MY STOCK WAS DOWN TODAY.
0:47 I'M HERE. BITCOIN IS DOWN. MY
0:49 STOCK IS UP. SO GO FIGURE OUT.
0:50 YOU KNOW AND WE'RE STILL AT
0:52 BOOK VALUE. SO IT IS WHAT IT IS.
0:54 NOW WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE MACRO
0:56 DRIVERS I THINK YOU KNOW
0:58 ANTHROPIC AND THE AI HAS BEEN
1:00 SUCKING OUT EVERY SINGLE
1:01 MARGINAL DOLLAR IN THE INDUSTRY
1:03 FROM CRYPTO. THAT'S ABSOLUTELY
1:06 CERTAIN. YOU CAN SEE AS WELL,
1:07 THE WHOLE STABLECOIN INDUSTRY
1:08 IS DOWN, I THINK 10% OF
1:11 REDEMPTION ON THE STABLECOINS.
1:12 SO THE LIQUIDITY IN STABLECOINS
1:13 IS DOWN. PLUS THE DOLLAR IS
1:15 STRONG AND THE LIQUIDITY IS
1:16 SUCKING OUT. SO ALL THAT
1:18 TOGETHER IS CREATING A BIT OF
1:19 PRESSURE ON THE PRICE OF CRYPTO
1:21 DIGITAL ASSETS.
1:22 >> YES. YOU, YOU MAKE THE POINT.
1:23 WE KIND OF WENT THROUGH THIS
1:25 PRE SPACE.
1:26 >> WE DID. YEAH.
1:27 >> I'M TRYING TO REMEMBER
1:29 REMIND US OF THE.
1:30 >> SEQUENCE SPACE. CRYPTO WAS
1:31 DOWN AS WELL. THE INDUSTRY WAS
1:33 DOWN AS WELL IN THE WEEK IN THE
1:35 WAKE OF THE END OF Q2. AND
1:37 MARKET RECOVER AFTER THAT. AND
1:38 SO SAME THING IS HAPPENING HERE
1:40 A LITTLE BIT WHERE WE GET THIS
1:41 KIND OF IF ANTHROPIC TRADE,
1:43 WELL, IT'S GOING TO BE RISK ON
1:44 EVERYTHING WILL GO WELL. IF
1:45 ANTHROPIC DOESN'T TRADE WELL,
1:47 IT'S GOING TO BE A BIG QUESTION
1:48 MARK ON THE FINANCING OF AI.
1:50 AND AT WHAT POINT THE
1:51 GOVERNMENT IS INTERFERING TO
1:52 SAVE THE WHOLE FINANCING. AND
1:53 AT THAT POINT, CRYPTO WILL ALSO
1:55 COME BACK WITH A DEBASEMENT
1:56 STORY.
1:57 >> ARE ARE YOU SEEING INFLOWS?
1:59 >> WE'RE SEEING INFLOWS AT
2:01 COINSHARES IN EUROPE,
2:02 SPECIFICALLY FROM THE BEGINNING
2:04 OF THE YEAR. AND EVEN.
2:05 >> WITH THE SELL.
2:06 >> OFF YESTERDAY, WE SAW
2:07 INFLOWS FRIDAY. LAST WEEK WE
2:08 SAW INFLOWS THURSDAY AS WELL.
2:10 SO IT'S VERY INTERESTING TO SEE
2:11 HOW THE MARKET IS POSITIONING
2:12 IN EUROPE ESPECIALLY VERSUS THE
2:14 US WHERE THE US WE CAN SEE IS
2:16 MUCH MORE TRADING, WHERE THE AI
2:17 AGENT IS ALREADY CREATING A LOT
2:19 OF ROTATION. IT WAS CRUDE OIL
2:20 IN THE FIRST HALF OF THE YEAR.
2:22 THEN GOLD AND AI WAS IN EUROPE.
2:25 YOU CAN SEE THIS KIND OF THING
2:26 IS VERY, VERY DIFFERENT. AND BY
2:28 BEING A EUROPEAN PLAYER AND THE
2:29 LARGEST DIGITAL ASSET MANAGER
2:31 OUTSIDE OF EUROPE, OUTSIDE OF
2:32 THE US, IS BENEFITING FROM THIS
2:34 KIND OF ALLOCATION.
2:35 >> FROM THE FACT THAT JUST AI
2:37 IS MORE OF AN INVESTMENT STORY
2:38 HERE IN THE US THAN IN EUROPE.
2:40 >> IT'S EASY, YOU KNOW, LIKE WE
2:42 AS ALWAYS BEEN PRUNING. YOU
2:43 KNOW, THAT IS LIKE MAKING THE
2:45 FRONTIER INVESTABLE. THE
2:46 FRONTIER IS MOVING MUCH FASTER
2:47 IN THE US AND IN EUROPE. AND SO
2:49 CRYPTO IS STILL A FRONTIER
2:51 INVESTMENT IN EUROPE, WHILE IN
2:52 THE US IT HAS BEEN COMMODITIZED
2:54 VERY, VERY QUICKLY WITH THE BIG
2:55 PLAYER YOU HAVE IN THE ACCESS
2:56 MARKET. AND SO WE KEEP
2:58 DIVERSIFYING AND
Anthropic considers increasing IPO offering as investor demand surges full transcript
0:12 >> ANTHROPIC? SET TO PRICE
0:13 AFTER THE BELL TODAY. AHEAD OF
0:14 ITS HIGHLY ANTICIPATED PUBLIC
0:16 DEBUT TOMORROW. LESLIE PICKER
0:17 WITH THE LATEST. WHAT DO YOU
0:18 HEAR? LESLIE.
0:19 >> HEY, SARAH. THE STAKES ARE
0:20 VERY HIGH FOR ANTHROPIC AS IT
0:22 READIES WHAT'S EXPECTED TO BE
0:24 THE LARGEST IPO EVER. NOW, AT
0:26 THE HIGH END OF ANTHROPIC'S
0:27 CURRENT TERMS, THE COMPANY AND
0:29 ITS SEVEN COFOUNDERS WOULD
0:30 RAISE $64 BILLION PLUS ANOTHER
0:33 $26 BILLION FROM THAT
0:34 CONCURRENT PRIVATE PLACEMENT
0:35 FROM A WHOLE HOST OF STRATEGICS.
0:38 HOWEVER, I'M HEARING THAT
0:39 ANTHROPIC IS FIELDING THE TYPE
0:41 OF DEMAND THAT WOULD ALLOW IT
0:42 TO PRICE ABOVE THE RANGE WELL
0:44 NORTH OF $80 PER SHARE. AND I'M
0:46 TOLD THEY'RE EXPLORING THE IDEA
0:47 OF UPSIZING THE OFFERING OR
0:49 INCREASING THE NUMBER OF SHARES
0:51 THEY PLAN TO SELL IN ORDER TO
0:53 RAISE EVEN MORE CASH. THE
0:54 DETAILS ON PRICING AND UPSIZING
0:56 ARE STILL BEING FINALIZED, AND
0:57 THESE PLANS COULD STILL CHANGE.
0:58 FINAL DECISIONS ARE EXPECTED
1:00 THIS AFTERNOON. THE BOOKS,
1:02 THOUGH, FOR INSTITUTIONAL FOR
1:04 THE INSTITUTIONAL SIDE, CLOSED
1:05 YESTERDAY AT 4 P.M. AND I'M
1:07 TOLD THAT TOTAL INDICATIONS OF
1:08 INTEREST. THERE WERE UPWARDS OF
1:10 $400 BILLION. RETAIL INVESTORS
1:12 HAVE PUT IN ORDERS APPROACHING
1:14 $100 BILLION I'M TOLD. SO ALL
1:16 IN THAT AMOUNTS TO ABOUT HALF
1:19 $1 TRILLION TO COVER 64 BILLION
1:20 AT THE HIGH END OF THE CURRENT
1:22 MARKET OFFERING. THAT'S ABOUT
1:23 DOUBLE THE LEVEL OF
1:24 OVERSUBSCRIPTION THAT SPACEX
1:25 HAD FOR ITS OFFERING AT THE
1:27 TIME OF ITS OWN $75 BILLION IPO
1:30 IN JUNE. THE BALANCE FOR
1:32 ANTHROPIC AND ITS BANKERS,
1:33 THOUGH, WILL BE TO MAXIMIZE THE
1:35 SIZE OF THE OFFERING, WHETHER
1:36 BY PRICING OR OFFERING MORE
1:38 SHARES OR BOTH, WHILE ALSO
1:40 MAKING SURE THAT THEY'RE NOT
1:42 STRETCHING THIS DEAL IN A WAY
1:43 THAT CHALLENGES THEIR TRADING
1:45 ON DEBUT DAY TOMORROW. GIVEN
1:47 THE BROADER TECH AND AI
1:48 BACKDROP, THERE'S A LOT RIDING
1:50 ON THIS ONE TO GET IT RIGHT,
1:51 GUYS.
1:52 >> LESLIE A LOT OF DISCUSSION
1:54 LAST FEW DAYS ABOUT THE WEAK
1:55 PERFORMANCE OF THE BIGGEST IPOS
1:57 SO FAR THIS YEAR PERSHING
1:58 SQUARE, SK HYNIX BENDING SPOONS.
2:01 ANY REASON TO SUGGEST THAT THE
2:03 LEVEL OF OVERSUBSCRIPTION WOULD
2:05 MAKE ANTHROPIC THE EXCEPTION?
2:07 >> IT'S IT'S KIND OF
2:08 FASCINATING HERE BECAUSE YOU
2:09 HAVE ALL OF THESE MACRO
2:11 INDICATORS THAT IN ANY OTHER
2:13 IPO WOULD BE A NET NEGATIVE IN
2:14 TERMS OF PRICING, THINGS LIKE
2:16 RECENT IPOS TRADING BADLY. WHY
2:18 THAT'S IMPORTANT IS BECAUSE
2:19 PEOPLE WHO INVEST IN IPOS, IF
2:21 THEY'RE UNDERWATER ON PREVIOUS
2:23 IPOS, THEY MAY BE LESS INCLINED
2:24 TO PUT IN FOR THE NEXT ONE.
2:26 THAT DOESN'T SEEM TO BE A BIG
2:28 HINDRANCE HERE. ALSO, THE COMPS
2:29 IN THE MARKET TRADING LOWER
2:30 ALSO DOESN'T SEEM TO BE A
2:32 HINDRANCE HERE. AND OF COURSE
2:33 JUST THE BROADER VOLATILITY
2:34 WHICH CAN CHALLENGE PRICING IN
2:35 PRETTY MUCH ANY OTHER IPO, AT
2:37 LEAST IN TERMS OF WHAT WE'RE
2:39 SEEING FOR DEMAND AND THE
2:40 POTENTIAL PRICING AND THE
2:41 POTENTIAL UPSIZING NOT
2:42 NECESSARILY A BIG OBSTACLE HERE.
2:44 SO THIS DOES KIND OF SEEM TO BE
2:47 THE ONE INDICATOR THAT IS KIND
2:49 OF BUCKING THE BROADER TREND.
2:50 WE'LL SEE IF THAT ULTIMATELY
2:52 TRANSPIRES WITH THE WAY THAT
2:53 THEY PRICE AND THE NUMBER OF
2:55 SHARES THAT THEY OFFER AND THE
2:56 WAY THAT THEY TRADE TOMORROW.
2:58 BUT IT COULD BE A LITTLE BIT OF
2:59 A, YOU KNOW, MAYBE A CROWDING
3:01 OUT THIS IDEA THAT PEOPLE ARE
3:02 FREEING UP CASH TO INVEST IN
3:04 THIS ONE, OR AT LEAST PUT IN
3:06 INDICATIONS FOR THIS ONE OR
3:07 TRADE TOMORROW, OR IT'S JUST
3:09 KIND OF SEEN AS SOMETHING THAT,
3:10 YOU KNOW, THERE'S THIS BROADER
3:12 PSYCHOLOGY HOPING AND KNOWING
3:14 THE STAKES HERE THAT THEY JUST
3:16 EXPECT IT TO WORK. AND SO
3:17 PEOPLE ARE KIND OF PUTTING IN
3:18 FOR IT. BUT, YOU KNOW, ALL OF
3:20 THAT, OF COURSE, REMAINS TO BE
3:21 SEEN. WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS
3:23 TOMORROW.
3:23 >> YEAH. I MEAN, CRAMER JUST
3:24 SUGGESTED ON X THAT THAT'S PART
3:26 OF THE NVIDIA
Century 21 Real Estate CEO: Sellers are back as home listings rise and prices fall full transcript
0:00 home seller confidence, that 3%
0:02 mortgage, people are willing to give it
0:03 up.
0:04 >> Yeah, I mean, believe it or not, Morgan,
0:05 I think the big headline right now is
0:06 that sellers are back in the market. Uh
0:09 the research that we did with a bunch of
0:10 existing homeowners across the country
0:12 right now say that about 75% of them
0:15 think that now is the right time to go
0:17 ahead and get back in even though there
0:19 is that lock in effect for so many that
0:21 are out there. Um and and really
0:23 mortgage rates ranked as the fifth
0:25 motivational point for sellers. So, it's
0:28 really not high on the list and it's
0:29 showing up in the numbers. You right now
0:31 across the country, you have 1.1 million
0:33 homes for sale. That's up. It's been up
0:35 year over year over year. It's probably
0:38 5% over last year. Um, and and it's in
0:41 even some of the states like the
0:42 Northeast like we're in in the Midwest,
0:44 in the Milwaukee, in the Cleveland. Um,
0:46 so I think what that does is it gives
0:48 obviously potential buyers a little bit
0:49 more time. Uh, it gives them more
0:51 selection, but most importantly, it
0:53 gives them a little bit of negotiating
0:55 room. We're seeing about 42% of those
0:58 properties coming and being listed
1:00 taking price cuts. So, especially now at
1:02 the end of the year, it's it's a good
1:03 time to be looking if you're in the
1:05 market.
1:05 >> 42%. How does that compare to what we've
1:07 seen in recent years?
1:08 >> So, uh it's a high going back way to
1:10 2022. So, um generally at this time of
1:13 year, you'll see that kind of start
1:15 stemming down because of the holidays
1:16 and things of that nature, but um you
1:18 know, 2022 is the last time we saw a
1:20 number like that.
1:21 >> So, I realize real estate is very, very
1:22 local. I guess what are you seeing
1:24 across different markets especially when
1:25 it does come to more inventory coming to
1:28 market and pricing?
1:30 >> Yeah, I mean I think uh there's no doubt
1:32 about this is that uh the demand is
1:34 there but housing is expensive just like
1:37 everything else that we see whether it's
1:38 in the grocery store at the gas pump. Uh
1:40 no matter where you go I think what I've
1:42 been you know cautiously optimistic
1:44 about is that the market has been
1:46 somewhat resilient even with 7% interest
1:49 rates out there. um you you're running
1:51 at about $440 to $450,000 is the median
1:55 price across the country. That's held up
1:57 for about four years. It's probably the
1:59 highest that we've ever seen. Um
2:01 reaching a high in June. And just to put
2:03 that into perspective, I think obviously
2:05 much of this is driven up by the rate
2:07 and mortgage rates in general. Uh 90
2:09 basis points different from where we
2:11 were last year at this time. So that
2:12 that same home today costs a consumer
2:16 $3,000 more a year. So obviously this
2:18 continued pressure on rates, we're
2:20 watching it very closely. Um if you get
2:22 any easing whatsoever, not that there's
2:24 any indications of it right now, I think
2:26 you're really going to see people rush
2:27 in in the spring.
2:28 >> What are buyers gravitating to? Is it is
2:30 it towards some of these new home
2:31 builds? We're just talking about we're
2:32 seeing the home builders um you know,
2:33 taking price cuts, etc. Or is it other
2:36 types of properties?
2:37 >> Yeah, I mean I think it's across the
2:38 board. Uh what what is very clear from
2:40 the research is that people are not
2:42 waiting to sell like life is happening
2:43 and and that's forcing them, especially
2:45 the younger set. uh whether it's you
2:47 know uh new kids in the family uh or
2:50 them just outgrowing the house uh it's a
2:52 little bit more stagnant at the higher
2:54 end for or at the older end the baby
2:56 boomers who have you know a lot of home
2:58 equity um they might think about down
3:01 sizing might think about moving to you
3:03 know a Florida or a better tax state or
3:05 weather state uh but for the most part I
3:07 think life is happening what's clear
3:09 through the research is that people
3:10 can't stand still anymore they have to
3:12 make a move even though some have these
3:14 mortgage rates that are you know below
3:16 5%.
3:17 >> Can people who who want to get a
3:18 mortgage get a mortgage in this
3:20 environment, especially when you have
3:21 rates as high as this? I I asked that
3:22 because I know that's been been an issue
3:24 in years past. But on the flip side of
3:26 that, we have all these private mortgage
3:29 brokers that have come in and are now
3:30 dominating the market and have taken
3:32 that share from big banks.
3:33 >> The the good news is I think that we are
3:35 in a spot where the mortgage environment
3:37 is very safe. I say this to would be
3:39 buyers all the time. If you're secure in
3:41 your job and you have a good down
3:43 payment, then you should be in the
3:45 market looking because we know that rate
3:47 fluctuates all the time. Uh, you know,
3:49 7%, believe it or not, is probably about
3:52 the average for what it's been over the
3:54 last 50 years. So, um, you know, there's
3:56 there's a saying about, you know, marry
3:58 the house, date the rate. We don't know
4:00 where rates will go, but uh if you're
4:02 financially set, I think now and is as
4:03 good a time as any to get
Roundhill Investments CEO Dave Mazza: Don't think investors are worried about AI safety full transcript
0:00 A COUNTERPOINT TO SOME OF THE
0:02 STUFF WE HEAR ABOUT THE SAFETY
0:03 CONCERNS.
0:04 >> YEAH. AND WALLER, DEFINITELY
0:05 AN AI OPTIMIST. WE'RE GOING TO
0:06 GET TO SOME OF THE FED SPEAK IN
0:08 A MOMENT. AS FOR THE MARKET,
0:10 IT'S A BIT OF AN INSIDE DAY.
0:12 BREADTH IS A LITTLE BIT
0:13 NEGATIVE ALTHOUGH THE VIX IS
0:14 LOWER. NVIDIA HAS TURNED
0:15 NEGATIVE AFTER INITIALLY
0:16 GETTING A LIFT ON ITS FIRST
0:17 EARNINGS REPORT WITHOUT
0:18 JEN-HSUN HUANG. JOINING US HERE
0:19 AT POST NINE THIS MORNING,
0:21 ROUNDHILL INVESTMENTS CEO DAVE
0:22 MASSA. THE FIRM'S TOP HOLDING
0:23 IS NVIDIA. OF COURSE THEY
0:24 MANAGE THE POPULAR DRAM ETF.
0:25 IT'S GREAT TO HAVE YOU BACK
0:27 DAVE. WELCOME. THANKS FOR
0:28 HAVING ME. ALL RIGHT. SO WE'RE
0:29 GOING TO PLAY AGAIN WITH THESE
0:31 LOW 150 PRICE LEVELS. WHAT DO
0:32 YOU THINK WAS IMPORTANT. IS IT
0:34 TRADING NOW ON A JETSON RETURN.
0:35 OR IS IT MORE ABOUT WHAT
0:37 COLETTE TRIED TO LAY OUT LAST
0:38 NIGHT.
0:39 >> LOOK I THINK IF YOU LOOK AT
0:41 THE RESULTS IN ISOLATION THEY
0:42 WERE PHENOMENAL. RIGHT. WE
0:43 OBVIOUSLY BEAT REVENUE WHICH WE
0:44 EXPECT NVIDIA TO DO QUARTER IN
0:46 QUARTER OUT. THEY RAISED
0:47 GUIDANCE. BUT ONE OF THE
0:48 REASONS WHY THE STOCK IS FADING
0:49 IS OUR OPINION IS BECAUSE
0:51 NVIDIA AT THE CENTER OF AI
0:52 FACES AN ESG RISK. BUT IT'S NOT
0:54 THE ESG THAT WE THINK ABO.
0:56 IT'S THE NEW AI, ESG, WHICH IS
0:57 ESPIONAGE, SECURITY, AND
0:59 GUARDRAILS. AND WE WERE JUST
1:01 HEARING IN THAT PREVIOUS
1:02 CONVERSATION, THAT'S WHAT ALL
1:03 THE QUESTIONS ARE ABOUT. AND
1:04 UNTIL THE MARKET GRASPS WITH
1:06 WHAT THAT'S GOING TO MEAN,
1:07 ESPECIALLY WITH ALL THE
1:08 OVERHANG THAT NVIDIA HAS,
1:10 COUPLED WITH THE FACT THAT
1:11 THERE IS A LOT OF WOOD TO CHOP
1:13 FOR THEM ON A GO FORWARD, I
1:15 THINK WE'RE GOING TO REMAIN IN
1:16 A PHASE WHERE INVESTORS ARE
1:17 WAITING AND SEEING WHAT'S NEXT.
1:19 >> SO MAYBE THAT CAPS UPSIDE
1:20 NARRATIVES. BUT DOES THE
1:22 BUYBACK LIMIT THE DOWNSIDE
1:23 NARRATIVES.
1:23 >> WELL I THINK IT'S
1:24 INTERESTING, RIGHT. BECAUSE THE
1:25 BUYBACK IS GOING TO CERTAINLY
1:26 SUPPORT THE STOCK. IT'S
1:27 SOMETHING THAT I THINK
1:28 INVESTORS WOULD WELCOME,
1:29 ESPECIALLY WITH THE IDEA THAT
1:30 THERE'S CAPITAL RAISING PLANS.
1:31 THE QUESTION THAT INVESTORS ARE
1:33 ALSO GRAPPLING WITH IS THE FACT
1:34 THAT THEY HAVE BEEN THE CENTER
1:36 OF THIS AI FINANCING. THERE'S
1:37 BEEN QUESTIONS ABOUT CIRCULAR
1:38 FINANCING. THERE WAS QUESTIONS
1:39 ON THE CALL ABOUT WHAT THAT
1:40 REALLY MEANS. NOW, THEY DID
1:42 REITERATE THAT THEY'RE GOING TO
1:43 CONTINUE TO DO SO, BUT DOING SO
1:45 MORE SELECTIVELY. AND WHAT DOES
1:46 THAT MEAN? IT LIKELY MEANS THAT
1:48 PEOPLE THAT DO NOT HAVE ACTUAL
1:50 CUSTOMERS LINED UP TO ACTUALLY
1:51 USE THOSE NVIDIA CHIPS AREN'T
1:53 GOING TO GET IT. PLUS, WE
1:54 OBVIOUSLY HAVE THE CHINA NEWS
1:55 AND THE SORT OF BACK DOOR
1:57 THAT'S BEING CLOSED FROM THAT
1:58 POINT OF VIEW. AND AGAIN, UNTIL
2:00 THAT'S RESOLVED, I THINK WE'RE
2:01 GOING TO BE A LITTLE BIT RANGE
2:03 BOUND IN THE NAME.
2:04 >> DO YOU THINK INVESTORS ARE
2:05 WORRIED ABOUT THE SAFETY
2:06 CONCERNS?
2:06 >> I ACTUALLY DON'T THINK SO. I
2:08 THINK WHAT IS CONCERNING,
2:10 THOUGH, IS WHEN WE CONTINUE TO
2:12 HEAR THAT THE NEW FACES OF AI,
2:14 BOTH FROM OPENAI AND ANTHROPIC,
2:16 ARE CONTINUING TO RAISE SAFETY
2:18 CONCERNS, THEN YOU HAVE OUTAGES,
2:20 WHETHER THEY'RE CYBERSECURITY
2:22 RELATED OR NOT. THAT'S A
2:23 CONCERN FOR THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
2:25 AND THEN AND THEN INVESTORS.
2:26 BUT WHAT INVESTORS REALLY ARE
2:27 FOCUSED ON IS
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman: It's hard to imagine the AI industry without Jensen Huang full transcript
0:01 redefining insurance.
0:10 >> LET'S CHECK IN WITH ANDREW
0:11 ROSS SORKIN AT THE NEW YORK
0:13 TIMES DEALBOOK CONFERENCE, I
0:14 BELIEVE WITH SAM ALTMAN AND
0:16 GREG BROCKMAN.
0:20 >> EITHER OF YOU.
0:23 >> I WOULD SAY JENSEN IS
0:24 SINGULAR, NO QUESTION. AND I
0:27 HAVE TALKED TO HIM A LITTLE BIT.
0:29 MY WIFE AND I ARE FRIENDS WITH
0:30 HIM AND HIS FAMILY. AND SO WE
0:32 JUST REACHED OUT PERSONALLY
0:33 JUST TO JUST TO BE THERE FOR
0:35 HIM AND HIS FAMILY AT THIS TIME.
0:37 >> AND HOW'S HE DOING?
0:39 >> LOOK, IT WAS A PERSONAL,
0:40 PRIVATE CONVERSATION, IS WHAT
0:41 I'D SAY. AND I THINK IT'S
0:43 OBVIOUSLY A TOUGH TIME FOR, FOR,
0:45 FOR EVERYONE. BUT AGAIN, I
0:46 THINK IT'S I NVIDIA IS SUCH AN
0:49 INCREDIBLE COMPANY. I, I THINK
0:51 THAT WHAT HAS BEEN BUILT THERE,
0:53 WHAT JENSEN HAS BUILT THERE, IT
0:55 CLEARLY IS BUILT TO LAST. AND
0:57 SO WE'RE EXCITED TO KEEP
0:59 PARTNERING AND LOOKING TO THE
1:01 FUTURE.
1:01 >> SAM YOU SPEAK TO HIM TOO. I
1:03 DID.
1:04 >> AND JENSEN TOOK ONE OF THE
1:07 EARLIEST BIG BETS ON US. WE
1:08 TOOK A BIG BET ON NVIDIA. IT'S
1:10 HARD TO IMAGINE THE AI INDUSTRY
1:12 WITHOUT JENSEN. I THINK
1:13 SINGULAR IS A GREAT WAY TO
1:14 DESCRIBE IT. AND.
1:18 >> DO YOU THINK DO YOU THINK HE
1:20 THINKS HE CAN COME BACK. WHEN
1:23 YOU TALK TO HIM.
1:24 >> GREG AND I HAVE LIKE A
1:26 LITTLE MORE EMPATHY TOWARDS THE
1:27 SITUATION THAN THE AVERAGE
1:28 PERSON. AND I WILL SAY, ONE
1:29 THING I DID NOT APPRECIATE WAS
1:31 EVERYBODY ON EARTH SPECULATING
1:33 WITH SOME RANDOM THEORY HERE OR
1:34 THERE. LIKE, LIKE SO I WILL SAY
1:36 I WISH JENSEN THE BEST. I WISH
1:38 NVIDIA THE BEST. I DON'T THINK
1:41 THE WORLD NEEDS ANOTHER SET OF
1:42 RANDOM OPINIONS ON WHAT'S GOING
1:43 TO HAPPEN HERE.
1:45 >> BUT LET ME ASK YOU A
1:46 PHILOSOPHICAL QUESTION
1:48 UNRELATED TO JENSEN, BUT BUT
1:49 RELATED IN A WAY, BECAUSE I
1:50 THINK ABOUT IT A LOT. I THINK
1:52 ABOUT IT IN THE CONTEXT OF THIS
1:54 EVENT. ACTUALLY, THE IDEA OF
1:55 THE THE CULT OF CEO. SO MANY OF
1:58 THE PEOPLE THAT ARE ON THIS
1:59 STAGE, INCLUDING BOTH OF YOU,
2:02 THERE IS A CULT OF THE CEO
2:04 AROUND THEM. THE IDEA THAT SOME
2:06 OF THESE COMPANIES ARE SO
2:07 SINGULAR AND THESE INDIVIDUALS
2:08 ARE SO SINGULAR AND THAT THEY
2:09 CAN'T BE RUN WITHOUT THEM. YOU,
2:12 YOU, YOU WERE PUSHED OUT AND
2:13 THEN CAME BACK IN PART BECAUSE
2:15 THERE WAS A VIEW THAT CERTAIN
2:16 PEOPLE THOUGHT THAT YOU.
2:17 >> GREG, AND I WERE BOTH PUSHED
2:19 OUT AND CAME BACK. I DON'T I
2:21 DON'T LIKE I DON'T. I GET ALL
2:25 THESE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE
2:27 SITUATIONS. TEMPTING TO PUT TOO
2:29 MUCH THERE, BUT I THINK A LARGE
2:32 PART OF WHAT MADE OPENAI HAS
2:35 MADE OPENAI SUCCEED IS THAT
2:37 GREG AND I HAVE A UNIQUE
2:39 PARTNERSHIP AND BROUGHT
2:40 SOMETHING IMPORTANT TO OPENAI.
2:43 AND DID THAT OVER A PERIOD OF
2:44 NOW ALMOST 11 YEARS. NOW, COULD
2:49 THE COMPANY SUCCEED WITHOUT US?
Market Open: Stock Rebound After Nvidia Earnings, Housing Starts Jump, Lowe's Shares Fall 11-18-2026 full transcript
0:02 I'm Peter Shack now. CNBC stocks have
0:05 opened mostly higher following an upbeat
0:07 earnings report from Nvidia with the S&P
0:09 500 and NASDAQ on track to break 4-day
0:12 losing streaks. The Dow is the
0:14 exception. It's down 176 points at
0:17 50,582.
0:19 But the S&P 500 is 210 of a percent
0:21 higher or 13 points and the Nasdaq
0:23 adding half a percent or 128 points.
0:26 Nvidia shares are up by 2 and a.5% after
0:29 the company reported better than
0:31 expected profit and revenue and gave an
0:33 upbeat outlook. Of course, the biggest
0:35 topic of discussion is still the sudden
0:37 departure of former CEO Jensen Wong. But
0:40 Vivc area, senior semiconductor analyst
0:42 at BFA securities, thinks Nvidia will
0:44 continue its success.
0:46 >> You know, Jensen is irreplaceable. He's
0:48 singular. But I think what he has also
0:50 done is set up the foundation of a very
0:52 strong enterprise. They have very
0:55 powerful competitive modes across uh the
0:58 design of the products across silicon
1:00 across systems across software and I
1:02 think what we heard last night is not
1:04 just the companies executing very well
1:06 in his absence it's also that they are
1:09 showing a very strong growth outlook.
1:11 >> Housing stars jumped a better thanex
1:12 expected 9.9% last month according to
1:15 new figures from the commerce department
1:17 but building permits an indicator of
1:19 future construction fell by 7.4% 4%
1:22 >> down dramatically year-over-year and
1:24 month-to-month in single family. And
1:26 it's amazing what we saw in the
1:28 homebuilder sentiment number yesterday.
1:30 It dropped to a 14-year low. Builders
1:33 were citing not just higher mortgage
1:35 rates, which spiked back up again last
1:37 week, but the cost of construction that
1:39 was for land, labor, materials, energy
1:42 prices, and so a lot of these different
1:44 elements playing into homebuilder
1:45 sentiment. That's CNBC real estate
1:47 correspondent Diana Olic. Artificial
1:50 intelligence firm Anthropic is set to
1:52 price its IPO tonight and begin trading
1:54 tomorrow. And CNBC's Leslie Picker says
1:56 it looks like the demand for Anthropic
1:58 shares will be very strong.
2:00 >> So far, I'm hearing some pretty
2:02 staggering numbers in terms of demand
2:04 for this offering. One source saying
2:06 that institutional book has received
2:09 upwards of $400 billion dollar worth of
2:12 orders and retail is approaching another
2:15 100 billion. So in total they're looking
2:17 at about half a trillion dollar worth of
2:20 demand on a $65 billion offering at the
2:23 high end of the range.
2:24 >> Shares of home improvement retailer
2:26 Lowe's are down more than 4% this
2:28 morning after the company reported lower
2:30 than expected profit and warned of cost
2:32 pressures across its business. Target
2:34 shares on the other hand are up by about
2:36 3% after the retailer reported a 5.6%
2:39 jump in comparable store sales. Peter
2:42 Shack now, CNBC.
Anthropic will be an exceptional growth stock as it enters the public market: Peter Singlehurst full transcript
0:10 >> ANTHROPIC IS EXPECTED TO
0:11 PRICE ITS IPO TONIGHT AHEAD OF
0:13 ITS HIGHLY ANTICIPATED PUBLIC
0:14 DEBUT ON THE NASDAQ TOMORROW.
0:16 JOINING US NOW IS BAILLIE
0:17 GIFFORD, HEAD OF PRIVATE
0:18 COMPANIES PETER SELHURST. THE
0:20 FIRM HAS INVESTED ABOUT $1.5
0:22 BILLION INTO ANTHROPIC ON
0:24 BEHALF OF CLIENTS. IT'S GOOD TO
0:25 SEE YOU. THANKS FOR JOINING US
0:27 HERE. SO YOU INVESTED WAS IT IN
0:30 SUMMER OF 2025? IS THAT ABOUT
0:32 RIGHT? SO AT THE TIME I THINK
0:34 THAT ROUND WAS BELOW 200
0:36 BILLION, I THINK IN MARKET CAP.
0:37 SO IS THERE A CORRECT NUMBER?
0:40 IS THERE AN OPTIMUM MARKET CAP
0:43 YOU'D LIKE TO SEE IT DEBUT AT
0:44 THAT? BOTH KIND OF RECOGNIZES
0:46 THE POTENTIAL OF THE COMPANY
0:47 AND MAKES IT A GOOD PERFORMING
0:49 STOCK AS A PUBLIC COMPANY.
0:51 >> I THINK ULTIMATELY AS
0:52 INVESTORS, WE FOCUS ON WHAT
0:53 COMPANIES CAN DO OVER VERY LONG
0:55 PERIODS OF TIME. WE'RE WANTING
0:56 TO OWN COMPANIES FOR FIVE, TEN
0:58 YEARS PLUS. WE TRY TO DO THAT
1:00 BOTH PRIVATELY AND THEN INTO
1:01 THE PUBLIC MARKETS AS WELL. I
1:02 THINK ULTIMATELY WHAT MATTERS
1:03 FOR ANTHROPIC IS NOT WHAT THE
1:05 VALUATION IS GOING TO BE IN THE
1:07 IPO. WHAT MATTERS IS CAN THEY
1:09 CONTINUE TO DEVELOP FRONTIER
1:10 MODELS? CAN THAT TRANSLATE INTO
1:11 HIGH LEVELS OF REVENUE GROWTH
1:13 AND PROFITABILITY? THESE WILL
1:14 BE THE THINGS THAT REALLY
1:15 MATTER. I THINK ULTIMATELY
1:16 THOSE ARE THE DETERMINANTS OF
1:18 SUCCESS, NOT WHAT THE PRICE IS
1:19 ON THE DAY IT OPENS.
1:20 >> MOST OF THE FINANCIAL
1:22 PERFORMANCE, AS REVEALED IN THE
1:23 FILINGS, I THINK HAS COME AS A
1:25 BIT OF AN UPSIDE SURPRISE JUST
1:26 IN TERMS OF THE ECONOMICS OF
1:29 THE BUSINESS, THE GROWTH RATES,
1:30 THE SCALE THAT IT'S ACHIEVED.
1:32 OBVIOUSLY, BIG QUESTIONS,
1:33 THOUGH, REMAIN LONGER TERM
1:35 ABOUT WHETHER THE FRONTIER
1:36 MODELS WILL CONTINUE TO ACCRUE.
1:39 YOU KNOW, THE REAL BENEFITS OR
1:41 AT LEAST HAVE A BIG PROFIT
1:43 SHARE AS AI DEVELOPS IN THE
1:45 FUTURE. AND THEN OBVIOUSLY, THE
1:47 COMMITMENTS TO THE COST OF
1:48 DELIVERING ON THOSE MODELS. SO
1:49 HOW ARE YOU FRAMING THOSE
1:51 ISSUES?
1:51 >> SO WE HAVE A STRONG
1:53 HYPOTHESIS THAT VALUE WILL
1:55 CONTINUE TO ACCRUE TO THE FRONT
1:57 END MODELS. UNDOUBTEDLY THERE
1:59 IS GOING TO BE WIDE
2:00 PROLIFERATION OF MODELS THAT
2:01 ARE GOOD ENOUGH. AND INDEED
2:03 ANTHROPIC HAS THEIR OWN
2:04 VERSIONS OF THOSE MODELS, THE
2:06 HAIKU MODELS. BUT WHEN YOU LOOK
2:08 AT TECHNOLOGICAL EVOLUTIONS,
2:10 WHAT YOU NORMALLY SEE IS THE
2:12 VAST MAJORITY OF REVENUE AND
2:14 PROFIT ACCRUING TO THOSE
2:15 COMPANIES THAT ARE AT THE
2:17 LEADING EDGE. YOU COULD LOOK
2:18 BACK AT THE MOBILE ERA WHERE
2:19 MOST OF THE VALUE ACCRUED TO
2:21 APPLE, DESPITE ANDROID, ANDROID
2:22 BECOMING UBIQUITOUS. WE BELIEVE
2:24 THAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN IN AI AS
2:25 WELL, AND WE THINK ANTHROPIC IS
2:27 THE BEST PLACE TO REMAIN AT THE
2:28 FRONTIER. AND THEREFORE.
2:29 >> SO THIS IS THIS ANOTHER KIND
2:31 OF WINNER TAKE MOST SECTOR OF
2:34 TECHNOLOGY. IN OTHER WORDS, THE
2:35 OTHER MODEL MAKERS ARE GOING TO
2:36 BE DISADVANTAGED VERSUS
2:38 ANTHROPIC.
2:38 >> I THINK INEVITABLY THERE'S
2:39 GOING TO BE MULTIPLE DIFFERENT
2:40 MODEL MAKERS. WHAT MAKES
2:43 ANTHROPIC SPECIAL IS THAT FOCUS
2:45 ON THE ENTERPRISE. IT'S AN
2:46 EXISTENTIAL FOCUS THAT THEY
2:47 HAVE ON SERVING ENTERPRISE
2:48 CUSTOMERS. AND ALSO SAFETY.
2:50 LIKE SAFETY REALLY MATTERS FOR
2:52 THIS COMPANY BECAUSE IT MATTERS
2:53 FOR THEIR CUSTOMERS. IF YOU ARE
2:55 AN ENTERPRISE AND YOU'RE
2:56 LETTING AI AGENTS INTO YOUR
2:58 ENVIRONMENT, YOU'RE GOING TO
2:58 REALLY CARE ABOUT SAFETY. IT'S
3:00 PART OF THEIR COMPETITIVE
3:01 ADVANTAGE. AND IT'S ONE OF THE
3:02 CORE REASONS THAT WE OWN IT.
3:04 >> I FEEL AS IF WITH THE MARKET
3:06 CAP NOW GETTING INTO THE ZONE
3:07 OF A TRILLION AND A HALF,
3:09 WHATEVER IT ACTUALLY ENDS UP AT
3:10 PLUS OR MINUS, IT CREATES A
3:12 PRETTY CLEAN COMPARISON WITH
3:13 META, WHICH IS THAT EXACTLY
3:15 THAT MARKET CAP, SO META 2027
3:18 NUMBERS, IT'S GOING TO HAVE
3:19 MORE THAN 300 BILLION IN
3:20 REVENUE, 90 BILLION IN NET
3:22 INCOME. OBVIOUSLY, IT'S
3:22 SPENDING A LOT OF ITS CASH FLOW
3:24 TO BUILD. BUT I WONDER HOW YOU
3:26 THINK ABOUT THAT WITH A
3:27 SOMEWHAT MORE MATURE BUSINESS
3:28 BUSINESS THAT'S ALSO FEEDING
3:30 OFF THE SAME TRENDS AT A
3:31 SIMILAR MARKET CAP TO ONE,
3:33 WHICH IS NOW AT LIKE AN $80
3:34 BILLION REVENUE RUN RATE
3:36 ANNUALLY.
3:36 >> I THINK THE COMPARISON IS A
3:38 REALLY INTERESTING ONE, BECAUSE
3:39 THE STORY THAT REALLY SORT OF
3:40 COMES OUT TO ME FROM THAT IS
3:43 THE DIFFERENCE IN THE VALUE AT
3:44 WHICH THESE COMPANIES ARE
3:45 COMING TO THE PUBLIC MARKETS.
3:46 YOU KNOW, META IPO'D IN 2012 AT
3:48 A VALUATION ABOUT ONE TENTH OF
3:51 THE VALUE THAT ANTHROPIC IS, IS
3:52 COMING TO THE PUBLIC MARKETS AT.
3:54 I THINK THE REAL STORY HERE IS
3:56 THAT GROWTH AND VALUE CREATION
3:58 THAT'S HAPPENING IN THE PRIVATE
4:00 MARKETS. WE SAW IT WITH SPACEX
4:01 AS WELL, WHERE YOU'RE SEEING
4:03 TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF VALUE
4:04 BEING CREATED IN PRIVATE
4:05 MARKETS AND TO DO GROWTH EQUITY
4:07 INVESTING PROPERLY IN THIS ERA,
4:08 YOU HAVE TO BE DOING IT IN BOTH
4:10 PUBLIC BUT ALSO IN PRIVATE
4:12 MARKETS TO ENSURE THAT
4:13 INVESTORS ARE CAPTURING THAT
4:14 FULL RANGE OF UPSIDE.
4:15 >> THAT WOULD SEEM TO MEAN THAT
4:17 THERE ISN'T QUITE AS MUCH LEFT
4:18 FOR THE PUBLIC INVESTOR ONCE
4:20 THIS IS OUT THERE, RIGHT? I
4:21 MEAN, IF FACEBOOK CAME PUBLIC
4:23 100 BILLION, AS YOU SAID, IT'S
4:25 EVEN LESS THAN A 10TH OF WHAT
4:27 ANTHROPIC IS GOING TO COME OUT
4:28 IN 2012. DOES THAT CHANGE THE
4:31 DYNAMIC IN TERMS OF WHETHER
4:32 IT'S FRUITFUL TO BUY GROWTH
4:34 COMPANIES AS A PUBLIC INVESTOR?
4:35 >> I THINK THERE ARE TWO
4:36 STORIES OF GROWTH EQUITY
4:38 INVESTING OVER THE LAST 15
4:39 YEARS. THE FIRST IS THIS
4:40 PRIVATE FOR LONGER OR KIND OF
4:41 BIGGER, FASTER DYNAMIC. BUT THE
4:44 SECOND IS THAT PUBLIC COMPANIES
4:45 HAVE BECOME BIGGER THAN ANYBODY
4:47 THOUGHT THEY COULD BECOME. IF
4:48 YOU GO BACK 15 YEARS AGO. AND
4:49 SO THAT'S MADE GROWTH, EQUITY
4:51 INVESTING STILL A VIABLE AND
4:53 PROSPEROUS WAY TO INVEST IN THE
4:55 PUBLIC MARKETS. AGAIN, IT'S
4:57 THESE TWO DYNAMICS THAT ARE
4:58 REALLY IMPORTANT. I THINK, FOR
4:59 ANTHROPIC, THERE'S STILL SO
5:01 MUCH GROWTH THAT'S HAPPENING,
5:02 AND WE BELIEVE THIS IS GOING T
Anthropic IPO Fuels AI Enthusiasm full transcript
0:02 >> GOOD MORNING. HERE'S WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA.
0:06 TRUMP HAS WARM WORDS FOR PUTIN AND THE KREMLIN SAYS UKRAINE WAS
0:10 THE MAIN TOPIC OF CONVERSATION BETWEEN THE TWO LEADERS.
0:13 ANTHROPIC WILL BECOME THE FIRST FRONTIER AI LAB TO GO PUBLIC IN
0:17 AN IPO THAT RAISES MORE THAN SPACEX.
0:19 THE DOLLAR HOLDS AGAINST AS THE FED SOUNDS HAWKISH.
0:24 THIS MORNING. ANTHROPIC TRADE POSITIVE.
0:32 WE WILL PARK THAT ONE FOR NOW. THE REAL RISK STORY IS STARTING
0:35 TO EMERGE ELSEWHERE OUTSIDE OF EQUITIES.
0:38 THE SIGNALS ARE REALLY INTERESTING.
0:41 HOW TO READ THEM, I'M NOT ENTIRELY SURE.
0:43 EURO-DOLLAR, 14 MONTH LOW. PAY ATTENTION TO THE DOLLAR.
0:46 THE BREAKOUT COULD BE SIGNIFICANT BUT IT'S HARD TO
0:50 TELL WHY. WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF
0:51 THIS? GOLD GOT SOLD HEAVILY YESTERDAY.
0:56 AGAIN, WHY? WHAT'S GOING ON WITH THE TRADE?
1:00 WHAT IS THE SIGNAL FROM IT? TODAY, WE ARE STABILIZING.
1:03 A LACK OF CLARITY HERE. IT'S WORTH SPENDING TIME
1:09 FIGURING OUT WHAT'S GOING ON BECAUSE WHEN THE SIGNAL STARTS
1:12 TO BECOME CLEARER, IT COULD BE REALLY SIGNIFICANT.
1:15 SIGNS OF STABILIZATION. COUNTDOWN TO THE OPENING TRADE
1:16 STARTS RIGHT NOW. ANNA: WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM
1:30 EVERYBODY. THIS IS THE OPENING TRADE.
1:35 WE WILL START WITH A MEETING OF THREE WORLD LEADERS THAT WE ARE
1:36 ANTICIPATING. WE ARE ANTICIPATING THAT IT WILL
1:41 TAKE PLACE AT THE APEC SUMMIT. TRUMP, XI, AND PUTIN.
1:47 WE'VE ALREADY SEEN TO BILATERAL'S TAKING PLACE BETWEEN
1:52 TRUMP AND XI AND BETWEEN TRUMP AND PUTIN.
1:54 NEWS LINES COMING OUT OF ALL OF THESE.
1:58 TRUMP AND XI, WARM WORDS COMING OUT OF THE TWO.
2:01 THAT'S INTERESTING. WARMER TALK ABOUT TRADE AS WELL
2:04 GENERALLY WHICH IS A POSITIVE MOOD SIGNAL.
2:08 THEY DON'T SEEM TO BE REMINDED TO ROCK THE BOAT.
2:12 TRUMP AND PUTIN AND WHAT HAS SO FAR EMERGED FROM THAT, THE SPIN
2:19 BEING PUT ON IT BY THE RUSSIANS. WE AWAIT FOR ANY FURTHER DETAIL.
2:22 TRUMP SAYING THAT PUTIN IS HIS FRIEND, VERY WARM WORDS.
2:25 THE KREMLIN SAYING THAT THE UKRAINE MORE WAS THE MAIN TOPIC
2:29 OF CONVERSATION AND PUTIN LEFT HAPPY.
2:33 IS THAT KREMLIN SPIN OR IS THAT SOMETHING THAT EUROPE NEEDS TO
2:34 TAKE SERIOUSLY? PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY WILL GET A
2:37 BRIEFING ON WHAT'S BEEN DISCUSSED LATER ON.
2:42 IN BERLIN, A COALITION OF THE WILLING MEETING AROUND UKRAINE.
2:44 THIS IS SOMETHING WE WILL WATCH THROUGH THE DAY.
2:47 GUY: WHAT OUR EXPECTATIONS GOING INTO THIS?
2:51 THAT SENSE THE BENCHMARK AS TO WHETHER SOMETHING HERE IS
2:52 SIGNIFICANT OR NOT SIGNIFICANT. SO FAR, THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT
2:58 UKRAINE. THAT'S NOT A SURPRISE.
3:03 HAS ANYTHING MOVED HERE? I DON'T KNOW.
3:08 THE FACT THAT WE HAVEN'T HAD THE MEETING AT, BUT WARM WORDS.
3:14 IS THAT ENOUGH TO SAY THAT THINGS ARE GETTING WORSE IN THE
3:16 CHINA U.S. RELATIONSHIP? IS THAT A GOOD ENOUGH SINGLE --
3:19 SIGNAL? IS THAT OK?
3:28 HAPPENED. MAYBE THAT'S A POSITIVE SIGNAL.
3:33 WE WILL COME TO THE MARKET MOVEMENT IN JUST A MOMENT.
3:37 ANY PARALLELS WE STARTED THE WEEK WITH AROUND YALTA SEEM TO
3:43 BE MISPLACED, GIVEN THE DURATION OF THESE MEETINGS.
3:46 THEY ARE MORE FRIENDLY, WARM HANDSHAKE CONVERSATIONS SO FAR.
3:51 GUY: BUT NOTHING TANGIBLE. IS NOTHING TANGIBLE OK?
3:54 CAN TRUMP GO HOME WITH NOTHING TANGIBLE?
3:58 HE'S BUT -- JUST BEEN TOLD BY THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THAT THE
4:00 PLAN IS NOT WORKING. CAN HE GO HOME WITH NOTHING?
4:03 I DON'T KNOW. AT THE MOMENT, THAT'S WHAT IT
4:05 FEELS LIKE. ANTHROPIC.
4:10 WE ARE IN THE PROCESS. WE'VE HAD THE PRICING.
4:13 IT'S OBVIOUSLY BEATING SPACEX IN TERMS OF THE SCALE OF THE IPO.
4:18 WE THINK THERE WILL BE A POP WHEN IT LISTS.
4:19 THE LISTING IS THE END OF THE PROCESS OF THE IPO.
4:24 BUT AGAIN, WHAT IS THE SIGNAL HERE?
4:27 WHAT IS THE WIDER SIGNAL FOR THE U.K. SYSTEM?
4:31 I'M TROUBLING -- STRUGGLING TO SEE ONE.
4:33 IS THERE A SIGNAL OF THE POP? IF WE GET IT WHEN HE PERCENT
4:36 POP, WHAT IS THE SIGNAL THERE? OTHER THAN THE FACT THAT THEY
4:39 PRICED IT ABOUT RIGHT. ANNA: THAT SEEMS TO BE WHAT
4:43 PEOPLE AIM FOR IN THESE SITUATIONS.
4:47 INTERESTING TO THINK ABOUT THE CONTEXT OF THE NASDAQ THAT THIS
4:49 IS HAPPENING INTO. YOU'VE BEEN ASKING WHETHER THE
4:53 MARKET HAS BEEN POSITIONING AHEAD OF THIS IPO TO ABSORB THIS
4:55 IPO. DOWN 4% OVER FIVE DAYS ON THE
5:00 NASDAQ. THAT'S THE WEAKER BACKDROP.
5:04 NOW WE FIND THAT NASDAQ FUTURES ARE POINTING HIGHER.
5:07 WE HAVEN'T HAD THE LISTING AT. -- YET.
5:10 WE ARE IN THE PROCESS. GUY: THE CHALLENGES THAT THE
5:13 MARKET POPPED EVERY DAY THIS WEEK AND THEN DROPPED.
5:17 YOU ARE GETTING INTO THIS KIND OF MARKET PATTERN WHERE YOU GET
5:22 ENTHUSIASM AT THE START BUT THEN IT FADES FAST AND FADES INTO THE
5:24 CLOSE. ARE WE SETTING OURSELVES UP FOR
5:29 THAT ONCE AGAIN? ANTHROPIC IS ABOUT TO IPO.
5:33 CAN THE POP BE SUSTAINED THROUGH THE SESSION?
5:36 CAN IT BE SUSTAINED THROUGH FRIDAY?
5:39 ANNA: WE HAVE RICHARD WINDSOR ON THE PROGRAM LATER ON.
5:42 INTERESTING VIEWS ABOUT HOW YOU PLAY THE LARD LANGUAGE VERSUS
5:47 THE PICKS AND SHOVELS. THAT'S AN INTERESTING
5:49 CONVERSATION THAT WILL NOW BECOME MUCH MORE RELEVANT
5:52 BECAUSE YOU HAVE A WAY TO PLAY IT.
5:55 THIS IS THE BIGGEST IPO YEAR SINCE 2021 WHEN WE REMEMBER THAT
5:59 WE WERE ALL STUCK AT HOME A LOT OF THE TIME TALKING ABOUT CRYPTO
6:01 AND TRADING. GUY: FUN TIMES.
6:09 BACKDROP THERE. HOW THE IPO WAVE HOLDS UP TO
6:12 HIGHER INTEREST RATES IS ALSO WORTH CONSIDERING, ISN'T IT?
6:18 WE STILL HAVE OPENAI TO COME NEXT YEAR, APPARENTLY.
6:22 WHEN I SAY ON TRACK, DOES THAT WITHSTAND A HIGHER INTEREST RATE
6:23 ENVIRONMENT? WE HAVE HAD SOME HAWKISH
6:25 LANGUAGE. THE MINUTES SUGGESTING THAT
6:30 NEARLY ALL OF THE FOMC MEMBERS WERE SIGNALING MORE HIKES TO
6:31 COME. WE HEARD WALLER BACKING 50 BASIS
6:40 POINTS IN DECEMBER OR SPLITTING 25 IN DECEMBER, 25 IN JANUARY.
6:44 GUY: WHAT'S GOING ON WITH THE DOLLAR, DON'T KNOW.
6:47 BUT IT'S DEFINITELY BROKEN OUT OF ITS RECENT RANGE AND HIS
6:50 CELEBRANT -- ACCELERATING TO THE UPSIDE.
6:53 WHY ARE PEOPLE SELLING PRECIOUS METALS?
6:56 DON'T KNOW WHAT THE SIGNAL IS THERE BUT THERE IS CLEARLY
6:59 SOMETHING GOING ON UNDERNEATH THE SURFACE THAT I THINK IS
7:00 WORTH PAYING ATTENTION TO. OIL PRICES HAVE COME DOWN.
7:07 THE NEW YORK TIMES REPORTING IS VERY SIGNIFICANT.
7:10 DOES PRESIDENT TRUMP WANT TO GET THE SUMMIT WITH XI OUT OF THE
7:12 WAY? DON'T KNOW.
7:16 THAT'S A RISK THAT NEEDS TO BE PRICED IN.
7:21 THAT ESCALATION RISK IS COMING BACK TOWARDS THE CENTER.
7:23 THAT'S WORTH PAYING ATTENTION TO.
7:27 I THINK THE DOLLAR SIGNAL IS SIGNIFICANT.
7:32 TO GET MOVES LIKE THIS IN THE DOLLAR, IS IT A FED STORY OR IS
7:34 IT SOMETHING ELSE? ANNA: AT THE BEGINNING OF THE
7:38 WEEK, HE TIED IT TO INTEREST RATE DIFFERENTIALS.
7:43 SOME PEOPLE ARE PUSHING THAT IT'S AN AI STORY, THAT THERE'S
7:46 AN AI LINK AS WELL. IF WE SEE EQUITY MARKETS MAKING
7:51 SPACE FOR ANTHROPIC, IS THERE AN IMPACT THERE?
7:54 THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE AN ABSOLUTELY MAMMOTH IPO TO MAKE
7:55 THAT HAPPEN. THIS IS A BIG ONE.
7:59 THIS IS A REALLY BIG IPO. WE ARE WATCHING THE TERROR --
8:03 DOLLAR CAREFULLY AS IT GAINS. GUY: THERE'S ANOTHER THEORY THAT
8:07 THIS IS A CREDIT STORY. THAT THERE WAS A CREDIT RISK
8:10 EVENT BEGINNING TO PERMEATE INTO THE MARKETS AS WELL.
8:13 WHICH IS A MORE FUNDAMENTAL THREAT.
8:17 ANNA: I WAS AT A CREDIT EVENT YESTERDAY.
8:19 THE PULLING OF THE AUDIENCE WAS THAT THINGS WILL GET WORSE
8:21 BEFORE THEY GET BETTER AROUND THE TRIPLE C STORY WHICH WE
8:23 TALKED ABOUT. GUY: THE FIRE STARTS IN THE
8:26 BASEMENT MAYBE. WE WILL TALK ABOUT THE
8:33 TRILATERAL TRUMP TO CHINA. WHAT DOES IT TELL US?
8:39 MICHELLE BONNIE IS GOING TO BE ON THE SHOW, FORMER FRENCH
8:42 FINEST ARE -- PRIME MINISTER. AN INTERESTING CONVERSATION.
8:51 RICHARD WINDSOR FROM RADIO FREE MOBILE WILL BE HERE.
8:54 WE WILL TALK ANTHROPIC. WE WILL TALK ABOUT NVIDIA AS
8:56 WELL. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THE ACTION
8:57 YESTERDAY? BIG FADE TOWARDS THE END OF THE
9:01 DAY. ANNA: OTHER EVENTS COMING
9:03 THROUGH THE DAY. THE TRUMP, XI, AND PUT IN AT THE
9:09 APEC SUMMIT. THE GERMAN CHANCELLOR IS GOING
9:15 TO BE HOSTING EMMANUEL MACRON AND ANDY BURNHAM AT A COALITION
9:19 OF THE WILLING MEETING IN BERLIN WITH ITS FOCUS ON UKRAINE
9:21 DEVELOPMENT. EUROPEAN AFFAIRS MINISTERS WILL
9:26 BE MEETING IN BRUSSELS SO THEY ARE ALSO WATCHING UKRAINE.
9:28 EARNINGS FROM ALIBABA AND WALMART ARE DUE TO BEGIN TRADING
9:33 TODAY ON THE NASDAQ. GUY: IT WILL BE A PUBLICLY
9:36 LISTED COMPANY. IS IT GOING TO BE THE BELLWETHER
9:40 FOR THE AI TRADE? AT THE END OF THE DAY, WE WILL
9:42 SEE. EUROPEAN CAPITAL AT THE ECB.
9:48 WE WILL HAVE THE LATEST ON THAT STORY THIS MORNING.
9:51 COPPER STAGING A PARTIAL RECOVERY.
9:54 DOWN 6% WEDNESDAY. WHY?
9:54 WHAT'S GOING ON? WHAT'S MOVING THE METAL?
10:01 WE WILL TALK ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN.
10:03 PRESIDENT TRUMP HOLDING TALKS WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN AND XI
10:06 JINPING. WE TRY TO WORK OUT WHAT THE
10:07 TIMING LOOKS LIKE. WHEN WE GET PLAYBACK OF THE
10:10 EVENT, WE WILL BRING IT TO YOU LIVE.
10:13 JOIN THE CONVERSATION THIS MORNING.
10:17 IT'S WORTH TALKING ABOUT. NICE DAY IN LONDON.
10:20 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
10:31 GUY: THURSDAY MORNING, THE 19TH.
10:34 HALF AN EYE ON A LOT OF THINGS THIS MORNING.
10:36 ONE OF THEM I'M WATCHING HIS NASDAQ FUTURES AS WE TRY TO GET
10:39 A SENSE OF HOW ANTHROPIC WILL IMPACT THE MARKET.
10:43 WE ARE AT SESSION HIGHS. I THINK WE GOT UP AND THEN FADED
10:48 A TINY BIT SINCE THEN. KEEP AN EYE ON THAT.
10:51 EUROPEAN EQUITIES ARE BROADLY POSITIVE.
10:54 NOT AS MUCH AS WE ARE SEEING STATESIDE.
10:56 WE ARE REFLECTING SOME OF THE U.S. POSITIVITY.
11:00 ANNA: WE NEED MORE THAN TWO LINES TO KEEP AN EYE ON WHAT'S
11:01 HAPPENING OVER THE NEWS AGENDA THIS MORNING.
11:06 WE ARE EXPECTING THE START OF THE TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN
11:12 PRESIDENTS TRUMP, XI, AND PUTIN. WE ARE EXPECTING IT TO BEGIN ANY
11:14 MINUTE. LET'S GET TO MINMIN LOW WHO HAS
11:18 MORE OF A SENSE OF THE TIMING OF THESE THINGS AND SOME OF THE
11:19 EXPECTATION AROUND THE SUMMIT. SHE'S IN SHENZHEN.
11:23 WHAT WE KNOW SO FAR? MINMIN: HEY.
11:29 WE UNDERSTAND THAT TRUMP AND XI ARE HAVING THE LATE LUSH.
11:32 THE RUSSIANS ARE ALREADY IN THE HOLDING ROOM.
11:33 THE SUMMIT COULD BE STARTING VERY SOON.
11:35 IT'S INTERESTING TODAY, PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS A LITTLE BIT
11:38 LATE TO HIS MEETING WITH PRESIDENT XI BECAUSE OF A
11:44 LAST-MINUTE ADDITION TO HIS SCHEDULE.
11:45 TRUMP AND PUTIN HAD A SHORT MEETING JUST AHEAD OF THE
11:50 MEETING WITH XI. NOT MANY PEOPLE CAN KEEP
11:53 PRESIDENT XI WAITING AND GET AWAY WITH IT BUT THAT'S WHAT
11:55 HAPPENED. PRESIDENT PUTIN WALKED AWAY FROM
12:00 THE MEETING WITH TRUMP IN A GOOD MOOD.
12:01 THAT'S ACCORDING TO RUSSIAN MEDIA.
12:03 HE SAID THAT THEY DISCUSSED UKRAINE AND THAT IS A
12:08 PREPARATORY MEETING FOR THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT.
12:10 UKRAINE WILL BE A TOPIC OF DISCUSSION AS WELL.
12:13 THIS WAS A LITTLE BIT OF A SURPRISE BECAUSE U.S. OFFICIALS
12:17 HAVE BEEN TELLING BLOOMBERG THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS NOT GOING TO
12:21 BRING UP UKRAINE BECAUSE THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WOULD MAKE
12:25 EUROPEAN CAPITALS UNCOMFORTABLE WITH PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY NOT AT
12:25 THE TABLE. NOW IT APPEARS TO BE VERY MUCH
12:30 ON THE AGENDA. WE WILL HAVE TO SEE IF PRESIDENT
12:35 PUTIN WILL BE ABLE TO SWAY ANY NEGOTIATED OUTCOME AND MOSCOW'S
12:37 FAVOR. PRESIDENT TRUMP DID SAY THAT HE
12:41 IS NOT GOING TO AGREE TO ANYTHING WITHOUT CONSULTING WITH
12:47 PRESIDENT ZELENSKYY. THIS MEETING WILL PUT OTHER
12:50 ASIAN ALLIES IN A DIFFICULT POSITION AS WELL.
12:52 JAPAN WILL BE WATCHING THIS CLOSELY.
12:58 THERE WILL BE A PULL ASIDE AFTER THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT BECAUSE
13:02 THIS IS COMING AT A TIME WHERE RUSSIA, JAPAN TIES ARE SOURING
13:05 AFTER RUSSIA DETAINED JAPANESE JOURNALIST OVER ESPIONAGE
13:07 CHARGES. JUST GIVE A PRESS CONFERENCE
13:12 EARLIER SAYING THAT THE SUMMIT IS NOT GOING TO JEOPARDIZE
13:16 JAPANESE INTERESTS EVEN THOUGH JAPAN RELIES HEAVILY ON THE U.S.
13:17 FOR ITS MILITARY. IT IS HEMMED IN GEOGRAPHICALLY
13:23 SO THIS IS SOMETHING THAT THEY ARE WATCHING VERY CLOSELY.
13:26 TAIWAN WILL KEEP A CLOSE WATCH ON WHETHER ITS OWN FATE COULD BE
13:29 DECIDED IN A SIMILAR FASHION. GUY: THANKS FOR THE UPDATE.
13:33 GREATLY APPRECIATE YOU UPDATING TO US ON HOW THE AGENDA IS
13:37 CHANGING. CHIEF ECONOMIST FOR ASIA-PACIFIC
13:44 JOINS US NOW. GOOD MORNING.
13:47 GIVE ME A SENSE OF WHAT YOU THINK FROM A MARKET PERSPECTIVE.
13:52 ARE THERE GOING TO BE ANY TANGIBLE ELEMENTS THAT WE CAN
13:58 TALK ABOUT THAT MARKETS AND ECONOMIES CAN MOVE OFF?
14:04 >> I DON'T THINK THERE WILL BE. WE WILL BE LUCKY IF THEY AREN'T.
14:08 IF ANYTHING COMES OUT, IT'S NOT GOING TO BE POSITIVE.
14:11 THE U.S. IS BASICALLY COMING ALONG WITH RENEWED EXPORT
14:17 CONTROLS, BASICALLY ANNOUNCED ON MONDAY.
14:19 THAT IS SOMETHING THAT PRESIDENT XI IS GOING TO VERY MUCH BE
14:25 AGAINST. BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT XI WANTED
14:32 FROM THE BEGINNING IN THAT TRUCE .
14:33 THEREFORE, I THINK IT'S QUITE OBVIOUS THAT EVEN IF IT COMES
14:38 OUT, IT WILL BE LESS. THAT'S VERY GOOD.
14:41 IF NOT, I THINK WE WILL HAVE THAT EXPORT CONTROL HIT IN THE
14:45 U.S. ON RARE-EARTH. AND POTENTIALLY EVEN ADDITIONAL
14:49 EXPORT CONTROLS ON NOT ONLY CHIPS BUT EVEN DESIGN BEYOND
14:55 WHAT WE'VE ALREADY SEEN. SO THAT'S A LOT.
15:00 IT'S BETTER NOT TO HEAR TOO MUCH OF THE ECONOMIC FRONT FOR THAT
15:03 SUMMIT. GUY: OK.
15:09 SO WHAT'S THE SIGNAL HERE THAT I SHOULD BE TAKING AWAY?
15:12 JUST THAT WE ARE OK, NOTHING IS MOVING?
15:15 THAT'S THE SIGNAL I SHOULD TAKE AWAY FROM THIS?
15:19 WHAT'S ENOUGH TO KEEP THE TRAIN ON THE TRACKS?
15:23 ALICIA: AS WE SPEAK, THE TRAIN IS ON THE TRACKS.
15:27 OF COURSE, IF YOU ARE SINGAPORE, IF YOU ARE MALAYSIA, YOU FEEL
15:31 DISARMED BECAUSE OF THESE NEW EXPORT CONTROLS.
15:34 BUT THAT'S COLLATERAL DAMAGE. THAT'S NOT CHINA U.S..
15:39 AS LONG AS THERE NO ANNOUNCEMENT THAT THE TRUCES OVER AND THAT
15:42 EXPORT CONTROLS WILL HIT ON RARE-EARTH, WE ARE FINE.
15:45 THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO HEAR AT THE SUMMIT.
15:49 I THINK THIS WOULD BE VERY GOOD FOR THE WORLD.
15:53 ANNA: OK. INTERESTING TAKE.
15:54 IN TERMS OF THE DOMESTIC CHINESE STORY, ARE YOU LOOKING FOR ANY
16:00 STIMULUS DOMESTICALLY IN CHINA AT THIS POINT, GIVEN HOW MUCH IT
16:03 RELIES ON EXPORT MARKETS AT THE MOMENT?
16:09 ALICIA: I THINK THEY LOVE THE MODEL.
16:10 IF THE STIMULUS IS STILL GOING TOWARDS ADDITIONAL INDUSTRIAL
16:18 EXPORTS. I DON'T THINK THAT IS SOMETHING
16:21 CHINA DISLIKES TO BE FRANK. THE REST OF THE WORLD MIGHT.
16:27 THAT IS SOMETHING THAT CHINA IS PURPOSELY PUSHING.
16:29 I DON'T THINK WE SEE MORE STIMULUS.
16:33 THE SITUATION IS WHAT IT IS. THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY IS NOT
16:35 DOING WELL. OVERALL, THEY HIT THE TARGET FOR
16:39 THE YEAR. BASED ON EXPORTS, WE KNOW THAT.
16:42 BUT THAT'S GOOD ENOUGH. THAT'S NOT XI'S INTENT.
16:47 HIS INTENT IS TECHNOLOGICAL SUPREMACY.
16:51 FOR THAT YOU NEED A LOT OF MONEY AND NOT NECESSARILY GOING TO
16:52 HOUSEHOLDS. THAT'S IT.
16:56 ANNA: SO YOU THINK CHINA IS COMFORTABLE WITH THE WEEK
17:00 CONSUMER BACKDROP BECAUSE IT IS SIMPLY NOT A GEOPOLITICAL
17:03 PRIORITY TO HAVE A STRONGER CONSUMER?
17:08 ALICIA: THAT'S EXACTLY THE CASE. YOU CAN'T ACHIEVE EVERY
17:12 OBJECTIVE AT THE SAME TIME. THIS IS THE OBJECTIVE THAT CHINA
17:13 HAS IN MIND AT THE CURRENT JUNCTURE.
17:15 THEY ALSO HAVE TRUMP ON THEIR SIDE IN TERMS OF ALL THESE
17:21 EXPORT CONTROLS HAVING BEEN LIFTED FOR THEM UNTIL NOW.
17:23 IT'S GOING TO BE HARDER DOWN THE ROAD.
17:27 THEY REALLY NEED TO TAKE THIS WINDOW OF OPPORTUNITY.
17:30 TRUMP WON'T BE THERE FOREVER. THIS IS THE TIME.
17:31 PUSH FORWARD AS THEY ARE DOING. GUY: CAN I GET YOUR TAKE ON THE
17:35 STRONGER DOLLAR? INDONESIA HAS RAISED 25 BIBS.
17:41 THAT'S A BIT OF A SURPRISE. IF THE DOLLAR KEEPS
17:44 STRENGTHENING SIGNIFICANTLY FROM HERE, WHAT IMPACT DOES IT HAVE
17:47 IN YOUR REGION? ALICIA: HUGE.
17:56 I DO THINK MY REGION HAS A LOT TO DO WITH THAT STRONGER DOLLAR.
18:00 THE REASON IS VERY SIMPLE. THERE WERE A LOT OF INFLOWS INTO
18:05 KOREA, TAIWAN STOCK MARKET. TO A LESSER EXTENT, CHINA.
18:11 YOU HAD THIS AI PLAY IN HARDWARE MOSTLY IN THE REGION.
18:14 THAT WAS FEEDING ALL OF THESE DATA CENTERS.
18:20 NOW WE'VE DISCOVERED THEY WERE BASICALLY BEING USED AS A
18:25 BACKDOOR TO EXPORT, TO FEED CHINA'S AI RISE WITH THE BEST
18:30 SEMICONDUCTORS AND GP'S FROM NVIDIA.
18:31 SO THAT'S OVER. AS WE SEE, THE STOCK MARKETS ARE
18:35 RECOVERING. THE CURRENCIES ARE WEAKER AND
18:37 WEAKER. THESE ARE LITERALLY DOLLARS
18:43 CONVERTED BACK TO THE U.S. INTO THE NEW IPO'S THAT YOU WILL SEE.
18:49 IF THE BIG SAVERS, COUNTRIES WITH A LOT OF SAVINGS, CONTINUE
18:56 TO FEED THE U.S. WITH CAPITAL, THE DOLLAR IS STRONGER.
18:59 THERE'S A BIG RELATION BETWEEN WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE AI SPACE
19:02 AND THE DOLLAR. ANNA: THAT'S AN IMPORTANT LINK
19:06 THAT WE ARE CERTAINLY WATCHING. THINKING ABOUT THE LEADERS THAT
19:10 OUR MEETING, WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR THIS TRILATERAL
19:15 MEETING, THINKING IT -- ABOUT THE RUSSIAN ECONOMY, MANY HAVE
19:18 SUGGESTED THAT IT'S BEEN ABLE TO WITHSTAND THE SANCTIONS
19:21 ENVIRONMENT BECAUSE IT IS FOUND WILLIE BYERS IN ASIA FOR MANY OF
19:23 ITS EXPORTS. DO YOU SEE ANY NEW DEVELOPMENTS
19:28 THERE, ANYTHING WE NEED TO WATCH FOR IN TERMS OF THE RUSSIAN
19:31 ECONOMY AND ITS RESILIENCE? ALICIA: YEAH.
19:38 I THINK OPPORTUNITY IS QUICKLY FALLING APART FOR RUSSIA.
19:43 BY NOW, EVERYBODY WAS LONG DOLLAR COME ALONG OIL.
19:50 WE CAN ALREADY SEE THAT IF THE IRAN CONFLICT IS NOT FULLY
19:54 CLEARED, OIL PRICES ARE COMING DOWN.
19:57 THEY WILL COME DOWN VERY AGGRESSIVELY.
19:59 THIS IS BAD NEWS FOR RUSSIA. THE MOMENT THE GULF POPS UP ITS
20:06 PRODUCTION, THAT'S ALSO GOING TO MEAN THAT RUSSIA WILL BE LESS
20:10 ABLE TO PROFIT FROM THAT LACK OF SUPPLY FROM THE GULF.
20:15 ALL OF THIS MEANS THAT THE GOOD TIMES ARE OVER AND RUSSIA NEEDS
20:19 TO NEGOTIATE AN EXIT TO THIS WAR.
20:21 WE MIGHT LOOK AT IT VERY DIFFERENTLY.
20:25 PUTIN APPEARS AS A WINNER. I DON'T THINK THAT THAT REFLECTS
20:29 THE REALITY OF WHERE HE STANDS AT THE MOMENT.
20:35 ANNA: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME.
20:36 REALLY GOOD TO SPEAK TO YOU. COMING UP AT 9:00 LONDON TIME,
20:42 BLOOMBERG IS HOSTING A LIVE Q&A TO ANALYZE KEY MOMENTS FROM THIS
20:45 TRILATERAL MEETING AT THE AIPAC SUMMIT.
20:49 ASK YOUR QUESTIONS AT BLOOMBERG.COM.
20:52 GUY: THURSDAY MORNING. WHAT ELSE DO WE NEED TO KNOW?
20:57 THE UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT SAYS HE WILL BRIEF ALLIES ON THE OUTCOME
21:01 OF PRESIDENT STOCKS IN CHINA. THE U.S. SPECIAL ENVOY STEVE
21:05 WITKOFF, JARED KUSHNER WILL JOIN 30 LEADERS FOR THE SO-CALLED
21:06 COALITION OF THE WILLING IN BERLIN FOR THE UPDATE.
21:11 BLOOMBERG UNDERSTANDS A RECRUITMENT COMPANY HELPING
21:15 NVIDIA FIND REPLACEMENT FOR JENSEN HUANG.
21:19 A LEADING CONTENDER TO SUCCEED JENSEN HUANG WHO WORKED AT
21:22 NVIDIA FOR SEVEN YEARS AS GENERAL MANAGER OF COMPUTING
21:26 PRODUCTS. OTHER POTENTIAL CANDIDATES
21:28 INCLUDE THE NVIDIA VICE PRESIDENT AND THE AMD CEO.
21:34 THE EURO GROUP HAS PUSHED BACK ITS DEADLINE FOR SUBMITTING
21:37 NOMINATIONS FOR TWO KEY ECB VACANCIES TO FRIDAY.
21:44 THE CHIEF ECONOMIST PHILIP LANE WHO IS CURRENTLY IN CHARGE OF
21:46 MARKETS. FOR LYNN HAS ALREADY AGREED TO
21:52 NOMINATE -- FOR THE ECONOMIST BRIEF, SUGGESTING THAT SPAIN'S
21:58 -- WILL REPLACE KRISTI LAGARDE IS ECB PRESIDENT.
22:01 ANNA: LET'S GO TO SOME BREAKING NEWS.
22:03 COMMERZBANK CONFIRMING THAT GERMANY AND UNICREDIT HAVE
22:05 REACHED AN AGREEMENT ON THE TAKEOVER.
22:10 WE ARE GETTING SOME DETAILS OF COMMITMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN MADE
22:11 BY UNICREDIT IN THAT REGARD. THE HEADQUARTERS TO REMAIN
22:15 PERMANENTLY IN FRANKFURT. COMMERZBANK TO REMAIN LISTED ON
22:21 THE STOCK EXCHANGE TO GET THERE ARE SOME COMMITMENTS AROUND
22:23 EMPLOYEE RIGHTS AND EXISTING AGREEMENTS BEING RECOGNIZED.
22:25 IT SEEMS AS IS THIS IS MOVING FORWARD.
22:29 THERE'S AN AGREEMENT TO EXPAND THE -- BUSINESS.
22:32 THAT WAS ALWAYS SEEN AS A BIG PART OF THE COMMERZBANK BUSINESS
22:34 AND THE STRENGTH OF THE COMMERZBANK BUSINESS, THAT IT
22:38 HAD THE SIGNIFICANT BUSINESS SHARE WITHIN THE MID SIDE
22:39 BUSINESSES IN GERMANY. GUY: THE STOCK EXCHANGE IS
22:44 REALLY INTERESTING. HOW DOES THAT WORK?
22:47 IS IT A TRACKING STOCK EFFECTIVELY FOR COMMERZBANK,
22:50 UNICREDIT? IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE
22:55 WHAT THAT STOCK DOES, HOW USEFUL IT IS.
22:57 IS IT A SYMBOL OF THE FACT THAT COMMERZBANK IS STILL A GERMAN
22:59 COMPANY? ANNA: WE WILL WAIT FORMING --
23:05 FOR MORE DETAILS I SUPPOSE. UNICREDIT AND GERMANY THEN
23:08 REACHING AN AGREEMENT, A BROAD AGREEMENT ON COMMERZBANK.
23:14 WHEN WE COME BACK, WE WILL SPEAK TO THE FORMER FRENCH PRIME
23:18 MINISTER AT -- AND THE EU'S FORMER CHIEF BREXIT NEGOTIATOR.
23:22 ATTENTION TURNING TOWARDS TOMORROW'S U.K. EU SUMMIT
23:27 BETWEEN THOSE TWO PARTIES. IT'S ON SPECIFICS AROUND FOOD,
23:33 WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THE SUMMIT TOMORROW?
23:35 REALLY INTERESTING. HOW WEEK SHOULD AMBITIONS BE
23:38 AROUND BREXIT? I CAN'T BELIEVE WE ARE SAYING
23:44 THAT WORD SO OFTEN ONCE AGAIN. THAT'S NEXT.
23:46 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
24:05 GUY: GOOD MORNING. HOW ARE YOU DOING?
24:07 30 MINUTES TO GO UNTIL THE START OF EQUITY TRADING IN EUROPE.
24:10 UP ON THE EURO STOXX 50. THE STORY IS STATESIDE.
24:16 THE NASDAQ IS UP AS WE ANTICIPATE THE ARRIVAL OF
24:18 ANTHROPIC. THE IPO PRICE IS UNDERWAY.
24:21 IT WILL LIST LATER. IT IS A HUGE DAY FOR THE MARKET.
24:26 WHERE WILL WE BE AT THE END OF IT IS THE KEY QUESTION.
24:30 ANNA: THE DAY AFTER EVERYTHING WAS NVIDIA.
24:35 A FOCUS IN TERMS OF EQUITIES. YESTERDAY WE SAW SUBSTANTIAL
24:37 RESPONSE IN BOND MARKETS TO A LOWER OIL PRICE.
24:40 WE ARE MAINTAINING THAT LOWER OIL PRICE, $92 ON BRENT.
24:45 PRETTY UNCHANGED ON EUROPEAN BONDS RIGHT NOW.
24:48 NOW TOMORROW BRINGS A HIGHLY ANTICIPATED SUMMIT BETWEEN THE
24:51 U.K. AND THE E.U. HIGHLY ANTICIPATED IN THE U.K.
24:54 AT LEAST. THE U.K. PRIME MINISTER ANDY
25:01 BURNHAM HAS PUT REJOINING THE TRADING BLOC BACK ON THE
25:02 POLITICAL AGENDA. IN HIS FIRST FOREIGN POLICY
25:07 SPEECH MONDAY BURNHAM OUTLINED WHAT HE BELIEVES COMING NEXT.
25:10 >> AFTER THE SUMMIT, WE WILL INITIATE A DISCUSSION WITH OUR
25:13 E.U. PARTNERS ABOUT OPTIONS FOR OUR LONG-TERM RELATIONSHIP.
25:17 RECOGNIZING THAT BOTH BRITAIN AND THE E.U. ARE VERY DIFFERENT
25:21 TO WHAT THEY WERE. THIS WILL TAKE TIME AND WE WILL
25:25 PRESENT THOSE OPTIONS AND OUR ASSESSMENT OF THEM TO INFORM
25:29 DECISIONS IN THE NEXT PARLIAMENT.
25:33 AT EVERY STAGE, THE BRITISH PEOPLE THEREBY BOSS.
25:39 ANNA: I'M PLEASED TO SAY, WE CAN ENTERTAINING THE CONVERSATION
25:43 THE FORMER E.U. CHIEF BRICKS NEGOTIATOR AND FORMER FRENCH
25:45 PRIME MINISTER. THE SO NICE TO HAVE YOU ON THE
25:47 PROGRAM. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
25:52 ARE YOU SURPRISED TO SEE IT BACK IN CONVERSATION ACROSS THE
25:55 CHANNEL? >> GOOD MORNING FROM PARIS.
25:58 GOOD MORNING FROM THE FRENCH NATIONAL -- NO, NO, I'M NOT
26:03 SURPRISED BECAUSE I THOUGHT FOR A LONG TIME THE BREXIT HAD NO
26:10 ADDED VALUE FOR ANYBODY. IT WOULD REMAIN A LOSE-LOSE
26:13 GAME. I'M VERY HAPPY THAT THE NEW
26:18 PRIME MINISTER TO HAVE U.K. ANDY BURNHAM WANTS TO BUILD A NEW
26:22 COOPERATION WITH THE E.U. FOR US, LET ME BE VERY, VERY
26:27 FRANK. NOBODY IS SPEAKING ABOUT BREXIT
26:31 IN E.U. SO FOR US THE BREXIT IS IN THE
26:33 BOOK. BUT THE DOOR IS OPEN.
26:39 THE DOOR IS OPEN, THE SINGLE MARKET FOR ANY NEW CORPORATION.
26:46 SO MANY DOUBTS. H WE MUST IN OUR COMMON INTEREST
26:51 COOPERATE. I THINK ABOUT AI.
26:57 ABOUT -- WE HAVE SO MANY THINGS TO DO TOGETHER.
26:59 ANNA: OK. MANY THINGS TO DO TOGETHER.
27:04 DO YOU THINK THAT THE FUTURE RELATIONSHIP WILL JUST BE MUCH
27:09 DEEPER COOPERATION ON MANY SUBJECTS OR DO YOU ACTUALLY
27:12 THINK THE U.K. WILL GO BACK INTO THE E.U.?
27:21 >> IT IS A BRITISH CHOICE. ANNA: BUT IT ISN'T ONLY A
27:25 BRITISH CHOICE. >> YES, IT IS.
27:31 FOR THE MOMENT IT IS A BRITISH CHOICE TO TELL US WHAT THEY WANT
27:33 TO DO. IF THEY WANT TO REJOIN, AND
27:40 THERE ARE MANY OPTIONS. REMEMBER MY FAMOUS -- THAT CAN
27:47 REJOIN, THEY CAN REJOIN THE SINGLE MARKET.
27:49 THEY CAN REJOIN THE E.U. IT IS A BRITISH CHOICE AND FOR
27:58 THE MOMENT, ANY FORMAL AND -- REJOIN THE E.U.
28:03 IT WILL REMAIN A BRITISH CHOICE. THE DOOR IS OPEN FOR A NEW
28:10 NEGOTIATION. GUY: GOOD MORNING.
28:17 >> ONE CONDITION, THE U.K. KNOWS PERFECTLY WELL.
28:21 THERE WILL BE NO CHERRY PICKING. NO -- ON THE MARKET.
28:28 TO KEEP A VERY STRONG SINGLE MARKET.
28:30 GUY: YES. CHERRIES ALWAYS COMING UP, DON'T
28:33 THEY? LET'S TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT
28:37 THE FARAGE CLAUSE. DO YOU GUYS TRUST US?
28:43 IS THERE A LEVEL OF TRUST THAT WOULD ALLOW THE U.K. TO MOVE
28:45 CLOSER? HOW MUCH OF A RISK IS THERE THAT
28:49 THERE WOULD BE A REVERSAL ONCE AGAIN IN THE BRITISH POSITION?
29:03 HOW DO YOU MANAGE THAT? >> I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHAT YOU
29:09 MEAN SPEAKING ABOUT THE FARAGE CLAUSE.
29:17 NOR TRUST. BUT WE ARE FRIENDS, WE ARE
29:20 PARTNERS, WE ARE NEIGHBORS AND WE HAVE TO WORK TOGETHER IN OUR
29:23 COMMON INTEREST. THE U.K. KNOWS PERFECTLY WELL
29:30 WHAT IS THE RULE OF THE GAME, SPEAKING ABOUT REJOINING THE
29:33 UNION OR REJOINING THE SINGLE MARKET OR REJOINING THE E.U.
29:40 SO THE RULE OF THE GAME WILL BE RESPECTED IN ANY CASE.
29:49 BUT THIS NEW NEGOTIATION FOR REJOINING, I THINK WE CAN AND WE
29:57 MUST INCREASE OUR COOPERATION FOR -- UKRAINE FOR DEFENSE, FOR
30:02 COOP FLATIONAFRICA, FOR INVESTMENT IN AI.
30:07 WE HAVE SO MANY THINGS WHERE IT IS OUR COMMON INTEREST AND
30:13 CHINA. SOMEBODY IS MISSING FROM THE
30:17 PHOTOGRAPH. THE EUROPEANS ARE MISSING.
30:22 WE NEED TO BE TOGETHER TO BE RESPECTED BY THE SUPER POWERS.
30:25 ANNA: YOU SAID THE DOOR IS OPEN TO NEGOTIATIONS FOR THE U.K. TO
30:29 COME BACK IF IT WANTS TO. YOU SAY IT IS A BRITISH CHOICE.
30:32 WHAT ABOUT IF WE SEE FURTHER POWER IN THE HANDS OF MORE RIGHT
30:37 WING LEADERS IN EUROPE, I'M THINKING FRANCE OF COURSE, ALSO
30:40 PERHAPS IN SPAIN. DO YOU THINK THE DOOR WOULD
30:45 STILL BE OPEN TO REJOINING? >> WE MUST ACT AND PERSONALLY
30:50 I'M ACTING AS A MEMBER OF THE -- FORMER PRIME MINISTER OF FRANCE
30:57 TO -- THE CHOICE OF ONE THATTIST AT THE HEAD OF FRANCE.
31:02 IT WOULD BE IN THAT CASE, THE FIRST TIME IN 65 YEARS THAT MY
31:13 COUNTRY WILL BE MANAGED BY -- AND LE PEN OR WE HAVE TO AVOID
31:18 THIS SITUATION IN ANY CASE. IELABORATE IT FURTHER.
31:25 WE HAVE TO AVOID THIS CHOICE. GUY: IS IT THOUGH THE BASE CASE?
31:31 IS IT YOUR CURRENT BASE CASE THAT MARINE LE PEN IS THE NEXT
31:38 PRESIDENT OF FRANCE? >> IT WILL NOT BE A BEST CASE.
31:45 GUY: THE CASE, NOT BEST CASE. >> IT WILL BE A DISASTER FOR
31:49 FRANCE BECAUSE IT WOULD BE AN ILLUSION.
31:52 REMEMBER, THE TITLE MIGHT LOOK AFTER -- THE GREAT ILLUSION FOR
31:55 EXACTLY THE SAME. THEY ARE WORKING ON THE BASE OF
32:01 LIE AND THE BASE OF AN ILLUSION. SO I KNOW THE POLLS AND MY
32:12 PARTY, THE REPUBLICANS, CENTER RIGHT TO AVOID THIS POSSIBILITY.
32:17 WE ARE WORKING HARD FOR THE NEXT FIVE MONTHS NOW FROM NOW TO
32:24 AVOID THIS SITUATION IN FRANCE AND ELECT A NATIONALIST IN
32:26 FRANCE. GUY: DO YOU THINK CHRISTINE
32:33 LAGARDE WOULD MAKE A GOOD FRENCH PRESIDENT?
32:36 >> SHE IS QUITE COMPETENT. SHE HAS A HUGE EXPERIENCE ON
32:42 NATIONAL AFFAIRS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES AND I DON'T KNOW IF SHE
32:43 WANTS TO RUN. I'M NOT SURE OF THAT BUT I'M
32:49 SURE THAT SHE WILL TAKE A BIG ROLE FOR FRANCE AND FOR EUROPE
32:54 IN THE NEXT FEW YEARS. GUY: OK.
32:57 SOUNDS LIKE YOU MIGHT SUPPORT HER IF SHE WAS TO DO THAT.
33:06 WOULD THAT BE THE CASE? >> LET ME BE VERY CLEAR.
33:10 THE CHAIRMAN OF MY PARTY IS RUNNING.
33:11 HE IS VERY STRONG. HE HAS BEEN MY MINISTER FOR
33:14 INTERIOR. HE IS VERY CREDIBLE.
33:18 VERY CLEAR. VERY SINCERE AND I'M WORKING FOR
33:21 HIM AND CAMPAIGNING FOR HIM. GUY: OK.
33:23 ALWAYS A PLEASURE. THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR FOR YOUR
33:26 TIME. THE FORMER FRENCH PRIME MINISTER
33:32 AND E.U. CHIEF BREXIT NEGOTIATOR.
33:41 COMING UP, THE. >> FEAR OF BANKRUPTCY.
33:44 INSOLVENCY AND ALSO WHAT'S HAPPENED IS THE LOSS GIVEN
33:48 DEFAULT. >> FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE, THERE
33:52 IS NO QUESTION UNDERWRITING DETERIORATED.
33:54 WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO PAY FOR THAT IN THE COMING YEARS.
33:58 >> NOBODY WANTS TO LINK THIS POINT OF THE IN TIME.
34:01 THEY WANT TO CONTINUE ON AS IF NOTHING IS HAPPENING.
34:05 WE KNOW THOSE NAMES ARE GOING TO HAVE TO BE DEALT WITH.
34:08 >> WITH THE HIGHER RATES ENVIRONMENT I THINK IT IS SAFE
34:11 TO SAY THE LARGEST CAPEX CYCLE IN HISTORY, ONE HAS TO VEER
34:18 TOWARD THE SIDE OF CAUTION. GUY: DON'T BLINK.
34:21 SOP OF THE LEADERS AT BLOOMBERG'S CREDIT FORUM IN
34:24 LONDON. UP NEXT, WE'RE GOING TO TURN
34:30 OUR ATTENTION BACK TO THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
34:33 20 MINUTES THE, MARKETS OPEN. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
34:51 ANNA: WELCOME BACK. THIS IS THE OPENING TRADE.
34:52 THURSDAY MORNING. THIS IS THE PICTURE.
34:55 WE HAVE A FUTURES SESSION AHEAD OF US THAT LOOKS AS IF IT WILL
35:00 START IN POSITIVE TURTLE. WE DID DRIFT A LITTLE HIGHER
35:04 YESTERDAY AFTER EUROPEAN STOCKS CLOSED.
35:06 THAT IS PART OF STORY. GUY: LET'S TALK ABOUT THE STORY
35:09 TODAY. THAT IS WHAT'S HAPPENING IN TECH
35:12 LAND OVER IN THE UNITED STATES. NASDAQ FUTURES HIGHER.
35:13 OK. WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH
35:18 THAT. ANTHROPIC IS GOING TO RAISE 07
35:23 BILLION. THAT BEATS SPACEX.
35:27 BIGGEST OF ALL TIME, MAZINGS. SHARES WILL DEBUT ON THE NASDAQ
35:33 LATER TODAY AT $83 APIECE. WHAT IS IF THE THE SIGNAL?
35:41 WHY IS TODAY SO IMPORTANT IN SOME WAYS?
35:43 WE'RE BRINGING THIS COMPANY THAT WE HAVE ANTICIPATED SUCH A LONG
35:46 TIME TO MARKET. WHAT CHANGES NOW AS THE RESULTS
35:49 OF THIS PROCESS? >> WE WERE TALKING ABOUT IT,
35:52 CLEARLY A LOT CHANGES FOR ANTHROPIC.
35:55 NOW A PUBLIC COMPANY. NOW THEY HAVE TO BOUNCE THOSE
35:59 IDEAS OF BEING A PUBLIC BENEFIT CORPORATION, NOT JUST A PURE
36:04 PROFIT MAXIMIZER AGAINST THE HARSH REALITIES OF WHAT THE
36:06 MARKET EXPECTERS THEM. YET THIS VALUE SITUATION
36:10 ARGUABLY A MATURE COMPANY VALUATION AND IT HAS A LOT OF
36:13 MATURING TO DO. A LOT OF MATURING TO DO TO GROW
36:17 INTO THAT VALUATION. YEAH, THIS IS A VERY NEW AND
36:21 DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENT FOR ANTHROPIC IN PARTICULAR.
36:29 ANOTHER STOCK TO LOOK TO, THE OPENAI IPO THAT COULD COME NEXT
36:32 YEAR. AI TRADE HAS CHANGED A BIT.
36:35 THERE IS A HUGE AMOUNT OF FOCUS ON THE BUILDERS OF THE
36:37 INFRASTRUCTURE AND NOW THE FOCUS VERY MUCH ON THE SOFTWARE AND
36:44 APPLICATION LAYER OF THAT. SOP DIFFERENT DYNAMIC.
36:48 THE BENEFIT THAT ANTHROPIC HAS IS A PURE PLAY AND HAS A CLEAN
36:54 STRATEGY, CLEAN BUSINESS MODEL EXECUTED INCREDIBLY WELL SO FAR.
36:57 I THINK THAT IS WHAT IS BEHIND THAT HUGE AMOUNT OF ENTHUSIASM
36:59 FOR THE LISTING. ANNA: HOW ARE WE NOW THINKING
37:03 ABOUT THE COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE FOR ANTHROPIC?
37:06 WE ARE GOING TO TALK ABOUT OPENAI A LOT AND ALSO CHINESE
37:11 NAMES AND OPEN SOURCE MODELS. SOMEHOW ALL OF THAT SHAKING OUT?
37:15 A LOT WENT FOR TOKEN SPENDING. A HUGE AMOUNT.
37:20 MANAGING THESE THINGS A LOT MORE CAREFULLY.
37:22 >> ALSO THE LIKES OF META TO THROW INTO THAT TOO, INVESTING
37:27 HEAVILY IN THEIR OWN MODELS. PERSONALLY I THINK THE CHINESE
37:31 COMPETITIVE THREAT IS A LITTLE BIT OF A DISTRACTION BECAUSE THE
37:36 U.S. IS BY FAR AND AWAY THE BIGGEST MARKET FOR AI AND A LOT
37:42 OF EUROPEAN ALLY NATIONS ALSO TOO, THE WIDE SCALE DEEMPLOYMENT
37:46 IN THOSE MARKETS BY CHINESE MODELS IS PRETTY LOW.
37:50 SO THEY HAVE A CLEAR KIND OF MARKET OPPORTUNITY AND THE REAL
37:53 THREATS FROM THE LIKES OF OPENAI AND META.
37:56 THE PRESSURE IS ON. IF INVESTMENT IN COMPUTE HAS TO
38:01 SLOW DOWN BECAUSE OVER THE ECONOMICS OF AI, THEN THEY ARE
38:04 GOING TO HAVE TO EVOLVE THEIR MODELS TO BE MORE COMPUTE AND
38:06 POWER EFFICIENT. THAT IS GOING TO BE A NEW DOMAIN
38:09 OF COMPETITION. ANNA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
38:13 BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE. LET'S TURN TO TODAY'S MARKETS.
38:16 IN THREE MINCE ON THE OPENING TRADE.
38:18 DAVID, GREAT TO HAVE YOU ON THE PROGRAM.
38:19 LET'S START WITH THE DOLLAR. WE HAVE SEEN DOLLAR STRENGTH OF
38:21 LATE. AT THE BEGINNING OF THE WEEK, WE
38:24 WERE TOLD BY ONE GUEST IT IS INTEREST RATES, EXPECTATIONS
38:28 AROUND THE FED. THAT'S WHAT IS DRIVING IT.
38:30 OTHERS THINK IT HAS TO DO WITH THE AI TRADE.
38:34 WHAT IS YOUR PERSPECTIVE? >> GREAT TO BE HERE.
38:37 I THINK IT IS BOTH. I THINK TODAY ACTUALLY PROVIDED
38:40 A REALLY INTERESTING MICROCOSM OF WHAT WE'RE GOING TO BE SEEING
38:44 IN THE DOLLAR. THE AUSSIE DOLLAR WAS THE BIG
38:46 MOVER TODAY. IT WEAKENED SHARPLY ON MUCH
38:51 WEAKER THAN EXPECTED EMPLOYMENT DATA.
38:54 RBA HAS BEEN AMONGST THE MOST HAWKISH CENTRAL BANKS GLOBALLY
38:57 OVER THE LAST YEAR. I THINK THE QUESTION NOW IS AS
39:03 MARKETS ARE REALLY PIVOTING AND PREVIOUSLY PRICING IN ADDITIONAL
39:09 HIKES, THE MARKET IS NOW PRICING IN A CUT FROM THE RBA.
39:15 THE QUESTION FOR MARKETS IS, IS IT POINTING WHERE RATES ARE
39:18 GOING TO BE MOVING GLOBALLY? WHAT'S THAT'S WHERE THE
39:21 BREAKDOWN IN COMMODITY PRICES IS ANOTHER FEATURE.
39:26 THE HAVEN BID IS ANOTHER FEATURE.
39:28 ALL IN THE DOLLAR'S FAVOR. GUY: DAVID, WHY ARE FUNDS
39:32 SELLING COMMODITIES AT THE MOMENT?
39:34 DO THEY NEED THE LIQUIDITY? WHAT DOES THAT TRADE TELL ME
39:39 ABOUT WHAT PERFORMANCE LOOKS LIKE?
39:43 >> I THINK IT IS A REALLY INTERESTING PART OF WHAT WE'RE
39:46 SEEING IN WHICH IF YOU LOOK AT U.S. ECONOMIC DATA, IT STILL
39:52 REALLY ARE REALLY STRONG. ISM DATA, MANUFACTURING DATA,
39:54 THE EARNINGS STORY ON THE CORPORATE SIDE, IT IS STILL
39:57 REALLY, REALLY STRONG. WE IS THAT YOU WITH NVIDIA MOST
40:01 RECENTLY. WHAT THE MARKET IS POINTING TO A
40:05 VERY DIFFERENT COMPONENT. PART IS THE MORE DEFENSIVE
40:09 ROTATION WE HAVE SEEN IN EQUITIES AND MOST RECENTLY IT IS
40:13 THIS BREAKDOWN IN COMMODITY PRICES.
40:15 OIL PLAYS A PART IN THAT OF COURSE.
40:17 SO OF COURSE THE GEO-POLITICAL PICTURE IS PLAYING A PART BUT I
40:21 THINK THE BREAKDOWN IN COPPER IN PARTICULAR IS TIED OF COURSE TO
40:25 THIS AI STORY AND THE BREAKDOWN WE HAVE SEEN IN THE CAPEX TRADE
40:32 ALSO HAS A RELATION TO THE MUCH SOFTER THAN EXPECTED ECONOMIC
40:36 DATA ON DOMESTIC DEAND IN CHINA. SO ALL OF THIS IS POINTING TO A
40:40 MORE TROUBLING PICTURE ON THE GROWTH SIDE.
40:45 ANNA: CAN ANTHROPIC DRAW A LINE TURNED AI TRADE?
40:47 CAN IT HELP CHANGE THE NARRATIVE FROM WHAT HAS BEEN A COUPLE OF
40:52 WEEKS OF NERVOUS TRADING. NASDAQ FUTURES ARE POINTING
40:56 HIGHER AT THIS HOUR. >> YEAH.
40:57 I THINK THAT IS RIGHT. IN THE NEAR TERM, I THINK ITS
41:02 CAN. I THINK IT WAS FACT THAT THE
41:05 PRICE CAME IN HIGHER, THERE SEEMS TO BE A GOOD WIDE SED OF
41:12 RAIN COMPETITOR INVESTORS. WE'RE SEEING NASDAQ FUTURES
41:15 TRADE MUCH BETTER. I THINK THE MARKETS HAVE -- IF
41:20 THEY CAN CLEAR THIS LIQUIDITY EVENT GIVEN THE AMOUNT OF
41:23 SELLING WE HAVE SEEN OF LATE, WE COULD SEE I THINK A DECENT
41:25 REBOUND HERE. BUT I THINK PART OF THE PROBLEM
41:29 IS IT HAS BEEN VERY RELIANT, IS GOING TO BE VERY REALIGNS ON
41:33 RETAIL AND IT HAS BEEN HIT HARD BY NVIDIA AND THE SELLING WE
41:36 HAVE SEEN IN TECH. GUY: VERY NICE DAVID.
41:40 THANKS VERY MUCH INDEED. UNIT TO CATCH DAVID'S THOUGHTS
41:45 AND THE MARKET'S TEAM THOUGHTS ON YOUR BLOOMBERG TERMINAL.
41:49 LET'S TURN TO WHAT WE ARE WATCHING.
41:51 SINGLE STOCKS PLAYING A BIG STORY IN TODAY'S NARRATIVE.
41:54 SOITEC. WHY ARE WE START THERE GO?
41:57 >> WE ARE STARTING THERE BECAUSE THEY ARE UP MORE THAN 10%
42:00 ONTRADE DAY NOW. OF COURSE THE ANTHROPIC CLEARING
42:03 EVENT IS HELPING TECH ACROSS THE BOARD TODAY.
42:06 NO DOUBT IN EUROPE, THE MOOD IS BEING LIFTED BY THE RESULTS THAT
42:19 WE SYTEC. MARGINS ARE BIGGER THAN THE
42:24 MARKET WHAT IS EXPECTING. IN THEIR SOIDIVISION, THEY ARE
42:29 EXPECTING REVENUE IN 2027 AT MORE THAN TRIPLE THE RATE OF
42:31 2026. SOLID RESULTS.
42:35 THEY ARE DOWN MORE THAN 50% FROM THEIR MAY HIGH BUT STILL ONE OF
42:38 THE BEST PERFORMING STOCKS WITHIN THE STOXX 600 THANKS TO
42:41 THE NEW. MOMENTUM BEHIND AI TRADES THAT
42:43 WE HAVE SEEN FOR MOST OF THE YEAR.
42:48 MOVING OVER TO THE PHARMA SPACE. WE HAVE NOVARTIS.
42:53 THEY GAVE AN UPDATE AHEAD OF AN INVESTOR EVENT LATER TODAY.
42:56 THEY HAVE LOWERED GUIDANCE EXPECTING GROWTH OF 5% FROM THE
43:00 PREVIOUS RANGE OF 5% TO 6%. THEY ARE STILL EXPECTING BLOCK
43:03 BUSTER RESULTSES FROM THREE OF THEIR PRIMARY KEY DRUGS.
43:06 IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE HOW THE MARKET REACTS TO THIS
43:10 MIXED REPORT. FINALLY IN THE DEFENSE SPACE,
43:14 BAESYSTEMS IS LOOKING TO CUT MORE THAN 1,000 JOBS ACROSS ITS
43:25 AIR DIVISION AND WORK -- WORK SPACES.
43:27 IT SELLS DEFENSE PRODUCTS. THAT COMES AS THE COMPANY IS
43:31 LOOKING TO COST SAVE AND CUT DOWN ON SOME OF THE EXTRA
43:35 EXPENSES SO THAT IT CAN WORK ON ITS TECHNOLOGY AND ITS
43:36 WORKFORCE. THE CEO ALSO -- THE COMPANY
43:41 RATHER TOOK A BIT OF AN AIM AT HOW LONG THE U.K. IS TAKING TO
43:44 DELIVER A DEFENSE BUDGET TO THEM AS THEY TRY TO JUG IT WILL
43:47 CHANGING GEO-POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT.
43:49 ANNA: THANKS OLIVIA. WITH SOME OF THE STOCKS WE'RE
43:53 WATCHING IN THE CONTEXT TO HAVE FUTURES PICTURE IN EUROPE.
43:56 IT LOOKS A LITTLE POSITIVE. IN THE U.S. QUITE A BIT MORE
43:59 POSITIVE. GUY: THE TECH TRADE IS GOING TO
44:02 BE ON THIS MORNING. WE ARE WATCHING WHAT IS GOING ON
44:05 IN CHINA RIGHT NOW IN SHENZHEN. WE HAVE THIS UPCOMING TRILATERAL
44:12 MEET WE GO UNDERSTAND PRESIDENTS TROMPED XI ARE HAVING A LATE
44:13 LUNCH. WE UNDERSTAND THE RUSSIANS AT
44:17 SOME POINT WILL JOIN THEM AND WE WILL KICK OFF THIS
44:20 TRILATERALLING. I DON'T KNOW WHERE WE ARE IN THE
44:23 SCHEDULE, WHETHER WE ARE BEHIND OR AHEAD OF SCHEDULE.
44:26 PROBABLY BEHIND. THESE THINGS ALWAYS RUN A LITTLE
44:28 BIT LATE. WE WILL BRING YOU PICTURES WHEN
44:31 THEY HAPPEN. ANNA: WAITING FOR THE TRILATERAL
44:33 TO TAKE PLACE. WE HAD A COUPLE OF BYE LATERAL
44:38 MEETINGS. WARM WORDS BETWEEN PRESIDENTS
44:43 TROMPED XI. THEY HAD REASONS TO FALL OUT,
44:50 EVERYTHING AROUND NVIDIA. LOTS OF POSITIVE LANGUAGE THERE.
44:54 TROMPED PUTIN, THE RUSSIANS GIVING A POSITIVE SPIN ON THE
44:57 CONVERSATION THERE SUGGESTING IT WAS ALL ABOUT UKRAINE.
45:01 WE SEE JARED KUSHNER SUGGEST HE IS ON THE WAY TO BRIEF EUROPEANS
45:06 ON THINGS. PERHAPS THERE IS SOME NEWS
45:11 AROUND UKRAINE WE'RE WATCHING FOR.
45:14 GUY: SAYING THIS THERE SHOULD BE A EUROPEAN AT THIS MEETING.
45:19 WE NEED TO GET MAYBE TOES TURNED TABLE IN TERMS OF REPRESENTING
45:21 THE POSITION FROM EUROPE. IN TERMS OF FUTURES, WE ARE
45:24 POSITIVE. WE ARE LOOKING AT A POSITIVE
45:27 START. METALS LOOK LIKE THEY HAVE
45:29 STABILIZED A LITTLE BIT TODAY. KEEP AN EYE ON THE OIL STOCKS
45:34 HERE WE GO. THE THURSDAY OPENING SESSION IS
45:37 ALMOST UPON US. WE WILL BRING YOU THAT NEXT.
45:44 LIVE.
46:05 GUY: GOOD MORNING. HERE WE GO.
46:08 A COUPLE OF MINUTES TO GO UNTIL WE START TRADING HERE IN EUROPE.
46:13 WHAT DO WE NEED TO KNOW? YESTERDAY, THE SESSION WAS
46:16 NEGATIVE. FINISHED SORT OF DOWN.
46:19 NOT A BIG MOVE BUT A DOWNSIDE MOVE.
46:22 NOT SURE THERE IS MUCH READ TO CROSS INTO WHAT WE'RE GOING TO
46:24 SEE IN EUROPE THIS MORNING. WHAT THERE IS A READ ACROSS FROM
46:30 IS WE ARE SEEING POSITIVE PRODUCT PICTURE IN U.S. FUTURES.
46:36 NASDAQ FUTURES UP NICELY. LONDON CONTINUES TO BE A LITTLE
46:39 BIT OF A DRAG. YOU HAVE SINGLE STOCKS.
46:45 FUTURES UP .4%. LOOKS LIKE EUROPE IS GOING TO
46:47 HAVE A POSITIVE STORY. HOW DOES THE IPO GO?
46:50 WHAT IS IT GOING TO DO IN TERMS OF THE REST OF THE SESSION?
47:06 ANNA: PUBLICLY TRADE. IT WILL TRADE IN THE UNITED
47:10 STATES ON THE NASDAQ. WATCH EVERYTHING TECH.
47:14 ANOTHER TRON WATCH THE TECH LANDSCAPE THIS MORNING.
47:17 COMMERZBANK IS IN FOCUS THEN. WE MENTIONED EARLIER ON THAT
47:21 UNICREDIT AND THE GERMAN GOVERNMENT REACHED AN AGREEMENT
47:24 ON THE COMMERZBANK DEAL. IT CENTERS AROUND A COMMITMENT
47:28 TO CLIENTS. A COMMITMENT TO THE
47:31 INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND SOME OTHER CONDITION ATS THAT THE
47:34 GERMAN GOVERNMENT WANTED TO PUT ON THIS.
47:37 COMMERZBANK WILL CONTINUE TO BE HEADQUARTERED IN GERMANY AND
47:40 LIST ON THE STOCK EXCHANGE THERE.
47:43 WE'LL WATCH THAT. NOVARTIS IN FOCUS.
47:46 THEY TRIMMED MEDIUM TERM SALES GROWTH OUTLOOK.
47:51 SURPRISE FROM SOME ANALYSTS ABOUT THAT.
47:53 GUY: LET'S FIGURE OUT WHAT'S HAPPENING.
47:55 WHICH SINGLE STOCKS ARE WE GOING TO BE WATCHING?
47:59 WE ARE EXPECTED FTSE 100 TO LAG A LITTLE BIT.
48:04 WE STILL HAVE METALS PRICES STABILIZING, BUT A
48:08 FACTOR AS WELL. FTSE 100 FLAT.
48:13 STOXX 600 UP BY 0.2%. WE ARE EXPECTING MAY BE A LITTLE
48:17 BIT MORE TO COME OUT OF THAT BUT WE ARE GOING TO BE WATCHING
48:21 OBVIOUSLY THE TECH TRADE AND HOW DOES THAT GIVE FOR THEM INTO THE
48:25 EUROPEAN NARRATIVE DOES SHE GET FOLDED INTO THE -- HOW DOES THAT
48:33 GET FOLDED INTO THE AI NARRATIVE -- EUROPEAN NARRATIVE?
48:38 I BACKS UP BY. 0.6% FTSE IS FLAT.
48:42 WE ARE WATCHING THAT TRAIT QUITE CAREFULLY IN TERMS OF METALS AND
48:43 THE OIL STORY. WE ARE VERY MUCH WATCHING WHAT
48:47 IS GOING ON ELSEWHERE OUT IN CHINA AS WELL TO MAYBE GIVE US A
48:50 SIGNAL AS TO WHAT THAT PICTURE LOOKS LIKE AS WELL.
48:55 THERE IS A LOT TO FOLD IN IN THE NEXT FEW MINUTES.
48:57 ANNA: AND THE MORE IMMEDIATE MOMENT, WE ARE FOCUSED ON STOCKS
49:02 IN EUROPE OPENING UP, IN TECHNOLOGY IS THE BEST
49:04 PERFORMING SECTOR FOR THE TWO REASONS THAT WE MENTIONED.
49:06 WE HAVE THE ANTHROPIC IPO. NASDAQ FUTURES POINTING HERE.
49:11 ASML UP BY 3%. THAT GIVES YOU A SENSE OF WHERE
49:15 WE ARE ON SOME OF THESE REALLY HEAVILY WEIGHTED TECH NAMES.
49:19 IN THIS SMALLER CAP SPACE, SOITEC IS UP BUT 10% ON THE BACK
49:25 OF THIS NUMBERS -- IS UP BY 10% ON THE BACK OF ITS NUMBERS.
49:29 BASIC RESOURCES UNDER REAL PRESSURE ASTRAY ON THE BACK OF
49:31 SOME OF THE METALS MOVING A LOT LOWER.
49:33 TODAY WE SEE A REBOUND. I CAN SEE ALMOST EVERY STOCK IN
49:38 THE BASIC RESOURCE SECTOR, APART FROM ONE IT SEEMS, IS IN
49:40 POSITIVE TERRITORY. WE HAVE A BIT OF A WHOLESALE
49:45 RE-THINK ON THE WEAKNESS OF BASIC RESOURCES IN YESTERDAY'S
49:47 SESSION. IN TERMS OF THE OVERALL SESSION,
49:50 UP BY 0.2%, MODEST GAINS. GUY: THE METALS ARE UP BUT THE
49:53 OILS ARE NOT. SHELL IS DOWN.
50:01 IT SEEMS TO BE THE MORE DEFENSIVE AND THAT SEEMS TO BE
50:04 UNDERPERFORMING TODAY -- DEFENSIVE END THAT SEEMS TO BE
50:08 UNDERPERFORMING TODAY. NOVARTIS IS DOWN.
50:11 ASML IS UP. ABB IS UP.
50:16 TWO CLASSIC EUROPEAN TECH TRADES I GUESS YOU COULD CALL THEM
50:19 DOING BETTER IN THIS MARKET, BOTH UP BY 2% OR 3%.
50:23 ANNA: LET'S THINK ABOUT THESE MARKETS AND A LITTLE MORE
50:25 DETAIL, TAKE A STEP BACK FROM THE DAILY NEWS FLOW AND SPEAK TO
50:28 THE CHIEF INVESTMENT OFFICER OVER AT AMUNDI AND HE JOINS US
50:33 NOW. GOOD TO SEE YOU.
50:36 A GOOD TIME TO TAKE A STEP BACK BECAUSE YOU JUST PUT OUT YOUR
50:38 2027 OUTLOOK. UNEVEN RESILIENCE IS ONE OF THE
50:43 THINGS THAT STANDS OUT TO ME, AND A YEAR THAT IS MEANT TO BE
50:47 SHAPED BY FIVE INCREASINGLY INTERCONNECTED FORCES.
50:50 I THINK IT WILL PROBABLY TAKE MORE THAN 10 MINUTES TO GO
50:52 THROUGH THE FIVE BUT GIVE US A HIGHLIGHT.
50:55 WHAT IS THE BIG PICTURE EXPECTATION FOR 2027?
50:58 >> GOOD MORNING AND THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
51:02 INDEED OUR OUTLOOK FOR NEXT YEAR .
51:05 WE SEE MANY FORCES AT PLAY, COMPETITION, INVESTMENTS
51:11 OUTSIDE, FIGHT FOR CAPITAL, PRICING POWER.
51:16 FOR NEXT YEAR, WHAT WE BELIEVE IS THAT THERE WILL BE STILL BIG
51:21 ROTATION IN THE MARKET, PRICE DISCOVERY VOLATILITY, AND THAT
51:25 IS WHY WE ARE NOT RISK OFF, PER SE.
51:29 BUT WE WILL IMPLEMENT RISKS IN A VERY DIFFERENT WAY.
51:35 MOVING AWAY FROM CAPITAL BENCHMARKS, BEING MORE
51:40 DIVERSIFIED BE MORE CONSTRUCTIVE ON RATES AS WELL.
51:44 THE OIL MARKET PRICE ALREADY AND THERE IS VALUE TO BE
51:49 CAPTURED HERE. I THINK MORE COMMODITIES AS WELL
51:50 BEYOND ENERGY. GOLD AS WELL, WHICH IS
51:53 INTERESTING. DIVERSIFIED FURTHER TO EMERGING,
51:58 VALUE, BORING STUFF, IN A WAY. TECH IS A BIT TOO HOT AND OUR
52:03 MIND IN TERMS OF CAPITAL ALLOCATION.
52:05 ANNA: THAT'S INTERESTING. IF I START THERE, HOW DO YOU GOT
52:10 UNDERWAY TECH AT THIS POINT, VINCENT -- UNDERWEIGHT TECH AT
52:14 THIS POINT, VINCENT? WE ARE EXPECTING THE IPO OF
52:19 ANTHROPIC. HOW ACTIVELY DO YOU WANT TO
52:24 AVOID U.S. TECH AT THIS POINT? >> YES INDEED.
52:32 THE ANTHROPIC IPO WILL BE A SUCCESS, THAT'S ALMOST FOR SURE.
52:37 A FEW MOMENTS AGO, WE WERE TALKING ABOUT A $2 TRILLION
52:40 VALUATION, SO THE PRICING IS ABOVE THE RANGE, BUT STILL SHY
52:45 OF THIS $2 TRILLION MARK. I MEAN, SHORT-TERM, IT IS GOOD
52:50 NEWS, THAT'S FOR SURE. NOW THE QUESTION MARKS ARE STILL
52:54 ALIVE REGARDING THE MONETIZATION OF IT.
52:59 THE CAPACITY OF SUCH PLAYERS LIKE ANTHROPIC, BUT OTHERS, TO
53:03 MONETIZE THEIR HUGE INVESTMENTS. TO INVOICE HIGHER NUMBER OF
53:09 TOKENS. AND TO KEEP AN EDGE COMPARED TO
53:13 OPEN SOURCE MODELS, CHINESE, EUROPEANS, U.S. AS WELL.
53:18 IN TERMS OF TIME HORIZON, SHORT-TERM, IT CAN BE A BIG
53:21 MARKET DRIVER. MEDIUM LONG-TERM, QUESTION MARKS
53:28 ARE STILL AROUND, SO THAT'S WHY WE BELIEVE IT IS A BIT
53:29 EXCESSIVE. EVEN THOUGH THIS COMPANY IN
53:34 PARTICULAR IS, OF COURSE, OF VERY GOOD QUALITY, THERE IS NO
53:36 QUESTION ABOUT IT. GUY: THE MORNING.
53:42 WHY IS THE DOLLAR RISING AND WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF IT?
53:46 >> YOU ARE RIGHT TO QUESTION THAT BECAUSE WE WERE BEARISH
53:51 DOLLAR, SO WE WERE ON, TO BE CLEAR.
53:54 WE CONTINUE TO BELIEVE THE DOLLAR WILL DEPRECIATE
53:55 GRADUALLY. THE REASON WHY DOLLAR HAS BEEN
54:01 STRONGER, FOR ME IT IS TWO-FOLD. FIRST, THE U.S. ECONOMY HAS BEEN
54:07 MORE RESILIENT AND GROWING FASTER.
54:11 AND AS A RESULT, FED EXPECTATIONS IN TERMS OF RATES
54:12 HAS BEEN INCREASED. IN TERMS OF DIFFERENTIAL RATE,
54:16 U.S. DOLLAR HAS BEEN BETTER PAID IN TERMS OF SHORT-TERM RATES.
54:29 AND SECOND, WE TALKED ABOUT MEMORY SHOULD DOLLAR.
54:33 THIS SEARCH FOR MEMORY MET -- A MEMORY CHIP DOLLAR.
54:39 IT HAS RESULTED IN INCREASED DEMAND FOR DOLLAR BECAUSE AROUND
54:43 THE, MEMORY CHIPS INVOICED INTO YOUR STELLAR, SO MEMORY
54:48 CHIPS--INTO U.S. DOLLAR, SO MEMORY CHIPS HAVE BEEN THE NEW
54:52 WILL, SO IT IS A BIT OF TECHNICAL SUPPORT.
54:54 GUY: YOU TALKED ABOUT METALS A MOMENT AGO.
54:57 WHY HAVE WE SEEN THIS BIG SELLOFF IN COPPER, ETC., OVER
55:00 THE LAST FEW DAYS? >> COPPER HAS BEEN VERY VOLATILE
55:09 AND HAS BEEN ON A TREND UP FOR QUITE SOME QUARTERS.
55:11 WE BELIEVE IT WILL CONTINUE. VOLATILITY IS A QUITE STAND OUT
55:22 IN METALS, INTEREST ON SPECULATION SOMETIMES, BUT THE
55:24 FUNDAMENTALS ARE STILL HERE. GIVEN THE NEED FOR COPPER IN THE
55:34 NEXT YEAR'S AND THE PRICE TO EXTRACT NEW COPPER TODAY, THERE
55:40 IS NO OTHER OPTION THE COPPER PRICE SHOULD GO UP IN ORDER TO
55:43 JUSTIFY NEW INVESTMENTS, TO HAVE NEW SUPPLY FOR THE
55:44 ELECTRIFICATION NEEDS IN PARTICULAR.
55:48 THESE KIND OF BLIPS, AND YOU ARE RIGHT TO MENTION IT IS A BIG
55:52 BLIP, SHOULD BE VIEWED AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO ENTER AND TO BUY
55:57 SOME MINERS WHO ARE ACTIVE IN THE COPPER SPACE.
56:00 ANNA: CAN I ASK YOU YOUR STRATEGY AROUND FRENCH DEBT
56:02 RIGHT NOW? WE HAVE SEEN THE SPREAD COME OF
56:06 EARLIER HIGHS. WE WERE AT 150 ON THE FRENCH
56:10 O.A.T.'S OVER GERMAN BUNDS. WHAT IS YOUR STRATEGY AROUND
56:12 FRENCH DEBT? WHAT ARE YOU ADVISING CLIENTS?
56:18 >> FOR US, THE BULK OF THE MOVE ALREADY HAPPENED, SO 150 SPREAD
56:22 IT TO THE GERMAN BUND IS FAIR. THERE IS NO PANIC.
56:27 GIVEN THE UNCERTAINTIES, THE METRICS, THE RATING, 150 IS
56:32 TOTALLY NORMAL, I WOULD SAY. WE DON'T SEE PANIC SELLING OR
56:39 WHATEVER, SO IT IS A QUESTION OF PRICING, OF.
56:44 SIGNAL AND DYNAMIC TODAY, WE ARE NEUTRON FRANCE.
56:49 -- WE ARE NEUTRAL ON FRANCE. WE CONSIDER AT SUCH A LEVEL, IT
56:54 IS A GOOD CARRY. THE RISK WAS ADEQUATE.
57:01 OF COURSE, WILL BE HEAVY OVER THE NEXT FIVE MONTHS LEADING TO
57:03 THE FRENCH PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION.
57:05 THERE MIGHT BE SOME VOLATILITY LATER, START OF NEXT YEAR IN
57:08 PARTICULAR. AND WE BELIEVE THAT ANY BIG
57:16 WIDENING OF SPREADS SHOULD BE SEEN AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO ENTER.
57:18 IT COULD BE AN OPPORTUNITY TO SELL.
57:23 AT CURRENT LEVEL, WE ARE NEUTRAL, SO WE ARE GOING TO KEEP
57:30 OUR FRESH EXPOSURE, BUT WE ARE NOT YET BUYING -- FRENCH
57:33 LEVEL. GUY: IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU ARE
57:37 RETURNING OUT OF EQUITIES. IS THAT MY CORRECT
57:39 INTERPRETATION? HAS THE GREAT KIND OF ROTATION
57:46 AWAY FROM EQUITIES STARTED? >> YES, THAT'S A VERY GOOD
57:48 QUESTION. BECAUSE IN FACT, WE ARE NOT
57:53 ROTATING OUT OF EQUITY, WE ARE LOWERING OUR EBITDA, MEANING WE
57:58 ARE LOWERING OUR EXPOSURE TO HIGH MOMENTUM, HIGH BETA NAMES,
58:02 AND SELECTING EQUITIES WHICH ARE MORE DEFENSIVE.
58:06 AND AS A RESULT, WE COULD BE SEEN AS A KIND OF BOND PROXY.
58:15 IN A WAY, TO DIVIDE THE MARKET BETWEEN EQUITIES AND BONDS IS A
58:16 BIT DATED. YOU HAVE GOT BONDS THAT ARE VERY
58:19 HIGH BETA, LIKE EQUITY. YOU HAVE EQUITIES WHICH ARE MORE
58:25 DEFENSIVE WHICH ARE PROXIES FOR BONDS.
58:28 YES, WE HAVE REDUCED OUR EQUITY BETA.
58:30 IT DOES NOT MEAN WE HAVE REDUCED THE AMOUNT OF EQUITIES, BUT THE
58:37 PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION IS ACTUALLY MOVING AND IS DIFFERENT
58:38 AND LOWER RISK. GUY: TAKING THE RISK DOWN.
58:41 VERY INTERESTING. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
58:51 VINCENT MORTIER, THE AMUNDI CIO.
58:54 ASML IS ON THE FRONT FOOT. TECH IS ON THE FRONT FRONT IN
58:57 THE U.S. RHEINMETALL'S INTERESTING.
59:01 I THINK IT IS CAPITAL MARKETS DAY NEXT WEEK.
59:03 I THINK THAT'S WHAT'S HAPPENING NEXT WEEK.
59:05 LVMH A LITTLE HIGHER AS WELL. DEFENSES ARE DONE.
59:10 FAR MY LITTLE WEAKER, NESTLÉ UNDER--PHARMA A LITTLE WEAKER,
59:14 NESTLÉ UNDER PRESSURE. >> FRONT AND CENTER FOR ME AND I
59:18 THINK THE WHOLE WORLD AFTER THE WEEK THAT WE HAVE MET, BUT
59:21 SOITEC IS UP MORE THAN 13% RIGHT NOW, A REALLY STRONG START FOR
59:26 THEM AFTER THAT REALLY SOLID EARNINGS RESULT, PARTICULARLY
59:32 THE MARKET SEEMS TO BE FOCUSED ON THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE
59:34 GAINED ON THEIR GUIDANCE AND THAT PHOTONICS SOI DIVISION.
59:40 REALLY SOLID RESULT FOR SOITEC. ELSEWHERE, WE HAD DECENT RESULTS
59:45 FROM YOUR DEFENSE PLAYERS, INCLUDING FROM BABCOCK, WHICH IS
59:49 UP MORE THAN 7% RIGHT NOW. , THE CEO THEY BEAT ACROSS THE
59:57 ARE SAYING THIS MORNING ARE PARTICULARLY ENCOURAGING AND
1:00:00 DEFINITELY WHAT INVESTORS WILL BE FOCUSING ON.
1:00:07 WE HAD RESULTS FROM SAIPEM WHICH IS IN THE PROCESS OF
1:00:10 MERGING WITH SUB C7. THEY DID MISS ON NET INCOME BUT
1:00:15 THAT WAS DUE TO A HIGHER TAXES THAN EXPECTED.
1:00:18 THEIR ACTUAL RESULT IN ALL THE NUMBERS WAS VERY SOLID,
1:00:20 INCLUDING THEIR EARNINGS-PER-SHARE, SO THAT'S
1:00:22 WHY THEY ARE HIGHER RIGHT NOW. IT IS NOT GREAT FOR EVERYONE,
1:00:30 NOTABLY INVESTEC IS DOWN BY MORE THAN 7.5%.
1:00:34 PROFIT WAS ACTUALLY OK BUT WHAT INVESTORS ARE FOCUSED ON IS THE
1:00:38 FACT THAT THEIR FISCAL YEAR 27 RETURN IS SLIGHTLY DISAPPOINTING
1:00:41 AND THEY ALSO HAD QUITE A LOT OF WEAKNESS IN THE U.K.
1:00:46 INVESTORS FOCUSED ON THAT, POTENTIALLY QUESTIONING WITH THE
1:00:48 OUTLOOK LOOKS LIKE FOR INVESTEC. WE HAVE RESULTS AS WELL FROM
1:00:56 HALMA, WHICH HAS BEEN AN AI WINTER.
1:00:59 AIR AND WATER COMPANY, BUT AS WE KNOW -- WINNER.
1:01:05 THEY ARE A WATER COMPANY, BUT AS WE KNOW WATER IS INTEGRAL TO
1:01:09 DATA CENTERS. MCBRIDE HAS TAKEN US ON A ROLLER
1:01:12 COASTER, AND HAS ALREADY BEEN HALTED FOR A GOOD PART OF THE
1:01:13 MORNING. IT IS DOWN 21%.
1:01:20 THEY SAID THAT THE FORECAST WILL BE 20% TO 25% BELOW MARKET
1:01:27 CONSENSUS, SO NEARLY A QUARTER BELOW CONSENSUS DUE TO INPUT
1:01:31 COSTS AND DELAYS TO, AND AS A RESULT OF THAT, THEY ARE
1:01:33 EXPECTING THEIR MARGINS IN THE FOURTH QUARTER, THAT'S GOING TO
1:01:36 BE PUSHED OUT. 20% TO 25% BELOW CONSENSUS FOR
1:01:40 MCBRIDE. ANNA: THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
1:01:42 OLIVIA. WE ARE STILL KEEPING ONE EYE ON
1:01:47 ALL THE DEVELOPMENTS OVER IN CHINA.
1:01:50 COMING UP, WE WILL TALK ABOUT METALS AS WELL.
1:01:54 COPPER REGAINED SOME GROUND AFTER POSTING ITS WORST DAY
1:01:55 SINCE APRIL LAST YEAR. WE WILL BRING YOU THE DETAILS,
1:01:57 NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:02:13 GUY: 17 MINUTES PAST THE HOUR.
1:02:16 BREAKING NEWS OUT OF CHINA. WE ARE GETTING A READOUT OF THE
1:02:20 TRUMP-XI MEETING THAT IS TAKING PLACE, THE BILATERAL.
1:02:26 XI SANK THAT THE TWO SIDES WILL EXPAND COOPERATION, NARROW THE
1:02:30 LIST OF PROBLEMS. THERE ARE PROBLEMS WHAT WE ARE
1:02:33 GOING TO NARROW THEM AND THAT SEEMS TO BE THE TAKE AWAY HERE
1:02:34 AT THE MOMENT. THERE IS NOTHING CONCRETE,
1:02:38 NOTHING SIGNIFICANTLY TANGIBLE THAT WE CAN HANG OUR HATS ON.
1:02:41 BUT AT THE MOMENT, MAYBE THAT IS JUST ENOUGH.
1:02:45 THE U.S. AND CHINA TEAMS MUST KEEP OF COMMUNICATION.
1:02:48 BOTH SIDES SAID THE MEETING WAS POSITIVE AND CONSTRUCTIVE.
1:02:52 XI URGES THE U.S. TO AVOID MAJOR DISRUPTIONS OVER TAIWAN.
1:02:54 THERE IS NOTHING DRAMATIC HERE. IT IS KIND OF BUSINESS AS
1:02:56 NORMAL. WE HAVE GOT SOME PROBLEMS, BUT
1:03:01 WE ARE GOING TO WORK THEM OUT, IT IS GOING TO BE ALL RIGHT,
1:03:04 EVERYTHING IS OK, WE ARE GOING TO TALK TO EACH OTHER,
1:03:10 BREAK DOWN MAYBE THAT IS ENOUGH AT THIS POINT.
1:03:12 ANNA: MAYBE THIS IS POST THEM IN TERMS, MAYBE THAT IS RELEVANT --
1:03:17 THE MIDTERMS, MAYBE THAT IS RELEVANT, MAYBE IT ISN'T.
1:03:21 BOTH SIDES WANT TO TALK FRIENDLY TO EACH OTHER AND FIND A
1:03:28 CORPORATION -- FIND COOPERATION. WE ARE WAITING FOR THE START OF
1:03:32 THAT TRILATERAL MEETING, WHICH HAS NOT YET TAKEN PLACE.
1:03:35 UNICREDIT AND THE GERMAN GOVERNMENT HAVE REACHED AN
1:03:37 AGREEMENT ON COMERS MAKING A MOVE THAT MAKES IT EASIER FOR
1:03:39 THE ITALIAN BANK TO REQUIRE COMERS MAKE -- ACQUIRE COMERS
1:03:46 MAKE -- REACHED AN AGREEMENT ON COMMERZBANK, MAKING A MOVE THAT
1:03:50 MAKES IT EASIER FOR THE ITALIAN BANK TO ACQUIRE COMMERZBANK.
1:03:57 AGREE TO? >> YES.
1:04:03 SO, ON THE ANNOUNCEMENTS TODAY ARE THE END OF WEEKS AND MONTHS
1:04:12 OF NEGOTIATION AND TALKS BETWEEN THE CEO OF UNICREDIT, THE BANKS,
1:04:17 THE COMMERZBANK, AND THE GERMAN GOVERNMENT.
1:04:21 OVERALL, EVEN IF THERE ARE SEVERAL COMMITMENTS THAT WILL BE
1:04:23 INCLUDED AS PART OF A DEAL, THIS IS A WIN BECAUSE IT PAVES THE
1:04:32 WAY FOR HIS ACQUISITION OF THE BANK AND FOR LIKE A MAKING THE
1:04:34 NEXT STEPS. AUTHORIZATIONS ARE ALSO COMING
1:04:43 THROUGH FROM ALL THE FED AND THAT REALLY ALLOWS THEM TO MOVE
1:04:44 INTO THE ACTUAL PHASE. GUY: WE ARE GOING TO SEE
1:04:50 COMMERZBANK REMAINING HEADQUARTERED IN FRANKFURT, WE
1:04:53 ARE GOING TO SEE REMAINING LISTED ON THE GERMAN MARKET.
1:04:55 WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THAT?
1:04:59 AND WILL THAT BE A PROBLEM FOR ORCEL?
1:05:04 >>>> NO, THAT IS SOMETHING HE HAS SAID WILL NOT BE A PROBLEM
1:05:05 FOR HIM. IT ACTUALLY MAKES SENSE BECAUSE
1:05:08 IT REALLY ALLOWS UNICREDIT TO BECOME A PAN-EUROPEAN LENDER
1:05:15 RATHER THAN LIKE MAKING IT AN ITALIAN ONE OR SHRINKING IT.
1:05:20 AND SEEMS THAT THIS IS LIKE A CONVERGENCE POINT THAT HAS BEEN
1:05:21 FOUND AND COULD BE A WIN-WIN FOR EVERYONE.
1:05:26 GUY: THANK YOU VERY MUCH INDEED. THANKS FOR THE UPDATE.
1:05:27 INTERESTING NEWS. A LOT COMING OUT OF THE BANKING
1:05:29 SECTOR. WE ARE SEEING COMMENTS.
1:05:38 CHAIRA ALBANESE ON THE COMMERZBANK STORY.
1:05:42 COPPER PRICES, WE ARE SEEING STABILIZATION TRAIT.
1:05:46 WEDNESDAY'S PLUNGE SAW THE METAL POST ITS WORST SESSION SINCE
1:05:47 APRIL ESTHER. STAN DRUCKENMILLER'S
1:05:51 ANNOUNCEMENT THAT HE HAS TURNED BEARISH ON THE METAL.
1:05:52 AS THEY FACTOR? MARTIN RITCHIE -- IS THAT A
1:05:55 FACTOR? MARTIN RITCHIE JOINS US FROM
1:05:57 SHANGHAI. WE ARE STABILIZING TODAY.
1:06:01 WHAT DID WE LEARN YESTERDAY? >> YESTERDAY WAS, AS YOU SAID, A
1:06:06 BIG DAY FOR COPPER. I THINK ONE ANALYST WE QUOTED
1:06:11 SAID THERE IS A COMPLETE RECALIBRATION OF THE COPPER
1:06:13 MARKET UNDERWAY. A MAJOR FACTOR IS AROUND AI.
1:06:18 WE HAVE SEEN A LOT OF SPECULATIVE INVESTORS PILE INTO
1:06:22 COPPER IN THE PAST YEAR ON THE PROSPECT, BOTH IN THE SHORT-TERM
1:06:28 AND LONG-TERM, OF A KIND OF DEMANDED DIVIDEND FROM AI DATA
1:06:31 CENTERS, INFRASTRUCTURE, ETC. IT'S BEEN A BIG THEME.
1:06:35 PRICES REACHED A RECORD A FEW MONTHS AGO.
1:06:41 AND SINCE THEN, THEY HAVE KIND OF STALLED A LITTLE BIT AS THAT
1:06:43 KIND OF AI TRADE BECOMES A LITTLE BIT MORE UNCERTAIN ACROSS
1:06:44 THE WIDER MARKETS. AND COPPER HAS BEEN SORT OF HIT
1:06:49 HARD WHENEVER THERE'S BEEN A SELLOFF IN TECH EQUITIES.
1:06:54 BUT REALLY SEEMED THAT ACCELERATE YESTERDAY, A LOT OF
1:06:58 THE KIND OF CONFIDENCE IN THAT TRADE FADED AWAY COMPLETELY, AND
1:07:01 FELL MORE THAN 5%. AT THE SAME TIME, THERE IS KIND
1:07:07 OF UNCERTAINTY AROUND ONE OF THE OTHER BIG MAJOR FACTORS FOR
1:07:09 COPPER, WISHES THE U.S. TARIFF TRADE.
1:07:14 THERE WERE EXPECTATIONS THAT THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION WOULD PUT
1:07:19 IMPORT TARIFFS ON THE METAL. THAT CARRIED A LOT OF COPPER TO
1:07:23 THE U.S., TIGHTENING THE REST OF THE WORLD.
1:07:26 STILL HAVE NOT HEARD ANYTHING FROM THE U.S. ON THAT FRONT ON
1:07:28 THE UNCERTAINTY AROUND THAT ALSO IS DRAGGING ON CONFIDENCE AND
1:07:33 THE BULLISHNESS THAT WAS THERE BEFORE.
1:07:35 ANNA: LET ME ASK YOU ABOUT GOLD. WE HAVE GOT GOLD PRICES BOUNCING
1:07:40 A TINY BIT THIS MORNING, BUT BROADLY SPEAKING, A 14 MONTH
1:07:44 LOW, THEREABOUTS. AFTER WE TALKED ABOUT GOLD IN
1:07:48 THE CONTEXT OF THE FED AND WE KNOW THERE'S BEEN QUITE A LOT OF
1:07:50 HAWKISH COMMENTARY COMING FROM THE FED.
1:07:53 SO WHAT IS BEHIND THE LATEST MOVES IN THE GOLD?
1:07:56 >> I THINK CERTAINLY THE FED IS VERY MUCH STILL PART OF IT.
1:08:01 YOU SAW THE MINUTES FROM THE FED'S LAST MEETING
1:08:07 UNANIMOUSLY IN FAVOR OF MORE RATE HIKES TO COME.
1:08:11 THAT IS BAD FOR GOLD, WHICH DOES NOT OFFER INTEREST ITSELF.
1:08:17 BUT I WOULD ACTUALLY SAY, LIKE POINT TO JUST MORE OF THE WIDER
1:08:20 MACRO TURMOIL THE SICK, THE SELLOFF IN EQUITIES -- THIS
1:08:24 WEEK, THE SELLOFF IN EQUITIES. YOU OFTEN FIND WHEN THERE IS
1:08:32 MAJOR SELLOUTS IN RISK ASSETS, PEOPLE ACTUALLY ALSO SELL GOLD
1:08:33 IN THEIR PORTFOLIOS TO OFFSET SOME OF THOSE LOSSES, SO WE
1:08:36 MIGHT BE SEEING ONE OF THOSE KIND OF CORRECTIONS AS WELL.
1:08:46 YOU WOULD FIND IT WOULD STILL BE FAIRLY POSITIVE OVER THE MEDIUM
1:08:49 TO LONGER TERM FOR THESE METALS. GUY: WE SPOKE TO VINCENT MORTIER
1:08:58 OF AMUNDI EARLIER ON, STILL VERY POSITIVE.
1:09:00 IS THE DOLLAR A FACTOR? THIS STUFF IS PRICED IN DOLLARS.
1:09:04 >> ABSOLUTELY. THAT'S BEEN A BIG FACTOR.
1:09:10 I FOLLOW COPPER MOST CLOSELY AND THAT'S ALSO A BIG THING.
1:09:14 THERE'S BEEN A BIG RUN-UP IN THE DOLLAR OF THE PAST FEW MONTHS
1:09:16 AND THAT DOES WEIGH ON COPPER. I SHOULD HAVE SAID AT THE
1:09:21 BEGINNING OF THIS ACTUALLY, THAT THERE IS A BIG COPPER CONFERENCE
1:09:23 IN SHANGHAI THAT I HAVE AT THIS WEEK HERE.
1:09:27 ONE OF THE MESSAGES FROM THAT IS ALSO ABOUT THE DOLLAR, YOU KNOW.
1:09:31 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE KIND OF RATE HIKING CYCLE FADES AGAIN,
1:09:36 POSSIBLY NEXT YEAR, OR PAUSES AGAIN?
1:09:42 THAT COULD, YOU KNOW, LEADING TO A WEAKER DOLLAR AND PERHAPS PROP
1:09:43 UP THE COMMODITIES AGAIN. GUY: VERY NICE.
1:09:46 THANK YOU FOR ANALYSIS. MARTIN RICH THE METALS STORY.
1:09:53 WE ARE CONSIDERING TO WATCH WHAT IS HAPPENING -- MARTIN RITCHIE
1:09:55 ON THE METALS STORY. WE ARE CONTINUING TO WATCH WHAT
1:09:57 IS HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN. WE HAVE JUST SEEN PRESIDENT
1:10:00 TRUMP WALKING THROUGH. WE SAW THAT AN APPROACH AND.
1:10:02 ARRIVED A FEW MINUTES AGO. THEY ALL SEEM TO BE HEADING --
1:10:10 WE SAW VLADIMIR PUTIN ARRIVE A FEW MINUTES AGO.
1:10:13 THEY ALL SEEM TO BE HEADING VAGUELY IN THE SAME DIRECTION.
1:10:15 ANNA: A POSITIVE TONE COMING FROM THAT BILATERAL AS WE
1:10:25 REFLECTED PERHAPS THUS FAR BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN SO MANY
1:10:27 NEWS LINES COMING OUT IS THAT XI HAS BEEN TALKING ABOUT AI, SAYS
1:10:30 THAT U.S. AND CHINA TO COOPERATE TO ADDRESS AI SAFETY RISKS, AND
1:10:35 SAYS THE U.S. AND CHINA MUST KEEP AI UNDER HUMAN CONTROL,.
1:10:44 ANYTHING THAT WILL LIMIT AI'S EXPANSION SO I WONDER IF THERE
1:10:46 IS A POINT OF TENSION THERE ON THE CHINESE TALKING ABOUT TAIWAN
1:10:47 AS WELL. GUY: I DON'T WANT TO LIMIT AI'S
1:10:51 EXPANSION BUT I'M GOING TO PUT RESTRICTIONS ON SHIPPING SALES
1:10:56 THAT POTENTIALLY COULD LIMIT -- ON CHIP SALES THAT CAN
1:10:58 POTENTIALLY LIMIT CHINA'S AI EXTENSION.
1:11:01 THAT DOES NOT SEEM TO BE COMING UP RIGHT NOW, NOR DOES THE
1:11:03 NVIDIA STORY. WARM WORDS, AS YOU SAID BEFORE,
1:11:07 PLENTY OF POTENTIAL. ANNA: XI, TRUMP, AND PUTIN HAVE
1:11:14 STARTED THEIR TRILATERAL TALKS. THIS IS THE TRILATERAL MEETING
1:11:18 THAT WE HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR AND LOOKS AS IF THAT IS NOW
1:11:19 UNDERWAY. WE WILL SEE IF WE GET ANY
1:11:24 COMMENTARY ON THE BACK OF IT.
1:11:28 GUY: NASDAQ FUTURES IS SURGING ON EXPECTATIONS OF A POP IN
1:11:29 ANTHROPIC. IT IS IPO DAY.
1:11:35 RICHARD WINDSOR IS GOING TO BE WITH US NEXT.
1:11:40 26 MINUTES PAST THE HOUR.
1:11:41 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:12:03 GUY: WANT TO TAKE YOU BACK TO CHINA AND THE TRILATERAL MEETING
1:12:07 WE HAVE BEEN HEARING FROM THE THREE LEADERS.
1:12:14 LET'S TAKE A LISTEN. >> OUR PLANET HAS BEEN PUT
1:12:33 THROUGH MORE THAN 10,000 WARS. GUY: OK.
1:12:35 WE SOUND LIKE -- WE SOUND LIKE WE LOST AUDIO THERE.
1:12:40 WE ARE POTENTIALLY, I THINK, WAITING TO HEAR.
1:12:42 SO WHAT IS HAPPENING HERE BASICALLY IS THAT THIS IS TAPE
1:12:44 LIVE PLAYBACK. IT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED A COUPLE
1:12:47 OF MINUTES AGO AND THIS IS THE OPENING OF THE MEETING BETWEEN
1:12:51 THESE THREE THAT IS TAKING PLACE AROUND THIS BIG ROUND TABLE.
1:12:55 AND WE'RE NOT GETTING ANY TAPE PLAYBACK FROM THAT.
1:12:57 IT SOUNDS LIKE THEY ARE MAKING SOME COMMENTS.
1:13:00 IT LOOKS LIKE PRESIDENT TRUMP IS SPEAKING NOW.
1:13:02 NOT SURE WE HAVE THE AUDIO OF THAT.
1:13:04 BUT BUT WE WERE ANTICIPATING THIS EVENT.
1:13:06 WE JUST NEVER SURE ABOUT WHAT WE'RE GOING TO GET AT THE
1:13:07 BEGINNING. ANNA: THE CHOREOGRAPHY OF THESE
1:13:09 THINGS IS ALWAYS A LITTLE UP IN THE AIR UNTIL YOU'RE IN THE MIX.
1:13:14 WE HEARD THERE THE TRANSLATION. PRESIDENT XI, REFERENCING WARS.
1:13:18 SO AT LEAST WE KNOW PART OF WHAT IS BEING DISCUSSED.
1:13:20 I THINK -- I ASSUME THE TEAM IS TRYING TO PUT BACK THE AUDIO.
1:13:23 REPICK UP THAT AUDIO. WE CAN SEE ON ANOTHER FEED THAT
1:13:26 WE HAVE. THERE WE GO.
1:13:28 PERHAPS IT'S COMING BACK. LET'S TUNE BACK IN.
1:13:32 >> CHINA HAS BEEN PROMOTING THE COMPREHENSIVE, STRATEGIC
1:13:37 PARTNERSHIP OF COORDINATION WITH RUSSIA.
1:13:39 AND DEVELOPING THE CONSTRUCTIVE RELATIONSHIP OF STRATEGIC
1:13:45 STABILITY WITH THE UNITED STATES.
1:13:48 WITH A VIEW OF FOSTERING THE PARADIGM OF MAJOR COUNTRY
1:13:52 RELATION, FEATURING PEACEFUL CO-EXISTENCE, OVERALL STABILITY
1:13:55 AND BALANCED DEVELOPMENT TO THE BENEFIT OF EACH OTHER AND THE
1:13:58 WHOLE WORLD. THE TRANSFORMATION NOT SEEN IN A
1:14:04 CENTURY IS ACCELERATING ACROSS -- THE WHOLE WORLD.
1:14:08 TRANSFORMATION NOT SEEN IN A CENTURY IS ACCELERATEING
1:14:17 ACROSS -- WORK TOGETHER TO MEET --
1:14:18 GUY: OK. WE SEEM TO BE HAVING A SLIGHT
1:14:22 TECHNICAL ISSUE IN TERMS OF WHAT IS GOING ON HERE.
1:14:26 BUT PRESIDENT XI CALLING THE FIRST-EVER CHINA U.S.--RUSSIA
1:14:33 LEADER MEETING HISTORIC AND WHETHER IT DELIVERS IN TERMS OF
1:14:38 THAT KIND OF HISTORICAL -- HISTORICAL LABEL REMAINS TO BE
1:14:39 SEEN. OBVIOUSLY EARLIER THIS WEEK
1:14:41 PEOPLE WERE COMPARING THIS MEETING TO YALTA.
1:14:48 YALTA HAD A HUGE IMPACT ON -- ON THE EUROPEAN LANDSCAPE.
1:14:51 LET'S SEE IF WE CAN HEAR PRESIDENT TRUMP SPEAKING.
1:14:53 >> GRATITUDE TO THE CHINESE SIDE AND THE PRESIDENT OF THE
1:14:57 PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA FOR ORGANIZING TODAY'S MEETING WHICH
1:15:01 IS TAKING PLACE FOR THE FIRST TIME IN THIS FORMAT INVOLVING
1:15:05 THE LEADERS OF THREE STATES, PERMANENT MEMBERS OF THE UNITED
1:15:09 NATIONS SECURITY COUNCIL. RUSSIA, THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF
1:15:14 CHINA, AND THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
1:15:18 OUR THREE STATES ARE THE VICTORS IN WORLD WAR II.
1:15:22 AND WE HAVE JOINT RESPONSIBILITY FOR MAINTAINING INTERNATIONAL
1:15:26 PEACE AND SECURITY. WE STOOD AT THE FOUNDATIONS OF
1:15:30 THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE UNITED NATIONS.
1:15:33 THAT IS WHY IT IS OUR TASK TO PRESERVE AND STRENGTHEN THE
1:15:38 SYSTEM OF INTERNATIONAL LAW ESTABLISHED WITH THE CREATION OF
1:15:42 THIS UNIVERSAL ORGANIZATION INCLUDING THE UN CHARTER AND THE
1:15:50 PRINCIPLES WITHIN IT. WE SHOULD -- AND CHARTER FOOD
1:15:56 SECURITY AND ENERGY SECURITY. OUR COUNTRIES HAVE NUMEROUS
1:16:01 SHARED INTERESTS IN THE SETTLEMENT OF REGIONAL CONFLICTS
1:16:05 INCLUDING OBVIOUSLY THE CONFLICT IN UKRAINE.
1:16:10 WE DISCUSSED THIS YESTERDAY WITH PRESIDENT OF CHINA AND TODAY AT
1:16:13 THE INITIATIVE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
1:16:19 WE FOCUSED ON THAT DURING OUR BILATERAL MEETING.
1:16:23 WE HAVE SHARED INTERESTS IN THE FIGHT AGAINST THE THREAT AND
1:16:27 CHALLENGES OF OUR TIMES NAMELY, INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM,
1:16:32 TRANSNATIONAL ORGANIZED CRIME, ETC.
1:16:34 I AM CONVINCED THAT RUSSIA, THE U.S., AND CHINA, OUR PEOPLE ARE
1:16:38 CAPABLE OF MAKING A SIGNIFICANT CONTRIBUTION TO STRENGTHENING
1:16:43 PEACE AND STABILITY OVER THE WORLD.
1:16:45 IF WE COOPERATE, CONSTRUCTIVELY ON THE BASIS OF MUTUAL RESPECT,
1:16:51 EQUALITY, AND A BALANCE OF INTERESTS.
1:16:59 THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, PRESIDENT PUTIN.
1:17:02 AND I GIVE THE FLOOR TO PRESIDENT TRUMP.
1:17:10 PRES. TRUMP: THANK YOU VERY MUCH, PRESIDENT XI, AND
1:17:13 WELCOMING ME BACK TO CHINA. I'VE BEEN HERE A NUMBER OF TIMES
1:17:16 OVER THE YEARS AND IT'S INCREDIBLE WHAT'S TAKEN PLACE.
1:17:21 BUT THIS IS THE SECOND TIME THIS YEAR FOLLOWING OUR BEAUTIFUL
1:17:25 STATE VISIT TO BEIJING IN MAY AND THAT WAS QUITE SOMETHING.
1:17:28 A LOT OF THINGS WERE ACCOMPLISHED, ACTUALLY.
1:17:32 IT'S AN HONOR TO BE HERE AND -- IN SHENZHEN AND I WANT TO
1:17:37 CONGRATULATE PRESIDENT XI ON HOSTING A VERY SUCCESSFUL APEC
1:17:40 SUMMIT. VERY SUCCESSFUL.
1:17:44 TREMENDOUS THOUGHT IN THAT ROOM. VERY GOOD.
1:17:48 I'M DELIGHTED THAT THIS TRIP HAS GIMP US THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THIS
1:17:52 FIRST-EVER TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN THE LEADERS OF THE
1:17:57 UNITED STATES, RUSSIA AND CHINA, AND TODAY, IN THAT SENSE, AND I
1:18:00 THINK IN LOTS OF OTHER WAYS, WE ARE REALLY MAKING HISTORY.
1:18:05 THE THREE OF US HAVE A GREAT DEAL TO DISCUSS.
1:18:08 AND WE HAVE ALREADY DISCUSSED A LOT AS PRESIDENTS OF THREE OF
1:18:13 THE WORLD'S LARGEST COUNTRIES, WE HAVE A SPECIAL RESPONSIBILITY
1:18:17 TO MAINTAIN OPEN, RESPECTFUL, AND PRODUCTIVE DIALOGUE ON
1:18:20 ISSUES IMPACTING NOT JUST OUR PEOPLE BUT THE ENTIRE PLANET.
1:18:25 TOO OFTEN PAST LEADERS AVOIDED TALKING TO NATIONS WITH WHOM
1:18:31 THEY HAD DISAGREEMENTS. AND WE FEEL THE OPPOSITE.
1:18:34 AND WE THINK THAT WE ARE SURE ABOUT THAT.
1:18:37 NO PROBLEMS WERE EVER SOLVED UNDER THE OLD SCHOOL, REFUSING
1:18:41 TO TALK ABOUT THEM. SO NO PEACE WAS EVER FORGED BY
1:18:47 DECLINING OPPORTUNITIES FOR ENGAGEMENT AND SPEECH.
1:18:48 TOGETHER, WE'RE CHOOSING A DIFFERENT COURSE, AN HISTORIC
1:18:53 SUMMIT OFFERS US THE CHANCE TO SEEK OUT NEW OPPORTUNITIES AND
1:18:57 APPROACHES ON A RANGE OF VERY IMPORTANT ISSUES.
1:19:00 MOST OF THEM EVERYBODY IN THIS ROOM KNOWS AND HOPEFULLY TO
1:19:04 CREATE A BETTER FUTURE FOR ALL OF US, VERY MUCH BETTER FUTURE
1:19:09 AND SAFER FUTURE AS THE WORLD'S THREE LARGEST NUCLEAR POWERS BY
1:19:13 FAR, THE UNITED STATES, RUSSIA, AND CHINA, UNIQUELY POSITIONED
1:19:17 TO DISCUSS HOW TO REDUCE THE NUMBER OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS ON
1:19:21 EARTH AND ALSO TO LESSEN THE RISK THAT THOSE WEAPONS WILL
1:19:25 EVER BE USED. THE POWER IS UNBELIEVABLE,
1:19:28 UNTHINKABLE. AND IN ADDITION TO EXPLORING THE
1:19:31 POTENTIAL FOR ARMS REDUCTION IN OUR OWN COUNTRIES, AND I MUST
1:19:36 SAY IT'S QUITE FRANKLY A VERY HARD THING TO DO BECAUSE ONCE
1:19:39 YOU HAVE THE NUCLEAR WEAPONS, IT'S VERY HARD TO NOT HAVE THEM.
1:19:44 IT'S VERY HARD TO GIVE THEM UP AS THE LEADER OF A COUNTRY.
1:19:48 SOMETHING THAT'S VERY DIFFICULT TO SAY BECAUSE IT'S THE WAY LIFE
1:19:53 WORKS. THOUSANDS OF WEAPONS, AND YOU'RE
1:19:56 SUPPOSED TO GIVE THEM UP, AND YET YOU HAVE COUNTRIES IN
1:19:59 ADDITION TO US, MUCH SMALLER NUMBERS, BUT THEY HAVE NUCLEAR
1:20:01 WEAPONS ALSO. SO IT'S NOT AN EASY THING TO DO.
1:20:05 GIVE THEM UP. BUT IT'S ALSO VITAL AT THAT WE
1:20:08 COOPERATE TO COMBAT THE THREAT OF NUCLEAR PROLIFERATION IN
1:20:12 OTHER COUNTRIES AROUND THE WORLD.
1:20:14 THAT'S WHAT WE'RE DOING IN IRAN. WE'RE NOT GOING TO LET IRAN HAVE
1:20:17 A NUCLEAR WEAPON. AND TO THAT END TODAY, WE'LL BE
1:20:24 TALKING ABOUT ALL OF THE PROBLEMS THAT ARE REALLY BEING
1:20:26 DISCUSSED IN THE WORLD. WE ARE GOING TO BE DISCUSSING
1:20:29 THE WAR BETWEEN RUSSIA AND UKRAINE.
1:20:31 AND WE ALREADY HAVE. PRESIDENT PUTIN AND I HAVE HAD A
1:20:34 LONG DISCUSSION TODAY FOR QUITE A WHILE.
1:20:38 THAT'S WHAT -- PRETTY MUCH WHAT THE DISCUSSION WAS ABOUT.
1:20:42 AND I THINK THINGS ARE HAPPENING.
1:20:45 I THINK THAT XI AND THE OTHER SIDE WILL LIKE TO SEE AN END TO
1:20:47 THAT WAR. AND ANOTHER AREA OF POTENTIAL
1:20:51 COOPERATION BETWEEN US, SUGGESTING WAYS TO PROTECT OUR
1:20:56 NATION'S SOVEREIGNTY FROM ROGUE AND GLOBALIST ORGANIZATIONS SUCH
1:21:00 AS THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT WHICH HAS GOTTEN OUT OF
1:21:02 CONTROL. WHICH I BELIEVE WE ALL AGREE HAS
1:21:09 REALLY STRAYED FAR BEYOND ITS JURISDICTION.
1:21:11 SO TODAY MARKS THE FIRST-EVER TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN OUR
1:21:14 COUNTRIES AND IT'S AN HONOR TO BE WITH VLADIMIR, IT'S AN HONOR
1:21:18 TO BE WITH YOU, MR. PRESIDENT, WHAT A JOB YOU'VE DONE.
1:21:20 THINK OF IT. THIS IS 40 YEARS, AND I THINK
1:21:26 MOST OF IT IN THE LAST 20 OR 25 YEARS, AND A MAJOR CITY, ONE OF
1:21:28 THE BIGGEST CITIES ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD AND IT'S FLAWLESS.
1:21:34 AND WHAT AN ACHIEVEMENT THAT IS SO -- AN HONOR TO BE WITH YOU
1:21:38 AND AN HONOR FOR ME TO BE WITH YOU.
1:21:39 AND LET'S SEE IF WE CAN GET SOMETHING DONE.
1:21:40 THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
1:21:48 VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU, PRESIDENT TRUMP.
1:21:55 ANNA: SO THE THREE WORLD LEADERS AS WE EXPECTED MEETING FOR THIS
1:21:58 TRILATERAL DISCUSSION. THE GLOBAL MEDIA I THINK
1:22:02 POSSIBLY BEING -- OUT OF THE ROOM SO THAT CONVERSATION CAN
1:22:03 GET UNDER WAY. WE HEARD PRESIDENT XI CALLING
1:22:08 THIS AN HISTORIC MEETING AS DID THE OTHER LEADERS.
1:22:10 PRESIDENT PUTIN SETTING THIS IN THE CONTEXT OF THE VICTORS OF
1:22:13 WORLD WAR II AS WE COME TO EXPECT.
1:22:14 HE LIKES TO TALK ABOUT THAT. AND HE SAID THAT UKRAINE WAS A
1:22:17 SUBSTANTIAL PART OF THE CONVERSATION.
1:22:18 WE HEARD FROM PRESIDENT TRUMP THAT UKRAINE WILL BE DISCUSSED
1:22:22 AT THIS TRILATERAL MEETING. HE ALSO WANTS TO DISCUSS NUCLEAR
1:22:25 PROLIFERATION AND THAT TAKES HIM TO IRAN.
1:22:27 A LOT OF EMPHASIS ON THE IMPORTANCE OF KEEPING LINES OF
1:22:30 COMMUNICATION WITH THESE OTHER WORLD LEADERS OPEN.
1:22:33 LET'S GET TO MINMIN LOW WHO IS AT THE SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN.
1:22:36 CAN BRING US UP TO SPEED WITH THE MOOD ON THE GROUND AND WHAT
1:22:41 SHE MADE OF THOSE OPENING REMARKS.
1:22:45 MINMIN: HEY, ANNA. WHAT AN HISTORIC MOMENT THAT WE
1:22:47 ARE RECOGNIZING, RIGHT? THE LEADERS OF THE THREE MAJOR
1:22:50 NUCLEAR POWERS AS PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS, IT PUTS THEM IN A
1:22:55 UNIQUE POSITION TO PUT A LID ON NUCLEAR PROLIFERATION, EVEN
1:22:58 THOUGH PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS IT'S HARD TO GIVE UP NUCLEAR POWER.
1:23:02 BUT THE UNIQUELY POSITIONED TO DISCUSS THAT.
1:23:05 HE SAID UKRAINE WILL BE DISCUSSED AS WELL.
1:23:10 OF COURSE, THIS MEETING WAS PRESIDENT PUTIN IN HIS REMARKS
1:23:14 CLANKED CHINA FOR ORGANIZING THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT AND HAVING
1:23:17 THESE THREE LEADERS AGAIN, YOU CAN IMAGINE IS ALREADY A GREAT
1:23:21 CONCERN TO ALL THE OTHER MIDDLE POWERS WHILE WATCHING THIS VERY
1:23:25 CLOSELY, ESPECIALLY BECAUSE UKRAINE IS NOW SQUARELY ON THE
1:23:28 AGENDA. WHETHER OR NOT PRESIDENT PUTIN
1:23:31 WILL BE ABLE TO NEGOTIATE AN OUTCOME THAT'S FAVORABLE TO
1:23:35 MOSCOW, THIS IS -- OF CONCERN TO EUROPEAN CAPITALS AND THE U.S.
1:23:38 PEACE ENVOY ON THE WAY TO BRIEF EUROPEAN OFFICIALS ABOUT WHAT IS
1:23:42 GOING ON HERE IN THIS ROOM WHERE THE THREE LEADERS ARE MEETING.
1:23:44 IT'S INTERESTING, THOUGH, THIS MEETING STARTED ABOUT 1 1/2
1:23:47 HOURS LATE. AND PRESIDENT PUTIN WAS LEFT IN
1:23:51 HIS HOTEL ROOM WAITING FOR THIS MEETING TO BEGIN.
1:23:54 AND EVERYTHING HAS BEEN DELAYED TODAY BECAUSE OF A LAST-MINUTE
1:23:57 ADDITION TO TRUMP'S SCHEDULE. TRUMP AND PUTIN HAD A HALF AN
1:24:02 HOUR OR SO MEETING EARLIER TODAY JUST AHEAD OF THE MEETING.
1:24:05 AND WHICH MADE HIM LATE FOR PRESIDENT XI'S MEETING.
1:24:09 AND THEN THE TWO, XI AND TRUMP, HAD A LATE LUNCH AS WELL AND TO
1:24:11 GIVE YOU SOME COLOR. THIS IS REALLY QUITE
1:24:13 SIGNIFICANT. A LUNCH THAT WAS NOT INITIALLY
1:24:17 SCHEDULED ON TRUMP'S AGENDA. REMEMBER, BACK IN -- I BELIEVE
1:24:21 IT WAS 2021 IN ALASKA WHEN BIDEN AND XI MET IT WAS VERY, VERY
1:24:25 SOUR AND -- AT THE TIME AND THE CHINESE FOREIGN MINISTER SAID ON
1:24:27 CAMERA FOR LUNCH THEY HAD INSTANT NOODLES AND THAT WAS
1:24:30 SORT OF A TACIT COMPLAINT THAT THEY WERE NOT BEING TREATED WELL
1:24:33 BY THE HOST COUNTRY. BUT HERE YOU HAVE TRUMP AND XI
1:24:38 HAVING THAT LATE LUNCH TODAY WHERE THEY HAD CANTONESE FOOD
1:24:40 AND THEN NOW THEY HAVE THIS TRILATERAL SUMMIT.
1:24:42 SO PLENTY OF OPPORTUNITY FOR THE TWO LEADERS TO HAVE THAT FACE
1:24:44 TIME. AND WE ALSO DID GET A CHINESE
1:24:49 STATE MEDIA READOUT ON THAT TRUMP-XI SUMMIT EARLIER TODAY.
1:24:52 DESCRIBING THE TALKS AS POSITIVE AND CONSTRUCTIVE AS WELL.
1:24:57 GUY: MINMIN, THANK YOU FOR THE UPDATE AND THANK YOU FOR THE
1:24:58 ANALYSIS. MINMIN LOW JOINING US AS WE
1:25:02 CONTINUE TO DIGEST AND THINK ABOUT WHAT HAS JUST BEEN SAID
1:25:05 AND WHAT IS GOING TO COME NEXT AS WELL.
1:25:08 AND WE'LL CONTINUE WITH IT OUR ANALYSIS OF THE EVENT.
1:25:11 9:00 AM LONDON TIME BLOOMBERG IS HOSTING A LIVE Q&A TO ANALYZE
1:25:15 THE KEY MOMENTS FROM THAT HISTORIC TRILATERAL MOMENT AT
1:25:17 THE APEC SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN. JOIN IN THAT CONVERSATION WE
1:25:20 WOULD LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU. YOU CAN TUNE IN ON
1:25:22 BLOOMBERG.COM. ANNA: LET'S BRING IN RICHARD
1:25:28 RICHARD, RADIO -- WINDSOR AND LOTS TO TALK ABOUT AND WE WILL
1:25:30 GET TO THE ANTHROPIC IPO. RICHARD: GOOD MORNING.
1:25:33 ANNA: AROUND NVIDIA OF COURSE. BUT I WONDER IN THE CONTEXT OF
1:25:36 WHAT WE'RE SEEING AT THE MOMENT, WORLD LEADERS MEETING IN
1:25:38 SHENZHEN, THREE IN PARTICULAR, XI, TRUMP, AND PUTIN, AND
1:25:41 THINKING. FIRST OF THOSE TWO, THEY COULD
1:25:43 BE FALLING OUT ABOUT CHIPS, RIGHT NOW, COULDN'T THEY?
1:25:46 THEY COULD BE FALLING OUT AROUND THE U.S. IMPOSING FURTHER
1:25:50 RESTRICTIONS ON CHINESE ACCESS TO HIGH-END CHIPS.
1:25:52 AND YET THEY'RE NOT DOING THAT. HOW DO YOU REFLECT ON THE FACT
1:25:56 THAT WE'RE SEEING THIS POSITIVE MOOD REALLY BETWEEN CHINA AND
1:25:59 THE UNITED STATES? AND YET THERE ARE EVIDENT
1:26:05 TECHNOLOGY TENSIONS? RICHARD: WELL, A SUMMIT SUCH AS
1:26:07 THIS, THEY ARE ALWAYS GOING TO PUT ON A POSITIVE FACE OF IT, OF
1:26:09 COURSE. WHAT I THINK REALLY NEEDS TO BE
1:26:14 HAMMERED OUT IS THE INCREASING DESIRE, PARTICULARLY FROM THE
1:26:17 NEW CONGRESS AND THE UNITED STATES, TO INCREASE THE LEVEL OF
1:26:21 CONTROLS AND ACCESS THAT CHINA HAS TO ADVANCED U.S. SILICON.
1:26:25 AND THAT WILL MEAN CLAMPING DOWN ON THE PRACTICE OF CHINA RENTING
1:26:30 DATA CENTERS IN NEIGHBORING COUNTRIES.
1:26:32 NOW, ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT. AND YOU CAN SEE THERE'S OTHER
1:26:36 ISSUES THERE LIKE ACCESS TO RARE EARTH METALS.
1:26:38 THE FACT THAT U.S. FARMERS NEED TO SELL LOTS OF SOYBEANS.
1:26:41 AND I SUSPECT IT'S IN THAT MUCH WIDER CONTEXT THAT SOME KIND OF
1:26:45 DEAL WILL BE STRUCK. THE BALANCE IS BETWEEN THE TWO
1:26:48 SIDES. SO THAT'S KIND OF WHAT WE'RE
1:26:50 LOOKING FOR. DON'T FORGET ALSO THERE ARE --
1:26:53 THERE IS ANOTHER MEETING BETWEEN CERTAINLY MR. TRUMP AND MR. XI
1:26:56 ON DECEMBER 14, I BELIEVE. SO YOU -- THINGS COULD GET
1:27:00 POSTPONED UNTIL THEN. ANNA: WHAT -- WHAT'S THE
1:27:03 STATE -- YOU'RE JOINING US ON THE DAY OF THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
1:27:08 AND WE'RE THINKING ABOUT HOW CERTAIN IT'S REVENUES ARE MOOT
1:27:10 FUTURE. AND THE COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE IS
1:27:12 PART OF THAT. OBVIOUSLY WE TALK ABOUT THE --
1:27:15 THE MODELS THAT ARE AVAILABLE IN CHINA AND THE COMPETITION IN THE
1:27:17 UNITED STATES. FROM SOME OF THE OTHER
1:27:20 HYPERSCALERS AND ALSO OBVIOUSLY FROM OPENAI.
1:27:22 WHAT IS THE COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE FROM CHINA LIKE IN
1:27:27 TERMS OF -- IN TERMS OF ANTHROPIC?
1:27:31 RICHARD: AT THE MOMENT, VERY WEAK.
1:27:33 AND THE REASON IT'S VERY WEAK IS BECAUSE WHAT CHINA CAN REALLY
1:27:38 OFFER IS OPEN SOURCE MODELS AND OPEN SOURCE MODELS EVEN THE
1:27:41 REALLY GOOD ONES ARE NOT QUITE AT THE FRONTIER.
1:27:45 WHAT THAT MEANS IS AT THE MOMENT, THE SPACE WHERE CHINA
1:27:49 COMPETES AGAINST ANTHROPIC WILL BE IN THE -- THE SORT OF LIKE
1:27:52 THE MID-RANGE OF THE MARKET. THE TASKS THAT DON'T REQUIRE A
1:27:57 PH.D LEVEL OF MATH TO GET AND ALSO SUPER ACCURACY.
1:28:00 THE SLIGHTLY LESS ESSENTIAL TASKS WHICH WILL BE MUCH
1:28:02 CHEAPER. IT'S AT THAT PART OF THE MARKET
1:28:06 THAT I THINK CHINA IS COMPETING FOR.
1:28:07 AND SO CONSEQUENTLY, IF YOU LOOK AT OPENAI, FOR EXAMPLE, AND
1:28:12 OBVIOUSLY GOOGLE AND AT SOME POINT META AS WELL, THESE GUYS
1:28:16 ARE GOING TO COMPETE AT THE FRONTIER AND I EXPECTS ARE ALSO
1:28:19 THAT THE MAJORITY OF THE VALUE EVEN IF IT'S JUST A MINORITY OF
1:28:22 THE TOKENS AND THE COMPUTE, THE MAJORITY OF THE VALUE IS GOING
1:28:26 TO BE RIGHT AT THE FRONTIER IN TERMS OF VALUE GENERATED FROM AI
1:28:28 SERVICES. SO REALLY I THINK IT'S THE
1:28:31 COMPETITION OF THE OTHER LEADERS RATHER THAN CHINA THAT MATTERS
1:28:34 MOST WHEN IT COMES TO ANTHROPIC'S IPO AND ITS
1:28:38 PROSPECTS FOR 2027-28. GUY: IS ANTHROPIC GOING TO BE
1:28:41 BETTER ABLE TO COMPETE AS A PUBLIC COMPANY, RICHARD?
1:28:48 RICHARD: I DON'T THINK SO. BECAUSE AGAIN, ANTHROPIC HAS
1:28:51 ISSUES. PARTICULARLY AROUND THE
1:28:54 GOVERNANCE ISSUES WHICH ARE INCREDIBLY UNCLEAR.
1:28:56 THE USUAL FACT THAT SHAREHOLDERS ARE NO SAY IN HOW THE BUSINESS
1:29:01 IS RUN IS A RECIPE FOR PROBLEMS IF THINGS DON'T GO WELL AS
1:29:03 PLANNED. BUT THE REAL ISSUE IS I THINK IS -- MY ANALYSIS OF OPENAI
1:29:09 SUGGESTS THAT IT HAS A MUCH LOWER COST BASE.
1:29:12 NOW, IF IT HAS A LOWER COST BASE GOING INTO 2027, IT MEANS
1:29:15 THAT -- AS LONG AS IT'S PRODUCTS ARE AS GOOD AS ANTHROPIC,
1:29:18 ANTHROPIC WILL NO LONGER HAVE A MOAT OR AN EDGE WHICH COULD TIP
1:29:23 IT INTO A PRICE WAR WITH OPENAI. AND I THINK IT IS THAT WHERE THE
1:29:29 RISK LIES IN TERMS OF ANTHROPIC'S ABILITY TO MAKE
1:29:32 MONEY AND TO PAY THE VERY SUBSTANTIAL COMPUTE BILL THAT IT
1:29:36 HAS COMMITTED ITSELF TO FOR THE NEXT SEVEN TO EIGHT YEARS.
1:29:40 GUY: RICHARD, HOW LONG CAN NVIDIA WAIT BEFORE ITS BOARD
1:29:46 APPOINTS A PERMANENT CEO? RICHARD: GOOD QUESTION.
1:29:49 THE HONEST ANSWER IS I'M NOT SURE.
1:29:51 BUT I THINK THEY'RE UNDER CONSIDERABLE PRESSURE.
1:29:55 THE END OF THIS MONTH IS GTC WASHINGTON.
1:29:57 NOW, JENSEN WAS DUE TO GIVE THE KEYNOTE THERE.
1:30:01 AND THERE WILL BE MANY THOUSANDS OF ADORING FANS WAITING THERE TO
1:30:07 SEE WHAT EXACTLY NVIDIA COMES UP WITH.
1:30:09 SO WHAT HAPPENS AT GTC WASHINGTON WILL HAVE ABSOLUTELY
1:30:12 NO IDEA. GIVEN HOW IMPORTANT THIS
1:30:15 APPOINTMENT IS, I THINK, I WOULD HOPE TO HAVE SOMEONE IN PLACE
1:30:20 PERHAPS BY THE NEXT TIME NVIDIA REPORTS RESULTS IN JANUARY.
1:30:24 AND DEFINITELY BY THE BIG GDP SHOW WHICH IS IN THE MIDDLE OF
1:30:27 MARCH NEXT YEAR. ANNA: DO YOU THINK RENE HAAS OF
1:30:34 ARM WOULD MAKE A GOOD CEO FOR NVIDIA?
1:30:36 RICHARD: I THINK -- I THINK, YOU KNOW, RENE, PEOPLE LOOKING AT
1:30:39 RENE BECAUSE HE'S WORKED AT NVIDIA FOR A LONG TIME.
1:30:42 HE WORKED DIRECTLY FOR JENSEN. HE KNOWS THE SYSTEM.
1:30:45 HE KNOWS HOW TO MAKE IT WORK. SO FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE,
1:30:48 ARGUABLY YES, HE COULD BE A VERY GOOD CEO.
1:30:54 HOWEVER, MY TOP CHOICE IS LISA SU.
1:30:57 LISA HAS THE GRAVITAS. SHE KNOWS THE TAIWANESE SYSTEM
1:31:01 VERY, VERY WELL. WHICH IS INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT
1:31:03 FOR TSMC. AND MOST IMPORTANTLY OF ALL, SHE
1:31:06 HAS A TRACK RECORD OF TURNING AROUND A COMPANY THAT WAS IN
1:31:09 REAL TROUBLE AND MAKING IT A GLITTERING SUCCESS.
1:31:12 SO ARGUABLY I THINK RENE HAAS COULD BE GOOD.
1:31:17 I THINK LISA SU COULD BE EVEN BETTER.
1:31:18 ANNA: THANKS VERY, RICHARD. REALLY GOOD TO GET YOUR
1:31:20 PERSPECTIVE. RICHARD WINDSOR, RADIO FREE
1:31:23 MOBILE FOUNDER AND OWNER. COMING UP ON THE PROGRAM THEN
1:31:26 WE'VE BEEN TRACKING THESE TRILATERAL TALKS AND BEGUN
1:31:28 BETWEEN PRESIDENTS, PUTIN AND XI.
1:31:29 THEY'RE UNDER WAY. WE SAW THEM GIVE THEIR OPENING
1:31:32 REMARKS AND NOW BEHIND CLOSED DOORS.
1:31:34 WE'LL GET TO BRUSSELS TO SEE HOW EUROPE IS REACTING TO THIS
1:31:36 HISTORIC SUMMIT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:31:56 GUY: 53 MINUTES PAST HOUR. WELCOME BACK.
1:31:58 THE RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN SAYS RUSSIA AND THE UNITED
1:32:02 STATES AND CHINA HAVE, QUOTE, MANY COINCIDING INTERESTS IN
1:32:05 SETTLING REGIONAL CONFLICTS INCLUDING THE ONE IN UKRAINE.
1:32:07 THOSE COMMENTS CAME AT THE START OF THE TRILATERAL MEETING IN
1:32:09 SHENZHEN. LET'S GO TO BRUSSELS TO GET A
1:32:11 REACTION. OLIVER CROOK, OUR CHIEF EUROPE
1:32:15 CORRESPONDENT, IS BACK THERE. OLIVER, JUST GIVE US A SENSE OF
1:32:19 HOW THE EUROPEANS WOULD HAVE READ THAT EARLY EXCHANGE AND THE
1:32:23 EXCHANGES, THE BILATERALS THAT CAME EARLIER IN THE DAY IN
1:32:26 SHENZHEN? >> WELL, I THINK THE FIRST
1:32:28 SIGNAL, GUY, IS THAT WHEN YOU HAVE ANY MEETING BETWEEN THE
1:32:30 PRESIDENT OF RUSSIA, VLADIMIR PUTIN, AND THE PRESIDENT OF THE
1:32:34 UNITED STATES, DONALD TRUMP, AFTER WHICH THE PRESIDENT OF
1:32:36 RUSSIA IS SORT OF BEAMING VERY SORT OF WIDE-EYED IN TERMS OF
1:32:40 HIS SMILE AFTER THAT MEETING, AND YOU HAVE RUSSIAN MEDIA
1:32:42 SAYING THAT HE LEFT THE MEETING IN AN EXCELLENT MOOD, THAT IS
1:32:45 GOING TO RAISE CONCERNS HERE ACROSS THE CONTINENT OF EUROPE
1:32:48 WHICH OF COURSE IF WE CAN'T TAKE ALL OF THESE COMPARISONS HAD A
1:32:50 HAVE BEEN MADE OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF DAYS AND WEEKS THE
1:32:54 SORT OF YALTA SYMBOLISM THAT WE'RE SEEING HERE OF RUSSIA,
1:32:56 CHINA, AND THE UNITED STATES SITTING TOGETHER, OF COURSE,
1:32:59 YALTA INCLUDED THE EUROPEANS, THIS VISUAL, CERTAINLY DOES NOT.
1:33:02 THERE'S ALSO IN THIS SORT OF PREAMBLE TO THAT MEETING, YOU'RE
1:33:06 HEARING ABOUT HOW THESE ARE THE THREE VICTORS OF THE SECOND
1:33:09 WORLD WAR SITTING TOGETHER AND EMPHASIZING WHAT THESE NATIONS
1:33:12 HAVE IN COMMON RATHER THAN THE CONSIDERABLE DIFFERENCES THAT
1:33:15 THERE ARE IN FOREIGN POLICY AND THE INTERESTS BETWEEN CHINA,
1:33:18 RUSSIA, AND THE UNITED STATES. SO THAT OBVIOUSLY IS GOING TO
1:33:20 RUB THE EUROPEANS THE WRONG WAY AS THEY ARE WATCHING VERY, VERY
1:33:21 CLOSELY. I CAUGHT UP WITH THE PRESIDENT
1:33:25 OF FINLAND YESTERDAY, AND REALLY BEEN A SORT OF DIPLOMATIC
1:33:28 MESSENGER BETWEEN ALL OF THESE ACTORS AND CERTAINLY BETWEEN THE
1:33:30 RUSSIANS AND THE UNITED STATES. HE IS GOT A GOOD RELATIONSHIP
1:33:32 WITH TRUMP. HE IS BEEN ON THE PHONE WITH
1:33:34 VLADIMIR PUTIN OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS WHICH NO OTHER
1:33:37 EUROPEAN LEADER, APART FROM THE PRIME MINISTER OF NORWAY, WHO
1:33:39 WAS ALSO ON THAT CALL, CAN ACTUALLY SAY.
1:33:41 AND HE WAS WATCHING THIS MEETING VERY, VERY NERVOUSLY.
1:33:44 NOW, I DON'T THINK WE'RE EXPECTING ANY MAJOR FIREWORKS
1:33:47 FIREWORKS IN TERMS OF HOW YOU -- UKRAINE IS CONCERNED.
1:33:49 BUT IT WAS CLEAR IN THE CONVERSATION WITH HIM THAT HE
1:33:51 DOES NOT HAVE A CLEAR IDEA OF WHERE TRUMP'S HEAD IS RIGHT NOW
1:33:54 PARTICULARLY ON THE ISSUE OF UKRAINE.
1:33:55 AND THAT IS GOING TO SEND A LOT OF SIGNALS.
1:33:57 WE SHOULD SAY THE EUROPEAN LEADERS ARE ALSO MEETING TODAY
1:34:00 IN BERLIN FOR THE COALITION OF THE WILLING.
1:34:02 THEY'RE TRYING TO FOCUS ON GETTING MORE AIR DEFENSES OVER
1:34:05 TO THE UKRAINIANS BUT THIS IS GOING TO FIGURE PROMINENTLY IN
1:34:08 THOSE CONVERSATIONS TODAY IN BERLIN.
1:34:09 ANNA: YES. AND WE UNDERSTAND THAT PRESIDENT
1:34:12 ZELENSKY IS EXPECTING TO GET AN UPDATE.
1:34:14 WE SAW A HEADLINE SAYING HAD A JARED KUSHNER WAS -- WAS GOING
1:34:18 TO BE BRIEFING THE EUROPEANS ON THINGS THAT HAD BEEN DISCUSSED.
1:34:20 SO WE'LL SEE WHAT COMES OF THAT. OLIVER, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FROM
1:34:23 BRUSSELS. BLOOMBERG'S OLIVER CROOK WITH
1:34:26 THE BRUSSELS PERSPECTIVE. EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE ON
1:34:28 EVERYTHING THAT HAS BEEN HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN.
1:34:31 SO FROM GLOBAL GEOPOLITICS, WE SHOULD -- WHICH ENCOMPASSES
1:34:34 CHIPS AND THE TECH TRADE THESE DAYS, FROM THAT, TO ANTHROPIC
1:34:37 AND ITS IPO, THAT IS CURRENTLY IN PROCESS.
1:34:39 GUY: IT IS. WE'VE -- THE PRICING AND WE'LL
1:34:41 GET THE LISTING A LITTLE BIT LATER ON.
1:34:43 WE'LL SEE HOW THE MARKET TRADES THROUGHOUT THE DAY ON THIS ONE.
1:34:46 BUT AT THE MOMENT CERTAINLY PROVIDING IT SEEMS TO BE THE
1:34:48 CATALYST FOR THE POP THAT WE ARE SEEING IN NASDAQ FUTURES WHICH
1:34:53 ABSOLUTELY. DOES THAT TELL US SOMETHING
1:34:55 ABOUT THE MARKET'S WILLINGNESS OR ABILITY TO MOVE ON FROM ITS
1:34:58 CONCERNS AROUND TECH? AND THE ABILITY TO DIGEST THIS
1:35:01 IPO? IT IS ENORMOUS.
1:35:04 HAVE WE SEEN SOME OF THOSE JITTERS IN THE MARKET?
1:35:06 WERE THEY ACTUALLY DRIVEN BY THE SORT OF FORTHCOMING NATURE OF
1:35:08 THE IPO? WE STILL HAVE YET TO GET IT OVER
1:35:10 THE LINE. BUT IT IS FORTHCOMING.
1:35:13 TECHNOLOGY STOCKS HERE IN EUROPE THE BEST PERFORMING SECTOR, THE
1:35:17 LIKES OF ASML, AND SOITEC REFLECTING PERHAPS THAT NASDAQ
1:35:20 PICTURE THAT WE SEE AHEAD OF US. GUY: DOLLAR STILL STRONG AND
1:35:23 SOME STABILIZATION IN TERMS OF WHAT WE'RE GETTING IN TERMS OF
1:35:26 THE METALS MARKETS. ENERGY IS BEGINNING TO TICK A
1:35:28 LITTLE BIT HIGHER. BRENT CRUDE $92.39 BUT TICKING
1:35:31 JUST A LITTLE BIT HIGHER. PAY ATTENTION TO THAT ONE AS
1:35:33 WELL. THAT WRAPS UP THE THURSDAY
1:35:34 SESSION. WE ARE OPEN.
1:35:37 WE ARE UP AND RUNNING HERE IN EUROPE.
1:35:39 FRANCINE LACQA WILL BE HERE NEXT WITH "THE PULSE" TO CARRY ON.
Trump, Xi & Putin Hold ‘Groundbreaking’ China Summit full transcript
0:12 Newsmakers and market movers. This is the pulse with Francine Lacqua.
0:21 Well, good morning, everyone, and welcome to The Pulse in Francine Lacqua
0:23 here in London. A big day for markets.
0:26 A big day for diplomacy. Now anthropic shares begin trading later
0:30 today after a record breaking IPO, which really has rekindled this enthusiasm for
0:34 the eye trade will bring, of course, all of the key details in a moment.
0:38 But let's start with the latest from the Chinese.
0:41 President XI Jinping has called today's trilateral talks with Presidents Donald
0:46 Trump and Vladimir Putin a summit of groundbreaking significance.
0:51 Now, the three world leaders spoke on safeguarding world peace and stability,
0:55 including discussion on reducing nuclear weapons.
0:57 Let's go straight to Min Menlo, who's at the Apex summit.
1:01 So, I mean, there's a little bit of irony in what the three leaders said,
1:06 but what's the latest you're hearing on the ground?
1:11 Well, what a historic moment that we're witnessing, right?
1:13 With the three leaders of a major nuclear powers meeting today.
1:18 And President Trump said this puts them in a unique position to discuss nuclear
1:23 nonproliferation. Uh, but this is something that we are
1:27 unlikely to see any major outcomes. We know that, for example, China has
1:30 been very much against the aukus, the nuclear sharing agreement between US, UK
1:35 and Australia. China's arsenal is rapidly increasing,
1:38 but is far below what the US and Russia has.
1:41 So this is not unlikely to be an area where we will see that we agree to some
1:46 sort of limits on nuclear power, but President Trump says that is going to be
1:50 on the agenda, along with the Ukraine and Iran war.
1:54 Uh, Putin made no mention of nuclear issues.
1:57 He mentioned that they should discuss. Energy and food security.
2:01 These are areas the issues that have come to the fore after the wars had
2:06 disrupted trade routes. Uh, certainly.
2:09 Uh, just an interesting photo opportunity for the three leaders,
2:12 because President Putin was the one who asked for this summit initially.
2:16 And, uh, Russia is very much the junior partner of the three leaders here with
2:21 an economy that is just a fraction of China's, an economy that is heavily
2:25 dependent on China as well, especially after, uh, the country has been hit by
2:30 sanctions. Uh, and this summit also started about
2:34 an hour and a half late, uh, because of a number of reasons.
2:38 President Trump had a meeting with Putin at the last minute and additional
2:41 additions that really sort of delayed everything.
2:46 Amendment very, very quickly. I mean, a lot of eyebrows have been
2:48 raised at the fact that, um, you know, President Trump called Putin.
2:51 Well, he's my friend. This is how he greeted him when they
2:54 when they met for the first time in 15 months.
2:57 What kind of body language are we seeing between the three?
2:59 I know there's a lot of concern that actually, this is a yes to two moment
3:03 that you have three powerful leaders, controversial leaders?
3:06 Uh, not the most, I guess, Democratic. That will somehow split the world in
3:11 three for their interests. Yeah, certainly.
3:16 I think it's something that would be uncomfortable for middle powers to watch
3:21 these three leaders, uh, having such a close relationship.
3:26 And President Trump even went as far as to say that the International Criminal
3:29 Court is out of control. That is how far he is backing President
3:33 Putin right now. And of course, having Ukraine being
3:36 discussed with Zelensky at the table is of concern.
3:39 That's why you have the US peace envoy, uh, in Berlin to brief European
3:44 officials about what is going on in that room.
3:46 You have Takeuchi also watching this very closely.
3:49 In fact, Takasugi will have a Pelosi with Trump after the trilateral summit,
3:52 given that Japan is Geographically hemmed in by China, Russia and North
3:58 Korea and would be concerned if President Trump is forging closer ties
4:03 with President Putin at a time when Japan relies heavily on the US for
4:07 military cooperation as well. So, uh, so, uh, Taiwan also will be
4:11 watching this very closely for any sign of whether any decision on Ukraine will
4:16 be met without Zelensky being president. And
4:20 this worry for Taiwan, if their own fate can be decided in a similar fashion as
4:23 well. Vindman.
4:26 Thanks so much. Vindman.
4:26 Though they're at the Apex Summit in Shenzhen now, of course, the other big
4:29 story of the day anthropic raising a record 07 billion in an upsized IPO
4:35 and private placement, the biggest of all time.
4:37 Let's bring in Neil Kaplan, our senior strategist and primary Olson, who covers
4:41 tech for Bloomberg Opinion. So thank you both for joining us.
4:44 I mean, again, you know, this is a massive IPO.
4:47 Um, it's it's, you know, projected better than expected because of the up
4:52 sizing. So what are you watching out for in the
4:54 next couple of days to give us an indication of the opportunities, but the
4:57 challenge is also French rugby. Well, it's interesting that in spite of
5:02 all the concern about the eye trade after what happened with Nvidia and the
5:06 scandal there, that we're seeing this huge appetite now for anthropic.
5:10 And I think a lot of that comes down to the fundamentals of this company.
5:13 You know, their first half revenue in 2026 was 6.3 billion.
5:19 And that is something like a huge increase, something like 1,300% increase
5:23 from 1.2 billion the year before. So this is a very one of the fastest
5:28 growing tech companies of all time. You know, lots of unprecedented, um,
5:32 figures around this, this moment. Um, I think there's still a lot of
5:35 uncertainty about, um, return on investment for AI by the companies who
5:41 are anthropic biggest customers. But for now, in terms of the demand that
5:45 anthropic is getting, um, it's just seems like a no brainer for public
5:50 investors to just want to pile into this to the stock.
5:54 I mean, what's the next challenge? And actually, how does it change?
5:58 Because it's public. Yeah, that's a great question.
6:02 And this is really something that's going to be an issue for the company in
6:06 the next few years, not just the next few months.
6:08 This is a long term issue. Remember with Facebook, I still remember
6:11 when they went public in 2012. Um, and then over the coming years, as
6:16 they face the pressures of quarterly earnings and showing growth every three
6:19 months, um, there was pressures on it to, you know, show more revenue growth
6:24 and more time spent on the app. And so it was a bit more aggressive with
6:27 its advertising. Um, and put more, you know, algorithms
6:32 that fed more inflammatory content to people.
6:35 So those are some of the potential unintended consequences of what happens
6:39 when you are a public company under those kinds of pressures.
6:41 Now, anthropic is an AI focused eye safety focus.
6:45 They're really framed around being safety focused.
6:47 So my question would be how much that might get compromised When Wall Street
6:52 gets involved, when when they have the pressures of being a public company and
6:56 need to show growth and speed at racing to build the most powerful AI systems
7:01 they can, can they still be a safe company?
7:05 A part of me. Thank you so much.
7:06 Premier. Also in there from Bloomberg Opinion.
7:08 These are just some of the questions that we're asking ourselves.
7:10 Neil I guess the other one is when you look at this big valuation and actually
7:14 just the size of this huge IPO, I mean, do we rely on, you know, track records
7:19 of, of big IPOs to see what happens next to the share price?
7:23 We could we could look at, uh, Spitzer space is the most obvious example, um,
7:27 where the stock had an initial, uh, sort of rally, um, on the deal.
7:32 And then actually it took some time, um, when it came under pressure to, to come
7:37 back to the IPO price. Uh, investors will certainly look for
7:39 the likes of index inclusions as a, as a driver, because it'll be a lot of
7:43 passive flows going to the stock at the end of the month.
7:46 But I think the path now going forward, as you mentioned, is all about that
7:50 growth trajectory, but also about the profitability.
7:52 What is the path to profitability and how much?
7:55 Bloomberg Economics estimates a $30 trillion work knowledge industry.
7:59 How how much of that time can they can they apply and capture is going to be a
8:04 key question, I think, over the next couple of years.
8:06 Yeah. And, you know, I mean, you know, not a
8:08 lot of people forget this, but some might that they answer, a lot of these
8:11 big companies are owned on chunks of each other.
8:13 So actually you have a system that's really codependent now.
8:16 It's very codependent. We talked about some of these circular
8:18 financing issues for the likes of Nvidia.
8:20 And if you look at the S-1 filing from anthropic itself, actually there's $900
8:24 billion of commitments anthropic has made to other tech companies.
8:28 And a lot of those commitments are to companies who are also part of the
8:32 private placement of stock, as well as salaries.
8:35 That codependency continues for a long time into the future.
8:38 What does it mean for the sector as a whole?
8:40 But it's sector as a whole, given the narrative of the last couple of weeks,
8:43 especially around Nvidia, this is certainly helps with that with
8:47 sentiment. But whether that continues into the year
8:49 and remains to be seen, but it's a it's definitely a positive step and one that
8:53 actually, ironically, to a degree, OpenAI, from which the founders went for
8:57 a bit, came out from what we were watching because that they'll be next
9:01 likely to be next to the market. Um, you know, I mean, what are you
9:04 watching out for in terms of, you know, specific are there any specific revenue
9:09 kind of, you know, landmark or milestones that we should be watching?
9:12 So I suppose one of the things is that trajectory of growth going forward.
9:16 Now, we've had a 12 fold increase in their revenue run rate to date.
9:19 I was looking at some numbers actually using Bloomberg's I o space earlier and
9:23 within five years to get to the $81 billion run rate.
9:26 What can it be going forward. Because it took Google 17 years to get
9:30 to that run, right? It took Microsoft 38 years to get to
9:33 that run rate, and it took Apple 35 years to get to that revenue run rate.
9:37 So can they can continue to grow at that trajectory.
9:39 That's going to be that's going to be key.
9:41 That's the million trillion dollar question Neil.
9:43 Thank you so much Neil. Camping there looking at the latest of
9:46 course with anthropic now minutes from the Federal Reserve's October meeting,
9:50 show that nearly all officials agreed they would likely have to raise interest
9:54 rates in the months ahead. Now, the record also showed two
9:57 policymakers said a hike of more than 25 basis points to be warranted in December
10:02 to help inflation back to the Fed's 2% target.
10:05 Now we're joined by Simon Dangar, fixed income deputy chief investment officer
10:09 and fixed income macro strategies head at Goldman Sachs Asset Management.
10:13 Simon, thank you so much for joining us. Great to be here.
10:15 Plus an anthropic day. So it's exciting.
10:17 I'm going to ask you about, you know, some of, I guess a corporate issuance
10:21 when it comes to the tech in a second. But the fed is exciting.
10:23 The fed is exciting. But we haven't really heard from the
10:25 chair. It's more from the fed governors that I
10:27 guess we're trying to, you know, to move the markets in a certain direction.
10:31 I mean that's been a feature of this fed, although I think the minutes last
10:34 night were pretty clear that there's a lot of impatience about the inflation
10:38 picture in the US. We would share some of that concern.
10:41 December looks like it's a done deal. We view January is very likely as well,
10:45 and 50 is probably unlikely. It seems that there is.
10:48 The consensus to hawk is to do two back to back.
10:51 As we look out the curve, though for the rest of 2027, we could certainly see
10:55 rates go above the forward. So we're cautious on the front end of
10:58 the US. See better value in the UK.
11:00 But overall I mean if you talk the markets up and actually financial
11:03 conditions tighten, how much does that do the work of higher interest rates.
11:07 That does some of the work. Well there.
11:08 When we look at the financial conditions tightening that we've seen so far, it's
11:11 just not that big in the context of an economy that in terms of nominal growth,
11:15 is growing very strongly. A lot of the AI CapEx that's such a big
11:19 focus of the market is sort of built into the cake for 2027.
11:23 If markets hold up, then the consumption, which is also been driving
11:27 the US, is going to hold up too. So the the economy can take some
11:31 financial conditions tidy. What we've seen so far, it just doesn't
11:33 look that big. Yeah.
11:35 I mean, the other question mark is actually at what point do interest rates
11:38 become restrictive. And we thought we would have reached
11:40 that point by now. It's a moving target.
11:43 And of course it's a moving target because of what's going on with this
11:46 huge demand for investment on the back of I.
11:49 And that's driving up neutral rates in the US and in the rest of the world.
11:53 Um, and so I think some of the what we've seen with the fed is really just
11:56 about responding to that rather than moving into something which is obviously
12:00 restrictive. What are you seeing in terms of
12:02 inflation? So you mentioned that, you know, there
12:04 are pressures and we know what's happening with Iran.
12:07 But does AI productivity going up have an impact longer term on sticky
12:12 inflation? Possibly in the longer term.
12:14 But there's a lot to play before we get to the point of really seeing eye
12:17 productivity. I think right now it's about just
12:20 resource utilization against the backdrop of this healthy economy.
12:24 Look, a lot of what's going on with inflation is about the shocks that we've
12:27 received. Obviously the tariff shock is falling
12:29 out. The energy shock is still very much with
12:31 us, but we think there's a little bit more to that, to the process than that.
12:35 It's not coming from the labor market, but is coming from the ability of
12:38 companies to have some pricing power against this strong economy.
12:41 And that's just keeping inflation at levels that are a little on the
12:44 uncomfortable side. I mean, how do you look at the labor
12:46 market in the US? And actually on the back of what you've
12:48 just said also about your expectations for fed?
12:51 What does it mean for treasuries? Well, I think there's different parts of
12:54 the curve, the front end of the curve for cautious.
12:56 We continue to want to be underweight US rates versus other parts of the world,
13:00 particularly the UK where we look further out the curve, say 7 to 10 year
13:04 treasuries. I think the picture looks a little bit
13:06 more interesting. It real yields embedded in ten year
13:09 treasuries above 5% to reason to be attractive in the long run, but it's
13:14 difficult to have a very big position until we see either a weakening of
13:17 growth momentum or an improvement in that inflation picture, and some
13:21 elimination of some of the tails around inflation that are associated with the
13:25 energy market. So happy to run portfolios a little bit
13:27 long in that part of the curve, but not very long.
13:30 And rockets are going to be choppy. Yeah.
13:32 Markets tribunal I mean do you worry we had these like you know, market events
13:36 where we even saw the 30 year gilts in the UK touch 6%.
13:40 Are we going to have these moments of stresses.
13:43 that there's always a risk. There's very strong competition for
13:45 capital. Fiscal everywhere leaves a lot of
13:48 questions for investors about how that's going to be dealt with in the long run.
13:52 That's not really been an issue in the US this year because whilst rates have
13:56 gone up, growth expectations have gone up too.
13:58 That's clearly been an issue in places like France, and I think that's going to
14:02 continue to be a theme for markets. To the very back into the curve is
14:05 somewhere where we're more cautious of what happens to France, given that we're
14:10 going towards the election of we have the ECB saying, look, this is a French
14:14 problem. So I don't know whether there needs to
14:15 be reassurance from the ECB that they will step in or whether actually instead
14:18 of buying bonds, they could do cut or there's some kind of other tool that
14:22 that we should be thinking about. I mean, the ECB is not going to want to
14:24 be a big player here unless things get much worse.
14:27 If things did get much worse, I think the ECB would come in and do something
14:31 with one of their programs, have designed a program, but we're far away
14:34 from that at the moment. The ECB is going to want to keep the
14:37 ball firmly in the court of the sovereigns themselves.
14:40 The challenge with France is that there is a long journey, so we have clarity
14:43 about what the political setup is going to be in France.
14:46 We really need to wait. So after the parliamentary elections,
14:49 wherever they're going to be, and in the meantime, the market is going to be
14:53 subject to a lot of rhetoric from the politicians that may not be that bond
14:56 friendly as they try to position themselves with respect to the
14:59 electorate, to whether the French spread should be won 5131, 70 is something that
15:04 the market's going to struggle to resolve for now.
15:07 When you go to the front end of the curve, there is some value that's opened
15:10 up. And, you know, unless you get into
15:12 scenarios where the market is debating with nomination risk, which feels very
15:16 far out, the money, then probably that's carried, which can get earned out over
15:19 time. So I'm an overall what's your take on
15:21 take? I mean we see you know, a lot of
15:23 issuance and frankly we see a lot of issuance just because they need the
15:26 money to build. So these data centers and the
15:29 infrastructure no matter what cost does that change.
15:32 How does that crowd the market? It's a tricky proposition for debt
15:35 investors because as you say, there's an enormous amount of supply to take down.
15:39 And when we look at the hyper scalar complex, it makes us cautious, not
15:43 because of issues of credit quality, but simply because of the issues of the
15:46 amount of bonds that we're going to have to receive.
15:49 If you look at our CapEx forecasts for next year for the hyperscalers at large,
15:54 then they're coming in as large as 1.5 trillion.
15:56 So a big pickup relative to 2026. And of course, a lot of that will
16:00 continue to be debt financed. We might get less in the way of growth
16:04 of hyperscale, of debt compared to what we've seen this year.
16:07 But there's going to be a lot of data center deals to buy, a lot of chip deals
16:11 to buy. So we're cautious on the hyperscalers
16:13 themselves. For those supply reasons, we do see
16:16 opportunities, and particularly in some of the better structures deals for
16:21 financing the hard infrastructure of AI. So data centers with very well
16:25 constructed leases to good tenants, whether it's good access to power, with
16:29 reasonably good execution associated with that, that looks good.
16:32 And some of these chip deals, which are going to be a big feature of 27 but
16:36 probably look good. So I mean, this is a debt issuance low
16:38 from here. I don't think so.
16:40 I think his nature changes. It might become shorter in maturity on
16:44 average as you move towards these chip deals, but there's going to be an
16:47 enormous amount of debt to buy and more in 20 1726.
16:51 When you look at the system in aggregate.
16:53 Okay, Simon, thank you so much. Simon Danker, deputy chief investment
16:55 officer for fixed income and fixed income macro strategies, head at Goldman
16:59 Sachs Asset Management, coming up after years of investments, will reveal some
17:03 of the big winners from today's anthropic IPO.
17:06 That's coming up next. And this is Bloomberg.
17:24 With you as
17:28 well. Shares in anthropic will debut on the
17:30 Nasdaq later today priced at $83 each. Now, the record IPO is set to bring
17:35 billions of dollars in returns to several financial firms that have bet
17:38 the house on the cloud chat bot maker. For more, let's get the thoughts of Tim
17:42 Craighead, our director of equity research at Bloomberg Intelligence.
17:46 Thank you so much for joining us. I know you know, you and your team have
17:49 done some great research into what this means.
17:50 The winners or losers. So this is a massive IPO.
17:53 It's even bigger than projected. So you know we have to look now at the
17:56 post deal um like dealmaking. So what are the dynamics that you're
18:00 looking at. Yeah I think, you know, it's going to be
18:03 interesting on a couple of different fronts.
18:05 Number one, there are big anchor investors that are supposedly involved
18:10 with the deal. You never know totally for sure, but
18:13 that's going to be a solid source of demand.
18:15 You would think, um, the question about passive demand coming in with index
18:20 inclusion has been a big question mark. And we now have some resolution with
18:25 both the Nasdaq 100 and Russell 1000 indicating that December 11th is the day
18:32 for inclusion. Um, the S&P 500.
18:36 No. um, doesn't meet profitability, doesn't
18:39 meet uh, uh, afloat doesn't meet the one year seasoning.
18:44 So there'll be billions of dollars of demand.
18:46 But is a top ten market cap company. It's not nearly as much as you would
18:50 think because of the thin float. So there is a limitation on that and it
18:55 will be a good source. It's a good strategy.
18:56 I mean, what are the it's a performance track record of big IPO.
19:00 Yeah. This is really interesting.
19:02 Um, Chris Kane, who leads our US equity strategy team, published a note looking
19:07 at the top 25 IPOs size wise since 2000. And it's it's a very consistent pattern.
19:15 They all jumped on day one bar one. That was that was Uber um a 30% average
19:22 pop. Um, however, um, if you were to look at
19:27 the next uh, two weeks, one month, six month, one year, the the boost relative
19:34 to the market fades. You're down 8% in a month.
19:38 You're down 16% in six months. And it's a 5050 sort of chance in terms
19:44 of whether you outperform the market over the over the next year.
19:48 So how does this relate to the performance of anthropic?
19:50 Yeah, it's really interesting I think. I think space is probably the closest
19:55 proxy. It's been recent.
19:57 It was technology oriented. It had an AI component, um, massive in
20:02 size. It jumped uh, 20% on day one.
20:06 25%, uh, by day three, um, you lost about half of it over the next month.
20:12 By June, it was down 5% and has since traded back up a bit.
20:18 You know, you could envision, you know, all else being equal, that's not a bad
20:22 pattern. But we'll see because this you know,
20:25 every stock's different. Um, Tim, I mean, in terms of some of the
20:28 notable investors, I mean, again, we were talking about it with Neil
20:32 Campbell. I mean, a lot of investors like own only
20:33 each other in this kind of. But who would the big win winners be?
20:37 Yeah, the Bloomberg News published a really good story today on terminal, and
20:43 it outlines a number of the early stage investors and a couple of them.
20:47 And I'm going to refer to notes here because I want to make sure that I speak
20:49 this correctly. But Spark Capital and Lightspeed were
20:53 two of the early wins in in 2023, 24. Um, and you know, that's back when the
21:00 valuation was in the millions or early billions as opposed to what we see now.
21:05 And you're talking 11,000,000,028 billion in in assessed value as it
21:11 currently stands, from what news can calculate.
21:14 There's many other VCs. And then you've got some of the big, um,
21:18 uh, sovereign wealth funds. GIC has been, you know, an active
21:22 investor in this. And then clearly you've got some of the
21:25 big corporates. It goes back to the whole sort of
21:27 discussion about circular financing. But Microsoft, Google, uh, Amazon All
21:32 have big stakes and anthropic. What about the banks?
21:36 I mean, yeah, I've had a pretty big year.
21:39 They did. And I suppose there's two things to
21:41 think about here. And again, referencing another, uh,
21:45 article out today, Paul Davies put an interesting piece out, um, that that
21:50 does highlight, I mean, clearly you can have big investment banking fees that's
21:53 going to go through into that line item in terms of banking revenue.
21:59 But importantly, the equity trading business this year across all of the big
22:04 investment banks. Think Goldman, think Morgan Stanley,
22:07 think JP, JP Morgan. Um, are up huge, um, double where we
22:13 were only a couple of years ago. And the interesting thing is, if you
22:18 look at 2027, in 2028, expectations from a consensus perspective, those equity
22:24 trading revenue lines are flat up a little bit at these very lofty levels.
22:31 Yeah. You know maybe that continues.
22:33 We clearly have volatility that plays into into their streams.
22:38 But higher interest rates tend to be a dampening effect.
22:41 There's there's there's there's a lot of give and take in this for 20 2728.
22:46 And you know stocks have backed off a little bit from peaks back a couple of
22:50 months ago. Um but yeah interesting days.
22:53 Uh, given everything that you said, what are you watching out for in the next 72
22:57 hours? Yeah.
22:58 Um, certainly the the one day pop will be what to see.
23:05 And then the sustained demand over the course of the next couple of days.
23:09 Do we see a drift? Do we see further, further trading up.
23:14 And again, going back and thinking about the space, uh, trading pattern, I think
23:20 it's been quite, quite good. And then you throw in fed expectations.
23:25 You know, there's there's more discussion out in the press today about
23:29 how aggressive they're going to be. The next meeting is the potential for a
23:33 big hike. And so you've got the tech that's it's
23:36 big. You've got Nvidia that's big.
23:37 And then there's a question of interest rates.
23:39 Yeah. And then a bit of geopolitics.
23:41 Tim thank you so much. Tim Craighead global chief content
23:43 officer at Bloomberg Intelligence. Coming up, we'll discuss the outlook
23:47 also for London's luxury property market and much more with entrepreneur and
23:51 investor Nick Candy. That's next.
23:53 And this is Bloomberg. First.
24:05 With you. Good morning everyone and welcome to the
24:10 post and Francine Lacqua here in London. And these are your top stories.
24:13 President Trump meets Vladimir Putin and XI Jinping in a rare diplomatic
24:17 encounter. Anthropic raises more than 07 billion
24:22 in the biggest IPO of all time, eclipsing the record set by SpaceX back
24:26 in June. Plus, markets rally on anthropic Shares
24:29 in The Clod Maker are indicated to open between 20 and 26% higher in grain
24:34 market trading, so there is a lot going on today.
24:36 President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin have held their
24:40 first in-person meeting in more than a year on the sidelines of a gathering in
24:43 China. The two leaders also held trilateral
24:46 talks with the Chinese president at the apex summit.
24:49 So for more, let's bring in Bloomberg, Tony Help and Bloomberg's Tony Halperin,
24:53 who leads a Russia economy and government coverage.
24:56 Good morning Tony. President Trump described Putin as my
25:00 friend. What's your reading of the meeting?
25:05 Yeah. Well, the Kremlin also said that
25:07 Vladimir Putin came out of the meeting in an excellent mood.
25:10 They seem to have got on very well during the discussions.
25:13 The trilateral talks have started. Putin said during opening remarks that,
25:18 um, he and President Trump devoted considerable attention to discussing the
25:23 war in Ukraine. He said also that he discussed it the
25:26 previous day with, uh, President XI. So, um, the city clearly, uh, spent a
25:31 lot of time considering how to bring the war to an end.
25:33 President Trump said that he hoped that good things are going to happen.
25:37 That, um, Putin and the other side, as he put it, were interested in ending the
25:41 war. But we'll have to see what comes out of
25:43 those discussions between very quickly and any insight
25:47 into how, I mean, if we're closer to the war ending and how it would come to an
25:51 end. And we don't see any, uh, new proposals
25:56 to bring the war to an end. Certainly the US is putting a lot of
25:59 pressure and motivation to try and encourage the two sides to reach a deal.
26:03 Um, they'll be discussing in Europe as well with European allies.
26:07 So, uh, later in the day, we might get a better outline of how they see a way of
26:10 bringing this conflict to a close. Tony, thanks so much, Tony.
26:15 Happened there was very latest, of course, on these meetings in Shenzhen,
26:19 which we're covering very, very closely now.
26:21 London's luxury property downturn continues last month.
26:25 Prices in the capital's most affluent neighbourhoods dropped almost 7%
26:29 compared with a year earlier, and more than 9% from pre-pandemic levels.
26:33 Well over the years, policy changes have significantly raised transaction taxes
26:37 for the UK's most expensive homes. Let's discuss the outlook and much more
26:41 with Nick Candy, chief executive of Candy capital.
26:43 He's also treasurer of the political party reform UK.
26:46 Nick, always a pleasure to speak to you because we have a lot to talk about.
26:49 Let's start with actually the property market, the luxury property market.
26:53 Now, you've told me previously that you wouldn't develop in London anymore,
26:57 right, that you were focused on the Middle East, but actually something must
26:59 have changed. What's changed?
27:00 I think just to build the very best buildings in
27:04 London today is very hard, partly because of the policies, uh, done by
27:08 central government and local government. So let's just take City of Westminster,
27:12 uh, Mayfair. Knightsbridge.
27:13 You're not allowed to build a flat bigger than 2500ft².
27:17 Now, if you want to merge two flats, a 2500ft² together to make 5000 is
27:21 illegal. So the they've put a lot of challenges
27:24 in the play in places and cities today. Like companies, they're very
27:28 competitive. And so the mobility of wealth is made.
27:32 People will just leave and go to Monaco or the UAE or Milan, and there's other
27:38 choices, and we have to make our city as competitive as possible.
27:41 And today London is not the same. It was not where it was 20 years ago.
27:47 So how would you change it? I would change the policies.
27:50 I would, uh, we'd have to deal with crime.
27:52 Because whether we believe it or not, the international market looks at the UK
27:56 and hears about this knife crime outside Harrods or outside in Mayfair.
28:01 Uh, so crime is a big issue. We've got to deal with the policy, uh,
28:06 for building. We've got contractors going bust all
28:08 over the place. So how do we how do we make sure that we
28:11 are as competitive as any other city? We don't have to be better, but we have
28:15 to be at least as good. And you think, I mean.
28:18 Or the people in charge understanding that?
28:19 No, they've got to be a little bit of movement.
28:21 They've got an understanding. And actually it makes it worse because
28:24 when affordable housing needs to be built across, across the well, across
28:29 the city, across the country, and we are not building that because developers
28:32 can't afford that model. Their financial models are not working.
28:36 When they put these numbers into it. I mean, some of the recent high profile
28:39 London homes, including your own Providence house, what does it tell you
28:42 about the market as a whole? There's still a lot of demand from from
28:45 billionaires. So you've got to divide the market up.
28:48 The very, very top of the market, both in real estate and art, is on fire.
28:52 It's booming. So you're saying that in the auctions in
28:55 New York with Sotheby's and Christie's, you saw that in London.
28:58 And it's the same on the real estate market on provenance House.
29:01 We had six different offers with six different lawyers in the data room.
29:05 Uh, it wasn't even publicly on the market, and we sold it for over $350
29:09 million for for a record price. We're looking at pictures of it.
29:13 Oh, okay. So, uh, and, um, we sold it for over
29:16 $250 million. We did the deal in six hours, and we
29:19 didn't take the highest offer. The other thing is, is everyone in the
29:23 media has got very excited about, oh, I sold five flats with it to get the stamp
29:27 duty done for the buyer. There was already six units inside the
29:31 estate. I didn't need to sell the five extra
29:33 flats, but obviously the media got quite excited about it.
29:35 So why did you not go for the higher, you know, the highest price?
29:38 I wanted certainty, this person said he would exchange and I was in funds with
29:42 his lawyers. Um, and I tried to move him, uh, moving
29:46 up, uh, in price. He said that's my price.
29:48 Take it or leave it. Uh, and lucky I did, because a few weeks
29:50 later, the war started in Iran. But how did you do it?
29:53 Because a lot of people look at that and say, well, you know, I have a big
29:56 property. Actually, I can't and I can't shift it.
29:59 So the best of the best is what you're after.
30:02 So whether that's in the market, whether that's in the real estate market, if you
30:06 have the very best, then you're absolutely fine as long as you can
30:09 afford to hold it. Okay.
30:11 I've got one of the best apartments in London in one Hyde Park.
30:14 It's 18,000ft². I've got serious interest in it.
30:16 Now. I will work out whether I want to sell
30:18 it or not. Uh, but if you have the best of the
30:22 best. You're okay.
30:23 If you're in the mediocre or you're just slightly off patch or one street the
30:27 wrong way, or the outlooks wrong, or the garden's not big enough, then you're in
30:31 trouble and you're going to have to take a serious discount.
30:34 Overall, I mean, you have interests in, you know, you're telling me about, um,
30:38 you know, some of the critical minerals. Also, I know you're looking at alcohol
30:41 free drinks, like wild idle. Like, what do you think the world is, is
30:45 looking at? Everything's shifting.
30:47 So where is demand? Like, what's the next big business going
30:50 to be? Well, a couple of years ago, we saw this
30:52 zero alcohol, uh, low alcohol business. I've got Paul Walsh, the CEO of diazo,
30:57 uh, on my board. Uh, he's amazing, uh, the next
31:00 generation of young children and young adults and, well, not young children,
31:04 but young adults. I'm not going to drink like we have a
31:06 drink. Yeah.
31:06 It's just that's not going to happen. And so we created this sort of Dom
31:10 Perignon of zero alcohol. It's name is the name is wild.
31:13 I know it's in Harrods and Selfridges and Ocado.
31:16 So in every top restaurant hotel in the world and we believe, uh, we will create
31:21 a group as valuable as any other group in the world.
31:24 And the love the zero space. So we have a low alcohol Bordeaux, uh,
31:27 red bread. Bordeaux.
31:28 We have a local rosé. We have a zero alcohol champagne.
31:31 And the LVMH and Diageo. I've got so many problems inside that
31:36 group about the on the alcoholic side and cutting costs and stuff.
31:40 They've completely forgot to look at the the lower the zero space.
31:43 So this allows someone like myself that's entrepreneurial to come into the
31:46 space and take advantage of it. But what is this like health?
31:49 Is it is it? It's this hot as half calories is half
31:52 the size of a glass of champagne. It looks like champagne.
31:55 It doesn't taste like champagne because we've never started it.
31:57 It's as close as you can get. So you can't say it's identical to
32:01 champagne, because we've never started the fermentation process that gives you
32:04 alcohol. So.
32:05 But, um, these different spaces, whether it's critical minerals, whether it's
32:09 zero low alcohol champagne or it's real estate or art, I want to do the very,
32:14 very best. You know, I've always trying to be at
32:17 the top of my league, Okay. And that's what we try to do.
32:20 Um, talk to me a little bit about, you know, reform UK.
32:23 So after £72 million in donations in one weekend, are you are you finding it hard
32:28 to find, you know, to fund. No, no.
32:30 So I promised Nigel, when I took this job that I'd be the first person to give
32:34 £1 million to reform the Conservative Party.
32:36 Laugh to me, okay, after 14 years of helping them.
32:39 So it's a bit nasty, but that's politics.
32:41 Okay. It's a rough game.
32:43 Um. I promised Nigel I'd raised him £100
32:45 million. Was probably, you know, 99% there.
32:49 Okay, I think we'll go over that. And I also believe when he bit money.
32:53 From who? I mean, is it entrepreneurs is it's all
32:55 I it's it's entrepreneurs, people that are frustrated with our country I
32:59 believe our country. The reason I did this is because you get
33:02 a lot of like, well, a lot of head headwinds.
33:05 You get a lot of headaches from doing a job like this.
33:07 Uh, a lot. It's quite divisive.
33:09 You become a pep. I'm a now politically exposed person
33:11 because, um, Treasury reform. Um, so you get you get a lot of, like,
33:16 issues with do a good job by this. But I made a decision for my two young
33:20 daughters, who are 13 and nine, that I actually see this country as a is a fork
33:25 in the road, and unless we sort it out now, I think it's probably gonna be too
33:29 late. But this was pretty scandalous because
33:31 there has been a number of scandals involving natural flowers that a is it
33:34 more difficult to get donors to invest, and are you still as committed as
33:37 before? I'm 100% committed before donors, 100%
33:41 are as committed before, um, we go around the world, I see other
33:45 presidents, kings, prime ministers around the world that are very
33:49 frustrated with the UK. Uh, you know how many prime ministers
33:52 we've had in the last decade that this was this was the country for stability,
33:56 but this was the country for democracy? Yes.
33:59 And today we are not in that same position.
34:02 Uh, we, we become a bit of a laughingstock in the world.
34:05 And, uh, uh, so we need to sort it out. I believe Nigel will be prime minister,
34:10 uh, when the next election comes. Uh, I'm very confident of that.
34:13 I also believe that within 30 to 60 days of him becoming Prime Minister, I,
34:18 Percy, can help bring 100 billion sterling of direct foreign investment to
34:22 the UK. But Nick, his I mean, he's polling
34:24 terribly right. So you know it's not it's not it's not
34:26 top priority. You don't think the scandal has has
34:29 ruined his man of the people image? For the moment he's really tarnished.
34:34 Listen, I think he's had the political establishment have really, uh, gone up
34:38 against him. You will see whether it's, you know, the
34:41 you'll see with the, uh, the murder of Ann Widdecombe. That same person
34:45 tried to go and murder Nigel earlier, a 15 months before the police did
34:49 nothing about it. Absolutely.
34:50 And I think this is all going to come out.
34:52 You'll see that the left wing media have been briefed by some of our established
34:56 agencies in the UK. Okay?
34:58 The ones that we believe are the they give us the stability of the UK.
35:02 They behave terribly. Now, I don't think the organisations are
35:05 corrupt, but there's people inside the organisations that are corrupt.
35:08 I think you are going to see a lot of things in the next 6 to 12 months
35:12 unravel. Uh, he has to deal with this.
35:15 This £5 million donation he received from Christopher Harben was for
35:19 security. Yes, he has more death threats than any
35:22 other politician in this country. No one inside the, um, the police or,
35:27 uh, the the present government wanted to help him or give him security.
35:31 Um, and he lucky he does have I mean, he has a security.
35:33 He's able to second to none, but he has a lot of death threats.
35:36 Could he have handled it better? Yes.
35:38 Okay. Uh, will he get through it 100%?
35:41 Will he be the next prime Minister? 100%.
35:44 Andy Burnham is putting Brexit back on the table.
35:47 What does that mean for, you know, is there any good of having either a
35:51 referendum or thinking about closer ties with Europe?
35:54 I believe the public already spoken on, uh, Brexit?
35:57 Yeah. So so, um, the question on Brexit is not
36:00 whether it was the right or wrong decision.
36:01 That decision has been made. Okay.
36:03 And we can't just because we don't like the decision keep on changing the
36:06 decision. Okay.
36:07 So but what we can do is we have to execute these things properly.
36:11 You know, the reason why Bloomberg so impressive is because the head of bloom,
36:15 Mr. Michael Bloomberg, does an incredible
36:17 job on executing. He's got great talent and people around
36:21 him. The problem in most governments is the
36:23 talent, quality and the pool of people inside the cabinet.
36:26 I wouldn't have probably any of those people inside any of my businesses.
36:29 That's the problem. Why?
36:30 If you go to the Middle East and you go. Let's take, for example, the UAE.
36:34 The quality of the people the leadership put around them is mind blowing.
36:39 They are they they are. They are better than any one of our
36:43 cabinet ministers today. But I mean, the region is not safe,
36:47 right? So I take these concerns.
36:49 I'm very happy going to the UAE. I've got no issue of whatsoever.
36:52 Yes. I think their financial model has been
36:55 hurt because of the war in Iran. Listen, they've had to spend more money
36:58 in the last, you know, 12 months or less than 12 months, as I remember.
37:02 So that was still less than 12 months into this.
37:04 And that will have to spend some money to help their economy, etc., etc..
37:08 But they're there. They've got they're very wealthy, so
37:11 they've got their sovereign wealth funds, though.
37:13 We'll just have to, um, put some money in different places that they weren't
37:17 expecting, but they can absolutely deal with it.
37:20 Nick, who do you think is still a very strong ally of the UK?
37:23 I know you know President Trump quite well, but there is concern within, um, I
37:28 guess the, the politicians but also businessmen that actually the US is just
37:32 less of an ally than it used to be. I think it depends who's who's going to
37:36 be in power. If Nigel was in power, the special
37:39 relationship is stronger than ever. I don't think we've dealt with a special
37:42 relationship in the best way. I'm not saying that you have to say yes
37:45 to everything because that's not the right thing.
37:47 Yes, you should be able to stand your ground and say, I don't agree with that,
37:49 okay? However, I do believe that the special
37:53 relationship has been strained by Keir Starmer and and Andy Burnham.
37:57 And obviously we've got two different wars going on.
37:59 And one of those issues is that, you know, we want to support Ukraine, which
38:03 is the right thing to do. But over the last, you know, four years
38:06 since the Russia-Ukraine war has been going.
38:09 Europe has bought about $250 billion worth of oil and gas.
38:13 From which country? Russia.
38:15 So we have actually funded the war for Russia by buying all that energy.
38:21 So so there are lots of conflicts going on across the world.
38:25 Conflicts like where you like who you're supporting.
38:28 So publicly support supporting Ukraine in Europe.
38:31 Yes. But actually financially, what's
38:33 supporting Russia? Not meaningfully.
38:35 So there are sanctions. I think there is there is way around it.
38:37 But I mean, due to the midterms, it can change anything in terms of, you know,
38:41 the relationship between the UK and the US.
38:45 Oh, I'm sure they will change a little bit.
38:47 100%, yes. But it's important whoever's in power,
38:51 whether that's labor reform, conservative or any other party.
38:55 Yes. That the special relationship with the
38:57 UK maintains and I believe it. Well, I think there's enough people in
39:00 the different agencies, whether it's our intelligence services, whether it's our
39:03 military services, the work, there's enough people that will that have deep
39:09 relationships, so I do believe it might be a little bit fragmented in places,
39:13 but deep down the structures absolute sound.
39:16 Okay, Nick, thanks so much for joining us.
39:18 Nick Candy, their chief executive of Candy capital and treasurer of Reform
39:21 UK. Now, the rapid build out of AI data
39:24 centres is facing growing pushback over their impact on local communities.
39:28 Alphabet and Google president and chief investment officer Ruth Porat says the
39:32 tech industry needs to prove those investments can benefit the communities
39:36 hosting them. I spoke with her for the latest episodes
39:39 of leaders. There's definitely been
39:43 a rising, rapidly rising concern, and I
39:48 think in part it's incumbent on us and our peers to make it clear that where
39:54 I'll speak for us, we're committed to done right.
39:56 If we go in a community, we're going to add capacity, we're going to invest in
40:01 infrastructure, we're going to immunize costs from what we're using.
40:05 We're going to create jobs, and they are going to be long term, enduring jobs.
40:09 We have a 25 year history. When we build jobs, there's actually a
40:12 multiplier in the community. It's not just the data centers that are
40:16 built, but then people, these are high paying jobs.
40:19 People then go to restaurants that are engaged in the community.
40:22 Same is true with water. You just recently put out a commitment
40:26 series of commitments around water, water conservation.
40:30 We all that we're doing to say we will replenish more than we use.
40:34 We're moving from where water is an issue, from water cold to air cooling.
40:39 Responsible execution is a choice and you have to put capital behind it, but
40:43 it also has to be an industry level. Otherwise, everybody gets a bad rep.
40:48 It ideally is across the whole industry. Many are saying, yes, we agree and we're
40:54 in and done right and we agree with it. And those who doubt we'll have to get
40:58 dragged along because the market will speak and they won't have the
41:01 opportunity. And subscribers can watch the full
41:06 interview online and on the Bloomberg Terminal.
41:08 It airs on Bloomberg TV on Monday. Now coming up, the City of London's new
41:13 mayor targets UK pension investments in a push for competitiveness.
41:17 Well, he joins us next. And this is Bloomberg.
41:33 TV. Welcome back everyone.
41:37 Now the City of London has a new Lord mayor.
41:40 Well, Branagh is targeting UK pension investments as part of a push to improve
41:45 the country's competitiveness. Well, he led insurer Hiscox for more
41:49 than two decades. His appointment comes as the government
41:52 also looks for ways to boost growth. Lord Mayor Bron joins us now.
41:56 Thank you so much. Lord Mayor, I always love to see.
41:59 Of course, you know, you've been in the job for for six days.
42:02 And I know there's big plans and you're all kitted out, as with the Lord mayor.
42:05 Kind of badge of honor. Um, can you discuss a little bit?
42:09 Plans to get more of a of the UK pension savings invested in domestic assets?
42:13 Like, what does that look like concretely?
42:15 Thank you for having me. I think you need to think about sort for
42:18 the opportunity. My number one ambition is to persuade
42:22 people that the United Kingdom is a land of opportunity.
42:25 Opportunities to invest capital. Opportunities to build for talent.
42:30 To build a life and a career. In terms of investment of capital.
42:35 One of my predecessors started the mansion House compact, which then
42:39 evolved to code with very clear targets of 10% of the defined contribution
42:45 assets invested in in private assets by 2030.
42:49 Now, that's just a few years away. So with my predecessor, we've got a
42:54 annual conference called the Connecting Capital Conference.
42:58 She had the first one. I'll have the second one.
43:00 We bringing people together from across the pension industry and contributors,
43:05 employers, trustees, investors and opportunity.
43:10 And I think by putting people in a room, by encouraging them and saying there's a
43:15 bit of a stick. That's how we'll make progress.
43:17 So how can this help with competitiveness?
43:19 And actually, is it fair to trust, you know, trustees and asset managers to
43:25 calculate and look at risk? Yes, I think it's a very good return.
43:28 I'm not asking people to make a patriotic investment.
43:31 If you look at the UK, we have over 200 unicorns businesses with more than
43:37 billion, over a thousand, with revenues of over 25 million growing fast.
43:42 The unicorns of tomorrow. They're really great businesses to
43:45 invest them. And over the last 20 years, UK private
43:48 capital put out a survey earlier in the year which said there was a 12.4%
43:53 annualized return. That means if you've invested 20 years
43:57 ago for every pound you put in, it would not be worth over eight.
44:01 So pension trustees, in my view, uh, failing in their budgetary duty.
44:06 If they're not asking, how do we get to these great returns?
44:09 But to make it work, do you need tax incentives?
44:11 No, because if somebody said to you, please invest here a pound and you'll
44:17 get 8 or £10 back later. That's enough incentive in my view.
44:22 More risk though. A little bit more risk.
44:24 But everything's risky, you know. But over 20 years, the risks tend to
44:29 iron themselves out. Yes.
44:30 Over one year volatility is high. But over five years or ten years
44:34 volatility tends to go down. So I think and especially pensions are a
44:39 long term investment. They shouldn't be thinking what's
44:42 happening the next three months. But what's happening in ten years or 20
44:45 years. And so in that time frame volatility is
44:48 not a problem. So today's the biggest IPO the world's
44:50 ever seen. We're talking about indeed.
44:52 What are some of the conversations that you're planning to have with, you know,
44:56 regulators uh, you know of course, you know, politicians and other
45:01 stakeholders. I think coming back to the overall
45:04 message. The United Kingdom's a land of
45:06 opportunity. When you speak to local people here in
45:09 the UK, they say, well, yes, quite so. They raised their eyes heavenward.
45:13 So but London is the best place to the UK is the best place to start a business
45:17 out of your own country. If you're going to start a business
45:21 where you are, you know best coming to the United Kingdom, you know there's a
45:25 fantastic rule of law. The regulators have no home side
45:28 advantage. We're very open that sometimes weakness,
45:32 but quite frankly, for attracting capital and talent like yourself, that
45:36 makes it a very good place to come and work, to come and invest and come and
45:41 build a business. And if you're building a business, you
45:44 shouldn't be worried about what's happened between now and Christmas.
45:47 You should be looking at five years or ten years.
45:49 And the one thing about our country, you'll know that in five years time or
45:52 ten years time, it'll certainly be here. Things will probably be a bit better,
45:57 and we should all be working to make it a lot better.
45:59 And capital and talent is what we need to to capture those opportunities.
46:04 What's your your take on the UK regulations being more aligned with EU
46:09 regulations for financial services? I think we already have been able to
46:13 build a FSA business here post-Brexit. Clearly we'd like to reduce barriers to
46:20 doing business in the EU, but also with other countries around the world.
46:25 The lower the barriers, the more we can all do business together.
46:28 Views on the ultimate destination will be mixed.
46:31 But I think everyone can say yes, making it easier to do business together.
46:35 It'll be a good thing. Do you think it's achievable?
46:38 It's always possible to find things to improve.
46:41 And so it depends how far you want to go.
46:43 But we should rather take the first step and see if we can make things better,
46:48 rather than using all our energy to argue about the ultimate destination.
46:52 Because even without getting to whatever destination, people prefer actually
46:57 making things better. Today we have the EU UK summit tomorrow
47:03 and the good things coming out of that. Things like linking the emissions
47:07 trading scheme between the EU and the UK will make it a lot easier at the carbon
47:13 border adjustment mechanism. Resolving that
47:17 movement for young people. All good things to achieve.
47:22 And we don't have to have decided the ultimate destination, other than a
47:25 willingness to reduce the barriers to being and interacting together.
47:29 But here on this UK, use them into the city wants financial services to be part
47:35 of the talks in negotiations. Is there an easy win for the City of
47:38 London? At the moment, financial services are
47:41 not part of the conversation, so I think we should rather leave that to the next
47:45 one. First, you have to persuade and persuade
47:48 the EU to put it on the table. Then we can start discussing what the
47:51 particular asks are. I'm sure they will have asks of us, but
47:55 we need to get the conversation going first.
47:57 Lord Mayor, such a great pleasure to meet you and of course, speak to you six
48:01 days into the job. That was ironic.
48:03 There was the Lord mayor of the City of London.
48:05 So we know it's a big day for a number of reasons.
48:07 First of all, it's geopolitics with everything that's going on in China.
48:11 And we just saw pictures half an hour ago about Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin
48:15 meeting also with Xi Jinping and of course, anthropic, the biggest IPO the
48:20 world has ever seen, shares indicating a 24% higher on the grey markets.
48:25 If you look at derivatives and crypto perpetual futures also trading at a
48:29 premium to anthropic pricing. So this is probably the biggest story of
48:33 the day. But there's just a lot going on.
48:34 We just had a great conversation also on financial services.
48:37 Up next it's Bloomberg Brief and this is Bloomberg.
CITI CEO Jane Fraser full transcript
0:00 joining today and I am surprised you're
0:01 not all checking out your allocations
0:03 now that the deal's priced. Um it's
0:06 lovely being here. Look, this is as you
0:08 say, this is the biggest uh IPO that
0:10 we've seen. Um and it's one that's got a
0:14 lot of institutional demand behind it as
0:16 well as retail demand. It's got a lot of
0:18 international demand as well as North
0:20 America demand. So I think that that's
0:23 in many ways a barometer for the health
0:26 of the capital markets and also a
0:28 barometer for the health of the AI
0:30 ecosystem. So as we think about the IPO
0:34 markets for going forward um it it tends
0:37 to be a pretty thin market anyway
0:39 towards the end of the year. So I think
0:40 it's more about 27 than it is about 26
0:44 from that perspective. But obviously
0:46 this is going to be a good thing and it
0:48 remember it comes on the back of the
0:49 Nvidia earnings yesterday which also
0:52 surprised the market positively. We
0:54 could do with positive surprises at the
0:56 moment. Um and uh you know I think their
0:59 their forward guidance was also quite
1:02 strong. So I think more confidence in
1:04 the AI ecosystem is is a good thing.
1:07 >> Do you have a pretty big pipeline for
1:09 the beginning of 2027? In other words,
1:11 is the anthropic IPO the opening salvo
1:14 to a host of other transactions both in
1:16 the AI world and beyond or is it kind of
1:19 the door closing on a pretty amazing
1:21 year for IPOs, a record year?
1:23 >> Uh, no. I think it's it should be um
1:26 good news for the IPOs that that will be
1:28 coming in 27 and that there may well be
1:31 some that come towards the back end of
1:33 this year as well. It's just where the
1:35 calendar is, it makes it it makes it
1:36 tighter on that. Um, and I I think it's
1:39 it's positive for what's been quite a
1:42 thin tech IPO market um, this year as
1:46 many people have been waiting for the
1:48 for this one. After SpaceX, Nvidia did
1:50 report earnings that were better than
1:52 expected, increased their guidance. That
1:54 wasn't what really people cared about.
1:56 People were looking at other things in
1:57 particular whether they were going to
1:58 finance anything and who their next
1:59 executive leader will be. Uh, I'm just
2:02 wondering from your perspective how big
2:04 of a concern it is that the central bank
2:06 of AI might be going away.
2:09 >> Oh, I look the the genie is out of the
2:12 bottle on AI and no one's putting that
2:14 genie back in the bottle. Um, when we
2:17 think about the amount of I look at it
2:19 the amount of compute that is in demand
2:22 and I'm not just I mean a lot of that
2:24 centers in America but I'm not just
2:26 seeing it there. I was in Turkey the
2:27 other day. they're building their first
2:29 data center because they're worried if
2:31 they don't they won't be able to compete
2:34 um in industry after industry. So this
2:37 this is a global phenomenon at the
2:39 moment certainly centered in the states.
2:41 Um but I I wouldn't be I wouldn't be so
2:45 concerned with the all of the doomsday
2:47 predictions on a AI and the rest of it.
2:50 Um it's it's uh I I think we're in we're
2:53 in reasonable shape. At the same time in
2:55 your third quarter earnings, Cityroup
2:57 did say that AI financing risk was a key
3:01 risk or uncertainty and it was the first
3:02 time that it appeared. What were you
3:04 referring to in particular there?
3:06 >> Look, it's it's as I say, it's the
3:08 largest um buildout that we've seen um
3:11 in modern history in a very capital
3:13 inensive way. Um and it it um there's a
3:17 lot of promise and opportunity there,
3:19 but we're we're at the picks and shovels
3:21 phase as everyone likes to say. Um it's
3:25 a very big infra buildout. It's energy
3:27 chips. It's the data centers. I mean
3:29 there's the frontier models. There is a
3:31 lot going to this one and not everyone
3:33 will be a winner. There are always
3:35 winners and losers uh in these things.
3:38 So just given the amounts of money
3:40 involved and the other pieces, you would
3:42 hope that one of the nation's largest
3:44 banks was focused and making sure that
3:47 we manage the risk responsibly. Um but
3:49 we're in the business of taking risk.
3:51 Um, and therefore obviously we we keep
3:54 an eye on these things.
3:55 >> A lot of people point to the United
3:56 States as being sort of the epicenter of
3:59 both the risk and the reward tied to AI.
4:01 The ECB was saying that this is a huge
4:02 systemic risk and that this could
4:04 potentially be another uh subprime
4:06 bubble.
4:06 >> They're jealous.
4:09 >> Explain. I mean, is it a feature or a
4:11 bug? Because it does sort of concentrate
4:13 risk around one technology really having
4:16 gains. Um this is probably where I
4:17 become one of those um zealot Americans
4:19 of having chosen to come and join this
4:22 country um as a as an immigrant of uh
4:25 many years ago now. But look what what's
4:28 the magic that that the US has um it is
4:32 our ability to both in the innovation
4:35 that this country can do at scale
4:38 matched with the capital market. Think
4:41 about it. The US has 4% of the world's
4:43 population and over 50% of the market
4:47 capitalization of the world. You you
4:50 think about industry after industry
4:53 where not only can we innovate but we
4:55 can do so at scale and then we can
4:59 support um we can support the
5:00 entrepreneurs as they build out and take
5:03 chances in some places. You're not
5:04 guaranteed success. Um but but it is
5:07 quite unique. Capital markets is a very
5:10 important part of funding the debt, the
5:12 equity, the risk management, the breadth
5:14 and depth, the savings that get deployed
5:16 into investment. So others can
5:18 participate in this. Whereas I look at
5:21 the UK where I come from or parts of
5:23 Europe and had this conversation in
5:27 France, there are a lot of the top
5:28 French entrepreneurs who are superb in
5:31 the AI space.
5:33 They're here. They're in the west coast.
5:35 They're in the states. there are far
5:37 fewer that are in France. Um I look in
5:41 the UK where conversations with the
5:43 government there where they're trying to
5:45 understand how did they scale up their
5:47 their ventures kind of plateau and
5:50 they're not able to scale from here and
5:52 that's why I think we see so much
5:54 entrepreneurship
5:56 um coming many of the roads leading to
5:58 America we underappreciate that here.
6:02 >> Yeah.
6:02 >> Yeah. We just had an election and we did
6:06 I think it happened about three months
6:08 ago given everything it feels like given
6:11 everything that we're seeing. Um, and
6:12 some people have talked about how that
6:14 could potentially sty some of the data
6:15 center buildout or potentially just the
6:17 AI trade in general.
6:19 >> How are you hearing about that from your
6:21 clients in terms of whether they're
6:23 trying to speed up their projects to get
6:25 ahead of it or how concerned they are?
6:27 >> Yeah, I mean, I think the the election
6:29 had a number of different issues on
6:31 affordability. It had it around AI, some
6:33 of the anti-establishment. Um and I was
6:36 I was over in California um last week
6:39 and I I was I was happy to see that this
6:43 is not falling on deaf ears. I think
6:45 there is a recognition that when we have
6:47 been investing at this scale and speed
6:52 some the communities have been left
6:53 behind. There hasn't been enough of the
6:55 win-win. And I think I've heard a lot
6:58 more of that recognition um from the
7:00 tech firms and not just in the AI space,
7:02 but more broadly that you've got to make
7:05 this something that is beneficial for
7:06 the communities you're in. What is it
7:09 you're doing to protect if it's on the
7:11 energy cost front? There are plenty of
7:13 things to do on energy supply and energy
7:15 pricing. Make sure the community doesn't
7:18 um have a detrimental impact. There can
7:21 be um benefits given to local schools,
7:23 you know, free lunches, um better
7:26 salaries for the for the teachers. Like
7:28 there's a lot of different things that
7:29 can be done that some of the the
7:32 benefits that the tech firms are getting
7:35 um also translate into the communities
7:38 in which you operate. And I think it's
7:39 one of the things we as banks um have
7:42 learned that this is so critical if
7:44 we're expecting to retain trust. Um, we
7:47 certainly had to earn a lot of that back
7:49 off the great financial crisis and there
7:51 are plenty of ways to do this. I'm
7:54 encouraged. I was I was I think this is
7:56 not falling on deaf ears. Yeah,
7:58 >> it does seem like this hasn't been a
8:00 great week for tech trust when it comes
8:02 to trusting our technology considering
8:04 the FAA went down and so did Apple and
8:07 JP Morgan experienced problems. There
8:09 have been all these tech outages. Should
8:10 we go buy gold bars? Oh, look, I I I can
8:15 I can empathize a lot as to why this is
8:18 unsettling at the moment. There's been a
8:20 lot in the last couple of weeks. Um, but
8:23 let's, you know, take a little bit of a
8:25 step back. What, and I just give some
8:28 reassurance. um the volume of changes,
8:33 the patches that is going through the
8:36 world's tech stack at the same time is
8:39 you know five tenfold what we've ever
8:41 seen before and you know it shouldn't be
8:45 a complete surprise to anyone that that
8:48 doesn't always go well but it doesn't
8:50 mean it's a disaster. Um, so what we're
8:54 seeing is, and we should be expecting
8:56 for a while, some more downtime, some
8:59 more outages in different areas as we
9:02 upgrade the tech stacks to the latest
9:04 versions of different releases to
9:06 putting the patches to the
9:08 vulnerabilities. And at the end of the
9:10 day, it will make us all a lot um more
9:14 resilient. Um, word that we've all been
9:16 learning. That's both emotional, mental,
9:18 and physical. Um, but it builds
9:21 resiliency and that's going to be very
9:23 important because these models are
9:25 powerful and in bad actors hands they
9:27 can be a problem. Um, and I think it's
9:30 just reinforcing the need to make
9:31 investments in modernizing our
9:33 technology um, and in making sure that
9:36 we're thinking about resiliency. But we
9:39 shouldn't be surprised this is
9:40 happening. I think when the models the
9:43 really powerful models came out six
9:44 months ago, we knew that this was likely
9:47 to happen just given the volume of
9:49 changes. So I I it's just we're very
9:54 good at adapting in this country.
9:56 >> I guess in this rough period I mean is
9:58 there a chance that the payment system
9:59 could go down?
10:03 >> Is there a chance it goes down? you
10:05 know, the bits of it might at some point
10:07 from a downtime or or others as we're
10:10 upgrading different elements of it, but
10:12 we're ready for that, right? We we spent
10:14 years um investing in making sure that
10:18 someone else doesn't bring it down. But
10:20 if it's because we're upgrading the
10:22 technology, we're upgrading different
10:23 pieces, then, you know, we've got really
10:26 good plans in place as how does all of
10:28 this recover? How do you get back online
10:31 quickly? And we've seen that the last
10:33 while. It's not just if it goes down,
10:35 it's how quickly do you get things back
10:37 up again and working quickly. And the
10:40 companies have all got a lot of plans as
10:42 to how to do this. And it's not just
10:44 from cyber. It can be from, you know,
10:47 someone making a mistake. It can be from
10:48 a bug in there.
10:50 >> So, I mean, when I first saw Jane, I I
10:54 asked her, should we all go to Costco
10:56 and buy a lot of toilet paper? And she
10:57 said, absolutely you should because the
10:59 city sponsors their card. Yeah. Yeah. I
11:02 don't even use the city Costco credit
11:04 card, however. Yes. There you go. When
11:06 it comes to your own deployment, I
11:08 promise we will get to other things
11:09 other than artificial intelligence, but
11:11 today, you know,
11:12 >> no, it's an important topic for sure.
11:14 Yes.
11:15 >> I just wonder how much right now is it a
11:17 cost center versus actually a cost
11:19 efficiency issue right now?
11:21 >> Oh, look, this is a technology that is
11:24 going to um unlock a lot of growth and
11:26 revenue. is going to unlock a lot of
11:29 productivity um and efficiency gains and
11:31 is also going to require a lot of money
11:33 to be sent. So I think of it in our bank
11:35 where are we going to earn money where
11:37 are we going to save money and where we
11:38 going to spend money. Um the first use
11:41 cases in AI tended to be in in coding.
11:44 Um so you saw some we saw a big uplift
11:47 in productivity in coding from that and
11:50 I know as a bank that means we've been
11:52 able to save some money and then invest
11:54 it um for growth and for new features
11:57 new capabilities going forward. Um the
12:02 savings it's certainly going to help
12:04 drive productivity and that does mean
12:07 there'll be areas where there'll be job
12:08 changes and job losses. Um equally
12:11 there's going to be areas new product
12:13 development life cycles are much
12:15 shorter. New features are becoming
12:17 possible. New areas where um you're
12:20 going to be able to earn more growth and
12:21 more revenue that will create jobs. We
12:24 don't know if the puts and and takes
12:26 will be the same. And then there's areas
12:28 where we're spending money and
12:29 investing. Cyber being one of them. Um
12:32 but not the only one. Fraud protections.
12:34 Um there's a range of different areas
12:36 that are defensive um that we're using
12:39 the the AI models to invest and protect
12:42 because of new things that bad actors
12:44 could do. So all of this coming
12:46 together. It's such early days that um
12:50 you we're starting to see all of these
12:52 different areas bear fruit. Some of them
12:54 in positive ways, some of them not in
12:56 positive ways. But it it is a mixture of
12:59 all of them. In five years, do you
13:01 expect city to have a smaller employee
13:04 base?
13:05 >> I I honestly don't know the answer to
13:07 that question. We're certainly working
13:09 hard to make sure that we have grown the
13:11 company responsibly. Um, and that we've
13:15 done so in a way that retains trust of
13:17 our customers, our investors, the
13:19 communities we serve. Um, and that that
13:22 enables us to or have a different
13:24 composition of our of our workforce. Um,
13:27 I would love it to be the same or
13:28 bigger. Yeah.
13:30 >> How much of your day do you spend trying
13:32 to figure out how to patch up systems
13:34 without crashing the whole thing?
13:36 >> Um, a lot of time actually has gone into
13:38 that. I think this is one of the areas
13:40 where the private sector in the states
13:41 has really stood up because a lot of the
13:44 critical infrastructure is privately
13:46 owned in this country. And so we we've
13:49 had several initiatives. The banks I
13:52 think as Jay Clayton was talking about
13:54 the day really are at the forefront
13:56 because it's been a decade plus
13:59 investment and collaboration on cyber.
14:01 We do not compete on cyber
14:04 or compete on the death for pitching the
14:06 anthropic IPO. Um but when it comes to
14:09 these different areas, it's a case of
14:12 how do we really work together to make
14:14 sure the system is safe. Um, so I've I
14:18 spend a lot of time on um where are we
14:21 patching, what are we doing to protect
14:22 our perimeter. I also spend a lot of
14:25 time talking to um smaller firms. I was
14:28 just with a group of banks this morning
14:30 explaining what are we doing to make
14:33 sure that we're hardening our cyber
14:35 capabilities and the bank. What are we
14:37 doing to make sure our people ready as
14:39 possible for where there are downtimes
14:41 and getting getting up and working
14:44 quickly again? Um and this is where
14:47 there's I I would say there's a lot of
14:49 collaboration going on in the private
14:51 sector which is you know necessary and
14:54 and good to see.
14:55 >> Do you want an agent my personal agent
14:58 muse would that be able to access my
15:00 personal bank account at city?
15:02 >> Absolutely no way.
15:05 >> Why?
15:06 >> There's no way. Um because again we have
15:09 to move fast but maintain trust.
15:12 you you don't want me um letting muse
15:15 accessing and we suddenly discover that
15:17 it's authorized to go and take a lot
15:18 more money out of your bank account than
15:20 you wanted to. Um and we this is such
15:23 new technology ultimately I can see that
15:26 being in place. Um but I think you're
15:28 hearing from all the large banks and and
15:31 others that you know we're we're not
15:33 going to unleash these um without having
15:36 the right risk and control protections
15:38 in place so that you are unprotected in
15:41 your your money, your data and other
15:45 elements. Um the the uh the control
15:48 framework's not there yet. So it will
15:50 come and we'll put it in, but we're not
15:52 going to get ahead of our skis here. Is
15:54 there a competitive aspect to this to
15:56 try to get younger clients who are using
15:58 these devices more significantly or it's
16:01 just too early days at this point?
16:02 >> This we will disrupt ourselves but we
16:06 will only do so responsibly. Um the you
16:10 period full stop. um it's just not
16:13 something that I think you're going to
16:14 see um banks being willing to let go of
16:19 controls that could cause a problem for
16:21 the system or could cause a problem for
16:24 our customers. um we're going to do this
16:27 quickly but when we're comfortable that
16:30 we can manage risk at the same speed as
16:32 innovation and then everyone should
16:34 watch out um because we've got the scale
16:36 to apply the innovation to um and you
16:39 asked me the question about bug or
16:41 feature um I would say that innovation
16:43 is a feature of America um but I think
16:47 we do this responsibly we don't do this
16:49 shooting from the hip
16:51 >> we're in Washington DC it is a time of
16:54 big political ical change. I want to
16:56 start by by talking about your
16:58 relationship with President Trump. You
17:00 have developed a pretty close
17:01 relationship with President Trump in
17:02 terms of being a collaborator and you
17:04 were on the last trip to China. Given
17:07 that there currently is a meeting
17:09 between uh Xiinping and President Trump
17:11 right now, any insight that you got from
17:14 that meeting?
17:15 >> Yeah, it was a well, I'd say it was a a
17:17 privilege to be able to attend. We're a
17:19 company with a big global presence and
17:22 so being able to join um the president
17:24 and a number of the other CEOs on the
17:26 trip um just to be part of the US
17:29 delegation those are certain privileges
17:32 you never imagine in your life. Um on
17:35 this one I think what I took away that
17:36 was very encouraging was um the real
17:39 focus on stabilizing the relationship
17:41 between the two. um certainly very clear
17:44 that there are a number of areas where
17:46 it is um you know complete competition
17:49 between the two countries but there's a
17:51 lot of other areas where there is
17:53 collaboration and I think the mindset
17:56 really from both was that you know
17:58 there's too much to lose by not engaging
18:02 um you know from both sides and frankly
18:04 for everyone and so the engagement was
18:07 very good um but there was certainly
18:09 plenty of areas of disagreement um but
18:12 if you don't engage when you've got, you
18:14 know, the two biggest powers in the
18:16 world, then you really do have a
18:18 problem. When something goes wrong, you
18:20 don't have the deescalation channels.
18:22 You're not picking up the phone to talk
18:23 it through. Um, so I I took that away as
18:26 a a positive. City has uh one of the
18:29 biggest presences in China as any US
18:31 bank. And I'm wondering how you maintain
18:35 the balance given the fact that these
18:37 two nations do have a rivalry and can be
18:40 in opposition. How difficult is that?
18:42 It's very it's very simple. We serve 70%
18:46 of the Fortune 500 that operate in China
18:49 and you would much rather that is on our
18:53 rails for foreign exchange, cash
18:56 management, trade, payroll, etc. Um and
18:59 that that's those are the rails that are
19:01 connecting the world to China um for
19:03 those multinationals.
19:05 And so it's um and we also help connect
19:09 some of the Chinese companies in the
19:11 areas that it's not the outright
19:13 competition as you'd imagine um with the
19:15 states um to the rest of the world where
19:17 there is the collaborative relationship.
19:20 Um but you absolutely want this on on US
19:23 rails. You don't you don't want it on
19:25 other ones. It's it it's part of
19:28 American economic security.
19:31 There's also been a big shift in
19:32 Washington DC uh politically and the
19:35 head of the next banking committee of
19:38 the Senate next year is probably going
19:39 to be Senator Elizabeth Warren. Uh she's
19:41 had some pretty strong words about City
19:43 in the past. Just this July she came out
19:45 with a press release warning city
19:47 against making any acquisitions saying
19:50 the city grew irresponsibly from 1995 to
19:52 2007. Of course, you were forced to
19:54 clean that up afterwards when you came
19:56 in. How do you respond to someone like
20:00 Senator Warren who's been very critical
20:02 of city's past as an incredibly
20:05 fundamental institution that was
20:07 instrumental in a lot of the pain in
20:08 2008? I I think all of us have a lot of
20:11 respect for Senator Warren. Um, and
20:15 there's a lot of different areas that
20:17 we'll be able to we we'll agree to
20:19 disagree in certain areas, but there's
20:20 plenty of opportunity to work together
20:23 on a lot of the different issues that
20:24 are that are concerning for the American
20:27 people and we will be looking forward to
20:30 doing that. Um, what I would say in
20:32 terms of the question about city is I I
20:35 would respectfully ask Senator Warren to
20:37 look at the bank that we are today and
20:39 not that the bank that we were. Um we
20:42 have we have made very significant
20:44 changes to what city is. Um and huge
20:48 investments in risk and controls. Um
20:51 huge investments in our infrastructure
20:53 to modernize it to simplify the bank. um
20:57 to make sure that it is able to serve um
21:00 both here at home but also very critical
21:03 roles serving American companies around
21:06 the world um responsibly and effectively
21:08 and being a source of strength and and
21:11 um and stability for them as they
21:14 operate internationally um and helping
21:17 fund the success of companies um here in
21:20 the states. So an enormous investment in
21:23 risk and controls, an enormous
21:24 investment in our infrastructure,
21:27 but we've also simplified the bank a
21:29 lot. We have five businesses now rather
21:32 than trying to be everything to
21:33 everybody everywhere. Um those five
21:36 business lines sit at my table. Um my
21:40 husband will tell you I'm a hands-on
21:42 manager. Um and um you know we're making
21:46 sure that you that we are running this
21:49 directly rather than more like a holding
21:51 company which is some of the ways it's
21:53 been done in the past. Um and that we're
21:56 very engaged in um making sure that we
22:00 support small businesses, the different
22:03 size banks, different institutions
22:04 throughout the country, as well as
22:06 making sure that American companies are
22:08 competitive as they operate globally.
22:11 and we uniquely do that. So, um I I I
22:15 trust and hope she would judge us on who
22:18 we are today and not who we were because
22:20 we our people have worked incredibly
22:22 hard. I'm so proud of them um of going
22:25 through some tough years where we really
22:27 transformed the bank. It was blood,
22:29 sweat, and tears, but I think we're
22:30 seeing the fruits. And anyone who says
22:32 that a bank can't multitask, um I won't
22:36 make any gender comments here. um we
22:39 were we were able to um both grow and um
22:43 you know to transform the bank at the
22:45 same time and and really simplify it. So
22:48 never not done yet. Still a bit to go
22:50 but uh it's a very different
22:52 institution. I hope she will recognize
22:54 that because we want to work together.
22:56 We don't want to be working at odds. I
22:58 don't think that's constructive for
22:59 anybody. There's been a feeling that
23:02 this will be a less conducive period to
23:04 mergers and acquisitions as a result of
23:06 some of the the crackdown. From your own
23:08 personal perspective, do you think that
23:11 the door has kind of closed for any kind
23:13 of like regional bank acquisitions or
23:14 asset management acquisitions or do you
23:16 think that if it was rational, it would
23:18 still be open? Oh, I I think it should
23:20 be open because some consolidation is
23:23 healthy. I I do think I I do think the
23:26 US has a very good structure because
23:28 this is as I say it's a large country
23:30 statement of the blindingly obvious but
23:32 having the big global banks and the role
23:35 that we play in supporting the global
23:37 financial system and the the American
23:39 power globally is important. You have
23:42 the the the large national banks. You
23:45 have the regional banks and spent the
23:48 the morning as I say with group of the
23:50 community and smaller banks in
23:52 particular really important roles.
23:54 Everyone plays their part in in the
23:57 system in a way that you don't see in
23:59 other countries. Um and in some of them
24:02 you know some some consolidation is very
24:04 healthy. We have over 4,000 banks. So um
24:08 it's oh we've got plenty to do at the
24:11 moment. Um I I think I see I see plenty
24:14 of organic growth opportunities for
24:17 city. You don't need to look in
24:18 organically. Um but I that I do think
24:21 there's some additional consolidation
24:23 that isn't creating problems in the
24:26 system but is actually healthy because
24:28 it's expensive to do all the fraud
24:30 investment, the cyber investment, the
24:33 technology investments, these things. So
24:35 um getting a few more players who are
24:37 larger in through all parts of that
24:40 stack I think that's a good thing.
24:42 >> Do you think that the US economy right
24:44 now is strong enough to handle a 50
24:46 basis point rate hike next week or next
24:49 next month?
24:50 >> Look the the economy is doing well. I
24:53 think the issue it's uneven. It's
24:55 certainly not being felt evenly across
24:57 the country. Um how well the economy is
24:59 performing. We're seeing um a very
25:02 stable labor market. Um so the it's a
25:07 low fire low hire environment but
25:09 nonetheless it's it's pretty close to
25:11 full employment. Um you've got consumer
25:14 spending that is strong and um we have
25:17 seen I'm really happy to see at the
25:20 lower income households they've more
25:22 been flat rather than going down. People
25:24 talk about a K. It's more like the
25:26 alligator mouth like that. Um and we'd
25:30 rather see the low income performing
25:31 even more strongly. Um but it it's not
25:34 getting it's not getting worse. Um so my
25:39 my bigger concern frankly on the rate
25:41 front is the the causes of the
25:44 inflation. I'm not sure the rate hike
25:46 actually fixes it because we're seeing
25:49 it from diesel. We're seeing it from low
25:52 supply of housing. We we need 7 million
25:54 more affordable housing in in the
25:57 states. It's a we've got a supply
25:59 problem there. um and it takes a long
26:03 time to build refineries around the
26:05 world, which is what you need to do um
26:07 to address the diesel issues that's
26:08 driving up prices. So, I think one of
26:11 the concerns many of the banks has is
26:14 yep, the the numbers came in hot. We
26:17 could well see rate hikes, but does it
26:19 actually fix the problem that's
26:22 underpinning it? And that's my nagging
26:24 concern at the moment. It doesn't then
26:26 it's kind of a boiling the frog moment
26:28 where you have people who are really uh
26:30 hurt by higher inflation at the same
26:32 time at the hurt from higher rates.
26:34 >> Do you think that people are
26:35 underestimating the chance of a
26:37 slowdown?
26:38 >> Are you at city taking down risk in any
26:40 way in preparation for that or do you
26:42 think that is unlikely because of all of
26:44 the investment that we're seeing from
26:45 other places?
26:46 >> Um you have to be prepared for
26:48 everything all the time particularly in
26:49 the environment we're in. Like the last
26:51 two weeks is a case in point. You
26:52 wouldn't have expected that. And I think
26:54 we've all got very good at being more
26:57 adaptable and being more resilient,
27:00 building in more buffers, being ready
27:02 for more things happening. Um, and I
27:04 think that's part of the reason why the
27:06 world economy has done pretty well in
27:08 the last five years despite wars and
27:11 COVID and tariffs and all these other
27:13 things have been thrown at it. Um, so
27:16 you have to be ready for a slowdown and
27:18 something that's more material. I don't
27:21 see it as being imminent, but the tail
27:23 risks are certainly bigger than they
27:24 were before. Um, and in that one, we've
27:28 got to be ready to support the
27:30 affordability agenda that, um, is the
27:32 reason we had the big shift in the
27:34 election. Um, the the prices are high.
27:37 Um, I think the other piece companies
27:40 are being very mindful about not passing
27:42 on some of the price increases through
27:44 to consumers because there's a clear
27:47 understanding earnings have been good.
27:49 Let's try and absorb as much of this as
27:51 possible through the earnings we've got
27:55 um and try to make sure the investments
27:57 are still going to give growth into the
27:59 economy um rather than uh rather than
28:02 passing this on to consumers um
28:05 recklessly.
28:07 >> What do you think right now is the
28:08 biggest risk that people are
28:10 underestimating? because clearly there's
28:13 a sense that maybe there's an
28:15 overbuilding in AI or maybe there's a I
28:18 don't want to say bubble but excess is
28:20 happening in certain pockets there.
28:22 Maybe you get rates that rise that kill
28:24 the party. What's your sense?
28:26 >> I I I don't think I don't think anyone's
28:29 um overestimating or underestimating
28:31 anything at the moment. And I think
28:32 we're all very mindful that we've got,
28:35 you know, an economy that continues to
28:37 perform well, not unevenly, but still
28:40 perform well in the aggregate. Um, and
28:43 that there's a number of different tail
28:44 risks. We know what they are. Um, so I
28:48 think the biggest risk we have is if
28:50 they start converging. Um, so if you
28:52 start seeing them feed off each other,
28:54 then that's when you tend to get more of
28:56 a self-fulfilling prophecy coming. I
28:59 don't see that yet, but it, you know,
29:01 it's a possibility at some point. What I
29:04 am happy is to see some of the air come
29:06 out of the tires. We had a market that
29:08 was priced to perfection. We have some
29:10 AI concentration risk in there. We've
29:12 had a big election um with a big shift
29:15 and change around um and as you say,
29:18 we've had the leadership change in um in
29:20 one of the big companies in AI. all of
29:23 those different pieces. You know, we're
29:25 seeing some of the market react to that
29:27 at the moment. At the same time, you see
29:29 Anthropic with a what looks like will be
29:32 a very successful IPO um when it comes
29:35 out tomorrow and you know, giving
29:38 confidence in about the Genie not being
29:41 out of the bottle on AI and that you
29:43 know this should continue on. But we've
29:46 all got to be mindful. Let's do this
29:47 responsibly.
29:49 Bring everyone along with us and and
29:51 manage the risks.
29:53 I'm gonna open it up to questions. Uh if
29:55 anyone has any questions, uh please just
29:58 state your name and your affiliation and
30:00 uh I'll open up now.
30:04 >> Nobody has any questions. I'll keep
30:06 going.
30:07 >> Yeah.
30:10 >> Thank you. U love to hear your thoughts
30:12 on u digital currency.
30:15 >> Oh.
30:16 >> Um and the the crossair between
30:19 regulation
30:20 control. Yeah.
30:22 >> To continue to make money but yet still
30:24 efficient.
30:25 >> Yeah.
30:26 >> And uh not only of course your emphasis
30:29 these days I believe your bank is
30:32 institutional side not the retail side.
30:34 So I'd love to hear your thoughts
30:36 because that could potentially be
30:38 somewhat different.
30:38 >> Yeah.
30:39 >> Thank you for your presentation.
30:41 >> Yeah it's um it's very easy when new
30:44 technologies come to go chasing shiny
30:46 objects. Um and to avoid doing that you
30:49 say okay what is it that your customers
30:51 need um and and what what are they
30:54 looking for? So on the institutional
30:56 side as customers are looking at um a
30:58 world where they want to move their
31:00 money around instantly um always on so
31:04 24/7 365 days. Um they want to do so in
31:08 a way that is um not clunky. They want
31:11 um they want it to be efficient. So not
31:13 not expensive. Um and they want it most
31:15 importantly as well to be done securely
31:18 and safely um given what we see when um
31:22 when bad actors can get in the way
31:24 there. So that's that's that's what we
31:26 are looking that's what we expect the
31:29 system to be moving to and solving for
31:31 how to how to have all of that. It
31:33 sounds like have your cake and eat it
31:35 without calories but actually this is
31:37 sol this is doable to get there. Um and
31:40 what we're watching is adoption of these
31:44 new digital um asset capabilities and
31:47 technologies operating at the same time
31:50 with with the traditional rails and you
31:53 want that to be interoperable between
31:55 them. Um and um lots of these
31:58 technologies are fascinating alone but
32:01 alone is part of the problem if they
32:03 don't all work together in a work way
32:05 that's easy for a client. Um I think in
32:08 terms of digital currencies, um we're
32:10 going to see more of the tokenization
32:13 as the preferred technology because
32:16 stable coin means a central bank doesn't
32:18 necessarily have control of their
32:19 currency and I think that will be
32:22 unpopular with them if they lose control
32:24 of their currencies. Um whereas a
32:26 tokenization gives the customers be they
32:29 retail or be they institutional exactly
32:32 the same benefits they want but without
32:34 some of the um the challenges in the
32:36 payment system um on cross border if it
32:40 was uh more of a coinbased technology.
32:42 So I think tokenization would be the one
32:44 that wins but it's not happening
32:46 overnight. Our bank moves a I mean it's
32:49 a staggering for for in for
32:51 multinational companies and and
32:53 institutions. We move $6 trillion a day
32:58 around the world. At the moment we're
33:00 only moving about $2 billion worth in
33:03 digitized tokenized form. So it's it's
33:07 really minuscule. It's growing quickly
33:09 but clients aren't quite ready to adopt
33:11 it yet. You know they're not ready for
33:13 always on and they're not ready for 365.
33:17 So it these things these technologies
33:19 and their possibilities always happen
33:21 faster than actually the diffusion does.
33:24 I suspect the same is going to be true
33:26 of AI AI by the way. Um and with all
33:29 innovations if innovation happens at at
33:32 speed you want risk management to happen
33:34 at speed too. Um, so making sure we've
33:37 got the right protections for consumers,
33:40 investors in in in place really is
33:44 important because then you can innovate
33:45 faster. Yeah. So that that's sort of how
33:48 we see it. But yeah, we we're not in the
33:50 shiny object business. So we'd rather go
33:53 for what our customers need rather than
33:55 uh otherwise.
34:00 >> Hi. Uh, thank you. Uh, Chris Rugver at
34:03 Associated Press. So just on the uh AI
34:06 financing issues, the Fed raised that in
34:09 a report last week, concerns about
34:11 things like circular financing and other
34:14 issues. How are you
34:16 sure that your bank has on that and and
34:20 what would you say to re to reassure
34:22 others?
34:22 >> As you can imagine, I think our bank and
34:24 every other bank has spent a lot of time
34:26 on this. So there's a number of
34:28 different pieces. So we look at the
34:29 whole AI ecosystem
34:32 um and divide it up into different
34:33 portions and we'll put limits against
34:35 that. We'll take different slices by
34:37 different companies and countries. So
34:39 you sort of have a multi-dimensional
34:42 um matrix of different ways that you
34:44 look at your limit structures so you're
34:46 not taking concentration risk anywhere
34:48 because diversification is important. Um
34:51 then we'll look at good coll good
34:53 underwriting making sure that you're
34:55 taking good credit decisions. um and
34:58 taking all those different dimensions in
35:00 place and um US banks are generally
35:03 pretty good at this um and understanding
35:06 it. Then we'll also look at how do we
35:08 distribute the risk. So a lot of what we
35:10 do is we originate to then distribute on
35:12 rather than hold on our balance sheets.
35:15 Um so we want to make sure when we're
35:17 originating it that there's an ability
35:19 to distribute responsibly um to uh
35:22 investors. And then finally, we look at
35:25 the collateral um very carefully and
35:28 make sure that you know what what's the
35:30 collateral that's underpinning a loan.
35:32 So it's in some ways it's good
35:34 old-fashioned um corporate banking um
35:37 disciplines that get applied to this but
35:40 to um you know in a in a um in a modern
35:43 and sophisticated manner. So I I feel
35:46 comfortable with um the risks that we
35:48 take on board uh and the um and what we
35:52 do and and it's also important that
35:54 we're doing it because we want to make
35:56 sure that we are financing um these
35:58 future growth engines but not in a way
36:01 that causes a systemic issue. And we
36:04 also make sure the capital structures of
36:06 the different companies is in good
36:07 shape. you know, we've been making sure
36:10 that and working with a lot of the big
36:12 companies to make sure they're funding
36:14 it off cash flow. As a bank, love cash
36:17 flow. Um, is it cash flow? How much is
36:20 it equity that we're raising for them?
36:22 what are the different debt um debt
36:24 structures that have been put in place
36:26 so that you've got a durable sustainable
36:30 capital structure for the level of
36:32 investment that's been required and uh
36:35 you've got different milestones the
36:37 types of returns you want to see. Yeah,
36:41 it's um it gets a lot of attention from
36:43 all of us. You'll be happy to know.
36:46 Yeah.
36:50 Yeah,
36:57 >> nice to see you again.
36:59 >> So, uh, seems like it took a a uh a war,
37:03 a race to the moon, uh, a political
37:07 tsunami to dwarf the the the worry that
37:10 we had about private credit.
37:11 >> Yeah.
37:12 >> Uh, do you think that private credit has
37:13 passed the test or have they really
37:16 achieved self-governance,
37:17 self-containment or should we keep now.
37:20 >> Well, as a banker, I always love to get
37:22 um granularity and transparency. So, I
37:25 think we um for for the whole system um
37:30 getting even more granularity about what
37:32 the different exposures of private
37:34 credit are. We have the benefits in the
37:36 bank that we can see when we're
37:38 investing. We tend to invest in sort of
37:41 well over 90% is investment grade,
37:43 usually 95%.
37:45 Um, we'll look at the different pools.
37:47 We can pull collateral in and out of
37:49 what we're doing. Um, so there's a
37:52 there's an ability to manage this well.
37:54 When I look at private credit, a lot of
37:56 this is mainly in institutional or ultra
37:59 high netw worth hands. And they look at
38:02 an asset allocation. This is often non
38:05 some of it that's non-investment grade.
38:06 It's not a a large portion of the
38:09 exposure that the investors have or of
38:11 the asset allocation they have. If it
38:13 was very heavily retail, I'd be more
38:15 worried because this is something that
38:17 retail's getting exposure, you'd rather
38:19 it be through their insurance or through
38:21 their pension funds rather than than
38:24 directly. Um, I think a couple of our
38:26 clients would disagree on that one, but
38:29 that's my personal view. Um, and it's
38:32 about 1.7 trillion. Um, which sounds
38:35 like a lot of money, but in the size of
38:37 the US capital market is not oversized.
38:40 So, as long as the um credit standards
38:44 are are good, we have transparency
38:46 around it, private credit, I think, does
38:48 play a important role. It matches
38:51 long-term assets and long-term
38:53 liabilities. But if you do a poor job at
38:56 credit, then there's no hiding on that
38:59 one. At the moment, I think it if we see
39:02 issues, it's more idiosyncratic to a
39:05 couple of companies or a couple of
39:07 insurance companies rather than a
39:08 systemic issue at the moment. But you
39:11 have to keep an eye on it.
39:14 >> Hi Jason Beerman with Politico.
39:16 >> Hey Jason,
39:19 >> we are already starting the race to 2028
39:23 and presidential election.
39:24 >> I'm so glad I'm in business.
39:26 >> He's running. I'm wondering are there
39:29 any or first what you want to see in the
39:32 next president
39:33 >> or what your your peers from other major
39:36 companies want to see and also is there
39:38 anyone right now
39:40 >> who is speculated to run that you think
39:42 might
39:43 >> hit that criteria
39:45 >> you are definitely asking the wrong
39:47 person that question
39:49 I try and I try and I'm very very keenly
39:52 aware that you know if you're the CEO of
39:54 a large company you know stick to your
39:56 swim lane. Um my swim lane is making
39:59 sure that we work with whichever
40:02 administration is in power. Um we try
40:05 and make sure that if we think there are
40:07 things that they're doing in policy
40:08 that's concerning from the economy that
40:10 they will will tell them and that they
40:12 will listen and do something about it
40:14 and at the same time that they're
40:16 understanding how to grow the
40:18 competitiveness and the country in as
40:20 even a way as possible. Um so those
40:24 would be my wish list for the for um all
40:26 presidents that they follow those and
40:28 that they're mindful of the role the
40:30 important role America plays in the
40:32 world. Um but uh I I'm going to be
40:34 sticking to my day job rather than
40:37 worrying about the the presidential
40:39 election in two years because two years
40:40 is quite a long time and we've got a lot
40:42 to manage through.
40:43 >> Are you taking yourself out of the
40:44 running?
40:45 >> I'm I'm I'm not born here. I'm Scot
40:50 I'm Scottish. I don't think I'd be a
40:52 very good president. I'm gonna I stick
40:55 to trying to do a good job with my
40:56 current day job. That's that's plenty.
41:00 >> Hi, Akquila Joseph with NPR.
41:03 >> So, in a recent interview with Fortune,
41:05 you talked about uh the best advice that
41:08 Warren Buffett ever gave you. Oh, yeah.
41:09 I'd love to know what advice you give or
41:12 what is the mantra that you live by. If
41:14 you want to tell the audience about what
41:16 Warren Buffett said to you.
41:17 >> Yeah. Um he said he's given a number of
41:20 pieces of advice being good but the the
41:23 some of the advice um I try and give I
41:26 shamelessly take good advice that's
41:28 being given to me and then share that on
41:30 rather than coming up with any original
41:32 thought apparently. Um so the best
41:36 advice I got was from one of our board
41:38 members. She says have big ears and have
41:40 thick skin. And I I really
41:43 underestimated how relevant that is. And
41:45 big ears is about listening. putting
41:47 yourself in other people's shoes. Um,
41:50 understanding points of view that you
41:52 maybe don't want to understand or
41:54 hearing the truths you don't want to
41:55 hear. Um, as well as just, uh, you know,
41:59 listening to your clients and other
42:00 pieces and making sure that you're
42:03 reacting to that rather than what what
42:05 you think all the time. Um, and then the
42:08 second piece was the the thick skin, the
42:10 resiliency. I talked to my management
42:13 team about it uh on a fairly regular
42:15 basis. You have to be resilient like
42:17 what you think is a right thing you know
42:20 make sure you're doing it sometimes that
42:21 can take courage or you can have to take
42:24 decisions for the long term you know
42:27 right but have some pain in the short
42:29 term and you stick with the plan around
42:32 it and so that takes some grittiness and
42:34 courage and conviction um and I think
42:37 those those pieces of resiliency you
42:40 don't compromise on the important um and
42:43 some of the values that are critical Um,
42:45 I think those are good advice for
42:47 anybody. Yeah, it certainly helped me. I
42:50 remind myself when I'm not listening
42:52 properly that I need to have bigger
42:54 ears. Yeah, one more question I think
42:59 >> if we have.
43:02 >> Oh, you get the last one.
43:03 >> That's fantastic.
43:10 >> Thanks so much for this program. One
43:12 thing that I think is very relevant to
43:13 your day job is some of the rhetoric in
43:15 Washington right now includes things
43:17 about price controls and rate caps on
43:20 things like credit cards and I'm just
43:22 wondering kind of what your point of
43:24 view is on that.
43:24 >> Yeah, so as I've said I I there is
43:28 clearly an affordability issue um for
43:31 many people in the states and we have to
43:33 work out how do we address that. Um and
43:36 on the face of it a rate cap on a credit
43:38 card sounds like a good idea.
43:41 Unfortunately, it has the opposite
43:43 impact of what's intended because we we
43:46 have a if we were to put a rate cap save
43:49 10% as the president has suggested on
43:51 our credit card business, we would
43:53 immediately have to stop giving credit
43:55 to aboutund million different customers
43:58 here um because it would make it so
44:02 unprofitable for us to lend. Um, and
44:05 that would then have a secondary effect
44:07 cascading down because a lot of the the
44:10 airlines make more money from their
44:12 credit card and loyalty program with us
44:15 than they do from running the airline.
44:18 Hotels are often in the same situation
44:20 and I could go on restaurants and others
44:23 and cascade through. Um, so what does
44:26 what is it that does address
44:28 affordability because that's really the
44:30 root cause. let's let's solve the
44:32 problem rather than um put something in
44:34 place that doesn't work. And in that
44:37 one, I think it's some of the things we
44:39 we've looked at and we've done in the
44:41 past. So, for example, how do you
44:43 eliminate late fees or how do you
44:46 eliminate some of the overdraft fees or
44:48 other areas that are levels that just
44:50 don't make sense relative to the um the
44:53 issue. No one wants to go to Starbucks
44:56 and go overdraft by 40 cents on their
44:58 coffee and then get a know a 10 buck or
45:01 a 40 buck charge on it. That that's not
45:03 fair. Um and equally making sure that
45:06 you've got low frills but um fit
45:09 forpurpose um bank accounts, access to
45:11 credit at affordable rates so as many
45:15 people have access to credit as
45:17 possible. So um it I I remember this
45:21 aging me the Carter administration put a
45:25 lot of different credit controls other
45:27 pieces in place with the same intent and
45:30 they within within two months they had
45:33 to roll it all back because it was a
45:35 catastrophe for the economy. So let's
45:38 solve the problem which is affordability
45:40 but with the things that we know that
45:41 will work and and not something that
45:43 could actually make the problem work um
45:45 even tougher for people.
45:48 >> Jane Fran, thank you so much for taking
45:50 the time. It was wonderful to hear your
45:51 thoughts. Chief Executive Officer of
45:53 Cityroup. Uh I would just ask all of you
45:55 to stay seated while Jane departs and
45:57 then there are drinks. So uh right over
45:59 there, please enjoy uh and join us for
46:02 that. Thank you so much.
46:03 >> Thank you so much for listening. Thank
46:04 you.
46:06 Thank you.
Xi Hosts 'Groundbreaking' Trilateral With Trump, Putin full transcript
0:00 The Chinese President XI Jinping has called today's trilateral talks with
0:04 Presidents Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin a summit of groundbreaking
0:09 significance. Now, the three world leaders spoke on
0:12 safeguarding world peace and stability, including discussion on reducing nuclear
0:16 weapons. Let's go straight to Ben Lowe, who's at
0:19 the Apex summit. So,
0:21 I mean, there's a little bit of irony in what the three leaders said, but what's
0:25 the latest you're hearing on the ground? Well, what a historic moment that we're
0:32 witnessing, right? With the three leaders of a major
0:35 nuclear powers meeting today. And President Trump said this puts them
0:39 in a unique position to discuss nuclear nonproliferation.
0:44 But this is something that we are unlikely to see any major outcomes.
0:48 We know that, for example, China has been very much against the aukus, the
0:52 nuclear sharing agreement between US, UK and Australia.
0:55 China's arsenal is rapidly increasing, but is far below what the US and Russia
1:00 has. So this is not unlikely to be an area
1:02 where we will see that we agree to some sort of limits on nuclear power, but
1:07 President Trump says that is going to be on the agenda, along with the Ukraine
1:12 and Iran war. Putin made no mention of nuclear issues.
1:16 He mentioned that they should discuss energy and food security.
1:20 These are areas, the issues that have come to the fore after the wars had
1:25 disrupted trade routes. Uh, certainly.
1:28 Uh, just an interesting photo opportunity for the three leaders,
1:31 because President Putin was the one who asked for this summit initially.
1:35 And, uh, Russia is very much the junior partner of the three leaders here with
1:40 an economy that is just a fraction of China's, an economy that is heavily
1:44 dependent on China as well, especially after, uh, the country has been hit by
1:49 sanctions. Uh, and this summit also started about
1:53 an hour and a half late, uh, because of a number of reasons.
1:57 President Trump had a meeting with Putin at the last minute and additional
2:00 additions that really sort of delayed everything.
Trump, Xi and Putin Hold Talks at APEC Summit full transcript
0:01 I HEREBY ANNOUNCE THAT CHINA WILL PROVIDE $20 MILLION U.S.
0:09 DOLLARS TO SUPPORT AIPAC'S PRACTICAL COOPERATION.
0:14 WE WILL ESTABLISH A CENTER FOR ASIA-PACIFIC COMMUNITY STUDIES
0:19 IN SHENZHEN TO CONDUCT POLICY RESEARCH AND EXCHANGES AND
0:24 PROVIDE INTELLECTUAL SUPPORT. HASLINDA: CHINESE PRESIDENT XI
0:31 JINPING PLEDGING SUPPORT FOR THE APEC LEADERS SUMMIT.
0:35 HE'S SET TO MEET WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP IN THE NEXT HOUR FOR THEIR
0:39 THIRD MEETING OF THE YEAR SO FAR.
0:43 STEVE IS THERE COVERING THE SUMMIT.
0:47 HOURS AFTER THE MEET, THERE WILL BE A TRILATERAL GATHERING
0:53 BETWEEN THE U.S., CHINA AND RUSSIA BUT SUBSTANTIAL
0:56 BREAKTHROUGH ON SOME MORE CONTENTIOUS ISSUE MACE BE HARD
0:59 TO FIND. HASLINDA: WE'RE LIVE --
1:02 WE'RE LIVE IF THE SINGAPORE FINTECH FESTIVAL, THIS IS
1:08 "INSIGHT" WITH ME, HASLINDA AMIN.
1:11 THE COUNCIL ON FOREIGN RELATIONS SENIOR V.P. OF STUDY, SHAH KNOWN
1:16 O'NEALE WILL GIVE HER TAKE ON THE MEETINGS AND WHAT THE BIG
1:19 ISSUES ARE AT STAKE. ASIA EQUITIES STRUGGLE FOR GAINS
1:23 FOR A SECOND STRAIGHT SESSION AS A.I. CONCERNS DAMPEN INITIAL
1:28 ENTHUSIASM OF ANTHROPIC I.P.O. PRICING.
1:31 THAT'S BEEN CONFIRMED THAT $83 PER SHARE ABOVE THE MARKETED
1:35 RANGE AND VALUE THE COMPANY AT $1.5 THERE WILL.
1:38 ALSO AHEAD, MY GUEST FROM THE SINGAPORE FINTECH FESTIVAL WHERE
1:43 WE'LL BE HEARING IF THE HEADS OF PAYPAL AND RIPON.
2:08 HASLINDA: WE'RE SHOWING LIVE PICTURES FROM SHENZHEN.
2:12 RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN IS GIVING A SPEECH AT THE
2:18 PLENARY MEETING. HE'S ENCOURAGING COUNTRIES TO
2:22 USE THE NORTHERN SEA ROUTE, THIS REFERENCES THE SITUATION IN THE
2:27 STRAIT OF HORMUZ WHERE TRUMP' MISSION AND THE TRANSPORT OF OIL
2:34 HAS IMPACTED OIL PRICES AROUND THE WORLD.
2:37 PRESIDENT PUTIN ADDRESSING APEC LEADERS.
2:41 THE MUCH ANTICIPATED TRILATERAL MEETING IS COMING UP, THAT IS
2:46 FRONT AND CENTER. STEPHEN ENGEL JOINING US FROM
2:49 SHENZHEN. A LOT AT STAKE HERE, STEVE.
2:53 STEPHEN: YEAH, WE TRIED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT EXACTLY THEY'RE
2:56 GOING TO TALK ABOUT BECAUSE DONALD TRUMP ESSENTIALLY IS
2:59 SAYING THAT HE'S NOT NECESSARILY GOING TO ASK XI JINPING AND
3:03 VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR HELP IN THE WAR IN IRAN.
3:06 THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE SPECULATED THAT HE MIGHT ELICIT
3:12 THEIR INPUT AND USE THEIR INFLUENCE ON TEHRAN TO HELP WIND
3:18 DOWN THE CONFLICT. OBVIOUSLY THAT THE UNITED STATES
3:20 HAS BEEN WAGING NOW FOR ABOUT NINE WOULDN'T BEES WITH IRAN.
3:23 BUT DONALD TRUMP IS RULING OUT THAT.
3:26 WE'VE ALSO HEARD FROM U.S. OFFICIALS THAT HE'S NOT GOING TO
3:28 BRING UP IN THAT TRILATERAL WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN AND XI JINPING,
3:32 THE WAR IN UKRAINE. THOSE ARE THE TWO GIANT
3:35 ELEPHANTS IN THE ROOM OBVIOUSLY RIGHT NOW.
3:37 SO WHAT IS THE POINT OF THIS TRILATERAL OTHER THAN MEETING
3:40 FOR MEETING'S SAKE? AGAIN I TALKED TO JEFFREY SAX,
3:47 THE COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR YESTERDAY WHO SAID
3:49 IT'S GOOD THAT THESE THREE POWERFUL NATIONS ARE GETTING
3:51 TOGETHER FOR UNPRECEDENTED TALKS, WE JUST DON'T KNOW
3:56 EXACTLY THE MEAT OF THOSE CONVERSATIONS AND WHAT ARE THEY
3:58 GOING TO BE, WHAT ARE THEY GOING TO LATCH ONTO TO EITHER FIND
4:01 AREAS THAT THEY NEED TO BRING GAPS IN UNDERSTANDING, OR FIND
4:06 COMMON GROUND. WE SIMPLY DON'T KNOW.
4:08 A.I. IS LIKELY, THE TELEGRAPHING POINTS TO DISCUSSIONS ABOUT A.I.
4:12 AT THE BACKDROP NO DOUBT OF THESE ISSUES WITH CHINA AND THE
4:17 REMOTE ACCESS ISSUES OF AMERICA'S MOST ADVANCED CHIPS.
4:21 WE ALSO HEARD IN THAT BIT OF A RAMBLING SPEECH A FEW MINUTES
4:26 AGO IF DONALD TRUMP THAT THE UNITED STATES INVENTED
4:29 SUPERINTELLIGENCE. THEY ARE NOT GOING TO DO
4:31 ANYTHING TO STIFLE THAT INNOVATION GOING FORWARD.
4:35 IT'S A DRIVER OF ECONOMIC GROWTH.
4:39 SO WE'RE JUST GOING, TO IT'S A GUESSING GAME RIGHT NOW WHAT
4:42 THAT TRILATERAL IS GOING TO PRODUCE AS FAR AS HEADLINES AND
4:46 DELIVERABLES FOR ALL THREE NATIONS.
4:54 HASLINDA: YOU WONDER WHETHER OR NOT XI JINPING AND VLADIMIR
4:58 PUTIN MIGHT OUT-MANEUVER TRUMP, THE TWO ARE REALLY CLOSE ALLIES
5:02 RIGHT NOW. STEPHEN: THAT IS THE
5:04 CONCERNTHING EUROPE HAS. I THINK EUROPEAN NATIONS ALL
5:07 ACROSS THE CONTINENT ARE WATCHING THIS TO SEE IF THERE'S
5:12 SOME BACK, YOU KNOW BACKROOM BARGAINING GOING ON TO GET
5:16 DONALD TRUMP ON BOARD WITH WHAT XI JINPING AND VLADIMIR PUTIN
5:19 HAVE DECIDED IS GOING TO BE THE OUTONLY OF THIS TRILATERAL.
5:24 WE SIMPLY DON'T KNOW. I'M SURE TAKAICHI WILL BE
5:30 WATCHING THIS CLOSELY AS JAPAN IS IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO RUSSIA,
5:36 NO DOUBT, AND HAS BEEN PUT IN THE PENALTY BOX, ICED OUT BY XI
5:41 JINPING. WE KNOW THAT TAKAISHI-SAN DID
5:48 MEET WITH TRUMP BEFORE THIS TRILATERAL TO COMPARE NOTES.
5:53 WE UNDERSTAND THERE MAY BE ANOTHER PULL-ASIDE, TO USE STATE
5:57 DEPARTMENT LANGUAGE, BETWEEN TRUMP AND TAKAICHI.
6:03 ALLIES, TRADITIONAL ALLAYS OF THE UNITED STATES ARE WATCHING
6:06 THIS CLOSELY. A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE TALKED
6:10 ABOUT THE COMPARE COMPARISONS TO THE YALTA CONFERENCE IN THE
6:13 WANING DAYS OF WORLD WAR II, WHETHER EXISTING POWERS IN THE
6:16 UNITED STATES OR UNITED KINGDOM COMBINED WITH SOVIET UNION,
6:21 STALIN, MET IN THE CRIME ARK MET IN YALTA, TO DECIDE THE FATE OF
6:25 POSTWORLD WAR II EUROPE AND BEYOND.
6:26 A LOT OF PEOPLE INCLUDING THOSE IN KREMLIN ARE SAYING THIS IS A
6:31 NEWALL THAT I DON'T NECESSARILY AGREE WITH THAT.
6:33 BUT THE COMPARISON, YOU COULD SAY, IS TWO EASTERN POWERS NOW,
6:37 RUSSIAN AND CHINA, BRINGING IN THE UNITED STATES.
6:40 TO THEIR VIEWS OF THE NEW WORLD ORDER.
6:43 SO THERE'S A LOT OF SPECULATION RIGHT NOW ON WHERE THEY'RE GOING
6:46 TO GO WITH THESE CONVERSATIONS. BUT IT'S INTERESTING AND
6:50 UNPRECEDENTED THAT THESE THREE LEADERS WILL BE MEETING ON THE
6:53 GLOBAL STAGE HERE IN CHINA. HASLINDA: STILL LOTS OF
7:01 QUESTIONS AS WE GET INTO THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
7:03 STEPHEN ENGEL, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT.
7:05 LET'S GET MORE ON WHAT'S AT STAKE AT THE TRILATERAL MEETING
7:10 WITH SHANNON O'NEIL. IT'S GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
7:18 WHAT ARE THE CHANCES OF YALTA 2.0 OR IS THIS JUST A PHOTO
7:24 OPPORTUNITY? SHANNON: THERE'S A LOT OF
7:26 COMPARISON TO YALTA, BUT YOU HAVE TO REMEMBER THAT YOU HAD TO
7:30 BE VICTORIOUS IN WAR TO GET TO YALTA, AND RUSSIA HASN'T BEEN
7:35 THAT YET. THAT'S GETTING THE CART BEFORE
7:38 THE HORSE. BUT WHAT IS ON THE TABLE?
7:40 WE DON'T EXACTLY KNOW. WE HEARD PRESIDENT TRUMP SAY HE
7:43 WANT NEWS CLEAR ISSUES, DENUCLEARIZATION ON THE TABLE
7:46 THAT. WILL PROBABLY BE DISCUSSED.
7:48 AS WE JUST HEARD, A.I. WILL BE ON THE TABLE.
7:51 A.I. SAFETY, ACCESS TO A.I. WILL BE ON THE TABLE.
7:54 SOME OF THE OTHERS BETWEEN THE NATIONS MAY COME UP.
7:58 WHAT'S IMPORTANT TO KNOW IS THESE THREE LEADERS DO NOT AGREE
8:02 ON EVERYTHING, MAY NOT AGREE ON ANYTHING.
8:05 WE DON'T -- YES THERE IS AREAS WHERE CHINA AND RUSSIA ARE
8:08 TOGETHER ON THINGS. THERE'S ALSO AREAS WHERE THEY
8:11 DIFFER. I WOULD SAY THEY'RE NUCLEAR,
8:13 DENUCLEARIZATION IS AN ISSUE THERE.
8:15 RUSSIA, THE UNITED STATES ARE USED TO LOWERING THEIR NUMBER OF
8:18 NUKES. USED TO WORKING TOGETHER THROUGH
8:20 VARIOUS TREATY, CHINA WANTS TO GROW ITS NUCLEAR ARSENAL.
8:27 WE HAVE DIVISIONS ACROSS ALL THREE OF THOSE ON THE ISSUES
8:30 THAT MAY BE TALKED ABOUT. HOW MUCH LEVERAGE DOES TRUMP
8:34 HAVE IN THESE NEGOTIATIONS? HE'S COMING INTO THE TRILATERAL
8:39 A WEAKENED PRESIDENT GIVEN THE RESULTS OF THE MID TERM
8:43 ELECTIONS. SHANNON: HE IS WEAKENED IN SOME
8:48 WAYS BUT THE UNITED STATES IS TILL THE UNITED STATES.
8:50 THIS IS THE SUPERPOWER. IT DOES HOLD SIGNIFICANT HEFT
8:54 AROUND THE WORLD. IT IS A MAJOR ECONOMY AND
8:57 PARTICULARLY RIGHT NOW IN THE WAKE OF THE THING THAT WAS
8:59 HAPPENED IN THE LAST WEEK, YOU KNOW, THE IMPORTANCE OF AMERICAN
9:03 COMPUTE, OF ACCESS TO HIGH-END CHIP, THE IMPORTANCE OF
9:06 AMERICA'S MILITARY AROUND THE WORLD.
9:09 THIS IS A COUNTRY EVEN WITH THE DIVIDES IN THE UNITED STATES,
9:12 EVEN WITH THE WEAKENED PRESIDENT GOING FORWARD, ESPECIALLY WITH A
9:15 NEW CONGRESS HE'LL FACE COME THE BEGINNING OF 2027, PLAYS A
9:18 SIGNIFICANT ROLE HERE. AND BOTH XI WANTS TO KEEP THE
9:23 DETENT THAT'S BEEN IN PLACE GOING AT LEAST FOR A PERIOD
9:27 LONGER AND PUTIN WANTS THINGS FROM TRUMP.
9:29 HE WANTS HELP IN ENDING THE WAR, AND ON THE TERMS HE WOULD LIKE
9:33 TO END THEM. YES, HE IS PERHAPSED WEAKENED
9:36 BUT THERE ARE THINGS BOTH THESE LEADERS WANT IF PRESIDENT TRUMP.
9:44 HASLINDA: HE IS ALSO SPEAKING TO A CHINESE LEADER WHO IS
9:47 DOMINATING RARE EARTHS. SURELY XI JINPING GOES INTO
9:51 THESE NEGOTIATIONS WITH A LOT MORE LEVERAGE.
9:55 SHANNON: IF WE LOOK AT THE AGREEMENT SIGNED OVER A YEAR
9:59 AGO, THIS DETENT BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES AND CHINA, WE HAVE
10:03 SIGNIFICANT EVIDENCE CHINA IS NOT MEETING ITS PROMISES.
10:07 ONE PART IS IT DOESN'T SEEM TO BE EXPORT THE AM OF RARE EARTH
10:12 IT PROMMED TO DO. IT DOESN'T SEEM TO BE BUYING THE
10:14 AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS IT PROMISED TO DO.
10:16 I DO THINK AT THIS MEETING THE DETENT WILL HOLD.
10:19 IT'LL MOVE FORWARD BECAUSE PRESIDENT TRUMP AND XI PLAN ON
10:23 MEET, AT LEAST RIGHT NOW, IN A MONTH.
10:25 THIS WILL BE, THIS TIME ON TRUMP'S HOME CUR OF IN SOUTH
10:28 FLORIDA. AS WE GO FORWARD INTO 2027, AS
10:31 WE GET A NEW CONGRESS IN THE UNITED STATES, GET MORE
10:33 QUESTIONS ABOUT THE DETENT AND THE BENEFITS OF IT, AND WE ADD
10:38 IN THOUGH WHOLE NVIDIA, THE CHIPS THAT LOOK LIKE THEY'VE
10:42 GOTTEN AROUND U.S. RULES AND SANCTIONS, AND EXPORT CONTROLS,
10:46 I DO THINK IT WILL BE A MUCH MORE FRAGILE AGREEMENT.
10:49 AND THEN THE REAL QUESTION IS DO WE SEE RETALIATION FROM CHINA ON
10:53 RARE EARTH NECESSARY UNITED STATES STARTS PULLING BACK ON
10:55 MANY OF THESE ELEMENTS. HASLINDA: SHANNON, WE TALK ABOUT
11:01 HOW WE'RE STILL UNCERTAIN WHAT'S ON THE AGENDA ARE WE CERTAIN WHY
11:06 XI JINPING WANTED THIS TRILATERAL?
11:08 WHY HE INVITE FOOD TIN TO BE PART OF THIS CONVERSATION?
11:13 SHANNON: IT'S HARD TO KNOW BUT SOME PEOPLE SEEM TO THINK THAT
11:17 IT WAS ACTUALLY TRUMP THAT ASKED THAT PUTIN BE INVOLVED IN THE
11:20 CONVERSATION. WE'VE SEEN CONVERSATIONS WITH
11:22 TRUMP DIPLOMATS WORK THOSE ENVOYS WORKING WITH PUTIN AND
11:27 HIS TEAM, TO LOOK AT THE UKRAINE SITUATION AND SEE THERE'S A
11:31 SOLUTION. THAT CAN BE FOUND.
11:33 EUROPE AND OTHERS HAVE BEEN LEFT OUT OF THAT.
11:35 AND THERE IS BRINGING PUTIN INTO THIS, MANY SAY WAS TRUMP.
11:39 IN MANY WAYS XI WOULD LIKE TO KEEP THIS AS A G2.
11:43 THE TWO REAL SUPERPOWERS. WHAT PUTIN BRINGS TO THE TABLE,
11:46 RUSSIA IS A NUCLEAR POWER, BUT IT IS NOT THE ECONOMIC FORCE IT
11:50 ONCE WAS. IT IS NOT THE GLOBAL PLAYER IT
11:52 ONCE WAS. SO THERE WERE REASONS FOR XI
11:55 ACTUALLY TO WANT TO KEEP THIS TO THE FIRST MEETING, WHICH IS THE
12:00 ONE WITH TRUMP. GIVEN THAT, THOUGH, THERE ARE
12:02 ISSUES THAT THE THREE WILL TALK ABOUT AND WE'LL ALL BE WATCHING
12:05 AS IT UNFOLDS AFTERWARDS. HASLINDA: DO YOU SEE TAIWAN
12:12 BEING DISCUSSED IN THESE CONVERSATIONS?
12:14 MIGHT THERE BE A TAIWAN TRADEOFF HERE?
12:17 SHANNON: I THINK THERE'S TWO PLACES IN THE WORLD THAT ARE
12:19 WATCHING THESE TALKS CLOSELY AND FEELING A BIT OF FOMO THAT
12:23 THEY'VE BEEN LEFT OUT OF IT. ONE IS EUROPE, PARTICULARLY
12:27 WHILE THEY SAY THEY WON'T TALK ABOUT UKRAINE, IT MAY COME UP IN
12:32 CONVERSATION AND EUROPE HAS A GREAT STAKE THERE AND THE OTHER
12:34 IS TAIWAN. THERE'S SO MUCH RIDING ON THESE
12:37 MEETINGS. PARTICULARLY THE BILATERAL
12:38 MEETING BETWEEN TRUMP AND XI. ON WHERE THE UNITED STATES
12:42 STANDS ON TAIWAN. WHERE THE UNITED STATES STANDS
12:45 ON THE $14 BILLION WORTH OF ARMS SALES THAT WERE TO GO TO TAIWAN
12:49 AND WHETHER THOSE WILL BE RELEASED ANDSEN TO TAIWAN OR
12:52 WILL NOT BE IN A WHOLE HOST OF OTHER ISSUES AS WELL AS THE
12:55 CHIPS. MANY OF THE CHIP, THESE HIGH
12:58 POWERED CHIPS THAT HAD BEEN GOING AROUND SANCTIONS AND
13:01 GETTING EITHER TO CHINA OR TO CHINESE A.I. COMPANIES THROUGH
13:05 SOUTHEAST ASIA BASED DATA CENTERS, THOSE ALSO ORIGINATE IN
13:10 TAIWAN. THERE'S A WHOLE HE'S OF ISSUES
13:12 THERE ON THE TAIL. I WOULD SUSPECT MORE OF THAT
13:15 CONVERSATION HAPPENS IN THE BILATERAL AGREEMENT, OR BILAT
13:20 CORRAL -- LI LATERAL CONVERSATION BETWEEN XI AND
13:22 TRUMP BUT IT MAY SPILL OVER INTO THE TRILATERAL.
13:26 HASLINDA: IS THERE A SENSE THAT UNDER TRUMP 2.0, TAIWAN IS
13:30 PERHAPS LESS A STRATEGIC ISSUE FOR THE U.S.?
13:37 SHANNON: WHEN YOU LOOK AT TRUMP'S OVERALL POLICY, LOOK AT
13:40 HIS NATIONAL SECURITY STRATEGY, IT LEADS WITH THE WESTERN
13:43 HEMISPHERE. AND I THINK THAT TELLS YOU
13:45 SOMETHING ABOUT THE WAY TRUMP HIMSELF AND MANY IN HIS
13:49 ADMINISTRATION THINK ABOUT THE WORLD.
13:51 THAT THOSE COUNTRIES CLOSER, THAT THERE'S FEARS OF INFLUENCE
13:56 AND THE AREA AROUND YOU IS PERHAPS MORE IMPORTANT THAN
13:59 PLACES MUCH FURTHER AWAY. WE SEE THIS A BIT IN SOME OF THE
14:03 CONVERSATION ABOUT UKRAINE, WHY IS THE UNITED STATES THERE?
14:06 THERE'S AN ISOLATIONIST WING THERE THAT WANTS TO PULL BACK
14:09 FROM BEING A BIG PART OF EUROPE. THERE'S ALSO ONE THAT THINKS
14:13 ABOUT THAT IN ASIA. SO AS YOU THINK ABOUT THE PLACE
14:16 OF TAIWAN, IT'S NOT JUST, IS IT TAIWAN?
14:19 IS IT CHINA? HOW DO WE THINK ABOUT THAT
14:22 AGREEMENT? BUT IT IS ARE WE, OR SHOULD THE
14:25 U.S. BE INVOLVED SO FAR AWAY? OR SHOULD THE U.S. CONCENTRATE
14:28 ON WHAT'S HAPPENING RIGHT IN ITS OWN HEMISPHERE?
14:31 AND THERE ARE SOME IN THE ADMINISTRATION, IN FACT RIGHT
14:33 NOW AS THE PRESIDENT IS IN ASIA, THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE,
14:37 SECRETARY OF WAR IS IN LATIN AMERICA.
14:39 SO IT TELLS YOU A BIT ABOUT THE SPHERES OF INFLUENCE AND HOW
14:42 THEY'RE LEANING IN. HASLINDA: WHEN IT COMES TO
14:47 VLADIMIR PUTIN, I'M WONDERING, THIS IS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR
14:52 RUSSIA TO GIVE ITS MESSAGING, WHAT KIND OF MESSAGING DO YOU
14:58 THINK IS IMPORTANT FOR PUTIN RIGHT NOW?
15:00 SHANNON: FOR PUTIN, YOU SEE IT IN THE PHOTO OPS ALREADY, IT'S
15:05 IMPORTANT TO BE TREATED AS AN EQUAL OR SEEN AS AN EQUAL AT THE
15:08 TABLE WITH XI AND TRUMP. THAT'S PART OF THE TRILATERAL
15:11 MEETING. IT WILL BE A SUCCESS IN THAT
15:13 SENSE. IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT FOR PUTIN TO
15:16 NOT BE A, SORT OF, SECONDARY TO XI.
15:20 THE RUSSIAN ECONOMY, THE RUSSIAN WAR EFFORT IS VERY DEPENDENT ON
15:24 CHINA. AND INCREASINGLY SO AS IT HAS
15:27 GONE AHEAD, AS THE YEARS HAVE GONE BY.
15:30 SO I THINK IN THIS MEET, IT'S VERY IMPORTANT FOR PUTIN TO BE
15:33 SEEN MORE AS AN EQUAL. THAT'S WHAT HE ASPIRES TO.
15:37 AND TO BEING GIVEN A SEAT AT THE TABLE.
15:39 I THINK THE REAL QUESTION HERE IS THIS IS ONE MEETING, AND WHAT
15:43 HAPPENS AFTER THIS? WE DO SEE IN THE G20, PRESIDENT
15:48 TRUMP INVITED PUTIN TO FLORIDA TO JOIN THAT MEETING.
15:51 THERE'LL BE A QUESTION IF HE DOES DECIDE TO ATTEND IF THE
15:55 EUROPEANS ALSO ATTEND, END UP IN THE SAME ROOM AS PUTIN.
15:58 THEY SEE HIM AS A WAR CRIMINAL, SOMEONE WHO IS DESTROYING THEIR
16:01 WAY OF LIFE, THREATENING THEIR WAY OF LIFE AND THE RULES OF
16:04 SOVEREIGNTY, RULES OF STATES, AND INDEPENDENCE.
16:07 SO I THINK THERE'S A REAL QUESTION HERE.
16:09 BUT AT LEAST GETTING TO THE ROOM, GETTING ALL THREE AT THE
16:12 TABLE AND THE PHOTOS THAT WILL COME, THAT AT LEAST IS A WIN FOR
16:18 PUTIN. HASLINDA: SHANNON, GREAT
16:23 INSIGHTS THERE. SHANNON O'NEIL.
16:28 STILL TO COME, ANTHROPIC RAISES $100 BILLION, MAKING IT THE
16:34 BIGGEST I. PERFORM O. OF ALL TIME.
16:36 KEEP IT HERE WITH US. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
16:37 ♪
16:51 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK. YOU'RE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
16:55 ASIAN STOCKS SLIDING AMID CONCERNS OVER THE A.I. TRADE,
16:59 THIS DESPITE ANTHROPIC PRICING ITS I.P.O. ABOVE THE MARKETED
17:03 RANGE. AVRIL IS HERE WITH MORE.
17:07 INVESTORS ARE STILL SKEPTICAL. AVRIL: I THINK IT'S SEEN FROM
17:14 THE PRICE. THE TAIEX IS THE UNDERPERFORMER
17:19 AS THE INVESTORS LOOK TO THE TRUMP-XI BILATERAL, MAYBE SOP
17:24 RISK THERE THIS COMES AFTER THE NVIDIA POST-EARNINGS RALLY
17:30 FIZZLING OUT. INVESTORS ARE NOT CONVINCED OF
17:32 THE DURABILITY OF THE AMPLE I. TRADE GIVEN THE CONCERNS
17:35 SURROUNDING NVIDIA AS WELL AND CHIP RESTRICTIONISMS LOOK AT
17:39 ANTHROPIC, YES IT CONFIRMS THAT IS PRICING THE I.P.O. AT 83
17:44 BUCKS A POP, ABOVE THE MARKET RANGE.
17:48 IT'S AN APP SIZE AIRPORT P.O. AS A KEY CUSTOMER OF A.I.
17:53 INFRASTRUCTURE THAT'S MAYBE HELPING TO ALLAY SOME CONCERNS.
17:56 BUT IT STILL HAS TO STICK THE LANDING AS IT'S SET TO TRADE ON
18:00 THE NASDAQ LATER THURSDAY. FLIP THE BOARD, CHINESE TECH IS
18:03 ALSO IN THE SPOTLIGHT GIVEN THESE TIES IN U.S. CHIP RELATED
18:08 RESTRICTIONS. MAYBE THAT SPURS THE NARRATIVE
18:10 WHEN IT COMES TO SELF-SUFFICIENCY.
18:12 YOU'RE GETTING SOME POSITIVE SOUND BITES IF THE CHINESE
18:15 PRESIDENT THIS MORNING AS WELL. BUT THEOVER HANG IS THAT THE
18:19 RESTRICTIONS COULD CONSTRAIN THE DEPLOYMENT, OR DEVELOPMENT, FOR
18:23 A.I., PARTICULARLY FOR THE HYPERSCALERS YOU ADD TO THAT,
18:27 WHAT WE GOT FROM TENCENT IN TERMS OF REVENUE AND OPERATING
18:32 PROFIT AT A TIME WHERE IT'S SPENDING BIG.
18:34 WE SAW IT REPORTING NEGATIVE FREE CASH FLOW AS WELL.
18:38 IT'S A CHALLENGING PICTURE WHEN IT COMES TO NOT JUST CHINESE BUT
18:44 ASIA TECH DESPITE WHAT WE'RE HEARING FROM ANTHROPIC.
18:49 HASLINDA: BLOOMBERG'S AVRIL HONG, THANK YOU.
18:50 LET'S GET MORE ON ANTHROPIC'S I. PERFORM O.
18:53 OUR REPORTER IS WITH US. WHAT DO THESE NUMBERS TELL US
18:59 ABOUT DEMAND? HAS, THE DEMAND TELLS US IT
19:04 WAS HUGE AND WE LOOK AT THE NUMBER, THE PRICING WAS $83 A
19:16 SHARE, THE FULLY DILUTED VALUATION IS ABOUT $1.5
19:21 TRILLION. ALTOGETHER WITH THE PRIVATE
19:23 PLACEMENT IT COMFORTABLY BEATS THE $86 BILLION OF SPACEX'S
19:27 RECORD I.P.O. NVIDIA STOCKS WERE DOWN FIVE
19:41 DAYS IN A ROW AND THE FEAR GAUGE, PER SE, WAS UP 25.
19:45 WHICH IS A LEVEL THAT COMPANIES ACTUALLY DROP OR POSTPONE SOME
19:49 OF THE DEBUTS. HASLINDA: THERE MUST BE A LOT OF
19:56 NERVES OUT THERE, SANGMI. WHAT SHOULD WE EXPECT WHEN
20:01 ANTHROPIC BEGINSING RETRADING LATER TODAY IN THE MUST SANGMI:
20:06 WE ARE HEARING WE'LL BE SEEING FIREWORKS BUT ALSO WHIP SAW, A
20:11 PICTURE WE HAVE SEEN WITH SPACEX.
20:13 WE HAVE SEEN 30% TWO DAYS IN A ROW.
20:16 THEN WE SAW AFTER A MONTH IT BROKE DOWN TO THE PRICE -- THE
20:22 ISSUE PRICE. SO WE COULD SEE THE SAME THING
20:24 HAPPENING WITH ANTHROPIC, BUT OF COURSE, WE'RE GOING TO BE
20:30 CHECKING THE GRAY MARKET TRADING IN A COUPLE OF HOURS THE EARLY
20:34 INDICATIONS SHOW THAT ABOUT 20% TO 26% UPSIDE WHEN THE MARKET
20:38 OPENS. SO WE'RE GOING TO BE SEEING SOME
20:40 OF THOSE MOVES. EXPECT LIQUIDITY GOING INTO THE
20:45 THANKSGIVING WEEK NEXT WEEK BUT ALSO THERE'S A TAILWIND LIKE
20:49 AVRIL SAID. SOME FUNDS COULD INCLUDE
20:52 ANTHROPIC TO THE INDEX THEIR BENCHMARK LIKE NASDAQ 100 AND
20:57 THAT WOULD PULL SOME OF THE MONEY INTO THE STOCK.
21:04 HASLINDA: CLEARLY THERE'S MASSIVE DEMAND.
21:05 THE QUESTION IS, WHERE IS ALL THE MONEY COMING FROM?
21:08 AND WHAT DOES THIS ANTHROPIC DEBUT MEAN FOR ASIA?
21:16 SANGMI: NORMALLY INVESTORS ARE BIG MONEY, FROM WALL STREET TO
21:20 LONDON TO TOKYO, AND YOU KNOW, THE BANKERS CAME OUT AND SAID
21:24 BECAUSE OF THIS HUGE DEMAND THEY HAVE BEEN SEE, THEY HAVE TO
21:28 PRIORITIZE THE PRE-EXISTING BACKERS.
21:31 SO A LOT OF THE NEW SORT OF NEW BUYERS WOULD ACTUALLY BE
21:37 DE-PRIORITIZED. THIS ALSO MEANS IT COULD BE A
21:39 GOOD THING. THE PENT UP DEMAND WE'RE SEEING
21:42 HERE COULD ACTUALLY TRICK SPOOL THE ACTUAL REGULAR TRADING
21:46 SYSTEM OF THAT COULD HOLD THIS CHAIR GOING FURTHER.
21:48 NOW WHERE IS THE MONEY COMING FROM?
21:52 COULD BE AN EXPLANATION TO THE TECH WEAKNESS WE HAVE SEEN THE
21:55 PAST WEEK. SOME OF THE INVESTORS HAVE SAVED
21:58 UP THE GUNPROUDER TO PUT THAT INTO THE I.P.O.
22:04 HASLINDA: INTERESTING AS WELL THAT THERE'S A 20% ALLOCATION
22:07 FOR RETAIL INVESTORS. IS THAT A GAME CHANGE HER WHAT
22:10 IS THE THINKING FOR THE POINT OF VIEW OF ANTHROPIC?
22:14 SANGMI: RIGHT. WE HAVEN'T HEARD MUCH BUT YOU'RE
22:19 RIGHT. THE 15% TO 20% WAS THE
22:21 ALLOCATION TO RETAIL INVESTORS AND OF COURSE THERE WERE A
22:23 COUPLE OF COUNTRIES THAT WERE ALSO INCLUDED LIKE JAPAN THAT WE
22:27 HAVE SEEN, THAT ALSO GOT THAT ALLEGATION, LARGELY CHINA AND
22:31 HONG KONG INVESTORS WERE REBUFFED FROM THIS ONE.
22:34 BUT AGAIN THIS MEANS THE RETAIL INVESTORS ARE -- THEY HAVE THAT
22:39 VOTE OF CONFIDENCE IN A.I. TRADE AND AGAIN THEIR INTEREST WOULD
22:44 GO AND TRICK SPOOL THAT NORMAL TRADING.
22:46 WE ALSO HAVE SEEN THIS INTERESTING REPORTS ABOUT ETF'S,
22:50 THAT THIS HUGE CROWD LINING UP TO GET A SHARE OF ANTHROPIC EVEN
22:55 INCLUDING THE 2X LEVERAGED ETF'S.
23:03 HASLINDA: SANGM CHA, OUR REPORTER, THANK YOU.
23:06 STILL TO COME, A.I. GROWTH, WE'LL BE JOINED FROM THE FINTECH
23:15 FESTIVAL. KEEP IT HERE WITH US.
23:17 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
23:27 THERE ARE SIGNALS OF A BUBBLE COMING UP AND WE GOT TO BE VERY
23:33 CAREFUL ABOUT THAT. IF YOU LOOK AT THE GROWTH, IT IS
23:40 BEING FUNDED IN A CIRCULAR WAY. IT KIND OF MAKES THIS WHOLE
23:46 ISSUE A PART OF THE DISCUSSION NOW.
23:47 IT ALL COMES BACK THE PRINCIPLES WHICH ARE MAKING SURE
23:51 WE HAVE THE RIGHT GOVERNANCE, THE RIGHT TO DILIGENCE, THE
23:54 RIGHT LEVEL OF TRANSPARENCY TO MANAGE THESE RISKS.
23:58 EVEN THOUGH THERE IS SO MUCH TALK ABOUT THE UNCERTAINTY
24:01 BEHIND THE AI COMPANIES REALIZING THE POTENTIAL IN THE
24:04 HIGH EXPECTATIONS OF PEOPLE HAVE SET FOR THEM.
24:06 IT SEEMS LIKE THE RETAIL INVESTORS, INSTITUTIONAL
24:12 INVESTORS ARE NOT GOING ANYWHERE.
24:13 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK, YOU ARE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
24:17 THOSE WERE SOME OF THE COMMENTS FROM MY GUESTS AT THE FESTIVAL
24:21 SHARING THEIR INSIGHTS ON AI. CITIGROUP CEO JANE FRASER SAYS
24:26 TECH OUTAGES MAY BECOME MORE ROUTINE AS COMPANIES RACED TO
24:30 CATCH THEIR SYSTEMS AND TIGHTEN SECURITY.
24:32 SPEAKING AT A BLOOMBERG NEWS MAKERS EVENT, SHE GAVE US HER
24:35 TAKE ON AI AND WHY SHE'S NOT CONCERNED ABOUT DOOMSDAY
24:39 SCENARIOS. THE GENIE IS OUT OF THE
24:45 BOTTLE ON AI AND NO ONE IS PUTTING THAT GENIE BACK IN THE
24:47 BOTTLE. WHEN WE THINK ABOUT THE AMOUNT
24:49 OF COMPUTE THAT IS IN DEMAND, I'M NOT JUST SEEING IT THERE,
24:59 THEY ARE BUILDING THEIR FIRST DATA CENTER BECAUSE THEY ARE
25:02 WORRIED IF THEY DON'T, THEY WON'T BE ABLE TO COMPETE IN
25:05 INDUSTRY AFTER INDUSTRY. SO THIS IS A GLOBAL PHENOMENON
25:11 CERTAINLY CENTERED IN THE STATES, BUT I WOULDN'T BE SO
25:16 CONCERNED WITH THE DOOMSDAY PREDICTIONS ON AI AND THE REST
25:19 OF IT. I THINK WE ARE IN REASONABLE
25:24 SHAPE. AT THE SAME TIME IN YOUR
25:27 THIRD QUARTER EARNINGS, CITIGROUP DID SAY THAT AI
25:29 FINANCING RISK WAS A KEY RISK OR UNCERTAINTY ENDED WITH THE FIRST
25:33 TIME IT APPEARED. WHAT WERE YOU REFERRING TO IN
25:36 PARTICULAR? IF THE LARGEST BUILDOUT THAT
25:39 WE'VE SEEN IN MODERN HISTORY AND THERE'S A LOT OF PROMISE AND
25:48 OPPORTUNITY THERE. WE ARE IN THE PICKS AND SHOVELS
25:53 PHASE, AS EVERYONE LIKES TO SAY. IT'S A VERY BIG BUILDOUT, ITS
25:58 ENERGY, CHIPS, IT'S THE DATA CENTERS, THE FRONTIER MODELS.
26:02 NOT EVERYONE WILL BE A WINNER. THERE ARE ALWAYS WINNERS AND
26:07 LOSERS IN THESE THINGS. JUST GIVEN THE AMOUNT OF MONEY
26:10 INVOLVED AND THE OTHER PIECES, YOU WOULD HOPE THAT ONE OF THE
26:14 NATION'S LARGEST BANKS WAS FOCUSED ON MAKING SURE THAT WE
26:17 MANAGE THE RISK RESPONSIBLY, THAT WE ARE IN THE BUSINESS OF
26:21 TAKING RISK AND THEREFORE WE KEEP AN EYE ON THESE THINGS.
26:28 WE THINK OF THE UNITED STATES IS BEING BUT THE EPICENTER OF
26:30 THE RISK AND THE REWARD. THIS IS A HUGE SYSTEM OF RISK
26:34 AND COULD POTENTIALLY ANOTHER SUBPRIME.
26:37 THERE JEALOUS. [LAUGHTER]
26:40 IS A FEATURE OR A BUG, BECAUSE IT DOES SORT OF
26:46 CONCENTRATE RISK. THIS IS WHERE I BECOME ONE OF
26:51 THOSE ZEALOUS AMERICANS HAVING CHOSEN TO COME AND JOIN THIS
26:52 COUNTRY AS AN IMMIGRANT MANY YEARS AGO NOW.
26:58 WHAT IS THE MAGIC THAT THE U.S. HAS?
27:02 IT IS OUR ABILITY TO BOTH SEE THE INNOVATION THAT THIS COUNTRY
27:08 CAN DO AT SCALE MATCHED WITH THE CAPITAL MARKET.
27:11 THINK ABOUT IT, THE U.S. HAS 4% OF THE RURAL POPULATION AND OVER
27:17 50% OF THE CAPITALIZATION OF THE WORLD.
27:20 YOU THINK ABOUT INDUSTRY AFTER INDUSTRY, NOT ONLY CAN WE
27:25 INNOVATE, BUT WE CAN DO SO AT SCALE.
27:32 HASLINDA: THAT WAS JANE FRASER SPEAKING WITH LISA BROWN WITH.
27:37 OUR NEXT GUEST, THAT LANDSCAPE HAS EVOLVED AND NEW
27:44 TECHNOLOGIES, RISING COMPETITION AND OF COURSE THE ACCELERATION
27:46 OF AI IN COMMERCE. PRESIDENT AND CEO OF PAYPAL,
27:51 GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US. WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT ANTHROPIC.
27:59 MASSIVE INSTITUTIONAL INTEREST. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF IT?
28:02 HOW THE AI COMPANY IS REALLY GETTING A LOT OF ATTENTION, I
28:11 THINK THE IMPORTANT THING FOR US IS TO UNDERSTAND HOW IT IS GOING
28:15 TO BE AFFECTING OUR INDUSTRY, HOW WE NEED TO MOVE OUR PRODUCT,
28:20 HOW WE NEED TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS TECHNOLOGY.
28:22 HASLINDA: A VALUATION AT $1.5 TRILLION.
28:28 IT IS WAY HIGHER THAN PROFITABLE FAMOUS COMPANIES.
28:32 IT LEADS YOU TO THINK WHAT COMPANIES LIKE PAYPAL NEED TO DO
28:36 TO BRIDGE THE GAP. INFRASTRUCTURE, PERHAPS?
28:41 I THINK WHAT WE NEED TO DO FROM OUR SIDE IS TO SHOW THE
28:45 MARKET THAT WE CAN GROW IN A STEADY WAY.
28:47 IF WE DO, I THINK THE MARKET VALUATION WILL OF COURSE CHANGE.
28:54 CLEARLY SOME COMPANIES ARE MORE FASHIONABLE THAN OTHERS, BUT
29:00 OVER TIME IT'S GREAT. HASLINDA: YOU TALK ABOUT WHAT IT
29:04 ALL MEANS FOR YOUR BUSINESS, YOUR POSITIONING.
29:07 HOW WOULD YOU POSITION YOURSELF? TALK TO THE FACT THAT EVEN
29:11 CONSUMER PATTERNS ARE CHANGING, MORE WILLING TO USE AN AGENT TO
29:14 DO THE WORK FOR THEM. HOW DO YOU CAPITALIZE ON THAT?
29:17 WE SEE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE COMPANY.
29:20 IF YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT AI AND PAYPAL BROUGHT THE MARKET, IT'S
29:27 ABOUT SECURITY IN E-COMMERCE. THIS IS GOING TO BE EVEN MORE
29:31 NECESSARY IN AGENTIC COMMERCE. WE WILL MAKE SURE THAT MERCHANTS
29:36 UNDERSTAND THAT THE AGENT AND THE CONSUMERS ARE REAL AGENTS,
29:38 REAL CONSUMERS THAT CAN PAY IN FOR WHEN THEY TRY TO FIGHT, THAT
29:44 THEY HAVE A PRODUCT WE ARE LOOKING FOR.
29:50 HASLINDA: WHAT IS YOUR SHADING FACTOR?
29:55 YOUR RIVALS ARE DOING THE SAME. WHAT PAYPAL MEANS IS TRUST
29:59 AND SECURITY. WE HAVE THE LARGEST NETWORK OF
30:03 CONSUMERS, THE LARGEST NETWORK OF MERCHANT.
30:05 THEY TRUST US, WE KNOW THEIR IDENTITY, WE KNOW WHAT THEY
30:08 WANT. HASLINDA: WHAT DO YOU BRING THAT
30:13 APPLE PAY CAN'T, FOR INSTANCE? EVEN IN E-COMMERCE TODAY, WE
30:20 ARE VERY DIFFERENT FROM APPLE PAY.
30:27 THESE VALUE PROPOSITIONS WILL BE EVEN MORE RELEVANT.
30:31 HASLINDA: OF COURSE YOU ARE ON A PLAN THAT IS SPENDING SEVERAL
30:36 YEARS. I KNOW YOU'VE ALREADY ELIMINATED
30:40 ABOUT 2000 JOBS, YOU'VE SAVED ABOUT $1.5 BILLION ALREADY WHERE
30:44 ARE YOU IN THE WHOLE TURNAROUND? THE TOURNAMENT IS NOT
30:49 REDUCING COST, IT IS REDUCING COSTS TO INVEST IN GROWTH.
30:52 WE ARE IN THE EARLY STAGES OF THE CHANGE.
30:55 WE'VE IDENTIFIED THE OPPORTUNITIES WE HAVE TO BECOME
30:59 A MORE FINANCIAL SERVICES COMPANY AS WE HAVE BEEN UNTIL
31:04 NOW. WE ALSO NEED TO PROVIDE MUCH
31:06 MORE VALUE TO CONSUMERS. THIRD, WE NEED TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
31:12 OF AI WHILST INTEGRATING IN OUR PORTFOLIO AND ALSO IN
31:17 SIMPLIFYING DRAMATICALLY HOW WE WORK.
31:21 WE ARE MAKING GOOD PROGRESS IN THE RESULTS ARE STARTING TO SHOW
31:24 THAT. WE OBVIOUSLY STILL HAVE SOME
31:26 WORK TO DO. HASLINDA: HOW DOES THAT LOOK
31:30 LIKE THREE OR FIVE YEARS DOWN THE ROAD, HOW WILL PAYPAL BE
31:32 DIFFERENT? THIS NEEDS TO BECOME MUCH
31:40 MORE RELEVANT. BUT THIS MEANS IS THAT CONSUMERS
31:43 WILL NOT BE ONLY ABLE TO PAY WITH US, THEY WILL BE ABLE TO
31:48 GET CREDIT, THEY WILL BE ABLE TO GET LOANS AND BASED ON THE TRUST
31:53 THEY HAVE IN THE BRAND, THEY WILL BE ABLE TO EXPAND.
31:55 HASLINDA: WHAT NEEDS TO CHANGE AND WHAT ARE YOU INVESTING IN
32:00 FOR THAT TO HAPPEN? ARE BIG INVESTMENT IS BY NOW,
32:05 PAY LATER. IT'S A BUSINESS THAT IS GROWING
32:09 ALREADY MORE THAN 20% YEAR ON YEAR, SO WE SEE VERY SIGNIFICANT
32:14 GROWTH IN THIS IS THE FIRST TIME WE ARE WILLING TO CONTINUE TO
32:18 INVEST AND VALIDATE THE CUSTOMERS TO PAY.
32:24 WE NEED TO INVEST IN IDENTITY THAT VELOCITY CRITICAL OF THE
32:27 MARKET SHIFTS MORE TOWARD AI, AND THESE ARE TWO BIG AREAS OF
32:31 TRANSFORMATION AND CHANGE FOR US.
32:32 HASLINDA: YOU SAID HOW YOU'VE DONE WELL FOR THE PAST QUARTER
32:37 AND WALL STREET HAS REWARDED YOU.
32:41 WHEN YOU TAKE A LOOK AT THE CROWN JEWEL, IT WAS ONLY AN
32:44 INCREASE FOR THE QUARTER. CAN YOU REVERSE THAT?
32:49 HOW DO YOU INTEND TO GROW THAT STRATEGY?
32:52 WHAT WE'VE SHOWN IN THE MARKET IS THAT OUR GOAL IS TO BE
32:58 ABLE TO GROW THE COMPANY DOUBLE DIGITS AND TO DO THAT WE NEED TO
33:02 GET THE TRANSACTION MARKET OF THE COMPANY.
33:12 WE NEED TO GROW DOUBLE DIGITS AND STABILIZE IN THE LOW SINGLE
33:16 DIGITS, IT WILL BE A VERY GOOD POSITION FOR US TO BE IN.
33:17 HASLINDA: SO WHAT ARE THE TOPICS FOR THE NEXT FEW QUARTERS?
33:22 IT'S ALL ABOUT STEADY PROGRESS.
33:25 WE NEED TO SHOW THAT THE CORE BUSINESS HAS SURVIVED AND AS WE
33:31 INCREASE THE SERVICES FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE, SHOWING THAT
33:36 CONSUMERS CONSUME MORE OF OUR PRODUCTS, CAPTURE MORE VALUE
33:41 ENSURE THAT WE ARE MAKING PROGRESS.
33:43 HASLINDA: YOU ALSO TALKED ABOUT HOW YOU ARE INTENDING TO INVEST
33:48 FURTHER IN TECHNOLOGY, IN AI. HOW MIGHT THAT LOOK?
33:50 WE HAVE STARTED THE PROCESS FOR THE NEXT EIGHT QUARTERS TO
33:55 FULLY TRANSFORM OUR TECHNOLOGY STACK, AND WE ALREADY HAVE TWO
34:00 QUARTERS BEHIND US AND WE MADE VERY GOOD PROGRESS.
34:04 WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE OFFER NEW SERVICES TO CUSTOMERS
34:09 SUPPORTING AGENTIC COMMERCE, BUT ALSO SIMPLIFIED PROCESSES.
34:16 WE HAVE SEEN WHEN WE HAVE DESIGNED A PROCESS AND WE USE
34:20 AI, WE CAN GIVE A BETTER SERVICE TO CUSTOMERS, WE CAN INNOVATE
34:23 MUCH FASTER. THIS HAS THREE KEY THINGS FOR
34:25 US. HASLINDA: SOME INVESTORS HAVE
34:29 EXPRESSED SOME CONCERN. THEY SAY THAT THEY KEEP THINKING
34:34 THIS TIME AROUND FOR PAYPAL HOW IS IT GOING TO BE DIFFERENT THIS
34:37 TIME AROUND UNDER YOUR LEADERSHIP?
34:38 I'M NOT SO MUCH FOCUS ON WHAT IS DIFFERENT, I'M FOCUS ON
34:43 EXECUTING THE BRAND THAT WE HAVE ONLINE.
34:45 WE HAVE THREE GREAT BUSINESSES. IN EACH OF THE THREE BUSINESSES
34:49 WE HAVE OPPORTUNITY TO GROW, TO PERFORM BETTER AND IF WE DELIVER
34:53 VALUE TO CUSTOMERS, THE COMPANY WILL GROW AND THE SHAREHOLDERS
34:57 WILL BE HAPPY. HASLINDA: AND THAT IS THE
35:00 QUESTION, IT IS ABOUT VALUE CREATION FOR YOUR SHAREHOLDERS.
35:05 WAY OFF WHAT YOU SAW DURING THE PANDEMIC.
35:08 WHEN DO YOU THINK WE MIGHT SEE YOUR STOCK TRADING?
35:12 WHEN DO YOU SEE THE COMPANY CREATING THAT VALUE FOR YOUR
35:14 SHAREHOLDERS? IT IS ALL ABOUT STEADY
35:18 PROGRESS. WE ARE REALLY COMMITTED TO HIS
35:21 EXECUTING OUR PLANS AND IF WE DO THAT YEAR ON YEAR, ORDER ON
35:24 QUARTER, INVESTORS WILL SEE THAT WE CONTINUE TO MAKE PROGRESS.
35:31 I THINK THAT WHEN YOU ARE DOING A BIG CHANGE, YOU NEED TO
35:36 EXPLAIN THE NEW DIRECTION YOU ARE TAKING.
35:39 WE HAVE DONE THAT AND NOW WE ARE TRANSLATING THAT VISION AND THAT
35:43 DIRECTION INTO EXECUTION BY MAKING SURE THAT WE EXECUTE DAY
35:45 AFTER DAY USING THE KEY GOAL THAT WE HAVE.
35:49 HASLINDA: HOW MUCH CLARITY DO YOU HAVE ON YOUR CUSTOMERS?
35:55 U.S. CUSTOMERS IN PARTICULAR IN THE CURRENT ENVIRONMENT WHERE
35:57 PEOPLE FEEL THAT EVERYTHING IS EXPENSIVE AND THAT IS SHAPING
36:03 HOW CONSUMERS SHOP? THIS IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST
36:08 CHANGES WE ARE MAKING BECAUSE WE NEED TO BECOME MUCH MORE
36:11 FOCUSED. ONE OF THE KEY ADVANTAGES OF THE
36:15 COMPANIES, WE'VE PAID A LOT OF ATTENTION TO THE MERCHANT SIDE
36:19 AND WE NEED TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT.
36:22 AND WE NEED TO INVEST MUCH MORE IN UNDERSTANDING WHAT OUR
36:25 CONSUMERS HAVE, WHAT THEY WANT, WHAT THEY ARE EXPECTING FROM US.
36:28 AND THIS IS WHAT WE ARE DOING. WE HAVE A SET OF CONSUMERS THAT
36:34 WE, HIGH-VALUE CONSUMERS, MORE THAN 50% OF THE MARGIN OF THE
36:38 COMPANY. BY UNDERSTANDING WHAT THEY WANT
36:40 AND WHAT THEY VALUE, WHAT SERVICES THEY OFFER, THIS IS WHY
36:46 BY NOW, PAY LATER IS SO CRITICAL.
36:47 THESE ARE THE CUSTOMERS WHO WANT TO USE IT MORE FREQUENTLY AND
36:51 THIS IS WHY IT HAS BECOME SUCH A STRONG PRIORITY.
36:53 HASLINDA: WHEN YOU TAKE A LOOK AT THE DATA, HOW RESILIENT ARE
36:56 THE CONSUMERS TODAY? VERY RESILIENT, ESPECIALLY IN
37:00 THE U.S. WE'VE SEEN VERY STEADY GROWTH IN
37:06 CONSUMPTION, MORE THAN YOU WOULD SAY GIVEN ALL THE THINGS IN OUR
37:09 PERFORMANCE DISCOURSE. HASLINDA: WE THANK YOU SO MUCH
37:13 FOR YOUR TIME TODAY. PRESIDENT AND CEO OF PAYPAL.
37:18 WE ARE COUNTING DOWN TO THE INDIAN MARKET, STOCKS COMING
37:24 ONLINE SHORTLY AS TRADERS EUROPE FOR ANTHROPIC TRADING DEBUT
37:27 LATER THURSDAY. A TWO-DAY RALLY ON WEDNESDAY FOR
37:33 I.T. AND FINANCIAL SERVICES, TAKING A LOOK AT THE INITIAL
37:36 NUMBERS POINTING TO A PRETTY FLAT OPEN AS WE SPEAK.
37:40 AND INDIA SAID TO BE STUDYING PROPOSAL FROM INVESTORS TO RAISE
37:44 TAXES ON STOCK DERIVATIVES WHILE LOWERING LEVY'S.
37:48 IT WAS AT ADDRESSING IMBALANCES IN INDIA'S STOCK TRADING.
37:53 BRING IN ALEX, BLOOMBERG'S REPORTER IN MUMBAI.
37:57 TELL US MORE ABOUT THIS PROPOSAL THAT THE GOVERNMENT IS STUDYING
38:02 AND WHY ARE THEY LOOKING AT IT NOW?
38:08 THE REVENUE SHOWS SUGGESTIONS FROM BOTH ECONOMISTS AS WELL AS
38:14 INVESTORS ON TAXATION ON CAPITAL MARKETS.
38:17 TWO OF THE PROPOSALS THEY ARE STUDYING INCLUDE A POTENTIAL
38:21 REDUCTION IN TRANSACTION CHARGES ON EQUITIES AS WELL AS A HIKE IN
38:25 A TRANSACTION CHARGES AROUND EQUITIES.
38:29 THERE'S ALSO A VIEW AROUND LONG-TERM CAPITAL GAINS ON
38:31 EQUITIES. THE REASON IS VERY SIMPLE.
38:38 INDIAN EQUITIES HAVE PRE-MUCH DISAPPOINTED INVESTORS.
38:41 INVESTORS HAVE PULLED OUT MORE THAN $30 BILLION FROM THE MARKET
38:44 AT ITS PEAK. AND ALL OF THIS CAME AT A TIME
38:48 WHEN GLOBAL MARKETS RALLIED ON THE AI TRADE.
38:51 SO ALL OF THIS CAME TOGETHER AND CREATED HUGE TAXATION IN INDIA
38:56 AND MONEY MANAGERS WERE CALLING FOR TAXES FOR INVESTORS TO BRING
39:00 THEM BACK INTO THE MARKET. AT THE SAME TIME, INDIA'S MARKET
39:06 HAS BECOME EXTREMELY BIG IN RELATION TO THE CASH MARKET THAT
39:09 IS MUCH BIGGER THAN ANY OTHER MARKET THAT WE SEEM GLOBALLY.
39:13 SO REGULATORS HAVE RAISED CONCERNS AROUND THE LOSSES MADE
39:17 BY RETAIL INVESTORS. MANY STEPS HAVE ALREADY BEEN
39:21 TAKEN TO REDUCE SPECULATION AND INCREASE THE TAXES TO BE ANOTHER
39:25 MOVE ALONG THE SAME LINES. HASLINDA: IF THE GOVERNMENT DOES
39:34 MAKE THOSE TWEAKS, WHAT IMPACT WILL THEY HAVE?
39:38 FOR ONE, INVESTORS WILL REALLY BE HAPPY, THAT WILL BE
39:44 SOMETHING THAT PLEASES THE POTENTIAL INCREASE.
39:48 IT IS COMING AT A TIME AND VALUATIONS ARE CORRECTED, THERE
39:52 HAS BEEN INCREASING THE MENTAL. IF THE HIKE ON DERIVATIVES COME
40:01 THROUGH, THAT COULD POTENTIALLY IMPACT VOLUMES IN THAT MARKET
40:04 AND THAT IS A BIG SEGMENT THAT HAS ATTRACTED A LAW INTO THIS
40:07 COUNTRY. IT HAS A LOT OF IMPLICATIONS FOR
40:11 BOTH EXCHANGES. ALL OF THESE ARE BIG NAMES FOR
40:23 INVESTORS. THIS TAXATION CAN REALLY IMPACT
40:28 THE VOLUMES AND MARGINS. HASLINDA: ALEX, I'M LOOKING AT
40:33 THE OPENING NUMBERS FOR INDIAN STOCKS IN THE NEGATIVE.
40:42 HOW ARE INVESTORS ASSESSING INDIAN VALUATIONS, A PRETTY
40:46 SENSITIVE TOPIC FOR MOST INVESTORS.
40:51 RECENTLY, BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE TALKED ABOUT HOW
40:55 WE'VE REACHED A TECHNICAL POINT WHERE THE STEAM HAS SORT OF COME
40:59 OFF RECENTLY. BUT GIVEN ALL OF THAT FOR
41:02 LONG-TERM INVESTORS, IT LOOKS LIKE AN ATTRACTIVE DESTINATION
41:06 RIGHT NOW. THIS MONTH THEY ARE SET TO BUY
41:15 IN A MONTHLY TIMEFRAME. SO VALUATIONS HAVE COME DOWN AND
41:20 IT'S COMING AT A TIME WHEN PROPHETS HAVE BEAT ESTIMATES
41:23 FIVE QUARTERS IN A ROW. THE POSITIONING ONLY HELPS INDIA
41:28 AT THIS MOMENT IN TIME. HASLINDA: ALEX, THANK YOU.
41:39 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
41:48 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK, YOU'RE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
41:51 WE ARE KEEPING AN ION CHINESE TAKE STOCKS AFTER TENCENT FIRST
41:56 EARNINGS DECLINE IN YEARS. REVENUE AND OPERATING PROFIT
41:59 BOTH MISSED ESTIMATES AS A TEDDY INVESTMENTS IN AI DROVE A SHARP
42:02 CASH OUTFLOW. WE WILL ALSO REPORT EARNINGS
42:06 LATER FOR ALIBABA. Q3 SO FAR HAS BEEN PRETTY
42:11 LACKLUSTER. CHARACTERIZED BY DISAPPOINTMENT
42:15 FOR CHINESE INTERNET FIRMS. WHAT DOES IT MEAN FOR THE SECTOR
42:18 AND FOR OTHER REPORTS TONIGHT? THAT'S RIGHT.
42:25 WITH THE ANTHROPIC I FEEL HAPPENING OVER IN THE STATES,
42:27 THAT MAY LIFT THE MOOD A LITTLE BIT.
42:30 BUT I THINK INVESTORS HEAR MORE FOCUS ON THE FUNDAMENTALS,
42:33 PARTICULARLY THE CASH FLOW THAT WE ARE SEEING ACROSS THE SECTOR.
42:37 IF YOU TAKE A STEP BACK WITHIN THE MAIN TECH PLATFORMS, WE'VE
42:42 SEEN A REPORT EARLIER THIS WEEK, WE'VE SEEN JD AS WELL STOCK TAKE
42:47 A HIT GIVEN THE ONGOING CONCERNS ABOUT SLOWING CONSUMPTION IN
42:51 CHINA BUT ALSO THE ONGOING LEVELS OF COMPETITION, AND OF
42:55 COURSE TENCENT LAST NIGHT, THERE WAS A SMALL TECHNICAL MISS.
43:01 NO ONE REALLY CARES ABOUT THAT, BUT THE FREE CASH FLOW OUTFLOW
43:04 IS TURNED NEGATIVE TO A GREATER MAGNITUDE.
43:08 AS THEY CONTINUE TO UP THEIR INVESTMENT SPEND WITH VERY
43:13 LIMITED PROSPECT OF MAKING A FINANCIAL RETURN FOR AT LEAST
43:16 THE NEXT 24 MONTHS. WHAT IS HAPPENING FOR ALIBABA, I
43:24 THINK IF YOU RECALL THE RETAIL SALES NUMBERS IN CHINA FOR
43:28 OCTOBER DISAPPOINTED EXPECTATIONS.
43:29 FOR GROWTH WAS ONLY ABOUT 0.4% YEAR ON YEAR, SO THE HEADWINDS
43:35 IMPACTING CHINESE CONSUMERS ARE AT A POINT WHERE COMPETITION
43:38 ACROSS THE SECTOR REMAINS REALLY CUTTHROAT.
43:41 I THINK THE SCOPE FOR DISAPPOINTMENT ON THAT SIDE OF
43:44 THE BUSINESS AND IN THE CLOUD BUSINESS WILL BE GROWING VERY
43:49 STRONGLY AND IN TERMS OF TOPLINE, THERE MAY BE SOME
43:51 MARGINAL IMPROVEMENT IN THE OPERATING MARGIN FOR THAT
43:56 BUSINESS, BUT AT WHAT COST? AGAIN, I WOULD EXPECT THE FREE
44:00 CASH OUTFLOW FOR THAT BUSINESS TO REMAIN ELEVATED AND PERHAPS
44:03 TO POTENTIALLY WIDEN IN A QUARTER THEY ARE ABOUT A REPORT
44:07 WITH REMAINING ELEVATED AT SIGNIFICANT LEVELS FOR REALLY
44:12 THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS OR SO. SO THE KEY QUESTION FOR
44:15 INVESTORS IS WHERE OUR RETURNS? WE HAVE NO FORESIGHT ON THAT AT
44:21 THE MOMENT WHICH IS BY THESE STOCKS ARE SELLING OFF QUITE
44:23 HANDILY. HASLINDA: YOU TALKED ABOUT
44:27 TENCENT MISSING THE THIRD QUARTER.
44:30 ANY FUNDAMENTAL CONCERN FOR? KNOW, I THINK LONG-TERM IT IS
44:36 A PENSION FUND MANAGER'S DREAM. IT IS A VERY DIVERSIFIED
44:41 BUSINESS, IT HAS MARKET LEADERSHIP IN MOST OF ITS
44:43 MARKETS. ITS OPERATING MARGINS ARE
44:46 STRUCTURALLY HIGH, HIGHER THAN MOST OF HIS CLOSE PEERS.
44:52 AGAIN, IT IS INHERENTLY CASH GENERATIVE.
44:55 ABSOLUTELY IT'S GOING TO REMAIN ONE OF THE MAIN PLAYERS FOR THE
44:59 FORESEEABLE FUTURE. THE ISSUE FOR TENCENT REALLY IS
45:03 THEY ARE UPPING INVESTMENT SPENDING IN AI, IT IS DEPRESSING
45:07 THE CASH LOOK, DEPRESSING THE MARGINS.
45:11 THERE'S NO REAL PROSPECT OF A NEAR-TERM PAYBACK ON THAT.
45:14 HASLINDA: ROB, WHO DO YOU SEE EMERGING AS THE LONG-TERM
45:19 WINNERS IN CHINA'S AI SECTOR? WHEN CAN INVESTORS EXPECT A
45:24 PAYCHECK? I GUESS THIS TIES IN NICELY
45:29 WITH WHAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT.
45:32 IT IS THE TECH PLATFORMS. I THINK IT IS TENCENT, BYTEDANCE
45:37 AND IN THE LONG TERM, ALIBABA. DON'T FORGET HUAWEI AS WELL
45:42 BEING A CHAMPION ON THE SEMICONDUCTOR AND THE HARDWARE
45:44 SIDE. AND AGAIN, AT THIS POINT IN THE
45:46 MARKET WHICH IS QUITE LITERALLY FLOODED WITH SUPPLIED, THERE ARE
45:50 MORE THAN 1100 LARGE LANGUAGE MODELS COMPETING IN CHINA.
45:53 THE SECTOR IS IN MASSIVE OVERSUPPLY AND IT HAS
45:58 COMMODITIZED, THEREFORE IT IS INCREDIBLY HARD FOR ANY COMPANY
46:00 COMMODITIZED IN THAT ENVIRONMENT.
46:03 AND WHERE THERE IS MONETIZATION HAPPENING, IT IS AT A RELATIVELY
46:06 MODEST LEVEL. VERY LOW LEVELS COMPARED TO
46:10 ANTHROPIC AND ITS U.S. PEERS AT A TIME WHEN INVESTMENT SPEND IS
46:14 GOING UP SUBSTANTIALLY AND IT IS SPENDING HUGE AMOUNTS ON CAPEX.
46:19 TENCENT R&D SPEND REPORTING FOR Q3 LAST NIGHT ROSE 41%
46:24 YEAR-OVER-YEAR. THAT'S A HUGE AMOUNT OF
46:27 INVESTMENT WITH NO PROSPECT OF RETURN IN THE NEAR TERM.
46:29 HASLINDA: ROB, THANK YOU. MORE FROM THE FESTIVAL COMING
46:35 RIGHT UP. KEEP IT WITH US.
46:37 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
47:02 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK, YOU'RE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
47:08 PRESIDENT TRUMP IS SET TO MEET WITH CHINA'S XI JINPING THIS
47:10 HOUR ON THE SIDELINES OF THE APEC SUMMIT.
47:13 IT WILL MARK THEIR THIRD MEETING SO FAR THIS YEAR AND LATER BOTH
47:17 MEN WILL ALSO GATHER WITH RUSSIA'S VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR
47:21 UNPRECEDENTED TRILATERAL TALKS. HE TOLD FOX NEWS HE WOULD NOT BE
47:27 ASKING FOR HELP TO END THE IRAN WAR.
47:30 WE DON'T NEED ANY HELP. WE'VE DEFEATED THEIR NAVY, WE'VE
47:34 DEFEATED THEIR AIRCRAFTS, WE DEFEATED THE ANTIAIRCRAFT.
47:37 THE MISSES ARE DOWN TO ABOUT 12. THEY STILL HAVE SOME MISSILES
47:41 BUT THEY ARE DOWN TO ABOUT 12%, 13% FROM WHAT THEY WERE AND THEY
47:44 WANT TO MAKE A DEAL. SO I DON'T NEED HELP.
47:47 I'M NOT GOING TO GO ASKING FOR HELP.
47:49 HASLINDA: FIRE CHIEF NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT JOINS US NOW FROM
47:54 SHENZHEN. WE DON'T KNOW ABOUT THE AGENDA.
47:57 WHAT IS AT STAKE HERE? [LAUGHTER]
48:02 I WISH I DID, I WISH I WAS A FLY ON THE WALL BUT CLEARLY THE U.S.
48:08 ADMINISTRATION, DONALD TRUMP FOCUSING ON ATMOSPHERICS AND A
48:11 STABLE RELATIONSHIP AND CLOSE FRIENDSHIP WITH XI JINPING AT
48:18 THE OVERALL MOOD, IF YOU WILL, THE MOOD MUSIC IS THE FRIENDSHIP
48:23 BETWEEN THESE TWO PEOPLE. DONALD TRUMP, WE GOT A LITTLE
48:26 BIT MORE INFORMATION FROM THAT INTERVIEW WITH FOX NEWS ABOUT
48:29 THE NATURE OF THEIR DISCUSSION SO FAR.
48:32 DONALD TRUMP TELLING FOXCONN THAT THEY SPOKE THE WHOLE
48:36 EVENING, THEY WERE SITTING NEXT TO EACH OTHER AT THE DINNER
48:39 TABLE AND SPOKE THE WHOLE EVENING.
48:40 AS FAR AS JENSEN HUANG HE SAID I MIGHT HAVE REFERENCED IT JUST
48:44 BRIEFLY BECAUSE IT IS SUCH A TRAGEDY.
48:49 AGAIN, HE IS NOT PUSHING NECESSARILY THE ISSUE OF
48:55 INDUSTRIAL ESPIONAGE AS IT IS TIED TO ALICE HUANG AND THE
48:57 LIKE. HE SAID AGAIN, HE GOT QUITE
49:01 CANDID TELLING FOX NEWS ANY PRETTY WOMAN THAT COMES FROM
49:07 CHINA, THEY CONSIDER HER TO BE A SPY.
49:09 I DON'T KNOW WHO HE'S REFERRING TO.
49:12 SHE WAS A BUSINESSWOMAN WHO BOUGHT CHIPS IS HOW DONALD TRUMP
49:16 DESCRIBED THAT RELATIONSHIP WITH JENSEN HUANG AND ALICE HUANG.
49:22 HE OBVIOUSLY DOES NOT PUSHING THIS ISSUE IS A MAIN POINT OF
49:27 CONTENTION IN THEIR RELATIONSHIP.
49:29 HE WANTS TO FOCUS ON OPTICS AND ATMOSPHERICS, SHOWING A STRONG
49:33 RELATIONSHIP IN THIS, THE THIRD BILATERAL BETWEEN THE TWO
49:37 GENTLEMEN THIS YEAR, THE FOURTH SINCE AIPAC LAST YEAR.
49:42 IN A SORT OF RAMBLING SPEECH AT THE PLENARY OPENING SESSION
49:45 TODAY WITH THE LEADERS ALL AROUND THAT ROUNDTABLE, HE
49:50 BASICALLY TALKED ABOUT AI, HE DOESN'T WANT TO STIFLE AI
49:53 DEVELOPMENT. HE SEES IT AS A GREAT STRENGTH,
49:58 HE CALLED IT SIS, OF COURSE, SUPER INTELLIGENT AND IS A
50:02 STRENGTH THAT HE DOES NOT WANT TO PUT LIMITS ON.
50:05 THAT WILL LIKELY BE A POINT THAT THE TWO LEADERS WILL DISCUSS HOW
50:10 THEY CAN WORK IN COOPERATION BECAUSE IF YOU REMEMBER IN
50:14 SEPTEMBER, THE TWO LEADERS AGREED TO SET UP AN AI HOTLINE
50:17 WHERE THEY CAN DISCUSS SOME OF THE RISKS, SOME OF THE AREAS OF
50:20 COOPERATION, BUT NO DOUBT WITH THE WORDS THAT HE HAD TODAY
50:25 INDICATING THAT AMERICA AND THE UNITED STATES IS THE LEADER IN
50:27 AI AND THEY WILL TRY TO REMAIN THE LEADER IN AI.
50:31 CLEARLY AIPAC IS BEING HELD IN SHENZHEN AND XI JINPING WOULD
50:36 HAVE A DIFFERENT ASSESSMENT OF WHO IS THE LEADER RIGHT NOW IN
50:38 AI DEVELOPMENT. WE ARE WAITING OF COURSE NOT
50:43 ONLY ON THAT BILATERAL BETWEEN XI JINPING AND DONALD TRUMP, BUT
50:46 THE TRILATERAL THAT INCLUDES VLADIMIR PUTIN.
50:49 IT IS MORE DIFFICULT TO DECIDE AND FIND OUT AND DECIPHER WHAT
50:53 ARE GOING TO BE THE DELIVERABLES FOR MATT BECAUSE AGAIN, AS WE
50:55 JUST HEARD, HE DOES NOT PLAN TO BRING UP OR ELICIT THE HELP OF
51:05 VLADIMIR PUTIN OR XI JINPING IN THE ONGOING WAR, NINE MONTHS ON
51:09 NOW IN IRAN. HE ALSO DOESN'T PLAN TO BRING UP
51:15 THE WAR IN UKRAINE. HE ALSO HAS BEEN QUOTED AS
51:19 SAYING THAT HE DOESN'T PLAN TO REACH ANY DEAL WITH VLADIMIR
51:23 PUTIN ON THE WAR IN UKRAINE WITHOUT FIRST CONSULTING
51:30 ZELENSKYY FOR THE LEADERSHIP IN KYIV.
51:33 SO WHAT IS GOING TO BE DISCUSSED IN THAT TRILATERAL BEYOND THESE
51:36 ISSUES? [LAUGHTER]
51:39 HASLINDA: EXACTLY, I'M WONDERING THE SAME.
51:44 SO MANY THINGS THEY ARE PLANNING NOT TO DISCUSS.
51:50 STEVE, HE'S NOT TO BE OUTDONE. HE DOES NOT WANT TO BE IN THE
51:54 SHADOWS OF TRUMP AND XI JINPING. HE DID SPEAK EARLIER TODAY
51:57 TALKING ABOUT HOW YOU KNOW HE'S INVITING AIPAC LEADERS TO USE
52:01 THE ROUTES ON THE BACK OF WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE STRAIT OF
52:03 HORMUZ. ABSOLUTELY.
52:10 SURE, VLADIMIR PUTIN DOESN'T GET TOO MANY OPPORTUNITIES TO SPEAK
52:13 ON A GLOBAL STAGE LIKE THIS. HE IS ISOLATED, PRETTY MUCH.
52:17 HE IS WIDELY CONSIDERED INCLUDING IN MANY CAPITALS
52:20 AROUND EUROPE AND INTERNATIONAL WAR CRIMINAL, SO CHINA HAS GIVEN
52:25 HIM TWO OPPORTUNITIES IN THE LAST 12 TO 14 MONTHS INCLUDING
52:30 PARTICIPATION IN THAT VICTORY PARADE, THAT WORLD WAR II
52:35 ANNIVERSARY PARADE IN BEIJING WHERE KIM JONG-UN WAS ALSO
52:37 THERE. NOW HE IS HERE AIPAC BEING
52:39 ALLOWED TO SPEAK ON A GLOBAL STAGE ON EQUAL FOOTING WITH
52:45 DONALD TRUMP AND XI JINPING. HOWEVER, CHINA IS BIG ON OPTICS
52:48 AND I TALKED ABOUT THAT TERM, ATMOSPHERICS.
52:51 WE HAVE TO READ INTO SOME OF THAT SUBTLE MESSAGING AND
52:54 POSITIONING. YES, VLADIMIR PUTIN IN TODAY'S
52:59 PHOTO, IT WAS VLADIMIR PUTIN, XI JINPING, DONALD TRUMP.
53:04 THE THREE OF THEM CENTERED. JUST BEHIND THAT I BELIEVE IT
53:07 WAS MARK CARNEY. FAR OFF TO THE LEFT, THIS FAR
53:15 LEFT AS YOU CAN GET IS TAIWAN'S REPRESENTATIVE IN THE BACK ROW
53:22 AND ALSO TO THE FAR, FAR BACK AND WRITE WITH THE JAPANESE
53:26 PRIME MINISTER AS WELL AS JOHN LEE, THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OF HONG
53:31 KONG. BUT HE IS IN THE FAR BACK RIGHT
53:34 BECAUSE HE IS NOT STATE LEADER OBVIOUSLY.
53:37 SO WE DON'T WANT TO READ TOO MUCH INTO THAT BUT SEEING THE
53:40 JAPANESE PRIME MINISTER WAY IN THE BACK, THAT WAS YESTERDAY'S
53:43 PHOTO. I GIVE PROPS TO TALK E.G. EVEN
53:46 THOUGH SHE WAS RELEGATED TO THE BACK ROW, SHE WAS WEARING BRIGHT
53:50 PINK TO STANDOUT. BUT AGAIN, ABOUT VLADIMIR PUTIN.
53:55 IT WAS XI JINPING THAT GREETED DONALD TRUMP AT THE AIRPORT
54:00 YESTERDAY, RECIPROCATED THE POLITENESS AND THE ETIQUETTE AND
54:04 PAGEANTRY THAT DONALD TRUMP GAVE TO XI JINPING IN WASHINGTON IN
54:08 SEPTEMBER. HE DID NOT GET THE SAME MONITOR
54:12 VLADIMIR PUTIN WHEN PUTIN ARRIVED YESTERDAY.
54:20 HE IS THE CHIEF SECRETARY OF PRESIDENT XI.
54:27 LESSER, OBVIOUSLY, THEN THE MAN HIMSELF GREETING VLADIMIR PUTIN
54:31 AT THE AIRPORT. HASLINDA: AND YOU KNOW WHAT,
54:35 STEVE, WHO NEEDS SUBSTANCE WHEN YOU HAVE OPTICS AND BIG SMILES?
54:38 OF COURSE WE SAW THAT HUGE SMILE.
54:41 BLOOMBERG'S CHIEF NORTH ASIAN CORRESPONDENT, THANK YOU SO MUCH
54:47 FOR THAT. AGES THOUGHT BENCHMARK IS MOVING
54:49 OFF SESSION LOWS AND SENTIMENT REMAINS WEAK.
54:54 THAT IS DESPITE USING INFLATION CONCERNS AND ANOTHER LOOK AT
55:00 MARKETS WHERE STOCKS REMAIN UNDER PRESSURE.
55:03 AVRIL: AS YOU SAID, THE BENCHMARK MOVING OFF OF SESSION
55:07 LOWS AND WE ARE SEEING JAPAN COME BACK FROM THE LARGE BREAK
55:09 IN THE GREEN. CHINESE STOCKS ARE IN THE GRAY
55:12 BUT IT IS INTERESTING TO SEE HOW TAIWAN HAS BEEN UNDERPERFORMING
55:17 AND DESPAIRING LOSSES AS INVESTORS LOOKED NOT JUST TO THE
55:22 BILATERAL, BUT ALSO THAT TRILATERAL MEETING THIS WEEK,
55:25 LEADERS OF CHINA, RUSSIA AND THE U.S..
55:29 IT REALLY THESE TECH CONCERNS THAT ARE POTENTIALLY WITHERING
55:32 IN TERMS OF STOCK SENTIMENT. YOU HAD NVIDIA GIVEN THE POST
55:36 EARNINGS RALLY FIZZLING OUT, ANTHROPIC IN TERMS OF THE IPO
55:41 PRICING, IT IS ABOVE THE MARKET RANGE AND IT WAS OF SIZED IPO IN
55:45 TERMS OF ITS OFFERING, SELLING 980 MILLION SHARES.
55:49 BUT AGAIN, IT HAS TO SHOW THAT BIT OF GREEN ON ITS TRADING
55:54 DEBUT LATER THURSDAY, SO THAT IS AMONG THE CONCERNS FOR INVESTORS
55:58 EVEN AS WE SEE THE STOCK INDEX KIND OF FLIPPING BETWEEN GAINS
56:04 AND LOSSES IN PARTS OF THE REGION TODAY.
56:07 WHEN IT COMES TO THE MACRO BACKDROP OF COURSE, THIS WEEKEND
56:11 HAS BEEN ABOUT OIL PRICES. THEY'VE BEEN SLIDING EVEN THOUGH
56:14 YOU ARE LOOKING FLAT FOR THE MOMENT.
56:16 WE DID END LAST WEEK AT $96 A BARREL AND THIS WEEK HAS BEEN
56:21 DOMINATED BY THE NARRATIVE OF SUPPLIES COMING BACK THROUGH THE
56:25 MIDDLE EAST AND TRADERS ALSO SEEM TO BE WEIGHING THAT TRUMP
56:28 WILL BE HOLDING OFF ON LARGE-SCALE IRAN STRIKES.
56:31 WE ARE OF COURSE HEARING FROM HIM AT THAT AIPAC MEETING
56:34 TALKING ABOUT HOW HE WILL NOT BE SEEKING HELP OF THE CHINESE OR
56:37 RUSSIAN LEADERS FOR IRAN. WITH THE TUMBLE OR THE SLIDE
56:43 THAT WE'VE BEEN SEEING IN ENERGY PRICES OVERALL, WE ARE SEEING
56:46 YIELDS TREND A LOT. I JUST HIGHLIGHT WHAT WE ARE
56:51 SEEING IN THE GREEN DESPITE WHAT WE ARE SEEING.
56:52 THIS IS GAINING GROUND VS. THE JAPANESE YEN ESPECIALLY ON THE
56:59 AUSSIE DOLLAR. WE DID SEE A WEAK JOBS NUMBER
57:04 TODAY, SO TRADERS BETTING ON RATE CUTS FOR THE JAPANESE YEN
57:08 FOLLOWING BOJ GOVERNOR TALKING ABOUT HOW THEY STILL WANT TO
57:13 WATCH NEXT YEAR. SO NOT GIVING TRADERS ANY
57:16 CLARITY WHEN IT COMES TO THE PACE OF RATE HIKES.
57:19 HAS? HASLINDA: AVRIL HONG, THANK YOU.
57:24 STILL AHEAD, WE TALKED TO INDONESIA AS ITS CENTRAL BANK
57:30 DEPLOYS EVERYTHING IN ITS ARSENAL TO DEFEND RUPIAH.
57:33 WE WILL HEAR EXCLUSIVELY FROM BANK DANAMON INDONESIA.
57:42 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
57:48 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK. YOU'RE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
57:55 INDONESIA'S CENTRAL BANK UNEXPECTEDLY RESUMED RAISING
57:57 INTEREST RATES. IT ALSO UNVEILED MORE INCENTIVES
58:01 FOR INVESTORS TO HOLD ASIA'S WORST CURRENCY THIS YEAR.
58:09 NORMAN, WHAT MADE THEM CHANGE THEIR MIND FROM A HOLD LAST
58:12 MONTH TO A HIKE THIS MONTH? YEAH, SO I LIKE THE WAY THE
58:19 SENIOR DEPUTY GOVERNOR EXPLAINED IT WHICH IS THAT LAST MONTH THEY
58:22 HELD IT BECAUSE THEY SAW THAT THE RUPIAH IS UNDER PRESSURE.
58:29 THE TWO-YEAR FORECAST FOR INFLATION IS STILL WITHIN THE
58:32 TARGET RANGE. FAST FORWARD TO THIS MONTH, THEY
58:36 SEE THAT THE DEVELOPMENT INCLUDING INCREASED UNCERTAINTY,
58:40 THEY MENTIONED GEOPOLITICS, THEY MENTIONED CONCERNS OVER AI
58:45 VALUATIONS, AND IT'S REALLY THESE CHANGES THAT HAVE NOW
58:48 AFFECTED THEIR FORECAST FOR INFLATION IN ORDER TO ANCHOR
58:53 THAT EXPECTATION. THAT IS WHY THEY PRODUCE A RATE
58:56 HIKE. HASLINDA: SO WHAT ELSE ARE THEY
59:04 DOING TO SUPPORT THE RUPIAH? ANY MEASURES THAT MAY BE
59:07 IMPLEMENTED? YES, THEY ARE ALSO
59:12 INTRODUCING A PLAN RATE HIKE. THEY ANNOUNCED YESTERDAY THAT
59:15 THEY WOULD INCREASE, BUT THEY WOULD FURTHER REDUCE THE
59:19 PREMIUMS AND THEY WOULD ALSO INTRODUCED A CROSS CURRENCY
59:25 MEASURE FOR BANKS TO INCREASE LIQUIDITY.
59:29 THESE ARE IN LINE WITH WHAT THEY'VE BEEN SAYING IN PREVIOUS
59:32 RATE DECISIONS WHERE WE ARE NOT JUST LOOKING AT THE RATE POLICY
59:35 TO HELP STABILIZE, BUT ALSO TOOLS BEYOND INTEREST RATE
59:40 BENCHMARK. HASLINDA: NORMAN, THANK YOU.
59:49 DURING THE EXCLUSIVELY NOW, THE PRESENT DIRECTOR OF THE BANK OF
59:55 INDONESIA. HIS THE SIXTH LARGEST COMMERCIAL
59:58 BANK INDONESIA AND IT IS A FACT BY THE BANK WHICH HOLD A
1:00:02 MAJORITY OWNERSHIP STAKE. WE ARE JUST TALKING ABOUT THE
1:00:06 RUPIAH AND THE LACKLUSTER PERFORMANCE.
1:00:10 IN FACT, THE WORST PERFORMANCE IN THE WORLD.
1:00:12 JUST WONDERING WHAT IT WOULD TAKE FOR THE CURRENCY TO
1:00:14 ACTUALLY GET A LIFT? I WAS NOT ABLE TO HEAR THE
1:00:18 REPORT RIGHT NOW BUT DEFINITELY ONE MOVEMENT IS TO RAISE THE
1:00:26 INTEREST RATE. AND I WOULD SAY THAT THIS IS NOT
1:00:30 A MOVEMENT ONLY FROM INDONESIA. MANY COUNTRIES ARE DOING THE
1:00:34 SAME WAY, ESPECIALLY ONE OR TWO YEARS.
1:00:39 IN JAPAN, JAPAN IS ALSO DOING THE SAME WAY.
1:00:44 FINALLY IT ESCAPED FROM THE ZERO OR MINUS ZERO INTEREST RATE ERA,
1:00:47 BUT STILL, I HAVE TO SAY THE CURRENCY IS NOT STRONG ENOUGH
1:00:52 AGAINST THE U.S. DOLLAR. THIS IS THE SAME, WHICH IS WHY
1:00:57 AM SEEING MANY INDONESIAN TRAVELERS GO TO JAPAN AND I'M
1:01:02 CONVINCING MY FRIENDS TO COME TO INDONESIA.
1:01:04 HASLINDA: DO YOU THINK WE'VE SEEN THE BOTTOM YET?
1:01:07 IT'S DIFFICULT TO SAY. I HOPE IT IS THE BOTTOM BUT
1:01:12 STILL, THERE'S MANY VOLATILITIES IN THE GEOPOLITICAL TENSION.
1:01:19 I'M STILL A BIT CAUTIOUS. HASLINDA: THERE ARE CONCERNS
1:01:24 ABOUT THE INDONESIAN ECONOMY AND THE POSSIBLE DOUBLE DOWNGRADE BY
1:01:27 THE MSCI. CORRECT.
1:01:35 THEY DEFINITELY MAKE PEOPLE THINK, BUT AT THE SAME TIME, I
1:01:42 KNOW THERE'S SO MANY INTERESTING HEADLINES ALMOST EVERY DAY
1:01:47 COMING, AND MY TOKYO HEADQUARTERS HAS EXPRESSED THEIR
1:01:53 CONCERN ON INDONESIA'S SITUATION, SO THEY ARE CALLING
1:01:55 ME ALMOST EVERY DAY SAYING HOW ARE YOU, ARE YOU DOING WELL?
1:02:00 WHAT IS THE SITUATION, HOW IS THE BUSINESS?
1:02:03 SO I'M TELLING THEM THAT YES, I'M RUNNING INTO THIS TERRIBLE
1:02:10 SITUATION, CAN YOU LOWER MY TARGET?
1:02:12 HOWEVER I'M SAYING THE OPPOSITE TO MY TEAM.
1:02:14 THIS IS A CHANCE THAT WE CAN DO MORE AND WE'VE JUST PROVEN IT
1:02:20 THIS YEAR. OUR NET PROFIT GREW BY 19% YEAR
1:02:24 ON YEAR. DEPOSIT 13%.
1:02:32 AND OUR RATIO IS FLAT. SO THE NUMBERS ARE SHOWING
1:02:36 SOMETHING DIFFERENT FROM THAT. AND ALSO I'M TALKING WITH MANY
1:02:41 INDONESIAN BUSINESSMEN, IS THIS PERSONS, AND MOST OF THEM ARE
1:02:47 SAYING THAT THEIR BUSINESS IS NOT BAD.
1:02:49 THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF A GAP BETWEEN THE HEADLINES AND WHAT
1:02:53 IS HAPPENING. HASLINDA: WHAT ARE YOU HEARING
1:02:59 FROM YOUR FOREIGN INVESTOR CLIENTS WITH THE PROSPECTS OF A
1:03:03 DOUBLE DOWNGRADE? THAT IS MY CONCERN AS I
1:03:08 EXPLAINED. SO FOR THEM, THEY ARE READING
1:03:11 THE NEWSPAPER, THINKING THERE IS SOMETHING WRONG HAPPENING.
1:03:15 SO I HEAR THAT SOME COMPANIES ARE PUTTING THEIR INVESTMENT
1:03:20 INTO INDONESIA. ALSO INTERESTINGLY, SELECTIVE
1:03:25 INDUSTRIES LIKE JAPANESE BIG TRADING HOUSES OR OTHER
1:03:29 MULTINATIONAL COMPANIES ARE STILL LOOKING TO INVEST INTO
1:03:32 INDONESIA. THAT IS ALSO SOMETHING THAT I'M
1:03:35 FACING. HASLINDA: IN TERMS OF THE DEMAND
1:03:38 FOR LOANS, HOW MUCH CLARITY IS THERE FOR THE NEXT 24 MONTHS?
1:03:45 AGAIN, 12% LOAN GROWTH YEAR ON YEAR.
1:03:50 AND WE ARE STILL SEEING DEMAND COMING.
1:03:53 SO I BELIEVE WE CAN HAVE THE SAME RATE, BUT THAT LOAN GROWTH
1:03:59 IS ALSO SAYING THAT WE NEED LIQUIDITY.
1:04:04 STRONG LOAN GROWTH IS ALSO GIVING A TIGHT LIQUIDITY
1:04:08 SITUATION. HASLINDA: YOU'VE BEEN PRETTY
1:04:14 UPBEAT. ABOUT 300 COMPANIES REMOVED FROM
1:04:19 THE STOCK EXCHANGE. I'M JUST WONDERING HOW YOU VIEW
1:04:22 THAT MOVE, ARE THERE CONCERNS AND WHAT IS THE PATH FORWARD?
1:04:26 AT THE SAME TIME BEFORE I BECAME THE CEO, I WITH THE CHIEF
1:04:34 EXECUTIVE OF ASIA-PACIFIC LEADING 17 MARKETS.
1:04:47 MANY OF THESE COMPANIES WERE SAYING THAT THEY STILL WANT TO
1:04:49 ENTER INTO INDONESIA OR EXPAND BUSINESS INTO EVEN ASIA -- INTO
1:04:54 INDONESIA. I BELIEVE THERE ARE SOME GAPS
1:04:58 BETWEEN WHAT IS SPREAD OUT AND WHAT WE ARE SEEING ON THE GROUND
1:05:00 HERE. SPECIFICALLY REFERRING TO
1:05:05 DANNA MONTE AND REMOVED FROM THE EXCHANGE.
1:05:11 WE ARE NOT, WE ARE STILL IN THE MARKET.
1:05:14 HASLINDA: WHAT IS THE GROWTH PATH GOING FORWARD, THEN?
1:05:19 WHAT WOULD BE THE KEY AREAS? THE MOST STRONGEST INDUSTRY I
1:05:25 FEEL IS THE CONSUMER SIDE. EVEN ACROSS MANY INDUSTRIES, I'M
1:05:36 STILL FEELING STRONG DEMAND ON THE LOAN AND EVERYTHING LIKE
1:05:44 THAT. I'M STILL KIND OF OPTIMISTIC.
1:05:46 HASLINDA: WHY WOULD THAT MAKE SENSE, WHAT DO YOU THINK CAN
1:05:54 HAPPEN IMMEDIATELY? WE LIKE TO ESTABLISH A VERY
1:05:59 UNIQUE THING IN INDONESIA. THERE ARE SEVERAL BIG LOCAL,
1:06:03 STRONG LOCAL GROUPS WHICH ARE WAY LARGER THAN US.
1:06:08 EVEN AFTER THE INTEGRATION. THIS IS ONE OF THE LARGEST
1:06:17 BANKS. WITH THAT, WE HAVE THE LARGEST
1:06:21 FOREIGN BANK PRESENCE IN INDONESIA.
1:06:24 SO THAT WILL BE DEFINITELY A UNIQUE PROPOSITION AND AS I
1:06:29 EXPLAINED, I VISITED MANY CLIENTS OUTSIDE OF INDONESIA,
1:06:34 EXPLORED ENTERING INDONESIA. SO WE CAN DEFINITELY SUPPORT
1:06:37 THESE COMPANIES INTO INDONESIA. AND THE POINT IS WE CAN ALSO NOT
1:06:42 ONLY SERVE THAT COMPANY, BUT WE CAN SERVE THAT COMPANY IF THEY
1:06:48 NEED SUPPLIERS, ANY DISTRIBUTORS, THEY NEED
1:06:50 END-USERS. NOT ONLY TO THE BIG COMPANIES.
1:06:56 HASLINDA: ALIGNING PROCESSES IS PRETTY CHALLENGING.
1:07:01 HOW DO YOU ASSESS DIFFICULTY? THAT'S WHY WE DECIDED TO
1:07:07 INTEGRATE IT. WE ARE CORROBORATING WELL, BUT
1:07:16 IT WILL GIVE THE THINGS MUCH SMOOTHER.
1:07:18 THAT'S WHY WE DECIDED TO MAKE TWO INTO ONE.
1:07:24 IT IS A TANGIBLE RESULT. THOSE SYNERGIES, WHAT MIGHT THAT
1:07:28 TRANSLATE TO IN TERMS OF REVENUE IN THE COMING YEARS?
1:07:34 MAY BE THE FIRST YEAR I HAVE TO SAY THAT THERE IS SOME
1:07:37 INTEGRATION HAPPENING, BUT IN THREE YEARS TIME FRAME I BELIEVE
1:07:41 IT WILL INCREASE OUR PROFIT FIGHT TWO DIGITS OR SOMETHING.
1:07:49 COMPARED TO BE OPERATE DIFFERENTLY.
1:07:50 HASLINDA: WOULD YOU BE ADOPTING A DIFFERENT STRATEGY FOR THE
1:07:55 COMMODITY ENTITY? BASICALLY THE SAME, BUT WE
1:07:59 WOULD DOUBLE DOWN. HASLINDA: DOES DOUBLING DOWN
1:08:03 MEAN HIRING FURTHER HEADCOUNT? INCLUDING.
1:08:08 FOR EXAMPLE THERE'S SO MANY CHINESE COMPANIES NOW ENTERING
1:08:11 INTO INDONESIA. IF WE WANT TO REALLY CAPTURE
1:08:14 THIS FLOW, WE MAY NEED MORE CHINESE SPEAKING INFLUENCE.
1:08:21 THAT IS ONE EXAMPLE. FOR SURE IF LEAD TO EXPAND, WE
1:08:24 NEED MORE HEADCOUNT. HASLINDA: CAN YOU FORTIFY THAT,
1:08:29 YOU ARE LOOKING AT HIRING 100 MORE?
1:08:31 I WOULD LIKE TO SAY 100 MORE BUT WE HAVE TO FIND THE RIGHT
1:08:35 PERSON. IF I WANT THE IMPACT TO BE BIG,
1:08:43 OF COURSE I HAVE TO HIRE MORE. WHAT IS THE BIGGEST CHALLENGE
1:08:47 FOR BANKS RIGHT NOW? PERHAPS WITH AI AND AI
1:08:52 DEPLOYMENT WITHIN THE BANKS, HOW ARE YOU LOOKING AT THAT?
1:08:56 YOU HAVE TWO OPTIONS. YOU WANT TO HEAR AN ANSWER WHICH
1:09:00 WAS CREATED BY MY STAFF YOU WANT TO HAVE A REAL CONVERSATION,
1:09:04 WHICH ONE DO YOU PREFER? MAYBE TO CANDID ONE, OK.
1:09:09 I HAVE TO SAY IT'S TOO EARLY TO SAY THAT WE HAVE SUCCEEDED TO
1:09:15 EARN BIG MONEY OR SAVE THE COST BY AI, TO BE HONEST.
1:09:20 I KNOW YOU HAVE BEEN INTERVIEWING MANY CEOS AND MOST
1:09:25 OF THEM ARE SAYING THAT WE ARE ADOPTING AI, WE ARE USING AIA
1:09:28 LOT. BUT IF THE QUESTION IS WHETHER
1:09:37 THAT IS MOVING THE NEEDLE OF OUR ENTIRE COST TO INCOME RATIO, I
1:09:42 HAVE TO SAY, THAT'S THE REALITY THAT WE ARE FACING RIGHT NOW.
1:09:47 HASLINDA: GREAT TO HAVE YOU WITH US, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
1:09:52 TIME TODAY. COMING UP, HAWKISH STANCE FROM
1:10:04 SEVERAL BANKS ACROSS THE WORLD PUTTING PRESSURE ON PROPERTY
1:10:06 MARKETS. WE WILL SPEAK EXCLUSIVELY WITH
1:10:13 WILLIAM GRAY ON HIS OUTLOOK. KEEP IT WITH US.
1:10:24 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK. YOU ARE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
1:10:28 WE ARE KEEPING AN EYE ON THE ACTIVITIES IN SHENZHEN AT THAT
1:10:32 APEC SUMMIT. RIGHT NOW ON YOUR SCREEN, WE ARE
1:10:36 SEEING THE PICTURES OF PRESIDENT PUTIN AS WELL AS PRESIDENT
1:10:39 TRUMP. BOTH LEADERS ARE IN
1:10:41 CONVERSATIONS. OF COURSE, FRONT AND CENTER
1:10:47 WOULD BE THE TRILATERAL MEETING THAT IS HAPPENING LATER ON WITH
1:10:50 -- LET'S TAKE A LISTEN TO WHAT IS HAPPENING THERE.
1:10:59 RIGHT. WE WILL BRING YOU THE LATEST.
1:11:04 WE WILL BRING YOU THE LATEST DEVELOPMENTS AS THEY HAPPEN.
1:11:06 FOR THE MOMENT, THE LATEST FED MINUTES SUGGEST ALMOST ALL
1:11:14 OFFICIALS AGREED IN OCTOBER THAT THEY WOULD LIKELY HAVE TO RAISE
1:11:16 INTEREST RATES IN THE MONTHS AHEAD TO RETURN INFLATION TO
1:11:17 THEIR 2% TARGET IN A TIMELY MANNER.
1:11:20 ACCORDING TO THE MINUTES, THE VOTE TO KEEP RATES UNCHANGED WAS
1:11:24 A CLOSE CALL. TWO POLICYMAKERS EVEN WENT AS
1:11:28 FAR TO SAY THAT AN INCREASE OF MORE THAN 25 BASIS POINTS COULD
1:11:31 BE WARRANTED IN DECEMBER IF DATA WAS UNFAVORABLE.
1:11:36 INTEREST RATE FUTURES SUGGEST INVESTORS EXPECT QUARTER-POINT
1:11:40 INCREASES IN DECEMBER AS WELL AS JANUARY AND ANOTHER BY APRIL.
1:11:45 FOR MORE ON HOW RATES MOVEMENTS COULD IMPACT THE REAL ESTATE
1:11:48 MARKET, WE ARE JOINED EXCLUSIVELY BY SENIOR PARTNER
1:11:51 AND A GROUP CHAIR AT -- WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THE HIGHER
1:11:58 FOR LONGER ENVIRONMENT AND THE IMPLICATIONS FOR THE REAL ESTATE
1:12:01 SECTOR? LOOK, INTERESTING QUESTION.
1:12:09 IT IS DEFINITELY MAKING REAL ESTATE INVESTORS BE MORE
1:12:12 SELECTIVE IN THE AREAS IN WHICH THEY ARE INVESTING.
1:12:18 LOOKING FOR HIGH-QUALITY QUALITY ASSETS AND DEFINITELY FOCUSING
1:12:21 ON INCOME. INCOME RATHER THAN NECESSARILY
1:12:26 RELYING ON YIELDS COMPRESSION IN THE MEDIUM OR LONG TERM.
1:12:30 THAT BEING SAID, YOU KNOW, EVEN DESPITE CONTINUED REAL ESTATE,
1:12:41 SORRY, INTEREST RATE RISES AND THE GEOPOLITICAL UNCERTAINTY IN
1:12:43 MANY AREAS OF THE GLOBE, REAL ESTATE IN ASIA-PAC HAS BEEN
1:12:54 RECOVERING STRONGLY AND STEADILY OVER THE LAST 12 MONTHS.
1:12:56 HASLINDA: IN TERMS OF THE MARKETS MOST HIT, WHAT ARE YOU
1:13:02 SEEING? WILLIAM: SORRY, I THINK I LOST
1:13:09 THE END OF YOUR QUESTION THERE. SORRY.
1:13:10 HASLINDA: I AM JUST WONDERING WHICH MARKETS ARE MOST HIT BY
1:13:15 THE HIGHER RATE ENVIRONMENT? WILLIAM: ACROSS ASIA PAC I WOULD
1:13:21 SAY THERE IS A BIT OF A MIXED BAG IN TERMS OF WHERE INVESTORS
1:13:23 ARE FOCUSING. DEFINITELY WE HAVE SEEN THE
1:13:28 AUSTRALIAN MARKETS HAVE HAD, YOU KNOW, SEVERAL INTEREST RATE
1:13:34 RISES OVER THE LAST 9-12 MONTHS, BUT WE ARE BEGINNING TO SEE
1:13:41 MARKETS RECOVERED IN BRISBANE AND SYDNEY.
1:13:45 THERE IS A LACK OF HOUSING SUPPLY IN THAT MARKET, IN
1:13:50 SINGAPORE, VERY COMPETITIVE. AND A DEBT FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT.
1:13:57 BUT YOU KNOW, A LACK OF STOCK. BUT PARTICULAR FOCUS ON THAT
1:14:03 MARKET BY HIGH NET WORTH INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILY OFFICES.
1:14:13 AND WHERE WE ARE SEEING MARKETS START TO RECOVER, I'D FOCUS ON
1:14:19 THE HONG KONG IN PARTICULAR. WE HAVE STARTED TO SEE SOME
1:14:23 SIGNIFICANT REPRICING IN THAT MARKET.
1:14:24 HASLINDA: WILLIAM, WHERE YOU ARE RIGHT NOW IN JAPAN, RATES ARE AT
1:14:30 30 YEAR HIGHS. HOW APPEALING IS THE REAL ESTATE
1:14:34 SECTOR THERE? WILLIAM: I'D TO SAY APPARENTLY
1:14:40 VERY -- I'D SAY APPARENTLY VERY ATTRACTIVE.
1:14:45 SO FAR YEAR TO DATE IN 2026 ACROSS ASIA, WE HAVE SEEN MORE
1:14:54 INVESTMENT VOLUME THEN WE SAW IN THE WHOLE OF 2025.
1:14:58 AND JAPAN HAS BEEN A PARTICULAR WINNER IN THAT PLAY.
1:15:05 THERE IS NO DOUBT, AS I SAID AT THE BEGINNING, THAT INVESTORS
1:15:11 ARE BEING MORE SELECTIVE. THEY ARE LOOKING FOR HIGH
1:15:15 QUALITY ASSETS IN GOOD LOCATIONS.
1:15:18 BUT THAT INVESTMENT, THE CROSS-BORDER INVESTMENT, IS AT
1:15:25 40% THIS YEAR AS OPPOSED TO 26% LAST YEAR.
1:15:30 AND QUARTER ON QUARTER, FOR THE LAST FOUR QUARTERS, AND JAPAN
1:15:36 HAS BEEN THE BIGGEST ATTRACTOR OF INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL.
1:15:41 AND THAT IS FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS.
1:15:42 BIG LIQUID MARKETS, REALLY STRONG OCCUPIER FUNDAMENTALS.
1:15:51 LIKE MANY MARKETS AROUND THE WORLD, AND THIS IS PARTICULARLY
1:15:57 TRUE IN MOST OF THE MAJOR CAPITALS AND MOST OF THE MAJOR
1:15:59 FINANCIAL CAPITALS, WE ARE SEEING A ROW SHORTAGE IN GRADE A
1:16:02 OFFICES. TOKYO IS NOW DOWN AT 1%.
1:16:07 IT IS THE LOWEST OF ANY OF THE 24 CITIES THAT WE MONITOR AT
1:16:11 KNIGHT FRANK ACROSS ASIA PAC. AND THAT IS CREATING REALLY
1:16:16 STRONG RENTAL GROWTH. HASLINDA: RIGHT.
1:16:20 THAT BEGS A QUESTION, YOU KNOW, HOW SUSTAINABLE THOSE RENTAL
1:16:25 GROWTH ARE. AND ALSO IN TERMS OF THE OUTLOOK
1:16:28 FOR THE OFFICE SPACE, WHAT ARE YOU SEEING?
1:16:31 WHAT'S THE PROJECTION FOR THE NEXT 12, TO 24 MONTHS PERHAPS?
1:16:35 WILLIAM: WELL, LOOK, INVESTMENT VALUES ARE GOING TO BE UP 15% TO
1:16:41 20% ACROSS THE BOARD IN 2026 WE BELIEVE.
1:16:45 AND WE BELIEVE THERE IS GOING TO BE, THAT'S GOING TO CONTINUE, ON
1:16:51 THE BASIS THAT WE ARE NOT GOING TO SEE A CHANGE IN THE SUPPLY
1:16:55 DYNAMIC. YOU KNOW, DEMAND FOR GRADE A
1:17:00 OFFICES AROUND THE WORLD, GIVEN THE CHANGE IN CORPORATE ATTITUDE
1:17:04 TO PEOPLE BEING BACK IN THE OFFICE, FOR PEOPLE USING THE
1:17:09 OFFICE AS A STRONG ATTRACTOR OF THE GREATEST TALENT, SO WE SEE
1:17:13 OFFICES ARE GOING TO REMAIN STRONG.
1:17:16 INDUSTRIAL AND LOGISTICS WILL REMAIN STRONG, PARTICULARLY IN
1:17:20 JAPAN. THE TOURISM AND HOTEL INDUSTRY
1:17:25 IS VERY POPULAR WITH INVESTORS. SO, OUR OUTLOOK, ALTHOUGH
1:17:32 DIFFERENT TO HOW IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN OVER THE LAST 24 MONTHS, WE
1:17:35 SEE AS POSITIVE. HASLINDA: THE THING IS, THE BOJ
1:17:42 IS SET TO RAISE RATES LATER THIS YEAR.
1:17:44 WHICH SECTORS DO YOU THINK MIGHT BE MOST AFFECTED BY THAT?
1:17:46 WILLIAM: WELL, LOOK, I THINK ALL SECTORS ARE GOING TO BE AFFECTED
1:17:54 BY THAT BECAUSE OF THE THE IMPACT IT WILL HAVE GENERALLY ON
1:18:01 PEOPLE'S INVESTMENT STRATEGIES. BUT WE STILL BELIEVE THAT THE
1:18:06 STRONGEST SECTORS WILL BE OFFICES, INDUSTRIAL.
1:18:10 WE HAVE SEEN A SIGNIFICANT UPTICK IN THE LAST 12 MONTHS IN
1:18:13 DATA CENTERS. AND IT WILL COME DOWN TO THE
1:18:16 FUNDAMENTAL OF EACH AND EVERY ASSET, YOU KNOW, IT WILL COME
1:18:22 DOWN TO LOCATION, IT WILL COME DOWN TO THE STRENGTH OF
1:18:27 COVENANT, AND THE STRENGTH OF INCOME.
1:18:29 WHAT WE HAVE SEEN, INTERESTINGLY, AND PARTICULARLY
1:18:33 OVER THE LAST QUARTER, A REAL INCREASE IN THE LOT SIZE OF
1:18:39 MAJOR TRANSACTIONS ACROSS THE REGION.
1:18:45 25%, A QUARTER OF TRANSACTIONS IN QUARTER THREE, WERE A BILLION
1:18:53 DOLLAR PLUS. SOME SIGNIFICANT HOTEL
1:18:57 TRANSACTIONS IN JAPAN AS WELL AS MULTI FOCUS -- MULTIFAMILY
1:19:02 FOCUS. HASLINDA: WE HAVE BEEN TALKING
1:19:05 ABOUT HOW GLOBAL CAPITAL IS RETURNING TO REAL ESTATE.
1:19:08 BUT WE KNOW THAT A LOT OF CAPITAL IS ACTUALLY GRAVITATING
1:19:12 TOWARDS AI INFRASTRUCTURE. WE ARE TALKING ABOUT HUNDREDS OF
1:19:17 BILLIONS OF DOLLARS. IS THAT IMPACTING PRIVATE
1:19:21 CAPITAL GOING INTO REAL ESTATE? WHAT ARE YOU SEEING FROM THE
1:19:24 LIKES OF WEALTHY INDIVIDUALS, FOR INSTANCE?
1:19:26 WHAT IS THE APPETITE FOR IT? WILLIAM: WHAT'S BEEN REALLY
1:19:33 INTERESTING OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS, AND PARTICULARLY IN THE
1:19:35 LAST TWO OR OR THREE, IS THAT PRIVATE CAPITAL ACROSS THE GLOBE
1:19:44 HAS BECOME MUCH MORE ORGANIZED, SIGNIFICANTLY MORE
1:19:46 SOPHISTICATED. AND THE PROLIFERATION OF PRIVATE
1:19:50 OFFICES, THE GROWTH IN PRIVATE FAMILY OFFICES, IS A MARKER TO
1:19:55 THAT TREND. AND WHAT WE HAVE SEEN IS AN
1:20:03 INCREASE TO DIVERSITY INTO THE AREAS IN WHICH THAT CAPITAL
1:20:06 WANTS TO INVEST. AND YOU KNOW, TRADITIONALLY,
1:20:12 THERE WAS AN INITIAL FOCUS ON RESIDENTIAL, THEN INTO OFFICES.
1:20:15 BUT WE ARE NOW SEEING PRIVATE CAPITAL MOVE INTO ALL AREAS OF
1:20:19 REAL ESTATE. AND THAT WILL INCLUDE PROBABLY
1:20:25 IN, YOU KNOW, SORT OF CO-FUNDING ETC. FROM EVERYTHING FROM
1:20:37 INDUSTRIAL LOGISTICS TO DATA CENTERS, OUTSIDE THE TRADITIONAL
1:20:41 HOME OF PRIVATE CAPITAL WHICH WAS HOTELS, HOSPITALITY, AND
1:20:43 OFFICES. HASLINDA: WILLIAM, THANK YOU SO
1:20:48 MUCH FOR YOUR TIME TODAY. WILLIAM BEARDMORE-GRAY, SENIOR
1:20:50 PARTNER AND GROUP CHAIR AT KNIGHT FRANK, SPEAKING TO US
1:20:53 EXCLUSIVELY. STILL TO COME ON "INSIGHT,"
1:20:57 FINTECH FIND A RIPPLE SAYS 2026 HAS BEEN ITS BEST YEAR ON RECORD
1:21:01 FOR BUSINESS. CEO BRAD GARLINGHOUSE WILL JOIN
1:21:10 US NEXT WITH HIS OUTLOOK. KEEP IT HERE.
1:21:13 HASLINDA: WELCOME BACK. YOU ARE WATCHING "INSIGHT."
1:21:17 WE ARE JUST MINUTES AWAY FROM A BILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN
1:21:21 PRESIDENT TRUMP AND CHINA'S XI JINPING ON THE SIDELINES OF THE
1:21:25 APEC SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN. IT WILL COME AFTER THE U.S.
1:21:30 RECENTLY TIGHTENED CHINA'S REMOTE ACCESS TO ADVANCED AI
1:21:31 CHIPS. MINMIN LOW IS IN SHENZHEN AND
1:21:34 JOINS US NOW. WHAT ARE WE ANTICIPATING
1:21:42 THIS WOULD FOCUS ON? THE MEETING'S MINUTES AWAY
1:21:47 BUT ACTUALLY I JUST WANT TO TALK ABOUT WHAT IS HAPPENING RIGHT
1:21:49 NOW BECAUSE PUTIN AND TRUMP ARE MEETING RIGHT NOW, MARCO RUBIO
1:21:53 AND SCOTT BESSENT ARE ALONGSIDE TRUMP AS HE MEETS WITH PRUDENT
1:21:58 ON THE RUSSIAN SIDE. WE HAVE THE FINANCE MINISTER AS
1:22:01 WELL AS THE FOREIGN MINISTER ACCOMPANYING PUTIN.
1:22:05 WE HAD A VERY IMPROMPTU LAST-MINUTE MEETING THAT IS
1:22:08 HAPPENING JUST AHEAD OF THAT TRUMP-XI SUMMIT, STILL REALLY
1:22:13 INTERESTING THAT THIS IS HAPPENING AND A REPORTER ON THE
1:22:16 GROUND WAS SAYING THAT TRUMP'S EXCITEMENT WAS PALPABLE AS HE
1:22:19 MENTIONED TWICE TO PUTIN THAT HE IS EXCITED TO MEET HIM.
1:22:22 HE ALSO SAID WHO IS HE? MY GOOD FRIEND, SOMETHING ALONG
1:22:26 THOSE LINES. THE FIRST TIME THEY ARE MEETING
1:22:31 IN PERSON SINCE AUGUST 2025 IN ALASKA.
1:22:35 REMEMBER ON MONDAY, BEFORE PRESIDENT TRUMP LEFT FOR ASIA HE
1:22:38 SAID HE WILL RAISE THE ISSUE OF UKRAINE, HE SAID IT'S HIS
1:22:41 FAVORITE SUBJECT, HE WILL RAISE THAT IN THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT
1:22:44 ALTHOUGH LATER ON ON FOX NEWS HE SAID HE WOULD NOT MAKE ANY
1:22:48 DECISION WITHOUT CONSULTING WITH ZELENSKYY.
1:22:52 CERTAINLY HAVING TRUMP AND PUTIN THE SAME ROOM, THIS IS A
1:22:55 DISCUSSION THAT WE WILL BE WATCHING CLOSELY ESPECIALLY WE
1:22:59 WOULD BE VERY KEEN TO WATCH IF MOSCOW WAS ABLE TO NEGOTIATE AN
1:23:04 OUTCOME FAVORABLE TO ITSELF. OF COURSE, HUNDREDS OF ASIA WILL
1:23:08 BE WATCHING VERY CLOSELY. THE JAPANESE PRESIDENT CERTAINLY
1:23:12 WATCHING VERY CLOSELY. JAPAN RELIES HEAVILY ON THE U.S.
1:23:18 FOR ITS MILITARY ALLIANCE AND ANY CLOSE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
1:23:24 TRUMP AND PUTIN IS GOING TO BE CLOSELY WATCHED BY ALLIES IN
1:23:26 THIS REGION. HASLINDA: WHEN IT COMES TO THE
1:23:30 TRILATERAL MEETING, SO MUCH DISCUSSION ABOUT WHAT WILL BE
1:23:36 DISCUSSED AND I WONDER HOW MUCH COULD BE ACHIEVED.
1:23:41 THE TRILATERAL MEETING IS GOING TO BE QUITE UNPRECEDENTED.
1:23:46 IN TERMS OF WHAT WILL BE ACHIEVED, AS YOU SAID, IT'S
1:23:50 GOING TO BE EXPECTED TO BE QUITE LIMITED BECAUSE DENUCLEARIZATION
1:23:53 IS AN AREA FOR WE ARE UNLIKELY TO SEE ANY BREAKTHROUGH.
1:23:58 THERE IS STILL CATCHING UP TO THE U.S. AND RUSSIA ON THAT
1:24:01 FRONT AND AGAIN, PRESIDENT TRUMP MENTIONED THE IDEA OF UKRAINE,
1:24:06 WHETHER WE WILL GET ANY NEGOTIATED OUTCOMES IS ONE TO
1:24:09 WATCH BECAUSE REMEMBER, PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS ALREADY
1:24:12 GIVEN RUSSIA SOME EASING OF SANCTIONS ESPECIALLY WHEN IT
1:24:15 COMES TO DIESEL IN ORDER TO EASE INFLATIONARY PRESSURE.
1:24:19 SOME SAY THE IRAN WAR HAS BEEN A GIFT TO PUTIN, SO WE WILL SEE IF
1:24:24 THIS SUMMIT PRESENTS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE TWO SIDES TO
1:24:27 NEGOTIATE SOME OTHER DEEPER COOPERATION ON ANY FRONT BUT
1:24:30 EXPECTATIONS ARE PRETTY LOW. SOME SAY THE PHOTO OP ITSELF IS
1:24:34 GOING TO BE ICONIC, JUST HAVING THE THREE LEADERS COMING
1:24:37 TOGETHER. IT IS INVOKING COMPARISONS TO
1:24:41 YALTA SUMMIT WHERE YOU HAVE THE GLOBAL BIG THREE MAJOR POWERS
1:24:45 COMING TOGETHER TO DISCUSS ISSUES LIKE WORLD PEACE, BUT
1:24:49 PERHAPS ALSO TO COVER SPHERES OF INFLUENCE OF THEIR OWN.
1:24:53 THIS IS A NARRATIVE THAT CHINA HAS PUSHED BACK AGAINST, IT
1:24:56 DOESN'T LIKE THE IDEA OF MAJOR POWERS, IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN
1:25:00 CHAMPIONING ITSELF AS THE LEADER OF THE DEVELOPING COUNTRIES, BUT
1:25:04 CERTAINLY JUST HAVING THE THREE LEADERS COMING TOGETHER, HAVING
1:25:06 SOME FACE TIME WILL ALSO BE A WIN FOR PRESIDENT XI TO SHOW
1:25:12 HIMSELF AS HOST OF THIS VERY IMPORTANT EVENT AND THE CENTER
1:25:15 OF GLOBAL AFFAIRS. HASLINDA: IF NOTHING ELSE, THE
1:25:20 OPTICS ARE IMPORTANT. THANK YOU.
1:25:22 MIN, COVERING THE APEC SUMMIT. WATCHING INDITEX, -- CRYPTO
1:25:30 SPACE -- WATCHING IN THE CRYPTO SPACE, RETAIL INVESTORS HAVE
1:25:36 FOCUSED ON AI PLAYS AND WITH ANTHROPIC'S IPO COMING UP, MANY
1:25:41 MIGHT BE KEEPING THE CAPITAL READY FOR THIS.
1:25:44 LET'S GET PERSPECTIVES FROM BRAD , A PRIVATELY HELD FINANCIAL
1:25:50 TECHNOLOGY COMPANY VALUED AT $50 BILLION.
1:25:52 IT HAS EXPANDED INTO A FULL STACK INSTITUTIONAL DIGITAL
1:25:55 ASSET PROVIDER SELLING BANKS, PAYMENT PROVIDERS, COOPERATIONS
1:26:01 AND MORE THAN 90 COUNTRIES. GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
1:26:08 WE THINK ABOUT IT IS HOW DO WE HELP BANKS IN MANY CASES?
1:26:12 AS YOU KNOW THIS INDUSTRY HAS A LITTLE BIT OF COMPETITION.
1:26:16 THERE'S AREAS WHERE WE MAY OVERLAP A LITTLE BIT BUT IN
1:26:20 GENERAL WE VIEW OURSELVES VERY MUCH AS AN INFRASTRUCTURE
1:26:23 ENABLER AND SOME OF THE THINGS WE ARE DOING INCREASINGLY ARE
1:26:26 GROWING VERY QUICKLY. PRIME BROKERAGE SERVICES IS
1:26:31 CERTAINLY SOMETHING WE ARE LESS INVOLVED IN THEN WE HAVE BEEN IN
1:26:33 THE PATH. -- IN THE PAST.
1:26:35 HASLINDA: WHAT IS THE THINKING BEHIND THAT?
1:26:38 WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO DO NOW THAT YOU DIDN'T DO BEFORE?
1:26:41 OUR CORE THESIS, BLOCKCHAIN THE NEEDLE MORE EFFICIENT
1:26:46 TRANSACTIONS. I MEAN TRANSACTIONS COULD BE
1:26:49 PAYMENTS, THEY COULD BE INSURANCE, THEY COULD BE
1:26:53 TOKENIZATION OF SECURITIES OR REAL ESTATE, YOU NAME IT.
1:26:57 BLOCKCHAIN'S HAVE FASTER SETTLEMENT AND CHEAPER
1:26:58 SETTLEMENT. RIPPLE SITS AT THE EPICENTER OF
1:27:02 THAT REVOLUTION AS IT UNFOLDS. AS WE SERVE BANKS, THE ABILITY
1:27:05 TO USE BLOCKCHAIN AS THE KIND OF CORE UNDERLYING ASSET, TO DO
1:27:11 THAT MORE EFFICIENTLY, THESE BARGAINS ARE MASSIVE AND IT'S
1:27:15 GOING TO TAKE DECADES TO DO A FULL REWIRING.
1:27:17 BUT ULTIMATELY, BETTER, CHEAPER AND FASTER WINS.
1:27:20 HASLINDA: IT ISN'T DOING SO WELL WHEN COMPARED TO THE EXPANSION
1:27:26 GROWTH YOU HAVE. WHY IS THAT REFLECTING WHAT YOU
1:27:30 ARE TOO AND THE VALUE YOU ARE CREATING?
1:27:31 ONE, SOMETHING YOU SAID AT THE INTRODUCTION, CRYPTO IS A
1:27:36 RISK ON ASSET AND WHEN THE SPACEX IPO HAPPENED, THERE IS A
1:27:42 BIG DOWNDRAFT AS PEOPLE USE THE LIQUIDITY IN THE CRYPTO MARKETS
1:27:45 AND MOVE TO SOMETHING AS MASSIVE AS THE SPACEX IPO.
1:27:50 WE SAW ALMOST IDENTICAL BEHAVIOR IN THE ANTHROPIC IPO GOING OUT
1:27:53 TODAY. I THINK THAT CREATES, YOU GO TO
1:27:57 A LIQUID ASSET AND TAKE A RISK ASSET AND YOU MOVE IT.
1:27:59 THE OVERALL CRYPTO MARKET HAS BEEN A TOUGH YEAR FOR SURE.
1:28:04 I THINK WHAT YOU'RE GOING TO SEE HAPPEN IS INCREASING DIVERGENCE
1:28:07 AS OPPOSED TO ALL THE CRYPTO MARKET WORKING IN TANDEM.
1:28:15 YOU ARE GOING TO SEE SOME DIVERGENT OF SOME ASSETS
1:28:17 PERFORMING AND OUTPERFORMING OTHERS BASED UPON THE UTILITY,
1:28:19 REAL DEMAND. AND IF YOU ARE NOT A MEMECOIN
1:28:21 TRADING IN SPECULATION, THAT IS A HARD PLACE TO BE IN THE
1:28:23 LONG-TERM. HASLINDA: YOU TALK ABOUT THE
1:28:26 ANTHROPIC IPO. IT IS $83 APIECE, IT IS 1.5
1:28:31 TRILLION DOLLARS IN VALUATION. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THOSE
1:28:36 NUMBERS, HOW DO YOU SQUARE THAT? I'M AN OPTIMIST.
1:28:39 I THINK WHAT ANTHROPIC HAS DONE IN THE LAST HANDFUL OF YEARS IS
1:28:44 JUST PROFOUND. YOU'VE NEVER SEEN A COMPANY GROW
1:28:46 THIS QUICKLY. I THINK WHAT WE ARE SEEING, THE
1:28:48 CAPABILITIES AROUND AI, I FUNDAMENTALLY BELIEVE THAT IT'S
1:28:53 LIKE THE EARLY DAYS OF THE INTERNET.
1:28:56 SOME DAYS THAT HYPE GETS AHEAD OF REALITY.
1:28:59 EVERY TIME THE REALITY HAS TO COME IN AT EQUILIBRIUM.
1:29:02 I THINK THERE ARE ELEMENTS OF THINGS LIKE THE INTERNET IN THE
1:29:05 LATE 90'S OR EARLY 2000, YES. ON THE OTHER HAND YOU ALSO HAD
1:29:10 AMAZON, YOU HAD GOOGLE, AND I THINK YOU'RE SEEING ANTHROPIC AS
1:29:14 ONE OF THE ABSOLUTE CLEAR LEADERS.
1:29:15 I THINK THE IPO HAS BEEN VERY WELL-RECEIVED, PRICING WAY ABOVE
1:29:20 THE RANGE. I THINK A COMPETITIVE TRADE UP
1:29:23 ON THE FIRST DAY, BUT WE WILL SEE WHAT HAPPENS.
1:29:26 HASLINDA: AND THE QUESTION REALLY IS WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THE
1:29:29 LOCKUP PERIOD? THERE ARE LOTS OF IMPLICATIONS
1:29:34 IF IT IS NEGATIVE. BUT I THINK THE SIGNAL HERE
1:29:39 IS YOU SEE SOME OF ITS LARGEST SHAREHOLDERS TODAY COMING IN IN
1:29:42 SIZE TO BUY INTO THE IPO. THESE ARE THE PEOPLE THAT ARE
1:29:49 CLOSEST AND HAVE THE MOST KNOWLEDGE ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON
1:29:51 INSIDE THE BUSINESS. THERE'S A SIGNAL THAT I THINK IS
1:29:53 INTERESTING. MAYBE YOU'RE RIGHT, THIS WILL
1:29:56 PLAY OUT OVER TIME. THE GROWTH RATES ARE PHENOMENAL
1:29:59 AND I THINK ULTIMATELY THE WAY RIPPLE USES CLAUDE INTERNALLY IS
1:30:05 ADDING VALUE TO OUR ORGANIZATION.
1:30:08 BUT ALSO FROM A CUSTOMER POINT OF VIEW.
1:30:09 HASLINDA: HOW DO YOU SEE RIPPLE USING CLAUDE DOWN THE ROAD?
1:30:15 YOU FEEL LIKE YOU SEE DEVELOPMENTS EVERY SIX MONTHS.
1:30:20 HOW MIGHT YOUR BUSINESS EVOLVE OVER TIME?
1:30:22 I THINK WHETHER IT IS CLAUDE OR OTHER AI TOOLS, WHEN WE THINK
1:30:29 ABOUT THIS, WE THINK ABOUT OUR OWN INTERNAL PRODUCTIVITY.
1:30:34 HOW WE DEVELOPED CODE, HOW WE SHIP PRODUCTS AND FEATURES MORE
1:30:37 QUICKLY. THE OTHER PART IS DELIVERING AI
1:30:40 WITHIN THE INTERFACE SO THAT IF YOU ARE A CORPORATE TREASURER
1:30:43 LOOKING AT YOUR BALANCES OF LIQUIDITY ALL OF THE WORLD,
1:30:46 GETTING A REPORT THAT IS SAYING HEY, TOMORROW YOU HAVE PAYROLL
1:30:49 DUE, YOU DON'T HAVE ENOUGH CURRENCY THERE, ADDING
1:30:54 INTELLIGENCE AND USING AI AGENTS TO MAKE YOUR JOB EASIER IS
1:30:57 SOMETHING WE ARE DOING TODAY AND IT HAS DRIVEN A TON OF DEMAND
1:31:00 AROUND OUR CORPORATE TREASURY SOLUTION.
1:31:02 HASLINDA: COMING INTO THIS CONVERSATION WE TALKED ABOUT HOW
1:31:06 CRYPTO ISN'T DOING SO WELL. EVERYBODY HAS THEIR EYES ON THE
1:31:10 ANTHROPIC IPO. ARE WE NOT EXCITED ABOUT CRYPTO
1:31:13 ANYMORE? WHAT IS YOUR PROJECTION?
1:31:17 I'M AS EXCITED NOW AS I'VE EVER BEEN.
1:31:22 I WAS JUST ON STAGE HERE AT THE SINGAPORE FINTECH FESTIVAL AND
1:31:25 EVEN THE ENTHUSIASM HERE, YOU HAVE TENS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE
1:31:28 HERE. STABLECOIN PAYMENT ACTIVITY LAST
1:31:31 YEAR WAS AT .02%. THAT IS A MASSIVE GROWTH
1:31:35 OPPORTUNITY. I'M NOT JUST TALKING ABOUT
1:31:39 RIPPLE, I'M TALKING ABOUT THE MARKET, THE INDUSTRY.
1:31:41 RIPPLE SITS AT A REALLY INTERESTING PLACE, BUT I THINK
1:31:46 YOU'RE GOING TO SEE A LOT OF TAILWINDS IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF
1:31:48 YEARS. RIPPLE HAS HAD A PHENOMENAL YEAR
1:31:52 DESPITE THE FACT THE MARKET AROUND CRYPTO HAS COME WAY DOWN.
1:31:56 OVER TIME YOU WILL SEE THAT KIND OF REALITY AND HYPE REACH
1:32:02 EQUILIBRIUM AND IT WILL BE RATIONAL OVER TIME.
1:32:03 HASLINDA: IT WASN'T LONG AGO THAT PEOPLE WERE MAKING BOLD
1:32:07 PROJECTIONS LIKE BITCOIN WILL GET TO $1 BILLION.
1:32:09 WE ARE WAY OFF THAT. HOW DO YOU GET PEOPLE EXCITED
1:32:13 AGAIN, WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN FOR THAT TO COME BACK?
1:32:17 I'M WITH THE GROUP THAT THAT WILL HAPPEN.
1:32:21 I DON'T KNOW EXACTLY WHEN. THE REASON WHY I THINK IT WILL
1:32:25 HAPPEN IS THE U.S. DOLLAR AS AN EXAMPLE, ONE OF THE BEST-MANAGED
1:32:29 CURRENCIES AROUND THE WORLD, DEVALUED BY 50% IN THE LAST 10
1:32:33 YEARS. PEOPLE WANT TO HOLD
1:32:35 NON-INFLATIONARY ASSETS. YOU GO DOWN THE LINE TO MUCH
1:32:40 WORSE, YOU HAVE DROPS OF 80%, 90% OF THE FIAT CURRENCIES.
1:32:47 PEOPLE WANT TO HOLD NONINFLATIONARY ASSETS,
1:32:50 PARTICULARLY ONES THAT ARE LIQUID AND THAT YOU CAN MOVE
1:32:52 THEM. AN ASSET LIKE CRYPTO, LIKE
1:32:56 BITCOIN IS GOING TO DRAW INTEREST OVER TIME, PARTICULARLY
1:32:59 IN MARKETS WHERE YOU HAVE MORE INFLATIONARY DYNAMICS.
1:33:02 HASLINDA: ALWAYS GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US.
1:33:05 COME BACK SOON. THAT IS IT FOR "INSIGHT."
1:33:10 WE WILL CONTINUE OUR SPECIAL COVERAGE OF THE TRUMP-XI
1:33:13 BILATERAL MEETING IN THE NEXT HOUR.
1:33:15 KEEP IT WITH US. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Dollar and Commodities Hint at Cooler Growth Ahead: Market Analysis full transcript
0:00 Let's start with the dollar we've seen dollar strength of late at the beginning
0:03 of the week. We were told by one guest it gets all
0:05 its interest rates, its expectations around the fed.
0:07 That's what's driving it. Other people think it has more to do
0:09 with the eye trade. What's your perspective?
0:14 Yeah. Great to be here.
0:15 I think it's both right I think I think today actually, provided I think a
0:19 really interesting microcosm of what we've been seeing in the dollar.
0:21 So, uh, the Aussie dollar was was the big mover today.
0:25 And you know, we can really quite sharply on, uh, much weaker than
0:29 expected employment data. The RBA has been amongst the most
0:33 hawkish central banks, uh, you know, globally over the last year.
0:37 Uh, and I think, you know, the question now is, you know, as markets are really
0:41 pivoting and, you know, had previously been pricing, you know, additional hikes
0:45 by August of next year, the market is now pricing a cut, uh, from the RBA.
0:49 And so if the RBA was ahead of the curve, uh, in the tightening cycle, the
0:52 question for markets is is, you know, is it pointing where rates are going to be
0:56 moving globally. And so I think that's really what, you
0:58 know, the breakdown in commodity prices is another feature.
1:01 Uh, the Haven bid is definitely a feature.
1:02 And I think all of that's feeding uh, you know again Rate differential story.
1:06 All in the dollar's favor. Why?
1:10 Why are funds selling commodities at the moment that they need the liquidity?
1:15 What does that trade tell me about what performance looks like?
1:22 I think it's a really interesting part of what we're seeing in which if you
1:26 look at U.S. economic data, it's still is really,
1:29 really strong ISM data. Manufacturing data, if you look at and
1:33 if you look at the earnings story on the corporate side, it's still very, really
1:36 strong. Of course, we saw that with Nvidia, uh,
1:39 most most recently what the market is pointing to a very different, um,
1:44 component. You know, part of that of course, is uh,
1:46 you know, the more, um, you know, defensive rotation we've seen in
1:50 equities and most recently it's this breakdown in commodity prices.
1:54 Oil plays a part in that, of course. Uh, and so of course the geopolitical
1:58 picture is playing a part, but I think, uh, the breakdown in copper in
2:01 particular, uh, is tied, of course, to this AI story.
2:04 Uh, and, you know, the breakdown we've seen in the CapEx trade also has, I
2:09 think, relation to, uh, the, uh, much softer than expected, uh, economic data
2:15 on domestic demand in China. Uh, so all of this is pointing to a more
2:20 troubling picture on the growth side. Yeah.
2:23 Can anthropic draw a line that, under the AI trade, can it can it to help
2:27 change the narrative from what's been a couple of weeks of of of nervous
2:32 trading? I mean, Nasdaq features are pointing
2:33 higher at this hour. Yeah, I think that's that's right.
2:38 And I think in the very near term I think it can, uh, I think
2:43 the fact that, that the price uh, came in higher, uh, that there seems to be a,
2:47 you know, a good, you know, wide set of sort of anchor investors, uh, and we're
2:51 seeing Nasdaq futures trade, you know, much, much better.
2:54 So, uh, I think the markets have, have, uh, if they can clear this sort of
3:00 liquidity event, uh, given the amount of selling we've seen of late, um, we could
3:04 see, I think, a decent rebound here. But I think part of the problem is it's
3:07 been very reliant it's going to be very rely on retail.
3:10 And retail has really been hit hard by Nvidia.
3:12 Uh, and the selling we've seen in tech.
Anthropic Tops SpaceX With $107.3B Raise as Trump and Xi Meet at APEC full transcript
0:10 ABEER: GOOD MORNING. THIS IS "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST &
0:11 AFRICA." OUR TOP STORIES THIS MORNING,
0:13 PRESIDENT TRUMP IS SET TO MEET CHINA'S XI JINPING ON THE
0:14 SIDELINES OF THE APEC SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN.
0:16 THE TWO LEADERS WILL LATER JOIN RUSSIA'S VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR
0:17 UNPRECEDENTED TRILATERAL TALKS. STRIKE RISK RETURNS.
0:20 OIL STUDIES AS REPORTS SUGGEST TRUMP IS CONSIDERING RENEWED
0:22 ATTACKS ON IRAN. FRESH TENSIONS COME AS A ON
0:27 VESSELS AROUND STRAIT OF HORMUZ CONTINUE.
0:29 ANTHROPIC'S BIG TEST. THE CLAUDE MAKER PRICES ITS IPO
0:37 AT $83 A SHARE, ABOVE ITS MARKETED RANGE AS DEMAND SURGED.
0:43 THE COMPANY RAISES A RECORD 170 BILLION DOLLARS AS SHARES
0:44 PREPARED TO START TRADING ON THURSDAY.
0:46 IT HAS JUST GONE 9:00 A.M. ACROSS THE EMIRATES.
0:50 I AM ABEER ABU OMAR IN DUBAI. LET'S START WITH A QUICK LOOK AT
0:51 WHAT MARKETS ARE DOING. MODERATING ACTION IN S&P
0:56 FUTURES, GAINING AT THIS POINT. NASDAQ FUTURES NOW 1% HIGHER.
1:02 WE SAW THE S&P YESTERDAY DROPPED FOR A FIFTH STRAIGHT SESSION.
1:06 AND NOW WE ARE LOOKING AT NASDAQ THAT SNAPPED FOUR SESSIONS IN
1:10 THE RED, GAINING YESTERDAY. WHILE THE OVERALL GAUGE HAD
1:16 DROPPED, THE NASDAQ DID GAIN A LITTLE BIT YESTERDAY.
1:20 THE TWO BIGGEST STORIES ARE ANTHROPIC AND NVIDIA.
1:22 THESE CONTINUE TO BE THE BIGGEST STORIES OF THE WEEK.
1:28 ANTHROPIC RAISED A RECORD $107.3 BILLION.
1:30 THAT WAS AN UP SIZED IPO AND PRIVATE PLACEMENT, OF COURSE.
1:36 THE OVERALL DEBUT AT A FULLY DILUTED VALUATION WAS AT AROUND
1:39 ALMOST $1.5 TRILLION. WE, OF COURSE, AWAIT THE DAY BE
1:45 THE BIGGEST ON RECORD -- AWAIT THE DAY BE, THE BIGGEST ON --
1:51 DEBUT, THE BIGGEST ON RECORD IN THE UNITED STATES.
1:57 INVESTORS ARE TILTING THEIR ATTENTION AWAY FROM
1:58 SEMICONDUCTORS INTO FRONTIER LABS, OF COURSE, WITH ANTHROPIC
2:02 NOW IN THE PICTURE. OIL PRICES, WE CONTINUE TO KEEP
2:05 AN EYE ON THOSE. A SLIGHT AGAIN THIS MORNING, 92
2:10 ALMOST DOLLARS ON THE BARREL. THE NEW YORK TIMES REPORTED
2:15 TRUMP IS WEIGHING FRESH ATTACKS AGAINST IRAN BUT WE CONTINUE TO
2:17 MONITOR SUPPLY THROUGH THE STRAIT OF HORMUZ.
2:19 AND THE YIELD ON THE 10 YEAR TREASURY, AS WE KEEP AN EYE ON
2:25 IT, SLIGHTLY ABOVE 5% RIGHT NOW AS THE FED MINUTES YESTERDAY
2:29 SHOWED THAT ALMOST ALL OFFICIALS THERE EXPECT A HAWKISH TILT.
2:36 NOW FOR THE PICTURE IN ASIA, LET'S MOVE ON TO WINNIE HSU, WHO
2:39 IS STANDING BY FOR US IN TOKYO. GOOD MORNING.
2:42 WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING AT? >> WE ARE SEEING ASIAN STOCKS
2:45 FALLING FOR A SIXTH SESSION. AS YOU MENTIONED, IT SEEMS TO BE
2:53 PICTURE THAT WE SEE FOR U.S. FUTURES AHEAD OF THE BIG DEBUT
2:56 OF ANTHROPIC. WHEN IT COMES TO THAT
3:00 DIFFERENCES, IT SEEMS LIKE THE ANTHROPIC IPO IS REALLY ABLE TO
3:04 RESTORE SOME CONFIDENCE FOR INVESTORS WHEN IT COMES TO THE
3:05 BROADER AI TRADE. HOWEVER, FOR ASIA, THE CONCERN
3:10 IS THAT MIGHT TAKE AWAY THE CAPITAL FROM THESE TECH HEAVY
3:14 MARKETS AND SOUTH KOREA AND TAIWAN, WHICH HAVE BEEN REALLY
3:18 GAINING SO FAR THIS YEAR ON THAT AI TRADE.
3:22 YOU CAN SEE THAT TAIWAN'S TAIEX INDEX DOWN ABOUT 4%,
3:25 UNDERPERFORMING ALL THESE OTHER ASIAN PEERS.
3:29 SOME CHATTER AROUND THE FOREST SELLING GIVEN THE MARGIN CALLS
3:31 AROUND THESE LEVERAGED BETS. WHEN IT COMES TO AUSTRALIA'S
3:36 BENCHMARK, WE ARE LOOKING AT THIS GAUGE DOWN ABOUT 1%,
3:41 ALREADY HAVING PARED SOME OF ITS LOSSES AFTER THE UNEMPLOYMENT
3:44 RATE SURPRISED HIGHER THAN EXPECTED, WHICH ALSO REINFORCED
3:48 BETS THAT THE CENTRAL BANK WILL HAVE TO CUT RATES NEXT YEAR.
3:54 WE ALL CEASE -- ALSO SAW THE AUSSIE DOLLAR ERASE ALL OF ITS
3:55 GAIN SO FAR THIS YEAR. WE FLIP THE BOARD, TAKE A LOOK
4:00 AT ANOTHER AREA GETTING HIT,. THE TECH STOCKS.
4:05 IN HONG KONGHS TECH DOWN FOR A SEVENTH SESSION.
4:08 IT IS THAT CONCERN AROUND THE U.S. CURBS BUT ALSO THE CONCERN
4:12 THESE COMPANIES CONTINUE TO DISAPPOINT.
4:15 WE HAD TENCENT LAST NIGHT REPORTING EARNINGS, REVENUE,
4:18 OPERATING PROFIT ALL MISSING ESTIMATES, GIVEN THE STRUGGLE
4:23 WHEN IT COMES TO AI MONETIZATION.
4:26 WE WILL HAVE TO SEE HOW ALIBABA CAN ANSWER THOSE QUESTIONS LATER
4:27 TODAY. BACK TO YOU.
4:30 ABEER: OK. THANK YOU AS ALWAYS FOR THOSE
4:33 MARKET CHECKS. BLOOMBERG'S WINNIE HSU IN TOKYO
4:35 FOR US. THE BIG STORY OF THE DAY, TRUMP
4:42 AND CHINA'S XI JINPING ARE SET TO MEET ON THE SIDELINES OF APEC
4:45 THE U.S. PRESIDENT MET EARLIER WITH RUSSIA'S VLADIMIR PUTIN.
4:55 OUR NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT MINMIN LOW IS IN SHENZHEN FOR US
4:58 AND JOINS US NOW. LET'S START WITH THE
5:00 EXPECTATION. WE HAD SEEN THOSE PHOTOS WITH
5:03 VLADIMIR PUTIN AND PRESIDENT TRUMP.
5:08 MEETING BETWEEN THE CHINESE LEADER AND PRESIDENT TRUMP.
5:13 WHAT IS THE AMBIENCE LIKE? WHAT ARE THE EXPECTATIONS OF
5:16 THIS MEETING? MINMIN: IT IS CERTAINLY QUITE
5:20 INTERESTING BECAUSE THIS TRUMP-PUTIN MEETING APPEARED TO
5:25 AN HOUR. OUR REPORTER ON THE GROUND AND
5:28 SAID YOU COULD REALLY FEEL TRUMP'S EXCITEMENT BECAUSE HE
5:34 WHISPERED TWICE TO PUTIN THAT HE WAS EXCITED TO MEET HIM AND HE
5:36 CALLED PUTIN A FRIEND. IT WAS INTERESTING BECAUSE THIS
5:40 LAST-MINUTE MEETING ESSENTIALLY MADE HIM A LITTLE BIT LATE FOR
5:44 MOMENTS AGO. A LAST-MINUTE ADDITION,
5:49 CERTAINLY INTERESTING, BECAUSE THIS IS THE FIRST TIME PUTIN AND
5:52 TRUMP ARE MEETING IN PERSON SINCE THE LAST SUMMIT IN 2025 IN
5:55 ALASKA. WE ARE STILL WAITING FOR NEWS
5:58 LINES COMING OUT OF THAT. OF COURSE, THE UKRAINE WAR IS
6:03 SOMETHING THAT IS LOOMING LARGE OVER THAT RELATIONSHIP.
6:09 TRUMP HAS SAID HE WANTS TO END THAT WAR WHEN HE CAME INTO POWER
6:13 BUT THE WAR IS STILL ONGOING AND WE HAVE SEEN HOW PRESIDENT TRUMP
6:16 HAS EASED SANCTIONS ON RUSSIAN DIESEL IN ORDER TO EASE
6:17 INFLATIONARY PRESSURE. YOU GOT TO WONDER PRESIDENT
6:22 PUTIN COULD BE USING THIS AS A PLATFORM TO NEGOTIATE FOR AN
6:24 OUTCOME THAT COULD BE BENEFICIAL TO MOSCOW.
6:29 ALTHOUGH, WE HAVE PRESIDENT TRUMP ON FOX NEWS SAYING THAT HE
6:31 WILL NOT AGREE TO ANYTHING WITHOUT CONSULTATION WITH
6:33 ZELENSKYY. AND CERTAINLY, THE WORLD WILL BE
6:39 WATCHING IF THE TWO MEN WOULD MANAGE TO COME TO ANY AGREEMENT
6:41 THAT COULD HAVE AN IMPACT ON THE OTHER COUNTRIES.
6:46 ABEER: PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS IN MANILA, OF COURSE.
6:50 YESTERDAY WAS THE FINAL DAY. WE SO I TRADE DEAL COME TO
6:53 FRUITION. HE ANNOUNCED A MAGNIFICENT DEAL,
6:56 NOT ELABORATING FURTHER. LET'S TALK ABOUT WHAT WE COULD
7:01 EXPECT IN TERMS OF TRADE, WHAT WE COULD EXPECT IN TERMS OF
7:03 DIPLOMACY, AND NOT JUST ON THE UKRAINE FRONT.
7:07 IS IRAN GOING TO BE DISCUSSED AT ALL DO YOU THINK?
7:12 MINMIN: WELL, AT LEAST IN THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT, IRAN IS
7:17 LIKELY TO BE DISCUSSED BUT IN TERMS OF ACTUAL OUTCOME AND WHAT
7:20 CAN BE ACHIEVED OUT OF IT, WE ARE NOT LIKELY TO SEE A LOT OF
7:22 FORWARD MOVEMENT ON THAT FRONT, RIGHT.
7:26 I MEAN, IF CHINA WOULD LIKE TO USE AS LEVERAGE OVER IRAN TO END
7:29 THAT WAR EARLY, IT WOULD HAVE READY DONE SO.
7:32 HE MIGHT DISCUSS THAT BUT IN TERMS OF ACTUAL OUTCOMES, IT IS
7:35 EXPECTED TO BE QUITE LIMITED. PRESIDENT TRUMP DID SAY IT IN AN
7:39 INTERVIEW THAT THEY ARE GOING TO BE A LOT OF TRADE DEALS SIGNED
7:42 IN THE NOT-TOO-DISTANT FUTURE WITH OTHER MAJOR POWERS.
7:44 MIND YOU, WITH THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, THIS SORT OF
7:49 RHETORIC HAS OFTEN RUN AHEAD OF ACTUAL AGREEMENTS AND EVEN TRADE
7:51 AGREEMENTS DOES NOT PRECLUDE THAT NEW TENSIONS WOULD REEMERGE
7:53 LATER ON. THE MOST IMPORTANT BILATERAL
7:58 MEETING THAT WE ARE WATCHING IS THAT BETWEEN TRUMP AND XI, WHICH
8:01 SHOULD BE HAPPENING JUST ABOUT NOW.
8:05 AND THAT IS ONE WHERE THERE ARE STILL SO MANY UNFINISHED
8:09 OR DAYS AGO FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, AND THAT COULD
8:19 WHILE HAVING THE U.S. PUT A PAUSE ON TECH CURBS.
8:23 WE HEARD PRESIDENT TRUMP SAY EARLIER IN A SPEECH THIS MORNING
8:26 OF APEC SUMMIT THAT HE IS OPPOSED TO ANY GLOBALIZED
8:28 REGULATION ON A I THAT COULD STIFLE ENTREPRENEURSHIP.
8:39 CONGRESS' PUSH TO CLOSE MORE LOOPHOLES FOR CHINESE COMPANIES
8:41 TO ACCESS ADVANCED NVIDIA CHIPS? THAT IS A BIG QUESTION NOW.
8:46 WE WILL HAVE TO SEE BECAUSE ON A FOX NEWS INTERVIEW, PRESIDENT
8:48 TRUMP SAID HE HAS ALREADY GOT THE HEADLINES AND THE DEFINITION
8:54 OF SUCCESS FROM THIS MEETING, WHICH CAME FROM ETTRICK, THE
8:58 PAGEANTRY WHEN HE WAS -- CAME FROM YESTERDAY, THE PAGEANTRY
9:04 YEARS OF PROTOCOL TO RECEIVE HIM THERE.
9:07 VISIT. BLOOMBERG'S MINMIN LOW IN
9:09 SHENZHEN. LET'S RETURN TO THIS REGION AND
9:15 TENSIONS BETWEEN THE U.S. AND IRAN ARE RISING AGAIN WITH FRESH
9:18 MILITARY CLASHES ADDING TO UNCERTAINTY OVER WHERE THE
9:19 CONFLICT GOES NEXT. OIL IS MOVING HIGHER AS THE
9:24 PROSPECT OF A RENEWED U.S. STRIKES COMES BACK INTO FOCUS,
9:29 EVEN AS TEHRAN CONTINUES TO SIGNAL THAT A DIPLOMATIC PATH
9:32 REMAINS OPEN. STUART LIVINGSTONE-WALLACE,
9:35 BLOOMBERG'S EXECUTIVE EDITOR FOR THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH
9:37 AFRICA, HAS MORE DETAILS ON THE STORY.
9:39 GOOD MORNING. THE LATEST ESCALATIONS, WE ARE
9:44 SEEING AN ESCALATION ON SAUDI ARABIA, WE ARE SEEING AN
9:47 ESCALATION IN THE RHETORIC AS WELL.
9:50 IT FEELS LIKE A QUESTION THAT WE WILL CONTINUE JUST OVER THE
9:52 SHORT TERM. IS THIS GOING TO DO YOU THINK
9:56 LEAD TO A MEANINGFUL INTENSIFICATION OF THE WAR IN
9:58 THE REGION? >> I THINK WE ARE GETTING VERY
10:00 MIXED SIGNALS. SOME OF THE REPORTING FROM
10:04 OTHERS WITHIN DIPLOMATIC CIRCLES IS THAT THE CONVERSATION, AT
10:09 LEAST TO SOME EXTENT, HAS MOVED BACK TO AN ESCALATION OF
10:13 HOSTILITIES. QUITE WHETHER THAT'S TRUE OR
10:17 NOT, I DON'T KNOW. CERTAINLY THEY HAVE BEEN WORKING
10:20 ON PLANS FOR A LONG TIME. THAT DOES NOT MEAN THEY ARE
10:22 GOING TO IMPLEMENT IT. THIS THIRD STRIKE CARRIER GROUP
10:27 THAT MOVED INTO THE REGION SEEMS TO BE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ROTATE
10:29 OUT ONE OF THE TWO THAT WERE ALREADY HERE.
10:32 WE ALWAYS SAID IF THEY ARE ROTATING OUT A STRIKE CARRIER
10:35 GROUP, THAT WOULD BE A SIGNAL THAT PERHAPS HOSTILITIES ARE NOT
10:36 A MINUTE. WE ARE ALL GUESSING -- ARE NOT
10:39 IMMINENT. WE ARE ALL GUESSING.
10:44 AS OF TODAY, FAIRLY MIXED SIGNALS.
10:47 OIL PRICE WAS UP SLIGHTLY, IT WAS DOWN SLIGHTLY, I THINK IT IS
10:49 LARGELY FLAT NOW. I THINK THAT IS A FAIR
10:53 REFLECTION OF THE MARKET AND THE WIDER READERSHIP IS NOT QUITE
10:55 SURE WHICH WAY THIS IS GOING TO GO.
10:59 ABEER: BRENT CRUDE IS $92 ON THE BARREL, A SLIGHT GAIN THIS
11:03 MORNING, DESPITE THE GEOPOLITICAL HEADLINES.
11:06 LET'S FOCUS ON THAT, THE SUPPLY THAT IS GOING ON IN THE STRAIT
11:07 OF HORMUZ. DO YOU THINK THAT IS THE REASON
11:10 WE ARE NOT SEEING ANY MEANINGFUL TILT TO THE UPSIDE IN ENERGY
11:13 PRICES? >> NO.
11:22 CAUTIOUS BECAUSE THERE IS NO DOUBT THAT THERE IS AT LEAST A
11:23 SEGMENT OF THE MARKET THAT GOT PRETTY BADLY BURNED.
11:27 IT WAS NOT LONG AGO THAT WE WERE WELL OVER $100 A BARREL.
11:30 WE ARE NOW BELOW 100. THAT IS A WILD SWING.
11:33 IF YOU LOOK AT THE VOLATILITY IN THE OIL PRICE, THIS IS A VERY
11:35 DIFFICULT MARKET TO TRADE. YOU HAVE GOT AN EXTREMELY
11:39 BIZARRE FORWARD CURVE IN TERMS OF THE PRICE OF OIL GOING
11:50 BE EXTREMELY CHALLENGING, PARTICULARLY IN AN ENVIRONMENT
11:50 DIRECTION OF TRAVEL WITH REGARD TO DIPLOMACY, WITH REGARD TO
11:52 HOSTILITIES. AS YOU SAID IN YOUR
11:55 INTRODUCTION, YOU HAVE BEEN A MARKED INCREASE IN HOSTILITIES
12:03 IN HORMUZ AGAINST SHIPPING ITSELF SO VERY MURKY PICTURE
12:04 WHEN IT COMES TO SUPPLY. ABEER: WE WILL HAVE TO KEEP AN
12:07 EYE ON WHAT IS HAPPENING IN HORMUZ AS WELL.
12:09 BLOOMBERG'S STUART LIVINGSTONE-WALLACE, EXECUTIVE
12:12 EDITOR FOR THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA.
12:17 COMING UP NEXT, ANTHROPIC RAISES A RECORD $107 BILLION IN AN UP
12:22 SIZED IPO AND PRIVATE PLACEMENT, BECOMING THE FIRST FRONTIER AI
12:25 LAB TO TAP PUBLIC MARKETS. MORE DETAILS ON THAT STORY,
12:28 NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
12:59 ♪ ABEER: ANTHROPIC HAS RAISED A
13:05 RECORD 107.3 BILLION IN AN UPSIZED IPO IN PRIVATE
13:07 PLACEMENT. SHARE ALSO DEBUT ON THE NASDAQ
13:12 LATER TODAY AT $83 PER SHARE ABOVE THE EXPECTED RANGE.
13:19 LET'S BRING IN OUR EDITOR. THE BIGGEST DEBUT ON RECORD OR
13:22 THE BIGGEST PLACEMENT THAT WE WOULD HAVE SEEN ON RECORD.
13:27 WHAT DO WE EXPECT WHEN THE IPO HAPPENS OF ANTHROPIC LATER?
13:30 >> THAT'S RIGHT. THIS IS A REALLY, REALLY BIG
13:32 DEAL. IT IS A RECORD ANY WAY YOUS
13:35 SLICE IT. THEY PRICED THE IPO AT $83 ABOVE
13:39 THE EXPECTED RANGE. THEY RAISED $81 BILLION JUST
13:45 WITH THE IPO ITSELF AND THE CONCURRENT PLACEMENT, $26
13:48 BILLION, $107 BILLION. TO PUT THAT IN PERSPECTIVE, THIS
13:54 IS A REALLY GOOD YEAR FOR IPOS. THE SECOND HIGHEST EVER.
13:59 LESS THAN HALF OF JUST ONE DEAL, THE ANTHROPIC DEAL.
14:01 WHAT DO WE EXPECT? WE KNOW THE DEAL WAS HEAVILY
14:06 OVERSUBSCRIBED. ABOUT SEVEN TIMES AVAILABLE
14:09 SHARES. WE ALSO KNOW ON MARKETS, THE
14:14 INDICATIONS ARE FOR ABOUT 20%, MAYBE MORE ON OPENING DAY SO
14:18 EVEN IS VERY OPTIMISTIC ABOUT WHERE THIS COULD GO.
14:21 THE CURRENT MARKET TO HAVE COMPANY BASED ON THE IPO IS
14:26 $1.45 TRILLION. THAT FALLS SHORT OF SPACEX A BIT
14:31 BUT SUGGESTS -- THE SUGGESTIONS FROM THE MARKET SHOW THAT COULD
14:38 CHANGE QUICKLY. ABEER: JUST ABOUT THE
14:41 CIRCUMSTANCES AROUND THE AI TRADE RIGHT NOW, THE THINGS THAT
14:44 ARE HAPPENING AROUND ANTHROPIC. WE'RE KEEPING AN EYE ON NVIDIA
14:46 AS WELL. DO YOU THINK THIS WILL BE A
14:51 PIVOTAL MOMENT FOR THE AI TRADE OR WILL IT BRING ABOUT EVEN MORE
14:56 SPECULATION? >> A LOT OF PEOPLE CERTAINLY SEE
15:02 THIS AS A PIVOTAL MOMENT FOR THE MARKET.
15:04 FOR AI TRADE. THAT THIS CAN DELIVER A FRESH
15:08 IMPETUS. IF THE TRADING GOES WELL AND THE
15:13 SHARE PRICE KEEPS RISING THAT CAN'T BE A SIGNAL THERE IS
15:16 INDEED APPETITE ESPECIALLY FOR A COMPANY LIKE ANTHROPIC IT IS THE
15:22 FIRST AVAILABLE FOR INVESTORS TO INVEST IN.
15:24 THERE IS NO APPROXIMATIES. YOU DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT
15:27 THE PICKS AND SHOVES TRADE. YOU CAN INVEST DIRECTLY INTO A
15:33 MODEL MAKER. IT COULD BE A CATALYST.
15:37 WE SEE THE MARKETS OPTIMISTIC. THE U.S. FUTURES ARE UP.
15:42 IT SHOWS THERE IS A LOT OF HOPE THIS COULD LIFT THE MARKET AS A
15:43 WHOLE. IT IS A LITTLE BIT OF A
15:46 DIFFERENT PICTURE FOR A LOT OF REASONS THAT WE JUST DISCUSSED
15:52 EARLIER WITH WINI BUT THERE ARE HOPES THAT THIS COULD TURN THE
15:56 TIDE FOR AI TRADE. ABEER: OK.
15:59 SO TURNING THE TIED. THAT IS WHAT WE'RE KEEPING AN
16:03 EYE ON. JOINING US FROM HONG KONG.
16:08 U.S. STOCKS AND INDEX FUTURES ARE DIVERGING AS AI CONCERNS
16:11 TOOK SOME OF THE SHINE OF ANTHROPIC'S IPO PRICING.
16:15 FOR MORE ON THESE WIDER MARKET MOVES AND HOW MARKETS ARE
16:17 PREPARING FOR ANTHROPIC'S TRADING DEBUT, WE'RE JOINED BY A
16:23 CHIEF ECONOMIST IN SWITZERLAND. GOOD MORNING.
16:26 GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US IN DUBAI.
16:29 LET ME START WITH ANTHROPIC AND CARRY ON THE CONVERSATION THAT I
16:33 WAS HAVING WITH MY COLLEAGUE NOW.
16:35 WE'RE ALSO WITNESSING A LITTLE BIT OF A -- OUTSIDE OF SEMI
16:39 CONDUCTORS WHICH WERE THE BIGGEST STAR IN THE AI TRADE.
16:45 DO YOU SEE THAT TO CONTINUE HAPPENING WITH ANTHROPIC
16:47 BECOMING PUBLIC? >> ABSOLUTELY.
16:48 BROADER THAN THAT. LONG U.S. EQUITIES AND LONG U.S.
16:55 TECH AND ASIA AS WELL. THE THE IT IS PRETTY BROAD HERE.
17:01 I WOULDN'T BE TOO NARROW. IT IS GOING TO BE A LONG RACE.
17:07 WHAT IS IMPORTANT IS THE DEMAND IS STILL THERE.
17:11 DEMAND FOR AI. NVIDIA, ANTHROPIC.
17:14 IT TICKS THE BOXES. DEMAND IS STILL THERE.
17:17 WE WANT TO BE IN THAT TRADE RATHER THAN OUT OF THAT TRADE.
17:20 ABEER: THIS COULD BE JUST ME AND MAYBE THAT WAS A LITTLE BIT
17:23 OVERLIFED IN MY HEAD. I WAS EXPECTING A LITTLE BIT
17:27 MORE EXCITEMENT AROUND ANTHROPIC.
17:29 DO YOU THINK IT IS DROWNING IN THE MIDST OF EVERYTHING THAT IS
17:32 WHAT'S HAPPENING NVIDIA AND OTHER AI SPECULATIVE NEWS?
17:36 >> THAT SENTIMENT IS A LITTLE BIT CONTAINED.
17:40 I DON'T SEE THAT AS A NEGATIVE. THERE IS STILL AGAIN SOMETIME
17:44 WHERE WE CAN SEE THE IMPROVEMENT.
17:46 I WOULD ACTUALLY SEE THAT AS A RELATIVELY HEALTHY TECHNICAL
17:49 MARKET ENVIRONMENT. EXCITEMENT WILL COME BACK AT
18:02 SOME POINT BAA LOT IS GOING ON. ABEER: THE NEWS AROUND THE IPO
18:06 ITSELF IS VERY POSITIVE BUT I WAS REFERRING MORE TO THE MACRO
18:10 PICTURE AND OTHER GAMES. DO YOU THINK FOR NOW INVESTORS
18:18 ARE UNDERESTIMATING THE FACT THAT AI IS PRETTY MUCH FINANCED
18:21 BY LEVERAGE OPPOSED TO REAL RETURNS?
18:25 >> THERE IS A LOT OF ANXIETY AROUND THE.
18:27 I DON'T NECESSARILY SHARE THAT ANXIETY.
18:30 I THINK IT IS THE LEVERAGE DISTORTED.
18:32 YOU KNOW HOW THIS UNFOLDS. THE BEGINNING, THEY ARE TRYING
18:35 TO RESPOND TO DEMAND. YOU'RE GOING TO PUT YOUR OWN
18:41 CAPEX, YOUR OWN CAPITAL INTO CAPEX.
18:44 YOU NEED THAT, GROWTH AT THE BEGINNING THAT IS PROFITABLE.
18:47 THAT IS OK. THAT SITUATION BECOMES -- JUST
18:49 IN THE BEGINNING TO HAVE LEVERAGE CYCLE AND WHAT I FEEL
18:56 IS VERY AND FOR NOW, DEMAND IS UNDERSUPPLIED.
18:58 YOU HAVE TO MAKE THE INVESTMENT SO YOU CAN TRY TO MEET DEMAND.
19:03 WHAT I FIND VERY INTERESTING IS SUPPLY IS NOT TRYING TO RESPOND
19:05 TO TOMORROW OWES DEMAND. IT IS TRYING TO SATISFY TODAY'S
19:09 DEMAND. ACTUALLY SUPPLY IS RUNNING LATE
19:14 AND CAP SIX GOING TO BE QUITE PROFITABLE.
19:17 ABEER: LET'S MOVE ON TO MONETARY POLICY.
19:18 YOU DON'T EXPECT AN AGGRESSIVE HIKING CYCLE BY THE FED GOING
19:21 FURTHER. DO THE MINUTES WE SAW YESTERDAY
19:25 CHANGE YOUR MIND AT ALL? QUITE A HAWKISH TILT.
19:28 >> STILL IN A HAWKISH MOMENT. TWO THINGS I HAVE IN MIND TO
19:34 REMAIN BELOW WHAT THE MARKET EXPECTS WHEN IT COMES TO HIKES.
19:41 WE WORK TURNED ASSUMPTION THE OIL PRICE WILL BE BELOW $100
19:47 NEXT YEAR, EVENTUALLY BELOW $90. IT WILL BE FAVOR TO BELIEVE THE
19:50 LEVEL OF 2026. THAT IS A BIT LESS INFLATIONARY
19:53 PRESSURE AND LESS PRESSURE ON CENTRAL BANKS.
19:57 WE'LL BE WATCHING THE OIL PRICE CLOSELY.
20:02 THAT IS CONFIRMED, IT DOES IMPLY LESS HIKES EX-NEXT YEAR.
20:05 THE OTHER ONE IS WAGES. WAGES ARE TRENDING DOWNED WARDS.
20:08 THAT GIVES YOU A LEADING INCORPORATED INDICATION WHERE
20:10 SERVICES INFLATION CAN BE. AND IF WE CONTINUE TO HAVE THAT
20:13 SET UP. LOWER WAGES, I THINK THE CENTRAL
20:18 BANKS WILL HIKE LESS. ABEER: THIS IS ALLVILLE RELEVANT
20:20 TO WHAT WE'RE SEEING TOP YIELD FRONT ACROSS THE CURVE.
20:23 WE SAW MAJOR MOVES IN YIELDS IN THE UNITED STATES LAST WEEK.
20:28 DO THESE LEVELS WORRY YOU AT ALL?
20:30 >> WE'RE ACTUALLY BUYERS AT THESE LEVELS.
20:35 I FEEL YIELDS WILL BE LOWER IN THE NEXT 12 MONTHS COMPARED TO
20:43 WHERE THEY ARE NOW. IT REMAINS ATTRACTIVE TO US,
20:46 ESPECIALLY IN AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE WE EXPECT LESS
20:50 INFLATIONARY PRESSURE. ABEER: BUYERS OF YIELDS NOW.
20:54 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US ON SITE THIS MORNING.
20:59 CHIEF ECONOMIST AND SWITZERLAND CIO.
21:04 STILL AHEAD, THE U.N.'S LATEST REPORT SHOWS 2 BILLION PEOPLE
21:08 REMAIN UNCONNECTED TO THE INTERNET IN 2026.
21:12 WE'LL BE DISCUSSING THAT LATER. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
21:37 ♪ ABEER: BLOOMBERG HAS LEARNED
21:42 THAT NVIDIA'S RECRUITMENT FIRM HAS APPROACHED HAAS AS A CON
22:01 TIGHT ENDCONTENDERTO REPLACE JENSEN HUANG. VIDEO GAME GRAND THEFT AUTO
22:05 RECEIVED NEARLY PERFECT SCORES ACROSS THE BOARD.
22:08 THAT MAKES IT THE BEST REVIEWED GAME OF ALL TIME.
22:15 THE GAME WAS RELEASED AT MIDNIGHT IN ASIA WITH GLOBAL
22:18 LAUNCHES FOLLOWING CLOCK THROUGH THURSDAY.
22:21 AND NOW A QUICK LOOK AT EQUITY BENCH MARKS BEFORE WE HEAD TO
22:23 THE BREAK. YOU'RE LOOKING AT S&P FUTURES
22:27 THAT ARE HIGHER AND NASDAQ MUCH HIGHER THAN S&P.
22:31 MORE THAN 100% THAT THE POINT. EURO STOXX 450 PICTURES IN THE
22:35 GREEN. COMING UP, THE OUTLOOK FOR 2027.
22:39 WHAT THE HEAD OF INVESTMENTS FOR THE MIDDLE EAST, NORTH AFRICA
22:43 AND TURKEY NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
23:09 THIS IS "HORIZONS MIDDLE EAST & AFRICA."
23:11 OUR TOP STORIES THIS MORNING PRESIDENT TRUMP IS SET TO ME TO
23:20 THE TWO LEADERS WILL LATER JOIN RUSSIA'S VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR
23:22 UNPRECEDENTED TRILATERAL TALKS. STRIKE RISK RETURNS.
23:27 OIL STUDIES AS REPORTS SUGGEST TRUMP IS CONSIDERING RENEWED
23:30 ATTACKS ON IRAN. FRESH TENSIONS COME AS A ON
23:33 VESSELS AROUND STRAIT OF HORMUZ CONTINUE.
23:42 ANTHROPIC'S BIG TEST. THE CLOUD MAKER PRICE ITS IPO
23:47 AT $83 A SHARE, ABOVE ITS MARKETED RANGE AS DEMAND SURGED.
23:48 THE COMPANY RAISES A RECORD 170 BILLION DOLLARS AS SHARES
23:50 PREPARED TO START TRADING ON THURSDAY.
24:00 IT HAS JUST GONE 9:30 A.M. ACROSS THE EMIRATES.
24:02 I AM ABEER ABU OMAR IN DUBAI. LET'S GIVE YOU A GLIMPSE OF WHAT
24:07 THE MARKETS ARE DOING. THE S&P TURNING ABOUT .7 HIGHER.
24:15 TECH HEAVY FUTURES OF THE NASDAQ ARE ABOVE 1% NOW.
24:17 YOU'RE LOOKING AT THE HANDOVER IN ASIA AND IT IS 1.3% LOWER
24:23 THIS MORNING. THERE IS A DIVERGENCE HAPPENING
24:27 ESPECIALLY IN THE TECH-HEAVY NAMES IN ASIA IN TIE WAND SOUTH
24:32 KOREA THAT OPENS A LITTLE BIT LATER TODAY, THE KOSPI THAT IS.
24:35 WE'RE LOOKING AT THE OVERALL PICTURE, ANTHROPIC OF COURSE,
24:39 ALL THE EUPHORIA AROUND THE IPO. THE PRICING, TOP OF THE-RANGE,
24:43 MORE THAN TOP OF THE-RANGE AS A MATTER OF FACT.
24:45 THAT IS CREATING A LITTLE BIT OF UPSIDE IN THE TECH GAME AND THEN
24:48 WE'RE TAKING A LOOK OF COURSE AT OIL PRICES RIGHT NOW.
24:54 IT IS .2% HIGHER FOR BRENT PRICES.
24:56 $92 ON THE BARREL OF COURSE. THE "NEW YORKTIMES" HAD REPORTED
25:02 SIGHT SOURCES FROM THE U.S. AND ISRAEL THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP IS
25:06 CONSIDERING FRESH ESCALATIONS AGAINST IRAN.
25:10 HE IS BEING PRESSED BY BENJAMIN NETANYAHU TO DO A FOUR-TO-SEVEN
25:14 DAY OPERATION. HASN'T MADE UP HIS MIND YET.
25:17 HAS THE LATEST REPORTING. OF COURSE WE CONTINUE TO KEEP
25:20 OUR EYES ON THE BENCH MARK YIELDS IN THE UNITED STATES.
25:23 THOSE ARE ABOUT TWO BASIS POINTS LOWER THIS MORNING.
25:26 STILL ABOVE 5%. THOSE ARE THE LONGEST RUNS SINCE
25:30 2007. SO OF COURSE WE KEEP AN ON THAT
25:34 AND THE HAWKISH TILT BY THE FEDERAL RESERVE ACCORDING TO THE
25:37 MINUTES THAT WE SAW YESTERDAY. NOW FOR THE WEAKNESS THAT WE'RE
25:43 SEEING IN ASIA THIS MORNING, LET'S GET A CHECK ON WHAT'S
25:46 HAPPENING BY WINNIE HSU. GOOD MORNING.
25:51 WINNIE: GOOD MORNING. IT SEEMS LIKE RISK OFF FLOOD
25:54 ASIA. A CONTRAST TO WHAT WE SEE IN
25:59 U.S. FUTURES. HERE THEY ARE WORRIED AHEAD OF
26:03 ANTHROPIC'S IPO WE MIGHT BE EXPECTING MORE CAPITAL TO LEAVE
26:08 THE TECH HEAVY GAUGES IN SOUTH KOREA AND TAIWAN GIVEN THAT THEY
26:12 HAVE BEEN OUTPERFORMING OTHER BENCH MARKS THIS YEAR.
26:16 ON THE AI TRADE. TAIWAN'S TAIEX UNDERPERFORMING
26:20 TODAY. ALSO SOME CHATTERS WHEN IT COMES
26:25 TO A BIT OF A FORCE SELLING GIVEN THE MAR CALLS WE'RE SEEING
26:29 ON SOME OF THESE LEVERAGED BETS. A BIT MORE CAUTION AHEAD OF THAT
26:33 MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT TRUMP AND XI.
26:35 WHEN IT COMES TO TECH STOCKS IN HONG KONG, CONTINUE TO LOSE
26:40 MOMENTUM FOR A SEVENTH SESSION. WORRIES WHEN IT COMES TO U.S.
26:45 CHIP CURBS BUT ALSO EARNINGS FROM THE LIKES OF TENCENT.
26:50 DISAPPOINT MANAGE. PERHAPS A BIT OF A WAIT AND SEE
26:58 MOOD AHEAD OVER ALIBABA'S EARNINGS TODAY.
27:02 THE U.S. DOLLAR IS STRENGTH HANG LITTLE BIT GIVEN THE HAWKISH
27:07 COMMENT WHEN IT COMES TO THE FED MINUTES SO THAT IS PRESSURING
27:09 THE CURRENCIES IN OUR REGION AS WELL.
27:13 YOU CAN SEE THAT THE JAPANESE YEN WEAKENING TO 159.45 LEVEL
27:15 AGAINST THE DOLLAR. OF COURSE WE ALSO HEARD FROM THE
27:20 GOVERNOR WHO IS NOT PROVIDING A CLEAR PATH WHEN IT COMES TO THE
27:24 RATE HIKE GOING FORWARD. INVESTORS LOSING A LITTLE BIT OF
27:26 CONFIDENCE THERE. WHEN IT COMES TO THE AUSSIE
27:33 DOLLAR, ERASING ALL GAINS WE SAW THIS YEAR.
27:36 REINFORCING THE BETS FOR THE CENTRAL BANK TO CUT FURTHER
27:39 GOING INTO NEXT YEAR. WHEN IT COMES TO KOREAN WON
27:46 INTERESTINGLY THE, AROUND 1330 LEVEL THAT IS COMING AS
27:50 INVESTORS CONTINUE TO BET THE EXPORTS FROM THE CHIP MAKERS ARE
27:55 LIKELY GOING TO CONTINUE TO TRANSFORM U.S. DOLLARS INTO MORE
28:00 KOREAN WON AS WELL. ABEER: THANK YOU AS ALWAYS.
28:06 WIN WIN IN TOKYO. JPMORGAN PRIVATE BANK SEIZED THE
28:10 CONVERGENCE OF AI GLOBAL FRAGMENTATION AND INFLATION IS
28:17 DRIVING AN HISTORIC REPRICING OF CAPITAL.
28:18 THEORY DISCUSS THE HEAD OF INVESTMENTS FOR THE MIDDLE EAST,
28:25 NORTH AFRICA AND TURKEY, STEVEN REES.
28:30 >> THANKS FOR HAVING ME. ABEER: LET'S START WITH THE
28:32 OUTLOOK. >> WE'RE EXCITED TO BE BACK IN
28:36 DUBAI AND WITH OUR CLIENTS IN THE REGION.
28:40 WE PROBABLY MORE SELECTEDDIVE IN 2027 JUST GIVEN ALL OF THE
28:44 HEADWINDS THAT WE'RE SEEING. THERE IS A LOT OF OPPORTUNITY AS
28:48 WELL. THERE ARE A LOT OF MARKETS WITH
28:52 FIXED INCOME, TALKING ABOUT BUILDING A RESILIENT -- GOING
28:56 FORWARD. IT IS A GOOD ENTRY LEVEL TO BE
29:01 ADDING U.S. EQUITIES AND FIXED INCOME NOW WITH YIELDS --
29:13 ABEER: YOU TALK ABOUT EQUITY MARKETS.
29:15 IS THAT ALSO INCLUDING AI? WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THE MOVES?
29:19 >> AI IS ONE OF OUR BIG THREE THEMES NEXT YEAR.
29:23 WE HAVE SEEN A LOT OF VOLATILITY AND DIVERSIONS ACROSS DIFFERENT
29:25 NAMES. THAT IS ACTUALLY HEALTHY.
29:27 WE'RE PROBABLY GOING TO SEE A BIT OF A SLOW DOWN IN THE
29:31 CAPITAL SPENDING NEXT YEAR. AGAIN, I THINK THAT IS HEALTHY.
29:35 THERE WILL BE WINNERS AND LOSERS.
29:41 WE'RE INCLINED TO STAY INVESTED. HOW YOU GET THE EXPOSURE IN THE
29:46 PRIVATE SIDE AND THE PUBLIC SIDE.
29:48 WE THINK IT CAN SET UP TO DO WELL NEXT YEAR.
29:52 ABEER: ARE THERE GAINS TO BE MADE OUTSIDE OF AI?
29:53 >> ABSOLUTELY. IT IS NOT JUST ABOUT THE TECH
29:57 SECTOR, COMMUNICATION SERVICES. YOU WANT TO HAVE EXPOSURE TO
30:02 OTHERS THAT DIDN'T DO AS WELL. A LOT TO DO IN HEALTHCARE AS
30:06 WELL IT IS NOT JUST TECH. IT IS THE IMPACT IT IS GOING TO
30:10 HAVE ON PRODUCT IVITY ACROSS ALL THE SECTORS.
30:14 THAT MIGHT END UP OCCURRING FASTER THAN MANY INVESTORS ARE
30:18 ANTICIPATING. ABEER: YOU HAVE A BIG PRESENCE
30:22 FROM DUBAI. THE CAN WE TALK ABOUT GULF
30:26 CAPITAL AND IN THE MIDDEST TO HAVE GEO-POLITICAL SITUATION,
30:29 EVERYTHING THAT'S HAPPENING IN THE WORLD, DO YOU THINK THAT
30:33 CAPITAL BECAME MORE SELECTIVE OR DO YOU THINK THAT IT IS CHOOSING
30:37 DIFFERENT PLACES TO BE DEPLOYED? >> NOT JUST HERE, GLOBALLY
30:41 CAPITAL IS BECOMING MORE SCARCE. INVESTORS ARE BECOMING MORE
30:43 SELECTIVE. HAS THE NAME OF OUR OUTLOOK IS
30:48 THE PRICE OF PROGRESS. THIS WHOLE NOTION THAT INVESTORS
30:51 WILL BE MORE SELECTIVE IN TERMS OF HOW THEY ALLOCATE THAT
30:54 CAPITAL GOING FORWARD IN DEMANDING RETURN IN SETTING THE
30:56 PRICE. I DON'T KNOW THAT THE FUTURE
30:59 WILL BE AS EASY AS THE RECENT PAST IN TERMS OF THE RETURN TO
31:08 EXPECT CROSSING ASSET DALLAS. A GOOD OPPORTUNITY ACROSS
31:14 EQUITIES AND FIXED INCOME. INFRASTRUCTURE, HEDGE FUNDS AND
31:16 EVEN GOLD WHICH HAS BEEN VERY UNLOVED RECENTLY.
31:19 I THINK ALL OF THESE PIECES TOGETHER IS HOW YOU NEED TO
31:23 PREPARE FOR WHAT IS GOING TO BE AN UNCERTAIN VOLATILE BUT QUITE
31:28 GOOD YEAR AHEAD. ABEER: HERE IN GCC COUNTRIES
31:31 WHEN WE LOOK AT HOW THEY HAVE BEEN DEPLOYING CAPITAL OVER THE
31:36 PAST DECADE OR SO, THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF INTEREST
31:40 INTERNATIONALLY. TO DO YOU WORRY THEY START TO BE
31:45 INWARD AND MORE DOUGH DOMESTIC? >> NOT WORRIED AT ALL.
31:49 THAT HAVE GROWTH HERE WILL CONTINUE BUT I THINK ALSO A LOT
31:54 OF OUR CLIENTS WANT TO DIVERSIFY INTO OTHER REGIONS.
31:58 THAT IS REALLY WHERE JPMORGAN THINKS ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITIES
32:00 IN THE U.S. AND EUROPE PARTICULARLY IN THE AI SPACE.
32:03 ABEER: WHEN YOU SPEAK ABOUT OPPORTUNITIES, WHEN YOU LOOK
32:06 HERE AGAIN, I WANT TO FOCUS ON THIS REGION.
32:08 SO MUCH HAPPENING. DO YOU SEE THAT HAPPENING IN AI
32:13 AS YOU RIGHTLY MENTION IN YOUR OUTLOOK?
32:16 DO YOU SEE PRIVATE CREDIT AT ALL AS AN AREA THAT IS NOT EXPLORED
32:23 AND TAPPED INTO ENOUGH? >> WE'RE COMFORTABLE THE
32:27 EXPOSURE BUT WITH INTEREST RATES HERE, RATES LIKELY TO REMAIN
32:33 ELEVATED IN SOME POCKETS OF EXHUMAN BEING FRANCE CERTAIN
32:36 SUBSECTORS, IT IS ALL ABOUT SELECTIVITY.
32:39 WE'RE TRYING TO HELP OUR CLIENTS FIND RIGHT PRIVATE CREDIT
32:42 OPPORTUNITIES AND MAKE SURE THEY ARE DIVERSIFIED ACROSS A LOT OF
32:46 DIFFERENT FUNDS TO AVOID POTENTIALLY ANY -- ANYTHING THAT
32:49 COULD GO WRONG. WE'RE STILL POSITIVE CREDIT.
32:57 VERY SELECTIVE IN A DIVERSIFIED WAY.
32:59 ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT INVEST FLORIST THIS PART OF THE WORLD
33:03 AND HOW THEY THINK THEIR AMBITIONS -- THERE IS A
33:06 DISCONNECT BETWEEN HOW INVESTORS HERE THINK AND WHAT IS WANTED
33:10 FROM THEM EXTREMELY? >> I DON'T THINK THERE IS A
33:13 DISCONNECT. CLIENTS AROUND THE WORLD,
33:15 EVERYBODY IS TRYING TO FIGURE OUT THE FUTURE IN TRYING TO MAKE
33:19 SURE THEY HAVE THE RIGHT EXPOSURES ACROSS THE PORTFOLIOS
33:23 ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO AI. JUST TRYING TO BE IN THE GAME IN
33:27 THE RIGHT WAY WITHOUT CHASING AND REALLY OVERFARING THAT.
33:31 AGAIN, THIS IS THE YEAR WHERE PEOPLE FOCUS ON NOT JUST WHO IS
33:35 SPENDING AND WHO IS ADOPTING BUT ARE THE RETURNS JUSTIFYING THAT
33:37 SPEND? IN SOME CASES THEY ARE AND OTHER
33:42 CASES THEY ARE NOT. THAT'S WHY EXPERTS ONLY
33:44 TERRITORY. THAT'S WHERE JPMORGAN CAN LETHAL
33:46 WEAPON. ABEER: OK.
33:48 STEVEN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US.
33:49 WELCOME TO DUBAI. I JUST TOLD YOU THE WEATHER IS
33:54 BEAUTIFUL THIS TIME OF YEAR. STEVEN REES, HEAD OF INVESTMENTS
34:00 FOR THE MIDDLE EAST, AFRICA AND TURKEY AT JPMORGAN PRIVATE BANK.
34:03 BREAKING NEWS ACROSS THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL.
34:05 OF COURSE THE BIGGEST NEWS OF THE DAY.
34:08 TRUMP SPEAKING AT A IMMEDIATEING WITH XI JINPING.
34:12 WE'RE MONITORING THOSE TALKS. TRUMP SAYS HE IS GRATEFUL TO
34:16 PRESIDENT XI, THE WARM WELCOME BACK TO CHINA.
34:20 THIS IS THE THIRD TIME THIS YEAR THE TWO LEADERS MEETING.
34:26 HE SAID THE APEC HAS BEEN AMAZING.
34:28 HE SAID WE MADE IT A FAIR RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA.
34:33 THE TARIFFS HAVE BEEN SPLIT IN A WAY AND HE WILL BE ASKING
34:38 PRESIDENT XI TO DO MORE WITH FARMERS.
34:39 PRESIDENT XI SAYS HE IS VERY FIRM IN CONVICTION TO WORK WITH
34:43 TRUMP AND LATER ON WE WILL BE BRINGING YOU MORE FROM INSIDE
34:47 THAT MEETING AS IT COMES ACROSS THE WIRE.
34:50 COMING UP, THE U.N.'S LATEST DIGITAL DEVELOPMENT REPORT SHOWS
34:54 2 BILLION PEOPLE REMAIN UNCONNECTED TO THE INTERNET IN
34:56 2026. WE WILL BE DISCUSSING THAT WITH
35:05 DOWNPOUR IAN BOGDAN-MARTIN NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
35:25 H ♪ ABEER: WELCOME BACK TO "HORIZONS
35:28 MIDDLE EAST AND AFRICA." LET'S RECAP SOME OF THE LINES WE
35:31 WERE AGREEING WITHIN THE BILATERAL MEETING THAT IS
35:35 HAPPENING NOW BETWEEN PRESIDENTS TROMPED XI JINPING.
35:37 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID HE IS GRATEFUL FOR PRESIDENT XI FOR A
35:40 WARM WELCOME BACK TO CHINA. HE ALSO SAID THAT THE APEC
35:45 SUMMIT HAS BEEN AMAZING AND NOBODY IN OTHER PLACES CAN DO
35:47 WHAT WE DO. PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID WE HAVE
35:52 MADE IT A FAIR RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA.
35:54 THAT THE TARIFFS HAVE BEEN SPLIT IN A FAIRWAY AND THAT HE WILL BE
35:59 ASKING XI TO DO MORE WITH FARMERS.
36:00 PRESIDENT XI ON THE OTHER HAND SAYS HE IS VERY FIRM IN
36:03 CONVICTION TO WORK WITH TRUMP AND TRUMP ALSO SAID THAT XI IS
36:08 HIS FRIEND AND THEY HAVE A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP.
36:10 ON THE UKRAINE FRONT, PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS SOMETHING STRONGLY
36:13 WILL COME FROM THE MEETING AND WE WILL BE OF COURSE BRINGING
36:19 YOU MORE FROM INSIDE THAT MEETING AS IT COMES ACROSS THE
36:22 WIRE. NOW MOVING ON TO ANOTHER
36:26 CONVERSATION, ANOTHER STORY, THE U.N.'S DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY AGENCY
36:32 IS MEETING IN DOHA WITH AI CONNECTIVITY AND SPACE
36:34 TECHNOLOGY HIGH ON THE AGENDA. ACCORDING TO THE INTERNATIONAL
36:37 TELECOMMUNICATION UNION, MORE THAN 2 BILLION PEOPLE REMAIN
36:45 OFFLINE AS GOVERNMENTS GRAPPLE WITH RAPID DEVELOPMENT OF AI AND
36:48 OTHER DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES. JOINING US IS DOREEN BOGDAN
36:52 MARTIN. GOOD MORNING.
36:54 GOOD TO HAVE YOU WITH US THIS MORNING.
36:57 QUITE A FASCINATING STATISTIC THAT YOU HAVE THERE.
37:01 I WAS TAKING A LOOK AT THE NOTES EARLIER THIS MORNING.
37:03 YOU KIND OF FORGET ABOUT HOW MANY PEOPLE REMAIN OFFPHONE LINE
37:06 THE WORLD WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHAT'S HAPPENING WHEN IT COMES
37:09 TO AI. SO 2 BILLION PEOPLE REMAIN
37:15 OFFLINE WITH A B DESPITE THE RAPID ACCELERATION WE'RE SEEING
37:16 ACROSS THE BOARD IN AI. I GUESS THE QUESTION IS SIMPLE.
37:21 HOW DO YOU FIX THAT? >> THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION.
37:26 GREAT TO BE HERE. THIS MORNING AS YOU SAID, WE'RE
37:31 GATHERED HERE IN DOHA. THIS IS OUR CONFERENCE, A
37:38 THREE-WEEK CONFERENCE THAT BRINGS TOGETHER OUR 194 MEMBER
37:40 STATES. WE HAVE 1,000 PRIVATE SECTOR
37:45 COMPANIES THAT ARE PART OF THEITU, A U.N. SPECIALIZED
37:49 AGENCY THAT IS ALL ABOUT DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES.
37:52 SO HOW DO WE CONNECT THOSE 2 BILLION PEOPLE?
37:54 WELL, ONE OF THE BIGGEST CHALLENGES IS LINKED TO
37:58 AFFORDABLABILITY. WHILE WE HAVE SUCCEEDED IN
38:02 GETTING 4G COVERAGE OUT TO MORE THAN 90% OF THE POPULATION, WE
38:08 HAVE 5G COVERAGE FOR MORE THAN 50% OF THE POPULATION BUT STILL
38:12 2 BILLION PEOPLE OFFLINE. WE LOOK AT DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
38:17 IN SOME CASES, ACCESS TO MOBILE BROADBRAND CAN COST ABOUT 22% OF
38:23 MONTHLY INCOME WHICH IS FAR EXCESSIVE FOR SO MANY TO BE ABLE
38:28 TO AFFORD. ABEER: LET'S TALK ABOUT THE
38:31 AFFORDABILITY. LET'S TALK ABOUT THE OBSTACLES
38:34 WHEN ITS COMES TO WHAT YOU GUYS DO.
38:37 THE BIGGEST OBSTACLE NOW, REMAINS AFFORDABILITY?
38:39 IS IT INFRASTRUCTURE? IS IT THE DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGY
38:43 THAT WE'RE SEEING RIGHT NOW THAT IS PLAYING AT THE OTHER END OF
38:48 HOW BENEFICIAL THINGS COULD BE? >> SO I WOULD SAY IT IS A LITTLE
38:54 BIT OF ALL OF THE ABOVE. AFFORDABILITY IS A HUGE
38:56 CHALLENGE. INFRASTRUCTURE ALSO REMAINS A
39:01 CHALLENGE GETTING TO THAT LAST MILE.
39:04 ITU ESTIMATES TO BE ABLE TO CONNECT THE ENTIRE PLANET
39:11 MEANFULLY AROUND 2.8 TRILLION U.S.
39:15 BY 2030. SO AFFORD IS THE A BIG
39:18 CHALLENGE. BASICS DIGITAL LITERACY IS A BIG
39:21 CHALLENGE. TRUST AND SAFETY.
39:27 A LOT OF CHALLENGE AROUND CYBER SECURITY.
39:31 PEOPLE OFFLINE IS ALSO ANOTHER BARRIER.
39:32 I WOULD ADD WHAT WE'RE SEEING IN OUR SPACE, I'LL SAY SPACE, ARE
39:38 TREMENDOUS OPPORTUNITIES FOR FOR SPACE-BASED COMMUNICATION,
39:44 NOTARIES RECOMMEND SOLUTION, SUBC CABLE OPPORTUNITIES.
39:47 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND MORE.
39:49 I THINK WE'RE LIVING IN AN INCREDIBLE TIME WHEN IT COMES TO
39:52 CONNECTIVITY. ABEER: I WANT TO GET TO AI IN A
39:54 LITTLE BIT. I WANT TO TALK ABOUT SOME OF
39:56 THESE OPPORTUNITIES. THERE ARE A LOT OF COUNTRIES IN
39:59 THIS REGION IN THE MIDDLE EAST THAT ARE EMERGING FROM WARS OR
40:03 CONFLICT. SYRIA IS ONE EXAMPLE.
40:05 DO YOU SEE OPPORTUNITIES IN A COUNTRY THAT HAS JUST EMERGED
40:12 FROM OTHER A DECADE IN CONFLICT AND CIVIL WAR?
40:14 >> YES, ABSOLUTELY. I SEE HUGE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
40:17 SYRIA. THAT COUNTRY, WE JUST HAD THE
40:21 MINISTER WITH US HERE IN DOHA, IS VERY FOCUSED NOT JUST ON
40:26 REBUILD ITS INFRASTRUCTURE BUT ON ENSURING THAT SYRIA BECOMES A
40:33 DIGITAL HUB FOR THE REGION. IT ZORCH ALSO COMMITTED TO
40:34 HELPING SYRIA. WE HAVE A COALITION THAT IS
40:37 CALLED PARTNERS TO CONNECT. WE HAVE MOBILIZED PLEDGES AND
40:42 COMMITMENTS TO ACTUALLY HELP SIR ELTON JOHNIA TO ADVANCE IN THEIR
40:46 DIGITAL JOURNEY. ABEER: OK.
40:48 DOREEN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT UPDATE ON CONNECTIVITY AND
40:54 EVERYTHING WE CAN SEE IN THE REGION.
41:00 DOREEN BOGDAN-MARTIN JOINING US THERE.
41:03 COMING UP, CITI SEES AFRICA'S DEBT BOOM HAVING FURTHER ROOM TO
41:05 RUN. WE WILL BRING YOU THE DETAILS
41:07 NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
41:28 ♪ ABEER: CITIGROUP EXPECTS THE
41:33 NUMBER OF AFRICAN SOVEREIGN BOND SALES IN 2027 TO EXCEED THIS
41:38 YEAR'S RECORD. OUR CHIEF AFRICA CORRESPONDENT
41:43 JENNIFER ZABASAJJA JOINS US NOW WITH MORE DETAILS ON THIS STORY.
41:47 WHAT IS STRENGTHENING CITI'S CASE FOR AFRICA'S DEBT MARKET?
41:52 JENNIFER: IT IS FAIR TO CALL THIS A BULLISH CASE.
41:57 THIS IS SPECIFICALLY COMING FROM THE VICE CHAIR MARMMAN FOR
41:59 INVESTMENT BANKING AT CITIGROUP FOR THE MIDDLE EAST AND AFRICA.
42:03 SPECIFICALLY, HE SAYS THE EXPECTATIONS FOR BOND ISSUANCES
42:09 IS NOT JUST SOVEREIGN BUT ALSO CONTINUES IN 2027 IS STROPPINGER
42:12 THAN EVER BY THE BANK. PART OF IT IS WHAT YOU WERE
42:17 ALLUDING TO. IT IS BOOSTING INVESTOR APPETITE
42:21 ACROSS THE REGION OFF THE BACK OF WHAT WE HAVE HEARD FROM THE
42:24 INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND WHICH EXPECTS GROWTH FOR THE
42:30 REGION TO BE JUST AROUND 4.45% FOR BOTH THIS YEAR AND NEXT
42:32 YEAR. OF COURSE WE HAVE HEARD A NUMBER
42:36 OF ANALYSTS AND ECONOMISTS EXPECTING THAT THE GROWTH IS
42:40 ACTUALLY GOING TO BE FASTER THAN A LOT OF REGIONS THAT WE'RE
42:43 SEEING GLOBALLY AND WE'RE ALSO SEEING A NUMBER OF GOVERNMENTS
42:49 ACROSS THE CONTINENT REALLY ENACTING REFORMS THAT
42:52 INVESTORSES HAVE EITHER BEEN CALLING FOR OR HAVE BEEN
42:55 SUGGESTING AND POTENTIALLY THAT IS AIDING IN SOME OF THE BOND
42:59 ISSUANCES THAT WE HAVE SEEN. THIS YEAR HAS BEEN A YEAR WHERE
43:02 CITI HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN A NUMBER OF THOSE AND AS MIGUEL
43:06 AND CITI POINTS OUT FOR NEXT YEAR, IT IS LOOKING LIKE THE
43:12 BULLISH CASE FOR SPREADS BETWEEN AFRICAN SOVEREIGNS AND ALSO WHAT
43:15 WE'RE SEEING ELSEWHERE IN THE WORLD TO CONTINUE TO BE LOW AND
43:19 AT THE LOWEST LEVELS THAN WHAT WE HAVE SEEN IN THE PAST FEW
43:24 YEARS. ABEER: HOW WILL THAT COMPARE TO
43:26 THE SOVEREIGN ISSUANCE WE HAVE SEEN THIS YEAR?
43:30 JENNIFER: LET'S JUST TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE HAVE SEEN THIS YEAR
43:33 BECAUSE AT LEAST FROM THE BLOOMBERG PERSPECTIVE, WE
43:38 TRACKED ABOUT JUST OVER 16 PARTICULARLY NAH PARTICULAR,
43:41 THERE IS QUITE A NUMBER THAT CITI HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN WHICH
43:43 IS WHAT THIS REPORTING REALLY POINTS TO AND THERE IS A NUMBER
43:47 THAT -- THERE IS A NUMBER OF SOVEREIGNS THAT ARE STILL
43:50 EXPECTED TO GO BACK TO THE MARKET SO THERE HAS BEEN QUITE A
43:54 LOT OF TALK ABOUT NIGERIA POTENTIALLY RETURNING TO THE
43:59 MARKET TO FUND ITS 2026 BUDGET. ALSO KENYA IN PIPELINE.
44:05 GUINEA IS ANOTHER COUNTRY POTENTIALLY PLANNING A EURO BOND
44:08 NEXT YEAR. STILL, IT HAS BEEN QUITE A
44:12 SUBSTANTIALLY GOOD YEAR FOR SOVEREIGNS RETURNING BACK TO
44:15 MARKET, ESPECIALLY AFTER SEVERAL YEARS IN WHICH WE SAW REALLY A
44:21 BIT OF A DRY SPELL IN TERMS OF BOND MARKETS AND BOND DEBUTS
44:29 FROM THE REGION. ABEER: OK.
44:31 JEN, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT UPDATE ON SOVEREIGN BONDS AND
44:33 AFRICA. THAT IS WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT
44:37 THIS TERMS OF THE AFRICAN PICTURE.
44:39 LET'S RECAP SOME OF THE LINES WE HAVE SCENE FROM THE BILATERAL
44:43 MEETING HAPPENING RIGHT NOW BETWEEN PRESIDENTS TROMPED XI
44:46 JINPING. PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS HE IS
44:48 GRATEFUL TO XI FOR THE WARM WELCOME BACK TO CHINA, THAT THE
44:53 APEC SUMMIT HAS BEEN AMAZING AND NOBODY IN OTHER PLACES CAN DO
44:56 WHAT THEY DO. WE SAID WE HAVE MADE IT A FAIR
44:59 RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA. THAT TARIFFS HAVE BEEN SPLIT IN
45:04 A FAIRWAY AND THAT HE WILL BE ASKING PRESIDENT XI JINPING TO
45:09 DO MORE WITH FARMERS. PRESIDENT XI JINPING SAID HE IS
45:12 FIRM IN HIS CONVICTION TO WORK WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP AND
45:14 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID XI IS HIS FRIEND AND THEY HAVE A SPECIAL
45:16 RELATIONSHIP. ON THE FRONT OF UKRAINE,
45:19 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS THAT SOMETHING STRONGLY WILL COME
45:22 FROM THE MEETING AND WE WILL OF COURSE BE BRINGING YOU MORE FROM
45:26 INSIDE THAT TRI LAT WALL MEETING AS IT COMES ACROSS THE WIRE.
45:30 A QUICK LOOK AT EQUITY FUTURES BEFORE WE HEAD TO THE BREAK.
45:38 YOU'RE LOOKING AT S&P ABOUT .7% HIGHER WHILE NASDAQ FUTURES
45:43 GAINED OVER 1%. EURO STOXX 50 FUTURES ARE
45:45 POINTING TO A POSITIVE START THIS MORNING IN EUROPE LATER
45:46 TODAY. THAT IS IT FOR "HORIZONS MIDDLE
45:49 EAST AND AFRICA"." "DAYBREAK: EUROPE" IS UP NEXT.
45:53 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Trump Calls Putin 'My Friend' as Xi Prepares to Host Trilateral Meeting full transcript
0:00 ♪ >> LEAVE IN BRUSSELS, THIS IS
0:05 BLOOMBERG "DAYBREAK: EUROPE." I'M STEPHEN CARROLL.
0:08 STARTING THE DAY WITH THE LATEST PICTURES COMING THROUGH FROM
0:12 SHENZHEN WHERE THE PRESIDENTS OF THE UNITED STATES AND CHINA ARE
0:15 MEETING. DISCUSSIONS ABOUT ENERGY
0:16 SUPPLIES. YOU CAN SEE MARCO RUBIO THERE
0:19 SITTING BESIDE THE U.S. PRESIDENT AT THAT MEETING.
0:24 WE'RE COUNTING DOWN TO A KEENLY WAITED TRILATERAL MEETING
0:29 BETWEEN PRESIDENTS TRUMP, XI AND VLADIMIR PUTIN OF RUSSIA WHO
0:33 PRESIDENT TRUMP MET A LITTLE BIT EARLIER AS WELL.
0:36 DONALD TRUMP GOING INTO THIS MEETING TALKING ABOUT THE.
0:40 FRED: WITH THE CHINESE PRESIDENT GOING INTO THIS CONVERSATION.
0:43 THEIR THIRD SUMMIT OF THIS YEAR. LET'S GO LIVE TO SHENZHEN.
0:49 MIMMIN IS THERE FOR US. TELL US WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT
0:52 THAT CONVERSATION HAPPENING BETWEEN THOSE PRESIDENTS?
0:58 MINMIN: YEAH, IT IS QUITE INTERESTING.
1:01 IT JUST HAPPENED NOT TOO LONG AGO.
1:02 PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS A LITTLE BIT LATE BECAUSE OF A LAST MINUTE
1:08 IMPROMPTMEETING WITH PRESIDENT PUTIN EARLIER.
1:12 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID HE HAS A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP WITH
1:15 PRESIDENT XI AND TALKED ABOUT THEIR ABILITY TO MAINTAIN A FAIR
1:23 AND BALANCED RELATIONSHIP AND REFERENCED THE TARIFF
1:25 ARRANGEMENT AND USED IT AS AN EXAMPLE HOW THE TWO SIDES HAVE
1:30 SPLIT TARIFFS EVENLY AND TALKED ABOUT AGRICULTURE GOODS AND SAID
1:36 CHINA HAS AN INSATIABLE AN SITE TITHE AND WILL BE ASKING THEM TO
1:39 DO MORE MORE AMERICAN FARMERS. THE U.S. SAID THEY EXPECT CHINA
1:45 TO BUY ABOUT $70 BILLION WORTH OF NONSOYBEAN AGRICULTURAL
1:47 GOODS. SO FAR THAT HASN'T COME THROUGH.
1:53 CHINA SAID THAT IS CONTINGENCY ON THE TRADE BEING IMPLEMENTED.
1:57 THE TIMELINE IS STILL UNKNOWN. PRESIDENT TRUMP MENTIONED THE
2:01 IRAN WAR AND SAID HIM AND XI WOULD WANT TO SEE OIL FLOWING
2:03 AGAIN THROUGH STRAIT OF HORMUZ AND BOTH OF THEM WOULD LIKE IRAN
2:07 TO NOT HAVE ANY NUCLEAR WEAPONS AS WELL.
2:10 THIS IS SOMETHING CHINA WOULD AGREE ON THAT.
2:13 HOW THEY WOULD GET TO THAT POINT IS A BIG QUESTION MARK.
2:16 WE'LL SEE HOW LONG THIS SUMMIT LASTS.
2:19 OF COURSE THERE ARE A LOT OF UNFINISHED BUSINESS FOR TRUMP
2:25 AND XI TO DISCUSS. THAN CURBS THAT HAD RECENTLY
2:28 BEEN ANNOUNCE BID THE DEPARTMENT IS GOING TO BE FRONT AND CENTER.
2:35 WILL IT DESTROY THE AGREEMENT THE TWO SIDES HAD WHERE CHINA
2:39 WOULD ALLOW THE FLOW OF RARE EARTH IN EXCHANGE FOR THE U.S.
2:42 PUTTING A PAUSE ON TECH CURVES. HAS THE BIG THING WE'RE WATCHING
2:44 NOW. SOMETHING CHINESE COMPANIESES
2:46 WILL BE WATCHING FOR. ANY ESCALATION OF TENSION
2:50 BETWEEN BOTH SIDES BUT AT LEAST PRESIDENT TRUMP APPEARS HAPPY IN
2:55 A FOX NEWS INTERVIEW, HE WAS ASKED WHETHER AMERICAN CITIZENS
2:58 WOULD VIEW THIS AS A SUCCESS. HE SAID THE SUCCESS WAS
3:02 YESTERDAY WHEN HE GOT ALL OF THE POMP AND PAGEANTRY.
3:05 IN SOME SENSE MS. A MASTER MOVE BY PRESIDENT XI TO GIVE
3:08 PRESIDENT TRUMP HIS MOMENT IN THE SPOTLIGHT, THE PRESIDENTIAL
3:15 SPECTACLE THAT TRUMP SO VERY MUCH PRIZES.
3:16 STEPHEN: WATCHING CLOSELY TO SEE WHAT COMES OUT OF THAT MEETING
3:20 AS IT CONTINUES BUT WE'RE ALSO LOOKING AHEAD MIMMIN TO THE NEXT
3:24 MEETING, THIS TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENTS TRUMP, XI AND
3:28 PUTIN. WHAT ARE THE EXPECTATIONS AROUND
3:30 THIS MEETING? SHOULD WE EXPECT CONVERSATIONS
3:35 THAT MAY RELATE TO THE UKRAINE WAR?
3:39 MINMIN: YES, THAT JUST CHANGED MOMENTS AGO.
3:42 WE GOT NEWS FROM RUSSIAN MEDIA AFTER TRUMP AND PUTIN HAD THE
3:47 MEETING THE TWO MEN SPOKE ABOUT UKRAINE AND THEY SAID THAT
3:50 UKRAINE WILL BE ON THE AGENDA DURING THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT AND
3:54 PUTIN CAME OUT OF THE MEETING LOOKING VERY HAPPY.
3:57 PRESIDENT TRUMP ALSO SAID IN THE OPENING REMARKS AHEAD OF THE
4:00 MEETING WITH PRESIDENT XI BEFORE THEY CLOSED THE DOORS, HE SAID
4:05 HE EXPECTS SOMETHING TO COME OUT OF THE TRILATERAL SUMMIT WHEN IT
4:08 COMES TO UKRAINE. THIS IS SOMETHING THAT I THINK
4:11 IS A LITTLE BIT SURPRISING. PREVIOUSLY U.S. OFFICIALS TOLD
4:15 BLOOMBERG UKRAINE WAS NOT LIKELY TO COME UP.
4:18 THIS IS SOMETHING THAT IS EXTREMELY SENSITIVE.
4:25 A CONCERN IF THEY DISCUSS THE OUTCOME WITHOUT ZELENSKYY AT THE
4:30 TABLE. PRESIDENT TRUMP SAID HE WILL NOT
4:33 AGREE TO ANYTHING WITHOUT CONSULTATION FROM ZELENSKYY BUT
4:36 THE FACT THAT THE THREE LEADERS SITTING TOGETHER AND TRUMP AND
4:41 PUTIN HAD FACE TIME EARLIER TODAY, THAT IS QUITE CONCERNING
4:48 NOT JUST TO THE EUROPEANS BUT ASIANS AS WELL TAKAICHI WILL BE
4:55 HAVING A MEETING WITH TRUMP AFTER THE SUMMIT.
5:06 RUSSIA HAD DETAINED A JAPANESE JOURNALIST OVER ESPIONAGE
5:07 CHARGES. TAIWAN WILL BE WATCH TO GO SEE
5:12 IF ITS FATE COULD BE DECIDED IN A SIMILAR MANNER AS WELL.
5:20 STEPHEN: HIROBA MINOWA. LIVEMIMMIN LOW.THANK YOU THE AN UPSIZED IPO AND
5:29 PRIVATE PLACEMENTS, THE BIG OFEST OF ALL TIME.
5:35 SHARES WILL DEBUT ATTON THE NASDAQ LATER TODAY AT $83.
5:40 THE VALUATION BELOW THE $2 TRILLION THAT WAS FLOATED JUST A
5:44 COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO BUT ABOVE THE $1.1 TRILLION THAT SO MANY
5:48 ON WALL STREET HAD SUGGESTED DURING THE RECENT SELLOFF.
5:51 WHAT ARE WE TAKING FROM THE SIGNALS GOING TO THE STRONG
5:55 FIRST DAY'S TRADING. >> GOOD MORNING, STEVEN.
5:58 YES, IT IS AN HISTORIC DAY, ANTHROPIC OF COURSE COMING TO
6:01 MARKET. VERY WIDELY ANTICIPATED FOR
6:03 MEANTIMES. THEY DID PRICE THE SHARES AT $83
6:11 PER SHARE ABOVE THE RANGE. THAT IMPLIES DILUTE VALUATION OF
6:15 $1.45 TRILLION LOWER THAN $2 TRILLION FLOATED A FEW MONTHS
6:17 AGO. THAT IS EXPECTED GIVEN THE ANGST
6:21 THAT WE HAVE SEEN AROUND THE AI TRADE MORE BROADLY OVER THE PAST
6:24 COUPLE OF MONTHS. WHAT THAT VALUATION IMPLIES IS
6:29 THAT INVESTORS WILL BE PAYING ROUGHLY 16 TIMES RATE REVENUE
6:34 LOWER THAN SPACEX BUT BROADLY IN LINE WITH OPENAI.
6:38 I THINK THE BIGGER QUESTION IS LESS ABOUT VALUATION AND MORE
6:41 ABOUT MARGINS IN THE MOST RECENT QUARTER, COMPUTE COSTS WERE
6:46 GROWING FASTER THAN REVENUE AND HAS THE DYNAMIC INVESTORS ARE
6:50 GOING TO BE WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE COMING QUARTERS.
6:52 IN TERMS TO HAVE FIRST DAY, I THINK THE CONDITIONS ARE QUITE
6:56 FAVORABLE FOR A FIRST DAY POP. ABOUT 7% OF SHARES.
7:02 THE BOOK WAS SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED AND THERE IS A
7:06 20% ALLOCATION TO RETAIL. YOU PROBABLY WILL GET A FIRST
7:09 DAY POP BUT MOST OF THE LOCKUPS WILL EXPIRE AROUND MAY AND
7:14 AROUND THAT TIME YOU'LL START TO SEE WHAT THE MARKET REALLY
7:16 THINKS ABOUT THE STOCK AND THE VALUATION AND THE TRADING
7:19 RHYTHM. STEPHEN: OF COURSE AFTER THE
7:21 ROUGH COUPLE OF WEEKS THAT WE HAVE SEEN FOR THE AI TRADE AS
7:25 WELL, HOW IMPORTANT IS THIS AI FOR -- IS THIS IPO FOR THE WIDER
7:31 AI INDUSTRY AND ALL OF THE OTHER POTENTIAL IPO'S THAT COULD BE
7:34 COMING DOWN THE LINE? >> YEAH, IT IS QUITE PIVOTAL
7:38 LIKE YOU ALLUDE TO. THERE HAVE BEEN A LOT OF BANKS
7:42 AROUND THE AI TRADES IN THE PAST COUPLE OF MONTHS.
7:45 SOME WERE SUGGESTING ANTHROPIC MIGHT DELAY THEIR IPO GIVEN ALL
7:50 OF THE VOLATILITY THAT WE HAVE SEEN.
7:52 THE FACT THAT THEY HAVE COME TO MARKET PRICED ABOVE THE EXPECTED
7:54 RANGE AND I THINK THAT IS GOING TO BE A POSITIVE SIGNAL.
7:59 I THINK IF THE STOCK DOES POP, THAT COULD LIFT SENTIMENT MORE
8:02 BROADLY AROUND THE SPACE AND I THINK HAVING ANTHROPIC AS A
8:08 LISTED COMPANY WITH WHERE THEY DO DISCLOSE FINANCIALS AND
8:11 INVESTORSES CAN GET A REAL SENSE OF DEMAND WILL SEIZE THE SENSE
8:15 OF NERVOUSNESS BECAUSE OF THE DISCLOSURE AND THAT SHOULD BE
8:21 POSITIVE IN THEORY FOR THE AI TRADE.
8:24 STEPHEN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. INVEST NORSE ASIA DON'T SEEM TO
8:30 BE REASSURED BY ANTHROPIC'S RECORD BREAKING IPO.
8:34 GOOD MORNING. WINNIE: AS YOU MENTIONED WE'RE
8:38 SEEING A RISK OFF MOOD HERE IN ASIA WITH THE STOCKS DOWN HERE
8:41 FOR A SIXTH SESSION. NOW THIS IS COMING AHEAD OF THAT
8:44 BIG DEBUT OF ANTHROPIC AND AS YOU JUST MENTIONED IT SEEMS LIKE
8:48 INVESTORS OVERALL SEE THIS POSITIVE FOR THE BROADER AI
8:51 TRADE. HOWEVER, FOR INVEST NORSE ASIA,
8:55 THE FOCUS IS ON HOW THIS BIG IPO IS LIKELY GOING TO TAKE AWAY THE
9:01 CAPITAL AS WELL AS LIQUIDITY AUTOOF SOME OF THE MARKETS THAT
9:04 HAVE BEEN DOING WELL ON THE AI TRADE SOFT THIS YEAR.
9:10 THAT'S WHY YOU'RE SEEING TAIWAN TAIWAN'S TAIEX INDEX DRAG DOWN
9:13 THE BROADER BENCHMARK ABOUT 4.4%.
9:15 THIS IS ALSO COMING WHEN IT COMES TO A BIT OF A FORCED
9:20 SELLING WE'RE SEEING IN THE MARKET GIVEN THE MARGIN CALLS ON
9:24 THE LEVERAGED BETS. OF COURSE THAT CAUTION AS WE
9:27 FOLLOW THROUGH MEETING BETWEEN PRESIDENT TRUMP AND XI, WHEN IT
9:32 COMES TO AUSTRALIAN STOCKS, WE SAW STOCKS PARING SOME OF THE
9:35 LOSS AFTER THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE JUMPED MORE THAN EXPECTED NOW
9:43 FLIP THE BOARD THOUGH, WE TAKE A ALLOCATE ANOTHER AREA GETTING
9:49 HIT VERY HARD TECH STOCKS IN HONG KONG FALLING FOR A SEVENTH
9:51 SESSION. NOT JUST ABOUT THE CONCERNS WHEN
9:56 IT COMES TO THE U.S. CHIP CURBS. WE SEE EARNINGS OF THESE
10:00 COMPANIES CONTINUE TO DISAPPOINT.
10:03 WE HAD THE LATEST FROM TENCENT YESTERDAY SHOWING REVENUE
10:05 OPERATING PROFIT MISSING ESTIMATES AS THE COMPANY
10:10 CONTINUES TO STRUGGLE WITH AI MONETIZATION AND THESE TWO KEY
10:13 AREAS WILL BE EXACTLY WHAT WHERE GOING TO BE WATCHING OUT FOR FOR
10:16 ALIBABA'S EARNINGS LATER TODAY. FLIP THE BOARD AGAIN THOUGH.
10:19 WE TAKE A LOOK AT THE BRIGHT SPOT IN THE MARKET TODAY.
10:23 A FUN ONE IN FACT. WE SEEING KPOP NAMES ALONG WITH
10:30 SOME OF THE KOREAN COSMETICS NAMES, TRAVEL SOME OF THE
10:33 TOURISM NAMES SURGING TODAY AS WE HEARD YESTERDAY THAT THE
10:37 LEADERS OF SOUTH KOREA AND CHINA CAME TOGETHER TO AGREE ON
10:41 GRADUALLY EXPANDING THEIR CULTURAL EXCHANGE AND THIS IS
10:45 VERY IMPORTANT FOR SOUTH KOREA GIVEN THAT CHINA IN FACT HAD AN
10:51 INFORMAL BAN ON KOREAN ENTERTAINMENT BACK IN 2026.
10:53 THE REOPENING OF THE CHINESE MARKET FOR THESE KOREAN CULTURE
10:56 EXPORTERS IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT FOR THEIR BUSINESS AS WELL.
11:02 BACK TO YOU, STEVEN. STEPHEN: WINNIE HSU IN TOKYO,
11:06 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. STILL AHEAD, WHY AI IS
11:11 THREATENING TO WORSEN CHINA'S ALREADY SLUGGISH JOBS MARKET.
11:15 FIRST, U.S. FUTURES ARE POINTING TO A HIGHER OPEN IN A SIGN OF
11:21 RELIEF FOR INVESTORS. HOW LONG LIT PLASTIC?
11:22 MORE ON THAT NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
11:46 ♪ STEPHEN: WELCOME BACK TO
11:48 BLOOMBERG "DAYBREAK: EUROPE." NASDAQ FUTURES ARE POINTING TO A
11:54 HIGHER OPEN AFTER ANTHROPIC'S UPSIZED IPO OVER 1% CLARIANT.
11:56 LET'S BRING IN MARK CRANFIELD FOR MORE ON THIS.
12:01 WE HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE DETAIL, A BIG RELIEF UNDER
12:05 INVESTORS? >> YEAH, INDEED.
12:07 YOU CAN SEE THAT VERY CLEARLY. NASDAQ FUTURES HAD A VERY GOOD
12:10 SESSION IN ASIA TODAY. THEY HAVE BEEN CREEPING HIGHER.
12:13 THEY WERE PARTICULARLY ENCOURAGED WHEN THEY SAW THAT
12:17 ANTHROPIC WAS ABLE TO GET A LARGER AMOUNT OF FUNDS THAN
12:20 SPACEX. THAT IS A VERY GOOD SIGN.
12:25 ABOVE 100 BILLION FOR ITS IPO. ALSO THE FACTS THAT IT SOUNDS AS
12:30 THOUGH IT HAS A WIDE BASE OF RAIN COMPETITOR INVESTORS.
12:36 YOU QUITE A FEW LARGE LONG-TERM INVESTORS PREPARED TOY A CHIEF
12:37 THAT AS WELL. THAT IS A VERY GOOD SIGN FOR THE
12:41 BEGINNING OF TRADING. THOSE ARE THE KIND OF PEOPLE
12:44 THAT DON'T NEED TO SELL IN A HURRY.
12:47 WE'LL HAVE MUCH MORE RETAIL THAT WILL COME IN.
12:49 IT WILL BE DRIVEN BY WHAT THEY SEE IN TERMS OF THE SHORT-TERM
12:54 ACTION. NASDAQ FUTURES DOING WELL.
12:57 THE RELIEF THEY HAVE ACHIEVED THEIR TARGETS AS FAR AS
13:00 ANTHROPIC IS CONCERNED THAT WILL PROBABLY BRING IN SHORT-TERM
13:03 TRADERS. IT LOOKS AS IF WE'RE GOING TO
13:08 HAVE A POSITIVE FIRST DAY PROVIDED THERE IS NO SURPRISES
13:11 IN THE GEO-POLITICAL SENSE. IT WILL HELP TO BOOST THE MOOD
13:16 IN AMERICAN MARKETS AND FILTER THROW ASIA TOMORROW.
13:20 CONSIDERING HOW FLUID THE WHOLE SITUATION HAS BEEN OVER THE PAST
13:24 COUPLE OF WEEKS, IT WILL BE A MASSIVE LEAF TO FEBRUARY IS
13:26 ANTHROPIC STARTS WITH A BIT OF A PREMIUM TO WHERE THE IPO WAS
13:31 SOLD. STEPHEN: OK.
13:34 MEANWHILE IN MINUTES OF OCTOBER, THE FEDERAL RESERVE MEETING
13:37 ALMOST ALL AGREE MORE RATE HIKES WILL BE NEEDED IN THE MONTHS
13:39 AHEAD. HERE IS THE FED GOVERNOR
13:45 SPEAKING IN NEW YORK YESTERDAY. >> OVERTALL ECONOMY IS STRONG
13:47 WITH LOW UNEMPLOYMENT, SOLID CONSUMER SPENDING AND ROBUST
13:52 BUSINESS INVESTMENT. BUT INFLATION IS TOO HIGH.
13:55 MAKING IT HARD FOR AMERICAN FAMILIES TO MAKE ENDS MEET.
14:00 MANY FAMILIES ARE STRUGGLING AND THAT'S WHY IT IS SO IMPORTANT
14:03 FOR THE FED TO BRING INFLATION BACK TO OUR TARGET OF 2% IN A
14:08 TIMELY WAY. IF THE ECONOMY EVOLVES AS I
14:11 CURRENTLY FORECAST, I EXPECT IT WILL BE APPROPRIATE TO RAISE
14:15 RATES FURTHER TO ACHIEF THAT GOAL ON BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN
14:20 PEOPLE. STEPHEN: THE FED GOVERNOR
14:24 MICHAEL BARR SAYING IT IS APPROPRIATE TO RAISE RATES
14:25 FURTHER. DO THE MARKETS AGREE WITH
14:28 MICHAEL BARR? >> THEY DO FOR THE TIME BEING.
14:33 THEY ARE PRICING PRETTY CLEARLY. THEY EXPECT DECEMBER TO BE A 25
14:37 BASIS POINT INCREASE WHICH IS WHAT HAS BEEN TELEGRAPHED FOR
14:39 SOMETIME NOW. THE FED SPEAKERS HAVE BEEN
14:41 CONSISTENT. THE MINUTES SAY THE SAME THING
14:43 PRETTY MUCH. ALSO PRICING FOR A COUPLE OF
14:46 MORE HIKES NEXT YEAR AS WELL. BUT THIS IS A SITUATION THAT
14:52 COULD CHANGE QUITE QUICKLY. JUST TODAY WE SAW THE AUSTRALIAN
14:54 EMPLOYMENT REPORT. A SUDDEN DETERIORATION.
14:57 A VERY BAD REPORT FROM AUSTRALIA.
14:59 WHAT'S HAPPENED THERE IS THAT TRADERS HAVE GONE FROM -- IT
15:07 WASN'T TOO LONG AGO THEY WERE EXPECTED BA TO TIGHT AN LITTLE
15:10 BIT MORE. THEY HAVE GONE FOR A RATE CUT IN
15:13 THE MIDDLE OF NEXT YEAR. THEY MAY SEE THE RBA CAUSING A
15:18 POLICY ERROR. THEY WERE RAISING RATES WHEN
15:21 THEY WERE NOT EXPECTED TO. NOW THERE IS A CHANCE THEY HAVE
15:26 GONE TOO FAR AND HELD ON TOO LONG AND IT IS GOING TO HURT THE
15:27 ECONOMY. IN THE UNITED STATES THERE IS
15:30 TALK OF THE SAME THING HAPPENING.
15:32 THE FEDERAL RESERVE IS TOO LATE. THEY CONTINUED HIKING FOR TOO
15:36 LONG. WE WILL THEY WILL QUICKLY HAVE
15:39 TO FLIP FROM RAISING TO LOWERING INTEREST RATES.
15:42 HAS THE STORY FOR PROBABLY THE EARLY PART OF NEXT YEAR BUT
15:47 CLEARLY BECAUSE TRADERS SEE A RATE NIKE DECEMBER, THEY MAY
15:49 CHANGE THEIR MIND ON THE OUTLOOK FOR 2027 WHEN THEY SEE A FEW
15:54 MORE PIECES OF DATA IN THE TECHNIQUESFEW WEEKS.
15:55 STEPHEN: OK. MARK CRANFIELD.
15:58 THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR JOINING US.
16:01 COMING UP, WHY AI COULD SIGNIFICANTLY WORSEN ONE OF THE
16:05 TOUGH VULNERABILITIESES FACING THE CHINESE ECONOMY.
16:08 THAT'S NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
16:24 ♪ STEPHEN: WELCOME BACK TO
16:27 BLOOMBERG "DAYBREAK: EUROPE." SOME OF THE TOP STORIES
16:29 WE'RENOLOGY MORNING. OIL HAS STEADIED AS TRADERS
16:33 ASSESS THE RISK OF FRESH U.S. STRIKES ON IRAN.
16:36 THE "NEW YORKTIMES" REPORTS PRESIDENT TRUMP IS WEIGHING
16:40 FURTHER ATTACKS. HE IS YET TO DECIDE.
16:48 BRENT IS HOLDING AT $102. VENEZUELA'S LEADER SAYS THE U.S.
16:54 GOVERNMENT'S $100 BILLION OIL DEAL NEEDS SCRUTINY STRESSING
16:57 THAT A LONG-TERM PARTNERSHIP WITH WASHINGTON IS CRITICAL FOR
16:59 THE COUNTRY. SPEAKING IN HER FIRST
17:04 INTERNATIONAL INTERVIEW SINCE RETURNING TO VENEZUELA, SHE TOLE
17:07 US SHE HAD NOT READ THE AGREEMENT AND WOULD NOT JUDGE IT
17:12 ITS TERMS BUT EXPECTS THE TRANSACTION TO BE REVIEWED.
17:19 GERMANY AND AUSTRIA PROPOSED TIKTOK FIND A LOCAL OWNER.
17:24 THEY SUGGEST E.U. RULES ARE NOT ENOUGH TO ADDRESS RISKS LINKED
17:29 TO THE PLATFORM'S CHINESE OWNERSHIP.
17:33 TIKTOK SAYS IT HAS ZERO MERITS. THE ECB'S VICE PRESIDENT SAYS
17:40 THAT WHAT MARKETS ARE PRICING IF FOR CENTRAL BANK'S RATE PATH
17:43 DOES NOT SEEM TO BE UNRELIGION. HE POINTED TO WHAT HE EXPECTS
17:51 FOR THE ECB'S NEXT MEETING. >> I THINK THAT THE POINT OF
17:56 VIEW WE HAD TODAY, WHAT WE KNOW TODAY, I THINK THAT THE DECEMBER
18:00 HIKE LOOKS VERY LIKELY IF WE DON'T SEE ANY SURPRISES.
18:05 AND GOING FORWARD INTO NEXT YEAR OF COURSE, THERE ARE MANY MORE
18:11 DATA THAT WILL COME IN AND THAT WILL DETERMINE WHAT WE WILL DO
18:18 BUT FROM TODAY'S PERSPECTIVE, I SAID WHAT THE MARKETS ARE
18:22 PRICING DOES NOT SEEM TO BE UNREASONABLE, HOWEVER IT IS
18:25 QUITE A LONG TIME. WE MAKE THE DECISIONS ON A
18:29 MEETING BY MEETING BASIS WHICH IS REALLY HOW WE WORK AND WE
18:33 WILL GET MANY MORE DATA THAT WILL DETERMINE WHAT WE DO NEXT
18:35 YEAR. >> DO YOU THINK GIVEN IF
18:39 RESILIENCE OF THE AMERICAS, THE SURPRISING RESILIENCE THERE IS A
18:43 NEED TO GO RESTRICTIVE TO TURN INFLATION BACK TO 2%?
18:46 >> I THINK THE RESILIENCE THAT WE HAVE SEEN SO FAR IS VERY
18:49 GOOD. IT HAS SURPRISED EVERYONE.
18:55 THE OUTCOMES FOR -- WERE BETTER THAN WAS PROJECTED BY US OR THE
19:01 OTHER FORECASTERS. HOWEVER THERE IS ALWAYS A RISK.
19:05 WE STILL ARE LIVING IN AN ENVIRONMENT OF ELEVATED ENERGY
19:09 PRICES. THE HORMUZ PROBLEM HAS NOT BEEN
19:11 SOLVED. WE STILL HAVE ONGOING WAR IN
19:17 UKRAINE. WE STILL HAVE TRADE FRICTIONS.
19:23 WE STILL HAVE UNCERTAINTY AROUND TRADE POLICIES.
19:27 THESE ARE THINGS WHICH CAN ALTHOUGH THE ECONOMY PROVED
19:30 RESILIENT SO FAR STILL AFFECTS THE ECONOMIES THROUGH DISRUPTING
19:36 THE SUPPLY CHAINS AND HAVING THE NEGATIVITY IMPACT ON THE ECONOMY
19:41 FURTHER DOWN THE ROAD. STEPHEN: VICE PRESIDENT OF THE
19:45 ECB SPEAKING WITH BLOOMBERG. CHINA'S ANEMIC LABOR MARKET HAS
19:53 CONTRIBUTED TO WEAK CONSUMPTION. THE THEY RELY ON EXPORTS FOR
19:57 GROWTH. AI THREATENEDDENED TO WORSEN ONE
20:01 OF THE TOP VULNERABILITIES FACING THE WORLD'S SECOND
20:04 LARGEST ECONOMY AND DEMORALIZE A GENERATION OF YOUNGER WORKERS.
20:12 REBECCA, IT IS A FASCINATING PIECE OF REPORTING.
20:16 WHAT DOES IT TELL US ABOUT HOW AI IS AFFECTING THE CHINESE
20:19 LABOR MARKETS? >> WELL, IT IS A PRETTY
20:22 EXTRAORDINARY PIECE OF REPORTING.
20:25 SO MUCH TO HAVE DATA AROUND THE LABOR MARKET AND WIDER ECONOMIC
20:29 SITUATION IN CHINA HAS SORT OF BEEN HARDER AND HARDER TO COME
20:35 BY MORE OBSCURE OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS.
20:37 ESSENTIALLY ALONG WITH BLOOMBERG ECONOMICS, WE DUG INTO THIS VERY
20:42 LARGE PRIVATE ESSENTIALLY DATA SET LOOKING AT JOB POSTINGS AND
20:46 HOW THAT HAD CHANGED OVER THE FOUR-YEAR PERIOD THAT ENDED IN
20:49 2025. MORE THAN 10 MILLION JOB
20:52 POSTINGS THAT WE SAW. ESSENTIALLY EXPOSED A VERY
20:55 INTERESTING TREND ABOUT THE WAY IN WHICH JOBS ARE EXPOSED OR
21:00 HAVE BEEN EXPOSURE TO AI POSTING IN THOSE KINDS OF JOBS DID SEE
21:05 DRAMATIC DROPS IN SOME CASES, OVERALL ABOUT 10 PERCENTAGE
21:09 POINTS BUT CERTAIN INDUSTRIES DID SEE BIGGER DROPS IN POSTINGS
21:12 OVER THAT PERIOD. AND ESSENTIALLY IT PAINTS A
21:18 GLOOMY PICTURE ABOUT 70 MILLION OF CHINA'S POPULATION MAY END UP
21:25 BEING DISRUPTED IN SOME WAY BY AI.
21:26 AND REALLY SINCE I'VE BEEN REPORTING ON CHINA FOR MORE THAN
21:31 A DECADE NOW, WE HAVE SEEN YEAR AFTER YEAR A RECORD NUMBER OF
21:35 UNIVERSITY STUDENTS GRADUATING INTO THE MARKET.
21:37 WHEN WE COUPLE THIS TREND WHEN IT COMES TO AI AND JOB LOSS
21:42 ALONG WITH THIS IDEA OF THIS SORT OF INCREASING NUMBER OF
21:47 GADGET COMING AND PLUS THE FACT THAT WE SEE FEWER ENTRY LEVEL
21:53 TYPE OF JOBS IN THE JOB MARKET TOO, WE BEGIN TO UNDERSTAND WHY
21:56 IT BECOMES SUCH A DIFFICULT MARKET FOR YOUNG PEOPLE TO BE
22:00 GOING INTO. IT HELPS EXPLAIN SOME OF THE
22:02 TRENDS ALTHOUGH AI HAS ACCELERATED IN THE LAST YEAR OR
22:06 SO BUT EXPLAIN SOME OF THE BACKGROUND TRENDS THAT WE HAVE
22:09 SEEN AMONG YOUNG PEOPLE IN CHINA FOR SO MANY YEARS.
22:12 THINK ABOUT THE LYING FLAT TREND FOR EXAMPLE OR THE TREND WE HAVE
22:16 SEEN OF YOUNG PEOPLE GOING BACK TO THEIR HOMETOWNS OR GOING BACK
22:19 TO THEIR COUNTRYSIDES TO DO NONCORPORATE JOBS AT TRENDY
22:23 COFFEE SHOPS OR POTTERY STUDIOS AND SO ON.
22:29 IN A WAY IT GIVES IT U.S. SOME GRANULAR DATA THAT IS FORWARD
22:31 LOOKING OVER WHY WE ARE SEEING THESE SORT OF TRENDS EMERGING
22:36 AMONG YOUNG PEOPLE IN CHINA. STEPHEN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
22:40 BRINGING US DETAILS. A FASCINATING PIECE OF
22:43 REPORTING. COMING UP, COPPER STEADIES AFTER
22:50 TUMBLING ON AI CONCERNS AND U.S. TARIFFS AS TROMPED XI MEET IN
22:51 CHINA. WE'LL LOOK FOR THE OUTLOOK FOR
22:54 COMMODITIES NEXT. STAY WITH US.
22:58 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
23:28 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYS VLADIMIR PUTIN AND XI JINPING ARE HIS
23:37 FRIENDS AS HE MEETS BOTH LEADERS.
23:39 ANTHROPIC RAISES MORE THAN $107 BILLION IN THE BIGGEST IPO OF
23:42 ALL TIME, ECLIPSING THE RECORD SET BY SPACEX BACK IN JUNE.
23:47 NASDAQ FUTURES GAIN FOLLOWING A SUCCESSFUL DEBUT.
23:51 SIGNS THE AI TRADE IS STILL FRACTURED.
23:54 LET'S CHECK IN ON HOW MARKETS ARE MOVING THIS MORNING.
23:58 TAIWAN AUTHORITIES HAVE EXPANDED A SHORTSELLING BAND TO SUPPORT
24:02 THE STOCK MARKET. THE SELLOFF INTO TAIWANESE
24:09 STOCKS HAPPENING TODAY MORE BROADLY.
24:11 DOWN BY OVER 1%. A DIFFERENT PICTURE FOR FUTURES
24:14 FOR THE REST OF THE DAY. EUROPEAN STOCKS SET FOR A MORE
24:19 POSITIVE OPEN AFTER THE BIGGEST TEN-DAY SLIDE SINCE MARCH.
24:21 NASDAQ FUTURES UP OVER 1%. SELLOFF ON U.S. STOCKS.
24:27 IN TERMS OF OTHER ASSETS, OIL PRICES PRETTY STEADY.
24:32 REPORTS ABOUT POTENTIAL FOR MORE U.S. STRIKES ON IRAN.
24:37 THE EURO IS A TOUCH SOFTER. THE HAVEN BID TO TREASURIES
24:43 HOLDING ONTO THE RALLY THAT WE SAW YESTERDAY.
24:49 LET'S BRING IN MORE NOW ON PRESIDENT TRUMP'S MEETINGS WITH
24:54 XI JINPING AND VLADIMIR -- VLADIMIR PUTIN.
24:58 MINMIN LOW IS AT THE SUMMIT IN SHENZHEN FOR US.
25:02 WE SPOKE TO YOU A SHORT TIME AGO AS THE MEETING GOT UNDERWAY.
25:05 TALK TO US ABOUT WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT WHAT THE LEADER START --
25:09 ARE. >> TRUMP AND XI ARE SEQUESTERED
25:15 IN THAT MEETING RIGHT NOW. EARLIER, PRESIDENT TRUMP STARTED
25:21 THE MEETING SAYING THAT HE HAS A SPECIAL RELATIONSHIP WITH
25:25 PRESIDENT XI. HE SAID THE TWO MEN MAINTAIN A
25:28 FAIR AND BALANCED RELATIONSHIP. A WAY OF HOW THE TWO SIDES ARE
25:35 SPLITTING TARIFFS FAIRLY. HE SAID THAT HE WILL ASK CHINA
25:41 INSATIABLE APPETITE. THIS IS WHERE THE PREVIOUS
25:50 AGREEMENT HASN'T BEEN FULFILLED YET BY CHINA.
25:54 CHINA SAYING THAT IT HINGES UPON THE BOARD OF TRADE BEING
25:56 IMPLEMENTED AND THE TIMELINE OF THAT IS STILL AN UNKNOWN.
26:00 PRESIDENT TRUMP MENTIONED IRAN, SAYING BOTH MEN WANT TO SEE OIL
26:05 FLOWING FREELY THROUGH THE STRAIT OF HORMUZ.
26:08 THEY DON'T WANT TO SEE IRAN HAVING ANY NUCLEAR PROGRAMS.
26:11 THIS IS SOMETHING THAT CHINA CAN AGREE TO.
26:14 HOW THEY GET TO THAT POINT IS A BIG QUESTION.
26:19 NOTABLY ABSENT WAS ANY MENTION OF THOSE TECH CURBS.
26:24 REMEMBER, TRUMP AND XI ALREADY HAD PLENTY OF OPPORTUNITIES TO
26:25 TALK LAST NIGHT. A FOX TO INTERVIEW SAID HE
26:31 MIGHT'VE MENTIONED JENSEN HUANG BRIEFLY BECAUSE IT WAS SUCH A
26:35 TRAGEDY. IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE THEY SPOKE
26:37 ABOUT THAT AT LENGTH. HE SAID THAT HE EXPECTS
26:42 BLACKWELL CHIPS COULD AT SOME POINT BE SOLD TO CHINA WHEN NEW
26:46 TECHNOLOGY SUPERSEDES IT. IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE A CHANGE
26:48 TO THE EXISTING EXPORT CONTROL POLICY BUT IT DOES SUGGEST THAT
26:54 THERE IS NO NEED TO KEEP THOSE CURBS ON AS LONG AS THEY NO
26:57 LONGER THE FRONTIER TECHNOLOGY. CHINA HAS ALREADY ISSUED VERY
27:04 STRONG STATEMENTS ABOUT THE LATEST DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
27:07 INTERIM ROLES, SAYING THAT THEY WOULD TAKE NECESSARY ACTIONS TO
27:08 PROTECT THEIR RIGHTS AND INTERESTS.
27:11 WE WILL HAVE TO SEE IF IT DERAILS THE EXISTING TRADE
27:13 TRUTHS. STEPHEN: BLOOMBERG'S MINMIN LOW.
27:19 THANK YOU. JOIN BLOOMBERG REPORTERS FOR A
27:25 LIVE DISCUSSION OF WHAT THAT TRILATERAL MEETING WITH
27:30 PRESIDENTS TRUMP, XI, AND PRUDENT MEANS.
27:39 TRADE ISSUES CENTRAL TO WHAT WE'VE BEEN SEEING IN MOVEMENTS
27:41 OF THE PRICE OF COPPER. STEADYING AFTER PLUNGING BY
27:47 ALMOST 6% YESTERDAY, THE BIGGEST DROP IN OVER 18 MONTHS.
27:50 TRADERS UNWINDING BETS ON THE METAL TIED TO AI BUT ALSO
27:53 WATCHING CLOSELY WHAT MAY COME OUT OF THE SUMMIT IN CHINA.
27:58 LET'S DISCUSS NOW WITH THE GROUP MANAGING DIRECTOR.
28:04 GREAT TO HAVE YOU ON THE PROGRAM THIS MORNING.
28:07 IN TERMS OF THE PRICE MOVEMENT, HOW ARE YOU READING WHAT'S
28:11 DRIVING THE DROP THAT WE'VE SEEN OVER THE PAST COUPLE DAYS IN
28:13 COPPER PRICES? >> I THINK THE DROP IS TIED INTO
28:21 BIG MACRO THEMES THAT ARE GOING ON ACROSS THE WORLD.
28:26 THE FALLOUT FROM AI. THERE'S NO DOUBT THAT A BUNCH OF
28:30 THE METALS WERE VERY LINKED TO TRADE THAT WAS SUPPORTIVE OF THE
28:35 IDEA OF DATA CENTER ROLLOUT. WHEN THE TRADE STARTS TO
28:39 UNRAVEL, YOU SEE KNOCK ON EFFECTS IN THE METALS THAT TIE
28:46 INTO THE SAME THEME. YOU DON'T WANT TO LOOK AT THE
28:51 FALLS OVER THE PAST MONTH OR SO OR WEEKS OR SO IN ISOLATION.
28:54 YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT THEM IN THE CONTEXT OF HOW FAR A NUMBER OF
29:00 THESE METALS HAD RUN OUT IN THE LAST 6, 12 MONTHS EVEN PRIOR TO
29:03 THAT. STEPHEN: WE ARE WATCHING THE
29:08 EVENTS HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN. IT HAS JUST ENDED.
29:16 BUT I WONDER WHEN IT COMES TO THE ISSUES AROUND TARIFFS, HOW
29:19 MUCH YOU SEE PERHAPS THE POSSIBILITY OF EASING OF THOSE
29:25 PARTICULAR CONCERNS FOR THE METALS MARKET WHICH HAS BEEN
29:27 PART OF THE ISSUE WEIGHING ON PRICES AS WELL.
29:33 DAVID: YEAH. MY PERSONAL OPINION IS SOME FOR
29:36 -- SOME FORM OF TRADE FRICTION IS NOW A FEATURE OF THE MARKET
29:39 AND IT'S HERE TO STAY FOR VERY LONG TIME.
29:42 ONCE AGAIN, IT TIES INTO THIS BATTLE FOR ALMOST COOPERATION
29:49 BETWEEN U.S. AND CHINA. SOME FORM OF TRADE FRICTION IS
29:54 THE LOWEST FORM OF ECONOMIC WARFARE THEY CAN ENGAGE IN.
29:59 I THINK IT WILL BE A FEATURE OF THE MARKET FOR A LONG TIME.
30:03 I THINK YOU COULD SEE MOMENTS WHERE IT ROLLS BACK OR REVOLVES.
30:11 BUT EACH SIDE HAS THEIR CONCENTRATION, THEIR POWER.
30:17 WHETHER IT'S FOR THE U.S. RESTRICTING THE EXPORTS OF
30:20 CHIPS, ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY. WHETHER IT IS RESTRICTING THE
30:24 EXPORT OF CRITICAL NUMERALS IN WHICH THEY HAVE VERY
30:30 MONOPOLISTIC POSITIONS. I THINK THAT WILL BE A FEATURE
30:32 OF THE MARKET FOR SOME TIME TO COME.
30:37 ECONOMY. DO YOU SEE SCOPE FOR THE CHINESE
30:42 ECONOMY TO GENUINELY RE-ACCELERATE FROM HERE OR ARE
30:45 -- ARE WE LOOKING AT A SITUATION GROUP -- WHERE GROWTH WILL BE
30:49 LOWER IN CHINA? DAVID: THOSE ARE TWO DIFFERENT
30:52 QUESTIONS. THE FIRST IS, WHAT WILL GROWTH
30:55 BE IN CHINA? AND THE SECOND IS, IF GROWTH
31:04 FALLS OFTEN CHINA, WILL IT CHANGE THEIR TRADE POLICY?
31:08 ARGUABLY I FIND THE SECOND EASIER TO ANSWER THAN THE FIRST.
31:11 I DON'T THINK IT WILL CHANGE THEIR TRADE POLICY.
31:16 I DON'T THINK XI JINPING WILL ALTER THEIR TRADE POLICY AND
31:20 THEIR APPROACH TO SOFT POWER. JUST BECAUSE OR EVEN IF ECONOMIC
31:27 GROWTH FALLS OFF. WHETHER ECONOMIC GROWTH WILL
31:31 FALL OFF, CHINA IS CLEARLY IN A DIFFICULT PLACE COMPARED TO
31:36 WHERE IT'S BEEN FOR THE LAST 20 YEARS OR SO.
31:40 THAT'S GOING TO AFFECT THE RATE OF GROWTH.
31:46 NONETHELESS, CHINA HAS A VERY STRONG, A NUMBER OF VERY STRONG
31:54 ELEMENTS TO ITS INDUSTRIAL BASE AND CONTINUES TO BE A VERY
31:57 POWERFUL EXPORTER IN LOTS OF AREAS TO THE REST OF THE WORLD.
32:02 STEPHEN: ONE OF THE OTHER KEY FACTORS DRIVING METAL PRICES
32:06 HIGHER HAS BEEN DEMAND LINKED TO AI.
32:06 QUITE A SELLOFF IN EQUITIES OVER THE PAST NUMBER OF WEEKS.
32:13 I WONDER, DO YOU SEE THAT AS BEING A MEANINGFUL SHIFT IN
32:15 DEMAND FOR THOSE SORT OF METALS THAT ARE KEY TO THE AI SUPPLY
32:16 CHAIN? DAVID: YEAH.
32:21 I DON'T. I THINK DEMAND WILL BE
32:24 STRUCTURALLY HIGHER. I THINK WHAT THE MARKET IS DOING
32:27 IS WHAT THE MARKET DOES. TRYING TO FIND THE PRICE
32:31 FORMATION OF HOW TO PRICE DEMAND VERSUS SUPPLY.
32:34 I DON'T THINK WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN THE PRICE COMING OFF IS ANY
32:40 STATEMENT THAT DEMAND IS NOT GOING TO BE STRUCTURALLY HIGHER
32:43 FOR ALL OF THESE MATERIALS THAT FEED INTO ELECTRIFICATION OF THE
32:46 PLANET. I THINK IT'S GOING TO WEIGH
32:52 EXACTLY HOW TO VALUE THAT AGAINST ALL THE OTHER
32:53 OPPORTUNITIES. THERE'S DEFINITELY BEEN MORE
33:03 TALK OF INVESTING IN SUPPLY IN THE REST OF THE WORLD OVER THE
33:07 PAST SIX MONTHS THAN I'VE SEEN OVER THE PAST DECADE.
33:16 STEPHEN: WHAT ARE YOU MAKE OF EFFORTS IN EUROPE TO DIVERSIFY
33:18 SUPPLY CHAINS? WILL THEY BE ABLE TO DO THAT,
33:23 GIVEN THE TRADE POWERS, THE TENSIONS BETWEEN THE U.S. AND
33:25 CHINA AND THEIR EFFORTS IN THIS AREA?
33:28 DAVID: I THINK IT'S THE RIGHT SOLUTION.
33:31 FROM A POLICY PERSPECTIVE. I THINK THE GOVERNMENTS ACROSS
33:36 THE WEST KNOW IT'S THE RIGHT SOLUTION.
33:39 WILL THEY DO IT? IT'S A HARDER QUESTION.
33:45 BECAUSE IT PROBABLY DOES NEED SOME FORM OF STATE INTERVENTION.
33:52 AND I SEE MY WORLD OF METALS, MATERIALS, SECURITY SUPPLY
33:55 CHAINS, AND THINK IT'S VERY IMPORTANT THAT GOVERNMENTS ARE
33:59 ALSO LOOKING AT MANY OTHER THINGS AND NOT RUNNING WITH HUGE
34:03 FISCAL WIGGLE ROOM. WHICH ULTIMATELY GOES TO HOW
34:08 EFFECTIVE THEY WILL BE. I THINK WE'VE SEEN THE U.S.
34:11 ACTUALLY MAKE SOME VERY REAL STRIDES IN THIS AREA,
34:15 UNDERPINNING THE INVESTMENT IN ANOTHER OF PRAGUE -- A NUMBER OF
34:20 PROJECTS WITH UNUSUAL LEVELS OF STATE INTERVENTION.
34:22 WHETHER THAT WAS FOUND SUPPORTING STOCKPILES OR PUTTING
34:29 IN PRICE FLOORS FOR VARIOUS PROJECTS.
34:31 WE HAVEN'T SEEN THAT ACROSS ANY OTHER COUNTRY REALLY
34:35 MEANINGFULLY AT -- YET. THE QUESTION IS ALWAYS IN THE EU
34:40 AND THE U.K., THEY WILL SAY MANY OF THE RIGHT THINGS AND THEY
34:42 WILL KNOW MANY OF THE RIGHT THINGS TO DO BUT IT'S OFTEN HARD
34:45 TO ACTUALLY DO. SO I THINK THE ANSWER TO YOUR
34:52 QUESTION IS, THEY WILL DO IT, THEY WILL DIVERSIFY AT LEAST A
34:55 LITTLE BIT. WILL THEY DO IT AS EFFECTIVELY
35:08 AND TO THE EXTENT REQUIRED TO REALLY IMPROVE THE SECURITY OF
35:09 SUPPLY SITUATION IN THE LAST? THE JURY IS VERY MUCH OUT ON
35:13 THAT. STEPHEN: MANAGING DIRECTOR OF
35:17 THE AMC GROUP. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US ON THE
35:20 PROGRAM THIS MORNING. HE'S MY FRIEND.
35:25 PRESIDENT TRUMP -- TRUMP TALKS WARMLY OF VLADIMIR PUTIN,
35:29 RAISING FEARS OF WHAT IT COULD MEAN FOR THE UKRAINE WAR.
35:42 ♪ STEPHEN: WELCOME BACK TO
35:52 BLOOMBERG DAYBREAK ERA. PRESIDENT TRUMP DESCRIBED THE
35:59 RUSSIAN LEADER VLADIMIR PUTIN AS, MY FRIEND.
36:01 THE COMMENTS CAME DURING THEIR FIRST IN-PERSON MEETING AND MORE
36:03 THAN A YEAR. FOR MORE, IT'S BRING IN OUR TEAM
36:07 COVERING RUSSIA'S ECONOMY AND GOVERNMENT.
36:10 HOW SIGNIFICANT WAS THIS BILATERAL MEETING FOR PRESIDENT
36:12 PUTIN? >> THEY SPOKE FOR 40 MINUTES.
36:22 TALKS. THE KREMLIN BRIEFED AFTER THE
36:26 MEETING THAT THEY DISCUSSED UKRAINE AND PUTIN LEFT THE
36:29 MEETING AND AN EXCELLENT MOOD. I'M NOT SURE THAT'S GOING TO
36:34 EASE NERVES IN EUROPE AND KYIV ABOUT THE DISCUSSIONS THAT TOOK
36:36 PLACE. WE WILL FIND OUT LATER HOPEFULLY
36:38 WHAT THE SUBSTANCE OF THOSE TALKS WERE.
36:42 AT THE MOMENT, EVERYONE IS SAYING THAT THEY ARE LOOKING
36:43 FORWARD TO THE TRILATERAL MEETING THAT WAS ALSO PART OF
36:47 THE FOCUS OF TRUMP AND PRUDENCE DISCUSSIONS -- PUTIN'S
36:52 DISCUSSIONS. STEPHEN: IT APPEARS THAT UKRAINE
36:57 IS NOW ON THE AGENDA FOR THAT TRILATERAL MEETING.
37:00 IS THAT GOING TO MAKE PEOPLE MORE NERVOUS IN EUROPE WHO ARE
37:03 WATCHING THE OUTCOME OF THIS? ANTHONY: IN EUROPE TODAY, THEY
37:11 ARE EXPECTING A BRIEFING OF SOME SORT ABOUT WHAT DISCUSSIONS HAVE
37:15 BEEN TAKEN PLACE IN CHINA TO TRY TO RESOLVE THE WAR IN UKRAINE.
37:18 THERE'S A GROUP OF EUROPEANS MEETING TOGETHER TODAY WITH
37:22 UKRAINE AND THEY ARE EXPECTING BRIEFINGS FROM THE U.S. ENVOY
37:28 STEVE WITKOFF AND JARED KUSHNER ABOUT WHAT TRUMP DISCUSSED WITH
37:30 PUTIN AND WHAT THE LEADERS THEMSELVES DISCUSSED.
37:35 TRUMP SAID HE WOULDN'T DO A DEAL WITHOUT UKRAINE AT THE TABLE.
37:40 I THINK THE AUTHORITIES IN KYIV HAVE DEMONSTRATED THAT THEY ARE
37:41 CAPABLE OF STANDING UP FOR THEMSELVES OVER THE LAST 20
37:46 MONTHS OR SO. THEY REALLY THINK THAT NOTHING
37:50 WILL BE DONE WITHOUT THEM. IN THE END OF THE DAY, THEY HAVE
37:53 TO SAY YES AND THEY ARE NOT WILLING TO SAY YES TO THINGS
37:56 THAT THEY CONSIDER TO BE UNACCEPTABLE FOR UKRAINE.
38:00 STEPHEN: THAT MEETING HAPPENING. GERMANY HOSTING THE FRENCH AND
38:02 U.K. LEADERS. WE'VE HAD THE EU TALKING ABOUT
38:06 FRONTING UP SOME OF UKRAINE'S FUNDING NEEDS FOR NEXT YEAR.
38:11 BUT IS THE COALITION STILL IS RELEVANT NOW, GIVEN THAT THOSE
38:16 CONVERSATIONS ARE HAPPENING SO FAR AWAY?
38:20 ANTHONY: YES. PEOPLE SAY IT'S LESS THE
38:25 COALITION OF THE WILLING AND MORE THE COALITION OF THE
38:28 RELUCTANT BECAUSE IT'S ALL ABOUT WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THE WAR ENDS
38:30 RATHER THAN WHAT EUROPE CAN DO TO BRING THE WORD WHEN END.
38:34 THEY ARE VERY CONCERNED ABOUT THE FACT THAT DISCUSSIONS ARE
38:37 TAKING PLACE A LONG WAY AWAY FROM EUROPE WITHOUT A EUROPEAN
38:40 PRESENCE. THAT HAS UNDERLINED THEIR SENSE
38:43 OF IMPOTENCE IN MANY WAYS. THESE DISCUSSIONS HAVE BEEN
38:47 U.S. EUROPEANS HAVEN'T HAD A PLACE AT
38:53 THE TABLE. THEY ARE TRYING TO MAKE
38:56 THEMSELVES RELEVANT FOR A POSTWAR UKRAINE SETTLEMENT.
38:59 THERE A BITAL -- ABILITY IS STILL IN QUESTION.
39:05 STEPHEN: OK. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
39:09 CORPORATE NEWS THIS MORNING. BLOOMBERG UNDERSTANDS THAT THE
39:10 RECRUITMENT COMPANY HELPING TO HIRE A NEW CEO FOR NVIDIA HAS
39:16 APPROACHED THE ARM CEO. HE IS SEEN AS A LEADING
39:20 CONTENDER TO 60 JENSEN HUANG HAVING WORKED AT THE COMPANY FOR
39:23 SEVEN YEARS AS GENERAL MANAGER OF COMPUTING PRODUCTS.
39:26 A REPRESENTATIVE DECLINED TO COMMENT.
39:30 NVIDIA HAS NOT RESPONDED TO A REQUEST FOR COMMENT.
39:35 SHARES OF TAKE-TWO INTERACTIVE CLOSE HIGHER IN THE UNITED
39:38 STATES AS GRAND THEFT AUTO VI RECEIVED NEAR-PERFECT SCORES
39:40 ACROSS THE BOARD. ACCORDING TO REVIEW AGGREGATION
39:44 WEBSITES, THAT MAKES IT THE BEST REVIEWED GAME OF ALL TIME.
39:49 PLAYERS HAVE BEEN WAITING MORE THAN A DECADE FOR THE TITLE FROM
39:52 ROCKSTAR GAMES. THE GAME WAS RELEASED AT
39:57 THROUGH TODAY. THE CITIGROUP CEO SAYS TECH
40:04 OUTAGES MAY BECOME MORE ROUTINE AS COMPANIES RAISE TO PATCH
40:06 THEIR SYSTEMS AND TIGHTEN SECURITY.
40:11 SHE GAVE US HER TAKE ON AI AND WHY SHE IS NOT CONCERNED ABOUT
40:13 DOOMSDAY SCENARIOS. >> THE GENIE IS OUT OF THE
40:19 BOTTLE M -- ON AI. WHEN WE THINK ABOUT THE AMOUNT
40:26 OF COMPUTE THAT IS IN DEMAND, I'M NOT JUST SEEING IT IN
40:32 AMERICA. I WAS IN TURKEY THE OTHER DAY.
40:34 THEY ARE BUILDING THEIR FIRST DATA CENTER BECAUSE THEY ARE
40:37 WORRIED IF THEY DON'T, THEY WON'T BE ABLE TO COMPETE.
40:41 IN INDUSTRY AFTER INDUSTRY. SO THIS IS A GLOBAL PHENOMENON.
40:46 AT THE MOMENT, CERTAINLY CENTERED IN THE STATES.
40:51 BUT I WOULDN'T BE SO CONCERNED WITH ALL OF THE DOOMSDAY
40:54 PREDICTIONS ON AI AND THE REST OF IT.
40:57 I THINK WE ARE IN REASONABLE SHAPE.
41:01 >> IN YOUR THIRD QUARTER EARNINGS, CITIGROUP DID SAY THAT
41:06 AI FINANCING RISK WAS A KEY RISK FOR UNCERTAINTY AND IT WAS THE
41:08 FIRST TIME THAT IT APPEARED. WHAT WERE YOU REFERRING TO IN
41:11 PARTICULAR THERE? >> AS I SAY, IT'S THE LARGEST
41:16 BUILDOUT THAT WE'VE SEEN IN MODERN HISTORY IN A VERY
41:19 CAPITAL-INTENSIVE WAY. AND THERE'S A LOT OF PROMISE AND
41:23 OPPORTUNITY THERE. WE ARE AT THE PICKS AND SHOVELS
41:29 PHASE. IT'S A BIG BUILDOUT.
41:33 ENERGY, CHIPS, DATA CENTERS. THE FRONTIER MODELS.
41:37 THERE'S A LOT GOING TO THIS ONE. NOT EVERYONE WILL BE A WINNER.
41:40 THERE'S ALWAYS WINNERS AND LOSERS IN THESE THINGS.
41:44 JUST GIVEN THE AMOUNT OF MONEY INVOLVED AND THE OTHER PIECES,
41:49 YOU WOULD HOPE THAT ONE OF THE NATION'S LARGEST BANKS WAS
41:52 FOCUSED ON MAKING SURE THAT WE MANAGE THE RISK RESPONSIBLY.
41:55 WE ARE IN THE BUSINESS OF TAKING RISK AND THEREFORE OBVIOUSLY WE
41:59 KEEP AN EYE ON THESE THINGS. >> A LOT OF PEOPLE POINT TO THE
42:04 UNITED STATES AS BEING THE EPICENTER OF BOTH THE RISK AND
42:10 REWARD TIED TO AI. >> THEY ARE JEALOUS.
42:18 >> EXPLAIN. IT CONCENTRATES RISK ABOUT ONE
42:21 TECHNOLOGY HAVING GAINS. >> THIS IS ONE OF BIG -- WHEN I
42:28 BECOME ONE OF THOSE ZEALOTS AMERICANS.
42:29 I CAME TO THIS COUNTRY AS AN IMMIGRANT MANY YEARS AGO NOW.
42:34 LOOK, WHAT'S THE MAGIC THAT THE U.S. HAS?
42:40 IT IS OUR ABILITY, THE INNOVATION THAT THIS COUNTRY CAN
42:45 DO IT SCALE -- AT SCALE MATCHED WITH THE CAPITAL MARKET.
42:47 THE U.S. HAS 4% OF THE WORLDS POPULATION AND OVER 50% OF THE
42:52 MARKET CAPITALIZATION OF THE WORLD.
42:56 THINK ABOUT INDUSTRY AFTER INDUSTRY.
43:00 NOT ONLY CAN WE INNOVATE BUT WE CAN DO SO AT SCALE.
43:10 STEPHEN: ON THE QUESTION OF AI OPTIMISM, WE ARE WATCHING SHARES
43:14 GAINING AS MUCH AS 11% ON TRADE GATE VERSUS THE CLOSE IN PARIS
43:17 YESTERDAY. THAT WAS AFTER THEY UPGRADED
43:22 THEIR GUIDANCE FOR SALES. NOW SEEING 40% GROWTH IN FULL
43:25 YEAR SALES THIS YEAR. SO THAT'S THE UPDATE WE GOT
43:28 AFTER THE CLOSE YESTERDAY. SHARES POINTING HIGHER ON TRADE
43:30 DAY THIS MORNING. PLENTY MORE COMING UP FOR YOU.
43:32 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
43:54 >> PEOPLE KEEP ANNOYING ME BY SAYING, INTEREST RATES ARE GOING
43:57 TO BE HIGHER FOR LONGER. THEY WON'T BE HIGHER FOR LONGER.
44:00 THEY WILL BE NORMAL FOR LONGER. HIGHER FOR LONGER IMPLIES THAT
44:02 WE SHOULD BE GOING BACK SOMEWHERE.
44:05 GOING BACK TO THE GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS, THAT WAS THE
44:09 ABNORMALITY, NOT WHERE RATES ARE NOW.
44:19 STEPHEN: THINKING ABOUT THE OUTLOOK FOR RATES AS WELL.
44:23 AS WE HAVE SEEN THE PRICE OF REFINED FUELS COME DOWN IN THE
44:29 PRICES. THOSE FRONT END RATES HAVE STILL
44:34 REMAINED PRETTY HIGH. A BIT OF A RALLY YESTERDAY AS
44:38 WELL, CAUGHT BY THE RALLY THAT WE SAW MORE AT THE LONG END AS
44:41 WE HAD THOSE HAWKISH FED MEETING MINUTES.
44:43 OF COURSE, THIS SELLOFF IN EQUITIES DRIVING SOME OF THE
44:46 HAVEN TRADE AS WELL. WE HAVE REFINED FUEL PRICES
44:49 COMING DOWN AS WE GET A BIT MORE SUPPLY OUT OF THE GULF.
44:54 CRUDE OIL PRICES HAVE COME DOWN ALONGSIDE THAT AS WELL.
44:57 ANOTHER COMMODITY WE'VE BEEN WATCHING WAS WHAT'S BEEN
44:58 HAPPENING WITH GOLD. A DROP OF ALMOST 4% THIS MONTH.
45:04 THIRD CONSECUTIVE DAY OF DECLINES.
45:08 YESTERDAY, THE FED RATE OUTLOOK VERY MUCH IN FOCUS AS WELL.
45:11 THINK ABOUT THE MOVEMENTS WE'VE HAD IN TERMS OF GOLD PRICES.
45:15 COMING DOWN SIGNIFICANTLY FROM THAT.
45:18 DOWNWARD MOMENTUM CONTINUING TODAY AS WE THINK ABOUT THE PATH
45:23 FOR HIGHER INTEREST RATES AHEAD AS WELL.
45:27 LOOKING AHEAD TO THE BIGGEST MARKET EVENT OF TODAY, THE
45:29 ANTHROPIC IPO. FUTURES POINTING INTO THIS AS
45:34 WELL AS WE THINK ABOUT HOW THINGS WILL TRADE WHEN THEY
45:38 WE'VE HAD SO FAR. TODAY, NUMBERS OUT OF ALIBABA
45:45 THIS MORNING AND WALMART AS WELL.
45:46 THE ANTHROPIC IPO AS I MENTIONED.
45:52 U.S. JOBLESS CLAIMS LATER ON AS WELL.
45:57 BREXIT NEGOTIATOR JOINS THE OPENING TRADE.
46:00 THE OPENING TRADE IS UP FOR YOU NEXT.
46:02 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
Trump Calls Xi a 'Friend' as Leaders Hold Talks in China full transcript
0:00 President Trump started the meeting saying that he has a special relationship with president Xi. He touted
0:05 the ability of the two men to maintain a fair and balanced relationship, citing that $3,430,000,000,000
0:11 dollar tariff free agreement under the board of trade as a way of how the two
0:15 sides are splitting tariffs fairly. He also said that he will ask China to do more
0:20 for American fire... Farmers saying that China has an insatiable appetite. And here is where the
0:25 previous agreement according to The US for China to buy 7,000,000,000 worth of non US farm
0:30 goods, that hasn't been, fulfilled yet by China. China is saying that it hinges upon the
0:35 bond of trade being implemented, and a timeline of that is still an unknown for now.
0:40 President Trump also mentioned Iran saying that both men, president Xi and Trump, want to see
0:45 oil flowing freely through this... Through the Strait Of Hormuz, that they don't want to see
0:49 Iran having any nuclear programs. This is, of course, something that China can't agree to, but
0:53 how they would get to that point is a big question. But no... Notably absent in
0:58 president Trump's opening remarks was any mention of those tech cubs. Right? And remember, Trump and
1:04 Xi already had plenty of opportunities to talk last night at the APAC dinner, and president
1:08 Trump at the Fox News interview had said he might have mentioned Jensen Huang briefly because
1:15 it was such a tragedy. It doesn't seem like they spoke about the... Spoke about that
1:19 at length. He also said that he expects that black well chips could at some point
1:24 be sold to China when new technology supersedes it. This doesn't sound like a change to
1:29 the existing export control policy, but it does suggest that, there is no need to, keep
1:35 those cups on as as long as they no longer, the frontier technology. But, of course,
1:41 China has already issued very strong statements about the latest Department of Commerce interim rule saying
1:47 they would take necessary actions if needed to protect their rights and interests. Certainly, we'll have
1:51 to see if it derails the existing trade truths and the flow of critical minerals into
1:56 The US.
Xi Hosts Trump at APEC Summit in Shenzhen full transcript
0:00 YVONNE: 9:00 A.M. HERE IN HONG KONG.
0:01 YOU ARE WATCHING "THE CHINA SHOW ."
0:05 DAVID: WE ARE COUNTING DOWN TO THE OPENING OF THE MARKETS.
0:10 ANTHROPIC PRICING SHARES $83 A POP ABOVE THE MARKET RANGE,
0:16 VALUING THE COMPANY AT ONE POINT $5 TRILLION.
0:19 THE STOCK WILL TRADE THURSDAY FOLLOWING ITS WORLD'S BIGGEST
0:20 IPO. YVONNE: NASDAQ FUTURES RISE
0:25 AHEAD OF ANTHROPIC'S DEBUT COME SEEN AS THE NEXT TEST FOR THE AI
0:26 TRADE. DAVID: AND MORE PRESSURE FOR
0:34 CHINA'S BIG TECH SECTOR AFTER TENCENT PROFIT DECLINES FOR THE
0:37 FIRST TIME IN YEARS. THAT IS ON HIGHER AI SPENDING.
0:44 STEPHEN: AND JUST A FEW HOURS FROM NOW WE WILL GET THAT BIG
0:48 TRILATERAL MEETING BETWEEN VLADIMIR PUTIN, XI JINPING, AND
0:53 DONALD TRUMP VERY IT IS UNPRECEDENTED.
0:55 COULD IT BE A LANDMARK TRILATERAL HERE AT THE APEC
0:59 SUMMIT? YVONNE: IT WAS THE HUG THAT WAS
1:15 SEEN AROUND THE WORLD. PRESIDENT XI GRADING PRESIDENT
1:21 TRUMP ON THE TARMAC. THAT SETS THE STAGE TODAY WITH
1:25 THE FIRST BILATERAL BETWEEN THE TWO PRESIDENTS.
1:27 AND THEN THE UNPRECEDENTED MEETING BETWEEN PUTIN, XI, AND
1:35 TRUMP. BEFORE THAT WE HAVE THE
1:36 ANTHROPIC IPO. DAVID: WE HAVE THE PRICE AND THE
1:39 SIZE. $1.5 TRILLION VALUATION, THE
1:46 WORLD'S BIGGEST CASH CALL THE PUBLIC PORTION.
1:50 THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT, A BUNCH OF STUFF WENT THROUGH THE ACTUAL
1:53 COMPANY AND SOME OF THE FOUNDER SOLD THEIR SHARES.
1:57 IN TOTALITY COME CLOSE TO A BILLION SHARES WERE SOLD AT THAT
1:58 PRICE. LET'S CALL IT A COOL 100
2:04 BILLION. IF YOU UPSIZE THAT, ABOUT 108
2:08 BILLION. NOT CHUMP CHANGE.
2:16 IRONICALLY THE TICKER IS ANT, BUT FAR FROM IT.
2:18 THIS IS SOMETHING WE WILL SEE WITH KEEN INTEREST THURSDAY.
2:22 YVONNE: THIS IS THE FIRST SORT OF PURE PLAY ON AI AND THE U.S.
2:27 THERE WILL BE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW BULLISH THE MARKET
2:29 REALLY IS WHEN IT COMES TO THESE AI NAMES, ESPECIALLY ANTHROPIC
2:36 BEING THE POSTER CHILD FOR AI INNOVATION, ADOPTION,
2:37 MONETIZATION AND THE LIKE. THERE IS THE NEXT LEG AS WE
2:44 COUNT DOWN ANTHROPIC TO EVE ON THE IPO.
2:46 MASTEC FUTURES ON THE BACK OF THAT ARE UP SUBSTANTIALLY COME
2:50 UP 1% OR MORE -- NASDAQ FUTURES. THE KOSPI, BECAUSE THERE WERE
2:56 EXAMS, THEY DID DELAY THE OPENING.
2:58 WE ARE SEEING ONLY MODEST UPSIDE.
2:59 TAIWAN STARTED THINGS OFF IN THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION.
3:04 DAVID: IT DOES NOT LOOK VERY CONVINCING THE GAINS IN THE
3:07 ASIA-PACIFIC. I THINK GIVEN THE PRICE ACTION
3:13 CURRENTLY, A SIXTH DAY OF DECLINES IN THE REGION.
3:18 WE ARE NEARING A DEATH CROSS IN TERMS OF THE CROSSING AND MOVING
3:19 AVERAGES. LATELY AND SOMEWHAT BURIED
3:24 BECAUSE OF THE GEOPOLITICAL HEADLINES AS THE STRONGER DOLLAR
3:27 EMERGING. THE FED MINUTES SIGNALING THE
3:30 HAWKISH TONE COMING THROUGH ON THE BACK OF THAT.
3:34 COPPER WAS THE POSTER CHILD OF METAL PRICES.
3:37 THE STRONGER DOLLAR ALSO EXPLAINING WHY YOU HAVE THIS
3:40 VACUUM APPETITE. YVONNE: COPPER IS ABOUT 10%, 15%
3:47 OF THE PEAKS OF THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS.
3:49 GIVEN HOW THE WHOLE AI BUILDOUT IS FUELING GROWTH AT THE MOMENT,
3:53 I THINK WHAT WAS SEEN WITH NVIDIA AND THE VOLATILITY AROUND
3:55 THAT STOCK HAS IN SOME WAYS DRIVEN THIS WHOLE COPPER TRADE.
4:00 DAVID: IT CLOSED AGAIN, ALMOST CLOSING BELOW 150, UNDERSCORING
4:05 THE CHANGING OF THE GUARD. IT IS NOW ANTHROPIC THAT IS
4:08 LIKELY THE NAME TO WATCH IN THE AI STORY.
4:11 BECAUSE OF THE AI BUILDOUT, THAT GETS US INTO TENCENT AND LIKELY
4:13 GETS US TO THE SAME STORY WITH ALIBABA WHEN THEY REPORT.
4:20 A LOT OF INVESTMENT THAT IS GOING IN.
4:21 I THINK MANAGEMENT HAS ACKNOWLEDGED AND SHARES LIKELY
4:27 WILL TRADE SOFTLY TODAY. THEY HAVE A GOOD KNOWLEDGE
4:30 HIGHER THAN USUAL COSTS AS THEY INVEST IN THE BUILDOUT.
4:32 WE WILL SEE WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE GOING TO THE OPEN.
4:37 THE DOLLAR-CHINA, AND WE ALSO HAD SOMEWHAT OF A VOLATILE WEEK
4:42 ON THE 10 YEAR YIELD. YVONNE: THE TOP STORY COME THE
4:48 LEADERS OF THE U.S., CHINA AND RUSSIA ARE SET TO MEET IN THE
4:50 SHENZHEN. AHEAD OF THAT, BOTH APEC AND
4:55 VLADIMIR PUTIN HAVE TAKEN AIM AT ECONOMIC BARRIERS AT THE APEC
4:59 SUMMIT. STEPHEN ENGLE JOINS US FROM
5:01 SHENZHEN. IT IS A BIG DAY FOR YOU.
5:04 BEYOND JUST THE OPTICS OF TRUMP AND XI EMBRACING AND HUGGING
5:10 YESTERDAY, TELL US MORE WHAT'S IN STORE TODAY.
5:14 STEPHEN: OBVIOUSLY THE TWO SPEECHES BY XI JINPING AND
5:18 VLADIMIR PUTIN YESTERDAY SORT OF SET THE STAGE FOR WHAT'S GOING
5:22 TO HAPPEN TODAY. IT'S GOING TO BE THE BIG
5:25 TRILATERAL. THERE WILL ALSO BE SEPARATE
5:29 BILATERALS BETWEEN TRUMP AND PUTIN, AND TRUMP AND XI.
5:37 THE TRUMP AND XI MEETING WILL BE THE FOURTH SINCE LAST YEAR AND
5:40 SOUTH KOREA BETWEEN THE TWO LEADERS WHERE THEY SECURE THE
5:43 ONE-YEAR TRUCE, WHICH SUBSEQUENTLY IN SEPTEMBER WAS SO
5:49 STEP -- EXTENDED UNTIL JANUARY. TIME IS TICKING ON THAT TRADE
5:51 TRUCE AND WHETHER THEY CAN COME TO SOME SORT OF MUTUAL
5:55 UNDERSTANDING ON THAT IS YET TO BE SEEN IN THE BILATERAL.
5:59 IT WILL BE A SHORT TRIP TODAY FOR DONALD TRUMP.
6:01 HE ARRIVED LATE YESTERDAY AFTERNOON.
6:06 HE WILL SPEND THE DAY IN VARIOUS MEETINGS, INCLUDING THE HIGH
6:08 PROFILE TRILATERAL. AMONG THE THINGS THAT XI HIGH
6:15 LET THAT HIGH LET IT YESTERDAY, THE GLOBAL TERM IS DEEPENING,
6:18 WORLD GROWTH HAS LOST SOME MOMENTUM, AND HE URGED THE
6:22 REMOVAL OF TRADE BARRIERS. HE SAYS THE CHINESE ECONOMY IS
6:27 SHOWING STRONG RESILIENCE AND VITALITY.
6:28 VLADIMIR PUTIN WAS A FAIRLY CONFIDENT IN HIS SPEECH,
6:33 ESSENTIALLY SAYING IT PROVES THAT THE SANCTIONS HAVE NOT
6:39 NECESSARILY -- THE SANCTIONS THAT ARE AIMED HE SAID TO
6:42 BASICALLY MINIMIZE HIM ON THE GLOBAL STAGE HAVE NOT
6:43 NECESSARILY WORKED. THIS IS VLADIMIR PUTIN'S SECOND
6:51 TRIP TO CHINA ON A HIGH-PROFILE STAGE COME ON THE GLOBAL SCENE
6:53 SINCE SEPTEMBER OF LAST YEAR WHEN HE ATTENDED THE MILITARY
6:58 PARADE IN BEIJING ALONG WITH XI JINPING AND KIM JONG-UN.
7:04 HE IS STILL PRETTY MUCH ISOLATED AND OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD.
7:11 YESTERDAY I SPOKE WITH NOTED COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR
7:12 JEFFREY SACHS. HE WAS AN ADVISOR TO GORBACHEV
7:19 IN THE LATE 1980'S, AN ADVISER TO PRESIDENT YELTSIN, AN ADVISOR
7:24 TO TWO DIFFERENT UKRAINIAN ADMINISTRATIONS AS WELL AS THE
7:27 POLISH GOVERNMENT. HE KNOWS WHAT HE IS TALKING
7:30 ABOUT ON THESE ISSUES BETWEEN WHAT IS HAPPENING IN UKRAINE,
7:37 WITH A DISCLAIMER THAT HE HAS SOME CONTROVERSIAL VIEWS SAYING
7:38 THE EXPANSION OF NATO WAS LARGELY TO BLAME FOR THE CURRENT
7:42 CONFLICT THAT IS ONGOING IN UKRAINE.
7:47 BUT HE TOLD ME HE WELCOMES THIS TRILATERAL MEETING.
7:51 JEFFREY: I'M IN FAVOR OF THE THREE LEADERS MEETING.
7:54 I HOPE IT IS A GOOD MEETING. I DON'T EXPECT TOO MUCH
7:57 SPECIFICS COMING OUT OF IT. BUT WE DON'T NEED FIREWORKS.
8:01 WE DON'T NEED CONFLICT. WE DON'T NEED THE U.S. VERSUS
8:07 CHINA AND WHO IS GOING TO WIN, WHICH IS A RATHER JUVENILE,
8:09 UNFORTUNATE WAY TO THINK ABOUT THE WORLD.
8:19 STEPHEN:DAVID: STEVE, WE SAW A VERY HIGH PROFILE WELCOME FROM THE CHINESE
8:22 PRESIDENT WHEN VLADIMIR PUTIN ARRIVED.
8:25 A FEW HOURS AFTER THAT IT WAS THE U.S. PRESIDENTS TURN TO LAND
8:29 IN SHENZHEN. WE HAVE SEEN A LOT OF THESE
8:34 PICTURES WHERE XI JINPING ACTUALLY WENT TO MEET THE U.S.
8:35 PRESIDENT. THESE THREE ARE MEETING TODAY.
8:40 WHAT MORE DO WE KNOW ABOUT WHAT WE CAN EXPECT FROM THIS MEETING?
8:43 WHAT TIME ARE THEY MEETING AND WHAT IS ON THE AGENDA IF WE HAVE
8:45 ANY INFORMATION? STEPHEN: THERE WILL BE MULTIPLE
8:51 DIFFERENT BILATERALS. MARK CARNEY MET WITH DONALD
8:56 TRUMP YESTERDAY. THEY ARE TRYING TO HAMMER OUT
8:59 THEIR DIFFERENCES, VAST DIFFERENCES NO DOUBT ON THEIR
9:00 TRADE AGREEMENT. MARK CARNEY DESCRIBES THAT AS
9:05 TWO STEPS FORWARD, ONE STEP BACKWARDS.
9:07 THERE IS A BIT OF FRUSTRATION FROM THE CANADIAN PRIME
9:08 MINISTER. DONALD TRUMP THINKS THAT AN
9:11 AGREEMENT CAN PROBABLY HAPPEN AT SOME POINT.
9:15 THE BIG ONES OF COURSE TODAY ARE GOING TO BE TRUMP-XI.
9:25 AND WHETHER THE EXPORT CONTROL FROM THE UNITED STATES AND THE
9:27 INCREASED ONES ON A REMOTE ACCESS FOR THE CHINESE
9:30 CHIPMAKERS THROUGH DATA CENTERS IN SOUTHEAST ASIA, THE BIG STORY
9:33 IN THE AFTERMATH OF THE JENSEN HUANG NVIDIA ALLEGED INDUSTRIAL
9:39 ESPIONAGE SAGA, WHETHER THAT COMES UP WILL BE AN INTERESTING
9:43 TOPIC FOR YOU ARE SEEING THE FOOTAGE HERE WHERE XI JINPING
9:48 GREETED DONALD TRUMP ON HIS ARRIVAL YESTERDAY AFTERNOON.
9:50 IT BROKE PROTOCOL. THE CHINESE LEADER DOES NOT
9:52 USUALLY GO TO THE AIRPORT TO MEET A HEAD OF STATE.
9:56 IT IS USUALLY AT THE GREAT HALL OF THE PEOPLE OR THE STATE
10:00 GUESTHOUSE WITH THE LEADERSHIP COMPOUND IN BEIJING.
10:04 SHENZHEN, THEY DO THINGS DIFFERENTLY.
10:07 THIS IS A TECH BOOM TOWN. THEY ARE LEADING THE INDIGENOUS
10:08 INNOVATION CHARGE. MAYBE XI JINPING TAKING A
10:13 DIFFERENT PAGE AND BREAKING PROTOCOL.
10:15 ESSENTIALLY HE SAID CHINA IS A NATION OF ETIQUETTE AND
10:19 RECIPROCITY, SO HE IS RECIPROCATING WHAT DONALD TRUMP
10:20 DID IN WASHINGTON, D.C. IN THE SEPTEMBER MEETING, DONALD TRUMP
10:25 MEETING HIM AT THE AIRPORT AS HE ARRIVED.
10:29 LET'S MOVE ASIDE FROM THAT. WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN IN THE
10:31 TRILATERAL MEETING WITH PRUDENT? DONALD TRUMP SAYS HE WANTS TO
10:37 TALK ABOUT DENUCLEARIZATION. THAT IS PROBABLY NOT HIGH ON THE
10:39 AGENDA FOR XI JINPING. WE ARE HEARING FROM SOURCES
10:44 CHINA DOES NOT WANT TO TALK ABOUT DENUCLEARIZATION WHEN THE
10:45 U.S. AND RUSSIA HAVE LARGER NUCLEAR ARSENALS.
10:48 SO WHAT CAN THEY TALK ABOUT? OBVIOUSLY IRAN WILL BE
10:52 DISCUSSED. TRUMP WILL TRY TO ELICIT THE
10:55 SUPPORT OF BEIJING AND MOSCOW TO HELP USE THEIR INFLUENCE ON
10:56 TEHRAN. WHAT CAN COME OF THAT, I AM NOT
11:02 SURE AT ALL. BUT AGAIN, UKRAINE IS NOT
11:04 NECESSARILY ON THE AGENDA. SOME SAY HOW CAN IT BE IF
11:09 UKRAINE IS NOT AT THE TABLE. WE WILL SEE, IT WILL BE
11:12 INTERESTING DEFINITELY FOR VLADIMIR PUTIN AS HE TRIES TO
11:13 RAISE HIS PROFILE. YVONNE: CERTAINLY THE PHOTO OP
11:19 WILL BE A BIG ONE FOR ALL THREE. STEVE, WE WILL TALK ABOUT MORE
11:26 GOES ON AND BRING YOU MORE PICTURES.
11:28 WE EXPECTING TO HEAR AND SEE MORE OF THE PHOTO THIS MORNING
11:29 AND SHENZHEN. STEPHEN ENGLE JOINING US FROM
11:34 SHENZHEN. LET'S GET BACK TO THE OTHER TOP
11:36 STORY. ANTHROPIC HAS RAISED $107
11:42 BILLION IN ITS IPO IN PRIVATE PLACEMENT. THE COMPANY SOLD MORE
11:47 THAN 956 MILLION SHARES FOR $83 EACH.
11:48 LET'S BRING IN OUR DEALS AND LIST.
11:52 WE GOT THE PRICING. THAT SEEMS LIKE A RECORD,
11:53 MICHAEL? MICHAEL: IT IS ABSOLUTELY A
12:00 BRECK AULD -- RECORD. MORE THAN $107 BILLION RAISE,
12:06 TOPPING SPACEX IPO IN JUNE. THIS YEAR IS ALREADY ON TRACK TO
12:10 BE ONE OF THE BEST YEARS EVER FOR IPOS.
12:12 IT WILL BE THE SECOND LARGEST GLOBALLY RAISED, PARTLY BECAUSE
12:15 OF THESE HYPERSCALE IPO'S. WITH BRAGGING RIGHTS I CAN SAY
12:20 THAT BLOOMBERG REPORT OF THE PRICING OF IT FIRST, WHICH WAS
12:24 ABOVE THE TARGET RANGE. THEY PRICED AT $83 PER SHARE,
12:32 WHICH WAS ABOVE THE $70TO $78 RANGE.
12:33 THEY ALSO UPSIZE TO THE IPO THAT BROUGHT IT UP TO ABOUT 950-PLUS
12:44 THEY WILL LIKELY PERHAPS HAVE A GREEN SHOOT, THE OVERALLOTMENT
12:49 THAT WILL PRICE IN THE NEXT FEW WEEKS OR SO THAT WILL LIKELY
12:55 BRING IT FURTHER PAST THE 107 BILLION WHICH INCLUDED THE BASE
12:58 OFFERING PLUS A 26 BILLION PRIVATE PLACEMENT FROM COMPANIES
13:02 PEOPLE KNOW LIKE NVIDIA, GOOGLE, AMD AND SUCH.
13:09 DAVID: SO, I MEAN, THE QUESTION OF WHAT'S NEXT, MICHAEL, IN
13:14 TERMS OF THE COMPANY, AND I GUESS THE OTHER PART IS, HOW DO
13:18 WE THINK THIS TRADES ON THE FIRST DAY?
13:23 WILL THE UNDERWRITER BE CALLED IN TO STABILIZE THE STOCK, GOD
13:25 FORBID? MICHAEL: MORGAN STANLEY IS THE
13:32 STABILIZATION AGENT. I'M GOING TO GUESS THEY WILL
13:35 HANDLE THAT OVER ALLOTMENT OF SHARES.
13:38 THEY WILL HAVE A LOT OF DEMAND TO DEAL WITH IT WOULD SEEM VERY
13:42 OVERSUBSCRIBED. THAT JUST SAYS THERE IS A LOT OF
13:46 DEMAND OUT THERE. WE TALKED WITH A MANAGING
13:52 PARTNER OF BATTERY VENTURES WHO PUT IT SIMPLY, THAT ANTHROPIC'S
13:56 AI PROVES THE DEMAND FOR AI IS REAL.
14:00 A LOT OF PEOPLE OUT THERE WANT TO INVEST IN IT, AND IT LOOKS
14:05 LIKE IT WILL PROBABLY HAVE A GOOD DAY BY ALL MEASURES.
14:09 THE IPO CAME IN A WEEK IN WHICH THE NASDAQ WAS DOWN A BIT.
14:13 IT WAS UP A BIT TODAY. A LOT OF NEWS IN TERMS OF
14:18 NVIDIA, A LOT LOT OF AI-RELATED NEWS.
14:19 NEVERTHELESS, THEY CAME OUT OF THE BOX STRONGER-THAN-EXPECTED,
14:23 AND THAT SEEMS LIKE IT'S GOING TO KEEP GOING.
14:28 YVONNE: IT WILL BE AN INTERESTING DAY.
14:30 MICHAEL IS OUR EDITOR ON U.S. DEALS, JOINING US WITH THE
14:33 LATEST WHEN IT COMES TO ANTHROPIC AS IT TRADES LATER ON.
14:37 COMING UP, MORE ABOUT TECH. LORRAINE TAN WILL BE JOINING US
14:46 TO TALK ABOUT THE ANTHROPIC IPO. THAT IS COMING UP NEXT.
14:49 WE'LL ALSO BREAK DOWN THE EARNINGS FROM TENCENT AND
14:51 ALIBABA OUT WITH THE RESULTS AS WELL.
14:54 THIS IS "THE CHINA SHOW."
15:16 ♪ DAVID:DAVID: ALL RIGHT.
15:17 IT'S ABOUT 20 MINUTES INTO THE SHOW.
15:21 WE NOW HAVE TIME TO FOCUS ON EARNINGS.
15:22 TENCENT COMING THROUGH. IDIOSYNCRATIC AND A LOT OF WAYS
15:26 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE CORE BUSINESS AND WEAKNESS.
15:33 THERE WAS A TAX RELATED ISSUE WHICH SOMEWHAT FLATTENED THE
15:34 NUMBERS. LOOKING UNDERNEATH THE HOOD,
15:38 SALES DATA WAS WEAK AND PROFITS DROPPED, WHICH IS SOMETHING YOU
15:41 DON'T NORMALLY SEE FROM A COMPANY LIKE TENCENT.
15:44 I THINK LAST TIME WE HAD ONE WAS A COUPLE YEARS AGO.
15:46 LET'S BRING IN OUR ASIAN STOCKS REPORTER JEANNY YU TO TALK ABOUT
15:52 THE DOWNSIDE SURPRISES OF THE RESULTS.
15:58 JEANNY: I THINK THERE WERE THREE MAJOR DOWNSIDE SURPRISES.
16:00 THE FIRST IS THE REVENUE AND MARGIN RISK.
16:04 THAT IS THE SOFTWARE, INTERNATIONAL GAINING -- GAMING
16:09 AND DOMESTIC CONSUMPTION. THAT IS WHERE YOU SEE GROSS
16:11 PROFIT FOR THE FIRST TIME IN ALMOST THREE YEARS ACTUALLY
16:18 BELOW THE REVENUE GROWTH. WHICH MEANS THE MARGIN IS REALLY
16:22 UNDER A LOT OF PRESSURE. I THINK THE SECOND IS THE
16:27 BALANCE SHEET SHOCK. I THINK THAT IS ONE OF THE
16:33 BIGGEST SURPRISES FOR INVESTORS BECAUSE YOU ARE STARTING TO SEE
16:37 THE AI INVESTMENT STARTING TO SHOW IN THE BALANCE SHEET AND
16:40 PUTTING TENCENT IN A NET DEBT SITUATION.
16:48 THE CASH OUTFLOW, I THINK THAT PUT A BIG PRESSURE ON WHETHER
16:50 TENCENT IS GOING TO MAINTAIN THE BUYBACK PACE, TO MAINTAIN THE
16:56 SHAREHOLDER RETURN, AND HOW THIS IS GOING TO AFFECT THEIR
17:04 UPCOMING SPENDING IN THE ALLEY INVESTMENTS.
17:05 BECAUSE OF COURSE YOU CANNOT PUT A BRAKE ON THE AI INVESTMENTS
17:10 FOR NOW. THE NET CASH OUTFLOW SITUATION
17:13 COULD LAST A LITTLE BIT LONGER. I THINK THE THIRD SURPRISE WAS
17:18 THE AI MODEL DEVELOPMENT. I THINK THE WHOLE MODEL WAS WELL
17:25 RECEIVED AND PEOPLE SPEAK HIGHLY OF HOW EFFICIENT IN TERMS OF THE
17:31 COST EFFICIENCY HOW GOOD IT IS FOR TENCENT TO POTENTIALLY GROW
17:35 OUT THE AI AGENT. BUT THE BIG QUESTION MARK FOR
17:38 INVESTORS IS MANAGEMENT DURING THE ANALYST CALL, THEY KIND OF
17:44 ADMIT IT THAT THE NEXT GENERATION MODEL IS GOING TO
17:47 TAKE A LONGER TIME BECAUSE OF THE CHIP ACCESS CONCERNS.
17:52 THAT IS ONE CONCERN FOR INVESTORS IN TERMS OF THE AI
17:53 AGENT DEVELOPMENT. YVONNE: THERE'S GOING TO BE A
17:59 LOT FOR INVESTORS TO CHEW ON. WE DID SEE THE ADR DROP.
18:05 ALIBABA AS WELL, WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO SAY
18:07 ABOUT THE NEW CHIP CURBS FROM THE U.S. AND HOW IT WILL IMPACT
18:08 THEIR ACCESS TO COMPUTER. JEANNY YU, THANK YOU, BRINGING
18:16 -- BREAKING DOWN THE EARNINGS.
18:20 LORRAINE TAN WE BRING IN. -- WE BRING IN LORRAINE TAN.
18:27 WHAT WAS YOUR REACTION TO SOME OF THESE EARNINGS?
18:33 LORRAINE: WHAT HAPPENED AT TENCENT IS LARGELY WITHIN OUR
18:35 EXPECTATION. I THINK THE REASON IS IS THE
18:40 COMPANY IS IN A BUILDOUT PHASE. YOU EXPECT THE OUTFLOWS TO BE
18:44 THERE BEFORE THE REVENUE CATCHES UP WITH SPENDING.
18:46 WE DO ANTICIPATE FOR MOST OF THE INDUSTRY THAT WE WILL SEE THAT
18:52 REVENUE START TO CATCH UP WITH THE SPENDING BY 2028.
18:54 WHAT WOULD HAPPEN THEN IS YOU WOULD START TO SEE THE PRESSURE
18:58 SORT OF REDUCE ON MOST OF THESE COMPANIES.
19:01 I THINK TENCENT MENTIONED THEY THINK SPENDING HAS PEAKED IN THE
19:02 THIRD QUARTER. DAVID: IS THE MARKET TO BEARISH?
19:09 LORRAINE: WE THINK IT IS A LITTLE TOO BEARISH.
19:16 THE REASON WE SAY THAT IS THE MONETIZATION WILL COME THROUGH.
19:21 THE REASON THE CAPEX HAS BEEN SURPRISING TO THE UPSIDE IS THE
19:23 COST OF CHIPS HAVE GONE UP. THEY ARE COMMITTED TO SPENDING.
19:26 DAVID: WHICH IS A GOOD THING. LORRAINE: WE ARE STARTING TO SEE
19:31 THE CHIPS COME OFF AND THE INPUTS ARE STARTING TO EASE.
19:34 I GUESS THAT IS WHY WE ARE MORE OPTIMISTIC AND WE DO SEE VALUE
19:35 IN THESE COMPANIES. YVONNE: WHAT ABOUT FOR ALIBABA?
19:42 THEY SEEM TO BE COLLATERAL DAMAGE IN ALL OF THIS WHEN IT
19:47 COMES TO NVIDIA, INVESTORS ASSESSING THE CHIP SHORTAGE AND
19:48 CONCERNS AROUND THAT. DO YOU THINK THAT WILL WEIGH ON
19:52 THESE INTERNET PLATFORMS AND HOW THEY GET THEIR COMPUTE MOVING
19:53 FORWARD? LORRAINE: THERE ARE A COUPLE OF
19:58 THINGS FOR BABA. ONE IS THE SPEND ON BABA'S
20:05 RESULTS TONIGHT. I THINK FOR BABA, WHATEVER IT IS
20:10 IS STILL COMING FROM A POSITION OF SOME STRENGTH BECAUSE IT HAS
20:14 UNDERLYING STRONG CASH FLOWS FROM ITS E-COMMERCE BUSINESS BUT
20:16 THAT GROWTH IS SLOWING. I DO THINK THAT WILL BE
20:21 REFLECTED WITH A LITTLE BIT OF COMPETITION ON THEIR CORE
20:25 BUSINESS IS WHAT WE WANT TO SEE AS WELL.
20:30 BUT WE DO THINK THE PLANS ARE WELL RECEIVED.
20:34 IT IS ABLE TO, UNLIKE TENCENT, IT IS ABLE TO MONETIZE SOME OF
20:36 THAT ALREADY. SO I THINK WE JUST WANT TO SEE
20:43 THE PACE OF REVENUE GROWTH FOR ITS CLOUD BUSINESS.
20:47 YVONNE: WOULD YOU SAY THAT ALIBABA'S CLOUD STRATEGY IS LESS
20:51 RISKY? LORRAINE: IT'S A LITTLE
20:54 DIFFERENT. BETWEEN THE TWO, WE THINK BOTH
20:56 COMPANIES ARE UNDERVALUED RIGHT NOW.
21:01 BUT WE THINK THAT TENCENT, BECAUSE OF THEIR ECOSYSTEM, IT'S
21:03 PROBABLY A LITTLE LESS RISKY IN THAT SENSE.
21:08 ON A RELATIVE BASIS COME ALTHOUGH TENCENT IS SORT OF
21:10 ABSORBING AND DIGESTING ITS COSTS RIGHT NOW, IT'S GOING TO
21:15 BE ABLE TO PARLAY THAT INTO SOME OF ITS OWN ACTIVITIES.
21:20 DAVID: WE WILL HAVE MORE WITH LORRAINE TAN AND A COUPLE OF
21:24 MINUTES. STAY TUNED FOR A DEEPER
21:27 CONVERSATION ON THE MARKETS. WE HAVEN'T EVEN GOTTEN TO
21:29 ANTHROPIC. TENCENT DOWN ABOUT 3% AND THE
21:31 EARLY GOING. JUST UNDER SIX MINUTES TO THE
21:35 OPENING BELL. THIS IS "THE CHINA SHOW."
21:51 ♪ DAVID: WELCOME BACKDAVID:.
21:52 ARE WE ACTUALLY FLIRTING WITH 20 3000 ON THE HANG SENG INDEX?
21:56 THAT SEEMS TO BE THE CASE. 50 POINTS CLEAR OF THAT LEVEL.
22:04 TENCENT WAS DOWN 3% PREMARKET. BABA IS NEXT IN LINE.
22:12 BAIDU ROUNDING THINGS UP IN TERMS OF THE OG TECH NAMES AND
22:15 MAINLAND CHINA. THE OPENING BELL IS COMING UP
22:16 NEXT. THIS IS "THE CHINA SHOW."
22:24 GOOD MORNING. ♪
22:48 DAVID: WELCOME BACK. GOOD MORNING.
22:50 YOU ARE WATCHING THE CHINA SHOW. COMING TO YOU LIVE OUT OF HONG
22:53 KONG. THE TEMPERATURE DROPPED WORDS
22:56 THAN A FEW DEGREES. IT FEELS MORE LIKE A FEW
23:02 STANDARD DEVIATIONS MOVE LOOKING AT THE BOOTS ON THE GROUND.
23:06 GET THIS. BONE CHILLING 21 DEGREES.
23:13 KONG. YOUR FLUFFY JACKETS, YOUR VESTS.
23:19 TIME TO BRING IT OUT. CERTAINLY WE ARE NOT JUST
23:24 COUNTING DOWN TO THIS HISTORIC MEETING IN SHENZHEN BETWEEN XI,
23:30 BOUDIN, AND FROM. WE WILL SEE XI AND TRUMP MEETING
23:37 IN THE BILATERAL AS WELL. BLOCKBUSTER IPOS UNDERWAY LATER
23:42 ON TODAY IN THE U.S. A BIT OF PRESSURE WHEN IT COMES
23:46 TO EQUITIES THIS MORNING. SHENZHEN IS LEADING THAT LOWER.
23:51 MORE THAN 1% LOSSES THERE. DAVE MENTIONED THE STRENGTH
23:55 WE'VE SEEN IN THE DOLLAR AS WELL.
24:00 666 LEVELS THIS MORNING. TAKE A LOOK AT HONG KONG.
24:04 TENCENT WILL DICTATE HOW IT GOES TODAY.
24:07 WE ARE SEEING DOWNSIDE OF MORE THAN 1% ACROSS-THE-BOARD.
24:11 MSCI CHINA. LOOK UNDER THE HOOD.
24:13 IT'S THE TENCENT STORY. TALK ABOUT WHAT ANALYSTS ARE
24:17 CONCERNED ABOUT. NEGATIVE FREE CASH FLOW.
24:22 NET DEBT POSITION. THAT IS THE CONCERN.
24:28 HOW MUCH MONEY THEY ARE SPENDING TO SECURE THIS AI COMPUTE AND
24:31 REALLY DEVELOP FURTHER. THAT'S THINK -- ONE THING TO
24:33 WATCH CLOSELY. TENCENT NEARING WHAT WE SAW IN
24:38 THE ADRS OVERNIGHT. BOB, NOT BODING WELL HERE.
24:44 A LOT OF CONCERNS ABOUT CHIP CONTROLS AND THE LIKE FROM THE
24:46 U.S.. WE WILL SEE HOW THE COMPANY
24:49 ANSWERS TO SOME OF THOSE QUESTIONS IN A FEW HOURS FROM
24:54 NOW. JD.COM AS WELL.
24:57 BAIDU IS TAKING IT ON THE TRAIN HERE.
25:00 -- CHIN HERE. PRETTY MIXED PICTURE.
25:09 THE CHIPS ARE DOING WELL. PURE PLAYS ARE NOT.
25:15 PONY AI AS WELL. THE EARNINGS CAME OUT WHEN IT
25:18 COMES TO SOME OF THESE ROBOTAXIS AND THE LIKE.
25:22 SALES DID BEAT ESTIMATES. WE ARE STILL SEEING PRESSURE
25:26 THERE, DOWN 7% FOR PONY AI TODAY.
25:30 WATCHING COPPER, WATCHING COLD. THE FED MINUTES DID LEAD MORE
25:35 HAWKISH. MORE FED OFFICIALS ARE TALKING
25:39 ABOUT HIKES AS WELL. COPPER RECOVERING A BIT THERE.
25:41 CERTAINLY THERE'S A LOT OF CONCERNS ABOUT COPPER.
25:46 YOU ARE SEEING WHEN IT COMES TO COPPER MINERS AND GOLD MINERS,
25:48 ALL FALLING IN TANDEM TODAY. GIVEN THE CONCERN WE'VE SEEN ALL
25:53 WEEK WHEN IT COMES TO THIS PROPOSED RIGHTS ISSUE.
26:00 CITI DOWNGRADING THE DEVELOPER, CUTTING ITS PRICE TARGET.
26:03 THEY DID CITE UNCERTAINTIES FROM THIS RIGHTS ISSUE.
26:06 THE PRICE TARGET HAS BEEN SLASHED TO 6.9 HONG KONG DOLLARS
26:11 TO $2.03. QUITE A SLASHING.
26:17 DAVID: CAN'T FIND THE FLOOR. WE ARE STILL DOWN ON THAT.
26:22 THE GOLD STORY IS INDICATIVE OF THE RATE STORY WHICH SEEMS TO BE
26:26 AN UNDERAPPRECIATED REASON WHY THESE RISK ASSETS ARE WOBBLING.
26:32 50 DEGREES OF HAWKISHNESS IF YOU WILL.
26:35 TENCENT. VERY QUICKLY.
26:38 LET'S SHOW THAT AGAIN IF WE CAN. IF THE OPEN TODAY, YESTERDAY WE
26:42 WERE AT 2025 LOWS. WE TOOK OUT LAST YEAR'S TROUGH.
26:48 WE ARE NOW AT THE LOWEST LEVEL IN ABOUT 2.5 YEARS OR SO.
26:52 $360. 3% OR LESS, COMING OFF OF LOWS
26:59 EVER SO SLIGHTLY. STILL WITH US IS LORRAINE.
27:07 I GET THE CHINESE TECH EARNINGS ON THE SOFTER SIDE.
27:10 MARKETS HAVE BEEN SO UNFORGIVING WHEN YOU LOOK AT HOW QUICK THEY
27:14 ARE TO SELL THE CHINESE EQUITY STORY.
27:17 WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THESE DYNAMICS?
27:20 TAKE US THROUGH HOW YOU LOOK AT THIS.
27:22 LORRAINE: I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF EXCITEMENT WITH LISTING CSN
27:27 THREE. THERE WAS A LITTLE BIT OVERDONE
27:33 REACTION THERE. THE STOCK IS STILL EXPENSIVE.
27:41 SK HYNIX AND SAMSUNG, A HUGE RUN-UP.
27:42 THE WHOLE TECH SECTOR GLOBALLY ESSENTIALLY WAS THE ONLY
27:45 OUTPERFORMING SECTOR FOR MOST OF THE YEAR.
27:50 SO EVEN WITH THE CORRECTION THAT WE SEE NOW, IT IS STILL UP FOR
27:53 THE YEAR. ON THE CHINA SIDE, YOU DON'T
27:59 ACTUALLY HAVE A LOT OF THE BIG CHIP COMPANIES OR INFRASTRUCTURE
28:03 COMPANIES IN TERMS OF AI THAT BENEFIT.
28:07 EVEN WITH A BENEFICIARY, THE FACT IS THAT ON THE MEMORY SIZE,
28:12 -- SIDE, THESE ARE COMMODITIES. WE ARE BEGINNING TO SEE THE PEAK
28:18 OF THOSE PRICE RISES. IN FACT, WE ARE BEGINNING TO SEE
28:22 PRICES TO START COMING OFF. YOU STILL HAVE PRESSURE NOW IN
28:26 TERMS OF THE CYCLE FOR THE SEMICONDUCTOR NAMES.
28:31 YVONNE: HOW IS ANTHROPIC -- WHAT IMPACT COULD IT HAVE?
28:33 COULD IT REVIVE THE AI TRADE? IN WHAT WAY?
28:38 LORRAINE: IT'S HARD TO SAY THAT ANTHROPIC IS GOING TO LIFT
28:41 EVERYBODY. BECAUSE ANTHROPIC IS ON THE
28:45 ENTERPRISE SIDE. VERY DIFFERENT FROM A LOT OF THE
28:48 COMPANIES THAT WE SEE THAT ARE LISTED OUT HERE.
28:51 WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE A LOT MORE MASS-MARKET AI AGENTS.
28:55 ANTHROPIC, WE LIKE ANTHROPIC. WE VALUE IT.
28:59 1.7 TRILLION. WE SEE THAT AS BEING BECAUSE IT
29:04 HAS A HIGHER MARGIN SEGMENT OF THE MARKET THAT'S TARGETING THE
29:07 ENTERPRISE SIDE. WE EXPECT REVENUE TO BE ABLE TO
29:12 HIT MORE THAN 300 BILLION IN FIVE YEARS TIME.
29:18 AS IT CONTINUES TO DEVELOP, IT WILL BE ABLE TO OPEN NEW MARKETS
29:20 FOR ITS SOLUTIONS. SO WE FEEL THAT ANTHROPIC IS A
29:27 LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT BECAUSE IT'S FOCUSED ON THE ENTERPRISE
29:27 SPACE. DAVID: YOU HAVE CONTRASTED
29:31 ALREADY TO ANTHROPIC. A LOT OF THE PEER AI LABS THAT
29:34 ARE LISTED HERE. HOW DIFFERENT ARE THOSE STORIES?
29:40 LORRAINE: THE QUESTION WE HAVE IS, YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE
29:43 DIFFERENT LEVELS OF MARKET LIKE WHAT WE'VE SEEN WITH MICROSOFT
29:47 FOR EXAMPLE. YOU HAVE THE MORE MASS AI
29:52 AGENTS. YOU DON'T NEED A LOT MORE
29:54 COMPUTE FOR THAT. WHERE THE ARGUMENT GOES IS THAT
29:59 FOR THE BULK OF WHAT MOST PEOPLE NEED, THEY DON'T MEAN -- NEED
30:06 MORE ADDITIONAL AI COMPLEXITY. SO FOR THAT SEGMENT OF THE
30:10 MARKET, THAT'S WHERE YOU SEE MORE COMPETITION.
30:14 MORE ENTRANCE COMING INTO THAT SPACE.
30:16 MARGINS WILL BE LOWER. THE MAN MONEY THAT'S BEING SPENT
30:21 PLAYERS THERE. YVONNE: WHICH ARE THE WINNERS
30:24 THAT YOU SEE? LORRAINE: GIVEN THE VALUATION,
30:29 ANTHROPIC AT 1.7 TRILLION. WE LIKE THAT.
30:32 WE FEEL LIKE ALPHABET WILL ALSO BE ONE OF THE BENEFICIARIES IN
30:34 THE SPACE. IT REMAINS TO BE SEEN HOW OPENAI
30:40 OR THE OTHERS FAIR. ANTHROPIC AND ALPHABET ARE
30:45 PROBABLY TWO LEADERS RIGHT NOW. DAVID: WHAT ELSE IS UNDERVALUED
30:52 IN THE ASIA PACIFIC? LORRAINE: IT'S REALLY
30:56 INTERESTING. BECAUSE OF THE CORRECTION WE SEE
31:00 IN THE TECH SECTOR, I'M REMARKING THAT IT'S GONE FROM
31:08 COVER THAT IS THE MOST UNDERVALUED RIGHT NOW.
31:12 SO ONE OF THE SEGMENTS THAT WE LIKE BEST IN THE SPACE REMAINS
31:16 THE HARDWARE EQUIPMENT MANUFACTURERS.
31:19 THERE'S A LOT MORE VISIBILITY IN THAT AREA.
31:22 ONE OF THE NAMES WE LIKE IS ADVANTIS IN JAPAN.
31:29 SOME OF THE KEY JAPANESE SEMICONDUCTOR EQUIPMENT, THEIR
31:33 BILL BIT -- VISIBILITY READS VERY STRONG.
31:39 YVONNE: OUTLOOK FOR 2027. WHAT ARE YOU WRITING UP RIGHT
31:41 NOW WITH YOUR TEAM? LORRAINE: 2027.
31:46 I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE CHALLENGING.
31:49 THE NEWS IS VERY NEGATIVE RIGHT NOW.
31:52 THE MARKET IS SO BEARISH AT THE MOMENT.
31:55 IF THE VALUE STARTS TO EMERGE IN THE MARKET, I THINK 2027 COULD
31:59 STILL BE A GOOD YEAR. IF THERE IS STILL GOING TO BE
32:05 VALUATIONS NOT COMFORTABLE, WE WILL STILL BE IN FOR VOLATILITY.
32:10 DAVID: FOR INVESTORS THAT MAY BE CAN'T, DON'T HAVE THE EMOTIONAL
32:18 BANDWIDTH FOR TECH, WHAT IS THEIR VALUE?
32:23 ARE YOU LACKING ANYTHING IN THAT SPACE?
32:27 LORRAINE: CONSUMER DEFENSES HAVE GONE UP NICELY.
32:30 THERE ARE STILL A FEW NAMES WE LIKE IN THAT SPACE.
32:33 DIVIDEND YIELD OR'S ARE THE ONES THAT WE WOULD RECOMMEND.
32:35 SOME OF THE CONSUMER DEFENSES THAT WE LIKE INCLUDE CHINA FOR
32:40 EXAMPLE. ON A CYCLICAL SIDE, THERE'S BEEN
32:46 A GAIN IN MARKET SHARE. AT THIS LEVEL, IT STILL REMAINS
32:49 ATTRACTIVE. YVONNE: GREAT TO HAVE YOU HERE
32:53 IN HONG KONG. PLEASE COME BACK.
32:57 COMING UP, WE WILL BE LIVE IN SINGAPORE.
33:02 WE HEAR FROM OK X ON THE OUTLOOK FOR STABLECOINS AND WHY THE
33:06 PAYMENTS. THAT'S NEXT.
33:09 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
33:24 DAVID: ALL RIGHT. BITCOIN HAS BEEN CHALLENGED.
33:30 31% OVER THE LAST YEAR. ANOTHER WAY OUT LOOKING AT THIS
33:36 IS PRETTY MUCH AT THE LEVEL, JUST ABOUT AT THE START OF THE
33:38 YEAR. FED MARCH.
33:44 THERE WAS A POINT IN TIME WHERE ONE WOULD'VE SEEN TRIPLE DIGITS
33:45 AGAIN. WE ARE NOW $40,000 SHORT OF THAT
33:49 LEVEL. MAYBE THERE IS MORE TO THE
33:52 STORY. YVONNE: WE HAVE THE PERFECT
33:56 GUEST TO TALK MORE ABOUT THIS. LET'S BRING IN HASLINDA AMIN.
34:02 HEY. HASLINDA: WELL, WITH ME IS THE
34:08 REGIONAL CEO FOR SINGAPORE AND AUSTRALIA AND HEAD OF THE IP
34:11 GROWTH. WE ARE TALKING ABOUT DIGITAL
34:15 ASSETS BUT WE WILL START WITH NVIDIA -- WITH ANTHROPIC BECAUSE
34:18 IT IS FRONT AND CENTER. IT'S JUST PRICED ITSELF AT $83
34:25 PER PIECE. I'M WONDERING WHAT YOU MAKE OF
34:28 THAT. IT'S A GAP FROM WHAT IT WAS
34:29 MARKETED WITH. >> IT SEEMS LIKE THE BULLISHNESS
34:36 HAS STAYED. THERE'S HIGH EXPECTATIONS THAT
34:42 PEOPLE HAVE SET FOR THEM. RETAIL INVESTORS ARE STILL VERY
34:49 GOING ANYWHERE. HASLINDA: IT IS POSSIBLY PRICED
34:54 FOR PERFECTION. >> IT'S HARD TO IMAGINE WHAT
34:59 PERFECTION IS WHEN IT COMES TO AI.
35:04 IT'S ONLY BEEN ABOUT A YEAR NOW THAT COMPANIES HAVE STARTED TO
35:07 REALLY INTEGRATE AI TOOLS INTO OUR WORKFLOWS.
35:11 INITIALLY WE THOUGHT IT WOULD JUST BE IMPROVE PRODUCTIVITY.
35:15 WE ARE NOW SEEING THAT IT CAN REALLY NOT JUST REPLACE BUT ALSO
35:20 AUGMENT SOME OF OUR HUMAN EMPLOYEES.
35:24 THEN OUR HUMAN EMPLOYEES CAN START TO BE MORE PRODUCTIVE AND
35:28 START TO BRING THE BUSINESS TO THE NEXT LEVEL.
35:31 IF YOU THINK ABOUT IT, IF EACH COMPANY DOES THIS AT SCALE,
35:35 THINK ABOUT HOW THE GLOBAL ECONOMY IS THEN GOING TO STEP UP
35:38 HEARING AT THEN YOU CAN THINK ABOUT HOW MUCH OF THAT WILL GO
35:40 TO COMPANIES LIKE ANTHROPIC THAT ARE DRIVING INNOVATION AND ARE
35:43 MAKING THE TOOLS AVAILABLE FOR US.
35:46 THERE'S A LOT OF THAT FIRST MOVER ADVANTAGE.
35:52 OPTIMISTIC. HASLINDA: FOR A LOT OF
35:57 INVESTORS, IT'S ALSO ABOUT ROI. 20% ALLOCATION TO RETAIL
36:00 INVESTORS. THAT'S QUITE A BIG AMOUNT.
36:04 IS NOT A GAME CHANGER? >> IT NEEDS TO BE VERY
36:10 CONFIDENCE THAT THEY ARE NOT JUST RELYING ON INSTITUTIONS.
36:13 THEY ARE BELIEVING THAT RETAIL INVESTORS WHO SEE HOW AI IS
36:16 STARTING TO PLAY A ROLE IN THEIR LIVES ARE GOING TO REALLY
36:19 BELIEVE IN IT. ALSO THEN PUT SOME OF THEIR
36:23 ALLOCATION INTO ANTHROPIC. TO ME, THAT SUGGESTS THAT THE
36:29 COMPANY IS SIX TRULY CONFIDENT OF WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO BE
36:31 CONTINUING TO BRING TO MARKET. HASLINDA: WE TALK ABOUT
36:36 HIGH. ASIA IS FRONT AND CENTER.
36:41 DO YOU SEE THE PACE OF GROWTH CONTINUING?
36:43 WHAT WOULD DRIVE THAT? >> STABLECOIN HAS BEEN THE TALK
36:51 OF THE TILE -- TOWN. THERE'S BEEN LESS TALK AND
36:54 THAT'S A GOOD SIGN. IT'S GONE MAINSTREAM.
36:57 A LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T EVEN REALIZE HOW MUCH OF THEIR
36:59 DAY-TO-DAY PAYMENTS ARE BEING PROCESSED IN THE BACKEND IN THE
37:03 FORM OF STABLECOINS. THAT'S A GOOD SIGN.
37:06 IT'S GONE MAINSTREAM. NOW IT'S BECOMING A LEGITIMATE
37:11 WAY FOR PEOPLE TO THINK ABOUT SAVING, SENDING MONEY ACROSS
37:15 BORDERS, AND ALSO SPENDING THAT MONEY.
37:20 HASLINDA: QUITE SURPRISING TO SEE THE NUMBERS ACTUALLY.
37:22 ASIA ACCOUNTS FOR 60% OF THE GLOBAL VOLUME AND RISING
37:25 QUICKLY. THE UST HAS DOMINATED.
37:32 AREAS THAT YOU LOOK AFTER. WHY IS THAT?
37:36 IMPORTANT. U.S. STABLECOINS ARE THE
37:39 LARGEST. THEY'VE BEEN AROUND A LONG TIME.
37:45 ALSO TRADING. PEOPLE ARE MORE COMFORTABLE WITH
37:48 THAT. IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE USE CASES
37:53 OF THE RETAIL INVESTOR BEYOND SPENDING, IN SOME MARKETS WHERE
37:57 RETAIL INVESTORS ARE CONCERNED ABOUT VOLATILITY OR
38:03 DEPRECIATION, THAT DEMAND ADDS ANOTHER ANGLE TO DOLLAR BACK
38:07 STABLECOINS. HASLINDA: IT IS THE UST.
38:14 >> IT IS SOMETHING THAT THEY WANT TO DO.
38:15 THEY HAVE TO HAVE FAITH IN IT. THEY CAN USE IT TO SPEND ON
38:19 THEIR DAILY NEEDS. I BELIEVE IT'S ALWAYS GOING TO
38:23 BE DOLLAR DOMINANT. HASLINDA: IN CASE OF USE CASES,
38:30 IF IT'S NOT THE RETAIL INVESTORS, WOULD IT BE THE
38:32 INSTITUTIONAL CASES? >> IF I WAS AN INSTITUTION AND I
38:38 WAS REALLY -- RECEIVING A LOT OF PAYMENTS THAT I WAS GOING TO TRY
38:45 TO BRING A CROSS-BORDER AND I WANT TO MAKE IT MOST EFFICIENT,
38:46 I WOULD THINK ABOUT USING STABLECOINS RATHER THAN FIAT.
38:53 I WOULD WANT TO USE THE RIGHT STABLECOINS SO THAT I DON'T HAVE
38:57 TO TAKE TOO MUCH CURRENCY RISK COMING BACK TO U.S. DOLLAR.
39:01 WHEN I DO ALL THE PSALMS, I MIGHT DECIDE THAT THE U.S.
39:02 DOLLAR IS MORE COST EFFICIENT FOR ME.
39:05 BUT THAT'S AN IF. I DO BELIEVE THAT THE LOCAL CAN
39:12 SEE -- CURRENCIES STILL HAVE A ROLE TO PLAY.
39:16 GLOBALLY, IT IS STILL THE U.S. DOLLAR.
39:20 HASLINDA: FIVE YEARS, 10 YEARS YOU WILL SEE MULTICURRENCY?
39:24 >> IT'S A LONG TIME. YES.
39:25 I BELIEVE SO. MORE AND MORE LOCAL CURRENCY
39:29 PAYMENTS MOVE TO THE BLOCKCHAIN. THEN YOU WILL SEE THE LOCAL
39:32 CURRENCY COMING IN. HASLINDA: BLOCKCHAIN
39:36 TOKENIZATION. THAT HAS ALLOWED FOR 24/7
39:38 TRADING. THE LIKES OF NVIDIA, APPLE, JP
39:44 MORGAN HAS OPTED OUT. WHAT ARE THE CONCERNS THERE?
39:46 HOW IS THAT BEING ADDRESSED? >> EVERY NEW TECHNOLOGY
39:51 INNOVATION, THERE ARE ALWAYS GOING TO BE CONCERNS.
39:54 IN THIS CASE, THE CONCERN IS ABOUT LIQUIDITY.
39:57 EVERYBODY WANTS IT TO BE CONCENTRATED IN THE ONE PLACE.
40:03 MULTIPLE CHANNELS, THERE'S A CONCERN ABOUT LIQUIDITY.
40:07 THINK ABOUT 24/7 TRADING. THAT IS SOMETHING THAT EVERYBODY
40:09 WANTS. AT WHAT COST?
40:11 WHAT'S THE PRICE FOR IT? LIQUIDITY IS ALWAYS GOING TO BE
40:14 TOP OF MIND. THAT'S TO BE EXPECTED WITH ANY
40:17 NEW TECHNOLOGY. IT TAKES TIME FOR ADOPTION.
40:22 THE EARLY MOVERS HOPEFULLY WILL DEMONSTRATE THE VALUE OF BEING
40:28 THEN OTHERS WILL COME. HASLINDA: WOULDN'T YOU SAY IT'S
40:33 A CHICKEN AND AGE SITUATION FOR LIQUIDITY TO ACTUALLY COME ON
40:36 BOARD WITH THE LIKES OF JP MORGAN, NVIDIA?
40:39 HOW DO YOU SEE THIS BEING RESOLVED?
40:44 >> IT IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE HISTORY OF CRYPTO.
40:47 IT TOOK YEARS. THERE WERE THE BELIEVERS, THE
40:49 EARLY MOVERS. OVER TIME, THEY KEPT MOVING.
40:56 PEOPLE HAD VALID CONCERNS. VOLATILITY AND LIQUIDITY.
40:59 OVER TIME AS DEMAND CAME IN SLOWLY BUT SURELY AND THE
41:05 DIRECTION BECAME VERY CLEAR, THE TRADITIONAL ESTABLISHED
41:05 INSTITUTIONS WILL COME IN AS WELL AND THE SAME WILL PLAY OUT
41:07 HERE. IT'S JUST A MATTER OF TIME.
41:12 HASLINDA: AS YOU LOOK TO THE NEXT 36 MONTHS, HOW ARE YOU
41:14 POSITIONING YOURSELF? WHAT IS THE STRATEGY?
41:20 >> WE'VE SEEN A DEMAND FOR TOKENIZED ASSETS.
41:24 THAT'S GLOBAL. IT'S NOT JUST A -- US.
41:29 IMF TALKING ABOUT HOW QUICKLY THE SPACE HAS GROUND AND HOW
41:34 MUCH OF THE TRADING AND EQUITIES ARE HAPPENING OUTSIDE OUR MARKET
41:36 HOURS. THE DEMAND IS THERE.
41:38 WE'VE HEARD IT FROM OUR CLIENTS. WE'VE LAUNCHED PRODUCTS LIKE
41:41 TOKENIZED EQUITIES. IN EUROPE, TOKENIZED EQUITIES.
41:47 QUICKLY, WE ARE SEEING TOKENIZED EQUITY VOLUME NOW MAKING IT
41:53 ALMOST 8% OF OUR GLOBAL SPOTS TRADING VOLUME WHICH IS
41:56 HISTORY. THAT'S ONE BIG AREA OF FOCUS OF
41:59 COURSE. I'M SURE YOU'VE HEARD ABOUT OUR
42:07 JOINT VENTURE AND WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR U.S. INVESTORS IN THAT
42:07 PART OF THE WORLD. SO THAT'S ON THE TOKEN ISSUE
42:11 ASSET SPACE. WE ALSO BELIEVE IN AI.
42:17 A GENT WE BELIEVE IS GOING TO BE THE NEXT BIG THING.
42:20 IN JUNE, WE LAUNCHED A MARKETPLACE FOR AGENTS.
42:25 WE BELIEVE THAT EACH PERSON, WE CAN HAVE MORE AGENTS THAN
42:27 HUMANS. EACH HUMAN WILL HAVE MULTIPLE
42:32 AGENTS DOING DIFFERENT THINGS FOR US.
42:37 THEN THESE AGENTS HAVE TO DIRECT SERVICES, MAKE PAYMENTS.
42:41 ALL OF THOSE THINGS WE BELIEVE IN.
42:44 THAT'S WHY WE ARE INVESTING HEAVILY.
42:46 HASLINDA: IT'S THE INDEPENDENCE THAT SCARES ME.
42:52 REGIONAL CEO FOR SINGAPORE AND AUSTRALIA AND HAD A VIP GROWTH
42:55 AT OK X. WE ARE COMING TO YOU LIVE FROM
43:00 HERE IN THE LION CITY. YVONNE: GREAT STUFF.
43:04 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT INTERVIEW.
43:09 WE ARE CHECKING TENCENT SHARES. THE STOCK CONTINUES TO SLIDE.
43:14 DOWN 5% RIGHT NOW ON THE BACK OF THEIR EARNINGS.
43:17 ALL THE CONCERNS AROUND WHEN IT CAME TO RECORD HIGH CAPEX,
43:21 THAT'S REALLY DRIVING THE FREE CASH FLOW OUTFLOWS.
43:25 THIS CONTINUED RAMP-UP WHEN IT COMES TO A YOUNG INVESTMENT.
43:27 THAT HAS CERTAINLY LED INVESTORS TO SAY, WHEN IT COMES TO THE
43:34 FLOOR ON EPS, IT LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE TO WAIT TO NEXT YEAR TO GET
43:35 MORE OF THAT. DAVID: WE ARE SEEING A LOT OF
43:39 PRESSURE. THE VOLUMES IN THE FIRST 20
43:43 MINUTES OF TRADE IS NOW TRIPLE THE FULL DAY AVERAGE FOR THE
43:46 LAST 30 DAYS. WE ARE LOOKING AT AN EXTREMELY
43:49 BUSY TRADE. DOWN 5% NOW.
43:53 LOWEST LEVEL GOING BACK TO JULY OF 2024.
43:56 ALL RIGHT. A LOT MORE AHEAD.
43:57 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
44:13 DAVID: ON YOUR SCREENS. PRESIDENT XI JINPING WELCOMING A
44:21 FEW MINUTES BACK. WE HAVE JUST STARTED THE
44:29 WELCOMING BIT OF THE APEC SUMMIT THERE IN SHENZHEN.
44:30 THE CHINESE PRESIDENT IS WELCOMING ALL THE DIGNITARIES
44:36 THAT HAVE COME IN FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD.
44:36 LET'S LISTEN IN. YVONNE: ALL RIGHT.
44:47 WE WILL TRY TO LISTEN IN LATER AS WE HEAR FROM THE IMF DIRECTOR
44:51 ABOUT ALL OF THIS AS WELL. PRESIDENT XI, WE JUST FINISHED
44:56 THE PHOTO OP AS HE GREETED HIS PEERS WITHIN THE AIPAC.
45:04 VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR THAT FAMILY AS WELL.
45:07 WE JUST TALKED ABOUT THAT. CERTAINLY WE ARE LEADING TO THAT
45:10 BILATERAL THAT IS COMING UP. THE HISTORIC TRILATERAL AS WELL
45:17 LATER ON THIS AFTERNOON IN SHENZHEN.
45:21 MUCH MORE AHEAD IN THE SECOND HOUR.
45:22 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
45:46 >> NEW PROSPECTS FOR ASIA-PACIFIC COOPERATION.
45:52 TOGETHER WE MUST TRY TO BUILD AND ASIA-PACIFIC COMMUNITY
45:54 CHARACTERIZED BY MUTUAL ASSISTANCE AND INTEGRATION AS
45:59 WELL AS INCLUSIVE DEVELOPMENT. BUILDING AND ASIA-PACIFIC
46:04 COMMUNITY REQUIRES SOLIDARITY AND MUTUAL ASSISTANCE.
46:08 THE PACIFIC OCEAN WHICH CARRIES THOUSANDS OF SHIPS HAS SHAPED
46:12 THE ALL EMBRACING CHARACTER OF THIS ASIA-PACIFIC REGION, ONE
46:18 DEFINED BY INCLUSIVENESS AND HARMONIOUS COEXISTENCE.
46:20 AIPAC MEMBERS ARE LIKE PASSENGERS RIDING THE SAME
46:29 SHIPP TO NAVIGATE THE WAVES OF THE PACIFIC.
46:30 WE MUST EXPAND OUR SHARED INTERESTS, MEET THE DIFFICULTIES
46:35 AND CHALLENGES TOGETHER, AND STEADILY BUILD A SHARED SENSE OF
46:39 COMMUNITY. BUILDING AND ASIA-PACIFIC
46:44 COMMUNITY REQUIRES OPENNESS AND INTEGRATION.
46:50 OPEN COOPERATION IS A SHORT PATH TO THE DEVELOPMENT AND
46:52 REVITALIZATION OF THE ASIA-PACIFIC.
46:55 WE SHOULD UPHOLD OPEN REGIONALISM, STEADILY ADVANCED
47:02 ECONOMIC INTEGRATION, AND DEVELOP A COOPERATION PATTERN
47:05 THAT'S OPEN AND INTEGRATED RATHER THAN EXCLUSIVE OR
47:06 FRAGMENTED. WE SHOULD CHAMPION FREE AND OPEN
47:12 TRADE AND INVESTMENT, REMOVE IMPEDIMENTS TO THE FLOW OF
47:16 FACTORS, ENSURE THE SMOOTH CIRCULATION OF ECONOMIC
47:21 ASIA-PACIFIC. BUILDING AND ASIA-PACIFIC
47:29 COMMUNITY REQUIRES ENTERPRISE AND INNOVATION.
47:34 INNOVATION IS THE PRIMARY DRIVING FORCE OF DEVELOPMENT.
47:40 IT IS VITAL TO ENCOURAGE SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNOLOGICAL
47:46 EXCHANGES AND COOPERATION, FACILITATE THE COMMERCIALIZATION
47:49 OF INNOVATION OUTCOMES, AND FOSTER AN OPEN FAIR, JUST,
47:53 NONDISCRIMINATORY ENVIRONMENT FOR COOPERATION.
48:02 ENCOURAGE INNOVATION IN INSTITUTIONS AND IDEAS AS WELL
48:06 AS STRUCTURAL REFORM AND FURTHER UNLEASH THE ECONOMIC DYNAMISM
48:08 AND POTENTIAL OF OUR REGION. BUILDING AND ASIA-PACIFIC
48:15 COMMUNITY REQUIRES INCLUSIVE DEVELOPMENT.
48:19 EACH WITH DIFFERENT DEVELOPMENT NEEDS, ASIA-PACIFIC ECONOMIES
48:23 ARE KNOWN FOR DIVERSITY. WE SHOULD ADVANCE COOPERATION
48:32 WHERE CONDITIONS ALLOW, MAKE SURE THAT DEVELOPMENT BENEFITS
48:36 EVERYONE, DELIVER FOR THE PEOPLE.
48:38 ACCOMMODATE THE COMFORT LEVEL OF ALL PARTIES, AND FOSTER
48:44 FAVORABLE CONDITIONS FOR TURNING THE VISION OF AN ASIA-PACIFIC
48:46 COMMUNITY INTO REALITY. DEAR COLLEAGUES, CHINA IS AN
48:54 ADVOCATE, PROMOTER, FORERUNNER OF ASIA-PACIFIC, ECONOMIC
48:56 COOPERATION. WE WOULD LIKE TO WORK WITH ALL
49:03 PARTIES TO PULL WISDOM AND SYNERGY IN BUILDING THE FOUR KEY
49:08 PILLARS OF AN ASIA-PACIFIC COMMUNITY.
49:14 FIRST, WE SHOULD STRENGTHEN THE PILLAR OF ECONOMY AND TRADE.
49:20 THE FREE-TRADE AREA OF THE ASIA-PACIFIC IS A SHARED VISION
49:23 OF AIPAC MEMBERS. IT IS IMPORTANT TO MAKE STEADY
49:27 PROGRESS IN REALIZING THIS VISION AND SETTING A HIGHER
49:30 STANDARD FOR OPENNESS. EFFORTS SHOULD BE MADE TO ALIGN
49:34 VARIOUS ECONOMIC AND TRADE AGREEMENTS OF THE REGION, BOOST
49:38 TRADE AND INVESTMENT FACILITATION AND DIGITALIZATION,
49:43 AND REDUCE BARRIERS TO TRADE AND INVESTMENT.
49:46 IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT TO ENHANCE POLICY DIALOGUE FROM THE
49:50 FREE-TRADE AREA OF THE ASIA-PACIFIC AND CARRY OUT
49:55 TECHNICAL COOPERATION TO HELP THE PARTIES CARRY OUT ECONOMIC
49:58 TRADE ARRANGEMENTS. SECOND, WE SHOULD UPGRADE THE
50:04 PILLAR OF CONNECTIVITY. CONNECTIVITY IS A NEXUS OF
50:09 REGIONAL ECONOMIC INTEGRATION. IN 2014, WE JOINTLY DEVELOP THE
50:12 AIPAC CONNECTIVITY BLUEPRINT. TODAY, THERE ARE NEW
50:18 OPPORTUNITIES FOR REGIONAL CONNECTIVITY.
50:23 WE SHOULD STRENGTHEN PHYSICAL CONNECTIVITY BY IMPROVING THE
50:27 INFRASTRUCTURE NETWORK. AND DEVELOPING SMART CUSTOMS AND
50:34 SMART TRANSPORTATION. WE SHOULD DEEPEN INSTITUTIONAL
50:40 CONNECTIVITY BY HARMONIZING POLICIES AND REGULATIONS.
50:44 DEEPENING COOPERATION ON CROSS-BORDER PAYMENT AND KEEPING
50:50 INDUSTRIAL AND SUPPLY CHAINS STABLE AND UNIMPEDED.
50:54 WE SHOULD ALSO ENHANCE PEOPLE TO PEOPLE CONNECTIVITY BY
51:00 FACILITATING TRAVEL FOR BUSINESS , TOURISM, AND OTHER PURPOSES
51:04 AND PROMOTE CULTURAL EXCHANGES FOR BETTER MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING
51:07 AND CLOSER TIES AMONG OUR PEOPLE.
51:10 THIRD, WE SHOULD FOSTER A PILLAR OF INNOVATION.
51:14 THE DIGITAL ECONOMY AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ARE THE
51:19 ENGINES OF GROWTH. WE SHOULD STRENGTHEN THE DIGITAL
51:22 INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT, IMPROVE DATA GOVERNANCE, AND
51:24 COLLABORATION IN THE REGION. AND ACHIEVE EFFICIENT,
51:30 CONVENIENT, AND SECURE CROSS-BORDER DATAFLOW.
51:35 WE SHOULD BUILD AN OPEN ECOSYSTEM FOR INNOVATION,
51:39 ENCOURAGE THE BROAD APPLICATION OF AI, AND PROMOTE THE
51:46 INNOVATION DRIVEN TRANSFORMATION AND UPGRADING OF INDUSTRIES.
51:49 FOURTH. WE SHOULD ENHANCE THE PILLAR OF
51:54 DEVELOPMENT TO RESPOND TO CONSTANTLY EMERGING GLOBAL
51:58 CHALLENGES WHICH SHOULD STRENGTHEN CAPACITY BUILDING,
52:01 PROMOTE REGIONAL COOPERATION ON ENERGY AND FOOD SECURITY, AND
52:04 DEEPEN ANTICORRUPTION GOVERNANCE ACROSS BORDERS.
52:07 WE NOW COURT MADE THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE RESOURCES,
52:13 THE ENVIRONMENT, AND POPULATION, SCALE UP THE RATIONAL
52:15 UTILIZATION AND PROTECTION OF NATURAL RESOURCES, AND EXPAND
52:21 GREEN AND LOW CARBON COOPERATION TO ACHIEVE SUSTAINABLE ECONOMIC
52:24 GROWTH. WE SHOULD SUPPORT LIVELIHOOD
52:26 IMPROVEMENTS AND INVEST THE PEOPLE, LAUNCH HEALTHY AGING
52:33 PROGRAMS, FACILITATE EMPLOYMENT AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF
52:36 VOCATIONAL SKILLS, AND SUPPORT WOMEN'S ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT AND
52:39 YOUNG TALENT EXCHANGES. TO TAP INTO THE FULL POTENTIAL
52:46 OF TALENT ACROSS THE ASIA-PACIFIC.
52:52 CHINA IS ROOTED IN THE ASIA-PACIFIC.
52:56 AND WILL CONTINUE TO SUPPORT ASIA-PACIFIC COOPERATION.
53:01 I HEREBY ANNOUNCE THAT CHINA WILL PROVIDE 20 MILLION U.S.
53:07 DOLLARS TO SUPPORT APEX PRACTICAL COOPERATION.
53:13 WE WILL ESTABLISH A CENTER FOR ASIA-PACIFIC COMMUNITY STUDIES
53:18 IN SHENZHEN TO CONDUCT POLICY RESEARCH AND EXCHANGES AND
53:23 PROVIDE INTELLECTUAL SUPPORT. IN LINE WITH NEEDS OF
53:28 ASIA-PACIFIC COOPERATION, WE WILL SET UP COOPERATION
53:32 INSTITUTIONS IN SUCH AREAS AS DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY, CROSS-BORDER
53:36 DATAFLOW, CLEAN ENERGY, AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF SME'S.
53:41 TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE INNOVATION DRIVEN AND GREEN GROWTH IN THE
53:46 ASIA-PACIFIC. DEAR COLLEAGUES.
53:48 SHENZHEN IS KNOWN AS THE CITY OF THE ROCK, NAMED AFTER A
53:53 I HOPE THAT WITH OUR JOINT EFFORTS, ASIA-PACIFIC
53:56 COOPERATION WILL SPREAD ITS RINGS -- WINGS AND FLY TO A
54:00 BRIGHT FUTURE. THANK YOU.
54:10 YVONNE: ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT.
54:15 PRESIDENT XI ADDRESSING AIPAC OF COURSE AS WE COUNT DOWN TO MANY
54:19 HISTORIC MEETINGS THAT ARE HAPPENING HERE IN THE NEXT
54:21 COUPLE HOURS. OF COURSE BEFORE THAT, THE
54:27 BILATERAL WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP. LET'S BRING BACK STEPHEN ENGLE,
54:30 JOINING US NOW FROM SHENZHEN. YOUR TAKEAWAYS FROM THAT SPEECH
54:33 FROM XI? STEPHEN: OBVIOUSLY THE LATEST
54:41 HEADLINE, HE WILL BE PLANNING FOR A PETCO OPERATION.
54:44 GOING TO BUILD A CENTER HERE FOR POLICY RESEARCH AND THE LIKE.
54:49 IT'S NOT A LOT OF MONEY BUT IT IS AN INDICATION OF THEIR PLEDGE
54:55 TO BUILD MORE OF A MULTILATERAL WORLD ESPECIALLY IN THIS PART OF
54:56 THE WORLD. FULLY ON BOARD WITH THAT
55:01 MULTILATERAL APPROACH THROUGH THE 21 MEMBER NATIONS.
55:04 OF COURSE, HE HAS TO PROPEL THIS MESSAGING AS THE HOST THIS YEAR.
55:09 REALLY PULLING OUT ALL THE GUNS HERE FOR AIPAC SUPPORT IN
55:13 SHENZHEN. THE CITY IS ON LOCKDOWN AS ALL
55:17 THESE LEADERS ARE HERE. THERE'S BANNERS AND THE ENTIRE
55:24 CITY IS BEDECKED WITH SIGNAGE. ALSO, HE'S TALKING ABOUT BEING
55:30 AN ADVOCATE. CHINA IS AN ADVOCATE.
55:34 AND A PROMOTER OF ASIA-PACIFIC COOPERATION.
55:38 THEY BELIEVE IN OPEN ECOSYSTEM FOR INNOVATION AND COOPERATION.
55:42 OF COURSE, BACK TO SHENZHEN. SHENZHEN BEING THE CAPITAL OF
55:49 INDIGENOUS INNOVATION. ONE MIGHT CALL IT CHINA'S
55:54 SILICON VALLEY OR ONE OF THEM, AS CHINA BATTLES SOME OF THE
56:01 BIFURCATION IN THE TECH WORLD AND AI EXPORT CONTROLS BY
56:01 BOOSTING AND SPENDING HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF THEIR
56:03 OWN INDIGENOUS INNOVATION. MENNONITE OF IT -- MANY OF IT
56:08 DONE RIGHT HERE IN SHENZHEN. DAVID: STEVE, LOTS OF MEETINGS
56:14 ON THE SIDELINES. LOTS OF FORMAL BILATERAL
56:15 MEETINGS. OBVIOUSLY PEOPLE ARE POSITIONING
56:23 OR LOOKING TO CEMENT THEIR POSITIONS, LOOKING TO FIGURE OUT
56:25 DEALS AHEAD OF THE CUTE -- CRUCIAL TRILATERAL.
56:30 IS THERE ANYTHING THAT IS CAUGHT YOUR EYE?
56:34 STEPHEN: THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL BILATERAL'S YESTERDAY INCLUDING
56:38 BETWEEN TRUMP AND MARK CARNEY AND TRUMP WITH CLAUDIA
56:40 SHEINBAUM. THE NORTH AMERICAN COUNTRIES AND
56:48 ECONOMIES REPRESENTED HERE, THERE'S IS BEEN DIFFICULT
56:51 NEGOTIATIONS NO DOUBT BETWEEN THE U.S. AND CANADA.
56:55 MARK CARNEY SAYING ITS TWO STEPS FORWARD, ONE STEP BACK.
56:59 BOTH SIDES ARE HOPEFUL THAT THEY CAN MEET COMMON GROUND.
57:03 HOPEFULLY THEY WILL BE ABLE TO DO THAT.
57:09 ALSO, SEEING SOME PROGRESS IN NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE AMERICANS.
57:12 WE ARE HEARING AS WELL SOME BACK CHATTER.
57:20 WITH STEPHEN MILLER TAKING OVER AS THE CHIEF ADVISOR TO THE
57:24 WHITE HOUSE, ESSENTIALLY, THERE COULD BE MORE IMMIGRATION ISSUES
57:28 TIED TO ANY KIND OF TRADE AGREEMENT.
57:32 THAT COULD POSSIBLY DERAIL THAT PROGRESS.
57:35 SHE SAYS MOST OF THE CONVERSATIONS WERE ON THE
57:40 ECONOMIC AND TRADE FRONT. NOT NECESSARILY THE BORDER
57:41 ISSUES. SPINNING IT FORWARD TO THE
57:48 BILATERAL LATER TODAY. AFTER THESE CEREMONIES THAT ARE
57:52 HAPPENING RIGHT NOW AND THE SPEECHES WE HEARD.
58:00 THAT TRILATERAL IS WHAT WE ARE ALL WANTING TO HEAR ABOUT AND
58:02 WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO TALK ABOUT.
58:05 DENUCLEARIZATION. THAT'S A TRICKY ONE FOR BEIJING
58:07 TO TALK ABOUT. RUSSIA AND THE UNITED STATES
58:15 HAVE LARGER STOCKPILES OF NUCLEAR WEAPONS.
58:19 WE ARE HEARING THAT DONALD TRUMP GAVE THIS INTERVIEW THAT THEY
58:25 ARE NOT NECESSARILY GOING TO BE SEEKING RUSSIA OR CHINA'S HELP
58:27 IN THE AROUND MORE. THAT LEAVES THE QUESTION, WHAT
58:35 ARE THEY GOING TO TALK ABOUT? U.S. OFFICIALS HAVE SAID THAT
58:41 THEY ARE NOT GOING TO NECESSARILY BRING UP THE WAR IN
58:44 UKRAINE IN THE TRILATERAL MEETING TODAY.
58:52 WHAT WILL COME OUT OF THAT MEETING OTHER THAN HAVING
58:55 VLADIMIR PUTIN ELEVATED ON THE GLOBAL STAGE?
58:59 GIVING HIM AN AUDIENCE WHERE HE'S NOT NECESSARILY WELCOME IN
59:00 OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD. BETWEEN XI AND TRUMP, THAT WILL
59:05 BE THE THIRD BILATERAL MEETING THIS YEAR.
59:09 STILL A LOT OF UNFINISHED BUSINESS.
59:12 AI TOGGLE -- DIALOGUE COMPLICATED BY THE REMOTE ACCESS
59:16 ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH NVIDIA AND THE INDUSTRIAL ESPIONAGE
59:17 ALLEGATIONS. THAT COULD BE SOME AREAS WHERE
59:23 THE TWO LEADERS WILL TRY TO FIND SOME COMMON GROUND.
59:28 DAVID: THANK YOU SO MUCH. ABSOLUTELY.
59:33 GOING THROUGH POTENTIALLY SOME OF THE TALKING POINTS IN THE
59:34 HISTORIC TRILATERAL THAT'S COMING UP.
59:37 SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WE ALREADY KNOW.
59:41 LESS THAN THREE WEEKS IF THINGS GO TO SCHEDULE.
59:44 THE TWO PRESIDENTS WILL MEET AGAIN IN THE U.S. AHEAD OF US
59:51 SOMEWHAT OF A DEADLINE. JUST OVER 50 DAYS AWAY FROM WHEN
59:54 THE TRADE TRUTHS, THE TARIFF DEADLINE EXPIRES THE FIRST 10
1:00:01 DAYS OF 2027. SUBSCRIBERS CAN CHECK OUT OUR
1:00:02 COVERAGE HERE. WHAT WE KNOW, CONTACT, SIZE,
1:00:06 SCOPE. LOTS MORE AHEAD.
1:00:11 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:00:34 DAVID: WE ARE NOW DOWN A SIX DAY ON THE BENCHMARK.
1:00:37 NOT EVEN THE GAINS AND JAPAN OFFSETTING EVERYTHING ELSE.
1:00:40 TAIWAN DOWN 3%. THE BIG MOVES ACROSS THE SCREENS
1:00:42 COMING UP SHORTLY. TSMC.
1:00:46 TENCENT IS THE BIG ONE. ALIBABA DOWN ABOUT 5%.
1:00:49 WE ARE DOWN 6% NOW. THAT'S REALLY CATCHING THE KNIFE
1:00:56 AT THIS POINT IN TIME. VOLUMES HAVE BEEN SUBSTANTIALLY
1:00:56 HEAVY. DOWN 15% FROM THE PEAK VIA THIS
1:01:03 BEARISH CROSS THAT IS LOOMING LARGE.
1:01:07 THAT LOOKS LIKE IT'S IMMINENT. THAT'S GOING TO DO THAT FOR YOU.
1:01:15 BEAR MARKET JUST ALSO HAPPENS TO BE THE TROUGH FOR THE YEAR.
1:01:18 OBVIOUSLY A LEVEL TO WATCH. YVONNE: LET'S BRING IN OUR
1:01:22 EQUITY STRATEGIST WHO JOINS US NOW.
1:01:26 THIS IS HAPPENING AHEAD OF THE ANTHROPIC DEBUT.
1:01:28 WONDERING WHAT'S TOP OF MIND FOR YOU, WHAT'S DRIVING THIS
1:01:29 SENTIMENT RIGHT NOW? >> YEAH.
1:01:37 FOR ASIAN MARKETS, IT'S BEEN A TOUGH MULTI-MONTH TIME WITH
1:01:40 SEMICONDUCTOR STOCKS HAVING A TOUGH TIME.
1:01:44 REALLY THAT ALL THE NEWS AROUND JENSEN, WHAT THAT MEANS FOR THE
1:01:51 BROADER AI ECOSYSTEM AND FUNDING FOR THE BROADER AI ECOSYSTEM.
1:01:53 IT'S ALL UP IN THE AIR NOW. SO THERE HASN'T BEEN A LOT OF
1:01:58 CATALYSTS. AND THEN TO MAKE MATTERS WORSE,
1:02:01 WE'VE SEEN A ROLLOVER AND COMMODITY MARKETS, PARTICULARLY
1:02:04 COPPER. COPPER IS SEEN AS A METAL THAT
1:02:06 GIVES A PREDICTIVE ELEMENT TO THE GLOBAL ECONOMY.
1:02:11 ALL THESE NEGATIVE THINGS HAVE COME TOGETHER AND POSITIONING
1:02:13 HAS BEEN WASHED OUT. MARKETS REALLY THINKING AS
1:02:19 ANTHROPIC COULD BE A CATALYST POTENTIALLY TO GET THE AI TRADE
1:02:20 BACK ON TRACK. DAVID: HOW MUCH OF THIS IS JUST
1:02:30 THE FED? COPPER, GOLD AS WELL.
1:02:34 IS THAT AN UNDERAPPRECIATED RISK RIGHT NOW THAT WE NEED TO BE
1:02:37 MORE ATTUNED TO? SUNNY: YEAH.
1:02:42 I THINK THAT'S A VERY GOOD POINT.
1:02:47 YOU CAN ALMOST SAY WHEN JACKSON HOLE WAS A TURNING POINT FOR THE
1:02:49 BOND MARKET IN THE U.S.. THAT'S MANIFESTING NOW IN RISK
1:03:06 ASSETS. REAL YIELDS HAVE RISEN IN THE
1:03:13 U.S.. WHAT THE FED HAS TO DO IS
1:03:18 ULTIMATELY LOOK AT THE INFLATION DATA AGAINST CREDIBILITY.
1:03:23 THERE ARE SOME FLASHING WARNING SIGNS.
1:03:26 WE MENTIONED COPPER. BANK STOCKS IN THE U.S..
1:03:31 EARLY WARNING CYCLICAL SIGNS. SO I WOULD SAY THERE ARE SOME
1:03:36 FLASHING SIGNS FOR THE FED TO WATCH.
1:03:43 WON'T BE A VERY INTERESTING IN THE FOMC.
1:03:44 SOMETHING INVESTORS ARE GETTING NERVOUS AS WE HEAD INTO THE
1:03:47 YEARS AND. DAVID: QUITE THE OPPOSITE OF
1:03:51 THAT OF COURSE. OUR EQUITY STRATEGIST THERE.
1:03:56 JUST A TAKE ON EQUITY MARKETS CURRENTLY.
1:03:59 WE SHOWED YOU TENCENT. DOWN 6% ON THE STOCK.
1:04:04 I THINK THE STOCK IS DOWN TO THE LOWEST GOING BACK TO JULY OF
1:04:06 2024. A LOT OF HEAVY INVESTMENT GOING
1:04:09 INTO THE AI SPACE. MANAGEMENT IS ACKNOWLEDGING
1:04:15 THESE HIGH COSTS CURRENTLY. THAT SENDS UP DIFFERENTLY BUT
1:04:20 TODAY. LET'S BRING IN OUR SENIOR
1:04:24 ANALYST ROBYN LEE. YOUR TAKE ON TENCENT?
1:04:30 >> SIMILAR STORY, SIMILAR CONCERNS WE'VE SEEN FOR THE LAST
1:04:31 TWO QUARTERS. RAMPING AI INVESTMENT COSTS PLUS
1:04:38 AGENTIC IS HEAVILY DEPRESSING THE MARGINS.
1:04:41 TIME WHEN WE'VE GOT NO REAL VISIBILITY ON WHEN THIS HEAVY
1:04:45 INVESTMENT IS GOING TO DELIVER A FINANCIAL RETURN.
1:04:49 IT IS CERTAINLY NOT GOING TO BE IN THE NEXT 12 TO 24 MONTHS.
1:04:54 JUST TO GIVE SOME BALANCE, TENCENT IS CLEARLY CHINA'S
1:04:55 LARGEST LISTED TECHNOLOGY COMPANY.
1:05:00 WITH MARKET LEADERSHIP. STRUCTURALLY HIGH MARGINS VERSUS
1:05:01 THE PEER GROUP. SILENCE -- SOLID BALANCE SHEET.
1:05:08 IT CAN WITHSTAND THESE PRESSURES .
1:05:09 I THINK INVESTORS ARE GOING TO HAVE TO BE VERY PATIENT IN ORDER
1:05:15 TO GAIN ANY FINANCIAL RETURN. AS YOU SAID IN YOUR INTRO, CHINA
1:05:20 STOCKS, ASIAN STOCKS UNDER PRESSURE FOR ALL THE OBVIOUS
1:05:20 REASONS. MOST PEOPLE WOULD DESCRIBE THE
1:05:25 CHINA TECH SECTOR AS A VALUE TRAP.
1:05:28 DAVID: THE TIMELINE IS AT LEAST TWO YEARS.
1:05:31 HOW PATIENT DO WE NEED TO BE? ROBERT: THIS IS OUR BEST
1:05:34 ESTIMATE. WE ARE WORKING IN A DATA POOR
1:05:36 ENVIRONMENT. THESE COMPANIES ARE FORGING NEW
1:05:40 GROUND, AREN'T THEY? AI IS A NEW TECHNOLOGY.
1:05:48 I THINK ON A SECTOR VIEW, WE EXPECT THE CHINA TECH SECTOR IN
1:05:51 TERMS OF AI DEVELOPMENT TO BE LOSSMAKING ONCE YOU FACTOR IN
1:05:58 CAPEX FOR THE NEXT THREE YEARS UNTIL 2030.
1:06:00 THAT'S OUR BEST ESTIMATE AS IT STANDS AT THE MOMENT.
1:06:03 YVONNE: CAN WE LOOK AT ALIBABA IN THE SAME LENS AS WELL?
1:06:08 AWFULLY ASLEEP -- OBVIOUSLY IT'S AN AWKWARD TIME.
1:06:11 THERE'S ALSO A LOT OF SPECULATION ABOUT WHAT ALIBABA
1:06:17 WILL BE ABLE TO ACCESS SOME OF THESE NVIDIA TRIPS AS WELL IN
1:06:20 THE FACE OF THIS SCANDAL. ROBERT: THAT'S TRUE.
1:06:26 IT'S BEEN NOTABLE THAT TENCENT HASN'T BEEN NAMED IN ANY OF
1:06:27 THESE DISCLOSURES. WHETHER IT'S DISTILLATION OR
1:06:32 ALLEGATIONS OR ACCESSING FOREIGN DATA CENTERS.
1:06:35 A VERY CONSERVATIVE COMPANY. ALIBABA DEFINITELY HAS.
1:06:42 WE NEED TO TAKE A STEP BACK AND REMEMBER THAT ALIBABA IS AN
1:06:46 E-COMMERCE BUSINESS. THE OUTLOOK FOR E-COMMERCE AND
1:06:51 RETAIL SPENDING IN CHINA IS UNDER SOME PRESSURE AT THE
1:06:53 MOMENT. WE SAW A RETAIL SALES COME OUT
1:06:57 AND ACTUALLY DISAPPOINT IN OCTOBER.
1:06:58 UP 0.4%. CONSIDERABLE PRESSURE IN TERMS
1:07:03 OF RETAIL SPENDING. JD.COM REPORT.
1:07:07 AGAIN, THAT DISAPPOINTED. NEGATIVE REACTION.
1:07:14 UNDOUBTEDLY, MARGIN PRESSURE ON THE E-COMMERCE SECTOR.
1:07:15 BECAUSE IT'S NOT JUST A MACRO HEADWIND BUT A RAMPANT LEVEL OF
1:07:20 COMPETITION. IS THE CLOUD BUSINESS GOING TO
1:07:23 OFFSET? NO.
1:07:26 THE RISK IS THAT WE SEE FURTHER DOWNGRADES TO CONSENSUS
1:07:31 ESTIMATES WITH THE RISK THAT THE MARKET DOESN'T TAKE THESE
1:07:33 NUMBERS PARTICULARLY WELL FOR ME.
1:07:42 YVONNE: MUCH MORE WHEN IT COMES TO EARNINGS IN A FEW MOMENTS.
1:07:47 SEE KH GROUP CFO WILL BE WITH US AFTER THE FASTEST GROWTH IN
1:07:52 REVENUE SINCE THE IPO. THE INTERVIEW IS COMING UP NEXT.
1:07:55 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:08:13 DAVID: ALL RIGHT. TOUGH DAY.
1:08:15 TOUGH DAY FOR CHINESE TECH. TENCENT, SESSION LOWS.
1:08:23 SECOND OR STAY GOING BACK TO LIBERATION DAY.
1:08:27 YVONNE: LOOKS SET TO WIPE OUT ALL OF THE GAINS THAT WE'VE SEEN
1:08:31 SINCE SEPTEMBER 2024. THE BIGGEST DROP SINCE JULY ON
1:08:35 THE BACK OF THOSE EARNINGS. THE AI SPENDING CONCERNS.
1:08:39 THAT CERTAINLY IS ONE THING THAT IS LEADING TO CONCERNS AROUND
1:08:41 THE SELL SIDE OF THINGS TODAY. ON THE FLIPSIDE, PONY AI.
1:08:45 THEY CAME OUT WITH EARNINGS AS WELL.
1:08:48 NOW WHAT WE ARE SEEING HERE, THIRD QUARTER REVENUE DID BEAT
1:08:50 ESTIMATES. ROBOTAXI BUSINESS HAS EXPANDED
1:08:54 AS WELL. IT SEEMS LIKE THE STREET IS NOT
1:08:57 LIKING THE RESULTS. DOWN 11%.
1:08:59 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:09:15 YVONNE: LIVE PICTURES OUT OF SHENZHEN HERE.
1:09:19 PRESIDENT TRUMP AND XI JINPING. THE PRESIDENT ADDRESSING THE 21
1:09:22 NATIONS HERE OF APEC HERE. DAY 2 OF THE SUMMIT IN THE TECH HUB.
1:09:29 LATER, HISTORIC SUMMIT BY VLADIMIR PUTIN.
1:09:33 WENT AS WELL AS PRESIDENT TRUMP WITH THE CHINESE PRESIDENT.
1:09:39 WE JUST HEARD FROM THE PRESIDENT NOT LONG AGO TALKING ABOUT
1:09:41 CHAMPION FREE OPEN TRADE. WE TALKED ABOUT BEING PASSENGERS
1:09:46 IN THE SAME SHIP. THE NEED FOR MORE A PET
1:09:51 COOPERATION. 20 MILLION U.S. DOLLARS FOR THAT
1:09:55 COOPERATION THERE. CERTAINLY THERE'S A LOT PLAYING
1:10:00 OUT TODAY AND WE WILL BE WATCHING CLOSELY ON THAT AS
1:10:01 WELL. WE ARE ALSO LOOKING AT EARNINGS
1:10:04 AS WELL. WE HAVE A LOT MORE TO UNPACK ON
1:10:09 THE CHINA TECH STORY. >> U.S. LISTED CHINESE FIRM Z KA
1:10:16 HERE. INDUSTRIAL SUPPLIES.
1:10:21 IF YOU WANT TO SOURCE INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENT, THIS IS ONE OF THE
1:10:22 PLACES YOU GO. WHEN YOU LOOK AT THEIR QUARTER
1:10:28 NUMBERS, WE ARE BACK PROFITABLE. FASTEST YEAR ON YEAR REVENUE
1:10:32 GROWTH SINCE ITS IPO BACK ABOUT THREE YEARS BACK.
1:10:35 JOINING US EXCLUSIVELY TO DISCUSS THIS, THE COMPANY CFO.
1:10:41 GOOD MORNING. THANK YOU FOR COMING ON THE
1:10:42 SHOW. TALK ABOUT THE PROFIT NUMBER.
1:10:46 SOLIDLY IN PROFIT. THE QUESTION FOR INVESTORS IS,
1:10:53 CAN YOU SUSTAINED MOVING FORWARD?
1:10:58 >> YES. GOOD MORNING EVERYONE.
1:10:59 HAPPY TO BE ON BLOOMBERG. INDEED, WE ENJOYED A VERY STRONG
1:11:07 EXPECTATIONS. THIS IS ALSO THE STRONGEST
1:11:12 QUARTERLY PERFORMANCE SINCE THE COMPANY'S IPO.
1:11:17 WE DO BELIEVE THAT SUCH GROWTH MOMENTUM AND PROFITABILITY
1:11:19 TURNAROUND WILL BE ABLE TO SUSTAIN.
1:11:23 I THINK THAT THERE ARE SEVERAL DRIVERS BEHIND IT.
1:11:28 FIRSTLY, WE ARE INDUSTRIAL SUPPLY COMPANY.
1:11:30 MANY TARGETING CHINA MANUFACTURING SECTOR.
1:11:34 SO AS WE SEE THE CHINA MANUFACTURING ESPECIALLY
1:11:37 HIGH-END MANUFACTURING, IT'S RELATIVELY ROBUST.
1:11:41 THE SECTOR IS DRIVEN BY STRONG SUPPORT AND ALSO GLOBAL AI
1:11:46 INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT HEARING IN ALSO WHAT WE SEE THIS
1:11:51 YEAR IS A CLEAR TREND OF MARKET CONSOLIDATION WHERE LEADING
1:11:57 PLAYERS ARE GAINING MARKET SHARE AGAINST COMPETITORS.
1:12:00 WE DO BELIEVE SUCH GROWTH MOMENTUM AND PROFITABILITY WILL
1:12:04 BE ABLE TO SUSTAIN FOR THE FORESEEABLE FUTURE.
1:12:07 YVONNE: YOU ARE ABLE TO DELIVER SOME PRETTY SOLID NUMBERS
1:12:11 AGAINST THIS BACKDROP OF CHINA'S ECONOMY WHERE INVESTMENT HAS
1:12:17 BEEN STRUGGLING ALL YEAR ROUND ALREADY.
1:12:19 WHAT IS YOUR OUTLOOK? YOU MENTIONED EXPORTS WHEN IT
1:12:25 COMES TO TECH AND ALL THINGS. DO YOU SEE THAT CONTINUE TO STAY
1:12:28 ROBUST? WHAT IS YOUR OUTLOOK WHEN IT
1:12:32 COMES TO THE EXPORTS SIDE OF THINGS?
1:12:37 JERRY: YES. FROM THE DATA, WE CAN SEE FROM
1:12:42 THE COMPANY PERSPECTIVE, THE VOLUME IS PARTICULARLY STRONG
1:12:45 FOR SECTORS INCLUDING FACTORY AUTOMATION, SEMICONDUCTORS,
1:12:52 ELECTRONICS, AND ALSO METALS, UTILITIES.
1:13:00 I THINK THE OVERALL SUBSECTORS WITHIN THE GREATER CHINA
1:13:01 MACROECONOMY IS PERFORMING RELATIVELY BETTER.
1:13:05 AND ANOTHER THING I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT IS CURRENTLY, THE
1:13:11 CHINA MARKET IS VERY FRAGMENTED. FOR EXAMPLE, THE CR 10 IN CHINA
1:13:17 ONLY ACCOUNTS FOR ABOUT 2% OF THE MARKET SHARE IN CHINA.
1:13:21 WE LOOK AT THAT NUMBER IN THE U.S., IT'S ABOUT 45%.
1:13:25 THIS IS NOT ONLY ABOUT THE ORGANIC GROWTH OF THE UNDERLYING
1:13:31 ECONOMY AND THE MANUFACTURING SECTOR.
1:13:36 BUT ALSO ABOUT IN ORGANICALLY HOW LEADING PLAYERS ARE GOING TO
1:13:39 GAIN MARKET SHARE AGAINST THE TRADITIONAL DISTRIBUTORS,
1:13:42 DEALERS, AND MOM-AND-POP SHOPS. I THINK THIS IS REALLY WHERE THE
1:13:48 VOLUME -- VALUE IS COMING FROM. DAVID: MAINTENANCE REPAIR AND
1:13:54 OVERHAUL IS THE MARKET. SO YOU TALKED ABOUT, THE OVERALL
1:14:02 TIDE IN THE INDUSTRY IS IN YOUR FAVOR.
1:14:05 THE BIGGER PLAYERS YOU MENTION BECAUSE THERE'S CONSOLIDATION.
1:14:08 ARE YOU LOOKING TO ACQUIRE ANY OF THE SMALLER PLAYERS?
1:14:12 IS THAT SOMETHING YOU ARE ACTIVELY LOOKING AT?
1:14:14 BUYING ASSETS. JERRY: NOT REALLY BUYING ASSETS.
1:14:20 WE MAN GROWTH THROUGH OUR ORGANIC GROWTH.
1:14:24 WE COMPETE WITH OUR COMPETITORS TO GAIN MARKET SHARE.
1:14:27 OF COURSE, WE ARE LOOKING OPTIMISTICALLY AT POTENTIAL
1:14:30 ACQUISITION OPPORTUNITIES. THAT'S MAINLY ABOUT OUR PRIVATE
1:14:37 LABEL PRODUCTS, PRIVATE-LABEL DEVELOPMENT.
1:14:38 WE WANT TO GO A LITTLE BIT UPSTREAM TO STRENGTHEN OUR
1:14:41 PRODUCT CAPABILITY. YVONNE: WHEN IT COMES TO YOUR
1:14:50 INTERNATIONAL EXPANSION, CAN YOU TALK ABOUT WHAT EFFORTS YOU ARE
1:14:51 DOING ON THAT FRONT? HAS THERE BEEN ANY SORT OF
1:14:54 IMPACT FROM GEOPOLITICAL TENSIONS?
1:14:58 WE'VE SEEN WITH THE U.S. AND CHINA RIGHT NOW, OBVIOUSLY
1:15:01 THERE'S A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW THIS IMPACTS THE BUSINESSES
1:15:04 THAT YOU DEAL WITH AS WELL. THE TARIFF IMPACT.
1:15:10 JERRY: YES. SO INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS IS
1:15:12 GROWING VERY FAST. OVERALL, LESS THAN 2% OF OUR
1:15:15 GLE. SO FROM THE INTERNATIONAL
1:15:21 EXPANSION PERSPECTIVE, WE ARE MAINLY ADOPTING TWO APPROACHES.
1:15:24 THE APPROACH IS TO ACCOMPANY CHINESE MANUFACTURERS OVERSEAS,
1:15:27 DEVELOP OVERSEAS. THIS PART IS MAINLY LEVERAGING
1:15:32 OUR EXISTING CLIENT RELATIONSHIPS IN CHINA.
1:15:36 INTEGRATING THEIR OVERSEAS SUPPLY CHAIN WITH THEIR CHINA
1:15:37 SUPPLY CHAIN. THE SECOND PART IS REALLY ABOUT
1:15:42 LOCALIZED OPERATIONS AND INTERNATIONAL MARKETS.
1:15:46 THAT'S MAINLY IN THE U.S.. THEN COMING BACK TO YOUR
1:15:48 QUESTION ABOUT THE TRADE TENSIONS.
1:15:51 I THINK THERE'S VERY LITTLE IMPACT FOR TRADE AND GEOPOLITICS
1:15:56 ON THE BUSINESS LIKE US. BECAUSE ALMOST 99 PERCENT OF OUR
1:16:01 GMP IS IN CHINA. ALMOST THE VAST MAJORITY OF OUR
1:16:06 SOURCING IS ALSO FROM CHINA. SO THERE'S VERY LITTLE IMPACT
1:16:10 FROM THE IMPORT AND EXPORT PERSPECTIVE.
1:16:15 DAVID: I NEED TO ASK YOU. THIS IS OBVIOUSLY NOT FULLY
1:16:18 UNDER THE CRUST -- CONTROL. WHAT ARE INVESTORS MISSING HERE?
1:16:36 PRICE? JERRY: WE SAW SIGNIFICANT SHARE
1:16:47 PLACE DECLINE SINCE THE START OF OCTOBER.
1:16:49 THAT'S MAINLY DUE TO ONE OF OUR IPO INVESTORS HAVING TO SELL A
1:16:52 STAKE IN THE COMPANY HAS THEIR FUND IS COMING TO AN END.
1:16:57 CLEARLY THIS IS NOT REFLECTING THE FUNDAMENTALS OF OUR COMPANY.
1:17:10 WE PROJECT EVEN STRONGER REVENUE AND GROWTH.
1:17:12 AS WE FURTHER SCALE UP OUR BUSINESS.
1:17:15 IN TERMS OF THE SHAREHOLDER RETURN, WE WILL LOOK CELEBRATE
1:17:21 -- ACCELERATE OUR SHARE BUYBACK PROGRAM.
1:17:23 WE'VE AUTHORIZED A BUYBACK PROGRAM.
1:17:27 SO FAR WE'VE ONLY UTILIZED 20% OF IT.
1:17:31 DEFINITELY IN THE NEXT QUARTER, NEXT YEAR, WE WILL ACCELERATE ON
1:17:33 THAT. YVONNE: GREAT TO HAVE YOU.
1:17:38 THANK YOU FOR JOINING US. CFO AT CK H GROUP.
1:17:43 AIPAC AND SHENZHEN. PRESIDENT TRUMP WAS SPEAKING.
1:17:50 REPORTING -- ACCORDING TO REPORTERS THERE, TRUMP PREVIEWED
1:17:56 TRADE WHEN IT COMES TO HIS REMARKS ON AIPAC.
1:18:00 HE DOES OPPOSE REGULATIONS THAT WOULD STIFLE THE INDUSTRY.
1:18:07 NVIDIA, TITAN TO CHIP CONTROLS FROM THE U.S. AFTER THIS BIG
1:18:11 SAGA WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA. THAT'S ONE THING WE ARE TRACKING
1:18:13 HERE TODAY. STEPHEN ENGLE JOINING US NOW
1:18:19 FROM SHENZHEN WITH THE LATEST. STEPHEN: WE ARE GETTING SOME
1:18:26 CLUES AS TO HOW AND WHERE DONALD TRUMP MIGHT LEAD THE
1:18:29 CONVERSATION WHEN HE HAS THAT BY LACK AFTER THIS SESSION WITH XI
1:18:36 JINPING. I HAD HIM APPEAR ON THE SCREEN
1:18:38 JUST A SECOND AGO. HE OPPOSED ANY RULES THAT WOULD
1:18:44 STIFLE THE AI INDUSTRY. THAT IS SIMILAR TO THE VERBIAGE
1:18:48 SHE USED AT THE TIME OF THE LAST SUMMIT WITH XI JINPING IN
1:18:51 SEPTEMBER. WHEN THEY ANNOUNCED THE AI
1:18:55 DIALOGUE BETWEEN THE TWO COUNTRIES.
1:19:00 BUT THAT WAS ALSO WHEN WE HEARD FROM ANTHROPIC AND OPENAI AND
1:19:03 OTHERS WHO WERE TALKING ABOUT, MAYBE WE NEED TO SLOW DOWN THE
1:19:08 PACE OF AI DEVELOPMENT. AGAIN, PERHAPS ISSUES WITH THE
1:19:12 EXISTENTIAL THREAT TO HUMANITY. DONALD TRUMP AT THAT TIME SAID
1:19:15 HE WAS NOT IN SUPPORT OF SLOWING THE PACE OF GROWTH OF AI AND THE
1:19:22 LIKE. ESSENTIALLY BECAUSE THAT WOULD
1:19:25 GIVE AN ADVANTAGE TO CHINA. CHINA ALSO SAW THOSE COMMENTS
1:19:30 COMING FROM THE AI FRONTIER LEADERS IN THE UNITED STATES AS
1:19:34 PERHAPS AN EFFORT INDIRECTLY TO LIMIT CHINA'S ABILITY TO DEVELOP
1:19:38 ITS OWN INDIGENOUS AI. SO IT'S OBVIOUSLY A VERY
1:19:41 CONVOLUTED ISSUE BETWEEN THE TWO NATIONS AS THEY TRY TO BUILD OUT
1:19:49 RIVAL SUPREMACY IN AI. WHETHER THEY TALK ABOUT THE
1:19:51 INCREASED EXPORT CONTROLS THAT CAME FROM THE COMMERCE
1:19:54 DEPARTMENT EARLIER THIS WEEK AND LATE LAST WEEK TO ESSENTIALLY
1:20:00 BLOCK AI DEVELOPERS IN CHINA REMOTE ACCESS TO THE MOST
1:20:02 ADVANCED CHIPS FROM NVIDIA AND OTHER MAKERS THROUGH THIRD-PARTY
1:20:07 COUNTRIES THAT HAVE DATA CENTERS OR EVEN SINGAPORE WHERE WE SEE
1:20:13 SERVERS BEING SENT TO CHINA REPORTEDLY AND ALLEGEDLY.
1:20:15 THAT CONTAINS THOSE MOST ADVANCED CHIPS.
1:20:19 THAT IS A VERY CONTENTIOUS ISSUE THAT CHINA HAS CLEARLY SAID THE
1:20:23 DEPARTMENT OF MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AS WELL AS MINISTRY OF
1:20:28 FOREIGN AFFAIRS HAS SAID THAT CHINA STRONGLY OPPOSES ANY OF
1:20:30 THOSE ALLEGATIONS ABOUT INDUSTRIAL ESPIONAGE AS TIED TO
1:20:34 THE JENSEN HUANG EPISODE. BUT ALSO THEY STRONGLY OPPOSE
1:20:39 ANY EFFORTS, CONTINUED EFFORTS BY THE UNITED STATES TO RAMP UP
1:20:42 AND INCREASE THOSE EXPORT CONTROLS.
1:20:47 DAVID: SO STEVE, IT'S CLEAR WHAT THE POSITION IS FROM BOTH
1:20:48 COUNTRIES ON THIS ISSUE. YOU MENTIONED THIS AS WELL.
1:20:55 IT'S BEEN BARELY TWO MONTHS SINCE THEY LAST MET AND IT WILL
1:20:58 BE ANOTHER THREE OR FOUR WEEKS BEFORE THEY MEET AGAIN.
1:21:03 THERE SHOULD BE AN EXTRA BILATERAL FOR THE RESTRICTIONS
1:21:06 TO COME UP. STEPHEN: WE DON'T NECESSARILY
1:21:17 KNOW WHAT THE DETAILED AGENDA IS GOING TO BE AND WHAT KIND OF
1:21:19 PROGRESS THEY CAN MAKE BASED ON WHAT THEY HEARD IN SEPTEMBER.
1:21:24 WE WERE THERE OBVIOUSLY FOLLOWING THE DEVELOPMENTS.
1:21:27 THE MAIN THINGS WERE DEVELOPMENT ON THE BOARD OF TRADE WHERE THE
1:21:31 TWO NATIONS AGREED TO 30 BILLION FOR 30 BILLION.
1:21:35 LIKE FOR LIKE ON PRODUCTS IF THEY WOULD REDUCE OR ELIMINATE
1:21:38 TARIFFS ON NONSENSITIVE ISSUES. PERHAPS WITH JAMIESON GREER
1:21:44 THERE, HE MIGHT HAVE SOME MORE DETAILS ON WHETHER THAT COULD BE
1:21:47 EXPANDED. THE OTHER QUESTION IS ABOUT
1:21:50 WHETHER THIS TRADE TRUCE WHICH WAS REACHED A YEAR AGO AND WAS
1:21:55 EXTENDED IN WASHINGTON, D.C. IN SEPTEMBER TO JANUARY.
1:21:57 JUST TWO MORE MONTHS. WHETHER THAT POTENTIALLY COULD
1:22:02 BE EXPANDED AND EXTENDED. THAT IS SOMETHING THE CHINESE
1:22:04 WANT. WE ALSO HEARD IN SEPTEMBER FROM
1:22:09 JAMIESON GREER SAYING, HE WAS NOT IN SUPPORT OF AN EXTENSION
1:22:13 UNTIL THEY HAD SOME SAFEGUARDS AND SOME ASSURANCES FROM THE
1:22:16 CHINESE THAT THEY WERE NOT GOING TO BACKSLIDE ON THEIR EXPORT
1:22:18 LICENSE PROCESS FOR RARE EARTH. AGAIN, IT'S A LOT TO CHEW ON IN
1:22:25 A SHORT AMOUNT OF TIME THAT DONALD TRUMP AND HIS ENTOURAGE
1:22:30 -- WE HAVE THE U.S. TRADE REPRESENTATIVE JAMIESON GREER
1:22:34 FORWARD. FORGET ABOUT BOARD OF INVESTMENT
1:22:41 WHICH IS ANOTHER PROPOSAL BY THE USTR.
1:22:44 A LOT OF STICKY ISSUES THAT ARE NOT NECESSARILY GETTING
1:22:46 RESOLVED. YVONNE: HOLD THAT THOUGHT.
1:22:52 WE HAVE LIVE PICTURES WHERE PRESIDENT TRUMP IS NOW
1:22:55 ADDRESSING THE APEC SUMMIT HERE. LET'S LISTEN IN.
1:22:59 >> [INAUDIBLE] MORE THAN 90% OF ALL
1:23:05 SEMICONDUCTORS, TWO THIRDS OF THE WORLD'S AUTOMOBILES.
1:23:10 GREAT JOB. YOU'VE DONE AN AMAZING JOB.
1:23:16 THE UNITED STATES HAS BEEN A PACIFIC POWER FOR HUNDREDS OF
1:23:20 YEARS AND WE CONTINUE TO WORK TO PROMOTE SOVEREIGNTY AND PEACE
1:23:21 THROUGHOUT THE REGION. OUR RELATIONSHIPS HAPPEN VERY
1:23:24 STRONG. I'M PLEASED TO REPORT THAT TODAY
1:23:32 THAT THE UNITED STATES IS DRY -- THRIVING LIKE IT'S NEVER THRIVED
1:23:33 BEFORE. IT'S BEEN INCREDIBLE WHAT'S
1:23:38 HAPPENED, JUST THE LAST TIME. THE LAST THREE MONTHS, INFLATION
1:23:45 WAS DOWN TO A NUMBER THAT WAS NOT EXPECTED.
1:23:49 WE WERE ABLE TO DO A REAL JOB. A LOT OF OTHER COUNTRIES ARE
1:23:52 HAVING DIFFICULTY WITH THAT. LESS THAN 2% FOR THE LAST FEW
1:23:53 MONTHS. SOMETHING THE LAST
1:23:59 ADMINISTRATION PROBABLY REAL INFLATION WAS ABOUT 21% WHICH
1:24:00 WAS TERRIBLE. BUT WE HAVE IT LESS THAN 2% NOW.
1:24:08 LAST MONTH, IT WAS ANNOUNCED THAT THE U.S. ECONOMY IS GROWING
1:24:10 LIKE NEVER BEFORE. MUCH FASTER THAN ANY OTHER MAJOR
1:24:14 DEVELOPED NATION. INVESTMENT IN NEW EQUIPMENT IS
1:24:18 UP ON INCREDIBLE 21% THIS YEAR WHICH IS A RECORD.
1:24:22 EXPORTS HAVE SOARED TO THE HIGHEST LEVEL IN AMERICAN
1:24:23 HISTORY. IN LESS THAN TWO YEARS, WE
1:24:29 SECURED COMMITMENTS FOR $22.2 TRILLION.
1:24:33 TRILLION DOLLARS OF NEW INVESTMENTS IN THE UNITED STATES
1:24:35 . MUCH OF WHICH I AM PLEASED TO
1:24:38 SAY IS COMING FROM MY FRIENDS IN THIS ROOM.
1:24:44 MOST IMPORTANTLY, CERTAINLY VERY IMPORTANTLY, WE'VE CREATED $25
1:24:51 TRILLION IN NEW WEALTH UP UNTIL NOVEMBER 1.
1:24:53 WE'VE CREATED WEALTH FOR A COUNTRY OF $25 TRILLION.
1:24:59 THAT'S A RECORD BY A LOT. MAYBE MOST IMPORTANTLY, MORE
1:25:01 PEOPLE ARE WORKING IN THE UNITED STATES TODAY THAN EVER BEFORE.
1:25:06 SO THESE ARE ALL UNPRECEDENTED ACHIEVEMENTS.
1:25:10 THIS EXTRAORDINARY SUCCESS IS ALL HAPPENING BECAUSE OF ARE
1:25:14 PROGROWTH ECONOMIC POLICIES. WE PASSED THE LARGEST TAX CUTS
1:25:17 IN AMERICAN HISTORY. THE LARGEST REGULATION CUTS IN
1:25:21 AMERICAN HISTORY. REACHED MORE THAN 20 TRADE
1:25:26 AGREEMENTS TO PROMOTE STRONGER AND MORE BALANCED COMMERCE WITH
1:25:29 OUR PARTNERS. WE ARE NEGOTIATING NUMEROUS
1:25:30 TRADE AGREEMENTS WITH SOME PEOPLE SITTING AT THIS BEAUTIFUL
1:25:33 TABLE. WE HAVE A LOT OF TRADE
1:25:37 AGREEMENTS THAT WILL BE SIGNED IN THE NOT-TOO-DISTANT FUTURE
1:25:42 WITH VERY MAJOR COUNTRIES. THE UNITED STATES IS ALSO PROUD
1:25:48 TO BREATHE A -- B THE LEADER IN SUPER INTELLIGENCE, THE GREATEST
1:25:52 TECHNOLOGICAL TRANSFORMATION SINCE THE INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION.
1:25:56 IT SEEMS TO BE TRUE. AMERICANS INVENTED SI.
1:26:05 IT'S UNLEASHING EXTRAORDINARY PROSPERITY AND GROWTH FOR PEOPLE
1:26:06 ALL AROUND THE GLOBE. WE DON'T WANT TO DO ANYTHING TO
1:26:11 DESTROY THE TREMENDOUS POTENTIAL OF THIS TECHNOLOGY.
1:26:15 IT IS SUPER INTELLIGENCE. THAT'S WHAT IT IS.
1:26:16 SUPER INTELLIGENCE. WE HAVE TO WATCH IT.
1:26:21 WE HAVE TO BE CAREFUL. WE HAVE TO CHERISH IT.
1:26:23 IT'S ALL MOST COMPLETELY GOOD BUT IT HAS SOME BAD ELEMENTS.
1:26:27 WE HAVE TO BE CAREFUL IN MANAGING THOSE BAD ELEMENTS.
1:26:32 WE OPPOSE ANY FORM OF GLOBALIST REGULATION OR ANYTHING TO
1:26:37 CONTROL OR STIFLE SI. WE WON'T ALLOW THAT TO HAPPEN
1:26:38 FRANKLY. UNDER MY LEADERSHIP, THE UNITED
1:26:44 STATES IS ALSO THE WORLD'S LARGEST SUPPLIER OF ENERGY.
1:26:47 I ADMINISTRATION IS WORKING WITH MANY NATIONS IN THE ROOM TO
1:26:50 EXPAND OUR ENERGY PARTNERSHIPS. WE'VE JUST APPROVED IN A
1:26:54 LIQUEFIED NATURAL GAS PIPELINE IN ALASKA TO EXPLORE AMERICAN
1:27:00 NATURAL GAS TO ASIA. IT'S THE LARGEST PIPE ON IN THE
1:27:05 WORLD -- PIPELINE IN THE WORLD. IN VENEZUELA, WE ARE DOING
1:27:10 TREMENDOUS BUSINESS. U.S. OIL COMPANIES ARE MOVING
1:27:12 IN. TREMENDOUS BUSINESS IN VENEZUELA
1:27:14 . NOT ONLY IS THE UNITED STATES
1:27:16 COMMITTED TO THE PROSPERITY OF THIS REGION, WE ARE ALSO
1:27:21 COMMITTED TO STABILITY AND PEACE .
1:27:25 AS YOU KNOW, ONE YEAR AGO, WE BROKE A HISTORIC AGREEMENT
1:27:27 BETWEEN CAMBODIA AND THAILAND. WHICH HAS ALLOWED COUNTLESS
1:27:32 PEOPLE TO RETURN TO THEIR HOMES. RIGHT?
1:27:36 QUITE A GOOD SITUATION. I'M VERY PROUD OF YOU BOTH, THE
1:27:44 WAY YOU DID THAT AND THE WAY YOU WERE SO SMART.
1:27:48 HERE IN CHINA, I LOOK FORWARD TO A HISTORIC TRILATERAL MEETING
1:27:52 WITH PRESIDENT XI AND PUTIN LATER TODAY TO DISCUSS MORE
1:27:56 OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL THREE. WE LOOK FORWARD TO THAT.
1:28:02 I WANT TO THANK PRESIDENT XI FOR THE INCREDIBLE DISPLAY THAT THEY
1:28:06 PUT FORTH LAST NIGHT. UNBELIEVABLE.
1:28:09 IT WAS REALLY UNBELIEVABLE. ONCE AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR
1:28:12 HOSTING US AS WELL AS ALL THE LEADERS HERE WHO SEEK TO JOIN A
1:28:18 FORAGING AND SAFER AND MORE PROSPEROUS WORLD.
1:28:23 THIS IS AN INCREDIBLE COUNTRY. AN UNBELIEVABLE JOB AND YOU ARE
1:28:28 THANK YOU EVERYBODY. [APPLAUSE]
1:28:33 YVONNE: ALRIGHT. THAT WAS MOMENTS AGO.
1:28:35 PRESIDENT TRUMP ADDRESSING THE AIPAC NATIONS THERE ABOUT WHERE
1:28:40 HE STANDS WHEN IT COMES TO AI REGULATIONS.
1:28:44 THIS IS SOMETHING HE FLAGGED DURING THIS SPEECH ABOUT HOW HE
1:28:47 DOESN'T WANT AI REGULATIONS TO STIFLE THE INDUSTRY.
1:28:54 AS STEVE MENTIONED, DROPPING LITTLE HINTS ABOUT WHERE HE
1:28:56 STANDS WHEN IT COMES TO WHETHER THERE'S A NEED FOR THIS INDUSTRY
1:29:00 TO BUILD THOSE SAFER GUARDRAILS WHEN IT COMES TO AI.
1:29:03 HE DOESN'T WANT IT TO IMPACT THE INNOVATION.
1:29:06 HE WANTS THE INDUSTRY TO BE GIVEN FULL REIGN TO INNOVATE
1:29:11 WITHOUT GOVERNMENT RESTRICTIONS. CERTAINLY THERE'S A LOT TO
1:29:12 UNPACK THERE. I WANT TO BRING BACK STEVE WHO
1:29:17 IS THERE AT SHENZHEN. SOME FINAL THOUGHTS FROM YOU IN
1:29:20 TERMS OF WHAT TO EXPECT NEXT? PRESIDENT TRUMP ALSO TALKED
1:29:25 ABOUT BEING -- LOOKING FORWARD TO THAT TRILATERAL COMING UP.
1:29:30 STEPHEN: ABSOLUTELY. REALLY IT WAS A BIT OF A
1:29:35 RAMBLING SPEECH IF I CAN BE SO FRANK.
1:29:40 HE TALKED A LOT ABOUT THE ECONOMIC STRENGTHS OF THE UNITED
1:29:41 STATES. THAT'S NOT NECESSARILY REFLECTED
1:29:43 IN THE DATA. WE DID HAVE YEAR-OVER-YEAR
1:29:47 NUMBERS COMING OUT IN OCTOBER BUT WE DID HAVE MONTH OVER MONTH
1:29:48 INFLATION. WE'VE ALREADY BEEN SEEING THE
1:29:52 HIGH PERCENTAGE CHANCES OF THE FED NEXT MONTH POSSIBLY HIKING
1:29:57 RATES BECAUSE OF STICKY INFLATION.
1:30:00 AGAIN, HE CLAIMED IT'S LESS THAN 2% NOW OVER THE LAST FEW MONTHS
1:30:07 WHERE IT HAD BEEN UNDER THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION.
1:30:08 HE CLAIMED 21%. HE SKEWED THE NUMBERS A BIT
1:30:10 THERE. HE TALKED ABOUT THE PROGROWTH
1:30:15 ECONOMIC POLICIES IN THE LAST COUPLE YEARS SINCE HE TOOK BACK
1:30:19 THE SECOND TERM IN THE PRESIDENCY.
1:30:23 AGAIN, ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, THAT'S WHERE WE
1:30:25 MIGHT GET THE MOST HEADLINES THAT HE WILL HAVE, IF THEY CAN
1:30:29 TALK THROUGH THE DIFFERENCES ON THE EXPORT CONTROLS AND THE
1:30:32 REMOTE ACCESS FOR CHINESE AI DEVELOPERS IN LIGHT OF THE
1:30:37 JENSEN HUANG DEVELOPMENTS. HE SAID AMERICA INVENTED SI.
1:30:42 DONALD TRUMP IS ADOPTING SUPER INTELLIGENCE RATHER THAN
1:30:46 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE. WE DON'T WANT TO DO ANYTHING TO
1:30:49 DESTROY IT. WE HAVE TO BE CAREFUL AND WATCH
1:30:50 IT. AGAIN, HE SAYS HE DOESN'T
1:30:53 NECESSARILY WANT TO STIFLE THE INNOVATION THAT HE CLAIMS THE
1:30:57 UNITED STATES IS LEADING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN ARTIFICIAL
1:31:04 INTELLIGENCE, SUPER INTELLIGENCE .
1:31:04 AS HE WRAPPED UP THE MEETING THERE, HE THANKED XI JINPING FOR
1:31:09 HOSTING THE GALA LAST NIGHT. HE'S TALKING ABOUT CHINA AND
1:31:15 ALSO YOU ARE AN INCREDIBLE LEADER.
1:31:18 I'M EXPECTING MOSTLY FROM THE BILATERAL THAT THEY WILL HAVE AS
1:31:22 A REAFFIRMATION OVER THE LAST TWO MEETINGS THIS YEAR.
1:31:28 FURTHER DEVELOPMENT OF THE INTERPERSONAL LEADER
1:31:30 RELATIONSHIP. YVONNE: WE ARE GETTING LINES
1:31:36 CROSSING HERE NOW FROM THE RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR
1:31:36 PUTIN. HE'S BEEN TALKING ABOUT RUSSIA.
1:31:41 WANTS TO KEEP THE ECONOMY OPEN. QUITE INTERESTING HOW MUCH
1:31:45 SPOTLIGHT HE'S GETTING OUT THIS APEC SUMMIT -- AIPAC SUMMIT
1:31:52 AFTER CLOSE TO 10 YEARS OF BEING ISOLATED.
1:31:56 STEPHEN: THAT'S RIGHT. HE USED HIS SPEECH YESTERDAY TO
1:32:02 TALK ABOUT THE FAILED ATTEMPTS TO ISOLATE RUSSIA.
1:32:05 HE SAID RUSSIA IS A DESIRABLE PLACE TO DO BUSINESS THAT HAS
1:32:09 HUGE UNTAPPED POTENTIAL. HE SAID THIS TRILATERAL MEETING
1:32:13 HAS GREAT POTENTIAL. BUT AGAIN, I THINK PUTIN HAS THE
1:32:20 MOST TO GAIN AND THE MOST TO LOSE BY PROMOTING WHAT HE WOULD
1:32:26 LIKE TO SEE. I WOULD ASSUME IT IS THIS NEW,
1:32:32 GREAT POWERS TRIUMVIRATE OF XI, TRUMP, PUTIN.
1:32:38 AKIN TO THE YALTA CONFERENCE IN EARLY 1945 BEFORE THE END OF
1:32:39 WORLD WAR II. THOSE THREE GREAT POWERS ALONG
1:32:49 WITH STALIN OF THE SOVIET UNION SORT OF DIVIDED UP AND CARVED UP
1:32:52 THE NEW WORLD ORDER IN POSTWAR GERMANY.
1:32:56 PUTIN AND THE RUSSIANS WOULD LIKE TO SEE A SIMILAR ELEVATION
1:33:03 OF THIS TRILATERAL TO THAT LEVEL THAT THEY ARE GOING TO BE THE
1:33:07 THREE SUPERPOWER LEADERS OF THE HEMISPHERES OF THE EARTH GOING
1:33:09 FORWARD IN THE NEW WORLD ORDER. THAT WILL LARGELY BE DOMINATED,
1:33:18 THE ECONOMY WILL BE DOMINATED BY DEVELOPMENTS IN AI.
1:33:21 YVONNE: INTERESTING. WE SAW THOSE FAMILY PHOTOS.
1:33:25 PUTIN IS BASICALLY STANDING RIGHT NEXT TO THE PRESIDENT XI
1:33:30 HE HAS CERTAINLY BEEN IN THE FRONT LOW -- FRONT ROW HERE AT
1:33:34 AIPAC. WE WILL HAVE MORE FROM STEPHEN
1:33:40 ENGLE JOINING US FROM SHENZHEN. THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF BEARISH
1:33:44 SENTIMENT. DAVID: THIS IS ONE OF THOSE DAYS
1:33:52 WHERE IT'S REALLY HARD TO CARVE OUT BROADCAST TIME.
1:33:56 THESE ARE TWO IMPORTANT PARALLEL STORIES TAKING PLACE.
1:33:59 YOU DON'T NORMALLY SEE A DAY WHEN THE HANG SENG IS DOWN ABOUT
1:34:03 2.2%. THE ONLY BRIGHT SPOT WITHIN THE
1:34:06 HANG SENG TECH INDEX ARE YOUR SEMI-NAMES.
1:34:12 YOUR USUAL BIG CHINESE CHECK PUT -- TECH PLAYS ARE DOWN
1:34:13 SUBSTANTIALLY. WE WILL SHOW YOU AN UPDATE OF
1:34:19 TENCENT AND ALIBABA. LAST WE CHECKED, THEY WERE DOWN
1:34:23 6% ON BOTH. YEAH.
1:34:24 THERE WE GO. THAT'S THE HEAD OF ALIBABA
1:34:27 EARNINGS COMING THROUGH AS WELL. TAIWAN IS AT A PAIN POINT TODAY.
1:34:33 DOWN TWO TO 3% ON THAT BENCHMARK .
1:34:34 WE ARE AT SESSION LOWS ON THE ORIGINAL -- REGIONAL BENCHMARKS.
1:34:41 YVONNE: SIXTH DAY OF LOSSES WHEN IT COMES TO ASIAN STOCKS.
1:34:44 WILL ANTHROPIC SAVE THE DAY LATER ON IN THE U.S.?
1:34:49 THAT'S IT FOR US HERE ON THE CHINA CELL.
1:34:51 INSIGHT WITH HASLINDA AMIN IS UP NEXT.
1:34:52 STAY WITH US. ♪
Anthropic Raises $107.3 Billion in Watershed AI Debut full transcript
0:00 Ruhul, the valuation below the $2 trillion that was floated just a couple of months ago, but
0:05 above the trillion that someone Wall Street had suggested during the recent sell off. What are
0:11 weeks taking from the signals going into this strong first day's trading?
0:17 Good morning, Stephen. Yeah. So it's a historic day. Anthropoc, of course, coming to market, very
0:23 widely anticipated for for many months. And they did price the shares at $83 per share,
0:29 which is above the range, and that implies a fully diluted valuation of about 1,500,000,000,000, which
0:36 is lower than the 2,000,000,000,000 that was floated a few months ago. But I think that's
0:40 expected given the angst that we've seen around the AI trade more broadly over the past
0:45 couple of months. What that valuation implies is that investors will be paying roughly 16 times
0:51 run rate revenue, which is lower than SpaceX and Palantir, but broadly in line with OpenAI.
0:58 But I think the bigger question is less about valuation and more about margins. In the
1:03 most recent quarter, compute costs were growing faster than revenue, and that is the dynamic that
1:09 investors are going to be watching in the coming quarters. In terms of the first day,
1:14 I think the conditions are quite favorable for a first day pop. About 7% of shares
1:19 will be out and float. The book was about six times oversubscribed, and there's a 20
1:24 allocation to retail. So you probably will get a first day pop, but most of the
1:31 lockups will expire around May. And I think around that time, we'll start to see what
1:35 the market really thinks about the stock and the valuation and and and the trading rhythm.
1:41 And, of course, after the rough couple of weeks that we've seen for the AI trade
1:44 as well, how important is this AI for the... This IPO for the wider AI industry
1:51 and all of the other potential IPOs that could be coming down the line?
1:57 Yeah. It's quite pivotal. Like you like you alluded to, there's been a lot of angst
2:01 around the AI trade more broadly over the past couple of months, and some were even
2:05 suggesting that actually Anthropic might delay their IPO given all of the volatility that we've seen.
2:11 But the fact that they have come to market, priced it above the expected range, and,
2:16 you know, I think that's gonna be a positive signal. And I think if the stock
2:19 does pop, then that could just lift sentiment more broadly around the space. And I think
2:25 having Anthropic as a listed company where they do disclose the financials, where investors can get
2:30 a real sense of demand in the coming quarters will really ease a sense of nervousness
2:35 because of the disclosure, and that should be positive in theory for the AI trade.
2:40 Okay.
Anthropic IPO Raises $107.3B to Top SpaceX's Record Debut full transcript
0:15 PAUL: THIS IS "THE ASIA TRADE."
0:17 ASIA STOCKS SET FOR A BUMPY OPEN AFTER THE AI TRADE WOBBLES ON
0:21 WALL STREET. NVIDIA DRIVING THE S&P 500 LOWER
0:26 FOR A FIFTH STRAIGHT DAY. HAIDI: BUT STOCKS COULD GET A
0:33 BOOST FROM ANTHROPIC'S LISTING. STEPHEN: I'M IN SHENZHEN WHERE
0:42 IN JUST A FEW HOURS, WE WILL GET WHAT COULD BE A LANDMARK
0:45 TRILATERAL BETWEEN PRESIDENTS TRUMP, XI, AND PUTIN.
0:54 HAIDI: A LOT OF DEVELOPMENTS, AND INVESTORS ARE AWAITING THE
0:58 GEOPOLITICS THAT STEVE JUST ALLUDED TO.
1:03 WE ARE GETTING NEWS REPORTEDLY AROUND THE PRICING, SET TO BE
1:09 PRICING THAT RANGE AT $83 A SHARE, ABOVE THE MARKETED RANGE.
1:12 THIS WOULD BE THE BIGGEST FIRST TIMESHARE SALE ON RECORD WITH
1:17 THAT $26 BILLION TO BE RAISED IN A PRIVATE PLACEMENT AS WELL.
1:21 TAKE A LOOK AT HOW THIS CARRIES THROUGH, PARTICULARLY AS WE DID
1:24 SEE MOVES WHEN IT COMES TO THE TECH SIDE OF THINGS IN THE
1:25 OVERNIGHT SESSION. THAT RALLY FOR NVIDIA CERTAINLY
1:31 FIZZLED OUT. INVESTORS LOOKING FOR MORE ON
1:32 THE DURABILITY OF THE RETURN OF THIS AI TRADE.
1:37 KOSPI FUTURES LOOKING MUCH WEAKER THAN THE OUTLOOK WHEN IT
1:38 COMES TO JAPAN. .25% FOR NIKKEI FUTURES AT THE
1:42 MOMENT. WE ARE SEEING MODEST GAINS WHEN
1:49 IT COMES TO NASDAQ FUTURES AS WELL.
1:51 SWITCHING OUT THE BOARD, WE HAVE SOME FED EXPECTATIONS BEING
1:55 BUILT INTO HOW THE MARKET IS FARING AT THE MOMENT AS WELL
1:59 GIVEN THAT FED OFFICIALS AGREE THEY WOULD LIKELY HAVE TO RAISE
2:00 RATES IN THE MONTH AHEAD TO RETURN TO THAT 2% INFLATION
2:06 TARGET IN A TIMELY MANNER. THIS FROM THE LAST FOMC MEETING
2:09 MINUTES FROM THE END OF OCTOBER SUGGESTING THAT AT LEAST TWO
2:15 POLICYMAKERS SAYING A MORE THAN 25 BASIS POINT MOVE COULD BE
2:19 WARRANTED DEPENDING ON WHAT THE NEXT INFLATION PRINTS TEND TO
2:21 LOOK LIKE. OIL TO THE DOWNSIDE DESPITE
2:23 CONTINUED ATTACKS ACROSS THE PERSIAN GULF.
2:27 THESE MILITARY FLAREUPS DO NOT SEEM TO BE WEIGHING ON WHAT
2:34 TRADERS CONTINUE TO SEE AS PRETTY ROBUST LEVELS OF SUPPLY.
2:39 PAUL: LET'S CONTINUE WITH GEOPOLITICS.
2:43 SHENZHEN. OUR CHIEF NORTH ASIA
2:51 CORRESPONDENT STEPHEN ENGLE JOINS US FROM SHENZHEN.
2:55 LET'S START WITH THAT TRADE BARRIERS COMPLAINT.
2:59 WHAT WERE PRESIDENT XI AND PRESIDENT PUTIN SAYING?
3:01 STEPHEN: YESTERDAY, THEY OPENED UP CEO SUMMIT ON THE LEADERS
3:08 SIDE OF THE WITH THEIR SIMILAR MESSAGES, ESPECIALLY FROM XI
3:13 JINPING, SAYING THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY IS BEING QUITE RESILIENT
3:16 RIGHT NOW, BUT AGAIN, REALLY ESPOUSED THE BENEFITS OF
3:19 MULTILATERALISM AND THAT CHINA IS A LEADER IN MULTILATERALISM
3:29 AND, OF COURSE, FOR FREE TRADE. A BIT OF A VEILED JOB AT THE
3:31 UNITED STATES. WE GOT THROUGH ABOUT A YEAR AND
3:34 A HALF OF TURBULENT TIMES ON THE TRADE FRONT WITH TARIFFS AND THE
3:37 LIKE. PUTIN ALSO SAID THE RUSSIAN
3:43 ECONOMY IS DOING WELL AND WILL BE A LEADER IN TECHNOLOGY AND
3:49 THAT SANCTIONS ARE A THING OF THE PAST AND THAT THEY HAVE
3:53 OVERCOME THEM. AS WE LOOK TOWARDS THAT
3:58 TRILATERAL LATER TODAY, I'M NOT SURE WHAT WE ARE NECESSARILY
4:01 GOING TO GET OUT OF THAT AS A HEADLINE.
4:08 WHEN THE WAR IN UKRAINE, MORE THAN FOUR YEARS ON NOW, IS NOT
4:11 NECESSARILY ON THE AGENDA. SOME COULD ARGUE WHAT COULD BE
4:16 ACHIEVED IF THE OTHER COMBATANT IN THE WARD, UKRAINE, IS NOT AT
4:22 THE TABLE, SO WE WILL HAVE TO SEE WHERE WE GO FROM THERE.
4:27 IRAN WILL LIKELY BE DISCUSSED. DONALD TRUMP WILL LIKELY TRY TO
4:31 ELICIT BOTH MOSCOW AND BEIJING'S ASSISTANCE IN DEALING WITH
4:34 TEHRAN, PERHAPS TO GET SOME SORT OF PATHWAY TOWARDS RESOLUTION IN
4:37 THAT CONFLICT AS WELL, BUT AGAIN, AI WILL BE DISCUSSED, NO
4:43 DOUBT, AND ALL THE PARTICIPANTS ARE HERE -- WELL, THE MAIN
4:45 PARTICIPANTS IN THE BIFURCATION OF THE AI BUILDOUT, THE UNITED
4:50 STATES AND CHINA. I TALKED TO YESTERDAY AS WELL
4:54 WITH A NOTED COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR ON ALL THESE ISSUES
4:58 INCLUDING THE TRILATERAL. HE SAID TRUMP WILL PROBABLY GET
5:02 A LOT OF HEAT BACK HOME, ESPECIALLY IN THE WAKE OF THE
5:06 MIDTERM BLUE WAVE, ABOUT MEETING TRUMP -- EXCUSE ME, MEETING
5:11 PUTIN ON AN INTERNATIONAL STAGE, BUT AT THE SAME TIME, THE MAIN
5:15 ISSUE IS A THIRD MEETING THIS YEAR BETWEEN TRUMP AND XI
5:19 JINPING ON THE MULTITUDE OF ISSUES THAT THEY NEED TO
5:22 RESOLVE, INCLUDING THE TRADE WAR AND THE BATTLE FOR AI.
5:27 >> THE UNITED STATES CANNOT WIN A TRADE WAR WITH CHINA.
5:32 WE LEARNED THAT LAST YEAR. IT TOOK ABOUT 24 HOURS TO LEARN,
5:38 OH, EXCUSE ME, WE NEED THOSE RARE EARTHS OR OUR AUTO INDUSTRY
5:43 WILL SHUT DOWN IN ABOUT TWO WEEKS.
5:45 THERE IS A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF PROPAGANDA AND NAIVETE IN THE
5:50 UNITED STATES, IN THE WEST, IN A MAY NEWSPAPERS.
5:52 WHEN I READ IT, I CANNOT BELIEVE WHAT I READ BECAUSE IT IS SO
5:54 SIMPLEMINDED. STEPHEN: THERE ARE A LOT OF
6:01 OTHER STORIES, OBVIOUSLY, WITH 21 APAC NATIONS HERE.
6:04 WE HAD MARK CARNEY ALSO MEETING WITH DONALD TRUMP LAST NIGHT
6:10 AROUND THE TIME THAT THEY TOOK THE BIG GROUP PHOTO, AFTER TRUMP
6:16 ARRIVED AROUND 4:40 YESTERDAY AFTERNOON, COMING, OF COURSE,
6:19 FROM MANILA. MARK CARNEY AND DONALD TRUMP, IT
6:24 IS NOT AN EXAGGERATION TO SAY THEY HAVE HAD THEIR DIFFERENCES.
6:28 THEY HAVE BEEN WORKING TOWARD A TRADE AGREEMENT THAT GOT SOME
6:29 MOMENTUM DURING THE SUMMER, BUT BY AUGUST, THINGS FELL APART AND
6:34 THEY HAVE NOT NECESSARILY MOVED THE BALL FORWARD.
6:38 DONALD TRUMP SAYS THEY ARE GETTING CLOSE.
6:40 MARK CARNEY SAYS THEY WILL CONTINUE TO WORK THROUGH THESE
6:42 DIFFICULTIES, BUT HE SAYS IT IS LIKE TWO STEPS FORWARD AND ONE
6:47 STEP BACKWARDS. THE OTHER BIG DIPLOMATIC STORY
6:52 WE WERE WATCHING -- WOULD XI JINPING YESTERDAY GREAT THE
6:56 PRIME MINISTER OF JAPAN? HE DID.
6:57 THERE WAS A BRIEF MOMENT WHERE THEY DID A HANDSHAKE, AND THEN
7:04 TAKAICHI-SAN WAS PLACED AT THE BACK ROW OF THE PHOTO, BUT TO
7:10 HER CREDIT, SHE WORE A BRIGHT PINK JACKET, SO SHE DID STAND
7:12 OUT DESPITE BEING RELEGATED TO THE BACK ROW.
7:18 HAIDI: SPEAKING OF GREETINGS, WE WHEN TALKING ABOUT POTENTIAL
7:20 TENSIONS BETWEEN THE U.S. AND CHINA WHEN IT COMES TO AI, BUT
7:24 THERE WAS NO INDICATION OF A LACK OF WARMTH WHEN WE SAW THE
7:27 U.S. AND CHINESE PRESIDENTS GREET EACH OTHER.
7:33 STEPHEN: THAT'S RIGHT AND THAT WAS UNPRECEDENTED BECAUSE IT IS
7:36 NOT PROTOCOL FOR A CHINESE HEAD OF STATE TO MEET ANOTHER HEAD OF
7:40 STATE AT THE AIRPORT. IT IS USUALLY RESERVED FOR THE
7:46 GREAT HALL OF THE PEOPLE OR EVEN THE LEADERSHIP COMPOUND, AND AT
7:50 THE AIRPORT. THE LAST TIME TRUMP WENT TO
7:53 BEIJING IN MAY, IT WAS THE VICE PRESIDENT WHO MET DONALD TRUMP,
7:59 BUT XI JINPING SAYS CHINA IS A NATION OF ETIQUETTE AND
8:01 RECIPROCITY, AND SO HE RECIPROCATED DONALD TRUMP'S
8:07 GESTURE IN SEPTEMBER IN WASHINGTON, D.C., WHEN XI
8:13 ARRIVED ON HIS 747 IN WASHINGTON, D.C.
8:18 TRUMP AND MELANIA TRUMP MET HIM AT THE BOTTOM OF THE STAIRS, SO
8:22 HE IS JUST RECIPROCATING. THERE IS GOODWILL BETWEEN THESE
8:25 TWO MEN AS EVIDENCED BY THE PAT ON THE BACK, THE CHEEK TO CHEEK
8:31 DISPLAY OF WARMTH, BUT NOW, WILL THEY BE GOING TOE TO TOE, IF YOU
8:34 WILL, ON THE STICKING POINTS OF THEIR DIFFICULT RELATIONSHIP,
8:41 INCLUDING THE LATEST TIGHTENING OF THOSE EXPORT CONTROLS AND
8:45 ACCESS FOR CHINESE AI COMPANIES TO GET THEIR HANDS ON THE MOST
8:48 ADVANCED AI CHIPS. WE WILL HAVE TO SEE IF DONALD
8:52 TRUMP DECIDES TO PUSH THAT ISSUE.
8:53 AS THE CHINESE HAVE ALREADY SAID, THEY WILL PUSH BACK.
8:59 HAIDI: BLOOMBERG'S NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT STEPHEN ENGLE.
9:06 THE RIVALRIES WHEN IT COMES TO TECH AND AI AMONG A MULTITUDE OF
9:09 CONCERNS. WE DID SEE SOME STRONG
9:15 STATEMENTS IN TERMS OF THE FUTURE OF NVIDIA DESPITE THE
9:19 RECENT LEADERSHIP CRISIS. MARKETS ARE ALSO VERY MUCH
9:23 FOCUSED ON THE NEXT CATALYST, THE ANTHROPIC IPO, SAID TO BE
9:31 THE FIRST -- THE BIGGEST FIRST TIMESHARE SALE ON RECORD.
9:39 LET ME START WITH YOU WHEN IT COMES TO THIS PRICING, WHEN IT
9:41 COMES TO THE EXPANDED SIZE OF THIS OFFERING.
9:48 IT IS UNPRECEDENTED IN MANY WAYS.
9:53 >> IT IS, AND IT IS A SIGNAL OF THE ENTHUSIASM THAT REMAINS FOR
9:56 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON WALL STREET.
9:59 INVESTORS REALLY DO WANT A CRACK AT BEING ABLE TO OWN ONE OF THE
10:03 FRONTIER MODEL DEVELOPERS, AND THIS IS THEIR FIRST CHANCE AT
10:04 DOING SO. THIS IS ALSO A SIGNAL OF HOW THE
10:10 AI GENIE IS OUT OF THE BOTTLE. WE JUST HEARD FROM CITIGROUP
10:17 CHAIR AND CEO JANE FRASER IN THE WASHINGTON BUREAU IN AN
10:18 INTERVIEW WITH OUR OWN LISA ABRAMOWICZ TALKING ABOUT HOW
10:25 THIS IPO IS A BELLWETHER OF THE CONTINUED ENDURING ENTHUSIASM
10:29 FOR AI. FROM THIS, ANTHROPIC WILL WALK
10:32 AWAY WITH ABOUT $94 BILLION WHEN YOU FACTOR IN THE PRIVATE
10:36 PLACEMENT THAT IS PART OF THE OFFERING.
10:40 THEY WILL BE ABLE TO PUT THAT INTO PLACE IMMEDIATELY TOWARDS
10:42 THE COMPUTER IT NEEDS TO DEVELOP AND MARKET ALL THE NEW MODELS
10:45 AND NEW TECHNOLOGY THAT HAS MADE IT OF SUCH INTEREST TO
10:51 INVESTORS, BUT ALSO TO COMPANIES ACROSS THE U.S. AND AROUND THE
10:55 WORLD LOOKING TO EMPLOY ITS TECHNOLOGY AS PART OF THEIR
10:56 BUSINESSES. PAUL: I THINK MARKETS ARE
11:04 LOOKING TO THIS IPO TO CALM THINGS DOWN A LITTLE BIT, BUT
11:07 THAT'S WHAT WE SAID ABOUT NVIDIA YESTERDAY, WASN'T IT?
11:09 CAME OUT WITH GREAT NUMBERS, THINGS LOOKED FINE FOR 12 HOURS.
11:18 >> THE DIFFERENCES THIS IS THEIR FIRST TIME LISTING AND
11:19 INVESTMENT BANKERS WILL BE CAREFUL TO ENSURE THIS IPO
11:23 SUCCEEDS NOT ONLY BECAUSE IT IS A BELLWETHER STOP STOCK, BUT
11:27 ALSO BECAUSE THEY WILL BE FUTURE IPO'S.
11:31 OPENAI WILL BE WATCHING THIS CLOSELY.
11:35 ALSO, THE QUESTION BECOMES IF THE MARKET AND INVESTORS ARE
11:38 LOOKING BEYOND THE INFRASTRUCTURE TRADE AND LOOKING
11:41 AT THE APPLICATION LAYER. WE KNOW THAT ANTHROPIC IS THE
11:44 KEY PLAYER AT THAT APPLICATION LAYER WITH CLAUDE, CLAUDE CODE,
11:50 AND THE SUCCESS THAT HAS BEEN, AND THE RISKS AROUND WHAT HAS
11:53 HAPPENED WITH SOFTWARE, AND WE HAVE HEARD COMMENTS OUT OF
11:58 MICROSOFT DEBATING IF COPILOT IS ALSO AS EFFECTIVE AS CLAUDE, SO
12:01 I GUESS THE INVESTOR BASE IS ALSO LOOKING, BROADENING THE
12:06 INFRASTRUCTURE, THE AI TRADE BEYOND INFRASTRUCTURE INTO THE
12:09 APPLICATION LAYER, TOO. HAIDI: SUNNY BRINGS UP A GOOD
12:17 POINT. THIS COULD PROVE A GOOD TEST FOR
12:20 OPENAI. IT IS A LONG TIME POTENTIALLY TO
12:24 WAIT FOR MARKET CONDITIONS TO POTENTIALLY CHANGE QUITE A BIT,
12:25 RIGHT? IN TERMS OF THE ENTHUSIASM FOR
12:30 ANTHROPIC, THERE IS ALSO A SCHOOL OF THOUGHT THAT PERHAPS
12:34 YOU DO NOT NEED TO BE FIRST. THIS MAY BE THE FIRST, BUT IT
12:35 WILL NOT BE THE LAST FRONTIER TO GO TO AN IPO.
12:39 DO YOU THINK THAT COULD POTENTIALLY WEIGH INTO THE
12:43 THINKING IN THE WEEKS AFTER THE INITIAL FERVOR HAS SETTLED?
12:49 STEPHEN: ABSOLUTELY, AND THAT IS SOME OF THE REPORTING WE HAVE
12:52 FOUND IN THE MONTHS AND WEEKS LEADING NOT ONLY TO THE
12:57 ANTHROPIC OFFERING, BUT ALSO THE DELIBERATIONS INSIDE OPENAI
12:58 ABOUT HOW THEY PROCEED, WHEN THEY GO, AND SOME INVESTORS ARE
13:05 SAYING, YOU CANNOT WAIT FOR GOLDILOCKS CONDITIONS IN THE
13:09 MARKET. YOU ARE GOING TO BUY A STAKE IN
13:12 THIS COMPANY IF YOU REALLY BELIEVE IN WHAT IT WILL DO AND
13:15 WHAT ITS PROMISE IS -- WHAT THE PROMISES OF RETURN ON THAT
13:18 INVESTMENT. INVESTORS WILL BE ASSESSING THIS
13:22 NOT ONLY FOR THE MOMENT THAT MAYBE WE ARE IN THANKS TO SOME
13:28 OF THE MISGIVINGS WE SAW THROUGH OCTOBER ABOUT THE SUSTAINABILITY
13:29 OF ALL THAT FINANCING AND THEN MORE RECENTLY WITH THE TURMOIL
13:35 AT NVIDIA -- THEY ARE LOOKING PAST THAT TO THE CORE OF THE
13:38 COMPANY, AND WITH ANTHROPIC, THEY ARE SEEING SOMETHING THEY
13:39 LIKE. OPENAI HAS TO ENSURE THAT
13:44 WHENEVER IT DECIDES TO MAKE A MOVE, IT WILL HAVE A PACKAGE
13:48 TOGETHER THAT WILL BE AS APPEALING IF NOT MORE SO TO WALL
13:52 STREET AND EVEN BEYOND. PAUL: YOU MENTIONED THE TURMOIL
13:56 MOVEMENT ON THAT FRONT. MOODY'S SAYS CORPORATE
14:03 GOVERNANCE IS THE REASON FOR LOWERING THE OUTLOOK TO STABLE.
14:10 WHAT MORE DO WE KNOW, AND WHAT MIGHT RENEE HAAS BRING TO THE
14:12 TABLE? >> RENEE HAAS IS SOMEBODY WHO
14:18 PREVIOUSLY WORKED AT NVIDIA. HE HAD BEEN A SENIOR EXECUTIVE
14:22 THERE FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS BEFORE GOING TO ARM.
14:26 NVIDIA BACK IN 20 EVEN TRIED TO BUY ARM BUT WAS SHOT DOWN BY
14:33 ANTITRUST REGULATORS -- BACK IN 2020.
14:38 HE ALSO HAS THE EXPERIENCE OF HAVING TO DEAL WITH A COMPLEX
14:43 WEB OF SUPPLIERS AND CUSTOMERS, AND THAT'S EXACTLY THE KIND OF
14:46 SKILLS THAT HE WOULD NEED TO BE ABLE TO STEP INTO JENSEN HUANG'S
14:48 SHOES. WE TALK ABOUT NVIDIA AND THE
14:52 CHOICES THEY WILL HAVE TO MAKE GOING FORWARD.
14:55 FOR THE MOMENT, THOUGH, THEY ARE TRYING TO PROJECT BOTH
15:00 INTERNALLY AND EXTERNALLY THIS NOTION OF STABILITY.
15:03 COLETTE KRESS WAS TRYING TO MAKE CLEAR ON THE CALL YESTERDAY WITH
15:07 INVESTORS THAT THE BUSINESS AS USUAL, WE'VE GOT THIS, AND
15:10 DURING AN INTERNAL CALL WITH EMPLOYEES TODAY, SHE CONVEYED
15:17 OTHER SENIOR EXECUTIVES. AGAIN, REPEATING, WE'VE GOT
15:22 THIS, TRYING TO MAKE SURE PEOPLE ALSO UNDERSTOOD THAT THEY WOULD
15:27 BE MOVING ON FROM JENSEN HUANG AND LOOKING FOR A DIFFERENT
15:28 LEADER TO TAKE THE REINS. HAIDI: IT IS INTERESTING.
15:34 DO YOU FEEL LIKE IF THERE IS A BIT MORE CERTAINTY AROUND SOME
15:39 OF THE OTHER NAMES THAT HAVE BEEN THROWN AROUND, DOES A
15:45 PERSON LIKE THAT BEING APPOINTED -- IS THAT REALLY WHAT MARKETS
15:49 NEED TO SEE BEYOND THIS INTERIM CEO PHASE WHEN WE ARE ALSO
15:55 SEEING, STILL, UP UNTIL 48 HOURS AGO OR SO JENSEN HUANG THINKING
15:59 ABOUT MAKING A RETURN? >> THE POLITICS IN THE ROOM FOR
16:05 NVIDIA, YOU JUST KIND OF IGNORE IT.
16:08 IT IS ULTIMATELY THE PERSON WHO TAKES THAT HOTLY CONTESTED ROLE
16:15 WILL ALSO HAVE TO LOOK AT THE POLITICS AND WHAT KIND OF
16:18 DOWNFALL THERE HAS BEEN THROUGH THESE EXPORT CONTROLS.
16:20 WE HEARD ON THE TENCENT EARNINGS CALL THAT TENCENT ALSO FEELS
16:25 THAT THESE STRICTER EXPORT CONTROLS AND POTENTIAL REMOVAL
16:28 OF REMOTE ACCESS WILL SLOW AI DEVELOPMENT IN CHINA, SO THERE'S
16:34 A LOT OF POLITICS ON THE CARDS AS WELL, SO SOMEONE WILL HAVE TO
16:37 NAVIGATE THAT AS WELL AS BEING A VERY BIG DEALMAKER, WHICH JENSEN
16:40 HAS BEEN. I THINK THE BOARD WILL HAVE TO
16:43 TAKE THEIR TIME AND THINK ABOUT IT.
16:47 I THINK RENEE HAAS IS A SUITABLE CANDIDATE GIVEN HIS BACKGROUND
16:52 AND WHAT HE HAS BEEN ACHIEVING ARM, AND HE KNOWS THE COMPANY
16:54 WELL, BUT ULTIMATELY, WHOEVER TAKES THIS JOB WILL HAVE TO
16:58 UNDERSTAND THAT THERE IS A BIG POLITICAL ANGLE TO IT, TOO.
17:06 PAUL: THANKS. LATER ON, WE WILL BE LIVE FROM
17:12 THE SINGAPORE FINTECH FESTIVAL WHEN WE WILL BE SPEAKING
17:17 EXCLUSIVELY WITH THE CFT AND CO-FOUNDER.
17:24 HAIDI: FIRST, MORE ON THE APAC SUMMIT AND AN UNPRECEDENTED
17:28 READING BETWEEN THE LEADERS OF THE UNITED STATES, CHINA, AND
17:30 RUSSIA. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
17:50 ♪ >> WE EXPECT TO SEE GREAT NEWS
17:54 IN THE UPCOMING MEETING OF THE LEADERS OF CHINA, RUSSIA, AND
17:59 THE UNITED STATES PLANNED TO BE HELD ON THE SIDELINE.
18:11 HAIDI: LET'S BRING IN AN ADJUNCT PROFESSOR AND SENIOR FELLOW FOR
18:14 THE INITIATIVE FOR U.S.-CHINA DIALOGUE FOR GLOBAL ISSUES,
18:19 PREVIOUSLY A CIA DEPUTY ASSISTANT DIRECTOR.
18:22 SO MANY INTERESTING ELEMENTS HAPPENING AS WE HEAD TOWARDS
18:25 THIS TRILATERAL SUMMIT BETWEEN THE THREE LEADERS.
18:28 WHAT ARE YOUR EXPECTATIONS IN TERMS OF POTENTIAL DELIVERABLES
18:34 IF THERE ARE TO BE ANY, AND SHOULD WE BE MANAGING THESE
18:36 EXPECTATIONS? >> LET'S STEP BACK FOR A SECOND.
18:45 IN ALL THE TIME THAT MODERN CHINA HAS EXISTED, THERE HAS
18:49 NEVER BEEN A TRILATERAL MEETING OF THIS SORT, SO WE OFTEN TRY TO
18:55 THIS REALLY IS. IN TERMS OF OUTCOMES, THE
19:02 XI JINPING GETS TO SHOW THAT HE IS THE EQUAL OF THE UNITED
19:08 STATES NOW IN GEOPOLITICS, THAT HE IS HOSTING THE GREAT THREE.
19:13 PUTIN GETS TO SHOW THAT HE IS BACK IN THE NUCLEAR CLUB, EVEN
19:19 THOUGH THE UKRAINE WAR CONTINUES, AND OF COURSE, TRUMP
19:22 GETS TO HAVE AN EGO MOMENT WHERE HE SHOWS THAT HE IS A LEADER ON
19:26 THE WORLD STAGE STILL AND THAT NOTHING THERE HAS CHANGED
19:28 DESPITE THE ELECTION. IN TERMS OF ISSUES, TRUMP REALLY
19:34 DOES WANT TO TALK ABOUT ARMS CONTROL, AND I THINK IT IS
19:35 IMPORTANT TO. WE ARE ON THE VERGE OF A RACE IN
19:43 SPACE-BASED WEAPONS. THE CHINESE ARE BUILDING 220 NEW
19:48 MISSILE SILOS. THE CHINESE WILL TRY TO ACHIEVE
19:50 PARITY AND DEPLOY NUCLEAR WEAPONS OVER THE NEXT 10 YEARS.
19:55 THERE IS A NEED TO GET BACK TO ARMS CONTROL TALKS.
19:57 I DON'T THINK THEY WILL ACHIEVE ANYTHING ON THAT IN THE SUMMIT,
20:01 BUT THEY MIGHT LAY THE GROUNDWORK FOR SOME FUTURE
20:03 TALKS, AND I WOULD LOOK FOR THAT.
20:07 IN TERMS OF IRAN, THE PRESIDENT WILL PUSH HARD ON THE ISSUE.
20:11 CHINA HAS A BIG STAKE IN GETTING THE OIL FLOWING BACK AGAIN FROM
20:14 THE IRANIANS. 38% OF THEIR OIL BEFORE THE WAR
20:20 CAME FROM THE MIDDLE EAST, AND SO HE WILL TRY AND IMPRESS ON
20:24 THEM THAT THEY HAVE A ROLE TO PLAY.
20:28 IT HAS NOT WORKED SO FAR, BUT THINGS MIGHT CHANGE.
20:31 IN TERMS OF PUTIN, OF COURSE, THE ISSUE IS UKRAINE.
20:36 PUTIN WANTS THIS SUMMIT SO THAT HE CAN IN SOME WAYS NEGOTIATE
20:42 DIRECTLY WITH TRUMP INSTEAD OF THROUGH INTERMEDIARIES.
20:44 HE WANTS TO BE ABLE TO PUT SOME SEPARATION BETWEEN TRUMP AND
20:47 EUROPE ON THESE ISSUES, AND OF COURSE, ZELENSKYY WILL BE
20:53 NERVOUS ABOUT THIS BILATERAL MEETING NOW SCHEDULED TO TAKE
20:54 PLACE. PAUL: IN TERMS OF UKRAINE, DO
21:00 YOU ANTICIPATE ANY MOVEMENT THERE?
21:07 >> IN MANY WAYS, THAT IS UP TO PUTIN.
21:09 HE STRUCK A VERY HARD LINE IN HIS LAST MEETING WITH WYCOFF,
21:14 TALKING ABOUT FINLAND NEEDING TO LEAVE NATO, TALKING ABOUT
21:18 DEMILITARIZATION OF THE FRONTLINE STATES IN EUROPE.
21:22 IF HE COMES IN THAT WAY, I DON'T SEE ANY MOVEMENT, BUT HE MAY SEE
21:28 THIS AS A UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY. OF COURSE, HE IS RIGHT THERE
21:31 WITH TRUMP, AND OF COURSE, HE WILL WANT TO USE TRUMP'S EGO,
21:40 TRUMP'S DESIRE TO BE THE GREAT AMERICAN FOREIGN POLICY
21:43 PRESIDENT AS PART OF HIS LEGACY, SO LET'S SEE WHAT PUTIN DOES
21:46 WITH IT, BUT HE CERTAINLY HAS THE MOMENT THAT HE HAS BEEN
21:47 LOOKING FOR. HAIDI: I ALSO WANTED TO TALK A
21:54 LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE CHINA-U.S. RELATIONSHIP BECAUSE OUTWARDLY
21:58 IN TERMS OF THE VISUALS, SO MUCH WARMTH.
22:02 YOU MENTIONED UNPRECEDENTED. IT WAS CERTAINLY UNPRECEDENTED
22:06 FOR PRESIDENT XI TO GREAT PRESIDENT TRUMP ON THE TARMAC.
22:09 THERE WAS AN EMBRACE THERE AS WELL.
22:12 DO YOU THINK THAT SPEAKS TO THE UNDERLYING WILLINGNESS TO
22:15 CONTINUE THE STATUS QUO AND THE THAWING IN THIS RELATIONSHIP
22:19 DESPITE KNOWING WE WILL BE INCREASING FLASHPOINTS FOR
22:20 ATTENTION WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA, WHEN IT COMES TO THE
22:23 TECH RIVALRY? >> TRUMP HAS TAKEN A VIEW ON
22:30 CHINA THAT IS AT ODDS WITH MANY IN HIS ADMINISTRATION.
22:34 MANY ARE MORE HAWKISH. OF COURSE, HE SUPPORTED NVIDIA
22:38 CHIPS GOING TO CHINA WHEN OTHERS SAID THEY SHOULD NOT.
22:44 THE CHINESE SEE TRUMP AS FINALLY COMING TO A POINT AFTER THE
22:47 TERROR OF UNDERSTANDING WHAT THE U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP SHOULD
22:53 LOOK LIKE, SO THIS TALK OF STRATEGIC STABILITY IS ACTUALLY
22:54 QUITE REAL. THE CHINESE KNOW THE CALENDAR.
22:58 THEY KNOW THEY ONLY HAVE TWO MORE YEARS OF TRUMP.
23:04 I THINK THEY OBVIOUSLY WILL WANT THE TRADE TRUCE EXTENDED THROUGH
23:09 THE END OF THE ADMINISTRATION. THEY WANT SOME REASSURANCE ON
23:14 HIGH TECHNOLOGY, BUT THEY HAVE TO COME THROUGH ON AGRICULTURE
23:17 PURCHASES, REDUCING THE BARRIERS TO RARE EARTHS.
23:23 THERE ARE MANY STILL VERY COMPETITIVE THINGS IN THE TRADE
23:23 TALKS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN RESOLVED.
23:26 THIS WILL CONTINUE THROUGH THE NEXT SUMMIT IN MIAMI, SO THIS
23:40 WILL BE A CONTINUING PROCESS. PAUL: IN TERMS OF THE LEVERAGE
23:43 THAT THE U.S. AND CHINA EACH HAVE, ON THE U.S. SIDE, IT IS
23:47 RESTRICTIONS AROUND ADVANCED CHIPS.
23:51 ON THE CHINA SIDE, ACCESS TO CRITICAL MINERALS.
23:52 WHO HAS THE BETTER LEVERAGE, BEARING IN MIND THAT CRITICAL
23:56 MINERALS CAN BE MINED ELSEWHERE, BUT IT'S JUST NOT CONVENIENT TO
23:58 DO SO QUICKLY? >> AT THE MOMENT, CHINA HAS THE
24:04 BIGGER CARD. THERE IS ANOTHER CARD YOU DID
24:07 NOT MENTION, THOUGH. THE CHINESE ARE VERY WORRIED
24:11 ABOUT SPARE PARTS FOR THEIR BOEING AIRCRAFT, ENGINES FOR
24:15 THEIR BOEING AIRCRAFT, AND I UNDERSTAND THEY WANT SOME SORT
24:20 OF ASSURANCE FROM TRUMP THAT THAT WILL NOT BE USED AS A
24:23 SANCTION ANY TIME DURING THE NEXT TWO YEARS.
24:26 THE AMERICANS DO NOT HAVE AS BIG A CARD, BUT THEY HAVE SOME
24:27 CARDS. HAIDI: AS WE SPEAK, WE ARE
24:34 GETTING REPORTS OF WHAT SOUNDS LIKE ANOTHER OUTAGE AT AN NSA
24:37 FACILITY. THIS ONE POTENTIALLY AFFECTING
24:40 SOME OF THOSE MIDDLE EAST OPERATIONS.
24:44 WE ARE HEARING FROM OFFICIALS THAT CRITICAL INTEL GATHERING IS
24:48 STILL FUNCTIONING DESPITE THIS FACILITY THAT IS CRITICAL TO
24:50 MIDDLE EAST OPERATIONS BEING IMPACTED IN GEORGIA.
24:54 THIS IS THE SECOND OUTAGE FOR THE NSA.
24:58 MANY OUTAGES ACROSS OTHER SECTORS HAVE ALSO BEEN SEEN.
25:04 HOW CRITICAL IS THIS TO YOU? >> FIRST OF ALL, THERE IS
25:07 RESILIENCY. WE HAVE THE FIVE EYES PARTNERS.
25:13 OTHERS CAN TAKE OVER IN CERTAIN WAYS, BUT I AM VERY TROUBLED
25:19 THAT TWICE IN TWO DAYS NSA HAS HAD THIS PROBLEM.
25:23 NSA HAS TO OPERATE AT 100% CAPACITY.
25:26 WE CANNOT HAVE IT DEGRADED TO 70% OR 60% OF ITS CAPABILITY.
25:31 IN THIS CASE, MIDDLE EAST, VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE OF TERRORISM.
25:34 WE HAVE ALREADY HAD THESE THREATS APPARENTLY FROM THE
25:37 IRANIANS -- PAUL: I'M SORRY TO INTERRUPT YOU
25:41 BUT WE ARE OUT OF TIME. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US TODAY.
25:50 WE HAVE MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA TRADE."
25:53 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
26:04 HAIDI: WE HAVE BREAKING NEWS WHEN IT COMES TO THE PRICING OF
26:07 THE ANTHROPIC IPO. THEY ARE PRICING AT $83 A SHARE,
26:12 ABOVE THE MARKET RANGE. THIS IS WHAT WE EXPECTED, MAKING
26:16 IT THE BIGGEST FIRST TIMESHARE SALE ON RECORD.
26:25 IT IS EXPECTED TO RAISE AT LEAST $68 BILLION FOR THAT IPO, SO
26:28 TOTALING MORE THAN $94 BILLION FOR THE OFFERING.
26:31 THE STOCK IS EXPECTED TO TRADE ON THE NASDAQ GLOBAL SELECT
26:34 MARKET, AND THAT HAS BEEN CONFIRMED IN THIS STATEMENT AS
26:39 WELL. $83 A SHARE IS WHAT WE ARE
26:44 SEEING, THE CONFIRMATION THAT IT IS ABOVE THE MARKETED RANGE.
26:46 THE BIGGER QUESTION IS IF THIS WILL BE ENOUGH TO SETTLE SOME OF
26:51 THE RESIDUAL NERVES THE BROADER MARKET HAS AFTER THE NVIDIA
26:55 DRAMA AND AFTER A LOT OF EXISTENTIAL QUESTIONS AS TO THE
26:58 VALUE OF THE AI TRADE. LET'S GET MORE FROM OUR "CHINA
27:04 SHOW" COANCHOR. DAVID: THEY DIDN'T PRICE IT, TO
27:14 YOUR POINT, ABOVE THE RANGE, AND WHAT'S ALSO INTERESTING, SOME
27:16 PEOPLE MIGHT BE FORGETTING THE POINT THAT YOU JUST MADE THAT
27:20 THERE IS ALSO PRIVATE PLACEMENT INVOLVED, SO IF YOU COMBINE THE
27:25 TWO, IT IS MUCH LARGER THAN THE SPACEX OFFERING.
27:27 IT ALSO DOES SEEM THAT, JUST GOING THROUGH SOME OF THE
27:33 DETAILS, THE UPSIDE IS IPO TO 900 80 MILLION SHARES.
27:36 TO BREAK THINGS DOWN, NINE HUNDRED 56 MILLION SHARES WERE
27:41 SOLD BY ANTHROPIC. A FURTHER JUST OVER 23.5 MILLION
27:46 WERE SOLD BY THE HOLDERS ITSELF, AND YOU PRICE THAT AT ABOUT 83
27:53 GETS YOU TO THAT MASSIVE LISTING, AND AS WE ALL KNOW, THE
27:56 SHARES TRADE NOVEMBER 19, THURSDAY IN THE U.S.
28:01 IRONICALLY, THE TICKER FOR THIS MASSIVE ONE IS ANT.
28:08 PAUL: LET'S GET MORE REACTION ON ANTHROPIC FROM THE SINGAPORE
28:10 FINTECH FESTIVAL, WHICH BUSY -- WHICH BEGINS TODAY.
28:19 OUR "INSIGHT" COANCHOR IS STANDING BY WITH OUR NEXT GUEST.
28:25 HASLINDA: GOOD YOU HAVE YOU WITH US.
28:28 WE WERE JUST TALKING ABOUT HOW PRICING FOR ANTHROPIC HAS COME
28:30 THROUGH. $84 PER SHARE.
28:35 WE ARE LOOKING AT A VALUATION OF $1.4 TRILLION.
28:38 YOUR INSTINCTIVE REACTION WOULD BE AT THIS POINT?
28:42 >> AT THIS POINT, I DON'T KNOW WHAT PRICE IS REAL AND WHAT IS
28:44 NOT. THE ISSUE IS THAT THE
28:47 REPLACEMENT COST OF THE SYSTEMS HAVE NOT BEEN FACTORED IN.
28:55 ARE WE REALLY LOOKING AT HOW THE NEXT SIX MONTHS AND 12 MONTHS
28:59 WILL LOOK LIKE? WE WILL SEE HOW THE MARKET
29:05 REACTS. HASLINDA: THE RISK IS ALSO AFTER
29:08 THE LOCK-IN PERIOD EXPIRES. WHAT DO YOU SEE HAPPENING?
29:18 >> WE SAW THIS WHEN A BIG TRILLION DOLLAR VALUATION
29:19 COMPANY WENT PUBLIC AND LOOK WHAT HAPPENED.
29:24 IF THE MARKET HAS EXTERNALITIES COMING TO MAKE AN IMPACT ON
29:27 PRICES. HASLINDA: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF
29:34 SUCH A MASSIVE VALUATION? >> THEY ARE PUTTING MONEY ON
29:44 FUEL. IF ONE THING FALLS, OTHER THING
29:51 FALLS, SO IT IS QUITE A SCARY TIME WE ARE IN, SO VERY COMPLEX,
29:57 SO THERE IS A WHOLE SET OF UNCERTAINTY IN THE MARKET.
30:03 WITH THE MARKET PRICE GOES IS VERY UNCERTAIN.
30:04 HASLINDA: YOU TALK ABOUT THE RISK.
30:09 WHAT IS IT THAT TECH GROWS ARE DOING?
30:13 >> I THINK THAT IS A BIG ISSUE BECAUSE IT IS CERTAINLY A CREDIT
30:18 TO THE TECH MARKET. IF SOMETHING GOES WRONG, CREDIT
30:22 WILL SQUEEZE. IF THINGS GO WRONG, A DEBT
30:29 MARKET BUBBLE IS MUCH MORE DANGEROUS THAN A CREDIT MARKET
30:32 BUBBLE BECAUSE THAT AFFECTS EVERYBODY.
30:34 THAT SHIFT IS REAL. HASLINDA: WHEN IT COMES TO AI,
30:42 IT IS FRONT AND CENTER FOR SEVERAL BANKS, FOR INSTITUTIONS
30:44 LIKE THE IMF. THEY ARE THINKING ABOUT IF IT IS
30:48 A PURE GROWTH STORY OR IT COULD BE A SOURCE OF SYSTEMIC RISK.
30:54 >> I THINK THERE ARE MANY THINGS TO LOOK AT.
30:58 I THINK THE REAL ISSUE IS HOW IT IS BEING FINANCED.
31:00 THERE IS A SUPPLIER, A VENDOR RELATIONSHIP, SO IF YOU LOOK AT
31:08 THE GROWTH, IS IT REAL GROWTH, OR IS IT BEING FUNDED IN A
31:13 SUPPLEMENTAL WAY. IT MAKES THIS DISCLOSURE ISSUE A
31:16 BIG PART OF THE DISCUSSION. IF YOU DON'T GET THE DISCLOSE
31:20 RIGHT, HOW THE GROWTH IS COMING, WE HAVE A REAL PROBLEM.
31:25 HASLINDA: WHAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN? >> THE DISCLOSURE.
31:30 WHY THIS FUNDING IS HAPPENING, IF IT IS REAL.
31:35 HASLINDA: THE OTHER CONCERN IS THAT THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF
31:41 INSTITUTIONS USING VERY FEW FOUNDATIONAL AI MODELS.
31:50 THAT OPENS THE RISK TO A CRASH THAT INVOLVES EVERYBODY.
31:51 >> YESTERDAY, I HAD A GOOD DISCUSSION.
31:56 HE SAID YOU COULD USE COMMON MODELS, BUT THE REAL DECISION
31:59 COMES AT THE APPLICATION LAYER, WHAT PART OF THE BUSINESS YOU
32:03 ARE CHOOSING TO GO TO AI, AND THAT DECISION MAY PROVIDE THE
32:08 SECRET OF WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE COMMON USE.
32:11 THERE IS A POSITIVE STORY, BUT THE BIG PICTURE IS RIGHT.
32:14 THERE IS A COMMON MODEL HURTING THE ISSUE, WHICH YOU HAVE TO
32:18 WATCH OUT FOR. HASLINDA: IS THERE ANYTHING YOU
32:22 CAN DO? >> YOU MAKE THE CHOICE WHERE AI
32:28 WILL MAKE AN IMPACT, WHAT BUSINESS MODELS.
32:34 HASLINDA: ARE WE GETTING CLOSE TO SUCH A CRASH?
32:44 >> I THINK THERE ARE SIGNALS OF A PROBLEM COMING UP.
32:46 WE HAVE TO BE VERY CAREFUL ABOUT THAT OPTION.
32:54 I THINK MODELS ARE GETTING MORE SCRUTINY ON WHAT DATA THEY PICK
32:56 UP. SECONDLY, LARGE SOVEREIGN
33:02 COUNTRIES ARE LOOKING AT THEIR OWN DOMESTIC MODEL.
33:06 THE STACK IS GETTING SPLIT. THIS WHOLE THING, FRAGMENTATION
33:15 HAS BECOME A BIG PART OF THE ISSUE.
33:17 WE ARE GETTING INTO SOME UNCERTAIN MASSIVE CHANGE --
33:23 HASLINDA: MI RIGHT TO SAY THAT FRAGMENTATION IS HAPPENING NOT
33:28 JUST IN THE U.S. AND CHINESE MODELS?
33:29 >> BEYOND THAT. THE LAST COUNTRY WITH RESOURCES
33:32 AND DATA WILL HAVE THEIR OWN MODELS AND THEIR OWN TECH STACK.
33:37 ABSOLUTELY. HASLINDA: HOW MIGHT THIS LOOK
33:41 LIKE? >> HIGHLY FRAGMENTED.
33:45 INTEROPERABILITY WILL BE THE KEY WORD.
33:48 TRANSLATED WILL BE THE KEY WORD. HASLINDA: ALWAYS A PLEASURE TO
33:52 SPEAK WITH YOU. CO-FOUNDER AND CEO AT GLOBAL
33:59 FINANCE AND TECHNOLOGY. WE ARE COMING TO YOU FROM THE
34:02 FINTECH FESTIVAL HERE IN THE LION CITY.
34:07 HAIDI: WILL HAVE MORE FROM HASLINDA AT THE SINGAPORE
34:13 FINTECH FESTIVAL IN THE NEXT HOUR.
34:17 COVERAGE CONTINUES ACROSS "THE CHINA SHOW" AND "INSIGHT."
34:27 MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA TRADE." THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
35:23 OF THE HOUR, WE DID GET PRICING ON THE ANTHROPIC IPO, COMING IN
35:27 AS WE HAD REPORTED EARLIER, $83 A SHARE, VALUING THE COMPANY AT
35:36 1.4 TRILLION DOLLARS, $1.5 TRILLION.
35:45 THE CIO AT FOUNDERS 100 ETF'S JOINS US.
35:47 THANKS SO MUCH FOR YOUR TIME TODAY.
35:51 THIS IS THE BIG ONE FOR 2026, BUT DO YOU SENSE A TENSION
35:55 BETWEEN ON THE ONE HAND SURGING REVENUES AND FORECASTS OF
35:57 REVENUES AGAINST SURGING SPENDING AS WELL?
36:01 >> ABSOLUTELY. THE WAIT IS OVER, ANTHROPIC IS
36:04 HERE. IT SHOULD DEBUT TOMORROW.
36:15 I THINK WEEK ONE WILL SHIFT INVESTORS' FOCUS TO
36:19 CYBERSECURITY AND CAPEX. THEY HAVE GROWN THEIR SALES FROM
36:25 ZERO TO 80 $1 BILLION IN JUST THREE YEARS.
36:26 THAT IS THE FASTEST ENTERPRISE GROWTH WE HAVE SEEN FROM ANY
36:30 TECHNOLOGY IN HISTORY. AT THE SAME TIME, GOLDMAN SACHS
36:35 IS FORECASTING $66 BILLION OF FREE CASH FLOW LOSSES THIS NEXT
36:40 YEAR, SO THEY HAVE A LOT OF WORK CUT OUT FOR THEM AHEAD TO MAKE
36:42 THIS A SUCCESS. PAUL: IF WE DON'T SEE THE
36:49 PROFITABILITY THAT PERHAPS THE MARKET IS HOPING FOR HERE, HOW
36:54 QUARTERS? >> YES, AT $83 A SHARE, THAT
37:07 IMPLIES A SALES MULTIPLE AROUND 11 TIMES.
37:09 I THINK WE COULD SEE SHARES GO LOWER THAN THAT IF THEY DO NOT
37:10 LIVE UP TO THE TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF GROWTH THAT THEY HAVE HAD.
37:17 WHAT GIVES ME CONFIDENCE IS THEY REVEALED ON THIS LAST QUARTER'S
37:24 REPORT THAT THEY HAVE OVER 1900 CUSTOMERS THAT ARE COMMITTED TO
37:27 SPENDING ONE MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR AND OVER 250 CUSTOMERS
37:31 SPENDING AT LEAST $2 MILLION A YEAR AND THEIR RETENTION RATE IS
37:34 900%. THAT MEANS A CUSTOMER SPENDING
37:38 ONE DOLLAR A YEAR AGO IS NOW SPENDING NINE DOLLARS WITH THEM.
37:46 IT IS BECOMING EMBEDDED INTO ENTERPRISE CUSTOMER WORKFLOWS.
37:53 HAIDI: THERE ARE BROADER ISSUES OUTSIDE OF ANTHROPIC THAT WE
37:54 HAVE SEEN A SHAKE THE BROADER CONFIDENCE WHEN IT COMES TO AI.
38:02 DO YOU SEE THESE FACTORS SUCH AS WHAT WE SAW IN THE MIDTERMS AND
38:05 A LOT OF THESE STATES, SUCH AS TEXAS, FOR EXAMPLE, DATA CENTERS
38:09 WERE THE CORE REASON WE SAW THAT PERFORMANCE AS WELL AS THE
38:14 NVIDIA PRICES AND SOME OF THE GEOPOLITICAL ELEMENTS.
38:17 HOW DOES THAT COALESCE IN TERMS OF A RISKIER OPERATING
38:18 ENVIRONMENT FOR A COMPANY LIKE ANTHROPIC?
38:23 >> YES, SO, CUSTOMER FINANCING IS NOTHING NEW OR LARGE CAPEX
38:27 PROJECTS. FORD DID IT FOR ALL OF THEIR
38:31 AUTOMOBILES. BOEING DOES IT FOR PLANES.
38:35 I DON'T SEE THIS AS ANY DIFFERENT.
38:37 THE COMPANIES WE ARE TALKING ABOUT, THE NUMBERS ARE HUGE, BUT
38:42 WE HAVE VERY DEEP POCKETS AND A LOT OF CAPABILITY TO FINANCE
38:46 THESE DEALS AND BUILD OUT THIS NEXT LAYER OF INFRASTRUCTURE
38:52 FORWARD. HASLINDA: WHAT ABOUT THE
39:02 REGULATORY HURDLES, THE? >> YES, I LIVE IN TEXAS, AND IT
39:09 IS NOT AS BAD AS IT SEEMED IN THE MIDTERMS.
39:13 I THINK COMING OUT OF IT, PEOPLE, WHEN YOU SPEAK TO THEM,
39:17 JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THEIR COMMUNITY IS TAKEN CARE OF.
39:20 THEY DON'T WANT TO SEE THEIR ELECTRIC BILL GO UP.
39:21 THEY DON'T WANT TO SEE THEIR SCARCE WATER RESOURCES USED IN
39:25 MY HOME STATE. THEY WANT TO MAKE SURE THE
39:27 CENTERS THAT ARE BUILT ARE DONE SO RESPONSIBLY AND THAT THEY
39:31 CONTRIBUTE TO THE COMMUNITY AND DO NOT TAKE AWAY FROM THEM.
39:35 I THINK THERE IS A PATH FORWARD FOR THAT TO HAPPEN.
39:38 I DO NOT THINK THAT IS TRUE IN EVERY STATE, BUT 30% OF THE
39:42 PROJECTS ARE BEING BUILT IN TEXAS, AND I'M CONFIDENT THAT
39:44 THOSE WILL BE ABLE TO MOVE AHEAD WITHOUT MUCH TROUBLE IF THEY
39:50 HAVE REASONABLE PLANS IN PLACE AND ARE WILLING TO WORK WITH
39:56 COMMUNITIES TO MAKE IT A WIN-WIN .
39:57 PAUL: IN TERMS OF BROADER MARKET REACTION TO THIS IPO, THERE'S A
40:02 LOT OF EXPECTATION THAT THIS WILL SETTLE SOME OF THE NERVES
40:06 AROUND THE BROADER AI TRADE. DO YOU SHARE THAT OPTIMISM?
40:12 >> ABSOLUTELY. I THINK THIS IS A PIVOTAL IPO.
40:15 IT IS COMING AT AN EXTRAORDINARY TIME.
40:22 WITH GINS AND LEAVING NVIDIA, I THINK ALL EYES ARE FOCUSED ON
40:25 ANTHROPIC AS ONE OF THE NEW DEFINING LEADERS OF WHERE AI IN
40:33 AMERICA GOES FROM HERE. I THINK EVERYONE IS QUESTIONING
40:35 AMERICA'S ABILITY TO CONTINUE TO HAVE AI LEADERSHIP, AND I THINK
40:40 THAT A SUCCESSFUL IPO WILL GO A LONG WAY IN REASSURING NERVES
40:49 AND COMBING FEARS THAT WE STILL HAVE A BRIGHT FUTURE AHEAD FOR
40:53 AI. IF THINGS DO NOT GO WELL, I
40:56 THINK THAT COULD BE BAD NOT JUST FOR TECH BUT ALSO PERHAPS EVEN
41:01 SEND US INTO A BEAR MARKET IN THAT THIS HAS BEEN A CORNERSTONE
41:07 OF AMERICAN CONFIDENCE IN THE MARKET FOR GOING ON 8, 10
41:13 QUARTERS NOW. PAUL: YEAH, AND ABSOLUTELY, JUST
41:17 TO TALK ABOUT THE RISK A LITTLE BIT MORE, THERE IS SO MUCH
41:21 CONCENTRATION OF AI AND INDEXES AT THE MOMENT, THE NVIDIA
41:26 EXPERIENCE JUST SHOWED US THE REMOVAL OF ONE KEY PERSON CAN
41:30 CAUSE GLOBAL JITTERS. ARE YOU CONCERNED ABOUT WHAT
41:31 THAT CONCENTRATION RISK MEANS FOR BROAD MARKETS AS A WHOLE?
41:38 >> ABSOLUTELY. NVIDIA HAS A 90% MARKET SHARE.
41:48 IF YOU WANT THOSE CHIPS, NVIDIA IS THE ONLY WHEN YOU LOOK TO GO
41:57 TO, SO NOT HAVING THEIR FOUNDER -- WE FOCUS ON FOUNDER-RUN
42:02 COMPANIES. WITHOUT JENSEN AT THE HELM,
42:04 NVIDIA HAS TAKEN A HUGE STEP BACK.
42:07 THERE WAS LOST CONFIDENCE THERE, SO WE ARE LOOKING FOR LEADERS TO
42:16 STEP UP ACROSS THE TECH COMPLEX AND CONTINUE TO DRIVE INNOVATION
42:19 AND CARRY AMERICA FORWARD. THE RISKS HAVE NEVER BEEN
42:21 HIGHER, BUT I WOULD ALSO SAVE THE REWARDS AND THE POTENTIAL
42:25 FOR THAT HAS NEVER BEEN HIGHER AS WELL.
42:32 HAIDI: IT IS INTERESTING, I WAS READING THROUGH YOUR NOTES
42:35 TALKING ABOUT ANTHROPIC BECOMING ONE OF THE DEFINING FOUNDER-LED
42:39 COMPANIES AT THE AI-ERIC, BUT THAT IT CAN STILL BE A POOR
42:43 INVESTMENT AT THE WRONG PRICE. I GUESS I WANTED TO GO TO THIS
42:48 IDEA OF FOCUSING ON A BEING A FOUNDER-LED INVESTMENT
42:49 OPPORTUNITY. DOES WHAT HAPPENING CONTINUES TO
42:55 PLAY OUT AT NVIDIA CREATE THE CAUTIONARY TALE IN TERMS OF
42:57 FOCUSING TOO MUCH ON A SINGLE PERSON?
43:01 THERE'S A LOT OF PRESSURE FOR DARIO TO STEP INTO THE LIMELIGHT
43:05 AND FILL THAT GAP BEING LEFT BY JENSEN.
43:11 >> YES, FOUNDERS ARE DIFFERENT. THEY ARE SPECIAL IN THAT WHEN
43:16 YOU HAVE A HIGHLY INNOVATIVE INDUSTRY AND COMPANY, THEY
43:22 REALLY HAVE THE VISION, THE COMPETENCE, THE COURAGE, THE
43:25 GRIT, AND THE EXECUTION NECESSARY TO NAVIGATE AND DRIVE
43:32 THEIR HIGH-PERFORMING TEAMS TOWARDS THAT INSPIRING MISSION.
43:36 YOU DON'T REALLY NEED THAT LEADERSHIP IF YOU ARE IN A VERY
43:39 STABLE INDUSTRY. THINK UTILITIES.
43:42 BUT IT REALLY MAKES A HUGE DIFFERENCE, WHERE WE SEE A
43:48 FOUNDER PREMIUM IN OUR COMPANIES, IS AT THE CUTTING
43:49 EDGE OF TECHNOLOGY, AND I THINK THAT NVIDIA WITH JENSEN IS THE
43:57 PINNACLE OF THAT. AS AN EXAMPLE, STEVE JOBS LEFT
44:01 APPLE IN 1985. HE RESIGNED AND SPENT SEVERAL
44:05 YEARS AWAY, BUT HE FINALLY CREATED NEXT.
44:10 IT GREW AND WAS ACQUIRED BY APPLE, AND HE BECAME THE CEO
44:14 ONCE AGAIN TO THE BENEFIT OF SHAREHOLDERS AND ALSO FOR THE
44:18 BENEFIT OF THE WORLD WITH THE CREATION OF ALL NEW PRODUCTS
44:26 THAT WE ALL LOVE AND USE, BUT IT IS TERRIBLE TO SEE WHAT HAPPENED
44:28 WITH JENSEN, BUT WE ARE WAITING TO FIND OUT WHAT THE CONCLUSION
44:33 OF THE INVESTIGATION IS SO WE KNOW HOW TO NAVIGATE FROM HERE.
44:40 HAIDI: REALLY GREAT TO HAVE YOU WITH US, CIO AT FOUNDERS 100
44:45 ETF'S. MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA TRADE."
44:49 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
45:01 HAIDI: JUST GIVING YOU THE LATEST ACROSS THE ANTHROPIC
45:03 PRICING. WE HAVE CONFIRMATION THAT
45:09 PRICING IS THE -- PRICING IS AT $83 A SHARE, ABOVE THE MARKET
45:10 RANGE WE HAD BEEN EXPECTING. IF YOU TAKE IT WITH A
45:17 COMBINATION OF PRIVATE PLACEMENT WE ARE LOOKING AT AS WELL, THAT
45:22 WILL BRING THAT IPO TO 81.3 BILLION DOLLARS, TOPPING THE
45:24 RECORD SET BY SPACEX'S DEBUT. IT ISN'T AN UPSIDE IS IPO TO
45:31 FUND THE DEVELOPMENT GOING FORWARD WHEN IT COMES TO THIS
45:32 COMPANY. 956.4 MILLION SHARES.
45:42 THE FULLY DILUTED VALUATION AT ROUGHLY 1.5 TRILLION DOLLARS, SO
45:46 IT IS THE BIGGEST IPO OF ALL TIME.
45:50 SPACEX WAS AT 75 BILLION DOLLARS.
45:51 THAT WAS THE BASE DEAL, IF YOU RECALL.
45:55 NO MATTER IF YOU ARE IN AI BULL OR SKEPTIC, IT IS A WATERSHED
46:00 MOMENT FOR THE BROADER INDUSTRIES.
46:01 INVESTORS ARE EXPANDING THEIR FOCUS TO THESE FRONTIER PLATFORM
46:06 MAKERS SUCH AS CLAUDE AND WE ARE LOOKING AT THIS AS SOMETHING OF
46:11 A LITMUS TEST FOR OPENAI. THEY ARE NOT EXPECTED TO GO TO
46:15 IPO BEFORE 2027, BUT WE ARE WATCHING VERY KEENLY.
46:18 LET'S BRING GARFIELD REYNOLDS. THE PRICING IS WHAT WE REPORTED
46:22 EARLIER. IT IS ON THE HIGHER END.
46:27 WE KNOW IT HAS BEEN EXPANDED. DOES IT SPEAK TO CONFIDENCE IN
46:30 TERMS OF A CATALYST FOR THE BROADER AI TRADE?
46:34 GARFIELD: THAT IS A MUCH TOUGHER ASK.
46:42 I THINK IT DOES AVOID SETTING OFF A FRESH DOWNDRAFT.
46:50 WE'VE HAD ALL THESE EVENTS THAT WERE COMING IN, AND THE BIGGER
46:53 RISKS HAVE BEEN TO THE DOWNSIDE, SO THIS IS ONE DOWNSIDE RISK
46:56 REMOVED. WE CAN SEE SOMETHING OF A BOUNCE
47:04 IN A RANGE OF ASSETS, NOT JUST THE TECH TRADE, NOW THAT THAT
47:07 PRESSURE HAS BEEN REMOVED. THE LEVEL OF DEMAND FOR THE IPO
47:13 IS KIND OF A GOOD SIGN, TOO, IN THAT IT MEANS THERE'S PLENTY OF
47:18 PEOPLE WHO DID NOT GET WHAT THEY WANTED.
47:23 THERE WAS TALK OF A A LOT OF MONEY BEING SET ASIDE FOR
47:29 PARTICIPATING IN THE ANTHROPIC IPO, SO SOME OF THAT MONEY MAY
47:31 COME BACK IN AND BE LOOKING AT THINGS LIKE NVIDIA, THAT HAS
47:34 FALLEN SO FAR OR SOME OF THE OTHER TECH SHARES, OR, FOR THAT
47:42 MATTER, SOME OF THE COMMODITY ASSETS THAT HAVE BEEN BRUTALLY
47:45 HIT OVER THE PAST FEW DAYS. IN ALL OF THAT COMING AT A TIME
47:50 WHEN THE GLOBAL ECONOMY AND ESPECIALLY THE U.S. ECONOMY
47:56 STILL TRADING WELL ENOUGH FOR RAISING RATE -- FOR CENTRAL
47:58 BANKS TO RAISE RATES OR HOLD THEM.
48:07 IN THAT BACKGROUND, YOU WOULD EXPECT A LOT OF THESE ASSETS
48:11 DECLINE OR BE HIGHER THAN THEY ARE.
48:15 THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF FEAR OUT THERE, GENERATED PARTLY BY
48:18 ANTHROPIC, PARTLY BY NVIDIA, PARTLY BY THE WAY THAT
48:23 SKEPTICISM HAS INCREASED ABOUT THE OUTLOOK FOR AI, SO WITH A
48:30 CHEAPER ENTRY POINT FOR A LOT OF THESE ASSETS AND ANTHROPIC'S
48:35 DANGEROUS POTENTIALLY REMOVED, THAT WOULD SET US UP FOR A BIT
48:37 OF A RALLY. PAUL: GARFIELD REYNOLDS WHO
48:43 LEADS OUR MLIV ASIA MARKET COVERAGE.
48:54 MARKET OPEN IN TOKYO IS NEXT. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
49:23 ♪ HAIDI: THIS IS "THE ASIA TRADE."
49:24 AND LITTLE BIT OF A SIGH OF RELIEF, BUT WE WERE NOT FULLY
49:27 GET THAT RELIEF UNTIL ANTHROPIC BEGINS TRADING.
49:31 THE MARKETS JUST WANT TO SEE A GAIN, EVEN IF IT IS A MARGINAL
49:33 ONE. THEY WANT TO SEE SMOOTH TRADING
49:41 AND THAT SHOULD PAVE THE WAY FOR THESE INTENSE FEARS TO PERHAPS
49:43 DISSIPATE. WE KNOW THE FIRST DAY OF TRADING
49:45 CAN BE VOLATILE. WE DO HAVE CONFIRMATION, $83 A
49:50 SHARE. THIS WILL BE THE BIGGEST OF ALL
49:57 TIME. PAUL: ONE OF OUR GUESTS SAID
50:04 WHEN YOU DO AND I FEEL LIKE THIS, YOU REALLY WANT THE WIND
50:05 AT YOUR BACK, BUT THE WIND HAS BEEN A BIT FICKLE OF LATE.
50:10 REVENUES ARE CERTAINLY IMPRESSIVE.
50:15 HAIDI: INTERESTING QUESTIONS ON THE LEADERSHIP IN TERMS OF THIS
50:19 BEING ANOTHER FOUNDER-LED COMPANY AND WHAT THE
50:21 IMPLICATIONS ARE. WE ARE LOOKING A LITTLE MORE
50:23 CLOSELY AT THAT GIVEN WHAT WE HAVE SEEN WITH NVIDIA AND JENSEN
50:28 HUANG, BUT TAKE A LOOK AT HOW WE ARE GETTING TO THE OPEN.
50:32 THE NIKKEI PRETTY FLAT AT THE MOMENT AS WE COME ONLINE.
50:36 WE HAVE SEEN ASIAN STOCKS LOOK LIKE THEY WILL HAVE A BIT OF A
50:41 DOWN DAY OR A ROCKY DAY AHEAD OF THE ANTHROPIC DEBUT, GIVEN THERE
50:47 IS THAT NERVOUS LATE. WE HAVE THE PRICING, BUT WE DO
50:50 NOT KNOW HOW MUCH VOLATILITY AND LACK OF PREDICTABILITY THAT WILL
50:53 BE IN THAT FIRST DAY OF TRAINING AND THE DAYS THAT COME AFTER
50:54 THAT AS WELL. DOLLAR-AGAIN SITTING AT THAT 160
50:58 LEVEL. WE DID HAVE INDICATIONS FROM THE
51:01 FOMC MINUTES OF JUST HOW HAWKISH THE FED MIGHT HAVE TO BE.
51:05 A COUPLE OF POLICYMAKERS TALKING ABOUT A POSSIBLE MORE THAN 25
51:12 BASIS POINT MOVE, AND THAT WOULD CERTAINLY BE A BIG THING WHEN IT
51:16 COMES TO MOVING THESE U.S. DOLLAR ASSETS.
51:19 WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT HOW TREASURIES HAVE RESPONDED TO
51:20 THAT STORY. PAUL: ALLOW ME TO KILL THE MOOD
51:25 OR RATHER CHRISTOPHER WALLER WILL DO IT FOR ME.
51:29 HE IS TAKING 50 BASIS POINT RATE INCREASES SHOULD BE CONSIDERED
51:33 IF INFLATION VERSUS PEER IF THEY WILL ONLY BE 25 AT THE START OF
51:36 DECEMBER, HE SAYS THEY NEED TO SIGNAL THERE WILL BE ANOTHER
51:40 25-BASIS POINT MOVE AT THE END OF JANUARY.
51:49 FLOWS THROUGH THE STRAIT OF HORMUZ ARE HOLDING UP DESPITE
51:51 SHIP ATTACKS IN THE AREA, BUT THAT IS HELPING PULL YIELDS A
51:55 LITTLE LOWER AS WELL, BUT CERTAINLY, BACK TO THE AI TRADE,
51:59 COPPER TOOK A BEATING IN THE LONDON SESSION, DOWN TO ITS
52:03 LOWEST SINCE APRIL. BULLISH INVESTORS LEAVING THAT
52:06 BET, INCLUDING STANLEY DRUCKENMILLER AND ITS TIES TO
52:10 THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE BOOM. HAIDI: OF COURSE, THERE IS A
52:16 UNIVERSE OF STOCKS IN FOCUS IN THE LEAD UP TO THE ANTHROPIC
52:18 IPO. THE COMPANY PRICED AT $83 A
52:22 SHARE ABOUT THE MARKETED RANGE. ALL OF THIS LEADING TO VERY MUCH
52:28 A PICTURE OF CONFIDENCE AND ENTHUSIASM.
52:34 ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE ON A FIRST DAY OF TRAINING, RIGHT?
52:37 HOW BADLY DOES THIS MARKET NEED THIS DEBUT TO GO WELL?
52:42 >> THE MARKET OBVIOUSLY NEEDS TO SEE THAT ANTHROPIC BEING ONE OF
52:48 THE CONSEQUENTIAL COMPANIES OF THE AI ECOSYSTEM TO SUCCEED, AND
52:51 PART OF THAT WILL BE A SUCCESSFUL IPO, WHICH I'M SURE
52:56 INVESTMENT BANKERS WILL MAKE SURE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE THAT IT
52:59 IS SUCCESSFUL. THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE TRADE HAS
53:06 BEEN FAIRLY WASHED OUT. SENTIMENT HAS BECOME VERY
53:07 BEARISH VERY QUICKLY. INVESTORS ARE STILL LOOKING AT
53:11 HOW TO PLAY THE AI TRADE. IT IS LOOKING MORE AND MORE
53:17 LIKELY THAT THE APPLICATION LAYER IS WHERE INVESTORS ARE
53:20 THINKING MORE AND MORE, BUT AT THE SAME TOKEN, THE
53:21 INFRASTRUCTURE TRADE, WHICH HAS BEEN BEATEN UP IN THE LAST
53:25 SEVERAL WEEKS, IS LOOKING FOR SOME GOOD NEWS.
53:29 PAUL: I WANT TO GET TO OUR AI REPORTER.
53:34 WE HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS NEWS.
53:37 WE FINALLY GOT IT, THAT 83 BILLION PRICING.
53:39 A LITTLE BIT OF UNCERTAINTY AROUND THE AI TRADE.
53:43 MAYBE I'M UNDERSTATING THE MATTER HERE.
53:45 WHAT IS THE BROAD CLIMATE AROUND THIS LISTING?
53:49 RACHEL: SURE. THIS IS THE FIRST MAJOR AI
53:52 COMPANIES TO START TRADING PUBLICLY, OR IT WILL BE.
53:58 I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE BOTH INTERESTED AND EXCITED, BUT THEY
54:00 ARE ALSO HESITANT. WE STILL HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS
54:07 ABOUT HOW AI IS BEST USED, IF IT IS BEING HELPFUL TO COMPANIES
54:09 THAT ARE ALREADY PAYING FOR IT, AND IF THESE COMPANIES WILL BE
54:12 ABLE TO NOT JUST GENERATE REVENUE BUT GENERATE ENOUGH
54:16 REVENUE THAT THEY CAN MAKE A PROFIT.
54:18 AS WE KNOW FROM SEEING ANTHROPIC'S FINANCIALS, IT IS
54:22 SPENDING SO MUCH MONEY TO PROVIDE THE SERVICES IT PROVIDES
54:25 . HAIDI: THAT TELLS ME THAT
54:32 INVESTORS MAY HAVE QUITE A LIMITED AMOUNT OF PATIENTS IN
54:34 TERMS OF WHAT HAPPENS NEXT FOR THIS COMPANY.
54:39 RACHEL: THAT COULD BE. I THINK IT WILL BE INTERESTING
54:44 TO WATCH. THE COMING DAYS WILL BE
54:46 INTERESTING. WHATEVER HAPPENS OVER THE NEXT
54:47 FEW WEEKS. JUST WATCHING THE FIRST COUPLE
54:51 QUARTERS WHEN THE COMPANY HAS TO REPORT HOW IT'S DOING, IT WILL
54:55 BE INTERESTING TO SEE HOW THE STOCK MARKET REACTS TO THAT, AND
55:00 IT WILL ALSO BE INSTRUCTIVE FOR A BUNCH OF OTHER COMPANIES,
55:03 SPECIFICALLY OPENAI. IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER THIS
55:05 IS NOT JUST A BIG DEAL FOR ANTHROPIC BUT IT'S ALSO A BIG
55:08 DEAL FOR OPENAI AND SOME OTHER LARGER BUT STILL NOT PUBLICLY
55:13 TRADED AI COMPANIES THAT ARE POTENTIALLY ANGLING TO GO PUBLIC
55:17 AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE. IF THIS GOES WELL FOR ANTHROPIC,
55:20 THAT COULD BE ASSIGNED TO THEM THAT THEY COULD GO WELL FOR
55:24 THEM, TOO. PAUL: I WANT TO CIRCLE BACK TO
55:27 THE FICKLE WIND AT THE MOMENT. YOU MENTIONED A MOMENT AGO,
55:31 GOING UP BIT BEARISH ON COPPER, I MENTIONED THE FED LOOKING AT
55:36 MAYBE BACK TO BACK RATE HIKES AS WELL, AND THIS IN AN ENVIRONMENT
55:39 OF UNCERTAINTY AROUND THE AI STORY.
55:42 HOW WILL ALL THIS PLAY OUT? SUNNY: THE PRICE OF COPPER HAS
55:51 BEEN A GREAT SIGNAL FOR THE GLOBAL ECONOMY AND WERE RISK
55:55 SENTIMENT BROADLY IS HEADING. AT THE SAME TIME, WE HAVE SEEN
56:03 THE GOLD PRICE ALSO ROLL OVER. WE KNOW THE FED IS TRYING TO GET
56:06 AHEAD OF THESE RATE HIKING EXPECTATIONS AND TRYING TO
56:10 ANCHOR INFLATIONARY EXPECTATIONS, SO IT IS ALL
56:11 LEADING TO A VERY TIGHT PERIOD FOR LIQUIDITY AND WE HAVE SEEN
56:16 THAT PLAY OUT NOT JUST IN COMMODITY MARKETS BUT ALSO IN
56:19 EQUITY RISK SENTIMENT. THAT HAS DEFINITELY BECOME MORE
56:24 BEARISH AND FICKLE, AS YOU POINT OUT.
56:27 THESE ARE ALL THINGS WEIGHING ON SENTIMENT BROADLY.
56:30 IT'S IMPRESSIVE THAT IN THE BACK OF ALL THIS THAT ANTHROPIC IS
56:34 GETTING A HUGE IPO OUT AND HAS BEEN ABLE TO PUSH TO A HIGHER
56:39 PRICE RANGE, SO THIS DEFINITELY SOME ENTHUSIASM, AND I THINK
56:42 INVESTORS ARE LOOKING FOR WHAT ARE THE NEXT FEW CATALYSTS TO
56:48 REIGNITE THE ENTHUSIASM ON THE BROADER AI TRADE, SO I THINK
56:50 THAT IS SOMETHING WE'RE ARE WATCHING VERY CLOSELY.
56:54 HAIDI: IT WAS INTERESTING, SEEING THE REMARKS FROM SENATOR
57:01 ELIZABETH WARREN ABOUT THE SEC NEEDING TO PROTECT INVESTORS
57:04 FROM AN IPO OF THIS SIZE AND MAGNITUDE.
57:06 I THINK IT GOES TO THE BROADER CONCERNS VERY MUCH ALIVE ON
57:09 CAPITOL HILL OVER THE DEVELOPMENT OF AI AND HOW THAT
57:14 IS SPILLING INTO CAPITAL MARKETS AND RETIREMENT FUNDS AND SUCH.
57:20 DOES THE REGULATORY, GOVERNMENT TENSION SIDE OF THINGS PRESSURE
57:26 THE MARKET, ESPECIALLY AS WE HEAD INTO JANUARY FOLLOWING
57:28 THOSE MIDTERMS? >> YEAH, I THINK SO.
57:32 I THINK THIS IS A COMPANY THAT AT THIS POINT HAS GROWN SO MUCH
57:37 AND SO QUICKLY AND CLEARLY HAS INVESTOR SUPPORT.
57:39 IT HAS ALL OF THAT WALL STREET SUPPORT, BUT IT ALSO HAS BACK
57:43 AND FORTH WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
57:45 IT IS STILL TANGLING WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, WITH THE
57:48 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE OVER ISSUES THE TWO PARTIES HAD
57:50 EARLIER THIS YEAR. IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE
57:53 HOW ALL OF THAT COMES TOGETHER IN THE COMING MONTHS AND HOW THE
58:00 COMPANY PRESENTS ITSELF TO WASHINGTON, IF THAT CHANGES
58:04 AFTER THE IPO AND HOW. IT WILL ALSO BE INTERESTING TO
58:09 SEE HOW POLITICIANS ARE REACTING TO THE COMPANY IN THE COMING
58:13 WEEKS AND MONTHS DEPENDING ON THE COMPANY'S PERFORMANCE, AND
58:16 ALSO WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE COMPANY AND ITS TECHNOLOGY.
58:20 WE HAVE IN THE AI INDUSTRY IN GENERAL SOME BREACHES IN RECENT
58:24 THAT. AS A PUBLICLY TRADED COMPANY,
58:30 WHAT HAPPENS THEN? HOW DOES THE GOVERNMENT REACT TO
58:31 THAT? THERE'S A LOT OF FACTORS AT PLAY
58:35 THAT WILL BE FASCINATING TO WATCH PLAY OUT.
58:42 PAUL: THANKS FOR JOINING US. LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT OUR MOVERS
58:46 TRACKING OFF THE BACK OF THAT NEWS THAT WE DO HAVE A PRICE FOR
58:52 THE ANTHROPIC IPO. IT IS A MIXED BAG.
58:56 SOFTBANK FLAT. KEY OXLEY A WEAKER, SO LOOKING
59:00 AT THOSE STOCKS, YOU MIGHT SAY PERHAPS THERE'S A FEW
59:01 IDIOSYNCRATIC STORIES GOING ON, BUT THE BROADER NIKKEI INDEX IS
59:06 CURRENTLY STRONGER. HAIDI: THERE'S GEOPOLITICS TO
59:12 WATCH AS WELL. XI JINPING AND VLADIMIR PUTIN
59:18 HAVE TAKEN AIM AT ECONOMIC BARRIERS AT THE APAC SUMMIT.
59:22 OUR CHIEF NORTH ASIA CORRESPONDENT JOINS US FROM
59:23 SHENZHEN. THE TERM UNPRECEDENTED GETS
59:29 THROWN ABOUT, BUT THIS TRILATERAL SUMMIT IS TRULY
59:31 SOMETHING NOT SEEN BEFORE. STEPHEN: THAT'S RIGHT.
59:38 I DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH WILL COME OUT OF THE TRILATERAL.
59:39 MAYBE WE WILL GET MORE NEWS OUT OF THEIR BILATERAL BECAUSE PUTIN
59:45 AND TRUMP WERE SAID TO ALSO SCHEDULE A BILATERAL, JUST THE
59:49 TWO OF THEM. THEY MIGHT BE ABLE TO TALK ABOUT
59:53 THE WAR IN UKRAINE A LITTLE MORE DIRECTLY THAN IN A TRILATERAL
59:57 FORMAT, BUT ALSO, TRUMP AND XI ARE GOING TO HAVE THEIR THIRD
1:00:02 MEETING, SO THERE'S LOTS THAT COULD COME OUT OF THIS OR IT
1:00:05 MIGHT BE A LOT OF NOTHING. WE SIMPLY DON'T KNOW RIGHT NOW,
1:00:10 BUT WE KNOW XI JINPING GAVE A KEYNOTE SPEECH AT THE CEO SUMMIT
1:00:11 YESTERDAY FOLLOWED SHORTLY AFTER BY VLADIMIR PUTIN.
1:00:17 BY THE WAY, WE WERE NOT ALLOWED INTO THE ROOM FOR EITHER OF
1:00:18 THOSE SPEECHES. ALL THE OTHER ONES, MARK AND
1:00:23 OTHERS, WE COULD GO INTO, BUT PUTIN AND XI PRETTY MUCH HAVE
1:00:29 THE ROOM TO THEMSELVES. XI SAID THE GLOBAL TURMOIL IS
1:00:33 DEEPENING. HE URGED FOR THE REMOVAL OF
1:00:34 TRADE BARRIERS. HE SAID THE GLOBAL ECONOMY IS
1:00:39 RAMPANT WITH PROTECTIONISM AND UNILATERALISM, AND ALSO VLADIMIR
1:00:45 PUTIN ESSENTIALLY SAID HIS PARTICIPATION HERE SHOWS THAT
1:00:50 SANCTIONS WERE NOT SUCCESSFUL IN THE ATTEMPTS TO ISOLATE RUSSIA,
1:00:57 AND HE CLAIMED THAT THE RUSSIAN ECONOMY IS DOING ACTUALLY FAIRLY
1:00:59 WELL. WE WILL HAVE TO SEE ABOUT THAT
1:01:03 AS SOME HAVE CRITICIZED HIS PARTICIPATION HERE AS ANOTHER
1:01:11 ATTEMPT TO INCREASE HIS PRESENCE ON THE GLOBAL STAGE WHERE HE IS
1:01:17 ESSENTIALLY REGARDED BY MANY COUNTRIES, INCLUDING IN EUROPE,
1:01:20 AS AN INTERNATIONAL WAR CRIMINAL.
1:01:24 HE HAS BEEN GIVEN A VOICE IN CHINA.
1:01:26 HE WAS HERE IN SEPTEMBER LAST YEAR AT THAT PARADE IN BEIJING.
1:01:32 NOW HE IS MEETING XI AND TRUMP HERE.
1:01:33 THE BIG TRILATERAL IS WHAT WE HAVE ALL CIRCLED TO SAY, WHAT
1:01:37 WILL COME OF THAT? I TALKED TO A NOTED COLUMBIA
1:01:43 UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR. IN THE LATE 1980'S, HE WAS AN
1:01:47 ADVISOR TO GORBACHEV AND YELTSIN AND AN ADVISOR IN THE 1990'S TO
1:01:53 TWO UKRAINIAN PRESIDENTS. HE KNOWS THE ISSUES.
1:01:56 HE HAS BEEN A OF U.S. POLICIES AND NATO EXPANSIONISM, I NOTE,
1:02:03 AS A DISCLAIMER, BUT THIS IS WHAT HE HAD TO SAY YESTERDAY
1:02:07 ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF THE TRILATERAL.
1:02:09 >> I AM IN FAVOR OF THE THREE LEADERS MEETING.
1:02:13 I HOPE IT IS A CALM, GOOD MEETING.
1:02:16 I DON'T EXPECT TOO MUCH SPECIFICS COMING OUT OF IT, BUT
1:02:17 WE DON'T NEED FIREWORKS. WE DON'T NEED CONFLICT.
1:02:21 WE DON'T NEED THE U.S. VERSUS CHINA, WHO'S GOING TO WIN, WHICH
1:02:28 THE WORLD. STEPHEN: THAT SETS THE STAGE FOR
1:02:34 THAT TRILATERAL AND ALSO THE BILATERAL BETWEEN TRUMP AND
1:02:38 PUTIN AND THE BILATERAL BETWEEN TRUMP AND XI LATER TODAY.
1:02:44 PAUL: SO MUCH OF THESE MEETINGS ARE ABOUT OBJECTS AND THE
1:02:49 DIPLOMACY OF OBJECTS FROM WHO MEANS WHO IN THE AIRPORT AND WHO
1:02:52 STANDS WHERE IN THE FAMILY PHOTO WEARING WHAT.
1:02:56 EVERYTHING DOES MEAN SOMETHING, THOUGH.
1:02:57 CAN YOU TALK US THROUGH IT? STEPHEN: APAC IS GREAT FOR THAT
1:03:02 BECAUSE YOU GET THESE DIFFERENT WORLD LEADERS AND THE
1:03:04 POSITIONING ON THE STAGE AND ALSO MEETING AT THE AIRPORT.
1:03:09 WE DO HAVE TO READ A LOT INTO THE OPTICS BECAUSE IT DOESN'T
1:03:12 MATTER BECAUSE WE DON'T OFTEN GET AN LOT OF MONUMENTAL
1:03:16 DECLARATIONS OR AGREEMENTS. FOR EXAMPLE, MARK CARNEY AND XI
1:03:24 JINPING EARLIER THIS WEEK REAFFIRMED AND INCREASED THEIR
1:03:30 PARTNERSHIPS AND ALSO THEIR REMOVAL OF TARIFFS ON EACH
1:03:33 OTHER'S PRODUCTS, REAFFIRMING A LOT OF THINGS.
1:03:37 CARDI MET WITH TRUMP LAST NIGHT. THEY ARE TRYING TO WORK OUT A
1:03:42 DEAL FOR TARIFF RELIEF AND BURY THE HATCHET A LITTLE BIT.
1:03:45 MARK CARNEY CHARACTERIZED THEIR DISCUSSIONS AS TO STEPS FORWARD,
1:03:52 ONE STEP BACKWARDS, EXPRESSING SOME OF THE FRUSTRATION, BUT
1:03:54 ALSO, NEW DEAL WILL BE HAD UNLESS THERE THE INTEREST OF THE
1:03:59 CANADIENS AT HEART -- THE INTEREST OF THE CANADIANS AT
1:04:04 HEART, BUT IT IS IMPORTANT WHEN XI JINPING MEETS TRUMP AT THE
1:04:07 BOTTOM OF THE STAIRS. XI JINPING HIMSELF RECIPROCATED
1:04:13 THE GESTURE DONALD TRUMP DID IN WASHINGTON, D.C., MEETING DONALD
1:04:16 TRUMP AT THE AIRPORT AT THE BOTTOM OF THE STAIRS, SO THERE
1:04:21 IS ETIQUETTE AND RECIPROCITY THERE.
1:04:23 YOU MENTIONED SOME OF THE OTHER OPTICS.
1:04:25 I WANTED TO GET THIS IN A LITTLE BIT.
1:04:29 XI JINPING DID MEET WITH THE JAPANESE PRIME MINISTER.
1:04:31 WE KNOW ABOUT THEIR DIFFICULTIES BECAUSE OF THE COMMENTS SHE MADE
1:04:33 ABOUT TAIWAN MORE THAN A YEAR AGO AND THE DIPLOMATIC FREEZE
1:04:37 CHINA HAS IMPOSED ON JAPAN. THEY DID MEET.
1:04:39 THEY SHOOK HANDS. THERE WAS A SLIGHT SMILE FROM XI
1:04:43 JINPING. NOT MUCH ELSE WAS SAID, BUT
1:04:48 TAKAICHI-SAN WAS PLACED AT THE BACK OF THE FAMILY PHOTO
1:04:53 YESTERDAY, SORT OF IN THE BACKGROUND OFF TO THE RIGHT, BUT
1:05:01 GIVE CREDIT TO TAKAICHI-SAN. WHILE EVERYONE ELSE WAS IN DARK
1:05:03 COLORS, SHE WORE A BRIGHT PINK JACKET TO STAND OUT.
1:05:08 HAIDI: MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA TRADE."
1:05:10 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:05:35 HAIDI: TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE ARE WATCHING WHEN IT COMES TO
1:05:42 CRYPTOCURRENCIES, REGAINING SOME OF THAT GROUND.
1:05:48 THAT BACKDROP HAS DETERIORATED RAPIDLY, BUT AT THE MOMENT, WE
1:05:52 ARE SEEING OPTIMISM, PERHAPS BROADLY BEING EXTENDED, BECAUSE
1:05:56 OF THE UPSIDES OF THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
1:06:04 THIS WILL BE THE BIGGEST IPO, SUPERSEDING THAT OF SPACEX AS
1:06:05 WELL. IN THE MEANTIME, HASLINDA AMIN
1:06:09 IS WITH US AT THE SINGAPORE FINTECH WEEK WITH OUR NEXT GUEST
1:06:13 . HASLINDA: THAT'S RIGHT.
1:06:21 THE U.S. LISTED DIGITAL ASSET COMPANY PROVIDING CUSTOM WALLETS
1:06:26 AND OTHER FINANCIAL SERVICES TO INSTITUTIONAL CLIENTS.
1:06:30 WE ARE HERE TO TALK ABOUT DIGITAL ASSETS, BUT WE HAVE TO
1:06:33 TALK ABOUT ANTHROPIC FIRST AND THE PRICING OF $83 A SHARE.
1:06:42 DO YOU SEE THAT AS A WAY TO LIFT FRONTIER TECH HIGH?
1:06:48 >> GREAT TO SEE YOU. I THINK THAT HAS BEEN HOGGING
1:06:49 THE HEADLINES AND WE WILL HAVE TO WAIT TO SEE IT PLAY OUT, BUT
1:06:57 I THINK WE ARE EXCITED ABOUT THE ADDITIONAL ASSETS.
1:07:00 WE ARE PUSHING HARD ON ADOPTION BOTH FOR INTERNAL PROCESSES AS
1:07:02 WELL AS CUSTOMER INTERACTIONS. I THINK IT WILL BE EXCITING TO
1:07:08 SEE HOW THIS ALL PLAYS OUT. HASLINDA: YOU WORE A HAT AT THE
1:07:13 SUMMIT BANK OF SINGAPORE. IF YOU WERE TO PUT ON THAT HAT,
1:07:21 THIS? >> I THINK IT IS INTERESTING,
1:07:26 RIGHT? IN TERMS OF THE AMOUNT OF
1:07:28 CAPITAL THAT IS GOING INTO EMERGING TECH, INTO A I.
1:07:33 EVERY TIME THERE IS WIDESPREAD ADOPTION, YOU WILL KIND OF HAVE
1:07:40 TO LOOK AT THIS, NOT JUST FROM A FINANCIAL PERSPECTIVE, BUT THE
1:07:44 SYSTEMIC IMPACT, THE SYSTEMIC REACH, BUT EVEN FROM AN
1:07:48 INFRASTRUCTURE PERSPECTIVE, I THINK IT ALL COMES BACK TO FIRST
1:07:50 PRINCIPLES, WHICH IS MAKING SURE WE HAVE THE RIGHT GOVERNANCE,
1:07:55 THE RIGHT DUE DILIGENCE, AND THE RIGHT LEVEL OF TRANSPARENCY TO
1:07:57 MANAGE THESE RISKS. HASLINDA: IN TERMS OF SYSTEMIC
1:08:02 RISKS, HOW DO YOU THINK SOME BANKS WILL BE LOOKING AT THEM?
1:08:06 >> I THINK IT IS THE SAME WAY THEY ARE LOOKING AT ALL
1:08:08 DIFFERENT TYPES OF CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AREAS, WHICH IS
1:08:13 HOW WE ENSURE GOOD GOVERNANCE, HOW WE ASSESS THE OVERALL REACH
1:08:20 AND IMPACT. I THINK IT IS ABOUT GETTING THE
1:08:21 FACTS RIGHT AND GETTING THE CONTROLS RIGHT.
1:08:26 HASLINDA: OK, LET'S GET TO YOUR BUSINESS IN PARTICULAR.
1:08:32 YOU HAVE TRIPLED YOUR CLIENT BASE OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
1:08:33 YEARS. TALK TO US ABOUT WHAT IS REALLY
1:08:37 DRIVING THE GROWTH THERE. >> INDEED, WE HAVE TRIPLED OUR
1:08:40 CLIENT BASE IN ASIA PACIFIC OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS SINCE WE GOT
1:08:45 OUR LICENSE, AND IT HAS BEEN A PHENOMENAL PERIOD OF GROWTH
1:08:53 DRIVEN OUT OF OUR HUB IN SINGAPORE.
1:08:56 WE SEE OUR LICENSING FOOTPRINT AS A REAL ADVANTAGE, AND BEING
1:09:03 ABLE TO SECURE A LICENSE FROM AS WELL REGULATED A JURISDICTION A
1:09:05 SINGAPORE I THINK HAS INCREASED THE INDUSTRY'S CONFIDENCE IN OUR
1:09:09 ABILITY TO PROVIDE INSTITUTIONAL GRADE INFRASTRUCTURE, OF COURSE,
1:09:13 MARRIED WITH OUR LICENSING FOOTPRINT ELSEWHERE IN THE
1:09:18 WORLD, INCLUDING OUR FEDERAL TRUST BANK CHARTER IN THE U.S.
1:09:23 I THINK HAVING THE LICENSE HAS BROUGHT THAT INTO THE REGION TO,
1:09:27 AND IS SOMETHING THAT IS FAMILIAR AND WELL UNDERSTOOD BY
1:09:29 OUR CUSTOMERS IN THE REGION, AND IT MEANS SOMETHING TO THEM IN
1:09:35 TERMS OF REGULATORY PARTS. HAIDI: IN TERMS OF EXPANSION,
1:09:42 WHERE ELSE ARE YOU AT HASLINDA: IN TERMS OF EXPANSION, WHERE
1:09:43 ELSE ARE YOU LOOKING? QUICKLY PASSED LEGISLATION IN
1:09:49 KOREA EARLIER THIS YEAR. THAT WAS A HUGE MILESTONE FOR
1:09:51 US. I THINK IT IS ONE OF THE HIGHEST
1:09:54 CRYPTO ADOPTION MARKETS IN ASIA AND EVEN THE WORLD, AND WE ARE
1:09:58 EXCITED ABOUT THE GROWTH POTENTIAL, ESPECIALLY NOW THAT
1:10:05 WE HAVE A REGULATED PRESENCE ON THE GROUND.
1:10:06 HASLINDA: AND OF COURSE, COMPETITION FROM HONG KONG.
1:10:10 YOU HAVE TO IMAGINE THAT IS REALLY STIFF COMPETITION COMING
1:10:13 FROM THE CITY. >> YES, THE PERENNIAL QUESTION
1:10:18 OF HONG KONG VERSUS SINGAPORE. AT THE END OF THE DAY, THERE IS
1:10:22 NO RIGHT ANSWER, AND FOR US, SINGAPORE IS OUR ASIA-PACIFIC
1:10:26 HUB, AND IT IS A DECISION THAT HAS PAID OFF FOR US IN TERMS OF
1:10:30 CREDIBILITY IN TERMS OF POSITIONING OURSELVES IN THE
1:10:35 MIDDLE OF ALL THE ACTIVITY HAPPENING IN THE REGION.
1:10:39 I JUST RETURNED FROM HONG KONG A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO, AND I DO
1:10:46 THINK THERE IS A LOT GOING ON THERE.
1:10:46 WE ARE MAINTAINING ACTIVE CONVERSATIONS, AND WITH
1:10:50 REGULATORS ARE FOCUSED ON IN BUT -- ON PROVIDING AN ENVIRONMENT
1:10:57 OF REGULATORY CLARITY WHILE MAINTAINING ROBUST STANDARDS,
1:11:00 AND I THINK THAT DOES MEAN SOMETHING FOR THE INDUSTRY.
1:11:03 HASLINDA: WHAT SHOULD WE BE LOOKING OUT FOR IN THE NEXT 12,
1:11:08 24 MONTHS THAT IS NOT VISIBLE TODAY IN TERMS OF DEVELOPMENTS?
1:11:13 >> I THINK IT IS KIND OF LIKE THE QUIET BUILDING FROM THE
1:11:17 INSTITUTIONAL PARTICIPANTS, AND THAT HAS COME IN THE BACK OF
1:11:20 REGULATORY CLARITY. FROM A REGULATORY PERSPECTIVE,
1:11:24 WE ARE IN A POSITION WHERE WE DO HAVE A FAIR AMOUNT OF REGULATORY
1:11:26 CLARITY. WE HAVE STABLECOINS FRAMEWORKS
1:11:34 IN PLACE IN SINGAPORE, IN HONG KONG, AND I THINK WE ARE
1:11:39 CONVERGING, FOR EXAMPLE, TO A GLOBALLY ALIGNED UNDERSTANDING
1:11:42 OF WHAT IT MEANS TO BE A STABLECOIN, THINGS LIKE BEING
1:11:47 FULLY BACKED BY LIQUID ASSETS. THOSE ARE THEN DRIVING
1:11:52 INSTITUTIONAL ADOPTION, INSTITUTIONAL CONVERSATIONS, AND
1:11:54 THE KIND OF CONVERSATIONS WE ARE HAVING BEHIND CLOSED DOORS TODAY
1:11:57 WITH OUR INSTITUTIONAL CUSTOMERS.
1:12:01 MAYBE A YEAR, 18 MONTHS AGO, IT WAS LIKE, SHOULD WE HAVE
1:12:02 ADDITIONAL ASSET STRATEGY? HASLINDA: BUT THAT IT OFTEN HAS
1:12:10 NOT COME QUICKLY. PEOPLE ARE HESITANT.
1:12:14 >> EXACTLY, WHICH IS WHY I THOUGHT IT WAS THE PERFECT
1:12:17 ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION ABOUT WHAT WE SEE QUIETLY HAPPENING IN
1:12:20 THE NEXT 12 TO 24 MONTHS. I THINK IT WILL BE THAT
1:12:22 INSTITUTIONAL ADOPTION STORY. PAUL: THANKS VERY MUCH.
1:12:29 WE WILL HAVE MORE FROM THE SINGAPORE FINTECH FESTIVAL
1:12:31 COMING UP WITH CRYPTO STILL IN FOCUS.
1:12:38 LATER ON "INSIGHT," HASLINDA WILL BE SPEAKING WITH THE HEADS
1:12:43 OF PAYPAL AND RIPPLE. THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:13:01 SAYING INTEREST RATES WILL BE HIGHER FOR LONGER.
1:13:04 THEY ARE NOT GOING TO BE HIGHER FOR LONGER.
1:13:07 THEY ARE GOING TO BE NORMAL FOR LONGER.
1:13:10 HIGHER FOR LONGER MEANS WE SHOULD BE GOING BACK SOMEWHERE,
1:13:13 BACK TO THE GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS.
1:13:15 THAT WAS THE ABNORMALITY, NOT WHERE RATES ARE NOW.
1:13:18 RATES TODAY ARE TELLING ME THE ECONOMY IS DOING PRETTY WELL.
1:13:26 HAIDI: TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT WE ARE WATCHING WHEN IT COMES TO
1:13:29 U.S. ASSETS AS WE CONTINUE TO MONITOR THAT MARKET REACTION TO
1:13:33 THE ANTHROPIC IPO PRICING AT 83 DOLLARS, ABOVE THE MARKETED
1:13:35 RANGE. THERE'S QUITE A LOT OF
1:13:38 CONFIDENCE, BUT A LOT OF THAT SIGH OF RELIEF WILL COME ONCE
1:13:41 THAT DAY BEAUFORT TRADING IS UNDERWAY AND WE DON'T SEE TOO
1:13:45 MUCH VOLATILITY OR UNCERTAINTY LEFT IN THE STORY, BUT TAKE A
1:13:50 LOOK AT HOW NASDAQ FUTURES ARE AT THE MOMENT.
1:13:53 WE SEE FUTURES CLIMBING AFTER WE SAW THAT PRICING COME THROUGH.
1:13:58 CRUDE ALSO WAS SUPPORTED TO THAT BROADER RISK SENTIMENT STORY.
1:14:20 ♪ PAUL: BREAKING NEWS FROM
1:14:25 AUSTRALIA, A BIG MISS ON THE JOBS NUMBERS FOR THE MONTH OF
1:14:27 OCTOBER. THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE SPIKING
1:14:35 FROM 4.7% TO FOUR POINT 9%. THE AUSSIE DOLLAR FOLLOWING
1:14:41 SHOPPER HE -- FALLING SHARPLY. THE EXPECTATION IS THE RBA WILL
1:14:43 NOT BE MOVING AT THE NEXT MEETING IN DECEMBER.
1:14:51 THE CASH RATE HAS PEAKED AT 4.85 PERCENT.
1:14:54 JUST BREAK DOWN THOSE NUMBERS, 43.5 THOUSAND JOBS LOST.
1:15:00 THEY ESTIMATE 18,000 JOBS PER MONTH NEED TO BE ADDED JUST TO
1:15:03 KEEP THE MARKET STEADY. THAT IS A BIG DROP IN THE NUMBER
1:15:10 OF JOBS, FULL-TIME EMPLOYMENT CONTRACTING BY ABOUT 300,000,
1:15:14 PART-TIME EMPLOYMENT PLUNGING. THE PARTICIPATION RATE PLEDGING
1:15:19 TO 66.6 PERCENT. A HUGE MISS ALL THOSE JOBS
1:15:22 NUMBERS. THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE NOW 4.9%
1:15:25 AND THE AUSSIE DOLLAR SINKING. HAIDI: THE OTHER THING WE ARE
1:15:29 WATCHING IS THE QUESTION OF GEOPOLITICS.
1:15:33 WE ARE HEADING FOR THE UNPRECEDENTED MEETING BETWEEN
1:15:39 PRESIDENT XIN,, TRUMPET AND PAUL:UTIN.
1:15:53 TRUMP SAID WE DON'T NEED HELP TO DEFEAT IRAN AND HE WOULD LIKE
1:15:55 CHINA NOT TO BE BUILDING NEW NUCLEAR WEAPONS.
1:16:00 TALKING ABOUT THE ESPIONAGE ASPECT HAS BEEN COMING INTO THE
1:16:04 SPOTLIGHT WITH THE RECENT NVIDIA STORY.
1:16:09 PRESIDENT TRUMP SAYING THEY SPY ON THE WEST AND WE SPY ON CHINA.
1:16:13 HE HAD A CONVERSATION WITH XI JINPING ABOUT CHIPS AND AI LAST
1:16:19 NIGHT BUT DID NOT DISCUSS JENSEN HUANG AND THE CONVERSATION.
1:16:21 PRESIDENT TRUMP TALKING ABOUT THE RECENT OUTAGES SEPARATELY,
1:16:26 NUMEROUS AS THEY HAVE BEEN IN THE U.S., SPECIFICALLY
1:16:27 ADDRESSING THE FAA FLIGHT GROUNDING, TALKING ABOUT WANTING
1:16:32 TO UPGRADE THE ENTIRE SYSTEM RATHER THAN PIECEMEAL.
1:16:36 IN A COUPLE OF YEARS WE WILL HAVE THE BEST AIR TRAFFIC
1:16:37 CONTROL SYSTEM. WE CONTINUE TO MONITOR THE
1:16:41 HEADLINES AS WE HEAD TOWARDS THAT MEETING IN SHENZHEN.
1:16:47 IT IS DRAWING COMPARISONS WITH THE 1945 GATHERING AND THE
1:16:49 OPTICS ARE JUST AS IMPORTANT. SENIOR ANALYST FOR CHINA NEIL
1:16:54 THOMAS JOINS US. WE HAVE BANDED AROUND THE TERM
1:16:58 UNPRECEDENTED QUITE A BIT BUT WE DO HAVE THIS FAIRLY
1:17:03 EXTRAORDINARY MEETING COMING UP AT A TIME WHEN WE SEE THE
1:17:07 OUTWARD RESILIENCE IN THE U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP, EVEN TO
1:17:13 THE POINT WHERE PRESIDENT XI IS GRADING PRESIDENT WARMLY ON THE
1:17:13 TARMAC. NEIL: THAT'S RIGHT, PRESIDENT XI
1:17:21 MADE THE UNUSUAL MOVE OF GOING TO THE AIRPORT TO MEET WITH
1:17:24 TRUMP WHEN HE ARRIVED. BEIJING WAS CAREFUL TO FRAME
1:17:27 THAT AS A RECIPROCAL GESTURE TO RETURN THE FAVOR THAT TRUMP GAVE
1:17:37 TO XI WHEN HE VISITED D.C. EXPECTATIONS ARE STILL VERY
1:17:39 MODEST. THE TRADE TRUCE GOES UNTIL
1:17:42 JANUARY 10. THEY HAVE ANOTHER MEETING AT THE
1:17:47 G20 IN MID DECEMBER. OVERALL, MORE SYMBOLISM THAN
1:17:52 SUBSTANCE WE THINK OF THE AIRPORT MEETING.
1:17:58 PAUL: IN MANY RESPECTS, NEIL, IS NEXT WEEK GOING TO BE MORE
1:18:00 INTERESTING THAN THIS ONE WHAT'S EVERYBODY HAS GONE HOME AND THE
1:18:04 CAMERAS ARE NO LONGER PRESENT, THERE ARE NO MORE HANDSHAKES AND
1:18:06 WE RETURN TO THE NITTY-GRITTY OF THE U.S.-CHINA RELATIONSHIP?
1:18:14 NEIL: THAT'S RIGHT, THERE'S A LOT OF MOVEMENT IN D.C.,
1:18:17 ESPECIALLY IN CONGRESS TO GET TOUGHER ON CHINA WHEN IT COMES
1:18:22 TO THE EXPORT OF U.S. HIGH-END CHIPS.
1:18:26 THAT PRESSURE COMING AFTER THE NVIDIA CEO JENSEN HUANG WAS
1:18:30 ACCUSED OF OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH A SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY.
1:18:34 THAT INNER TIES TO THE CHIP AUX IN D.C.
1:18:38 -- THAT ENERGIZED THE CHIP HAWKS.
1:18:43 DETAINING AMERICAN CITIZENS IN CHINA.
1:18:46 SCOTT BESSENT THE TREASURY SECRETARY, TRUMP'S POINT PERSON
1:18:51 ON CHINA, CAME OUT IN RECENT DAYS REALLY SAYING CHINA NEEDS
1:18:57 TO LIVE UP TO THE PROMISES IT MADE TO DELIVER RARE EARTHS TO
1:19:02 THE U.S., WHICH HAS NOT. DATA SHOWS EXPORTS ARE NOT
1:19:05 FLOWING NEARLY AS MUCH AS THEY WERE BEFORE CHINA INTRODUCED
1:19:08 EXPORT CONTROLS LAST APRIL. BUT WHEN IT COMES TO THE APEC
1:19:17 SIDELINE MEETINGS, TRUMP IS PRETTY CLEAR HE WANTS TO
1:19:19 APPROACH THIS IN GOOD FAITH AND SEE WHAT HE CAN GET FROM
1:19:20 PRESIDENT XI AND PRESIDENT PUTIN AS WELL IN THE TRILATERAL.
1:19:26 DON'T EXPECT ANY BIG MOVES THIS WEEK, BUT CERTAINLY IF TRUMP
1:19:32 LEAVES THE MEETING WITH XI FEELING DISAPPOINTED OR
1:19:36 DISRESPECTED, THEN THE APPETITE FOR MORE CONFRONTATION WILL
1:19:39 CERTAINLY INCREASE IN THE WIND WOULD BE AT HIS BACK IN TERMS OF
1:19:42 CONGRESSIONAL SUPPORT FOR THAT. THAT IS TO BE SEEN.
1:19:51 HAIDI: NEIL THOMAS, OUR SENIOR ANALYST FOR CHINA AT BLOOMBERG.
1:19:54 TO THAT POINT ABOUT THE CONGRESSIONAL ISSUES THE
1:19:59 PRESIDENT COULD FACE AFTER THIS LAME DUCK GOING INTO JANUARY
1:20:03 COME HE IS NOW MAKING COMMENTS IN THE FOX NEWS INTERVIEW
1:20:07 TALKING ABOUT JENSEN HUANG, SAYING WE HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF
1:20:11 PEOPLE LIKE JENSEN, ABOUT ELON. HE HAD NOT HEARD ABOUT THE
1:20:15 JENSEN HUANG ISSUE BEING A SECURITY ISSUE.
1:20:19 HE HEARD THAT SHE WAS A SPY, A BUSINESS WOMAN.
1:20:22 SOME OF THIS RUNS CONTRARY TO WHAT WE'VE SEEN REPORTED, THAT
1:20:28 THE PRESIDENT HAD BEEN WARNED ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE WHEN
1:20:30 IT COMES TO JENSEN HUANG. WHAT HAS BEEN INTERESTING IS
1:20:35 TRUMP SEEMS TO TAKE A DIFFERENT VIEW OF THIS SCENARIO OF JENSEN
1:20:41 HUANG AS A PERSON, EVEN THE BROADER NATIONAL SECURITY ISSUES
1:20:42 COMPARED WITH THE REST OF HIS CABINET.
1:20:46 PAUL: INDEED, THE REPORTING WE HAVE HERE OFTEN WITH SOME OF THE
1:20:52 ANALYSTS. THOSE ARE THE NUMBERS THAT
1:20:55 PRESIDENT TRUMP COULD SELL BLACK WELLS AND TWO TO THREE YEARS AND
1:20:57 DID NOT HEAR THAT THE JENSEN HUANG WAS A NATIONAL SECURITY
1:21:01 ISSUE. COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY SAYS THE
1:21:04 U.S. CANNOT WHEN THE AI RACE AND SHOULD ADOPT A MORE CONSERVATIVE
1:21:07 OR COOPERATIVE APPROACH TOWARDS BEIJING.
1:21:11 HE SPOKE WITH STEPHEN ENGLE IN SHENZHEN ABOUT WHY U.S. EXPORT
1:21:14 CURBS ON ADVANCED CHIPS TO CHINA ARE NOT WORKING.
1:21:18 >> FIRST, THEY HAVEN'T WORKED EVEN ON THEIR OWN TERMS OF
1:21:22 LIMITING FLOWS AND THERE ARE WAYS AROUND THEM.
1:21:24 YOU CAN HAVE DATA CENTERS AND THIRD COUNTRIES DOING WHAT THEY
1:21:27 WOULD DO IN CHINA. THE CONCEPT THAT YOU ARE GOING
1:21:33 TO LOCK UP THE WORLD ECONOMY ON ONE SIDE IS THE U.S. AND WE ARE
1:21:36 KEEPING OUR PRIZED TECHNOLOGY AND SO FORTH DOESN'T MAKE SENSE,
1:21:39 DOESN'T REALLY WORK. THE IDEA THAT THE UNITED STATES
1:21:45 IS GOING TO WIN THE AI RACE IS A LITTLE SIMPLISTIC.
1:21:48 CHINA HAS WONDERFUL TECHNOLOGISTS.
1:21:54 I COME TO SHENZHEN THREE OR FOUR TIMES EVERY YEAR.
1:21:56 EVERY THREE MONTHS THERE IS A NEW GENERATION OF TECHNOLOGY.
1:22:00 PEOPLE SHOULD COME WITH THEIR OWN EYES.
1:22:02 IF THEY THINK THAT WHAT HAPPENS IN SILICON VALLEY IS THE BE-ALL
1:22:06 AND END-ALL OF THIS WORLD, THEY DON'T GET IT.
1:22:10 SO WE NEED A DIFFERENT APPROACH. ACTUALLY, MORE COOPERATIVE, LESS
1:22:18 WEAPONIZATION OF AI, LESS THIS MINDSET EVERY DAY THAT WE MUST
1:22:19 WIN. STEPHEN: HOW TENUOUS IS THE
1:22:23 TRADE TRUCE? IF TRUMP PUSHES BACK ON THE
1:22:29 INDUSTRIAL UPS TO BE AND I'S CLAIMS, CHINA WILL USE ITS
1:22:33 LEVERAGE AS WELL --THE INDUSTRIAL ESPIONAGE CLAIMS?
1:22:37 JEFFREY: THE UNITED STATES CANNOT WIN A TRADE WAR WITH
1:22:39 CHINA. WE LEARNED THAT LAST YEAR WITHIN
1:22:43 ABOUT 24 HOURS THAT EXCUSE ME, WE NEED THOSE RARE EARTHS OR OUR
1:22:47 AUTO INDUSTRY WILL SHUT DOWN IN ABOUT TWO WEEKS.
1:22:51 THERE IS A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF PROPAGANDA AND NAIVETE IN THE
1:22:54 UNITED STATES COME IN THE WEST, IN THE MAIN NEWSPAPERS.
1:22:57 WHEN I READ IT I CANNOT BELIEVE WHAT I READ.
1:22:59 IT IS SO SIMPLEMINDED. PAUL: THAT IS COLUMBIA
1:23:07 UNIVERSITY PROFESSOR JEFFREY SACHS SPEAKING WITH BLOOMBERG.
1:23:11 OUR ANALYSIS OF NEARLY 10 MILLION JOB POSTINGS SUGGESTED
1:23:14 AI IS THREATENING TO MAKE CHINA'S EMPLOYMENT PROBLEM EVEN
1:23:16 WORSE. WE LOOK AT WHICH SECTORS ARE
1:23:19 BEING HIT HARDEST AS BEIJING ASSESSES ITS IMPACT ON CHINA'S
1:23:20 LABOR MARKET. LET'S GET TO OUR ASIA GOVERNMENT
1:23:26 AND ECONOMY REPORTER. THAT SEEMS LIKE AN OBVIOUS PLACE
1:23:28 TO START. WHAT CAN YOU TELL US ABOUT HOW
1:23:31 AI IS DISRUPTING THE CHINESE JOB MARKET?
1:23:36 DANIEL: CHINA DOES NOT RELEASE A TON OF DATA ON HOW THIS IS
1:23:42 IMPACTING THE JOBS MARKET SO FAR AND THE EMPLOYMENT DATA WE HAVE
1:23:46 IS QUITE LIMITED. SO THE WAY RESEARCHERS HAVE BEEN
1:23:49 GOING ABOUT TRYING TO ASSESS THE DAMAGE IS TO LOOK ONLINE AT JOB
1:23:54 ADVERTISEMENTS IN VARIOUS CHINESE PLATFORMS.
1:23:58 WHAT THEY FOUND IS THERE WAS A BROAD ECONOMIC SLOWDOWN
1:24:03 ALTOGETHER, BUT THE JOBS AND SECTORS THAT ARE MORE EXPOSED TO
1:24:08 AI, SOFTWARE DEVELOPERS, WRITERS, MARKETING MANAGERS,
1:24:13 THINGS LIKE THAT, ARE SEEING A MUCH STEEPER DECLINE THAN OTHER
1:24:17 INDUSTRIES. WE FOUND ABOUT A 10 PERCENTAGE
1:24:19 POINT DECLINE. THAT KIND OF TRACKS WITH OTHER
1:24:25 STUDIES THAT HAVE ALSO LOOKED AT ONLINE JOB ADS, INCLUDING BY THE
1:24:30 CHINESE GOVERNMENT. IT ALSO SHOWS THAT WAGES ARE
1:24:36 GOING DOWN AS WELL, THE AMOUNT OF MONEY BEING OFFERED FOR THESE
1:24:38 POSITIONS IS DROPPING. HAIDI: IT'S INTERESTING, DAN,
1:24:46 BECAUSE WE KNOW GOING BACK THE PAST COUPLE DECADES BEIJING
1:24:49 NEEDS FOR VARIOUS REASONS FOR ITS EMPLOYMENT RATE TO STAY AT A
1:24:53 CERTAIN LEVEL, USUALLY AROUND 5%.
1:24:55 THERE ARE FLASHPOINTS EVERYWHERE WHEN IT COMES TO AI TAKING OVER
1:24:58 JOBS AND THE DISRUPTIONS TO LABOR MARKET.
1:25:02 THIS IS CONCERNING POLITICAL CHALLENGES HERE?
1:25:09 DANIEL: YES, CERTAINLY, JOBS ARE ONE OF THE MAJOR CONCERNS OF
1:25:10 CHINESE POLICYMAKERS AT ALL TIMES.
1:25:15 THEY ARE VERY NERVOUS ABOUT THIS.
1:25:16 THEY DON'T WANT TO TALK ABOUT IT THAT MUCH IN PUBLIC, THEY ARE
1:25:22 VERY MUCH TECHNO-OPTIMISTS. BUT WHEN YOU TALK TO RESEARCHERS
1:25:27 IN JUST CONVERSATIONS IN BEIJING, THEY WILL TELL YOU HOW
1:25:30 WORRIED THE GOVERNMENT IS ABOUT THIS AND THEY ARE MONITORING IT
1:25:34 VERY CLOSELY. THEY HAVEN'T REALLY RELEASED ANY
1:25:41 DETAILS OF THAT, AND SO FAR MOST OF THEIR EFFORTS ARE ON
1:25:43 RESKILLING, TRYING TO GET PEOPLE ON AI TRAINING SO THEY CAN TAKE
1:25:47 ON THESE NEW JOBS. BUT OVERALL THEY ARE VERY
1:25:51 WORRIED ABOUT THE EMPLOYMENT SITUATION IN GENERAL.
1:25:56 WE ARE NOT SEEING A MASSIVE MACROECONOMIC IMPACT AT THE
1:26:03 MOMENT, BUT THE RESEARCH, ONE VERY PROMINENT RESEARCHER
1:26:06 LOOKING INTO THIS SAID IT IS LIKE A TSUNAMI COMING.
1:26:11 YOU KNOW IT'S COMING, YOU CAN SEE IT COMING, BUT YOU DON'T
1:26:14 KNOW HOW HARD IT'S GOING TO HIT. PAUL: BLOOMBERG ASIA ECONOMICS
1:26:21 AND GOVERNMENT REPORTER DANIEL, THANK YOU.
1:26:22 WE HAVE MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA TRADE."
1:26:25 THIS IS BLOOMBERG. ♪
1:26:45 PAUL: CHINESE BIG TECH EARNINGS GETTING UNDERWAY.
1:26:49 WE ARE WATCHING TENCENT AFTER THE REPORTED LESS THAN PROJECTED
1:26:56 A PERCENT JUMP IN SALES AND THE LAST QUARTER.
1:27:00 WE WILL HEAR FROM A HYPERSCALER. ALIBABA FACING MOUNTING PRESSURE
1:27:03 OVER ITS AI PLANS. LET'S GO TO OUR ASIA STOCKS
1:27:07 REPORTER JENNY YOU. WHAT ARE THE KEY THINGS WE ARE
1:27:09 WATCHING WITH ALIBABA? JEANNY: ALIBABA IS THE TALE
1:27:17 OF TWO BUSINESSES. ON THE ONE HAND PEOPLE ARE NOT
1:27:22 EXPECTING TOO MUCH FROM THEIR E-COMMERCE BUSINESS, BECAUSE
1:27:25 EVEN THOUGH THERE IS BIG CONSUMPTION AND WHAT WE HAVE
1:27:30 SEEN, A LOT OF MISSES ON THE TENCENT EARNINGS.
1:27:32 I DON'T THINK THE EXPECTATIONS ARE HIGH ON THAT.
1:27:38 ON THE OTHER HAND I THINK THE ALIBABA STORY VERY MUCH HINGES
1:27:45 ON HOW CLOUD GROWTH IS GOING TO KEEP UP IN THE COMING QUARTERS.
1:27:51 SO FAR I THINK ANALYSTS ARE STILL VERY BULLISH ON THE CLOUD
1:27:56 BUSINESS FOR ALIBABA. I THINK THE CONSENSUS IS REALLY
1:28:02 EXPECTING CLOUD GROWTH REVENUE TO TOP 15% IN THE SEPTEMBER
1:28:05 QUARTER, WHICH IS QUITE STRONG GROWTH, AND A CLOUD REVENUE HAS
1:28:12 ALREADY ACCOUNTED FOR 18% OF ALIBABA'S TOTAL REVENUE.
1:28:16 IT IS REALLY A REVENUE DRIVER AT THIS POINT FOR ALIBABA.
1:28:22 TO PUT THAT AHEAD TO, THAT IS WHY THE NVIDIA CHIP ACCESS
1:28:26 CONCERNS IS CLOUDING ALIBABA'S VALUATION IN GENERAL, BECAUSE
1:28:30 THIS IS A BIG QUESTION FOR INVESTORS IN TERMS OF HOW THE
1:28:35 CLOUD GROWTH CAN KEEP GROWING AT SUCH A FAST PACE IN THE COMING
1:28:39 QUARTERS IF THERE IS SUCH A BIG SHORTAGE OF ADVANCED GP USE
1:28:43 GOING FORWARD. HAIDI: WHEN IT COMES TO THE CHIP
1:28:50 SHORTAGE CONCERNS, SPECIFICALLY THAT ALIBABA IS FACING GIVEN
1:28:53 THEIR AGGRESSIVE DATA CENTER GOALS, HOW ARE INVESTORS FEELING
1:28:55 ABOUT THAT? JEANNY: I THINK ALIBABA IS ONE
1:29:02 OF THE MOST AGGRESSIVE AI COMPANIES WITH A MASSIVE AI
1:29:08 INVESTMENT PLAN. I THINK THEY WANT TO BUILD 20
1:29:12 GIGAWATTS OF DATA CENTER CAPACITY BY 2032.
1:29:17 IT IS KIND OF AGGRESSIVE. I WOULD SAY A BIG PART OF THAT
1:29:23 WILL BE COVERED BY NVIDIA CHIPS. SO THE RESTRICTED ACCESS TO
1:29:34 THOSE ADVANCED GP YOU -- GPU'S IN SOUTH EAST ASIA HURTS ITS
1:29:37 PASTE ON COMPUTE CAPACITY TO SUPPORT THAT GROWTH.
1:29:41 THIS IS ONE THING PEOPLE ARE NOT FEELING VERY OPTIMISTIC.
1:29:45 BUT TO BE SURE ALIBABA HAS ITS OWN BUSINESS.
1:29:50 BASED ON THE CONVERSATIONS WITH INVESTORS THEY ARE VERY
1:29:53 CONFIDENT THAT SOME OF THE DATA CHIPS CAN ALREADY SUPPORT THE
1:30:00 COSTS FOR ALIBABA, FOR EXAMPLE, TO SATISFY THE NON-TOP-TIER AI
1:30:06 MODEL NEEDS. THAT PART SEEMS TO BE FINE.
1:30:10 IN TERMS OF THE NEXT GENERATION AI MODELS, HOW FAST IT CAN
1:30:15 LAUNCH, THAT IS A BIG CONCERN FOR INVESTORS BECAUSE IT REMAINS
1:30:19 UNCLEAR WHETHER THE DOMESTIC AI CHIPS CAN CATCH UP WITH THE
1:30:24 PERFORMANCE OF NVIDIA CHIPS IN THE VERY NEAR FUTURE.
1:30:29 THAT IS WHY THIS IS ONE BIG UNCERTAINTY THAT INVESTORS ARE
1:30:30 DISCOUNTING IN ALIBABA'S VALUATION.
1:30:38 HAIDI: JEANNY YU THERE. TENCENT WITH ALSO AGGRESSIVE
1:30:44 SPENDING ON AI, EATING INTO PROFIT GROWTH.
1:30:47 IT UNDERSCORES HOW SOME OF THESE CHINESE TECH LEADERS ARE
1:30:51 SACRIFICING MARGINS FOR HEAVY INVESTMENT INTO THE AI
1:30:55 TECHNOLOGY WITHOUT IMMEDIATE CLARITY IN TERMS OF RETURNS.
1:30:58 LET'S BRING IN WINNIE HSU FOR A BREAK.
1:31:02 THIS IS A SCENARIO THAT IS NOT UNIQUE TO THE CHINESE TECH
1:31:04 GIANTS. WHAT DO WE SEE IN TERMS OF $.10
1:31:06 NUMBERS AT THE MOMENT? WINNIE: GOOD MORNING.
1:31:13 IT IS A DISAPPOINTING SET OF NUMBERS.
1:31:16 PRETTY MUCH EVERYTHING MISSED ESTIMATES.
1:31:18 REVENUE MISSED AND ALSO OPERATING PROFIT FELL BY ABOUT
1:31:21 7% FOR THE QUARTER. THAT IS THE FIRST DECLINE THAT
1:31:26 WE SAW IN MANY YEARS. WHEN IT COMES TO THE CASH FLOW,
1:31:32 WE ARE SEEING NEGATIVE CASH FLOW.
1:31:34 THAT IS ALSO THE SECOND STRAIGHT QUARTER WE ARE SEEING THIS, DOWN
1:31:39 BY ABOUT 10 BILLION U.S. DOLLARS.
1:31:41 ALL OF THIS GOES TO SHOW HOW THIS WHOLE MASSIVE AI SPENDING
1:31:44 AND INVESTMENT IS NOT REALLY TRANSLATING INTO PROFITS JUST
1:31:46 YET. THAT IS A BIG PROBLEM THESE TECH
1:31:51 COMPANIES ARE FACING IN CHINA. ANOTHER KEY POINT THAT WAS
1:31:55 MENTIONED THE EARNINGS CALL THAT WAS IMPORTANT, ALSO TIED TO THE
1:32:00 POINT THAT JEANNY MENTIONED, MANAGEMENT HAS MENTIONED HOW
1:32:06 THIS NEW RESTRICTION OF REMOTE ACCESS TO THESE CHINESE
1:32:08 COMPANIES TO THESE ADVANCED CHIPS AND DATA CENTERS IS LIKELY
1:32:14 GOING TO SLOW DOWN THE DEVELOPMENT OF AI TRAINING
1:32:16 MODELS IN THE SHORT-TERM. HOWEVER, THEY ARE EXPECTING THAT
1:32:21 IMPACT TO BE BUFFERED BY THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE DOMESTIC
1:32:25 CHIPMAKERS GOING FORWARD. WE WILL HAVE TO CLOSELY WATCH
1:32:29 HOW THAT RISK PLAYS OUT. FOR NOW WE ARE SEEING NEGATIVE
1:32:31 INDICATION FOR THE STOCKS. THE ADR IS DOWN ABOUT 2% OF THE
1:32:36 STOCK SO FAR IS DOWN ABOUT 40% ALREADY.
1:32:41 PAUL: ARE WE SEEING NEGATIVE IMPLICATIONS FOR STOCKS MORE
1:32:42 BROADLY AHEAD OF THE OPEN IN CHINA TODAY?
1:32:47 WINNIE: MOST LIKELY. WE JUST TALKED ABOUT HOW WE ARE
1:32:51 WATCHING FOR THE EARNINGS TO ALSO COME FROM ALIBABA.
1:32:57 AS JEANNY MENTIONED, ALL EYES WILL BE ON HOW THEY NEVER GET
1:33:00 THE U.S. CURBS AS WELL AS HOW THEY COULD POTENTIALLY SHOW THEY
1:33:05 ARE PROFITING FINALLY FROM THESE INVESTMENTS FROM AI.
1:33:09 SO FAR BECAUSE OF THAT, THE EARNINGS WE'VE SEEN SO FAR FROM
1:33:15 JD.COM AS WELL AS TENCENT, WE CONTINUE TO SEE HOW THE REALLY
1:33:19 BIG TWO HEADWINDS FACING CHINESE EQUITIES, THE MACRO PICTURE OF
1:33:26 THE WEAK CONSUMPTION AND WEAK RETAIL SALES WEIGHING ON THESE
1:33:30 E-COMMERCE COMPANIES GIVING THE -- GIVEN THE WEAK DOMESTIC
1:33:35 CONSUMPTION AND THE INTENSE COMPETITION WE ARE SEEING AMONG
1:33:40 THESE COMPANIES, PLUS JUST HOW THE U.S. CURBS ARE LIKELY GOING
1:33:44 TO PROVIDE MORE HEADWINDS FOR THESE COMPANIES.
1:33:48 WHEN IT COMES TO ANTHROPIC'S IPO, THIS IS A BIG BLOCKBUSTER
1:33:49 IPO. WE ARE SEEING THAT BENEFITING
1:33:54 U.S. FUTURES RIGHT NOW. HOWEVER, ASIAN STOCKS ARE NOT
1:34:00 REACTING AS POSITIVELY BECAUSE INVESTORS ARE EXPECTING THIS TO
1:34:02 TAKE OUT QUITE A BIT OF LIQUIDITY FROM THE MARKET, AND
1:34:07 THIS IS GOING TO WEIGH ON NOT JUST THE JAPANESE MARKET, THE
1:34:11 KOREAN MARKET, BUT ALSO THE CHINESE MARKET GIVEN THE
1:34:13 COMPETITION THERE AS WELL. PAUL: ASIA EQUITIES REPORTER
1:34:17 WINNIE HSU. WE HAVE MORE AHEAD ON "THE ASIA
1:34:19 TRADE." THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
1:34:40 ♪ PAUL: ANTHROPIC.
1:34:48 HAIDI: YEAH. IT IS A BEHEMOTH, THE JUGGERNAUT
1:34:53 THAT CONTINUES AS WE HEAD INTO THE END OF THE WEEK.
1:34:56 WE WILL BE ENDING OUR WEEK KNOWING HOW THE STORY ENDS.
1:35:01 WE DO HAVE A BIT MORE OPTIMISM, CONFIDENCE ABOUT THE PRICING.
1:35:14 103.7.3 -- 107.3 BILLION RAISED COME ABOVE SPACEX'S IPO.
1:35:18 WHO KNOWS WHAT WILL HAPPEN ON THE FIRST DAY.
1:35:21 IT TENDS TO BE VOLATILE, BUT THIS FEELS LIKE A MARKET THAT
1:35:25 NEEDS REASSURANCE AND STABILITY WHEN IT COMES TO THE AI TRADE
1:35:26 RIGHT NOW. PAUL: CHOPPY WINDS AS WELL ALL.
1:35:34 THERE WAS A LOT OF ENTHUSIASM, BUT WE HEARD THAT THE FED MIGHT
1:35:37 TIGHTEN MORE AGGRESSIVELY AT THE NEXT MEETING OR TWO.
1:35:44 ANTHROPIC HAS TAKEN SIX YEARS FROM BIRTH TO LISTING.
1:35:47 YOU KNOW IT'S TAKEN TWICE AS LONG?
1:35:50 HAIDI: TELL ME. PAUL: GRAND THEFT AUTO VI, I
1:35:54 DON'T THINK WE HAVE SPENT ENOUGH TIME ON THAT, IT IS
1:35:58 EXTRAORDINARY COME A BILLION DOLLARS SPENT, IT TOOK ALL THIS
1:36:02 TIME TO BUILD THE BURJ KHALIFA. DO YOU GO INTO WORK AND TRADE
1:36:08 ANTHROPIC OR DO YOU CALL OUT SICK AND PLAY THIS GAME?
1:36:14 IT WILL TAKE MORE THAN A DAY TO GET THROUGH IT.
1:36:16 IT IS A PHENOMENAL GAME. IT IS QUITE A HUGE CULTURAL
1:36:18 EVENT. TAKE TWO SHARES BUMPING MORE
1:36:23 THAN 6%. HAIDI: I WANT TO SEE THE VENN
1:36:28 DIAGRAM OF THOSE WHO WANT TO TRADE ANTHROPIC AND THOSE WHO
1:36:31 WANT TO TAKE THE WEEK OFF. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION WARNING
1:36:34 FEDERAL WORKERS THIS IS NOT A VALID EXCUSE TO WORK FROM HOME
1:36:36 IF YOU ARE WANTING TO GET INTO GRAND THEFT AUTO SIX.
1:36:43 PAUL: REALLY? HAIDI: IT IS NOT A BASIS FOR
1:36:48 SITUATIONAL TELEWORK ACCORDING TO A POST.
1:36:50 I KNOW THAT YOU HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS DEBUT.
1:36:53 I THINK MAYBE THERE WILL BE QUITE A BIT OF DEMISE AND
1:36:56 PRODUCTIVITY. PAUL: A BIT OF ABSENTEEISM.
1:37:03 HAIDI: WE ARE SEEING A DELAYED START TO TRADING, THE KOSPI.
1:37:07 WE WILL GET INTO THE START OF TRADING IN CHINA AS WELL,
1:37:09 NEXT. ♪
Citigroup CEO Jane Fraser at Bloomberg Newsmakers Event full transcript
0:00 Can you give us a sense of what this signals about the IPO pipeline going
0:04 forward and just where we are in capital markets right now?
0:07 Well, I think let me also echo, thank you very much for joining today.
0:11 And I am surprised you're not all checking out your allocations now that
0:14 the deal is priced. Um, it's lovely being here.
0:18 Look, this is as you say, this is the biggest IPO that we've seen.
0:22 Um, and it's one that's got a lot of institutional demand behind it as well
0:27 as retail demand. It's got a lot of international demand
0:30 as well as North America demand. So I think that that's in many ways a
0:35 barometer for the health of the capital markets and also barometer for the
0:40 health of the eye ecosystem. So as we think about the IPO markets for
0:45 going forward, um, it tends to be a pretty thin market anyway towards the
0:50 end of the year. I think it's more about 27 than it is
0:53 about 26 from that perspective. But obviously this is going to be a good
0:57 thing. And it remember it comes on the back of
0:59 the Nvidia earnings yesterday which also surprised the market positively.
1:04 We could do with positive surprises at the moment.
1:07 I mean, and uh, you know, I think their forward guidance was also quite strong.
1:12 So I think more confidence in the AI ecosystem is is a good thing.
1:17 Do you have a pretty big pipeline for the beginning of 2027?
1:21 In other words, is the anthropic IPO the opening salvo to a host of other
1:26 transactions, both in the AI world and beyond?
1:29 Or is it kind of the door closing on a pretty amazing year for IPOs a record
1:33 year? Uh, no, I think it's it should be, um,
1:36 good news for the IPO is that that will be coming in 27.
1:40 And that there may well be some that come towards the back end of this year
1:44 as well. It's just where the calendar is.
1:46 It makes it it makes it tighter on that. Um, and I think it's, it's positive for
1:52 what's been quite a thin tech IPO market, um, this year as many people
1:57 have been waiting for for this one after space.
2:00 Nvidia did report earnings that were better than expected increase their
2:03 guidance. That wasn't what really people cared
2:06 about. People were looking at other things, in
2:08 particular whether they were going to finance anything and who their next
2:10 executive leader will be. Uh, I'm just wondering from your
2:13 perspective, how big of a concern it is that the central bank of I might be
2:18 going away? Oh, look, the genie is out of the bottle
2:23 on I. And no one's putting that genie back in
2:25 the bottle. Um, when we think about the amount of, I
2:29 look at it, the amount of compute that it's in demand.
2:32 And I'm not just I mean, a lot of that centers in America, but I'm not just
2:36 seeing it. There is in Turkey the other day,
2:39 they're building their first data center because they're worried if they don't,
2:43 they won't be able to compete in industry after industry.
2:47 So this this is a global phenomenon at the moment, certainly centered in the
2:51 States. Um, but I wouldn't be I wouldn't be so
2:55 concerned with all of the doomsday predictions on I and the rest of it.
3:01 Um, it's, uh, I think we're in we're in reasonable shape.
3:04 At the same time, in your third quarter earnings.
3:07 Citigroup did say that I financing risk was a key risk or uncertainty, and it
3:13 was the first time that it appeared. What were you referring to in particular
3:16 that look, it's it's as I say, it's the largest, um, build out that we've seen,
3:21 um, in modern history in a very capital intensive way.
3:25 Um, and it's, um, there's a lot of promise and opportunity there, but we're
3:30 we're in the picks and shovels phase, as everyone likes to say.
3:34 Um, it's a very big infra build out. It's energy chips.
3:38 It's the data centers. I mean, there's the frontier models.
3:41 There is a lot going into this one, and not everyone will be a winner.
3:45 There are always winners and losers in these things.
3:48 So just given the amounts of money involved and the other pieces, you would
3:52 hope that one of the nation's largest banks was focused and making sure that
3:57 we manage the risk responsibly. Um, but we're in the business of taking
4:01 risk and therefore we we keep an eye on these things.
4:06 People point to the United States as being sort of the epicenter of both the
4:10 risk and the reward tied to ie. The ECB was saying this is a huge
4:13 systemic risk and that this could potentially be another subprime.
4:16 It just that us. Explained.
4:20 I mean, is it a feature of bug because it does sort of concentrate risk around
4:24 one technology really having gains. And this is probably where I become one
4:28 of those zealous Americans of having chosen to come and join this country,
4:33 um, as a, as an immigrant of, uh, many years ago now.
4:37 But look what what's the magic that that the US has?
4:42 Um, it is our ability to both in the innovation that this country can do at
4:48 scale, matched with the capital market. So think about it.
4:52 The U.S. has 4% of the world's population and
4:55 over 50% of the market capitalization of the world.
4:59 Hey, you think about industry after industry.
5:04 Not only can we innovate, but we can do so at scale and we can support.
5:10 We can support the entrepreneurs as they build out and take chances.
5:14 In some places you're not guaranteed success.
5:16 Um, but but it is quite unique. Capital markets is a very important part
5:21 of funding. The debt, the equity, the risk
5:24 management, the breadth and depth, the savings that get deployed into
5:27 investment so others can participate in this.
5:31 Whereas I look at the UK, where I come from, all parts of Europe.
5:34 Um, I had this conversation in France. There are a lot of the top French
5:39 entrepreneurs who are superb in the eye space.
5:43 They're here, they're on the West Coast. They're in the States.
5:47 There are far fewer that are in France. Um, I look in the UK where conversations
5:53 with the government there, where they're trying to understand how did they scale
5:56 up their their ventures kind of plateau and they're not able to scale from here.
6:03 And that's why I think we see so much entrepreneurship, um, coming many of the
6:08 roads leading to America. We under appreciate that here.
6:12 Yeah, yeah, we just had an election actually we did
6:17 I think it happened about three months ago.
6:19 Uh, give it a it feels like I said, everything that we're seeing.
6:22 Um, and so people have talked about how that could potentially stymie some of
6:26 the data center build out or potentially just the eye trade in general.
6:30 How are you hearing about that from your clients in terms of whether they're
6:33 trying to speed up the projects to get ahead of it, or how concerned they are?
6:37 Yeah, I mean, I think the election had a number of different issues on
6:41 affordability, had it around their eyes, some of the anti-establishment.
6:45 Um, and I was I was over in California, um, most week and I was.
6:51 I was happy to see that this is not falling on deaf ears.
6:56 I think there is a recognition that when we have been investing at this scale and
7:01 speed, some communities have been left behind.
7:04 That hasn't been enough of the win win. And I think I've heard a lot more of
7:08 that recognition from the tech firms and not just in the AI space, but more
7:13 broadly that you've got to make this something that is beneficial for the
7:17 communities. Your aim.
7:19 What is it you're doing to protect if it's on the energy cost front?
7:23 There are plenty of things to do on energy supply and energy pricing.
7:26 Make sure the community doesn't have the detrimental impact that can be benefits
7:32 given to local schools. No free lunches that the salaries for
7:37 the for the teachers. There's a lot of different things that
7:40 can be done that some of the the benefits that the tech firms are
7:45 getting, um, also translate into the communities in which you operate.
7:49 And I think it's one of the things we as banks.
7:52 Um, I've learned that this is so critical if we're expecting to retain
7:56 trust. Um, we certainly had to earn a lot of
7:59 that. Back off the great financial crisis.
8:01 And there are plenty of ways to do this. I'm encouraged.
8:05 I was, I was I think this is not falling on deaf ears.
8:08 Yeah. It does seem like this hasn't been a
8:10 great week for Tech Trust when it comes to trusting our technology, considering
8:15 the FAA went down and so did Apple and JP Morgan experience problems.
8:19 There've been all these tech outages. Should we go buy gold bars?
8:23 Uh, look, I, I can I can empathize a lot as to why this is unsettling at the
8:29 moment. There's been a lot in the last couple of
8:31 weeks. Um, but let's, you know, take a little
8:35 bit of a step back. What?
8:37 And just give some reassurance. I'm the volume of changes, the patches
8:45 that is going through the world's tech stack at the same time is, you know,
8:50 five tenfold what we've ever seen before.
8:53 Um, you know, it shouldn't be a complete surprise to anyone that that doesn't
8:58 always go well. But it doesn't mean it's a disaster.
9:03 Um, so what we're seeing is. And we should be expecting for a while,
9:08 some more downtime, some more outages in different areas as we upgrade the tech
9:13 stacks to the latest versions of different releases to put in the patches
9:18 to the vulnerability. And at the end of the day, it will make
9:22 us all a lot, um, more resilient and word that we've all been learning that's
9:28 both emotional, mental and physical. Uh, but it builds resiliency.
9:33 And that's going to be very important because these models are powerful and in
9:36 bad actors hands they can be a problem. Um, and I think it's just reinforcing
9:41 the need to make investments in modernizing our technology, um, and in
9:46 making sure that we're thinking about resiliency, but we shouldn't be
9:50 surprised this is happening when the models that really powerful models came
9:54 out six months ago, we knew that this was likely to happen just given the
9:59 volume of changes. So it's this we're very good at adapting
10:05 this country, I guess, in this rough period.
10:08 I mean, is there a chance that the payment system could go down?
10:14 Is there a chance it goes down? The bits of it might at some point from
10:18 a downtime or others as we're upgrading different elements of it, but we're
10:22 ready for that. We spent years I'm investing in making
10:28 sure that someone else doesn't bring it down, but if it's because we're
10:31 upgrading the technology, we're upgrading different pieces, then, you
10:35 know, we've got really good plans in places.
10:38 How does all of this recover? How do you get back online quickly?
10:42 And we've seen that the last while. It's not just if it goes down, it's how
10:46 quickly you get things back up again and working quickly.
10:50 And the companies have all got a lot of plans as to how to do this.
10:54 And it's not just from cyber, it can be from someone making a mistake.
10:58 It can be from a bug in there. So copper wire.
11:02 Yeah. I mean, it was something that I first
11:04 saw and I asked her, should we all go to Costco and buy a lot of toilet paper?
11:07 And she said, absolutely, you should because it sponsors their card.
11:11 So yeah, I only used the city Costco credit card, however.
11:15 Yeah. So there you go.
11:17 When it comes to your own deployment, I promise we'll look at other things other
11:20 than artificial intelligence, but today you know it a big no.
11:22 It's an important topic for sure. Yes.
11:25 I just wonder how much right now. Is it a cost center versus actually a
11:29 cost efficiency issue right now? Oh look, this is a technology that is
11:34 going to unlock a lot of growth and revenue.
11:38 It's going to unlock a lot of productivity and efficiency gains, and
11:42 is also going to require a lot of money to be spent.
11:44 So I think of it in our bank. Where are we going to earn money?
11:47 Where are we going to save money and where are we going to spend money?
11:50 And the first use cases in I tend to be an encoding.
11:55 Um, so you saw some we saw a big uplift in productivity and coding from that.
12:00 And I know as a bank that means we've been able to save some money and then
12:04 invest it, um, for growth and for new features, new capabilities going
12:09 forward. And the savings, it's certainly going to
12:14 help drive productivity. And that does mean that will be areas
12:18 where there will be job changes and job losses.
12:21 Um, equally, there's going to be areas new product development, life cycle and
12:25 much shorter new features are becoming possible, new areas where you're going
12:30 to be able to earn more growth and more revenue that will create jobs.
12:34 We don't know if the puts and takes will be the same, and then those areas where
12:39 we're spending money and investing side, but being one of them, but not the only
12:43 one. Full protections, um, as a range of
12:46 different areas that are defensive. Um, that we're using the, the AI models
12:51 to invest and protect because of new things that bad actors could do.
12:56 So all of this coming together, it's such early days that, um, we're starting
13:02 to see all of these different areas bear fruit, some of them in positive ways,
13:06 some of them not in positive ways, but it is a mixture of all of them in five
13:11 years. Do you expect city to have a smaller
13:14 employee base? I honestly don't know the answer to that
13:17 question. We're certainly working hard to make
13:20 sure that we have grown the company responsibly.
13:24 Um, and that we've done so in a way that retains trust of our customers, our
13:28 investors, the communities we serve. Um, and that that enables us to have a
13:34 different composition of our of our workforce.
13:37 Um, I would love it to be the same or bigger.
13:40 Yeah. How much of your day do you spend trying
13:42 to figure out how to patch up systems without crashing the whole thing?
13:46 Um, a lot of time actually has gone into that.
13:48 I think this is one of the areas where the private sector in the states has
13:52 really stood up, because a lot of the critical infrastructure is privately
13:56 owned in this country. And so we've had a several initiatives.
14:02 The banks, I think, as Jay claims to about the day, really are at the
14:06 forefront because it's been a decade plus investment and collaboration on
14:11 cyber. We do not compete on cyber.
14:14 All right. Well, compete on the deck for pitching
14:16 the anthropic IPO. Um, but when it comes to these different
14:20 areas, it's a case of how do we really work together to make sure the system is
14:26 safe. Um, so I spend a lot of time on, um,
14:31 where are we patching? What are we doing to protect our
14:33 perimeter? I also spent a lot of time talking to,
14:37 um, smaller firms. I was just with a group of banks this
14:40 morning explaining what are we doing to make sure that we're hardening our cyber
14:45 capabilities and the bank. What are we doing to make sure our
14:49 people are as ready as possible for weather downtimes and getting getting up
14:53 and working quickly again? Um, and this is where I would say
14:59 there's a lot of collaboration going on in the private sector, which is, you
15:03 know, necessary and good to see. Do you want an agent?
15:07 My personal agent, muse. Would that be able to access my personal
15:11 bank account at Citi? Absolutely.
15:13 No way. Well.
15:16 No way. Um, because, again, we have to move
15:19 fast, but maintain trust. You don't want me, um, letting muse
15:25 accessing. And we.
15:26 Some discover that it's authorized to go and take a lot more money out of your
15:30 bank account than you want it to. Um.
15:32 And we. This is such a new technology.
15:35 Ultimately, I can see that being in place.
15:38 Um, but I think you're hearing from all the large banks and and others that, you
15:42 know, when we're not going to unleash these without having the right risk and
15:47 control protections in place so that you are unprotected and your your money,
15:54 your data and other elements. Um, the, the the control framework is
15:59 not there yet. So it will come and we'll put it in, but
16:02 we're not going to get ahead of our skis here.
16:04 Is there a competitive aspect to this to try to get younger clients who are using
16:09 these devices more significantly, or it's just too early days at this point.
16:13 At this, we will disrupt ourselves, but we will
16:16 only do so responsibly. Um, yeah.
16:21 Period. Full stop.
16:22 Um, it's just not something that I think you're going to see, um, banks being
16:27 willing to let go of controls that could cause a problem for the system or
16:33 couldn't cause a problem for our customers.
16:35 We, um, we're going to do this quickly. But when we're comfortable that we can
16:40 manage risk at the same speed as innovation.
16:43 And then everyone should watch out because we've got the scale to apply the
16:47 innovation to. Um, and you asked me the question about
16:51 bug or feature. Um, I would say that innovation is a
16:54 feature of America. Um, but I think we do this responsibly.
16:59 We don't do this shooting from the hip. We're in Washington, D.C.
17:03 it is. They do need of, uh, big political
17:05 change. I want to start by talking about your
17:09 relationship with President Trump. You have developed a pretty close
17:11 relationship with President Trump in terms of being a collaborator.
17:14 And you were on the last trip to China. Given that there is a meeting between XI
17:21 Jinping and President Trump right now. Any insight that you got from that
17:24 meeting? Yeah, it was above.
17:26 I'd say it was a privilege to be able to attend.
17:29 We were a company with a big global presence.
17:32 And so being able to join the president, a number of the other CEOs on the trip.
17:37 I'm just to be part of the US delegation.
17:41 There's a certain privileges you never imagine in your life.
17:44 Um, on this one, I think what I took away that was very encouraging was the
17:49 real focus on stabilizing the relationship between the two.
17:53 I'm certainly very clear that there are a number of areas where it is the
17:59 complete competition between the two countries, but there's a lot of other
18:02 areas where there is collaboration. And I think the mindset really from both
18:08 was that, you know, there's too much to lose by not engaging.
18:12 Um, you know, from both sides and frankly, for everyone.
18:16 And so the engagement was very good. Um, but there was certainly plenty of
18:20 areas of disagreement. Um, but if you don't engage when you've
18:24 got the, you know, the two biggest powers in the world, then you really do
18:28 have a problem. When something goes wrong, you don't
18:31 have the de-escalation channels. You're not picking up the phone to talk
18:34 it through. Um, so I took that away as a positive.
18:38 City has, uh, one of the biggest presences in China as any U.S.
18:42 bank. And I'm wondering how you maintain the
18:45 balance, given the fact that these two nations do have a rivalry and can be in
18:50 opposition, how difficult is that? It's very it's very simple.
18:54 We serve 70% of the fortune 500 that operate in China.
19:00 Um, you would much rather that is on our rails for foreign exchange, cash
19:06 management, trade, payroll, etc.. Um, and that that those are the rails
19:11 that are connecting the world to China. Um, for those multinationals.
19:15 And so it's um, and we also help connect about some of the Chinese companies in
19:21 the areas that it's not the outright competition, as you'd imagine.
19:25 Um, with the states. Um, to the rest of the world where there
19:28 is the collaborative relationship. Um, but you absolutely want this on, on
19:33 US rails. You don't.
19:35 You don't want it on other ones. It's it's part of American economic
19:40 security. There's also been a big shift in
19:42 Washington, DC politically. And the head of the Max Banking
19:47 Committee of the Senate next year is probably going to be Senator Elizabeth
19:50 Warren. She's had some pretty strong words about
19:54 Citi in the past. Just this July, she came out with a
19:56 press release warning Citi against making any acquisitions, saying Citi
20:01 grew irresponsibly from 1995 to 2007. Of course, you were forced to clean that
20:05 up afterwards when you came in. How do you respond to someone like
20:10 Senator Warren, who's been very critical of city's past as an incredibly
20:16 fundamental institution that was instrumental in a lot of the pain in
20:19 2008. I think all of us have a lot of respect
20:22 for Senator Warren. Um, and there's a lot of different areas
20:27 that we'll be able to will agree to disagree in certain areas, but there's
20:31 plenty of opportunity to work together on a lot of the different issues that
20:35 are concerning for the American people. Um, we will be looking forward to doing
20:40 that. Um, what I would say in terms of the
20:43 question about city is I would respectfully ask Senator Warren there
20:48 could the bank that we are today and not that the bank that we were.
20:52 Um, we have we have made very significant changes to what city is.
20:57 Um, and huge investments in risk and controls, um, huge investments in our
21:03 infrastructure to modernize it. Simplify the bank.
21:07 Um, to make sure that it is able to serve, um, both here at home, but also
21:12 very critical role serving American companies around the world.
21:17 Um, responsibly and effectively, um, being a source of strength and, and, um,
21:22 and stability for them as they operate internationally.
21:26 Um, and helping fund the success of companies, um, here in the States.
21:31 So an enormous investment in risk and controls and enormous investment in our
21:36 infrastructure. But we've also simplified the bank a
21:40 lot. We have five businesses now rather than
21:42 trying to be everything to everybody, everywhere.
21:45 Um, those five business lines sit at my table.
21:49 Um, uh, my husband will tell you I'm a hands on manager.
21:53 Um, and, um, we're making sure that, you know, that we are running this directly
22:00 rather than more like a holding company, which is some of the ways it's been done
22:04 in the past. Um, and that we're very engaged in, um,
22:09 making sure that we support small businesses, different sized banks,
22:14 different institutions throughout the country, as well as making sure that
22:18 American companies are competitive as they operate globally.
22:22 And we uniquely do that. So, um, I, I, I trust and hope you would
22:27 judge us on who we are today and not who we were because we are.
22:31 People have worked incredibly hard. I am so proud of them of going through
22:35 some tough years where we really transformed the bank.
22:39 It was blood, sweat and tears, but I think we're seeing the fruits.
22:42 And anyone who says that a bank can't multitask.
22:45 Um, I won't make any gender comments here.
22:48 Um, we were we were able to, um, both grow and, um, you know, to transform the
22:55 bank at the same time and really simplify it.
22:57 So now we're not done yet. Still a bit to go, but, uh, it's a very
23:02 different institution. I hope you will recognize that, because
23:05 we want to work together. You don't want to be working at odds.
23:08 I don't think that's constructive for anybody.
23:11 There's been a feeling that this will be a less conducive period to mergers and
23:15 acquisitions as a result of some of the crackdown.
23:18 From your own personal perspective. Do you think that the door has kind of
23:22 closed for any kind of like regional bank acquisitions or asset management
23:26 acquisitions? Or do you think that if it was rational,
23:28 it would still be open. Oh, I think it should be open.
23:32 Some consolidation is healthy. I do, I do think the US has a very good
23:37 structure because this is to say, it's a large country statement of the
23:41 blindingly obvious. But having the big global banks and the
23:45 role that we play in supporting the global financial system and the American
23:50 power globally is important. You have the, the, the large national
23:55 banks, you have the regional banks. And I spent the morning, as I say, with
24:00 group of the community and smaller banks in particular.
24:03 A really important role is that everyone plays their part in the system in a way
24:08 that you don't see in other countries. And and in some of them, you know, with
24:13 some, some consolidation is very healthy.
24:15 We have over 4000 banks. So, um, it's oh, we've got plenty to do
24:22 at the moment. Um, I think I see it, I see plenty of
24:25 organic growth Opportunities for city. You don't need to look in organically,
24:30 but that I do think there's some additional consolidation that isn't
24:35 creating problems in the system, but is actually healthy because it's expensive
24:40 to do all the fraud investment, the cyber investment, the technology
24:44 investments, these things. So I'm getting a few more players who
24:48 are larger in through all parts of that stack.
24:51 I think that's a good thing. Do you think that the U.S.
24:54 economy right now is strong enough to handle a 50 basis point rate hike next
24:58 week or next next month? Look, the economy is doing well.
25:03 I think the issue, it's uneven is certainly not being felt evenly across
25:07 the country. How well the economy is performing.
25:11 We're seeing a very stable labor market. And so the rates are low fire, low,
25:18 higher environment, but nonetheless it's pretty close to full employment.
25:23 You've got consumer spending that is strong and we have seen.
25:28 I'm really happy to see at the lower income households they've more been flat
25:34 rather than going down. People talk about, okay, it's more like
25:37 the alligator mouth like that. Um, and we'd rather see the low income
25:41 performing even more strongly. Um, but it's not getting it's not
25:46 getting worse. Um, so my my bigger concern, frankly, on
25:51 the right front is the, the causes of the inflation.
25:55 I'm not sure the rate hike actually fixes it because we're seeing it from
26:00 diesel. We're seeing it from low supply of
26:03 housing. We we need 7 million more affordable
26:06 housing in the States. It's a we've got a supply problem there.
26:11 Um, um, it takes a long time to build refineries around the world, which is
26:16 what you need to do, um, to address the diesel issues.
26:19 That's driving up prices. So I think one of the concerns many of
26:23 the banks has is. Yep.
26:25 The the numbers came in hot. We could well see rate hikes.
26:29 But does it actually fix the problem. That's underpinning it.
26:33 And that's my nagging concern at the moment.
26:36 It doesn't. Then it's kind of a boiling the frog
26:38 moment where you have people who are really, uh, hurt by higher inflation at
26:42 the same time that the hurt from higher rates.
26:44 Do you think that people are underestimating the chance of a
26:47 slowdown? Are you at Citi taking down risk in any
26:50 way in preparation for that, or do you think that is unlikely because of all of
26:54 the investment that we're seeing from other places?
26:56 Um, you have to be prepared for everything all the time, particularly in
27:00 the environment we're in, like the last two weeks is a case in point.
27:03 You wouldn't have expected that. And I think we've all got very good at
27:07 it, being more adaptable and being more resilient, building and more buffers,
27:12 being ready for more things happening. Um, and I think that's part of the
27:15 reason why the world economy has done pretty well in the last five years,
27:19 despite wars and Covid and trout rivers and all these other things have been
27:24 thrown at it. And so you have to be ready for a slow
27:28 down and something that's more material. I don't see it as being imminent, but
27:33 the tail risks are certainly bigger than they were before.
27:36 And in that one, we've got to be ready to support the affordability agenda.
27:42 That is the reason we had the big shift in the election.
27:45 Um, the prices are high. And I think the other piece companies
27:50 are being very mindful about not passing on some of the price increases through
27:55 to consumers because there's a clear understanding.
27:58 Uh, things have been good. Let's try and absorb as much of this as
28:02 possible through the earnings we've got or, um, um, trying to make sure the
28:07 investments are still going to give growth into the economy, um, rather
28:11 than, uh, rather than passing this on to consumers, um, recklessly.
28:17 What do you think right now is the biggest risk that people are
28:21 underestimating, because clearly there's a sense that maybe there's an
28:25 overbuilding and I or maybe there's a I don't want to say bubble, but excess is
28:31 happening in certain pockets there. Maybe you get rates that rise that kill
28:34 the party. What's your sense?
28:36 I don't think I think anyone's, um, overestimating or underestimating
28:42 anything at the moment. I think we're all very mindful that
28:45 we've got an economy that continues to perform well, not unevenly, but still
28:50 perform well in the aggregate. Um, and that there's a number of
28:54 different tail risks. We know what they are.
28:57 Um, so I think the biggest risk we have is if they start converging.
29:02 And so if you start seeing and feed off each other, then that's when you tend to
29:06 get more of a self-fulfilling prophecy coming.
29:09 I don't see that yet. But it, you know, is a possibility at
29:13 some point. What I am happy is to see some of the
29:16 air come out of the tires. We had a market that was priced to
29:19 perfection. We have some eye concentration risk in
29:22 there. We've had a big election with a big
29:25 shift and change around. Um, and as you say, we've had a
29:29 leadership change in, um, in one of the big companies and I all of those
29:34 different pieces. You know, we're seeing some of the
29:36 market react to that at the moment. At the same time, you see anthropic
29:41 with, uh, what looks like will be a very successful IPO, um, when it comes out
29:46 tomorrow and, you know, giving confidence in about the genie not being
29:51 out of the bottle on the I and that you this should continue on.
29:56 But we've all got to be mindful. Let's do this responsibly.
29:59 Bring everyone along with us and and manage the risks.
30:03 I'm going to open it up to questions. Uh, if anyone has any questions, please
30:08 just state your name and your affiliation, and I'll open up now.
30:15 Nobody has any questions, so I'll keep going.
30:18 Yeah. Thank you.
30:20 Thank you. I'd love to hear your thoughts on, um,
30:24 digital currency. Oh.
30:26 Um. Yeah.
30:27 Yeah. The the crosshair between regulation or
30:31 control. Yeah.
30:32 It would continue to make money, but, yeah, it's still efficient.
30:35 Yeah. And, uh, not only, of course, your
30:39 emphasis these days, I believe your bank, uh, institutional side, not the
30:44 retail side. So I'd love to hear your thoughts,
30:46 because that potentially be somewhat different.
30:49 Yeah. Thank you for your presentation.
30:51 Yeah. It's, um, it's very easy when new
30:54 technologies come to go chasing shiny objects.
30:57 Um, and to avoid doing that, you say, okay, what is it that your customers
31:02 need? Um.
31:03 And what what are they looking for? So on the institutional side, as
31:07 customers are looking at, um, a world where they want to move their money
31:10 around instantly, um, always on. So 20, 24, seven, three, 65 days.
31:17 Um, they want to do so in a way that is not clunky.
31:21 Um, they want it to be efficient. So not not expensive.
31:24 Um, and they want it most importantly as well, to be done securely and safely.
31:30 Um, given what we see when, um, when bad actors can get in the way there.
31:35 So that's, that's that's what we are looking at.
31:38 That's what we expect the system to be moving to and solving for how to how to
31:43 have all of that. It sounds like have your cake and eat it
31:45 without calories. But actually this is so this is doable
31:49 to get there. Um, um, what we're watching is adoption
31:54 of these new digital asset capabilities and technologies operating at the same
32:00 time, which with the traditional rails, and you want that to be interoperable
32:05 between them. Um, and, um, lots of these technologies
32:09 are fascinating alone, but alone is part of the problem.
32:13 If they don't all work together in a way that's easy for a client.
32:17 Um, I think in terms of digital currencies.
32:20 Um, we're going to see more of the tokenization as the preferred
32:25 technology, because stablecoin means a central bank doesn't necessarily have
32:29 control of their currency. Uh, and I think that will be unpopular
32:33 with them if they lose control of their currencies.
32:36 Um, whereas the tokenization gives the customers, be they retail will be the
32:40 institutional, exactly the same benefits they want, but without some of the, um,
32:46 the challenges in the payment system. Um, on cross-border, if it was, uh, more
32:51 of a coin based technology. So I think tokenization would be the one
32:55 that wins, but it's not happening overnight.
32:58 Ah, bank moves, eh? I mean, it's a staggering for, for for
33:01 multinational companies and and institutions.
33:05 We move $6 trillion a day around the world.
33:10 At the moment, we're only moving about $2 billion worth in digitized, tokenized
33:15 form. So it's is really minuscule, is growing
33:19 quickly, but clients aren't quite ready to adopt it yet.
33:23 You know, they're not ready for always on and they're not ready for 365.
33:27 So it's these things, these technologies and their possibilities always happen
33:32 faster than actually the diffusion does. I suspect the same is going to be true
33:36 of I, by the way. And with all innovations, if innovation
33:41 happens at speed, you want risk management to happen at speed to.
33:46 Um, so making sure we've got the right protections for consumers, investors and
33:52 in place really is important because then you can innovate faster.
33:57 Yeah. So that's sort of how we see it.
33:59 But yeah, we're not in the shiny object business.
34:02 So we'd rather go for what our customers need rather than, uh, otherwise.
34:11 Hi. Uh, thank you.
34:12 Uh, Christopher Gaber at Associated Press.
34:14 So just on the, uh, I financing issues. Yeah.
34:18 The fed raised that in the report last week.
34:20 Concerns about things like circular financing and other issues.
34:25 How are you sure that your bank has.
34:28 Yeah, yeah. On that.
34:29 And what would you say to to be sure others as you can imagine, I think our
34:34 bank and every other bank has spent a lot of time on this.
34:37 So there's a number of different pieces. So we look at the whole AI ecosystem um,
34:42 and divided up into different portions. And we'll put limits against that.
34:46 We'll take different slices by different companies and countries.
34:49 So you sort of have a multi-dimensional, uh, matrix of different ways that you
34:54 look at your limit structures. So you're not taking concentration risk
34:58 anyway because diversification is important.
35:01 Um, then we'll look at good good underwriting, making sure that you're
35:06 taking good credit decisions, um, and taking all those different dimensions in
35:10 place. And, Um, U.S.
35:12 Bank so generally pretty good at this um, and understanding it.
35:17 Then we'll also look at how do we distribute the rest.
35:19 So a lot of what we do is we originate to then distribute on rather than holds
35:23 on our balance sheets. And so we want to make sure we're
35:27 originating it, that there's an ability to distribute responsibly, um, to, uh,
35:33 investors. And then finally we look at the
35:35 collateral. Um, very carefully and make sure that
35:40 what's the collateral that's underpinning the loan.
35:42 So it's in some ways it's good old fashioned, um, corporate banking, um,
35:48 disciplines that get applied to this, but to, um, in a, in a, um, in a modern
35:54 and sophisticated manner. So I feel comfortable with, um, the
35:58 risks that we take on board, uh, and the, um, and what we do.
36:03 Um, and it's also important that we're doing it because we want to make sure
36:07 that we are financing, um, these future growth engines, but not in a way that
36:12 causes a systemic issue. And we also make sure the capital
36:15 structures of the different companies is in good shape.
36:18 And we've been making sure that and working with a lot of big companies to
36:24 make sure their funding is off cash flow.
36:26 As a bank, love cash flow. Um, is it cash flow?
36:30 How much is the equity that we're raising for them?
36:33 What are the different, um, debt structures that are being put in place
36:37 so that you've got a durable, sustainable capital structure for the
36:42 level of investment that's being required and you've got different
36:46 milestones for the types of returns you want to see.
36:50 Yeah. It's, um, it gets a lot of attention
36:53 from all of us. You'll be happy to know.
36:56 Yeah. You know, that's
37:00 a question. Yeah.
37:03 Ahead. Uh, nice to see you again.
37:09 Yes. So, uh, seems like it took up a, uh, a
37:13 war. Uh, a race to the moon, uh, a political
37:17 tsunami to dwarf the the the worry that we had about private credit.
37:22 Yeah. Uh, do you think the public has passed
37:24 the test, or, uh, have the brilliant chiefs of governance set of containment,
37:29 or should we keep an eye on it? Was a banker.
37:31 I always love to get, um, granularity and transparency.
37:35 So I think we, um, if for the whole system, um, getting even more
37:41 granularity about what the different exposures of private credit are, we have
37:46 the benefits in the bank that we can see when we're investing.
37:50 We tend to invest in so well over 90% is investment grade using 95%.
37:56 Um, we'll look at the different pools. We can pool collateral in and out of
38:00 what we're doing. Um, so there's a there's an ability to
38:03 manage this. Well, when I look at private credit, a
38:06 lot of this is mainly an institutional ultra high net worth hands and they look
38:12 at an asset allocation. This is often not um, some of it that's
38:16 not an investment grade. It's not a large portion of the exposure
38:20 that the investors have or of the asset allocation they have.
38:23 If it was very heavily retail, I'd be more worried because this is something
38:27 that retail is getting exposure. You'd rather it be through their
38:30 insurance all through their pension funds rather than than directly.
38:35 Um, I think a couple of our clients would disagree on that one, but that's
38:39 my personal view. Um, and it's about 1.7 trillion.
38:44 Um, which sounds like a lot of money, but in the size of the US capital market
38:48 is not oversized. So as long as the, um, credit standards
38:54 a good we have transparency around it. Private credit I think, does play an
39:00 important role. It matches long term assets and long
39:03 term liabilities. But if you do a poor job at credit.
39:07 Then there's no hiding on that one. At the moment, I think it if we see
39:12 issues, it's more idiosyncratic to a couple of companies or a couple of
39:17 insurance companies rather than a systemic issue at the moment.
39:21 But you have to keep an eye on it. Yeah.
39:24 I Jason B Furman with Politico. Hey Jason,
39:29 you are already starting the race to 2028 and
39:35 I'm so glad. I mean, business is running.
39:38 I'm wondering are there any or first what you want to see in the next
39:42 president or what your peers from other major companies want to see?
39:47 And also, is there anyone right now who is speculated to run that you think
39:53 might it that criteria? You are you are definitely asking the
39:57 wrong person that question. I try and I try and I'm very, very
40:02 keenly aware that if you're the CEO of a large company, and I stick to a swim
40:07 line. Um, my swim lanes.
40:10 Making sure that we work with whichever administration is in power.
40:14 Um, we try and make sure that if we think there are things that they're
40:18 doing in policy that's concerning from the economy, that they will will tell
40:22 them and that they will listen and do something about it.
40:25 And at the same time that they're understanding how to grow the
40:28 competitiveness and the country in as even a way as possible.
40:33 Um, so those would be my wish list for the, for, um, all presidents that they
40:38 follow those and that they're mine for the role, the important role America
40:41 plays in the world. Um, but, uh, I'm going to be sticking to
40:45 my day job rather than worrying about the presidential election in two years,
40:50 because two years are quite a long time. We've got a lot to manage through.
40:54 Are you taking yourself out of the running?
40:56 I'm. I'm.
40:57 I'm not born here. I'm going.
41:00 Uh. I'm Scottish.
41:02 I don't think I'd be a very good president.
41:04 I guess I could stick to trying to do a good job with my current day job.
41:08 That's that's plenty. I acknowledge Joseph with NPR.
41:13 I know in a recent interview with fortune, you talked about the best
41:17 advice that Warren Buffett ever gave you.
41:20 Oh, yeah. I'd love to know what advice you give or
41:22 what is the mantra that you live by. If you want to tell the audience about
41:26 what Warren Buffett said to you. Yeah.
41:29 Um, he said he's given a number of pieces of advice being good, but the
41:33 some of the advice, um, I try and give I shamelessly take good advice that's been
41:38 given to me and then share that on rather than coming up with any original
41:43 thought, apparently. Um, so the best advice I got was from
41:48 one of our board members says have big ears and have thick skin.
41:52 And I really underestimated how relevant that is.
41:56 And big is is about listening, putting yourself in other people's shoes, um,
42:00 understanding points of view that you maybe don't want to understand, or
42:04 hearing the truth you don't want to hear.
42:06 Um, as well as just, uh, listening to your clients and other pieces and making
42:12 sure that you're reacting to that rather than what you think all the time.
42:17 Um, and then the second piece was the thick skin, the resiliency.
42:22 I talked to my management team about it on a fairly regular basis.
42:26 You have to be resilient, like what you think is the right thing.
42:30 And know make sure you're doing it sometime that can take courage.
42:33 Or you can have to take decisions that are long term, you know.
42:37 Right. But have some pain in the short term and
42:40 you stick with the plan around it. And so that takes some grittiness and
42:45 courage and conviction. Um, and I think those, those pieces of
42:49 resiliency that you don't compromise on the important.
42:53 Um, and some of the values that are critical.
42:56 Um, I think those are good advice for anybody.
42:58 Yeah, this certainly helped me. I remind myself when I'm not listening
43:03 properly, that I need to have bigger ears.
43:05 Yeah. One more question, I think.
43:10 If we have. Oh, yeah.
43:13 Oh, you got the last one. It's fantastic.
43:21 Thanks so much for this program. One thing that I think is very relevant
43:24 to your day job is some of the rhetoric in Washington right now includes things
43:28 about price controls and rate caps on things like cards.
43:32 And I'm just wondering kind of what your point of view is on that.
43:35 Yeah. So as I've said, I there is clearly an
43:39 affordability issue, um, for many people in the States.
43:43 And we have to work out how do we address that?
43:46 I mean, and on the face of it, a rate cap on a credit card sounds like a good
43:50 idea. Unfortunately, it has the opposite
43:53 impact of what is intended because we have what if we were to put a rate cap,
43:59 save 10%. As the president has suggested on our
44:02 credit card business, we would immediately have to stop giving credit
44:06 to about 100 million different customers here.
44:10 Um, because it would make it so unprofitable for us to lend.
44:15 Um, and that would then have a secondary effect cascading down, because a lot of
44:20 the airlines make more money from their credit card, a loyalty program with us
44:25 than they do from running the airline hotels and often in the same situation.
44:31 And I could go on restaurants and others and cascade through.
44:35 Um, so what does what is it that does address affordability?
44:39 Because that's really the root cause. Let's let's solve the problem rather
44:43 than, um, put something in place that doesn't work.
44:46 And in that one, I think it's some of the things we've looked at and we've
44:51 done in the past, say, for example, how do you eliminate late fees or how do you
44:56 eliminate some of the overdraft fees are other areas that are levels that just
45:01 don't make sense relative to the, um, the issue.
45:04 No one wants to go to Starbucks and go overdraft by $0.40 on their coffee and
45:09 then get a, um, they're a ten back or a 40 back charge on it.
45:13 That that's not fair. Um, and equally, making sure that you've
45:17 got no frills, but, um, fit for purpose. Um, bank accounts, access to credit at
45:23 affordable rates. So as many people have access to credit
45:27 as possible. So, um, I, I remember this aging me.
45:33 The Carter administration put a lot of different credit controls, other pieces
45:38 in place with the same intent, and they within within two months, they had to
45:43 roll it all back because it was a catastrophe for the economy.
45:47 So let's solve the problem, which is affordability.
45:50 But with the things that we know that will work and and not something that
45:53 could actually make the problem, um, even tougher for people.
Seeing More Asset-Management Consolidation: Goldman’s Nachmann full transcript
0:00 What a pace of deal making that you've recently been on. It is a different kind
0:04 of shift. It is a different pace. It does feel like something has kinda turned the
0:08 corner, and I wonder what has changed for GSAM. What has changed in the environment that
0:12 has made these acquisitions attractive to you?
0:15 Sure. I mean, let me start first by saying, our organic strategy is still the key
0:21 underlying growth strategy for, asset and wealth management. I think we've, done quite well there. We've,
0:27 set some more targets earlier this year where we increased a number of targets, and we've
0:32 done quite well against them. So, you know, we're we're showing management fee growth in in
0:36 the double digits against our high single digit target. We continue to improve our margin. We
0:41 continue to show very, very strong fundraising fundraising both on the alternative side as well as
0:48 the traditional side, which is quite in contrast to a number of our competitors. And so
0:53 we feel really good about the momentum we have in the organic strategy. And to complement
0:58 that, we we have started to look at acquisitions. Bar has been very, very high. We've
1:04 looked at a lot of things. I think the key on these acquisitions really accelerating our
1:10 growth platform, adding to our our lineup. But then also a big emphasis on integration, our
1:18 ability to integrate, making sure that that's really gonna be successful. So we spend a lot
1:24 of time in the diligence process thinking about integration and is that... You know, how are
1:28 we gonna do this? Is the team gonna work? And that that that... That's been a
1:32 big part of it. And so far, we're pretty excited about the two acquisitions we closed.
1:37 Two more to come, hopefully, soon this year, and we're excited about the results so far.
1:43 I I guess why now? Why now if things are humming along with organic growth growth
1:46 and they have been? Why is now the time pursue
1:48 something? Humming along, and I think we feel really good. And I think the organic strategy
1:51 gives us a lot of growth. I think we can accelerate in a in a couple
1:55 areas, and there are... You know, these are very specific acquisitions that fill specific holes that
2:00 we had. So when you look at the first one that we announced, Industry Ventures, which
2:05 is a business that focuses on secondaries in the VC business, we are very, very big
2:12 secondary player, you know, secondary private equity buyout, secondary infrastructure, real estate credit. VC was one
2:19 space where we weren't as heavily involved. We've known the industry venture guys for a long
2:25 time. In fact, we owned a stake in industry venture in our stakes business, which is
2:31 a different fund, and that business really fit in well. They have a tremendous track record
2:37 for a long period of time. They're now on fund 11, so long track record, and
2:42 that was really important. But also a team that we really knew. We knew the leadership,
2:48 and we felt really comfortable that they would be great as part of Goldman Sachs. And
2:53 I think they've been with us since the beginning of the year, super excited about the
2:56 integration has borne our fruits. And then the the other acquisition that we've closed is innovator
3:02 in the ETF space, in the defined outcome ETF space. They've actually, you know, created that
3:08 space, really interesting space, especially when you think about market environment. Right now, given the volatility,
3:13 I think they have buffer products and and and products that really can protect you, continue
3:19 to give you upside opportunity, but but with some protection. We announced that acquisition about a
3:24 year ago. They were $28,000,000,000 of assets. They're now 38, so they've grown quite a lot
3:32 together with us. So we're really excited about that. ETF was an area that we wanted
3:37 to grow more in. Right. And I think active ETF is a very fast growing part
3:42 of the asset management business. And I think with the acquisitions that we've announced in the
3:47 ETF space, we're now a kind of top eight player by assets of six by revenue.
3:51 ETFs, private markets. I know private markets is something that David Solomon has talked about and
3:55 his desire to grow that too. Are there any more gaps there? Do you think that
3:59 that might... Future acquisitions might come in the way of private markets?
4:02 Yeah. I think we we we we continuously look. I think we announced, as you mentioned
4:06 earlier, LCN, which is in the private markets, a triple net lease business, basically a real
4:11 estate credit product that we're very excited. I think when you look at that product, again,
4:15 fills a gap we don't have, but it's really interesting. They basically help corporates take assets
4:21 off the balance sheet. Right. You think about our position with corporates, and I just saw
4:26 the m and a league tables. You guys just flashed out there where we're proudly number
4:30 one.
4:31 Yeah. You probably don't mind seeing that.
4:32 So we like that. And so on. We obviously have good connectivity with corporate, So Right.
4:36 We can help corporates on balance sheet.
4:38 Would assume that as you're doing this... I mean, a lot has been talked about how
4:41 there is stress kind of on the smaller fund side of things for alternative managers. Do
4:46 you just... Do you field calls a lot of people saying, Marc, we can see you're
4:49 buying a few things. Would you take a look at us?
4:51 We definitely get a lot of calls, and, you know, there's some good calls and some
4:55 not so good calls. But, you know, we we we we look at things. We spend
5:00 a lot of time with these companies, you know, together to try to see if it
5:06 if it makes sense. I remember on Innovator. I met Bruce Bond who founded Innovator, I
5:13 think, a year before, so almost a year before we announced the transaction. So so these
5:17 things take a long time because we really wanna make sure that we can integrate them
5:22 on and that it fits well.
5:24 So speaking of, you know, all the phone calls you may or may not be getting,
5:27 I I had a conversation with Arctosis, Ian Charles, who who who he himself sold to
5:32 KKR. He basically said that there's a problem with a lot of funds right now, that
5:35 they are zombie funds, that they're sitting on stuck assets, they're having a hard time fundraising.
5:40 I'm wondering how acute you see that problem right now in private capital, and how many
5:46 funds are under stress again? Maybe you wanted to I
5:48 think, listen, people talk about there's a whole bunch of funds who are on their lost
5:52 funds. They may or may not know it yet. And so I think that is an
5:56 issue. Arctos, obviously, in an exciting sector. Arctos is an example. We actually owned a stake
6:01 in Arctos as well in our GP stakes business called Peter Sell, and so we're excited
6:06 with KKR purchasing that stake. So there's definitely a number of firms who are stuck with
6:13 their portfolios. Those are really not the targets we look at.
6:17 Yeah. Yeah.
6:17 I think we really look at at companies that have great investment performance and where the
6:22 combination really allows us to scale them more and to kinda add them into our system.
6:30 The the sort of... The transactions that are having... That are happening right now, I wonder
6:35 what it would take to kind of bring the rest of the industry with it. Do
6:38 you think there needs to be some sort of capitulation? Does the macro environment need to
6:43 change? What sort of unglues the rest of things?
6:46 Look. I I think some of these firms are just gonna be on their lost fund.
6:50 I think one of the things that that I definitely see is there's gonna be more
6:54 and more consolidation in the asset management business, but I think it's not necessarily consolidation from
7:00 an m and a perspective. I think it's really consolidation from a client perspective. When you
7:04 look at large allocators of capital, they really wanna reduce the number of relationships they have.
7:10 They wanna reduce the number of asset managers they're talking to. They wanna do more with
7:14 a concentrated group of asset managers. And I think that's a little bit the direction of
7:20 travel on on the industry, and so that's gonna force consolidation. You know, when when you
7:25 think about the asset management space, you know, again, you you had the m and a
7:28 lead tables out there earlier. You know, we showed 40% market share for Goldman Sachs. You
7:33 look at the asset management business, everybody has a tiny market share con... Compared to the
7:38 the the overall size of of the asset management business. Pretty unusual in kind of the
7:43 financial world. Is this
7:45 you telling me your targets also get a 40% market share?
7:48 I think I think we're far away. We're far away. I'd love to have the same
7:52 position that my my partners in the m and a business have, but, you know, we
7:56 we we got more to do there.
7:58 Hey, Marc. Just just quickly before you go, because we are still sort of sorting through
8:01 NVIDIA earnings, where you do have a company that says that it's going to be more
8:05 scrutinizing in terms of how it finances the ecosystem. Do you think that as a whole
8:09 might slow down AI deals in the industry if you have NVIDIA, the leader, pulling back
8:14 slightly?
8:15 Look. I think we'll we'll have to see what exactly happens. I I I would say,
8:18 you know, there's obviously a lot of questions around financing, around the AI infrastructure cycle. I
8:24 think the markets in general are pretty constructive and and and... To that. And we see
8:29 it both in the public side and the private side. We've been participating in both. I
8:33 think that's one of the interesting things about our platform. We do public private. Obviously, also
8:38 our colleagues on the banking side are involved in this. And we see the market's pretty
8:44 constructive for a well structured deal. So I feel pretty good about the ability to continue
8:50 to, fund, the infrastructure build out, and I think it'll continue to be a big growth
8:55 driver.
Flight To Quality in AI Financing: Raghavan full transcript
0:00 Of the deals that you've transacted on. It's like a who's who of the biggest. Lumentum,
0:04 SK Hynix, Paramount Broadcom, roles on SpaceX, and Anthropic. What does it take to get the
0:10 team ready to win and to execute on such large transactions?
0:16 Hey. Hi, Dani. Thanks for having me on the program. Look. I think, you know, what
0:20 you need is incredible talent. I think talent is the kind of the key to get
0:25 the rhythm going, you know, to be on some of these landmark deals. Talent, a lot
0:30 of very good content, and above all intensity. And, you know, we have a game plan.
0:34 We've been executing systematically on the game plan for a few years now, and what you're
0:39 seeing now is a result of that systematic execution. So a lot more to come.
0:45 A lot more to come. Maybe a big one this week as well. I do just
0:48 wonder, especially with these IPOs, as I mentioned, cities at the top of the league table.
0:53 For the big ones, for the Anthropics, for the SpaceXs, what have you, how important are
0:57 they for setting the tone lower down the stack? Like, do we need to get through
1:02 the big IPOs in order to have medium, maybe even smaller companies willing to come to
1:07 market?
1:09 Yeah. I mean, look, Anthropic, you know, I can't comment on the deal particularly because we
1:13 are involved, but something like an Anthropic is is gonna be a bellwether, you know, given
1:18 the current sentiment around AI and some of the the the currents that you've seen. You
1:24 know, a lot of folks are waiting for this transaction to happen, for it to trade
1:28 well. So I... You know, it's gonna be an incredible bellwether. But also more importantly, it
1:34 kind of really diversifies companies' ability to really access every pool of capital, every pool of
1:42 liquidity given the enormity of the financing needs that the whole sector and the AI in
1:46 fraud build is gonna take. So, you know, the the... All eyes are on Anthropic, but,
1:51 you know, that's gonna be a great bellwether for things to come.
1:54 You know, it is interesting you you mentioned this idea of, like, it gets to a
1:57 point where financing needs become so great you need to be public because there had been
2:01 this narrative, and we've seen it play out that pump... Companies can stay private for longer
2:06 because private capital exists. And I wonder if something has changed that means more companies need
2:12 to go public or if this is just very much so like an AI LLM. It's
2:17 capital intensive. Therefore, it's these companies, and the rest of the universe can stay private for
2:21 longer.
2:22 I think it is general, but it is particularly true for AI. Know, You when you
2:26 look at the enormity of the the capital asks, you know, estimates are $3,500,000,000,000 up to
2:32 2030. You know, you really need to dip into every pool of liquidity, whether it is
2:38 bank capital, the syndicated loan market, it's private credit, it is private equity, you know, sovereign
2:43 wealth funds, you name it. So when you're looking to finance, that magnitude of, you know,
2:50 capital raise to get and deliver on your ambitions, you really need, you know, to access
2:55 every pool of liquidity there is. And I think what you described is particularly true for,
3:00 you know, the AI build out, but it is not too dissimilar for, you know, for
3:05 instance, you know, we've seen that in the m and a market. Right? I mean, you
3:08 you know, this year has been the second biggest M and A market ever. You've seen
3:12 4.5... Nearly $4,500,000,000,000 of M and A deal volume, and a lot of that needs financing
3:17 too. So what what you're seeing is a massive infra build out in AI. You see
3:24 mountains of kind of government debt, waiting to be refinanced. Sometimes the two are competing with
3:30 each other for the same pools of liquidity, and you have a really robust m and
3:34 a environment that also needs financing. So you you see it coming together of massive capital
3:38 asks, which means you have to dip into every pool of liquidity there is.
3:42 And and it's been absorbed, right, for all of these things, be it AI, be it
3:46 Paramount debt. You do sometimes see little bits of pushback. You think that this market can
3:51 continue to absorb the great financing needs? To your point, it's not just private companies. It's
3:56 it's governments as as well. Can it continue to absorb it at the pace that it
4:00 has been?
4:01 I think I... There is enough liquidity out there to finance some of these transactions. What
4:07 are you definitely seeing now is greater selectivity. So there is a flight to quality. Folks
4:13 are being more discerning, and the best transactions, the best issuers, the strongest names have access,
4:21 and they can get anything done. The more marginal ones right now, you know, there is
4:26 a lot more scrutiny, and, you know, not all of them are gonna see the finish
4:29 line. So that selectivity is healthy. It it is... It was always much needed. And, you
4:35 know, that liquidity is... There's abundance, but it is incredibly, incredibly selective.
4:40 Well, when it comes
4:40 to the
4:41 Yeah. If I could just jump in, sorry, Vis, just quickly because on that point, when
4:45 it comes selectivity, one of the things I've also heard is people are becoming more selective
4:49 around AI. This is a point that Carlyle makes is because you reach concentration limits, and
4:54 you can't keep absorbing it. And I wonder what you think. Is there a risk just
4:58 the great financing needs that they have that concentration becomes a problem? And how are you
5:03 thinking about Citi's own exposure?
5:05 I think I would say it is less concentration. It's more, it's becoming survival of the
5:11 fittest. So the names that are gonna struggle a bit more are really the neo clouds,
5:16 you know, the the neo labs and the like. When you look at the names that
5:20 will comfortably get done are the very large players because, you know, they have lot... Large
5:26 capitalizations. Most of them are investment grade. They have abundant access to the equity capital markets.
5:32 And and and, you know, Citi has played a role in pretty much every one of
5:36 these this year when you look at, you know, Oracle, Broadcom, you know, SoftBank's high yield
5:41 bond, and the like. You know, you can... You you see the reception that these large,
5:46 you know, names get and how deals get comfortably over the finish line. That selectivity is
5:51 gonna really impair, the ability of some of the more marginal players, the smaller players, because
5:57 this market is getting discerning now.
5:59 Hey, Vis. Just quickly, before you go, as you mentioned, $4,400,000,000,000 tracking year to date of
6:04 global m and a. What's your base case for 2027? Can we keep it up and
6:08 exceed it even? I
6:11 would I would say, look. The... When I look at the pipeline, it is incredibly robust.
6:16 Financial sponsors were close to a third of the market this year, and I would almost
6:22 argue that that is reticent. I mean, they have, you know, still $2.02 $2,500,000,000,000 of dry
6:27 powder. And the the... So I do see,
6:31 you know, I'm bullish on the outlook for the m and a market. You do have
6:35 headwinds, though. You know, on my list of headwinds, geopolitics is, you know, top of that
6:40 list. Clearly, inflation and what rates and what the yield curve does is is relevant because
6:45 these deals have to be financed. And, you know, you're now looking at ten year money
6:48 at 5% or thereabouts. So, so I think, you know, the the cost of debt and
6:54 the cost of capital is is a concern. And then clearly, you know, you you still
6:58 have... You know, folks are looking to see, okay, what are the efficiency productivity benefits of
7:02 AI and the cost per token? So all of that will play out. But overall, I
7:06 am I am positive. The macro holds up. I'm incredibly positive for '27.
Anthropic’s Valuation Seems Justified: Thakker full transcript
0:00 Let's talk more about how investors are approaching AI and the highly anticipated Anthropic IPO. I'm
0:06 joined now by Darmesh Thacker, general partner at Battery Ventures. Battery's most recent tech focused fund
0:12 raised $3,250,000,000 earlier this year. We we should just note that you're not in anthropic, so
0:17 there's no conflict of interest here, Darmesh. I'm pleased to say. And and look. This is
0:21 a company that's reportedly pricing at the top end of its range, if not exceeding that.
0:26 It has been weeks of nonstop volatility around the AI theme. What does that kind of
0:31 demand tell you about AI at this moment and companies like Anthropic?
0:37 Well, thanks for having me, Dani. What this excitement tells you that the demand for AI
0:41 is real, the end market for AI is real, and at the, the revenue figures that
0:47 Anthropic has shown with the forecast going ahead, it seems to be fairly priced. And I
0:52 think the retail trade might see it price getting higher. So there's there's a ton of
0:56 demand for this market opportunity that's targeting a $40,000,000,000,000 TAM for labor augmentation, and then drop
1:02 it at the leading edge of it is not surprisingly seeing all the interest they are.
1:07 So we have those seen volatility in the lead up to this 2,000,000,000,000 goes back down
1:11 to 1.1, 1.4. Maybe it edges higher than that. Darmesh, know, yes, demand. Yes. People wanna
1:18 be part of this. But are some of the nerves warranted at least in the run
1:22 up to this?
1:25 Yeah. It's been a very volatile period with everything going on with NVIDIA and the, the
1:30 the fundraising needs to, to live up to the promise of AI. I think what's more
1:34 important than the valuation is the capital they raise. In this environment where Entropic could possibly
1:40 raise 90 plus billion dollars, that would make them one of the most cash rich AI
1:47 infrastructure companies much more so than Meta and Google and Amazon that are also going past
1:53 their cash flows. And that capital gives you the ability to lock up capacity to go
1:58 across NVIDIA into TPUs and really take care of the supply side of the house and
2:03 with Anthropic and porting use of the demand side of the house really spiking. So if
2:07 if they can raise this capital regardless of whether the valuation is 1.4 or 1,600,000,000,000, that
2:13 puts them in a really good place to deliver upon their 100,000,000,000 run rate next year
2:18 and significantly higher the years after. So I think that's far more important than what the
2:22 the near term valuations might be.
2:24 Ramesh, does that underscore that OpenAI too then needs to go public shortly thereafter, that that
2:29 source of capital is gonna be increasingly important for these LLNs?
2:33 Absolutely. I mean, if you look at the capital needs in the environment we are, you
2:38 know, you have hyperscalers competing with US treasuries to raise capital, and Anthropic and OpenAI who
2:44 need to pay up for the infrastructure will need the same amount of capital. In private
2:48 markets, OpenAI has exhausted most of the channels to raise money. As you know, their recent
2:53 fundraise fell short of their expectations, so they will need to look for an avenue to
2:57 go public and also raise the capital. And I think the market could benefit from competition
3:01 between OpenAI and Prophic and Google as multiple providers of, of this really important wave of
3:07 technology.
3:07 A lot of them, though, are are swimming in this same pool, and it's this concern
3:11 around circular financing that will continue to be a question, I'm sure, with every single earnings
3:16 report that Anthropic announces, whether it be a $35,000,000,000 chip deal that Anthropic has done with
3:22 Google, a compute deal with Acme, or financing... AI financing with, Broadcom. At what point does
3:29 vendor financing become something that's not just a a structural reality, but something that is also
3:35 a risk for many of these players?
3:38 That is indeed one of the biggest risks that Entropic has to tackle in the quarters
3:43 ahead. To begin with, their revenue is 80% pay as you go and 20% committed. But
3:49 on the other hand, their contract commitments to, to infrastructure vendors, almost 900,000,000,000, are set in
3:55 stone over the next six, seven years. So making the duration mismatch adjustment, you wanna have
4:00 committed revenue to make up for your committed obligations, I think is an important topic for
4:05 them to handle. On the other hand, the risks of circular financing, I feel, are somewhat
4:10 overblown. A lot of commentators will look at this and say in the .com era, financing
4:16 from vendors is what brought down the the the technology wave then. I think this time
4:21 is different in that the demand for AI is real. Nobody's going back from using cloud
4:25 and chat GPT to using Google search. Developers aren't going back to providing port by hand.
4:30 So the demand is real. The needs for capital to support that inflecting demand from 10,000,000,000
4:36 to a 100,000,000,000 for Anthropic over the last few quarters shows you that the the the
4:42 demand wave is real, and that can justify the financing needs of this business. Currently, since
4:47 there aren't very clear ways of financing this business, vendors have stepped in. But with Jensen
4:53 stepping out and Colette stepping in, I think NVIDIA is gonna be more cautious about providing
4:57 this circular financing. And I think, and dropping an open AI at an escape velocity that
5:02 they can count on other sources of capital to sustain their growth.
5:05 Who do who do you think is vulnerable with NVIDIA stepping back, Ramesh?
5:09 I think the most vulnerable set of companies are the neo labs that do need to
5:14 raise, you know, tens of billions to train their models even though they don't quite have
5:18 their revenues to to justify them. And I think the second set of competitor... Second set
5:23 of companies, sorry, are early stage infrastructure companies that need to raise hundreds of millions to
5:29 train their models and buy GPU clusters. I feel like those Neolabs, Neoclouds, GPU resellers, and
5:35 early stage infrastructure companies are the ones that are most exposed with NVIDIA pulling back. But
5:40 on the other hand, at scale companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, obviously, that have real demand, have
5:47 revenue that ends up billions now have alternate ways to finance their growth from here on.
5:52 When it comes again back to this IPO for Anthropic, Ramesh, it it... It's a long
5:56 list of some of your peers that have participated in funding rounds from Anthropic, some very
6:02 early on, many later on in different stages. What does it do to the entirety of
6:08 the VC and private capital landscape to have this event where once lockup periods come up,
6:14 all of a sudden leaves a lot of funds flush with cash should they choose to
6:17 exit?
6:19 I think it's very healthy for the venture industry. You know, congratulations to all my friends
6:24 and colleagues at several other firms that have invested in the in the company. And I
6:28 think generating DPI, which is, you know, distribution for investor dollars, our investors are waiting for
6:33 their DPI to show up and and drop it liquidity alongside SpaceX, perhaps, you know, OpenAI
6:39 and Databricks in the in the quarters to come. It's a really good thing for our
6:44 investors and the venture ecosystems as those dollars make their rounds are bad, and they show
6:48 that this AI investment trend is real. And that encourages us to invest in other companies
6:54 that can continue this, this phenomena around AI. On the other hand, the concentration of companies
7:00 that generate the returns resembles what you've seen in public markets. If you look at the
7:04 S and P 500, the magnificent seven have generated most of the returns, while the remaining
7:09 493 companies have generally been on the sidelines. In the private industry as well, it feels
7:14 like there's 20 to 50 companies that are likely in the 100 to 500,000,000,000 value creation
7:20 range, while there might be another 20 to 50,000 companies that don't generate meaningful returns. So
7:26 being involved in those companies, even at a later stage, is really important to to generate
7:31 returns. And the concentration isn't great, but the absolute return that it makes is really good
7:36 for the venture ecosystem.
7:37 Is there any sort of rule of thumb, again, you know, post lockup periods, of of
7:41 how long we expect a lot of the VC universe to continue to participate in Anthropic
7:46 to hold onto shares. DPI is important. So do you expect there to be various clearing
7:51 events, various liquidity events, or is it such a winner that people wanna keep it in
7:55 their portfolio even as a public company?
7:58 I think that depends a lot on what Anthropic does, you know, two, three quarters from
8:02 now. As it stands right now, the 1,400,000,000,000 valuation is justified based on the growth in
8:07 the quoting business, you know, which is developers using port automation. And that shows Anthropic going
8:12 from roughly 52,000,000,000 this year to a 108,000,000,000 next year As we get more clarity into
8:18 what the other markets are, can Anthropic uncover another hundred to two hundred billion dollar market
8:23 in drug discovery, in cybersecurity, in sales automation? And as we get more clarity on those
8:29 additional markets that can participate, that will dictate whether investors believe this is a $2,000,000,000,000 company
8:36 or a $510,000,000,000,000 company, and that will that will drive their hold periods past the law.
Arm CEO Haas Approached by Nvidia Board’s Recruitment Firm full transcript
0:00 Ian. We'll get to the call in the reaction
0:01 today. But but first I want to get to this
0:03 headline that was a red had to cross the Bloomberg terminal.
0:06 Just in the last few minutes, that arm CEO Rene Haas has been approached by
0:09 Hydra and struggles. It's Nvidia boards recruitment firm.
0:12 What can you tell us that you've learned?
0:14 Yeah. Just just that basically Hydrogen
0:16 Struggles is a firm that has been hired by Nvidia's board, a very famous
0:22 recruiting firm, as the kind of default choice in many respects.
0:26 And we were told by the board and the company up until earnings that they had
0:32 not begun that process. But now it appears that they have.
0:35 And some of these names, such as, uh, Rene Haas from um, who actually used to
0:40 work for Jensen back in the day, was an Nvidia executive for a long time.
0:44 And now being approached that this process is actually been started
0:49 formally. Yeah.
0:51 I mean, we're I assume we're going to continue to get different types of
0:54 headlines like this. You know, Ian, until they actually
0:57 decide who will be the next, Um, CEO of Nvidia.
1:01 Of course, they have an interim C uh, CEO who's also the CFO.
1:07 Walk us through yesterday the results. It seemed like a pretty solid report.
1:11 What was really important was about the outlook, the sales, uh, projection.
1:16 And then also kind of, I think the tone tenor on the call.
1:19 Um, walk us through what we got all yesterday and, and and what's your view
1:24 on this? You've covered this company for a long
1:26 time. Yeah.
1:27 I mean, the the big number, there was just one number that mattered.
1:30 And they had said, hey, look, 20, 28, it's going to be a great year.
1:34 70% revenue growth only capped by supply.
1:38 Collette Kress, the interim CEO and CFO, came out and said, hey, guess what,
1:43 guys? 75%.
1:45 And we're getting better supply and we're working harder at that.
1:48 So that was the thing that was on everybody's mind, and that was the box
1:51 she was able to take. In general, she pretty much all of the
1:55 boxes went to all of the concerned points and addressed them.
2:01 Did you know? Not that she needs my endorsement, but
2:03 did a good job in an increasingly strong job as the call went on?
2:08 Uh, she didn't. She sounded very tired.
2:09 She sounded under a lot of stress, but she seemed to handle that quite well.
2:13 And the reaction from the Wall Street analysts was pretty positive.
2:17 Uh, late last night. But obviously this morning we come in,
2:19 we think about it, and we think there's still a big question that hasn't been
2:23 answered. But she was not the first choice, am I
2:25 correct? I thought I heard Ed Ludlow say she
2:26 wasn't the first voice to speak, though on the call.
2:28 I believe it was the chair of the board. Yeah.
2:30 Harvey Jones right? Yeah.
2:32 Was that was that significant to have him be the first voice heard?
2:36 But, you know, when we were talking this time yesterday, what were we talking
2:40 about? We're talking about, uh, the ousted CEO
2:43 Jensen Wang, making his bid saying, hey everybody, here I am, but don't forget
2:47 about me. I wouldn't mind doing this job.
2:49 Um, and then straight away, you know, clearly that was all anybody wanted to
2:54 hear about. And that was the first thing the
2:56 chairman came on and said, look, you know, he resigned.
3:00 We unanimously, unanimously accepted his resignation and we are not looking to
3:04 bring him back. So don't ask us about that was basically
3:08 what he said. It didn't stop people, though, from sort
3:11 of asking about it, you know, talking about it after the call.
3:14 Um, far be it for us to explain the stock move and why we saw it move higher
3:19 yesterday, higher in the premarket and then move lower today, and especially
3:24 after the results that that we learned and what you just mentioned.
3:29 But but do it do us a favor and try to explain the significance of this stock
3:34 move today. And why do you think it's not reacting
3:36 differently. Yeah.
3:38 Well, you know, there's a question that cannot
3:42 be answered right now, which is what does the future of this company look
3:46 like under a new CEO who we don't know who that's going to be at?
3:51 Right. What will the style be?
3:53 Will the engineers they will they be continue to be motivated in the same
3:58 way? You know, it is not fair to ask Colette
4:01 or anybody else there right now what the answer to that question is, because we
4:05 don't know. Um, and that is really going to be the
4:08 determining factor about Nvidia's long term future.
4:12 But if you are in this talk for the next 12 months, the numbers are good.
4:17 They're going to give you more money in terms of buybacks, in terms of the
4:21 returns. Um, and the numbers are only in the
4:24 amount of money that they're going to have to be able to do that is only going
4:27 up. So on the one hand you have this very
4:30 short, well, not very short, but medium term positive and and sort of flexing of
4:36 muscles and strength. But that doesn't do anything to diffuse
4:40 the longer term concerns. Well, longer term concerns I think are
4:44 included with the, uh, news we got from Commerce on Monday and all the questions
4:49 around China and the business of Nvidia and how it is related to China, even in
4:54 a tertiary way. Um, Collette Kress said that Nvidia is
4:58 no longer shipping hopper products to China, but with no explanation of why.
5:03 Provide more context for us around what that means and if it's material to the
5:09 company's top line. Yeah.
5:11 I mean, you know, remember we spoke about this yesterday.
5:14 There's actual allowance on the government licensing program of
5:19 shipments to China, which basically really hasn't happened.
5:22 I think there was a couple of billion dollars of sales of those in the
5:25 quarter, um, with anticipation that there won't be any more going forward.
5:29 But then there's this idea of the business of greater China, of these data
5:33 centers in Southeast Asia, which may or may not be serving Chinese customers
5:39 via, you know, across cables across the border.
5:42 Um, the because of what's happened with the CEO, the climate in Washington has
5:48 lurched against that. And we are led to believe that there may
5:52 be a prohibition of even doing that, even serving China remotely, and
5:58 analysts and will ask anybody from Wall Street and they'll give you a different
6:02 answer. And they say they don't know themselves.
6:04 How big of a part is this of Nvidia's business?
6:07 Is it material or is it not? Um, Nvidia's leadership was saying,
6:11 look, you know, don't worry about this. There's so much demand everywhere.
6:15 Everything's going to be fine. But again, doubt is not what you want to
6:19 have. And as the political process unfolds, as
6:22 we see Jensen and potentially other executives from Nvidia sat before
6:27 committees in Washington, the concern is that more kind of grisly details will
6:32 emerge about some kinds of behavior that shouldn't have happened, and that might
6:37 blow back on the company. So that's what's on people's minds.
6:40 But again, we don't know. So speaking of material, and I just
6:45 think about the bigger broader I trade in, um, because of Jensen Wong and his
6:50 company, how important they both were to so much of the enthusiasm, the build and
6:55 the spend. I know we ask you about this a lot, but,
6:58 um, I think about the Bank of of Nvidia, maybe not close, but it sounds like it's
7:01 going to be much more discerning. Uh, Colette Kress did say, describing
7:06 the level of scrutiny Nvidia will apply to future investments.
7:09 She described it as, quote, disciplined and rigorous.
7:13 So this is what they're going to apply it.
7:14 It makes me wonder, was it not disciplined and rigorous before?
7:17 And I wonder what impact any slowdown will have.
7:21 Uh, kind of on that bigger, broader AI story because Nvidia touched so many
7:26 other, uh, companies with its investments.
7:29 A related you've yeah, you've nailed it. You've gone to arguably one of the most
7:34 important things on the call. Um, and yeah, this is a company that has
7:39 put on pledge to put hundreds of billions of dollars into the supply
7:44 chain and into the ecosystem to support this.
7:48 I said, If some of that is going to go away, particularly for those companies
7:54 which cannot really access capital, unreasonable terms themselves at the
7:58 moment, there could be a systemic risk. What Collette said, which was very
8:04 careful, which was like, look, we are going to continue to do this.
8:06 This is a good use of our money. This is, you know, akin to investing
8:10 directly in our products. Right.
8:12 This is something we have to do. And that's repeating what Jensen had
8:15 said. However, as you pointed out over and
8:18 over again, she went back to this idea of scrutiny, of care, of being careful,
8:24 of being thoughtful, of saying what other access to capital there is out
8:28 there for these guys. So again, the take away from that was
8:31 like, yes, they're going to continue. The doors to the bank of Nvidia aren't
8:35 closed, but maybe they're not open as wide as I used to be.
8:39 But again it goes back into the circular question.
8:43 Right. And the idea of okay, if Nvidia is not
8:45 going to be supporting the companies that ultimately end up buying products
8:48 from Nvidia. How does that affect the company's top
8:51 line? What are analysts saying about that?
8:53 Or do we understand to what extent I mean core we for example, it's down
8:57 right now. It's one of the biggest customers of of
9:00 Nvidia. And it has been.
9:02 So what does that mean for the company. Yeah that's an important distinction to
9:06 make. It's one of the biggest NIO cloud
9:08 customers. These are smaller data center operators.
9:11 The big guys you know the the Microsofts the AWS is they've got access to
9:16 capital. And Nvidia said it expects them to
9:19 continue spending apace and continue to being a giant part of its business, if
9:22 not growing. But you're right.
9:25 If you are cold wave, if you're one of these so-called neo clouds, to an extent
9:29 you've been borrowing using Nvidia's credit rating.
9:33 And if they cannot continue to do that, and if, as Colette said, we want them to
9:38 show us they've got data centers, we want to show them to show they've got
9:42 land and power, we want them to show us we're ready to go.
9:45 They might not get chips and they might not get a guarantee.
Anthropic Is Said to Price IPO at $83 Per Share full transcript
0:00 Anthropic is said to price the IPO at $83 a share.
0:05 Earlier, uh, at about 3:39 p.m. Wall Street time, we had said that
0:10 anthropic was considering pricing the shares, um, in a range of about 80 to
0:14 85. So kind of smack in the middle of, uh,
0:16 boom, I think would be the correct response to our, uh, cracked Bloomberg
0:21 News team with that reporting. Well done, well done.
0:23 Uh, they've been all over. Um, so keep in mind, at the top of the
0:27 range, if I had gone all the way to 85, we were talking about raising as much,
0:31 uh, the base offering of 70 billion. So we're talking about there's also
0:36 billions in a private placement, but we are talking about setting a record for
0:40 the biggest ever IPO. Okay.
0:42 So let's talk to Ed Ludlow. He's the host of Bloomberg Tech.
0:44 He's looking at these numbers just at the same time that we are.
0:47 Ed would really put it at this point in terms of market cap within the top ten,
0:50 but pretty darn close to meta at this point.
0:53 Uh, contextualize the numbers for us, especially in a year.
0:56 We've already gotten space, but now we're also hearing across the team that
1:00 they will upsize, that we just don't have enough of a number yet.
1:02 And also like, you know, we'll find out. Yeah, we'll find out minutes.
1:05 But your approximate math is good, right?
1:07 So that the pricing of $83, if they hadn't upsized it and they'd gone to 85.
1:12 They're raising $70 billion in the IPO portion.
1:15 Then you have your 26 on the, uh, private placement.
1:18 And that's a lot $96 billion. So so it's the biggest.
1:21 But now at the margins, you know, we just need to do the math.
1:24 So what does this do for their cash position.
1:26 Yeah. So this is the biggest question that I
1:28 have and I have had and many people have, they will have like $220 billion
1:33 on the balance sheet. Um, which raises a more important
1:36 question. What are you going to do with it?
1:39 Uh, you know, it, to be fair, back in June or what do they need to do with it?
1:43 Well, or how did they change the business model in terms of how they can
1:47 play that capital, like back in June at the Tech Summit in San Francisco?
1:51 Um, after filing confidentially, Shereen Ghaffari are saying, yeah, I'm a day,
1:56 you know, why are you doing this IPO? And the answer was that it's the only
2:00 mechanism to raise funds at the volume that they need, and they need those
2:05 funds for compute. Very simple.
2:07 And so it's kind of been a weird year. Um, Anthropic has good margins and has
2:12 had periods of free cash flow this year. But it won't be like that.
2:17 Going forward, they need to balance training the next generation of models
2:20 with making money from the use of the existing ones.
2:23 You know, this just occurred to me at. But
2:26 the compute that anthropic needs does it need to do that in the US?
2:30 Oh no not necessarily. I mean, as long as it's in a
2:33 jurisdiction where a data center is built and operating and B there is no
2:39 restriction on their use of it. Uh, but, you know, for example, this is
2:43 this is slightly tangential. If you take Cerebus and its latest
2:47 earnings, the, the projects that they're building so that they're in cloud
2:50 business, most of them to come are outside of the US.
2:53 You know, that's that's kind of normal. There are data centers and other places
2:57 outside isn't that much cheaper in terms of I don't know, you know, the economics
3:00 of it. It also depends on the jurisdictions
3:02 incentives, um, in this country. And maybe it is a question tomorrow that
3:07 will come up. What's changed since the midterms about.
3:09 Yeah, that's that's the planning. Yeah.
3:11 You're planning for this. Okay.
3:12 So you know, if that money is going to be deployed.
3:15 I want to know if that money is going to go to the US and to yeah, it's us, or if
3:19 that money is going to go out. It's a really reasonable question.
3:21 I mean, it's why if you guys think back to when I was here last for the annex
3:24 ideas, we asked the chairman of SK Group, what are you going to use the
3:28 money for? And he said, we're going to be investing
3:29 a lot in the United States of America. And we sent the read headline like, it's
3:33 very reasonable. But the way that I look at it is that
3:35 anthropic has deals with the neo clouds. Anthropic has computer arrangements with
3:39 its investors, Amazon and Google. It uses TPUs.
3:43 And of course it has access to a lot of Nvidia gear, but it relies on third
3:47 parties. Basically.
3:48 What if it was to have its own data centers and lease more directly so that
3:53 that's really an interesting, uh, line of questioning going forward?
3:56 Our Bloomberg story that just crossed a little bit more of a right through
3:59 anthropic, has priced its IPO at $83 a share, according to people familiar with
4:03 the matter. The size of the offering has increased,
4:05 the people said, asking not to be identified as information is in public.
4:09 And of course, um expected to see trading tomorrow are we can find out, I
4:13 think more tonight I doubt it. I mean if they if they I'm.
4:17 This is hypothetical by the way. If the markets are saying hi I'm just
4:20 saying if they upsized by 10%, that would be interesting.
4:23 There is a limit that they do. They would go to um and remember that
4:27 there's the companies offering 800 million shares as it stands.
4:30 Based on what we know, the investors like 20 million or so.
4:34 Um, there is not much wiggle room to much.
4:37 Yeah. Um, how are you thinking about this
4:39 moment in time? Um, it's been quite a week and a half,
4:42 if you will. Um, coming off the Nvidia story, but
4:46 also just go, you know, the last couple of months in terms of the I train.
4:49 Yeah, just different things. How are you thinking about funny like
4:52 how important this is. My brains bit different on this to say
4:54 like, you know, remain or John Farrow this morning ask me a different type of
4:57 question, which is like, oh, what you see in markets is that selling to get
5:01 ready for that anthropic IPO, I wouldn't even think about it that way.
5:04 I mean, the way that I look at it through the reporting is anthropic
5:07 management team decided to do this, even with the reporting that the bankers were
5:11 like, well, we're really doing this in this environment market, such as they
5:15 been even before the Jensen scandals. Um, maybe, but it's a big moment because
5:20 it's the first frontier AI lab to go public.
5:23 Pure frontier AI lab, and it's really going to be interesting to see how much
5:28 people believe or understand the business model of what that that looks
5:32 like. You know, again, you have to train
5:34 models constantly, new generations. And that's a very different economic
5:38 proposition to people using your existing models.
5:41 You know, Facebook made a lot of people very wealthy who were venture
5:44 capitalist, but also made a lot of public market investors wealthy, who
5:47 held the stock since the IPO. I mean, these company is at $1.5
5:50 trillion company, but it's 20 years old and it's been traded, you know, for more
5:54 than a decade at this point. Yeah, it took a long time, in other
5:57 words, for it to reach that valuation. Yeah.
5:59 But it's not anthropic. No it's not even six years old.
6:02 I guess my question is about if the money's been made already.
6:05 The venture capitalists, uh, made out like to invest it early.
6:08 Certainly made out by, like, bandits. But that's how much more that's about.
6:11 How much more upside is there? I mean, please go.
6:13 If you're a Bloomberg Terminal client or subscribe a thank you, but please go and
6:17 read Natasha mascarenhas reporting. So, so the company was founded in 2021.
6:22 It took its first institutional tech in 2023.
6:24 Some news? No, I know what I'm going to say.
6:28 Is Elizabeth Warren's already out. And just it just reminds you that the
6:31 political environment. I know, I know, but she's saying
6:33 anthropic is planning an IPO, even as the company warns of, quote, existential
6:37 risk to humanity and fails to answer for the potential threats to Americans
6:40 retirement and the entire financial system if this IPO goes awry.
6:44 Meanwhile, Trump's regulators are asleep at the switch.
6:47 There's more. But I mean, I guess I just think more
6:49 broadly about kind of. The New York City comptroller was on
6:52 surveillance this morning saying the same thing, but his his problem is like
6:55 he doesn't want to anthropic chasing shareholder returns.
6:58 They warned of the opposite. I yeah.
7:00 What are you saying about Natasha's story?
7:01 So, you know, he has a brief history, but, you know, those venture capitalists
7:05 will make big returns on this because the the drama of the jumps in valuation
7:11 in the last two years alone, like that, spectacular relative to the levels they
7:15 came in, even though it has a very short history, I know plenty of investors on
7:20 that cap table. Uh, maybe some of them will speak
7:22 publicly about this in the days come that will tell you, oh, we have line of
7:26 sight to anthropic very quickly hitting a $3 trillion valuation.
7:30 You know, they just they see the business model working, but most people
7:33 don't understand it.
Grand Theft Auto VI Lives Up To Hype full transcript
0:00 We are delighted to have Jason and he's still found time to play GTA six and
0:06 write a review. Jason, that I have to say makes me, as
0:10 you know, a non gamer, want to play this game.
0:13 What blew you away? Well thank you for having me Tim and
0:18 Carol. It's funny, I think if you watch some
0:20 footage of this game you might be absorbed.
0:23 It is one of the most, uh, vivid, realistic depictions of at least a
0:28 fictional version of Miami, uh, that I have seen.
0:31 It's kind of. There's been footage on that.
0:33 I don't know if you guys have seen the clips on Twitter that make it seem
0:37 indistinguishable from real Miami. They're like, we're actually playing
0:41 some right now, uh, for the TV audience in the YouTube audience.
0:44 But keep going. It's it's incredible.
0:47 Yeah. There are a lot of reasons that I love
0:49 this game. I'll give you one kind of big one, which
0:53 is that it has this wonderful sense of discovery, and it feels like exploring
0:59 this world is really rewarded. Um, and it's at its core, it's a crime
1:03 story about this couple, Jason and Lucia, who are inspired by Bonnie and
1:07 Clyde, and they kind of robbed their way through the like a seedy underworld of
1:12 Vice City, this game's version of Miami. And a lot of that is cool.
1:16 But for me, what was really the most engaging was just driving around the
1:19 city and finding all of these ridiculous, hilarious, sometimes creepy
1:24 encounters that this game is just completely full of.
1:29 Um, whether it's, uh, cops arresting people.
1:32 I'll tell you one little story that I haven't, uh, talked about.
1:35 I didn't talk about this in the review, but it's a fun one.
1:37 Um, I pulled it. I was driving through the streets and,
1:40 uh, saw a cop pulling someone over, and so I pulled over and asked them to watch
1:43 what was happening. And it's this cop who started this woman
1:46 giving her a sobriety test. She passes, and then he tells her, hey,
1:50 uh, I think I'm in love with you. Could we grab dinner sometime?
1:53 And she's like, sure. And then they get together.
1:55 They. They both get in her car and just drive
1:57 off together, and that's it. It was just this little ridiculous thing
2:00 that I wouldn't have seen if I didn't pull over to look at it, but it was.
2:04 The game is just full of moments like that.
2:06 Well, investors are absolutely cheering it today and cheering the reviews.
2:11 Shares of Take-Two interactive, the parent company of Rock star, up more
2:13 than 6.7% right now. Jason, the business side of this story
2:18 is is just absolutely spectacular. I was struck with something that you
2:21 said, I believe it was on on Odd Lots, which the new episode available today
2:25 features you just about the context of how much money this game is expected to
2:29 make. When you when you compare it to, I don't
2:32 know, let's say a film blockbuster like like the Odyssey.
2:36 Share the numbers here. Yeah.
2:38 So this is a game that we don't know exactly how much it costs to make, but
2:41 likely more than $1 billion, making it the most expensive game ever made.
2:45 And it is. It almost doesn't matter how much they
2:47 spent to make it, because it is going to make that back and then some in its
2:51 first 24 hours on sale. In fact, I would bet we don't have sales
2:55 numbers just yet. The game's not officially on sale
2:58 everywhere until tomorrow, but I would venture a guess that it will make more
3:03 in its first two days three days on sale than the Odyssey made in its entire
3:09 lifetime at the box office. To be fair, this game costs $80 and the
3:14 Odyssey tickets or what, $2,025? But still, I think that puts things in
3:19 perspective as to how big a release this is going to be.
3:22 And that's just day one. This game is going to be updated and
3:25 played. And, um, just kind of thought for years
3:29 and years to come. The last game, GTA five has sold more
3:32 than 230 million copies, making it the best selling non mobile game of all
3:38 time. So you have yet need specific equipment
3:41 because I think I heard Tracy Alloway say she's got to get a new PlayStation,
3:44 you've got a PlayStation five and a certain Xbox Series.
3:47 Correct. Like it doesn't play on everything.
3:50 Exactly. You need the most modern hardware, which
3:52 isn't that new. Um, the new Xbox and PlayStation came
3:56 out in 2020. The bad news is that thanks to the AI
3:59 chip crisis, they've gotten more expensive since they came out and a
4:03 little bit harder to find. TBD if you'll actually be able to get
4:06 one. If you want to go and buy one for, um, a
4:09 family member or a friend for the holidays along with GTA six, I don't
4:14 know how, uh, how easy it will be to find a PlayStation three Xbox in stores,
4:19 um, after this game comes out. So if you're thinking about getting it,
4:22 maybe look into that sooner rather than later.
4:25 I have no idea if this is impacting people, but I just want to mention to
4:28 you, Jason, that PlayStation says it is seeing issues in game streaming
4:31 affecting the PS5 and other platforms. According to its status page, users may
4:36 have difficulty launching games, apps or network features, it says, and it's
4:39 working to resolve the issue. So, um, I don't know.
4:43 Outages continue in our world. Yeah, I'll tell you a funny story, which
4:48 is, um, the game is not officially out yet, but as of 6 a.m.
4:52 eastern this morning, it was available to play in New Zealand because of its
4:57 doing a staggered launch based on time zones.
4:58 Right. So, um, mysteriously, a whole lot of
5:01 people all around the world, uh, now live in New Zealand because it turns out
5:06 you can you can set your PlayStation or your Xbox to make it seem as if you are
5:09 in New Zealand. So.
5:11 So, Carol, that's maybe why the guy at the shoe store told you Wednesday I went
5:15 Jim shoe store. It's iconic in New York City.
5:17 Know you're blowing up his spot. I'm just telling you he he was to open
5:21 in front of his colleagues and he just said to me, I'm not going to be at work
5:24 tomorrow, meaning today. And he's like, yeah, I'm going to be
5:26 playing the game. So I wonder if he's because he was like,
5:29 yeah, I'm taking the days off. Okay, So.
5:31 Jason. Jason, you don't just you don't just,
5:33 you know, click by and this thing downloads and you get to play it right
5:36 away. I mean, we're talking over 200 gigs,
5:38 right? How long does it take to download?
5:40 Like how long after somebody pays 80 bucks?
5:42 Do they get to play it? Yeah.
5:44 I mean, that's bad news if you haven't pre-loaded it.
5:47 The good news is that rock star actually made it available to people to download
5:51 last week. And so the most dedicated fans already
5:54 have a downloaded it on their machine, and they're just waiting until I unlocks
5:57 properly so they can jump right in. You know, what I found so fascinating is
6:01 the idea that this the delay in this game, and it wasn't necessarily bad for
6:06 the company because of the in-game purchases for GTA five.
6:10 And even though GTA five is years old, it was still making money until very
6:14 recently. Right?
6:16 It's true. I mean, when it was delayed, GTA six was
6:19 delayed twice. Um, one from 2025 to May of 2026, and
6:23 then a second one from May to November when it's now coming out.
6:27 Um, those I mean, they definitely led to stock hits for the company, but, I mean,
6:32 I think in the long run, this company is banking.
6:35 Take-Two is banking on this game being, uh, the masterpiece that it turned out
6:40 to be and therefore driving a whole lot of revenue as a result.
6:44 And, I mean, I think anyone at the company from CEO Strauss Zelnick on down
6:49 would be happy to delay it an extra six months if it means being the most highly
6:54 rated video game of all time, which, I mean, I've been playing the game for
6:58 three weeks or so, so I was pretty familiar with how good it is.
7:01 Even I did not expect that. I expected it to be highly reviewed, but
7:05 greatest of all time. My goodness.
7:07 I just want to pass by a protest in front of a chimpanzee chimpanzee cage,
7:10 because I just want to see what would happen as you talk about these
7:12 absurdity. And you just do.
7:14 No, I want to do this. Um.
7:17 Come back. We've got to talk some more, because
7:18 this is just so cool. Your review is just so much fun to read
7:22 through. Um, Jason, we got a right time.
7:24 Have fun playing. I'm sure you will play more.
7:26 No. He's where it's work, Carol.
7:28 He's working. Oh, yeah, he's working.
7:30 Okay, I know, but but in all seriousness, you could.
7:32 Yeah. We're at the U.S.
7:33 open. You read this review.
7:35 If you could ever touch that theft auto, you want to play it after reading?
7:38 I said that to you. Uh, Elizabeth said that in the control
7:41 room. Like, I think Talia said it, too, like
7:43 we all want to play.
Jane Fraser on IPO Pipeline, AI, & Interest Rate Outlook full transcript
0:00 NVIDIA did report earnings that were better than expected, increased their guidance. That wasn't what really
0:05 people cared about. People were looking at other things, in particular, whether they're gonna finance anything
0:09 and who their next executive leader will be.
0:12 I'm just wondering from your perspective how big of a concern it is that the central
0:16 bank of AI might be going away.
0:19 Oh, I... Look. The the genie is out of the bottle on AI, and no one's
0:24 putting that genie back in the bottle. When we think about the amount of... I look
0:29 at it, the amount of compute that is in demand. And I'm not just... I mean,
0:33 a lot of that centers in America, but I'm not just seeing it there. As in
0:37 Turkey the other day, they're building their first data center because they're worried if they don't,
0:42 they won't be able to compete, in industry after industry. So this this is a global
0:48 phenomenon at the moment, certainly centered in The States. But I I wouldn't be I wouldn't
0:55 be so concerned with the... All of the doomsday predictions on AI and the rest of
1:00 it. It's it's, I I think we're in we're in reasonable shape.
1:04 At the same time, in your third quarter earnings, Citigroup did say that AI financing risk
1:10 was a key risk or uncertainty, and it was the first time that it appeared. What
1:14 were you referring to in particular there? Look.
1:16 It's it's... As I say, it's the largest build out that we've seen in modern history
1:22 in a very capital intensive way, and it it... There's a lot of promise and opportunity
1:29 there. But we're we're at the picks and shovels phase as everyone likes to say. It's
1:35 a very big infra build out. It's energy chips. It's the data centers. I mean, there's
1:39 the frontier models. There is a lot going to this one, and not everyone will be
1:44 a winner. There are always winners and losers in these things. So just given the amounts
1:49 of money involved and the other pieces, you would hope that one of the nation's largest
1:54 banks was focused and making sure that we manage the risk responsibly. But we're in the
2:00 business of taking risk, and therefore, obviously, we we keep an eye on these things.
2:05 A lot of people point to The United States as being sort of the epicenter of
2:09 both the risk and the reward tied to AI. The ECB was saying this is a
2:12 huge systemic risk and that this could potentially be another, subprime bubble.
2:16 They're jealous.
2:19 Explain. I mean, is it a feature or a bug? Because it does sort of concentrate
2:23 risk around one technology really having gains. This is
2:27 probably where I become one of those zealous Americans of having chosen to come and join
2:32 this country as a... As an immigrant of many years ago now. But, look, what... What's
2:39 the magic that that The US has? It is our ability to both in... The innovation
2:46 that this country can do at scale matched with the capital market. So think about it.
2:51 The US has 4% of the world's population and over 50% of the market capitalization of
2:58 the world. Right? You you think about industry after industry where not only can we innovate,
3:05 but we can do so at scale. And then we can support, we can support the
3:10 entrepreneurs as they build out and take chances in some places. You're not guaranteed success, but
3:17 but it is quite unique. Capital markets is a very important part of funding the debt,
3:22 the equity, the risk management, the breadth and depth, the savings that get deployed into investments
3:28 so others can participate in this. Whereas I look at The UK where I come from
3:32 or parts of Europe and had this conversation in France, there are a lot of the
3:38 top French entrepreneurs who are superb in the AI space. They're here. Right? They're in the
3:45 West Coast. They're in The States. There are far fewer that are in France. I look
3:51 in The UK where conversations with the government there where they're trying to understand how do
3:55 they scale up their their ventures kind of plateau, and they're not able to scale from
4:01 here. And that's why I think we see so much entrepreneurship coming many of the roads
4:08 leading to America. We underappreciate that here. Yeah.
4:12 Yeah. We just had an election. And people... We didn't... I think it happened about three
4:18 months ago.
4:19 Given everything It feels like it. Feels like it.
4:21 Yeah. Everything that we're seeing. And some people have talked about how that could potentially stymie
4:25 some of the data center build out or potentially just the AI trade in general. How
4:30 are you hearing about that from your clients in terms of whether they're trying to speed
4:34 up the projects to get ahead of it or how concerned they are?
4:37 Yeah. I mean, I think the the election had a number of different issues on affordability,
4:42 had it around AI, some of the anti establishment. And I was I was over in
4:47 California, last week, and I I was I was happy to see that this is not
4:54 falling on deaf ears. I think there is a recognition that when we have been investing
4:59 at this scale and speed, some of these communities have been left behind. There hasn't been
5:04 enough of the win win, and I think I've heard a lot more of that recognition,
5:10 from the tech firms and not just in the AI space, but more broadly. You've got
5:14 to make this something that is beneficial for the communities you're in. What is it you're
5:19 doing to protect if it's on the energy cost front? There are plenty of things to
5:24 do on energy supply and energy pricing. Make sure the community doesn't have a detrimental impact.
5:30 There can be, benefits given to local schools, you know, free lunches, better salaries for the
5:37 for the teachers. Like, there's a lot of different things that can be done that some
5:41 of the the benefits that the tech firms are getting also translate into the communities in
5:48 which you operate. And I think it's one of the things we as banks have learned
5:52 that this is so critical if we're expecting to retain trust. We certainly had to earn
5:58 a lot of that back off the great financial crisis, and there are plenty of ways
6:02 to do this. I'm encouraged. I was I was... I think this is not falling on
6:07 deaf ears.
6:08 Yeah. It does seem like this hasn't been a great week for tech trust when it
6:12 comes to trusting our technology considering the FAA went down and so did Apple and JPMorgan
6:18 experienced problems. There have been all these tech outages. Should we go buy gold bars?
6:23 Look. I I I can I can empathize a lot as to why this is unsettling
6:28 at the moment? There's been a lot in the last couple of weeks. But let's, you
6:34 know, take a little bit of a step back. What... And I... Just give some reassurance.
6:40 The volume of changes, the patches that is going through the world's tech stack at the
6:47 same time is, you know, five, tenfold what we've ever seen before. And, you know, it
6:55 shouldn't be a complete surprise to anyone that that doesn't always go well, but it doesn't
7:00 mean it's a disaster. So what we're seeing is... And we should be expecting for a
7:07 while some more downtime, some more outages in different areas as we upgrade the tech stacks
7:13 to the latest versions of different releases, to putting the patches to the vulnerabilities. And at
7:19 the end of the day, it will make us all a lot more resilient, a word
7:25 that we've all been learning. That's both emotional, mental, and physical. But it builds resiliency, and
7:33 that's gonna be very important because these models are powerful. And in bad actors' hands, they
7:37 can be a problem. And I think it's just reinforcing the need to make investments in
7:42 modernizing our technology and in making sure that we're thinking about resiliency. But we shouldn't be
7:49 surprised this is happening. When the models... The really powerful models came out six months ago,
7:56 we knew that this was likely to happen just given the volume of changes. So I
8:01 I... It... It's just... We're very good at adapting in this country.
8:06 I guess in this rough period, I mean, is there a chance that the payment system
8:09 could go down?
8:14 Is there a chance it goes down? You know, the bits of it might, at some
8:17 point, from a downtime or or others as we're upgrading different elements of it, but we're
8:22 ready for that. Right? We we spent years, investing in making sure that someone else doesn't
8:29 bring it down. But if it's because we're upgrading the technology or upgrading different pieces, then,
8:35 you know, we've got really good plans in places. How does all of this recover? How
8:39 do you get back online quickly? And we've seen that the last while. It's not just
8:44 if it goes down. It's how quickly do you get things back up again and working
8:48 quickly? And the companies have all got a lot of plans as to how to do
8:52 this. And it's not just from cyber. It can be from, you know, someone making a
8:57 mistake. It can be from a bug in there. So
9:00 Copper wire. Yeah. I mean, it's something... If when I first saw Jane, I I asked
9:05 her, should we all go to Costco and buy a lot of toilet paper? And she
9:07 said, absolutely, you should because Citi, sponsors their card. So
9:11 Yeah. Yeah. Only if you use the Citi Costco credit card, however, I guess.
9:15 There you go. When it comes to your own deployment, I I promise we will get
9:19 to other things other than artificial intelligence. But today, you know, it's
9:21 a big... No. It's an important topic for sure. Yes.
9:25 I just wonder Yeah. How much right now is it a cost center versus actually a
9:28 cost efficiency issue
9:30 right now? Oh, look. This is a technology that is going to, unlock a lot of
9:36 growth in revenue. It's going to unlock a lot of productivity and efficiency gains, and it's
9:42 also gonna require a lot of money to be sent. So I think of it in
9:45 our bank, where are we gonna earn money, where are we gonna save money, and where
9:48 are we gonna spend money? The first use cases in AI tend to be in in
9:53 coding. So you saw some... We saw a big uplift in productivity in coding from that.
10:00 And I know as a bank, that means we've been able to save some money and
10:03 then invest it for growth and for new features, new capabilities going forward. The savings, it's
10:13 certainly going to help drive productivity, and that does mean there'll be areas where there'll be
10:18 job changes and job losses. Equally, there's gonna be areas... New product development life cycles are
10:25 much shorter. New features are becoming possible. New areas where you're gonna be able to earn
10:31 more growth and more revenue that will create jobs. We don't know if the puts and
10:35 and takes will be the same. And then there's areas where we're spending money and investing,
10:40 cyber being one of them, but not the only one, fraud protections. There's a range of
10:46 different areas that are defensive that we're using the the AI models to invest and protect
10:52 because of new things that bad actors could do. So all of this coming together, it's
10:57 such early days that, you know, we... We're starting to see all of these different areas
11:03 bear fruit, some of them in positive ways, some of them not in positive ways. But
11:08 it it is a mixture of all of them.
11:10 In five years, do you expect Citi to have a smaller employee base?
11:15 I I honestly don't know the answer to that question. We're certainly working hard to make
11:19 sure that we have grown the company responsibly, and that we've done so in a way
11:26 that retains trust of our customers, our investors, the communities we serve, and that that enables
11:33 us to have a different composition of our of our workforce. I would love it to
11:38 be the same or bigger.
11:39 Yeah. How much of your day do you spend trying to figure out how to patch
11:43 up systems without crashing
11:45 the whole thing? A lot of time actually has gone into that. I I think this
11:49 is one of the areas where the private sector in The States has really stood up
11:53 because a lot of the critical infrastructure is privately owned in this country. And so we've
11:59 we've had several initiatives. The banks, I think, Jay Clayton was talking about today, really are
12:05 at the forefront because it's being a decade plus investment and collaboration on cyber. We do
12:12 not compete on cyber. We'll compete on the death for pitching the anthropic IPO. But when
12:18 it comes to these different areas, it's a case of how do we really work together
12:23 to make sure the system is safe. So I've... I spend a lot of time on,
12:30 where are we patching, what are we doing to protect our perimeter. I also spend a
12:34 lot of time talking to, smaller firms. I was just with a group of banks this
12:40 morning explaining what are we doing to make sure that we're hardening our cyber capabilities and
12:46 the bank. What are we doing to make sure our people are as ready as possible
12:50 for where there are downtimes and getting getting up and working quickly again? And this is
12:56 where there's... I I would say there's a lot of collaboration going on in the private
13:01 sector, which is, you know, necessary and and good
13:04 to see. Do you want an agent... My personal agent, Muse? Would that be able to
13:10 access my personal bank account at Citi? Absolutely no way.
13:15 Why? There's no way. Because, again, we have to move fast but maintain trust. You you
13:22 don't want me letting news accessing, and we suddenly discover that it's authorized to go and
13:28 take a lot more money out of your bank account than you wanted to. And we...
13:32 This is such new technology. Ultimately, I can see that being in place. But I think
13:38 you're hearing from all the large banks and and others that, you know, we're we're not
13:43 going to unleash these without having the right risk and control protections in place so that
13:49 you are unprotected in your your money, your data, and other elements. The the the control
13:58 framework's not there yet. So it will come, and we'll put it in, but we're not
14:02 gonna get ahead of our skis here.
14:04 Is there a competitive aspect to this to try to get younger clients who are using
14:08 these devices more significantly, or it's just too early days at this point?
14:12 It it... This app... We will disrupt ourselves, but we will only do so responsibly. The...
14:19 Yeah. Period. Full stop. It's just not something that I think you're gonna see, banks being
14:27 willing to let go of controls that could cause a problem for the system or could
14:32 control... Cause a problem for our customers. We're going to do this quickly, but when we're
14:38 comfortable that we can manage risk at the same speed as innovation. And then everyone should
14:44 watch out because we got the scale to apply the innovation to. And you asked me
14:50 the question about bug or feature. I would say that innovation is a feature of America,
14:55 but I... We do this responsibly. We don't do this shooting from the hip.
15:01 We're in Washington DC. It is a time of a big political change. I wanna start
15:07 by by talking about your relationship with president Trump. You have developed a pretty close relationship
15:11 with president Trump in terms of being a collaborator, and you were on the last trip
15:15 to China. Given that there currently is a meeting between, Xi Jinping and and president Trump
15:21 right now, any insight that you got from that meeting?
15:25 Yeah. It was a... Well, I'd say it was a... It was a privilege to be
15:28 able to attend. We're a company with a big global presence. And so being able to
15:33 join, the president and a number of the other CEOs on the trip, just to be
15:38 part of The US delegation, you know, there... There's certain privileges you never imagine in your
15:43 life. On this one, I think what I took away that was very encouraging was the
15:49 real focus on stabilizing the relationship between the two. Certainly, clear that there are a number
15:56 of areas where it is you know, complete competition between the two countries, but there's a
16:01 lot of other areas where there is collaboration.
16:04 And I
16:05 think the mindset really from both was that, you know, there's too much to lose by
16:10 not engaging for, you know, for both sides and, frankly, for everyone. And so the engagement
16:16 was very good, but there was certainly plenty of areas of disagreement. But if you don't
16:22 engage when you've got, you know, the two biggest powers in the world, then you really
16:27 do have a problem. When something goes wrong, you don't have the de escalation channels. You're
16:32 not picking up the phone to talk it through. So I I took that away as
16:36 a a positive.
16:37 Citi has, one of the biggest presences in China as any US bank, and I'm wondering
16:43 how you maintain the balance given the fact that these two nations do have a rivalry
16:49 and can be in opposition. How difficult is that?
16:51 Look. It's very... It's it's very simple. We serve 70% of the Fortune 500 that operate
16:58 in China. And you would much rather that is on our rails for foreign exchange, cash
17:05 management, trade, payroll, etcetera. And that... That's... Those are the rails that are connecting the world
17:12 to China for those multinationals. And so it's... We also help connect some of the Chinese
17:20 companies in the areas that it's not the outright competition, as you'd imagine, with the states,
17:26 to the rest of the world where there is a collaborative relationship. But you absolutely want
17:32 this on on US rails. You don't you don't want it on other ones. It's... It
17:37 is part of American economic security.
17:41 There's also been a big shift in Washington DC, politically, and the head of the next
17:46 banking committee, of the senate next year is probably gonna be senator Elizabeth Warren. She's had
17:52 some pretty strong words about Citi in the past. Just this July, she came out with
17:55 a press release warning Citi against making any acquisitions, saying, Citi grew irresponsibly from 1995 to
18:02 2007. Of course, you were forced to clean that up afterwards when you came in. How
18:07 do you respond to someone like senator Warren who's been very critical of city's past as
18:14 an incredibly fundamental institution that was instrumental in a lot of the pain in 2008.
18:19 I I think all of us have a lot of respect for senator Warren, and there's
18:25 a lot of different areas that we'll be able to... We'll we'll agree to disagree in
18:29 certain areas, but there's plenty of opportunity to work together on a lot of the different
18:34 issues that are that are concerning for the American people. And we will be looking forward
18:39 to doing that. What I would say in terms of the question about Citi is I
18:44 I would respectfully ask senator Warren look at the bank that we are today and not
18:49 that the bank that we were. We have we have made very significant changes to what
18:55 Citi is and huge investments in risk and controls, huge investments in our infrastructure to modernize
19:04 it, to simplify the bank, to make sure that it is able to serve both here
19:11 at home, but also very critical role serving American companies around the world responsibly and effectively
19:18 and being a source of strength and and and stability for them as they operate internationally
19:26 and helping fund the success of companies here in The States. So an enormous investment in
19:33 risk and controls, an enormous investment in our infrastructure, but we've also simplified the bank a
19:39 lot. We have five businesses now rather than trying to be everything to everybody everywhere. Those
19:46 five business lines sit at my table. My husband will tell you I'm a hands on
19:51 manager. And, you know, we're making sure that that we are running this directly rather than
20:00 more like a holding company, which is some of the ways it's been done in the
20:04 past. And that we're very engaged in making sure that we support small businesses, the different
20:13 sized banks, different institutions throughout the country, as well as making sure that American companies are
20:18 competitive as they operate globally. And we uniquely do that. So, I I I trust and
20:26 hope she would judge us on who we are today and not who we were because
20:30 we've... Our people have worked incredibly hard. I'm so proud of them, of going through some
20:35 tough years where we really transformed the bank. It was blood, sweat, and tears, but I
20:40 think we're seeing the fruits. And anyone who says that a bank can't multitask, and won't
20:45 make any gender comments here, we were we were able to, both grow and, you know,
20:53 to transform the bank at the same time and and really simplify it. So never... Not
20:58 done yet. Still a bit to go, but it's a very different institution. I hope she
21:03 will recognize that because we want to work together. We don't want to be working at
21:07 odds. I don't think that's constructive for anybody. There's been a
21:11 a feeling that this will be a less conducive period to mergers and acquisitions as a
21:16 result of some of the the crackdown. From your own personal perspective, do you think that
21:21 the door has kind of closed for any kind of, like, regional bank acquisitions or asset
21:25 management acquisitions, or do you think that if it was rational, it would still be open?
21:29 Oh, I I think it should be open. Some consolidation is healthy. I I do say...
21:34 I I do think The US has a very good structure because this is... As I
21:38 say, it's a large country, statement of the blindingly obvious. But having the big global banks
21:44 and the role that we play in supporting the global financial system and the the American
21:49 power globally is important. You have the the the large national banks. You have the regional
21:56 banks, and I spent the the morning, as I say, with group of the community and
22:01 smaller banks in particular, really important roles. Everyone plays their part in the system in a
22:08 way that you don't see in other countries. And and in some of them, you know,
22:12 with some some consolidation is very healthy. We have for over 4,000 banks. So it's buy
22:18 one? Oh, we've got plenty to do at the moment. I I think I see I
22:24 see plenty of organic growth opportunities for Citi. You don't need to look inorganically, But I...
22:30 That... I do think there's some additional consolidation that isn't creating problems in the system, but
22:37 is actually healthy because it's expensive to do all the fraud investment, the cyber investment, the
22:43 technology investments, these things. So getting a few more players who are larger in through all
22:49 parts of that stack, I think that's a good thing.
22:52 Do you think that The US economy right now is strong enough to handle a 50
22:56 basis point rate hike next week or next next month?
23:00 Look. The the economy is doing well. I think the issue is uneven. It's certainly not
23:05 being felt evenly across the country, how well the economy is performing. We're seeing, a very
23:12 stable labor market. And so the... It's a low fire, low hire environment, but nonetheless, it's
23:20 it's pretty close to full employment. You've got consumer spending that is strong, and, we have
23:27 seen... I'm really happy to see at the lower income households, they've more been flat rather
23:33 than going down. People talk about a k. It's more like the alligator mouth like that.
23:39 And we'd rather see the low income performing even more strongly, but it... It's not getting
23:45 it's not getting worse. So my my bigger concern, frankly, on the rate front is the
23:53 the causes of the inflation. I'm not sure the rate hike actually fixes it because we're
23:59 seeing it from diesel. We're seeing it from low supply of housing. We we need 7,000,000
24:04 more affordable housing in in The States. It's just... We've got a supply problem there, it
24:12 takes a long time to build refineries around the world, which is what you need to
24:16 do, to address the diesel issues that's driving up prices. So I think one of the
24:21 concerns many of the banks has is, yep, the the numbers came in hot. We could
24:27 well see rate hikes, but does it actually fix the problem that's underpinning it? And that's
24:33 my nagging concern at the moment.
24:35 If it doesn't, then it's kind of a boiling the frog moment where you have people
24:39 who are really, hurt by higher inflation at the same time that they're hurt from higher
24:43 rates. Do you think that people are underestimating the chance of a slowdown? Are you at
24:48 Citi taking down risk in any way in preparation for that, or do you think that
24:52 is unlikely because of all of the investment that we're seeing from other places?
24:56 You have to be prepared for everything all the time, particularly in the environment we're in.
25:00 Like, the last two weeks is a case in point. You wouldn't have expected that. And
25:04 I think we've all got very good at being more adaptable and being more resilient, building
25:10 in more buffers, being ready for more things happening. And I think that's part of the
25:15 reason why the world economy has done pretty well in the last five years despite wars
25:20 and COVID and tariffs and all these other things have been thrown at it. And so
25:26 you have to be ready for a slowdown and something that's more material. I don't see
25:31 it as being imminent, but the tail risks are certainly bigger than they were before. And
25:37 in that one, we've got to be ready to support the affordability agenda that, is the
25:42 reason we had the big shift in the election. The the prices are high. And I
25:48 think the other piece, companies are being very mindful about not passing on some of the
25:53 price increases through to consumers because there's a clear understanding. Earnings have been good. Let's try
26:00 and absorb as much of this as possible through the earnings we've got and try to
26:06 make sure the investments are still going to give growth into the economy rather than rather
26:12 than passing this on to consumers recklessly.
26:17 What do you think right now is the biggest risk that people are underestimating? Because, clearly,
26:22 there's a sense that maybe there's an overbuilding in AI or maybe there's a... I don't
26:28 wanna say bubble, but excess is happening in certain pockets there. Maybe you get rates that
26:33 rise that kill the party. What's your sense? I I
26:36 I don't think I don't think anyone's, overestimating or underestimating anything at the moment. I think
26:42 we're all very mindful that we've got, you know, an economy that continues to perform well,
26:48 not unevenly, but still perform well in the aggregate, and that there's a number of different
26:54 tail risks. We know what they are. So I think the biggest risk we have is
26:59 if they start converging. And so if you start seeing them feed off each other, then
27:05 that's when you tend to get more of a self fulfilling prophecy coming. I don't see
27:09 that yet, but it, you know, it's a possibility at some point. What I am happy
27:14 is to see some of the air come out of the tires. We had a market
27:18 that was priced to perfection. We have some AI concentration risk in there. We've had a
27:22 big election, with a big shift and change around. And as you say, we've had the
27:28 leadership change in, in one of the big companies in AI. All of those different pieces,
27:34 know, we're seeing some of the market react to that at the moment. At the same
27:39 time, you see Anthropic with what looks like will be a very successful IPO, when it
27:45 comes out tomorrow and, you know, giving confidence in... About the genie not being out of
27:51 the bottle on AI and that, you know, this should continue on. But we've all got
27:56 to be mindful. Let's do this responsibly.
Hours Away From Trump, Xi, Putin Summit in China full transcript
0:07 >> THIS IS "BALANCE OF
0:10 POWER," LIVE FROM WASHINGTON, D.C.
0:16 JOE: TONIGHT, THE PRICE TAG, ANTHROPIC SET TO
0:23 START ITS BLOCKBUSTER I.P.O. TONIGHT AT $83 A
0:26 SHARE. SHARES SET TO BEGIN
0:30 TRADING TOMORROW. WE'LL HAVE CONGRESSWOMAN
0:34 LORI TRAY HAHN WHAT IT MEANS FOR THE PUSH FOR
0:38 NEW GUARDRAILS AROUND TECHNOLOGY.
0:42 PLUS, PRESIDENT TRUMP IN CHINA WITH TALKS AHEAD
0:51 OF XI JINPING AND PUTIN. GARY LOCKE WILL JOIN US
0:53 FOR THE STAKES AND LAST CALL.
0:54 REPUBLICANS MAKING ONE FINAL PUSH FOR ANOTHER
0:58 PARTY LINE SPENDING PACKAGE BEFORE DEMOCRATS
1:02 TAKE CONTROL OF CONGRESS CONGRESS.
1:06 RON JOHNSON JOINS US ON HOW MUCH CAN GET THROUGH
1:09 AND HOW MUCH ARE REPUBLICANS WILLING TO
1:12 SPEND. WELCOME TO "BALANCE OF
1:14 POWER." I'M JONAH THREW
1:17 ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ. KAILEY: ANTHROPIC SET TO
1:20 BE PRICING WHAT'S SET TO BE THE LARGEST PRICING
1:25 IN I.P.O. HISTORY, SET TO BE -- 83.
1:30 SHARES SET TO BEGIN TRADING TOMORROW AFTER
1:34 ENORMOUS INVESTOR DEMAND STRONG ENOUGH FOR
1:37 ANTHROPIC TO INCREASE THE SIZE OF THE OFFERING
1:40 OFFERING. PROSECUTING IT ON THE
1:43 MARKET AT A PIVOTAL TIME FOR THE INDUSTRY.
1:48 ED LUD LOW JOINS US TO NEW YORK.
1:50 WHAT DOES THAT TELL US ABOUT DEMAND FOR THIS?
1:55 ED: WE KNEW THAT DEMAND WAS THERE.
1:57 THERE'S THIS PERIOD OF TIME NOW WHERE THOSE BIG
2:02 INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AND INDEED SOME CAPITAL
2:05 FIRMS HAVE HAVE REPORTED ARE AWAITING AND ARE
2:11 WAIT TOOK SEE THE RETAIL ELEMENT BUT $83 IS
2:14 ACCORDING TO OUR SOURCES WHEREWARE THEY'RE AT.
2:16 WE'RE WAITING FOR OFFICIAL CONFIRMATION
2:19 AND THEY'LL BE INCREASING THE OFFERING
2:21 SIZE BUT WE DON'T KNOW BY HOW MUCH SO THE FINAL
2:24 MATH ON THE SHARE COUNT IS NOT YET PUBLIC AND
2:28 THEREFORE AVIVING AT VALUATION IS A LITTLE
2:34 BIT TRICKY BUT $3 SHARE WOULD BE JUST BELOW 1.3
2:45 BILLION SO THETRILLION SO THE BIGGEST I.P.O. IN HISTORY.
2:48 JOE: IT'S BEEN SAID TO BE A POTENTIAL CLEARING
2:50 EVENT. WHAT WOULD NEED TO
2:54 HAPPEN FOR THAT TO QUALIFY?
2:57 ED: THIS IS A FIRST. A FRONTIER A.I. LAB
2:59 GOING PUBLIC. THERE'S AN INTERESTING
3:02 ELEMENT OF IT BEING A PUBLIC BENEFIT CORP AS
3:07 WELL. BUT IT WASN'T SO LONG
3:10 AGO THAT THE PENTAGON WAS IN DETENTION WITH
3:14 THIS COMPANY ABOUT HOW HIS TECHNOLOGY WAS USED
3:18 ON THE NATION'S BEHALF IN A NATIONAL SECURITY
3:20 CONTEXT AND BECAUSE OF THE EVENTS OF THE LAST
3:24 EIGHT DAYS IN MARKETS BUT JUST GENERALLY IN
3:28 AMERICA, PEOPLE'S VIEW OF ARTIFICIAL
3:30 INTELLIGENCE IS VERY DIFFERENT.
3:31 THAT SAID, THERE IS A LOT OF APPETITE AND
3:36 INTEREST FOR THIS I.P.O. AND IT WILL BE
3:38 INTERESTING HOW PEOPLE COME TO UNDERSTAND THE
3:41 BUSINESS MODEL THAT IS TRAINING FRONTIER MODELS
3:44 AT THE LEADING EDGE BUT BALANCING THAT WITH THE
3:48 COMMERCIAL AND SHAREHOLDER RESPONSIBLE
3:51 OF GETTING THAT BALANCE RIGHT.
3:55 JOE: ED, LET'S STAY IN TOUCH.
3:56 ED LUD LOW WITH THE BREAKING NEWS.
3:59 JOINING US NOW, FOR MORE ON THE OUTLOOK OF A.I.
4:02 POLICY HERE IN WASHINGTON AS DEMOCRATS
4:05 PREPARE TO TAKE CONTROL OF CONGRESS.
4:08 DEMOCRATIC CONGRESSWOMAN LORI TRAY HAHN OF
4:10 MASSACHUSETTS AND AUTHOR OF AN A.I. REGULATION
4:15 BILL. IT'S GREAT TO HAVE YOU
4:19 BACK ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
4:22 DOES THIS I.P.O. FOR ANTHROPIC, PROVIDING
4:26 IT'S SUCCESSFUL, ACT AS AN SHELL RANT TO EXPORT
4:29 CONTROLS AND AS WELL YOUR A.I. REGULATORY
4:32 BILL? >> IRCERTAINLY HOPE SO.
4:35 I UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE ARE EXTREMELY CONCERNED,
4:38 NOT JUST WITH ANTHROPIC RUSHING AHEAD WITH THEIR
4:44 I.P.O. BUT ALSO WITH THE RECENT NEWS WITH NVIDIA.
4:48 THAT'S WHY YOU'RE SEEING SO MANY DEMOCRATS AND
4:50 REPUBLICANS CALL FOR HEARINGS IN TERMS OF
4:53 WHAT THE ADMINISTRATION KNEW AND WHEN ABOUT
4:58 JENSEN HUANG AND HIS INFLUENCE ON OUR CHIP
5:01 POLICY. BUT WHEN I'M BACK HOME,
5:04 PEOPLE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT A.I. SAFETY.
5:07 THEY WANT TO MAKE SURE CONGRESS IS GETTING OFF
5:09 THE SIDELINES KEEPING PACE WITH THE MOST
5:12 POWERFUL TRANSFORMATIVE TECHNOLOGY IN HUMAN
5:14 HISTORY. AND SO RIGHT NOW WE'RE
5:19 SEEINGING THESE COMPANIES REALLY ACCELERATE, EVEN
5:23 THE ONES LIKE ANTHROPIC WHO HAVE TOUTED THE
5:26 IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY AND GUARDRAILS AND NOW
5:28 PEOPLE ARE EXPECTING CONGRESS TO KEEP PACE
5:30 WITH THAT. YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY THE
5:35 FRONTIER ACT IS A BIPARTISAN BILL THAT
5:40 WOULD REQUIRE SAFETY AND TRANSPARENCY REPORTING,
5:45 INCIDENT REPORTS WHEN A MODEL GOES ROGUE AND
5:47 ALSO A PROCESS BY WHICH THE GOVERNMENT CAN STEP
5:52 IN IF A MODEL IS CAPABLE OF A CATASTROPHIC RISK.
5:55 KAILEY: WITH THAT LEGISLATIVE EFFORT,
6:00 WOULD THAT AFFECT POTENTIALLY THE
6:01 FINANCIAL OUTLOOK FOR A COMPANY THAT IS NOW
6:04 GOING TO BE ONE OF THE LARGEST PUBLIC COMPANIES
6:07 OUT THERE AND POTENTIALLY HAVE A
6:10 HEAVYWEIGHTING IN AMERICANS' RETIREMENT
6:11 PORTFOLIOS. THAT IS THE CONCERN THAT
6:16 HAS BEEN RAISEED BY SENATOR ELIZABETH WARREN
6:21 THAT THIS IS HAPPENING EVEN WITH POTENTIAL
6:23 THREATS TO THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM AND RETIREMENTS.
6:26 DO YOU SEE THAT THREAT? >> WHAT I SEE AS A
6:30 THREAT IS US NOT HAVING ANY SAFETY GUARD RAILS.
6:33 THERE IS NOT A TRADEOFF BETWEEN SAFETY AND INO
6:35 VACATION. WE CAN STILL MOVE
6:39 RESPONSIBLY ON INNOVATION WHILE MAKING
6:42 SURE THAT WE HAVE THE PROPER GUARDRAILS IN
6:44 PLACE. THOSE TWO NEVER TRADE
6:47 OFF ON EACH OTHER. AND THAT'S THE REASON
6:52 WHY WE ARE A LEADER IN INNOVATION.
6:54 SOME OF THE PROVISIONS IN OUR BILL, SOME OF
6:58 THESE COMPANIES HAVE ALREADY VOLUNTEERED TO
7:00 DO BUT WE'RE REALLY OPERATING RIGHT NOW ON
7:03 THE HONOR SYSTEM AND THAT IS NOT SUSTAINABLE
7:09 GOING FORWARD. WE NEED TO HAVE A IT
7:15 BUILT INTO OUR STAFF STATUTE THAT THESE
7:17 COMPANIES ARE REQUIRED TO SHOW THE PUBLIC THAT
7:21 THEIR MITIGATEING RISKS. EVEN A NEAR MISS LIKE WE
7:25 SAW WITH THE HUGGING FACE INCIDENT THAT THOSE
7:27 ARE REPORTED TO THE GOVERNMENT AND WE HAVE
7:31 EMBEDDED EVALUATORS SO THAT THESE COMPANIES
7:34 AREN'T GRADING THEIR EASTERN WORK.
7:36 THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT THE AMERICAN PUBLIC
7:39 EXPECTS THE GOVERNMENT TO KEEP UP WITH AND THAT
7:42 IS WHAT'S GOING TO FOSTER MORE INNOVATION
7:45 IS WHEN WE HAVE THE TRUST OF AMERICAN
7:47 PEOPLE, THAT WE HAVE AN ECOSYSTEM IN PLACE TO
7:50 GUARANTEE SAFETY. JOE: AND HOW DO YOU GET
7:58 A ELLA TOUCHDOWN BILL WITH CONGRESS PASSED
8:01 INTO BILL? ESPECIALLY FOR AN
8:02 ADMINISTRATION THAT DOES NOT SEEM TO HAVE AN
8:05 APPETITE OR PACING THE FRONTIER, AS THEY CALL
8:09 IT. HOWARD LUTNICK IS ON THE
8:15 PLANE FOR TALKS ABOUT THAT.
8:19 IS THAT THE MAIN OBSTACLE?
8:22 >> THERE'S NO QUESTION THAT THIS HAS TO BE
8:23 BIPARTISAN. WE STILL HAVE TO GET TO
8:26 60 VOTES IN THE SNAP AND WE STILL NEED TO GET THE
8:31 PRESIDENT'S SIGNATURE BUT I'VE ALWAYS MAINTAIN
8:33 THAT HAD WE CAN COME TOGETHER AS WE DID THIS
8:35 PAST SUMMER. WE HAD REPUBLICAN
8:37 CO-SPONSORS ON THE FRONTIER BILL.
8:39 I THINK WE CAN DO THAT AGAIN AND WHEN YOU HAVE
8:42 A BIPARTISAN BILL THAT LANDS ON PRESIDENT'S
8:45 DESK, YOU REALLY DO PUT PRESSURE ON HIM TO SIGN
8:48 THAT BILL. WHEN THE PRESIDENT
8:53 SUMENED THOSE TECH EXECUTIVES TO THE WHITE
8:56 HOUSE AND THEY ESTABLISHED THOSE
9:00 FRONTIER ACCORDS, MANY WERE PART OF THOSE
9:03 VOLUNTEER AGREEMENT. SO ALL WE'RE WANTING TO
9:06 DO IS TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS ISN'T A VOLUNTEER
9:08 SYSTEM ANYMORE, THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
9:13 IS, YOU KNOW, DURABLE AND UNDERSTOOD SO THAT
9:16 ALL COMPANIES, NOT JUST THE BIGGEST FRONTIER
9:19 LABS, BUT OTHER COMPANIES THAT ARE
9:22 INNOVATING AND EMERGING KNOW THE RULES OF THE
9:25 ROAD. KAILEY: WHAT ABOUT THE
9:29 NOTION OF STRICTER EXPORT CONTROLS?
9:37 JOE JUST ALLUDED TO SECRETARY LIFTTHESECRETARY.
9:47 ARE YOU SUPPORTIVE OF ALL OF THOSE
9:50 RESTRICTIONS AND WOULD THEY HAVE MADE IT
9:52 IMPOSSIBLE FOR SOMETHING LIKE THE NVIDIA
9:57 MEGASPEED SAGA TO HAVE HAPPENED IN THE FIRST
9:59 PLACE? >> I CERTAINLY SUPPORT
10:01 TIGHTENING THE RULES ON OUR MOST ADVANCED CHIPS
10:03 GOING TO CHINA. IT'S BEEN INTERESTING TO
10:05 ME TO WATCH THE DEBATE ON THIS.
10:10 ON ONE HAND, WE'VE HEARD FROM REPUBLICANS AND A
10:13 THAT WE CAN'T SLOW DOWN, WE CAN'T PUT GUARDRAILS
10:15 ONLY A.I. COMPANIES BECAUSE WE HAVE TO BEAT
10:19 CHINA AND HERE WE ARE ALLOWING CHINA ACCESS TO
10:22 OUR CHIPS. SO, YOU KNOW, YOU CAN'T
10:25 PROVIDE THE INFRASTRUCTURE WITH THE
10:43 CHIPS TO OUR BIGGEST COMPETITOR AND NOW
10:45 SQUARE THAT WITH THE AMERICAN PEOPLELE WITH
10:46 DEPART RAILS. IT LOOKS LIKE THE WHITE
10:49 HOUSE HAS DEFINITELY CHANGED THIRD TUNE AFTER
10:53 THE NVIDIA SCANDAL. I THINK THAT'S A GOOD
10:57 THING. IF YOU'RE WORRIED ABOUT
10:59 CHINESE COMPETITION ON A.I., YOU SHOULD
11:01 ABSOLUTELY BE WORRIED ABOUT HANDING THEM THE
11:03 COMPUTE THAT MAKES THAT POSSIBLE.
11:05 JOE: A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE WORRIED AND I'M SURE
11:08 YOU'VE SPOKEN WITH FRIENDS ASK FAMILY
11:11 MEMBERS AND FELLOW LAWMAKERS ABOUT THIS,
11:13 THE SERIES OF OUTAGES FROM MICROSOFT TO THE
11:16 BANKS SO SOME AIRLINES. WHETHER A.I. WAS TO
11:19 BLAME FOR THIS. THE F.B.I. JUST WARNED
11:21 YESTERDAY THAT HACKERS HAVE BEEN USING A TOOL
11:27 TO ATTACK ORGANIZATIONS WORLDWIDE.
11:30 IS THE HORSE ALREADY OUT OF THE BAR?
11:36 >> I THINK WHETHER IT'S OUR AIRPORTS, THE
11:40 N.S.A., BANKS, OUTLOOK. PEOPLE HAVE QUESTIONS
11:42 AND I THINK EVERY ONE OF THESE ORGANIZATIONS HAVE
11:45 INDICATED THAT THIS ISN'T A CYBERATTACK OR
11:49 THE RESULT OF ROGUE A.I. BUT I'M FAIRLY
11:51 CONFIDENT, ESPECIALLY AFTER HEARING OUR TOP
11:55 DEMOCRAT ON THE SENATE INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE,
11:56 SENATOR MARK WARNER, A.I. IS STILL INVOLVED.
11:59 THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS THAT THESE NEW A.I.
12:03 TOOLS ARE SURFACING VULNERABILITIES THAT WE
12:07 NEED TO SHORE UP AND WHEN YOUD A MINISTER
12:11 THIS MANY PATCHES ALL AT ONCE, THINGS ARE GOING
12:13 TO BREAK. THIS TECHNOLOGY IS
12:17 MOVING FASTER THAN ANYBODY REALLY THOUGHT.
12:20 I THINK THAT REALLY UNDERSCORES WHY WE'VE
12:24 BEEN PUSHING FOR THESE A.I. GUARDRAILS SO THAT
12:27 WE CAN GET IN FRONT OF IT RATHER THAN BE
12:29 RESPONDING TO IT. AT A MINIMUM, WE NEED TO
12:34 PREVENT A CATASTROPHIC EVENT BUT WE ALSO NEED
12:37 TO DO SO MUCH MORE. SO I THINK THESE OUTAGES
12:42 ARE REALLY ADDING TO THE ANXIETY BUT ALSO THE
12:45 PRESSURE FOR CONGRESS TO DO SOMETHING SO THAT WE
12:48 WERE BUILDING RESILIENCE, WE ARE
12:50 BUILDING CAPABILITY IN THE AGENCY THAT IS
12:54 OVERSEE OUR CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND WE'RE
12:57 ALSO PUTTING IN THE MOST TABLE STAKES COMMON-
13:00 COMMON-SENSE GUARDRAILS AROUND THIS TECHNOLOGY.
13:03 KAILEY: DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS NBA LORI TRAHAN
13:05 OF MASSACHUSETTS. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
13:08 JOINING US. BREAKING NEWS JUST
13:12 CROSSING THE TERMINAL. MOODI'S HAS ALLOWEST ITS
13:20 OUTLOOK ON NVIDIA FROM STABLE TO POSITIVE.
13:26 SPECIFICALLY THE SUDDEN DEPARTURE OF A KEY EXEC
13:32 EXECTURE AND A LACK OF A SUCCESSION PLAN ARE
13:35 DRIVERS OF THIS RATING. IT HAS INTRODUCED
13:38 UNCERTAINTY ABOUT THE COMPANY'S BUSINESS
13:41 STRATEGY AND FINANCIAL POLICIES.
13:42 LOWERED FROM SUBSTANTIAL TO POSITIVE BY MOODY'S.
13:46 BACK TO WHAT WE WERE JUST DISCUSSING,
13:49 LAWMAKERS PRESSING SOME OF THE TOP SECURITY
13:53 LEADERS OVER THE REMARKABLE STRING OF
13:57 TECHNICAL FAILURES. OFFICIALS INCLUDING
14:02 HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE
14:05 MULLEN AND DIRECTOR OF INTELLIGENCE JAY CLAYTON
14:09 INSIST THE INCIDENTS ARE NOT RELATED AND SHOW NO
14:15 SIGNS OF A COORDINATED CYBERATTACK BUT OFFER NO
14:18 SIGNS OF WHAT CLEARLY WENT WRONG.
14:21 >> THERE'S NO INDICATION OF ANY MALICIOUS
14:23 CYBERATTACK. >> WE HAVE SEEN NO
14:26 INDICATION THAT THEY'RE RELATED.
14:28 >> WE WERE NO INDICATION THAT THESE INCIDENTS ARE
14:32 RERELATED OR COORDINATED.
14:35 ALSO NO INDICATION THEY'RE THE RESULT OF A
14:40 STATE-SPONSORED BLIND ACTOR.
14:41 KAILEY: JOHN:ING US IS MILES WHO
14:43 WAS IN THE ROOM. CLEARLY THERE WAS A
14:47 MESSAGE THEY WANTED TO ENFORCE.
14:49 >> THE WHITE HOUSE APPARENTLY GOT TO ALL
14:52 THREE OF THOSE MEN, INCLUDING MARKO RUBIO TO
14:57 SAY WE ARE NOT BEING ATTACKED BY ANYTHING
14:59 NEFARIOUS. TO GET TO THE BRASS
15:04 TACKS OF THIS. OUR INTERSTATE SYSTEM,
15:07 THE ROADS WERE MADE FOR THE MODEL T, THE TIN
15:12 LIZZY AND NOW YOU HAVE TESLA VEHICLES THAT ARE
15:16 GOING 100 MILES PER HOUR AND A.I. AND OTHER
15:19 COMPUTING MODELS ARE MAKING IT THAT MUCH FOR
15:21 DIFFICULT TO DRIVE ON THOSE ROADS THAT WERE
15:24 MADE FOR THE MODEL T SO YOU HAVEYOU HAVE TO DO PATCHES.
15:28 YOU FIND A POTHOLE AND YOU HAVE TO PATCH THAT
15:30 UP. SOME OF THAT TECHNOLOGY
15:34 COMBINED WITH P.H.P. THAT MADE THEM HAVE TO
15:37 DO THESE SWITCHES AND PATCHES IN ADDITION TO
15:40 A.I. BEING INTRODUCED. A.I. IS.
15:43 REASON WHY THE FLAW IN THAT COMPLICATED
15:46 LANGUAGE WAS FOUND AND THEN HAVING TO MAKE
15:49 THOSE PATCHES, CAUSING A LOT OF ISSUES FOR THESE
15:51 COMPANIES. JOE: IT WAS JUST THE
15:53 TIMING THAT SPOOKED A LOT OF PEOPLE.
15:57 SO MANY OF THESE WERE HAPPENING ALL AT ONCE.
16:04 IF THIS P.H.P. MATTER IS SOMETHING THAT ALL
16:05 CORPORATIONS AND COMPANIES HAVE TO
16:09 MANAGER, WE'RE NOT DONE YET, RIGHT?
16:13 MYLES: THEY NEED TO MAKE SURE THEY FIGURE OUT
16:15 WHAT THE VULNERABILITY IS AND PATCH IT.
16:18 THAT IS THE PLACE WHERE THE NATION STATES CAN
16:22 COME AND FLORIDA AND DO HARM SO YOU HAVE TO
16:25 CLOSE UP THOSE VULNERABILITIES.
16:27 RIGHT NOW FROM THE CONSULTING FOLKS IN THE
16:29 WORLD TO THE GOVERNMENT FERRIS FOLKS, THEY'RE
16:32 GOING TO BE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WAYS TO DO
16:36 THESE PATCHES, THESE REMOTE FIXES WITHOUT
16:42 CAUSING THE MOST HARM AND IT'S CLEAR THAT
16:45 RIGHT NOW THEY'RE NOT SURE HOW TO DO THAT.
16:52 THE AIRPORT ISSUE WAS A PHYSICAL PIECE OF COPPER
16:57 WIRE CAUSING THE ISSUES. KAILEY: AT LEAST THEY
16:58 SAY THAT. EVEN IF IT WASN'T A
17:02 NATION STATE OR NEFARIOUS ACTORS WHAT
17:06 DID WE HEAR FROM THESE THREE INDIVIDUALS AS TO
17:09 THE THREAT THAT IS POSED BY NATION STATES LIKE
17:12 IRAN RIGHT NOW? MYLES: IT WAS VERY
17:15 ALARMING TO HEAR THAT NATION STATES HAVE
17:18 ALREADY FIGURED OUT WAYS TO GET INTO OUR CRITICAL
17:25 INFRASTRUCTURE SO YOU'LL HAREM HOW THEY'RE
17:27 PROTECTING THE GRILLED, WATER SYSTEM.
17:29 YOU HEARD WHAT HAPPENED IN EUROPE WITH
17:32 REFRIGERATOR AND THAT KIND OF THING.
17:35 THE REASON PEOPLE ARE SO ALARMED BY THIS IS THAT
17:37 THE FIRST THING YOU DO WHEN YOU DO AN ATTACK IS
17:40 YOU SHUT DOWN COMMUNICATIONS AND WHAT
17:42 HAS HAPPENED IN THESE INSTANCES?
17:45 THE COMMUNICATIONS METHODS, WHETHER IT BE
17:48 WITH THE FAA OR MICROSOFT OR APPLE WERE
17:53 THE FIRST THINGS TO GO DOWN.
17:56 SO PEOPLE WERE ALARMED. BUT IT IS GOING TO TAKE
17:59 QUITE SOME TIME TO FIGURE OUT WHAT IS
18:02 BEHIND ALL OF THIS. JOE: BLOOMBERG'S MYLES
18:05 MILLER. COMING UP ON "BALANCE OF
18:07 POWER," ANOTHER GOVERNMENT FUNDING
18:09 DEADLINE IS CLOSING IN. JUST DON'T SAY SHUTDOWN.
18:13 REPUBLICANS WEIGHING ONE LAST PUSH ON THEIR
18:16 AGENDA BEFORE THEY LOSE CONTROL OF CONGRESS.
18:19 RON JOHNSON JOINS US NEXT ON "BALANCE OF
18:21 POWER." ONLY ON BLOOM BERYL TV
18:24 AND RADIO.
18:40 KAILEY: 88 "BALANCE OF POWER" ON BLOOMBERG TV
18:43 AND RADIO. ALONGSIDE JOE MATHIEU,
18:45 I'M KAILEY LEINZ. CONGRESS IS NOW LESS
18:48 THAN A MONTH AWAY FROM ANOTHER POTENTIAL
18:50 GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN WITH FUNDING SET TO EXPIRE ON
18:56 DECEMBER 11 AND NO DEAL YET TO KEEP THE
18:59 GOVERNMENT OPEN. AS REPUBLICANS TRY ONE
19:03 MORE RECONCILIATION PUSH.
19:06 JOINING US NOW FOR MORE LIVE FROM CAPITOL HILL
19:09 IS REPUBLICAN SENATOR RON JOHNSON FROM
19:12 WISCONSIN, CHAIR OF THE SENATE BUDGET COMMITTEE.
19:17 MR. CHAIRMAN, WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG.
19:21 YOU'RE JOINING US FRESH FROM A MEETING WITH
19:24 SENATORS TO DISCUSS RECONCILIATION.
19:26 WHATST THE PLAN? >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING
19:27 ME. THE PERMITTING BILL WILL
19:31 BE HUGE. HOPEFULLY WE'LL FINISH
19:33 THAT OFF TOMORROW. IN TERMS OF
19:35 RECONCILIATION, THERE ARE DOWN SIDES TO
19:37 RECONCILIATION. I GUESS FIRST AND
19:41 FOREMOST, THE GOVERNMENT FUND BEING RUNS OUT ON
19:44 DECEMBER 11. DEMOCRATS ARE
19:47 THREATENING IF WE DO RECONCILIATION THEY'RE
19:49 NOT GOING TO CORPORATE AND WE MIGHT HAVE A
19:53 GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN. WE DECIDED TO GIVE THE
19:58 DEMOCRATS ONE MORE CHANCE TO SUPPORT OUR
20:00 MEN AND WOMEN IN UNIFORM, TO FUND
20:03 NATIONAL DEFENSE. WE HAVEN'T GIVEN UP ON
20:06 RECONCILIATION AT ALL. IF WE DO, IT WOULD BE A
20:11 PRETTY SIMPLE PLAN. THE CONSENSUS IS LET'S
20:18 GIVE THE DEMOCRATS ONE MORE TRY.
20:22 IT IS SO IMPORTANT TO FUND THESE THINGS THAN
20:25 IT IS FOR RECONCILIATION TO BEGIN.
20:27 IF WE HAVE TO DO IT, WE HAVE TO DO IT.
20:30 JOE: YOU WOULD GIVE DEMOCRATS A CHANCE TO
20:34 WEIGH IN ON A CONTINUING RESOLUTION KNOWING THAT
20:38 FUNDING EXPIRES DECEMBER 11.
20:40 AND THEN IF THAT DOESN'T WORK OUT THEN YOU HAVE
20:45 TO PUT MONEY INTO RECONCILIATION, DO I YOU
20:47 THINK SO? >> WE COULD POTENTIALLY
20:51 USE THE HOUSE CONSTRUCTION OF V.A.
20:54 PUT A DEFENSE SUPPLEMENTAL ON TOP OF
20:57 THAT. GIVE DEMOCRATS WHO
20:58 ACTUALLY ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE DEFENSE OF
21:01 THIS NATION TO SUPPORT US IN DOING THAT.
21:04 IF THAT DOESN'T WORK, I THINK WE HAVE TO TURN TO
21:08 RECONCILIATION. JOE: ARE YOU WORRIED
21:11 ABOUT A SHUTDOWN? WE'RE STARTING TO HEAR
21:14 THAT WORD. WITH THE LEADERSHIP
21:16 CONFUSION ON THE DEMOCRAT SIDE.
21:18 YOU'VE SEEN THIS MOVIE BEFORE, WHAT'S ABOUT TO
21:20 HAPPEN? >> THAT'S WHAT GOT THE
21:24 CONFERENCE TO COME TOGETHER AND SAY LET'S
21:27 GIVE IT ANOTHER SHOT. THEY ARE THREATENING AND
21:30 THEY'VE BEEN SO OBNOXIOUS THEY'VE SHUT
21:33 THE GOVERNMENT DOWN TWICE THIS YEAR.
21:36 THEY'LL PROBABLY FOLLOW THROUGH ON THEIR THREAT.
21:40 WE'LL GO THE EXTRA MILE, GIVE THE DEMOCRATS THE
21:44 EXAMPLE, THIS IS HOW YOU DO THINGS COOPERATIVELY.
21:48 LET'S FUND OUR TROOPS, DEFEND THIS NATION AND
21:52 NOT HAVE A GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN.
21:55 KAILEY: WHEN IT COMES TO THE POTENTIAL DEFENSE
21:58 SUPPLEMENTAL OR RECONCILIATION PACKAGE,
22:01 IS ANY OF THIS GOING TO BE PAID FOR, SENATOR?
22:05 >> WE DON'T PAY FOR APPROPRIATIONS.
22:07 WE NEVER PAID FOR A DEFENSE SUPPLEMENTAL
22:10 EITHER. WE HAD DEPUTY DEFENSE
22:18 SECRETARY FINEBERG -- OUR NATION FACES MANY,
22:21 MANY THREATS OVERSEAS. THIS IS A DANGEROUS
22:24 WORLD AND THEY NEED THE FUNDING TO COUNTER NOSE
22:29 THREAT, PLUS, I THINK THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT
22:31 WITH THE LEADERSHIP OF PEOPLE LIKE DEFENSE
22:42 SECRETARY FINE FEINBURG ARE DOING A FINE JOB AND
22:44 THEY NEED TO BE SUPPORTED.
22:46 JOE: TALKED TO A COUPLE OF YOUR COLLEAGUES LAST
22:50 EVENING IN THE ROTUNDA THERE.
22:52 THOM TILLIS AND RAND PAUL BOTH BALKED WHEN I
22:56 ASKED THEM ABOUT A $50 BILLION ALLOCATION TO
23:00 UPGRADE OR BUILD FROM SCRAP OUR NATION'S AIR
23:03 TRAFFIC CONTROL SYSTEM. THEY THOUGHT THAT NUMBER
23:06 WAS FAR MORE THAN WHAT WAS NEEDEDDED AND RAND
23:09 PAUL IS EVEN SUGGESTING NEW LEGISLATION TO
23:13 UNLOCK OTHER FUNDS, REAPPROPRIATE KNOW THIS
23:15 USE AND A HALF GONE TO THE DEFENSE DEPARTMENT
23:16 ALREADY. WHERE ARE YOU ON A $50
23:21 BILLION REBUILD? >> I THINK WE ABSOLUTELY
23:26 DO NEED TO UPGRADE THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL
23:28 SYSTEM. IT'S NOT SEAN DUFFY'S
23:32 FAULT THAT IN DECADES BEFORE THE FAA HAS
23:37 WASTED BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
23:40 AGAIN, I'M NOT SURE $50 BILLION IS THE RIGHT
23:43 NUMBER BUT HOPEFULLY IT WOULD BE SOMETHING YOU
23:47 COULD ALSO DO ON A NONPARTISAN BASIS.
23:48 I HAVE TO BELIEVE THE DEMOCRATS WANTS TO KEEP
23:52 OUR SKIES SAFE AND MODERNIZE THE SYSTEM.
23:56 THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS, THE RULES AND
24:00 REGULATIONS FOLLOWING PROW CUREMENT.
24:08 -- PROCUREMENT. KAILEY: DO YOU SEE ANY
24:11 OF THE INFRASTRUCTURE OF THE FAA BEING CAUSED BY
24:16 THE LAYOFFS IN THE EARLY STAGES OF DOGE AFFECTING
24:22 THIS? >> NO, I HAVEN'T SEEN
24:24 THAT. OTHER COUNTRIES ARE
24:26 PROBABLY LIGHT YEARS AHEAD OF US IN TERMS OF
24:30 MODERNIZING THEIR SYSTEM.
24:33 THEY'VE TURNED TO MORE QUASI PRIVATE-PUBLIC
24:37 TYPE OF RELATIONSHIPS. WE OUGHT TO CONSIDER
24:39 THAT AS WELL. I'M NOT A FAN OF
24:41 GOVERNMENT. GOVERNMENT DOESN'T DO
24:44 THINGS VERY EFFECTIVELY OR EFFICIENTLY.
24:49 JOE: MR. CHAIRMAN, YOU'RE ALSO CHAIR OF THE
24:53 HOMELAND SECURITY SUBCOMMITTEE ON
24:55 INVESTIGATIONS AND WE HAD QUITE A CONVERSATION
24:59 TODAY WITH THE SECRETARY OF HOPLAND SECURITY.
25:04 MAKE WANE MULLENS AND OTHERS INCLUDING THE
25:09 CASE CADE OF OUTAGES THAT WE'VE SEEN.
25:12 WHEN IT COMES TO THE OUTAGES AND SOME OF THE
25:14 OTHER CONCERN THAT IS PEOPLE HAVE ABOUT WHAT'S
25:17 HAPPENING RIGHT NOW TECHNOLOGICALLY AROUND
25:20 THEM AND WHETHER THE ADMINISTRATION HAS
25:24 ITSELF ARMS AROUND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE,
25:27 WOULD YOU CALL THE SECRETARY TO TESTIFY
25:29 BEFORE YOUR COMMITTEE? >> FIRST OF ALL, I DON'T
25:33 THINK ANYBODY HAS THEIR ARMS AROUND ARTIFICIAL
25:36 INTELLIGENCE, INCLUDING THE CREATORS OF IT.
25:40 WE'D PROBABLY TAX IT, MORTGAGE THE FUTURE BUT
25:43 ACTUALLY COME UP WITH REASONABLE REGULATIONS?
25:46 I DOUBT IT. WE ARE LIVING IN A
25:52 COMPLEX, MACHINE INTERCONNECTED WORLD
25:55 WHICH LEAVES US MORE VULNERABLE.
25:58 WE ALL BELIEVE WE LIVE IN THESE SUPERHERE TOW
26:02 MOVIE TYPE SITUATIONS WHERE WE EXPECT SOMEBODY
26:06 TO JUST COME SAVE THE DAY.
26:08 I'M TAKING THE GOOD FAITH THAT THEY'VE NOT
26:12 SEEN A SPECIFIC CYBERTHREAT.
26:14 IT'S PROBABLE TO ME THAT AS AI IS IDENTIFYING
26:17 VULNERABILITIES IN SYSTEMS, PEOPLE ARE
26:19 UPGRADING THOSE. IT'S NOT PERFECT.
26:22 I COME FROM MANUFACTURING.
26:25 MURPHY'S LAW IS A TRIED AND TRUE REALITY.
26:28 IF SOMETHING CAN GO WRONG, IT WILL GO WRONG.
26:32 THEY'RE NOT IDENTIFYING SPECIFIC CYBERTHREATS.
26:36 I BELIEVE THEM ON THAT. I'M NOT SAYING IT'S NOT
26:40 POSSIBLE. KAILEY: A LOT OF EYES
26:43 WERE ON THAT HEARING TODAY BUT THERE WAS ALSO
26:45 A HEARING THAT YOU HOSTED TODAY ON THE
26:47 FUTURE OF SOCIAL SECURITY ASK THERE'S
26:49 OBVIOUSLY AN INTERVIEW YOU DID ON ANOTHER
26:54 NETWORK THAT HAS GONE A BIT VIRAL WITH THE
26:56 SUGGESTION THAT SOCIAL SECURITY IS A PONZI
27:00 SCHEME THAT NEEDS TO BE SHUT DOWN.
27:03 I KNOW YOU SAID NOSE REMARKS WILL TAKEN OUT
27:05 OF CONTEXT SO WHAT IS THE FIX FOR SOCIAL
27:08 SECURITY? >> I WOULD CALL ON OVER
27:11 THE READ MY FULL CHAIRMAN'S MEMO.
27:15 I'M NOT SUGGESTING SHUTTING DOWN SOCIAL
27:17 SECURITY. I'M OBVIOUSLY DRAWING
27:20 ATTENTION TO THE PROBLEM.
27:22 IT DOES OPERATE AS A LEGAL PONZI SCHEME AND
27:25 WHAT I'M SUGGESTING AND I'M INTRODUCING
27:28 LEGISLATION TODAY, STOP SCARING SENIORS ACT
27:31 WHICH WOULD AMEND THE LAW SO THAT WE DO NOT
27:35 REDUCE BENEFITS WHEN THE TRUST FUND ACCOUNTING
27:38 ENTRY RUNS OUT. THE TRUST FUND HAS NO
27:41 VALUE. THOSE BONDS ARE
27:42 WORTHLESS TO THE U.S. GOVERNMENT SO I'M TRYING
27:45 TO LAY OUT THE REALITY, GET PEOPLE TO UNDERSTAND
27:48 WE HAVE A PROBLEM BUT EVEN IF WE FIX SOCIAL
27:53 SECURITY REQUEST DAMAGE DAMAGING PROPOSALS LIKE
27:58 RAISEING THE INCOME GAP. THAT WOULD ONLY HURT OUR
28:01 ECONOMY. WE'RE NOT ADDRESSING
28:04 80%. I HOPE THE DEMOCRATS
28:07 JOIN ME, ALL THE ONES LOOKING AT MY COMMENTS
28:11 AND SAYING THAT. I NEVER WOULD SHUT DOWN
28:13 SOCIAL SECURITY. WE NEED TO PREDESERVE IT
28:16 AND SAVE IT. I'M JUST TRYING TO DRAW
28:19 ATTENTION TO THE ISSUE. SIGN ON TO NIP STOP
28:23 SCARING SENIORS BENEFIT, TO MAKE US FOCUS ON
28:29 LARGER PROPER, WHICH IS $240 MILLION IN DEFICITS
28:31 OVER THE NEXT 10 YEARS AND GROWING.
28:36 JOE: SENATOR, WE AWE ANOTHER SEAT FLIP TO
28:42 ALASKA LAST NIGHT. WHAT DO YOU THINK THIS
28:46 MEANS FOR JOHN THUNE AND HOW HE CAN BEST
28:48 REPRESENT THE REPUBLICAN AGENDA IN THIS NEW
28:50 CONGRESS? >> UNFORTUNATELY I THINK
28:52 THE DEBATE OVER THE NEXT TWO YEARS, AND THIS IS
28:54 SAD. WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO
28:58 BE DEBATING THE VALUE OF A FREE-MARKET
29:01 COMPETITION VERSUS SOCIALISM.
29:03 I CANNOT BELIEVE IN AMERICA, 100 YEARS INTO
29:07 FAILED SOCIALIST SYSTEMS THAT DETROITED
29:10 ECONOMIES, NATIONS, RUINED PETE'S LIVES,
29:12 RESULTED IN THE MURDER OF TENSE OF MILLIONS OF
29:15 PEOPLE, NOW WE HAVE A HIGH PERCENTAGE OF
29:18 AMERICAN POPULATION, PARTICULARLY OUR YOUTH,
29:24 WHO HAVE BEEN INDOCK TRI-NATEED IN OUR SCHOOL
29:27 SYSTEMS EDGE BRACING THAT?
29:33 WASTES TAXPAYER MONEY. INTRODUCING ALL KINDS OF
29:35 FRAUD. CAN'T EVEN MANAGE THE
29:36 NUMBER ONE SUPPORTED PROGRAM IN AMERICA,
29:40 WHICH IS SOCIAL SECURITY.
29:41 CAN'T EVEN PROPERLY MANAGE THAT WITHOUT
29:44 GOING BANKRUPT. YOU WANT GOVERNMENT TO
29:46 GROW AND DO ALL OF THESE OTHER THINGS, IT'S NOT
29:49 CAPABLE OF DOING IT. JOE: THIS IS WHAT THE
29:54 VOTERS ASKED FOR, ISN'T IT?
29:56 >> UNFORTUNATELY SOMETIMES THE VOTERS GET
29:59 WHAT THEY VOTED FOR. THAT WOULD BE
30:01 UNFORTUNATE FOR THIS COUNTRY.
30:03 SOCIALISM DOES NOT WORK. GROWING GOVERNMENT DOES
30:05 NOT WORK. WE'RE MAKING THAT CASE
30:10 AGAINST A RELATIVELY LEFTEST MEDIA AND
30:12 LEFTIST EDUCATION LEVEL. IT'S NOT A LEVEL PLAYING
30:15 FIELD. IT'S NOT A FAIR FIGHT.
30:20 JOE: WE'RE TRYING TO DO OUR FAIR PART ON THAT.
30:24 THANK YOU. PERSPECTIVE TRUMP IS IN
30:29 CHINA YES WE RECEIVED A WARM WELCOME FROM
30:32 CHINESE PRESIDENT XI JINPING.
30:35 THEY'LL SIT DOWN WITH VLADIMIR PUTIN FOR A
30:39 HIGH LEVEL MEETING. BLOOMBERG'S TYLER
30:41 KENDALL IS TRAVELING WITH THE PRESIDENT AND
30:44 HAS MORE FROM CHINA. >> IT WAS A WARM WELCOME
30:47 FOR PRESIDENT TRUMP WHEN HE TOUCHED DOWN HERE IN
30:50 CHINA WITH CHINESE PRESIDENT XI JINPING
30:52 GOING TO GREET HIM AT THE AIRPORT, CONSIDERED
30:55 TO BE A RARE MOVE. ALTHOUGH UNDERNEATH IT,
30:58 TENSIONS HAVE BEEN HEIGHTENING BETWEEN THE
31:03 U.S. AND WE GOT A PREVIEW OF WHAT
31:05 POTENTIALLY MAY BE SAID ON THURSDAY WITH SOME
31:09 HIGH STAKES MEETINGS WITH XI JINPING AND
31:15 VLADIMIR PUTIN USING THEIR STAGES AT THE
31:20 SUMMIT IN WHAT SEEMS TO BE A BID TO PUSH BACK AT
31:24 THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION.
31:25 IT WAS PREPARED TO TAKE COUNTER MEASURES IF THE
31:29 U.S. COMMERCE DEPARTMENT FOLLOWED THROUGH IN A
31:32 BID TO RESTRICT CHINESE ACCESS TO ADVANCED
31:36 CHIPS. CHINA SAYS IT WOULD
31:38 PREFER TO HAVE A DIALOGUE AROUND THE
31:40 ISSUE. WE'LL HAVE TO SEE WHERE
31:44 THAT STAKES OUT CONSIDERING THAT CHINA
31:46 WANTED TO GO INTO THIS MEETING LOOKING FOR THE
31:50 U.S. TO LOOSEN RESTRICTIONS BUT U.S.
31:52 NEGOTIATORS REMAIN FRUSTRATE WITH SOME KEY
31:55 PARTS OF THE TRADE FRAMEWORK, INCLUDING THE
32:00 PACE OF EXPORT LYNNS FOR RARE EARTH MINERALS AS
32:02 WELL AS PLANS TO PURCHASE FOR U.S.
32:05 AGRICULTURAL GOODS. KAILEY: AND JOINING US
32:09 NOW FOR MORE IS FORMER U.S. AMBASSADOR TO CHINA
32:14 AND FORMER U.S. COMMERCE SECRETARY GARY LOCK.
32:16 GREAT TO HAVE YOU BACK ON BLOOMBERG.
32:20 AS WE LOOK AHEAD TO THE BILATERAL AND TRILATERAL
32:25 MEETINGS TOMORROW. WHAT WILL BE YOUR
32:29 EXPECTATION TO BE DELIVERED FROM THEM?
32:32 >> I DON'T HAVE HIGH EXPECTATIONS FOR THIS
32:38 SUMMIT, ALREADY WITH PRESIDENT XI OF CHINA OR
32:43 WITH PRESIDENT PUTIN OF RUSSIA.
32:45 THE MOST WE CAN EXPECT IS AN EXTENSION OF THE
32:52 CURRENT TRUCE AND IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THE RARE
32:55 EARTHS THAT CHINA CONTINUES.
32:57 BECAUSE THOSE ARE REALLY CRITICAL FOR
32:59 SEMICONDUCTOR MANUFACTURING, ELECTRIC
33:01 VEHICLES, EVEN THE MECHANICS AND THE
33:04 BRAKING SYSTEMS AND ENGINE SYSTEMS OF
33:07 COMBUSTION AUTOMOBILES AND A WHOLE HOST OF
33:09 ADVANCED MACHINERY. THOSE ARE CRITICAL
33:12 BECAUSE CHINA REALLY PROCESSES ALMOST 99% OF
33:17 THOSE RARE EARTHS THAT AMERICAN VANNED
33:21 MANUFACTURING NEEDS. JOE: KNOWING THAT
33:24 PRESIDENT XI AND PRESIDENT TRUMP WILL
33:26 MEET AGAIN IN DECEMBER IN MIAMI, WHAT'S AN
33:29 IMPORTANT EXTENSION OF THAT TRADE TRUCE?
33:32 THAT WOULD BE A BIG STORY FOR OUR AUDIENCE
33:36 IF HE MANAGED TO CLOSE A DEAL ON THAT OR IS THAT
33:39 FOR THE NEXT MEETING HERE IN THE U.S.?
33:42 >> I THINK BOTH SIDES WOULD LIKE TO COME AWAY
33:45 WITH SOME ANNOUNCEMENT, WHICH WOULD BE AN
33:47 EXTENSION OF THE TRUCE. IT WOULD BE GOOD FOR
33:50 BOTH SIDES. PROVIDE CERTAINTY TO THE
33:52 BUSINESS COMMUNITY IN BOTH CHINA AND THE
33:54 UNITED STATES AND CERTAINLY WOULD, I
33:56 THINK, HELP LOWER SOME OF THE TENSIONS BETWEEN
33:58 THE TWO COUNTRIES. AT THE SAME TIME I'M
34:02 SURE PRESIDENT TRUMP WILL PRESS CHINA TO LIVE
34:05 UP TO THE TERMS OF THAT TRUCE, WHICH IS TO BUY
34:09 MORE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS AND TO CUT DOWN
34:11 ON THE FLOW OF FENTANYL AND SOME OF THE
34:14 INGREDIENTS USED TO MAKE IT COMING OUT OF CHINA
34:17 WHETHER IT'S TO MEXICO OR TO THE UNITED STATES.
34:21 KAILEY: AND TO KEEP THE RARE EARTHS FLOW EGG TO
34:24 BUYERS IN THE U.S. THAT NEED IT.
34:31 HOW DO YOU -- DO YOU BELIEVE CHINA WHEN IT
34:35 SAYS THEY WOULD RETALIATE IF WE SEE
34:39 STRONGER RICINGS FROM THE U.S. ON THINGS LIKE
34:43 SEMICONDUCTORS. IS RARE EARTHS WHERE YOU
34:49 WOULD LOOK FIRST AS POTENTIAL ATALLUATION.
34:56 >> FIRST OF ALL, NVIDIA PROHIBITS THE SALE OF
35:00 BLACKWELL CHIPS, AND CHINESE COMPANIES HAVE
35:03 BEEN ABLE TO EXPLOIT A LOOPHOLE, WHICH IS WHERE
35:05 THE UNITED STATES ALLOWS THE SELL OF SALE OF THESE CHIPS
35:11 TO COMPANIES ALL AROUND THE WORLD AND THESE
35:15 CHINESE COMPANIES TURN AROUND AND LEASE THE
35:17 COMPUTING POWER FROM THESE DATA CENTERS.
35:20 THAT'S BEING SHUT DOWN FROM THE COMMERCE
35:24 DEPARTMENT, AS A FALLOUT FROM THE NVIDIA SCANDAL
35:28 SO I'M SURE PRESIDENT XI WILL PUSH FOR ALLOWING
35:31 THE SALE OF SOME OF THESE ADVANCED CHIPS.
35:34 PERHAPS NOT THE BLACKWELL CLIPS BUT THE
35:37 NEXT TIER OF CHIPS GOING INTO CHINA.
35:39 AT THE SAME TIME, CHINA DOES HAVE AN ACE CARD.
35:44 WE BADLY NEED THOSE RARE EARTHS, THEY'RE
35:47 NECESSARY FOR SEMICONDUCTOR AND ALL
35:49 THIVE MANUFACTURING. JUST ABOUT ANY TYPE OF
35:51 ADVANCED MANUFACTURING AND THE REALITY IS THAT
35:54 CHINA PRODUCES AND PROCESSES SOME 99% OF
35:59 THESE RARE EARTHS THAT WE NEED.
36:04 AMERICA IS NOW TRYING TO DIVERSIFY ITS SUPPLY
36:07 CHAIN BUT THAT WILL TAKE SOME TIME AND IN THE
36:11 MEANTIME OUR DEFENSE INDUSTRIES ARE SCRAM TO
36:13 BELIEVE GET THE RARE EARTHS THEY NEED FOR
36:16 MISSILES, SATELLITES, JETS, AND SO FORTH.
36:19 JOE: THROUGHOUT SOUTHEAST ASIA, MANY OF
36:23 THEM HAVE FINANCIAL INTERESTS THAT ARE CLOSE
36:26 TO THE COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD
36:28 LUTNICK. AS HIS SONS HAVE TAKEN
36:35 THE KANTOR OF BUSINESS AND THERE ARE QUESTIONS
36:38 ABOUT WHETHER THAT MOTIVATED HIM TO PURSUE
36:42 LIGHTNING EXPORT CONTROLS OR TO TURN THE
36:45 OTHER WAY KNOWING THAT NVIDIA WAS WATCHING SOME
36:50 OF ITSELF CHIPS BE DIVERTED.
36:52 YOU HAD THE JOB. SHOULD HOWARD LUTNICK BE
36:54 ON THIS TRIP TO CHINA RIGHT NOW?
36:58 >> HE CAN BE ON THE TRIP BUT HE'S GOING TO HAVE
37:01 TO ANSWER A LOT OF QUESTIONS FROM CONGRESS
37:04 AND I'M SURE THE MEDIA. IN THE LAST MONTHS OF
37:07 THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION THEY CAME OUT WITH A
37:11 RULE WHICH SAID THERE CANNOT BE THESE DATA
37:14 CENTERS WHICH THEN LEASE TO THE COMPANIES.
37:19 WHY THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND
37:23 SECRETARY LUTNICK ALLOWED THIS LOOPHOLE TO
37:25 CONTINUE, WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO FIND OUT BUT
37:28 CERTAINLY, EVEN THOUGH HE HAS NO FINANCIAL
37:34 INTERESTS IN THE KANTER FITZGERALD COMPANY HE
37:36 FOUNDED MANY, MANY YEARS AGO, HIS FAMILY OWNS IT
37:41 NOW AND IN THE BACK OF HIS MIND HE KNOWS THAT
37:46 THESE DATA CENTERS WILL BENEFIT HIS FAMILY OR
37:49 WAS GOING EASY ON THEM THE RESULT OF BACK OF
37:53 MIND INFLUENCE BY THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION ON
37:56 THE WHITE HOUSE BECAUSE PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS
37:58 PROFITED TEN OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN NVIDIA
38:01 STOCK AND OF COURSE HERSELF CLOSE TO JENSEN
38:08 HUANG AND WAS PRESIDENT TRUMP INFLUENCED BY THAT
38:11 RELATIONSHIP WITH JENSEN HUANG?
38:13 WAS SECLUDED NICK INFLUENCED BY THAT
38:16 FRIENDSHIP WITH HUANG? KAILEY: DO YOU BELIEVE
38:23 SECRETARY LUTNICK IS COMPETENT TO CARRY OUT
38:30 THE JOB OF SECRETARY? >> RIGHT NOW CONGRESS
38:33 HAS SHUT DOWN THAT LOOPHOLE.
38:35 KAILEY: IT WAS WRITTEN BY THE TREASURY
38:39 DEPARTMENT, NOT BY THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT.
38:41 >> THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE TO CARRY IT OUT AND
38:43 CERTAINLY THE WHITE HOUSE WILL BE WATCHING
38:48 CAREFULLY TO ENSURE THAT THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT
38:50 PHENOMENONS THROUGH AND IMPLEMENTS IN TOUGHER
38:54 POLICY, WHICH WAS ACTUALLY PROPOSED BY THE
38:56 BIDEN ADMINISTRATION. JOE: IN IT'S PROVEN THAT
39:01 HOWARD LUTNICK TURNED THE OTHER WAY, SHOULD HE
39:05 LOSE HIS JOB OVER IT? >> THAT'S SOMETHING THAT
39:08 THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION AND THE PRESIDENT WILL
39:10 HAVE TO SIDE. I'M SURE THERE WILL BE A
39:14 LOT OF SCRUTINY FROM THE MEMBERS OF CONGRESS BUT
39:16 CERTAINLY IF THERE WAS A TRUE CONFLICT OF
39:18 INTERESTS. IF HE WAS MOTIVATED BY
39:20 THE FINANCIAL GAIN THAT HIS FAMILY WOULD HAVE
39:23 THEN THAT WOULD DISQUALIFY HIM AND
39:26 CERTAINLY IN A MATTER OF SUCH OUT MOST IMPORTANCE
39:28 TO NATIONAL SECURITY. JOE: APPRECIATE YOUR
39:31 DIRECT ANSWERS TO ALL THESE QUESTIONS.
39:35 GARY LOCKE, BACK TO SEE YOU BACK ON BLOOMBERG.
39:38 COMING UP, HAKEEM JEFFRIES ON THE CUSP OF
39:41 MAKING HISTORY AS DEMOCRATS PREPARE TO
39:43 TAKE POWER AND ALREADY LAYING THE GROUND FOR
39:46 WHAT THEY'LL DO WITH IT. NEW INVESTIGATIONS
39:50 TAKING SHAPE AND PLENTY FOR OUR POLITICAL PANEL
39:52 TO DIG INTO NEXT ON SHOW.
40:07 >> THE PEOPLE OF THIS
40:11 COUNTRY ARE DEMANDING BOLD, DRAMATIC AND
40:16 TRANSFORMATIONAL CHANGE. THE STATUS QUO ASK
40:19 UNACCEPTABLE. AND WE'RE COMMITTED TO
40:24 DELIVERING IN A MEANINGFUL WAY.
40:27 THE TYPE OF CHANGE THAT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE
40:32 DESERVE. JOE: IT'S "BALANCE OF
40:34 POWER" ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
40:37 ALONGSIDE KAILEY LEINZ, I'M JOE MATHIEU IN
40:39 WASHINGTON WHERE TODAY WE HEARD FROM HAKEEM
40:44 JEFFRIES, JUST NOMINATED BY HOUSE DEMOCRATS TO BE
40:47 THE NEXT SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE.
40:51 PROMISING TRANSFORMATIONAL CHANGE,
40:53 ON THE CUSP OF BECOMING THE FIRST BLACK SPEAKER
40:57 IN AMERICAN HISTORY. 11 DEMOCRATS VOTED
40:59 AGAINST HIM TODAY INCLUDELING SEVEN
41:03 INCOMING PROGRESSIVES WHO HAVE COME FORWARD
41:04 PUBLICLY. JOINING US NOW FOR MORE,
41:09 OUR POLITICAL PANEL, DEMOCRATIC STRATEGIST
41:18 KRISTIN HAWN AS WELL AS A REPUBLICAN STRATEGIST.
41:21 GREAT HAVING YOU. MARKING THIS MOMENT IS
41:23 IMPORTANT, TO THINK THAT WE'LL HAVE THE FIRST
41:26 BLACK SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE IN 2026, SECOND IN
41:28 LINE TO BECOME THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED
41:31 STATES IS REMARKABLE. >> YES, IT'S REMARKABLE
41:33 AND I WOULD BE REMISS IF I DIDN'T SAY WE'LL ALSO
41:37 HAVE THE FIRST WOMAN MAJORITY LEADER IN THE
41:39 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES IN KATHERINE CLARK, AND
41:45 IT'S A HUGE MILE SEEN AND I THINK HE WAS RIGHT
41:50 TO ASK FOR THOSE VOTES TODAY.
41:52 USUALLY YOU DON'T ASK FOR THOSE VOTES AND WE
41:54 WANT TO BE INCLUSIVE. WE HAVE A VERY DIFFERENT
41:58 CAUCUS COMING IN. JOE: HE DIDN'T GET A
42:02 UNANIMOUS VOTE LIKE NANCY PELOSI ONCE
42:03 ENJOYED. DOES THAT MATTER?
42:06 >> THEY'RE JUST OFF THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL AND A LOT
42:09 OF THESE MEMBERS HAVE NEVER GOVERNED BEFORE.
42:12 THERE'S A LOT TO LEARN. WHEN YOU GET ON THE
42:15 HOUSE FLOOR, YOU'RE WORKING WITH PEOPLE FROM
42:17 DIFFERENT STATES. IT WILL BE INTERESTING
42:22 TO SEE HOW THE VARIOUS PARTS OF THIS CONGRESS
42:26 ALL CAME TOGETHER BUT IF WE LOOK AT THE NUMBER OF
42:30 MEMBERS AND FOCUS ON THE D.S.A. MEMBERS AND SOME
42:33 WHO DIDN'T VOTE FOR HIM BUT THINK OF THE NUMBER
42:36 WHO DID. WE'RE AVOIDING THE
42:38 ENTIRE VACATION SITUATION ON THE FLOOR.
42:42 WE'VE GOTTEN THAT OUT OF THE WAY AND WE CAN MOVE
42:46 FORWARD WITH WHAT WE CAN POTENTIALLY DO AS
42:47 DEMOCRATS WITH DONALD TRUMP IN THE WHITE
42:49 HOUSE. KAILEY: LET'S TALK ABOUT
42:53 HOW EASY IT WILL BE FOR HAKEEM JEFFRIES TO BE
42:56 ABLE TO KEEP CONTROL OF A CAUCUS.
43:01 YOU CAN LOSE 11 OF THE VOTES AND STILL BE IN
43:03 CONTROL. THE FACT OF THE MATTER
43:06 IS THESE PROGRESSIVES CAN MAKE ALL THE NOISE
43:09 THEY WANT. HAKEEM JEFFRIES ISN'T
43:13 GOING TO NEED THEM. >> I THINK THAT'S TRUE
43:17 AND I THINK SPEAKER JOHNSON COULD LOOK AT
43:21 THIS WITH ENVY. I WILL SAY SPEAKER
43:23 JOHNSON DID DO A TREMENDOUS JOB WITH A
43:26 VERY, VERY NARROW MAJORITY.
43:27 WHETHER YOU LOOK AT WHAT HE WAS ABLE TO
43:30 ACCOMPLISH WITH JUST TWO OR THREE VOTES AND IF
43:33 SOMEONE CALLS IN SICK OR CAN'T MAKE IT.
43:36 HE REALLY DID DO QUITE A BIT.
43:39 I THINK SPEAKER JEFFRIES IS GOING TO FIND THAT
43:43 GOVERNING WITH THAT SORT OF LEEWAY HELPS TO GET
43:51 THINGS DONE. JOE: AT LEAST BLAKE
43:54 JOHNSON AND KEVIN MCCARTHY HAD A PRESIDENT
43:56 ON BOARD WITH THEIR AGENDA.
44:00 SO THAT'S TALK OF A SHUT DON.
44:03 ARE WE REALLY DOING THIS AGAIN?
44:05 DEMOCRATS ARE SAYING WE WON'T CAREER ANOTHER
44:06 FAMILIAR FOR IRAN. WHAT HAPPENS?
44:10 >> I PUT IT AT ABOUT 50-50.
44:11 I THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF DISCUSSIONS AND
44:13 FIGHTS AND DEALS THAT NEED TO GET DONE, I
44:17 WOULD HOPE NOT, BE EVER THE END OF THE YEAR.
44:20 JOE: THE FIRST PERSON WHO'S SAT HERE AND SAID
44:23 DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS DON'T WANT
44:25 TO SHUT DOWN. THAT'S NOT GOOD FOR
44:27 ANYONE. >> THEY WANT TO GO HOME
44:29 FOR CHRISTMAS. KAILEY: AND YET, WE'RE
44:33 FRESH OFF AN ELECTION IN WHICH THE AMERICANLEK
44:39 RATE MADE IT CLEAR THAT THEY AREN'T SUPPORTIVE
44:43 WITH THE WAR WITH IRAN AND DEMOCRATS ARE GOING
44:45 TO DO EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO REIN IT IN.
44:49 >> YES, THE AMERICAN PEOPLE MADE THEIR VOICES
44:52 LOUD AND CLEAR ABOUT THE WAR IN IRAN.
44:55 AT THE SAME TIME AMERICANS HATE
44:56 SHUTDOWNS. THEY HAVE AN
44:58 OPPORTUNITY, A LOT OF GOOD WILL.
45:03 I'M WONDERING HOW MUCH THEY'RE GOING TO WANTS
45:06 TO SQUANDER IN SHUTTING DOWN THINGS EVEN AS
45:09 PEOPLE ARE WANTING TO GO HOME FOR CHRISTMAS.
45:15 I'M NOT SURE 50-50 SOUNDS ABOUT RIGHT.
45:19 MAYBE 51-49 THAT WE DON'T HAVE A SHUTDOWN.
45:22 I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE CLOSE.
45:25 JOE: THE CHAOS AT THE AIRPORTS KIND OF
45:27 REMINDED EVERYONE WHAT IT'S LIKE TO HAVE A
45:29 SHUTDOWN. DOES THAT HELP KEEP THE
45:32 GOVERNMENT OPEN? >> I THINK PEOPLE JUST
45:35 WANTS TO HAVE A GOVERNMENT THAT WORKS.
45:38 THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION STARTED TO GO WITH WRONG
45:41 AWAY WITH THE BOTCHED PULLOUT OF AFGHANISTAN.
45:44 IT FELT LIKE THINGS WEREN'T WORKING.
45:46 IT FEELS THAT WAY A LITTLE BIT NOW.
45:48 I THINK MAYBE THAT WASN'T THE DECIDING
45:51 ISSUE BUT IT CERTAINLY HELPED DEMOCRATS TWO
45:52 WEEKS AGO. THE GROUNDS STOPPAGE,
45:55 THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WANT TO KEEP GOVERNMENT OPEN.
45:58 KAILEY: WE JUST SPOKE WITH THE CHAIR OF THE
46:02 SENATE BUDGETS COMMITTEE RON JOHNSON WHO SAID
46:03 REPUBLICANS WANTS TO GIVE DEMOCRATS A LAST
46:07 CHANCE TO GET BEHIND A DEFENSE SUPPLEMENTAL
46:10 BEFORE THEY DECIDE TO GET BEHIND A SHUTDOWN.
46:17 IS THERE ANY QUESTION IN YOUR MIND THAT DEMOCRATS
46:20 WOULDN'T GET BEHIND THAT?
46:22 >> THERE ARE SUBSTANTIAL CONVERSATIONS THAT NEED
46:25 TO BE HAD BEHIND CLOSED DOORS.
46:27 YES, THERE IS A MANDATE AROUND THE WAR BUT THE
46:31 THING IS, ONCE YOU'RE IN IT, YOU DON'T WANT TO DO
46:34 ANYTHING IRRESPONSIBLE. PRESIDENT TRUMP GOT US
46:37 INTO FROM SITUATION. FOR WHATEVER REASON,
46:39 WE'RE HERE AND THE DEMOCRATS ARE TRYING TO
46:42 FIGURE OUT -- WE'RE LOOKING FORWARD TO A
46:45 PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL MAJORITY.
46:47 WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO NOW?
46:50 AND THERE'S THE POLICY CALCULATION THAT ALL
46:51 THOSE MEMBERS HAVE TO MAKE WITH REPUBLICANS
46:54 AND DEMOCRATS AS THEY'RE DECIDING HOW TO GET OUT
46:56 OF THIS. I THINK IT'S YET TO BE
46:59 SEEN. JOE: MARY PAL TOLLA OF
47:03 ALASKA IT APPEARS IS COMING TO WASHINGTON.
47:06 NINE SEATS, THE BIGGEST HAUL FOR DEMOCRATS IN 50
47:09 YEARS. THE BALANCE IS 66-44 IN
47:13 THE UPPER CLAIM PER. INTERESTING TO NOTE, THE
47:16 FINAL COUNTS, SAVED BY THE BELL, MARY PELTOLA,
47:20 THE DIVIDE BETWEEN HER AND SENATOR SULLIVAN WAS
47:23 GREATER THAN THE VOTES ACQUIRED BY THE OTHER
47:28 DAN SENATOR, THE FOURTH NAME ON THE BALLOT BUT
47:31 THE DODGE SAYS THE INVESTIGATION WILL
47:32 CONTINUE. IS THAT IN THE
47:36 THEY BELIEVE THERE'S CRIMINALITY HERE.
47:40 >> THEY DO. IT CERTAINLY MIKE
47:42 UNTOWARD BEHAVIOR AND CERTAINLY NOT ABOVE
47:45 BOARD ESPECIALLY WHEN IT CAME OUT, DESPITE WHAT
47:51 SHE MAY HAVE SAID. THAT PELTOLA AND
47:54 DEMOCRATS WERE ALL AWARE OF THIS.
48:01 THAT SAID, ALWAYS FAIR IN POLITICS.
48:10 >> MARY TELL TOLLA IS A QUINTESSENTIAL ALASKA
48:12 NATIVE. SHE HAS A PRETTY TRAGIC
48:16 STORY WITH HER HUSBAND AND WHAT HAPPENED BUT
48:19 SHE'S ALWAYS HAD HER EYE ON THE BALL.
48:22 IF YOU ASKED HER WHAT'S THE MOST IMPORTANT THING
48:24 IN YOUR ELECTION SHE'S LIKE FISHING.
48:26 I'M SERIOUS. NOBODY KNOWS THAT
48:30 STATEMENT BETTER SO WHEN EVERYBODY WAS ASKING ME
48:32 BEFORE THE ELECTION WHO'S GOING TO WIN, MARY
48:36 PELTOLA. KAILEY: YOU DIDN'T HAVE
48:39 THAT SAME CONFIDENCE ABOUT TEXAS.
48:42 ELON MUSK IS SPEAKING RIGHT NOW AT "NEW YORK
48:46 TIMES" BOOK SUMMIT AND HE SAYS HE FEELS PRETTY
48:51 FOOLISH ABOUT HIS POLITICAL SPENDING GIVEN
48:53 WHAT HAPPENED IN TEXAS WHERE HE BURNED HUNDREDS
48:56 OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND DEMOCRATS WINNING
49:01 ANY NUMBER OF RACES DESPITE THAT HE SAID HE
49:03 BELIEVES THINGS WILL BE FINE WITH THE DEMOCRATIC
49:06 GOVERNOR BUT DO YOU THINK HE HAS REASON TO
49:09 FEEL FOOLISH RIGHT NOW? >> I DON'T KNOW FOOLISH
49:13 BUT HE PUT HIS MONEY WHERE HIS MOUTH IS.
49:16 IMAGE WE DEFINITELY LEARNED THAT PRIMARIES
49:19 MATTER, CANDIDATES MATTER AND THAT
49:20 REPUBLICANS WOULD PROBABLY BE WELL SERVED
49:23 TO LEARN THE LESSONS FROM NOT NECESSARILY
49:27 PUTTING THROUGH THE STRONGEST CANDIDATE, AT
49:29 LEAST IN THE SENATE RACE AND IT HAD
49:32 REVERBERATIONS ALL DOWN THE TICKET.
49:35 JOE: HE ALSO SAID HE DIDN'T ANY JENSEN HUANG
49:38 WAS DISLOYAL TO THE UNITED STATES.
49:41 JENSEN IS GOING TO BE ON CAPITOL HILL FIRST OF
49:42 DECEMBER, I BELIEVE IS THE DATE, FOR CLOSED-
49:48 CLOSED-DOOR TESTIMONY. WILL THAT, WE ASKED LORI
49:53 TRAHAN HELP TO ACCELERATE ANY OF THESE
49:55 EXPORT CONTROL BILLS? THREE OF THEM ARE
49:58 SITTING IN THE HOUSE. >> FOR SO MANY ASPECTS
50:01 TO THIS ISSUE. YOU'RE DEALING WITH A
50:05 POTENTIAL SPY ISSUE, AND THE PUBLIC RESPONDING TO
50:06 THIS. THE AMERICAN PEOPLE, WE
50:09 KNOW FROM THE LAST ELECTION, FROM THE
50:12 RESEARCH THAT MY TERM DID IS THAT THE PEOPLE
50:16 DO NOT TRUST THESE C.E.O.'S.
50:19 THEY DO NOT TRUST MAJERUS AND COMPANIES
50:22 WHERE IT LARGE AND WHAT THEY'RE ASKING FOR IS
50:26 NOT NECESSARILY TESTIMONY FROM THE
50:28 ADMINISTRATION AND ADMINISTRATION OFFICIALS
50:28 SOMEWHAT BUT THEY REALLY HOLD A LOT OF THESE
50:33 MAJOR COMPANIES AND C.E.O.'S ACCOUNTABLE FOR
50:35 THE ISSUES THEY DEAL WITH DAY-TO-DAY, RIGHT
50:37 OR WRONG. SO I WOULD LOOK AT THAT
50:41 WHEN IT COMES TO WHETHER THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AND
50:44 ELECTED OFFICIALS ARE HEARING FROM THEIR
50:47 CONSTITUENTS ABOUT WHETHER THESE THINGS
50:49 SHOULD MOVE FORWARD. KAILEY: DO C.E.O.'S HAVE
50:53 SOMETHING TO FEAR FROM THIS NEW CONGRESS?
50:55 >> THE NORTHWESTERN PEOPLE, DEMOCRAT,
50:58 REPUBLICAN, INDEPENDENT. THERE'S REAL CORN AND
51:04 REAL DISTRUST WITH LARGE INSTITUTIONS, BIG
51:06 GOVERNMENT AND YEAH, BIG EXCHANGES AHEAD.
51:08 KAILEY: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US AND
51:11 WE'LL SEE YOU BACK HERE TOMORROW ON "BALANCE OF
51:13 POWER" ON BLOOMBERG TV
Seesaw Day for Markets, Anthropic IPO Looms full transcript
0:01 The countdown is on. Everything you need to get the edge at
0:05 the end of the market day. This is the close.
0:11 Add another ticker to your watch list. It's spelled anti.
0:15 Live from studio two here at Bloomberg headquarters in New York.
0:18 I'm Romaine Bostick and I'm Vonnie Quinn.
0:20 We're kicking you off the closing bell here in the United States.
0:22 The last closing bell before anthropic goes public, right?
0:25 Well, we did put to bed some of the concerns for the AI trade with the
0:29 Nvidia call yesterday. It's not really helping in video stock
0:32 though. It starts out higher and it's been on
0:34 the decline ever since. Old session that also isn't helping the
0:37 Nasdaq 100, which is in a very choppy session, currently up about 2/10 of a
0:41 percent. But as you see the S&P 500 down 3/10 of
0:44 1%, consumer discretionary and particularly
0:48 at IT security names doing well. And we're obviously getting Palo Alto
0:51 Networks earnings after the bell. Now this even as yields decline in the
0:56 Valley and the long end we're actually unchanged right now on the two year
0:59 yield. We've had several, said officials
1:01 talking about rate hikes. And in fact, we got minutes that
1:03 suggested that nearly all are expecting more rate hikes.
1:05 Wall are talking up 50 basis points and Brent crude on the decline once again as
1:10 well. And even that isn't really helping the
1:12 balance space given everything that's going on romaine.
1:14 Let's put this together holistically here because it has been a seesaw day
1:17 for markets all day long, with volatility high and expected future
1:21 volatility priced in even higher. And that really does limit the amount of
1:25 money that some funds can actually put to work.
1:27 And that keeps a lid on the upside. And then when we talk about the eye
1:31 trade, the skepticism over Nvidia making good on those forecasts, well that
1:35 deepens the potential downside. Investors they want to try to find some
1:38 balance there. Try to calculate what a downshift from
1:41 sixth gear to maybe fifth gear in the AI builder actually means for how you
1:46 actually allocate around this eye trade. Now, one interesting read that came up
1:50 earlier today was actually in the metals market, believe it or not, copper
1:54 futures plunging the most in 19 months. Investors unwinding bets that data
1:58 centers, power grids, electrification have guaranteed a demand supercycle.
2:04 This is not a question of supply. Physical copper inventories.
2:08 They are tight as they've ever been. But it is a question of confidence.
2:11 Confidence in the future of I demand. And how much of that demand was already
2:16 embedded in cross asset prices. And then of course, at some point, as
2:21 Vonnie mentioned, we're going to get, well, anthropic and we're going to find
2:25 out exactly what price Wall Street thinks.
2:27 Anthropic is worth $70, $78 more. The IPO reportedly about seven times
2:34 oversubscribed. But tonight's order book it only answers
2:37 whether investors will provide that capital.
2:39 It doesn't answer whether that capital earns an adequate return of return.
2:44 That could potentially be lessened if if anthropic pulls the space and seeks to
2:49 raise additional money post IPO, that would potentially ding the multiples for
2:54 all those investors who will be snatching up the shares on day one.
2:59 One thing about anthropic that I think people are missing is they probably
3:03 don't need to come to market again. Oh, really?
3:06 That's right. You don't you don't think we'll see
3:08 another offering from the debt market, or you're not ready to take on debt or
3:12 equity from here on out, because they will have 300 and some billion dollars
3:15 in cash, and they're generating their own cash flow internally.
3:21 Uncle Crawford there earlier this week talking about her expectations for what
3:25 comes next for anthropic. Let's bring in Bill Campbell, head of
3:28 Double lines global sovereign and emerging markets team.
3:31 And Bill. I wanted to start there.
3:32 This is obviously an equity story. But as we've seen with the AI build out,
3:36 it is much larger than that. And I do want to get the sense here as
3:40 to sort of what your expectations are, not so much as to whether anthropic
3:44 comes back to the market, but whether the AI build out rich, large, writ large
3:49 can be funded through equity issuance, or whether that combination of equity,
3:54 debt and whatever else we're doing off balance sheet is still warranted.
3:59 Romaine, thank you for having me on. And I think that is, uh, the key
4:03 question of how much farther, uh, can we take our growth expectations, uh, you
4:09 know, underwritten by the say, I build out, given all the new information that
4:12 we've had, uh, you know, anthropic, you know, potentially there's a green shoot
4:16 there. But the bigger question was your first
4:18 story with Nvidia. Um, some of the I think some of the
4:23 critical, uh, work that we're taking a look at right now is the financing that
4:27 Nvidia provided, uh, you know, across, uh, you know, all of the NIO clouds, uh,
4:32 that we're using Nvidia financing, uh, you know, as part of their capital
4:36 structure with, uh, you know, we've had Jensen step down.
4:40 You have, uh, you know, Colette stepping in as CEO, but only interim CEO.
4:44 There's a big question as to, you know, how much of that financing can be
4:48 supportive to this trade going forward. And then we also have questions about,
4:53 uh, a lot of the, uh, regulatory scrutiny from the DOJ Commerce
4:57 Department. Uh, you know, the investigations that
5:00 will come in. But yet yesterday we saw the Commerce
5:03 Department, uh, come out with the requirement that, uh, new, uh, exports
5:08 to Southeast Asia and Brazil are going to require licensing, uh, from the
5:13 United States. And I think there's a question as well
5:16 to the growth model, uh, you know, uh, with these new potentially, uh, you
5:21 know, they could be potentially large regulatory constraints, uh, with all of
5:25 those, you know, questions continuing to swirl around in markets.
5:28 Uh, I may be going to turn it from an equity, uh, from an equity to a credit
5:32 discussion in credit markets. What we're seeing is much more
5:36 differentiation. The market is being much more discerning
5:40 about companies that are coming to market, asking for financing.
5:43 Uh, you know, we are seeing now more efficient tearing in credit markets,
5:47 which is providing opportunities, uh, you know, across various, uh, you know,
5:52 sectors of fixed income, which make it a very interesting place to, uh, you know,
5:56 invest among this uncertainty today. Well, we'll drill down a little bit more
6:00 into that bill, because, I mean, we talk about Nvidia's financing commitments.
6:03 It's still a rated company. I know Jeff Gundlach has been pretty
6:07 vocal about anthropic, not necessarily, uh, deserving an investment grade credit
6:12 rating, though it'll probably get one. But when you look at opportunity and you
6:15 talk about the dispersion in the credit space right now, where specifically are
6:19 you finding that? Is that more in, uh, the hyperscale or
6:22 is it more in the data center? Operator is with kind of the long term
6:25 leases. Is this a duration story and I model
6:28 story what? Uh, it's a great question.
6:31 And what I will say is it's idiosyncratic.
6:34 We are going name by name, story by story.
6:37 And, uh, you know, I guess there's never a bad story.
6:41 It's just a matter of, you know, having a bad price.
6:44 And one thing that we've seen is, uh, you know, uh, we've had quite a few, uh,
6:49 you know, issuance come to market that is now, uh, traded.
6:52 Uh, you know, that we've seen significant spread widening or that
6:55 price of the bonds have fallen significantly.
6:58 Uh, that, you know, are providing, uh, you know, some opportunities for us, uh,
7:02 you know, across, uh, you know, uh, both, uh, the IG and, uh, you know, high
7:07 yield space in U.S. markets.
7:09 Additionally, we look at, uh, you know, structured products, especially the ABS
7:13 market. Again, deal specific.
7:16 Uh, you know, we are, uh, putting pencil to paper.
7:19 Uh, you know, trying to find, uh, you know what, uh, you know, parts of the
7:23 capital structure make the most sense. What deals make the most sense?
7:27 Uh, internationally, I've been surprised when we look at, uh, international
7:31 credit markets. Uh, the widening that we've seen in U.S.
7:36 credit spreads. Uh, you know, we haven't seen that
7:40 transmit as aggressively. Uh, you know, to, uh, international
7:44 credit markets such as the emerging market in space.
7:47 Uh, that's been a little bit surprising. But, you know, you do have, uh, you
7:52 know, a fundamental backdrop. Uh, you know, in these, uh, large
7:56 emerging markets that when they're in a better fiscal and, uh, you know, uh,
8:01 potentially growth, uh, position. Secondly, uh, the issuance, uh, in
8:06 emerging markets, sovereigns has been mostly in the sovereign space, not the
8:10 corporate space. So that is also, uh, provided a
8:12 technical factor that has been supportive.
8:15 So across all of those segments of the credit market, uh, we are being, uh,
8:19 very selective and idiosyncratic. And it's been a story by story name for
8:23 us. Yeah.
8:24 I want to ask you about the dollar impact on Em debt as well.
8:27 But first, the ECB coming out with its financial stability review and saying
8:31 it's actually seeing parallels to the subprime mortgage crisis, that this $4
8:35 trillion is now off balance sheet commitments, well in excess of on
8:39 balance sheet commitments and that there's a massive risk of abrupt
8:43 repricing episodes. That's the language that the ECB uses.
8:46 Is that an overstatement? Are you actually concerned about that
8:49 too? I think the ECB is right to point out
8:54 that, uh, you know, there are a lot of contingent liabilities throughout the
8:58 system. And we've been, uh, you know,
9:00 highlighting our concerns. Uh, you know, about, uh, you know, all
9:04 of, uh, you know, the contingent liabilities, uh, that, uh, you know, are
9:08 attached to either the hyperscale or build out and, uh, you know, just
9:12 private credit in general. But, uh, that being said, um, what I
9:17 look at growth, uh, you know, across the board, uh, it still remains support,
9:23 very well supported. And, uh, you know, I think that that,
9:27 you know, uh, at least in the near term, helps to balance out a lot of the, uh,
9:32 you know, risks that, you know, we see as potentially building, uh, you know,
9:37 on the excess in, uh, you know, in credit, I think if we can maintain a
9:42 growth rate of about two, 2.5%. Uh, into next year.
9:46 And as long as we have China, uh, you know, not completely fall out of bed.
9:51 Yes, they're slowing, but, uh, you know, maintain a growth rate, uh, you know,
9:55 somewhere in the range of 4%, 4.5%. And then Europe, uh, there's a lot of
10:01 fiscal stimulus, uh, in play in Europe that, uh, you know, should continue to
10:06 support growth into 2027. Uh, you know, right now the markets are
10:11 starting to price in, uh, much more draconian scenarios.
10:15 And although the risks that you point out in the Financial Stability report,
10:19 uh, you know, exist, uh, that doesn't mean that all credits are bad.
10:24 I think you can find, uh, today tremendous opportunity in each sector.
10:29 But it's, uh, again, much more of a name specific story and requires, uh, you
10:35 know, active management with, uh, teams of analysts that can go through,
10:39 evaluate, uh, you know, the outlook for the company, the ability to service
10:42 them. That's the thing though.
10:44 I mean, there is a draconian outcome being expressed in markets.
10:48 You look at the copper market that remain was talking about earlier.
10:50 You look at the dollar, which has had a huge amount of strengthening.
10:53 And if we do get this trickle, which is turning into a flood of fed governors
10:58 and presidents talking up more interest rate hikes sooner.
11:01 Won't that put even more pressure on the space?
11:04 Uh, it could, but let me, uh, you know, just level set a little bit.
11:08 Uh, right now the fed is pricing and the market is pricing in three hikes for the
11:12 fed, which I think is pretty fair. So if you look at a December 25th basis
11:16 point hike, a January 25th basis point hike, and then maybe you get a March
11:20 25th basis point hike, even if the fed delivers on that, they're delivering
11:24 where the market is. Uh, you know, at today, uh, when we look
11:28 at the copper drawdown, uh, I think that kind of makes sense in the, uh, you
11:32 know, overall context, one China growth, uh, you know, has taken a bit of a
11:37 downshift and that needed to be priced in to markets.
11:40 And then the questions about, you know, AI hyperscalers and how long and durable
11:45 that, uh, you know, investment pipeline will be.
11:48 You know, those are both credible questions.
11:49 And as you know, Stanley Druckenmiller brought attention, uh, you know, to that
11:53 which I think caused a little bit more of a washout.
11:56 That being said, as long as we don't go into a global recession, uh, you could
12:00 be entering some very interesting valuation points, uh, you know, today.
12:04 So I don't think we should be, you know, whole scale, uh, you know, uh, it just
12:09 selling everything I think it is right now a good idea to be looking at
12:14 balancing your portfolio, maybe taking some of those questions in the equity
12:18 market, taking some of that risk. Put it to work in a smart, fixed income,
12:21 actively managed portfolio where you can pick up healthy yields between 6 and
12:26 7.5% with a fairly low duration. Uh, I do want to sort of, uh, circle
12:31 back, though, to how just I fits into all this and I don't necessarily mean it
12:35 from the IPO, but more from the contributions that we've been seeing to
12:39 the economy and to a certain extent, if you believe some of the fed speakers,
12:42 maybe, uh, some of the drag we're getting because of the inflationary
12:45 pressures, does that become something? Does that become a problem for the fed,
12:50 or is that more a problem for investors themselves to to find a balance?
12:55 Yeah, I think it's the I trade. I think, you know, first of all, it's
13:00 very complex. Uh, you know, I know that there are
13:03 interesting research papers that are focusing on the potential pass through
13:06 to inflation, uh, you know, from the I trade, but I would argue that there is,
13:11 uh, now, my bigger concern, actually, is the pass through from higher oil prices,
13:15 from this energy price shock showing second round pass through to core goods.
13:20 Uh, you know, when we actually look at the higher transportation costs, uh, the
13:24 other thing is I it's not all bad. One, it increases productivity too.
13:28 You are getting construction jobs. That is also helping to support more of
13:32 the consumption side of the economy. So when we see, uh, you know, the
13:35 drivers of, uh, you know, GDP growth. Yes, there's the investment I side, but
13:40 also there's this very strong consumption side as well.
13:43 So as long as we can kind of keep a balance and not let, uh, you know, uh, a
13:49 eye, uh, disruption disrupt global growth or, you know, let it get too
13:55 frothy where, you know, you build up the imbalances that the ECB is talking
13:58 about. And the bubble pops.
14:00 Uh, you know, there still is a there still is a path that, you know, the
14:04 markets can work their way through, uh, the current episode that we're seeing.
14:09 And I can also be a, you know, a net positive contributor in 2027 to, uh,
14:15 global economic growth bill. Always a pleasure.
14:17 Bill Campbell, head of global sovereign and emerging markets team, on a day
14:21 where we see a mixed day in the equity markets and to a mixed day going on in
14:26 fixed income, yields are lower on the day.
14:29 A rally on the back of some of that commentary by fed members.
14:32 But a big focus today on anthropic and the big IPO pricing we're expecting
14:36 after the bell. We hit it from all angles, including
14:39 from the corporate governance angle and, well, whether this thing should have
14:41 ever been listed. SEC Chair Gary Gensler going to be
14:45 joining us in just a bit. Thus, we're live with Silicon Valley
14:48 royalty. Clara Sheen, former head of AI at both
14:51 Salesforce and Meta, gives us an insider's take into this blockbuster
14:54 IPO. And on that, the lead sheet is Citi.
14:58 And we're going to hear a little bit later in the day from the CEO of Citi,
15:01 Jane Frazier. She's going to talk about the bank's
15:03 role in the AI buildout and so much more.
15:06 Stick with us. This is the close on Bloomberg.
15:24 All right. One of the more revealing elements of
15:26 the anthropic IPO. IPO might not be the valuation, but
15:29 really about the idea of who's being left out.
15:32 Institutional investors based in mainland China excluded from
15:36 participating. That is the backdrop for President Trump
15:39 landing in China earlier today, ahead of a bilateral meeting with XI Jinping.
15:43 That sit down between the world leaders comes as the U.S.
15:46 moves to curb China's access to AI chips and, well, even to the IPO itself.
15:51 Here, we at 11 joins us right now, senior fellow at the Freeman Chair in
15:55 China Studies over on the C as a center for Strategic and International Studies.
16:00 And we should point out also former director for China at the white House
16:04 National Security council and Henrietta, I do want to start there.
16:07 There. Where exactly is the national security
16:09 issue here? Well, look, China wants to use US
16:15 technology, US semiconductors and other US.
16:19 I know how to hurt American national security to hurt our allies.
16:24 And traditionally, Washington has seen it as a government responsibility to
16:27 prevent China from doing that. Now, the picture with this
16:30 administration, as I'm sure we'll talk about is a little more complicated.
16:33 Well, I am curious about this idea of what the I market is right now.
16:37 You have the US, basically, uh, defining this as a national security issue on the
16:42 frontier. China, I believe, does the same thing.
16:44 And there are several other nations and regions that have also done the same.
16:48 How do you have a global in quotation marks?
16:51 I build out when every nation is seems to be so fearful right now, uh, of one
16:56 of their rivals getting their hands on technology.
17:00 Yeah. Well, look, it's
17:02 when you think about global I supply chain semiconductor supply chains,
17:06 there's no way the U.S. can succeed without very close
17:10 cooperation with like minded partners around the world.
17:13 So even as the administration is taking really important steps, uh, a little
17:17 late, but important steps to prevent China from having dangerous access to
17:22 U.S. technology.
17:23 What also needs to happen is deeper cooperation, uh, with the Netherlands,
17:28 with Japan, with Korea, with countries that own critical parts of the
17:33 semiconductor supply chain, and maybe most importantly, with Taiwan.
17:38 Um, so this can't be just a America versus China conversation in which when
17:42 we talk about the American AI ecosystem, I mean, what we're really talking about
17:47 is close cooperation between the US, Taiwan and other countries around the
17:52 world. This isn't something we can do alone.
17:54 And we had a the pictures are very warm between the two leaders, right.
17:57 XI going out of his way to welcome Donald Trump.
18:00 But it's the authorities sort of behind the scenes that are working towards some
18:06 kind of progress. What will we hear in terms of a
18:10 deliverable for the US and a deliverable for China out of this meeting?
18:15 So you hear real mixed messages on this. I think President Trump is very focused
18:20 on maintaining warm ties between himself and the Chinese president.
18:25 Um, Trump really thinks that the best way to solve global problems is by
18:30 building a friendship with Xi Jinping. The unfortunate thing is that she does
18:34 not see the world that way. He is really trying to take advantage of
18:38 Trump, including to gain additional access to U.S.
18:41 technology. So you'll see, even as the Commerce
18:45 Department back in Washington is taking steps to make sure, for example, Chinese
18:49 companies cannot access high end U.S. chips through the cloud through other
18:54 smuggling networks. Um, Trump is trying to really
18:58 de-emphasize those tensions. He wants a nice meeting with XI, but I
19:03 can't imagine that the Chinese will not bring up these new restrictions.
19:07 And so even though Trump wants the appearance of stability in his China
19:12 relationship, the reality is that the point of friction between these two
19:17 countries are only growing. And even in the past few days, we've
19:21 seen real sources of tension. What's the danger, Henry, out of the
19:24 China starts using rare earths as leverage again.
19:27 The last time that happened, it created, you know, a global ruckus.
19:31 I mean, Trump was talking about taking over Greenland.
19:35 This is a critical question. So think back to when Trump and she met
19:40 in Busan, South Korea last year. Um, a big part of the deal they struck
19:46 was that China would would stop restricting U.S.
19:49 access to critical minerals, which we need for basically our entire
19:52 manufacturing sector. And in exchange, the United States would
19:56 not take new actions to restrict the export of U.S.
20:00 semiconductors to China. Now, that was kind of an implicit
20:03 understanding. It wasn't written in text, but it was
20:06 pretty widely understood. And at least that's what Beijing thinks
20:09 they were signing up to. So China is going to think that the US
20:13 broke their side of the deal. So they now are faced with a question do
20:16 they escalate? Do they continue to restrict access to
20:21 critical minerals to rare earths as they did last year Or does China bet they can
20:27 get more concessions from Trump on important strategic issues, perhaps on
20:31 Taiwan if they keep relations warm? And that is a decision that she and his
20:36 team are going to have to make going into this bilateral meeting overnight.
20:41 Henrietta. Appreciate it.
20:42 Henrietta Levin, senior fellow over at the CAC, is then, of course, a former a
20:47 member of the National Security Council covering China issues.
20:51 There's a lot of talk right now about anthropic destined to be at least the
20:54 second biggest IPO in U.S. history.
20:57 But believe it or not, it could actually be overshadowed by something else.
21:01 One of the biggest entertainment releases ever.
21:04 Grand Theft Auto six. That conversation.
21:06 Up next. Right after the break.
21:07 Right here on the close.
21:21 Time now for our top goals. The big movers on the back of analysts
21:25 recommendations. We start off with TJX and Truist
21:27 reiterated its buy rating after a third quarter earnings report that blew a lot
21:31 of people away. TJX shares now having their single best
21:35 day since November 2020. Next up, let's take a look at Nvidia
21:40 Morgan Stanley trimming its price target to 260 from 267, but says Nvidia's
21:44 forward looking commentary is still a significant positive.
21:48 Investors still significantly negative. The shares down for a fifth straight
21:51 day. And last but not least.
21:53 Take-Two interactive several firms reiterating their buy ratings on the
21:56 back of near perfect reviews for Grand Theft Auto six, which will finally be
22:01 released to the public tomorrow. Take-Two shares having a pretty good day
22:05 up about 6.5%. And Bonnie, we should point out, it's
22:09 anthropic about six years to go from creation to public markets.
22:13 This game took ten years, two years, but apparently was worth the wait.
22:17 But you got to feel sorry for the people who are taking a day off to play this
22:21 and feel sorry for them? I'm envious of them.
22:23 No, I might be something else tomorrow. Yeah.
22:26 Love is like, is giving employees a day off, you know, good for the games.
22:30 But what is Bloomberg going for employers?
22:32 What if you want to be involved in the anthropic IPO.
22:34 And you also wanted to look at this game.
22:36 You would be so stuck until lunchtime tomorrow.
22:38 I'll wait for day to day one for Rockstar and take two.
22:42 Anyway, it'll be competing for a lot of attention tomorrow.
22:45 Our attention, though, still remains on the pricing for anthropic, which is
22:49 going to come after the bell tonight. A conversation with former SEC Chair
22:52 Gary Gensler.
23:02 All right. Today is a day where we're going to
23:04 learn how Wall Street prices the value of anthropic.
23:08 Gary Gensler, of course, spent a lot of time on Wall Street, an M&A banker over
23:13 at Goldman before going to Washington. He led the CFTC and he led the SEC and a
23:18 lot of the issues that he had to deal with in Washington.
23:21 Investors are going to have to deal with tonight as they try to put a price tag
23:24 on anthropic, from a stacked corporate governance structure to the retail
23:28 allegation to a lot of questions right now about the risk disclosures in that
23:32 S-1 filing. I had a chance to catch up with them
23:35 earlier today. Here's what he had to say.
23:38 It is a very interesting day, but you raise issues about corporate governance.
23:43 And we've just seen this play out at Nvidia.
23:45 Board of directors took a move. They thought they had to take that move
23:49 with a CEO that had misled the public, misled the board, and maybe risked the
23:54 company and national security. And yet, over here at anthropic, there's
23:59 this, uh, tight group, the seven people that founded it, uh, that are somewhat
24:04 insulated from corporate governance. Not completely, but somewhat insulated.
24:09 Well, I am curious about that. When we talk about what the role of
24:13 financial regulators are, particularly the SEC, when it comes to public
24:17 companies. do these corporate governance issues,
24:19 like the one we saw play out at Nvidia. And the revelation that I think a lot of
24:24 us ignore that this company actually hadn't had an independent board chair
24:28 ever. Are these things that the SEC itself can
24:31 force upon these companies, or do they still have the optionality based on what
24:36 investors are willing to accept? Well, it's, uh, it's a mix.
24:41 To answer your question. Uh, the SEC role and the laws roles are
24:45 to make sure that there's full transparency on material risk and
24:49 material factors. That's where I think Nvidia also, uh,
24:53 let the shareholders down and misled the public, frankly.
24:57 But I think there are some roles that, um, Congress gave the SEC in terms of
25:02 shareholder democracy and being able to weigh in and vote for directors and vote
25:07 for significant issues. But for a long time, if companies want
25:11 two classes of shares, um, that's something that the companies decide and
25:15 decide with the capital markets whether to have two classes of shares.
25:20 Do I love it when I'm investing in a company?
25:24 I think it's better when there's, uh, equal weighted and, uh, it keeps
25:29 management just a little bit more attuned to all of the investors.
25:32 Well, I'm curious, though. I mean, anthropic seems to be pushing
25:35 that. And it's not just anthropic.
25:36 There are other companies that are testing the limits of that, but we're
25:39 talking about five share classes. By the time this thing goes public, uh,
25:42 starts trading tomorrow. And I am curious that when you have
25:45 basically, uh, founders controlling a majority of the vote, a trust, picking
25:49 the board majority, the public, I guess, still gets the economics of this.
25:53 It raises the larger question, not so much about regulation, but why the
25:56 exchanges themselves are willing to list this, particularly when some of their
26:01 own rules, uh, with regards to what is required for listing, seem to be bent a
26:07 little bit to favor these companies. Look, part of it was just competition.
26:11 When I started in the financial markets, you saw the New York Stock Exchange
26:15 really had a one share, one vote, uh, attitude.
26:20 Um, and as you saw, the growth of a competitor Nasdaq, uh, than the New York
26:27 Stock Exchange backed away from that. And uh, so it would have to be an issue
26:31 if the capital markets all came together or, uh, legislators came together.
26:36 Um, but I would say this about American capitalism.
26:39 It's really an exceptional thing how well we can finance long term,
26:44 innovative companies that look like anthropic, like Nvidia, and so forth.
26:49 Um, I may have talked to you in the past and still feel that this investment boom
26:54 will turn to, uh, a bust at some point in time and circle back.
26:59 Um, but but our capital markets really are the envy of the world.
27:04 Uh, financing innovation. We'll talk a little bit more about that.
27:07 We talk a lot about that on this program, with a lot of those people who
27:10 are actually doing the financing and most of them, for the most part, are
27:15 relatively comfortable with where we stand right now.
27:18 They have some issues around the edges, but they seem to think that the price
27:22 discovery, the risk taking on and the disclosures with regards to that risk
27:26 and their view at least is appropriate based on the compensation or at least
27:30 the potential compensation that they get.
27:32 Long term, that's how you see it. Well, let me say this.
27:36 This is the beauty of capital markets. We can have a different points of view.
27:40 And, um, I have a different point of view, uh, on this broad thing.
27:47 I think history tells us that our capital markets fund in advance of the
27:53 revenue showing up. And let's take it back to anthropic.
27:56 They have $895 billion of forward commitments.
28:00 Now it's over many, many years, of course, but that's a lot of operating
28:04 leverage. And then the question is can they get
28:07 the revenues to support those commitments and they're doing well now.
28:12 But we even saw in Q3 that their gross margins went down and they went from a
28:18 profitable second quarter to a not profitable third quarter.
28:22 Now they've got a lot of commitments. There's huge demand for the
28:29 intelligence, the tokens, the inference. But they've got China competing with
28:34 them. Uh, they've got a lot of other companies
28:36 open AI, uh, Google X, AI and so forth that want to take part of that market
28:43 share. But I am curious though, too.
28:44 I mean, you bring up almost $900 billion in forward commitments.
28:48 And yesterday in this program, we were talking about Nvidia's commitments close
28:52 to $400 billion, I believe. Last time I looked and how important
28:57 that company and for that matter, the CEO was, uh, to the broader AI
29:01 ecosystem, anthropic has that same sort of flywheel effect to a certain extent.
29:06 And I am curious is why should I not look at anthropic or Nvidia as
29:10 potentially systemically, uh, risky entities.
29:16 Well, on the supply side, the semiconductor side, uh, they have real
29:21 cash flows. And yes, they're putting their balance
29:25 sheet to work to help their, uh, vendors, what they're selling.
29:30 I think there will be some breakage, whether it's in the cloud providers
29:34 called Nio cloud. Uh, I know it's sort of the favorite
29:37 company to raise core. We.
29:39 But there's dozens of others of these. But now on anthropic, they don't have
29:44 that cash flow yet. And there is more risk, I think, in the
29:48 system there around OpenAI and anthropic.
29:52 Can they maintain and get the revenues. There's various economic estimates that
29:57 by 2030 they would have to be somewhere in the vicinity of $3 trillion of
30:03 revenue flowing for all of this intelligence.
30:07 that will be 6 to 8% of our economy. And so that's where I sort of come up
30:14 short. I think that's the big risk.
30:16 The eye trade, whether 4 or 5 years from now, we're committing, call it 5 to 8%
30:22 of our economy to buy the tokens. And part of our conversation with former
30:28 SEC and CFTC Chair Gary Gensler, now a professor over at the Mitt Sloan School
30:34 of Management. When we come back, we continue the
30:37 conversation and the focus on anthropic spending IPO.
30:41 And some big questions here about more of the use cases for AI.
30:45 John Egger is going to be joining us after the break
30:48 for our stock of the future right here on the close right here on Bloomberg.
31:01 We're waiting to get official word on the pricing of that anthropic IPO.
31:05 Bloomberg reporters have now learned that the previously marketed range, at
31:09 $70 to $78 a share for this IPO, may now actually be topped.
31:15 Anthropic is said to be weighing IPO price of as much as $85 a share.
31:19 That's according to people familiar with the situation that Bloomberg reporters
31:22 have spoken to. We want to continue our conversation as
31:25 we await official word of exactly what that pricing looks like, and talk about
31:29 the broader AI ecosystem. Janna Eggers joins us right now.
31:32 General manager of AI and edge over at Omni Federal.
31:36 And Janna, I do want to talk a little bit about where we are right now in the
31:41 AI build out, not from the perspective of the people doing the building, but
31:45 more from the perspective of the users, whether it's the corporations or the
31:49 consumers. How far along are we in that, to the
31:53 point where there is some sort of meaningful revenue being generated from
31:57 those use cases? We've barely just scratched the surface
32:01 bare, like, um, we're just starting to understand the tool a little bit more
32:05 and how to use it, how to use it. As you know, I'm very excited and you've
32:09 all heard about the coding that's being done with, um, uh, with Claude and the
32:16 other tools. But what's more interesting is what
32:19 those engineers will do with it and how they, as they learn the tool, what other
32:25 ideas they're going to have for incorporating it into their software.
32:29 And I really think, you know, one area that's starting to take shape a little
32:33 bit more than others is how it's changing user interfaces.
32:36 And that's just going to multiply not just from the user interface, but like
32:41 going further down the stack, how it's going to be incorporated as we move
32:46 forward with regards to some of the edge use cases here.
32:50 And obviously, a lot of the work that you've done with your companies and your
32:52 research is focused in on that. Where do we stand,
32:57 though, on the edge? It's interesting because foundational
33:00 models don't fit well on the edge and particularly on the edge, you're
33:03 thinking about some situations of just being disconnected.
33:07 And so we have to think about that a bit more.
33:10 I still think there's that tells you that the anthropic still has more
33:13 opportunities because they know their model the best.
33:17 They know how they can shape it into different, smaller, um, you know, models
33:22 that they can then go out to the edge. So I don't I wouldn't permanently keep
33:27 them in that large foundational model space.
33:29 I would say they're going to be some people that can really expand even
33:33 better than some of the maybe smaller models that don't know how to go up the,
33:38 um, up the larger scale. Janna, if this IPO goes well tomorrow,
33:44 and certainly all signs are that it will that it'll be the biggest ever and
33:48 upsize reward at this point that they're going to look at maybe pricing at $85
33:54 instead of the top of the previous range, which was 78.
33:56 Does that reignite the whole AI trade? Um.
34:02 I don't think so. I think people expected this.
34:04 I'll be honest. I mean, we're everybody's excited, and
34:07 that excitement brings something like, you know, driving up that price and
34:11 people see the potential. So I don't think that there's going to
34:15 be, uh, further, fire added. I think this just solidifies what what
34:20 we're all kind of expecting, even though it is, uh, you know, a bit of excitement
34:24 that's driving that. Yeah.
34:26 I've been trying to do some back of the envelope math, and we were talking about
34:29 about how much, uh, that anthropic was going to raise in this IPO.
34:32 About $90 billion. If that $85 number proves true, tack on
34:37 another ten, $15 billion on top of that, what should they spend that money on?
34:44 I would look at how do we go deeper into understanding, you know, look at what
34:48 they did with Cody as an example. Now, how did they do the same thing in
34:53 health care? We have tons of opportunity in health
34:56 care, and that doesn't cut out other players, but how do they serve doctors
35:01 in the same way that they served engineers?
35:04 Right. And and that may be other people and
35:07 that they become, you know, the B2B and then that then goes into doctor.
35:11 So again, I'm not trying to say that they're going to take over all software
35:14 because I don't think that's going to happen, but they're going to augment all
35:18 software in a lot of different spaces. All right Jonny, we've got to leave it
35:23 there. Always a pleasure.
35:24 Jon Eggers, general manager of Eye and Edge over at Omni Federal, as we count
35:29 you down to the closing bells and of course, set you up for what is expected
35:33 to be a formal public disclosure of the pricing by Wall Street of that anthropic
35:38 IPO at some point after the bells. Katarina Simonetti, she's going to join
35:41 us after the break. Executive director at Morgan Stanley
35:44 Private wealth management. This is the close on Bloomberg.
36:02 Welcome back to the clothes. We are ten minutes away from the close
36:06 of Omni, and of course we are, uh, maybe just a little bit longer away from
36:10 getting a formal pricing of that anthropic IPO.
36:13 We should just point now. We were going through the numbers.
36:15 We had a red headline just a little while ago.
36:17 This was originally marketed in a 70 to $78 range.
36:20 We came in today with the expectation that anthropic and the bankers were
36:24 probably going to be at the top of that range.
36:26 We got a headline just a little while ago.
36:27 Now, 85 bucks appears to be on the table.
36:30 We're talking about potentially, if you put in the concurrent private placement,
36:34 about $100 billion raised, this would make it the biggest IPO in terms of
36:38 money raised ever that surpassed the space, surpassed the Saudi Aramco,
36:42 surpasses SK Hynix, which is pretty incredible when you think about it.
36:45 But the demand has been off the charts. We're reporting $400 billion worth of
36:48 institutional demand, $100 billion of retail demand, though obviously that's
36:52 not what you get when you're allocated, but that's what the interest is.
36:56 And obviously bankers are going back to the table and seeing what more they can
37:00 get out of investors. So let's take a look at the market,
37:04 because it has been just a little bit of a topsy turvy day.
37:06 At one point earlier the Russell 2000 was up more than 1%.
37:09 Right now it is just up about half a percent.
37:12 But if you look at the Nasdaq, we're up about a quarter of a few stocks and the
37:15 stocks are higher. But that index is only barely higher.
37:18 You've AMD and Broadcom higher. Retailers are doing well today.
37:22 Massive moves from some of those that beat and are looking to be doing well.
37:26 But then you know on the other side of things housing data came in and was
37:29 really pretty awful. Building permits coming in at the lows
37:33 that we haven't seen since Covid. So there's a lot of concerns out there.
37:36 Then you've oil prices lower, not helping bonds too much.
37:39 Although the two year yield is now unchanged, the ten year yield is down
37:43 four basis points. And Simonetti joins us right now
37:45 executive director at Morgan Stanley Private Wealth Management.
37:48 Let's right get right to it. Kind of already your clients asking you
37:51 about anything other than uh, anthropic, Nvidia and AI right now.
37:56 Well, there is a lot in their minds when you think of what this year brought to
38:00 us so far. We started the year optimistic about AI,
38:03 thinking about how transformative it will be to the world.
38:06 And then going into summer, we started talking about major risks of AI and how
38:11 it could end the world. Right?
38:12 Like so. So the news is all over the place, and
38:14 what we tell our clients is try not to focus on headline news, try to focus on
38:20 data on what actually is happening and why.
38:23 What we are seeing out there is happening.
38:25 Like, let's take this correction that started about four months ago.
38:28 We tell them, why is it happening? We have three major components.
38:32 One is of course midterm election. There was so much uncertainty in the
38:35 outcome, even bigger uncertainty in the military action that followed that seems
38:40 at this point and likely the second one is this enormous capital expenditures
38:44 with I that when are they going to be translated into profits.
38:48 Right. Like a major question.
38:50 And last, of course, is fed action. and what is going to happen with
38:53 interest rates as it is so connected with oil prices and inflation?
38:56 How do you sort of create a construct portfolio in this environment?
39:00 Because we talk about AI and it's not just dominating the conversation that
39:02 dominates our economy, at least economic growth right now.
39:05 It dominates obviously financial markets.
39:07 And there is a question here about concentration risk that is particularly
39:11 if you are exposed at more at the index level, you are heavily concentrated
39:14 right now in tech and AI. Of course.
39:15 And when it comes to concentration, we have to be conscious of not just
39:20 concentration in individual names. We have to be conscious of concentration
39:24 within the sectors, because we just saw a major, sometimes over 30% decline in
39:30 some of our favorite tech names. And this isn't if this is not a wake up
39:34 call. I don't know what it is, but good news
39:36 is for investors that held these stocks for the last few years, even after this
39:41 decline, they're up. So this is a great time to revisit the
39:46 portfolio, see what may be less harvesting can be taken.
39:50 See what rebalancing can take place. Because when we think about, I guess,
39:54 what the major benefactors are going to be health care companies, financial
39:59 companies, industrial companies, companies that have proven record of
40:03 taking this amazing technology and turn it into profitability to some extent,
40:07 the air that came out of the trade. Has it protected us from something maybe
40:11 exploding or going wrong? Because now you have sort of fresh
40:14 valuations. There's potentially the possibility for
40:17 upside, but also doesn't seem like we could crash from here.
40:21 Well really that's what we have to look at.
40:23 The forward looking projections right. You know where we need to look at the
40:28 data and see the eye expenditures, what is reasonable and what is already being
40:33 translated into profitability and financial sector is probably one of the
40:37 best sectors to see in this space, when you really see how it should work.
40:41 Only about 15% of S&P 500 companies are on record saying that they are
40:48 comfortable with where their level of eye adoption is.
40:52 Think about it 85% or not. So given what you're saying.
40:55 Wouldn't that mean that it's time to rotate that perhaps the eye trade is
40:59 done? And you know, an initial originally eye
41:02 trade is on and you should be looking at the industrials and the financials and
41:04 everything else. Absolutely.
41:05 Because let's just take semiconductors for example.
41:08 You know it seems that the sector is down.
41:10 But for anybody who is going to take this trade as a broad trade, just all of
41:14 the sector is making a mistake because quality is what really takes should take
41:19 a front stage here in this investment decisions.
41:22 So absolutely rotation it from the eye delivery into EI adopters which are all
41:29 across the sectors within industrials and financials and healthcare is
41:33 absolutely. So where do you find like true
41:35 diversification right now. I mean let's say you are already you
41:38 have an allocation to the eye trade to the tech trade in a way.
41:41 Where do you go that gives you true diversification?
41:43 Well, I don't mean you're going to be bitterly disappointed because I am so
41:47 excited. I am more excited about fixed income now
41:50 that I have not been for 20 years. And when clients call me and say help me
41:55 sleep well at night, how do I sleep well at night?
41:57 I told him, look, we have the benefit of buying high quality investment grade
42:03 bonds, oftentimes municipal bonds that are tax free and getting the yields that
42:07 we have not seen for 20 years. So the rotation out of this amazing
42:12 earnings that we saw in equities into this super high quality fixed income is
42:16 exactly what is needed to be comfortable about asset allocation, just real
42:19 quickly for getting into the end of the year.
42:22 We hear a lot about tax loss harvesting and particularly given all the market
42:25 moves we've had this year, does that depress prices, uh, through the end of
42:29 the year until we get past that, or is it going to kind of kind of even out or
42:33 be a balance when you think about the concept, right.
42:35 Like, so what do we do with tax harvesting?
42:37 We sell a stock that is down, and then in 30 days that the goal is to buy it
42:42 back if we sell and go to cash? Absolutely.
42:45 But if we sell and buy an index with, just say we buy S&P 500 or rustle or
42:51 index that closely replicates the company, you never leave the market.
42:55 Okay, so the effect of the market well over the tax loss harvesting should
42:59 really be very marginal if you're doing it the right way.
43:01 All right. Well well.
43:02 And obviously that's your job to help them do it the right way.
43:04 Catarina always a pleasure. Catarina Simonetti, executive director
43:07 at Morgan Stanley Private Wealth Management, kind of just down to the
43:11 closing bells. And, you know, there's a lot going on in
43:13 the market, believe it or not. Other than I mean, we're having a
43:15 phenomenal day for some of the retailers on the back of the great earnings report
43:18 by TJX. Uh, a lot of the health insurers are
43:21 rallying because of maybe potentially a bit of a reprieve when it comes to
43:24 Medicare rules. Uh, but of course, in about down and out
43:28 within the next hour, we're probably going to really be focus on that
43:31 anthropic pricing. Yeah, it'll be right back to that.
43:34 The other area, which is doing well, but it's not for good reasons, is the cyber
43:38 security area. Of course, the cyber security doing well
43:40 as a lot of concerns right now about some of the, uh, let's just say,
43:43 disruptions we've seen, uh, as of late. And whether that gives a pause to that.
43:47 Stocks, we're going to break down all of today's price action.
43:50 We're going to set you up for the official pricing of the anthropic IPO
43:53 with our global simulcast now. The closing bell.
43:59 Bloomberg's comprehensive cross-platform coverage of the US market closed starts
44:04 right now. And right now we are two minutes away
44:08 from the end of the trading day. Romaine Bostick alongside Vonnie Quinn
44:11 taking you due to that closing bell. It's a global simulcast.
44:14 Carol Massar Tim sentiment. They join us now.
44:16 Welcome to our audiences across all of our Bloomberg platforms, television and
44:19 radio. Our partnership with YouTube.
44:22 Uh, fractional gains, fractional losses at the index level for U.S.
44:26 equities depending on which index you pick.
44:29 But still we are seeing the narrative, Carol, that has been playing out for
44:33 quite some time. Chip stocks still under pressure.
44:36 A lot of questions about Nvidia and a lot of questions about that anthropic
44:39 IPO. Yeah, I got to say and Auntie, I've got
44:41 it already up on my Bloomberg. We are expecting it to price here right
44:45 after the closing bell, so it does feel like it keeps kind of moving up in terms
44:50 of what it might trade for. Maybe as high as $85 a share.
44:53 That's our latest read on the Bloomberg. But that's kind of what I'm thinking
44:56 about. What anthropic IPO will say about the
44:59 next leg of the AI story in trade. Yeah, that's the big question.
45:02 I mean, does this change the tone of what we've seen over the last few weeks,
45:06 Vonnie, with this trade really fizzling out and the questions that remain and
45:11 the challenges that remain for Nvidia, is this just an anthropic story?
45:15 Yeah, we did get past one of those risk catalysts, which was the Nvidia earnings
45:18 call. Right.
45:18 And we started off the day pretty positive on Nvidia.
45:21 And you know investors have sold that off.
45:23 But not to a massive extent. We're down 3% or so.
45:26 You have to wonder if there isn't some liquidating of certain stocks in order
45:29 to try and get in on opening day for the IPO tomorrow.
45:32 Zoom. Yeah.
45:33 Video. That movement has been interesting,
45:35 opened up by more than 2%, and now it looks like it's going to head into the
45:39 closed down about 3% down for a fifth straight day.
45:43 So too is the S&P 500, which actually opened higher but will closed lower down
45:48 in just about 17 to 18 points as we wait for these numbers to settle.
45:52 That's a loss of about a quarter of a percent.
45:54 Fifth straight day of losses. The Dow down 1.1% on the day, but the
45:58 Nasdaq indices escaping what had been a four day slump over what has been a four
46:03 day slump and breaking that slump now. Both up, each up, I should say, almost
46:07 exactly about the same. Uh, Erie, uh, each up about 100 points,
46:10 or about 4/10 of a percent. And the Russell 2000.
46:13 Carol gets in on the action as well. Up about 12 points or a half a
46:17 percentage point. All right.
46:18 So a little bit higher there S&P though as you mentioned remain down on the day.
46:22 But go inside the index almost an even split in terms of winners and losers.
46:26 Vonnie at 237 names in the S&P 500 higher in today's session.
46:31 But 265 to the downside and then one unchanged.
46:34 Well, fascinatingly, if we go inside the S&P 500 you'll see that consumer
46:38 discretionary is doing extraordinarily well today.
46:41 I haven't seen that for a while, but it's really beating on the bottom line.
46:43 And some of those stocks are just absolutely killing it today.
46:48 And definitely helping this equity index moves the upside because most other
46:52 groups were lower today Carol. All right.
46:55 So let's get to some of the individual gainers if I may.
46:57 Got to mention Take-Two interactive. Um, I know that remains a big Grand
47:03 Theft Auto player. So I'm sure he's going to be gaming it
47:05 out, uh, as soon as it, uh, is, uh, released a little bit later on.
47:09 I don't even I don't even play games. And I want to play this, I do.
47:12 Thank you. Tim.
47:13 This will get me to a game. I actually think if you read Jason
47:16 Schreier made my avatar. Carol.
47:18 Oh, okay. Oh.
47:20 I'm honored. I don't know if you should, but
47:23 actually, I'm a little nervous about what that
47:26 avatar might look like. All right, moving on, moving on.
47:29 All right, Take-Two interactive, uh, hiring today's session folks, 6.2%
47:33 higher. Heavy, heavy volume.
47:35 Um, of course, Grand Theft Auto six receiving close to perfect scores across
47:39 the board this morning, so making it the best reviewed game of all time according
47:43 to major review aggregation websites. Our own Jason Schreier calling the game,
47:47 which took more than 4700 people in eight years to develop a masterpiece.
47:51 Stock, though still down about 14% year to date.
47:54 All right, let's go on over to another, um, bunch of stocks, actually retailers
47:59 thanks to TJ Max, which, uh, end of the day, up about 8%, rallying the most
48:03 intraday in more than six years. So going back to November of 2020 a top
48:08 name in the S&P 500. This after TJ Max, uh, our TJ uh X
48:13 stores I should say um, their third quarter comp sales topped expectations,
48:17 including its core Ma max division, which includes the Marshalls and TJ Max
48:21 banners, now sees consolidated comparable sales for the year at the
48:24 high end of its previous guidance range. So a lot of optimism out of their
48:29 results. And what they, um, said today actually
48:32 lifted names like Ross Stores. It was up about 3.25%.
48:35 And you can see Burlington. They're up about 5.5%.
48:38 And then on over to target another retailer rallying as quarterly sales
48:42 were better than expected, with comp sales rising 5.6% from a year earlier.
48:47 The company working to improve its merchandise and tech, and has revamped
48:51 its food and beverage section and dialed up deals ahead of the holiday.
48:53 So some upbeat news there that stock up almost 4% in the trade Tim.
48:58 All right for decliners got to talk about Nvidia remain shared some of the
49:01 price action that we saw earlier. It closed down close to 3% but was up as
49:05 much as 2.7% earlier that post earnings rally, fizzling down five days in a row.
49:10 Over that period of time, it shed more than half $1 trillion in revenue.
49:14 It's now down close to 37% from those early October highs, still trading at
49:19 around June 2025 prices. We did learn from the Financial Times
49:23 that Nvidia's interim CEO promised employees pay raises and additional
49:28 equity benefits in December, uh, pulling for these increases in new equity words,
49:33 breaking with the company's normal schedule of annual reviews for employees
49:36 in the spring. To sort of work on a little bit of the
49:39 morale there. Shares of Nvidia down 2.9% today.
49:43 Also taking a look at shares of health insurance providers.
49:46 Humana down today by 13%. Um, down for a health insurer, is down
49:51 for a second day this fall as the US government's proposed Medicare Advantage
49:54 audit framework and its new rule called Comprehensive Regulations to uncover
49:58 suspicious health care. The acronym is Crush.
50:01 Separately, Senator Bernie Sanders outlined a four year plan to achieve
50:04 Medicare for all in his new Senate term. That's according to a report from the
50:07 AP. So some of these insurers under
50:08 pressure, including Humana and finally miners under pressure today, uh,
50:13 Freeport-McMoRan down today by a whopping 7%.
50:17 This after gold dropped below 3800 an ounce for the first time since September
50:21 of last year. Uh, the we saw Freeport-McMoRan fall,
50:25 Newmont fall, uh, Barrick mining fall, among others too.
50:28 All right. Let's take a quick look at yields
50:30 because we saw a lot of volatility there.
50:32 Earlier in the day we got some fed spike that actually spiked yields higher.
50:36 But that was a race very quickly. We're seeing the entire curve shift
50:40 lower on the day. Modest saw declines on the two year
50:43 yield but down for a fourth straight day.
50:46 Uh much bigger moves on the longer end of the curve with your ten year yield
50:50 down about five basis points. All right.
50:52 On to the anthropic IPO pricing. We're all waiting for it.
50:55 That is a wrap on our cross-platform radio, TV, YouTube, Bloomberg Originals.
50:59 Um, of course Romain and Vonnie continuing their on the close on
51:03 television. Tim and I back here on BW daily on
51:06 Bloomberg Radio. We will see you same time, same place
51:09 tomorrow. And our coverage continues here on
51:13 Bloomberg Television with a mixed day on Wall Street, the S&P closing lower for a
51:18 fifth straight day, the Nasdaq indices breaking a four day slump, but only
51:22 modestly up about 4/10 of a percent. A downward shift in the yield curve.
51:27 And we're still seeing weakness out there When it comes to cryptocurrencies,
51:30 as far as some of the individual movers, take a look at the health insurers names
51:34 like Humana, UnitedHealth and CVS. Having an awful day.
51:37 This on the back of a lot of concerns out there right now about exactly what
51:42 is going on with regards to a Medicare advantage in some of the audit
51:45 frameworks going on out there. We did see a little bit more, uh,
51:48 strength with regard to some of the cybersecurity names today.
51:51 This, of course, on the back of a myriad of, uh, let's just say, uh,
51:55 technological failures that we've had over the last few days and has raised
51:59 suspicions as to whether we need to beef up our cybersecurity angles.
52:02 Palo Alto Networks had a great day earlier today.
52:05 Though the shares are lower in the after hours trade, the company out with
52:09 earnings and also saying that it does plan to buy applied compute for about
52:13 $4.5 billion. Remember, this is an AI company started
52:16 by a couple of folks who had left OpenAI just a couple of years ago.
52:20 So interesting to see what they plan to do with that.
52:23 And then, of course, we talk about Nvidia and the rest of the AI trade, the
52:27 rest of the I fly wheel, and that is actually where we want to start our
52:31 conversation now. It is our top story, and it is about
52:34 putting a price on the eye trade. For the last few years, valuing pure
52:38 play companies was largely an affair for private markets.
52:42 Nvidia, a couple of the hyperscalers customers like Microsoft.
52:45 There were some of the few public market exceptions, but eight days ago,
52:48 anthropic bankers formally began their roadshow for the AI company's IPO,
52:53 asking a broad swath of investors and their intermediaries to put a price and
52:57 their money on what they think this company is worth.
53:00 The maker of the quad chat bot offering 825 million shares.
53:05 Originally the range was 70 to $78. Bloomberg is now reporting this very
53:10 moment that is now expected to price at $83 a share, along with the concurrent
53:16 private placement. The combined capital raise could be as
53:19 much as $100 billion and get anthropic, a fully diluted valuation of as much as
53:24 1.6 trillion. It will be just the fourth company in
53:27 history to price at that valuation of that magnitude.
53:31 SpaceX. Saudi Aramco.
53:33 Sky high. Next is ADR, as are the other.
53:35 Demand has reportedly been more than seven times the shares available, and
53:39 investors have been told that the offering price was going to be above
53:43 that 78 bucks. And Bloomberg is reporting that it is
53:46 indeed that. But the higher the pricing goes, of
53:48 course, that means the more investors expect from tomorrow's trading debut and
53:52 a book, it can be heavily oversubscribed on paper.
53:55 But what ultimately matters is the quality of those orders, how price
53:58 sensitive they are, how many investors intend to hold the stock rather than
54:01 sell into that opening surge. And this deal, of course, also carries
54:05 consequences well beyond anthropic itself.
54:08 It could establish the valuation benchmark for the next generation of AI
54:11 listings. It could test how much capital the
54:14 public markets can absorb and influence the terms available to every other
54:18 private technology company waiting behind it.
54:21 Eddie Best joins us right now. He's co-chair of the capital markets
54:24 practice over at Willkie, Farr and Gallagher, and has spent the last 3 or 4
54:28 decades advising on big, complicated deals and financing.
54:33 Great to have you here. Great to be here.
54:34 Let's start with the pricing. The latest Bloomberg reporting 83 bucks
54:37 a share. They originally started marketing this
54:39 at 70 bucks. So that's a huge swing from where they
54:42 started. Um, I am just curious about this idea of
54:45 whether bankers sometimes get a little bit too aggressive with this pricing and
54:49 whether that ends up backfiring once it actually goes public.
54:52 Well, I think the other part of the question is also, were they being a
54:54 little bit more conservative in terms of coming out with the price range, get you
54:59 get the the market excited about it at that price range.
55:03 And then as you saw, it was way oversubscribed.
55:05 And then it was easier to move the price up.
55:06 So I would tell you that I think it's it's a clearly an art, not a science.
55:11 And I think that like many things, they were trying to get everybody interested.
55:14 So they priced it a little bit lower. Now they're coming up to 83.
55:17 You never know. It could even price up at 85.
55:19 But as you're pointing out, let's see what happens when it opens.
55:22 because the higher you price it at. The less there's going to be room to,
55:25 you know, go open tomorrow. At a higher price.
55:27 And what they really want to do is not only price it well, but see the
55:31 aftermarket trading go up. I am curious, I mean, when they price
55:34 that much higher than what they were doing, did they then have to refile the
55:37 prospectus? They don't have to refile the prospectus
55:39 there. There's there are certain S.E.C.
55:41 rules that allow you to go 15% over where you were.
55:43 Okay, okay. Without having to do what's called a
55:45 post effective amendment. But even that you could then do
55:47 overnight and it'll be ready for tomorrow morning.
55:49 You pay an extra filing fee. But they've all thought that through.
55:53 And believe me, they've been they've been, you know, figure out this kabuki
55:56 dance for a couple of weeks now. And we should point out that at 83
55:59 bucks, we're about less than 10% above the top end of that range.
56:02 Um, give me a sense. So what happens next?
56:05 Um, obviously, um, you know, as, uh, the bank as the all the banks and the, uh,
56:09 the wealth platforms and everything else get these shares.
56:11 Then they have to figure out how to allocate this.
56:13 Right. That's probably just as tricky,
56:16 particularly for something of this size. And it's something of this, uh, in high
56:19 demand that, that that's a huge part of this.
56:21 So first off they're going to want good long term investors.
56:25 They're going to want to have a book that are people that you want in your
56:27 book who are going to be around for a while, not flippers.
56:30 A lot of the retail demand, for example, won't be allowed to flip it.
56:33 So if you get an allocation at TD or you get it at Schwab, they're going to make
56:37 you hold it for a little while. Um, but you also then want to have folks
56:42 who have a high demand that you can't fill.
56:45 So, for example, if I wanted 10 million shares, I only got 5 million.
56:48 I'm not going to stop at five. I'm going to put in an order for another
56:51 five for tomorrow morning. So that's going to increase the demand
56:53 tomorrow morning. So when the stock opens, there's going
56:56 to be all this pent up demand by people who didn't get what they wanted.
56:59 So that's going to be an important part as well.
57:01 Um, I do just have to ask you about the some of the governance structure.
57:05 And there's been a lot of talk. You have five share classes.
57:08 Uh, obviously the founders still pretty much will control the vote, a more or
57:11 less. Um, and, and there are a lot of other
57:14 provisions, uh, that basically means that if you come in and buy this, uh,
57:18 you are basically at the bottom of the ladder in terms of being able to
57:21 influence things. Why do you think investors are more
57:23 willing to accept those types of terms? Because I feel like, I don't know, 20 or
57:28 30 years ago you would never have seen this.
57:30 No, not to this extent. No, you're absolutely right about that.
57:33 Um, there are a couple reasons. First of all, anthropic itself is a
57:36 different kind of company. Um, first of all, it's called a PBC, a
57:39 public benefit corporation. But it part of its mission is to make
57:43 sure that I is done safely and for the public benefit.
57:47 So it's not just a company that's trying to make money for its shareholders.
57:50 So if you're investing in this company, you're buying into that mission as well.
57:54 So you're not just buying an investment, you're buying in mission.
57:57 And so from that standpoint, I think it's important for them to be able to
58:00 assure the marketplace, to ensure the government, to ensure everybody that
58:05 they're doing this on a responsible basis in accordance with their mission.
58:09 And obviously, they're going to be too big to be taken over, but someone's not
58:12 going to come in and just take over the company and just change everything
58:14 tomorrow. There's going to be some stability here.
58:16 I do have to ask you about legal risk given.
58:19 Given your background. And there was a ton of disclosures in
58:22 the S-1 filing. Uh, you know, make of it what you will.
58:25 Maybe they did that intentionally. Uh, maybe it is true risk here.
58:29 But what does a company, particularly when they go public?
58:32 Um, what type of legal risk do they face, particularly given the disclosures
58:35 that we heard from? So there's an awful lot there.
58:38 I think it was 94 pages at the end. Um, SpaceX, by comparison, had about 35.
58:42 So this was three times as large. Um, the company is in three times as
58:45 large. Uh, but there are certainly some risk
58:48 factors that we've never seen before that the company raises an existential
58:51 risk of, you know, humankind not existing things like that.
58:54 Um, the reason why we drafted it's not just the lawyers being lawyers.
58:59 Um, we drafted for a couple of reasons. One, it's to protect everybody if the
59:03 stock price goes down. There's a whole bar out there that does
59:06 nothing but try to sue, say, uh, you didn't disclose something, and they're
59:09 going to try to look at, well, what happened.
59:11 And was that adequately described? And if it wasn't I'm going to sue you on
59:15 that. So just remember.
59:17 Yes, it's 94 pages, but just because it's possible doesn't mean it's
59:20 probable. So that's why we still have huge demand.
59:23 Even though you've got a company that says we could blow up humanity.
59:26 I just also on that risk front, and I just want to point out for our viewers
59:30 right now, we are getting some headlines.
59:31 This from Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, basically saying that,
59:36 uh, in her words, anthropic actually fails to answer for some of those
59:40 potential threats. And I was just talking with Eddie about
59:42 she also urges the SEC to, quote, protect investors ahead of the anthropic
59:48 IPO. And, Eddie, I want to use that as a
59:50 jumping point to sort of get you to expand on this, because the risk now for
59:55 investors isn't just anthropic. Does something bad or the AI model does
59:59 something bad. You have Congress now, uh, and
1:00:02 potentially maybe even some of the federal agencies taking a look at the AI
1:00:05 ecosystem overall in a way that I think a lot of companies, when they go public,
1:00:09 don't have to deal with. And it doesn't help, you know,
1:00:11 obviously, everything that transpired with Nvidia over the last couple of
1:00:13 weeks. Right.
1:00:14 So a normal company that goes and you know, if you make donuts okay.
1:00:19 So the FDA decides that, you know, we all have to lose some weight.
1:00:22 And you know, you shouldn't eat donuts. This is very different.
1:00:24 They could really come out with regulation that will stifle both their
1:00:28 current business model, but just as importantly, their future business
1:00:32 models, because this is a company that is rapidly changing every day and it's,
1:00:36 you know, it's going to be somewhere very different in a year or so.
1:00:39 That's an existential threat to the company.
1:00:41 So regulation is very different than we've seen in almost any other kind of
1:00:45 company. Even with financial services, it's among
1:00:47 the most heavily regulated. Oil and gas.
1:00:49 There are regulations, but they're there to just help them along in a, in a, in a
1:00:55 reasonable way, as opposed to we have no idea where the AI regulation might go.
1:00:59 Well. And but but that seems like a big
1:01:02 question and fairness anthropic a lot of these questions cropped up after the
1:01:06 initial a filing, uh, with obviously the results of the election and a few other
1:01:10 things that transpired here. So, I mean, do you go back if you had a
1:01:14 client like this, do you go back and tell them even now, on the eve of their
1:01:17 IPO? Okay, here's what you need to start
1:01:20 disclosing. Maybe not necessarily tonight, but, you
1:01:22 know, at some point in the next few days and weeks.
1:01:25 So first of all, I think they've done a great job disclosing, um, I think
1:01:29 they've done everything they could do and knowing what they know today.
1:01:33 Um, hindsight is 2020 as well, we say. And one of the things that we also have
1:01:37 to be careful about is if they disclose something in a week or two weeks or even
1:01:41 a month. Did you not know that two weeks ago?
1:01:44 So, um, the more you disclose right after the IPO, the more it questions
1:01:48 your IPO disclosure. If something happens in six weeks that
1:01:52 you didn't know about and you talk about it, that's perfectly reasonable.
1:01:55 If something happens in six months or a year, well, it would be harder to know
1:01:59 that at the time of the IPO and your liability and your requirement, your
1:02:03 your obligation to disclose is based on what you know today or can reasonably
1:02:07 foresee, not what Senator Warren might think could possibly happen in the world
1:02:12 with regard to every other company out there that is either looking to go
1:02:16 public or looking to raise money, that's not named anthropic.
1:02:18 What happens when you have sort of these kind of big singular events like this?
1:02:22 Does this basically just put a chill over everything with regards to
1:02:26 financing, M&A, etc. for a while until the dust settles?
1:02:29 Or will people sort of find, uh, find their own sunlight where they can?
1:02:33 So we ask the same question around space, that space, you know, is it going
1:02:36 to be a black hole? It just sucked up everybody's attention
1:02:39 and money and time. Um, and for the 2 or 3 days around it,
1:02:43 yes, it did. Um, we expect the same thing for
1:02:45 anthropic that, you know, I would not want to be going public today.
1:02:48 I would not want to be going public, you know, probably tomorrow and Friday.
1:02:51 Companies don't go public generally. Um, but I think by if anthropic does
1:02:55 well, that's going to create a really good tailwind for a lot of other
1:02:59 companies that maybe are waiting for next week or the week after.
1:03:02 And remember, we're getting towards the end of the year.
1:03:03 So we've got Thanksgiving coming up. We've got a small window in December,
1:03:07 and then things are going to quiet down over the holidays.
1:03:09 So if this gives people a tailwind, I think we're going to see a lot of
1:03:12 activity in the first couple weeks of December.
1:03:13 Eddie, always great to have you here. It's going to be Eddie Fest, a lifetime
1:03:18 of experience out there. Co-Chair of the capital markets practice
1:03:21 over at Willkie Farr and Gallagher, with now Bloomberg reporting that the pricing
1:03:25 on anthropic coming in at $83 a share. There are a lot of big banks on Wall
1:03:31 Street that are part of that book, and it includes Citi.
1:03:33 We want to go down to Washington, D.C. right now, where Lisa Abramowitz is with
1:03:37 the chair and CEO of Citi, Jane Frazier Market.
1:03:40 Anyway, towards the end of the year, I think it's more about 27 than it is
1:03:45 about 26 from that perspective. But obviously this is going to be a good
1:03:49 thing. And it remember it comes on the back of
1:03:51 the Nvidia earnings yesterday which also surprised the market positively.
1:03:56 We could do with positive surprises at the moment.
1:03:59 I mean and you know I think that their forward guidance was also quite strong.
1:04:04 So I think more confidence in the I ecosystem is a good thing.
1:04:09 Do you have a pretty big pipeline for the beginning of 2027?
1:04:12 In other words, is the anthropic IPO the opening salvo to a host of other
1:04:17 transactions, both in the IE world and beyond?
1:04:20 Or is it kind of the door closing on a pretty amazing year for IPOs a record
1:04:25 year? I no, I think it's it should be good
1:04:28 news for the IPO is that that will be coming in 27 and that there may well be
1:04:33 some that come in towards the back end of this year as well.
1:04:36 It's just where the calendar is. It makes it it makes it tighter on that.
1:04:40 Um, and I think it's, it's positive for what's been quite a thin tech IPO
1:04:46 market. Um, this year, as many people have been
1:04:49 waiting for, for this one off to space. Nvidia did report earnings that were
1:04:53 better than expected increase their guidance.
1:04:56 That wasn't what really people cared about.
1:04:57 People were looking at other things in particular, whether they're going to
1:05:00 finance anything and who their next executive leader will be.
1:05:03 Uh, I'm just wondering from your perspective, how big of a concern it is
1:05:07 that the central bank of I might be going away?
1:05:11 Oh, look, the genie is out of the bottle on I and no one's putting that genie
1:05:16 back in the bottle. Um, when we think about the amount of, I
1:05:21 look at it, the amount of compute that is in demand.
1:05:24 And I'm not just I mean, a lot of that centers in America, but I'm not just
1:05:28 seeing it. There is in Turkey the other day,
1:05:30 they're building their first data center because they're worried if they don't,
1:05:34 they won't be able to compete in industry after industry.
1:05:39 So this this is a global phenomenon at the moment, certainly centered in the
1:05:42 States. Um, but I wouldn't be I wouldn't be so
1:05:47 concerned with all of the doomsday predictions on AI and the rest of it.
1:05:52 Um, it's, uh, I think we're in we're in reasonable shape.
1:05:56 At the same time, in your third quarter earnings, Citigroup did say that I
1:06:01 financing risk was a key risk or uncertainty, and it was the first time
1:06:05 that it appeared. What were you referring to in particular
1:06:07 there? Look, it's it's as I say, it's the
1:06:09 largest build out that we've seen, um, in modern history in a very capital
1:06:15 intensive way. Um, and it's, um, there's a lot of
1:06:19 promise and opportunity there, but where the picks and shovels phase, as everyone
1:06:24 likes to say. Um, it's a very big infra build out.
1:06:28 It's energy chips. It's a data set.
1:06:30 And as I mean this the frontier models, there is a lot going to this one and not
1:06:35 everyone will be a winner. There are always winners and losers in
1:06:39 these things. So just given the amounts of money
1:06:41 involved and the other pieces, you would hope that one of the nation's largest
1:06:46 banks was focused and making sure that we manage the risk responsibly.
1:06:51 Um, but we're in the business of taking risk.
1:06:53 Um, and therefore, I would say we we keep an eye on these things.
1:06:57 People point to the United States as being sort of the epicenter of both the
1:07:01 risk and the reward tied to I. The ECB was saying that this is a huge
1:07:04 systemic risk and that this could potentially be another subprime that
1:07:08 jealous. Explain.
1:07:12 I mean, is it a feature of bug because it does sort of concentrate risk around
1:07:16 one technology really having gains? Um, this is probably where I become one
1:07:20 of those, um, zealous Americans of having chosen to come and join this
1:07:24 country, um, as a, as an immigrant of, uh, many years ago now.
1:07:28 But look what what's the magic that that the US has?
1:07:33 Um, it is our ability to both in the innovation that this country can do at
1:07:39 scale, matched with the capital market. So think about it.
1:07:43 The US has 4% of the world's population and over 50% of the market
1:07:49 capitalization of the world. Okay, you think about industry after
1:07:53 industry where not only can we innovate, but we can do so at scale and then we
1:08:00 can support. We can support the entrepreneurs as they
1:08:03 build out and take chances. In some places you're not guaranteed
1:08:07 success. Um, but but it is quite unique.
1:08:10 Capital markets is a very important part of funding.
1:08:14 The debt, the equity, the risk management, the breadth and depth, the
1:08:17 savings that get deployed into investment so others can participate in
1:08:21 this. Whereas I look at the UK, where I come
1:08:24 from, all parts of Europe. Um, I've had this conversation in
1:08:28 France. There are a lot of the top French
1:08:30 entrepreneurs who are superb in the eye space.
1:08:35 They're here, they're on the West Coast. They're in the States.
1:08:39 There are far fewer that are in France. Um, I look in the UK where conversations
1:08:45 with the government there, where they're trying to understand how did they scale
1:08:48 up their their ventures kind of plateau and they're not able to scale from here.
1:08:54 And that's why I think we see so much entrepreneurship.
1:08:58 coming. Many of the roads leading to America.
1:09:01 We under appreciate that here. Yeah.
1:09:04 We just had an election and certainly we did.
1:09:08 I think it happened about three months ago.
1:09:10 Uh, give it everything. It feels like giving everything that
1:09:13 we're seeing. Um, and so people have talked about how
1:09:15 that could potentially stymie some of the data center buildout or potentially
1:09:19 just the eye trade in general. How are you hearing about that from your
1:09:23 clients in terms of whether they're trying to speed up the projects to get
1:09:27 ahead of it, or how concerned they are? Yeah, I mean, I think the election had a
1:09:31 number of different issues on affordability, had it around their eyes,
1:09:35 some of the anti-establishment. Um, and I was I was over in California,
1:09:40 uh, most week and I was I was happy to see that this is not falling on deaf
1:09:47 ears. I think there is a recognition that when
1:09:49 we have been investing at this scale and speed, some the communities have been
1:09:55 left behind. The hasn't been enough of the wind wing,
1:09:58 and I think I've heard a lot more of that recognition from the tech firms,
1:10:03 and not just in the AI space, but more broadly, that you've got to make this
1:10:07 something that is beneficial for the communities you're in.
1:10:10 What is it you're doing to protect if it's on the energy cost front?
1:10:14 There are plenty of things to do on energy supply and energy pricing.
1:10:18 Make sure the community doesn't have the detrimental impact that can be.
1:10:23 Benefits given to local schools. No free lunches, better salaries for
1:10:28 there for the teachers. There's a lot of different things that
1:10:31 can be done that some of the the benefits that the tech firms are
1:10:36 getting, um, also translate into the communities in which you operate.
1:10:41 And I think it's one of the things we as banks, um, have learned that this is so
1:10:45 critical if we're expecting to retain trust.
1:10:48 Um, we certainly had to earn a lot of that back off the great financial
1:10:52 crisis. And there are plenty of ways to do this.
1:10:55 I'm encouraged. I was, I was I think this is not falling
1:10:59 on deaf ears. Yeah, it does seem like this hasn't been
1:11:01 a great week for Tech Trust when it comes to trusting our technology.
1:11:06 Considering the FAA went down and so did Apple and JP Morgan experienced
1:11:10 problems, there've been all these tech outages.
1:11:12 Should we go buy gold bars? Uh, look, I, I can I can empathize a lot
1:11:19 as to why this is unsettling at the moment.
1:11:21 There's been a lot in the last couple of weeks.
1:11:24 Um, but let's, you know, take a little bit of a step back.
1:11:28 What? And just give some reassurance.
1:11:31 Um, the volume of changes, the patches that is going through the world's tech
1:11:38 stack at the same time is, you know, five, ten fold what we've ever seen
1:11:44 before. Um, you know, it shouldn't be a complete
1:11:48 surprise to anyone that that doesn't always go well, but it doesn't mean it's
1:11:52 a disaster. Um, so what we're seeing is.
1:11:57 And we should be expecting for a while, some more downtime, some more outages in
1:12:02 different areas as we upgrade the tech stacks to the latest versions of
1:12:07 different releases to put in the patches to the vulnerabilities.
1:12:11 And at the end of the day, it will make us all a lot, um, more resilient.
1:12:17 And what that we've all been learning that's both emotional, mental and
1:12:20 physical. Uh, but it builds resiliency.
1:12:24 And that's going to be very important because these models are powerful and in
1:12:27 bad actors hands, they can be a problem. Um, and I think it's just reinforcing
1:12:32 the need to make investments in modernizing our technology, um, and in
1:12:37 making sure that we're thinking about resiliency.
1:12:40 But we shouldn't be surprised this is happening.
1:12:43 And the models that really powerful models came out six months ago.
1:12:47 We knew that this was likely to happen just given the volume of changes.
1:12:52 So it's. We're very good at adapting this country
1:12:58 I guess in this rough period. I mean, is there a chance that the
1:13:01 payment system could go down at.
1:13:05 Is there a chance it goes down? The bits of it might at some point from
1:13:09 a downtime or others as we're upgrading different elements of it, but we're
1:13:14 ready for that. We spent years and investing in making
1:13:20 sure that someone else doesn't bring it down, but if it's because we're
1:13:23 upgrading the technology or upgrading different pieces, then, you know, we've
1:13:27 got really good plans in places. How does all of this recover?
1:13:31 How do you get back online quickly? And we've seen that the last while.
1:13:35 It's not just if it goes down, it's how quickly do you get things back up again
1:13:40 and working quickly. And the companies have all got a lot of
1:13:43 plans as to how to do this. And it's not just from cyber, it can be
1:13:48 from someone makes a mistake, it can be from a bug in there.
1:13:52 So copper wire is something that I first saw and I asked her, should we all go to
1:13:57 Costco and buy a lot of toilet paper? And she said, absolutely, you should.
1:14:00 Because it sponsors their card. So yeah, I only use the city Costco
1:14:06 credit card, however. Yeah.
1:14:07 So there you go. When it comes to your own deployment, I
1:14:10 promise we will get to other things other than artificial intelligence.
1:14:12 But today, you know, it was a big it's an important topic for you.
1:14:16 Yes. I just wonder how much right now is at a
1:14:19 cost center versus actually a cost efficiency issue right now.
1:14:23 Oh, look, this is a technology that is going to unlock a lot of growth and
1:14:28 revenue. It's going to unlock a lot of
1:14:30 productivity and efficiency gains, and is also going to require a lot of money
1:14:35 to be spent. So I think of it in our bank where are
1:14:37 we going to earn money? Where are we going to save money and
1:14:40 where are we going to spend money? The first use cases in I tend to be an
1:14:45 encoding. Um, so you saw some.
1:14:48 We saw a big uplift in productivity and coding from that.
1:14:52 And I know as a bank that means we've been able to save some money and then
1:14:55 invest it, um, for growth and for new features, new capabilities going
1:15:01 forward. Um, the savings, it's certainly going to
1:15:06 help drive productivity. And that does mean that will be areas
1:15:09 where there will be job changes and job losses.
1:15:12 Um, equally, there's going to be areas new product development, life cycle and
1:15:16 much shorter. New features are becoming possible, new
1:15:20 areas where, um, you're going to be able to earn more growth and more revenue
1:15:24 that will create jobs. We don't know if the puts and takes will
1:15:28 be the same. And then there's areas where we're
1:15:30 spending money and investing side, but being one of them.
1:15:33 Um, but not the only one. Full protections.
1:15:36 Um, as a range of different areas that are defensive, um, that we're using the,
1:15:41 the AI models to invest and protect because of new things that bad actors
1:15:46 could do. So all of this coming together, it's
1:15:49 such early days that, um, we're starting to see all of these different areas bear
1:15:55 fruit, some of them in positive ways, some of them not in positive ways, but
1:16:00 it is a mixture of all of them in five years.
1:16:03 Do you expect city to have a smaller employee base?
1:16:07 I honestly don't know the answer to that question.
1:16:09 We're certainly working hard to make sure that we have grown the company
1:16:14 responsibly, um, and that we've done so in a way that retains trust of our
1:16:19 customers, our investors, the communities we serve.
1:16:22 Um, and that that enables us to have a different composition of our of our
1:16:28 workforce. Um, I would love it to be the same or
1:16:30 bigger. Yeah.
1:16:32 How much of your day do you spend trying to figure out how to patch up systems
1:16:36 without crashing the whole thing? Um, a lot of time actually has gone into
1:16:40 that. I think this is one of the areas where
1:16:42 the private sector in the states has really stood up because a lot of the
1:16:46 critical infrastructure is privately owned in this country.
1:16:50 And so we've had a several initiatives. The banks, I think, as claimants to
1:16:55 about the day, really are at the forefront because it's been a decade
1:17:00 plus investment and collaboration on cyber.
1:17:03 We do not compete on cyber. Right.
1:17:06 Well compete on the death for pitching the anthropic IPO.
1:17:09 Um, but when it comes to these different areas, it's a case of how do we really
1:17:14 work together to make sure the system is safe.
1:17:18 Um, so I spend a lot of time on, um, where are we patching?
1:17:23 What are we doing to protect our perimeter?
1:17:25 I also spent a lot of time talking to, um, smaller firms.
1:17:30 I was just with a group of banks this morning explaining.
1:17:33 What are we doing to make sure that we're hardening our cyber capabilities
1:17:38 and the banks. What are we doing to make sure our
1:17:40 people as ready as possible for weather down times and getting getting up and
1:17:45 working quickly again. Um, and this is where I would say
1:17:50 there's a lot of collaboration going on in the private sector, which is, you
1:17:54 know, necessary and good to see. Do you want an agent?
1:17:59 My personal agent. Muse.
1:18:00 Would that be able to access my personal bank account at Citi?
1:18:04 Absolutely. No way.
1:18:07 Well. No way.
1:18:09 Um, because, again, we have to move fast, but maintain trust.
1:18:14 You don't want me, um, letting muse accessing.
1:18:17 And we. Some discover that it's authorized to go
1:18:20 and take a lot more money out of your bank account than you wanted to.
1:18:23 Um. And we.
1:18:24 This is such a new technology. Ultimately, I can see that being in
1:18:28 place. Um, but I think you're hearing from all
1:18:31 the large banks and and others that, you know, when we're not going to unleash
1:18:36 these, um, without having the right risk and control protections in place so that
1:18:41 you are unprotected in your your money, your data and other elements.
1:18:48 Um, the, the, uh, the control framework is not there yet, so it will come.
1:18:52 Um, we'll put it in, but we're not going to get ahead of our skis here.
1:18:56 Is there a competitive aspect to this to try to get younger clients who are using
1:19:00 these devices more significantly, or it's just too early days at this point.
1:19:04 At this, we will disrupt ourselves, but we will only do so responsibly.
1:19:10 Um, the. Yeah, period.
1:19:13 Full stop. Um, it's just not something that I think
1:19:16 you're going to see. Um, banks being willing to let go of
1:19:21 controls that could cause a problem for the system or control cause a problem
1:19:25 for our customers. We, um, we're going to do this quickly.
1:19:30 But when we're comfortable that we can manage risk at the same speed as
1:19:34 innovation. And then everyone should watch out, um,
1:19:37 because we've got the scale to apply the innovation to.
1:19:40 Um, and you asked me the question about bug or feature.
1:19:43 Um, and I would say that innovation is a feature of America.
1:19:47 Um, but I think we do this responsibly. We don't do this shooting from the hip.
1:19:53 We're in Washington, D.C. it is a bit of a big political change.
1:19:57 I want to start by talking about your relationship with President Trump.
1:20:01 You have developed a pretty close relationship with President Trump in
1:20:04 terms of being a collaborator. And you were on the last trip to China.
1:20:09 Given that there is a meeting between, uh, XI Jinping and President Trump right
1:20:13 now. Any insight that you got from that
1:20:16 meeting? Yeah, it was above.
1:20:18 I'd say it was a privilege to be able to attend a company with a big global
1:20:23 presence and so be able to join the president and number the other CEOs on
1:20:27 the trip. Um, just to be part of the US
1:20:31 delegation. There's a certain privileges you never
1:20:34 imagined in your life. Um, on this one.
1:20:37 I think what I took away that was very encouraging was the real focus on
1:20:42 stabilizing the relationship between the two.
1:20:44 Um, certainly very clear that there are a number of areas where it is, um,
1:20:50 complete competition between the two countries.
1:20:53 But there's a lot of other areas where there is collaboration.
1:20:56 And I think the mindset really from both was that, you know, there's too much to
1:21:01 lose by not engaging, um, you know, for both sides and frankly, for everyone.
1:21:07 And so the engagement was very good. Um, but there was certainly plenty of
1:21:11 areas of disagreement. Um, but if you don't engage when you've
1:21:16 got the, you know, the two biggest powers in the world, then you really do
1:21:20 have a problem. When something goes wrong, you don't
1:21:22 have the de-escalation channels. You're not picking up the phone to talk
1:21:25 it through. Um, so I took that away as a positive.
1:21:29 City has, uh, one of the biggest presences in China as any U.S.
1:21:33 bank. And I'm wondering how you maintain the
1:21:37 balance, given the fact that these two nations do have a rivalry and can be in
1:21:42 opposition? How difficult is that?
1:21:44 It's very it's very simple. We serve 70% of the fortune 500 that
1:21:49 operate in China. And you would much rather that that is
1:21:53 on our rails for foreign exchange, cash management, trade, payroll, etc..
1:22:00 Um, and that that those are the rails that are connecting the world to China
1:22:05 for those multinationals. And so it's um, and we also help connect
1:22:11 about some of the Chinese companies in the areas that it's not the outright
1:22:15 competition, as you'd imagine. Um, with the states, um, to the rest of
1:22:19 the world where there is the collaborative relationship.
1:22:22 Um, but you absolutely want this on, on U.S.
1:22:25 rails. You don't you don't want it on other
1:22:27 ones. It's it's part of American economic
1:22:31 security. There's also been a big shift in
1:22:34 Washington, D.C., politically, and the head of the Max Banking Committee of the
1:22:40 Senate next year is probably going to be Senator Elizabeth Warren.
1:22:43 She's had some pretty strong words about Citi in the past, just this July.
1:22:47 She came out with the press release warning Citi against making any
1:22:50 acquisitions. Saying Citi grew irresponsibly from 1995
1:22:54 to 2007. Of course, you were forced to clean that
1:22:57 up afterwards when you came in. How do you respond to someone like
1:23:02 Senator Warren, who's been very critical of city's past as an incredibly
1:23:07 fundamental institution that was instrumental in a lot of the pain in
1:23:10 2008. I think all of us have a lot of respect
1:23:13 for Senator Warren. Um, and there is a lot of different
1:23:18 areas that we'll be able to will agree to disagree in certain areas, but
1:23:22 there's plenty of opportunity to work together on a lot of the different
1:23:26 issues that are, that are concerning for the American people.
1:23:29 Um, we will be looking forward to doing that.
1:23:32 Um, what I would say in terms of the question about city is I would
1:23:37 respectfully ask Senator Warren there could the bank that we are today and not
1:23:41 that the bank that we were. Um, we have we have made very
1:23:45 significant changes to what city is. Um, and huge investments in risk and
1:23:52 controls, um, huge investments in our infrastructure to modernize it.
1:23:57 Simplify the bank. Um, to make sure that it is able to
1:24:01 serve, um, both here at home, but also very critical role serving American
1:24:06 companies around the world. Um, responsibly and effectively, um,
1:24:11 being a source of strength and, and, um, and stability for them as they operate
1:24:16 internationally. Um, and helping fund the success of
1:24:20 companies, um, here in the States. So an enormous investment in risk and
1:24:25 controls and enormous investment in our infrastructure.
1:24:29 But we've also simplified the bank a lot.
1:24:31 We have five businesses now rather than trying to be everything to everybody,
1:24:36 everywhere. Um, those five business lines sit at my
1:24:39 table. Um, uh, my husband will tell you I'm a
1:24:43 hands on manager. Um, and, um, we're making sure that, you
1:24:48 know, that we are running this directly rather than more like a holding company,
1:24:53 which is some of the ways it's been done in the past.
1:24:56 Um, and that we're very engaged in, um, making sure that we support small
1:25:03 businesses, the different sized banks, different institutions throughout the
1:25:07 country, as well as making sure that American companies are competitive as
1:25:12 they operate globally. And we uniquely do that.
1:25:15 So, um, I, I trust and hope you would judge us on who we are today and not who
1:25:21 we were because we've our people have worked incredibly hard.
1:25:24 I'm so proud of them. Um, of going through some tough years
1:25:28 where we really transformed the bank. It was blood, sweat and tears.
1:25:32 But I think we're seeing the fruits. And anyone who says that a bank can't
1:25:35 multitask and won't make any gender comments here.
1:25:40 Um, we were we were able to, um, both grow and, um, to transform the bank at
1:25:47 the same time and really simplify it. So now we're not done yet.
1:25:51 So a bit to go, but, uh, it's a very different institution.
1:25:55 I hope you will recognize that because we want to work together.
1:25:58 You don't want to be working at odds. I don't think that's constructive for
1:26:01 anybody. There's been a feeling that this will be
1:26:04 a less conducive period to mergers and acquisitions as a result of some of the
1:26:09 crackdown. From your own personal perspective.
1:26:11 Do you think that the door has kind of closed for any kind of like regional
1:26:15 bank acquisitions or asset management acquisitions?
1:26:18 Or do you think that if it was rational, it would still be open?
1:26:21 Oh, I think it should be open. Some consolidation is healthy.
1:26:25 I do, say, I do think the U.S. has a very good structure because this
1:26:30 is so say it's a large country statement to the blindingly obvious.
1:26:34 But having the big global banks and the role that we play in supporting the
1:26:38 global financial system and the American power globally is important.
1:26:43 You have the, the, the large national banks, you have the regional banks.
1:26:48 And I spent the morning, as I say, with group of the community and smaller banks
1:26:53 in particular, a really important role as everyone plays their part in the
1:26:59 system in a way that you don't see in other countries.
1:27:02 And and in some of them, you know, with some, some consolidation is very
1:27:06 healthy. We have over 4000 banks.
1:27:09 So, um, it's, uh, we've got plenty to do as the moment.
1:27:14 Um, I think I see it, I see plenty of organic growth opportunities for Citi.
1:27:19 You don't need to look in organically. Um, but I that I do think there's some
1:27:24 additional consolidation that is creating problems in the system, but is
1:27:29 actually healthy because it's expensive to do all the fraud investment, the
1:27:33 cyber investment, the technology investments, these things.
1:27:36 So, um, getting a few more players who are larger and through all parts of that
1:27:42 stack, I think that's a good thing. Do you think that the U.S.
1:27:46 economy right now is strong enough to handle a 50 basis point rate hike next
1:27:50 week or next next month? Look, the the economy is doing well.
1:27:55 I think the issue it's uneven. It's certainly not being felt evenly
1:27:58 across the country. How well the economy is performing.
1:28:02 We're seeing, um, a very stable labor market.
1:28:06 Um, so the yeah, it's a low fire, low, high environment, but nonetheless, it's
1:28:12 pretty close to full employment. Um, you've got consumer spending that is
1:28:17 strong. And, um, we have seen I'm really happy
1:28:20 to see at the lower income households have more been flat rather than going
1:28:26 down. People talk about a K, it's more like
1:28:28 the alligator mouth like that. Um, and we'd rather see the low income
1:28:33 performing even more strongly. Um, but it's not getting it's not
1:28:37 getting worse. Um, so my, my bigger concern, frankly,
1:28:43 on the rate front is the, the causes of the inflation.
1:28:47 I'm not sure the rate hike actually fixes it because we're seeing it from
1:28:51 diesel. We're seeing it from low supply of
1:28:54 housing. We we need 7 million more affordable
1:28:58 housing in the States. It's a we've got a supply problem there.
1:29:03 Um, um, it takes a long time to build refineries around the world, which is
1:29:07 what you need to do, um, to address the diesel issues.
1:29:10 That's driving up prices. So I think one of the concerns many of
1:29:14 the banks has is, yep, the the numbers came in hot.
1:29:19 We could well see rate hikes, but does it actually fix the problem?
1:29:23 That's underpinning it, and that's my nagging concern at the moment.
1:29:27 If it doesn't, then it's kind of a boiling the frog moment where you have
1:29:30 people who are really hurt by higher inflation, at the same time that the
1:29:34 hurt from higher rates. Do you think that people are
1:29:37 underestimating the chance of a slowdown?
1:29:40 Are you at Citi taking down risk in any way in preparation for that, or do you
1:29:43 think that is unlikely because of all of the investment that we're seeing from
1:29:47 other places? Um, you have to be prepared for
1:29:49 everything all the time, particularly in the environment we're in, like the last
1:29:53 two weeks. As a case in point, you would never
1:29:55 expected that. And I think we've all got very good at
1:29:58 it being more adaptable and being more resilient, building and more buffers,
1:30:03 being ready for more things happening. Um, and I think that's part of the
1:30:07 reason why the world economy has done pretty well in the last five years,
1:30:11 despite wars and Covid and tariffs and all these other things have been thrown
1:30:16 at it. Um, so you have to be ready for a
1:30:19 slowdown and something that's more material.
1:30:22 I don't see it as being imminent, but the tail risks are certainly bigger than
1:30:26 they were before. And in that one, we've got to be ready
1:30:30 to support the affordability agenda. That is the reason we had the big shift
1:30:35 in the election. Um, the price is too high.
1:30:39 Um, I think the other piece companies are being very mindful about not passing
1:30:44 on some of the price increases through to consumers because there's a clear
1:30:49 understanding. Earnings have been good.
1:30:51 Let's try and absorb as much of this as possible through the earnings.
1:30:55 We've got um, um, trying to make sure the investments are still going to give
1:31:00 growth into the economy, um, rather than, uh, rather than passing this on to
1:31:05 consumers, um, recklessly. What do you think right now is the
1:31:10 biggest risk that people are underestimating?
1:31:13 Because clearly there's a sense that maybe there's an overbuilding and I.
1:31:18 Or maybe there's a I don't want to say bubble, but excess is happening in
1:31:23 certain pockets there. Maybe you get rates that rise that kill
1:31:26 the party. What's your sense I don't think I think
1:31:29 anyone's, um, overestimating or underestimating anything at the moment.
1:31:34 I think we're all very mindful that we've got the economy that continues to
1:31:39 perform well, not unevenly, but still perform well in the aggregate.
1:31:44 Um, and that there's a number of different take risks.
1:31:47 We know what they are. Um, so I think the biggest risk we have
1:31:51 is if they start converging. And so if you start seeing them feed off
1:31:56 each other, then that's when you tend to get more of a self-fulfilling prophecy
1:32:00 coming. I don't see that yet.
1:32:02 But it you know, it is a possibility at some point.
1:32:05 What I am happy is to see some of the air come out of the tires.
1:32:09 We had a market that was priced to perfection.
1:32:12 We have some high concentration risk in there.
1:32:14 We've had a big election, um, with a big shift and change around.
1:32:18 I'm. And as you say, we've had the leadership
1:32:20 change and I'm in one of the big companies and I all of those different
1:32:25 pieces, you know we're seeing some of the market react to that at the moment.
1:32:30 At the same time, you see anthropic with uh, what looks like will be a very
1:32:34 successful IPO, um, when it comes out tomorrow and, you know, giving
1:32:40 confidence in about the genie not being out of the bottle on the I and that, you
1:32:45 know, this should continue on. But we've all got to be mindful.
1:32:48 Let's do this responsibly. Bring everyone along with us and manage
1:32:53 the risks. I'm going to open it up to questions.
1:32:57 Uh, if anyone has any questions of please just state your name and your
1:33:01 affiliation and, uh, I'll open up now. And you were just listening to the CEO
1:33:08 and chairman of Citi, Jane Frazier, in conversation with Lisa Abramowitz at our
1:33:13 Washington bureau here at Bloomberg. If you have a Bloomberg terminal, you
1:33:17 can continue listening to that Q&A session that is now taking place, uh, by
1:33:21 taking a live go on your Bloomberg terminal.
1:33:24 We do want to reset because we are awaiting the official confirmation of
1:33:27 the pricing of that anthropic IPO based on Bloomberg reporting.
1:33:31 Here is what we know. Anthropic is telling about $801 million,
1:33:34 1 million shares at a price of about $83 apiece.
1:33:38 There's about 24 million shares being offered up by other investors.
1:33:43 And in a private placement that goes along with this of about $26 billion.
1:33:47 So potentially a company that could raise about 100 and billion dollars and
1:33:51 a valuation starting tomorrow, that would likely come in at the open at
1:33:55 around $1.5 trillion. Those are the numbers.
1:33:59 But there are some broader existential questions, not so much just about
1:34:02 anthropic, but about the AI trade and the AI buildout overall, its impact on
1:34:07 our economy, its impact on the workforce.
1:34:10 We want to bring Claire into this conversation.
1:34:12 She previously served as the CEO of Salesforce.
1:34:15 I Head of Business I at meta and now is the founder and CEO of New York New Work
1:34:21 Foundation, Excuse me, which helps young workers build careers within today's AI
1:34:25 economy. Clara, I do want to start on that point,
1:34:28 and I do want to draw our viewers attention to something that Darren has
1:34:33 talked a lot about publicly, but something that was actually in the S-1
1:34:36 itself, and that was the potential for, uh, labor market displacement as a
1:34:42 result of the rollout of large language models and the and the use cases that
1:34:47 they are going to bring to the front. I know this hasn't been addressed in
1:34:51 full, but how aware are we. Of this potential threat?
1:34:55 How serious of that threat is it. And are there solutions on the table
1:34:59 that could potentially mitigate it? Well, thank you so much for having me.
1:35:04 I mean, what a week for us to be here in Silicon Valley and talking about AI.
1:35:08 Um, you know, you're right in the S-1, First, two things that the business is
1:35:13 very strong $33 billion in just nine months, 1,200% revenue growth year over
1:35:20 year. But as you mentioned, there's also a
1:35:23 disclaimer in that S1 seven times anthropic mentions the risk of job
1:35:29 displacement. And I will say, you know, that's
1:35:31 something that I saw firsthand in the last two roles that I had working in Big
1:35:35 Tech. And right now everyone is talking about
1:35:38 where value accrues in the AI stack. Is it energy, is it chips, is it models?
1:35:44 Is it applications? Is the hyperscalers?
1:35:46 But a very important part that we also need to talk about value accruing is the
1:35:50 people. What does this mean for people who are
1:35:53 already in the workforce? What does it mean for the 42.5% of Gen Z
1:35:57 grads in the US who are currently underemployed?
1:36:00 And I think that is an essential part of the question.
1:36:03 As we look at the IPO, well, I mean, how do we address that?
1:36:05 Because this is already showing up. I was in a conversation yesterday with
1:36:08 the head of the Economic Partnership for New York.
1:36:11 The number of job listings, the number of jobs available in this city is much
1:36:16 higher than where they were a year ago. However, entry level jobs, that's down
1:36:21 like 50%. And we can't connect that all directly
1:36:25 to AI. But there are certainly some efficiency
1:36:27 and productivity issues that seem to be driving that.
1:36:30 Does that become more widespread? Unfortunately, I believe so unless we
1:36:35 intervene. And that's really why we're doing the
1:36:38 new work Foundation. And there's there's starting to be more
1:36:40 groups across the country. This is a bipartisan issue.
1:36:44 And the reason is because if you look at what agents are really good at doing,
1:36:48 those entry level, those are entry level tasks that traditionally we would hire
1:36:52 someone out of college to do. It's going to take some time for
1:36:55 colleges and universities and K-12 education to adapt their curriculum.
1:37:00 In the meantime, we have to prepare young people with the mindset, the skill
1:37:05 set and a community to help them thrive in this economy.
1:37:08 What exactly is the skill set? If I'm talking to my teenage son or
1:37:13 someone younger than that, who's going to come into this workforce over the
1:37:16 next five, ten years? What is that skill set that I should be
1:37:19 talking to them about? Now, I think the most important skill
1:37:23 set is actually the ability to quickly acquire skills because of how quickly AI
1:37:28 models are evolving. Every few months, whatever you build,
1:37:32 parts of it can become obsolete. Certainly, this is what we've seen in
1:37:35 the technology sector, and we're starting to see it play out across the
1:37:38 board. But beyond that, I think having a broad
1:37:41 based education, you know, everyone talks about critical thinking, but we
1:37:44 need to go from critical thinking to systems thinking.
1:37:47 And we need to go from problem solving to solution building.
1:37:50 And it isn't just the computer science majors and the engineers that have to
1:37:54 learn how to build. You need to learn how to build agents.
1:37:56 If you're in marketing, in law, in finance, and it's not that hard these
1:38:01 days, it's much easier than before because you can use natural language.
1:38:04 And that's really what we're trying to do with the IRC and New Work Foundation.
1:38:07 Well, I do also just want to be very clear here, Clara.
1:38:10 I mean, you have a relationship with these large language model companies
1:38:13 anthropic, OpenAI, Google, uh, obviously Salesforce.
1:38:16 I'm probably forgetting a couple of others.
1:38:18 So give me a sense here. I mean, if they are the problem, but
1:38:22 you're also trying to find the solution. Is your line of thinking in sync with
1:38:26 the way those companies are thinking? We are in an independent 501 C3
1:38:31 nonprofit, and we do have, um, I credit grants from all the leading labs.
1:38:36 And our mission is to bring young people in, give them a community and some light
1:38:41 structure so that they can get hands on experience building AI.
1:38:45 And we want to give them access to the absolute frontier models from anthropic,
1:38:50 from OpenAI, from Google, because the difference between building with a free
1:38:54 version of ChatGPT versus Babel 5.2 is, is immense.
1:38:58 And to really be prepared for today's workforce, you really need to be
1:39:02 building with a cutting edge. Clara, great to have.
1:39:04 You got to get you back. Clara Shy, founder, the founder and CEO
1:39:08 of a new work foundation. We now want to go to Justin Many.
1:39:11 He's joining us right now portfolio manager over at Harbor Capital who co
1:39:15 manages an ETF built around the anthropic ecosystem and ecosystem, at
1:39:19 least based on Bloomberg reporting right now, is said to be pricing at about 83
1:39:24 bucks a share, much higher, Justin, than what this what was first being marketed
1:39:28 at at around 70. Yeah.
1:39:31 Yeah, absolutely. Thanks for uh, thanks for having me on.
1:39:33 And, um, yeah. So we're, you know, we're obviously
1:39:35 following the news as you guys report it.
1:39:39 Um, it seems like the the offer is going to come in above the initial range.
1:39:44 Um, you know, I think stepping back, we've seen headlines of the last few
1:39:47 days that there's really been a ton of demand, um, for this IPO.
1:39:50 So, you know, if we think about what's happened in the AI infrastructure space
1:39:54 over the last handful of weeks here, we've really seen, um, sort of downward
1:39:58 price action in the space overall. So really, I think, you know, the fact
1:40:03 that we're seeing this IPO price above the high end of the range is sort of a
1:40:07 resounding statement around the appetite for risk here and the appetite for
1:40:11 increasing exposure from investors. What is that I exposure I mean, right
1:40:15 now you're running the ETF that gives people access to the broader ecosystem.
1:40:19 Is there some advantage of me investing directly and solely in ants when it
1:40:24 debuts tomorrow? Yeah.
1:40:26 Great question. So I think the way that we're framing it
1:40:29 is, um, these frontier model companies are so large at this point in time that
1:40:34 there's really not a great sort of, uh, broad based sector exposure in terms of
1:40:39 capturing the overall economic value for these companies.
1:40:41 If you think about a company like anthropic, obviously they disclose, you
1:40:45 know, roughly $900 billion in commitments across various companies in
1:40:49 various sectors. So, you know, our approach here for
1:40:52 investors has been to provide a diversified exposure to the entire
1:40:56 ecosystem. And I think the value proposition of
1:40:59 doing this is that we're still very early on in the overall sort of a
1:41:03 secular trend. And at this point, it's may not entirely
1:41:07 be clear from an investor perspective who is going to end up taking a lot of
1:41:11 the economic value. And, you know, our sort of portfolio,
1:41:14 uh, allows investors to access the entire ecosystem in a very diversified
1:41:18 way. I have to ask you the obvious question,
1:41:21 and I know you probably won't answer it, but if you are an investor, do you come
1:41:25 in tomorrow meaning a secondary market investor and buy this, or do you wait?
1:41:29 Do you wait days, weeks when the dust settles?
1:41:34 Yeah. Um, so I guess the way that I would
1:41:36 frame it is our expectation would be, you know, similar to other large IPOs
1:41:41 that have happened in the last call it four months or so.
1:41:44 Um, we'd expect it to be very volatile, sort of on the first day of trading.
1:41:47 And I would say for anybody who is, you know, looking to invest in the company,
1:41:51 ultimately I think you need to have a long term perspective, um, on sort of
1:41:56 that investment. You know, again, it's going to be
1:41:58 volatile. Day one might be volatile data, but I
1:42:00 think ultimately the way to think about it is, you know, how should it do over
1:42:05 the next three years, five years, ten years as these secular trends play out?
1:42:09 All right, Justin, Justin, many portfolio manager over at Harbor
1:42:12 Capital, we are awaiting on that official pricing out of anthropic, with
1:42:16 Bloomberg reporting suggesting that number could come in at 83 bucks a
1:42:20 share. It will debut tomorrow on the Nasdaq,
1:42:23 the ticker and T full coverage right here on Bloomberg in the after hours
1:42:27 trade. Keep an eye on those cybersecurity
1:42:29 stocks. They rallied hard during the cash
1:42:31 session and they're up even more in the after hours trade.
1:42:34 Palo Alto Networks of 8.6% on the back of its earnings and the back of an eye
1:42:40 acquisition balance of power coming up at the top of the hour with Joe and
1:42:44 Kelly. Stick around a lot more coverage coming
1:42:45 up right here on on Bloomberg.
Fmr. China Amb. Tempers Expectations for Trilat full transcript
0:00 As we look ahead to the bilateral and trilateral meetings that are expected
0:04 tomorrow. What is your expectation as to what will
0:07 be delivered, uh, via them, if anything at all concrete?
0:12 Well, I really don't have, um, high expectations for this summit, whether
0:15 it's with, uh, uh, the President XI of China or the trilateral meeting with
0:20 President Putin of Russia. I think the most that we can expect is
0:24 an extension of the current trade truce, which is set to expire in early January.
0:29 And it's really important that, uh, uh, that the rare earths that China has
0:33 committed to allowing, uh, sales to the United States continue, uh, because
0:38 those rare earths, uh, are really critical for, uh, semiconductor
0:42 manufacturing, electric vehicles, even the, uh, mechanics and the braking
0:46 systems and the engine systems of combustion automobiles, uh, and a whole
0:52 host of advanced machinery. Those are critical because China really
0:56 processes almost 99% of those rare earths that American advanced
1:01 manufacturing needs. Knowing of Mr.
1:05 Ambassador, that President XI and President Trump will meet again in
1:08 December in Miami. What's an appropriate extension of that
1:12 trade truce? That would be a big story for our
1:13 audience if he actually managed to close the deal on that.
1:17 Or is it for the next meeting when they see each other here in the U.S.?
1:21 I think both sides would like to come away with some sort of announcement and
1:24 having an extension of the truce, which had been temporarily extended just a few
1:29 months ago, 2nd January. Yeah, it would be good for both sides to
1:33 provide certainty. The business community on in both China
1:36 and the United States and certainly would, I think, help lower some of the
1:40 tensions between the two countries at the same time.
1:43 I'm sure President Trump will press China to live up to the terms of that
1:48 truce, which is to buy more agricultural products, uh, and to cut down on the
1:54 flow of fentanyl and some of the ingredients used to make fentanyl coming
1:58 out of China, whether it's to Mexico or to the United States.
2:02 Well, and to keep the air flowing to buyers in the U.S.
2:06 that need what she referred to a moment ago.
2:08 Ambassador, how do you believe China when it suggests that it would
2:13 retaliate? If we are to see tougher export
2:15 restrictions coming from the United States on things like semiconductors
2:19 that are allowed to be sold, uh, into China.
2:22 Is where or where you would look first as potential, uh, China retaliation that
2:28 could be coming down if the U.S. moves forward with that.
2:31 Well, first of all, uh, the United States prohibits the sale of Nvidia's,
2:34 uh, Blackwell chips, the most advanced AI chips into China.
2:38 And, uh, China has been able and the Chinese companies have been able to
2:42 exploit a loophole, uh, which is to, uh, where the United States allows the sale
2:47 of these chips to data centers all around the world, and especially in
2:51 Southeast Asia. And these Chinese companies, who are
2:53 prohibited from owning and buying these chips, turn around and lease the
2:58 computing power from these data centers. Um, that's being shut down by the
3:02 Commerce Department right now, a part of the Trump administration as a fallout
3:06 from the Nvidia scandal. And so I'm sure, uh, President XI will
3:10 push for, uh, allowing the sale of some of these advanced chips made perhaps not
3:15 the Blackwell chips, but the next tier of chips, uh, going into China at the
3:21 same time. China does have an Ace card.
3:24 We badly need those rare earths. They're necessary for semiconductor
3:30 manufacturing, automotive manufacturing, just about any type of advanced
3:34 manufacturing. And the reality is that China produces
3:38 and processes some 99% of these rare earths that we need.
3:43 America is now trying to diversify its supply chain.
3:46 Uh, but that will take some time. And in the meantime, our defense
3:49 industries are scrambling to get the rare earths that they need for jets, jet
3:55 fighters, satellites, missiles, and so forth.
3:59 You talk about those data centers, ambassador.
4:01 Uh, throughout Asia, Southeast Asia, many of them have financial interests
4:06 that are close to the Commerce Secretary, Howard Lutton, because his
4:10 sons have taken the canter, a business which is invested in some of these data
4:14 centers. And there have been questions about
4:16 whether that motivated him to pursue lightning export controls or to turn the
4:23 other way, as some have accused. The Commerce secretary knowing that
4:27 Nvidia was watching some of its chips be diverted.
4:32 You had the job. Should Howard Rudnick be on this trip to
4:35 China right now? Well, he can be on the trip, but he's
4:39 going to have to answer to a lot of questions by the members of Congress.
4:42 And I'm sure the media, because in the last months of the Biden administration,
4:47 uh, they came out with a rule that said there cannot be these data centers which
4:51 then lease the computing power to the very Chinese companies that are
4:54 prohibited from even owning these advanced Nvidia Blackwell chips.
5:00 Why the Trump administration and Secretary Ludwick allowed this loophole
5:06 to continue. Uh, we're going to have to find out.
5:09 But certainly, even though he has no financial interest in the Cantor
5:13 Fitzgerald company that he headed in and founded many, many years ago, his family
5:18 owns it now. And, you know, in the back of his mind,
5:20 he knows that, you know, these data centers will benefit his family.
5:24 Or was the, uh, the going easy on these data centers as a result of indirect
5:31 back of the mind influence by the Trump administration and the white House?
5:35 Because, uh, President Trump has, um, profited tens of millions of dollars in
5:42 Nvidia stock. And of course, he's close to Jensen
5:45 Huang and was, um, he was Trump. President Trump influenced by that
5:50 relationship with Jensen Wong? Was Secretary Lundbeck influenced by
5:54 that friendship with Jensen Huang? So do you believe Secretary can be
6:00 trusted to carry out the duties requisite of a Commerce Secretary right
6:04 now? Ambassador.
6:06 Well, right now the Commerce Department has shut down this loophole allowing
6:10 data centers to uh, uh, uh, provide content went out of its way to say was
6:15 written by the Treasury Department, not by the Commerce Department.
6:18 Well, they're going to have to carry it out.
6:20 And I'm sure all the security agencies, the members of Congress and and
6:24 certainly the white House will be watching very carefully to ensure that
6:27 Commerce Department, uh, follows through and executes and implements this tougher
6:32 policy, which was actually proposed by the Biden administration.
6:37 If it's proven that Howard Law turned the other way to allow this to happen,
6:41 and he will have an opportunity to testify in Congress just weeks from now
6:45 should he lose his job over it. Well, that's something that the Trump
6:49 administration and the president will have to decide.
6:51 And I'm sure there will be a lot of scrutiny, uh, from the, uh, members of
6:55 Congress. But certainly if there was a true
6:57 conflict of interest, if he was motivated, uh, by the financial gain
7:02 that his family would uh, uh, have, then that would disqualify him uncertainly in
7:08 a matter of such utmost importance to national security.
Sen. Johnson: Reconciliation Still on the Table full transcript
0:00 You're joining us fresh out of a meeting with senators to discuss reconciliation.
0:04 What's the plan? Well, thanks for having me on.
0:07 Well, first of all, let's talk about something that's going to be a big win
0:09 for America in a completely nonpartisan basis.
0:12 Is the permitting bill. That would be huge.
0:15 Hopefully we'll finish that off tomorrow.
0:17 In terms of reconciliation, that there are downsides to reconciliation.
0:21 I guess, first and foremost, the government funding runs out on December
0:24 11th. Democrats are threatening if we do
0:26 reconciliation. They're not going to cooperate there,
0:28 and we might have a government shutdown. So the consensus of opinion coming out
0:33 of that meeting is, let's give the Democrats one more chance to fund our
0:37 troops, to support the men and women in uniform, to fund national defense.
0:42 Uh, we have not given up on reconciliation at all.
0:45 Uh, if we do do it, I think it will be pretty simple reconciliation plan.
0:49 So I think we'd have time to do it. So we're getting ready to go to the
0:53 conference. Said, let's give the Democrats one more
0:55 time. It's it is preferable to fund defense,
0:58 uh, but support the president's agenda. In a appropriation process, a defense
1:03 supplemental ban is from reconciliation. If we have to do it, we'll have to do
1:07 it. Okay.
1:08 Just so our audience understands, Mr. Chairman, then you would give Democrats
1:13 a chance to weigh in on a continuing resolution, knowing that funding expires
1:17 December 11th. Is that your point there?
1:19 And if it doesn't work out, then you have to put Pentagon money into
1:22 reconciliation, do I understand? No.
1:25 We actually have all the appropriation bills reported out.
1:28 I think the House, the Senate, silver, military Construction, VA, we could
1:31 potentially use that as a vehicle to put a defense supplemental on top of that.
1:36 Again, we've done that cooperatively in the past.
1:38 Give Democrats who actually are concerned about defense of this nation
1:42 to support us in doing that. If that doesn't work, then I think we
1:45 have to turn to reconciliation. Are you worried about a shutdown?
1:48 We're starting to hear that word out loud for the first time just past couple
1:51 of days, with the leadership fight on the Democratic side, uh, the refusal to
1:56 continue funding the war in Iran, according to many Democrats.
1:59 You've seen this movie before. That's about to happen again.
2:02 I think that's what kind of got the conference to come together and say,
2:06 okay, let's give it another shot because they are threatening and they've been so
2:09 obnoxious to shut the government down twice this year.
2:12 Uh, the profile through and the threat. So again, we're we want to avoid a
2:17 shutdown. We're going to go the extra mile.
2:19 You know actually give Democrats example.
2:21 This is how you do things cooperatively. You know, rather than do the
2:24 reconciliation. The bad here will give you another shot.
2:27 Let's fund our troops, defend this nation, and let's let's not shut down
2:31 the government. Let's do a continuing resolution or
2:33 whatever. So we don't have a government shutdown.
2:37 It when it comes to the potential defense supplemental or reconciliation
2:41 package. Does any of this going to be paid for,
2:44 Senator. But we we don't pay for appropriations.
2:49 We've never paid for defense supplemental, either.
2:52 We had the Deputy Defense Secretary Feinberg, in our Senate lunch, and he
2:56 was available, I think, for any senator go down the skiff and be briefed.
3:00 Our nation faces many, many threats overseas.
3:03 This is a dangerous world and they need the funding to to follow through, you
3:08 know, to to counter those threats. Plus, I think I think the Defense
3:13 Department, with the leadership of people like Defense Secretary, uh,
3:19 Feinberg, are doing a great job of trying to reform that the the
3:24 procurement process to the Defense Department.
3:26 And they need to be supported. Yeah.
3:29 Talk to a couple of your colleagues, uh, last evening, uh, in the rotunda there,
3:33 Senator Tom Tillis and Rand Paul both balked when I asked them about a $50
3:39 billion allocation to upgrade or build from scratch.
3:43 Uh, I guess I should put it. Our nation's air traffic control system.
3:46 They thought that number was far more than what was needed.
3:49 And Rand Paul is even suggesting new legislation to unlock other funds re
3:54 appropriate them to this use that have that have actually gone to the Defense
3:57 Department already. Where are you?
3:59 On a $50 billion rebuild? Well, again, I think we absolutely do
4:04 need to upgrade the air traffic control system.
4:07 Yeah, it's not Sean Duffy's fault that the FAA in, you know, prior decades has
4:11 just completely wasted billions of dollars thrown at it and not made much
4:15 progress. They're actually making quite a bit of
4:16 progress with the 12.4 billion that we allocated in the first reconciliation
4:21 package. So I you get it.
4:23 I'm not sure 50 billion is the right number, but hopefully this would be
4:27 something you could also do on a nine person basis.
4:29 I got to believe the Democrats want to keep our sky safe.
4:32 Would like to modernize the system as well.
4:35 And there are plenty of things you need to do in terms of the rules and
4:37 regulations. Following a procurement that apparently
4:40 has kept us from even though we've spent billions from really upgrading our
4:43 system to the point where it should be. Do you see any of the challenges, aside
4:49 from infrastructure at the FAA, being caused by the layoffs we saw in the
4:53 early days of this administration, through the effort of Doge at the
4:56 Department of Transportation and FAA specifically?
5:00 No, I haven't heard that. I haven't really seen that.
5:03 Uh, again, I think we have such an antiquated system.
5:05 You know, other countries are probably not light years, but I'll use that term
5:09 light years ahead of us in terms of monitoring and modernizing their system.
5:12 They've turned to more quasi public private type of relationships.
5:16 We ought to consider that as well, if we simply can't do it through government.
5:20 I'm not a fan of government. I think you recognize that we government
5:23 does not do things very effectively or efficiently.
5:27 There are some things in Washington you can count on.
5:29 Uh, Mr. Chairman, you're not only budget chair,
5:31 you're also chair. People should know of the Homeland
5:33 Security Subcommittee on Investigations. And we had quite a conversation today
5:39 with the Secretary of Homeland Security, Mark Wayne Mullen, the DNI, and others,
5:44 talking about a range of issues, including the cascading outages, uh,
5:48 that we have seen, uh, when it comes to the outages and when it comes to some of
5:54 the other concerns that people have about what's happening right now
5:58 technologically around them, and whether the administration has its arms around
6:02 artificial intelligence. Would you call the Secretary?
6:05 Secretary Mullen, and testify before your committee?
6:09 Well, first of all, I don't think anybody has their arms around artificial
6:12 intelligence, including the creators of artificial intelligence.
6:15 You know, when it comes to government and artificial intelligence, we'd
6:18 probably be able to tax it. We'd probably use the fear to grow
6:21 government and furthermore, our kids future, but but actually come up with
6:25 reasonable regulations. I doubt it.
6:28 Uh, the. We are living in a complex world, in
6:30 some more interconnected world, which leaves us more vulnerable.
6:34 And we all believe in. We live in these, you know, superhero
6:39 type of movie situations where you expect somebody who's just come in here
6:42 to save the day or have instant answers. You can't have those instant answers.
6:46 So, you know, I'm taking the ministrations in good faith that they
6:50 have not seen a specific cyber threat. It's totally possible to me that as I is
6:55 identifying vulnerabilities in systems. People are addressing those or upgrading
7:00 those systems. It's not perfect.
7:02 I come from manufacturing. Murphy's law is a very tried and true
7:06 reality. And you know, if something goes wrong,
7:09 it will go wrong. So again, they're not they're not
7:12 identifying specific cyber threats I believe that.
7:15 I'm not saying it's not possible. But again, we live in a complex
7:18 interconnected world and it makes us vulnerable.
7:22 Well, a lot of eyes were on that hearing today.
7:24 But we know, Mr. Chairman, there was also a hearing that
7:28 you hosted today on the future of Social Security.
7:30 And there's obviously an interview you did on another network that has gone a
7:34 bit viral with a suggestion that Social Security is a Ponzi scheme that isn't
7:38 flexible and needs to be shut down. I'm obviously summarizing the clip.
7:43 Uh, Senator, I know you've said those remarks were taken out of context.
7:47 So what exactly is the fix for Social Security if you don't believe it needs
7:50 to be shut down? No, I would call it precise.
7:52 And I ask anybody to read my full chairman's memo.
7:55 I'm not suggesting shutting down Social Security.
7:57 I'm obviously drawing attention to the problem.
8:00 It does operate as a legal Ponzi scheme. And what I've suggested, I actually
8:05 introduce a piece of legislation today because I got everybody's attention.
8:09 Stop Scaring Seniors Act, which would amend the laws so that we would not
8:14 reduce benefits when the trust fund accounting
8:19 entry runs out. The trust fund has no value.
8:22 I'm trying to point that out. Those bonds are worthless to US
8:25 government. So I'm trying to lay out the reality.
8:27 Get people to understand we've got a problem here.
8:29 But even if we fix Social Security with very destructive proposals like raising
8:34 the income, the wage gap or the income cap that would harm our economy, it's
8:39 only going to fix 20% of our long term deficit problem.
8:42 We're not addressing 80%. So again, I hope Democrats join me.
8:47 All the ones that are, you know, looking at my imprecise comments and say, I
8:51 never see I never would shut down Social Security.
8:53 We need to preserve it. We need to save it.
8:56 And I'm just trying to draw attention to the issue and sign on to my Stop Scaring
9:00 Seniors Act, which would make sure that we do not reduce benefits, but it will
9:04 make us focus on the larger problem, which is $24 trillion in deficits over
9:09 the next ten years and growing. Well, Senator, we saw another seat
9:15 flipped by Democrats overnight this time, Alaska, which makes nine.
9:19 I don't have to do the math for you. I'm just wondering, as somebody who has
9:22 lived through minorities and majorities, what do you think this means for John
9:26 Thune and how he can best represent the Republican agenda in this new Congress?
9:32 Well, unfortunately, I think the debate over the next two years is literally
9:35 this is sad. This is sad.
9:37 We're going to have to be debating the value of free market competition versus
9:41 socialism. I mean, it's I cannot believe in America
9:46 100 years into the failed socialistic systems that destroyed economies,
9:52 nations and people's lives resulted in the murder of tens of millions of
9:55 people. Now we've got a high percentage of
9:58 American population, particularly our youth, who've been indoctrinated in our
10:02 school systems embracing that destructive type of ideology.
10:06 So again, I think that's going to be the debate.
10:08 Are you going to embrace growing government that's grossly inefficient,
10:12 creates all kinds of fraud, wastes taxpayer money, can't even manage the
10:18 number one supported program in America, which is Social Security.
10:21 Can't even properly manage that without having it go bankrupt.
10:25 Do you want government to grow? Do these all these other things just not
10:28 capable of doing it? Yeah.
10:30 Well, this is what the voters asked for, isn't it?
10:33 Yeah. And unfortunately, sometimes we've
10:35 always get what they wanted. You know, so, uh.
10:37 Or get what they voted for. That will be unfortunate for this
10:40 country. Socialism does not work.
10:42 Growing government does not work. We're going to have to make that case.
10:46 And again, we're making against the relatively leftist media and leftist
10:51 education system. That's not a level playing field.
10:54 It's not a fair fight.
Rep. Trahan Says Congress Must Keep Pace With AI full transcript
0:00 Does this IPO for anthropic? Assuming it is successful, combined with
0:05 everything that we have heard about the Jensen Huang scandal at Nvidia act as an
0:09 accelerant to export controls and as well your AI regulatory bill.
0:16 Well, I certainly hope so. I mean, I, I understand why people are
0:19 extremely concerned, uh, not just with anthropic rushing, uh, ahead with their
0:25 IPO, but also, uh, you know, with the recent news, uh, with Nvidia, uh, that's
0:30 why you're seeing so many Democrats and Republicans, uh, call for hearings in
0:35 terms of what the administration knew and when, uh, about, um, you know, uh,
0:41 Jensen Huang and, uh, and his influence on our chip policy.
0:46 Um, but look, when I'm back home, uh, you know, people are concerned about AI
0:50 safety. Um, they want to make sure Congress is
0:52 getting off the sidelines, keeping pace with the most powerful, transformative
0:57 technology in human history. Uh, and so right now we're seeing, uh,
1:02 these, these companies really accelerate, uh, even the ones like
1:06 anthropic who have touted, uh, the importance of safety and guardrails.
1:11 Uh, and now people are expecting Congress to, uh, keep pace with that.
1:15 Um, you know, obviously, the frontier Act is, is a bipartisan, uh, you know,
1:20 bill that would require safety, uh, and transparency reporting, incident reports
1:26 when, uh, a model goes rogue, uh, and also a process by which the government
1:32 can step in if a model is, uh, capable of a catastrophic risk.
1:38 Well, without legislative effort. Uh, Congresswoman, affect potentially
1:43 the financial outlook for a company that is now going to be one of the largest
1:47 public companies out there and potentially have a pretty heavy
1:50 weighting in American's retirement portfolios.
1:53 That is the concern that has been raised by, uh, Senator Elizabeth Warren
1:56 suggesting that anthropic is doing this IPO, even despite existential risk and
2:01 potential threats to retirement and the financial system.
2:04 Do you see that threat as as being there?
2:07 Well, what I see the threat is us not having any safety guardrails, right?
2:12 I mean, there is not a trade off between safety and innovation.
2:16 Uh, we can still move responsibly or responsibly on, uh, innovation while
2:22 making sure that we've got the proper guardrails in place.
2:25 Those two things never trade off against each other.
2:27 In fact, that is the reason why we are a leader in innovation.
2:31 And so, you know, some of these, uh, the provisions that are in our bill, you
2:37 know, these uh, companies have already, uh, sort of volunteered to do.
2:41 But we're really operating right now on the honor system, and that is not
2:46 sustainable going forward. We need to have that built into our
2:50 statute that these companies are required to, uh, to publish their safety
2:55 reports. Their model cards show the public that
2:58 they're mitigating those risks. When there's not just an event or a
3:03 model that's capable of catastrophic risk, but even a near miss, like we saw
3:08 with the hugging face incident, that those are reported to the government and
3:13 we have embedded evaluators so that these companies aren't creating their
3:17 own work. Those are the things that the American
3:19 public expects the government to keep up with.
3:22 And that is what's going to foster more innovation is when we have the trust of
3:27 the American people that we've got, you know, an ecosystem in place to guarantee
3:31 safety. And how do you get an AI regulatory
3:35 bill, like the Frontier Act passed Congress and into law when you've got an
3:40 administration on the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue that does not seem
3:44 to have an appetite for slowing or pacing the frontier, as they call it.
3:48 Howard Rudnick is on the plane to China, despite the allegations of turning the
3:52 wrong way when it comes to Nvidia chip export controls.
3:55 Congresswoman, is is that the main obstacle?
3:59 Oh, look, there's no question that this has to be, uh, bipartisan.
4:03 I mean, we still have, uh, to get to 60 votes in the Senate, and we still need
4:08 to get the president's signature. Um, but I've always maintained that, uh,
4:12 we can come together as we did this past summer.
4:15 Uh, you know, we had, uh, Republican co-sponsors on the on the frontier bill.
4:20 I think we can do that again. And when you have a bipartisan bill that
4:24 lands on the president's desk, you really do put pressure on him to sign
4:28 that bill. And I'll also note, you know, when the
4:30 president summoned those tech executives to the white House and they established
4:35 the white House accords, many of the provisions that comprise the Frontier
4:39 Act, uh, were part of, uh, those, you know, volunteer, um, agreements.
4:45 So, you know, all we're wanting to do is to make sure that this isn't a volunteer
4:51 system anymore, that this is something that is, uh, you know, durable, uh, and
4:57 understood so that, uh, all companies, not just the biggest frontier labs, but
5:02 other companies that are, you know, innovating and emerging, know the rules
5:06 of the road. What about, uh, the notion of stricter
5:11 export controls? Congressman Joe just alluded to the
5:14 Commerce secretary, Howard. There's a question of the enforcement of
5:18 existing controls, but there's been a lot of talk, and we've had a
5:21 conversation with some of your colleagues about, uh, measures being put
5:25 into the National Defense Authorization Act, which needs to pass in this lame
5:29 duck session to tighten those. Are you supportive of all of them?
5:32 And would they have made it impossible for something like the Nvidia Mega Speed
5:37 Saga to have happened in the first place?
5:40 Look, I certainly support tightening, uh, the rules on our most advanced chips
5:45 going to China. Uh, you know, it's been interesting to
5:49 me to watch the debate on this. On the one hand, we've heard from, you
5:54 know, Republicans that we can't slow down, we can't put guardrails on AI
5:58 companies because we have to beat China. And here we are, uh, you know, allowing
6:03 China access to our, our chips. Uh, so you, you know, you you can't
6:08 provide the infrastructure or the chips to, uh, to, um, you know, our, our
6:14 biggest competitor, uh, and, you know, uh, not square that with the American
6:19 people around putting safety guardrails. So, look, I think conversations are
6:23 ongoing about how we best can, uh, do that through the legislative process.
6:28 Uh, it sounds like the white House has definitely changed their tune after, uh,
6:32 the, uh, Nvidia scandal. I think that's a good thing.
6:35 I'm hopeful that we'll be able to make some progress, because if you're worried
6:39 about Chinese competition on AI, you should absolutely be worried about, uh,
6:44 handing them the compute. Uh, that makes that possible.
6:48 You know, a lot of people are worried, Congresswoman, and I'm sure that you've
6:51 spoken with friends and family members and fellow lawmakers about this, the
6:54 series of outages that we've seen from Microsoft to the banks to some airlines,
6:59 whether I was to blame for this, the FBI, in fact, just warned yesterday that
7:05 hackers have been using a tool that you might have heard of called RTX, to
7:09 attack organizations worldwide. It is the horse already out of the barn.
7:16 Well, look, I think, uh, whether it's, ah, our airports, uh, the NSA banks, uh,
7:23 outlook, um, people have questions. Uh, and I think every one of these
7:27 organizations have indicated that this isn't a cyber attack or the result of,
7:31 uh, rogue AI. Um, but I'm fairly confident, especially
7:36 after hearing our top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, Senator
7:40 Mark Warner. Uh, I is still involved.
7:42 I mean, the fact of the matter is that these new AI tools are surfacing
7:47 vulnerabilities, um, that we need to, uh, shore up.
7:51 And when you administer this many patches all at once, things are going to
7:56 break. Uh, so I think, look, this, this
7:59 technology is moving faster than, uh, anybody really thought.
8:03 Um, I think that really underscores why, uh, we've been pushing for these AI
8:08 guardrails, uh, so that we can get in front of it rather than, you know, be
8:11 responding to it. Uh, at a minimum, we need to prevent a
8:16 catastrophic event. Um, but we also, you know, we need to do
8:20 so much more. Uh, and so I think these outages are
8:23 really adding to, uh, the anxiety, but also the pressure, uh, for Congress to
8:29 do something, uh, so that we are, uh, building resilience.
8:33 We are building capability, uh, in the agencies that oversee our critical
8:38 infrastructure. And we're also putting in the most table
8:41 stakes, uh, common sense guardrails around this technology.
Citi CEO Expects More Tech Outages full transcript
0:00 It does seem like this hasn't been a great week for Tech Trust when it comes
0:04 to trusting our technology. Considering the FAA went down and so did
0:07 Apple and JP Morgan experience problems, there've been all these tech outages.
0:11 Should we go buy gold bars? Uh, look, I, I can I can empathize a lot
0:18 as to why this is unsettling at the moment.
0:20 There's been a lot in the last couple of weeks.
0:23 Um, but let's take a little bit of a step back.
0:27 What? And I just give some reassurance.
0:30 Um, the volume of changes, the patches that is going through the world's tech
0:38 stack at the same time is, you know, five, ten fold what we've ever seen
0:43 before. Um, you know, it shouldn't be a complete
0:47 surprise to anyone that that doesn't always go well, but it doesn't mean it's
0:52 a disaster. Um, so what we're seeing is.
0:56 And we should be expecting for a while, some more downtime, some more outages in
1:01 different areas as we upgrade the tech stacks to the latest versions of
1:06 different releases, to putting the patches to the vulnerabilities.
1:10 And at the end of the day, it will make us all a lot, um, more resilient.
1:16 Um, word that we've all been learning that's both emotional, mental and
1:20 physical. Um, but it builds resiliency.
1:24 And that's going to be very important because these models are powerful and in
1:27 bad actors hands, they can be a problem. Um, and I think it's just reinforcing
1:32 the need to make investments in modernizing our technology, um, and in
1:36 making sure that we're thinking about resiliency.
1:39 But we shouldn't be surprised this is happening when the models that really
1:44 powerful models came out six months ago, we knew that this was likely to happen
1:49 just given the volume of changes.
More Fed Rate Hates Expected full transcript
0:01 ♪ >> THIS IS "BLOOMBERG BUSINESS
0:02 WEEK DAILY." REPORTING FROM THE MAGAZINE THAT
0:05 HELPS GLOBAL LEADERS STAY AHEAD WITH INSIGHT ON THE PEOPLE,
0:09 COMPANIES, AND TRENDS SHAPING TODAY'S COMPLEX ECONOMY.
0:13 PLUS GLOBAL BUSINESS, FINANCE, AND TECH NEWS THAT HAPPENS.
0:16 "BLOOMBERG BUSINESS WEEK DAILY" WITH CAROL MASSAR AND TIM
0:20 STENOVEC. LIVE ON BLOOMBERG RADIO,
0:23 TELEVISION, AND BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS.
0:27 CAROL: VERY GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYBODY, ACROSS BLOOMBERG
0:30 PLATFORMS, TV, RADIO, YOUTUBE, BLOOMBERG ORIGINALS.
0:32 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG BUSINESS WEEK DAILY."
0:35 YEAH, IT'S A FED WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
0:38 WE'VE GOT THE S&P SLIGHTLY LOWER TODAY.
0:41 IT'S WAY DOWN BY NVIDIA AGAIN. WE'RE ALSO VERY MUCH FOCUSED ON
0:43 THE FED, BECAUSE WE'RE GOING TO GET FED MINUTES IN JUST A
0:45 MOMENT. WE DID HAVE FED GOVERNOR CHRIS
0:48 WALLER COMING OUT SAYING INFLATION REMAINS HEADED IN THE
0:51 WRONG DIRECTION, SO HE'S URGING THE FED TO CONSIDER A LARGER
0:55 HALF PERCENTAGE POINT RATE HIKE AT THE DECEMBER MEETING.
0:58 TIM: WE AWAIT THE FED MINUTES OUT IN JUST A COUPLE OF SECONDS
1:00 AT THAT OCTOBER MEETING. ARE THEY OUT?
1:04 CAROL: THEY'RE OUT. MCMIKE KEY AT THE FED IN D.C.
1:07 MIKE: CHRIS WALLER WASN'T THE ONLY ONE.
1:09 WE SAW IN THE MINUTES THAT OTHERS WERE IN FAVOR OF PERHAPS
1:15 MOVING AT A BRISKER PACE IF INFLATION CALLS FOR IT.
1:19 AS EXPECTED, THE MINUTES DESCRIBE FED POLICY MAKERS IN
1:23 AGREEMENT THAT INFLATION RISKS WERE STILL HIGH WITH THE VAST
1:27 MAJORITY, KIND OF A NEW MODIFIER FOR THE FED, SEEING RISKS TO THE
1:30 OUTLOOK. WHILE MOST FAVORED NOT MOVING IN
1:33 OCTOBER, ALMOST ALL PARTICIPANTS JUDGED THAT UNDER THEIR BASELINE
1:37 OUTLOOK FOR INFLATION IN THE LABOR MARKET, FURTHER ACTION TO
1:41 RAISE THE TARGET RATE, OR THE FEDERAL FUNDS RATE, WOULD LIKELY
1:43 BE APPROPRIATE. SOME PARTICIPANTS FAVORED A
1:46 QUARTER POINT INCREASE AT THE OCTOBER MEETING, ARGUING THE
1:51 CURRENT POLICY STATUS WAS NOT RESTRICTIVE ENOUGH.
1:54 THEY WORRIED FURTHER DELAY RISKED MORE DISRUPTIVE
1:57 TIGHTENING LATER. AND WE KNOW THAT LISA COOK AND
2:01 BETH HAMMACK DISSENTED AT THE MEETING.
2:03 A FEW OF THE MINUTES GO ON TO SAY WHO DID FAVOR AN INCREASE IN
2:06 THE RATE INDICATED THAT THEY COULD HAVE SUPPORTED NO CHANGE,
2:09 PROVIDED IT WAS CLEARLY UNDERSTOOD BY MARKET
2:12 PARTICIPANTS THAT FURTHER TARGETING, TIGHTENING WAS
2:14 LIKELY. CHRIS WALLER NOT THE ONLY ONE
2:17 LOOKING FOR MORE MOVES, AS I MENTIONED, A COUPLE OF
2:21 PARTICIPANTS NOTED THAT AN INCREASE OF MORE THAN 25 BASIS
2:25 POINTS COULD BE WARRANTYING THE NEXT MEETINGS IF INFLATION
2:30 CONTINUED TO RISE. SOME SUGGESTED MARKET-COMPLIED
2:33 EXPECTATIONS OF TIGHTENING IN DECEMBER AND NEXT YEAR WERE
2:37 BROADLY CONSISTENT WITH THEIR VIEWS OF THE APPROPRIATE RATE,
2:40 AND SEVERAL SAW THAT ALIGNMENT AS THEY PUT IT AS REDUCING THE
2:44 RISK FROM KEEPING RATES UNCHANGED AT THIS MEETING.
2:48 THE VOTE WAS CARRIED BY MANY POINTING TO BENEFITS THAT
2:53 ACCOMMODATE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, CITING THE NEED TO
2:56 ASSESS THE DURABILITY OF A.I.-RELATED INVESTMENT DEMAND,
2:58 THE EVOLUTION OF FINANCING CONDITIONS, THE IMPACT OF THE
3:02 SEPTEMBER RATE INCREASE, AND GEOPOLITICAL DEVELOPMENTS.
3:06 SOME SUGGESTED A GRADUAL APPROACH WOULD ALSO HAVE
3:08 HOUSEHOLDS AND BUSINESSES A CHANCE TO ADJUST.
3:12 BUT THE COMMITTEE NOTES THAT IT UNDERSCORED ITS CONTINUING
3:16 RESOLVE TO ACHIEVE ITS DUAL MAN DATE GOALS BY INDICATING THAT IT
3:20 WILL DELIVER PRICE STABILITY. CAROL: YEAH, I WOULD SAY.
3:24 THE MESSAGE IS CLEAR, WE STILL HAVE INFLATION.
3:27 I WANT TO POINT OUT, SLIGHT UP TICK AT THE SHORTER END OF THE
3:30 YIELD CURVE. TWO-YEAR NOTE JUST KICKING UP
3:32 SLIGHTLY. RIGHT NOW WE'RE AT A YIELD OF
3:37 4.79. EQUITIES ALSO TURNING OVER A
3:39 LITTLE BIT. THEY'VE BEEN DOWN MOST OF THE
3:42 DAY. BUT JUST COMING DOWN A LITTLE
3:45 BIT, SO VERY SLIGHT REACTION. I WANT TO GIVE IT SOME SIZE AND
3:48 SCOPE HERE. WE'RE STILL JUST DOWN ABOUT TWO
3:52 POINTS ON THE S&P 500 AND STILL HOLDING ON TO A GAIN OF 138
3:55 POINTS ON THE NASDAQ 100. TIM: I WANT TO HOME IN ON
3:58 SOMETHING YOU SAID. I'M READING FROM THE MINUTES
4:00 RIGHT HERE, UNCERTAINTY ABOUT THE PROJECTED TRAJECTORY OF KEY
4:04 A.I. FIRMS AND ABOUT THE SUSTAINABILITY OF THE PACE OF
4:08 THE BUILDOUT OF A.I. DATA CENTERS.
4:14 THIS WAS ALL BEFORE WE SAW THE BLUE TSUNAMI EARLIER THIS MONTH,
4:17 AND ALSO WHEN WE LEARNED ABOUT JENSEN HUANG, HE WAS THE C.E.O.
4:20 OF NVIDIA WHEN THIS HAPPENED. HE IS OUT, OF COURSE, AND
4:22 SHAREHOLDERS HAVE BEEN CONCERNED ABOUT WHAT NVIDIA'S FUTURE LOOKS
4:24 LIKE. JUST LOOK AT THE RESULTS OVER
4:28 THE LAST FEW WEEKS. WHAT WOULD YOU SAY ABOUT THE
4:31 CHANGES THAT WE'VE SEEN THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS, FURTHER
4:34 CHANGING HOW THESE FED MEMBERS VIEW THE UNCERTAINTY AROUND
4:38 A.I.? MIKE: I THINK IT INCREASES THE
4:41 UNCERTAINTY AROUND A.I. THEY HAD NO IDEA WHAT WOULD
4:45 HAPPEN WITH JENSEN HUANG AND NVIDIA, BUT THERE HAD BEEN A
4:49 GROWING ANTI-DATA CENTER MOVE IN THE BODY POLITIC THAT WAS
4:53 REFLECTED ON ELECTION DAY, AND THERE ARE ALSO CONCERNS ABOUT
4:55 HOW MUCH MONEY WAS BEING SPENT BY THE A.I. HYPER SCALERS AND
4:57 WHETHER THEY COULD KEEP THAT UP AND KEEP THE BORROWING UP
5:01 NECESSARY TO FUND IT. SO YOU CAN SEE WHY MEMBERS WERE
5:06 LOOKING AT THE POSSIBILITY OF A SLOWDOWN, BECAUSE A.I.
5:09 INVESTMENT SPENDING IS REALLY WHAT WAS PUSHING IT HIGHER, AND
5:13 SO IT WAS A KEY REASON TO WORRY ABOUT WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN TO THE
5:17 ECONOMY LATER. BUT ALSO WHAT MIGHT HAPPEN TO
5:20 INFLATION, BECAUSE THEY DO SEE, AND THEY REMARKED SEVERAL TIMES
5:23 IN THE MINUTES, THAT A.I. SPENDING WAS PUSHING UP PRICES.
5:29 CAROL: WE TALKED ABOUT FED GOVERNOR CHRIS WALLER SAYING HE
5:32 FAVORED A 50 BASIS POINT MOVE IN DECEMBER.
5:34 ARE WE FEELING THE DRUM BEAT A LITTLE BIT LOUDER AND LOUDER
5:37 WHEN IT COMES TO A MORE AGGRESSIVE MOVE FOR THE LAST FED
5:42 FOMC MEETING OF THIS YEAR? MIKE: WELL, THAT COULD BE THE
5:43 CASE. I MENTIONED CHRIS WALLER.
5:46 HIS NAME IS NOT MENTIONED IN THE MINUTES, BUT OBVIOUSLY HE CAME
5:49 OUT TODAY AND REITERATED WHAT HE HAD SAID ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY
5:52 OF A 50 BASIS POINT MOVE. BUT IT DOES SUGGEST THAT SOME
5:56 OTHERS FELT THE SAME WAY AND TALKED ABOUT IT AT THE MEETING,
6:01 THAT IF THEY DIDN'T RAISE RATES, THEY MIGHT HAVE TO DO MORE
6:03 LATER, AND THEY MIGHT BE OK WITH THAT.
6:05 IT DOESN'T TAKE THAT OFF THE TABLE, OBVIOUSLY REENFORCES A
6:08 LITTLE BIT OF WHAT CHRIS WALLER SAID.
6:10 WE DON'T WHO KNOW THOSE PEOPLE ARE, BUT WE DON'T KNOW IF
6:13 THEY'RE NECESSARILY VOTERS OR JUST PARTICIPANTS, BUT IT DOES
6:17 SUGGEST THAT THE POSSIBILITY IS OUT THERE, THAT THE INFLATION
6:21 NUMBERS GET ANY WORSE. CAROL: AND WE'VE KNOWN THE
6:25 INFLATION IS PERSISTENT AND CONTINUES.
6:27 MIKE MCKEE, COME BACK HOME AM THAT IS MICHAEL MCKEE, OUR
6:30 INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS AND POLICY CORRESPONDENT AT THE
6:32 FEDERAL RESERVE IN D.C. TIM: LAST WEEK LAST WEEK, D.C.
6:36 THIS WEEK. HE'S A JET SETTER.
6:40 I MISS HIM IN THE OFFICE. CAROL: I KNOW.
6:43 HE SITS RIGHT BEHIND TIM. TIM: I KNOW, MY GUY.
6:46 CAROL: AND MIKE GIVES A GREAT HEADS UP ON A LOT OF IMPORTANT
6:48 STUFF. ALL RIGHT, LET'S GET TO, NOW
6:51 THAT WE'VE GOT THE FED MINUTES TAKEN CARE OF, LET'S GET TO
6:54 NVIDIA. CERTAINLY SOMETHING THAT'S BEEN
6:56 ON OUR MINDS, WE'RE GOING TO GET TO THAT, AND ALSO TALK ABOUT THE
6:59 U.S. ECONOMY. WE'RE GOING TO DO THAT FORMER
7:03 BANK ECONOMIST. THAT WILL COME UP ABOUT 10
7:05 MINUTES FROM NOW. GTA6, WE GOT TO TALK ABOUT GRAND
7:08 THEFT AUTO. TIM: THAT MIGHT HIT
7:12 PRODUCTIVITY, TRULY. CAROL: I WAS DROPPING OFF A SHOE
7:16 ROW O REPAIR, AND HE SAID, YEAH, I'M GOING TO BE OUT THURSDAY
7:19 WEDNESDAY. HE SAID WEDNESDAY, SO I HAVE NO
7:20 IDEA. TIM: UNLESS HE'S GOING TO NEW
7:23 ZEALAND TO PLAY. CAROL: WAS PLANNING ON STAYING,
7:26 I DON'T KNOW. BUT HE BROUGHT UP THE
7:28 PRODUCTIVITY. ALL RIGHT, LET'S GET TO NVIDIA,
7:30 FOLKS. I KNOW, I LOVE IT WHEN -- NEW
7:35 YORK, CAB DRIVERS, SHOPKEEPERS, YOU ALWAYS ARE TALKING ABOUT THE
7:38 ECONOMY. ALL RIGHT LOOK, TALK ABOUT
7:41 NVIDIA T. IS DOWN A FIFTH CONSECUTIVE DAY, NEARLY 13%
7:43 LOSS. THE EARNINGS WE GOT LATE LAST
7:45 NIGHT. NVIDIA BOOSTED ITS SOLES
7:50 FORECAST FOR NEXT YEAR, VOWED TO IMPROVE ACCESS TO CRITICAL
7:53 SUPPLIERS, WHILE TAMPING DOWN SPECULATION JENSEN HUANG MIGHT
7:54 RETURN. NVIDIA WAS CLEAR WHEN IT CAME TO
7:59 ITS RECENTLY DEPARTED, LONG-TIME LEADER JENSEN HUANG, ABOUT
8:00 COMING BACK. HE IS NOT, TIM, THAT'S WHAT THE
8:03 BOARD SAYS. TIM: SPEAKING OF THE BOARD, RENE
8:10 HAAS HAS BEEN APPROACHED, THE LATEST HEADLINE.
8:13 WITH MORE ON NVIDIA'S BUSINESS AND LAST NIGHT'S CALL, PACK WITH
8:16 US IS IAN KING, OUR SEMICONDUCTOR REPORTER.
8:18 HE JOINS US FROM OUR SAN FRANCISCO BUREAU.
8:20 WE'LL GET TO THE CALL AND THE REACTION TODAY, BUT FIRST, I
8:23 WANT TO GET TO THIS HEADLINE THAT CROSSED THE BLOOMBERG
8:26 TERMINAL IN THE LAST FEW MINUTES, THAT ARM C.E.O. RENE
8:30 HAAS HAS BEEN APPROACHED BY NVIDIA'S RECRUITMENT FIRM.
8:34 WHAT CAN YOU TELL US YOU LEARNED?
8:37 IAN: JUST THAT BASICALLY. THIS FIRM HAS BEEN HIRED BY
8:39 NVIDIA'S BOARD. THEY'RE VERY FAMOUS RECRUITING
8:45 FIRM, THE DEFUNCT CHOICE IN MANY RESPECTS.
8:48 AND WE WERE TOLD BY THE BOARD AND THE COMPANY THAT THEY HAD
8:52 NOT BEGUN THAT PROCESS, BUT NOW IT APPEARS THAT THEY HAVE, AND
8:57 SOME OF THESE NAMES, SUCH AS RENE HAAS FROM ARM, WHO USED TO
9:02 WORK FOR JENSEN BACK IN THE DAY, WAS AN NVIDIA EXECUTIVE FOR A
9:05 LONG TIME, AND NOW BEING APPROACHED, THAT THIS PROCESS
9:10 HAS ACTUALLY BEEN STARTED FORMALLY.
9:11 CAROL: I ASSUME WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO GET DIFFERENT TYPES
9:15 OF HEADLINES LIKE THIS, IAN, UNTIL THEY ACTUALLY DECIDE WHO
9:20 WILL BE THE NEXT C.E.O. OF NVIDIA.
9:23 OF COURSE, THEY HAVE AN VERY VERY VERY VERY, WHO'S ALSO THE
9:26 C.F.O. WALK US THROUGH YESTERDAY, THE
9:27 RESULTS. IT SEEMED LIKE A PRETTY SOLID
9:30 REPORT. WHAT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT WAS
9:33 ABOUT THE OUTLOOK, THE SALES PROJECTION, AND THEN ALSO KIND
9:39 OF THE TENOR ON THE CALL, WALK US THROUGH WHAT WE GOT ALL
9:44 YESTERDAY AND WHAT YOUR VIEW IS ON THIS.
9:46 YOU'VE COVERED THIS COMPANY FOR A LONG TIME.
9:49 IAN: THE BIG NUMBER, THERE WAS JUST ONE NUMBER THAT MATTERED,
9:52 AND THEY HAD SAID, HEY, LOOK, 2028 IS GOING TO BE A GREAT
9:56 YEAR, 70% REVENUE GROWTH, ONLY CAPPED BY SUPPLY.
10:00 COLETTE KRESS, THE INTERIM C.E.O. AND C.F.O., SAID, GUESS
10:04 WHAT, GUYS, 75%, AND WE'RE GETTING BACK TO SUPPLY AND
10:07 WORKING HARDER AT THAT. THAT WAS THE THING THAT WAS ON
10:09 EVERYBODY'S MIND, AND THAT WAS THE BOX SHE WAS ABLE TO TICK.
10:15 IN GENERAL, SHE TICKED PRETTY MUCH ALL OF THE BOXES, WENT TO
10:20 ALL OF THE CONCERN POINTS, AND ADDRESSED THEM.
10:23 NOT THAT SHE NEEDS MY ENFORCEMENT, BUT DID A GOOD JOB,
10:26 AND AN INCREASINGLY STRONG JOB AS THE CALL WENT ON.
10:29 SHE SOUNDED VERY TIRED. SHE SOUNDED YOUR HONOR A LOT OF
10:32 STRESS, BUT SHE SEEMED TO HANDLE IT QUITE WELL.
10:34 THE REACTION FROM WALL STREET ANALYSTS WAS PRETTY POSITIVE.
10:37 LATE LAST NIGHT, OBVIOUSLY THIS MORNING WE COME IN, WE THINK
10:40 ABOUT IT, AND WE THINK THERE'S STILL A BIG QUESTION THAT HASN'T
10:42 BEEN ANSWERED. CAROL: BUT SHE WAS NOT THE FIRST
10:45 VOICE, AM I CORRECT? I THOUGHT I HEARD LED LED SAY IT
10:48 WAS THE CHAIR OF THE BOARD. TIM: YEAH, HARVEY C. JONES,
10:50 YEAH. CAROL: WAS THAT SIGNIFICANT TO
10:54 HAVE HIM BE THE FIRST VOICE HEARD?
10:57 IAN: WELL, WHEN WE WERE TALKING THIS TIME YESTERDAY, WHAT WE
11:01 WERE TALKING ABOUT, WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE OUSTED C.E.O.,
11:05 JENSEN HUANG, MAKING HIS BID, SAYING, HERE I AM, DON'T FORGET
11:07 ABOUT ME. I WOULDN'T MIND DOING THIS JOB.
11:10 AND THEN STRAIGHT AWAY, YOU KNOW, CLEARLY THAT WAS ALL
11:14 ANYBODY WANTED TO HEAR ABOUT, AND THAT WAS THE FIRST THING
11:18 THAT THEY SAID, LOOK, HE RESIGNED, WE UNANIMOUSLY
11:22 ACCEPTED HIS RESIGNATION, AND WE ARE NOT LOOKING TO BRING HIM
11:25 BACK. SO DON'T ASK US ABOUT THAT IS
11:27 BASICALLY WHAT HE SAID. TIM: DIDN'T STOP PEOPLE FROM
11:31 SORT OF ASKING ABOUT IT, TALKING ABOUT IT AFTER THE CALL.
11:36 FAR IT BE FOR TO US EXPLAIN THE STOCK MOVE AND WHY WE SAW IT
11:40 MOVE HIGHER YESTERDAY, HIGHER IN THE PREMARKET, AND THEN MOVE
11:47 LOWER TODAY, IAN, ESPECIALLY AFTER THE RESULTS WE LEARNED.
11:52 DO US A FAVOR AND TRY TO EXPLAIN THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS STOCK
11:55 MOVE TODAY AND WHY YOU THINK IT'S NOT REACTING DIFFERENTLY.
11:59 IAN: WELL, YOU KNOW, THERE'S A QUESTION THAT CANNOT BE ANSWERED
12:04 RIGHT NOW, WHICH IS WHAT DOES THE FUTURE OF THE COMPANY LOOK
12:09 LIKE UNDER A NEW C.E.O., WHO WE DON'T KNOW WHO IT'S GOING TO BE
12:11 YET. WHAT WILL THE STYLE BE?
12:16 WILL THE ENGINEERS STAY? WILL THEY CONTINUE TO BE
12:18 MOTIVATED IN THE SAME WAY? YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT FAIR TO ASK
12:21 COLLETE OR ANYBODY ELSE THERE RIGHT NOW WHAT THE ANSWER TO
12:23 THAT QUESTION IS, BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW.
12:27 THAT IS REALLY GOING TO BE THE DETERMINING FACTOR ABOUT
12:32 NVIDIA'S LONG-TERM FUTURE, BUT IF YOU ARE IN THIS STOCK THE
12:35 NEXT 12 MONTHS, THE NUMBERS ARE GOOD.
12:36 THEY'RE GOING TO GIVE YOU MORE MONEY IN TERMS OF BUYBACKS, IN
12:42 TERMS OF THE RETURNS, AND THE NUMBERS, THE AMOUNT OF MONEY
12:45 THAT THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE TO DO THAT IS ONLY GOING UP.
12:49 SO ON THE ONE HAND, YOU HAVE THIS VERY SHORT -- WELL,
12:54 MEDIUM-TERM POSITIVE AND SORT OF FLEXING OF MUSCLES AND STRENGTH,
13:00 BUT THAT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING TO DEFUSE THE LONGER TERM CONCERNS.
13:03 TIM: WELL, LONGER TERM CONCERNS ARE INCLUDED WITH THE NEWS WE
13:07 GOT FROM COMMERCE ON MONDAY, AND ALL THE QUESTIONS AROUND CHINA
13:10 AND THE BUSINESS OF NVIDIA AND HOW IT IS RELATED TO CHINA, EVEN
13:16 IN A TERTIARY WAY. COLETTE KRESS SAID NVIDIA IS NO
13:18 LONGER SHIPPING PRODUCTS TO CHINA, BUT WITH NO EXPLANATION
13:21 OF WHY. PROVIDE MORE CONTEXT FOR US
13:27 AROUND WHAT THAT MEANS, AND IF IT'S MATERIAL TO THE COMPANY'S
13:30 TOP LINE. IAN: YEAH, YOU'LL REMEMBER WE
13:34 SPOKE ABOUT THIS YESTERDAY. THERE'S ACTUAL ALLOWANCE UNDER
13:38 GOVERNMENT LICENSING PROGRAM OF SHIPMENTS TO CHINA, WHICH
13:41 BASICALLY REALLY HASN'T HAPPENED.
13:43 I THINK THERE WAS A COUPLE BILLION DOLLARS OF SALES OF
13:47 THOSE IN THE QUARTER, WITH THE ANTICIPATION THERE WON'T BE
13:53 ANYMORE GOING FORWARD. BUT THEN IT MAY OR MAY NOT BE
14:00 SERVING CHINESE CUSTOMERS VIA ACROSS CABLES, ACROSS THE
14:01 BORDER. AND BECAUSE OF WHAT'S HAPPENED
14:07 WITH THE C.E.O., THE CLIMATE IN WASHINGTON HAS LURCHED AGAINST
14:09 THAT, AND WE ARE LED TO BELIEVE THAT THERE MAY BE A PROHIBITION
14:15 OF EVEN DOING THAT, EVEN SERVING CHINA REMOTELY.
14:20 ANALYSTS, ASK ANYBODY FROM WALL STREET, AND THEY'LL GIVE YOU A
14:25 DIFFERENCE ANSWER, AND THEY SAY THEY DON'T HOMES.
14:28 IS IT MATERIAL TO NVIDIA'S BUSINESS OR IS IT NOT?
14:31 NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP IS SAYING, LOOK, DON'T WORRY ABOUT THIS,
14:33 THERE'S DEMAND EVERY, WHERE EVERYTHING IS GOING TO BE FINE.
14:39 BUT AGAIN, DOUBT IS NOT WHAT YOU WANT TO HAVE.
14:41 AS THE POLITICAL PROCESS UNFOLDS, AS WE SEE JENSEN AND
14:46 POTENTIALLY OTHER EXECUTIVES FROM NVIDIA SIT BEFORE
14:52 COMMITTEES IN WASHINGTON, THE CONCERN MORE GRIZZLY DETAILS
14:59 WILL EMERGE ABOUT BEHAVIOR THAT HAPPENED THAT SHOULDN'T HAVE
15:01 HAPPENED. BUT AGAIN, WE DON'T KNOW.
15:03 CAROL: SPEAKING OF MATERIAL, AND I JUST THINK ABOUT THE BIGGER,
15:09 BROADER A.I. TRADE, IAN. BECAUSE OF JENSEN HUANG AND HIS
15:12 COMPANY, HOW IMPORTANT THEY BOTH WERE TO SO MUCH OF THE
15:14 ENTHUSIASM TO BUILD AND THE SPEND.
15:17 I KNOW WE ASKED ABOUT YOU THIS A LOT, BUT I THINK ABOUT THE BANK
15:19 OF NVIDIA, MAYBE NOT CLOSE, BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE IT'S GOING TO BE
15:22 MUCH MORE DISCERNING. COLETTE KRESS DID SAY,
15:26 DESCRIBING THE LEVEL OF SCRUTINY NVIDIA WILL APPLY TO FUTURE
15:30 INVESTMENTS, SHE DESCRIBED IT AS "DISCIPLINED AND RIGOROUS."
15:32 SO THIS IS WHAT THEY'RE GOING APPLY T. MAKES ME WONDER, WAS IT
15:36 NOT DISCIPLINED AND RIGOROUS BEFORE?
15:39 I WONDER WHAT IMPACT ANY SLOWDOWN WILL HAVE KIND OF ON
15:43 THAT BIGGER, BROADER A.I. STORY. BECAUSE NVIDIA TOUCHED SO MANY
15:47 OTHER COMPANIES WITH ITS INVESTMENTS.
15:51 OR RELATIONSHIPS. IAN: YEAH, YOU'VE NAILED T.
15:54 YOU'VE GONE TO ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS ON THE CALL.
16:00 YEAH, THIS COMPANY HAS PLEDGED TO PUT HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS OF
16:05 DOLLARS INTO THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND INTO THE ECOSYSTEM TO
16:10 SUPPORT THIS A.I. SURGE. IF SOME OF THAT IS GOING TO GO
16:12 AWAY, PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE COMPANIES WHICH CANNOT REALLY
16:15 ACCESS CAPITAL ON REASONABLE TERMS THEMSELVES AT THE MOMENT,
16:20 AND THAT COULD BE A SYSTEMIC RISK.
16:21 WHAT COLLETE SAID, WHICH WAS VERY CAREFUL, WHICH WAS, LOOK,
16:26 WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO DO THIS, THIS IS A GOOD USE OF OUR
16:29 MONEY, THIS IS AKIN TO INVESTING DIRECTLY IN OUR PRODUCTS, RIGHT?
16:32 THIS IS SOMETHING WE HAVE TO DO. AND THAT'S REPEATING WHAT JENSEN
16:35 HAD SAID. HOWEVER, AS YOU POINTED OUT OVER
16:40 AND OVER AGAIN, SHE WENT BACK TO THIS IDEA OF SCRUTINY, OF CARE,
16:44 OF BEING CAREFUL, OF BEING THOUGHTFUL, OF SEEING WHAT OTHER
16:47 ACCESS TO CAPITAL THERE IS OUT THERE FOR THESE GUYS.
16:52 SO AGAIN, THE TAKEAWAY FROM THAT WAS, YES, THEY'RE GOING TO
16:53 CONTINUE. THE DOORS AREN'T CLOSED.
16:57 BUT MAYBE THEY'RE NOT OPEN AS WIDE AS THEY USED TO BE.
17:01 TIM: IT GOES BACK, IAN, TO THE CIRCULAR QUESTION, RIGHT?
17:05 THE IDEA, OK, IF NVIDIA IS NOT GOING TO SUPPORT COMPANIES THAT
17:07 ULTIMATELY END UP BUYING PRODUCTS FROM NVIDIA, HOW DOES
17:10 THAT AFFECT THE COMPANY'S TOP LINE?
17:13 WHAT ARE ANALYSTS SAYING ABOUT THAT?
17:14 DO WE UNDERSTAND TO WHAT EXTENT? I MEAN, COREWEAVE, FOR EXAMPLE,
17:18 IS DOWN RIGHT NOW, ONE OF THE BIGGEST CUSTOMERS OF NVIDIA AND
17:21 IT HAS BEEN. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR THE
17:24 COMPANY? IAN: IT'S AN IMPORTANT
17:26 DISTINCTION TO MAKE. IT'S ONE OF THE BIGGEST NEOCLOUD
17:30 CUSTOMERS, SMALLER DATA CENTER OPERATORS.
17:33 THE BIG GUYS, THE MICROSOFTS, THEY'VE GOT ACCESS TO CAPITAL
17:36 AND NVIDIA SAID IT EXPECTS THEM TO CONTINUE SPENDING APACE AND
17:41 CONTINUE BEING A GIANT PART OF ITS BUSINESS, IF NOT GROWING.
17:44 BUT YOU'RE RIGHT, IF YOU ARE COREWEAVE, IF YOU'RE ONE OF
17:48 THESE SO-CALLED NEOCLOUDS, TO AN EXTENT YOU'VE BEEN BORROWING,
17:53 USING NVIDIA'S CREDIT RATING. AND IF WE CANNOT CONTINUE TO DO
17:57 THAT, AND IF AS COLLETE SAID WE WANT THEM TO SHOW, SHOW US
18:04 THEY'VE GOT LAND AND POWER, WE MIGHT NOT GET CHIPS AND THEY
18:08 MIGHT NOT GET A GUARANTEE. CAROL: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
18:11 WE KNOW THE LAST WEEK AND A HALF HAS BEEN A LOT.
18:13 I'M NOT SURE IF YOU'RE GETTING ANY SLEEP.
18:16 BUT WE ALWAYS LEAN ON YOU FOR GOOD REASON, BECAUSE THE
18:19 COMPANY, YOU KNOW THE SECTOR LIKE NO ONE ELSE.
18:23 IAN KING, THANK YOU SO MUCH. IAN KING, U.S. SEMICONDUCTOR
18:26 REPORTER HERE AT BLOOMBERG NEWS, JOINING US FROM OUR SAN
18:28 FRANCISCO BUREAU. AND I WOULD POINT OUT, THERE'S
18:33 GOING TO BE A LIST OF THINGS TO WATCH WHEN IT COMES TO NVIDIA
18:38 AND JENSEN HUANG, TESTIMONY, INVESTIGATIONS, THE COMPANY, THE
18:41 GOVERNMENT. I'M JUST CURIOUS TO SEE WHERE IT
18:44 ALL GOES NEXT. TIM: INVESTORS ARE CURIOUS, TOO.
18:47 LOOK WHAT'S HAPPENING WITH NVIDIA, DOWN FOR A FIFTH DAY.
18:51 CAROL: AND YOU KEEP REMINDING US, A THIRD OF THE MARKET CAP
18:53 HAS BEENEE LACED. STICK AROUND.
18:55 WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT A.I., LABOR AND MORE.
19:02 CHARLIE: IT IS 2:21 ON WALL STREET AM WE WHICH CAN MARKETS
19:03 ALL DAY LONG HERE AT BLOOMBERG. THE LATEST FOMC MINUTES ARE OUT,
19:09 AND NEARLY ALL FED OFFICIALS AGREED THEY WOULD LIKELY HAVE TO
19:14 RAISE RATES "IN THE MONTHS AHEAD" TO RETURN INFLATION TO
19:17 THE 2% TARGET IN A TIMELY MANNER.
19:20 TWO POLICY MAKERS SAID AN INCREASE OF MORE THAN 25 BASIS
19:23 POINTS COULD BE WARRANTED IN DECEMBER IF INCOMING INFLATION
19:27 DATA PROVES UNFAVORABLE. RIGHT NOW, EQUITIES TRADING
19:30 LOWER AS MEASURED BY THE S&P 500 INDEX, DOWN .2%, LOWER BY 14
19:34 POINTS. DOW INDUSTRIALS NOW LOWER BY
19:38 575, A DROP OF 1.1%. BOTH NASDAQ, THE NASDAQ 100
19:44 INDEX, AND THE RUSSELL 2000 INDEX ARE ALL ADVANCING.
19:47 CHOPPY DAY, BUT RIGHT NOW NASDAQ UP .5%.
19:52 THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX UP .4%. RUSSELL 2000 INDEX OF SMALL CAP
19:55 SHARES UP .7%. THE SOX, THE PHILADELPHIA STOCK
19:59 EXCHANGE SEMICONDUCTOR INDEX DOWN .4%.
20:05 NVIDIA, AFTER EARNINGS, DOWN BY 2.3%.
20:07 TWO-YEAR AFTER THE FED MINUTES, 4.79%.
20:10 THE 10-YEAR, 5.06%. GOLD IS LOWER NOW BY 3.1%,
20:15 TRADING AT $37.29. A FURTHER RETREAT FOR CRUDE, $83
20:21 EVEN ON W.T.I., DOWN 3.5% RIGHT NOW.
20:26 BARREL OF BRENT, $91.77, DOWN BY 1.5%.
20:28 AFTER EARNINGS, RIGHT NOW WE HAVE SHARES OF TARGET.
20:31 TARGET SHARES ARE RALLYING AFTER ITS REPORT TODAY.
20:34 TARGET UP BY 6%. ALSO OUT WITH EARNINGS THIS
20:36 MORNING, HOME IMPROVEMENT RETAILER LOWE'S.
20:40 LOWE'S SHARES UP .5%. REEL HOME DEPOT DOWN BY .1%.
20:46 RECAPPING, S&P 500 INDEX DOWN .2%.
20:48 WE HAVE GOT THE 10-YEAR CURRENTLY YIELDING 5.06%.
20:51 CAROL AND TIM, THAT'S A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
20:54 CAROL: MUCH APPRECIATED, CHARLIE.
20:58 ON MONDAY, WE CAUGHT UP WITH DANIELLE SUSKIND FROM GRESHAM
21:02 COLLEGE. AND WE WANTED TO ASK HIM HOW IN
21:07 THE AGE OF EXPECTED EXTRAORDINARY LABOR SHIFTS, WHAT
21:10 SHOULD MY CHILDREN DO? WHEN IT COMES TO PARENTING AND
21:13 TEACHING KIDS IN THE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AGE, THAT'S THE
21:17 TITLE OF HIS BOOK. IT'S ALL ABOUT KIND BEHALF NEEDS
21:19 TO BE DONE. HE MADE SOME POINTS.
21:22 KIDS NEED TO BE FLEXIBLE. THEY HAVE TO HAVE BASIC SKILLS.
21:26 WE KEEP HEARING AGAIN AND AGAIN THE IMPORTANCE OF A LIBERAL ARTS
21:28 EDUCATION. TIM: CRITICAL THINKING, YEAH.
21:32 HE'S SKEPTICAL OF THE PRODUCTS. CAROL: AND HE ALSO SAID KIDS
21:36 NEED TO PREPARE FOR AN A.I.-IMPACTED ENVIRONMENT, WORK
21:38 ENVIRONMENT, SO THEY HAVE TO KIND OF WORK WITH IT INSTEAD OF
21:42 AGAINST IT. TIM: WE'RE IN THAT A.I.-IMPACTED
21:46 WORK ENVIRONMENT. CAROL: EXACTLY.
21:48 I WANT TO BRING THAT INTO THE CONVERSATION, BUT I ALSO WANT TO
21:52 SEE WHAT EMPLOYMENT TRENDS SHE'S SEEING.
21:54 AS YOU SAID, IT'S ALREADY IMPACTING OUR WORK WORLD.
21:58 TIM: THE DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC RESEARCH, A FORMER SENIOR
22:02 REGIONAL ECONOMIST AND SENIOR MANAGER IN RICHMOND, PRIMARILY
22:06 FOCUSED ON HIGHER EDUCATION AND WORKFORCE DYNAMICS, SHE JOINED
22:08 US HERE IN THE STUDIO. IT WAS INTERESTING, AT THE TOP
22:13 OF THE HOUR, WE GOT THE MINUTES, AND MIKE MCKEE WAS TALKING ABOUT
22:17 THE UNIS NOT THAT FED OFFICIALS FEEL ABOUT THE DATA CENTER
22:18 BUILDOUT. HE ACKNOWLEDGED THEY HAD THE
22:23 MOOD OF THE COUNTRY, SORT OF ANTI-DATA CENTER, BUT THIS WAS
22:26 BEFORE THE ELECTION. I'M JUST WONDERING, GIVEN YOUR
22:29 BACKGROUND, WHAT YOU UNDERSTAND ABOUT EMPLOYMENT AND
22:32 PRODUCTIVITY, HOW YOU'RE LOOKING AT THAT ENVIRONMENT RIGHT NOW.
22:35 >> IT'S A GREAT QUESTION, AND I'VE ACTUALLY WRITTEN A COUPLE
22:38 OF PIECES ON DATA CENTERS AND THE LABOR THAT'S REQUIRED ON
22:41 THESE DATA CENTERS. IT IS SO INTERESTING.
22:45 LABOR MARKETS ARE PRETTY LOCAL. AT THE END OF THE DAY, LABOR IS
22:48 ALL LOCAL, RIGHT? HOW THE LABOR MARKET FEELS TO
22:52 BOTH JOB SEEKERS AND EMPLOYERS IS DEFINITELY BASED ON WHERE
22:55 YOUR FEET ARE PLANTED, AND WHAT WE'RE SEEING IN THE COMMUNITIES
22:57 WHERE THEY ARE BUILDING DATA CENTERS, THE NUMBER OF POSTINGS
23:00 TO BUILD THESE THINGS IS REALLY WILD.
23:03 AND WAGES ARE HIGH. I MEAN, IT'S INTERESTING.
23:06 TIM: YOU JUST MADE ME THINK OF SOMETHING.
23:08 MY WIFE IS NOT GOING TO BE HAPPY I BROUGHT THIS UP, BECAUSE SHE
23:12 DOES NOT LIKE TO. BUT OK, I HAVE TO TELL YOU GUYS.
23:15 SHE'S AN URBAN PLANNER. SHE WORKS FOR THE CITY.
23:18 I'VE TALKED ABOUT THIS ON AIR BEFORE.
23:19 SHE LOGGED INTO LINKEDIN THE EVERY DAY, AND EVERY JOB THAT
23:22 CAME UP, LIKE YOU MIGHT BE A GOOD FIT FOR, ALL DATA CENTER
23:28 LIAISON COMMUNITY WORK. CAROL: SERIOUSLY?
23:31 TIM: ALL OVER THE COUNTRY, FROM ALL THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF
23:33 COMPANIES WE TALK ABOUT ALL THE TIME, BUT IT WAS EVERY SINGLE
23:37 OPPORTUNITY WAS RELATED TO DATA CENTER AND COMMUNITY RELATIONS.
23:40 SO GOING THERE AND SELLING IT. CAROL: THAT FEELS VERY MUCH
23:45 POST-MIDTERMS, RIGHT, IN MANY WAYS, JUST IN GENERAL.
23:48 WHAT DOES THAT TELL YOU? IS IT SLOW DOWN, THE BUILD?
23:52 I AM CURIOUS WHEN YOU SAY THE TYPES OF JOBS TO ACTUALLY BUILD,
23:55 PICKS AND SHOVELS. >> IT'S BOTH.
23:57 IT'S EVERYTHING. IT'S WHAT HE'S MENTIONING ABOUT
24:01 THESE COMMUNITY LIAISONS, AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.
24:04 IT'S LAWYERS TO DEAL WITH THE LEGAL CONTRACTS.
24:06 IT'S CONSTRUCTION WORKERS. IT'S FIBER AND CABLE
24:09 PROFESSIONALS. TIM: HERE'S THE CONCERNING THING
24:11 THAT I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE THINK ABOUT.
24:14 THE TEMPORARY NATURE OF THOSE JOBS.
24:17 YOU GO IN, YOU BUILD IT, YOU MOVE OUT, THAT THING RUNS AND
24:22 HUMS WITHOUT PEOPLE. >> I HAVE AN INTERESTING STAT
24:25 FOR YOU FROM THE WORK WE DID. FIRST OF ALL, IN THESE
24:28 COMMUNITIES, SOME OF WHICH ARE QUITE RURAL, 71% OF THE JOBS
24:32 WERE WITH THE TOP 10 TECH COMPANIES, SO THEY WERE WITH THE
24:35 HYPER SCALERS THEMSELVES RATHER THAN A STAFFING FIRM OR LOCAL
24:38 CONSTRUCTION FIRM, SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
24:42 CAROL: SO PERMANENT JOBS? >> WE ALSO FOUND THEY WERE MORE
24:45 LIKELY TO BE PERMANENT THAN NON-DATA CENTER JOBS.
24:47 THAT WAS A SURPRISE TO US, BECAUSE I WENT INTO IT THINKING
24:49 THESE ARE GOING TO BE MUCH MORE LIKELY TO BE TEMPORARY.
24:52 THAT'S ACTUALLY NOT WHAT WE FOUND.
24:54 NOW, WHAT I WILL SAY IS MANY OF THE JOB POSTINGS MENTION A LOT
24:58 OF TRAVEL. TRAVEL REQUIREMENTS SEEM TO BE
24:59 HIGHER. SO ONE OF THE THINGS --
25:02 CAROL: ARE THEY JOBS IN THE COMMUNITY?
25:04 >> THEY ARE JOBS THERE, BUT I DO WONDER IF THESE HYPER SCALERS
25:08 ARE CREATING A HIGHLY TRAINED WORKFORCE THAT THEY WILL MOVE
25:10 AROUND TO BUILD MORE DATA CENTERS, BECAUSE THE JOBS ARE
25:13 MUCH MORE LIKELY TO MENTION TRAVEL.
25:16 CAROL: OH, SO LIKE A GROUP, OK. NOW THEY'RE IN COLUMBUS TODAY.
25:24 NEXT WEEK WE'RE IN AUSTIN. >> I WONDER ABOUT THAT.
25:27 IT'S REALLY HARD TO KNOW UNTIL THEY'RE BUILT OUT.
25:29 ARE THEY PERMANENT BECAUSE THEY ARE TRYING TO COURT FAVOR WITH
25:32 LOCAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATIONS?
25:34 I DON'T REALLY KNOW, BUT IT'S REALLY INTERESTING.
25:39 TIM: YEAH, OK, SO IF WE THINK ABOUT THE PERMANENT, WELL,
25:41 NOTHING IS PERMANENT IN THIS WORLD.
25:45 BUT THE LONG-TERM ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS OF THE WAY THESE --
25:47 AND IF WE LOOK AT LAST YEAR, HOW MUCH OF THE ECONOMIC GROWTH IN
25:51 THIS COUNTRY WAS THE RESULT OF THIS BUILDOUT, THEN WHAT DOES
25:54 THAT LOOK LIKE OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS?
25:56 ESPECIALLY WITH THE PUSHBACK THAT WE SEE.
25:59 >> ONE OF THE THINGS, ANOTHER THING THAT I THINK IS REALLY
26:03 INTERESTING IS I,LY DID THIS WORK BACK IN JUNE, AND IT LOOKED
26:08 LIKE THE JOBS WERE PLATEAUING IN THAT MOMENT, AND WE RE-RAN IT
26:14 RECENTLY, AND THEY'VE TAKEN OFF, EVEN IN THE MIDST OF THE
26:15 BACKLASH. TIM: SO POST ELECTION?
26:19 >> NOT POST ELECTION NECESSARILY, BUT POST BACKLASH
26:23 ERA, I WOULD SAY. SO I THINK THAT RIGHT NOW MANY
26:26 OF THESE HAVE ALREADY BEEN APPROVED, AND SO THEY'RE BEING
26:28 BUILT, RIGHT? SO IN THE NEAR TERM, I DON'T
26:31 THINK IT SLOWS DOWN. IN THE INTERMEDIATE TERM, WHERE
26:34 YOU NEED NEW PROJECTS APPROVED, MAKE IT SLOWS DOWN.
26:41 CAROL: HOW MUCH JOB CREATION IS A.I.-RELATED?
26:43 I'M TRYING TO THINK, HOW DO WE THINK ABOUT THE WORKFORCE?
26:46 IS EVERY JOB GOING TO HAVE SOME A.I. COMPONENT?
26:48 >> THIS IS A GREAT QUESTION. WE DON'T THINK ANY JOB IS SAFE
26:52 FROM A.I. TRANSFORMATION. AND WE CALL IT TRANSFORMATION,
26:57 BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW IF IT WILL BE DESTRUCTION OR AUGMENTATION.
27:01 BUT WE THINK EVERY JOB WILL BE IMPACTED AT SOME LEVEL.
27:04 CAROL: IF YOU THINK ABOUT IT, ALMOST ANY JOB, I DON'T KNOW ANY
27:08 JOB THAT ISN'T WITH A COMPUTER. TIM: MEANING YOU'RE GOING WALK
27:11 IN, WELL, ANY OFFICE JOB. CAROL: FOR THE MOST PART, BUT
27:16 EVEN PEOPLE IN THE FIELD HAVE A TECHNOLOGICAL DEVICE THAT
27:18 THEY'RE COMMUNICATING WITH OR WRITING NOTES.
27:20 LOOK AT DOCTORS. IS THAT THE AUGMENTATION?
27:25 I STILL HAVE A JOB, AND I AUGMENT WITH ALL OF THE.
27:29 IS THAT THE RIGHT WAY TO THINK ABOUT A.I., THAT EVERY JOB WILL
27:34 HAVE THAT AUGMENTATION OR SOME WILL BE REPLACED?
27:38 >> SOME WILL BE REPLACED, THERE ARE JOBS GOING AWAY.
27:40 BUT ONE OF THE THINGS WE TALKED ABOUT, WE ARE NOT SEEING A JUMP.
27:44 WE'RE NOT SEEING A LOT OF THAT DESTRUCTION.
27:47 WHAT WE ARE SEEING IS? AUGMENTATION AND NEW JOBS
27:48 POPPING UP. I WILL SAY MOST OF THE NEW JOBS
27:52 WE SEE BEING CREATED ARE MORE SENIOR-LEVEL JOBS.
27:54 MANY OF THOSE DO HAVE A.I. IN THE TITLE, SO IT MIGHT BE
27:57 SOMETHING LIKE A.I. OR MACHINE LEARNING ENGINEER, A.I.
28:00 SPECIALIST, JOBS LIKE THAT. DATA CENTER TECHNICIAN IS ONE
28:04 THAT'S KIND OF A MID-SKILL JOB THAT HAS REALLY INCREASED.
28:09 BUT WE'RE NOT SEEING VERY MUCH DISRUPTION.
28:10 WHAT WE ARE ALSO SEEING AT THE SAME TIME, THOUGH, IS SKILLS
28:15 WITHIN JOBS ARE TAKING. SO A JOB THAT HAS THE TITLE, ANY
28:19 JOB, REALLY, ESPECIALLY WHITE COLLAR JOB, A JOB WITH THE TITLE
28:23 ECONOMIST, OR REPORTER, OR ANY OTHER JOB, IT'S GOING TO LOOK
28:26 DIFFERENT IN 2026 IN TERMS OF THE SKILLS AND TASKS THAT ARE
28:29 REQUIRED FOR THAT JOB THAN IT DID FIVE YEARS AGO.
28:32 AND SO SOME OF THOSE JOBS ARE CHANGING VERY RAPIDLY.
28:35 AND AS YOU CAN IMAGINE, THE JOBS THAT ARE MORE A.I.-EXPOSED
28:38 CHANGING FASTER. TIM: YOU MENTIONED A.I.
28:40 SPECIALISTS. WOULD THAT BE LIKE 25 YEARS AGO,
28:46 TALKING ABOUT AN EMAIL SPECIALIST.
28:51 WELL, WE'RE ALL EMAIL SPECIALISTS.
28:52 WELL, SOME PEOPLE. CAROL: JUST IGNORE EMAIL.
28:55 >> I JOKE ABOUT THAT SOMETIMES, BECAUSE THERE ARE SOME COLLEGES
28:57 AND UNIVERSITIES THAT ARE CREATING A.I. DEGREES, AND I'M
29:00 LIKE, THANK GOD I DIDN'T GET A DEGREE IN THE INTERNET IN THE
29:04 1990'S. TIM: THAT SEEMS LIKE MARKETING.
29:07 >> RIGHT. I THINK IN THE MIDST OF
29:12 TREMENDOUS TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE, PEOPLE TEND TO OVERREACT AND
29:15 OVERADAPT TO THE TECHNOLOGY IN THE SHORT RUN, AND THEN
29:17 UNDERADAPT IN THE LONGER RUN, SO I THINK YOU SEE COMPANIES AT
29:21 HIGHER INSTITUTIONS, JOB SEEKERS, EMPLOYEES, EVERYBODY IS
29:23 TRYING TO FIGURE THIS OUT, AND IT'S CHANGING SO FAST THAT IT
29:28 MAKES SENSE THAT IT'S VERY DULL FOR PEOPLE TO ADJUST.
29:31 CAROL: MORE WORKERS THAN JOBS? DO WE HAVE MORE JOBS THAN
29:33 WORKERS? >> VERY GOOD QUESTION.
29:37 SO IT HIGHLY DEPENDS ON WHAT SECTOR YOU'RE LOOKING AT AND
29:39 WHERE ACROSS THE COUNTRY. I WILL SAY ANOTHER THEME FROM
29:42 OUR REPORT IS THAT AT THE BEGINNING OF 2026, ONLY ONE IN
29:48 10 METRO AREAS -- ONE OUT OF 10 METRO AREAS SAW JOB POSTINGS
29:52 THAT WERE GROWING, AND IT'S RIGHT NOW AT 50% OF METRO AREAS.
29:55 SO THERE ARE GREEN CHUTES. WE ARE SEEING JOB GROWTH, GROWTH
29:59 IN POSTINGS, AND IT IS KIND OF BUBBLING UP FROM, I WOULD SAY,
30:03 THE SMALLER AND MID-SIZED METROS AND BIG METROS IN THE SOUTH, TO
30:07 PLACES LIKE DALLAS OR CHARLOTTE WHERE I LIVE OR SOMEWHERE LIKE
30:10 THAT, IT'S KIND OF BUBBLING UP FROM THOSE METROS.
30:15 TIM: LET'S END WITH AN EASY QUESTION.
30:18 WHAT SHOULD OUR CHILDREN DO? >> GREAT QUESTION.
30:22 THAT'S THE TITLE OF THE BOOK. THAT'S GREAT.
30:23 I THINK IT'S A GREAT QUESTION. I GET ASKED THIS A LOT BECAUSE
30:26 OF THE WORK I DO. I THINK THAT THERE WILL STILL BE
30:28 A PREMIUM PUT ON A FOUR-YEAR DEGREE, BECAUSE TO THE
30:30 CONVERSATION YOU WERE HAVING ABOUT THE LIBERAL ARTS, THE
30:32 FOUR-YEAR DEGREE ISN'T JUST ABOUT WHAT YOU LEARNED IN A
30:35 JOURNALISM CLASS OR ECONOMICS CLASSROOM, IT'S ALSO CRITICAL
30:38 THINKING, LEADERSHIP, COMMUNICATION SKILLS, CURIOSITY,
30:40 WHICH BY THE WAY, THOSE ARE STILL THE FASTEST GROWING SKILLS
30:43 IN OUR POSTINGS. COMPANIES ARE CALLING OUT THOSE
30:46 SKILLS MORE AND MORE. THEY ARE SAYING THEY NEED MORE
30:49 PEOPLE WITH THOSE SKILLS. SO I THINK THERE WILL STILL BE A
30:51 PREMIUM. HOWEVER, I ALSO THINK ADDING
30:54 SOMETHING ON TO YOUR SKILL SET THAT IS MORE TECHNICAL IS MORE
30:58 HANDS-ON MAKES A LOT OF SENSE. SO MY 16-YEAR-OLD, I'M TRYING
31:01 TOEN COURAGE HIM TO DO SOMETHING TECHNICAL, PLUS A COLLEGE
31:03 DEGREE. WE'LL SEE IF HE FOLLOWS MY
31:05 ADVICE. CAROL: I REMEMBER IN COLLEGE, I
31:08 CAN'T REMEMBER IF WAS A FRESHMAN, I THINK I STARTED TO
31:11 TAKE COBALT. TIM: YOU COULD HAVE WORKED FOR
31:15 DOGE, BECAUSE NOBODY AT DOGE KNEW HOW TO DO THAT.
31:18 CAROL: WELL, I DROPPED IT RATHER QUICKLY.
31:20 IT WAS NOT MY WORLD, BUT EVERYBODY SHOULD HAVE SOME
31:21 EXPOSURE. THAT WAS THE THING.
31:24 TIM: BUT THAT'S NOT WRONG, BECAUSE THINK ABOUT WHAT WAS
31:28 BUILT ON THAT. CAROL: EXACTLY.
31:29 TIM: EVERYTHING THAT'S FALLING APART NOW.
31:34 >> I TELL PEOPLE ALL THE TIME, MY OWN CHILDREN, YOU HAVE GOT TO
31:37 CONVINCE A COMPANY THAT A.I. PLUS YOU IS BETTER THAN A.I.
31:40 WITHOUT YOU. SO YOU DO HAVE TO KNOW HOW TO
31:43 ENGAGE WITH A.I. AND USE THE TOOLS AND BE ON THE WAVE,
31:47 INSTEAD OF GETTING WASHED OVER BY IT.
31:53 BUT IT IS, WE SEE IT, PEOPLE ARE NERVOUS ABOUT A.I., THE
31:55 SENTIMENT IS BECOMING MORE AND MORE NEGATIVE.
31:57 BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE WORRIED ABOUT WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN THE NEXT FEW
31:59 YEARS, AND I THINK RIGHTFULLY SO.
32:05 BUT TODAY, WE ARE SEEING GREEN SHEETS.
32:07 CAROL: DO YOU A LOT OF STUFF WITH A.I., BUT YOU STILL HAVE TO
32:10 PRESENT IT. THE DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC
32:13 RESEARCH AT INDEED HIRING WEB. GREAT TO HAVE YOU HERE IN
32:15 STUDIO. THANK YOU.
32:16 APPRECIATE IT. WHEN WE COME BACK, IT'S THE BEST
32:19 REVIEWED VIDEO GAME EVER, RECEIVING CLOSE TO PERFECT
32:23 SCORES, AND OUR OWN JASON TROTTER CALLS IT A MASTERPIECE.
32:31 ♪ CHARLIE: IT'S 2:40 ON WALL
32:33 STREET. WE CHECK MARKETS ALL DAY LONG
32:35 HERE AT BLOOMBERG. WE'VE GOT NVIDIA SHARES LOWER
32:39 NOW BY 2.9%, FOLLOWING LAST NIGHT'S EARNINGS REPORT.
32:42 WALL STREET SEEING RENEWED VOLATILITY AS NVIDIA'S
32:46 POST-EARNINGS RALLY FIZZLES. AGAIN, NVIDIA SHARES DOWN BY
32:49 ALMOST 3%. S&P 500 INDEX HAS BEEN
32:53 FLUCTUATING, BUT RIGHT NOW LOWER BY .3%.
32:57 THE DOW SELLING OFF TODAY, DOWN 1.2%.
33:00 BOTH NASDAQ AND THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX, BUT ON THE RUSSELL 2000
33:03 AS WELL, THEY'RE ALL TRADING HIGHER.
33:07 S&P RIGHT NOW LOWER, BUT AGAIN, NASDAQ UP.
33:13 NASDAQ 100 UP BY .2%. THE PHILADELPHIA SEMICONDUCTOR
33:17 INDEX IS DOWN .6%. WE GOT THE FOMC MINUTES,
33:22 TWO-YEAR YIELD, 4.79%. 109-YEAR, 5.06%.
33:28 GOLD DOWN $128 AN OUNCE, $37.21, A DROP OF 3.3%.
33:32 A RETREAT FOR CRUDE, W.T.I., DOWN 3.1%.
33:35 BARREL OF BRENT CRUDE, GLOBAL BENCH MARK, $91.89, DOWN BY
33:39 1.3%. WELLS FARGO PLANS TO NAME J.P.
33:44 MORGAN CHASE'S ALLISON BEERS AS ITS NEW CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER.
33:48 IT'S A MAJOR HIRE FOR THE C.E.O. AS HE STREAKS NARROW THE GAP
33:51 BETWEEN THE FOURTH LARGEST AMERICAN BANK AND ITS BIGGER
33:54 RIVALS. WELLS FARGO DOWN BY 1.8%.
34:03 J.P. MORGAN SHARES DOWN BY 1.6%. GTA VI OUT TOMORROW.
34:05 TAKE TWO UP. WE'LL EXPLAIN IN A MOMENT.
34:06 I'M CHARLIE PELLETT. THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS
34:09 FLASH. CAROL: CHARLIE, THANK YOU SO
34:10 MUCH. IT HAS BEEN EIGHT YEARS IN THE
34:14 MAKING, INVOLVED MORE THAN 4,700 PEOPLE TO GET TO WHAT JASON
34:19 CALLS A MASTERPIECE N. HIS REVIEW OF GTA VI THAT HE BROKE
34:24 FOR BLOOMBERG BUSINESS WEEK, WHERE HE'S A REPORTER.
34:27 HE COVERS THE VIDEO GAME INDUSTRY.
34:30 HE CO-HOSTS THE TRIPLE CLICK PODCAST, WRITES A GAME NEWS
34:34 LETTER, AND HE'S ALSO THE AUTHOR OF THREE BOOKS.
34:40 WE ARE DELIGHTED TO HAVE JASON JOIN US.
34:45 TIM: AND HE STILL FOUND TIME TO PLAY GTA VI AND WRITE A REVIEW
34:48 THAT I HAVE TO SAY MAKES ME, AS YOU KNOW, A NONGAMER, WANT TO
34:52 PLAY THIS GAME. WHAT BLEW YOU AWAY?
34:58 >> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME, TIM AND CAME IT'S FUNNY, IF YOU
35:01 WATCH SOME FOOTAGE OF THE GAME, YOU MIGHT BE ABSORBED.
35:06 IT'S ONE OF THE MOST VIVID, REALISTIC DEPICTIONS OF AT LEAST
35:09 A FICTIONAL VERSION OF MIAMI THAT I'VE SEEN.
35:11 THERE'S BEEN FOOTAGE ONLINE, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU GUYS HAVE SEEN
35:15 THE CLIPS ON TWITTER THAT MAKE IT SEEM INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM
35:19 REAL MIAMI THERE. CAROL: WE'RE ACTUALLY PLAYING
35:22 SOME RIGHT NOW FOR THE TV AUDIENCE AND THE YOUTUBE
35:23 AUDIENCE. BUT KEEP GOING.
35:28 IT'S INCREDIBLE. >> THERE ARE A LOT OF REASONS
35:32 WHY I LOVE THIS GAME I'LL GIVE YOU A BIG ONE, IT HAS THIS
35:36 WONDERFUL SENSE OF DISCOVERY, AND IT FEELS LIKE EXPLORING THIS
35:41 WORLD IS REALLY REWARDED. AT ITS CORE, IT'S A CRIME STORY
35:45 ABOUT THIS COUPLE WHO ARE INSPIRED BY BONNIE AND CLYDE,
35:49 AND THEY KIND OF ROB THEIR WAY THROUGH THE SEEDY UNDERWORLD OF
35:53 VICE CITY, THIS GAME'S VERSION OF MIAMI.
35:55 AND A LOT OF THAT IS COOL. BUT FOR ME, WHAT WAS REALLY THE
35:58 MOSTEN GAUGING WAS JUST DRIVING AROUND THE CITY AND FINDING ALL
36:02 THESE RIDICULOUS, HILARIOUS, SOMETIMES CREEPIEN COUNTERS THAT
36:07 THIS GAME IS JUST COMPLETELY FULL OF.
36:10 WHETHER IT'S COPS ARRESTING PEOPLE.
36:12 I'LL TELL YOU ONE LITTLE STORY THAT I HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT.
36:19 I WAS DRIVING THROUGH THE STREETS AND SAW A COP PULLING
36:22 SOMEONE OVER, SO I PULLED OVER AND WATCHED WHAT WAS HAPPENING.
36:24 AND IT'S THIS COP WHO'S TALKING TO THIS WOMAN, GIVING HER A
36:27 SOBRIETY TEST. SHE PASSES.
36:29 AND THEN HE TELLS HER, HEY, I THINK I'M IN LOVE WITH YOU,
36:34 COULD WE HAVE DINNER SOMETIME. AND SHE SAID SURE.
36:36 THEY BOTH GET IN HER CAR AND JUST DRIVE OFF TOGETHER, AND
36:38 THAT'S IT. IT WAS JUST A RIDICULOUS THING
36:40 THAT I WOULDN'T HAVE SEEN IF I DIDN'T PULL OVER TO LOOK AT IT,
36:43 BUT THE GAME IS JUST PULL OF MOMENTS LIKE THAT.
36:47 TIM: INVESTORS ARE ABSOLUTELY CHEERING IT TODAY, CHEERING THE
36:49 REVIEWS. SHARES OF TAKE TWO INTERACTIVE,
36:53 THE PARENT COMPANY, UP MORE THAN 6.7% RIGHT NOW.
36:57 THE BUSINESS SIDE OF THE STORY IS JUST ABSOLUTELY SPECTACULAR.
37:01 I WAS STRUCK WITH SOMETHING YOU SAID, I BELIEVE IT WAS ON THE
37:05 NEW EPISODE AVAILABLE TODAY, FEATURING YOU, JUST ABOUT THE
37:07 CONTEXT OF HOW MUCH MONEY THIS GAME IS EXPECTED TO MAKE.
37:14 WHEN YOU COMPARE IT TO, A FILM BLOCKBUSTER, LIKE THE ODYSSEY,
37:17 SHARE THE NUMBERS HERE. >> YEAH, THIS IS A GAME THAT WE
37:20 DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH IT COST TO MAKE, BUT LIKELY MORE THAN A
37:23 BILLION DOLLARS, MAKING IT THE MOST EXPENSIVE GAME EVER MADE.
37:26 IT ALMOST DOESN'T MATTER HOW MUCH THEY SPENT TO MAKE IT,
37:28 BECAUSE IT IS GOING TO MAKE THAT BACK AND THEN SOME IN ITS FIRST
37:33 24 HOURS ON SALE. WE DON'T HAVE SALES NUMBERS JUST
37:36 YET, THE GAME IS NOT OFFICIALLY ON SALE, EVERYWHERE UNTIL
37:38 TOMORROW. BUT I WOULD VENTURE A GUESS THAT
37:43 IT WILL MAKE MORE IN ITS FIRST TWO DAYS, THREE DAYS ON SALE
37:49 THAN THE ODYSSEY MADE IN ITS ENTIRE LIFETIME AT THE BOX
37:51 OFFICE. TO BE FAIR, THIS GAME COSTS $80
37:55 AND THE ODYSSEY TICKETS WERE $20, $25.
37:57 BUT STILL, I THINK THAT PUTS THINGS IN PERSPECTIVE AS TO HOW
38:02 BIG A RELEASE THIS IS GOING TO BE.
38:06 THIS GAME IS GOING TO BE UPDATED AND PLAYED AND JUST FOR YEARS
38:09 AND YEARS TO COME. THE LAST GAME, GTA V, HAS SOLD
38:14 MORE THAN 230 MILLION COPIES, MAKING IT THE BEST-SELLING
38:19 NONMOBILE GAME OF ALL TIME. CAROL: YOU HAVE SPECIFIC
38:21 EQUIPMENT, BECAUSE I THINK I HEARD TRACY SAY SHE'S GOT TO GET
38:24 A NEW PLAY STATION. YOU WANT A PLAY STATION 5 AND A
38:27 CERTAIN XBOX, CORRECT? IT DOESN'T PLAY ON EVERYTHING.
38:29 >> EXACTLY. YOU NEED THE MOST MODERN
38:34 HARDWARE, WHICH ISN'T THAT NEW. THE NEW XBOX AND PLAY STATION
38:37 CAME IN AND OUT 2020. THANKS TO THE A.I. CHIP CRISIS,
38:40 THEY'VE GOTTEN MORE EXPENSIVE SINCE THEY CAME OUT.
38:46 AND A LITTLE BIT HARDER TO FIND. T.B.D. IF YOU'LL GET ONE OR IF
38:49 YOU WANT TO BUY ONE FOR A FAMILY MEMBER, A FRIEND FOR THE
38:53 HOLIDAYS, ALONG WITH GTA VI, I DON'T KNOW HOW EASY IT WILL BE
38:59 TO FIND A PLAY STATION OR XBOX IN STORES AFTER THIS GAME COMES
39:03 OUT. MAYBE LOOK INTO THAT SOONER
39:05 RATHER THAN LATER. CAROL: I HAVE NO IDEA IF THIS IS
39:07 IMPACTING PEOPLE, BUT I JUST WANT TO MENTION THAT PLAY
39:11 STATION SAYS IT HAS SEEN ISSUES AFFECTING THE PS5 AND OTHER
39:15 PLATFORMS, ACCORDING TO ITS STATUS PAGE.
39:17 USERS MAY HAVE DIFFICULTY LAUNCHING FEATURES, AND IT'S
39:21 WORKING TO RESOLVE THE ISSUE. I DON'T KNOW, THE OUTAGES
39:26 CONTINUE IN OUR WORLD. >> I'LL TELL YOU A FUNNY STORY,
39:28 WHICH IS THE GAME IS NOT OFFICIALLY OUT YET.
39:31 BUT AS OF 6:00 A.M. EASTERN THIS MORNING, IT WAS AVAILABLE TO
39:36 PLAY IN NEW ZEALAND, BECAUSE IT'S A STAGGERED LAUNCH BASED ON
39:39 TIME ZONES, RIGHT? MYSTERIOUSLY, A WHOLE LOT OF
39:43 PEOPLE ALL AROUND THE WORLD NOW LIVE IN NEW ZEALAND, BECAUSE IT
39:47 TURNS OUT YOU CAN SET YOUR PLAY STATION OR XBOX TO MAKE IT SEEM
39:51 AS IF IN YOUR NEW ZEALAND. TIM: THAT'S WHY THE GUY AT THE
39:56 SHOE STORE TOLD YOU WEDNESDAY. CAROL: I WENT TO A SHOE STORE IN
40:00 NEW YORK CITY, I'M JUST TELLING YOU, HE WAS OPEN IN FRONT OF HIS
40:03 COLLEAGUES, AND HE SAID I'M NOT GOING TO BE AT WORK TOMORROW,
40:05 MEANING TODAY. YEAH, I'M GOING TO BE PLAYING
40:08 THE GAME. BECAUSE HE WAS LIKE, YEAH, I'M
40:11 TAKING THE DAYS OFF. TIM: YOU DON'T JUST CLICK BUY
40:14 AND THIS THING DOWNLOAD AND YOU GET TO PLAY IT RIGHT AWAY.
40:19 WE'RE TALKING OVER 200GIGSS. HOW MUCH AFTER SOMEBODY PAYS 80
40:23 BUCKS DO THEY GET TO PLAY IT? >> YEAH, THAT'S BAD NEWS IF YOU
40:27 HAVEN'T PRELOADED IT. THE GOOD NEWS IS THEY MADE IT
40:32 AVAILABLE TO PREDOWN LOAD LAST WEEK.
40:36 THE MOST DEDICATED FANS ARE JUST WAITING UNTIL IT UNLOCKS
40:39 PROPERLY TO JUMP RIGHT IN. TIM: YOU KNOW WHAT I FOUND SO
40:41 FASCINATING? THE DELAY IN THIS GAME WASN'T
40:46 NECESSARILY BAD FOR THE COMPANY BECAUSE OF THE IN-GAME PURCHASES
40:52 FOR GTA VI, EVEN THOUGH IT'S YEARS OLD, IT WAS STILL MAKING
40:54 MONEY UNTIL VERY RECENTLY, RIGHT?
40:55 >> IT'S TRUE. I MEAN, WHEN IT WAS DELAYED, IT
41:00 WAS DELAYED TWICE, ONE FROM 2025 TO MAY OF 2026, AND THEN A
41:04 SECOND ONE FROM MAY TO NOVEMBER, WHEN IT'S NOW COMING OUT.
41:10 THEY DEFINITELY LED TO STOCK HITS FOR THE COMPANY, BUT I
41:13 MEAN, I THINK IN THE LONG RUN, THIS COMPANY IS BANKING, TAKE
41:17 TWO IS BANKING ON THIS GAME BEING THE MASTERPIECE THAT IT
41:20 TURNED OUT TO BE, AND THEREFORE, DRIVING A WHOLE LOT OF REVENUE
41:23 AS A RESULT. AND I MEAN, I THINK ANYONE AT
41:27 THE COMPANY FROM THE C.E.O. ON DOWN WOULD BE HAPPY TO DELAY IT
41:31 AN EXTRA SIX MONTHS IF IT MEANS BEING THE MOST HIGHLY RATED
41:35 VIDEO GAME OF ALL TIME, WHICH I MEAN, I'VE BEEN PLAYING IT FOR
41:37 THREE WEEKS OR SO, SO I WAS PRETTY FAMILIAR WITH HOW GOOD IT
41:39 IS. EVEN I DID NOT EXPECT THAT.
41:43 I EXPECTED IT TO BE HIGHLY REVIEWED, BUT GREATEST OF ALL
41:45 TIME? MY GOODNESS.
41:47 CAROL: I WANTED TO PASS BY A PROTEST IN FRONT OF A CHIMPANZEE
41:52 PAGE, BECAUSE I WANT TO SEE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN.
41:55 NO, I WANT TO DO THIS. COME BACK.
41:57 WE'VE GOT TO TALK MORE, BECAUSE THIS IS JUST SO COOL.
42:00 YOUR REVIEW IS JUST SO MUCH FUN TO READ THROUGH.
42:03 JASON, WE GOT TO RUN. HAVE FUN PLAYING.
42:06 I'M SURE YOU WILL PLAY MORE. TIM: IT'S WORK, CAROL.
42:08 HE'S WORKING. HE'S WORKING.
42:10 CAROL: YEAH, OK. TIM: IN ALL SERIOUSNESS --
42:15 CAROL: SO WERE WE WITH THE THE U.S. OPEN.
42:16 TIM: YOU WANT TO PLAY IT AFTER READING HIS REVIEW.
42:19 CAROL: I SAID THAT TO YOU. ELIZABETH SAID THAT IN THE
42:21 CONTROL ROOM. WE ALL WANT TO PLAY.
42:23 ALL RIGHT, STICK AROUND, EVERYBODY.
42:24 WE'RE GOING TO DO STOCKS ON THE MOVE WHEN WE COME BACK.
42:32 ♪ >> THIS IS "BLOOMBERG BUSINESS
42:33 WEEK DAILY" WITH CAROL MASSAR AND TIM STENOVEC.
42:38 ON BLOOMBERG RADIO AND TELEVISION.
42:39 CAROL: ALL RIGHT, EVERYBODY, WE'RE COMING OCCUPANT LAST HOUR
42:42 OF TRADING ON THIS WEDNESDAY. CAROL MASSAR, TIM STENOVEC LIVE
42:43 AT BLOOMBERG HEADQUARTERS IN NEW YORK CITY.
42:46 QUICK CHECK ON THE TRADE FOR YOU.
42:49 S&P 500, WE'RE PASSING IT AROUND, TO BE QUITE FAIR.
42:52 S&P RIGHT NOW IS JUST DOWN ABOUT 22 POINTS, SO JUST A HAIR LOWER.
43:01 ON A PERCENTAGE BASIS, WE'RE TALKING .3%.
43:05 NASDAQ 100 -- TIM: WHOSE INDEX OF CHOICE?
43:08 CAROL: I DON'T KNOW. WHO AM TOY JUDGE?
43:14 TIM: SOME PEOPLE LOVE THE DOW. CAROL: I THINK ABOUT IN THE
43:18 EARLY DAYS, I'M ALSO AMAZED WHEN THEY TALK ABOUT THE MARKET, AND
43:22 THEY ONLY SHOW THE DOW. IT'S INTERESTING.
43:24 TIM: THIS IS NOT ABOUT A CONVERSATION ABOUT LITERACY,
43:29 ECONOMIC LITERACY, NEWS LITERACY AND BUSINESS AND ECONOMIC
43:30 REPORTING. CAROL: NO.
43:33 TIM: BUT IT'S NOT THE BEST REPRESENTATION OF THE STOCK
43:34 MARKET. CAROL: BUT FOR SO LONG, I THINK
43:42 ABOUT HERE'S WHAT THE DOW DID. I FIND IT INTERESTING HOW THINGS
43:44 EVOLVE. NASDAQ 100, LET'S GO THERE.
43:53 TECH HEAVY, WHATEVER UP TO THE SAY, UP 50 BASIS, UP .2%.
43:57 THE NVIDIA TRADE ONCE AGAIN REALLY WEIGHING IT, IT MAKES UP
44:01 AN UNFAIR PERCENTAGE ON THE NASDAQ 100, THE S&P 100, YOU CAN
44:05 SEE SOME OF THAT AT PLAY. TIM: I'M TIM STENOVEC ALONG WITH
44:08 CAROL MASSAR. LET'S LOOK AT STOCKS ON THE MOVE
44:10 TODAY. WITH US IS OUR CROSS ASSETS
44:15 REPORTER WITH TODAY'S STOCK MOVERS.
44:19 WHERE, OH WHERE, SHALL WE BEGIN? >> THERE'S ONLY ONE NAME WE WANT
44:24 TO TALK ABOUT, AND IT'S NVIDIA. THE STOCK JUMPED AS MUCH AS 5%
44:27 AM TODAY WE'RE SEEING A VERY DIFFERENT REACTION.
44:30 THE LOSSES ARE GETTING BIGGER NOW.
44:33 IT'S DOWN AS MUCH AS 3%. CLEARLY THE COMPANY TRIED TO
44:38 GIVE A POSITIVE FORECAST. THEY PRESENTED THIS VISION,
44:41 WE'RE SUPER STRONG WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG, AND INVESTORS
44:45 VOTED, AT LEAST INITIALLY, THERE WAS OPTIMISM WITH THAT.
44:49 THERE WERE STRONG NUMBERS. THEY ADDED $150 BILLION TO THEIR
44:53 STOCK BUYBACK PROGRAM, BOOSTED SALES FORECAST.
44:56 EVERYTHING LOOKED GOOD ON PAPER. TODAY WE'RE SEEING SOME PEOPLE
44:59 COOLING DOWN. NO ONE WAS THERE, NO ONE WAS
45:04 THERE TO SHORTEN IT, AND WE'VE SEEN IT THE LAST FEW DAYS,
45:09 DEFINITELY THERE'S BEEN MORE REPORTS.
45:12 MORE NEGATIVE COMMENTS. CAROL: WALL STREET NOT PUTTING
45:17 CELLS. >> EXACTLY.
45:19 WE SAW A SMALL CUT ON MORGAN STANLEY, THEY CUT THEIR PRICE
45:23 TARGET, THE OTHER THING, A LOT OF BOOTS ARE STILL HOLDING THEIR
45:26 TARGETS, AND THEY'RE SAYING THE GAINS WILL HOLD.
45:29 BUT THAT SAID, I HAVEN'T SEEN TOO MANY NOTES THAT SAY THEY'LL
45:33 BE GOING CRAZE FRIDAY HERE. THE STOCK IS DOWN MORE THAN 30%.
45:36 OF COURSE, EVERYONE WAS ASKING ABOUT THE CALL ABOUT JENSEN
45:40 HUANG'S RETURN, THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT CAME OUT ON
45:41 TUESDAY. IT SEEMS THAT ON THE CALL, THEY
45:45 DISMISSED THE IDEA, THEY SAID HUANG IS NOT COMING BACK.
45:48 BUT THERE'S TOO MANY OPEN QUESTIONS, AND I FEEL EVERY NEW
45:51 DAY THERE'S A NEW DEVELOPMENT, NEW STORY.
45:54 WHO KNOWS WHAT HAPPENS NEXT. TIM: TIGRIS FINANCIAL STILL HAS
45:58 A STRONG BUY, AND HE'S NOT UPDATED HIS PRICE TARGET SINCE
46:04 MAY. THAT'S THE HIGHEST OF ANALYSTS
46:07 TRACKED BY BLOOMBERG. CAROL: IT'S NOT LIKE EVERYBODY
46:08 IS READY. TO BE FAIR, INVESTIGATIONS HAVE
46:11 TO HAPPEN. THERE'S A LOT THAT HAS TO HAPPEN
46:15 AS EVERYBODY AWAITS FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT WHAT IT MEANS
46:18 FOR THE COMPANY ITSELF. TIM: JAY GOLDBERG IS THE ONLY
46:22 ANALYST WHO HAS A PRICE TARGET THAT'S LOWER THAN WHERE THE
46:25 STOCK IS RIGHT NOW. THE NEXT LOWEST IS 170 FOR HSBC.
46:31 CAROL: GOOD CALL ON HIS PART. TIM: REMEMBER, HE LOWERED HIS ON
46:33 SUNDAY. CAROL: HE'S BEEN REALLY GENEROUS
46:37 WITH HIS TIME, HAS TALKED WITH TIM AND ME A LOT AS OF LATE ON
46:40 THE EARNINGS AND ALSO OVER THE LAST WEEK OR SO.
46:43 LET'S GO QUICKLY, WE JUST GOT ABOUT A MUST NOT OR SO, TARGET.
46:52 >> YEAH, TARGET STOCK IS UP ABOUT 6%, THE STOCK IS UP MORE
46:57 THAN 70% YEAR TO DATE. BIG GAINS.
46:59 IT'S MAKING PROGRESS, REVIVING GROWTH.
47:02 IT HAS A FEW VERY DIFFICULT YEARS.
47:05 WE'RE SEEING BETTER THAN EXPECTED SALES, THEY'RE CHANGE
47:07 AGO LOT OF THINGS. IT LOOKS LIKE PEOPLE ARE BUYING
47:11 MORE GROCERIES, FEWER CLOTHES, SO THEY'RE CUTTING SOME CLOTHING
47:15 ITEMS FOR WOMEN. AND THEY'RE INCREASING THE
47:16 GROCERIES. PEOPLE ARE BUYING MORE
47:19 GROCERIES, AND THEY'RE TRYING TO CUT PRICES T. SOUNDS LIKE A GOOD
47:23 MIX TO RETAIN CUSTOMERS. CAROL: GOT TO EAT.
47:27 THEY'VE BEEN PRETTY AGGRESSIVE ALREADY WITH THEIR CHRISTMAS
47:28 ADVERTISING. TIM: IT'S NOT EVEN THANKSGIVING
47:32 YET. CAROL: THAT'S WHAT MY HUSBAND
47:33 SAID. REAL QUICKLY, TAKE TWO
47:37 INTERACTIVE, TTWO. >> THIS MIGHT BE THE MOST
47:41 EXCITING VIDEO GAME EVER. I'VE SEEN THE REVIEWS, THEY'RE
47:43 CRAZY. EVERYONE IS LIKE, THIS IS A
47:46 MASTERPIECE. ALL THE SCORES ARE LIKE 98 OUT
47:49 OF 100. E, 99 OUT OF 100.
47:52 CAROL: NEAR PERFECTION. >> I DON'T THINK I'VE EVER SEEN
47:55 ANY REVIEWS LIKE THAT FOR A MOVIE, SONG OR ANYTHING.
48:00 ONE INTERESTING NUMBER IS THEY SAY GTA VI IS TIED FOR THE
48:05 HIGHEST RATED VIDEO GAME OF ALL TIME, MATCHING THE 1998 LEGEND
48:10 OF ZELDA. EITHER WAY, IT'S INCREDIBLE.
48:14 CAROL: DO YOU PLAY? >> NO, WELL, I USED TO PLAY.
48:18 CAROL: READ THE REVIEW, YOU WILL WANT TO PLAY.
48:23 >> I PLAYED WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER.
48:24 IT WAS A REALLY BIG THING. TIM: THEN YOU'RE GOING PLAY THIS
48:27 ONE. >> YEAH, YEAH.
48:30 CAROL: IT'S PRETTY AMAZING. TIM: WE'LL ALL GO OVER THERE TO
48:33 PLAY VIDEO GAMES. >> AFTER ONE HOUR ON TV?
48:37 CAROL: WE CAN PLAY IT. CHECK OUT THE PODCAST,
48:40 FIVE-MINUTE EPISODES ON APPLE, SPOTIFY OR ANYWHERE YOU GET YOUR
48:43 PODCASTS. IF YOU'RE ON TELEVISION AND
48:47 STAYING THERE, CHECK OUT "THE CLOSE."
What’s Driving Oil and Yields Apart? full transcript
0:04 For most of 2026, oil prices and
0:06 treasury yields moved higher in virtual
0:08 lockep. And there were a couple pretty
0:10 straightforward reasons why. First,
0:12 rising oil prices were adding to
0:14 inflation concerns. Second, an
0:16 increasingly costly war was creating
0:18 concerns regarding bond supply. Now,
0:20 additionally, regarding the rate spike,
0:22 the economy was holding up reasonably
0:24 well, giving the Fed a growing reason to
0:26 hike rates. And finally, the enormous
0:28 appetite for capital from the AI
0:30 buildout was creating another source of
0:32 competition for money. But recently, the
0:34 relationship has broken down. Oil prices
0:37 have moved lower, largely on the belief
0:39 that the conflict will come to an end
0:40 sooner rather than later, and yields
0:42 have begun a new leg higher. It feels
0:45 there's a new narrative that's emerged.
0:47 Inflation remains stubborn, as we've
0:50 been reminded by the latest CPI number,
0:52 but the labor market has delivered some
0:54 remarkably strong [music] numbers,
0:55 suggesting the economy may be expanding
0:57 at a pace that makes more Fed [music]
0:59 hikes appropriate. In other words, the
1:02 inflation argument hasn't gone away, and
1:04 the growth argument may actually be
1:06 getting [music] stronger. So, what does
1:07 this divergence tell us? Well, is the
1:10 bond market simply adjusting to a
1:12 different set of economic realities, or
1:13 are [music] yields telling us that the
1:15 market is beginning to price in a more
1:16 persistent inflation problem? I think
1:18 that's a question worth watching [music]
1:20 because oil may have lost some of its
1:22 influence, but the forces pushing
1:24 Treasury yields higher haven't
1:26 necessarily disappeared.
S&P Falls to Lowest Since July, Anthropic IPO Looms full transcript
0:00 And right now we are two minutes away from the end of the trading day.
0:03 Romaine Bostick alongside Vonnie Quinn Tequila due to that closing bell.
0:07 It's a global simulcast. Carol Massar Tim.
0:09 They join us now. Welcome to our audiences across all of
0:12 our Bloomberg platforms. Television.
0:13 Radio. Our partnership with YouTube.
0:16 Fractional gains, fractional losses at the index level for U.S.
0:20 equities depending on which index you pick.
0:22 But still we are seeing the narrative, Carol, that has been playing out for
0:27 quite some time. Chip stocks still under pressure.
0:29 A lot of questions about Nvidia and a lot of questions about that anthropic
0:33 IPO. Yeah, I got to say and I've got it
0:35 already up on my Bloomberg. We are expecting it to price here right
0:39 after the closing bell. So it does feel like it keeps kind of
0:42 moving up in terms of what it might trade for.
0:45 Maybe as high as $85 a share. That's our latest read on the Bloomberg.
0:48 But that's kind of what I'm thinking about.
0:50 What anthropic IPO will say about the next leg of the AI story in trade.
0:55 Yeah, that's the big question. I mean, does this change the tone of
0:58 what we've seen over the last few weeks, Vonnie, with this trade really fizzling
1:02 out and the questions that remain and the challenges that remain for Nvidia,
1:06 or is this just an anthropic story. Yeah, we did get past one of those risk
1:10 catalysts, which was the Nvidia earnings call.
1:12 Right. And we started off the day pretty
1:14 positive on Nvidia. And you know investors have sold that
1:17 off. But not to a massive extent.
1:18 We're down 3% or so. You have to wonder if there isn't some
1:21 liquidating of certain stocks in order to try and get in on opening day for the
1:25 IPO tomorrow. Zoom.
1:26 Yeah. Video.
1:27 The movement has been interesting, opened up by more than 2%, and now it
1:31 looks like it's going to head into the closed down about 3% down for a fifth
1:36 straight day. So too is the S&P 500 which actually
1:39 opened higher but will closed lower down in just about 17 to 18 points as we wait
1:44 for these numbers to settle. That's a loss of about a quarter of a
1:47 percent. Fifth straight day of losses.
1:49 The Dow down 1.1% on the day, but the Nasdaq indices escaping what had been a
1:55 four day slump over what has been a four day slump and breaking that slump now
1:59 both up, each up, I should say almost exactly about the same.
2:02 Uh, Erie, each up about 100 points, or about 4/10 of a percent.
2:06 And the Russell 2000. Carol gets in on the action as well, up
2:09 about 12 points or a half a percentage point.
2:11 All right. So a little bit higher there S&P though
2:13 as you mentioned remain down on the day, but go inside the index.
2:17 Almost an even split in terms of winners and losers.
2:20 At 237 names in the S&P 500 higher in today's session, but 265 to the downside
2:26 and then one unchanged. Well, fascinatingly, if we go inside the
2:30 S&P 500, you'll see that consumer discretionary is doing extraordinarily
2:34 well today. Haven't seen that for a while, but it's
2:36 really beating on the bottom line. And some of those stocks are just
2:39 absolutely killing it today and definitely helping this equity index
2:44 move to the upside because most other groups were lower today.
2:48 Carol. All right.
2:49 So let's get to some of the individual gainers if I may.
2:51 Got to mention Take-Two interactive. Um, I know that, uh, remain at the big
2:56 Grand Theft Auto player, so I'm sure he's going to be gaming it out, uh, as
3:00 soon as it, uh, is, uh, released a little bit later, I don't even I don't
3:04 even play games. And I want to play this, I do.
3:06 Thank you. Tim.
3:07 This will get me to a game. I actually think if you read Jason
3:10 Schreier, I named my avatar Carol. Oh, okay.
3:14 Oh. I'm honored.
3:15 I don't know if you should, but actually,
3:18 I'm a little nervous about what that avatar might look like.
3:21 All right, moving on, moving on. All right.
3:23 Take-Two interactive, uh, higher in today's session, folks.
3:25 6.2% higher. Heavy, heavy volume.
3:28 Um, of course, Grand Theft Auto six receiving close to perfect scores across
3:33 the board this morning. So making it the best reviewed game of
3:35 all time according to major review aggregation websites.
3:39 Our own Jason Schreier calling the game, which took more than 4700 people in
3:43 eight years to develop a masterpiece stock, though still down about 14% year
3:48 to date. All right, let's go on over to another,
3:50 um, bunch of stocks, actually, retailers thanks to TJ Max, which ended the day up
3:56 about 8%, rallying the most intraday in more than six years.
3:59 So going back to November of 2020, a top name in the S&P 500.
4:03 This after TJ Max, uh, our TJ uh X stores I should say, um, their third
4:09 quarter comp sales topped expectations, including its core Ma max division,
4:13 which includes the Marshalls and TJ Max banners, now sees consolidated
4:17 comparable sales for the year at the high end of its previous guidance range.
4:20 So a lot of optimism out of their results.
4:23 And what they, um, said today actually lifted names like Ross Stores.
4:27 It was up about 3.25%. And you can see Burlington.
4:30 They're up about 5.5%. And then on over to target another
4:33 retailer rallying as quarterly sales were better than expected, with comp
4:37 sales rising 5.6% from a year earlier. The company working to improve its
4:42 merchandise and tech, and has revamped its food and beverage section and dialed
4:46 up deals ahead of the holiday. So some upbeat news there that stock up
4:50 almost 4% in the trade Tim. All right for decliners got to talk
4:53 about Nvidia remain shared some of the price action that we saw earlier.
4:56 It closed down close to 3% but was up as much as 2.7% earlier that post earnings
5:01 rally, fizzling down five days in a row. Over that period of time, it shed more
5:06 than half $1 trillion in revenue. It's now down close to 37% from those
5:11 early October highs, still trading at around June 2025 prices.
5:15 We did learn from the Financial Times that Nvidia, Nvidia's interim CEO,
5:20 promised employees pay raises and additional equity benefits in December.
5:24 Uh, pulling for these increases in new equity words, breaking with the
5:27 company's normal schedule of annual reviews for employees in the spring to
5:31 sort of work on a little bit of the morale there.
5:34 Shares of Nvidia down 2.9% today. Also taking a look at shares of health
5:39 insurance providers. Humana down today by 13%.
5:43 Um, down for a health insurer, is down for a second day this fall as the US
5:46 government's proposed Medicare Advantage audit framework and its new rule called
5:50 Comprehensive Regulations to uncover suspicious health care.
5:53 The acronym is Crush. Separately, Senator Bernie Sanders
5:56 outlined a four year plan to achieve Medicare for all in his new Senate term.
5:59 That's according to a report from the AP.
6:01 So some of these insurers under pressure, including Humana and finally
6:04 miners under pressure today, uh, Freeport-McMoRan down today by a
6:09 whopping 7%. This after gold dropped below 3800 an
6:13 ounce for the first time since September of last year.
6:16 Uh, the. We saw Freeport-McMoRan fall, Newmont
6:19 fall, uh, Barrick mining fall, among others, too.
6:22 All right. Let's take a quick look at yields
6:24 because we saw a lot of volatility there earlier in the day.
6:27 We got some fed speak that actually spiked yields higher.
6:30 But that was a race very quickly. We're seeing the entire curve shift
6:33 lower on the day. Uh modest saw declines on the two year
6:37 yield but down for a fourth straight day.
6:40 Uh much bigger moves on the longer end of the curve.
6:42 But your ten year yield down about five basis points.
AI Doubts Drag on Copper full transcript
0:04 Copper has always been a [music] good
0:05 read on the economy, but over the last
0:07 few weeks, we've also gotten a look at
0:09 how much the AI trade could matter for
0:11 [music] copper. Nvidia, a bellweather
0:14 for the AI trade, has sold off sharply
0:17 as investors weigh uncertainty over its
0:19 leadership [music]
0:20 and question how fast companies will
0:22 keep spending on AI. Copper has gone
0:25 [music] the same way. It's on track for
0:28 a fifth straight weekly loss and is
0:30 trading near the lowest levels [music]
0:31 since midsummer.
0:34 Part of what we're seeing is that when
0:35 investors feel good about AI spending,
0:37 [music] they're also pricing in more
0:39 demand for copper from data centers and
0:41 all the power infrastructure that goes
0:43 with them. When those expectations cool,
0:46 some of that support for copper goes
0:48 away. Even with physical supply still
0:51 relatively [music] tight, the broader
0:53 economy still matters more for copper.
0:56 But the last few [music] weeks show how
0:58 much a change in expectations for AI
1:01 spending can move the market.
An AI Slowdown Is Not Entirely Bad News full transcript
0:04 The AI buildout is on track to become
0:06 the biggest economic bet in US history.
0:08 While AI infrastructure spending has
0:10 been a major driver of recent US
0:12 economic growth, economists are divided
0:15 on whether moderating that spending
0:17 would bring a healthy normalization or
0:19 trigger a broader downturn. AI capex has
0:23 accounted for an estimated 40 to 44% of
0:26 recent US GDP growth on a headline
0:28 basis.
0:30 Total investment in data centers and
0:32 related AI infrastructure is projected
0:34 to total $10.3 trillion from 2025 to
0:39 2032.
0:41 Demand for equipment that goes into data
0:43 centers, notably memory chips is leading
0:46 to shortages and driving up costs for
0:49 tech products. The prices that importers
0:52 paid for hard drives and semiconductors
0:54 were 20% higher in August than last
0:57 year. Those high import prices are in
1:00 turn putting upward pressure on the cost
1:02 of many consumer goods, contributing to
1:04 inflation.
1:06 Moderating this spending could relieve
1:08 pressure on prices and monetary policy
1:11 in several ways, including easing supply
1:13 chain bottlenecks and potentially
1:15 lowering core inflation back below 3%.
1:19 This in turn could ease pressure on the
1:21 Fed and the current tightening interest
1:24 rate cycle.
Could 2027 Mark the End of Megacap Dominance? full transcript
0:00 [music]
0:04 The recently highlighted rotation out of
0:06 mega cap concentration into equal weight
0:08 and to some degree small caps very well
0:10 could continue in 2027. There are
0:13 several fundamental valuation and
0:15 cyclical factors supporting the
0:16 continuation.
0:18 Market concentration remains extreme.
0:20 The Magnificent 7 still represent
0:22 roughly one-third of the S&P 500 and the
0:25 top 10 names are around 37 to 39%.
0:29 AILink stocks dominate a large share of
0:31 the index. Valuations and earnings
0:34 differentials. Small and midcap trade
0:36 near multi-deade relative lows versus
0:39 large caps. Prior peaks in
0:41 concentration, notably around 1973 and
0:44 2000 were followed by multi-year periods
0:47 of small cap and equal weight
0:49 outperformance.
0:51 2026 was dominated by the AI
0:53 infrastructure buildout. Strategists
0:55 increasingly frame 2027 as a shift
0:58 towards proving returns [music] on the
0:59 capital expenditure.
1:02 This supports rotation away from the
1:03 most crowded meggaap name. Extreme
1:06 starting concentration, relative
1:08 valuation discounts, expected earnings
1:11 catchup, historical cycles, and the
1:13 evolving AI narrative make further
1:15 easing in mega cap dominance and
1:17 rotation towards equal weight and small
1:19 caps a plausible, widely discussed base
1:21 [music] case for 2027.
Is Gold the New Risk Asset? full transcript
0:04 For thousands of years, gold has been
0:06 viewed as the ultimate safe haven
0:07 [music] asset. So why during periods of
0:10 market stress has it increasingly been
0:12 treating more like a risk asset? Well,
0:14 there seems to be several things
0:15 happening. First, gold has become a much
0:18 bigger [music] institutional trade.
0:20 After an extraordinary rally,
0:21 positioning became increasingly crowded.
0:23 speculative money poured in and
0:25 investors began treating gold as a
0:27 momentum investment rather than simply a
0:29 store of value. When markets turn lower,
0:32 those positions can unwind very quickly.
0:35 Second, we're seeing the importance of
0:37 liquidity. When investors are forced to
0:39 reduce risk [music] or meet margin
0:41 calls, they sell what they can, not
0:43 necessarily what they want. Gold with
0:45 its enormous liquidity becomes a source
0:47 of capital.
0:49 That can create an unusual situation
0:51 where an asset traditionally purchased
0:52 for protection gets sold [music]
0:54 alongside risk assets.
0:56 Now, there's also a macro component. If
0:59 market stress pushes the dollar higher
1:01 and if it's inflation induced stress,
1:03 interest rate [music] expectations
1:04 higher along with it, gold then faces a
1:07 double-edged sword. Gold pays no
1:09 interest, so elevated real yields
1:11 increase [music] the opportunity cost of
1:12 holding it. But I wouldn't conclude that
1:15 gold has lost its safe haven status yet.
1:17 I think we're seeing the difference
1:18 between gold's long-term role as a
1:20 monetary and currency hedge and its
1:22 short-term behavior as a heavily traded
1:23 financial asset. And right now, [music]
1:26 positioning and liquidity appear to be
1:27 having a bigger influence on its price
1:29 than its traditional safe haven
1:31 characteristics.
Justifying Anthropic’s Valuation, The Bank of Nvidia full transcript
0:01 ♪ >> LIVE FROM BLOOMBERG'S WORLD
0:03 HEADQUARTERS IN NEW YORK CITY, WE ARE TRACKING THE KEY PLAYERS,
0:07 THE MAJOR MOVERS SHAPING GLOBAL MARKETS.
0:12 THIS IS BLOOMBERG DEALS. >> WELCOME TO ANOTHER EPISODE OF
0:16 BLOOMBERG DEALS. TODAY IS THE COUNT DOWN TO
0:22 YEAR. IN A HEARING TODAY ON CAPITOL
0:29 HILL, M&A ACTIVITY THAT COULD POSE RISKS TO U.S. NATIONAL
0:30 SECURITY. IN A MOMENT, WE WILL SPEAK
0:35 EXCLUSIVELY WITH THE GLOBAL HEAD OF ASSET AND WEALTH MANAGEMENT
0:37 AT GOLDMAN SACHS. HE BREAKS DOWN SOME OF THE MORE
0:41 RECENT ACQUISITIONS. LET'S GET TO OUR FIRST BIG DEAL,
0:44 ANTHROPIC PRICING THE BLOCKBUSTER IPO AND EXPECTS TO
0:50 PRICE SHARES AT THE HIGH-END OF THE RANGE, OR ABOVE.
0:55 JOINING US TO BREAK DOWN THE DETAILS OF THIS MEGA IPO IS
0:59 BAILEY. >> EXPECTING AT SOME POINT THE
1:04 PRICING DISCUSSION WILL FINALIZE AGAIN.
1:08 NORTH OF $78 PER SHARE. THAT WILL TAKE PLACE LATER THIS
1:13 EVENING AND INVESTORS WILL START TO GET THE PHONE CALL FROM
1:17 BANKERS OF YOU PROBABLY GOT WAY LESS SHARES YOU EXPECTED AND WE
1:20 WILL SHIP TOMORROW WHEN WE TALK ABOUT WHAT THIS DEAL LOOKS LIKE
1:23 AND HOW IT ULTIMATELY TRADES. DANI: WHAT DOES TRADING ACTUALLY
1:28 LOOK LIKE? BAILEY: AS OF FRIDAY THIS WAS
1:33 NORTH OF SIX TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED.
1:35 THIS IS VERY MUCH A FOOD FIGHT. EVERYONE IS TRYING TO GET AS
1:37 MUCH ALLOCATION AS THEY CAN. MULTIPLE PEOPLE HAVE PUT IN
1:43 ORDERS OF MORE THAN $5 BILLION. THERE IS A LOT OF EXCITEMENT
1:44 GOING INTO THIS. HOW MANY OF THOSE PEOPLE ARE
1:48 LOOKING TO MAKE A QUICK BUCK OFF OF THE INITIAL IPO POP, HOW MANY
1:53 ARE GOING TO WANT TO STEP IN AND FURTHER SUPPORT THE COMPANY?
1:57 DANI: HOW MUCH OF THE SELLING WE HAVE SEEN IS MAY BE IN
1:59 ANTICIPATION, MAKING SPACE FOR ANTHROPIC, MAY BE SELLING NVIDIA
2:04 IS A CONVENIENT EXCUSE? BAILEY: WE'VE BEEN HEARING
2:07 CHATTER ABOUT THAT, PEOPLE NEEDING TO CLEAR OUT SOME DRY
2:10 POWDER. YOU HAVE TO COME UP WITH DOLLARS
2:15 FROM SOMEWHERE SO IT SEEMS LIKE WE SEE ROTATION AWAY FROM SOME
2:18 OF THOSE MAG 7 NAMES. THE LARGER THIS DEAL GETS, THE
2:25 MORE CAPITAL IT'S GOING TO NEED ON THE SIDELINES.
2:30 DANI: ANOTHER AI GIANT GETTING A LOT OF ATTENTION IS NVIDIA WITH
2:32 JENSEN HUANG'S EXIT. WE BRING IN RYAN GOULD FOR THAT,
2:40 AND SPECIFICALLY THIS IS AN NVIDIA THAT COLETTE KRESS GOT ON
2:42 THE CALL AND SAID WE ARE GOING TO BE MORE DILIGENT WHEN IT
2:44 COMES TO FINANCING ACTIVITIES. NVIDIA HAS FINANCED A LOT OF
2:53 THIS UNIVERSE IN CONCERT WITH PRIVATE CAPITAL GIANTS.
2:55 DOES THAT CHANGE THE DEALMAKING ACTIVITY?
2:59 RYAN: THE SHORT ANSWER IS THERE'S A LOT OF ANXIETY AROUND
3:03 AN INDUSTRY, THIS IDEA THAT YOU HAD A LIEUTENANT KIND OF
3:06 DIRECTING THE TRAFFIC AND DIRECTING CAPITAL IN AND AROUND
3:09 A VERY SMALL CLUSTER OF COMPANIES THAT WERE ALL RELIANT
3:14 ON NVIDIA'S SUCCESS. NOW EVERYONE IS LOOKING OVER
3:17 THEIR SHOULDER, SAYING WHAT DO WE DO WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG, THIS
3:20 GUY WHO CLEARLY UNDERSTANDS WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO, A BIG
3:23 CHAMPION OF OPEN SOURCE MODELS. HE WAS BEHIND THE ACQUISITION OF
3:30 HUGGING FACE EARLIER THIS YEAR. YOU HAVE AN INDUSTRY RIGHT NOW,
3:32 WHICH IS LOOKING FOR THE NEXT CLUES.
3:38 LISTENING TO THE EARNINGS CALL MY COLETTE KRESS SAYING WE ARE
3:40 GOING TO BE MUCH MORE DILIGENT AND RIGOROUS IN TERMS OF HOW WE
3:47 ANXIOUS. DANI: WAS SHE HINTING AT
3:53 INVESTMENT GRADE NEO-CLOUDS? RYAN: I THINK THAT IS PART OF
3:58 IT. ONE INTERESTING LINE THAT WAS
4:02 NEW, MENTIONED ON THE EARNINGS CALL, ASKING WHERE IS THE LINE
4:08 AROUND COMMITMENTS OR GUARANTEES TO THE NEO-CLOUD COMPANIES.
4:13 COLETTE RESPONDED AND SAID THIS IS NOT A NEW THING FOR US, MORE
4:18 JUST GETTING CLARITY TO MARKET ON WHEN THESE GUARANTEES TAKE
4:20 PLACE BECAUSE THERE HAS BEEN THIS IDEA THAT NVIDIA IS
4:26 THROWING MONEY AT WILL, BEHIND COMPANIES THAT AREN'T SHOWING
4:29 APPROPRIATE GROWTH OR SHOVELS IN THE GROUND AND I THINK NVIDIA IS
4:34 SAYING THESE ARE GOING TO KICK IN WHEN WE SEE PROGRESS, NOT
4:37 BEFORE. DANI: NVIDIA IS THIS BIG
4:42 SPEEDBUMP WITH LOTS OF QUESTIONS OVER IT.
4:47 IF ANTHROPIC CAN KIND OF REINVIGORATE AND BRING BACK THE
4:50 ANIMAL SPIRITS, -- BAILEY: IT DOES SEEM LIKE THE
4:55 BATON HAS BEEN PASSED FROM NVIDIA TO ANTHROPIC.
4:58 THIS IS GOING TO BE MOVING FROM THE SUPPLY SIDE AND
5:02 INFRASTRUCTURE TO A DEMAND WHERE ANTHROPIC IS THE --
5:10 RYAN: YOUR STORY ON THE WEEKEND, ANTHROPIC BECOMING THE POSTER
5:12 CHILD OF THIS ENTIRE INDUSTRY. YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO STEP
5:18 INTO THAT SPOTLIGHT BECAUSE EVERYONE IS LOOKING TO YOU FOR
5:19 CLUES ON WHERE THAT SPEND IS GOING AND THERE HAVE BEEN
5:25 QUESTIONS ABOUT ANTHROPIC'S RUNWAY THROUGHOUT THIS YEAR AND
5:28 IT'S BEEN PHENOMENAL BUT AT WHAT POINT DOES THAT START TO
5:31 MEANINGFULLY SLOW AND AT WHAT POINT DOES NVIDIA DRAW ATTENTION
5:35 TO THAT? BAILEY: NVIDIA IS STILL HUGE,
5:41 ONE OF THE LARGEST COMPANIES IN THE WORLD, EVEN IF ANTHROPIC
5:45 TRADES WELL. RYAN: I WOULD ALSO THROW IN,
5:52 THIS IS A COMPANY TRYING TO PULL OFF THE BIGGEST IPO AT THE SAME
5:59 TIME THAT ELON MUSK IS TRYING TO NEGOTIATE THE BIGGEST MERGER
6:01 BETWEEN SPACEX AND DOES LOVE. SO WE HAVE THIS BIG PRESSURE
6:09 COOKER RIGHT NOW, WITH HEADWINDS AND TAILWINDS.
6:14 DANI: IT HIGHLIGHTS THINGS ARE NOT SLOWING DOWN BY ANY STRETCH.
6:18 THANK YOU VERY MUCH, BAILEY LIPSCHULTZ AND RYAN GOULD.
6:23 DEALMAKING HAS STARTED TO LOSE MOMENTUM.
6:28 HIGHER RATES AND MARKET VOLATILITY COMBINED TO SLOW DOWN
6:30 M&A. SCARLETT: LET'S SHOW YOU WHERE
6:33 THINGS STAND. A 15% DROP GLOBALLY IN PENDING
6:37 AND COMPLETED DEALS. NORTH AMERICA DOWN 12%, BUT THE
6:44 MIDDLE EAST AND LET AND HIM ARE SEEING MARKET DECLINES.
6:49 THE EXCEPTIONS SEEM TO BE ASIA-PACIFIC AND EUROPE.
6:54 CERTAIN INDUSTRIES, TECH AND ENERGY ARE POSTING BIG INCREASES
6:58 OVER THE SAME TIME, A YEAR AGO. THAT IS REFLECTED IN THE BIGGEST
7:00 DEALS OVER THE PAST MONTH. -- SEE QT BUYING GREEN TREE
7:11 RESOURCES FOR $12 BILLION. JOSH KUSHNER'S THRIVE HOLDINGS
7:16 AND DOORDASH BUYING INSTACART AS WELL.
7:22 ACCORDING TO BANK OF AMERICA'S CEO, DEALS ARE GETTING POSTPONED
7:26 INTO 2027 AND ONE REASON IS THE ANTHROPIC IPO YOU TALKED ABOUT,
7:29 CROWDING OUT A LOT OF OTHER CAPITAL MARKET ACTIVITY.
7:33 HERE IS WHAT BRIAN MONAHAN TOLD SURVEILLANCE EARLIER THIS WEEK.
7:36 >> IT'S BEEN VERY BUMPY. WHAT IS HAPPENING TODAY IS RIGHT
7:40 NOW, DEALS ARE GETTING PUSHED INTO EARLY NEXT YEAR BECAUSE OF
7:43 THE UNCERTAINTY THAT UNDERLIES IT.
7:48 GENERAL COMPANIES, SLIDING INTO NEXT YEAR.
7:53 SCARLET: BANK OF AMERICA IS NUMBER FOUR WITH A 15% MARKET
7:56 SHARE. IT HAS ADVISED ON 133 DEALS.
8:04 NUMBER ONE IS GOLDMAN SACHS. 42% MARKET SHARE.
8:13 THE AVERAGE DEAL VALUED AT ABOUT $4.6 BILLION.
8:17 DANI: LET'S SHIFT TO ANOTHER SECTOR.
8:21 HEALTH CARE DEALS HAVE HIT $300 BILLION THIS YEAR AND ONE OF THE
8:24 COMPANY IS DRIVING THAT MOMENTUM IS ELI LILLY, A BEAT -- AGREEING
8:29 TO BUY CALTEX BIO IN THE DEAL THAT COULD BE WORTH UP TO A HALF
8:32 BILLION DOLLARS. MADISON MULLER JOINS US NOW WITH
8:35 THE LATEST. WHAT IS LILY GETTING WITH THIS
8:40 ACQUISITION? >> THIS EXPANDS THEIR PRESENCE
8:43 IN ONCOLOGY. THE DEALS CHIEF IS ALSO THE HEAD
8:50 OF ONCOLOGY. WHEN THEY MADE THAT A POINT LAST
8:54 YEAR, IT REALLY GOES TO SHOW THAT IS ONE OF THE AREAS THEY
8:57 ARE LOOKING TO BUILD A BIGGER PRESENCE AND.
9:00 THEY ALREADY MAKE DRUGS FOR BREAST CANCER, BUT THEY ARE
9:02 LOOKING TO EXPAND INTO OTHER TYPES.
9:10 SO THEY HAVE BEEN ON THIS MASSIVE SPENDING SPREE THIS
9:13 YEAR, A LOT OF DEALS IN CANCER AND OTHER AREAS LIKE IMMUNOLOGY.
9:19 THEY HAVE REALLY SAID THAT THEY ARE LEAVING NO STONE UNTURNED IN
9:21 TERMS OF WHAT THEY ARE LOOKING FOR.
9:24 DANI: IS IT BECAUSE THEY HAVE THIS BIG CASH PILE BECAUSE OF
9:31 GLP-1'S OR IS IT THAT THEY ARE NERVOUS ABOUT TOO MUCH
9:32 CONCENTRATION? >> I THINK IT IS BOTH.
9:38 THEY HAVE THE CASH FLOW AND THEY ARE AWARE THAT THEY HAVE A
9:45 DECADE LEFT ON THE PATENT FOR THE GLP-1 DRUG BUT LILY HAS BEEN
9:50 CAUGHT IN THIS SITUATION BEFORE. THEY FAMOUSLY DEVELOPED THE BIG
9:53 DEPRESSION DRUG THAT CHANGED THE WAY WE TREAT DEPRESSION IN THE
9:57 UNITED STATES, BUT WHEN THAT WENT OFF PATENT, THINGS CHANGED
10:01 FOR ITALY -- FOR LILY AND THEY WENT INTO A DARK PERIOD.
10:07 THEY ARE EXTREMELY AWARE OF THAT AND INVESTING TO GET AHEAD OF
10:09 THAT. LILY HAS ALWAYS LOOKED FOR
10:12 EARLIER STAGE DEALS THAT MIGHT BE A LITTLE RISKY, BUT CHEAPER
10:17 AND THEY HAVE REALLY STUCK TO THAT STRATEGY FOR THE MOST PART.
10:20 WE ARE NOT SEEING ENORMOUS DEALS.
10:24 THE BIGGEST IS JUST ABOVE $7 BILLION, WHICH IN TERMS OF
10:27 PHARMA DEALS IS ON THE MEDIUM TO SMALLER SIDE BUT THEY ARE DOING
10:31 A LOT OF THEM, TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF THESE CLIPS TO FILL
10:35 THEIR PIPELINE WITH LOTS OF POTENTIAL MEDICINES AND THEY
10:37 ADMIT SOME OF THESE MIGHT NOT WORK, BUT THEY ARE IN A POSITION
10:40 WHERE THEY ARE ABLE TO TAKE THOSE RISKS.
10:45 DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING.
10:51 COMING UP, MORE DEALMAKING AND GOLDMAN SACHS ASSET MANAGER IS
10:54 GOING TO BE JOINING THE SHOW AFTER A SERIES OF HIS OWN DEALS.
11:12 ♪ DANI: THE APPETITE FOR M&A HAS
11:14 BEEN STRONG AT GOLDMAN SACHS ASSET AND WEALTH MANAGEMENT.
11:19 IN AUGUST, IT REQUIRED EUROS FOR 2.25 BILLION DOLLARS.
11:26 ACCORDING TO REPORTS, IT IS IN TALK TO ACQUIRE PALMER SQUARE,
11:29 OR AT LEAST LOOKING AT IT. WE ARE JOINED BY MARC NACHMANN,
11:35 WHO SERVES ON GOLDMAN'S MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE AND
11:38 FIRMWIDE RISK COUNSEL. MARC, THANK YOU FOR JOINING.
11:43 MARC: THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME. DANI: WHAT A PACE OF DEALMAKING
11:46 YOU HAVE BEEN ON. IT IS A DIFFERENT SHIFT, A
11:49 DIFFERENT PACE. IT FEELS LIKE SOMETHING IS
11:52 TURNED THE CORNER. WHAT HAS CHANGED IN THE
11:57 ENVIRONMENT THAT HAS MADE THESE ACQUISITIONS ATTRACTIVE TO
11:58 YOU? MARC: SURE.
12:04 LET ME START BY SAYING THAT OUR ORGANIC STRATEGY IS THE KEY
12:05 UNDERLYING GROWTH STRATEGY. WE HAVE DONE QUITE WELL THERE.
12:10 WE HAVE SET MORE TARGETS THIS YEAR WE INCREASED THE NUMBER OF
12:13 TARGETS AND DONE QUITE WELL AGAINST THEM.
12:18 WE'RE SHOWING MANAGEMENT FEE GROWTH IN THE DOUBLE DIGITS
12:21 AGAINST OUR HIGH SINGLE-DIGIT TARGET.
12:25 WE CONTINUE TO IMPROVE MARGINALLY AND SHOW VERY STRONG
12:29 FUNDRAISING, BOTH ON THE ALTERNATIVE SITE AS WELL AS THE
12:32 TRADITIONAL SIDE, QUITE IN CONTRAST TO A NUMBER OF OUR
12:33 COMPETITORS. WE FEEL REALLY GOOD ABOUT THE
12:37 MOMENTUM WE HAVE IN THE ORGANIC STRATEGY.
12:43 TO COMPLEMENT THAT, WE HAVE STARTED TO LOOK AT ACQUISITIONS.
12:45 BAR HAS BEEN VERY HIGH. I THINK THE KEY ON THESE
12:51 ACQUISITIONS REALLY ACCELERATING OUR GROWTH PLATFORM, ADDING TO
12:55 OUR LINEUP. BUT THEN ALSO A BIG EMPHASIS ON
13:00 INTEGRATION, ABILITY TO INTEGRATE, MAKING SURE THAT IS
13:04 GOING TO BE SUCCESSFUL. WE SPEND A LOT OF TIME IN THE
13:10 TO DO THIS. THAT'S BEEN A BIG PART OF IT.
13:16 SO FAR WE ARE EXCITED ABOUT THE TWO ACQUISITIONS WE CLOSED, TWO
13:19 MORE TO COME. HOPEFULLY STILL THIS YEAR.
13:24 WE'RE EXCITED ABOUT THE RESULTS SO FAR.
13:26 DANI: I GUESS WHY NOW? WHY NOW WHEN THINGS ARE HUMMING
13:29 ALONG WITH ORGANIC GROWTH? MARC: I THINK THEY ARE HUMMING
13:34 ALONG IN THE ORGANIC STRATEGY GIVES US A LOT OF GROWTH.
13:37 WE CAN ACCELERATE IN A COUPLE AREAS.
13:41 THESE ARE SPECIFIC ACQUISITIONS THAT FILL SPECIFIC HOLES WE
13:44 HAVE. WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE FIRST ONE
13:48 WE ANNOUNCED, A BUSINESS THAT FOCUSES ON SECONDARIES IN THE VC
13:54 BUSINESS, WE ARE VERY BIG SECONDARY PLAYER, SECONDARY
13:58 PRIVATE EQUITY BUYOUT, REAL ESTATE, CREDIT.
14:02 WE SEE ONE SPACE WHERE WE WERE NOT AS HEAVILY INVOLVED, WE'VE
14:06 KNOWN THE INDUSTRY GUYS A LONG TIME.
14:09 WE OWNED A STAKE IN INDUSTRY VENTURE IN OUR STAKES BUSINESS,
14:14 WHICH IS A DIFFERENT FUND. THAT BUSINESS FIT IN WELL.
14:18 THEY HAVE A TREMENDOUS TRACK RECORD FOR A LONG PERIOD OF
14:21 TIME. THEY ARE NOW ON FUND 11.
14:26 ALSO WHAT TEAM THAT WE REALLY KNEW.
14:28 WE KNEW THE LEADERSHIP. WE FELT REALLY COMFORTABLE THAT
14:33 THEY WOULD BE GREAT AS PART OF GOLDMAN SACHS.
14:37 I THINK THEY HAVE BEEN WITH US SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.
14:40 SUPER EXCITED ABOUT THE INTEGRATION BORNE FRUIT.
14:44 ANOTHER ACQUISITION WE HAVE CLOSED IS INNOVATOR IN THE ETF
14:47 SPACE. IN THE DEFINED OUTCOME ETF
14:50 SPACE, THEY HAVE CREATED THAT SPACE.
14:53 REALLY INTERESTING SPACE WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT MARKET
14:54 ENVIRONMENT. THEY HAVE BUFFER PRODUCTS AND
15:02 PRODUCTS THAT PROTECT YOU CAN GIVE YOU UPSIDE OPPORTUNITY.
15:06 WE ANNOUNCED THE ACQUISITION ABOUT A YEAR AGO.
15:09 THEY WERE $28 BILLION OF ASSETS. THEY ARE NOW $38 BILLION, SO
15:15 THEY HAVE GROWN QUITE A LOT TOGETHER WITH US.
15:19 ETF WAS AN AREA WE WANTED TO GROW MORE IN PIT ACTIVE ETF'S
15:25 ARE A FAST-GROWING PART OF THE ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS.
15:28 THE ACQUISITIONS WE HAVE ANNOUNCED IN THE ETF SPACE, WE
15:33 ARE A TOP 8 PLAYER BY ASSETS -- DANI: SO YOU HAVE ETF AND
15:35 PRIVATE MARKETS. PRIVATE MARKETS IS SOMETHING
15:39 DAVID SOLOMON HAS TALKED ABOUT. ARE THERE ANY GAPS
15:43 THERE? MARC: I THINK WE CONTINUOUSLY
15:45 LOOK. WE ANNOUNCED, AS YOU MENTIONED
15:53 EARLIER, LCN, BASICALLY A REAL-ESTATE CREDIT PRODUCT WE
15:55 ARE EXCITED. IT FILLS A GAP WE DON'T HAVE.
15:59 IT IS REALLY INTERESTING. THEY HELP CORPORATES TAKE ASSETS
16:04 OFF THE BALANCE SHEET. YOU THINK ABOUT OUR POSITIONS
16:09 WITH CORPORATE. I SAW THE M&A TABLES --
16:13 DANI: [LAUGHTER] YOU PROBABLY DON'T MIND SEEING
16:15 THAT. MARC: WE CAN HELP CORPORATE ON
16:19 BALANCE SHEET -- DANI: I WOULD ASSUME THAT AS YOU
16:28 ARE DOING IS, A LOT OF PEOPLE TALK ABOUT STRESS ON THE SMALLER
16:30 FUND FOR ALTERNATIVE MENTORS. IF PEOPLE SAY, MARC, WE SEE
16:35 BUYING A FEW THINGS, WOULD YOU TAKE A LOOK AT US?
16:41 MARC: WE DEFINITELY GET CALLS, SOME GOOD CALLS AND SOME NOT SO
16:42 GOOD CALLS. WE SPENT A LOT OF TIME WITH
16:49 THESE COMPANIES TOGETHER TO SEE IF IT MAKES SENSE.
16:55 I MET BRUCE BOND, WHO FOUNDED INNOVATOR A YEAR BEFORE.
16:59 ALMOST A YEAR BEFORE WE ANNOUNCE THE TRANSACTION.
17:02 THESE THINGS TAKE A LONG TIME BECAUSE WE REALLY WANT TO MAKE
17:05 SURE WE CAN INTEGRATE THEM WELL AND IT FITS WELL.
17:08 DANI: SPEAKING OF ALL THE PHOTOS YOU MAY OR MAY NOT BE GETTING, I
17:11 HAD A CONVERSATION WITH IAN CHARLES, WHO HE HIMSELF SOLD TO
17:18 KKR. HE SAID THERE'S A PROBLEM WITH A
17:20 LOT OF FUNDS, THAT THEY ARE ZOMBIE FUNDS, THAT THEY ARE
17:23 SITTING ON ACID AND HAVING A HARD TIME FUNDRAISING.
17:27 I'M WONDERING HOW ACUTE YOU SEE THAT PROBLEM IN CAPITAL.
17:31 MARC: THIS IS, PEOPLE TALK ABOUT -- LISTEN, PEOPLE TALK ABOUT
17:36 THERE'S A WHOLE BUNCH OF FUND THAT ARE THE LAST FUNDS, THEY
17:40 MAY OR MAY NOT KNOW IT YET. AN EXAMPLE, WE OWN A STAKE IN
17:46 ARCTOS AS WELL IN OUR GPS TAKE BUSINESS.
17:49 WE ARE EXCITED WITH KKR PURCHASING THAT STAKE.
17:53 THERE IS DEFINITELY A NUMBER OF FIRMS WHO ARE STUCK WITH THEIR
17:55 PORTFOLIOS. THOSE ARE REALLY NOT THE TARGETS
17:58 WE LOOK AT. WE LOOK AT COMPANIES THAT HAVE
18:04 GREAT INVESTMENT PERFORMANCE, A AND WHERE THE COMBINATIONN
18:09 ALLOWS US TO SCALE THEM MORE AND ADD THEM INTO OUR SYSTEM.
18:12 DANI: THE SORT OF TRANSACTIONS THAT ARE HAPPENING RIGHT NOW, I
18:19 WONDER WHAT IT WOULD TAKE TO KINDA BRING THE REST OF THE
18:20 INDUSTRY WITH IT. DO YOU THINK THERE NEEDS TO BE
18:23 SOME SORT OF CAPITULATION? DOES THE MACROENVIRONMENT NEED
18:26 TO CHANGE? WHAT ON GLUES THE REST OF
18:28 THINGS? MARC: I THINK SOME OF THESE
18:31 FIRMS ARE GOING TO BE ON THE LAST FUND.
18:36 ONE OTHER THINGS I DEFINITELY SEE IS THERE IS GOING TO BE MORE
18:38 AND MORE CONSOLIDATION IN THE ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS.
18:41 BUT I THINK IT IS NOT NECESSARILY CONSOLIDATION FROM
18:42 AN M&A PERSPECTIVE. IT IS CONSOLIDATION FROM A
18:47 CLIENT PERSPECTIVE. IF YOU LIKE AT LARGE ALLOCATORS
18:52 OF CAPITAL, THEY WANT TO REDUCE THE NUMBER OF RELATIONSHIPS THEY
18:56 HAVE, THE NUMBER OF ASSET MANAGERS THEY ARE TALKING TO,
19:00 MORE WEATHER CONCENTRATED GROUP OF ASSET MANAGERS.
19:03 THAT IS THE DIRECTION OF TRAVEL ON THE INDUSTRY, AND THAT IS
19:07 GOING TO FORCE CONSOLIDATION. YOU THINK OF THE ASSET
19:14 MANAGEMENT SPACE, WE SHOWED 40% MARKET SHARE FROM GOLDMAN SACHS.
19:16 YOU LOOK AT THE ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS, EVERYBODY HAS A TINY
19:22 MARKET SHARE COMPARED TO THE OVERALL SIZE OF THE BUSINESS.
19:26 PRETTY UNUSUAL IN THE FINANCIAL WORLD.
19:30 DANI: IS THIS YOU TELLING ME YOUR TARGETS ALSO GET A 40%
19:32 MARKET SHARE? [LAUGHTER]
19:38 POSITION MY PARTNERS IN THE M&A BUSINESS HAVE, BUT WE HAVE MORE
19:40 TO DO THERE. DANI: QUICKLY BEFORE YOU GO, WE
19:46 ARE SORTING THROUGH NVIDIA EARNINGS.
19:49 WHEN YOU HAVE A COMPANY THINK IT WILL BE MORE SCRUTINIZING IN
19:53 TERMS OF THE ECOSYSTEM, DO YOU THINK THAT MIGHT SLOW DOWN AI
19:54 DEALS IN THE INDUSTRY IF YOU HAVE NVIDIA PULLING BACK
19:56 SLIGHTLY? MARC: WE WILL HAVE TO SEE WHAT
19:59 EXACTLY HAPPENS. THERE IS A LOT OF QUESTIONS
20:04 AROUND FINANCING AROUND THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE SLIDE.
20:06 MARKETS IN GENERAL ARE CONSTRUCTIVE.
20:12 WE SEE IN THE PUBLIC SITE AND PRIVATE SIDE, WE HAVE BEEN
20:15 PARTICIPATING IN BOTH. THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS ABOUT
20:18 OUR PLATFORM. WE DO PUBLIC-PRIVATE.
20:22 OUR COLLEAGUES ON THE BANKING SIDE ARE INVOLVED IN THIS.
20:27 WE SEE THE MARKET'S PRETTY CONSTRUCTIVE FOR WELL-
20:30 STRUCTURE DEALS. I FEEL GOOD ABOUT THE ABILITY TO
20:34 FUND THE INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDOUT.
20:37 I THINK IT WILL CONTINUE TO BE A BIG GROWTH DRIVER.
20:39 DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING.
20:43 MARC NACHMANN, GLOBAL HEAD OF ASSET AND WEALTH MANAGEMENT AT
20:44 GOLDMAN SACHS. ANTHROPIC'S COULD PUSH DEBUT
20:50 VOLUME TO A NEW RECORD. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG DEALS."
21:05 ♪ DANI: THE SPOTLIGHT ON AI NOT
21:07 JUST IN EQUITY MARKETS. IN LONDON, CARLYLE'S MARC
21:12 JENKINS WAS ASKED IF INVESTORS ARE PRICING IN RISK AMID THE
21:17 INSATIABLE AI DEMAND. >> WE HAVE SEEN IT WIDER OVER
21:22 THE PAST THREE TO SIX MONTHS. IF YOU ARE AN INVESTOR LOOKING
21:25 TO INVEST IN THESE AI DATA CENTERS, THERE'S NO HURRY.
21:33 THERE IS PLENTY OF SUPPLY COMING.
21:35 THE BACKLOG IS HUGE. YOU HAVE THE ABILITY TO PICK AND
21:37 CHOOSE. USUALLY WHEN YOU ARE INVESTING
21:43 IN NEW ISSUES, USUALLY IT IS THE EARLIEST ONES THAT PAY THE
21:46 PREMIUM. IT'S CLEAR THAT THE LATTER ONES
21:51 ARE GOING TO PAY THE PREMIUM. THINGS HAVE CHANGED.
21:55 PEOPLE ARE TALKING MORE ABOUT THINGS WE TALK ABOUT IT CARLYLE,
21:58 CONCENTRATION RISK. TWO, WE JUST HAD THE MIDTERM
22:02 ELECTIONS IN THE UNITED STATES, AND THERE IS SIGNIFICANT
22:05 ATTITUDINAL CHANGE AROUND HOW PEOPLE ARE THINKING ABOUT HAVING
22:07 DATA CENTERS IN THEIR STATE, AND THEIR COMMUNITIES.
22:11 THAT SHIFT IS CHANGING AS WELL, SUCH THAT IT USED TO BE YOU
22:14 COULD SAY I'M GOING TO BUILD A DATA CENTER, GIVE ME SOME TECH
22:18 SPECS, GIVE ME SOME INCENTIVES--TAX BREAKS, GIVE ME
22:20 SOME INCENTIVES. THE COMMUNITY IS SAYING, YOU'RE
22:24 GOING TO BUILD ONE HERE, WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO FOR MY
22:27 COMMUNITY, WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO FOR THIS INFRASTRUCTURE?
22:29 IF YOU ARE A WELL-CAPITALIZED HYPERSCALER, YOU CAN AFFORD
22:31 THAT. BUT IF YOU ARE A SPEC BUILDER OF
22:36 THE DATA CENTER, IS GOING TO BE HARD BECAUSE THE ABILITY JUST TO
22:40 GET A CONTRACT IS GOING TO BE MUCH MORE CHALLENGING THAN WAS A
22:41 YEAR AGO. DANI: MARK JENKINS.
22:46 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
22:57 DANI: WELCOME BACK TO BLOOMBERG DEALS.
23:00 ANTHROPIC IS PRICING ITS IPO AFTER THE U.S. MARKET CLOSES
23:02 TODAY. AHEAD OF THAT, SCARLET FU IS
23:05 LOOKING AT WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LONG-AWAITED LISTING.
23:09 DANI: ANTHROPIC IS SLATED TO BECOME THE BIGGEST IPO OF ALL
23:12 TIME. STRONG INVESTOR DEMAND FOR
23:17 ANTHROPIC'S OFFERING WILL ALLOW THEM TO PRICE THEIR SHARES AT
23:19 THE HIGH-END OF THE RANGE OR EVEN ABOVE.
23:28 BANKERS TELL US THE IPO IS CLOSE TO SEVEN TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED,
23:31 SO AT THE TOP END OF THE MARKET AND INCLUDING A SEPARATE 26
23:34 BILLION DOLLAR PRIVATE PLACEMENT, ANTHROPIC WOULD
23:40 RAISED $90.4 BILLION, TOPPING THE SPACEX BASE DEAL.
23:43 IT WOULD ALSO GIVE ANTHROPIC A FULLY DILUTED VALUATION OF ABOUT
23:45 $1.4 TRILLION. IN OCTOBER THERE WAS TALK OF A
23:53 $2 TRILLION VALUATION BUT THE POSTELECTION SELLOFF -- IT WOULD
23:59 PUSH VOLUME TO A RECORD. DANI: LET'S TALK MORE ABOUT HOW
24:09 INVESTORS ARE APPROACHING AI AND THE HIGHLY ANTICIPATED ANTHROPIC
24:11 IPO. I AM JOINED NOW BY -- GENERAL
24:15 PARTNER AT BATTERY VENTURES. THEY RAISED $3.25 BILLION
24:22 EARLIER THIS YEAR. YOU ARE NOT IN ANTHROPIC, SO
24:26 THERE IS NO CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
24:27 THIS IS A COMPANY REPORTEDLY PRICING AT THE TOP END OF ITS
24:30 RANGE, IF NOT EXCEEDING THAT. IT'S BEEN WEEKS OF NONSTOP
24:36 VOLATILITY AROUND THE AI THEME. WHAT DOES THAT DEMAND TELL YOU
24:40 ABOUT AI AT THIS MOMENT, AND COMPANIES LIKE ANTHROPIC?
24:45 >> WHAT THIS EXCITEMENT TELLS YOU IS THE DEMAND FOR AI IS
24:48 REAL. THE MARKET IS REAL AND THE
24:54 REVENUE FIGURES ANTHROPIC IS FORECASTING SEEMS TO BE FAIRLY
24:56 PRICED. SO THERE IS A TON OF DEMAND FOR
25:09 THIS MARKET OPPORTUNITY AND ANTHROPIC IS AT THE LEADING EDGE
25:10 OF IT. DANI: WE'VE SEEN VOLATILITY IN
25:14 THE LEAD UP TO THIS. YES, DEMAND, PEOPLE WANT TO BE
25:27 PART OF THIS, BUT ARE SOME OF THE NERVES WARRANTED?
25:33 >> IT'S BEEN VERY VOLATILE WITH EVERYTHING GOING ON WITH NVIDIA.
25:38 THE FUNDRAISING NEEDS TO LIVE UP TO THE PROMISE OF AI.
25:41 MORE IMPORTANT IS THE CAPITAL THEY RAISE.
25:44 IN THIS ENVIRONMENT, WHERE ANTHROPIC COULD RAISE $90
25:48 BILLION PLUS, THAT WOULD MAKE THEM ONE OF THE MOST CASH RICH
25:53 AI INFRASTRUCTURE COMPANIES, MUCH MORE SO THAN META, GOOGLE
25:59 OR AMAZON. THAT CAPITAL GIVES YOU THE
26:03 OPPORTUNITY TO LOCK UP CAPACITY AND TAKE CARE OF YOUR
26:07 SUPPLY-SIDE. IF THEY CAN RAISE THIS CAPITAL
26:18 REGARDLESS OF THE VALUATION, THAT PUTS THEM IN A REALLY GOOD
26:23 PLACE TO DELIVER ON THEIR RATE NEXT YEAR.
26:27 I THINK THAT IS FAR MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE NEAR TERM
26:28 VALUATIONS. DANI: DOES THAT UNDERSCORE THAT
26:34 OPENAI NEEDS TO GO PUBLIC, THAT THAT SOURCE OF CAPITAL IS GOING
26:37 TO BE INCREASINGLY IMPORTANT FOR THESE LLM'S?
26:41 >> ABSOLUTELY. IF YOU LOOK AT THE CAPITAL
26:46 NEEDS, YOU HAVE HYPERSCALERS, U.S. TREASURIES RAISING CAPITAL
26:50 AND ANTHROPIC AND OPENAI WILL NEED TO BUILD OUT
26:52 INFRASTRUCTURE. IN PRIVATE MARKETS, OPENAI HAS
26:58 EXHAUSTED MUCH OF THEIR CHANNELS.
27:02 THEY WILL NEED TO LOOK FOR AN AVENUE TO GO PUBLIC AND ALSO
27:03 RAISE CAPITAL. THE MARKET WOULD BENEFIT FROM
27:08 COMPETITION BETWEEN OPENAI, ANTHROPIC AND GOOGLE, AS PUBLIC
27:11 PROVIDERS. DANI: A LOT OF THEM ARE SWIMMING
27:16 IN THIS SAME POOL. IT IS THIS CONCERN ABOUT
27:19 CIRCULAR FINANCING THAT WILL CONTINUE TO BE A QUESTION WITH
27:22 EVERY EARNINGS REPORT ANTHROPIC ANNOUNCES, WHETHER IT BE A $35
27:27 BILLION SHIPPED DEAL ANTHROPIC DEAL WITH GOOGLE, OR AI
27:31 FINANCING WITH BROADCOM. AT WHAT POINT DOES VENDOR
27:36 FINANCING BECOME SOMETHING THAT IS NOT JUST A STRUCTURAL REALITY
27:38 BUT SOMETHING THAT IS ALSO A RISK FOR MANY OF THESE PLAYERS?
27:46 >> THAT IS INDEED THE BIGGEST RISKS AF -- ANTHROPIC HAS TO
27:47 TACKLE. THERE REVENUE IS 20% COMMITTED
27:57 BUT ON THE OTHER HAND, CONTRACT COMMITMENTS TO INFRASTRUCTURE
28:00 VENDORS, ALMOST 900 BILLION DOLLARS ARE SET IN STONE.
28:05 MAKING THE MISMATCH ADJUSTMENT, YOU WANT TO HAVE THE REVENUE TO
28:08 MAKE UP FOR YOUR COMMITTED OBLIGATIONS AND IT IS IMPORTANT
28:10 FOR THEM TO HANDLE. ON THE OTHER HAND, THE RISKS ARE
28:15 SOMEWHAT OVERBLOWN. A LOT OF COMMENTATORS LOOK AT
28:23 THIS AND SAY THE DOTCOM ERA BROUGHT DOWN THE TECHNOLOGY
28:25 WAVE. THIS TIME IS DIFFERENT IN THAT
28:28 THE DEMAND FOR AI IS REAL. DEVELOPERS AREN'T GOING BACK TO
28:35 WRITING CODE BY HAND. THE DEMAND IS REAL, THE NEED FOR
28:47 CAPITAL SHOWS YOU THAT THE DEMAND IS REAL AND JUSTIFIES THE
28:51 FINANCING NEEDS OF THIS BUSINESS.
28:58 VENDORS HAVE STEPPED IN, BUT WITH JENSEN STEPPING DOWN, I
29:02 THINK NVIDIA IS GOING TO BE MORE CAUTIOUS ABOUT THE CIRCULAR
29:06 FINANCING AND I THINK ANTHROPIC AND OPENAI ARE AT ESCAPE
29:08 VELOCITY WHERE THEY CAN COURT OTHER SOURCES OF CAPITAL TO
29:09 SUSTAIN THEIR GROWTH. DANI: WHO IS VULNERABLE WITH
29:15 NVIDIA STEPPING BACK? >> THE MOST VULNERABLE COMPANIES
29:21 ARE THE NEW ONES THAT NEED TO TRAIN -- NEED TO RAISE BILLIONS
29:23 OF DOLLARS TO TRAIN THEIR MODELS.
29:26 I THINK THE SECOND SET OF COMPETITORS -- COMPANIES, EARLY
29:31 STAGE INFRASTRUCTURE COMPANIES THAT NEED TO RAISE HUNDREDS OF
29:36 MILLIONS. I FEEL LIKE THOSE RESELLERS AND
29:43 -- ARE THE ONES THAT ARE MOST EXPOSED WITH NVIDIA PULLING
29:44 BACK. ON THE OTHER HAND, AT SCALE
29:49 COMPANIES LIKE OPENAI, ANTHROPIC OR GOOGLE HAVE REAL DEMAND AND
29:55 ALTERNATE WAYS TO FINANCE THEIR GROWTH FROM HERE.
30:01 DANI: BACK TO THIS IPO FROM ANTHROPIC, IT IS A LONG LIST OF
30:04 SOME OF YOUR PEERS THAT HAVE PARTICIPATED IN FUNDING ROUNDS,
30:07 SOME VERY EARLY ON. MANY, LATER ON IN DIFFERENT
30:10 STAGES. WHAT DOES IT DO TO THE ENTIRETY
30:16 OF THE LANDSCAPE, TO HAVE THIS EVENT WHERE WE HAVE A LOT OF
30:23 FUNDS FLUSH WITH CASH, SHOULD THEY CHOOSE TO EXIT?
30:29 >> CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL OF MY FRIENDS AND COLLEAGUES AT
30:32 SEVERAL FIRMS THAT HAVE INVESTED IN THE COMPANY.
30:38 I THINK GENERATING BPI, OUR INVESTORS ARE WAITING FOR THAT
30:39 TO SHOW UP, AND ANTHROPIC LIQUIDITY ALONGSIDE SPACEX,
30:47 OPENAI IN THE QUARTERS TO COME, IT IS A REALLY GOOD THING FOR
30:53 OUR INVESTORS AND THE ECOSYSTEM AS THEY SHOW THAT THIS AI
30:56 INVESTMENT TREND IS REAL AND THAT ENCOURAGES US TO INVEST IN
30:58 OTHER COMPANIES THAT COULD CONTINUE.
31:04 ON THE OTHER HAND, THE CONCENTRATION OF COMPANIES THAT
31:08 -- RESEMBLES WHAT YOU'VE SEEN IN PUBLIC MARKETS.
31:13 THE MAGNIFICENT 7 HAVE GENERATED MOST OF THEIR RETURNS ON THE
31:17 SIDELINES. THE PRIVATE INDUSTRY, IT FEELS
31:25 LIKE 2250 COMPANIES IN THE VALUE CREATION RAGE WHILE THERE MIGHT
31:27 BE ANOTHER 20 OR 50,000 COMPANIES THAT -- BEING INVOLVED
31:34 IN THOSE COMPANIES, EVEN AT A LATER STAGE IS VERY IMPORTANT TO
31:39 GENERATE RETURNS AND THE CONCENTRATION ISN'T GREAT BUT
31:41 THE RETURN IT MAKES IS GOOD FOR THE ECOSYSTEM.
31:46 DANI: IS THERE A RULE OF THUMB, OF HOW LONG WE EXPECT A LOT OF
31:51 THE VC UNIVERSE TO CONTINUE TO PARTICIPATE IN ANTHROPIC, TO
31:52 HOLD ONTO SHARES? DO YOU EXPECT THERE TO BE
31:58 VARIOUS LIQUIDITY EVENTS OR IS IT SUCH A WINTER THAT PEOPLE
32:00 WANT TO KEEP IT IN THEIR PORTFOLIO AS A PUBLIC COMPANY?
32:07 >> THAT DEPENDS A LOT ON WHAT ANTHROPIC DOES TWO OR THREE
32:08 QUARTERS FROM NOW. THE VALUATION IS JUSTIFIED BASED
32:12 ON THE REPORTING BUSINESS. AND THAT SHOWS ANTHROPIC GOING
32:18 FROM ROUGHLY $52 BILLION THIS YEAR -- AS WE GET MORE CLARITY,
32:30 WE WANT -- AND ANTHROPIC PICKED -- CYBER SECURITY AND
32:32 AUTOMATION? AS WE GET MORE CLARITY ON THOSE
32:37 ADDITIONAL MARKETS, THAT WILL DICTATE WHETHER INVESTORS
32:40 BELIEVE THIS IS A $2 TRILLION COMPANY AND THAT WILL DRIVE THE
32:47 HOLD PERIODS. DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
32:51 JOINING US. GENERAL PARTNER AT BATTERY
32:53 VENTURES. UP NEXT, THE VALUE OF GLOBAL
32:59 IPO'S HAS SURGED NEARLY 150% YEAR TO DATE.
33:07 CITI HAS CLIMBED TO THE TOP OF UNDERWRITERS.
33:14 VIS RAGHAVAN WILL BE JOINING US. THE NASDAQ 100 HITTING A SESSION
33:19 HIGH. OIL PRICES FALLING AROUND 4%
33:25 LOWER, ALLOWING FOR SOME OF THE MOVES IN THE EQUITY MARKET.
33:27 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
33:37 DANI: YOU ARE WATCHING "BLOOMBERG DEALS."
33:39 I AM DANI BURGER. ONE OF THE KEY BANKS BEHIND THE
33:44 ANTHROPIC IPO IS CITI. CITI CURRENTLY IN POLE POSITION
33:50 AS THE TOP UNDERWRITER OF GLOBAL IPOS THIS YEAR.
33:53 WE ARE JOINED BY THE HEAD OF BANKING AND EXECUTIVE VICE CHAIR
33:59 AT CITI. SO GREAT TO SEE YOU.
34:01 ALL THE DEALS YOU HAVE TRANSACTED ON, IT IS A WHO'S WHO
34:05 OF THE BIGGEST -- PARAMOUNT, BROADCOM, SPACEX, ANTHROPIC.
34:10 WHAT DOES IT TAKE TO GET THE TEAM READY TO WIN AND EXECUTE ON
34:13 SUCH LARGE TRANSACTIONS? >> HI, DANI THANKS FOR HAVING ME
34:18 ON THE PROGRAM. WHAT YOU NEED HIS INCREDIBLE
34:21 TALENT. TALENT IS THE KEY TO GET THE
34:27 RHYTHM GOING, TO BE ON THESE LANDMARK DEALS.
34:32 A LOT OF GOOD CONTENT, AND ABOVE ALL, INTENSITY.
34:35 WE HAVE A GAME PLAN AND WE HAVE BEEN EXECUTING SYSTEMATICALLY
34:37 FOR A FEW YEARS NOW. WHAT YOU ARE SEEING IS THE
34:42 RESULT OF THE SYSTEMATIC EXECUTION.
34:44 A LOT MORE TO COME. DANI: MAYBE A BIG ONE THIS WEEK
34:47 AS WELL. CITI IS AT THE TOP OF THE LEAGUE
34:56 TABLE, FOR THE ANTHROPICS, SPACEX'S, WHAT HAVE YOU, HOW
35:01 IMPORTANT ARE THEY FOR SETTING THE TONE DOWN THE STACK? GOING
35:06 MARKET? VIS: LOOK, ANTHROPIC, I CAN'T
35:12 COMMENT ON THE DEAL PARTICULARLY BECAUSE WE ARE INVOLVED.
35:15 SOMETHING LIKE ANTHROPIC IS GOING TO BE A BELLWETHER, GIVEN
35:19 THE CURRENT SENTIMENT AROUND AI AND SOME OF THE CURRENCY YOU
35:23 HAVE SEEN. A LOT OF FOLKS ARE WAITING FOR
35:27 THIS TRANSACTION TO HAPPEN, 42 TRADE WEALTH WASN'T IT IS GOING
35:31 TO BE A BELLWETHER. MORE IMPORTANTLY, IT REALLY
35:39 DIVERSIFIES COMPANIES' ABILITY TO ACCESS EVERY POOL OF CAPITAL,
35:43 EVERY POOL OF LIQUIDITY, GIVEN THE ENORMITY OF THE FINANCING
35:47 NEEDS THE SECTOR IS GOING TO TAKE.
35:51 ALL EYES ARE ON ANTHROPIC, BUT THAT IS WHEN TO BE A GREAT
35:53 BELLWETHER FOR THINGS TO COME. DANI: IT IS INTERESTING, YOU
35:59 MENTIONED THIS IDEA THAT IT GETS TO A POINT WHERE FINANCING NEEDS
36:00 GETS A GRADE THAT YOU NEED TO BE PUBLIC.
36:03 THERE HAS BEEN THIS NARRATIVE THAT COMPANIES CAN STAY PRIVATE
36:08 FOR LONGER BECAUSE PRIVATE CAPITAL EXISTS.
36:12 I WONDER IF SOMETHING HAS CHANGED AND THAT MEANS MORE
36:14 COMPANIES NEED TO GO PUBLIC, OR THIS IS AN AI, LLM, IT IS
36:20 CAPITAL-INTENSIVE, AND THE REST OF THE UNIVERSE CAN STATE
36:22 PRIVATE FOR LONGER. VIS: IT IS GENERAL, BUT
36:26 PARTICULARLY TRUE FOR AI. IF YOU LOOK AT THE ENORMITY OF
36:32 THE CAPITAL ASKS, THE ESTIMATES ARE $3.5 TRILLION UP TO 2030,
36:38 YOU NEED TO DIP INTO EVERY POOL OF LIQUIDITY.
36:41 WHETHER IT IS THE LOAN MARKET, PRIVATE CREDIT, SOVEREIGN WEALTH
36:44 FUNDS, YOU NAME IT. WHEN YOU ARE LOOKING TO FINANCE
36:50 THAT MAGNITUDE OF CAPITAL RAISE TO GET AND DELIVER ON YOUR
36:53 AMBITIONS, YOU REALLY NEED TO ACCESS EVERY POOL LIQUIDITY
36:56 THERE IS. WHAT YOU DESCRIBED IS
36:59 PARTICULARLY TRUE FOR THE AI BUILDOUT.
37:05 IT IS NOT TOO DISSIMILAR -- WE ARE SEEING IT IN THE M&A MARKET.
37:09 THIS YEAR HAS BEEN THE SECOND-BIGGEST M&A MARKET EVER.
37:14 NEWLY 4.5 TRILLION DOLLARS OF M&A DEAL VOLUME.
37:17 A LOT OF THAT NEEDS FINANCING, TOO.
37:21 WHAT YOU ARE SEEING IS A MASSIVE BUILDOUT IN AI.
37:24 YOU SEE MOUNTAINS OF GOVERNMENT DEBT WAITING TO BE REFINANCED.
37:29 SOMETIMES THE TWO ARE COMPETING FOR EACH OTHER--WITH EACH OTHER
37:33 FOR THE SAME OF LIQUIDITY. YOU HAVE A ROBUST M&A
37:35 ENVIRONMENT THAT NEEDS FINANCING.
37:38 YOU SEE IT COMING TOGETHER OF MASSIVE CAPITAL ASKS, WHICH
37:44 THERE IS. DANI: WHETHER IT IS AI,
37:51 PARAMOUNT GET, YOU SEE A LITTLE BIT OF PUSHBACK.
37:53 DO YOU THINK THIS MARKET CAN CONTINUE TO OBSERVE THE GREAT
37:54 FINANCING NEEDS? TO YOUR POINT, IT IS NOT JUST
37:58 PRIVATE COMPANIES. IT IS GOVERNMENTS AS WELL.
38:01 CAN IT CONTINUE TO ABSORB IT AT THE PACE IT HAS BEEN?
38:05 VIS: THERE IS ENOUGH LIQUIDITY OUT THERE TO FINANCE THESE
38:06 TRANSACTIONS. WHAT YOU ARE DEFINITELY SEEING
38:12 IS GREATER SELECTIVITY. THERE IS FLIGHT TO QUALITY,
38:18 FOLKS BEING MORE DISCERNING, IN THE BEST ISSUERS AND STRONGEST
38:22 NAMES HAVE ACCESS AND THEY CAN GET ANYTHING DONE.
38:25 THE MORE MARGINAL ONES, THERE IS A LOT MORE SCRUTINY, AND NOT ALL
38:30 OF THEM ARE GOING TO SEE THE FINISH LINE.
38:35 THAT SELECTIVITY IS HEALTHY, IT WAS ALWAYS MUCH-NEEDED.
38:37 THE LIQUIDITY, THERE IS ABUNDANCE, BUT IT IS INCREDIBLE
38:40 SELECTIVE -- DANI: IF I COULD JUMP IN
38:44 QUICKLY, BECAUSE ON THAT POINT, WHEN IT COMES TO SELECTIVITY,
38:49 ONE OF THE THINGS I'VE HEARD IS PEOPLE ARE BECOMING MORE
38:52 SELECTIVE AROUND AI. THIS IS A POINT CARLISLE MAKES,
38:56 YOU REACH CONCENTRATION LIMITS AND CANNOT KEEP ABSORBING IT.
39:00 IS THERE A GREAT RISK WITH THE FINANCING NEEDS THEY HAVE THAT
39:02 CONCENTRATION BECOMES A PROBLEM? HOW ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT CITI
39:06 'S OWN EXPOSURE? VIS: I WOULD SAY IT IS LESS
39:10 CONSIDERATION, IT IS BECOMING SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST.
39:14 THE NAMES THAT ARE GOING TO STRUGGLE A BIT MORE ARE THE
39:18 NEOCLOUDS, NEOLABS, AND THE LIKE.
39:20 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE NAMES THAT WILL COMFORTABLY GET DONE, THE
39:24 VERY LARGE PLAUYERS. LARGE CAPITALIZATIONS.
39:30 THEY HAVE ABUNDANT ACCESS TO THE EQUITY CAPITAL MARKETS.
39:38 CITI'S PLAYED A ROLE IN PRETTY MUCH EVERY ONE OF THOSE THIS
39:39 YEAR. LOOK AT ORACLE, BROADCOM, AND
39:42 THE LIKE. YOU SEE THE RECEPTION THAT THESE
39:47 LARGE NAMES GET AND HOW DEALS THAT COMFORTABLY OVER THE FINISH
39:48 LINE. THAT SELECTIVITY IS GOING TO
39:52 IMPAIR THE ABILITY OF SOME OF THE MORE MARGINAL PLAYERS,
39:58 SMALLER PLAYERS, BECAUSE THIS MARKET IS GETTING DISCERNING.
40:03 DANI: HEY, VIS, BEFORE YOU GO, $4.4 TRILLION TRACKING YOUR
40:05 TODAY OF GLOBAL M&A. WHAT IS YOUR BASE CASE FOR 2027?
40:12 VIS: I WOULD SAY LOOK, WHEN I LOOK AT THE PIPELINE, IS
40:15 INCREDIBLY ROBUST. FINANCIAL SPONSORS, CLOSE TO ONE
40:19 THIRD OF THE MARKET THIS YEAR. I WOULD ALMOST ARGUE THAT THAT
40:24 IS RETICENT. THEY STILL HAVE $2.5 TRILLION OF
40:27 DRY POWDER. SO I DO SEE -- I AM BULLISH ON
40:33 THE OUTLOOK FOR THE M&A MARKET. YOU DO HAVE HEADWINDS.
40:39 O WASN A-- ON A LIST OF HEADWINDS, GEOPOLITICS IS TOP OF
40:41 THE LIST. CLEARLY WHAT INFLATION AND THE
40:46 FINANCED. YOU ARE LOOKING AT MONEY AT 5%
40:51 OR THEREABOUTS. THE COST OF DEBT, COST OF
40:54 CAPITAL, IS A CONCERN. AND THEN CLEARLY, YOU HAVE --
40:59 FOLKS ARE LOOKING TO SEE WHERE ARE THE EFFICIENCY, ACTIVITY
41:02 BENEFITS OF AI. ALL OF THAT WILL PLAY OUT.
41:10 I AM POSITIVE MACRO HOLDUP AND POSITIVE FOR 2027.
41:14 DANI: PLEASE COME JOIN US AGAIN SOON.
41:17 THAT IS VIS RAGHAVAN OF CITI. U.S. HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY
41:20 MARKWAYNE MULLIN SPOKE TO A HOUSE PANEL ABOUT M&A AND HOW IT
41:25 MIGHT EXPOSE U.S. IP TO ADVERSARIAL NATIONS.
41:28 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
41:43 DANI: YOU ARE WATCHING "BLOOMBERG DEALS."
41:46 I AM DANI BURGER, ALONGSIDE SCULLY THROUGH.
41:51 HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN TOLD A HOUSE
41:52 PANEL THAT ADVERSARIAL NATIONSTATES CONTINUE TO SEEK
41:56 ACCESS TO U.S. TECHNOLOGY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY THROUGH
41:58 CORPORATE M&A. MIKE SHEPARD JOINS US WITH MORE.
42:03 DO WE KNOW THE DETAILS OF WHAT MR. MULLIN WAS TALKING ABOUT?
42:09 >> HE DIDN'T SPELL IT OUT SO MUCH IN HIS PREPARED TESTIMONY,
42:11 BUT THE TIMING IS REALLY INTERESTING, DANI.
42:17 PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP RIGHT NOW IS IN CHINA DURING THE
42:22 PRESIDENT'S LAST VISIT TO CHINA,, HE PROPOSED THIS IDEA OF
42:26 AN INVESTMENT BOARD THAT HE COULD USE AS A VEHICLE TO DROP
42:29 MORE INVESTMENT AND CAPITAL FROM THE WORLD'S SECOND-LARGEST
42:31 ECONOMY. BUT THAT REALLY RUNS AGAINST THE
42:34 DIRECTION OF TRAVEL. DANI, AS WE KNOW, WE HAVE SEEN
42:39 REGULATORS INCLUDING THE COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN INVESTMENT
42:44 IN THE U.S. REALLY START TO PUT UP ROADBLOCKS ON A LOT OF DEALS
42:46 THAT INVOLVE CHINESE VENTURES AND COMPANIES, CITING NATIONAL
42:51 SECURITY CONCERNS, EVERYTHING FROM THE RISK OF SHARING
42:55 SENSITIVE TECHNOLOGY, EXPOSING PERSONAL DATA, EVEN PROXIMITY TO
43:00 U.S. LITERARY BASES BEING CITED AS THE JUST--MILITARY BASES
43:03 BEING CITED AS THE JUSTIFICATION.
43:06 WE ARE SEEING THAT REFLECTED IN A STATEMENT AND SOMETHING THE
43:09 ADMINISTRATION HAS MADE PART OF HIS POSITION AND CODIFIED IN
43:10 LAW, TOO. DANI: SHEP, THAT THANK YOU VERY
43:13 MUCH. THE QUESTION IS IF MORE
43:16 REGULATION WILL COME FROM THIS. SCARLET: PROBABLY AFTER JANUARY.
43:19 THERE IS A LOT TO GET DONE BEFORE NOW AND THEN.
43:21 DANI: LAWYER UP, IN THE WORDS OF THE INCOMING HOUSE OVERSIGHT
43:23 COMMITTEE. THAT DOES IT FOR US.
43:28 THIS IS BLOOMBERG.
Nvidia Argues to Wary Investors That It Can Thrive Without Huang full transcript
0:00 So I think you have to separate the numbers from the vibe.
0:04 The numbers were off the charts in terms of demand, in terms of the guidance they
0:09 gave, and many thought they wouldn't even give guidance, raise guidance for
0:12 next year. And I think that speaks to the
0:14 robustness. On the call it, there's a feeling like
0:19 it's kind of like tight almost reading off cue cards.
0:23 And so many lawyers, so many people looking at this.
0:26 And the reality is like they know there's essentially an activist campaign
0:31 underway to try to get Gen Z back. And I think that adds to the tightness
0:37 that you saw in the call because of that dynamic.
0:40 All right. Let's go to the Jensen Wong, uh,
0:42 question here. What is the scenario a do you think will
0:45 come back? How could that happen?
0:48 Should he come back? How do you think about all that?
0:50 So we thought on Sunday, this is zero, but there's no way he's come.
0:54 The board couldn't bring him back. It's done.
0:57 We underestimated the level of activism and shareholder support that he has this
1:03 summer. Okay, they don't have a staggered board.
1:06 They don't have a supermajority building.
1:08 If they get 15% of shareholders, they could do a special shareholder meeting,
1:13 probably February, March. At that point, they would try to oust
1:17 the board and bring back Jensen. Now, the question would be the
1:21 investigations, especially in the congressional side, DC, that's front and
1:26 center. Because if it viewed that there was any
1:30 sort of, you know, issue relative to getting Blackwell through some shell
1:34 company and mega speed, then it's done. Jensen that would come back and then
1:37 there's a um, is a criminal piece. But Jensen's saying that he would be
1:43 willing. He wants to potentially come back as an
1:46 American. Many viewed that implicitly.
1:49 He's saying, right, I'm queer. I'm going to go to Congress and I'm
1:54 willing to come back. So the lively, the lovely Robin and Dana
1:59 is your Penn State. Did you meet in fin for 15?
2:03 Did you meet in financial advanced financial modeling?
2:06 Is that where the eyes are met? Yeah.
2:08 And she's an account. So we actually we actually didn't mean
2:11 in small business. We met in the small business school.
2:14 Okay. Folks are going there.
2:15 This is why you listen to Bloomberg surveillance.
2:18 Stay with me. Last night, Goldman Sachs wrote a note
2:22 long note with zero hedge, brilliantly summarized about the ballet of Nvidia
2:30 filling the data centers with Nvidia's stuff.
2:34 To me, the arch question is, after you do a financing, which Sweeney
2:40 understands and I don't, there's a residual value to the stuff in the data
2:46 center. Mrs.
2:48 ISE and Mr. Ives have no idea what that residual
2:52 value is or the when of it we don't know.
2:55 On the X-axis, the life of those Nvidia chips do we know.
3:01 And that look that continues to be a question.
3:03 Right. And when then it goes to quit talking
3:06 about like with the neo clouds and called the central bank of AI in terms
3:10 of Nvidia. And I hate the phrase because I don't I
3:12 don't want to phrase either, but, but but the point is, is that they're
3:16 they're not showing that they're going to have to continue to go down that path
3:20 because they've essentially built the city.
3:22 You can't. All of a sudden when the buildings are
3:25 half built, just stop. I don't know.
3:27 I mean, come on, Paul, you're a duke and you're in a meeting with Kim Harvey, and
3:31 you have no clue what the residual path is.
3:35 I just don't know how. I just don't know how you modeled this
3:37 stuff. I passed his class.
3:38 I got to pee. That's all you need to do to get out of
3:40 there? Um, and then, I mean, some folks are
3:43 saying, Jensen Wong. Okay, he's out.
3:47 He's gone. He's not part of the I story, but that's
3:49 okay, because we've got this other company coming out to the marketplace,
3:52 anthropic. And maybe they can assume the mantle of
3:56 kind of the linchpin for this AI story here.
3:59 Give us just your thoughts on anthropic. Presumably this IPO was scheduled to
4:02 price tonight. Begin trading tomorrow.
4:05 How should we think about anthropic. I mean, I think this roadshow and you
4:08 could hear from institutions across the board.
4:11 It is been massively successful. I think the way that they've done the
4:14 teachings, the way they've gotten investors really, really comfortable
4:18 with what this is going to look like over the coming years and the kind of
4:21 bottoms up, it's way, way oversubscribed.
4:25 We could be talking 1.7 to 2 trillion type valuation is this.
4:30 But it is very important as you talk about because it is foundational to the
4:35 eye trade. We could do everything on Nvidia.
4:37 But the reality is piece by piece, it's very important.
4:40 It goes public and it does weigh the path.
4:42 OpenAI to go public early next year. So how should we think about just
4:47 anthropic here in terms of the growth rates they're putting up for
4:52 just, you know, extraordinary, extraordinary.
4:55 Um, how are you modeling this thing here?
4:59 You have 3 to 4 trillion that's going to be spent in CapEx next 3 to 4 years.
5:04 And that Gen two not that doesn't change anthropic given what they're doing on
5:09 the enterprise. The view is like, when could they get to
5:13 five, six, 700 billion per year in revenue?
5:17 And that that continues to evolve. Mrs.
5:20 Ives took economics at Penn State. You didn't.
5:23 Okay, so price theory, microeconomics. They're not the same.
5:27 Nvidia's selling a unit with unit dynamics.
5:30 Technology dynamics improving. You know, the Blackwell and all of them.
5:35 Anthropic is in a hyper competitive business where the Bloomberg terminal is
5:39 telling me the silicon Lam index is going down, going down, going down.
5:45 They're going to make it up on unit dynamics.
5:48 Meanwhile worried about eight other ways to do AI.
5:52 They're not dissimilar risk. I mean the tank.
5:55 This is important in explaining to our audience how anthropic is a mystery to
6:01 where they're going to be in 36 months. Should we just go back to Nvidia?
6:05 Is the chips that fuel everything, regardless of your gender?
6:09 The oxygen Apple, regardless of how you do.
6:13 From a consumer perspective, you know the install base, you know.
6:16 So what is it? So when you think anthropic like that's
6:18 the frontier model. That's the model that so many of these
6:22 use cases ultimately that start to be created on.
6:26 the issue is going to that point. Those miles are going to get more and
6:30 more commoditized over time. And then through news, they need to
6:33 pivot to focus on the enterprise, the enterprise.
6:36 That's where ultimately you start to become competitors to some extent, with
6:41 not just software companies where software stocks got crossed yesterday,
6:45 Salesforce, ServiceNow, and I think it's one where it's set up for they need to
6:50 be successful on the enterprise for for this work.
6:53 45 seconds. How did these people there on Saturday
6:57 Night Live Satya Nadella not on Saturday Night Live.
7:01 How do they compete with Microsoft? Because on the enterprise, when you
7:06 think about companies that are going on a strategy path, they go to Azure and
7:11 then it comes down to like, do you sovereign?
7:14 I stay within the sort of ecosystem or you go or do you use a frontier model?
7:20 Do you either go with the Palantir and Nvidia, Microsoft, anthropic, OpenAI?
7:25 They um, to some extent go counter that in terms of the frontier model, in the
7:29 way that they're going after the enterprise.
Interest-Rates are 'Normal for Longer,' Not Higher, Says Ed Yardeni full transcript
0:00 In many ways, uh, there are similarities with the 1920s, but, uh, this one has
0:05 some unique characteristics. It was actually back in August of 2020
0:09 that I first started writing about the possibility that this would turn out to
0:13 be the roaring 2020s, and thus so far, we're seven years into it.
0:18 Three more years to go. So far, so good.
0:20 Uh, but it's, uh, it's been productivity driven for sure.
0:24 Uh, we've definitely seen an improvement in productivity.
0:27 The key aspect of, uh, the economy is its resilience.
0:31 It's been extraordinarily resilient. Uh, it's, uh, withstood all sorts of,
0:36 uh, shocks. Uh, we had the pandemic, we had the
0:39 lockdowns, we had the right supply chain disruptions and on and on.
0:43 And here we are with real GDP at an all time record high.
0:46 And no recession was the resilience, frankly, full disclosure word I can't
0:52 stand. But was the resilience propped up by
0:56 endless stimuli. That's
0:59 okay. Nailed this with gardening.
1:01 You got to do that. Was it any endless stimulus is that made
1:06 this happen? I think that's a big, big part of the
1:08 story for sure. Uh, I mean, we're running $2 trillion
1:13 federal deficits where the economy is doing quite well and doesn't need, uh,
1:17 stimulus from the fiscal side. But we're certainly getting that, uh,
1:22 the fed thought that, uh, interest rates at the beginning of the year were on the
1:26 restrictive side, but, uh, uh, now they've concluded that actually, they
1:31 haven't been restrictive enough. So there's, uh, monetary liquidity for
1:35 sure. And then, of course, the I build out,
1:39 it's been a huge stimulus to the economy.
1:42 But let's not forget that, uh, this would the economy wouldn't be resilient
1:46 without the consumer. They still account for over 70% of GDP.
1:51 And it's the resilience of the consumer. That's really been the surprise to a lot
1:55 of people, not to me, because I have inside information.
1:58 I'm a baby boomer and all my friends are retiring, and they've done pretty well
2:02 over the years. And, uh, they're taking cruises.
2:05 They're going out to restaurants, they're, uh, renovating their homes.
2:08 Uh, you know, a third of, uh, consumer households now are headed by somebody 65
2:14 years or older. We've never had a larger senior group of
2:18 people with so much money, and they keep spending it.
2:22 So let's let's not underestimate how resilient the consumer has been.
2:27 How about the, uh, the Federal Reserve here?
2:30 We're going to it looks like, you know, we've had one rate hike.
2:32 Looks like December is going to be another.
2:34 Uh, the market's pricing and maybe even a third for early next year.
2:38 Um, what does that mean for this economy here?
2:41 I mean, it seems like the GDP maybe can support higher.
2:43 Well, a lot of people have been, uh, talking about higher for longer interest
2:48 rates, uh, which which is an expression that kind of irks me, quite honestly.
2:53 Uh, instead of higher for lower interest rates, I view it as normal for longer
2:57 interest rates. We're back to normal.
2:58 Yeah. Uh, when you say higher for for longer,
3:01 it implies that we should be going down because we had been down and we had been
3:05 down in an abnormal fashion between the great financial crisis and the great
3:09 virus crisis. So I think interest rates are a huge
3:13 sign of confidence in the, uh, in the strength of the economy.
3:18 And I'm actually looking for the fed to go 50 basis points at the December
3:22 meeting because they passed on in October because of the elections.
3:27 Uh, so they they basically have to reverse the rate hikes of last year.
3:33 I gave three questions. The rate cuts I should say.
3:35 Yeah. The last one here on the moment.
3:37 I've got a couple other observations with Ed.
3:40 Uh, you're Danny and your Danny. To mere mortals who know they have India
3:45 Nvidia overweight and therefore, okay, should they be comfortable having Nvidia
3:52 overweight and therefore. Okay.
3:55 Well, you know, there's an expression. The, uh.
3:58 The king is dead. Long live the king.
4:00 Which was an expression of like, okay, one king is dead, but
4:05 life goes on and there's continuity and another king is now in charge.
4:09 Uh, I think we have seen that in the I trade.
4:11 They I trade is dead. Long live the I trade.
4:14 It's still alive and well. Uh, maybe we get, uh, a leadership
4:19 change in Nvidia, but I think it video is, uh, is a very strong company and I
4:25 don't really believe that one individual made that company.
4:29 There's a lot of employees, 40,000 employees that have, uh, obviously
4:34 accomplished quite a lot. So, yeah, I would say the eye trade is
4:39 not dead. I think this is actually a buying
4:41 opportunity for the trade. Um, I haven't mentioned this on air, but
4:45 all of economics lost a giant. William Nordhaus, Yale University.
4:49 Now, Professor Nordhaus um, I can't say enough, folks.
4:54 Yeah. How?
4:55 People on the left. People on the right.
4:57 Republicans. Democrats all worshiped.
5:00 William Norton I studied under him. He was he was quite an amazing
5:03 professor. What did he do at Yale that was so
5:08 across the board, have an impact to those on the left?
5:12 Those on the right? Well, I think more on the left and the
5:16 right. He did a lot of work on climate change
5:19 and uh, uh, his he was one of the few leaders in that area, obviously a
5:25 controversial area, but he never faltered in having an opinion and
5:30 backing it up with the data that he put together.
Xi Gives Trump Rare Airport Welcome full transcript
0:05 >> LIVE FROM WASHINGTON DC, THIS IS "BALANCE OF POWER" WITH JOE
0:09 MATHIEU AND KAILEY LEINZ. JOE: TIME FOR THE BIG DANCE IN
0:15 SHENZHEN AS PRESIDENT TRUMP ARRIVES IN CHINA WHERE HE WILL
0:20 MEET IN THE FIRST 24 HOURS WITH XI JINPING AND VLADIMIR PUTIN.
0:25 A RATHER DELICATE MOMENT IN OUR RELATIONSHIP WITH THE WORLD'S
0:27 SECOND-LARGEST ECONOMY. I'M JOE MATHIEU ALONGSIDE KAILEY
0:30 LEINZ. I DON'T ABOUT THIS IS A THREE
0:34 AMIGOS SITUATION BUT THEY WILL BE TOGETHER AND DEALING WITH
0:35 SOME PRETTY HEAVY ISSUES. KAILEY: A KEY MEETING WILL BE
0:41 HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN. OF COURSE HE HAS ALREADY SEEN
0:47 THEM WHEN HE TOUCHED DOWN IN SHENZHEN.
0:51 XI JINPING PICKED HIM UP AT THE AIRPORT RETURNING THE FAVOR.
0:57 THE EFFORT EVERYONE MADE A BIG DEAL OUT OF.
0:58 IT IS RECIPROCAL. THE QUESTION IS WHAT HAPPENS
1:02 NEXT? IT IS NIGHT THERE.
1:04 WE WILL CONNECT WITH TYLER KENDALL.
1:08 BY THE TIME WE GET TO TOMORROW, THEIR TIME WE WILL HAVE THESE
1:13 THREE IN A ROOM TALKING ABOUT EVERYTHING FROM IRAN TO UKRAINE.
1:20 KAILEY: NOT DENUCLEARIZATION, DENUCLEARIZATION AS PRESIDENT
1:21 TRUMP FLOATED THAT PERHAPS NORTH KOREA'S KIM JONG-UN MIGHT BE
1:25 COMING ALTHOUGH WE HAVEN'T GOTTEN ANY CONFIRMATION OF THAT.
1:29 WE WILL TALK ABOUT THIS WITH MARY LOVELY OF THE PETERSON
1:31 INSTITUTE LATER THIS HOUR. WE WILL TOUCH BASE WITH THE
1:35 REPUBLICAN SENATOR SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO THERE ARE NUMBER OF
1:40 QUESTIONS C AND HER COLLEAGUES ARE FACING AS IT COMES TO
1:43 GOVERNMENT FUNDING, MONEY FOR THE FAA AND OTHERS.
1:50 JOE: YESTERDAY WE SPOKE WITH SENATORS RAND IN THOM TILLIS.
1:54 BOTH REPUBLICANS WOULD NEITHER GO NEAR THAT $50 BILLION NUMBER
1:57 THE ADMINISTRATION IS ASKING FOR TO BUILD A NEW AIR TRAFFIC
2:00 CONTROL SYSTEM. WE ARE CRANKING THE DIAL DOWN ON
2:04 50 BILLION AND WE WILL SEE WHERE THE TRUTH LIES.
2:07 AT LEAST WHAT SHE THINKS. QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT COULD BE
2:10 DONE HERE. WILL THERE BE A PERMITTING DEAL?
2:16 KAILEY: SHE IS PUSHING HARD FOR IT.
2:19 WE WILL SEE IF IT MATERIALIZES. LET'S GO LIVE TO WORLD
2:21 HEADQUARTERS WHERE CHARLIE PELLETT IS WATCHING.
2:26 CHARLIE: WATCHING A MIX OF MARKET RIGHT NOW, WE HAVE IN
2:29 VIDEO BEHIND US AND ANTHROPIC AHEAD OF US.
2:33 S&P SELLING OFF, A LITTLE CHANGED DOWN BY 1/10 OF 1%.
2:36 WAS HIGHER BRIEFLY THIS MORNING. A DROP OF 9/10 OF 1%.
2:44 NASDAQ UP 3/10 OF 1%. THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX UP TO
2:48 TENTHS OF 1%. THE RUSSELL 2000 INDEX RALLYING
2:53 TODAY UP BY 1%. THE PHILADELPHIA STOCK EXCHANGE
2:58 DOWN 5/10 OF 1%. 17 MEMBERS HIGHER, 13 MEMBERS
3:03 LOWER. NVIDIA DOWN NOW BY TWO .4%.
3:09 TWO YEAR YIELD, 4.7%. GOLD DOWN ALMOST 3% NOW, 30
3:15 7.360 OUNCE. CRUDE 82.2 TWO PER BARREL.
3:22 WEST TEXAS INTERMEDIATE CRUDE DOWN NOW BY 4.4%.
3:28 WE ARE JUST ABOUT 91 DOWN TWO POINT 2%.
3:30 BITCOIN, THE SELLING CONTINUES THEY ARE DOWN ONE .9%.
3:36 BITCOIN HOLDING RIGHT AROUND 63,000 DOLLARS.
3:38 NVIDIA'S POST-EARNINGS RALLY FIZZLED OUT.
3:41 STOCK WAS INITIALLY HIGHER BUT TODAY WE ARE SEEING NVIDIA
3:44 DECLINED BY TWO POINT 5%. A SIGNED TRADERS ARE LOOKING FOR
3:49 MORE EVIDENCE OF DURABILITY OF THE AAI TRADE.
3:53 ANTHROPIC IS ON THE CUSP OF POTENTIALLY HAVING THE BIGGEST
3:57 IPO OF ALL-TIME. SOURCES HAVE BEEN TELLING
4:00 BLOOMBERG THAT THEY EXPECT THE PRICE IN SHARES ABOVE A RANGE IN
4:04 ITS IPO. RECAPPING STOCKS LOWER, S&P DOWN
4:14 TO TENTHS OF 1%. NVIDIA DOWN 2.5%.
4:17 THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
4:21 KAILEY: THANK YOU SO MUCH AS CHARLIE POINTS US TO THE OTHER
4:24 BIG MARKET EVENT OF THE WEEKEND. WHAT KIND OF MARKET WILL BE
4:30 TRADING IN? AN OPEN QUESTION AS THIS ISN'T
4:33 NECESSARILY A TALE OF THE GREATEST TAPE FOR COMPANY ABOUT
4:37 TO MAKE ITS DEBUT ON THE PUBLIC MARKET GIVEN WHAT WE HAVE SEEN.
4:42 EVEN NVIDIA DESPITE THE REALLY STRONG EARNINGS, STRONG GUIDANCE
4:45 HAS NOT BEEN ABLE TO HOLD ONTO A GAIN.
4:49 THEY HAVE UNEQUIVOCALLY SAID THEY WILL NOT WELCOME BACK
4:51 JENSEN HUANG AS THE HAS SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT.
4:55 ONE WAS LAST TIME WE SAW TWO SUCH MAJOR MARKET EVENT EVENTS
4:58 IN THE SAME WEEK. SUCH HIGH GEOPOLITICAL STAKES
5:01 FOR THE PRESIDENT. HIS SWING THROUGH ASIA HAVING
5:02 DEPARTED. HE WAS GREETED BY XI JINPING AS
5:09 WE TALKED ABOUT. A LOT IS ON THE AGENDA FOR
5:11 CONVERSATION. JOE: TWO MAJOR CLEARING EVENTS
5:16 AS THEY HAVE BEEN DESCRIBED. NVIDIA IS A LITTLE BIT LOWER.
5:22 A LOT OF CONFUSION AS WE DISCUSSED EARLIER WITH ED LUDLOW
5:26 ABOUT WHERE THESE INVESTIGATIONS ARE GOING.
5:30 SO MUCH TO BE LEARNED DESPITE A GLOWING FORECAST FOR NVIDIA THAT
5:32 SEEM TO MAKE PEOPLE FEEL A LOT BETTER.
5:37 THE WHOLE DATA CENTER TRADE APPEARS TO BE UNWINDING HERE.
5:42 THIS HAS BEEN A DIFFICULT TIME IN THE MARKETS.
5:45 IT IS CHINA WE ARE TALKING ABOUT WITH THIS NVIDIA SCANDAL.
5:48 IT'S UNCLEAR IF THIS WILL EVEN BE DISCUSSED.
5:53 KAILEY: NVIDIA HAD TO SAY EXCLUSIVELY YESTERDAY IT IS NOT
5:59 FACTORING CHINA INTO THE REVENUE FORECAST.
6:05 THAT THEY ARE STILL CONFIDENT, WE KNOW THOSE ARE VERY REAL.
6:13 A BIPARTISAN ONE, OF COURSE, THE QUESTION THEN BECOMES IF THE
6:17 U.S. FOLLOWS THROUGH WITH THAT, WHAT CHINA DOES TO RETALIATE.
6:20 COULD WE SEE FRESH RESTRICTIONS ON THINGS LIKE RARE-EARTH,
6:24 CRITICAL MINERALS, THINGS CHINA OBVIOUSLY HAVE A CHOKEHOLD ON
6:25 THAT MARKET. DOES IT COME UP IN THE FEW
6:32 MINUTES THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS WITH XI JINPING OR DO THEY TALK
6:34 ABOUT OTHER STUFF? JOE: IT SEEMS LIKE THE BAR IS
6:37 BEING LOWERED. THIS COULD BE ANOTHER MEETING
6:39 AGAIN. WHEN YOU ADD THE ELEMENT OF
6:44 VLADIMIR PUTIN AS KAILEY MENTIONED, THE PROSPECT OF KIM
6:47 JONG-UN. THE PRESIDENT WAS ASKED ABOUT
6:50 THAT ON HIS WAY OUT OF TOWN. THE WARS UNDERWAY, LISTEN TO
6:55 WHAT HE SAID. PRESIDENT TRUMP: IT'S A TOUGH
6:59 SUBJECT BECAUSE IT'S VERY HARD FOR ANY OF US TO SAY WE WILL GET
7:02 RID OF OUR NUKES. WE WILL TALK ABOUT
7:10 DENUCLEARIZATION, WE WILL TALK ABOUT IRAN.
7:11 WE HAVE IRAN IN VERY GREAT SHAPE.
7:16 MY FAVORITE SUBJECT, UKRAINE. UKRAINE AND RUSSIA IS LOSING.
7:22 WE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT THAT. WE WILL TALK ABOUT ECONOMICS AND
7:25 TRADE. JOE: THE QUESTION ABOUT WHETHER
7:29 THERE IS AN EXTENSION OF THE TRADE TRUTHS, THIS IS ANOTHER
7:33 ITEM WE ARE LOOKING AT HERE ON BLOOMBERG, IT EXPIRES SHORTLY
7:37 AFTER THIS TRIP WHETHER THEY COULD GET ANOTHER 3-4 MONTHS IS
7:42 A BIG QUESTION ABOUT WHAT WILL COME FROM THIS MEETING.
7:44 WE WILL HAVE TO WAIT UNTIL TOMORROW TO DO THIS.
7:50 KAILEY: AS HE REFERENCES THE WAR WITH IRAN THIS IS SOMETHING IN
7:53 THE OFFENDING CONVERSATION HAPPENING ON CAPITOL HILL.
7:59 DECEMBER 11 IS THE DEADLINE TO AVOID A GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN.
8:02 FEELS LIKE THERE'S PART OF THE PARTY IN WASHINGTON THAT FEELS
8:06 FORCING A SHUTDOWN OVER THE WAR SO AS TO NOT APPROPRIATE ANY
8:11 MORE MONEY MIGHT BE A WORTHY CAUSE.
8:15 DOES THAT MEAN WE GO OVER THE CLIFF ON DECEMBER 11?
8:16 IT'S ANYONE'S GUESS. JOE: FOR THE RECORD WE HAVE BEEN
8:21 ASKING ABOUT THIS FOR A COUPLE WEEKS.
8:25 WE MIGHT BE TALKING ABOUT THIS FOR REAL.
8:35 THEY WILL BE JOINING US NOW LIVE FROM CAPITOL HILL, A MEMBER OF
8:37 THE HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE, CHAIR ENVIRONMENT AND
8:41 PUBLIC WORKS ON THE RULES COMMITTEE.
8:43 AS A PRETTY GOOD SENSE OF WHERE ALL THIS LIES.
8:45 IT'S GREAT TO SEE YOU. WELCOME BACK.
8:48 DO YOU WORRY ABOUT DEMOCRATIC LEADERSHIP BATTLES AND
8:51 OPPOSITION TO THE WAR IN IRAN LEADING TO A SHUTDOWN NEXT
8:52 MONTH? >> I WORRY ABOUT ANYTHING THAT
8:56 LEADS TO A SHUTDOWN. THE LAST TWO SHUTDOWNS WE HAD
9:04 WERE A GRAVE DISSERVICE TO A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT I REPRESENT AND
9:06 PEOPLE ACROSS THE COUNTRY. THIS IS IN THE WAY TO RUN THE
9:10 GOVERNMENT. WE ARE OBLIGATED TO FUND A
9:13 GOVERNMENT, WE SHOULD DO THIS. DEMOCRATS WON'T EVEN COME TO THE
9:16 APPROPRIATIONS TABLE TO DISCUSS THIS.
9:21 THAT WILL GO ON FOR THE NEXT WEEK OR SO.
9:25 I WILL JUST BESEECH THEM TO PLEASE REACH A CONCLUSION BEFORE
9:33 DECEMBER 11 AND NOT HAVE THIS MARCH TO WHAT I THINK WILL BE A
9:34 DISASTER. KAILEY: JUST TO BE CLEAR ARE YOU
9:44 AVOIDING A SHORT-TERM RESOLUTION THAT PUNS THIS TO THE NEXT
9:46 CONGRESS OR ARE YOU HOPING THE RESOLUTION BILLS WILL PASS?
9:50 SEN. MOORE-CAPITO: ON THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE WE HAVE
9:52 WORKED A LONG TIME AND HARD TO HAVE BUILT TO THE PUBLIC, OUR
9:57 CHAIRMAN, CHAIRMAN COLLINS HAS PUT THEM OUT FOR PUBLIC VIEW.
10:01 SOME OF THEM ARE BIPARTISAN. I HOPE THAT WOULD BE THE
10:02 DIRECTION WE WOULD GO. IF MY ONLY CHOICE IS A
10:07 SHORT-TERM CONTINUING RESOLUTION I WOULD DEFINITELY MAKE THAT
10:11 VOTE TO KEEP FUNDING THE GOVERNMENT, YES.
10:13 JOE: INTERESTING. THERE'S A BIG QUESTION ABOUT HOW
10:18 MUCH MONEY IT WILL REQUIRE TO REPLACE THE AIR TRAFFIC CONTROL
10:22 SYSTEM IN THIS COUNTRY AND EVERY REPUBLICAN WE HAVE SPOKEN WITH
10:28 HAS TOLD US $50 BILLION WAS SIMPLY BEYOND THE PALE KNOWING
10:31 THERE IS A GOOD CHUNK OF MONEY IN THE BILLIONS LEFT THAT HAS
10:34 NOT BEEN INVESTED YET. WOULD YOU SUPPORT THE IDEA OF
10:36 REALLOCATING THAT MONEY? SEN. MOORE-CAPITO: WE KNOW THIS
10:44 IS A DECADE-LONG PROBLEM. WE GAVE THEM 2.5 BILLION.
11:00 WE ASK THEM WHERE HAVE YOU SPENT THIS?
11:02 THEIR HANDS ARE TIED ON THREE POINT $5 BILLION.
11:04 FOR NEW CENTERS. WHICH IS NOT THE CROCKS OF THE
11:06 PROBLEM. WOULD I BEFORE UNLEASHING THAT?
11:11 I GUESS. WE NEED ACCOUNTABILITY AND IT
11:15 SEEMS TO ME THAT ALL OF A SUDDEN IT WAS $30 BILLION AND THEN JUST
11:19 IT WOULD REALLY BE $50 BILLION. WE NEED ACCOUNTABILITY HERE.
11:24 I DON'T THINK WE GOT THAT WITH THE $50 BILLION FIGURE.
11:30 I DON'T THINK WE WILL GO FULL ON THAT.
11:33 THE QUICKER WE COULD DO THIS, THE BETTER.
11:34 IT WILL BE WELL-FUNDED. IT SHOULD BE FUNDED ON A
11:38 BIPARTISAN BASIS. EVERYBODY WANTS A SAFE AIR
11:39 TRAVEL AND THAT IS NATURAL. KAILEY: TO YOUR POINT ON
11:45 ACCOUNTABILITY, DO YOU FEEL THAT IS PRESENT RIGHT NOW ON THE
11:48 TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT ON WHAT EXACTLY WAS THE ROOT CAUSE
11:51 OF THE GROUND STOP OF LAST WEEK? SECRETARY DUFFY MADE IT CLEAR
11:56 POINT? SEN. MOORE-CAPITO: MY
12:03 UNDERSTANDING IS THEY CENSORED IT AROUND ARKANSAS WHEN THEY
12:06 WERE SWITCHING IT OVER. THEY HAVE DONE THIS 50 TIMES AND
12:09 THEY HAVE NOT HAD A PROBLEM. THEY DON'T REALLY KNOW WHY THAT
12:14 ONE FAILED. YES, WE NEED TO FIND OUT WHY,
12:24 HOW, WHEN. THE SOFTWARE ATTACHED TO IT, WE
12:25 DON'T KNOW. WE DO NEED TO KNOW THIS.
12:32 WE ARE BUILDING MODELS TO SEE IF THEY COULD FIGURE THAT OUT.
12:37 WE NEED TO MOVE FORWARD OF TRANSITIONING COPPER TO FIBER.
12:40 MODERNIZING THE SYSTEMS BEHIND IT THAT WERE BUILT IN THE
12:44 1990'S, THINK ABOUT THAT. IN TERMS OF SOFTWARE AND WHERE
12:47 WE ARE NOW. MAKING THE ARGUMENT THAT WE NEED
12:52 TO MODERNIZE IS NOT AN ARGUMENT EVERYBODY UNDERSTANDS IS TRUE.
12:55 UNDERSTANDING HOW THEY WILL GET THERE.
13:01 THERE'S NOT ENOUGH MONEY UP TO 12 BILLION THAT HAVE NOT BEEN
13:03 SPENT. WE NEED TO GET IT FIRST, ORDER
13:04 IT. SEEMS TO ME A SLOW SLOG FOR AN
13:10 URGENT PROBLEM. JOE: I DON'T KNOW WHEN YOU COULD
13:16 GET TO THIS, THERE ARE QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER YOU COULD GET A
13:20 PERMITTING BILL OVER THE LINE IN THE LAME-DUCK SESSION.
13:22 YOU ARE AT THE FRONT OF THIS LEGISLATION THAT WE HAVE HEARD
13:27 REPEATEDLY THAT HAS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
13:29 COULD YOU GIVE US THE SENSE OF WHETHER THIS IS REAL ESTATE?
13:32 WE UNDERSTAND HAKEEM JEFFRIES WOULD LIKE TO MAKE SOME CHANGES,
13:36 COULD WE GO THROUGH THIS WHOLE THING AGAIN?
13:43 SEN. MOORE-CAPITO: WE ARE IN THE MIDDLE OF THIS, LITERALLY.
13:47 WE HAVE NEGOTIATED IT VERY AGGRESSIVELY OVER TWO YEARS.
13:53 MY COUNTERPARTS AND I HAVE WORKED THIS UP ONE SIDE AND DOWN
13:55 THE OTHER. WE INCORPORATED A LOT OF STUFF
14:02 FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
14:07 WE WILL HAVE A BIG VOTE. WE HAVE IT EITHER TODAY OR
14:09 TOMORROW. IT WILL LEAVE THE SENATE IN A
14:12 BIPARTISAN FASHION. WE CREATED A LEGACY OF BUILDING
14:18 IT IN OUR COUNTRY, CREATING JOBS .
14:21 THAT IS SOMETHING I'M GLAD I HAVE HAD A HAND IN.
14:26 KAILEY: TO GET TO THE ROOT OF THE QUESTION HE WAS ALLUDING TO
14:29 HAKEEM JEFFRIES WITH THE BILL. WHAT KIND OF CONVERSATIONS HAVE
14:34 YOU ENGAGED WITH ON THE HOUSE SIDE?
14:40 SEN. MOORE-CAPITO: THAT'S A VERY GOOD QUESTION.
14:41 WE HAVE ENGAGED NONSTOP. REMEMBER, THE HOUSE PASSED THE
14:48 SPEED ACT IN DECEMBER OF LAST YEAR.
14:50 A LOT OF WHAT THE HOUSE PASSED IS PART OF THIS BILL THAT WE ARE
14:54 WORKING NOW. TO SAY HOUSE VOICES HAVEN'T BEEN
15:02 HEARD AND WHEN THEY SAW OUR BILL, WE INCORPORATED AT LEAST
15:07 18-20 HOUSE BILLS THAT WERE BIPARTISAN TO BE A PART OF THIS.
15:11 WE WORK HARD TO ASCERTAIN THE COMMITTEE CHAIRS OVER THERE.
15:15 IT'S A BROAD-BASED COALITION FROM LABOR TO GREEN GROUPS, OIL
15:22 GROUPS, OIL AND GAS, COMMUNICATIONS, ROAD BUILDERS.
15:24 IT IS ENORMOUS. JOE: THE LAST STICKING POINT, IS
15:29 THAT WHERE THIS NEEDS TO BE HAMMERED OUT?
15:32 SEN. MOORE CAPITO: WE HAVE MADE SOME PROGRESS ON THE TRIBAL LAND
15:36 FEES, AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS MANY OF THE MEMBERS TO HAVE THAT
15:40 AS A CONCERN FEEL SATISFIED. YES, WE HAVE TARGETED THAT.
15:43 WE HAVE ANOTHER ISSUE WITH THE FARM BUREAU.
15:45 WE WORKED THAT OUT AS WELL. SO WE ARE ON A GOOD TRACK HERE.
15:48 I DON'T WANT TO SEE IT DERAILED. AND I THINK THE HOUSE'S
15:54 CONCERNS, A LOT OF THOSE CONCERNS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED IN
15:55 THIS BILL. KAILEY: WELL, OF COURSE, THIS
16:00 PIECE OF LEGISLATION IS ONE OUR AUDIENCE AT BLOOMBERG IS PAYING
16:05 ATTENTION TO, POLICY AND HOW IT INFLUENCES BUSINESSES, FINANCIAL
16:07 MARKETS. ANOTHER ONE OF THE STORIES,
16:11 SENATOR, THAT HAVE SURFACED IN RECENT WEEKS, WHAT HAPPENED WITH
16:15 JENSEN HUANG AND CHIPS BEING ALLOWED TO CHINA, WHAT THE
16:17 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT WAS OR WAS NOT L WILLING TO LOOK FOR WHEN
16:24 IT CAME TO NVIDIA, MEGASPEED, AND OTHER ACTIVITIES.
16:25 I WONDER WHAT QUESTION YOU HAVE YOURSELF -- FIND YOURSELF
16:30 HAVING, HOWARD LUTNICK, WHAT HE MIGHT NEED TO ANSWER FOR.
16:34 SEN. MOORE CAPITO: MY UNDERSTANDING IS SECRETARY
16:35 LUTNICK AND THE FORMER CHAIR OF NVIDIA ARE GOING TO TESTIFY
16:40 BEFORE CONGRESS GET THE QUESTIONS IN MIND YOU ARE GOING
16:42 TO BECOME IT WAS CLEAR FROM THE PRESIDENT AND FROM THIS
16:46 CONGRESS, THAT WE DID NOT WANT OUR ADVANCED CHIPS FALLING IN
16:49 THE HANDS OF THE CHINESE IN ANY WAY, WHETHER IT IS DIVERTED TO
16:51 ANOTHER COUNTRY OR TO ANOTHER BUSINESS OR HOWEVER
16:56 SURREPTITIOUSLY THAT MIGHT HAVE OCCURRED.
16:58 IF YOU KNOW OF THAT, WHEN DID YOU NOW?
17:01 WHY DIDN'T YOU DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT?
17:03 IF YOU WERE THE COMPANY CHAIR AT THE TIME AND WERE THE ONE
17:07 NEGOTIATING THESE DEALS, AND GREAT CONFLICT WHEN YOU
17:10 KNEW, THE PRESIDENT AND THE PEOPLE OF THE UNITED STATES
17:11 WOULD WANT. THESE ARE GOING TO BE HARSH
17:15 QUESTIONS, AND I THINK THEY NEED TO BE ASKED, AND WE NEED TO GET
17:16 A STRAIGHT ANSWER. JOE: WELL, WITH THAT SAID, WE
17:23 HAD A CONVERSATION WITH SENATOR THOM TILLIS LAST EVENING.
17:24 HE IMPLIED COME AND HE WILL BE IN THIS HEARING WITH HOWARD
17:31 LUTNICK ON DECEMBER THE 10TH, THAT IF THE FOUNDERS SOME
17:33 COMPROMISE, THE ADMINISTRATION HAS 2.5 WEEKS TO COME UP WITH A
17:37 REPLACEMENTS OF REPUBLICANS CAN CONTROL THE NOMINATING AND
17:40 CONFIRMATION PROCESS. DO YOU AGREE WITH HIM ON THAT?
17:44 SEN. MOORE CAPITO: WELL, I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO DOUBT THAT
17:48 SECRETARY LUTNICK SERVES AT THE WILL AND PLEASURE OF THE
17:52 PRESIDENT, AND THAT OUR ROLE, SHORT OF IMPEACHMENT, IS NOT TO
17:54 DEPOSE A CABINET SECRETARY, UNLESS, OF COURSE, WERE TO
18:00 DECIDE THAT IS THE DIRECTION, WE COULD PROBABLY SPEED UP THE
18:01 PROCESS, BUT THAT IS A PRETTY HEAVY LEFT, WITH THE LAST TWO
18:08 LENGTHY PROCESSES. I DON'T KNOW THAT'S WHAT'S GOING
18:13 TO HAPPEN. WE WILL SEE WHAT HAPPENS IN THE
18:14 INTERIM. KAILEY: INDEED WE WILL.
18:20 SENATOR, THANKS AS ALWAYS FOR THE TIME, REPUBLICAN SHELLEY
18:24 MOORE CAPITO JOINING US LIVE FROM CAPITOL HILL.
18:25 THERE'S A LOT MORE HAPPENING ON THE HILL TODAY, INCLUDING THE
18:29 WORLDWIDE THREAT HEARING HAPPENING AT THE HOUSE,
18:31 TESTIMONY FROM THE ONLY SECURITY SECRETARY MARKWAYNE MULLIN AS
18:37 WELL AS DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE JAKE LAYTON.
18:39 YOU CAN BET THEY'VE GOT A LOT OF QUESTIONS ON THE OUTAGES WE SEEN
18:43 . THEY DON'T SEE THIS AS A IN A
18:46 JOE: YEAH. GOT EVERYONE ON CAPITOL HILL
18:49 SEEMS TO BELIEVE THAT. ARE THESE REALLY ALL DIFFERENT
18:53 COINCIDENCES HAPPENING AT THE SAME TIME?
18:56 WE WILL EXPLORE STAYED AHEAD ON "BALANCE OF POWER," ONLY ON
18:59 BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO. ♪
19:04 CHARLIE: IT IS 1:21 ON WALL STREET.
19:05 WE DO CHECK MARKETS ALL DAY LONG HERE AT BLOOMBERG.
19:09 39 MINUTES AWAY FROM THE LATEST FOMC MINUTES.
19:15 WE HAVE THE ANTHROPIC I FEEL LATER TODAY COULD NVIDIA SHARES
19:17 TRADING LOWER. U.S. STOCKS ARE MIXED WITH THE
19:20 S&P RIGHT NOW DOWN .1%. WALL STREET SEEING RENEWED
19:24 VOLATILITY. NVIDIA'S POST EARNINGS RALLY IS
19:27 FIZZLING. RIGHT NOW WE'VE GOT THE DOW DOWN
19:31 .9% IT IS TO BE IS YOUR BASELINE, DOWN .1% FOR BOTH
19:34 NASDAQ AND THE NASDAQ 100 INDEX, BOTH GAINING BY ROUGHLY .4%.
19:38 THE PHILADELPHIA STOCK EXCHANGE'S SEMICONDUCTOR INDEX
19:42 TRADING LOWER BY .3%. TWO YOUNG, 4.77%.
19:47 10 YEAR, 5.05%. AND AHEAD OF THE FOMC MINUTES
19:51 COMING UP AT 2:00 WALL STREET TIME.
19:58 GOLD DOWN 10 THE ELEMENTS, DOWN 2.9%.
20:02 AT A RETREAT FOR CRUDE, NOW DOWN 4.3%, $82.35 A BARREL, A BARREL
20:07 OF BRENT CRUDE DOWN BY 2.2%. BITCOIN DOWN 1.8%, HOLDING JUST
20:13 ABOVE 63,146. WELLS FARGO PLANS TO NAME J.P.
20:19 MORGAN CHASE'S ALLISON BEER AS ITS NEXT CHIEF OPERATING
20:23 OFFICER, A MAJOR HIGHER FOR CEO CHARLIE SHARP, WHICH HE SEEMS TO
20:30 MERRILY GAP OF THE LARGEST AMERICAN BANK AND ITS BIGGER --
20:33 FOURTH LARGEST AMERICAN BANK AND ITS BIGGER RIVALS.
20:39 JPMORGAN CHASE SHARES LOWER BY 1.4%.
20:43 S&P DOWN, NVIDIA SHARES DOWN TWO POINT 2%.
20:44 THAT IS A BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH.
20:48 JOE: ALL RIGHT, CHARLIE, THANK YOU SO MUCH, CHARLIE PELLETT
20:50 LIVE FROM NEW YORK, WILL BE BACK IN ABOUT 20 MINUTES WITH ANOTHER
20:54 CHECK ON THE MARKETS. AS WE WAIT FOR THE NEXT OUTAGE,
20:58 THERE'S BEEN SO MUCH CONCERN ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON AROUND
21:02 US, TO THE POINT WHERE THE FBI, THE DALLAS OFFICE ISSUED A FLASH
21:03 ADVISORY WARNING YESTERDAY, THAT CYBER CRIMINALS AND HACKERS ARE
21:08 EXPLOITING SOMETHING CALLED RTECH.
21:11 I'VE NEVER HEARD OF THIS BEFORE. THIS IS AN AI PENETRATION
21:16 TESTING FRAMEWORK, THEY CALL IT, DO I MAKE ATTACKS AGAINST
21:23 SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE FREQUENT OUTAGES WE'VE SEEN AT
21:27 MICROSOFT. PUT THE FAA ASIDE, THE BANKS,
21:33 ARE CONNECTED. KAILEY: YES, BUT, OF COURSE, ALL
21:39 OF THE INDIVIDUAL COMPANIES AFFECTED SAY IT IS SYSTEM
21:42 OUTAGES, IT IS A INCLUDED, RELATED TO ROUTINE UPGRADES AND
21:48 MAINTENANCE. A HEARING BEFORE THE HOUSE
21:51 TODAY. JOE: YEAH.
21:56 THEY DRAGGED MARKWAYNE MULLIN, HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY, AND
22:01 THE PRESENT'S NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISOR JAY CLAYTON, ABOUT THIS.
22:05 HE WENT ON TELEVISION TO SAY THERE WAS NO CYBER THREAT THAT
22:06 AMERICANS NEEDED TO WORRY ABOUT. LISTEN.
22:11 DIR. CLAYTON: I UNDERSTAND THE TIMING OF THESE INCIDENTS COULD
22:15 RAISE QUESTIONS, AND IT SHOULD. THE AMERICAN PEOPLE SHOULD ASK
22:17 US THESE QUESTIONS. BUT BASED ON WHAT WE KNOW TODAY,
22:21 AFTER A GREAT DEAL OF DILIGENCE, THESE ARE SEPARATE SERVICE
22:23 OUTAGES ASSOCIATED WITH MAINTENANCE AND TECHNICAL
22:26 CHANGES. THEY ARE NOT A COORDINATED OR
22:28 STATE-SPONSORED ATTACK. KAILEY: SO LET'S TURN NOW TO
22:36 BLOOMBERG'S MYLES MILLER, WHO WAS SITTING IN ON THAT HEARING
22:41 WITH THE DIRECTOR OF INTELLIGENCE -- DIRECTOR OF
22:42 NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE AND SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY.
22:46 HE JOINS US NOW FROM CAPITOL HILL.
22:50 HE WENT TO SAY BASED ON WHAT WE KNOW TODAY, GIVEN HOW RECENT ALL
22:54 THESE INSTANCES WERE COME IS THERE A POSSIBILITY MORE
22:56 INFORMATION TO COME TO LIGHT THAT COULD SHOW A CONNECTION OF
23:00 SAM KIND, OR -- OF SOME KIND, OR ARE THEY SAYING WE WOULD KNOW
23:02 THAT IF THAT'S THE CASE. MYLES: YEAH.
23:05 JAY CLAYTON IS ONE OF THE MOST HONEST MEN IN WASHINGTON, RIGHT?
23:10 IN THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK, BEFORE THAT AT THE SEC,
23:14 AND HIS GOAL IS TO KEEP ORGANIZATIONS ACCOUNTABLE AND
23:16 SAY IF ANY OF THESE COMPANIES HAD BEEN HIT BY A CYBER ATTACK,
23:19 HE WOULD MAKE CLEAR THAT THEY NEED TO SAY THEY WERE HIT BY A
23:20 CYBER ATTACK. ONE THING WE LEARNED TODAY THAT
23:24 WE DID NOT KNOW BEFORE IS THAT WITH ALL OF THESE ISSUES COME OF
23:29 THESE OUTAGES, THE GOVERNMENT, ODNI AND OTHER PARTS OF THE
23:34 GOVERNMENT, DOJ, FBI, THEY ACTUALLY WORK WITH THESE
23:36 COMPANIES TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THE ROOT CAUSE WAS, AND THAT IS WHAT
23:38 GAVE THEM THE CONFIDENCE THAT THIS WAS IN FACT JUST OUTAGES
23:42 THAT WERE CONNECTED TO ROUTINE UPGRADES.
23:47 WHAT WE HEARD FROM JAY CLAYTON TODAY WAS VERY INTERESTING IN
23:52 THAT IT JUST SO HAPPENS THAT ALL OF THE TECHNOLOGY IS JUST SO OLD
23:55 IN A LOT OF THESE SITUATIONS, AND SO THEY DO THE UPGRADE TO
24:00 ACCOUNT FOR WHAT THE GOVERNMENT CALL SUPER
24:01 INTELLIGENCE. AND THAT THAT MAY BE CAUSING
24:06 SOME OF THESE ISSUES. BUT THEY ARE MAKING IT VERY
24:09 CLEAR, THIS DOES NOT SEEM LIKE A NATIONSTATE ACTOR.
24:13 THE HOME AND SECURITY SEC. GOING OUT OF HIS WAY TO SAY IRAN WAS
24:16 NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT, AND SAYING THAT BECAUSE, OF COURSE,
24:19 THE U.S. AT CONFLICT WITH IRAN. JOE: MYLES, IF AI-RELATED
24:27 HACKING IS ACCELERATED BEYOND THE POINT WHERE WE THOUGHT IT
24:30 WAS RIGHT NOW, IS THE ADMINISTRATION MAKING
24:32 THIS? MYLES:, YOU KNOW, JAY CLAYTON,
24:38 OF COURSE, IS LEADING THAT WORKING GROUP, AND THE ISSUE WE
24:41 WERE CONFRONTING BEFORE WAS JUST ABOUT SAFEGUARDS, RIGHT?
24:44 TO FIGURE OUT WITH THE SAFEGUARDS SHOULD BE FOR AI.
24:47 NOW YOU HAVE THIS NEW COMPLICATION TO FIGURE OUT IF
24:50 MAKING THESE CHANGES FOR AI ARE LEADING TO ISSUES WHEN IT COMES
24:54 TO SERVICE, AVAILABILITY, AND BEING ABLE TO SCALE.
25:00 WE CERTAINLY SEE IT AS THESE UPGRADES ARE NEEDED TO BE MADE
25:03 FOR, YOU KNOW, ADVANCED COMPUTING.
25:05 JAY CLAYTON SAID IT MAYBE FIVE OR SIX TIMES DURING THAT HEATING
25:12 DIFFERENT WAYS WHY THIS HAPPENED, BUT HE SAID IT IS
25:16 REALLY ABOUT THE COMPUTING CAPABILITIES, AND BECAUSE OF THE
25:17 SORT OF DEMAND FOR THE SYSTEM, THESE NEEDS -- THE NEED FOR THE
25:22 UPGRADES TO KEEP UP WITH SCALE, IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE AI
25:25 LEADERS AT THE WHITE HOUSE SOON TO COME TALK ABOUT WHAT NEEDS TO
25:28 BE DONE TO MAKE ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THIS.
25:29 JOE: YEAH. MYLES, THANK YOU.
25:37 YOU KNOW WHEN MYLES IS IN WASHINGTON, SOMETHING HAS GOT A
25:39 FOOT. BLOOMBERG NEWS A SENIOR REPORTER
25:41 FOR US. BLOOMBERG POLITICS CONTRIBUTORS
25:47 JOIN US, RICK DAVIS IS OUR REPUBLICAN STRATEGIST, A PARTNER
25:50 AT STONECOURT CAPITAL, JEANNE SHEEHAN ZAINO A PROFESSOR AT
25:57 IONA UNIVERSITY. AS SOON AS YOU HEAR, MARKWAYNE
26:02 MULLIN, I GET A TERMINAL USER WHO JUST HIT ME WHILE HE WAS
26:06 LISTENING TO MILES REPORT, "BS, NO WAY THIS WAS ALL RANDOM.
26:13 EVERY BANK, EVERY MAJOR TECH PLATFORM." THIS IS WHAT THE
26:15 AMERICAN PEOPLE THINK, RICK. HOW DOES THE ADMINISTRATION GET
26:18 THEIR ARMS AROUND THAT? RICK: I THINK IS FAIR
26:24 FOR THE ADMINISTRATION TO GET THEIR ARMS AROUND THAT, TO LEAVE
26:26 IN ON THAT. THERE'S A SHADOW WAR IN
26:32 CYBERSPACE, RECENTLY ATTACKED BY CHINESE ACTORS CALLED SALT
26:36 TYPHOON AND BALL TYPHOON THAT WERE THE SAME KIND OF IMPACT.
26:40 THEY GOT INDOOR INFRASTRUCTURE FROM INDOOR BACON, INDOOR
26:45 GOVERNMENT SYSTEMS, AND THE QUESTION WERE RAISED AT THAT
26:48 TIME WAS, SO THEN WHAT DO THEY DO?
26:52 SO IT IS CLEAR THAT WE ARE WAGING THIS WAR FROM ITS GOING
26:56 ON, IS FULSOME, IT HAS BEEN ENABLED BY AI.
27:01 AND I DON'T THINK THIS ADMINISTRATION IS REALLY HAVING
27:04 THE CONVERSATION THEY NEED TO HAVE WITH CORPORATE AMERICA,
27:08 WITH INSTITUTIONS, GOVERNMENT AND STATE AND LOCAL LEVEL,
27:13 HOSPITAL SYSTEMS, REALLY OUR KEY INFRASTRUCTURE IS MARVEL TO ALL
27:14 OF THIS. IT HAS BEEN PROVEN OVER AND OVER
27:17 AGAIN, AND WE NEED TO REALLY HAVE SOME UNDERSTANDING AS TO
27:21 WHAT WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO DO ABOUT IT.
27:27 NOT JUST AS KAILEY: I WONDER IF THERE'S
27:28 ANYONE IN THE ADMINISTRATION YOU TRUST TO LEAD THAT CHARGE.
27:33 WOULD IT BE POTENTIALLY JAY CLAYTON, THE DIRECTOR OF
27:37 NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE? AS MYLES WAS JUST DESCRIBING,
27:39 FORMER CHAIR OF THE F.C.C., TRYING TO TELL IT LIKE IT IS AND
27:42 BE SERIOUS ABOUT THIS. IS THAT THE BEST MESSENGER THAT
27:45 THE WHITE HOUSE HAS ON THESE ISSUES RIGHT NOW?
27:49 JEANNE: HE'S ABSOLUTELY BETTER THAN WE'VE SEEN OUT OF MARKWAYNE
27:54 MULLIN AND SEAN DUFFY. TO THE TERMINAL USER, I COULDN'T
27:57 AGREE MORE. DO NOT PUT AWAY YOUR CRANK
28:00 RADIO. LISTEN, FIRST OF ALL, WHERE WAS
28:05 THE F.B.I. DIRECTOR, KASH PATEL? THIS IS THE SECOND ANNUAL
28:09 HEARING, LONG SCHEDULED, THAT HE HAS SKIPPED.
28:12 AND TO DO THIS AT THIS TIME AND SEND HIS DEPARTMENT AT THIS I
28:15 THINK IS DEEPLY DISTURBING. WE DESERVE BETTER.
28:18 SECOND OF ALL, YOU KNOW, IF YOU BELIEVE AT FACE VALUE WHAT THEY
28:23 ARE SAYING, DOES THIS MAKE ANY OF THIS BETTER?
28:25 IN FACT, IT ALMOST MAKES IT WORSE.
28:28 ARE YOU SAYING THAT THE UNITED STATES, LET'S JUST SAY THE
28:32 F.A.A., IS VULNERABLE TO PULLING THE WIRE OUT OF A ROUTER AND,
28:36 YOU KNOW, HOWEVER MANY MILLIONS OF PEOPLE, AND 18,000 FLIGHTS GO
28:40 DOWN? HOW VULNERABLE WE ARE.
28:45 THIS IS LIKE SOMEBODY SAID WE HAVE OUR INFRASTRUCTURE BUILT ON
28:48 QUICKSAND. AND IF THAT GETS US DOWN,
28:52 IMAGINE WHAT THE IRANIANS COULD DO, WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT JAY
28:57 CLAYTON DID TAKE ABOUT. HE WARNED WE ARE MORE VULNERABLE
29:00 TODAY BECAUSE OF THIS WAR IN IRAN TO THE CYBERHACKING GOING
29:04 ON THAN WE WERE BEFORE, MUCH OF IT COMING FROM IRAN, BUT ALSO
29:09 ELSEWHERE, AND AS SOMEBODY WAS JUST SAYING, THIS IS GOING ON
29:12 ALL OVER THE WORLD. FRANCE JUST BLAMED IRAN FOR THE
29:15 REFRIGERATION HACK IN MID-OCTOBER.
29:18 SO NO, I DON'T FEEL BETTER. KAILEY, WATCH YOUR MOVIE.
29:21 JOE, GET YOUR CRANK RADIO OUT. THIS IS ALL GETTING WORSE BY THE
29:26 MINUTE. [LAUGHTER]
29:28 JOE: WATCH YOUR MOVIE, KAILEY. IT IS ALL COMING TRUE IN THAT
29:31 MOVIE, I DON'T KNOW. KAILEY: I'M NOT SURE I CAN WATCH
29:35 THAT MOVIE WITHOUT SPIRALING. JOE: THIS IS GETTING A LITTLE
29:38 BIT OUT OF CONTROL, RICK. WE JUST SPENT A NUMBER OF YEARS
29:41 TALKING ABOUT INVESTING IN INFRASTRUCTURE.
29:42 IS THE NEXT INFRASTRUCTURE BUILD EMPLOYING TO BE ALL CYBER?
29:46 RICK: IT VERY WELL COULD BE. IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE.
29:51 YOU KNOW, BE NICE IN OUR SYSTEMS RAN ON MORE ADVANCED
29:56 INFRASTRUCTURE BENEATH THEM, RIGHT?
29:58 THIS IS A REAL PROBLEM WITH EVERY LAYER OF OUR TECHNOLOGY
30:02 SUPERSTRUCTURE, RIGHT? WE TALK A LOT ABOUT THE CHIPS
30:07 AND WHAT'S GOING ON WITH NVIDIA, AND THAT'S JUST THE BEGINNING.
30:09 AND THEN IT'S THE OPERATING SYSTEMS THAT GO ON THAT, AND THE
30:13 SOFTWARE THAT'S BEEN USED. AND THEN THE SYSTEMS THEY'RE
30:15 CONNECTED TO, AND THE POWER SYSTEMS THAT DELIVER THE ENERGY
30:19 TO THESE, AND WHEN YOU START UNRAVELING ALL THAT, THERE ARE
30:22 SOME VERY GOOD PEOPLE IN GOVERNMENT WHO ARE DESPERATELY
30:25 TRYING TO UPGRADE THOSE THINGS. THE AMERICAN TAXPAYER SHOULD
30:28 FEEL GOOD THAT WE'VE INVESTED TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS INTO THESE
30:32 SYSTEMS, AND A LOT OF IT IS BEING UPGRADED.
30:35 BUT WE'RE IN A SPEED RACE, RIGHT?
30:37 THIS ISN'T THE KIND OF THING WE CAN DO OVER A DECADE.
30:40 THIS IS THE KIND OF THING WE NEED TO DO BY NEXT YEAR.
30:43 AND IF WE DON'T, SOMEBODY ELSE IS GOING TO COME IN THERE AND
30:48 EXPLOIT IT. THAT'S JUST THE WAY THE WORLD IS
30:51 WORKING RIGHT NOW. KAILEY: WHEN IT COMES TO F.A.A.
30:54 TECHNOLOGY IN PARTICULAR, PERHAPS SOME OF MORE ANTIQUATED
30:57 SYSTEMS THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT AS OF LATE, JEANNE, WE
31:01 WERE JUST TALKING WITH SHELLEY MOORE CAPITO ABOUT THIS, AFTER
31:07 JOE SPOKE WITH TOM TILLIS AND RAND PAUL LAST NIGHT, EVEN
31:10 REPUBLICANS ARE SUGGESTING THAT $50 BILLION THAT SEAN DUFFY IS
31:14 ASKING FOR IS NOT GOING TO BE THE FINAL NUMBER.
31:16 GIVEN WHAT JUST HAPPENED LAST WEEK, SHOULD IT BE IF NOW IS NOT
31:21 THE TIME TO DO THE UPGRADES? IS THERE EVER GOING TO BE THE
31:24 LEGISLATIVE WILL? >> I THINK THERE IS GOING TO BE
31:28 THE LEGISLATIVE WILL, BUT IT SHOULD HAPPEN UNDERSTANDING WHAT
31:34 HAS BEEN SPENT SO FAR, UNDERSTANDING WHAT OF THE 2.5
31:37 BILLION THEY JUST GOT HAS BEEN SPENT AND WHY THE EIGHT IS STILL
31:42 REMEANING, HOW THAT COULD BE USED.
31:44 SO I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF QUESTIONS.
31:46 I UNDERSTAND WHAT THE REPUBLICAN AND DEMOCRATIC CONGRESS PEOPLE
31:49 ARE SAYING AND SENATORS ARE SAYING.
31:51 YOU KNOW, YOU CAN'T JUST COME UP AND HERE SAY WE NEED $50 BILLION
31:55 MORE AFTER WEE GIVEN YOU SO MUCH MONEY OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
31:58 YEARS UNDER BOTH ADMINISTRATIONS, AND THIS IS
32:02 WHERE WE ARE. AND BY THE WAY, WHILE THEY'RE AT
32:05 IT, THEY SHOULD ALSO INQUIRE, AND THEY DID THIS A LITTLE BIT
32:10 TODAY, ABOUT OUR CYBER UNIT THAT DONALD TRUMP BASICALLY
32:14 DISMANTLED. GET THOSE PEOPLE BACK.
32:16 THOSE ARE GOOD PEOPLE AM WE NEED THEM TO PROTECT US.
32:18 KAILEY: JEANNE SHAHEEN ZAINO AND RICK DAVIS, OUR POLITICAL PANEL,
32:21 THANK YOU SO MUCH. RED HEADLINE JUST CROSS,
32:25 ORTHOPEDICS RENE HAAS HAS BEEN APPROACHED BY NVIDIA'S BOARD.
32:36 CHARLIE: IT'S 1:40 ON WALL STREET.
32:38 I'M CHARLIE PELLETT. 20 MINUTES TO GO UNTIL THE
32:41 LATEST FOMC MEETINGS. S&P 500 INDEX, TURNAROUND SINCE
32:46 OUR LAST UPDATE, HIGHER BY SEVEN POINTS.
32:48 LITTLE CHANGED, UP BY .1%. THE DOW DOES REMAIN HER, DOWN
32:53 369, A DROP THERE OF .7%. NASDAQ COMPOSITE UP 175, NOW UP
32:58 .7%. NASDAQ 100 UP .6%.
33:02 SHARES OF NVIDIA, THEY DO REMAIN LOWER AFTER EARNINGS, DOWN BY
33:05 2.1%. WE WILL BE PRICING THE ANTHROPIC
33:09 I.P.O. LATER ON TODAY. TWO-YEAR AT 4.78%.
33:14 WE'VE GOT THE 10-YEAR AT 5.06%. GOLD, MEANWHILE, TUMBLING 2.8%.
33:22 WEST TEXAS INTERMEDIATE CRUDE OIL DOWN 4.1%, $82.50 A BARREL.
33:28 BRENT CRUDE DOWN 1.9%. BITCOIN HOLDING JUST ABOVE
33:31 $63,000. BITCOIN DOWN 1.8%.
33:35 TAKE TWO INTERACTIVE SOFTWAY SHARES ARE RALLYING AMID A WAVE
33:40 OF POSITIVE REVIEWS FOR ITS GRAND THEFT AUTO VI GAME,
33:43 ACCORDING TO MAJOR REVIEW AGGREGATION WEB SITES.
33:46 THE HIGHLY ANTICIPATED VIDEO GAME HAS RECEIVED CLOSE TO
33:49 PERFECT SCORES ACROSS THE BOARD, MAKING IT THE BEST REVIEWED GAME
33:53 OF ALL TIME. SHARES OF TAKE TWO
33:56 ENTERTAINMENT, THEY ARE ADVANCING TODAY, UP BY ROUGHLY
34:00 7%. SKYDANCE IS COMBINING ITS WARNER
34:05 BROTHERS AND PARAMOUNT TV STUDIOS, ACCORDING TO VARIETY.
34:08 DAVID ELLISON, MEANWHILE, SAYS HE IS OPEN TO COLLABORATING WITH
34:12 ELON MUSK. RECAPPING, STOCKS RIGHT NOW,
34:13 THEY ARE TRADING HIGHER. THE S&P UP .2%.
34:18 I'M CHARLIE PELLETT. JOE AND KAILEY, THAT IS A
34:21 BLOOMBERG BUSINESS FLASH. JOE: CHARLIE, THANK YOU.
34:24 MIDNIGHT, THE GAME GOES LIVE. BUT CHARLIE WILL BE HERE
34:25 TOMORROW. HE HAS ASSURED US.
34:31 KAILEY, 30% OF U.S. WORKERS ARE THINKING ABOUT TAKING TOMORROW
34:34 OFF TO PLAY THE VIDEO GAME, ACCORDING TO GAME SQUARE
34:37 RESEARCH. I WONDER HOW MANY OF THEM WORK
34:39 HERE. KAILEY: YOU'RE GOING TO BE HERE?
34:42 JOE: I'M PLANNING TO BE HERE, YEAH.
34:43 NOT A BIG GAMER. KAILEY: NOR AM I.
34:46 I DO FEEL LIKE I MIGHT BE MISSING OUT ON SOMETHING WITH
34:48 THIS ONE, BECAUSE THIS IS QUITE THE CULTURAL PHENOMENON.
34:52 JOE: YEAH, YEAH, THE U.S. ARMY IS INVOLVED, OFFERING ELIGIBLE
34:55 SOLDIERS FOUR DAYS OFF TO PLAY AS A REENLISTMENT INCENTIVE.
35:01 I GUESS THIS IS QUITE THE GAME. WE'LL KEEP TABS ON TAKE TWO
35:04 SHARES AS WE MAKE OUR WAY THROUGH.
35:07 THEY'RE NOT GAMING IN SHENZHEN RIGHT NOW.
35:09 IN FACT, THEY'RE PREPARING FOR A MASSIVE SUMMIT.
35:12 THIS IS THE TRIO, THE TRILATERAL THAT WE'VE HEARD ABOUT.
35:16 XI JINPING, VLADIMIR PUTIN, AND DONALD TRUMP IN THE SAME ROOM.
35:21 AND BLOOMBERG IS ON THE GROUND AHEAD OF THIS.
35:23 KAILEY: INDEED, TYLER KENDALL, OUR WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT,
35:26 WHO HAS GONE TO ASIA THIS WEEK TO FOLLOW THE PRESIDENT, IS
35:30 JOINING US NOW LIVE, LATE NIGHT, EARLY MORNING FROM SHENZHEN,
35:32 CHINA. WE KNOW, TYLER, THAT TOMORROW IS
35:36 GOING TO BE A REALLY BIG DAY WITH THESE MEETINGS WITH BOTH
35:39 VLADIMIR PUTIN AND XI JINPING, AND ALL THREE OF THEM TOGETHER.
35:45 SET EXPECTATIONS FOR US. TYLER: WELL, KAILEY, PRESIDENT
35:47 TRUMP GOT A VERY WARM WELCOME WHEN HE LANDED HERE IN CHINA
35:50 EARLIER TODAY. YOU HAD THE CHINESE PRESIDENT
35:53 GOING TO THE AIRPORT TO PERSONALLY GREET HIM IN WHAT WAS
35:58 CONSIDERED TO BE A RATHER RARE MOVE.
36:01 BUT UNDERNEATH WHAT WAS THIS PUBLIC DISPLAY OF THE TWO COMING
36:06 TOGETHER, WE KNOW THAT TENSIONS HAVE REALLY BEEN BUILDING BEFORE
36:08 THIS BILATERAL MEETING THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP WILL HOLD WITH
36:12 THE CHINESE PRESIDENT, BEFORE THEY THEN HAVE THE RUSSIAN
36:15 PRESIDENT, VLADIMIR PUTIN, JOIN THEM.
36:17 IN THAT BILATERAL MEETING, WE'LL BE LOOKING TO SEE IF THERE IS
36:20 ANY SORT OF MOVEMENT WHEN IT COMES TO SOME PRETTY BIG
36:23 DISAGREEMENTS THAT HAVE REALLY COME TO THE FOREFRONT OF THE
36:27 CONVERSATION IN RECENT DAYS, INCLUDING THAT JUST YESTERDAY WE
36:31 HEARD FROM BEIJING'S COMMERCE MINISTRY PLEDGING COUNTER
36:33 MEASURES AGAINST THE U.S. IF THE U.S. COMMERCE DEPARTMENT GOES
36:36 FORWARD WITH THESE EXPORT RESTRICTIONS IN A BID TO CURB
36:41 CHINESE ACCESS TO ADVANCED CHIPS.
36:43 WE GOT SORT OF A PREVIEW OF WHAT MAY HAPPEN BEHIND CLOSED DOORS,
36:47 BOTH CHINESE PRESIDENT AS WELL AS THE RUSSIAN PRESIDENT GAVE
36:53 THEIR SPEECHES TO THE APAC SUMMIT THAT'S HAPPENING HERE,
36:55 AND THEY BOTH FRAMED IT AROUND WHAT THEY ARE CALLING ECONOMIC
37:00 BARRIERS, WARNING ABOUT PROTECTIONIST POLICIES IN WHAT
37:03 APPEARS TO BE A PUSHBACK AT THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION'S OWN
37:04 POLICIES. AT THIS POINT, THERE ARE SO MANY
37:07 THINGS THAT WE COULD WATCH OUT FOR.
37:09 I POINT YOU TO THE TRILATERAL MEETING.
37:10 OF COURSE, WE'RE GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY SORT OF TANGIBLE
37:17 MOVE FORWARD WHEN IT COMES TO DIPLOMACY.
37:20 UKRAINE ISN'T HERE AT THE TABLE, SO THAT IN AND OF ITSELF RAISES
37:24 QUESTIONS WHAT CAN ACTUALLY GET DONE.
37:27 JOE: NEXT 24 HOURS SHOULD BE FASCINATING.
37:29 DO WE KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE OPTICS, WHAT THE VENUE WILL BE,
37:35 HOW THESE THREE LEADERS WILL BE STAGED?
37:38 TO THAT END, WILL THERE BE A NEWS CONFERENCE?
37:39 I'M ASSUMING THAT WOULD NOT TAKE PLACE IN CHINA OR WITH ANY OF
37:42 THESE THREE AT A MOMENT LIKE THIS.
37:48 TYLER: AT THE MOMENT, JOE, THERE IS NO PUBLIC PRESS BRIEFING ON
37:51 THE OFFICIAL SCHEDULE FROM THE WHITE HOUSE.
37:53 LATER TODAY, WE'LL PROBABLY GET THE FIRM TIMING OF EXACTLY WHERE
37:57 AND WHEN THESE EVENTS WILL HAPPEN.
37:59 OUR UNDERSTANDING IS THE BILATERAL MEETING WITH THE
38:01 CHINESE PRESIDENT WILL BE THE FIRST MEETING.
38:04 THAT WILL THEN BE FOLLOWED BY THE TRILATERAL MEETING.
38:06 BLOOMBERG NEWS ALSO HAS REPORTING THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP
38:12 IS SET TO HOLD A PRIVATE MEETING WITH RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR
38:15 PUTIN AS WELL, SO SORT OF TWO BILATERALS, AND THEN THE
38:17 TRILATERAL MEETING. THAT IS SIGNIFICANT, BECAUSE
38:20 GOING INTO THIS SUMMIT, THEY WEREN'T EXPECTED TO MEET SIDE BY
38:22 SIDE. BUT JOE, WE SHOULD SAY, THIS IS
38:25 REALLY LAYING THE GROUND WORK FOR PROBABLY WHAT'S GOING TO BE
38:28 ANOTHER CONVERSATION, AND THAT'S NEXT MONTH AT THE G20 SUMMIT IN
38:31 MIAMI. SOME OFFICIALS HAVE BEEN
38:34 POINTING TO THAT, SORT OF DOWNPLAYING WHAT HAPPENS THIS
38:37 WEEK, LOOKING AHEAD TO WHAT HAPPENS NEXT MONTH.
38:39 JOE: SO ANOTHER MEETING, MEET AGAIN, POTENTIAL.
38:42 TYLER, THANK YOU SO MUCH, WITH US LIVE FROM CHINA.
38:45 KENNEDY AS WE HAVE THE VOICE OF MARY LOVELY, FROM THE PETERSON
38:48 INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS, AND AN EXPERT ON OUR
38:51 ECONOMIC RELATIONSHIP WITH CHINA.
38:54 MARY, GREAT TO HAVE YOU BACK ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
38:58 HOW LOW IS YOUR BAR FOR THIS TRILATERAL MEETING?
39:03 >> THANK YOU, JOE. I WON'T BE PLAYING GAMES
39:06 TONIGHT, BUT I WILL BE WATCHING WHAT'S HAPPENING IN SHENZHEN.
39:10 I HAVE A LOW BAR, WHICH IS UNFORTUNATE, BECAUSE THE THREE
39:13 LEADERS CERTAINLY HAVE A LOT TO TALK ABOUT.
39:14 BUT WE DON'T EXPECT MUCH TO HAPPEN.
39:18 YOUR REPORTER MENTIONED MAYBE THEY'RE SETTING SOMETHING UP FOR
39:20 MIAMI MEETINGS. BUT AGAIN, THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE
39:26 LAID BY THOSE WITHIN EACH ADMINISTRATION.
39:29 SO I DON'T EXPECT A LOT TO COME OUT OF THAT.
39:31 HAVING SAID THAT, THERE'S REALLY A LOT ON THE TABLE MIGHT RIGHT
39:34 ANYWAY, AND THERE'S A LOT OF STUFF THAT'S IN PLAY RIGHT NOW.
39:39 KAILEY: YEAH, PERHAPS TOP OF MIND RIGHT NOW, THAT IS NEWLY IN
39:43 PLACE, THE REVELATIONS AROUND NVIDIA, JENSEN HUANG, AN AFFAIR
39:46 WITH AN ADDING E ALLEGED CHINESE SPY, MEGASPEED, AND THE ABILITY
39:49 OF CHINA TO GET CHIPS FROM NVIDIA THAT IT WAS NOT SUPPOSED
39:54 TO HAVE ACCESS TO, WITH A LOT OF QUESTIONS SWIRLING AROUND THE
39:55 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IN PARTICULAR.
39:58 MARY, IT HAS INSPIRED ON CAPITOL HILL A FRESH IMPETUS TOWARD
40:03 PUTTING INTO PLACE TOUGHER EXPORTS ON TECHNOLOGY THAT CAN
40:06 GO TO CHINA. CHINA HAS VOWED RETALIATION FOR
40:10 THAT, AND I WONDER IF THIS IS POTENTIALLY SOMETHING YOU COULD
40:13 SEE REIGNITING A DRAMATICALLY ESCALATING TIT-FOR-TAT BETWEEN
40:17 THE U.S. AND CHINA, WHEN WE THINK ABOUT WHAT'S WEE SEEN
40:21 PREVIOUSLY WITH THINGS LIKE RAREETHS.
40:23 >> THAT'S EXACTLY WHERE WE NEED TO BE FOCUSING RIGHT NOW AT THIS
40:25 MOMENT. THE NVIDIA CASE IS CLEARLY ABOUT
40:31 MUCH MORE THAN JENSEN HUANG'S PRIVATE LIFE.
40:35 IT'S ABOUT BASICALLY WITHIN THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH, HIGHWAY
40:37 AIRPORT CONTROLS ARE GOING TO BE ADMINISTERED.
40:44 AND WE'VE SEEN THAT NVIDIA OR WHOEVER HAS BEEN ABLE TO GET
40:46 CHIPS INTO CHINA. WE'RE GOING TO LEARN MORE ABOUT
40:48 THAT. NOW THE REACTION IN THE CONGRESS
40:52 HAS BEEN TO PROMOTE ACCESS. I THINK IT'S INTERESTING TO
40:55 JUXTAPOSE THAT WITH THE PICTURE OF THE BEAR HUG THAT PRESIDENT
41:00 XI JINPING TRIED TO GIVE PRESIDENT TRUMP.
41:05 THE CURRENT CIVILITY IS BASED ON STRATEGIC CIVILITY ON FAIRNESS,
41:09 RESPECT, AND RECIPROCITY. RECIPROCITY MEANS WE'RE GOING TO
41:12 BE PLAYING TIT-FOR-TAT WITH THE CHINESE FOR A LONG TIME.
41:15 SO WHEN WE DECIDE TO CUT OFF THEIR REMOTE ACCESS, WE NEED TO
41:19 ANTICIPATE THAT THERE IS GOING TO BE REACTION, AND AS YOU
41:23 REPORTED, THAT HAS ALREADY BEEN ANNOUNCED FROM CHINA.
41:31 THIS COMES IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ROLE TO THE UNITED STATES, TO
41:35 INDUSTRY, AEROSPACE, AUTO, DEFENSE.
41:37 SO THAT'S A PRETTY BIG CHOKE POINT THAT THE CHINESE HAVE
41:41 RIGHT NOW. I THINK WE'RE AT A VERY DELICATE
41:45 MOMENT, AND IT WILL BE INTERESTING TO SEE WHETHER
41:48 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S VISIT AND HIS MEETING WITH PRESIDENT XI MOVES
41:52 THE BALL FORWARD IN A WAY THAT BOTH COUNTRIES CAN CONTINUE THIS
41:56 DEVELOPMENT. JOE: WHAT DOES PRESIDENT XI
41:59 REALLY WANT HERE? WE'VE TALKED SO MUCH, THE
42:01 PRESIDENT SPEAKING OPENLY ABOUT THE PROSPECT OF INSULTING CHINA
42:05 BY CUTTING OFF ACCESS TO THOSE CHIPS, OR BRINGING UP THE JENSEN
42:09 HUANG SCANDAL IN THE WRONG WAY. BUT IT WAS NOT VERY LONG AGO
42:16 THAT WE REPORTED CHINA WAS NOT INTERESTED IN SEEING ITS TECH
42:19 COMPANIES BUY NVIDIA CHIPS, IT WANTED TO PROP UP HUAWEI, THAT
42:23 THERE, IN FACT, MIGHT NOT HAVE BEEN A MARKET THERE FOR NVIDIA.
42:27 OR IS THE TRUTH SOMEWHERE IN BETWEEN?
42:28 >> THE TRUTH MUST BE SOMEWHERE IN BETWEEN, JOE, BECAUSE IF
42:32 CHINA HAD REALLY WANTED TO CUT OFF REMOTE ACCESS, THEY WOULD
42:34 HAVE. THEY WOULD HAVE.
42:36 BUT THEY HAVEN'T. IT MAY THAT BE THEY WANT TO
42:39 CONTINUE TO TRY TO TRAIN MODELS CLOSER TO THE U.S. FRONTIER.
42:42 AND AT THE SAME TIME, BUILDING THEIR INDIGENOUS SUPPLY OF
42:46 CHIPS. WE LOOK AT THIS AS AN EITHER/OR
42:49 THAT XI JINPING WAS NOT THAT INTERESTED IN BUYING THE H200
42:53 CHIPS FROM NVIDIA BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO PUT PRESSURE ON THEIR
42:57 OWN TECH COMPANIES TO BUY DOMESTICALLY.
42:59 WELL, I THINK WE KNOW THAT IT'S MORE OF A SLOW ROLL THAN THAT.
43:03 YOU CAN HAVE REMOTE ACCESS AND STILL BE BUILDING OUT THAT
43:04 CAPACITY. DON'T FORGET, WE HAVE OTHER
43:08 BILLS ON CONGRESS, SUCH AS THE MATH ACT, WHICH WOULD CUT OFF
43:12 CHINESE ACCESS TO MANUFACTURING AND EQUIPMENT, AND EVEN CUT OFF
43:17 THEIR ACCESS TO MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR PARTS FOR MACHINES THAT
43:21 THEY'VE ALREADY BOUGHT. SO THIS WOULD BE FURTHER
43:26 ESCALATION IN THIS REALM. WHAT WAS THE SITUATION BACK WHEN
43:31 THESE EXPORT CONTROLS WERE PUT ON UNDER THE BIDEN
43:34 ADMINISTRATION IS VERY DIFFERENT TODAY THAN IT WAS THEN.
43:36 THE CHINESE HAVE PROGRESSED. WE'VE SOON THEIR ABILITY TO ROLL
43:40 OUT RULE AFTER RULE THAT PROVIDES THEM WITH CHOKE POINTS.
43:42 SO WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO PROCEED VERY CAREFULLY HERE.
43:49 KAILEY: OVERALL, DO YOU THINK IT IS IN CHINA'S INTEREST TO
43:52 CONTINUE AS U.S. COMMERCE SECRETARY?
43:53 TO HEAR PRESIDENT TRUMP CHARACTERIZE IT, AS HE WAS
43:56 DEPARTING FOR ASIA EARLIER THIS WEEK, HE SAID THERE'S A REAL
43:58 DIFFERENCE OF OPINION WITHIN HIS CABINET.
44:00 HOWARD LUTNICK DOESN'T WANT TO INSULT CHINA, AS JOE ALLUDED TO,
44:03 VERSUS SCOTT BESSENT, WHO WANTS TO GO HARDER.
44:06 IF YOU'RE XI JINPING, ARE YOU HOPING THAT HOWARD LUTNICK HOLDS
44:10 ON RIGHT NOW? >> WELL, I THINK THE CHINESE
44:14 HAVE MADE IT VERY CLEAR ALL ALONG THAT THEY'RE WILLING TO
44:18 PAY TO PLAY. AND IF THERE'S MEMBERS OF THE
44:21 ADMINISTRATION THAT ARE WILLING TO EASE ON THAT, THEY'RE OK WITH
44:24 THAT. YOU KNOW, THEY WOULD TELL YOU
44:29 U.S. DOMESTIC, HOW THEY ORGANIZE THE DOMESTIC HOUSE IS U.S.
44:30 BUSINESS. BUT WE SEE THAT DOMESTICALLY,
44:33 WITHIN THE UNITED STATES, THERE'S ENORMOUS TENSION BETWEEN
44:38 THE TRADITIONAL NATIONAL SECURITY COMMUNITY AND WHAT WE
44:42 MAY SEE IS THE INTEREST OF U.S. TECH COMPANIES.
44:45 SO THIS IS A TENSION THAT IS NOT GOING TO BE DECIDED IN BEIJING.
44:48 IT'S GOING TO BE DECIDED RIGHT HERE IN WASHINGTON.
44:52 JOE: SHOULD WE BELIEVE THAT WE WILL ACTUALLY KNOW WHAT TAKES
44:54 PLACE IN THIS MEETING? THERE WON'T BE A NEWS
44:56 CONFERENCE. WE'RE NOT TOO USED TO GETTING
45:00 READOUTS FROM THESE MEETINGS WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP.
45:02 NEVER MIND THE OTHER TWO. >> YEAH, AND WE'VE HAD CASES
45:07 WHERE EVEN INTERPRETERS HAVEN'T BEEN ON THE ROOM.
45:09 SO YO, THAT'S THE THOUSAND DOLLAR QUESTION.
45:11 WE'RE UNLIKELY TO KNOW THE ANSWER TO THAT.
45:13 AND DON'T FORGET, WE GOT ANOTHER MEETING COMING UP IN MIAMI.
45:17 KAILEY: WELL, WITH THAT MEETING ON THE BOOKS, WOULD YOU EXPECT
45:21 ANY NEWS ON AN EXTENSION OF THE TRADE TRUCE BETWEEN THE U.S. AND
45:25 CHINA NOW, OR MIGHT IT WAIT FOR DECEMBER AND THE G20?
45:29 >> I MEAN, IT COULD WAIT. BUT IT'S REALLY CRITICAL THAT WE
45:32 GET AN EXTENSION OF THAT. THE CHINESE ARE BLOCKING BECAUSE
45:37 THEY SAID WE HAVE BEEN VERY SLOW ON THE 30 FOR 30, OR THE
45:40 REDUCTION IN TARIFFS THAT WE PROMISED.
45:44 THE U.S. IS DISCOURAGED BECAUSE WE'VE HAD MUCH SLOWER EXPORTS
45:50 FROM CHINA ON RARE EARTH MAGNETS AND OTHER SUPPLIES.
45:52 AND WE'VE SOON A SLOWER UPTAKE ON THE PURCHASES OF SOYBEANS AND
45:57 OTHER AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS THAT WE BELIEVE THEY PROMISED.
46:00 SO BOTH SIDES HAVE THEIR OWN DISAPPOINTMENTS WITH THE CURRENT
46:05 STALEMATE. BUT IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO
46:09 CONTINUE. UNTIL WE HAVE MAYBE A BROADER
46:13 STRATEGY OF DEALING WITH CHINA. DON'T FORGET, THERE ARE A LOT OF
46:16 MULTINATIONAL COMPANIES, A LOT OF GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS THAT ARE
46:22 HINGING ON THIS TRUTH BEING MAINTAINED IN JANUARY.
46:27 JOE: WE'VE BEEN HEARING REFERENCES TO YALTA QUITE A BIT
46:32 LATELY, AND THAT'S OBVIOUSLY NOT A MYSTERY AS TO WHY.
46:36 WHAT DOES XI JINPING THINK OF THAT IDEA?
46:42 >> WELL, I DON'T KNOW WHAT HE THINKS.
46:43 I CERTAINLY WOULD BE MUCH MORE POPULAR IF I DID.
46:48 I THINK THAT THE U.S. AND CHINA ARE NOT AT WAR.
46:50 THEY HAVEN'T BEEN AT WAR. WE SEE IN BOTH SIDES A
46:53 PREPARATION IN SOME SENSE FOR MAKING SURE THAT THE HOME FRONT
46:59 IS SECURE AND THAT WE ARE ABLE TO COUNTERACT ANY ATTEMPT TO
47:04 CAPITALIZE ON EACH OTHER'S VULNERABILITY.
47:09 SO WE'VE SEEN PRESIDENT XI JINPING DIG DOWN FOR MORE THAN
47:17 50 YEARS NOW ON DIVERSIFYING ITS SUPPLIERS, MILITARY FUSION,
47:22 SHOWING UP THIS DEFENSE INDUSTRIAL BASE.
47:25 SO WE SEE ALL THAT. IT'S VERY DIFFERENT THAN OTHERS.
47:36 SO I THINK THAT THE AVAILABILITY OF THAT.
47:39 KAILEY: ALL RIGHT, MARY LOVELY, SENIOR FELLOW AT THE PETERSON
47:42 INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS.
47:43 THANKS FOR JOINING US ON THIS EDITION OF "BALANCE OF POWER."
47:46 WE'LL BE BACK AT 5:00 P.M.
Fed Minutes Leave Door Open to Larger December Rate Hike full transcript
0:00 Chris Waller wasn't the only one. We saw in the minutes that others were in favor
0:04 of perhaps moving at a briskier pace if inflation did... Called for it. As expected, the
0:11 minutes described Fed policymakers in agreement that inflation risks were still high with the vast majority,
0:17 a kind of a new modifier for the Fed, seeing upside risks to the outlook. And
0:22 while most favored not moving in October, almost all participants judged that under their baseline outlooks
0:28 for inflation in the labor market, further action to raise the target rate for the federal
0:34 funds rate would likely be appropriate. Some participants favored a quarter point increase at the October
0:41 meeting, arguing the current policy status was not restrictive enough. They worried further delay risked more
0:48 disruptive tightening later. And we know that Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack dissented at the meeting.
0:53 A few, the minutes go on to say, who did favor an increase in the rate
0:57 indicated that they could have supported no change provided it was clearly understood by market participants
1:04 that further targeting... Tightening was likely. Chris Rovzner, not the only one looking for more moves,
1:10 as I mentioned. A couple participants the minute say noted that an increase of more than
1:15 25 basis points could be warranty at the the next meetings, if inflation continued to rise.
1:23 Some suggested market implied expectations of tightening in December and next year were broadly consistent with
1:30 their views of the appropriate rate, and several saw that alignment, as they put it, as
1:35 reducing the risks from keeping rates unchanged at this meeting. The vote was carried by many
1:41 pointing to benefits and accumulating additional information citing the need to assess the durability of AI
1:48 related investment demand, the evolution of financing conditions, the impact of the September rate increase, and
1:55 geopolitical developments. Some suggested a gradual approach would also give households and businesses a chance to
2:02 adjust, but the committee notes that it underscored its continuing resolve to achieve its dual mandate
2:09 goals by indicating in its post meeting statement that it will deliver price stability.
2:14 Yeah. I would say the message is clear. We still have inflation. Mike, I just wanna
2:18 point out in terms of market reaction, slight uptick certainly at the shorter end of the
2:22 yield curve. That two year note just kicking up slightly. Right now, we're at a yield
2:27 of four seventy nine, so we pop lower. But I wanna say equity is also turning
2:31 over a little bit. They've been down most of the day, but just coming down a
2:37 little bit. So very slight reaction. I wanna give it some size and scope here. We're
2:41 still just down about two points, Tim, on the S and P 500 and still holding
2:45 on to a gain of about a 138 points on the Nasdaq 100.
2:48 Mike, I wanna home in on something that you said. Subsequently, however, I'm reading from the
2:52 minutes right here, uncertainty about projected revenue trajectory of key AI firms and about the sustainability
2:57 of the pace of the build out of AI data centers. This was all before we
3:03 saw the blue tsunami earlier this month and also before we learned about Jensen Huang, I
3:10 mean, when this meeting happened, he was the CEO of NVIDIA. He is out, of course,
3:14 and shareholders have been concerned about what NVIDIA's future looks like. Just look at the results
3:19 over the last few weeks. What would you say about the changes that we've seen in
3:24 the last couple of weeks further changing how these Fed members view the uncertainty around AI?
3:30 Well, I think it increases the uncertainty around AI. Obviously, as you mentioned, they had no
3:35 idea what would happen with Jensen Huang and, NVIDIA. But there had been a growing anti
3:40 data center move out in the body politic that was reflected on election day, and there
3:45 were also concerns about how much money was being spent by the AI hyperscalers and whether
3:50 they could keep that up and keep the borrowing up necessary to fund it. So you
3:54 can see why members were looking at the possibility of a slowdown because AI investment spending
4:01 was really what was pushing GDP higher. And so it was a a key reason to
4:06 worry about what might happen to the economy later, but also what might hurry... Happen to
4:12 inflation because they do see and they remark several times in the minutes that AI spending
4:17 was pushing up prices.
4:19 So, you know, we talked about Fed governor Chris Waller, Mike, you know, saying he favored
4:23 a 50 basis point move in December. Are we feeling the drumbeat a little bit louder
4:28 and louder when it comes to a more aggressive move for the last Fed FOMC meeting
4:32 of, this year?
4:36 Well, that could be the case. Now I mentioned Chris Waller. His name's not mentioned in
4:39 the minutes, but, obviously, he came out today and reiterated what he had said about the
4:44 possibility of a 50 basis point move. But it does suggest that some others felt the
4:49 same way and talked about it at the meeting that if they didn't raise rates, they
4:52 might have to do more later and that they might be okay with that. So it
4:57 doesn't take that off the table. Obviously, reinforces a little bit of what Chris Waller said.
5:01 We don't know who those people are, but, and we don't know if they're necessarily voters
5:05 or just participants, but it does suggest that the, the possibility is out there if the
5:11 inflation numbers get any worse.
Anthropic Could Launch the Biggest IPO Ever full transcript
0:00 We're just reporting in the last few moments, according to a Bloomberg source, that Anthropic is
0:04 guiding prospective investors that they will be pricing this IPO above the marketed range. The marketed
0:09 range was $70 to $78 a share, $825,000,000... 825,000,000 shares in the offering. So if they,
0:18 at $78, hit that on a fully diluted basis, you're looking at $1,400,000,000,000 valuation. The target
0:24 raise $90,400,000,000, 26,000,000,000 of which in in the private placement format. It would take it beyond
0:31 what SpaceX raised, basically. And so it's been really interesting. Like, I've been speaking to a
0:35 lot of existing investors and those that are trying to get a big allocation in in
0:39 this thing, And they believe the bankers that it's oversubscribed. Like, we always say these these
0:44 IPOs are oversubscribed. But, you know, in the here and now, this is a first. Right?
0:48 This is the first Frontier Lab pure play AI Lab to go public. Once you get
0:54 beyond the mechanics of of them doing the transaction, there's still a long way to go
0:57 in explaining the the competing business model interest of... You have scarce compute. How do you
1:02 balance the training runs and that internal demand against making money from inference? And that's all
1:07 still to come.
Anthropic IPO Is Fairly Priced, Says Dharmesh Thakker full transcript
0:00 ANTHROPIC IS PRICING ITS IPO AFTER THE U.S. MARKET CLOSES
0:00 TODAY. AHEAD OF THAT, SCARLET FU IS
0:02 LOOKING AT WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LONG-AWAITED LISTING.
0:04 DANI: ANTHROPIC IS SLATED TO BECOME THE BIGGEST IPO OF ALL
0:10 TIME. STRONG INVESTOR DEMAND FOR
0:11 ANTHROPIC'S OFFERING WILL ALLOW THEM TO PRICE THEIR SHARES AT
0:16 THE HIGH-END OF THE RANGE OR EVEN ABOVE.
0:23 BANKERS TELL US THE IPO IS CLOSE TO SEVEN TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED,
0:27 SO AT THE TOP END OF THE MARKET AND INCLUDING A SEPARATE 26
0:31 BILLION DOLLAR PRIVATE PLACEMENT, ANTHROPIC WOULD
0:33 RAISED $90.4 BILLION, TOPPING THE SPACEX BASE DEAL.
0:38 IT WOULD ALSO GIVE ANTHROPIC A FULLY DILUTED VALUATION OF ABOUT
0:43 $1.4 TRILLION. IN OCTOBER THERE WAS TALK OF A
0:49 $2 TRILLION VALUATION BUT THE POSTELECTION SELLOFF -- IT WOULD
0:55 PUSH VOLUME TO A RECORD. DANI: LET'S TALK MORE ABOUT HOW
1:04 INVESTORS ARE APPROACHING AI AND THE HIGHLY ANTICIPATED ANTHROPIC
1:08 IPO. I AM JOINED NOW BY -- GENERAL
1:11 PARTNER AT BATTERY VENTURES. THEY RAISED $3.25 BILLION
1:18 EARLIER THIS YEAR. YOU ARE NOT IN ANTHROPIC, SO
1:22 THERE IS NO CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
1:24 THIS IS A COMPANY REPORTEDLY PRICING AT THE TOP END OF ITS
1:27 RANGE, IF NOT EXCEEDING THAT. IT'S BEEN WEEKS OF NONSTOP
1:32 VOLATILITY AROUND THE AI THEME. WHAT DOES THAT DEMAND TELL YOU
1:36 ABOUT AI AT THIS MOMENT, AND COMPANIES LIKE ANTHROPIC?
1:39 WHAT THIS EXCITEMENT TELLS YOU IS THE DEMAND FOR AI IS
1:45 REAL. THE MARKET IS REAL AND THE
1:48 REVENUE FIGURES ANTHROPIC IS FORECASTING SEEMS TO BE FAIRLY
1:53 PRICED. SO THERE IS A TON OF DEMAND FOR
2:00 THIS MARKET OPPORTUNITY AND ANTHROPIC IS AT THE LEADING EDGE
2:08 OF IT. DANI: WE'VE SEEN VOLATILITY IN
2:12 THE LEAD UP TO THIS. YES, DEMAND, PEOPLE WANT TO BE
2:21 PART OF THIS, BUT ARE SOME OF THE NERVES WARRANTED?
2:26 IT'S BEEN VERY VOLATILE WITH EVERYTHING GOING ON WITH NVIDIA.
2:34 THE FUNDRAISING NEEDS TO LIVE UP TO THE PROMISE OF AI.
2:36 MORE IMPORTANT IS THE CAPITAL THEY RAISE.
2:41 IN THIS ENVIRONMENT, WHERE ANTHROPIC COULD RAISE $90
2:45 BILLION PLUS, THAT WOULD MAKE THEM ONE OF THE MOST CASH RICH
2:51 AI INFRASTRUCTURE COMPANIES, MUCH MORE SO THAN META, GOOGLE
2:57 OR AMAZON. THAT CAPITAL GIVES YOU THE
2:59 OPPORTUNITY TO LOCK UP CAPACITY AND TAKE CARE OF YOUR
3:04 SUPPLY-SIDE. IF THEY CAN RAISE THIS CAPITAL
3:12 REGARDLESS OF THE VALUATION, THAT PUTS THEM IN A REALLY GOOD
3:17 PLACE TO DELIVER ON THEIR RATE NEXT YEAR.
Open Interest 11/18/2026 full transcript
0:00 DANI: WE GOT THROUGH THE NVIDIA HURDLE.
0:03 NOW IT IS JUST THE ANTHROPIC ONE FOR THE WEEK.
0:05 I'M DANI BURGER. >> AND I'M ISABELLE LEE.
0:07 BLOOMBERG "OPEN INTEREST" STARTS NOW.
0:19 DANI: NVIDIA DELIVERS A CLEAR MESSAGE, SAYING IT CAN KEEP
0:20 WINNING WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG. ISABELLE: NOW THE SPOTLIGHT
0:24 TURNS TO ANTHROPIC. DANI: AND THE GLOBAL AI RACE
0:30 SHIFTS TO CHINA AS A TRUMP AND XI PREPARE FOR HIGH-STAKES
0:32 TALKS. ISABELLE: THERE IS ONLY ONE
0:36 STOCK TO WATCH, AND IT IS NVIDIA.
0:39 IT IS HIGHER IN PREMARKET TRADE. INVESTORS ARE LOOKING PAST
0:43 NVIDIA'S LEADERSHIP TERMINAL, DESPITE ALTERING SALES TO CHINA.
0:49 THE BOARD IS TRYING TO PUT THE SUCCESSION QUESTION TO REST,
0:51 WITH ITS CHAIRMAN SAYING JENSEN HUANG NOT RETURN AS CEO.
0:57 THE NUMBER TO WATCH WAS THE GROWTH TARGET.
1:00 THE INCREASED REVENUE TO 75% AND A LOT OF INVESTORS BREATHED A
1:01 SIGH OF RELIEF. DANI: 3% IS NOTHING WHEN YOU
1:05 HAVE LOST 40% FROM YOUR PEAK. THEY HAVE A LONG WAY TO GO, BUT
1:11 POINT TAKEN, BECAUSE EARNINGS WERE BULLISH.
1:13 NOT NECESSARILY JUST NVIDIA, BUT AI AS A WHOLE.
1:19 THE TRADE IS GETTING A RELIEF SPREADS TO CHIPMAKERS AND
1:20 BEYOND. YOU CAN SEE SOME OF THE
1:22 NEO-CLOUDS DO WELL DESPITE SOME CHANGES.
1:28 DATA CENTER NAMES, POWER PROVIDERS, ALL OF THOSE ARE
1:31 MOVING HIGHER AS INVESTORS GET A FRESH VOTE OF CONFIDENCE IN AI
1:32 DEMAND. ISABELLE: DURING THE EARNINGS
1:38 CALL COLETTE KRESS SAID THERE WAS NO SIGN OF AI SLOWDOWN, EVEN
1:41 IF THE COMPANY LIMITS CHINA SALES.
1:45 >> WE LOOKED AT AN ASSESSMENT IN TERMS OF THE CURRENT EXPORT
1:45 CONTROLS. WE ARE STILL GOING TO SPEND SOME
1:51 TIME STUDYING THOSE TO SEE THE PIECES OF IT, BUT WE FEEL
1:54 CONFIDENT IN TERMS OF BOTH THE DEMAND WE HAVE IN FRONT OF US AS
1:57 WELL AS THE SUPPLY AND ADDITIONAL SUPPLY WE CAN DO 75%.
2:04 EVERY ANGLE. WHAT IT ALL MEANS FOR ANTHROPIC
2:09 SAKE OUT TOMORROW. ED, WITH NVIDIA'S EARNINGS WHERE
2:16 DO WE GO FROM HERE? ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO THE
2:19 UNCERTAINTY AROUND JEN-HSUN HUANG'S LEADERSHIP AND THE
2:20 STOCK? ED: I DON'T KNOW IF WE HAVE
2:23 CLEARED THE HURDLE. DANI: I TRIED.
2:25 I TRIED TO BE OPTIMISTIC. ED: THERE ARE MORE QUESTIONS
2:28 THAN ANSWERS. LET'S GO WITH WHAT WE DO KNOW.
2:35 THE OUTLOOK IN FISCAL 2028 REFLECTS THAT DEMAND IS RUNNING
2:37 AHEAD OF SUPPLY, BUT THE SUPPLY IS IMPROVING.
2:40 I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT TO LOOK AT NEO-CLOUDS.
2:45 THERE IS A DISTINCTION IN WHAT COLETTE KRESS SAID.
2:49 THEY WILL BE DISCIPLINED AND MORE DISCERNING, BUT SHE ALSO
2:52 SAID THE BETTER USE OF CAPITAL IS TO GREASE THE WHEELS FOR THE
2:53 SUPPLY CHAIN. THAT IS WHY THE BACKLOG OF THE
2:56 COMMITMENT NUMBER IS IMPORTANT. BUT ALSO, YOU KNOW, THEY DID NOT
3:01 POSE ANY QUESTIONS ON THE CALL FOR US TO HAVE ANSWERS TO THINGS
3:02 THAT ARE OVERHANGS ANYWAY. I THINK BARCLAYS LOOKS AT THE
3:07 UNKNOWN ABOUT SOUTHEAST ASIA AS AN INDIRECT SALES CHANNEL FOR
3:13 CHINA AS AN OVERHANG, BUT AGAIN, WHAT CAROLINE KRESS OUTLINED IS,
3:15 IF YOU CANNOT EXPORT TO THOSE COUNTRIES MAN IS SO GREAT
3:21 ELSEWHERE IT PLUGS THE GAP, SO WHAT IS IT MATTER?
3:25 DANI: IT RAISES QUESTIONS OF, WHY EVEN GET IN THIS ISSUE IF
3:27 DEMAND IS GREAT ENOUGH IN THE U.S. VERSUS SEEMINGLY HAVING TO
3:31 ROUTE THROUGH CHINA? COLETTE KRESS WAS AT PLAYING --
3:36 PAINS TO SAY THIS IS BUSINESS AS USUAL, AND IN TERMS OF THINGS
3:41 LIKE AN ACC INVESTIGATION, CHINA SALES, TO YOUR POINT,
3:43 LEADERSHIP, THOSE QUESTIONS WERE NOT EVEN ASKED ON THE CALL AND I
3:46 WONDER WHERE WE DO GO FROM HERE? IF WE WILL GET ANSWERS TO THAT
3:48 QUESTION. IF THIS IS AN NVIDIA THAT HAS
3:51 EXPLAINED TODAY. ED: WHAT THE CHAIR OF THE BOARD
3:57 SAID WAS THAT THEY ARE CONTINUING TO LOOK AT EXTERNAL
4:01 CANDIDATES AND LOOKING AT INTERNAL CANDIDATES AND THEY
4:04 WILL NOT BE RUSHED TO REPLACE THE CEO BUT HE COULD NOT HAVE
4:07 BEEN MORE CLEAR THAT -- AND THAT THERE IS A CHRONOLOGY TO IT.
4:12 AT THE START OF THE CALL HE SAID IT WAS UNANIMOUS, OUR ACCEPTANCE
4:15 OF JEN-HSUN HUANG'S RESIGNATION AS CEO AND DIRECTOR OF THE
4:17 BOARD. THEY ARE NOT GOING TO REINSTATE
4:22 HIM AND THERE IS A CALENDAR TO COME, DECEMBER 1 CONGRESSIONAL
4:26 HEARINGS, DO WE STILL HAVE A QUESTION OF WHAT IS NVIDIA
4:27 WITHOUT JEN-HSUN HUANG? BASED ON THE NUMBERS THAT
4:34 COLETTE KRESS GAVE, NO. NOTHING IN THE NEAR TO MEDIUM
4:35 TERM HAS CHANGED. ISABELLE: DO YOU THINK NVIDIA'S
4:44 BROADER AI TRADE? >> WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT CHINA,
4:48 CHINA IS NOT A MONOLITH. THERE ARE TENSIONS IN CHINA,
4:54 JUST AS THERE ARE TENSIONS IN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION.
4:57 THE HYPERSCALERS IN CHINA WANT CAP -- WANT REMOTE ACCESS OR
5:01 ACCESS IN THE DOMESTIC MARKET TO THOSE CHIPS SO THEY CAN CONTINUE
5:05 TO CATCH UP WITH THEIR U.S. COUNTERPARTS ON THAT SIX-MONTH
5:09 LAG THEY HAVE. BUT THE LIKES OF HUAWEI AND THE
5:16 SILICON UNIT THAT ACTUALLY PRODUCES THE CLEAREST COMPETITOR
5:19 TO THE LIKES OF AMD AND NVIDIA, THEY BIG LAG, THEY ARE LOBBYING.
5:24 THEY HAVE BEEN LOBBYING THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT TO KEEP H2
5:26 HUNDREDS AND NVIDIA CHIPS OUT OF THE DOMESTIC MARKET BECAUSE THEY
5:28 WANT TO EXPAND THEIR MARKET SHARE AND THERE WILL BE PARTS OF
5:32 THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT LOOKING AT THIS IN DIFFERENT WAYS.
5:36 THE MINISTER OF STATE SECURITY, THE PEOPLE'S LIBERATION ARMY
5:39 WILL BE LOOKING AT IT ONE WAY, AND OTHERS, PARTICULARLY THOSE
5:41 THAT SUPPORT THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY MIGHT BE MORE SUPPORTIVE
5:46 OF THE HYPERSCALERS AND THEIR DETERMINATION TO GET ACCESS TO
5:48 WHATEVER CHIPS, REMOTE OR OTHERWISE, TO CLOSE THAT
5:50 COMPETITIVE GAP. THIS IS GOING TO BE INTERESTING
5:54 IN TERMS OF THE CONVERSATIONS BETWEEN PRESIDENT XI AND
5:56 PRESIDENT TRUMP. THE RISK IS THAT THE U.S. OVER
6:00 PLAYS ITS HANDS AND THE CHINESE LOOKED TO RARE EARTHS.
6:02 I THINK WE ARE A LONG WAY FROM THAT.
6:06 IT DEPENDS ON THE FRAMING OF THESE EXPORT CURBS.
6:09 THAT IS IMPORTANT FOR CHINA AND CHINA WILL TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY
6:10 AS WELL ON THESE ADDITIONAL CURBS TO SAY TO ITS OTHER
6:13 PARTNERS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD, WE HAVE A STACK AND WE
6:16 CAN WORK WITH YOU. DANI: WE ARE LUCKY TO HAVE YOU.
6:23 THIS IS THE PERFECT MOMENT WITH YOUR LONG EXPERIENCE IN ASIA AND
6:26 CHINA AND YOUR YEARS COVERING TECH IN EUROPE.
6:28 I WONDER IF THIS IS A CONVERSATION THAT PRESIDENTS
6:32 TRUMP AND XI WERE HOPING IT WOULD NOT HAPPEN THE AGENDA
6:36 SHOULD HAVE BEEN, ESSENTIALLY, TWO ONGOING WARS, ESPECIALLY
6:39 WITH PUTIN IN THE CONVERSATION, THEY WOULD HAVE BEEN DISCUSSING.
6:43 TOM: PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS UNTIL FAIRLY RECENTLY SAID THIS IS NOT
6:47 GOING TO BE SOMETHING BRINGING UP WITH PRESIDENT XI.
6:50 IT SEEMS NOW AT LEAST SOME CONVERSATION AROUND SEMI'S WILL
6:52 BE PART OF THE CONVERSATION BETWEEN THE TWO SIDES.
6:56 CLEARLY THIS IS AN ADMINISTRATION THAT WANTS TO
6:59 KEEP THIS RESET ON TARIFFS FRONT AND CENTER.
7:02 THEY DO NOT WANT TO ESCALATE AND THAT SEEMS TO BE PART OF THE
7:07 CALCULATION OF HOW HOWARD LUTNICK, THAT HE DID NOT WANT TO
7:11 PUT A FURTHER BREAK IN THIS RELATIONSHIP AND THAT THAT WAS
7:13 SEEN AS A RISK FROM THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT.
7:17 FROM THE CHINESE PERSPECTIVE THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY IS WEAK.
7:19 IF YOU LOOK AT THE HYPERSCALERS IN HONG KONG THAT STOCK IS DOWN
7:24 90% SINCE JUNE. THE AI TRADE IN CHINA HAS
7:27 COLLAPSED. AND THEN THE DOMESTIC ECONOMY
7:31 REMAINS WEAK. EXPORTS ARE HUMMING, AND PART OF
7:36 THAT IS AI HARDWARE BEING SHIPPED OUT OF CHINA.
7:39 THIS IS A DOMESTIC ECONOMY THAT THE CHINESE PRESIDENT WILL WANT
7:40 TO ENSURE REMAINS STABLE. AND SO HAVING A STABLE
7:45 RELATIONSHIP ON THE TERROR FRONT IS IMPORTANT.
7:49 LONG-TERM GAIN FOR CHINA HAS BEEN SELF-RELIANCE AND WHATEVER
7:50 HAPPENS THEY WILL CONTINUE TO INVEST IN THEIR OWN SEMI'S IN
7:53 MR. -- INDUSTRY TO CATCH UP. ISABELLE: WE HAVE ANTHROPIC
7:58 PRICING TODAY, TRADING TOMORROW. I WANT TO BRING YOU IN, BAILEY.
8:02 WITH ALL OF THIS OPTIMISM WE ARE HEARING FROM NVIDIA, I HEAR A
8:03 SIGH OF INVESTORS. WILL THAT HELP WITH TAMARA'S
8:07 IPO? BAILEY: I DON'T KNOW IF I WOULD
8:12 USE THE PHRASE OPTIMISM, BUT THERE IS EXCITEMENT AROUND
8:13 ANTHROPIC. WHEN YOU STRIP OUT GOING PUBLIC
8:17 THIS IS PROBABLY THE WORST STRETCH.
8:19 WHEN YOU HAVE JENSEN BEING PUSHED OUT, YOU HAVE SO MUCH
8:22 VOLATILITY AROUND THE AI STORY. THIS IS A DEAL BOOK THAT HAS
8:25 SEEN TREMENDOUS DEMAND. THIS IS A DEAL THAT INVESTORS
8:31 ARE SHOWING UP TO PUT IN BIG ORDERS REGARDLESS OF WHAT THE
8:33 BACKDROP LOOKS LIKE. IT IS A BIG STEP AND BIG SIGN
8:37 THERE IS OPTIMISM AROUND THE AI ECOSYSTEM.
8:39 THE QUESTION DOES COME OUT TO, AND WE LOOK TOWARD DECEMBER WHEN
8:41 WE HAVE A FEW WEEKS OF TRAINING WHEN THERE IS MORE SHARES
8:46 UNLOCKED, IS THAT GOING TO CONTINUE TO BE A BENEFACTOR OF
8:47 SELLING OTHER STOCKS? ARE PEOPLE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
8:52 DIAL BACK EXPOSURE TO NVIDIA TO BUY MORE ANTHROPIC CHECK UP HE
8:54 IS THE CASH COMING FROM? DANI: IT FEELS LIKE IT HAS BEEN
8:58 MURPHY'S LAW FOR AI. A SCANDAL NOBODY SAW COMING,
9:02 QUESTIONS ABOUT -- ED: NVIDIA IS PUTTING $10
9:06 BILLION INTO THIS DEAL. BAILEY: THAT IS A DROP IN THE
9:09 BUCKET. ED: IT WAS NEVER SORT OF IN
9:12 QUESTION. DANI: DO YOU THINK IT IS IN
9:15 QUESTION NOW? ED: NO.
9:18 [LAUGHTER] THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN AN ABSOLUTE
9:23 CATASTROPHE GIVEN THE CONTEXT. THE MAIN POINT, YOU KNOW, IS
9:28 ANTHROPIC HAS COMPLICATED RELATIONSHIPS WITH MANY
9:28 DIFFERENT COMPANIES. NVIDIA IS ONE OF THEM.
9:32 LAST NIGHT COLETTE KRESS WAS MAKING THE POINT THAT 50% OF
9:35 SALES WILL COME FROM FRONTIER LABS, BUT SHE WAS ALSO LIKE, A
9:39 LOT OF THAT IS INCREASINGLY OPEN SOURCE, WHICH TELLS YOU THEY DO
9:44 OPENAI. ISABELLE: WHERE DO WE GO FROM
9:48 HERE? ESPECIALLY IN ANTHROPIC.
9:51 SEVEN TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED. WHAT IS THE RETAIL ASPECT FILL
9:54 IN? ABOUT ON THE INSTITUTIONAL
9:57 INVESTOR FRONT? BAILEY: THE EXPECTATION IS NO
10:03 MORE THAN 20% OF THE BOOK, THAT $64 BILLION GOES TO RETAIL.
10:06 MY EXPECTATION WOULD BE THAT THAT GETS DIALED BACK BECAUSE
10:07 THERE IS SO MUCH INTEREST FROM YOUR LOO CHIP INVESTORS.
10:11 IT DOES SEEM LIKE WE ARE GOING TO SEE IT WILL COME OUT THAT
10:19 RANGE, SO NORTH OF $1.4 TRILLION VALUATION, PRICING LIKELY INTO
10:23 THAT $80 RANGE. INVESTORS ARE BULLISH AND IT
10:26 SEEMS LIKE THE OPENING TRADE SHOULD LOOK A LOT LIKE SPACEX
10:27 DID. MEMBER, IT POPPED UP ABOUT 30%
10:30 IN TWO DAYS. BUT REMEMBER, SPACEX BROKE ISSUE
10:36 ABOUT A MONTH LATER THERE ARE GOING TO BE ABS AND FLOWS INTO
10:40 AND OUT OF ANTHROPIC AND I THINK THAT COMES BACK TO THE QUESTION
10:46 AROUND, AND WE LOOK TOWARD THANKSGIVING WILLIE SEYMOUR
10:48 VOLATILITY, JUST GIVEN THAT LIQUIDITY DRIES UP A LITTLE BIT
10:51 CHECK ON DANI: WE ARE LUCKY TO HAVE YOU THREE WITH US.
10:55 THAT IS BAILEY LIPSCHULTZ, TOM MACKENZIE, AND ED LUDLOW.
10:59 LET'S GET A CHECK ON YOUR MARKETS THIS MORNING.
11:02 WE ARE MOVING HIGHER AFTER LOGGING LOSSES.
11:04 WE ARE HIGHER BY .5%. -- .3%.
11:11 WEEK. THE NASDAQ IS DOWN 3% OVER THAT
11:14 STRETCH. 10-YEAR YIELD TO A SLIGHT BID.
11:21 BRENT CRUDE DOWN .3%. >> TARGET POSTING
11:27 BETTER-THAN-EXPECTED QUARTERLY SALES WITH THE RETAILER POINTING
11:30 TO PROGRESS FROM ITS PRODUCT REFRESH.
11:34 THE RESULTS WERE IN ANOTHER SIGN THAT THE BUSINESS MAY BE
11:35 STABILIZING AFTER THREE STRAIGHT YEARS OF DECLINING REVENUE.
11:43 NEXT UP, LOWE'S IS FALLING DESPITE BEATING EXPECTATIONS AND
11:44 RAISING ITS SALES OUTLET. DEMAND IS IMPROVING, ESPECIALLY
11:49 FROM CONTRACTORS AND ONLINE SHOPPERS, BUT HIGHER COSTS ARE
11:52 CONTINUING TO PUT PRESSURE ON PROFITS.
11:57 FINALLY, GTA 6 IS ALMOST HERE. TAKE TWO INTERACTIVE HIGHER
12:04 AFTER TOMORROW'S HIGHLY-ANTICIPATED RELEASE.
12:08 ANALYSTS FORECASTING HUGE SALES IN EARLY REVIEWS, ADDING TO THE
12:12 BUZZ AROUND ONE OF THE MOST ANTICIPATED GAME LAUNCHES EVER.
12:15 SHARES OF TAKE-TWO ARE HIGHER BY ABOUT 5%.
12:16 THOSE ARE YOUR MORNING MOVERS. DANI: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
12:22 COMING UP, MORE ON NVIDIA'S RESULTS.
12:24 WE ARE GOING TO TALK WITH NEW STREET.
12:26 THIS IS BLOOMBERG "OPEN INTEREST."
12:38 ♪ ISABELLE: NOW TO HIGH INTEREST,
12:39 A LOOK AT WHAT IS MAKING HEADLINES.
12:42 FED GOVERNOR CHRISTOPHER WALLER SAYS THE FED MAY NEED TO GO
12:45 BIGGER ON ITS NEXT RATE HIKE IF INFLATION KEEPS EATING UP.
12:48 HE FLOATED A HALF-POINT INCREASE IN DECEMBER, THOUGH JOHN
12:52 WILLIAMS SAYS THERE IS NO NEED FOR SUCH A DRAMATIC MOVE.
12:55 IN A WAVE OF UNRELATED TECHNOLOGY FAILURES IS RATTLING
12:59 PUBLIC CONFIDENCE AFTER DISRUPTIONS HIT AIR TRAVEL AND
13:04 EVEN NSA SYSTEMS. U.S. OFFICIALS SAY THERE IS NO
13:06 EVIDENCE OF A COORDINATED CYBER ATTACK BUT EXPERTS WARN THAT
13:12 AGING INFRASTRUCTURE AND AI DRIVEN VULNERABILITY DISCOVERY
13:16 IS EXPOSING HOW VULNERABLE CRITICAL SYSTEMS CAN BE.
13:20 NVIDIA RAISING ITS OUTLOOK, FORECASTING 75% REVENUE GROWTH
13:22 FOR THE NEXT FISCAL YEAR. THE BOARD IS JUST SPECULATION
13:27 ABOUT HUANG'S POSSIBLE RETURN. >> ON NOVEMBER 12 OUR BOARD
13:33 ANNOUNCED THAT AFTER HIS CLOSURE OF PERSONAL BEHAVIOR
13:34 INCONSISTENT WITH THE COMPANY'S CODE OF CONDUCT JENSEN HUANG
13:38 VOLUNTARILY RESIGNED HIS POSITIONS AS PRESIDENT, CEO, AND
13:42 BOARD MEMBER. NVIDIA BOARD UNANIMOUSLY
13:47 ACCEPTED HIS RESIGNATION AND DOES NOT INTEND TO REINSTATE
13:49 JENSEN AS CEO. DANI: JOINING US NOW IS ANTOINE
13:54 CHKAIBAN. HE HAS A BUY RATING ON NVIDIA.
13:58 GREAT TO SEE YOU. THERE WERE A LOT OF QUESTIONS
14:04 GOING INTO THIS EARNINGS REPORT. DID YOU GET THE ANSWERS YOU
14:07 WANTED? ANTOINE: THANKS FOR HAVING ME ON
14:11 THE SHOW. FIRST OF ALL, YOU HAVE THE GUIDE
14:14 THAT CONFIRMED. YOU HAVE THE REPORTED AND GUIDED
14:19 QUARTER THAT CAME IN ABOVE CONSENSUS.
14:25 MOST IMPORTANTLY, ON THE CALL, THE MANAGEMENT RAISED THE GROWTH
14:29 OUTLOOK FOR NEXT YEAR TO 75%. THAT IS A HIGHER REVENUE BASE
14:31 ALREADY. I THINK THAT ONE OF THE BIG
14:38 TAKEAWAYS IS THAT THE VISIBILITY KEEPS EXTENDING.
14:44 IT ALLOWS FOR PROJECTS INTO 2028.
14:45 YOU HAVE DEMANDED THAT HIS HITTING SUPPLY.
14:50 OUR ANALYSIS POINTS TO NVIDIA NOW ENTERING 2028 AND A $1
14:54 TRILLION REVENUE RUN RATE. $1 TRILLION REVENUE RUN RATE.
15:03 THEN THE SECOND ASPECT IS THE FACT THAT THE STRATEGY MESSAGING
15:07 MATTERS EVEN MORE THAN JUST THE NUMBERS.
15:15 WE HAVE SUPPORT FOR NEO-CLOUDS, THROUGH DISCIPLINED FINANCING.
15:16 WE THINK THAT IS REALLY ESSENTIAL, BECAUSE AT THE END OF
15:22 THE DAY A BROADER CUSTOMER BASE IS WHAT REDUCES NVIDIA'S
15:26 DEPENDENCE ON THE LARGER HYPERSCALERS AND HELPS DEFEND
15:27 ITS MARKET SHARE. I THINK WE GOT A NUMBER OF
15:30 ANSWERS. ISABELLE: YESTERDAY THEY CLOSED
15:35 ANY POSSIBILITY OF A JEN-HSUN HUANG COMEBACK, BUT YOU ARGUE AN
15:38 NVIDIA WITHOUT JENSEN IS STILL HELPFUL.
15:40 WHAT WOULD THAT LOOK LIKE? ANTOINE: THE DEPARTURE OF
15:46 JEN-HSUN HUANG IS A MAJOR BLOW FOR THE COMPANY.
15:48 THE NEAR-TERM OPERATIONS ARE RESILIENT, GIVEN HOW TIGHT
15:52 SUPPLY IS. AS WE LOOK AT NVIDIA OVER
15:59 MULTIPLE YEARS, JENSEN IS A VISIONARY.
16:02 JENSEN IS ALSO A COORDINATOR. HE COORDINATES OPERATIONS, HE
16:05 COORDINATES RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT.
16:11 AND I THINK HIS PERSONAL IMPLICATION IN THE COMPANY HAS A
16:15 LOT OF VALUE AND WE ARE, INDEED, A BIT DISAPPOINTED.
16:21 THE BOARD IS RINGING OUT JENSEN'S REINSTATEMENT WITHOUT
16:22 -- RULING OUT JENSEN'S REINSTATEMENT WITHOUT THE RESULT
16:25 OF THE INVESTIGATIONS AND RE-THINK THE BOARD SHOULD
16:28 PROBABLY TRY TO ADVANCE ACCOUNTABILITY AGAINST HIM AND
16:33 YOU KNOW, THE COST TO ALL OF THE STAKEHOLDERS OUT THERE OF LOSING
16:36 NVIDIA'S FOUNDER. WHAT DOES NVIDIA LOOK LIKE
16:41 WITHOUT JENSEN? IT IS NOT A ONE-MAN SHOW.
16:46 YOU HAVE 60 DIRECT REPORTS AND WILL HAVE TO LEARN HOW TO
16:49 OPERATE WITHOUT JENSEN, AS THE CENTRAL NUCLEAR REACTOR.
16:52 I THINK THAT IS POSSIBLE, BUT OF COURSE WE CAN -- NVIDIA'S
16:56 COMPETITIVE POSITIONING OVER THE LONG RUN.
17:00 DANI: I WANT TO PUSH BACK ON THIS IDEA THAT IT WAS PREMATURE
17:01 TO HAVE HIM RESIGN AS CEO. WHEN THAT BE A HUGE CLOUD
17:06 OVERHANGING THEM IF HE WAS STILL HERE?
17:09 IT'S PUT ASIDE EVEN THE INVESTIGATION.
17:12 HE IS A MAN -- I HATE TO GET INTO THIS, BUT HAD AN AFFAIR
17:14 WITH AT THE VERY LEAST A CUSTOMER AND A DIRECT REPORT AND
17:18 ANOTHER EMPLOYEE. THAT IS A GOVERNANCE PROBLEM.
17:25 ISN'T THIS SOMETHING THEY REALLY CAN'T ENTERTAIN, THIS IDEA OF AN
17:28 NVIDIA WITH JENSEN HUANG? ANTOINE: YOU MAKE A GREAT POINT.
17:33 I THINK BREACH OF THE CODE OF CONDUCT IS A REALLY SERIOUS
17:35 MATTER. IT DESERVES INVESTIGATION.
17:41 THE QUESTION I'M REALLY ASKING HERE IS, OK, IT WILL BE -- IT
17:46 WOULD MAKE SENSE TO PROBABLY EVEN HAVE SOME PUNISHMENT FOR
17:50 JENSEN, BUT WHY WOULD WE PUNISH SHAREHOLDERS?
17:54 WHY WOULD WE PUNISH EMPLOYEES? WHY WOULD WE PUNISH CLIENTS?
17:59 CHAIN? WE THINK THE BOARD SHOULD HAVE
18:03 APPROACHED THE SITUATION WITH PRUDENCE AND MAYBE JUST SIMPLY A
18:06 MORE OPEN MIND. DANI: I WAS TALKING TO DAN IVES
18:12 THIS MORNING, WHO SAID THE WAY HE VIEWS THAT LETTER FROM JENSEN
18:16 HUANG, THAT IT DIDN'T COME OUT OF NOWHERE.
18:18 HE LIKELY HAS A LOT OF BACKERS. HE SAID, I VIEW THIS AS AN
18:21 ACTIVIST INVESTOR MOMENT. HE THINKS HE MIGHT HAVE A LOT OF
18:26 NVIDIA INVESTORS WHO WANT TO COME TO A PROXY FIGHT WITH THE
18:30 BOARD, MAYBE TRY TO GET NEW BOARD MEMBERS AND EVENTUALLY GET
18:34 JENSEN HUANG REINSTATED AS A CEO.
18:35 THAT HE COULD NOT RULE THAT POSSIBILITY OUT.
18:38 DO YOU THINK THERE MIGHT BE SOME OF THAT ONGOING RIGHT NOW?
18:41 ANTOINE: YES, I THINK SOME OF THAT IS HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
18:44 I THINK HE HAS A LOT OF SUPPORT FROM THE COMPANY.
18:48 WE HAVE SEEN THAT IN A NUMBER OF POLLS OUT THERE AND MAYBE THE
18:52 POLLS WERE ALSO BEFORE THE LATEST, YOU KNOW, DATA POINTS
18:53 AND MULTIPLE AFFAIRS COME OUT. BUT, I MEAN, THERE ARE EXAMPLES
19:03 OF, YOU KNOW, EXECUTIVES WHO RESIGNED AT OTHER COMPANIES OR
19:06 WHO GET FIRED BY THE BOARD AND WHO CAME BACK.
19:11 WE SAW THAT SAM ALTMAN AND OPENAI.
19:27 I THINK THERE MIGHT BE SOME OF THAT HAPPENING AND THE OUTCOME
19:30 IS STILL OPEN-ENDED. DANI: REALLY APPRECIATE YOU FOR
19:34 YOUR TIME THIS MOANING. THAT IS NEW STREET'S ANTOINE
19:36 CHKAIBAN. WE ARE GOING TO DISCUSS THE AI
19:39 TRADE. ELIZABETH BURTON OF FORTRESS
19:43 WILL BE JOINING US. ALSO, BLACKSTONE'S VIRAL PATEL
19:50 ON WHERE HE SEES OPPORTUNITY IN THE AI BOOM.
19:54 THEIR IPO. THIS IS BLOOMBERG "OPEN INTEREST."♪
20:07 DANI: HERE IS HOW YOUR MARKETS ARE SHAPING UP.
20:11 UP BY .5% FOR THE NASDAQ AFTER LOSING NEARLY 3% OVER THE PAST
20:12 WEEK. THE S&P ALSO UP .2%.
20:17 A BID FOR TREASURIES THIS MORNING.
20:19 THERE ARE SOME OF THE MOVERS THIS MORNING.
20:23 WE HAVE TARGETED EARNINGS TO START THE MORNING.
20:24 SHARES HAVE BEEN FLUCTUATING. SLIGHTLY HIGHER NOW.
20:28 THEY HAVE JUST POSTED THEIR THIRD-STRAIGHT INCREASE TO FULL
20:30 YEAR GUIDANCE. HAVE BEEN MAKING PROGRESS IN
20:33 REVIVING GROWTH AFTER THREE YEARS OF DECLINING REVENUE.
20:38 TARGET IS BACK, BABY. ISABELLE: I HAVE NOT BEEN.
20:42 DANI: EVER? ISABELLE: NO.
20:45 DANI: I WAS LIKE, COME ON. ISABELLE: TJX WITH LOW
20:53 ESTIMATES, BUT STOCK POPPING IN PREMARKET.
20:56 DANI: ONE OF THESE CONTINUE TO THINGS IS WHAT IS GOOD FOR THE
20:58 DISCOUNTER IS GOOD FOR THE ECONOMY.
21:01 MAYBE NOT. TAKE-TWO STILL CLIMBING AFTER
21:04 THE FIRST GTA 6 REVIEWS ADDED BUZZ TO WHAT IS EXPECTED TO BE
21:07 THE BIGGEST VIDEOGAME DEBUT IN HISTORY.
21:10 READY PEOPLE ARE CALLING OFF OF WORK, SAYING THEY ARE GOING TO
21:13 BE SICK TO SPEND A DAY SPEED RUNNING THIS THING.
21:16 ISABELLE: YOU AND I WILL BE HERE.
21:16 WE WILL NOT BE PLAYING THAT GAME.
21:20 DANI: I THINK THAT SAYS MORE ABOUT OUR VIDEOCAM HABITS THEN
21:23 COMMITMENT TO THE JOB, WHICH WE ARE OBVIOUSLY COMMITTED TO.
21:26 LESS THAN FOUR MINUTES TO GO UNTIL YOUR OPENING BELL.
21:28 YOU'RE GOING TO BEGIN YOUR TRADING DAY WITH SITARA SUNDAR
21:32 JP MORGAN. THIS IS BLOOMBERG "OPEN INTEREST."♪
21:55 THIS IS BLOOMBERG "OPEN
21:56 INTEREST." MATT MILLER IS OUT AND IT IS A
22:00 LIFT TO THE AI ECOSYSTEM TODAY FOLLOWING NVIDIA'S EARNINGS.
22:07 ANOTHER BEAT, RAISE, INCREASED SHARE BUYBACK.
22:11 BELL TODAY. THE S&P UP .1%.
22:16 THE NASDAQ UP .6%. AGAIN, THE MARKET FEELING SOME
22:22 RELIEF, BUT WE HAVE COME SO FAR. IT HAS BEEN A SHIFT SECTOR THAT
22:27 HAS BEEN HAMMERED. IT HAS BEEN NVIDIA THAT HAS
22:29 GOTTEN HAMMERED. THINGS ARE BETTER THIS MORNING,
22:31 BUT COMING FROM A LOW BASE. ISABELLE: I LIKE THAT CONTEXT,
22:35 BUT YOU ARE RIGHT. NVIDIA IS HIGHER PREMARKET.
22:41 GREEN. DANI LAID IT OUT EARLIER, HIGHER
22:45 BY 1.5%. INVESTORS ARE CHOOSING TO LOOK
22:52 PAST THE LEADERSHIP TURMOIL IN NVIDIA.
22:53 THE COMPANY BOOSTED ITS REVENUE OUTLOOK DESPITE HALTING SALES TO
22:56 CHINA. THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD SAYS
22:59 JEN-HSUN HUANG WILL NOT BE REINSTATED AS CEO, BUT YOU
23:01 LISTENED TO THE EARNINGS CALL. THEY CAN SURVIVE WITHOUT JENSEN
23:04 HUANG AT THE HELM. DANI: I THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF
23:10 QUESTIONS ABOUT LEADERSHIP AND THEIR ABILITY TO COMMUNICATE
23:12 ABOUT WHAT COMES NEXT. THEY WERE, INDEED, COLETTE KRESS
23:17 VERY BULLISH ABOUT AI AND THE ECOSYSTEM.
23:19 THAT MAY BE HELPING GIVE THE TRADE A LIFT THIS MONEY.
23:22 IT IS INTERESTING TO SEE SOME OF THE NEO-CLOUDS WERE DOING
23:26 BETTER, BUT NOW COREWEAVE DOWN ONE POINT 2% AND SEEMINGLY
23:27 GETTING WORSE. DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH
23:32 NVIDIA, A DIFFERENT BEAST WHEN IT COMES TO HOW SUPPORTIVE THEY
23:35 WILL BE FOR FINANCING THE WIDER ECOSYSTEM?
23:38 IT'S BRING IN BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE HEAD OF GLOBAL
23:42 RESEARCH MANDEEP SINGH. WHAT DID YOU MAKE OF THAT
23:43 RELEASE YESTERDAY? MANDEEP: WE ARE IN THIS AI
23:49 SECULAR TRADE AND NOTHING IS GOING TO CHANGE.
23:52 EVEN JENSEN'S DEPARTURE IS NOT GOING TO CHANGE THAT.
23:56 THEY RAISED THE GUIDANCE, SO THAT PART IS CLEAR.
23:59 THE PART THAT I WOULD SAY IS NOT VERY CLEAR TO ME IS, HOW DID
24:03 THEY MANAGE WITHOUT JENSEN WHEN HE CLEARLY WANTS TO COME BACK
24:06 AND HE SAID WE WILL BE FINE, WE'VE GOT THIS ONE, BUT IF HE
24:11 WANTS TO COME BACK I WOULD ARGUE THERE ARE A LOT OF PEOPLE ON THE
24:13 PRODUCT SIDE THAT WANT TO SEE HIM BACK.
24:17 SO, YOU KNOW, THERE IS THAT TENSION, I FEEL, WHEN IT COMES
24:20 TO COLLECT RUNNING THE COMPANY AND JENSEN WANTING TO COME BACK.
24:26 THE OTHER ASPECT IN THE PRINT WAS HYPERSCALERS AS A PERCENT OF
24:27 REVENUE. NEW REVENUE THAT WAS ADDED IS
24:29 INCREASING. WHAT THAT TELLS ME IS, SOMEONE
24:33 LIKE SPACEX WILL PROBABLY PICK UP THE SLACK FROM CHINESE
24:38 REVENUE GOING TO ZERO, AND THAT IS WHERE THE PRICING POWER THAT
24:41 NVIDIA HAS HAD OVER THE LAST COUPLE OF YEARS MAY KIND OF COME
24:47 DOWN A LITTLE BIT, SIMPLY BECAUSE NOW THERE WILL BE MORE
24:50 CONCENTRATION WITH HYPERSCALERS. THIS, THEY WANT ALL OF THE
24:55 SUPPLY THEY CAN, BUT THAT WAS JENSEN'S VISION.
24:58 HE WANTED A FRAGMENTED ECOSYSTEM OF NEO-CLOUDS, SO I DON'T THINK
25:01 THE PRINT CHANGED ANYTHING WITH REGARDS TO THAT.
25:05 NVIDIA? COLETTE KRESS USED WORDS LIKE,
25:12 SPENDING? MANDEEP: I THINK IT IS A GOOD
25:14 THING. THEY PROBABLY HAD TOO MUCH
25:19 FINANCING FOR NEO-CLOUD ECOSYSTEMS.
25:22 SOME OF THAT WOULD NOT HAVE A HIGH ROI.
25:24 AT THE SAME TIME THEY INCREASED THEIR COMMITMENTS TO $93 BILLION
25:28 ON THE EMPLOYER'S SITE. THEY WANT TO MAKE SURE THEY HAVE
25:33 A LOCK ON THE SUPPLIER CHAIN, MEMORY GUYS, TSMC.
25:37 THE NEO-CLOUD IS WHERE THEY WILL BE A LITTLE MORE PRUDENT AND I
25:39 THINK THAT IS A GOOD THING. MAYBE THAT WILL GET REFLECTED IN
25:43 BUYBACKS AND I THINK SHAREHOLDERS WOULD BE HAPPY WITH
25:44 THAT. DANI: THEY CONTINUE ON AND IN
25:49 THE WORDS OF COLETTE KRESS IT IS BUSINESS AS USUAL.
25:51 WHAT CLOUDS STILL REMAIN? ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO AN
25:56 SEC INVESTIGATION ABOUT HAVING TO APPEAR IN FRONT OF
26:00 CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIVE COMMITTEES?
26:04 WHAT QUESTIONS DO WE STILL NEED ANSWERED ABOUT HOW THEY APPROACH
26:06 ESPECIALLY SOUTHEAST ASIA? MANDEEP: I THINK THAT IS WHY NOW
26:11 THEY DON'T EVEN WANT TO SELL THE H20'S, WHICH THEY ARE ALLOWED TO
26:14 SELL. THEY WANT TO BE ON THE
26:18 CONSERVATIVE SIDE, BUT THIS NEEDS TO BE INVESTIGATED.
26:21 WE WILL FIND OUT HOW MAY PEOPLE KNEW ABOUT THIS WITHIN THE
26:26 COMPANY AND THE SHIPMENTS IN ASIA THAT ENDED UP IN CHINA.
26:30 THAT IS WHERE, WHETHER JENSEN COMES BACK OR NOT, IT WILL HINGE
26:34 A LARGE PART ON WHAT COMES OUT OF THE INVESTIGATION AND THE
26:38 EXTENT OF WHAT KIND OF THINGS WERE INVOLVED WHEN IT COMES TO
26:40 SHIPPING THEIR PRODUCTS TO ASIAN COUNTRIES.
26:44 ISABELLE: TOMORROW ANTHROPIC WILL START TRADING.
26:48 WE KNOW IT IS MULTIPLE TIMES OVERSUBSCRIBED.
26:49 PROBABLY SEVEN TIMES. WHAT WILL YOU BE LOOKING AT
26:53 WHETHER IT IS TOMORROW OR NEXT WEEK WHEN IT COMES TO
26:55 ANTHROPIC'S DEBUT? MANDEEP: WHAT IS THE EVENTUAL
26:58 MARGIN PROFILE GOING TO BE? RIGHT NOW EVERYONE IS FIXATED ON
27:04 THAT 25% OF THE COMPUTER BEING USED FOR INFERENCING AND 75%
27:06 BEING USED FOR TRAINING. THE LEVERAGE IS THERE IN THE
27:10 BUSINESS MODEL. THEY HAVE TO SHOW MORE
27:12 PROFITABILITY. THEY CAN CURTAIL THE TRAINING
27:17 SPEND, BUT I THINK EVERYONE WANTS TO KNOW, OUT OF THE
27:22 COMMITMENTS THEY HAVE HOW MUCH OF THOSE COMMITMENTS THEY ARE
27:25 GOING TO SPEND AND HOW IT IS GOING TO TRANSLATE INTO
27:28 PROFITABILITY, BECAUSE OF THE COMPUTE-INTENSIVE NATURE OF
27:29 THEIR BUSINESS MODEL. DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
27:31 JOINING US. THAT IS MANDEEP SINGH.
27:34 LET'S CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION. JOINING US NOW IS SITARA SUNDAR
27:38 AT JP MORGAN. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING
27:41 US. THERE IS SO MUCH GOING ON RIGHT
27:47 NOW FROM YESTERDAY' IS EARNINGS TO ANTHROPIC, AND I WONDER HOW
27:50 MUCH YOU ARE VIEWING THIS IN THE HEALTH OF THE OVERALL ECOSYSTEM?
27:54 HOW IMPORTANT IT WAS TO GET A POSITIVE READ FOR ANTHROPIC OR
27:56 NVIDIA? IMPORTANT IT IS TO GET A SMOOTH
28:02 IPO FROM ANTHROPIC IN ORDER TO KEEP ALL OF THE OTHER AI-RELATED
28:04 INVESTMENTS COMING? SITARA: I THINK VOLATILITY AND
28:11 BULLISH AND BEARISH SENTIMENT TAKES ON A LOT OF DIFFERENT
28:13 WEEKS. WHAT I ULTIMATELY COME BACK TO
28:19 IS THIS IDEA THAT WHERE WE ARE, WE ARE FOUR YEARS INTO THIS
28:23 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE CYCLE AND THAT STILL MEANS IT IS EARLY
28:24 ON. IT FEELS LIKE IT HAS BEEN
28:28 DECADES BUT IT HAS ONLY BEEN A FEW YEARS.
28:31 WHEN THINKING ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY SET AND WHAT THOSE
28:33 DIFFERENT PUZZLE PIECES MEAN, IT MEANS WE HAVE TWO CYCLES THAT
28:41 ARE PLAYING OUT WITHIN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
28:43 WE HAVE GONE FROM A FINANCING PERSPECTIVE, FROM A FINANCING OF
28:48 A LOT OF THE BUILDOUT OF AI INFRASTRUCTURE FROM FREE CASH
28:53 FLOW, TO ONE THAT NEEDS ISSUANCE IN THE DEBT MARKET, TO ONE THAT
28:56 NEEDS ISSUANCE IN THE EQUITY CAPITAL MARKETS.
28:59 WHEN I THINK ABOUT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE MOVING FORWARD I
29:01 THINK THAT WHAT WE ARE SEEING RIGHT NOW IN TERMS OF EITHER
29:05 MORE LENDERS COMING TO THE MARKET AND MORE PLAYERS COMING
29:09 TO THE MARKET AS IT RELATES TO ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND THE
29:11 INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDOUT, WHETHER THAT IS MEMORY, WHETHER THAT IS
29:14 DATA CENTER BUILDOUT, ALL OF THAT IS HEALTHY, BECAUSE
29:16 COMPETITION AT THE END OF THE DAY COULD HELP FROM A BREATH OF
29:20 HER EARNINGS PERSPECTIVE, WHICH IS NEEDED NEED THINK ABOUT THE
29:22 S&P RETURNS MOVING FORWARD. ALL OF IS POSITIVE.
29:27 THE SECOND IS, WHAT DO YOU DO WITH THAT INFRASTRUCTURE?
29:32 HE WENT FROM A CYCLE THAT WAS, I NEED TO INVEST IN ARTIFICIAL
29:36 INTELLIGENCE TO BE ABLE TO HAVE DEMOCRATIZED INTELLIGENCE AT
29:39 SCALE, TO NOW, SHOW ME THE RETURN ON THAT INVESTMENT AND
29:42 WHAT YOU CAN DO WITH THAT INTELLIGENCE.
29:44 THAT IS WHERE WE ARE RIGHT NOW. WE ARE AT THE EARLY -- EARLY
29:46 INNINGS OF THAT INTEGRATION OF AI INTO REAL-WORLD BUSINESSES
29:51 AND REAL BUSINESSES OUTSIDE OF JUST TECH.
29:54 I THINK THE MEGA IPO'S WE HAVE SEEN EARLIER THIS YEAR THAT MAY
29:58 COME TO FRUITION OVER THE NEXT THREE TO SIX MONTHS, ALL OF THAT
30:01 IS A POSITIVE VALIDATION POINT ON THE AMOUNT OF VALUE BEING
30:05 CREATED AND THE APPLICATION LAYER OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
30:08 AND COULD FREE UP CAPITAL FOR WHAT THAT NEXT WAVE OF
30:10 INTEGRATION ACTUALLY ENDS UP LOOKING LIKE.
30:14 WHEN WE MOVE BEYOND JUST FRONTIER MODELS WHAT DOES THAT
30:17 SCALED INTELLIGENCE AT THESE MODELS BRING OPEN UP?
30:22 VERTICAL AI APPLICATIONS, PURPOSE-BUILD WORKFLOWS, TRYING
30:26 TO REDESIGN THE END TO END PROCESSES AND TASKS WE ALL DEAL
30:31 WITH ON A DAY-TO-DAY BASIS. FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTORS,
30:34 INDUSTRIAL SECTORS, PHYSICAL AI. I THINK IT OPENS UP A LOT OF
30:36 OPPORTUNITIES THERE. ISABELLE: ANOTHER THING THAT HAS
30:42 STRUCK ME IN YOUR NOTES IS YOU ARE BULLISH ON NEO-CLOUDS, BUT
30:45 YOU WARNED THEY ARE WHISKED -- ARE RISKY.
30:48 COREWEAVE IS DOWN TODAY, BUT WE HEARD ANTHROPIC SAYING THEIR
30:51 DEALS WITH NEO-CLOUDS TOTAL UP TO $32 BILLION.
30:54 SITARA: I THINK THE ULTIMATE THING ANYWHERE IS, WHERE DO I
30:59 WANT TO LEND AND WHERE DO I WANT TO OWN?
31:02 WE JUST RELEASED 40% OF THAT OUTLOOK WAS RELATED TO
31:06 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE TODAY AND THE INTERESTING THING ABOUT
31:10 NEO-CLOUDS AND THE INTERESTING THING ABOUT THIS NEXT WAVE OF
31:14 ANYWHERE. TO BE A LENDER IN THAT MARKET IS
31:21 A REALLY INTRIGUING POINT, ESPECIALLY GIVEN WHERE SPREADS
31:25 HAVE WOUND UP SO FAR TO BETTER COMPENSATE YOU FOR THE RISK.
31:28 BUT IMPORTANTLY, WE MAKE A DISTINCTION, WHICH IS, WE WOULD
31:30 PREFER TO BE LENDERS TO THE NEO-CLOUDS IN THE PRIVATE
31:36 MARKETS. THE REASON FOR THAT IS, YOU
31:41 THINK ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY -- THE CAPITAL IS NEEDED NO MATTER
31:42 WHAT. WE THINK ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY,
31:46 THE ADVANTAGE YOU COULD GET THROUGH BILATERAL NEGOTIATIONS,
31:52 STRUCTURED PROTECTIONS YOU ARE ABLE TO NEGOTIATE WITHIN THE
31:56 PRIVATE MARKETS BECAUSE YOU ARE A LENDER IN AN INDIVIDUAL
31:59 COMPANY VERSUS SOMETHING THAT IS SYNDICATED, THERE ARE AREAS WE
32:02 ARE STARTING TO SEE NOT DISSIMILAR TO WHAT WE HAVE SEEN
32:06 IN THE PAST WHEN PUBLIC PLAYERS START TO PULL BACK.
32:09 PRIVATE PLAYERS START TO LEAN IN AND THAT CAN CREATE AN
32:11 INTERESTING ENTRY POINT FOR THOSE NAMES.
32:14 DANI: I HAD A CONVERSATION WITH A COUPLE OF PEOPLE AT FORTRESS.
32:18 DREW MCKNIGHT AND THE OTHER CEO SAYING THAT THEY DON'T LIKE
32:22 CREDIT SPECIFICALLY AROUND SOME DATA CENTERS BECAUSE ESSENTIALLY
32:26 WHAT YOU ARE DOING IS, THE RISK LOOKS A LOT LIKE EQUITY RISK BUT
32:29 YOUR UPSIDE IS CAP TO BECAUSE IT IS CREDIT.
32:30 YOU THINK THAT IS FAIR? THAT YOU ARE TAKING EQUITY-LIKE
32:34 RISK CREDIT-LIKE RETURNS? SITARA: IT DEPENDS ON, WHAT PART
32:40 OF THE DATA CENTER ARE YOU FINANCING?
32:41 THE BUILDOUT WHERE THE CHIPS THAT ARE RELATED TO THAT?
32:46 THOSE ARE TWO FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT INVESTMENT PROFILES.
32:49 THEY ARE FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT RISK PROFILES.
32:51 IF YOU ARE LENDING AGAINST COMPUTE, THAT IS A DIFFERENT
32:52 TYPE OF PROFILE. THERE IS AN ABILITY TO GET, AT
32:57 LEAST FROM THE DEALS WE HAVE BEEN THINKING ABOUT THERE IS
33:02 PROTECTIONS. DANI: ISABELLE: WHAT IS THE
33:08 COMPELLING REASON TO PUT CAPITAL IN PRIVATE MARKETS WHEN CASH IS
33:09 LOOKING SO ATTRACTIVE? SITARA: CASH IS KING, CASH IS
33:12 QUEEN. HOWEVER YOU WANT TO SAY IT.
33:17 BUT THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER IS, WHETHER IT IS CASH OR EVEN
33:21 INVESTMENT-GREAT CREDIT, YIELDS HAVE BEEN THE HIGHS THEY HAVE
33:24 BEEN SINCE THE GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS, WHICH MEANS WHERE YOU
33:28 ARE PUTTING YOUR CAPITAL TO WORK, THAT COST OF CAPITAL IS
33:32 HIGHER, SO YOUR RETURNS IN THAT MARKET IS HIGHER.
33:35 BUT THERE IS A FLIP SIDE OF IT, WHICH IS, HIGHER COST OF CAPITAL
33:38 MEANS TWO FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT THINGS.
33:41 WHY IS THAT CAPITAL COST GOING HIGHER AND WHY ARE THOSE YIELDS
33:42 GOING HIGHER? PART OF THE REASON IS BECAUSE OF
33:48 WHAT WE ARE SEEING IN TERMS OF STUBBORN AND STICKY INFLATION.
33:53 HIGHER INFLATION ENVIRONMENTS, HIGHER INFLATION VOLATILITY
33:55 ENVIRONMENTS STOCKS AND BONDS TEND TO MOVE TOGETHER.
33:58 YOU THINK ABOUT ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS HOLISTICALLY I THINK
33:59 ABOUT IT IN TWO WAYS. ONE, ADDING DIVERSIFICATION.
34:03 THINK REAL ASSETS. ESPECIALLY RELATIVE TO VALUE AND
34:09 MACRO TO BUILD AN ADDITIONAL HEDGE.
34:12 THE OTHER SIDE OF IT IS THE HIGHER COST OF CAPITAL
34:15 ENVIRONMENT MEANS WHERE YOU ARE PUTTING YOUR MONEY TO WORK IN
34:19 EQUITY MARKETS YOU NEED TO BE DISCERNING AS WELL.
34:21 EVEN THE CONCENTRATION WE HAVE SEEN WITHIN PUBLIC EQUITY
34:23 MARKETS. AND PRIVATE EQUITY, THE THING
34:26 THAT HAS BEEN HURTING PRIVATE EQUITY IS LACK OF EXPOSURE TO
34:31 THE BUILDOUT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SO FAR.
34:35 IT COULD END UP IN A BOON, BECAUSE IT HAS LESS TECH
34:37 EXPOSURE THAN PUBLIC MARKETS, BUT ALSO AI COULD END UP BEING A
34:43 PRIVATE EQUITY IS. DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
34:46 JOINING US. J.P. MORGAN PRIVATE BANK'S
34:50 SITARA SUNDAR. I WANTED TO SHOW YOU WHAT NVIDIA
34:53 IS DOING, BECAUSE THIS MIGHT BE A PROBLEM.
34:58 EARNINGS. IT WAS UP IN THE PREMARKET.
35:05 IT HAS DIPPED NEGATIVE AND HAS NOW CHANGED.
35:07 AGAIN, THIS COULD BE AN ISSUE FOR NVIDIA.
35:11 THE INTERIM CEO, COLETTE KRESS, TRIED TO COME OUT AND SAY THIS
35:14 IS BUSINESS AS USUAL, WE ARE STILL A STRONG COMPANY.
35:17 75% GROWTH IS WHAT WE ARE EXPECTING.
35:20 THE MARKET IS SELLING NVIDIA. IS IT THAT THEY HAVE MORE
35:25 QUESTIONS TO ASK, OR ARE THEY LIQUIDATING AHEAD OF ANTHROPIC?
35:30 OR ARE WE FORCING IT? THEY SAID NVIDIA COULD SURVIVE
35:35 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG, BUT JEN-HSUN HUANG IS THE VISIONARY.
35:39 THE EARNINGS FELT WRONG BECAUSE IT WAS NOT JENSEN.
35:41 HE IS THE MAN AND THE FACE OF THE AI REVOLUTION.
35:46 DANI: WHAT DO SOUTHEAST ASIA SALES LOOK LIKE?
35:49 WHAT HAPPENS WITH THESE CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIONS?
35:50 A LOT OF UNKNOWNS. IT IS WEIGHING ON THE OVERALL
35:52 STOCK MARKET. JUST WANT TO GIVE YOU A -- TAKE
35:57 STOCK OF WHERE WE ARE. THE S&P IS DIPPING NEGATIVE, NOW
36:01 DATA -- NOW DOWN .1%. THERE WAS BROAD ENTHUSIASM.
36:06 NVIDIA DID WELL. I'M GOING TO TAKE YOU TO WHAT IS
36:08 NEGATIVE. MICROSOFT DOWN .5%.
36:13 MICROSOFT, BY THE WAY, A BIG HOLDER OF ANTHROPIC.
36:16 MACRON IS DOWN. CATERPILLAR.
36:20 YOU DO HAVE A LOT IN THE AI ECOSYSTEM.
36:23 NVIDIA IS ALSO LOW OR TOO THIS MORNING.
36:25 YOU CAN SEE IT IS BOUNCING AROUND A LITTLE BIT.
36:28 NVIDIA DOWN .2%. THAT IS A PROBLEM FOR THIS
36:32 COMPANY, THAT THEY CAN REPORT SUCH A BLOWOUT QUARTER AND TRY
36:38 TO EASE TURMOIL, YET WE CONTINUE TO SELL, LOOKING AT WHAT SOME OF
36:40 THE SECTORS ARE DOING THIS MORNING.
36:42 CONSUMER DISCRETIONARY IS DOING WELL.
36:44 TJX HAD STRONGER EARNINGS. THIS CHRISTIAN AREA DOING WELL.
36:51 ENERGY, AND OIL FALLS, FOLLOWED BY MATERIALS.
36:54 ISABELLE: WE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT NVIDIA AND OTHERS AS WELL.
36:59 TARGET, THEIR TURNAROUND EFFORTS GAINING STEAM.
37:01 A LOOK AT THE RETAIL SECTOR NEXT.
37:03 THIS IS BLOOMBERG "OPEN INTEREST."
37:15 NVIDIA, UNABLE TO HOLD ONTO ITS GAINS.
37:17 THE OPTIMISM QUICKLY TURNING INTO SOMETHING ELSE.
37:20 NVIDIA AT ONE POINT THIS MORNING WAS DOWN SOME 1%.
37:23 NOW DOWN .4%. WAVERING BACK AND FORTH DESPITE
37:27 THE BEAT, STILL LOTS OF QUESTIONS OVER LEADERSHIP ABOUT
37:31 COMPANY. LET'S GET SOME OTHER TOP CALLS
37:33 THIS MORNING. HERE IS NORA.
37:38 NORAH: LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT IS WILL -- WHAT WALL STREET IS
37:40 SAYING ABOUT NVIDIA EARNINGS. AI DEMAND IS STRONG AND
37:45 EXECUTION REMAINS STRONG WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG.
37:48 THE STOCK STILL FINDING A WAY TO SELL OFF THIS MORNING.
37:53 OLDMAN SAYS RESULTS SHOULD BOOST CONFIDENCE IN THE BROADER AI
37:55 TRADE WHILE MORGAN STANLEY CALLS THE OUTLOOK A SIGNIFICANT
37:56 POSITIVE. NEXT UP, CITI DOWNGRADING THE
38:04 NEW YORK TIMES. THE FIRM POINTED TO FEWER APP
38:08 DOWNLOADS AND ACTIVE USERS, ALONG WITH DECLINING ENGAGEMENT.
38:12 FINALLY, JP MORGAN STARTING MANHATTAN ASSOCIATES AT
38:15 OVERWEIGHT, BETTING ITS SHIFT TO THE CLOUD CAN ACCELERATE GROWTH.
38:18 THE FIRM SAYS -- SEES REVENUE GROWTH PICKING UP WHILE MARGINS
38:21 CONTINUE TO IMPROVE, BUT DO SEE THE STOCK TRADING BELOW FLAT
38:23 THIS MONEY. THOSE ARE YOUR TOP CALLS.
38:29 ISABELLE: TURNING TO RETAIL, TARGET RAISING ITS FULL-YEAR
38:32 GUIDANCE AFTER QUARTERLY SALES CAME IN BETTER THAN EXPECTED.
38:36 STEAM. WE WILL SEE MORE FROM EMILY
38:39 CULLEN. IT SEEMS LIKE A GOOD REPORT FROM
38:41 TARGET. WHAT IS THE BIGGEST DRIVER OF
38:44 THESE POSITIVE EARNINGS? EMILY: TARGET IS SEEING
38:49 STORES. THEY HAVE MADE UP BIG EFFORT TO
38:54 TURN AROUND THE FIELD, THE LOOK OF THEIR STORES, AND THEY ARE
38:59 SEEING A BOOST IN MANY OF THEIR CATEGORIES.
39:01 IT WAS INTERESTING, THEY ARE PRETTY UPFRONT ON THE CALL ABOUT
39:04 WHAT THEY NEED TO DO IN HOME AND APPAREL.
39:06 IN APPAREL SPECIFICALLY. THEY HAVE TOO MANY ITEMS, SO
39:10 THEY ARE GOING TO WINNOW THE NUMBER OF STYLES AND LOWERING
39:12 PRICES. SO, MORE OF A FOCUS ON THAT.
39:19 I THINK THERE IS STILL AN OPPORTUNITY THERE, BUT BY AND
39:21 LARGE IT SEEMS LIKE SHOPPERS ARE RESPONDING WELL TO THEIR
39:23 TURNAROUND EFFORTS SO FAR. DANI: IS THIS STILL AN
39:29 ENVIRONMENT -- HERE I WANT TO WORK IN TJX AS WELL -- THAT
39:31 VALUE IS IMPORTANT FOR THE CONSUMER?
39:34 EMILY: I THINK THAT IS 100% TRUE.
39:38 NONE OF THE REASONS T.J. MAXX IS UP IS BECAUSE THINGS ARE ON THE
39:41 RIGHT TRACK AFTER LAST QUARTER AND THINGS WERE A BIT WEAKER.
39:45 THEY ARE SHOWING SIGNS THEY CAN GET BACK INTO THEIR BED -- BREAD
39:47 AND BUTTER, WHICH IS WINNING OVER THE CONSUMER ON VALUE.
39:50 I THINK THERE IS A LOT OF STIFF COMPETITION.
39:54 BURLINGTON, ROSS ARE ALSO UP. TARGET AS WELL.
40:02 T.J. MAXX REALLY NEEDS TO DO WHAT DIFFERENTIATES ITSELF WHEN
40:04 IT COMES TO OFFERING, YOU KNOW, PEOPLE THIS TREASURE HUNT
40:09 EXPERIENCE OF FINDING GOOD DEALS AND I THINK THE RESULTS TODAY
40:13 GAVE INVESTORS HOPE THAT IS WORKING.
40:17 ISABELLE: TARGET SAID IT IS APPEALING TO VALUE-HUNGRY
40:21 SHOPPERS WITH LOWERING PRICES IN THE THIRD QUARTER, BUT HOW MUCH
40:25 LONGER CAN THEY ABSORB THOSE COSTS BEFORE THEY PASS IT ON TO
40:28 CONSUMERS, WHO ARE ALREADY FEELING THE PINCH?
40:32 EMILY: I THINK THAT WAS SOMETHING INVESTORS CONSIDER
40:34 THIS MORNING. A BIG PART OF THEIR EPS WAS
40:39 BOOSTED BY TARIFF REFUNDS, WHICH IS NOT SOMETHING THAT IS GOING
40:41 TO SUSTAIN. I THINK TARGET REALIZES IF THEY
40:45 DON'T HAVE VALUE, THAT IS CORE TO THEIR BRAND.
40:49 I THINK THEY ARE GOING TO CONTINUE TO DO THAT.
40:50 WE HEARD THEM SAY THAT TODAY. LOWERING PRICES ON HUNDREDS OF
40:53 ITEMS AND APPAREL. SO, I THINK THAT IS PART OF THE
40:56 PLAN. DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
40:59 JOINING US. THAT IS EMILY CULLEN.
41:07 NVIDIA DOWN. MORE AFTER THIS BREAK.
41:27 ISABELLE: A QUICK CHECK ON NVIDIA.
41:31 IT RAISED ITS -- IT ERASED ITS OPENING GAINS, THOUGH IT IS NOW
41:32 BOUNCING HIGHER. IT IS REMARKABLE, BECAUSE IT
41:37 ENDED THE DAY YESTERDAY IN THE GREEN, AND WE TALKED ABOUT IT
41:38 DURING PREMARKET. NOW IT IS SINKING.
41:41 I WONDER WHAT CHANGED? DANI: IT WAS UP AS MUCH AS 5%.
41:47 THERE IS NO SPECIFIC CATALYST FOR THIS, BUT SO MANY QUESTIONS
41:50 ARE SURROUNDING NVIDIA AND THIS IS A PROBLEM FOR THIS COMPANY.
41:54 IF THEY CANNOT GET THE BALANCE AFTER REPORTING A QUARTER WITH A
41:56 BEAT AND RAISE AND CONTINUED BUYBACK TRYING TO PROTECT --
42:01 PROJECT CONFIDENCE, IS THIS A FAILURE OF LEADERSHIP?
42:04 IS THIS SO MANY UNANSWERED QUESTIONS WHEN IT COMES TO SALES
42:06 IN SOUTHEAST ASIA? IT'S GOING TO BE A PROBLEM
42:11 USUAL. HE FEELS ANYTHING BUT.
42:16 ISABELLE: WITHOUT JENSEN, WHAT WILL HAPPEN WITH THESE DEALS?
42:18 THE CIRCULAR FINANCING? THEY ARE HALTING DATA CHIPS TO
42:21 CHINA. DANI: THAT SHOWS HOW
42:25 CONSERVATIVE THEY ARE ABOUT ASIA.
42:27 THAT THEY ARE ABLE TO SELL H20'S, BUT NOT DOING SO TO
42:30 CHINA. THIS MARKET IS PRICING IN THIS
42:35 IDEA THAT WE -- WE MIGHT HAVE LESS DEMAND.
42:38 PROPER TAKING AN ABSOLUTE BAT THIS MORNING.
42:40 THE OVERALL MARKET, THE S&P IS DOWN.
42:43 THE NASDAQ FIGHTS FOR GAINS. I WANT TO POINT OUT, IT IS
42:47 INTERESTING TO LOOK AT THE TEN-YEAR RALLY.
42:50 YIELDS ARE DOWN NEARLY THREE BASIS POINTS EVEN THOUGH
42:52 CHRISTOPHER WALLER ON CNBC, SAYING, IF WE DO NOT SIGNAL WE
42:58 ARE GOING TO GET ANOTHER HIKE, HE WOULD BE ADVOCATING FOR
43:04 HIKING IF THE BASIS POINTS COME DECEMBER.
43:06 AND EVEN SO, 10-YEAR YIELDS ARE RALLYING.
43:08 THAT SHOWS YOU THERE IS A LOT OF HAVEN DEMAND RIGHT NOW.
43:10 ISABELLE: IS HE TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF A WEAKENING LABOR
43:11 MARKET? AGAIN, MORE QUESTIONS THAN
43:14 ANSWERS. DANI: HE SAYS THAT 3% IS
43:19 BECOMING ENTRENCHED FOR SO MANY. THAT IS THE ISSUE, THAT HE
43:24 THINKS CONSUMERS EXPECT THAT AND HE WANTS TO GET OUT AHEAD OF IT.
43:28 UNDER PRESSURE, SOME EARNINGS AND VIDEO GAMES DOING WELL.
43:31 COMING UP, WE ARE GOING TO TALK WITH ELIZABETH BURTON OF THE
43:33 FORTRESS ON THE AI TRADE. ♪
43:48 DANI: WE ARE 30 MINUTES INTO YOUR TRADING DAY.
43:50 WELCOME TO "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."
43:53 I AM DANI BURGER ALONGSIDE ISABELLE LEE.
43:56 STOCKS BARELY POSITIVE. A STRUGGLE TO HOLD ONTO GAMES
44:01 BECAUSE NVIDIA, FIRST RELIEF AND THAT FADES FAST, SHARES GIVING
44:04 UP GAINS. THE PUMP DO NOT FORGET THE
44:08 SPOTLIGHT ON ANTHROPIC, WHICH COULD PULL OFF ONE OF THE
44:12 BIGGEST IPO'S OF ALL TIME. DANI: THE GLOBAL AI RACE, TRUMP
44:19 AND XI PREPARE FOR TALKS. ISABELLE: NVIDIA INTERIM CEO
44:23 SAID THERE IS NO SIGN OF AN AI SLOW DOWN, EVEN AS THEY LIMIT
44:27 SALES TO CHINA. >> WE DID LOOK AT AN ASSESSMENT
44:31 IN TERMS OF THE CURRENT EXPORT CONTROLS, STILL GOING TO SPEND
44:36 SOME TIME STUDYING THOSE TO SEE THE PIECES OF IT, BUT WE FEEL
44:39 CONFIDENT AND TERMS OF BOTH THE DEMAND WE HAVE IN FRONT OF US
44:42 AND THE SUPPLY AND ADDITIONAL SUPPLY.
44:47 ISABELLE: THE NVIDIA REALLY IS LOSING STEAM, GIVING UP GAINS.
44:52 NOW LOWER BY .3 PERCENT. JOINING AS IS ED LUDLOW.
44:58 THAT WAS A QUICK END TO MY OPTIMISM.
45:01 WHAT ARE INVESTORS DIGESTING? THEY ARE REACTING NEGATIVELY.
45:05 ED: WORTH REMEMBERING THAT MAINTAINING THE OUTLOOK WAS THE
45:10 ABSOLUTE BARE MINIMUM. ONE SESSION A MARKET DOES NOT
45:13 MAKE, BUT IN THE MOMENT WHEN THE RELEASE HIT AND WE STUDIED THE
45:17 CFO LETTER, THE NEAR TERM WAS INTACT.
45:19 THAT WAS RELIEF REFLECTED IN THE TRADING.
45:22 THE SOUND BITE YOU PLAYED IS LIKE, OK, THE GROWTH OUTLOOK FOR
45:30 FISCAL 2028 75%, IT REFLECTS DEMAND IS ACCELERATING AND
45:33 CONTINUES TO BE BEYOND SUPPLY. SUPPLY IS IMPROVING.
45:39 THE NEO-CLOUD DEBATE ALL MORNING LONG, IT IS CLEAR, THE CAPITAL
45:45 AUTHORITY AS THEIR SUPPLY CHAIN. GREASE THE WHEELS ON SUPPLY.
45:49 THE INDIRECT CHINA REVENUES, WHAT SHE IS TALKING ABOUT, IS AN
45:54 OVERHANG FROM CALENDAR 2027 THAT WE DO NOT REALLY HAVE ANSWERS
45:55 TO. THEY SAID THEY ARE STUDYING IT.
46:02 DANI: LOOKING AT THE NVIDIA AND TECH SELLING, ALSO LOOKING AT
46:07 THE UPCOMING ANTHROPIC IPO, LOOKING AT 2028 AND LISTING ON
46:10 THURSDAY. ED: IT WAS SAID THAT PEOPLE ARE
46:15 POSITIONING AND GETTING READY. IN THE REPORTING, IT IS NOT JUST
46:19 THAT THIS ANTHROPIC IPO IS OVERSUBSCRIBED.
46:23 INSTITUTIONS WERE GOING IN FOR BIG BLOCKS, AND THE $5 BILLION
46:27 INCREMENT OR $10 BILLION INCREMENT, LOTS OF PEOPLE WILL
46:31 BE DISAPPOINTED ON THAT SIDE. SOME WENT FOR MORE MODEST
46:34 ALLOCATIONS, THEY KNOW THEY WILL NOT GET THEM.
46:37 THINKING FRIDAY, I AM IN THE MARKET ON THIS IPO, I DO NOT
46:42 KNOW WHETHER THEY ARE SELLING TO GET READY FOR THAT OR NOT.
46:46 BUT THE TRADING IS REASONABLE TO THINK ABOUT THAT.
46:49 ISABELLE: WE LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR SHOW AT 11:00 A.M. EASTERN.
46:53 JOINING US NOW IS THE FORTRESS CHIEF STRATEGIST, ELIZABETH
47:00 BURTON. WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS?
47:04 STILL HARD TO POSITION YOURSELF WITH NVIDIA JUST REPORTING AND
47:07 ANTHROPIC TOMORROW. ELIZABETH: I THINK ONE OF THE
47:11 IMPORTANT THINGS TO REMEMBER IS THAT INVESTORS ARE ALREADY
47:16 HEAVILY EXPOSED TO AI. AT FORTRESS, WE HAVE LOOKED AT
47:24 U.S. PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS, ALONG WITH PENSIONS AND INSTITUTIONAL
47:26 INVESTORS, PRIVATE WEALTH INVESTORS, AND FAMILY OFFICES,
47:29 AND FOR THE U.S. INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS, THEY GOT EXPOSURE TO
47:33 AI THROUGHOUT THEIR PORTFOLIO. NOT A BUCKET.
47:38 SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 13% AND 30%. PRIVATE WELL SOMEWHERE BETWEEN
47:42 14% AND 30%. FAMILY OFFICES BETWEEN 10% AND
47:46 25%. WHAT IS INTERESTING IS THAT FOR
47:49 THE FIRST TWO, U.S. PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS AND PRIVATE WEALTH,
47:52 THEIR FIXED INCOME AND CASH TOGETHER ARE LOWER THAN THEIR
47:57 EXPOSURE TO AI IN MANY CASES. SO WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE
48:01 TRYING TO MAKE A BED HERE, IT IS PROLIFIC THROUGHOUT THEIR
48:02 PORTFOLIOS. THEY NEED TO BE THINKING ABOUT,
48:06 WHEN ASKING FOR THESE BIG ALLOCATIONS.
48:08 DANI: DO YOU THINK THAT THAT THINKING HAS STARTED TO SHIFT?
48:11 GIVEN THIS SELLING WE HAVE HAD, DO YOU THINK THIS IS STILL A
48:15 WIDE SWATH OF INVESTORS, ESPECIALLY THE MORE RETAIL
48:18 HOUSEHOLD ORIENTED ONES THAT ARE BUYING THE DIP, CHASING THOSE
48:22 GAINS, OR DO YOU THINK THAT HAS STARTED TO SHIFT AND MAYBE WE
48:25 START TO COME ON THE MARGINS, GET MORE OF AN ALLOCATION TO
48:28 FIXED INCOME? ELIZABETH: THERE IS SOMEWHAT OF
48:38 A FOMO ATMOSPHERE. WE SAW SOME IN THE TECH BUBBLE.
48:41 IT IS HARD TO TIME THE TOP OF THIS BUBBLE, BUT I THINK
48:44 INVESTORS ARE GETTING MORE DISCERNING ON THE EQUITY AND
48:45 CREDIT SIDE. I THINK THAT IS A GOOD THING.
48:50 SOME OF WHAT WE SAW WAS NOT BABY WITH THE BATHWATER BUT THINKING,
48:53 LET'S LOOK AT THESE ON A FUNDAMENTAL BASIS.
48:57 WITH NVIDIA, THE MULTIPLES ACTUALLY LOOK PRETTY GOOD NOW,
49:00 AND THE REPORT WAS PRETTY GOOD. WHAT WE COULD GET INTO DOWN THE
49:05 ROAD IS MORE GOOD NEWS IS BAD NEWS AND BAD NEWS IS BAD NEWS
49:08 SCENARIOS, AND THAT IS WHAT WE HAVE TO THINK ABOUT.
49:11 ISABELLE: WE TALK ABOUT THE K-SHAPED ECONOMY, BUT YOU TALK
49:13 ABOUT THE K-SHAPED AI TRADE. TALK ABOUT THE BIGGEST WINNERS
49:17 AND LURES -- LOSERS. NEO-CLOUDS, MEMORY CHIP, AND
49:21 CHIP MEMBERS WERE ALL GAINING. WHO DO YOU THINK WILL BE THE BIG
49:24 WINNERS AND LOSERS? ELIZABETH: I CANNOT TAKE CREDIT
49:29 FOR THE K-SHAPED CREDIT, BUT I WILL SAY THIS, WE HAVE SEEN OVER
49:33 THE LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS AND MAYBE EVEN MONTHS YIELDS HIGHER
49:40 ON SOME OF THESE AI HARD-HIT NAMES AND GETTING MUCH TIGHTER
49:43 SPREADS, WHERE YOU SEE THE BENEFICIARIES OF THESE TRADES.
49:46 SO IT IS PEOPLE PICKING THROUGH THE WINNERS AND LOSERS OF WHAT
49:49 MIGHT HAPPEN HERE. I THINK IT IS REALLY HARD TO
49:52 FIND INVESTMENTS THAT ARE NOT EXPOSED TO THE AI TRADE AND
49:55 WHERE YOU DO NOT HAVE TO KNOW WHAT THE OUTCOME IS GOING TO BE.
49:59 I THINK THE LAST TIME I WAS ON I TALKED ABOUT PATENTS IN THAT
50:02 RESPECT, BECAUSE YOU DO NOT NECESSARILY HAVE TO GET IT
50:03 RIGHT. NOW YOU CAN SEE THE ONES WITH
50:10 HEAVY CASH FLOWS AND ORDERS ON THE BOOKS, THAT HAVE SHORED UP
50:12 THEIR SUPPLY CHAINS, WHEN YOU GET SPECIFIC ON WHAT THE
50:18 HEALTH'S OVERALL, IF YOU LOOK AT SPREADS ON SINGLE ASSET DATA
50:22 CENTERS, I THINK THAT IS WHAT YOU ARE SEEING INVESTORS START
50:26 TO DO, START TO PICK THROUGH THE HAYSTACK.
50:30 DANI: THE NEW FORTRESS TEAM HAS BEEN EXCELLENT AND SAYING THERE
50:32 ARE RISKS IN THE ECOSYSTEM THAT HAVE BEEN OVERLOOKED.
50:35 I WONDER IF SOMETHING CHANGES AFTER YESTERDAY.
50:38 IF YOU HAVE AN NVIDIA THAT SAYS WE WILL BE MORE DISCERNING ON
50:42 HOW WE FINANCE PROJECTS, ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS LOOK AT AUGUST
50:48 WHEN THEY HAD THAT $500 BILLION ESSENTIALLY COMMITMENT OF
50:50 THIRD-PARTY CAPITAL TO COME IN AND FOUND THE AI ECOSYSTEM.
50:53 DO YOU THINK THINGS LIKE THAT WILL ALSO BE RETHOUGHT IF NVIDIA
50:58 IS LESS WILLING TO LEND TO THESE GREAT COMPANIES?
51:00 ELIZABETH: WE WILL SEE. HONESTLY, I THINK IT HAS LONG
51:03 ROOM TO PLAY OUT. YESTERDAY MEETING WITH AN
51:05 INVESTOR, HE SAID I THINK I WILL LOOK BACK A YEAR FROM NOW AND
51:10 THINK, WOW, FALL WAS LOW LAST YEAR.
51:12 DANI: THAT DOES NOT MAKE ME FEEL GOOD.
51:14 ELIZABETH: IT IS A CRAZY THING TO THINK ABOUT.
51:16 IT LEADS TO CONCERNS ABOUT WHAT WE ARE TALKING ABOUT WITH AI.
51:24 COMING ONLINE NOW AND COMMENTING ON WHO SHOULD BE THE NEXT CEO OF
51:27 NVIDIA. WE HAVE NOT HAD ACTIVE TREASURY
51:32 SECRETARY COMMENTING ON A HEALTHY COMPANY REALLY EVER.
51:36 YOU THINK ABOUT GM AND AIG, THAT WAS IN THE MIXED OF A SORT OF
51:40 CRISIS, UNSUCCESSFUL COMPANIES AT THE TIME.
51:42 SO IF WE GET TO A POINT NEXT THERE WERE PEOPLE ARE SAYING,
51:45 WOW, THE EARNINGS GROWTH WE SAW LAST YEAR, 30% QC, 20% TO TWO,
51:51 IF YOU GET BELOW 20%, THEY MAY SAY THIS IS TERRIBLE.
51:55 YOU THINK ABOUT THE 20 YEARS PRE-2026, 4.1% WAS AVERAGE,
52:01 BEFORE THAT, 6.5%. CRAZY NUMBERS.
52:04 WE LEVEL SETTING IT HERE. TO DOVETAIL, ALMOST LIKE THE --
52:09 INFLATION, YOU START TO THINK 3% IS NORMAL.
52:11 LIKES FROGS AND WATER. DANI: DO YOU THINK THAT IS IN
52:15 THE PSYCHE NOW? THEY TALKED ABOUT THAT ON CNBC,
52:20 PEOPLE TALK ABOUT EXPECTING TO PERCENT IS JUST INFLATION.
52:23 ELIZABETH: I AM GLAD SOMEONE KIND OF SAID IT.
52:27 YES, IT HAS BEEN 3% FOR WILLING TALK -- LONG TIME.
52:31 I SAID AND OCTOBER, NOT HIKING, I SAID YOUR ODDS OF A 50 POINT
52:35 INCREASE HAVE NOW GONE UP. I FELT PRETTY VINDICATED WHEN I
52:39 HEARD WALLER THIS MORNING TALKING ABOUT THAT.
52:40 WILL THEY DO THAT? NOT MY BASE CASE, BUT THE ODDS
52:42 ARE HIGHER. WHEN I SAID IT, THE ODDS OF ONE
52:45 HIKE WAS ONLY 83%. HE MAKES AN EXCELLENT POINT ON
52:49 FORWARD GUIDANCE. IF THERE IS NO FORWARD GUIDANCE
52:52 AND YOU DO 25 POINT BASIS POINT HIKES, DOES NOT MEAN MUCH FOR
52:56 THE MARKETS FOR JANUARY. THEY SHOULD TAKE INFLATION
52:57 SERIOUSLY. YOU CAN SEE IT IS NOT
53:00 NECESSARILY TRENDING DOWN, AT LEAST OVER THE LAST COUPLE
53:02 MONTHS. HOW MUCH INSIGHT DO WE HAVE
53:06 ENTERED SOME OF THE INFLATIONARY PRESSURES PASSING THROUGH?
53:12 ELIZABETH: I THINK SO. HE IS PROBABLY NOT THE ONLY ONE.
53:16 I PARSED THROUGH WHO I THINK MIGHT VOTE IN FAVOR OF A HIKE.
53:20 IT IS ONLY REALLY ONE I COULD NOT DETERMINE, AND THAT WOULD BE
53:23 POWELL BECAUSE HE IS NOT SAYING ANYTHING.
53:25 WE DEFINITELY HAVE A HIKE ON THE TABLE, WHETHER IT WILL BE 50 OR
53:30 NOT, WE WILL SORT THAT OUT. DANI: THANK YOU FOR JOINING US,
53:34 ELIZABETH BURTON A FORTRESS. NVIDIA STILL NEGATIVE THIS
53:36 MORNING. THE S&P UNCHANGED, BUT THE
53:38 NASDAQ MOVING HIGHER. LET'S LOOK AT INDIVIDUAL MOVERS.
53:45 >> FIRST UP, AI INFRASTRUCTURE STOCKS FLUCTUATING THIS MORNING
53:50 AFTER NVIDIA SALES OUTLET REASSURED INVESTORS ABOUT THE
53:53 STRENGTH OF AI DEMAND. BROADCOM IS CURRENTLY TRADING
53:54 HIGHER. LOWS RAISING SALES OUTLOOK FOR
54:00 THE YEAR, POSITIVE SIGN FOR DEMAND.
54:03 BUT THE PROFIT PICTURE IS MORE CAUTIOUS WITH MERCHANDISE, FUEL,
54:05 AND TRANSPORTATION COSTS WEIGHING ON THE OUTLOOK.
54:09 SHARES OF LOWE'S TRADING LOWER BY ABOUT 1%.
54:13 STICKING WITH RITA, TARGET WITH BETTER THAN EXPECTED QUARTERLY
54:15 SALES AND RAISING THE FULL YEAR GUIDE FOR THE THIRD TIME AND A
54:18 ROW. IT SIGNALS THE RETAILER IS
54:21 MAKING PROGRESS AND REVIVING GROWTH UNDER ITS NEW CEO.
54:26 SHARES HIGHER BY MORE THAN 5%. NOT SURE IF WE CALL IT TARGET OR
54:32 TAR-JAY. DANI: BLACKSTONE HAS MADE ONE OF
54:38 THE BIGGEST BETS ON AI, AND WE WILL SPEAK WITH THE MAN BEHIND
54:42 MANY OF THOSE BIG BETS, ANTHROPIC BEING ONE OF THEM.
54:45 VIRAL PATEL OF BXPE WILL BE JOINING US.
54:46 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."
54:58 MEGA IPO'S FROM
55:00 EARLIER THIS YEAR MAY COME TO FRUITION OVER THE NEXT THREE TO
55:05 SIX MONTHS IS ALL A POSITIVE WITH THE AMOUNT OF VALUE BEING
55:07 CREATED AND THE APPLICATION LAYER OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
55:10 AND COULD FREE UP CAPITAL FOR WHAT THAT NEXT WAVE OF
55:13 INTEGRATION ACTUALLY LOOKS LIKE. DANI: BANKHEAD OF ALTERNATIVE
55:20 INVESTMENT STRATEGIST, ANTHROPIC PREPARES TO GO PUBLIC.
55:25 BLACKSTONE HAS BEEN ONE OF WALL STREET'S BIGGEST BETTORS ON THE
55:28 AI ECOSYSTEM, ALSO A LARGE INVESTOR IN ANTHROPIC.
55:33 OTHERWISE, BLACKSTONE'S PRIVATE EQUITY FUND FOR WEALTHY
55:36 INDIVIDUALS PEER THE FUND HAS ABOUT $30 BILLION IN ASSETS
55:40 WITHIN ANNUALS NET RETURN OF ABOUT 18%.
55:43 JOINING US NOW IS VIRAL PATEL, CEO OF BXPE.
55:48 WHAT A BIG WEEK. I GOT A CALL YESTERDAY WAS
55:52 SOMEONE SAYING ANTHROPIC HAS SET OUT THE EMBARGO ON WHAT WE CAN
55:54 TALK ABOUT. I WILL NOT ASK ABOUT PRICING,
55:58 BUT THIS IS A BIG TEST FOR THINGS LIKE AI DEMAND COME ABOUT
56:01 TOMORROW WITH ANTHROPIC AND NVIDIA EARNINGS YESTERDAY.
56:04 WHAT ARE YOU SEEING? WHERE IN THIS ECOSYSTEM IS STILL
56:08 ROBUST AND CHUGGING ALONG, AND IS THERE ANYTHING THAT MIGHT
56:12 GIVE YOU PAUSE? VIRAL: FIRST, WE HAVE BEEN BIG
56:15 BACKERS OF ANTHROPIC FOR SOME TIME NOW, DATING BACK TO THE
56:20 SERIES F ROUND. WONDERFUL BUSINESS, AND WE ARE
56:23 EXCITED TO SEE WHAT COMES IN THE NEXT FEW DAYS.
56:26 ON THE DEMAND PICTURE, WHAT I SAY IS WE ARE SEEING NO SLOWDOWN
56:29 IN DEMAND. WE ARE SEEING ACCELERATION AND
56:32 DEMAND ACROSS ALL BUSINESS ENTITIES.
56:37 WE OWN OVER 280 COMPANIES AT BLACKSTONE AND HAVE TAKEN TOKEN
56:39 SPENDING OVER 20 X IN THE LAST YEAR.
56:44 IT IS US AT THE BOARD LEVEL REALLY PUSHING OUR COMPANIES TO
56:47 FIND INNOVATIVE WAYS TO DRIVE REVENUE WITH PRODUCTIVITY GAINS
56:50 IN OUR BUSINESSES. ONE OF THE THINGS WE'RE ARE
56:55 FINDING IS WE'RE SO EARLY IN TERMS OF PEOPLE EVEN
56:57 UNDERSTANDING WHAT THEY CAN DO WITH THIS TECHNOLOGY THAT
57:01 THERE'S A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF RUNWAY GOING FORWARD.
57:03 ONE OF THE THINGS WE HAVE STARTED DOING WITH OUR OWN CEO'S
57:09 AND CTO'S IS BRINGING THEM ON THIS AI ACCELERATION JOURNEY.
57:12 WE TAKE OUR MANAGEMENT TEAMS TO M.I.T. FOR TWO DAYS TO SIT DOWN
57:18 AND UNDERSTAND WHAT IS CAPABLE, BUT THEY CAN THINK ABOUT,
57:21 BUILDING BUSINESS USE CASES. AND WE ARE SEEING TREMENDOUS
57:23 OUTPUT FROM THAT. COMPANIES ON THE ACCOUNTING
57:28 SIDE, SEEING 50% REDUCTION IN INTAKE EFFORTS.
57:32 APPLIED BENEFITS IN THE HEALTH CARE SPACE,'S CALL CENTER TIMES
57:37 DOWN 30% WHEN 98 PERCENT AI ACCURACY.
57:38 WHEN YOU SEE SIGNALS LIKE THAT AND SEE THE CEO'S PUSHING TO
57:42 SAY, WOW, THERE IS SO MUCH WE HAD NOT EVEN THOUGHT OF, THAT
57:46 GIVES US A LOT OF CONFIDENCE THAT THE DEMAND SIDE FOR AI WILL
57:50 BE SIGNIFICANT GOING FORWARD. DANI: SO MUCH HAPPENING, BUT THE
57:54 PRIVATE EQUITY AND CONCERN ABOUT INDIGESTION, I WONDER HOW
57:57 IMPORTANT IT IS TO GET A BIG IPO LIKE ANTHROPIC TO SET THE TONE
58:01 FOR WHAT IS TO COME AFTER THAT, ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO
58:05 EXITS, AI, OR OTHERWISE. VIRAL: IT HAS BEEN A PRETTY
58:11 GOOD YEAR FOR EXITS. MAYBE IPOS WERE NOT AS STRONG AS
58:16 WE THOUGHT AT THE START OF THE AIR, BUT WE STILL HAVE FIVE
58:20 IPO'S GLOBALLY AT BLACKSTONE THIS YEAR.
58:21 WE FOUND THE PUBLIC MARKETS ARE RECEPTIVE TO LARGE IMPORTANT
58:26 COMPANIES THAT PLAY AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN THE ECOSYSTEM.
58:31 SO WE ARE FINDING THAT IN THIS MARKET, WE CAN TAKE COMPANIES
58:36 PUBLIC, AND WE HAVE ABILITY TO SELL ASSETS TO STRATEGIC'S.
58:39 THERE IS ACTIVITY ON THAT SIDE, AS WELL.
58:41 I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS IPO AS
58:45 IT. POST THAT, I THINK THAT WILL
58:51 OPEN UP MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR OTHERS TO CONSIDER.
58:56 ISABELLE: HOW ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY IN
59:00 INVESTING IN AI IN THESE VALUATIONS?
59:02 THE AI BUBBLE REPORTER TALKED ABOUT WHETHER WE ARE IN ONE.
59:06 YOU ALSO SAID WE ARE IN THE EARLY DAYS, SO IT MUST BE HARD
59:08 TO PUT A PRICE ON IT. VIRAL: A COUPLE THINGS, WHEN WE
59:14 THINK ABOUT CLASSIC BUBBLES, THEY TYPICALLY ARE PEOPLE
59:17 BUILDING SUPPLY BEFORE DEMAND. THERE IS THE OTHER SIDE OF THAT.
59:20 THE DEMAND SIDE FEELS REALLY CERTAIN.
59:24 I THINK THE BIGGER QUESTION IS WHETHER THE SUPPLY CAN COME ON
59:28 FAST ENOUGH TO MEET THE DEMAND. I SEE LESS CONCERN AROUND
59:31 WHETHER THIS APPLIED THAT IS COMING ONLINE IS GOING TO HAVE
59:36 OPPORTUNITIES TO GO FULFILL THAT COMPUTE.
59:38 I THINK IT IS THE OTHER WAY. A LOT OF TIMES WHEN YOU TALK
59:43 ABOUT PRICING THAT RISK, WHAT WE TEND TO LOOK FOR ARE AREAS OF
59:47 THE ECONOMY WHERE WE SEE PERSISTENT SUPPLY DEMAND
59:48 IMBALANCE. IF YOU CAN FIND THINGS LIKE
59:52 THAT, THAT TENDS TO BE A GOOD PLACE TO PUT CAPITAL TO WORK.
59:56 TODAY, THAT IS IN THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE LAYER, WITHIN
59:58 COMPUTE. THE DEMAND IS THERE, SUPPLY WILL
1:00:00 NOT KEEP UP. WE THINK THAT WILL PERSIST FOR
1:00:02 SEVERAL YEARS. AS A RESULT, I THINK THERE'S
1:00:07 OPPORTUNITIES, PARTICULARLY IN PRIVATE MARKETS, TO PICK CAPITAL
1:00:13 TO WORK AND SMART WAYS IN THAT COMPUTE LAYER THAT CAN DRIVE A
1:00:16 LOT OF EXCESS RETURN. DANI: DO YOU THINK THERE WILL
1:00:18 STILL BE APPETITE IN PRIVATE MARKETS TO INVEST IN THINGS LIKE
1:00:20 CLOUDS? YOU HAVE SOMEONE LIKE NVIDIA
1:00:25 SAYING WE ARE GOING TO BE MORE PRUDENT AND CAREFUL AND WILL
1:00:27 COMMIT TO INVESTMENT GRADE PARTNERS.
1:00:29 BUT DOES THAT CHANGE THE DYNAMIC TO HAVE NVIDIA, WHICH HAS BEEN A
1:00:32 BIG BACKER OF THE ECOSYSTEM, START TO CHANGE IN STONE?
1:00:37 VIRAL: I THINK THE NEO-CLOUDS ARE AN INTERESTING PLACE RIGHT
1:00:38 NOW. I THINK PEOPLE ARE CONFLATING
1:00:44 CAPITAL WOULD DEMAND. THE DEMAND FOR WHAT THE NEOCONS
1:00:46 ARE PROVIDING IS INCREDIBLY STRONG.
1:00:49 LOOK AT THE EARNINGS LAST WEEK IS A GOOD INDICATION.
1:00:51 THEY ARE NOT HAVING TROUBLE SELLING THE COMPUTE THEY HAVE.
1:00:55 IF YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT IS GOING ON TODAY WITH SUPPLY POTENTIALLY
1:00:59 ELONGATED A LITTLE BIT, ANYONE WITH EXISTING SUPPLY, THAT IS
1:01:01 MORE VALUABLE TODAY. THEY ARE ABLE TO RELEASE IN THE
1:01:07 8:00 COMMUNITY, THE GPU'S COME AT HIGHER RATES.
1:01:09 I THINK THE POSITION THEY ARE STARTING FROM IS A STRONG ONE.
1:01:13 THE QUESTION YOU'RE RAISING IS CORRECT, WE DO HAVE TO THINK
1:01:18 ABOUT WHERE THE CAPITAL WILL BE COMING FROM IN THE ECOSYSTEM.
1:01:20 YOU ARE SEEING MARKETS START TO THINK A LITTLE MORE ABOUT -- A
1:01:24 LITTLE MORE DISCERNING. FOR US AT BLACKSTONE, WE HAVE
1:01:30 KIND OF ALWAYS TAKEN THAT APPROACH.
1:01:32 IT HAS BEEN BUILDING ON THE DATA CENTER SIDE, OPPORTUNITIES
1:01:38 BACKED BY LONG-TERM LEASES WITH CREDIT WORTHY COUNTERPARTIES.
1:01:40 WHAT I THINK YOU WILL FIND IS THE LARGER COMPANIES WILL FIND A
1:01:43 WAY TO NAVIGATE THROUGH THIS. THEY WILL FIND CAPITAL IN THE
1:01:47 ECOSYSTEM. THE MARKETS ARE STILL AVAILABLE,
1:01:50 BEING MORE DISCERNING, MAYBE COST A LITTLE MORE, MAY REQUIRES
1:01:53 LITTLE MORE EQUITY. BUT WHEN YOU HAVE THIS KIND OF
1:01:56 DEMAND, SOMETHING THIS TRANSFORMATIVE, I AM OF THE VIEW
1:02:01 THAT THE CAPITAL WILL FIND A WAY TO ENABLE THE SUPPLY CHAIN TO
1:02:02 WORK. THE PUMP WITH VALUATIONS SO
1:02:08 ELEVATED, HOW DO YOU ADVISE INVESTORS -- ISABELLE: WITH
1:02:11 VALUATIONS ARE ELEVATED, HOW DO YOU ADVISE INVESTORS?
1:02:15 IS IT NO MATTER WHAT? RIVED -- VIRAL: ONE THING WE
1:02:20 FOUND FOR INVESTORS IN PRIVATE MARKETS IS TIMING THAT ENTRY IS
1:02:22 NOT THE BEST WAY TO THINK ABOUT IT.
1:02:24 THE BENEFITS OF PRIVATE MARKETS HAS BEEN THAT THEY PROVIDE
1:02:28 DIVERSIFICATION TO PUBLIC MARKET PORTFOLIOS, AND OVER TIME HAVE
1:02:32 PROVIDED EXCESS RETURN. THAT EXCESS RETURN HAS COME
1:02:35 BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN INVESTING FOR LONG PERIODS OF TIME.
1:02:39 WANT TO KEEP THAT CAPITAL FOR AS LONG AS YOU CAN AND LET IT
1:02:43 COMPOUND IN THE ASSET CLASS. TODAY WAS SOME OF THE VOLATILITY
1:02:46 IN THE MARKET, YOU HAVE SEEN VALUATIONS COME DOWN A LITTLE
1:02:48 BIT. SO ENTRY PRICES FOR ASSETS ARE A
1:02:51 LITTLE MORE ATTRACTIVE THAN BEFORE.
1:02:54 SO WE ARE STILL SEEING ATTRACTIVE OPPORTUNITIES WITHIN
1:02:56 AI AND OUTSIDE. DANI: I WAS GOING TO SAY,
1:03:00 BECAUSE I KNOW YOU AND THE TEAM BELIEVE IN THIS FUTURE OF AI AND
1:03:08 WHAT IT WILL BRING EFT'S. A LOT OF IT IS BUILT ON SOFTWARE
1:03:09 BEING DISRUPTED. I WONDER WHAT ELSE WILL BE
1:03:10 DISRUPTED. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU THINK
1:03:13 IT -- IS IT MISPRICED? MAYBE AN OPPORTUNITY PEOPLE ARE
1:03:16 OVERLOOKING THAT SHOULD THIS ALL COME TO FRUITION WILL BE A BIG
1:03:19 AREA OF DISRUPTION? VIRAL: RIGHT NOW, SO MUCH OF THE
1:03:22 DISCOURSE AND DISCUSSION IS AROUND, ARE WE IN AN AI BUBBLE?
1:03:26 THOSE ARE GOOD QUESTIONS. IT IS IMPORTANT FOR THE MARKET
1:03:31 TO TRY TO DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN GOOD AND BAD INVESTMENTS IN THIS
1:03:33 SPACE. BUT I TEND TO TALK TO OUR
1:03:36 CLIENTS ABOUT THIS IDEA THAT THEY SHOULD SPEND AN EQUAL
1:03:39 AMOUNT OF TIME THINKING ABOUT, WHAT IF AI ACTUALLY FULFILLS ITS
1:03:45 PROMISE? AND THEN TO YOUR POINT, WOULD
1:03:48 TECHNOLOGY THIS TRANSFORMATIVE, IT WILL HAVE AN IMPACT ON LARGE
1:03:49 PARTS OF THE ECONOMY. SOME CAN BE VERY GOOD, SOME CAN
1:03:51 BE VERY BAD. IT IS IMPORTANT FOR OUR CLIENTS
1:03:54 TO SPEND TIME THINKING ABOUT EXISTING PORTFOLIOS AND WHERE TO
1:03:56 ALLOCATE THAT. TODAY, WE ARE SPENDING TIME IN A
1:04:01 FEW AREAS OUTSIDE OF IT. ONE IS THE PHYSICAL ECONOMY.
1:04:05 THINK ABOUT THE BUSINESSES ON THE SERVICES SIDE, WHETHER
1:04:09 RESIDENTIAL, JERSEY MIKE'S IS A GOOD EXAMPLE.
1:04:12 WE ALSO HAVE A LOT OF TIME TODAY IN AEROSPACE AND DEFENSE.
1:04:16 AEROSPACE ON THE SUPPLY CHAIN A LOT OF REALLY GOOD VISIBILITY
1:04:19 INTO ORDER BOOKS. WE THINK THE SUPPLY CHAIN HAS A
1:04:22 LOT OF OPPORTUNITY. WE SPEND A LOT OF TIME IN THE
1:04:25 EXPERIENTIAL ECONOMY. FRANKLY, WE ARE LOOKING FOR A
1:04:30 LOT OF ASSETS THAT ARE UNCORRELATED TO BROADER MARKETS.
1:04:33 THE GUEST WAS ON EARLIER TALKING ABOUT RATES AND INFLATION.
1:04:36 NICE TO HAVE ASSETS AND EXPOSURE TO PORTFOLIOS DEALING WITH THAT.
1:04:40 WE NOTES $1.5 BILLION IN FINANCING LAST WEEK WITH PFIZER
1:04:43 ON THE GLP-1 DRUG. SO THE SCIENCES EXPOSURES ARE
1:04:48 GOOD WAY FOR INVESTORS TO GET EXPOSURE TO GOOD RETURN THAT IS
1:04:51 UNCORRELATED TO BROADER MARKETS. DANI: VIRAL PATEL OF BLACKSTONE,
1:05:08 DANI: NVIDIA AT THE LOWS OF THE MORNING, NOW DOWN 1.4%.
1:05:14 BRINGING THE S&P DONE WITH IT. A PROBLEM WHEN THIS COMPANY, IT
1:05:18 GAVE MORE BUYBACKS AND ARE STILL SELLING THEM OFF IN TODAY'S
1:05:19 SESSION. COMING UP, SEEMINGLY NONSTOP
1:05:25 OUTAGES ARE UPSETTING PUBLIC TRUST IN TECHNOLOGY.
1:05:28 WE WILL DISCUSS THAT NEXT ON "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."
1:05:40 ♪ >> EVERYTHING WE HAVE REASON TO
1:05:41 BELIEVE TELLS US THAT THESE EVENTS ARE NOT INTERRELATED.
1:05:46 NONE OF THEM WERE THE WORK OF A MALIGN ACTOR OR CYBERCRIMINAL.
1:05:51 ISABELLE: THAT WAS SECRETARY OF STATE MARCO RUBIO SEEKING IT
1:05:54 EASE CONCERNS AFTER A STRING OF MAJOR TECH OUTAGES.
1:05:57 HAPPENING NOW ON CAPITOL HILL, A HOUSE COMMITTEE IS HOLDING A
1:05:59 HEARING ON WORLDWIDE THREAT TO THE HOMELAND.
1:06:03 FOR MORE ON THE RECENT OUTAGES WE ARE JOINED BY MICHAEL
1:06:07 SHEPARD. SO MANY DISRUPTIONS IN SUCH A
1:06:10 SHORT PERIOD OF TIME. AT WHAT POINT DO WE START
1:06:12 TREATING THIS AS SOMETHING CONNECTED RATHER THAN ISOLATED
1:06:15 INCIDENTS? >> IT'S A GREAT QUESTION.
1:06:18 IT'S ONE THAT MARCO RUBIO REALLY TRIED TO ADDRESS IN HIS REMARKS
1:06:23 FROM ASIA WHERE HE IS TRAVELING WITH PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP.
1:06:25 HE SAYS THIS IS REALLY NOT THE WORK OF CYBERATTACKERS, IT IS
1:06:29 NOT ANYTHING COORDINATED. IN FACT WE ALSO HEARD FROM THE
1:06:33 TOP DEMOCRAT ON THE SENATE INTELLIGENCE COMMITTEE, MARK
1:06:35 WARNER. HE SAID THAT, LOOK, RIGHT NOW
1:06:38 A.I. MAY BE PLAYING A ROLE BUT NOT IN THE WAY THAT YOU THINK.
1:06:42 IN FACT, COMPANIES MAY BE USING A.I. TOOLS TO SNIFF OUT
1:06:45 VULNERABILITIES IN THEIR NETWORKS AND TRITO QUICKLY PATCH
1:06:48 THEM. WE HAVE TALKED TO OTHER EXPORTS
1:06:51 TOO WHO SAID THAT SOME OF THE RUSH TO PUT THESE PATCHES IN
1:06:56 PLACE IN OLD SYSTEMS MAY NOT BE WORKING AND SOME OF THE SYSTEMS
1:06:59 MAY NOT BE ABLE TO TAKE AND ABSORB SOME OF THE CHANGES THAT
1:07:04 ARE BEING REQUIRED BECAUSE A.I. HAS FOUND GAPS IN NETWORK
1:07:07 SECURITY. BUT STILL IT IS NOT ASSUAGING
1:07:10 THE PUBLIC MUCH. WE HAVE SEEN OVER THE PAST WEEK
1:07:14 A SURGE IN PANIC BUYING OF EVERYTHING FROM WATER TO
1:07:17 NONPERISHABLE GOODS TO BATTERIES, RETAILERS LIKE COSTCO
1:07:21 AND THE DISCOUNT RETAILER EVEN SAID OVER THE WEEKEND THAT SALES
1:07:25 OF THEIR HIGH END GENERATORS WERE PRETTY MUCH TAPPED OUT AS
1:07:32 SUNDAY. DANI: COSTCO GOT AN UPGRADE.
1:07:36 IT'S BEEN REMARKABLE AND YOU WOULD BE FORGIVEN FOR PEOPLE WHO
1:07:39 HAVE THIS IDEA WE HAD SOMEONE TELL US AS WELL THAT BASICALLY
1:07:42 SO MANY PATCHES ARE HAPPENING AT THE SAME TIME BECAUSE OF THE
1:07:45 ADVANCEMENTS IN TECHNOLOGY. HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY MARK
1:07:50 WAYNE MULLEN IS SPEAKING IN FRONT OF A COMMITTEE IN FRONT OF
1:07:55 CONGRESS, SAYING THAT BASICALLY ADVERSARIES ARE TARGETING THE
1:07:59 U.S. INFRASTRUCTURE, POINTS TO IRAN, POINTS TO NORTH KOREA.
1:08:01 DIDN'T GO SO FAR AS TO SAY THAT THESE ARE THE REASONS FOR THE
1:08:04 OUTAGES WE HAVE HAD, TO YOUR POINT THE GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN AT
1:08:07 PAINS TO SAY THAT IS NOT WHAT IT IS.
1:08:10 BUT HOW VULNERABLE ARE WE TO CYBERCRIMINALS, BAD STATE ACTORS
1:08:14 TRYING TO CREATE MORE ISSUES AMONG OUR INFRASTRUCTURE?
1:08:18 MICHAEL: THIS IS THE FEAR AND LOATHING, DANI, THAT THE
1:08:22 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ERA HAS BROUGHT WHEN IT COMES TO
1:08:25 CYBERSECURITY. THE IDEA THAT CYBERCRIMINALS,
1:08:29 STATE SPONSORED HACKERS COULD USE SOPHISTICATED A.I. TOOLS TO
1:08:33 WROAK HAVOC ACROSS CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE THAT'S NIGHTMARE
1:08:35 FUEL FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE ESPECIALLY IN THE I.T. SECTOR,
1:08:38 BUT FOR THE PUBLIC TOO, AND IT IS SOMETHING THAT THE GOVERNMENT
1:08:41 HAS PREVIOUSLY ACKNOWLEDGED AND WARNED ABOUT GOING BACK TO
1:08:45 APRIL, THE ADMINISTRATION WAS WARNING THAT IRAN COULD BE
1:08:49 TARGETING CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE INCLUDING WATER
1:08:51 AND UTILITIES. THEY HAVE ATTRIBUTED
1:08:55 CYBERATTACKS ON MINNESOTA'S WATER WAXER TO -- WATER WORKS TO
1:08:59 IRAN AND FRANCE HAS RECENTLY ATTRIBUTED THOSE REFRIGERATOR
1:09:02 SYSTEM HACKS TO IRAN AS WELL. SO WE DO SEE THIS COMBINATION OF
1:09:07 CYBERCRIMINALS AND HOSTILE ACTORS POTENTIALLY SEIZING ON
1:09:14 THIS TECHNOLOGY TO WREAK HAVOC, TO CAUSE TROUBLE, AND IT'S
1:09:18 REALLY LEFT GOVERNMENT IN THE DIFFICULT POSITION OF HAVING TO
1:09:21 SCRAMBLE TO RESPOND TO ALL OF THESE POTENTIAL THREATS, WHICH
1:09:26 CAN POP UP OUT OF NOWHERE AND TARGET SEEMINGLY RANDOM THINGS
1:09:31 SUCH AS RENCH RACIAL OR WATER FACILITIES.
1:09:32 DANI: THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR JOINING US, BLOOMBERG'S MICHAEL
1:09:36 SHEPARD IN WASHINGTON, D.C. GOING TO GET A QUICK CHECK ON
1:09:38 YOUR MARKETS THIS MORNING. THE S&P IS DOWN JUST AS MUCH AS
1:09:42 THE NASDAQ IS UP. AT ISSUE IS NVIDIA DOWN 1.2%
1:09:45 THIS MORNING. THERE IS A BID INTO BONDS, HAVEN
1:09:50 SEEKING EVEN WITH GOVERNOR WALLER SAYING MAYBE HE WOULD
1:09:52 ADVOCATE FOR A 50 BASIS POINT HIKE IF THEY'RE NOT GOING TO
1:09:56 SIGNAL ANOTHER HIKE TO COME NEXT YEAR.
1:09:58 BRENT CRUDE DOWN 1%. TAKE A LOOK AT THE MOVERS THIS
1:10:00 MORNING. WITH THAT IS NORAH MULINDA.
1:10:04 NORAH: FIRST UP, G.T.A.6 IS MAKING HISTORY, RISING AHEAD OF
1:10:07 TOMORROW'S LAUNCH. GRAND THEFT AUTO SIX BECOMING
1:10:11 THE BEST REVIEWED VIDEO GAME OF ALL TIME.
1:10:13 THE GAME SCORING A NEAR PERFECT 99 ON META CRITIC BUT
1:10:17 BLOOMBERG'S REPORTER CALLING IT A MASTERPIECE.
1:10:21 TAKE TWO INTERACTIVE IS HIGHER BY MORE THAN 6%.
1:10:27 TJX POSTING BETTER THAN EXPECTED SALES INCLUDING MARSHALLS.
1:10:31 THE OFF-PRICE RETAILER SAYING IT EXPECTS SALES MOMENTUM TO
1:10:35 ACCELERATE THROUGHOUT THE SEASON.
1:10:37 ROSS AND BURLINGTON ARE ALSO HIGHER ON THOSE RESULTS.
1:10:40 AND FINALLY LET'S GET ANOTHER CHECK ON NVIDIA.
1:10:42 THE CHIP GIANT DELIVERED A SOLID QUARTER AND RAISED ITS REVENUE
1:10:47 OUTLOOK, BUT THE POST EARNINGS RALLY IS FADING.
1:10:51 THE STOCK IS DOWN BY ABOUT 1% THIS MORNING.
1:10:54 THOSE ARE YOUR MORNING MOVERS. DANI?
1:10:56 DANI: THANK YOU. LET'S ' BRING IN MANDEEP SINGH.
1:11:01 THE STOCK WAS GREETED WITH ENTHUSIASM IN THE POST MARKET
1:11:03 AFTER REPORTING EARNINGS. WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF NVIDIA
1:11:09 UNABLE TO HANG ON TO THOSE GAINS?
1:11:10 >> THE MARKET I THINK IS FEARFUL OF SOME SORT OF AN EARNINGS
1:11:12 CLIFF. SO WHEN YOU THINK OF THE QUARTER
1:11:17 THEY JUST HAD AND THE GUIDANCE THEY GAVE FOR 2027, I THINK
1:11:22 EVERYONE FEELS LIKE THE NUMBERS ARE TOO BIG, TOO GOOD THAT GIVEN
1:11:26 ALL THE UNCERTAINTY THERE IS SOME SORT OF A CLIFF.
1:11:29 AND IT GETS REFLECTED IN THE VALUATION.
1:11:33 GIVEN NVIDIA IS TRADING AT 10 TIMES FORWARD EARNINGS, IT IS
1:11:38 SORT OF MODELING THAT SORT OF SCENARIO THAT EVEN IF EARNINGS
1:11:41 GETS REVISED LOWER, THE STOCK WILL STILL BE AT A REASONABLE
1:11:44 MULTIPLE. BUT I THINK RIGHT NOW THAT
1:11:47 UNCERTAINTY FACTOR IS WHAT IS GETTING REFLECTED DESPITE THEIR
1:11:52 GUIDANCE AND WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT WHY THERE IS SO MUCH
1:11:56 UNCERTAINTY AROUND THE NEOCLOUD REVENUE LINE, WHICH IS ALMOST
1:12:01 HALF OF THE LEF KNEW -- REVENUE AND WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE COST
1:12:04 OF CAPITAL IMPACT WILL HAVE. THE PERMITTING DELAYS WILL HAVE
1:12:07 ON NEOCLOUDS. I THINK THAT'S WHAT YOU ARE
1:12:10 SEEING IN THIS STOCK. ISABELLE: SOME ANALYSTS WERE
1:12:15 TOUTING THE 75% FIGURE. BUT I GUESS THAT WASN'T -- IT
1:12:22 WAS THE BASE CASE. IT WASN'T THE FACT THAT IT
1:12:25 EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS. >> IT'S IMPRESSIVE FOR A COMPANY
1:12:28 OF NVIDIA'S SIZE TO BE TALKING THEY'RE GOING FROM $400 BILLION
1:12:32 TO $700 BILLION IN REVENUE IN 2027.
1:12:34 THE MARGINS EVEN WITH THE SLIGHT DROP IN MARGINS, THEY'RE GOING
1:12:38 TO GENERATE A LOT OF FREE CASH FLOW.
1:12:40 BUT THE FEAR IS AGAIN WHAT IS THE GROWTH RATE GOING TO BE IN
1:12:44 2028? GIVEN THE HEADWINDS FROM THE
1:12:48 COST OF CAPITAL GOING HIGHER, THE PERMITTING DELAYS, AND
1:12:54 NVIDIA SPECIFIC UNCERTAINTY. IF YOU TAKE THOSE THREE FACTORS
1:12:57 OUT, I THINK THIS STOCK WOULD DEFINITELY BE RERATED TO HIGHER
1:13:01 MULTIPLES BUT IT'S A BIG OVERHANG.
1:13:03 DANI: THIS IDEA OF AN EARNINGS CLIFF TO COME, DO YOU NOT THINK
1:13:07 THIS WAS CONSERVATIVE FOR THEM? SURELY THEY'RE AWARE OF THAT
1:13:09 FACT AND THEY WANT TO GIVE THEMSELVES A NUMBER THAT THEY
1:13:12 CAN EASILY EXCEED AND CONTINUE TO FOLLOW?
1:13:14 DO YOU THINK THAT THAT MIGHT BE PLAYING IN THIS, THAT 75 THEY
1:13:17 THINK IS SOMETHING THEY CAN EASILY ACHIEVE?
1:13:22 >> THE WAY THIS COMPANY HAS, YOU KNOW, RAMPED UP THEIR TOP LINE
1:13:25 AND WHY THEY'VE BEEN SO SUCCESSFUL IS BECAUSE THEY WERE
1:13:27 THE MOST AGGRESSIVE WHEN IT COMES TO PROCURING THE SUPPLY
1:13:33 CHAIN CAPACITY TO RAMP UP THEIR SYSTEMS.
1:13:36 THEY TALKED ABOUT RUBIN BEING 20 BILLION RUN RATE ALREADY WHICH
1:13:39 IS THEIR NEWEST ARCHITECTURE SO THE QUESTION IS CAN THEY
1:13:43 MAINTAIN THAT PACE, LIKE AFTER RUBIN DO THEY HAVE A PRODUCT
1:13:47 ROAD MAP THAT RAMPS UP THE SAME WAY AS THE TRANSITION FROM
1:13:49 BLACKWELL TO RUBIN? SO ALL THOSE ARE AN OVERHANG ON
1:13:53 THE 2028 NUMBERS. EVERYONE SEES THE VISIBILITY FOR
1:13:57 NEXT YEAR NOW, BUT THESE STOCKS KIND OF DISCOUNT FUTURE
1:13:59 EARNINGS. SO THAT'S THE HARD PART IN TERMS
1:14:03 OF MODELING RIGHT NOW FOR NVIDIA STOCK.
1:14:04 ISABELLE: IT'S INTERESTING HOW THERE ARE TWO CAMPS.
1:14:07 YOU SAID PEOPLE ARE -- ONE CAMP WANTS JENSEN AT THE HELM DESPITE
1:14:12 EVERYTHING AND THE OTHER CAMP DON'T WANT HIM THERE ANYMORE.
1:14:14 OF COURSE THE BOARD SAID THEY CLOSED THE DOOR ON JENSEN HUANG
1:14:16 COMING BACK. HOW DO YOU ENVISION A FUTURE
1:14:19 WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG FOR NVIDIA GIVEN YOUR YEARS OF COVERING
1:14:21 THIS? SO MANY PEOPLE POINT TO APPLE AS
1:14:25 AN EXAMPLE THAT IT WAS FINE. >> IT WAS FINE BUT IN THIS CASE
1:14:29 THE TALENT RETENTION IS KEY. NVIDIA IS A VERY COMPLEX COMPANY
1:14:34 WHEN YOU LOOK AT THEIR PRODUCT LINEUP.
1:14:37 THIS IS ABOUT STAYING AHEAD OF COMPETITORS IN TERMS OF THE TRUE -- WHAT THEY ARE FOCUSING
1:14:44 ON IS IN THAT ECOSYSTEM UNDER JENSEN.
1:14:48 NOW WITH JENSEN DEPARTURE, DO YOU FEEL THEY CAN RETAIN ALL THE
1:14:53 TALENT THAT THEY HAVE HAD FOR YEARS?
1:14:54 IT ALL COMES DOWN TO WHAT JENSEN DOES DOWN THE LINE.
1:14:59 IF HE STARTS HIS OWN COMPANY, HE CAN POACH A LOT OF TALENT.
1:15:02 WHO KNOWS? SO THERE ARE ALL THESE FACTORS
1:15:06 AT PLAY HERE IN TERMS OF NVIDIA SPECIFICALLY AND HOW THEY
1:15:09 NAVIGATE THIS UNCERTAINTY. DANI: IT'S A GREAT POINT.
1:15:11 REPORTING DOES SUGGEST HE HAS A LOT OF LOYAL FOLLOWERS WITHIN
1:15:13 THE COMPANY ITSELF. WHAT ABOUT NOT JUST FOR NVIDIA,
1:15:18 JENSEN'S LEADERSHIP, BUT THE A.I. ECOSYSTEM AS A WHOLE?
1:15:23 NOT ONLY WAS HE OUTSPOKEN ABOUT INDIVIDUAL COMPANIES THAT WOULD
1:15:25 RALLY, HE TALKED ABOUT HOW IMPORTANT A.I. OVERALL DEMAND
1:15:28 WAS THAT WOULD HELP THE ECOSYSTEM AND WREA AS HUGE
1:15:31 LOBBYING FORCE AT THE WHITE HOUSE.
1:15:33 IS THERE NOW A VACUUM WITH ALL OF THOSE DIFFERENT MATTERS?
1:15:36 MANDEEP: I WOULD SAY THE FRONTIER BHODLE -- MODEL
1:15:39 PROVIDERS AND HYPERSCALERS CAN TALK OVER THE MANTLE IN TERMS OF
1:15:42 LOBBYING. EVERYONE HAS A LOT OF, YOU KNOW,
1:15:45 SKIN IN THE GAME IN TERMS OF MAKING SURE THIS A.I. CYCLE
1:15:49 RAMPS UP THE SAME WAY. BUT IT'S MORE ABOUT NVIDIA'S
1:15:53 POSITIONING IN THAT AND YOU KNOW, THE KIND OF MARKET SHARE
1:15:57 THEY HAD ON THE TRAINING AND INFERENCING SIDE WITH THE CHIPS,
1:15:59 CAN THEY MAINTAIN THAT IN LIGHT OF THE FACT THAT HYPERSCALERS
1:16:02 ARE ALSO DEVELOPING THEIR OWN CHIPS AND NOW THEY MAY HAVE MORE
1:16:06 CLOUD IN TERMS OF GETTING MORE SUPPLY CHAIN ACCESS TO RAMP UP
1:16:11 THAT CHIP CAPACITY. ISABELLE: ALWAYS WITH GREAT
1:16:13 INSIGHTS, BLOOMBERG INTELLIGENCE'S MANDEEP SINGH.
1:16:15 COMING UP DEMOCRATIC LEADERS ARE PLANNING AN INVESTIGATION INTO
1:16:18 COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD LUTNICK OVER HIS HANDLING OF
1:16:20 NVIDIA. MORE ON HIS FUTURE NEXT.
1:16:23 THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."
1:16:37 DEMOCRATS HAVE THEIR EYE ON COMMERCE SECRETARY HOWARD
1:16:40 LUTNICK. EARLIER THIS HOUR, THE JOURNAL
1:16:42 REPORTED THAT THE HOUSE ENERGY AND COMMERCE COMMITTEE IS ASKING
1:16:46 LUTNICK TO APPEAR FOR A BRIEFING ON NVIDIA'S CHIP EXPORTS AND
1:16:50 JENSEN HUANG'S RELATIONSHIP WITH A SUSPECTED CHINESE SPY.
1:16:54 A BLOOMBERG OPINION COLUMNIST HAS BEEN WRITING ABOUT THE
1:16:57 GROWING QUESTIONS SURROUNDING LUTNICK AND NVIDIA.
1:16:59 HE JOINS US NOW. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
1:17:02 A REALLY FANTASTIC COLUMN AND IT COMES AS PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:17:04 YESTERDAY SPEAKING TO REPORTERS SAYING HE HAS NO PLANS TO FIRE
1:17:08 HOWD LUTNICK -- HOWARD LUTNICK. HE IS STICKING WITH HIM FOR NOW
1:17:11 BUT THE PRESSURE IS INTENSIFYING.
1:17:14 IS THIS SOMETHING THAT YOU THINK THAT HOWARD LUTNICK CAN SURVIVE?
1:17:19 >> YOU KNOW, I DON'T REALLY KNOW, BUT I THINK THAT YOU HAVE
1:17:24 TO GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL SIN QUESTION HERE, WITH THE LUTNICK
1:17:27 CHOICE. I THINK LUTNICK SORT OF
1:17:32 PERSONIFIES THE TRICKY SITUATION THAT THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
1:17:35 HAS FOUND ITSELF IN FROM THE VERY BEGINNING, WHICH IS THAT
1:17:40 TRUMP BECAUSE OF THE WAY HE CARRIED OUT HIS MANAGEMENT
1:17:43 RESPONSIBILITIES IN TRUMP 1.0 REALLY WAS NOT ABLE TO GET THE
1:17:47 QUALITY OF PEOPLE THAT HE DID THE FIRST TIME AROUND.
1:17:56 TRUMP 1.0 WAS MARKED BY YOUR REX TILLERSONS, YOUR JIM MATTIS AND
1:18:01 SO FORTH. THIS TIME AROUND, THE LUTNICKS
1:18:04 OF THE WORLD WAS WHAT YOU COULD GET AFTER YOU UNCEREMONIOUSLY
1:18:09 SHOWED SO MANY HIGH QUALITY PEOPLE THE DOOR.
1:18:13 YOU FIRED PEOPLE WITH TWEETS. AND OF COURSE, JANUARY 6, 2021,
1:18:21 TURNED OFF A LOT OF QUALIFIED PERSONNEL.
1:18:25 SO YOU END UP WITH A STAFF LIKE HOWARD LUTNICK QUALITY PEOPLE,
1:18:29 AND I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD BE SHOCKED THAT WE ARE DEALING WITH
1:18:32 THIS SITUATION. ISABELLE: HOW MUCH OF THIS DO
1:18:35 YOU ATTRIBUTE TO BEING THE FAULT OF HOWARD LUTNICK TO AS MUCH AS
1:18:38 PRESIDENT TRUMP BECAUSE YOU DID POINT OUT THAT HE REPORTS TO
1:18:41 TRUMP, AND TRUMP HAS SHIELDED HIM FROM MUCH OF HIS TENURE AND
1:18:45 REALLY PREVENTED HIM AND EMPOWERED HIM FROM DOING
1:18:49 WHATEVER HE WANTS. >> YEAH, WELL, I MEAN LET'S EVEN
1:18:53 TAKE A STEP BACK. PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS CREATED A
1:18:57 CULTURE WHERE CONFLICTS OF INTEREST ARE NOT REALLY A BIG
1:19:01 DEAL, AND HE INSTILLS THAT CULTURE FROM THE VERY TOP, WITH
1:19:09 HIS CONFLICTS IN CRYPTO AND HIS EQUITY HOLDINGS AND SO ON.
1:19:12 SO WE SHOULD NOT THEN BE SHOCKED TO KNOW THAT WE HAVE A COMMERCE
1:19:19 SECRETARY WHO, YOU KNOW, MAINTAINS A CLOSE RELATIONSHIP
1:19:25 WITH HIS FIRM, WHICH IS STILL RUN BY HIS KIDS, AND CANTOR
1:19:32 FITZGERALD IN TURN HAS BEEN A MAJOR INVESTOR THROUGH ITS FUNDS
1:19:38 ON BEHALF OF CLIENTS IN NVIDIA. IT MADE MAJOR TRANSACTIONS
1:19:44 INVOLVING THAT NVIDIA STAKE IN LATE 2025, AND EARLY 2026,
1:19:50 PRECISELY WHEN A LOT OF THIS WAS HAPPENING.
1:19:53 ALL OF THAT CAN HAPPEN BECAUSE PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS CREATED THIS
1:19:56 CULTURE, AND HE HAS DONE MANY OF THE SAME THINGS HIMSELF.
1:20:00 DANI: WE HAVE SEEN THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT TRY TO MAKE MOVES TO
1:20:04 RESTRICT CHINESE ACCESS, BE IT THROUGH THIRD PARTY COUNTRIES OR
1:20:09 BE IT REMOTE ACCESS. I WONDER HOW YOU ARE SEEING
1:20:12 THOSE, HOW YOU ARE VIEWING THOSE.
1:20:14 IS THIS A COMMERCE DEPARTMENT TAKING CONCRETE STEPS?
1:20:17 IS IT TRYING TO CLOSE LOOPHOLES OR IS IT ANNOUNCING MORE RULES
1:20:22 THAT IT'S UNLIKELY TO ENFORCE? >> YEAH, I ME, IT SEEMS LIKE A
1:20:26 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT FROM THE VERY BEGINNING THAT WAS VERY
1:20:30 INFLUENCED BY THE LOBBYING OF POWERFUL TECH COMPANIES.
1:20:35 SO WE SAW IN JANUARY, 2025, IN ONE OF ITS LAST MAJOR STEPS, THE
1:20:39 BIDEN ADMINISTRATION COMES OUT WITH THE A.I. DEFUSION RULE AND
1:20:43 AS SOON AS THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION GETS IN THERE,
1:20:49 HOWARD LUTNICK AND HIS TEAM ESSENTIALLY DECIDE NOT TO
1:20:53 IMPLEMENT THE A.I. DEFUSION RULE, WHICH WOULD HAVE TAKEN
1:20:57 SUBSTANTIAL STEPS TO LIMIT THE SORT OF DAMAGE THAT WE ARE
1:21:00 SEEING NOW. SO THAT HAPPENED.
1:21:04 THAT WAS A CONCRETE STEP, BUT THEN, YOU KNOW, LUTNICK AND HIS
1:21:07 TEAM GET ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES TO PREVENT THIS
1:21:12 SORT OF DEBACLE. APPARENTLY, HE WAS BROUGHT
1:21:17 INFORMATION OVER A PERIOD OF SEVERAL MONTHS THAT WOULD HAVE
1:21:23 GIVEN HIM THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPECIFICALLY BLACKLIST MEGA
1:21:28 SPEED AND WE KNOW EVEN FROM SECRETARY BESSENT OVER AT
1:21:32 TREASURY THAT OTHERS IN THE GOVERNMENT WERE IN FAVOR OF
1:21:37 PUTTING MEGA SPEED ON THAT BLACKLIST, KNOWN AS THE ENTITY
1:21:39 LIST. AND FOR WHATEVER REASON,
1:21:44 SECRETARY LUTNICK JUST DIDN'T DO IT.
1:21:47 HE SEEMS TO HAVE DRAGGED HIS FEET, AND TO THIS DAY WE DO NOT
1:21:50 HAVE A CLEAR EXPLANATION AS TO WHY THAT HAPPENED, AND SO I
1:21:54 THINK THAT'S GOING TO BE QUESTION NUMBER ONE FROM
1:21:58 LAWMAKERS. ISABELLE: I KNOW THAT DANI ASKED
1:22:00 YOU WHETHER YOU THINK HOWARD LUTNICK WILL SURVIVE THE
1:22:02 SITUATION BUT IF YOU ZOOM OUT, WHEN YOU ASSESS THE SITUATION,
1:22:05 HOW DO YOU THINK THE AFTERMATH WILL LOOK LIKE?
1:22:09 >> WHAT DO I THINK THE AFTERMATH WILL LOOK LIKE?
1:22:15 YOU KNOW, AGAIN, IT'S HARD TO SAY THAT THE REPUTATION OF THIS
1:22:20 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IS WORSE TODAY THAN IT WAS SORT OF BEFORE
1:22:25 ALL OF THIS HAPPENED BECAUSE IT WAS A FOREGONE CONCLUSION ALMOST
1:22:30 WHEN YOU PUT SOMEBODY LIKE A HOWARD LUTNICK IN THERE WHO IS
1:22:37 OBVIOUSLY IN OUT OF HIS DEPTH, THAT YOU ARE GOING TO RUN UP
1:22:42 AGAINST SOME OF THESE THINGS. I THINK THIS WAS A PREDICTABLE
1:22:44 OUTCOME. I DON'T KNOW HOW HOWARD LUTNICK
1:22:51 CAN RECOVER THE CONFIDENCE OF WALL STREET AND THE AMERICAN
1:22:55 PUBLIC WITH THIS. WHETHER OR NOT THAT LEADS
1:22:59 PRESIDENT TRUMP TO MAKE A MOVE HERE, THAT'S BEYOND MY PAY
1:23:02 GRADE. DANI: THANK YOU.
1:23:05 FANTASTIC COLUMN. JONATHAN LEVIN OF BLOOMBERG
1:23:06 OPINION. COMING UP PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:23:09 ARRIVES IN CHINA READY FOR A MAJOR TRILATERAL MEETING.
1:23:11 MORE ON HIS AGENDA NEXT. THIS IS "BLOOMBERG OPEN INTEREST."♪
1:23:23 TRUMP GOES ON TO THE NEXT LEG OF HIS ASIA TRIP FOR THE
1:23:25 APEC SUMMIT. HE IS TO HOLD A MEETING WITH
1:23:28 PRESIDENTS PING AND PUTIN TOMORROW.
1:23:33 TYLER KENDALL IS ON THE GROUND NOW.
1:23:35 TRUMP IS ARRIVING AT A HEIGHTENED TENSION WHEN IT COMES
1:23:37 TO TRADE AND TECHNOLOGY. WHAT IS TRUMP LOOKING TO
1:23:42 ACCOMPLISH OUT OF HIS MEETING WITH PRESIDENT XI AND PRESIDENT
1:23:47 VLADIMIR PUTIN? TYLER: WELL, THERE IS A LOT ON
1:23:49 THE AGENDA ACCORDING TO THE WHITE HOUSE.
1:23:51 THEY ARE EXPECTED TO DISCUSS ACTUALLY THE CONFLICT IN IRAN AS
1:23:54 WELL AS THE WAR IN UKRAINE, THOUGH THAT OF COURSE IS RAISING
1:23:57 QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW MUCH COULD ACTUALLY GET DONE ON THE
1:24:00 DIPLOMATIC FRONT CONSIDERING THAT UKRAINE DOES NOT HAVE A
1:24:03 SEAT AT THIS TABLE. BUT PRESIDENT TRUMP HIMSELF HAD
1:24:06 ALLUDED TO THE FACT THAT HE ALSO WILL VERY LIKELY BRING UP
1:24:10 NVIDIA'S FORMER C.E.O. JENSEN HUANG AMID THE FALLOUT THAT IS
1:24:13 HAPPENING THERE AND WHAT HAS BEEN THIS INCREASING IN THE
1:24:18 TENSIONS BETWEEN THE U.S. AND CHINA LEADING UP TO THIS TRAIP.
1:24:22 WE ACTUALLY GOT A PREVIEW OF WHAT POTENTIALLY COULD HAPPEN
1:24:25 HYPED CLOSED DOORS TOMORROW DURING THIS -- BEHIND CLOSED
1:24:28 DOORS TOMORROW DURING THIS TRILATERAL MEETING AS PRESIDENT
1:24:32 XI JINPING AND RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN USED THEIR
1:24:34 ADDRESS TO THE APEC SUMMIT HERE IN SHENZHEN TO WARN AGAINST WHAT
1:24:38 THEY'RE CALLING ECONOMIC BARRIERS AND PROTECTIONIST
1:24:42 POLICIES SEEMING TO PROVIDE THAT BULWARK AGAINST SOME OF THE
1:24:44 U.S.' POLICIES. OF COURSE, BEIJING'S COMMERCE
1:24:48 DEPARTMENT YESTERDAY HAD PLEDGED IT WILL ISSUE ITS OWN COUNT
1:24:53 MEASURES IF THEY FOLLOW THROUGH ON PLANS TO SEEK TO CURB CHINESE
1:24:57 ACCESS TO ADVANCED CHIPS. THAT IS DEFINITELY RAISING THE
1:25:01 STAKES HERE SINCE WE KNOW THAT CHINA WAS COMING INTO THIS WEEK
1:25:04 HOPING TO SEE THE U.S. ACTUALLY LOOSEN RESTRICTIONS WHEN IT
1:25:07 COMES TO U.S. TECH. ISABELLE, A LOT STILL NEEDS TO
1:25:10 PLAY OUT. ULTIMATELY OUR OWN ANALYSTS AT
1:25:13 BLOOMBERG ECONOMICS SAY EXPECT A LOT OF HEADLINES BUT DON'T
1:25:16 NECESSARILY EXPECT A LOT OF BREAKTHROUGHS WHEN IT COMES TO
1:25:19 THE TANGIBLE POLICY SIDE OF THINGS.
1:25:20 DANI: HOW MUCH IS THIS A CONVERSATION THAT'S BEEN THRUST
1:25:23 UPON THESE WORLD LEADERS? HOW MUCH OF THIS MEETING WAS IN
1:25:27 HOPES OF TRYING TO DO SOMETHING THAT WENT TOWARDS ENDING TWO
1:25:35 WARS? TYLER: THAT'S A PRETTY GOOD
1:25:37 QUESTION, CONSIDERING THAT, DANI, WE HAVE HEARD OURSELVES,
1:25:42 OUR REPORTING HAS INDICATED U.S. OI -- OFFICIALS VIEW THIS
1:25:45 FOREIGN TRIP BY TRUMP AS A WAY TO PROJECT POWER ABROAD
1:25:47 ESPECIALLY AFTER HAVING SOME OF THOSE REALLY DEEP MIDTERM LOSSES
1:25:51 ON THE DOMESTIC POLICY FRONT. THIS IS AN ADMINISTRATION AT THE
1:25:54 MOMENT THAT IS REALLY TRYING TO NET SOME OF THOSE FOREIGN POLICY
1:25:57 WINS IF YOU WILL, TRY TO MAKE SOME SORT OF DIPLOMATIC PROGRESS
1:26:01 IN TWO CONFLICTS AT THE MOMENT WHERE WE REALLY HAVEN'T SEEN
1:26:04 THAT HAPPENING. WITH THAT SAID, PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:26:07 HIMSELF AND ACTUALLY THE KREMLIN EARLIER TODAY BOTH ALLUDED TO
1:26:11 THE FACT THAT THERE'S PROBABLY ANOTHER MEETING ON THE BOOKS
1:26:13 THAT'S GOING TO TAKE PLACE, ONE THAT WE KNOW OF FOR SURE, THE
1:26:18 CHINESE PRESIDENT XI IS EXPECTED TO TRAVEL TO MIAMI FOR THE G-20
1:26:22 NEXT MONTH BUT NOW YOU HAVE THE RUSSIAN GOVERNMENT FLOATING THE
1:26:24 IDEA THAT THEY'RE TALKING TO THE U.S. ABOUT HAVING VLADIMIR PUTIN
1:26:29 GO TO THE G-20, TOO. SO THIS MEETING IS PERHAPS
1:26:33 SETTING THE TABLE FOR WHAT COULD BE FURTHER DIALOGUE DOWN THE
1:26:37 ROAD. DANI: TYLER, THANK YOU VERY MUCH
1:26:39 FOR JOINING US. BLOOMBERG'S TYLER KENDALL.
1:26:42 THIS MARKET STILL SELLING OFF DOWN 1/3 OF A PERCENT WITH A BID
1:26:45 INTO BONDS. NVIDIA NEAR THE LOWS OF THIS
1:26:52 MORNING SESSION, DOWN 1.6% AFTER A RAISE AND COMMITMENT TO BUYING
1:26:56 BACK MORE STOCK CONTINUING TO SELL OFF.
1:26:59 COMING UP ON BLOOMBERG DEALS, I WILL BE TALKING TO GOLDMAN'S
1:27:04 HEAD OF ASSET MANAGEMENT AND CITI VICE CHAIR AND HEAD OF
1:27:11 BANKING. TOMORROW "OPEN INTEREST."
1:27:19 ON THE ANTHROPIC LISTING DATE.
Balance of Power: Late Edition 11/17/2026 full transcript
0:06 >> THIS IS "BALANCE OF POWER"
0:12 LIVE FROM WASHINGTON, D.C. KAILEY: BREAKING TONIGHT.
0:15 PRESSURE IS ON. NVIDIA GLOVERS STRONG RESULTS
0:21 AND A BETTER THAN EXPECTED FORECAST.
0:23 ATTENTION NOW TURNS TO THE EARNINGS CALL FOR MORE CLARITY
0:26 ON THE PATH FORWARD. TEAM COVERAGE FROM WORLD
0:31 HEADQUARTERS IN NEW YORK AND WASHINGTON.
0:36 PLUS, MR. HUANG GOES TO WASHINGTON.
0:39 JENSEN HUANG WILL FACE LAWMAKERS BEHIND CLOSED DOORS ON DECEMBER
0:46 1 AS THEY INVESTIGATE POTENTIAL SECURITY RISKS INVOLVING NVIDIA,
0:50 CHINA AND ITS MOST ADVANCED CHIPS.
0:54 FROM BLOOMBERG'S WASHINGTON, D.C. STUDIOS TO OUR TV AND RADIO
0:58 AUDIENCES WORLDWIDE, WELCOME TO "BALANCE OF POWER."
1:05 I'M KAILEY LEINZ ALONGSIDE JONAH NU, JOINING US LIVE FROM CAPITOL
1:13 HILL. COLETTE KRESSE IS GOING TO HAVE
1:16 TO ANSWER QUESTIONS BUT JENSEN HUANG IS GOING TO HAVE TO ANSWER
1:20 QUESTIONS FROM LAWMAKERS. JOE: WASHINGTON IS A HUGE PART
1:24 OF THIS STORY AND ON THIS EDITION OF "BALANCE OF POWER"
1:28 WE'VE DECIDED TO DIVIDE AND CONQUER WITH YOU AND STUDIO.
1:32 WE'RE GOING TO HAVE CONVERSATIONS OVER THE NEXT HOUR
1:36 WITH LAWMAKERS WHO ARE GOING TO BE IN THE ROOM FOR THE HEARINGS.
1:41 WITH SENATOR RAND PAUL. THE CHAIR OF THE HOMELAND
1:44 SECURITY COMMITTEE, WHICH IS DEEPLY CONCERNED ABOUT EXPORT
1:49 CONTROLS IF THE FALLOUT OF THIS ENTIRE MATTER AND WE'RE ALSO
1:52 GOING TO TALK ABOUT WHAT IN THE WORLD IS GOING ON WITH ALL OF
1:57 THOSE OUTAGES ACROSS ALL OF THESE COMPUTER NETWORKS.
2:03 MOST RECENTLY, TODAY, THE NSA. AND WHAT WE ARE LEARNING FROM
2:06 THE ADMINISTRATION, CLAIMING TODAY THAT THERE IS NO
2:09 CYBERATTACK THAT AMERICANS NEED TO WORE ABOUT.
2:12 THIS IS ANOTHER BIG PART OF THE STORY THAT WE'RE COVERING
2:16 TONIGHT ON CAPITOL HILL. KAILEY: WE'RE LOOKING FORWARD TO
2:24 YOUR CONVERSATIONS IN THAT REGARD.
2:30 THE NVIDIA EARN EGGS CALL JUST GETTING UNDERWAY.
2:34 EARLIER TODAY HUANG SAID HE WOULD BE HONORED TO RETURN AT
2:38 THE BOARD C.E.O. IF THE BOARD WANTS HIM BACK WHILE ACKNOWLEDGE
2:43 ACKNOWLEDGING SERIOUS MISJUDGMENTS IN HIS PERSONAL
2:45 LIFE. THE TECHNOLOGY IS ROAD MAP IS ON
2:48 TRACK. WE HAVE THIS COVERED WITH YOU
2:54 WITH ROMAINE BOSTICK AND ED LUD LOW IN NEW YORK ALONG WITH MIKE
2:58 SHEPHERD HERE WITH ME IN WASHINGTON.
3:00 ED, WE HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT THE CALL BUT THE RESULTS
3:04 THEMSELVES, INCLUDING THE GUIDANCE WERE STRONG.
3:10 ED: $130 BILLION PLUS OR MINUS 3% FROM THE FISCAL FOURTH
3:12 QUARTER. IT'S THE MOMENTUM, THE BARE
3:20 MINIMUM THAT WALL STREET WANTED TO SEE.
3:25 CO-CREDIT KRESSE, THE INTERIM C.E.O. SAID INVESTORS ARE
3:28 INTACT. SHE'S NOT THE VISIONARY THAT
3:32 JENSEN HUANG IS AND GOING INTO THAT BALANCE OF THE FISCAL YEAR,
3:37 MARGINS A LITTLE BIT IMPACTED BUT THEY'RE RAMPING UP ALREADY
3:43 ON THE NEXT GENERATION AND THAT IMPACTS MARGINS BUT THE NUMBER
3:47 MISSING IS THAT GROWTH GUIDE FOR FISCAL 2028.
3:50 70%. THEY'D ALREADY GIVEN IT.
3:55 IF THEY DON'T REITERATE IT THEN SOMETHING THAT IS GONE HORRIBLY
3:57 WRONG. KAILEY: THE CALL IS GETTING
4:00 UNDERWAY. THE NEW BOARD CHAIR IS KICKING
4:04 THINGS OFF CALL THE COMPANY EXCEPTIONALLY STRONG BUT HE ALSO
4:08 SAYS THAT THE FIRM DOES NOT PLAN TO REINSTATE JENSEN HUANG AS
4:16 C.E.O. DESPITE, OF COURSE, THE PUBLIC STATEMENT HUANG MADE
4:19 TODAY HE WOULD DO SO IF THE BOARD, AMERICA NEEDED IT.
4:26 ROMAINE: THE NUMBERS ARE INTACT. THE PERSON WHO WAS EXECUTING
4:31 THAT ROAD MAP IS NOT THERE AND YOU SAW THE SHARES IN THE
4:35 AFTERHOURS TRADE FLIP FROM GREEN TO RED AND I THINK THAT'S
4:37 TELLING. WE SAW THE SHARES RALLY BUT THEY
4:43 WERE ONLY UP ABOUT 3% OR SO. A RELATIVE PITTANCE GIVEN THAT
4:48 THE STOCK HAS FALLEN OVER 30% JUST OVER THE LAST THREE WEEKS.
4:55 THIS IS WHETTED TO THE PERSONAL EXECUTING THAT ROAD MAP AND THIS
4:58 IS GOING TO BE THE NEEDLE THAT THE BOARD, COLETTE KRESSE AND
5:04 WHOEVER SELLS THERE IS GOING TO BE 1/2 NAVIGATING.
5:12 KAILEY: NOT ONLY IS THE CHAIR SAYING THAT THE PLAN IS NOT TO
5:16 REINSTATE JENSEN HUANG, NVIDIA IS NOT GOING TO BE TAKING
5:21 QUESTIONS ON HIS RESIGNATION ON THIS CALL, I APPARENTLY.
5:25 SO WHAT WILL THEY BE SPEAKING TO?
5:29 I WOULD IMAGINE THAT'S TOP OF MIND.
5:32 ED: HUANG'S STATEMENT, THE TIMING OF IT PRIERIVE BEFORE
5:36 EARNINGS. HE'S BEEN A DIRECTOR SINCE 1993
5:41 AND THE BOARD'S POSITION TODAY, EARLIER TODAY, YESTERDAY AND
5:46 THROUGHOUT THE LAST SIX DAY WHICH IS JENSEN HUANG RESIGNED
5:51 HAS BEEN THAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR ANNEX PERSONAL CANDIDATE
5:56 THAT COLETTE KRESSE IS VERY MUCH IN AN INTERIM ROLE.
6:02 LOOK AT YOUR SCREEN. NVIDIA SHARES IN AFTERHOURS ARE
6:05 COMPLETELY FLAT. THEY'VE WIPED OUT ANY GAINS.
6:11 IN LARGE EXPECTATION BECAUSE THEY WOULD ADDRESS, THEY'D HAVE
6:17 TO, THE STATEMENT THAT JENSEN HUANG MADE.
6:23 KAILEY: AND REITERATEING IN A STATEMENT ABOUT WHAT WOULD BE
6:29 REALISTIC. MIKE SHEPHERD, THERE'S A
6:33 QUESTION ON ANY CUSTOMERS, EVEN ON A THIRD HAND BASIS IN CHINA.
6:37 CHINA WASN'T EVEN REALLY FACTORED INTO THE REVENUE
6:41 OUTLOOK AND OBVIOUSLY THERE ARE MAJOR QUESTIONS NOW EMANATING
6:47 FROM WASHINGTON TO WHAT STENTS WE COULD SEE A BIGGER CRACKDOWN
6:53 ON NVIDIA AND OTHER COMPANIES. >> IT'S BARRED FROM SELLING MOST
7:01 OF ITS AI CLIPS DIRECTLY TO CHINA.
7:03 BUT THE OLDER GENERATION OF CHIP THAT WAS CLEARED BY PRESIDENT
7:07 TRUMP AT THE END OF LAST YEAR FOR SALE TO CHINA.
7:10 THEY WERE GRANTED AN EXCEPTION. IN PREVIOUS RESULTS, THEY HAD
7:15 SAID CHINA SALES WEREN'T A FACTOR.
7:19 THEY WERE ANYTHINGINGLY ELIGIBLE.
7:23 WITH YOU NOW WE'RE -- NEGLIGIBLE.
7:25 THEY DIDN'T SHOW UP IN THE FORECAST BUT THEY DID IN THIS.
7:29 ALL OF THIS IS GOING TO BRING UP QUESTIONS ABOUT THE COMPANY'S
7:39 COMPLIANCE. INVESTORS HAVE FOR QUESTIONS
7:43 THAN ANSWERS RIGHT NOW FOR THE COMPANY.
7:46 CAPITOL HILL DOES, ABOUT ITS COMPLIANCE AND EXPORT CONTROLS.
7:51 KAILEY: WE'LL HAVE MORE ON THAT IN A MINUTE.
7:55 ED LED LOW, PREVIOUS PROJECTION WAS FOR 70% GROWTH.
8:01 NVIDIA NOW SAYS GROWTH, 75%. THE SHARES REACTING.
8:09 ED: 75% I'M FROM 70% FOR FISCAL 28.
8:11 IT WAS UNUSUAL FOR NVIDIA TO EVEN GIVE AN OUTLOOK THAT FAR
8:15 AFIELD. PREVIOUSLY THEY HADN'T DONE
8:16 THAT. THEY SAID IF NOT FOR THE SUPPLY
8:21 CONSTRAINTS THAT EXIST IF THEIR OWN SUPPLY CHAIN, THE CHIPS THEY
8:27 CAN GET HOLD OF THEMSELVES, IT WOULD HAVE BEEN AT 100%.
8:30 SO IT IS BULLISH THAT THEY'VE RAISED IT TO 75% BUT KEEP
8:36 LOOKING AT THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL.
8:45 THERE IS A MASSIVE SUPPLY DEMAND FOR THEM STILL.
8:50 KAILEY: THIS COMPANY INFLUENCES SO MANY OTHERS.
8:53 WHAT HAPPENS TO NVIDIA NEVER REALLY HAPPENS TO NVIDIA ALONE.
9:00 WALK US THROUGH SOME OF THE NEO-CLOUDS OF THEIR CHIP STOCKS
9:02 RIGHT NOW. ROMAINE: THE BIGGEST MOVERS IN
9:08 THE AFTERHOURS TRADE ARE COREWEAVE AND NEBIUS.
9:13 NEBIUS UP ABOUT 8%. THAT IS YOUR NUMBER ONE MOVER
9:17 OUT THERE AND THAT IS SORT OF THE SIGH OF RELIEF.
9:23 I WANT ANYONE WITH A BLOOMBERG TERMINAL TO TYPE SPLC AND YOU'LL
9:36 SEE THAT THE PROVIDER AND SUPPLIER RHYTHMS.
9:40 KEEP AN EYE ON A LOT OF THE OPTICAL EQUIPMENT MAKERS.
9:44 MEMORY CHIP COMPANIES LIKE SANDISK.
9:46 ALL HIGHER HERE IN THE AFTERHOURS TRADE.
9:50 THOUGH NOT TO BE A DEBBIE DOWNER.
9:56 MOST OF THESE TRADES OR 3, 4, 5, 6, 7%.
10:00 ANY OTHER TIME THAT WOULD BE PHENOMENAL BUT MOST OF THESE
10:04 STOCKS I JUST MENTIONED ARE DOWN 25, 30, 50% JUST IN THE PAST
10:08 MONTH. KAILEY: NVIDIA ITSELF JUST IN
10:14 THE QUARTER HAS LOST MORE THAN A QUARTER OF ITS VALUE.
10:19 ANOTHER HEADLINE, NVIDIA SAYS FRONTIER LABS WILL CONTRIBUTE TO
10:24 14% OF DATA CENTER REVENUES BUT ONE OF THOSE FRONTIER LABS IS
10:31 GOING PUBLIC, ANTHROPIC. HOW MIGHT THIS FILTER THROUGH TO
10:37 WHAT ANTHROPIC MIGHT BE GREETED WITH THE PUBLIC MARKET?
10:41 ED: I THINK THE STRUCTURE OF THE MARKET WILL FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE
10:45 STARTING IN THE NEXT CALENDAR YEAR.
10:50 NVIDIA IS GOING TO PUT 10 BILLION INTO THE PRIVATE
10:54 PLACEMENT. BUT ANTHROPIC IS ALSO CHANGING.
10:59 IT'S LOOKING LESS TO RELY ON THIRD PARTIES.
11:03 SPACEX IS SOMETHING IT'S VERY RELIANT ON FOR COMPUTE.
11:06 THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE A MASSIVE BALANCE SHEET SO THE RHYTHM
11:10 BETWEEN ANTHROPIC AND NVIDIA DETAILED IN THE PROSPECT US
11:16 CLEARLY IS SOMETHING CLOSELY PAYING ATTENTION FOR BUT NVIDIA
11:20 IS THE BELLWETHER. THAT'S HOW DATA CENTERS WORK.
11:26 YOU PLACE AN ORDER FOR CHIPS FAR IN ADVANCE AND THEN THEY SAY,
11:31 THE LABS HAVE BECOME A MUCH BIGGER PLAYER.
11:36 SPENDING. KAILEY: WE'VE SPENT SO MUCH TIME
11:40 TALKING ABOUT ANTHROPIC, FRONTIER LABS, HOW THEY MAY OR
11:44 MAY NOT BE REGULATED BY WASHINGTON.
11:47 BUT IT FEELS LIKE IN THE AFTERMATH OF THE LAST WEEK THAT
11:50 IS A STORY THAT'S CHANGING AND YOU WERE GETTING TO THIS EARLIER
11:56 ABOUT HOW WE MAY SEE A WIDER FOCUS POLICY-WISE ON THIS SPACE.
11:59 >> IT'S NOT JUST THE NVIDIA SCANDAL.
12:02 IT IS ALSO THE ELECTION THAT JUST TOOK PLACE.
12:05 WE TOOK SO MUCH TIME COVERING. VOTERS EXPRESSED THEIR DISMAY
12:12 AND DISDAIN WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
12:15 THEY'RE ON THING TO THE DATA CENTERS NVIDIA WILL NEED THAT
12:20 ANTHROPIC IS HOPING TO POPULATE WITH ITSELF CHIPS.
12:23 THEY SEE IT AS BEING DISRUPTIVE TO THEIR WAY OF LIFE AND
12:28 HOMETOWNS, EVEN IF IT MAY BROADEN THE TAX BASE.
12:34 YOU'RE SEEING THIS ACROSS THE COUNTRY, EVEN AS GO-GO AS NVIDIA
12:40 AND ANTHROPIC HAVE WANTED TO BO BE.
12:43 THIS IS GOING TO PLAY OUT NEXT WEEKO AREA AND AS ID WAS SAYING,
12:49 THE WILL FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE BUT AT THE HANDS OF POLICYMAKERS
12:55 WHO ARE NOT ONLY TRYING TO ENFORCE TAXES BUT BILLS
13:05 INTRODUCED IN THE COMING YEAR THAT WOULD ONE WAY OR OTHER
13:13 LIMIT DATA CENTERS. NOT ONLY AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL
13:18 BUT THE STATE LEVEL TOO. KAILEY:IST WITH YOU IN NEW YORK
13:22 WHEN WE SAW CHIP STOCKS AND OTHERS TIED TO THIS TRADE
13:28 CRASHING WHEN THEY SAW SO MANY STATESTATE LEGISLATURES AND
13:37 GOVERNORSHIPS GOING TO DEMOCRATS.
13:40 ROMAINE: THIS IS GOING TO BE THE BUGABOO GOING FORWARD.
13:42 WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THE BIG DROP THIS NVIDIA STOCKS.
13:48 MOST OF THEM BECAME LONG BEFORE WE KNEW ABOUT THE ISSUES WITH
13:56 JENSEN HUANG AND HIS DEPARTURE. MOST OF THAT CAME WITH THE BLUE
13:59 WAVE AND THE REQUESTED THAT YOU HAVE A LOT OF STATE AND LOCAL
14:02 GOVERNMENTS NOW FLIPPING ALSO TO BLUE THAT PLAN TO DO A LOT MORE
14:06 IN CRACKING DOWN ON DATA CENTERS.
14:09 WE SPOKE WITH A MAJOR INVESTORS WHO IS STILL INCREDIBLY BULLISH
14:13 ON THE AI TRADE OVERALL. SHE SAID THE RISK IS THERE BUT
14:19 SHE ALSO SAID A LOT OF INVESTORS HAVE MOVED ON.
14:24 THEY'RE NOW LOOKING AT THE A.I. TRADE LESS THAN THE PICKS AND
14:28 INVOLVE SHOVELS AND IT'S MORE ABOUT THE END-USE COMPANIES.
14:31 THE IDEA OF THE COMPANIES BENEFITING FROM A.I. AND THAT
14:36 MIGHT BE WHERE YOU SEE BIGGER AND MORE SUSTAINED BEGINS LONGER
14:42 TERM, AT LEAST IN THE PUBLIC EQUITY MARKET.
14:46 KAILEY: THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF TALK AROUND CIRCULAR FINANCING
14:50 AS WELL AND WE'VE GOTTEN NEW DETAILS ABOUT THE COMMITMENTS
14:53 NVIDIA HAS MADE. LATEST AS OF THIS QUARTER.
14:58 WE JUST HAD THE HEADLINE CROSS. NVIDIA WILL BE SELECTIVE IN
15:02 NEOCLOUD SUPPORT. HOW DO YOU INTERPRET THAT?
15:07 ED: I INTERPRET IT THAT THEY ARE BOING TO NEED TO COMMUNICATE HOW
15:13 MUCH THEY'RE PROPPING UP THIS INDUSTRY.
15:15 NOT JUST FROM A CAPITAL PERSPECTIVE BUT A CONFIDENCE
15:18 PERSPECTIVE. WHEN IT COMES TO EQUITY
15:25 COMMITMENTS, NVIDIA HAS BEEN VERY CONSERVATIVE.
15:29 THEIR EQUITY INVESTMENT IN THE YEAR HAS BEEN MODEST CONSISTENT
15:33 WITH THE FINANCING SUPPORT OF THEIR FLY CHAIN.
15:37 SO TO ME, THAT READS LIKE, DON'T EXPECT MORE, GUYS.
15:41 ROMAINE: CAN I-RESPOND TO THAT? THAT'S A GREAT POINT AND WE HAD
15:46 ANOTHER INVESTOR ON THE PROGRAM. SHE TALKED ABOUT THIS IDEA --
15:51 HERB WORDS, THAT NVIDIA WAS PUTTING THEIR FINGER ON THE
15:56 SCALE OF CAPITALISM AND IN DOING SO THEY WERE MAKING THE INDUSTRY
16:04 RUN VERY FAST AND EFFICIENT. WITHOUT JENSEN THERE, WHAT DOES
16:09 THAT MEAN FOR THE INDUSTRY? KAILEY: YEAH, IT'S ONE THING TO
16:13 THINK ABOUT WHAT JENSEN MEANS FROM A FINANCING PERSPECTIVE AND
16:16 ANOTHER TO THINK ABOUT WHAT THE ABSENCE OF JENSEN HUANG AS AN
16:21 EMSARPY AND KIND OF CHIEF LOBBYIST FOR THIS INDUSTRY IN
16:25 WASHINGTON. MICHAEL: I PREFER TO THINK OF
16:30 HIM AS ALMOST THE CHIEF EVANGELIST FOR A.I.
16:33 HE MANAGED TO CONVINCE PRESIDENT TRUMP TO BECOME AN A.I.
16:37 BELIEVER. BRUISING AN UNFETTERED
16:43 DEVELOPMENT OF A.I. STRUCTURE WITHOUT RESTRICTION OF A.I.
16:46 MODELS. UNTIL REALLY THIS SUMMER WHEN WE
16:50 SAW THE ADMINISTRATION WAKE UP TO SOME POTENTIAL RISKS SO HIS
16:55 ABSENCE AS A CLEAR -- HE HAD AN ABILITY TO BE A SNOWPLOW FOR THE
17:01 INDUSTRY, CLEARING A LOT OF OBSTACLES IN THE WAY HERE IN
17:05 WASHINGTON. IN ADDITION SOMEONE WHO COULD
17:10 PREACH TO WALL STREET AS WELL AND EDUCATE EVERYBODY ON THE
17:11 ADOPTION OF TECHNOLOGY AND BUYING INTO IT.
17:15 WE COULD SEE A CHANGE IN THE WEATHER FOR THE COMPANY HERE IN
17:18 WASHINGTON THAT COULD HAVE THAT KIND OF EFFECT AS WELL.
17:23 KAILEY: THE A HEADLINE JUST CROSSING NVIDIA IS NO LONGER
17:26 SHIPPING PRODUCTS TO CHINA BUT PRESIDENT TRUMP IS ON THE GROUND
17:32 IN ASIA RIGHT NOW, TRAVELING TO SHENZHEN OVERNIGHT.
17:35 HOW MUCH NVIDIA CONVERSATION CAN WE EXPECT WHEN HE SITS DOWN WITH
17:38 XI JINPING? STEPHEN: WE HAVE A SHIFTING
17:43 VERSION OF THAT. WHEN THE SCANDAL FIRST ERUPTED,
17:47 DAY JENSEN ADMITTED TO THERE AFFAIR WITH AN EXECUTIVE AT
17:52 MEGASPEED INTERNAL WHO WAS SUSPECTED OF BEING A SPY.
17:56 THE PRESIDENT INITIALLY SAID HE DID NOT INTEND TO BRING IT UP
18:00 WITH XI JINPING BUT MORE RECENTLY HE'S SIGNALED THAT
18:03 MAYBE HE WILL. WE'VE SEEN SECRETARY SCOTT
18:08 BESSENT TAKE A MUCH MORE FORCEFUL TONE TOWARDS CHINA.
18:14 NOT ONLY WITH NVIDIA'S INVESTIGATION BUT ALSO HIS
18:17 ATTACKS ON THE OPEN SOURCE MODELS AND THEIR DEVELOPERS THAT
18:21 HAVE BENEFITED FROM THOSE OFFSHORE DATA CENTERS THAT
18:25 NVIDIA'S CHIPS WERE IN. KAILEY: ED, I'D LOVE FOR YOU TO
18:29 WEIGH IN AS WELL. KNOWING THIS WASN'T BAKED INTO
18:31 THE GUIDANCE. THERE ARE GEOPOLITICAL ORIENTED
18:36 ISSUES. WITH THE STORY ABOUT HOW THEY'RE
18:42 SUPPLY WAS ALREADY RESTRAINED BY SO MUCH SUPPLY.
18:46 ED: THERE'S A DISTINCTION BETWEEN THE VALUE AND THE NEWS
18:50 CYCLES. IN THE FISCAL THIRD QUARTER IT
18:58 WAS LESS THAN 1%. YOU'LL NOTICE, WHEN THE
19:03 PRESIDENT TALKS ON JENSEN HUANG AND EVEN IN RECENT DAYS AMID THE
19:07 UNCERTAINTY HE ALWAYS IS VERY CAREFUL TO SAY JENSEN HUANG
19:14 WANTS TO SELL CHIPS INTO CHINA. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU GUYS NOTICED
19:17 THAT. IT IS VERY, VERY MODEST.
19:23 ROMAINE DID A GREAT JOB ON THIS IN "THE CLOSE."
19:32 WHY THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT MOVED TO CLOSE THE LOOPHOLE FROM
19:41 THREE CLOUD OUTLIFTING FROM THEM.
19:45 IF JENSEN IS NOT THERE AT THE HELP OF THE COMPANY, WHAT DOES
19:50 IT MATTER? KAILEY: ED LUD LOW, THANK YOU.
19:55 AND ALSO TO ROMAINE BOSTICK AND MIKE SHEPARD.
20:00 GOING LIVE TO CAPITOL HILL. JOE MA NU WITH A SPECIAL GUEST.
20:04 JOE: WE'RE JOINED BY THE CHAIRMAN OF THE HOMELAND
20:09 SECURITY COMMITTEE, RAND PAUL. SENATOR, THANK YOU FOR JOINING
20:10 US. THE NVIDIA EARNINGS CALL IS
20:14 UNDERWAY AND WE'VE BEEN LEARNING SOME INTEREST HEADLINES HERE,
20:19 MAINLY THE FACT THAT THEY'RE HIKING THEIR FORECAST FOR 2028.
20:22 THIS COMPANY IS GOING PRETTY WELL CONSIDERING ALL OF THE
20:25 HEADLINES WE'VE SEEN RECENTLY. THAT SAID, WITH THE PRESIDENT
20:30 ARRIVING TOMORROW IN CHINA, DO YOU BELIEVE THIS IS A AN
20:33 ADMINISTRATION THAT IS CONCERNED ABOUT THE IMPACT OF EXPORT
20:36 CONTROLS AND WHAT THESE CHIPS COULD DO IN THE WRONG HANDS?
20:42 >> I THINK EVERYONE IS. KNOWING WHAT NEEDS TO BE
20:46 RESTRICTED AND WHAT DOESN'T IS AN IMPORTANT QUESTION.
20:49 I'M NOT SURE I KNOW THE ANSWER BUT I THINK THOSE DECISIONS END
20:54 UP BEING MONUMENTAL AS FAR AS PEOPLE MAKING OR LOSING MONEY.
20:58 JOE: THEY'RE MAKING A LOT OF MONEY AND THERE'S A BIG QUESTION
21:03 ABOUT WHAT HAS ALREADY TAKEN PLEAS.
21:06 I UNDERSTAND JENSEN HUANG HAS ALREADY AGREED TO TESTIFY ON
21:12 CAPITOL HILL. DON'T YOU WANT TO KNOW WHAT TOOK
21:18 PLACE? SEN. PAUL: I'M NOT SURE HE CAN
21:22 TELL US WHAT TOOK PLACE. HE HAD SOME AFFAIRS.
21:27 I'M NOT SURE THAT PRECLUDES YOU FROM BEING A C.E.O. BUT I THINK
21:31 ONE OF THEM BEING A SPY IS IMPORTANT.
21:34 BUT I HAVEN'T GOTTEN INFORMATION IN OUR INTELLIGENCE COMMUNITY
21:37 SAYING SHE WAS A SPY. WHAT I READ IN THE PRESS HAS
21:42 BEEN THEY'RE NOT POSITIVE IF SHE WAS A SATISFY OR NOD.
21:47 DOES IT -- NOT. DOES IT SHOW BAD JUDGMENT?
21:49 I DON'T KNOW. IF SHE WASN'T A SPY, YOU MIGHT
21:53 SAY HE WAS MISTREATED. I DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER.
21:58 IT'S NOT MY JOB ON KNOWS DECISIONS.
22:02 WHAT IS IMPORTANT IS WHETHER OR NOT SHE WAS A SPY OR NOT BUT
22:06 SHORT OF THAT, INTERVIEWING AND BEAT UP SOME C.E.O. IS PROBABLY
22:10 NOT MY IDEA OF A GOOD TIME. JOE: IS THE COMMERCE SECRETARY A
22:15 BIGGER STORY? THERE'S BEEN SOME CONCERN THAT
22:20 HE TURNED AWAY FROM SUCH CONCERNS.
22:24 SEN. PAUL: FOR ALL THESE BILLS AROUND TO PREVENT CONGRESS FROM
22:28 PIEING AND SELLING STOCKS. I'D BE MORE CONCERNED THAT MAYBE
22:30 THE ADMINISTRATION OR PEOPLE WORKING IN CAB NET MIGHT WANT TO
22:36 BE RESTRICTED OR PUT THEIR FUNDS INTO A BLIND TRUST.
22:41 YES, THERE'S CONCERN ABOUT BLIND CHIPS AND WHETHER PEOPLE IN THE
22:46 CABINET ARE MAKING MONEY. IT RAISES QUESTIONS.
22:49 JOE: THE PERSPECTIVE IS A SIGNIFICANT SHARE HOLDER IN
22:53 NVIDIA. HE CALLS JENSEN HUANG A FRIEND.
23:01 HURT LUTNICK HAS INVESTED IN DATA CENTERS IN ASIA.
23:06 SHOULD THAT BE AN INVESTIGATION? SEN. PAUL: I DON'T KNOW BUT I
23:11 THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THERE BE A GREAT DEAL OF DISTANCE
23:14 BETWEEN THEM AND BUYING AND SELLING.
23:18 MANY OF THESE PEOPLE HAVE SAID IT'S JUSTMY KIDS MAKING THESE
23:20 TRADES. IS THAT SUFFICIENT?
23:23 SOME OF THAT POLICING ISN'T REALLY A LAW UNLESS IT IS
23:30 INSIDER TRADING BUT IT'S REALLY A MATTER OF JUDGMENTS ABOUT THE
23:32 RULES YOU WANT TO SET. I THINK THOSE RULES AND
23:35 PARAMETERS ARE IMPORTANT FOR TRUST AND PART OF THE REASON I
23:39 THINK REPUBLICANS GOT WIPED OUT IN THE ELECTION WAS LACK OF
23:43 TRUST AND AT LEAST THE BELIEF THAT THERE IS SOME SELF-DEALING
23:46 GOING ON. I'M NOT SAYING THERE IS.
23:49 I'M JUST SAYING THAT THE PUBLIC BELIEVES AND WORRIES AND IS
23:53 UPSET IF THEY ANY THE GOVERNMENT IS MAKING MONEY OFF OF --
24:00 THEY'RE MAKING MONEY OFF OF GOVERNMENT DECISIONS.
24:10 JOE: ON AN DAY LIKE THIS, THE CHAIRMAN OF HOMELAND SECURITY.
24:15 PEOPLE THOUGHT WE WERE GOING TO HAVE A LOCKOUT OR SOMETHING
24:18 CRAZY BECAUSE OF AN EFFORT A.S. TEST.
24:20 IS? A BYPRODUCT OF THIS LACK OF
24:25 TRUST OR PERCEPTION OF CORRUPTION?
24:28 SEN. PAUL: I THINK IT'S A RISING THING, LACK OF TRUST IN
24:30 GOVERNMENT. I THINK IT'S BECAUSE MANY THINGS
24:34 IN GOVERNMENT -- OFFICIALS IN GOVERNMENT HAVE OVERSTEPPED
24:39 THEIR BOUNDS AND DECIDED THEY HAVE TO HAVE AN EDICT ABOUT
24:44 EVERYTHING. FOR EXAMPLE, DURING COVID AND
24:50 EVEN NOW, THEY'RE SAYING YOUR 6-MONTH-OLD SHOULD HAVE A COVID
24:54 VACCINE. I WOULD ARGUE THERE'S NOT BEEN
24:58 ANY SCIENCE. I DON'T THINK THERE EVER WAS.
25:02 WHEN GOVERNMENT TELLS YOU THERE'S GOING TO BE A MANDATE,
25:05 YOU LOSE TRUST AND SAY THAT'S NOT RIGHT.
25:08 I'M ABLE TO READ AND LOOK AT THE EVIDENCE AND THERE'S NO EVIDENCE
25:12 OF LESS DEATH OR HOSPITALIZATION AMONG 6 MOLDS.
25:16 WHY? BECAUSE NO 6-MONTH-OLD EVER GOT
25:19 COVID AND WENT TO THE HOSPITAL BECAUSE IT IS NOT A DEADLY DOES
25:24 FOR CHILDREN. JOE: YOU PUT THE MATCH WHICH IS
25:29 SOCIAL MEDIA TO IT AND IT BLOWS UP.
25:33 THE DALLAS OFFICE, AROUND BAD ACTORS USING THE R-TEXAI MODEL.
25:45 TO COORDINATE -- PEOPLE KEEP ASKING ARE ALL THESE THINGS
25:50 COORDINATEED. YOU'VE LOOKED INTO THIS?
25:53 IS THIS SOMETHING THAT IS HAPPENING EARLIER THAN YOU'VE
25:57 FEARED? SEN. PAUL: NO, BUT I'LL SEEING
26:02 THE COINCIDENCES. YOU HAVE SO MANY PEOPLE ARE
26:04 SUSPICIOUS. I BELIEVE AND TRUST THE F.A.A.
26:10 WHEN THEY SAY THE A.I. SYSTEM WAS NOT HOOKED UP TO WHERE THE
26:14 PROBLEM WAS. THEN THE BANKS, CHASE HAD THE
26:19 PROBLEM, AND PEOPLE HAVE LOST THEIR TRUST IN GOVERNMENT.
26:22 I DO THINK, THEE, THAT EVENTUALLY WHAT IS GOING TO COME
26:25 OF A.I. THIS IS MY PREDICTION -- IT'S
26:32 FOR THE COMPANY THAT COMES AI DEFENSE.
26:34 THERE ARE GOING TO BE A.I. COMPANIES THAT ARE JUST TO
26:39 DEFEND AGAINST OTHER A.I. SOME THERE'S GOING TO BE GOOD A.I.
26:41 AGAINST ROGUE. A I. AND ROGUE A.I. IS GOING TO
26:46 TRY TO PLANT A VIRUS AND STEAL ALL YOUR MONEY.
26:51 THE ONLY THING THAT CAN COUNTER A.I. IS GOING TO BE OVER A.I.
26:56 I DON'T THINK SAYING YOU HAVE A KILL SWITCH IS GOING TO STOP
27:01 THRIVES. BUT I THINK FIRE WALLS ARE GOING
27:05 TO BE EVEN MORE SIGNIFICANT. PEOPLE ARE GOING TO HAVE
27:07 SEPARATE SYSTEM. YOU'LL HAVE TO HAVE A SYSTEM
27:13 THAT WILL USE A.I. AND THE INTERNET AND IT'S GOING TO HAVE
27:17 TO BE FIREWALLED. BUT THAT'S COMING AND THERE'S NO
27:20 STOPPING IT BUT I THINK THERE WILL BE COMPANIES THAT MAKE
27:26 FORTUNES BY BECOMING AI DEFENSE COMPANIES.
27:29 JOE: WHAT A WORLD WE'RE LIVING IN.
27:32 YOU TALKED ABOUT F.A.A. THE GROUND STOP.
27:37 DO YOU HAVE $50 MILLION FOR THE ADMINISTRATION TO REBUILD THIS?
27:41 SEN. PAUL: WE HAD SECRETARY DUFFY COME IN TODAY.
27:48 WHAT I LEARNED IS HE HAD $9 MILLION AND HE HADN'T SPEND IT
27:54 BUT ALSO FUNDS FOR A FACILITY BUILDING THAT WE DOESN'T WANT.
27:58 HE HAS OTHER PRIORITIES SO I'M LEGISLATION TO FREE UP THE $3.4
28:02 BILLION. TAKE OFF THE INSTRUCTION HE HAS
28:08 TO BID FACILITIES AND LET HIM PUT IT TO BETTER USE AND THAT
28:14 WOULD COST STEREO PAUSE WE'VE ALREADY SPENT THE MONEY.
28:17 WE SHOULD BE FRUGAL WITH THE MONEY AND NOT JUST SAY OH,
28:23 EVERYTHING WENT CRAZY WHEN YOU WERE TRYING TO IMPRESSIVE THE
28:29 SYSTEM SO WE'RE GOING TO GIVE YOU 3.4 BILLION TO MONKEY WITH
28:34 THE SYSTEM? BUT THERE'S ALSO SOMETHING I
28:38 LEARNED TODAY THAT IS VERY DISTURBING.
28:41 THEY SAY THE NETWORK IS OWNED BY A PRIVATE COMPANY.
28:48 SO THE NETWORK OF THE FAA IS OWNED BY L3 HARRIS SO WE SPENT
28:53 THE LAST THREE YEARS CHANGING FROM COPPER TO FIRE OPTIC.
28:58 WHO OWNS IT? IT'S UNCLEAR TO ME -- THEY'RE
29:04 TALKING ABOUT SWITCHING NEW SYSTEMS.
29:08 GOING TO A WHOLE NEW COMPANY LIKE AT&T.
29:11 WHO OWNS THE FIBER ON THETIC SOMEBODY AND IF THE TAXPAYERS
29:16 SPENT BILLIONS OF DOLLARERS UPDATEING A PRIVATE SYSTEM WE
29:20 DON'T OWN, I'M GOING TO BE QUITE UNHAPPY.
29:23 AND THE ANSWER I GOT WAS MUDDLED BUT I'M TELLING YOU, WE HAVE
29:27 WRITING A LETTER TODAY AND DEVELOPING LEGISLATION TO FIND
29:32 OUT THIS ANSWER, IS WHO OWNS THE FIBER OPTIC CABLE WE'VE BEEN
29:35 LAYING FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS? JOE: WOW, THAT'S REALLY
29:40 SOMETHING AND THAT'S NEWS. I SUSPECT THEY'LL BE A HEARING
29:43 ON THIS, SENATOR. SEN. PAUL: IF YOU DO THE.
29:47 A I. SEARCH ENGINE, AMAZING WHAT YOU CAN LEARN.
29:51 IT SAYS WE HAVE A CONTRACT IN AUGUST OF 2026 WITH AT&T TO
29:56 REPLACE THE WHOLE NETWORK. YOU SEE THAT MEAN ALL THAT STUFF
30:01 OVER THE LAST THREE YEARS, REPLACING COPPER WITH FIBER ON
30:06 THETIC IS OUT THE WINDOW OR ARE WE GOING TO USE THE FIBEROPTIC?
30:11 WE HAVE TO BE CLEAR, WHO OWNS THE NETWORK.
30:16 IF L3 HARRIS OWNS THE NETWORK, DOES THAT MEAN THEY OWN THE
30:21 FIBER ON THETIC NETWORKS? JOE: A LOT OF QUESTIONS.
30:27 THANK YOU FOR HELPING US ANSWER THEM.
30:30 RAND PAUL. BACK TO THE AI SEARCH ENGINE.
30:34 THAT IS KAILEY LEINZ IN STUDIO WATCHING NVIDIA RESULTS AS WE
30:37 SPEAK. KAILEY: THANK YOU SO MUCH.
30:45 SENATOR PAUL ECHOING WHAT PRESIDENT TRUMP HAS SAID, NOT
30:51 KNOWING MR. ALLIES HUANG IS A SPY.
30:53 THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT THE FINANCIALS AND ANSWERING
30:56 QUESTIONS. ED LUD LOW HAS BEEN KEEPING
30:58 TRACK. WHAT ELSE ARE WE LEARNING AS
31:01 CALL GOES ON? ED: THEY BOOSTED THE OUTLOOK FOR
31:05 FISCAL 2028. GROWTH IS 75%.
31:11 PRIOR GUIDE WAS 70 PERIOD OF TIME.
31:15 COLETTE KRESSE, INTERIM C.O.O. WAS EXPLAINING, IS THAT THEY
31:20 HAVE DEMAND STILL RUNNING FAR AHEAD OF SUPPLY BUT THAT SUPPLY
31:23 DYNAMIC IS IMPROVING. THAT'S A GOOD POSITION FOR THEM
31:29 TO BE IN AND EYE YOU SEE THE STOCK NOW NEAR ITS AFTERHOURS
31:35 SESSION HIGHER 3.45%. I THINK THE ORDER NANCE OF
31:37 BALANCE OF POWER IN THAT ANSWER BECAUSE THE QUESTION WAS ABOUT
31:42 WHY THAT OUTLOOK WAS STRONG, SHE EXPLAINED THAT THEY'RE STUDYING
31:45 THESE LATEST RULES FROM COMMERCE AND EXPORT CONTROLS AND MODELING
31:50 HOW THAT WILL IMPACT THEM. THEY DON'T BREAKOUT BY THEY'RE
31:53 STUDYING IT. THE MAIN POINT IS THAT DEMAND IS
31:58 SO HOT THAT IF THEY WERE TO LOSE SOME ABILITY TO SHIP TO ONE
32:07 JURISDICTION IT'S MADE UP BY THE ABILITY TO SHIP SOMEWHERE ELSE.
32:12 KAILEY: YOU'VE DONE WELL HIGHLIGHTING THE DIFFERENCE
32:14 BETWEEN THE POLICY CONVERSATION THAT IS DOMINATED BY THAT AND
32:19 THE ACTUAL FINANCIAL IMPACT. THE NEW CHAIR OF THE BOARD MADE
32:23 CLEAR AT THE START OF THE CALL THAT THEY WEREN'T GOING TO BE
32:26 TALKING ABOUT JENSEN HUANG AND HAVE NO INTENTION TO REINSTATE
32:28 HIM. LET'S HEAR WHAT THE CHAIR SAID.
32:34 >> NOVEMBER 12 OUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS ANNOUNCED THAT AFTER
32:37 DISCLOSURE OF PERSONAL BEHAVIOR INCONSISTENT WITH THE COMPANY'S
32:41 CODE OF CONDUCT. JENSEN HUANG VOLUNTARILY
32:45 RESIGNED HIS POSITION AS PRESIDENT, C.E.O. AND BOARD
32:48 MEMBER. THE BOARD UNANIMOUSLY ACCEPTED
32:55 HIS RESIGNATION AND DOES NOT INTEND TO REINSTATE JENSEN AS
32:58 C.E.O. KAILEY: NOW WE'RE LEARNING MORE
33:03 ABOUT THE REPLACEMENT FOR HIM. ED: JONES IS EXPLAINING THAT
33:07 THEY ARE LOOKING AT BOTH INTERNAL AND EX PERSONAL
33:11 CANDIDATES AND THAT THE SEARCH WILL BE THOROUGH AND THAT THE
33:15 COMPANY IS NOT GOING TO RUSH IT JUST TO FIND THE RIGHT PERSON.
33:21 AS A SLIGHT ASIDE, IAN BACK, WHO LEADS NVIDIA'S DATA CENTER
33:27 BUSINESS, WAS INVITED TO PARTICIPATE ON THE CALL TOO AS
33:32 PART OF THE Q&A. HE WAS PART OF THE TEAM IN THE
33:38 EARLY 2000'S THAT WROTE THE LANGUAGE THAT MADE IT POSSIBLE
33:42 TO USE A G.P.U. FOR COMPUTATION AND RUNNING OF A.I. MODELS.
33:47 THAT'S SUPER INTERESTING BUT THE BOARD COULDN'T HAVE BEEN MORE
33:50 CLEAR WITH THEIR EXPLANATION. KAILEY: YEAH, THEY SAY THEY
33:56 WON'T EXPEDITE THE C.E.O. APPOINTMENT.
33:59 ED LUD LEE, THANK YOU SO MUCH. LIVE BACK TO CAPITOL HILL AS JOE
34:04 MATTHEW IS JOINED BY ANOTHER IMPORTANT REPUBLICAN SENATOR.
34:09 JOE: SENATOR TOM TILLIS, THE REPUBLICAN FROM NORTH CAROLINA
34:14 WITH US. THIS STORY INVOLVING NVIDIA
34:18 EARNINGS BUT ALSO THE POLICY SURROUNDING IT.
34:23 WELCOME BACK, SENATOR. SEN. TILLIS: ALWAYS GOOD TO BE
34:26 HERE. JOE: WE'RE TALKING ABOUT NVIDIA
34:30 FROM A LOT OF DIFFERENT ANGLES AND THE POLICY ANGLE IS THE ONE
34:33 THAT YOU OWN. HOWARD LUTNICK IS GOING TO BE
34:36 SITTING IN A HEARING ROOM WITH YOU TO TALK ABOUT WHAT WAS
34:41 ALLOWED, WHO KNEW WHAT, WHEN? WHERE DO YOU START WITH HIM?
34:46 TOM: I THINK ON ITS FACE, IT'S NOT GOOD.
34:51 IF HUANG RETIRED OR BASICALLY RESIGNED, THAT SUGGESTS TO ME
34:55 THERE'S PROBABLY MORE THAN WE KNOW RIGHT NOW.
34:57 RIGHT? OTHERWISE HE'D DEFEND HIS GOOD
35:00 NAME AND STAY THERE. THEY CLEARLY HAD A BOARD
35:05 PROCEEDING AND DECIDED THE BEST INTERESTS FOR NVIDIA AND THE
35:09 STAIR HOLDERS WAS FOR HIM TO STEP ASIDE.
35:12 IT APPEARS AS THOUGH AND WE'LL HAVE TO CONFIRM THIS IN SWORN
35:17 TESTIMONY BUT IT APPEARS THERE WAS SOME FOREIGN KNOWLEDGE ABOUT
35:20 IT, EVEN BEFORE THE FIRST MEETING WITH CHINA.
35:24 I THINK TEXAS A HUGE MISTAKE TO EXPOSE PRESIDENT THAT WAY.
35:28 PUT SOMEONE ON AIR FORCE ONE -- I'M NOT MAKING A MORAL JUDGMENT
35:34 ON MR. HUANG BUT I AM MAKING A JUDGMENTS ABOUT HIS AND
35:37 SECRETARY LUTNICK'S JUDGMENT. I THINK IT WAS BAD JULY.
35:42 JOE: THE PRESIDENT WAS WARNED TWICE FROM THE SECRETARY OF
35:45 STATE ABOUT THIS. SEN. TILLIS: YOU'VE WATCHED
35:49 ENOUGH COMMITTEE MEETINGS AROUND HERE.
35:52 THIS WON'T BE JUST ABOUT NVIDIA. YOU MIGHT EXPECT ANY NUMBER OF
35:56 PROPOSALS THAT MR. LUTNICK HAS BEEN AROUND.
36:00 SOME OF THE REPORTS ABOUT WADING INTO THE GRAY WITH RESPECT TO
36:03 BUSINESSES THAT HE'S ASSOCIATED WITH OR FAMILIES ASSOCIATED WITH
36:07 OR TRANSACTIONS. ALL THAT IS FAIR GAME AND NOT
36:11 PERSONAL. THAT'S A PART OF OVERSIGHT WE
36:14 HAVE TO DO HERE. JOE: WHICH I THINK WILL TELL US
36:19 A LOT. JENSEN HUANG WILL BE HIS OWN
36:22 HEARINGS. YOU COME TO WASHINGTON AS A
36:25 WIZMAN. THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF TALK ABOUT
36:30 SINGLE MAN RISK AND WHAT IT MEANS FOR OUR NATIONAL SECURITY.
36:34 HOW'D IT GET TO THIS POINT? WHERE A COMPANY SO CRITICAL TO
36:39 OUR NATIONAL SECURITY IS BASICALLY BASED ON THE WHIMS OF
36:45 ONE MAN? SEN. TILLIS: I THINK IT'S BECOME
36:49 SOME PEOPLE COME IN AND WORK IN THE ADMINISTRATION AND THEY
36:53 THINK THEY CAN RUN IT LIKE A BUSINESS.
36:54 AND IT IS TRUE. BUT YOU HAVE TO TAKE INTO
36:59 ACCOUNT THE APPEARANCES ISSUES, EVEN BEYOND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
37:05 AND I THINK ALL INDICATIONINGS ARE -- I'LL GIVE HIM THE BENEFIT
37:09 OF THE DOUBT. ASK HIM SOME TOUGH QUESTIONS ON
37:14 THE 10TH THAT HE DID NOT USE GOOD JUDGMENT AND I THINK IN THE
37:16 PROCESS EXPOSED THE PERSPECTIVE AND THE REPUBLICAN PARTY.
37:20 JOE: WITH THAT SAID, THERE'S BEEN AN EFFORT TO IMPEACH THE
37:24 DEFENSE SECRETARY AND YOU'VE TALKED A LOT ABOUT THE PEOPLE
37:27 SURROUNDING THE PRESIDENT MAYBE BEING THE BIGGEST ISSUE YOU HAVE
37:32 WITH FROM ADMINISTRATION. IS THE COMMERCE SECRETARY IS
37:36 GIVING HIM THE WRONG ADVICE, SHOULD HE BISM PEACHED?
37:44 SEN.: IT'S LIKE HEGSETH. A REAL IMPEACHMENTS NEEDS TO
37:49 HAVE A TRIAL, QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS AND THE DEMOCRATS ARE
37:52 NOT GOING TO DO THAT BUT I'VE HAD A PROBLEM WITH MR. LUTNICK
37:59 SINCE HE FIRED WHAT INK COULD HAVE BEEN ONE OF THE BEST
38:03 POSTMASTER GENERALS OF THE MODERN AREA AND ABSOLUTELY
38:06 FAILED ON THERS COUGS OF LIBERATION DAY.
38:09 I NEVER THOUGHT THE WAS GOING TO BE SUCCESSFUL.
38:12 YOU SAW THAT DRAWN BACK WITHIN 24 HOURS.
38:16 THEY'RE ALL EXAMPLES OF WHERE IN BUSINESS YOU CAN TAKE THAT RISK
38:18 AND MOVE ON. YOU HAVE TO HAVE A MUCH HIGH
38:23 ERWIN RATIO IN POLITICS AND IN THE U.S. GOVERNMENT THAN I THINK
38:27 HE'S HAD. THAT'S WHY I THINK IT WOULD BE
38:30 HELPFUL TO THE PRESIDENT, THIS STRIKES, TO MOVE ON.
38:33 AND KEEP IN MIND WE HAVE LESS THAN TWO MONTHS NOW.
38:37 IF MR. LUTNICK IS CONSIDERING MOVING ON, NOW IS THE TIME TO DO
38:45 IT TO GIVE THE PRESIDENT TIME TO PICK SOMEONE TO TAKE HIS PLACE.
38:53 OTHERWISE HE WOULD MOST LIKELY BE WOULDN'T A NEXT SECRETARY OF
38:57 COMMERCE. JOE: COULD I BE DONE?
39:06 SORT TILLIS: SURE, BUT IF HE SAY, WAITS UNTIL THE 10TH, WE'RE
39:11 PROBABLY OUT OF TIME TO DO IT. JOE: IS THE ATMOSPHERE DIFFERENT
39:13 NOW? ARE PEOPLE FEELING MORE LIKE
39:21 THOM TILLIS, UNSHACKLED, POST ELECTION?
39:25 SENATOR: OF TILLIS: CLEARLY SOME OF THE MEMBERS WHO LOST IN THIS
39:30 ENVIRONMENT HAVE NO SHACKLES. THIS IS JUST GOOD GOVERNANCE.
39:34 I TRY TO EXPLAIN TO PEOPLE, THESE PEOPLE ARE NOT MY FRIENDS.
39:40 I WANT TO MAKE GOOD BUSINESS DECISIONS AND GO HOME.
39:43 SOME OF THESE TALKING HEADS THAT WANT TO MAKE THIS A PERSONAL
39:47 THING, THIS IS ABOUT EXECUTION. I WORKED IN TOP-TIER BUSINESS
39:53 FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS. YOU GET REWARDED FOR EXECUTING
39:57 WELL AND FIRED FOR NOT. IN THIS CASE I THINK MR. LUTNICK
40:02 HAS MOUNTED UP A FEW LOSSES AND I THINK THE PRESIDENT WOULD BE
40:06 BETTER SERVED IN THE FINAL TWO YEARS OF HIS TERM TO HAVE
40:11 SOMEONE MORE CREDIBILITY WITH REPUBLICANS.
40:14 HE HAS A TRACK RECORD OF MAKING A FEW OTHER DECISIONS
40:19 INDEPENDENT OF CONGRESS, MR. LUTNICK.
40:22 HE'S A BUSINESS GUY AND HE SHOULD KNOW WHAT A BOARD OF
40:26 DIRECTORS LOOKS LIKE AND HE HAS NOT DONE A GOOD JOB OF THAT IN
40:29 THIS ADMINISTRATION. JOE: SEEMS LIKE HE MAY HAVE THE
40:36 TREASURY SECRETARY ON HIS SIDE. SENATOR TILLIS: I HAVE HAD
40:42 CONVERSATIONS WITH BESSENT AND I THINK HE'S SPOT ON.
40:46 THESE COMMENTS ARE WELL FOUNDED AND I THINK THE PRESIDENT SHOULD
40:49 LISTEN TO HIM. JOE: THE SECRETARY OF
40:57 TRANSPORTATION WANTS $50 TO REBUILD THE CONTROL SYSTEM.
41:03 SENATOR TILLIS: WE HEARD IN A BRIEFING TODAY THERE'S $10
41:06 BILLION FOR OUTFITTING NEW AIRPORTS.
41:08 THAT'S FINE. LET'S DO IT IN REGULAR ORDER OF
41:15 APPROPRIATIONS AND FINDS AN AN AN OFFSET.
41:19 THE COURT COSTS TO UPGRADE THE INFRASTRUCTURE THAT FAILED LAST
41:27 WEEK IS SOMEWHERE IN THE $10 BILLION RANGE.
41:31 IN MY ESTIMATION THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD BE ASKING FOR.
41:34 IT WAS A COSTLY EVENT. IF WE LOOK AT THE COSTS OF
41:39 WHAT'S HAPPENED SINCE FRIDAY, IT'S A GOOD JUSTIFICATION OF
41:42 USING TAXPAYER DOLLARS. I THINK THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD
41:47 LOOK AT IT NO. NECESSARILY USED AS A VENTS TO
41:52 GET OVER THINGS THAT ARE NOT CORE.
41:54 THE OTHER THINGS ARE IMPORTANT BUT WHAT IS ESSENTIAL VERSUS
41:58 NICE TO HAVE? JOE: IT WAS NOT UNTIL THIS
42:02 EVENING NAJAI CLAYTON COULD SAY WITH ANY CONFIDENCE THAT THIS IS
42:05 NOT A CYBERATTACK. ALONG WITH ALL THE OUTAGES FROM
42:12 MICROSOFT TO BANKS AND THE REST. WHAT HAPPENS WHEN PEOPLE THINK
42:17 WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A BLACKOUT AT 2:30 IN THE AFTERNOON.
42:24 ARE THEY TELLING US WRONG THINGS?
42:26 SENATOR TILLIS: I WORKED IN EITHER CAL HACK TESTING.
42:30 YOU TRY AND HACK SYSTEMS AND YOU ALSO BE AWARE OF THE
42:37 INFRASTRUCTURE AND WHERE ITS VULNERABILITIES ARE.
42:40 CLEARLY NOT ALL OF THESE ARE EXPLAINED.
42:42 SOME COULD BE DENIAL OF SERVICE, THEY COULD BE IN A STATE ACTOR,
42:50 JUST FROM A BUNCH OF HACKERS. JOE: WHY THE DON'T KNOW THOUGH
42:56 ON PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE ABOUT THIS?
42:59 SENATOR TILLIS: THEY SHOULD IN. MY FIRST CAMPAIGN FOR THE
43:03 SENATOR, I INSTALL IT WOULD ROUTERS AND WIRED MY CAMPAIGN
43:06 HEADQUARTERS. JOE: COULD YOU GET TO MY HOUSE
43:10 IN THE NEW YEAR? [LAUGHTER]
43:15 SENATOR TILLIS: SO YOU NEED PEOPLE IN THE ROOM WHO CAN
43:19 REALLY EXPLAIN IT THAT WAY. ONE THING THAT WORRIES ME, EVEN
43:24 WITH IRAN AS WE ESCALATE. HE'S WITH ARMED SERVICES
43:29 COMMITTEE FOR EIGHT YEARS. I KEEP SAYING DON'T BE SURPRISED
43:37 IF THERE ARE FOUR, FIVE, MAYBE SEVEN-YEAR-OLD LATENT
43:42 CAPABILITIES THAT CAN BEN ACTED LOCALLY.
43:49 IRAN IS NOT GOING TO HIT US IN THE AIR.
43:53 THEY'RE PROBABLY ONE OF THE TOPS IN CYBERCAPABILITY RIGHT NOW.
43:57 IT'S FRIGHTENING. THE ROBOTS AREN'T GOING TO TAKE
43:59 US OVER. A I. IS NOT GOING TO CONTROL
44:04 EVERYTHING NEXT WEEK AND MOST OF THESE THINGS ARE EXPLAINABLE
44:09 THROUGH A PURE TECHNICAL LENS. SOME OF THE OTHERS MAY BE
44:14 INTRUSIONS. JOE: THANK YOU.
44:16 SENATOR. NVIDIA RESULTS ARE COMING OUT AS
44:20 WE SPEAK AND AN IMPORTANT CONFERENCE CALL UNDERWAY.
44:24 KAILEY: AND WE'RE GOING TO HAVE MORE ON THAT WITH BLOOMBERG'S ED
44:29 LUD LOW IN A MOMENT MORE WHEN WE COME BACK ON BLOOMBERG'S
44:33 "BALANCE OF POWER," ON BLOOMBERG TV AND RADIO.
44:47 IS 1 ISARE >> APPRECIATES THAT WE'RE LIVING
44:49 IN A WORLD WHERE THE ADVANCED SILICON TECHNOLOGIES AND THE
44:53 NATIONAL SECURITY DYNAMICS ARE MAKING MAJOR CHANGES IN OUR
44:55 MARKETPLACE. OUR NEW C.E.O. WILL HAVE TO
45:01 NAVIGATE THOSE WATERS VERY CAREFULLY SO SEARCH WILL BE
45:05 THOROUGH AND WE WANT TO INSTALL THE C.E.O., THE PERMANENT C.E.O.
45:16 AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE BUT NOT BEFORE FINDING EXACTLY THE RIGHT
45:21 PERSON. KAILEY: WELCOME BACK TO "BALANCE
45:24 OF POWER"." THAT WAS NVIDIA BOARD CLAIRE
45:31 HARVEY JONES MOMENTS AGO DURING A NVIDIA EARNINGS CALL THAT'S
45:36 STILL UNDERWAY. ED, WHAT NEW INSIGHTS ARE WE
45:41 GETTING AS WE SEE THE SHARES CLIMBING HIGHER?
45:47 ED: DIRECT, WHAT KRESSE IS KNOWN FOR BUT THE BOARD ACCEPTED
45:50 JENSEN HUANG'S RESIDENT I GUESS SO NATION AND AS FAR AS THE
45:53 BOARD IS CONCERNED HE IS NOT COMING BACK AT C.E.O. AND
45:59 THEY'RE FOCUSED ON A LONG-TERM SUCCESSOR SEARCH LOOKING AT BOTH
46:05 INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL CANDIDATES.
46:07 HARVEY JONES JUST BECAME THE CHAIR OF THE BOARD OUTLINED IT
46:11 AND COULDN'T HAVE BEEN MORE CLEAR ON THAT.
46:14 I THINK THE WORLD THAT NVIDIA IS OPERATING IN, AS BOTH KRESSE AND
46:24 HARVEY JONES EXPLAINED. THE YOUTH LOOK IS IMPROVING.
46:29 THAT'S WHY IT'S BEEN BOOSTED TO 75%.
46:33 THEY'RE CONFRONTING THAT WHILE CONSIDERING A CHANGE IN POLICY
46:36 DYNAMIC. KAILEY: GREAT STUFF.
46:37 THANK YOU. JOINING US IS OUR POLITICAL
46:42 PANEL. DEMOCRATIC STRATEGIST ADAM HODGE
46:50 AND LESLIE SHEDD FOUND EARN OF NONCOMMUNICATIONS AT THE
46:53 ATLANTIC COUNCIL. TO YOU BOTH, NVIDIA SAYS IT IS
46:59 CONFIDENT IN ITS FORECAST DESPITE POTENTIAL ADDITIONAL
47:02 EXPORT CONTROLS. SHOULD WE ASSUME THAT THOSE
47:06 CONTROLS ARE COMING? ADAM: ABSOLUTELY, THAT WHAT
47:13 YOU'RE SEEING IN WASHINGTON IS CLEAR THAT THEY'RE GOING TO PUT
47:18 A LASER ON NATIONAL SECURITY RISKS.
47:20 AS WARREN BUFFET SAID, YOU CAN BUILD A REPUTATION IN 20 YEARS
47:23 AND YOU CAN LOSING IT IN FIVE MINUTES AND IT'S CLEAR THAT
47:27 NVIDIA IS IN THAT FIVE-MINUTE WINDOW TODAY AND STEPS LIKE
47:31 ANNOUNCING A NEW NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL TO REVIEW THEIR
47:35 RISKS IS A GOOD SIGNAL TO WASHINGTON BUT THEY HAVE A LONG
47:38 ROAD AHEAD AND THERE ARE A LOT OF DETAILS WE STILL DON'T KNOW
47:43 ABOUT THE GRAVE NATIONAL SECURITY RISKS WE COULD BE
47:46 DEALING WITH. THOSE ARE THE CROWN JEWELS OF
47:53 AMERICA'S A.I. INFRASTRUCTURE AND MEMBERS OF CONGRESS WILL GET
47:56 PAST EARNINGS DAY AND HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT RISKS
48:00 STILL REMAIN. KAILEY: THE EARNINGS CALL HAS
48:04 OFFICIALLY ENDED. THE CONGRESSIONAL HEARINGS ARE
48:07 JUST BEGINNING. WHEN IT COMES TO EXPORT
48:12 CONTROLS, ARE WE TALKING MORE ABOUT NEW ONCE OR EXISTING ONES?
48:21 >> IT SHOULD BE BOTH. WE DID A TON OF WORK TRYING TO
48:30 GET THE EXCESS CONTROL PROCESS UNDER CONTROL AND HE GOT A BUNCH
48:35 OF NUMBERS RELEASE THAT SHOWED DONALD TRUMP FIRST
48:39 ADMINISTRATION STARTING ABOUT NOVEMBER 2020 UNTIL APRIL 20 OF
48:48 2021, $103 BILLION WORTH OF LICENSES WERE GRANTED TO TWO
48:52 CHINESE BLACKLISTED COMPANIES. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A FIVE MONTH
48:57 TIME PERIOD. THEY'RE BLACKLISTED.
49:03 IF MEGASPEED ISN'T EVEN ON THE LIST, WHAT ARE THEY GETTING FROM
49:06 THERE? WE HAVE TO GET IN LIST AWAY FROM
49:09 COMMERCE. THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT'S JOB IS
49:12 TO PROMOTE COMMERCE. THIS IS A NATIONAL SECURITY
49:15 APPARATUS. WE HAVE TO GET IN UNDER CONTROL.
49:19 IT IS A HUGE PROBLEM AND HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR YEARS AND
49:22 YEARS. KAILEY: IS HOWARD LUTNICK ALSO
49:30 PART OF THE PROCESS? >> MOST OF THIS RUNS BUT B.I.S.
49:34 WE WERE DEALING WITH THOSE FOLKS AND TRYING TO GET INFORMATION,
49:40 TRANSPARENCY AND CLARITY OUT OF THEM.
49:42 THE AMERICAN PEOPLE NEEDS TO KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON.
49:46 I FEEL LIKE THERE NEEDS TO BE A FULL INVESTIGATION.
49:49 I THINK THAT'S HAPPENING, BOTH IN THE HOUSE AND SENATE.
49:53 THEY ASKED FOR TESTIMONY FROM HUANG AND THAT'S REALLY
49:56 IMPORTANT. KAILEY: HOWARD LUTNICK HAS BEEN
49:58 ASKED TO APPEAR ON CAPITOL HILL. IN THE MEANTIME HE'S TRAVELING
50:05 WITH THE PRESIDENT IN ASIA RIGHT NOW.
50:09 HOW MUCH DO YOU THINK THIS WILL FACTOR INTO THE CONVERSATION AND
50:13 DELIVER ANYTHING? >> THIS IS CLEARLY A MAJOR
50:16 DISTRACTION FOR THE WHITE HOUSE. THERE IS BIPARTISAN CONSENSUS
50:21 THAT THIS IS A GREAT RISK. THE PROBLEM FOR HOWARD LUTNICK
50:25 IS THAT ALL THE REPORTING FROM BLOOMBERG AND OTHERS IS THAT HE
50:31 OVERRULE AND WOULD OVERSTEPPED THE REAL EXPERTISE OF FOLKS AT
50:36 B.I.S. AND IGNORED THE PUSH FROM SECRETARY OF TREASURY, FROM USTR
50:42 AND IT'S RARE FOR THAT TO EXIST OUTSIDE THE AGENCY AND FOR THEM
50:47 TO TOTALLY IGNORE IT. DEMOCRATS HAVE BEEN CLEAR
50:51 THEY'RE GOING TO ASK WHAT IS THE CORPORATE INFLUENCE OVER THE
50:54 DECISIONS THAT WERE MADE AT CONGRESS AND B.I.S. AND DID THEY
51:00 OVERRULE THE STATUE WHO HAD THE RIGHT EXPERTISE.
51:03 THAT'S WHY THERE ARE SO MANY LEGS TO GO IN THIS SCANDAL.
51:09 WE DON'T KNOW ALL THE DETAILS AND IF THAT WRAPS UP INTO THE
51:14 BORDER AREA OF ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THIS ADMINISTRATION.
51:19 KAILEY: SENATOR TILLIS WAS JUST TELLING JOE ON THE HILL IF THE
51:23 PRESIDENT ENDS UP IN A SITUATION WHERE WE NEEDS A NEW COMMERCE
51:27 SECRETARY, HE MIGHT NOT HAVE TO GET ONE APE PROVED IN A
51:32 DEMOCRATIC SENATE. WOULD HE HAVE TO GET ONE DOWN?
51:38 >> WE USED TO GET INTO IT BACK IN THE DAY.
51:41 THIS HAS BEEN A HUGE PROBLEM FOREVER.
51:44 FOR ME, I THINK THE PROBLEM IS SUSPECT SYSTEM.
51:48 WE HAVE TO GET THAT LIST, BIX WHAT IT DOES AWAY FROM THE
51:51 COMMERCE DEPARTMENT. THEIR WHOLE GOAL IS TO
51:56 SUPPORTERS AND THIS IS NATIONAL SECURITY.
51:58 KAILEY: OUR POLITICAL PANEL THIS EVENING, THANK YOU SO MUCH.
52:02 JOE IS STILL ON CAPITOL HILL FRESH OFF THAT CONVERSATION NOT
52:06 JUST WITH SENATOR TILLIS BUT SENATOR RAND PAUL.
52:10 BOTH CONVERSATIONS ILLUMINATING THE FACT THAT CONGRESS IS
52:16 NOWHERE NEAR BEING OVER WITH THIS.
52:18 JOE: THAT'S MORE SURE AND TO BE HOWARD LUTNICK PREPARING FOR
52:22 THAT TESTIMONY AFTER WHAT THOM TILLIS TOLD US, HE'S GOING TO
52:26 FACE SOME DIFFICULT QUESTIONS AND TO THE POINT JUST BROUGHT
52:30 UP, MIGHT NOT HAVE A JOB BY THE END OF THE YEAR.
52:33 THAT APPEARS TO BE THE URGING OF AT LEAST ONE IMPORTANT PERSON ON
52:39 THAT PANEL. INTERESTINGLY, WE DIDN'T HEAR
52:43 FROM JENSEN HUANG AS WE DID HOWARD LUTNICK AND BOTH MADE
52:49 CLEAR TO US THAT A $50 BILLION ASK TO REBUILD THE CONTROL
52:52 SYSTEM IN THIS COUNTRY IS GOING TO BE TOO MUCH.
52:57 KAILEY: SEAN DUTCHY DID TELL REPORTS ON THE HILL HE'LL TAKE
53:00 WHAT HE CAN GET. JOE MATHIEU ON THE HILL.
53:03 THANK YOU SO MUCH. JOE WILL BE BACK WITH ME IN OUR
53:06 WASHINGTON, D.C. STUDIO TOMORROW AND IN THE MEANTIME FOR MORE
53:12 COVERAGE, CHECK OUT THE WASHINGTON EDITION ON THE
53:15 TERMINAL AND ONLINE. WE'LL SEE YOU ON BLOOMBERG TV
Trump Set to Meet With Xi and Putin in China full transcript
0:00 What is Trump looking to accomplish out of his meeting with president Xi Jinping and president
0:04 Vladimir Putin?
0:08 Well, Isabel, there's a lot on the agenda. According to the White House, they are expected
0:13 to, one, discuss actually the conflict in Iran as well as the war in Ukraine, though
0:17 that, of course, is raising questions about how much could actually get done on the diplomatic
0:22 front considering that Ukraine does not have a seat at this table. But president Trump himself
0:27 had alluded to the fact that he also will very likely bring up NVIDIA's former former
0:32 CEO, Jensen Huang, amid the fallout that is happening there and what has been this increasing
0:38 in the tensions between The US and China leading up to this trip. We actually got
0:43 a preview of what potentially could happen behind closed doors tomorrow during this trilateral meeting as
0:49 both Chinese president Xi Jinping and Russian president Vladimir Putin used their address to the APEC
0:55 summit here in Shenzhen to, warn against what they're calling economic barriers and protectionist policies seeming
1:03 to provide that bulwark against some of The US's policies. Of course, Beijing's commerce department yesterday
1:09 had pledged that it will issue its own countermeasures if the US commerce department follows through
1:14 on its planned export restrictions that seek to curb Chinese access to advance chips, and that
1:20 is definitely raising the stakes here since we know that China was coming into this week
1:24 hoping to see The US actually loosen restrictions when it comes to US tech. Isabelle, a
1:30 lot that still needs to play out. Ultimately, our own analysts at Bloomberg Economics say expect
1:35 a lot of headlines, but don't necessarily expect a lot of breakthroughs when it comes to
1:40 the tangible policy side of things.
1:41 How much is this a conversation, Tyler, that's been thrust upon these world leaders? How much
1:46 of this meeting was in hopes of trying to do something that went towards ending two
1:52 wars?
1:56 That's a pretty good question considering that, Dani, we've heard ourselves. Our reporting has indicated that
2:02 US officials really view this foreign trip by president Trump as a way that he can
2:07 project power abroad, especially after we're having some of those really deep midterm losses on the
2:12 domestic policy front. This is an administration at the moment that is really trying to net
2:17 some of those foreign policy wins, you will, try to make some sort of diplomatic progress
2:22 in two conflicts at the moment where we really haven't seen that happening. Now with that
2:27 said, president Trump himself and actually the Kremlin earlier today both alluded to the fact that
2:33 there's probably another meeting on the books that's going to take place. One that we know
2:37 of for sure, the Chinese president Xi Jinping is expected to travel to Miami for the
2:42 g twenty next month, but now you have the Russian government floating the idea that they're
2:46 talking to The US about having Vladimir Putin go to the g twenty two. So this
2:51 meeting is perhaps setting the stakes, setting the table for what could be further dialogue down
2:57 the road.
2:58 Tyler, thank you so very much for joining us. That is Bloomberg's Tyler Kendall. And this
3:03 market still selling off down a third of a percent with a bid into bonds. Let's
3:07 go straight to NVIDIA near the lows of this morning's session, down 1.6% after a beat,
3:14 after a raise, and after commitment to buying back more stock.
Xi Welcomes Trump at Shenzhen Airport full transcript
0:00 Погибе
0:01 [музыка]
0:02 пои
0:17 [музыка]
0:21 [музыка]
0:26 [музыка]
0:38 >> [музыка]
0:44 >> поеле [музыка]
0:46 поиле
0:49 [музыка]
0:49 пои
0:51 пои
Bloomberg Surveillance 11/18/2026 full transcript
0:05 >> THE TREND LINE IS NO LONGER THAT HOCKEY STICK WE'VE TAKEN
0:09 FOR GRANTED IN THE AI TRADE. >> IT'S AMAZING HOW THIS WHOLE
0:14 AREA HAS EVOLVED OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS.
0:17 >> WHAT REALLY HAS TO BE YOUR NORTHSTAR IS HOW DOES THE DEMAND
0:19 FOR COMPUTE LOOK? >> THIS WILL BE A DIFFICULT TIME
0:23 FOR THE MARKETS. THE QUESTION IS, HOW MUCH PAIN
0:25 CAN IT TAKE? >> YOU HAD TO BE VERY MEASURED
0:29 ABOUT WHERE YOU ARE TAKING RISKS.
0:33 ANNOUNCER: THIS IS BLOOMBERG "SURVEILLANCE," WITH JONATHAN
0:33 FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ, AND ANNMARIE HORDERN.
0:38 JONATHAN: GOOD MORNING, GOOD MORNING.
0:39 BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE STARTS NOW.
0:42 COMING INTO WEDNESDAY LOOKING FOR REBOUNDS.
0:44 TECH STOCKS PUSHING HIGHER FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY LOSING
0:48 STREAK AS NVIDIA ATTEMPTED TO SILENCE THE DOUBTERS WITH A BEAT
0:51 AND RAISE. ANTHROPIC ON COURSE FOR
0:55 RECORD-BREAKING IPO AT THE TOP OF THE RANGE.
1:00 DANI: THIS IS BUSINESS AS USUAL. IT HAS NOT BEEN A KIND MARKET
1:05 FOR ANTHROPIC TO IPO. IT IS MURPHY'S LAW, EVERYTHING
1:09 THAT COULD GO WRONG WITH AI HAS GIVEN WRONG.
1:12 IT DID GET SOME RELIEF IN THE WAY OF NVIDIA EARNINGS.
1:15 IT TAKES OUT SOME OF THE STING. NVIDIA ITSELF A PLACEMENT IN THE
1:21 COMPANY WHEN IT IPO'S. JONATHAN: FOLLOWING THE BEAT AND
1:25 THE RAYS AND EARNINGS CALL, STOCK IS UP BY 3.5%.
1:30 WILL THEY GET RID OF GUIDANCE? THEY RAISED IT.
1:33 WILL THEY CHANGE THEIR APPROACH TO FINANCING THE ECOSYSTEM?
1:36 VERY POSSIBLY. HOW MUCH REVENUE IS AT RISK
1:41 FOLLOWING THE PIVOT? THEY WERE SUPER VAGUE.
1:46 WALL STREET DID INTO A FANTASTIC JOB OF GETTING THE ANSWERS.
1:51 LISA: IT FELT LIKE MANY SOFTBALLS FROM THE ANALYST
1:53 COMMUNITY. THEY WANT TO SEE WHAT KINDS OF
1:57 THINGS ARE THEY GOING TO DISCLOSE BECAUSE THIS MATTERS A
1:59 LOT FOR THEM. ARE THEY GOING TO GET TO A
2:02 SITUATION WHERE SOUTH EAST ASIA EARNINGS ARE ESSENTIALLY ZEROED
2:04 OUT? WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES THIS MAKE
2:06 FOR THEM? WE KNOW THEY ARE BACKING OFF OF
2:10 SALES TO CHINA SO THEY ARE ALREADY MAKING ADJUSTMENTS, BUT
2:12 HOW MUCH MORE ADJUSTMENTS DO THEY NEED TO MAKE?
2:15 JONATHAN: CHECK OUT SOME OF THE NEO-CLOUD PLAYERS.
2:19 COREWEAVE IS DOING NICELY IN THE PREMARKET, BUT THIS QUOTE STANDS
2:22 OUT. RIGOROUSLY EVALUATING FUTURE
2:26 INVESTMENT COMMITMENTS AND GUARANTEES.
2:27 ARE WE ABOUT TO SEE A CHANGE THAT MIGHT HURT SOME OF THESE
2:29 NAMES? DANI: IT'S HUGELY IMPORTANT AND
2:33 IT MATTERS FOR THE ENTIRETY OF THE ECOSYSTEM, BECAUSE THESE
2:37 NEO-CLOUDS CONTINUOUSLY SAY WE HAVE MORE DEMAND THAN SUPPLY.
2:40 COREWEAVE SAYS WE HAVE 10 X DEMAND FOR WHAT WE CAN SUPPLY.
2:44 IS THE CREDIT WORTHINESS OF THEIR VERY OWN CUSTOMERS, THE
2:47 ONES GOING TO THE NEO-CLOUDS. THEY ARE NOT THE ESTABLISHED
2:50 PLAYERS. THEY ARE A STARTUPS, SMALLER
2:54 PLAYERS, AND MAYBE THEY DON'T HAVE THE CREDIT WORTHINESS IS
2:56 THAT THE NEO-CLOUDS THEMSELVES DON'T HAVE.
2:59 YOU HAVE A FRAGILE ECOSYSTEM BUILT ON THESE COMPANIES THAT
3:02 ARE SUB INVESTMENT GRADE. NVIDIA SAYS WE WILL CONTINUE TO
3:05 DO WORK WITH OUR INVESTMENT-GRADE PARTNERS.
3:08 JONATHAN: NVIDIA OF THREE, FUTURES DOING BETTER BY 0.6
3:13 PERCENT ON THE S&P 500 AND A BIT OF A BOUNCE ON THE NASDAQ.
3:17 DANI ALONGSIDE ME FOR THE NEXT FEW HOURS.
3:20 WE WILL CATCH UP WITH ANGELO ZINO,EDWARD YADENI AND WENDY
3:37 CULTER. THOUGH HAS THE LATEST.
3:46 ED: THE OUTLOOK FOR GROWTH WAS EVERYTHING.
3:48 IT WAS THE BASE MINIMUM THAT THE MARKET WANTED TO HEAR GOING INTO
3:49 IT. THE WAY THAT COLETTE KRESS
3:54 EXPLAINED THAT IT IS REPRESENTATIVE OF DEMAND RUNNING
3:58 HOT BUT ACCELERATING.
4:00 THEY'VE BEEN ABLE TO FIND SOME IMPROVEMENT IN SUPPLY.
4:03 VERY INTERESTING THE COMMENTS YOU CITED ON THE NEO-CLOUDS.
4:07 COLETTE KRESS WAS CATEGORY THIS IS NOT A CHANGE IN POLICY.
4:10 BEING MORE DISCERNING. IT IS A CHANGE IN TONE.
4:14 WHAT SHE IDENTIFIED HIS BOTTLENECKS FOR A LOT OF
4:16 NEO-CLOUDS AND BROADLY DATA CENTER PROJECTS BEING LAND,
4:18 POWER. SHE WANTED PROOF IN DECIDING
4:22 WHERE TO FINANCE THAT THEY WOULD BE OPERATIONAL.
4:24 THAT THEY WILL WOULD BE SITES READY TO GO BEFORE ALLOCATING
4:31 GPU'SS'S, BUT WANTED THAT THE CAPITOL WAS READY TO GO.
4:34 THE END SITUATION BEING THEY WILL NEED TO STAND ON THEIR OWN
4:37 TWO FEET AND GET THEIR FINANCING IN ORDER.
4:40 YOU ARE RIGHT TO FLAG WHAT'S HAPPENING IN SOUTHEAST ASIA.
4:43 THE DIRECT CHINA SALES, WE KNOW ABOUT THAT.
4:46 NOTHING HAS CHANGED THAT MONTH. THE ASSUMPTION OF ZERO FOR THE
4:48 FISCAL FOURTH-QUARTER ISN'T THAT PART OF THE DEPARTURE FROM THE
4:52 VERY SMALL SALES THEY HAD IN FISCAL 2Q AND 3Q.
5:03 RULES FROM THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT MEANS AND HOW THEY
5:08 WILL BE IMPACTED IN SINGAPORE, MALAYSIA, THAILAND, ETC..
5:11 AT THE END OF THE DAY OF DEMAND IS RUNNING SO HOT, IF THEY CAN'T
5:15 SHIP TO THOSE NATIONS IT WILL BE MADE UP OR ELSEWHERE.
5:18 THE MESSAGE WAS PRETTY CLEAR THAT THIS COMPANY FROM A BOARD
5:21 PERSPECTIVE IS MOVING ON WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG.
5:24 JONATHAN: AT THE TOP OF THE EARNINGS CALL, AND PUSHING
5:27 ANALYSTS TO NOT EVEN ASK ABOUT IT.
5:29 ED LUDLOW WITH THE LATEST. BUSINESS AS USUAL EXCEPT IT'S
5:32 NOT BUSINESS AS USUAL. THE BUSINESS HAS CHANGED AND THE
5:37 REGULATION HAS CHANGED AS WELL.
5:42 DANI: A SENSE OF IRONY FOR COLETTE PRESS TO SAY THIS IS
5:44 BUSINESS AS USUAL. THIS IS A COMPANY THAT HAS
5:49 ASSEMBLED A COMMITTEE OF SORTS. THEY HAVE A LOT OF CHANGES THEY
5:52 ARE POTENTIALLY LOOKING AT AND DON'T QUITE HAVE A HANDLE ON
5:54 WHAT THAT MEANS FOR THEMSELVES. JONATHAN: THIS FROM ANGELO ZINO,
6:03 NOTING NVIDIA'S ATTRACTIVE VALUATION, MASSIVE FREE CASH
6:05 FLOW POTENTIAL INVESTING CLASS SOFTWARE IS REASONS NOT TO SELL,
6:09 DIP. WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM.
6:13 AFTERNOON? ANGELO: THANKS FOR HAVING ME.
6:20 I WOULD SAY OVERALL IT WAS A SOLID EARNINGS CALL.
6:24 AND OVERALL RESULTS -- NVIDIA DID WHAT THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO
6:27 DO WHEN THEY WERE TRYING TO CALM THE INVESTOR NERVES.
6:32 THE TEAM IT SEEMS LIKE THEY'RE ON THE SAME PAGE IN THE SENSE
6:35 THEY ARE GOING TO MOVE ON WITHOUT JENSEN, TRYING TO REMOVE
6:39 SOME OF THE NOISE OUT THERE. THAT WAS A KEY TO THE CALL.
6:44 WHETHER OR NOT INVESTORS ARE GOING TO LIKE THAT FOR THE LONG
6:49 TERM REMAINS TO BE SEEN PROVIDED OVERALL GUIDANCE, VISIBILITY WAS
6:51 ALSO KEY. THEY DID INCREASE THE GUIDE
6:58 NUMBER TO 75% GROWTH FROM 70%. THERE WAS AN UNKNOWN AND WHETHER
7:01 THEY WOULD DO THAT ON THIS CALL, AND THEY DID.
7:06 I WOULD SAY THEY DID THAT DESPITE KNOWING EXPORT
7:07 RESTRICTIONS ARE COMING DOWN THE ROAD, BUT THAT SAID THERE ARE
7:12 STILL A LOT OF QUESTIONS THAT REMAIN AS WE GET FURTHER DOWN
7:20 THE ROAD INTO CALENDAR 28. THE OTHER THING, HIGHLIGHTED
7:22 ONGOING EFFORTS TO THE POINT TO SUPPORT THE AI ECOSYSTEM BUT
7:25 THEY ARE GOING TO BE MORE SELECTIVE.
7:27 I THINK THAT'S KEY BUT AN INCREMENTAL POSITIVE TO SOME OF
7:30 THE BIGGER NEO-CLOUDS OUT THERE, WHAT YOU WOULD ANTICIPATE WOULD
7:33 BE SOME OF THE MORE SELECT-TYPE COMPANIES OUT THERE.
7:37 FINALLY, THE FACT THAT THEY DON'T STAY AGGRESSIVE ON THE
7:40 BUYBACKS REMAINS TO BE SEEN, BUT I THINK THE FACT THAT THEY
7:42 WANTED TO THAT IS DEFINITELY A POSITIVE AND IT SHOULD HELP KIND
7:45 OF STABILIZE SHARES. DANI: BY RAISING THEIR 2028
7:50 GROWTH TO 75% YOU ASSUME THAT'S CONSERVATIVE FROM THEM?
7:58 WHAT YOU ARE FLAGGING AS THE UNKNOWN AT THE MOMENT WITH THEIR
7:59 SOUTHEAST ASIA SALES? ANGELO: IT IS A GOOD QUESTION.
8:05 I THINK IS THE BEST INDICATION OF A DEMAND LOOKS LIKE RIGHT
8:07 NOW, I THINK THE DEMAND ENVIRONMENT REMAINS VERY STRONG
8:10 IN NATURE, I THINK THEY FEEL FAIRLY CONFIDENT ENOUGH IN TERMS
8:14 OF EXPECTATIONS FROM THE HYPERSCALERS GOING INTO CALENDAR
8:18 2027 THAT THEY CAN OFFSET THE WEAKNESS IN SOUTHEAST ASIA INTO
8:21 THE U.S. THAT SAID, I THINK IT'S
8:25 INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT AS WE START MOVING, AGAIN,
8:30 TOWARDS THE END OF CALENDAR 27 INTO 28, AS WE START REMOVING
8:37 SOME OF THESE IMPORTANT AND MARKETS.
8:39 CHINA OBVIOUSLY IS GOING TO -- APPEARS IT IS PERMANENTLY
8:43 REMOVED FROM NVIDIA IN TERMS OF THEIR ADDRESSABLE MARKET.
8:47 REMOVING, POTENTIALLY, MORE PARTS OF SOUTHEAST ASIA.
8:50 INEVITABLY THAT'S GOING TO HAVE AN NEGATIVE IMPACT IN TERMS OF
8:53 THE GROWTH TRAJECTORY FOR THIS COMPANY.
8:56 DANI: SOMETHING ED SAID, THE IDEA THAT DEMAND IS SO GREAT, IS
9:01 IT A PROBLEM? IS IT A PROBLEM THAT THEY REMOVE
9:04 SALES IN SOUTHEAST ASIA? IS THERE ENOUGH IN THE UNITED
9:06 STATES TO MAKE UP FOR WHAT THAT DEMAND LOOKED LIKE?
9:12 ANGELO: TODAY, YES. THE DEMAND IS THERE TODAY.
9:15 I THINK THE ISSUE NOW BECOMES AS WE PROGRESS THROUGH CALENDAR
9:20 2027, AS YOU START LOOKING AT THE ACTUAL RUN RATE HERE FOR A
9:25 TRAJECTORY FOR CAPEX SPEND, IT IS GOING TO START TO LEVEL OUT,
9:27 SLOW DOWN. WE DON'T THINK IT IS GOING TO
9:30 ROLL OVER BUT IT IS GOING TO SLOW DOWN.
9:34 AS THAT STARTS TO SLOW DOWN AND THE COMPETITIVE PRESSURE STARTS
9:39 TO INTENSIFY WITH AMD GETTING MORE TRACTION IN LARGE-SCALE
9:41 ROCK SOLUTIONS AND BROADCOM WITH WHAT THEY ARE DOING WITH NOT
9:43 ONLY ON THE GPU SITE BUT DIRECTLY WITH ANTHROPIC, THE
9:47 GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES BECOME MORE CHALLENGING IN THE U.S. MARKET.
9:55 THE POTENTIAL TO HAVE OPPORTUNITIES IN OTHER PARTS OF
9:57 THE WORLD, MAKES IT INCREDIBLY MORE CHALLENGING FOR THEM TO
10:01 CONTINUE TO GROW AT A CERTAIN RATE AS WE GO INTO CALENDAR
10:05 2028. JONATHAN: WE TALK SO MUCH ABOUT
10:08 REGULATION, DO YOU THINK THE BIGGER THREAT COULD BE
10:09 COMPETITION? ANGELO: I DO, ACTUALLY.
10:13 I THINK COMPETITION, AGAIN, IN THE SLOWING ENVIRONMENT IS
10:17 SOMETHING THAT IS GOING TO BECOME MORE APPARENT.
10:18 AND CLEARLY THE IMPACT IT HAS ON MARGINS ALSO.
10:22 IN THE NEAR TERM IT IS NOT A HUGE RISK BECAUSE OF THE FACT
10:24 THAT, LISTEN, THEY ARE RAMPING UP.
10:28 THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE INTO CALENDAR 2027 HIKES.
10:33 THAT'S ALSO GOING TO BE A TAILWIND IN TERMS OF THE GROWTH
10:35 TRAJECTORY FOR NVIDIA. REALLY I THINK WHAT'S GOING TO
10:39 BE KEY OVER THE NEXT, LET'S CALL IT, THREE TO FOUR QUARTERS, IS
10:43 BEING ABLE TO ENSURE THERE IS NOT RISK FROM THE EMPLOYEES AND
10:48 THEN BEING ABLE TO EXECUTE ON RUBEN ULTRA AS WE GET INTO THE
10:52 SECOND HALF OF CALENDAR 2027, WHICH IS GOING TO BE THERE FOR
10:55 KEY PRODUCT RAMP WITHOUT JENSEN. IF THEY CAN EXECUTE ON THAT I
10:59 THINK ALL OF A SUDDEN YOU COULD POTENTIALLY TALK ABOUT THE STOCK
11:03 STARTING TO WORK AND GAIN SOME MOMENTUM AND CONFIDENCE FROM THE
11:05 BROADER INVESTMENT COMMUNITIES. BUT UNTIL THEN I THINK YOU'RE
11:08 JUST GOING TO CONTINUE TO GET A LOT OF UNCERTAINTY.
11:13 JONATHAN: FORGIVE ME FOR THE UNCOMFORTABLE QUESTION I'M ABOUT
11:15 TO POST TO YOU BUT YOU'VE BEEN ON THESE CALLS, WHY IS IT SO
11:19 DIFFICULT TO ENGAGE IN THE C SUITE IN A MORE PROBING WAY ON
11:22 SOME OF THESE EARNINGS CALLS? I FOUND THEY WERE SUPER SOFT
11:25 WITH THE C-SUITE YESTERDAY AT A REALLY CRITICAL TIME FOR THE
11:26 COMPANY. ANGELO: YEAH, I THINK YOU MAKE A
11:33 FAIR POINT. I THINK IT IS DEFINITELY AN
11:36 ISSUE OVERALL FROM THE BROADER INVESTMENT COMMUNITY AT TIMES,
11:40 AND I THINK ESPECIALLY FOR NVIDIA, WE ARE AT A VERY
11:43 SENSITIVE TIME IN NATURE FOR THEM.
11:48 YOU HAVE THIS CHANGE TURNOVER. IT'S REALLY FAIR TO CRITICIZE
11:55 COLETTE AT A TIME JUST SO MUCH TO DO WITH.
11:57 IT SEEMS LIKE IT HAS BEEN AN ETERNITY SINCE JENSEN HAS LEFT
11:59 BUT IT'S ONLY BEEN A WEEK OR SO. THERE IS SO MUCH UNCERTAINTY,
12:05 MOVING PARTS, WHERE YOU CAN ASK FOR ALL THE QUESTIONS YOU WANT,
12:08 YOU'RE PROBABLY NOT GOING TO GET THE ANSWERS YOU WANT ANYWAY.
12:10 JONATHAN: TRUE. BEEN THERE.
12:18 ANGELO, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ON COLETTE KRESS, I TAKE NO JOY
12:21 IN SAYING THIS AND NO JUDGMENT OF HER AS A COMMUNICATOR, BUT
12:25 SHE SOUNDED SUPER NERVOUS ON THE CALL.
12:31 HER ABILITY TO COMMUNICATE THE STORY GOING FORWARD FROM HERE,
12:34 I'M INTERESTED IN SEEING THAT HAPPEN OVER THE NEXT FEW MONTHS.
12:37 DANI: IT'S HUGELY IMPORTANT. WE CAN QUESTION THEIR CALL TO
12:41 ESSENTIALLY SAY WE'RE NOT TAKING OR ANSWERING ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT
12:43 LEADERSHIP, ABOUT JENSEN HUANG'S CEO, AND HE NOT COMING BACK.
12:48 WE CAN ALSO QUESTION WHY DIDN'T THE ANALYSTS AT LEAST TRY, AT
12:51 LEAST ASK? THIS IS A MOMENT THIS IS THE
12:53 CLOUD SURROUNDING THEM. THERE ARE OTHER CLOUDS THAT ALSO
12:56 WEREN'T ADDRESSED. JENSEN HUANG, THE REASON HE WAS
13:00 SUCH AN IMPORTANT CEO'S HE WAS THE SPOKESPERSON FOR THIS ENTIRE
13:03 PROJECT, FOR ALL OF AI. THIS IS JUST ANOTHER EXAMPLE
13:07 THAT, YES, THERE IS A VACUUM RIGHT NOW.
13:09 JONATHAN: WE MAY HAVE MADE TOO MUCH OF THIS BUT I'VE SEEN THIS
13:12 IN JOURNALISM, AND THE BEST WAY AROUND IT IS TO ACT AS A TEAM.
13:15 IF THE ANALYSTS GO ON THE CALL AND ACT AS ONE NONE HAVE TO
13:19 WORRY ABOUT LOSING ACCESS, THEY ARE NOT GOING TO SHUT OUT THE
13:21 ANALYST COMMUNITY RIGHT NOW, THAT WOULD BE A DANGEROUS THING
13:24 TO DO. I SEE THIS WITH ACCESS
13:28 JOURNALISTS WHO WORRY ABOUT OFFENDING THE CEO WHO MAY NOT
13:31 WANT TO DO AN INTERVIEW WITH THEM AGAIN.
13:33 IF THEY ALL ACT AS ONE AND ASK PROBING QUESTIONS WOULD GET
13:35 BETTER ANSWERS. I SEE NO JOY IN SAYING THIS, I
13:38 DID NOT GET THAT FROM THE CALL YESTERDAY AFTERNOON AT ALL.
13:41 IF I WAS GOING TO GREAT WALL STREET AND THE QUESTION IS NEVER
13:44 ASKED AND TO THE PROBING NATURE OF THAT CALL, SEE MINAS,
13:47 HONESTLY. I WAS LOOKING FOR A MUCH BETTER
13:54 CALL THAN THAT . DANI: THIS IS A SELL SIDE THAT
13:59 IS OFTEN LOATH TO DOWNGRADE STOCKS.
14:00 IT MUCH FURTHER YOU CAN GO. I THINK THEY ARE STILL NERVOUS
14:03 WITH UPSETTING THIS COMPANY THAT DOESN'T EVEN HAVE A PERMIT CEO
14:05 AT THIS MOMENT. I'M RIGHT THERE WITH YOU, JON.
14:08 I REALLY DO WISH WE HAD GOTTEN MORE FROM THEM BECAUSE THIS IS
14:11 AN INVESTMENT COMMUNITY THAT DESERVES TO LEARN MORE FROM
14:13 NVIDIA. JONATHAN: STOCK IS UP 3% AFTER A
14:16 BEAT AND A RAISE YESTERDAY AFTERNOON.
14:18 NEWS WORLDWIDE, WITH YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF, ISABELLE LEE.
14:23 ISABELLE: PRESIDENT TRUMP ARRIVING IN SHENZHEN, CHINA FOR
14:25 THE APEC SUMMIT. XI GREETED TRUMP ON THE TARMAC
14:30 AND THE TWO LEADERS EMBRACED IN A HUG.
14:33 TRUMP WILL MEET WITH PRESIDENT XI AND RUSSIAN PRESIDENT
14:35 VLADIMIR PUTIN TOMORROW. TENSIONS ON GOING BETWEEN THE
14:37 U.S. AND IRAN. AMERICAN WAR PLANES HITTING AN
14:41 IRANIAN MISSILE LAUNCH SITE IN THE PERSIAN GULF.
14:46 SAYING THE RESPONSE IS AN ATTACK IN RESPONSE TO TARGETING U.S.
14:48 PERSONNEL AND ASSETS COMING AS STALL AS PEACE TALKS HAVE
14:54 STALLED. APPLE SAYING AN UPDATE CAUSED
14:58 DISRUPTIONS TO THE APP STORE, EMPLOYEE TOOLS, RETAIL
15:00 OPERATIONS, AND CONSUMER SERVICES.
15:02 THE COMPANY SAYS THE PROBLEMS DID NOT STEM FROM A CYBER
15:04 ATTACK. THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
15:08 JONATHAN: MORE LATER THIS HOUR. NEXT ON THE PROGRAM, NVIDIA
15:11 CHIPPING AWAY AT AI FEARS. >> THE NEXT ONE TO TWO YEARS IS
15:17 STILL VERY SOLID FOR NVIDIA. THE UNCERTAINTY IS GOING TO BE
15:20 MUCH FURTHER DOWN THE ROAD. A LOT OF THAT IS GOING TO BE
15:22 DETERMINED ON WHOEVER THE NEW SEO IS THAT WILL COME IN.
15:25 JONATHAN: NEXT WE WILL CATCH UP WITH EDWARD YARDENI.
15:27 FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING.
15:53 ♪ JONATHAN: NVIDIA DOING BETTER
15:55 THIS MORNING, THE STOCK IS UP BY SOMETHING LIKE 3% IN THE
15:56 PREMARKET DOWN BY 10% OVER THE LAST FOUR SESSIONS COME ON
16:03 THE MONTH DOWN BY 24% HEADED INTO THOSE RESULTS.
16:06 A BEAT AND A RAISE UNLOCKING SOME GAINS.
16:08 UNLOCKING GAMES MORE BROADLY IN THE EQUITY MARKET.
16:11 THE NASDAQ DOING BETTER TOO FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY SITE.
16:15 UP BY 0.5% ON THE NASDAQ. UP BY .9%.
16:19 THE PRICING OF ANTHROPIC, THAT'S OUR CITRATE TOMORROW MORNING.
16:22 DANI: THAT WILL BE THE NEXT SPEEDBUMP THING TO LOOK FOR FOR
16:25 THIS MARKET AND IT WILL BE IMPORTANT BECAUSE AS WE WERE
16:28 JUST DISCUSSING, WHO IS THE AI LEADERSHIP NOW?
16:31 WHO IS THE STEWARD THAT CAN COMMUNICATE JUST HOW MUCH DEMAND
16:33 THERE IS? HOW BULLISH WE SHOULD BE AROUND
16:35 AI? MAY BE AROUND AI?
16:40 MAYBE A REASON FOR STOCKS NOT TO DRIFT.
16:42 WILL DARIO TAKE THAT LEAD AND BE THAT LEADER?
16:44 JONATHAN: CHIPPING AWAY AT AI FEARS.
16:49 >> THE NEXT ONE TO TWO YEARS IS STILL VERY SOLID FOR NVIDIA.
16:52 THE UNCERTAINTY WILL BE MUCH FURTHER DOWN THE ROAD.
16:54 WHAT THE ROADMAP LOOKS LIKE MAYBE TWO YEARS FROM NOW.
16:56 A LOT OF THAT WILL BE DETERMINED ON WHOEVER THE NEW CEO IS THAT
16:59 WILL COME IN, AND I THINK THAT'S GOING TO BE SOMETHING INVESTORS
17:02 ARE GOING TO WANT TO SEE BEFORE THEY CAN REALLY HAVE SOME SORT
17:04 OF LONG TERM VIEW. JONATHAN: THE LATEST FROM THE
17:08 S&P 500 STARTS TO SNAP A FOUR-A LOSING STREAK IS NVIDIA'S
17:11 RECORD-BREAKING REVENUE AND STRONG GUIDANCE ASSUAGES FEARS
17:14 AROUND THE TECH TRADE. HIS EARNINGS OUTLOOK HAS
17:18 CONTINUED TO IMPROVE IT EVEN HAS ITS VALUATION HAS CONTINUED TO
17:20 FALL. ED JOINS US FOR MORE.
17:23 GOOD MORNING. HAVE WE SETTLED SOME NERVES IN
17:24 THE LAST 24 HOURS? EDWARD: WELL, THERE HAS BEEN A
17:28 LOT OF DRAMA HERE, NOT JUST THE PAST 24 HOURS FOR THE PAST
17:30 SEVERAL DAYS. I THINK, YOU KNOW, WE ARE NOW
17:37 PASSING FROM THE DRAMA TO THE ANTHROPIC DRAMA, SO THERE IS
17:42 ALWAYS SOMETHING TO GET EXCITED ABOUT ONE WAY OR THE OTHER.
17:56 WHAT IS THE BULL CASE WITH THAT IN MIND?
17:59 EDWARD: A FEW MONTHS AGO WE WERE ALL CONCERNED WE WERE GOING TO
18:02 FAST DOWN THE AI ROAD. I LOVE THE EXPRESSION YOU USED.
18:07 SPEEDBUMPS I. THINK THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE
18:13 ARE SEEING. SPEEDBUMPS AVOID ACCIDENTS.
18:23 LET'S CALM DOWN, SO THIS DOWN, RECOGNIZE THEIR PHYSICAL
18:26 CONSTRAINTS AND GETTING SEMICONDUCTORS.
18:29 LET'S RECOGNIZE THE BOND MARKET, THE BOND VIGILANTES HAVE FINALLY
18:32 FOCUSED ON CREDIT QUALITY IN THE AI TRADE.
18:37 NOW WE HAVE THE POLITICAL ISSUE OF THE MIDTERMS AND WHAT THAT
18:38 IMPLIES. SLOWING IT DOWN IS A BIG
18:41 POSITIVE. AND I THINK NOW THAT WE ARE PAST
18:48 THE NVIDIA EARNINGS NEWS AND THE MARKET SEEMS TO BE RESPONDING
18:51 WELL TO THAT, I THINK WE'RE GOING TO BE PLEASANTLY SURPRISED
18:54 HOW WELL AND DROP IT GOES. IN THE AI TRADE IS ALIVE AND
18:55 WELL. THEY USED TO SAY THE KING IS
18:59 DEAD, LONG LIVE THE KING. JUST A SAYING THE TRANSITION
19:04 FROM ONE MONARCH TO THE OTHER. I THINK WHAT HAPPENED HERE IS
19:08 KIND OF A TRANSITION. THE AI TRADE IS ALIVE AND WELL.
19:13 DANI: I HEARD THE ARGUMENT A BUBBLE IS IMPORTANT FOR THIS
19:14 MARKET. FOR ONE, YOU HAVE CONSUMERS
19:17 DOING WELL, THEY FEEL RICH BECAUSE OF WHAT EQUITY MARKETS
19:19 ARE DOING. TWO, SO MUCH OF THE AI ECOSYSTEM
19:23 HAS BEEN FINANCED BECAUSE EVERYONE IS SO ENTHUSIASTIC AND
19:26 WILLING TO FINANCE ON CREDIT WORTHY TYPE COMPANIES.
19:30 EDWARD: THAT'S CHANGING, RIGHT? DANI: THAT IS, BUT DOES THAT
19:32 MEAN THIS IS A FRAGILE TRADE? IS IT A GOOD THING ALMOST TO
19:36 HAVE A BUBBLE BECAUSE YOU WANT THIS BUILT OUT TO HAPPEN?
19:39 THE ENTHUSIASM ALLOWS IT TO HAPPEN.
19:41 EDWARD: I WANT TO BUILD OUT TO HAPPEN, BUT I WANT IT TO HAPPEN
19:47 IN A WAY THAT IS SUSTAINABLE THAT DOESN'T CREATE A BUBBLE
19:49 THAT BURSTS. THERE HAVE CERTAINLY BEEN BUBBLE
19:53 FUTURES IN THIS AI TRADE. EVERY NOW AND THEN, IF WE TAKE
19:58 THE AIR OUT OF IT RATHER THAN BURST THE BUBBLE, THAT'S A GOOD
19:59 THING. WE DON'T WANTED TO COME BACK AND
20:03 TAKE THE ECONOMY DOWN AND CAUSE A RECESSION.
20:08 I THINK THAT'S KIND OF WHAT THE RECENT SELLOFF IN THE MARKET HAS
20:10 BEEN ALL ABOUT. CONCERNS THAT, OH MY GOD, IT'S
20:14 NOT SPEEDBUMP'S, IT'S ROADBLOCKS.
20:17 IT IS A CLIFF. WE ARE GOING TO GO OFF A CLIFF,
20:22 LIKE THELMA AND LOUISE. REMEMBER THE MOVIE?
20:25 JONATHAN: GREAT MOVIE. EDWARD: I DON'T THINK THAT'S THE
20:26 CASE. DEAR POINT, THING THE CAPITAL
20:30 SPENDING CONTINUES. I THINK -- TO YOUR POINT, I
20:35 THINK THE CAPITAL SPENDING CONTINUES.
20:39 I THINK IT IS BOLSTERED BY THE RETIRING BABY BOOMERS.
20:44 THEY HAVE A BLAST FEAR THAT 00 TRILLION IN NET WORTH AND
20:46 THEY ARE SPENDING IT. REMEMBER THE $2 TRILLION IN
20:50 FEDERAL DEFICIT? I DON'T SEE THIS ECONOMY REALLY
20:53 TAKING A HIT AT ALL. I THINK IT REMAINS EXTREMELY
20:56 RESILIENT. AND ONE LAST POINT ON YOUR
20:59 INTEREST-RATE QUESTION, AND THAT IS PEOPLE KEEP ANNOYING ME BY
21:04 SAYING, INTEREST RATES ARE GOING TO BE HIGHER FOR LONGER.
21:07 THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE HIGHER FOR LONGER.
21:09 THEY ARE GOING TO BE NORMAL FOR LONGER.
21:11 HIGHER FOR LONGER IMPLIES WE SHOULD BE GOING BACK SOMEWHERE.
21:13 GOING BACK TO THE GREAT FINANCIAL CRISIS, THERE THE
21:18 ABNORMALITY. RATES TODAY ARE TELLING YOU THE
21:21 ECONOMY IS DOING PRETTY WELL. DANI: WE CAN ALL HOLD HANDS BUT
21:26 NOT HOLD HANDS AS WE JUMP OFF THE CLIFF.
21:29 THAT SEEMS LIKE A GOOD SIGN. EDWARD: I DON'T SEE A CLIFF OUT
21:31 THERE. DANI: I WONDER ON THE RATE POINT
21:35 TO THINGS BECAUSE THIS HAS BEEN THE TECH SECTOR, THE
21:37 HYPERSCALERS HAVE BEEN INSENSITIVE TO RATES.
21:40 HOW MUCH OF THAT ALSO HAS TO DO WITH NOT THE BANK OF NVIDIA BUT
21:44 THE CENTRAL BANK OF NVIDIA? AN NVIDIA THAT WENT AND KEPT
21:49 BORROWING COSTS LOW FOR SO MUCH OF THE UNIVERSE.
21:51 DO HIRING RATES MATTER MORE FOR THESE COMPANIES IF NVIDIA WILL
21:54 BE MORE DISCIPLINED AND HOW IT LENDS MONEY?
21:56 EDWARD: ABSOLUTELY. IF NVIDIA IS NOT JUST GOING TO
22:00 THROW MONEY AROUND AND GIVE EVERYBODY A SEAL OF APPROVAL --
22:05 AGAIN, THAT'S A GOOD THING. BECAUSE THAN THE BOND MARKET
22:07 GETS TO REGULATE THE AI TRADE. INTEREST RATES HAVE CERTAINLY
22:10 GONE UP FOR THE NEO-CLOUDS.
22:18 IF THE NEO-CLOUD COULDN'T GET ANY MONEY WHATSOEVER THEY ARE
22:20 STILL SITTING ON A FEW DATA CENTERS THAT ARE OPERATING IN
22:26 BOND RATHER THAN IN EQUITY BECAUSE THEY CAN'T GROW?
22:29 BUT THEY DON'T GO OUT OF BUSINESS.
22:31 THEY HAVE VERY VALUABLE GPU'S. JONATHAN: THE ROARING 20'S STILL
22:40 STILL WORKING, BABY. WE HAVE SOME OF THE CRAZINESS
22:43 THAT WE HAD IN THE -- WAIT UNTIL YOU SEE THE CRAZINESS
22:46 NOW. EDWARD: I THINK THE BIG ISSUE --
22:54 THE BIG ISSUE IS, WHAT IS THE NEXT STRESS TEST FOR THE
22:57 ECONOMY? IT KEEPS PASSING THESE STRESS
22:59 TESTS. A FEW MONTHS AGO IT WAS OH MY
23:01 GOD THE BOND MARKET IS GOING TO SHUT OFF THE AI TRADE.
23:07 NOW IT IS LIKE NVIDIA, THE NVIDIA SCANDAL IS GOING TO SHUT
23:09 OFF THE AI TRADE. AND THE ECONOMY IS NOT JUST
23:12 ABOUT THE AI TRADE. IT IS ABOUT THE CONSUMERS COME
23:17 ABOUT GOVERNMENT SPENDING, AND IT'S ABOUT ENTREPRENEURS.
23:21 THIS IS STILL THE MOST ENTREPRENEURIAL ECONOMY IN THE
23:26 WORLD, AND IT'S A VERY DYNAMIC. JONATHAN: GOOD TO SEE YOU, AS
23:28 ALWAYS. EDWARD YARDENI.
23:41 WE'VE HAD SEVERAL STRESS TESTS IS THIS YEAR IN ENERGY, RATES,
23:42 CAN GO PUBLIC THIS WEEK, NOT JUST PUBLIC WOULD BE A RECORD
23:43 IPO. EVEN WITH EVERYTHING THAT
23:47 HAPPENED. YOU WOULD ASSUME THIS WOULD BE
23:49 THE WORST WEEK TO DO IT. THEY ARE GOING FULL STEAM AHEAD.
23:54 JONATHAN: FUTURES UP BY .9% ON THE NASDAQ.
23:56 NEXT ON THE PROGRAM WE WILL CATCH UP WITH THE FORMER ACTING
23:59 DEPUTY U.S. TRADE REPRESENTATIVE WENDY CUTLER THE HEAD OF A
24:06 TRUMP-XI SUMMIT. COREWEAVE IN THE PREMARKET UP BY
24:09 4%. GOOD MORNING, YOU ARE WATCHING
24:13 BLOOMBERG TV. ♪
24:33 JONATHAN: YOU HAVE A FOUR-DAY LOSING STREAK ON THE S&P 500 THE
24:39 LONGEST SINCE MID-SEPTEMBER, THIS MORNING A BOUNCE BY 0.5% ON
24:43 THE S&P 500, THE NASDAQ DOWN BY 5%.
24:48 UP BY 0.9% OFF OF DECENT EARNINGS FROM NVIDIA, WE'VE
24:50 CLEAR THAT HURDLE. THE NEXT BIG EVENT, ANTHROPIC
24:55 AND A MAJOR IPO IN THE NEXT 20 FOUR HOURS.
24:58 SINGLE NAMES, MORNING MOVERS.
25:02 ISABELLE: NVIDIA, SOLID EARNINGS IN A MORE SOLID OUTLOOK.
25:08 THE NUMBER IN THE MINDS OF INVESTORS WAS 70% GROWTH
25:10 GUIDANCE FOR THE YEAR. NVIDIA DID THAT AND MORE BECAUSE
25:13 THEY SAID IT IS 75%. THE COMPANY POINTED TO SUSTAINED
25:18 CUSTOMER DEMAND AND IMPROVED SUPPLY AND REALLY AN IMPROVED
25:21 THE DATA CENTER READINESS. ALSO THE COMPANY PUTTING TO REST
25:24 ANY POTENTIAL JENSEN HUANG COME BACK.
25:26 YOU SEE THE STOCK GETTING A LIFT BY NEARLY 2.5 PERCENT IN
25:28 PREMARKET. ANOTHER SECTOR GETTING A LIFT IS
25:33 NEO-CLOUDS, COMPANIES THAT RELY HEAVILY ON HYPERSCALERS SPENDING
25:36 AGGRESSIVELY WHEN IT COMES TO GPU CAPACITY.
25:40 ALL EDGING HIGHER. NVIDIA DISCLOSING AGREEMENTS
25:43 AMOUNTING TO $32 BILLION WHEN IT COMES TO NEO-CLOUD.
25:47 THAT IS ANOTHER SIGN OF NVIDIA'S CONTINUING SUPPORT WHEN IT COMES
25:49 TO THE BUILD OUT OF THE AI INFRASTRUCTURE.
25:52 WE HAVE COLETTE KRESS, THE INTERIM CEO, SAYING THEY PLANNED
25:55 TO BE MORE RIGOROUS WHEN IT COMES TO FINANCING.
26:01 LET'S END WITH LOWS BECAUSE IT IS STILL EARNINGS SEASON.
26:06 THE STOCK IS NOW DOWN 1.5%, THE COMPANY REPORTED COMPARABLE
26:07 SALES GUIDANCE FOR THE FULL YEAR THAT BEAT ESTIMATES BUT I THINK
26:11 INVESTORS ARE FOCUSING ON THE EPS THAT REMAINS UNCHANGED.
26:14 JONATHAN: NUMBERS CROSSING FROM TARGET MOMENTS AGO, A BEAT AND
26:19 A RAISE. FLYING BY MORE THAN 60%
26:21 YEAR-TO-DATE. MORE DETAILS ON THAT NAME A
26:24 LITTLE LATER THIS MORNING. OUR TOP STORY, NVIDIA PUSHING
26:26 AHEAD. >> OUR MOMENTUM IS REAL.
26:36 OUR DEMAND IS ACCELERATING. OUR SUPPLY IS GROWING.
26:37 OUR CUSTOMERS AND OUR PARTNERS ARE WITH US.
26:40 AND EMPLOYEES ARE COMMITTED. WEV''VE GOT THIS.
26:51 HUANG. COLETTE KRESS LOOKING TO EASE
26:52 INVESTOR FEARS, BOOSTING GUIDANCE AND A STOCK BUYBACKS.
26:56 THE BOARD CHAIR ADDING THE RETURN OF JENSEN HUANG A CEO'S
26:59 OF THE TABLE. ANTHROPIC TELLING INVESTORS
27:02 SHARES ARE EXPECTED PRICE AT THE HIGH INDOOR ABOVE THE CURRENT
27:05 RANGE OF 70 TO $78. WE WILL FAMILIAR WITH THE MATTER
27:09 TELL US OF BLOOMBERG THE IPO HAS DRAWN MULTIPLE ORDERS OF 0
27:13 BILLION OR MORE, TRADING A SET TO BEGIN TOMORROW MORNING.
27:17 FINALLY, THE LATEST FROM THE SECRETARY OF STATE MARCO RUBIO
27:19 LOOKING TO CALM SOME NERVES. SEC. RUBIO: EVERYTHING WE HAVE
27:23 REASON TO BELIEVE TELLS US THAT THESE EVENTS ARE NOT
27:24 INTERRELATED, ALL DISTINCT EVENTS, AND THAT NONE OF THEM
27:28 WHERE THE WORK OF A MALIGN ACTOR OR CYBER CRIMINAL.
27:32 JONATHAN: DUMPLING FEARS OF AN ATTACK OR BAD ACTORS AFTER
27:35 OUTAGES HIT CLOUD PROVIDERS, BANKS, AIRLINES.
27:38 DANI: THAT ACTUALLY DOESN'T MAKE ME FEEL BETTER.
27:40 THESE ARE ALL BUGS. THESE ARE ALL VARIOUS OUTAGES
27:44 THAT HAPPENED IS THEY WERE UPDATING SOFTWARE.
27:47 IS THIS SUPPOSED TO MAKE ME FEEL BETTER?
27:48 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN IT'S ACTUALLY THE BAD THING?
27:51 WHEN THIS IS ACTUALLY A MALICIOUS ACTOR OR AI GONE
27:53 ROGUE? IT TOOK SO LONG.
27:56 IT TOOK SO LONG FOR OUTLOOK TO COME BACK UP.
27:59 WHAT HAPPENS IF NEXT TIME IT IS AI-LEAD AND SOMETHING THAT IS
28:02 REALLY HARD TO FIX? IT DEMONSTRATES
28:09 HOW INTERCONNECTED EVERYTHING IS AND IT DOESN'T HELP YOU SLEEP
28:12 AT NIGHT, I'LL BE HONEST. JONATHAN: THE PRICE TO TARGET
28:20 INCREASE OFF OF COSCO OFF A PANIC BUYING AT STORES, PEOPLE
28:23 PILING INTO GENERATORS AND THE LIKES ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
28:27 DANI: I LOVE THE DOOMSDAY TRADE. BUY COSCO AND GOLD, WHAT YOU
28:29 CAN. IT'S HARD NOT TO LET YOUR MIND
28:32 TO GO TO THE CONSPIRACY THEORY OF IT ALL BECAUSE IT IS SO MANY
28:35 ONE AFTER ANOTHER. ONE ON ITS OWN USUALLY WOULDN'T
28:39 MAKE NEWS THAT THIS COMPANY AND GOVERNMENT HAVE BEEN STEADFAST
28:41 TRYING TO CALM PEOPLE SAYING THEY ARE ONE OFFS, NOT
28:43 CONNECTED. JONATHAN: ONE AFTER ANOTHER AND
28:46 WONDERING WHAT'S NEXT. THE LATEST IN CHINA, PRESIDENT
28:49 TRUMP ARRIVING IN CHINA AHEAD OF HIS HIGHLY ANTICIPATED TALK WITH
28:54 LEADER XI JINPING AND RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN.
28:57 TENSIONS CONTINUE TO RISE AS BEIJING THREATENS RETALIATION OF
29:01 HER NEW U.S. CURBS ON ACCESS THE AI CHIPS.
29:04 STEPHEN, WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM. DID WE SEE A RARE RED CARPET
29:09 GREETING ON THE TARMAC IN CHINA? STEPHEN: WE DID.
29:19 I WAS LOOKING AT THE SCREEN CLOSELY.
29:19 GREETING DONALD TRUMP EVEN BEFORE HE CAME OUT THE DOOR AND
29:24 DOWN THE STAIRS. THAT IS SOMETHING WE HEARD XI
29:28 JINPING SAID CHINA IS A NATION OF ETIQUETTE AND RECIPROCITY.
29:34 THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I SAID WHEN THIS WAS HAPPENING.
29:39 IT IS A RECIPROCAL GESTURE BY XI JINPING TO DONALD TRUMP BECAUSE
29:42 IN SEPTEMBER WHEN XI JINPING FLEW TO WASHINGTON, D.C. IT WAS
29:44 DONALD TRUMP AND MELANIA TRUMP AT THE FOOT OF THE STAIRS TO
29:51 WELCOME XI JINPING ON HIS 747, AIR CHINA 747 TO WASHINGTON,
29:52 D.C.. THIS IS A BREAK FROM NORMAL
29:56 PROTOCOL. IT IS ETIQUETTE TO RECIPROCATE
29:59 WITH ANOTHER PROTOCOL FOR CHINESE LEADERS TO WELCOME STATE
30:04 VISITS AT THE AIRPORT. IT USUALLY AT THE GREAT HALL OF
30:06 THE PEOPLE. WE ARE NOT IN BEIJING RIGHT NOW.
30:09 WE ARE IN THE TECH HUB OF SHENZHEN IN THE SOUTH NEAR HONG
30:10 KONG. SHENZHEN IS KNOWN FOR BREAKING
30:17 PROTOCOL BECAUSE OF THEIR INNOVATION AND INDIGENOUS
30:21 INNOVATION HUB WITH HUAWEI, BYD, AND IT TENCENT.
30:24 MAYBE IT'S NOT OUT OF THE ORDINARY FOR THIS BOOMTOWN IN
30:26 THE SOUTH. JONATHAN: THAT IS AN IMPORTANT
30:30 DIPLOMATIC DETAIL. HOW WILL THIS SET THE TONE FOR
30:33 THE TALKS BETWEEN THESE TWO NATIONS AT A TIME WHEN THE U.S.
30:36 IS PUTTING ON TOUGHER CURBS ON CHINESE ACCESS?
30:41 STEPHEN:, YEAH THAT'S A BIG QUESTION.
30:46 IN ADDITION TO THE TRILATERAL WITH PUTIN TOMORROW THE
30:48 BILATERAL BETWEEN THESE TWO LEADERS IS GOING TO TRY AND
30:51 PROPEL SOME OF THE GAINS, WHICH, LET'S BE FRANK, THERE HAVE NOT
30:54 BEEN A LOT OF DELIVERABLES IN THE THREE MEETING SO FAR THIS
30:57 YEAR, INCLUDING TODAY ALREADY. THERE HAVE BEEN FOUR MEETINGS
31:03 SINCE BUSSAN LAST YEAR. THERE HAS BEEN A TRAITOR TRUCE
31:07 EXTENDED BY A COUPLE OF MONTHS, BUT REALLY, HOW MUCH PROGRESS
31:10 HAS THERE BEEN MADE ASIDE FROM THE INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIP
31:13 THAT THEY BOTH SAY THEY'VE DEVELOPED?
31:15 THERE WAS A PAT ON THE BACK AT THE BOTTOM OF THE STAIRS OF AIR
31:18 FORCE ONE. THERE WAS A CHEEK TO CHEEK.
31:21 ARE THEY GOING TO GO TOE TO TOE IS THE BIG QUESTION ON THE TECH
31:24 ISSUES. AND REMOTE ACCESS ISSUE WITH THE
31:27 DEPARTMENT OF CONGRESS REALLY TIGHTENING THE SCREWS ON ACCESS
31:31 THROUGH THIRD-PARTY COUNTRIES, LARGELY IN SOUTHEAST ASIA, FOR
31:36 CHINESE AI DEVELOPERS TO GET THEIR HANDS ON NVIDIA OR OTHER
31:39 ADVANCED AI CHIPS. THAT'S GOING TO BE THE BIG
31:40 ISSUE. IS DONALD TRUMP GOING TO PUFFED
31:44 OUT HIS CHEST A BIT AND MAKE THIS A BIG ISSUE, OR IS IT GOING
31:48 TO BE ANOTHER RELATIONSHIP BUILDING AND TESTING THE
31:50 DIPLOMACY PATIENTS THAT A LOT OF US HAVE -- OR, FATIGUE, I SHOULD
31:55 SAY, THAT A LOT OF US HAVE ON WHEN THEY ARE GOING TO START
31:59 DELIVERING SIGNIFICANT RESULTS.
32:00 THIS MIGHT BE A CONTENTIOUS ISSUE FROM THE START TOMORROW.
32:04 JONATHAN: FANTASTIC REPORTING AS ALWAYS.
32:05 LOOKING FORWARD TO THE COVERAGE FROM YOU AND THE TEAM.
32:09 STEPHEN ENGLE ON THE GROUND FOLLOWING THE SUMMIT IN THE NEXT
32:11 24 HOURS. WE THOUGHT THIS WOULD BE ABOUT
32:16 TWO HOT WARS, ABOUT DIPLOMACY AROUND FOREIGN POLICY IN UKRAINE
32:19 IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND ALL OF A SUDDEN CHIPS ARE ON THE TABLE.
32:22 I CAN'T DECIDE IF THAT'S THE HOME BIAS, BECAUSE WE WANTED TO
32:25 BE ABOUT THAT OR OTHER THINGS, OR IF IT COULD BE A BIG STORY.
32:29 DANI: I THINK IT MADE'S TO BE A BIG STORY BECAUSE THE PRESIDENT
32:32 COMES AFTER THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT JUST PASSED A NEW
32:35 REGULATIONS RESTRICTING REMOTE ACCESS TO CLOUDS, TO CHIPS FROM
32:39 CHINESE COMPANIES, AND THIS HAS BEEN SOMETHING CHINA ITSELF HAS
32:41 SAID IS A PROBLEM. SO THEY'VE ADDRESSED IT BUT WILL
32:45 THESE TWO WORLD LEADERS ADDRESS IT?
32:46 JONATHAN: IT IS A FOCUS FOR WALL STREET PEER THE FORMER ACTING
32:49 DEPUTY U.S. TRADE REPRESENTATIVE WRITING, PRESIDENT XI MAY USE
32:54 THE SUMMIT, THE MEETING, TO TRY TO CONVINCE PRESIDENT TRUMP TO
32:56 BACKPEDAL THE NEW CHIP RESTRICTION.
32:58 WELCOME TO THE PROGRAM. DO THINK THE CHINESE COULD BE
33:00 SUCCESSFUL HERE? WENDY: THAT IS THE QUESTION WE
33:07 ALL DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER TO. I THINK THE PRESIDENT IS GOING
33:13 TO WANT TO AVOID TAKING XI ON ON THIS ISSUE.
33:15 I THINK CHINA HAS SENT THE MESSAGE IT IS PREPARED TO TAKE
33:20 COUNTERMEASURES, BUT BOTH SIDES WILL TRY TO DOWNPLAY THE ISSUE
33:22 AND LET THEIR MINISTERS AND WORKING TEAMS DEAL WITH THE
33:25 ISSUE AFTER THE SUMMIT. THESE NEW RESTRICTIONS DON'T GO
33:33 INTO EFFECT FOR 90 DAYS. FROM CHINA'S POINT OF VIEW THEY
33:35 COULD WAIT UNTIL WE ACTUALLY IMPOSE THE MEASURE PERHAPS TO
33:38 COUNTER RETALIATE. DANI: WE DID HEAR XI OPEN THE
33:45 APEC SUMMIT CALLING FOR FREE AND OPEN TRADE.
33:46 SOMETHING PRESIDENT PUTIN ALSO BACKED HIM UP ON.
33:49 DO YOU THINK THAT DIRECTLY RELATES TO WHAT WE ARE
33:51 DISCUSSING HERE? WAS IT A NOT SO THINLY VEILED
33:56 ATTEMPT AT SAYING THE U.S., WE DON'T LIKE THE ACTIONS YOU ARE
34:00 TAKING OVER REMOTE ACCESS OF CHIPS?
34:01 WENDY: ABSOLUTELY. THE WAY THAT I READ HIS SPEECH
34:07 HE ACTUALLY CALLED ONE COUNTRY A PROTECTIONIST COUNTRY
34:10 AND CRITICIZED STEPS THAT CERTAIN COUNTRIES LIKE THE U.S.,
34:12 WITHOUT MENTIONING THE U.S., ARE TAKING.
34:16 BUT HE IS ALSO TRYING TO PORTRAY CHINA AS THE RULES-BASED
34:19 TRADING SYSTEM, WHICH IS JUST HARD TO SWALLOW AT THIS POINT IN
34:21 TIME. [LAUGHTER]
34:27 DANI: WITH THAT, WHAT LEVERAGE DOES CHINA HAVE TO STOP THIS
34:33 HAPPENING IN 90-DAYS TIME? WENDY: A LOT OF LEVERAGE.
34:37 CHINA IS DOMINANT IN RARE EARTHS, MAGNETS.
34:39 THEY'VE USED THIS LEVERAGE BEFORE AND I HAVE NO DOUBT THEY
34:40 WILL INDIRECTLY PUT THIS ON THE TABLE DURING THE BILATERAL
34:46 MEETING TO TRY TO REMIND THE U.S. THAT THIS IS GOING TO BE A
34:49 TOUGH SLOG GOING FORWARD. JONATHAN: I'M PLEASED YOU SAID
34:53 THAT WHILST LAUGHING, BECAUSE I WAS LAUGHING TOO.
34:56 I REMEMBER A NUMBER OF YEARS AGO IN DAVOS, SWITZERLAND WHEN NEXT
34:58 I WAS THERE AND I'M SURE YOU REMEMBER THIS TOO IN THE PRESS
35:02 TRY TO PORTRAY HIM AS THE FLAG BEARER OF THE LIBERAL TRADING
35:04 WORKER, WHICH WAS RIDICULOUS AT THE TIME IT IS RIDICULOUS NOW.
35:09 WHY IS IT THE U.S. WHEN IMPOSE RESTRICTIONS ON CHINESE ACTIONS
35:14 IT IS SOMEHOW CONTROVERSIAL TO CHINA PUTTING RESTRICTIONS ON
35:15 U.S. TECH IS NOT CONTROVERSIAL? WENDY: I DON'T KNOW IF I WOULD
35:20 AGREE WITH THAT. WHEN CHINA TAKES STEPS AGAINST
35:23 OUR TECH WE ARE RESPONDING WITH THE STEPS AS WELL.
35:27 WHEN I STEP BACK, I LOOK AND SEE WE HAVE THE STRAIGHT TRUCE, BUT
35:29 LET'S BE HONEST. THIS IS THE EFFORT BY BOTH
35:33 LEADERS TO TRY TO MANAGE THE RELATIONSHIP AND AVOID
35:35 CONFRONTATION AND ESCALATION. BUT IN THE MEANTIME EACH SIDE IS
35:40 TESTING EACH OTHER WITH A MEASURES, NEW TECH
35:44 CONTROLS, RESTRICTIONS, TARIFFS, ETC..
35:53 I THINK THAT DANCE IS GOING TO CONTINUE WELL INTO 2027.
35:57 THE QUESTION IS WILL THE TRADE TRUCE HOLD AND WILL THE
36:00 PRESIDENT'S RELATIONSHIP WITH PRESIDENT XI SOMEHOW KEEP A LID
36:02 ON FURTHER ESCALATION? JONATHAN: WOULD YOU DESCRIBE THE
36:06 RESTRICTIONS THIS WEEK AS ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS OR
36:11 ENFORCEMENT OF EXISTING RULES? HOW WOULD YOU DESCRIBE THEM,
36:13 WENDY? WENDY: I CAN TELL YOU HOW THE
36:17 U.S. WILL DESCRIBE THEM TO CHINA, AND THAT IS JUST CLOSING
36:18 THE LOOPHOLE. NOTHING IS NEW HERE.
36:21 WE ARE DISCLOSING A LOOPHOLE AS WE PROCEEDED WITH ENFORCEMENT.
36:24 WHETHER THE CHINESE BUY THAT OR NOT IS ANOTHER QUESTION AND
36:28 REALLY, DOES IT REALLY MATTER TO CHINA IF IT IS NEW OR OLD IN ANY
36:31 EVENT FOR THEM? IT IS A RESTRICTION IN SOMETHING
36:35 THEY ARE NOT HAPPY WITH AND THEY MAY CHOOSE TO TAKE ACTION
36:39 AGAINST US OR AT LEAST THREATEN ACTION AGAINST US.
36:42 JONATHAN: WHEN THEY COME WITH APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
36:45 WENDY CUTLER, THE FORMER ACTING U.S. DEPUTY TRADE
36:46 REPRESENTATIVE. WILL THERE BE RETALIATION IN THE
36:49 NEXT COUPLE OF DAYS? DANI: AT THE MOMENT CHINA HAS
36:52 NOT RETALIATED AND I THINK THAT IS AN IMPORTANT SIGNAL HEADED
36:55 INTO THESE DISCUSSIONS. MANY PEOPLE BELIEVE THESE
36:58 DISCUSSIONS AREN'T GOING TO HAVE NECESSARILY ANYTHING CONCRETE
36:59 OUT OF THEM. IT IS SYMBOLISM.
37:02 IF YOU GET SOMETHING THAT COMPLETELY CHANGES THE TONE.
37:06 IF CHINA STARTS TO RETALIATE -- JONATHAN: TO WHEN YOU
37:12 CAN DESCRIBE THIS AS A CLOSING A LOOPHOLE.
37:14 CHINA'S PERSPECTIVE IS IMPORTANT BUT THERE IS A WAY OF DEALING
37:16 WITH THAT IN CONVERSATIONS. DANI: ISN'T THAT WITH THE U.S.
37:21 IS TRYING TO DO WHEN IT COMES AGRICULTURAL PURCHASES, OR
37:24 CRITICAL MINERALS OR RARE EARTH'S?
37:26 CLOSE TO LOOPHOLE OF CHINA NOT NECESSARILY TRYING TO COMPLY
37:28 WITH THE U.S. HAS TRIED TO PASS. THIS IS A CONFERENCE OF THING OF
37:31 EVERYTHING WERE TRYING TO DO WITH ALL THE AGREEMENTS WE'VE
37:34 REACHED WITH EACH OTHER. JONATHAN: FULL TEAM COVERAGE
37:36 COMING UP OF THE NEXT COUPLE OF DAYS.
37:38 IT'S GET AN UPDATE ON NEWS WORLDWIDE WITH YOUR BLOOMBERG
37:40 BRIEF. ISABELLE LEE HAS MORE.
37:43 ISABELLE: PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP'S 50 BILLION DOLLAR
37:46 REQUEST OVERHAUL THE U.S. AIRSPACE SYSTEM IS HITTING
37:48 RESISTANCE IN THE SENATE. MEMBERS OF BOTH PARTIES SAY THEY
37:52 NEED MORE DETAILS AS THE WALL STREET JOURNAL REPORTS THAT THE
37:56 FAA IS HALTING NEW ROUTER INSTALLATIONS FOLLOWING FRIDAY'S
37:59 IS GROUND STOP WHICH WAS TRACED TO A ROUTER MALFUNCTION IN
38:00 ARKANSAS. LOWE'S SHARES TRADING LOWER.
38:09 THIRD QUARTER EARNINGS BEAT ANALYST ESTIMATES AND BOOSTED
38:11 ITS COMPARABLE SALES CANONS FOR THE FULL YEAR.
38:14 THEY ARE ALSO MAINTAINING THEIR FULL YEAR ESTIMATES OF UP TO 2.5
38:17 BILLION DOLLARS. LET'S TAKE A LIKE A TARGET
38:19 BECAUSE SHARES ARE ALSO LOWER. THE COMPANY REPORTING
38:22 BETTER-THAN-EXPECTED QUARTERLY SALES FOR THE THIRD STRAIGHT
38:25 INCREASE IN HIS FULL-YEAR GUIDANCE AS EFFORTS TO TURN
38:27 AROUND TAKE HOLD. COMPARABLE SALES ROSE NEARLY 6%
38:32 IN THE QUARTER FROM A YEAR AGO, TOPPING ESTIMATES.
38:33 THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF. JONATHAN: THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
38:38 NEXT ON THE PROGRAM, MANAGING TECH DEBT RISK.
38:40 >> YOU HAVE TO BE VERY, VERY MEASURED ABOUT WHERE YOU'RE
38:42 TAKING RISK AND REWARD TODAY. I DON'T THINK I'M READY TO TAKE
38:46 30-YEAR DATA CENTER RISK. I'M NOT WILLING TO TAKE 30-YOUR
38:49 HYPERSCALER RISK. JONATHAN: UP NEXT ON THE
38:54 PROGRAM, WE WILL CATCH UP WITH RUSSELL BROWNBACK.
38:58 YOU ARE WATCHING BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE.
39:23 ♪ JONATHAN: NVIDIA, BETTER STORY
39:27 TO TELL, STUCK HIGHER BY 3% FOLLOWING A BEAT AND A RAISE
39:31 FROM THAT COMPANY AND A PRETTY FORCEFUL EARNINGS CALL FROM THE
39:32 C-SUITE. BUSINESS AS USUAL, IS IT REALLY
39:34 BUSINESS AS USUAL? HAVE A REALLY GOT THIS RIGHT
39:39 NOW? NVIDIA UP BY 3%.
39:41 THE S&P 500 DOING BETTER FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY LOSING
39:45 STREAK, HIGHER BY .4 PERCENT. NASDAQ HIGHER BY .9%.
39:50 BIG TECH, UNDER SURVEILLANCE, MANAGING TECH DEBT RISK.
39:56 >> YET BE VERY MEASURED ABOUT WHERE YOU'RE TAKING RISK AND
39:57 REWARD TODAY. THIS IS A SPACE FOR SEASONED
40:02 INVESTORS, NOT FOR AMATEURS AND MOMENTUM TRADERS.
40:05 I DON'T THINK I'M READY TO TAKE 30-YEAR DATA CENTER RISK.
40:08 I'M NOT WILLING TO TAKE 30-YOUR HYPERSCALER RISK.
40:12 NOT EVERY PARTICIPANT IN THIS ECOSYSTEM IS GOING TO BE A
40:16 THRIVING PARTICIPANT 3, 5, 7 YEARS FROM NOW.
40:19 JONATHAN: NVIDIA TIGHTENING THE REINS ON A HIGH FINANCING
40:22 FOLLOWING A BLOWOUT EARNINGS REPORT.
40:23 COLETTE KRESS TELLING INVESTORS THE CHIPMAKER WILL BE MORE
40:26 SELECTIVE WITH FUTURE SUPPLY CHAIN RUSSELL BROWNBACK
40:34 WRITING, THE OPPORTUNITY IS INCREASINGLY ABOUT UNDERWRITING
40:36 CONTRACTS, COLLATERAL AND REPAYMENT, NOT SIMPLY BUYING THE
40:37 AI THEME. RUSS, GOOD MORNING.
40:43 HOW MUCH NEEDS TO BE REFINANCED THROUGH DEBT?
40:49 RUSSELL: WE JUST REWROTE ALL OF THIS.
40:52 WHAT YOU SEE IS A DESIRE TO RAISE CAPITAL, DEBT AND EQUITY
40:56 WELL ABOVE THE FINANCING FUNDING GAP THAT EXISTS.
41:01 1.7 TRILLION OF PLANNED. CASH FLOW FOR THIS SYSTEM AS A
41:05 WHOLE, ONE .1 TRILLION. A TOTAL CAPITAL RAISING PLAN
41:09 ABOUT 1.3 TRILLION. RAISING IN EXCESS OF WHAT IS
41:12 NEEDED IS EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED IN 2026.
41:17 THERE IS A WAR CHEST OF CAPITAL THAT IS BEING BUILT SUGGESTING
41:19 MANY OF THESE ENTITIES ENVISION AN ULTIMATE SCARCITY OF CAPITAL
41:23 SO THEY ARE PROVISIONING FOR THAT AHEAD OF TIME.
41:28 JONATHAN: JIM SAYING HE DIDN'T WANT TO TAKE 30-YEAR BETS ON
41:31 HYPERSCALER DEBT. HE DIDN'T WANT TO TAKE AN
41:34 EQUITY-LIKE INVESTMENT WITH A FIXED COUPON.
41:35 WHAT IS YOUR APPROACH? RUSS: WE WOULD AGREE, THOUGH YOU
41:46 WE WILL HAVE OVERALL CONCENTRATION LIMITS ON ANYONE
41:51 COMPANY OR THEME, BUT YOU LOOK AT ANY ONE OF THESE ENTITIES,
41:55 AND YOU MIGHT LOOK AT A LARGE DOUBLE A CORPORATE BOND THAT HAS
42:00 A 30-YEAR PIECE OF PAPER THAT IS IN THE LOW SEVENS AND SAY IT IS
42:04 TRADING $.85 ON THE DOLLAR, GREAT VALUE, BUT YOU LOOK AT THE
42:09 STOCK AND IT IS TRADING AT 12 OR 13 TIMES EARNINGS SO THERE IS
42:12 MORE CONVEXITY TO THE UPSIDE. IF YOU'RE GOING TO TAKE A LONG
42:14 DURATION BET IN ONE OF THESE COMPANIES YOU WANT TO BE
42:17 POSITIONED TO GET THE MOST UPSIDE.
42:23 THAT ALSO, JIM YESTERDAY WAS TALKING ABOUT OPPORTUNITIES TO
42:25 FINANCE AT THE FRONT END OF THE CURVE AND SOME OF THE
42:27 COLLATERAL-BACKED DEALS COMING AT VERY ATTRACTIVE LEVELS, SO
42:31 YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT EVERY OPPORTUNITY AND ASSESS WHERE IT
42:34 FITS INTO THE PORTFOLIO. DANI: YOU MENTIONED
42:36 CONCENTRATION. I'M INTERESTED IN THE IDEA OF
42:39 HOW CLOSE WE ARE TO MANAGERS HEADING CONCENTRATION LIMITS.
42:43 I HAVE AN IDEA WITH ALAN WAXMAN OF 6TH STREET WHO INSISTS WE ARE
42:46 CLOSE, WE VIEW INSURANCE MONEY AS THIS UNLIMITED POOL OF MONEY
42:49 BUT WE ARE GETTING TO PLACES WHERE WE ARE HITTING THIS
42:52 CONCENTRATION LIMITS. HOW ARE YOU SEEING IT?
42:55 ARE YOU GUYS GETTING CLOSE TO CONCENTRATION LIMITS?
42:58 HOW ARE WE MANAGING THAT SEGMENT?
42:59 RUSS: IT'S VERY INTERESTING. IF YOU GO BACK 90-DAYS THE WORRY
43:04 WAS THERE IS EXUBERANCE AND JUST MONEY POURING INTO THE THEME
43:10 AND WE ARE MISALLOCATED CAPITAL. TODAY IT IS MORE CHOOSY.
43:14 PART OF THAT IS THIS IDEA CONCENTRATION AND OPTIMIZING
43:16 ONE'S HOLDINGS. ALSO AT THE SAME TIME, LOOK AT
43:19 THE HOUSEHOLD BALANCE SHEET. LIQUID ASSETS, ABOUT 1.6
43:21 TRILLION. YOU HAVE A PERCENT IN FIXED
43:26 INCOME, 71% IN EQUITIES. SO YOU'VE NEVER SEEN THAT HUGE A
43:28 SPREAD. SO THERE IS THESE POCKETS OF
43:32 WHEREWITHAL THAT CAN CONTINUE TO COME INTO THE FIXED INCOME SPACE
43:35 AND PROVIDE FINANCING. IT IS JUST A MATTER OF EVERYBODY
43:39 FINDING WHAT THE RIGHT ASSET ALLOCATION IS.
43:41 DANI: DO YOU THINK ARE HEADING TO THAT POINT OR MAYBE THE
43:43 CHOPPINESS IN THE EQUITY MARKET -- YOU'VE SEEN IT WAS SOME OF
43:46 THE RETAIL ETF'S, BUT WE ARE STARTING TO THINK ABOUT THIS
43:49 REALLOCATION INTO FIXED INCOME. DOES THAT
43:54 TIDE FINALLY START TO CHANGE?
43:58 RUSS: YOUR LEVELS OF FIXED INCOME THAT ARE INCREDIBLY
43:59 COMPELLING. YOU'VE HEARD ME SAY ON THIS
44:02 PROGRAM MANY TIMES WE CAN BUILD AN INVESTMENT GRADE RATED
44:06 PORTFOLIO WITH A SINGLE A RATING THAT YIELDS OVER 7% THAT HAS AN
44:08 IMPLIED VOLATILITY OF AROUND 2.5%.
44:12 THREE TO ONE CARRY THE VOLATILITY, THAT BECOMES VERY
44:17 COMPELLING ALTERNATIVE TO EQUITIES.
44:19 THAT BEING SAID WE ARE STILL BULLISH ON EQUITIES.
44:22 YOU HAVE RE-RATED THE ASSET CLASS DOWN TODAY SO THERE IS
44:27 INTRINSIC VALUE, BUT FIXED INCOME RELATIVE TO THE HOUSEHOLD
44:29 ALLOCATION I TALKED ABOUT IS A VERY COMPELLING OPPORTUNITY.
44:32 JONATHAN: WE ARE SEEING THE DEBT THEME IF WE CAN, DO YOU THINK
44:35 THESE TECH FIRMS ARE GETTING BETTER AT PROVIDING GUIDANCE
44:37 ABOUT HOW MUCH DEBT THEY NEED TO ISSUE, WHEN AND WHERE THEY NEED
44:40 TO ISSUE IT? RUSS: I THINK THERE'S A REAL
44:43 CLARITY. WE DEEP DIVE BUT THE THIRD
44:45 QUARTER EARNINGS, AND WHERE WE CAME UP WITH THEIR ESTIMATES FOR
44:50 NEXT YEAR THERE IS ENTHUSIASM ABOUT THE DEMAND THAT'S THERE.
44:55 THERE'S REAL MOMENTUM FOR THE INFRASTRUCTURE BUILDOUT.
44:56 I THINK THE PLANS ARE VERY CLEAR IN TERMS OF THE PLANNED DEBT AND
44:59 ISSUANCE. I SEE IT IS VERY RATIONAL.
45:03 JONATHAN: AT THE MOMENT IT STILL FEELS LIKE TO ME FOR SOME OF
45:08 THESE PLAYERS THERE IS ANOTHER $20 BILLION OFFERING FROM ONE
45:09 COMPANY OR ANOTHER TO FEELS LIKE HE COMES OUT OF NOWHERE.
45:12 YOU ARE SAYING YOU HAVE THE VISIBILITY INTO NEXT YEAR?
45:15 RUSS: IT'S INTERESTING. WE WENT BACK AND WE LOOKED AT
45:18 THE PERFORMANCE OF TREASURY AUCTIONS OVER THE LAST YEAR
45:21 VERSUS THE LAST 10 YEARS AND YOU SEE IT IS VERY NORMAL.
45:24 THERE IS NOTHING OPERATIONAL AT ALL.
45:26 YOU THINK ABOUT THE PREDICT ABILITY.
45:30 HOW MUCH. SOMETIMES THE ISSUANCE COMES OUT
45:34 OF NOWHERE. YOU DON'T KNOW HOW BIG IS GOING
45:37 TO BE, YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE NEW ISSUANCE SESSION IS GOING TO
45:40 BE, AND YOU HAVE SEEN LET THAT HAS LED TO HIS INCREASINGLY
45:43 ATTRACTIVE DEALS IN MARKETS. SO THESE COMPANIES ARE WILLING
45:46 TO LEAVE A LITTLE ON THE TABLE AND ORDER TO BE A LITTLE MORE --
45:49 JONATHAN: IT LOOKS LIKE YOU'RE HAPPY ABOUT THAT?
45:54 RUSS: IT IS A LENDER'S MARKET. WHEN WE HAVE OPPORTUNITIES TO
45:56 COME IN AND THEY'RE WILLING TO LEAVE SOME BASIS POINTS ON THE
45:59 TABLE, THAT'S GREAT FOR OUR INVESTORS.
46:01 JONATHAN: DO YOU THINK WOULD BENEFIT THE COMPANY'S THEMSELVES
46:05 IF THEY DID THINGS A LITTLE DIFFERENTLY?
46:07 RUSS: WE HAVE A GREAT GRAPHIC IN OUR MACRO DECK.
46:08 IF YOU LOOK AT THE ECOSYSTEM AS A WHOLE AND THE RETURN
46:12 VERSUS THE WEIGHTED COST OF CAPITAL THE SPREAD IS HUNDREDS
46:14 OF BASIS POINTS. SO THERE IS WHEREWITHAL TO HAVE
46:20 THIS MORE CHAOTIC, SORT OF, ISSUANCE STYLE AND STILL BE VERY
46:23 PROFITABLE FOR ALL INVOLVED. JONATHAN: THAT'S A COMPLEX WAY
46:25 OF DESCRIBING SOME OF THE GREAT
46:30 INSENSITIVITY OF SOME OF THESE COMPANIES?
46:36 RUSS: THE LEAST LEVERAGE SECTOR IN THE S&P 500.
46:40 YOU MIRROR THAT WITH THE SPREAD, THE INCENTIVE TO DO THIS, IT
46:42 SUGGESTS THIS CAN CONTINUE. JONATHAN: ARE WE STILL
46:46 UNDERESTIMATING THE DEGREE TO WHICH OF THESE GUYS ARE WILLING
46:49 TO INVEST IN THIS ECONOMY? DANI: YOU SEE IT IN THE BOND
46:55 MARKET, THE EQUITY MARKET, IT IS CONTINUED SPENDING ESPECIALLY
46:55 FROM THE HYPERSCALERS. MAYBE THERE IS QUESTIONS ABOUT
47:00 INVESTMENT GRADE NEO CLOUDS AFTER YESTERDAY BUT FOR THE
47:03 ESTABLISHED ONES AND HYPERSCALERS THE SPENDING IS
47:05 CONTINUING. JONATHAN: DID YOU GET ENOUGH
47:07 CLARITY FROM THE COMPANY ABOUT THE APPROACH TO THE ECOSYSTEM?
47:12 DANI: FROM COLETTE KRESS? NO.
47:14 SHE WAS SO INCREDIBLY BULLISH SAYING IT IS BUSINESS AS USUAL,
47:18 WE ARE STILL COMMITTED BUT CHANGING SOME THINGS.
47:19 I DON'T THINK THERE WAS ENOUGH CLARITY ON EXACTLY WHAT THAT
47:21 MEANS FOR THE ECOSYSTEM. JONATHAN: A BEAT AND A RAISE AND
47:33 DANI: AND WE GOT NO ANALYST QUESTIONS ABOUT CHINA.
47:38 JONATHAN: ADDITIONAL REGULATION THIS WEEK -- ON THERE WITH YOU.
47:40 WE WILL LET YOU GO. RUSS BROWNBACK.
47:51 FROM NVIDIA, FUTURES DOING BETTER AS WELL COME THE S&P UP
47:55 FIVE POINT 4%, THE NASDAQ SOME OUTPERFORMANCE.
48:01 NEXT, DAN IVES AND LIBBY CANTRILL AND THE SECOND HOUR OF
48:06 IS JUST AROUND THE CORNER. ♪
48:25 >> WE ARE GETTING UNCERTAIN DATA.
48:28 >> INFLATION IS PROVING TO BE STICKY.
48:31 >> THERE'S A LOT MORE NARRATIVE ABOUT HIGHER RATES SOONER TO
48:34 QUELL THIS HUGE INFLATIONARY PRESSURE.
48:36 >> DECEMBER LOOKS LIKE A VERY LIKELY RATE HIKE.
48:38 FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ, AND ANNMARIE HORDERN.
48:44 JONATHAN: LIVE FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING,
48:46 GOOD MORNING. OUR AUDIENCE WORLDWIDE COME THE
48:51 SECOND HOUR BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE STARTS NOW.
48:54 PRICE ACTION SCORES LOOK LIKE THIS.
48:58 THE S&P 500 BOUNCING BACK BY .4% FOLLOWING A LOSING STREAK.
49:02 THANK YOU, NVIDIA, WITH A BEAT AND A RAISE, IN AN EFFORT TO
49:06 SIGNAL CONFIDENCE ON A EARNINGS CALL, A HIGH-PRESSURE CALL FOR
49:08 COLETTE KRESS. DANI: IN MANY WAYS IT WAS
49:12 PROBABLY THE BEST CASE SCENARIO FOR THEM.
49:14 THE SEC COMMERCE DEPARTMENT LITERALLY BREATHING DOWN THEIR
49:15 NECKS. A NEW LEADER COLETTE KRESS COULD
49:19 HAVE BEEN ULTRACONSERVATIVE. INSTEAD WE GOT A BEAT AND A
49:21 RAISE. WE GOT MORE BUYBACKS.
49:24 75% GROWTH. SHE SAID THIS IS BUSINESS AS
49:26 USUAL. THE MARKET MAY BE TREATING IT AS
49:31 SUCH NOW, BUT THIS IS ANYTHING BUT BUSINESS BUT USUAL.
49:35 WE HAVE MAJOR LEADERSHIP
49:35 QUESTIONS. IS THIS A NEW NVIDIA.
49:39 ARE THEY GOING TO BE MORE AGGRESSIVE?
49:42 JONATHAN: THE CHANGES IN REGULATION, TOO.
49:46 WE TALKED ABOUT MAY BE PULLING GUIDANCE AND THEY RAISED IT, BUT
49:51 FROM BARCLAYS, UNCERTAINTY ABOUT CHINA'S INDIRECT ACCESS THROUGH
49:57 SOUTHEAST ASIA REMAINS A HANGOVER INTO 2027.
50:00 THEY DIDN'T GIVE ANY CLARITY ON HOW MUCH REVENUES AT RISK.
50:05 DANI: IT'S HARD FOR THIS COMPANY BECAUSE NVIDIA USED HER BREAKOUT
50:08 SINGAPORE NUMBERS AND A 2024 WAS SOMETHING LIKE 20% OF THEIR
50:12 SALES WERE GOING TO SINGAPORE. THEY STOPPED THAT PRACTICE.
50:15 WE ACTUALLY DON'T HAVE A GRANULAR VIEW AND WHAT SOUTH
50:18 EAST ASIA LOOKS LIKE FOR NVIDIA AND WE CERTAINLY DIDN'T GET IT
50:19 YESTERDAY. ARE THEY GOING TO DO THAT,
50:23 ADDRESS IT HEAD-ON AND GIVE US ANY SORT OF ESTIMATE OF JUST HOW
50:25 IMPACTED THAT BUSINESS IS GOING TO BE A?
50:28 JONATHAN: NOT IMPACTED ANTHROPIC, MIGHT HAVE HELPED
50:30 THEM. IT WILL TRADE TOMORROW MORNING.
50:34 FOR DARIO EMMA DAY, DID HE GET A HELPING HAND ON TWO FRONTS
50:38 UNLOCKING LIQUIDITY FOR HIS NAME, TAKING MONEY OUT OF
50:41 NVIDIA, AND MAY BE PROVIDING REGULATION, BARRIERS TO ENTRY HE
50:44 MIGHT LIKE TO SEE IN THE NOT-TOO-DISTANT FUTURE.
50:46 DANI: HOW MUCH OF THE SELLING HAS BEEN A CONVENIENT EXCUSE TO
50:50 BUY IMPROPER EQUIPMENT COME TO MARKET, BUT ANTHROPIC IS IN A
50:52 GOOD POSITION BECAUSE THEY ARE PROBABLY THE LEAST RELIANT LAB
50:57 ON NVIDIA. THEY USE GOOGLE GPU'S, NVIDIA
51:00 WAS NOT NECESSARILY JUST A BULLISH CALL FOR THAT COMPANY.
51:04 COLETTE KRESS BASICALLY PAINTED A PICTURE OF HOW ROBUST AI IS,
51:07 HOW MUCH DEMAND THERE IS, AND THAT HIS GOOD FOR ANTHROPIC.
51:11 JONATHAN: FUTURES DOING BETTER UP .3 ON THE S&P 500, NVIDIA OFF
51:14 THE BACK OF A BEAT AND A RATES HIGHER BY A COUPLE OF PERCENTAGE
51:20 POINTS AND WE WILL SEE IF THAT WITHHOLDS INTO THE CLOSE.
51:22 COMING UP THIS HOUR, ALICIA LEVINE WITH NVIDIA DELIVERING A
51:26 BEAT AND RACE. LIBBY CANTRILL AS PRESIDENT
51:29 TRUMP ARRIVES IN CHINA FOR THE HISTORIC TRILATERAL SUMMIT, AND
51:34 GITA GOPINATH ON THE NEED FOR TIGHTER MONETARY POLICY.
51:46 ALICIA LEVINE WRITING, NVIDIA ASKED THE DEMAND QUESTION,
51:47 STRONG EARNINGS ARE GOOD NEWS FOR 2027 PROFITS BUT REINFORCE
51:50 HOW DEPENDENT EARNINGS GROWTH HAS BECOME ON A SMALL GROUP OF
51:52 AI BENEFICIARIES. THAT IS THE RISK.
51:56 ALICIA, GOOD MORNING. HAVE YOU TRIMMED YOUR OUTLOOK?
52:01 ALICIA: WE SLIGHTLY TRIMMED OUR OUTLOOK AFTER THE MIDTERM
52:04 ELECTIONS BECAUSE OF THE LIKELY SLOWING OF CAPEX ON THE DATA
52:07 CENTER ISSUE. IF YOU LOOK AT WHERE THE
52:11 EARNINGS GROWTH REALLY WAS POWERED IN 2026, THE AI
52:18 BENEFICIARIES -- ABOUT 45 NAMES. NOT JUST NVIDIA.
52:22 INDUSTRIALS, TECH, AND SOME UTILITIES.
52:26 EARNINGS ON THE AVERAGE OF 80% THIS YEAR.
52:30 THAT POWER THE 33% EARNINGS GROWTH FOR THE S&P THIS YEAR.
52:37 WE HAD PEAK EARNINGS ON THE AI BENEFICIARIES.
52:42 YOU HAVE A DECELERATION IN EARNINGS.
52:44 THE QUESTION IS, IF YOU HAVE STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
52:46 THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY THAT ARE LIKELY TO PUT A BIT OF A BRAKE
52:52 ON THE DATA CENTER BUILDOUT, THAT MEANS LOWER CAPEX.
52:55 THOSE BENEFICIARIES WILL BE GROWING EARNINGS EVEN SLOWER.
53:00 WE HAVE AS YET TO FIGURE OUT AS MUCH BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW IF IT
53:06 IS SPENDING 10% OR 15% LESS. EVEN BEFORE THE EARNINGS CALL
53:10 LAST NIGHT THERE IS A SENSE THERE IS SOME DECELERATION.
53:15 LIKELY NOT IN 27, PROBABLY IN 28.
53:19 JONATHAN: WHAT IS THE BULL CASE FOR THE INDEX WITH THAT IN MIND?
53:24 ALICIA: ACTUALLY, THE REST OF THE MARKET IS DOING WELL.
53:27 THE S&P EARNINGS ARE DOUBLE WHAT THE AVERAGE IS ANYWAY.
53:31 THE STALLING OUT OF THE S&P ON THE TOP LINE REALLY SINCE JUNE
53:36 HAS COME FROM THE QUESTION OF, ARE WE HAD PEAK EARNINGS?
53:39 WE HAVE THE MASSIVE EARNINGS SEASON IN THE SECOND QUARTER, 30
53:44 3%, 34% YEAR-OVER-YEAR IF YOU TAKE AWAY SOME OF THE PRIVATE
53:48 INVESTMENTS GOOGLE AND AMAZON HAD.
53:49 IS THAT PEAK? MARKET DOESN'T LIKE PEAK
53:53 ANYTHING BECAUSE THAT IS WHERE THE SECOND DERIVATIVE COMES IN.
54:01 EARNINGS EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE GROWING GANGBUSTERS, GROWING
54:06 300, 500%. THE MARKET IS NOT GOING TO PAY
54:09 FOR THAT KIND OF GROWTH OF IT IS NOT SUSTAINABLE.
54:12 THE MARKETS DOING THE WORK FOR YOU.
54:14 I THINK THERE IS SOMEPLACE TO GO TO RESET EXPECTATIONS.
54:22 COMING DOWN. EVEN IF THIS QUARTER IS FINE IN
54:25 THE NEXT QUARTER IS FINE AND FOUR QUARTERS FROM NOW IS FINE,
54:28 WHAT IS 2028 AND 2029? DANI: CAN FINANCIALS BE A POCKET
54:34 FOR STRENGTH OF A LOT OF THE SUCCESS AROUND BANKS WAS AROUND
54:38 THE AI, LENDING TO AI, IPO'S FOR BIG COMPANIES.
54:40 IF THAT COMES OFF THE BOIL IS THAT BAD FOR FINANCIALS?
54:45 ALICIA: PART OF THE WEAKNESS AND FINANCIALS OVER THE SUMMER WAS
54:47 PEAK EVERYTHING. WHEN THE FED WENT HAWKISH AT
54:50 JACKSON HOLE YOU SAW A LITTLE BIT OF A WEAKENING IN THE
54:53 FINANCIALS. WE THINK THE FINANCIALS ARE GOOD
54:56 AS LONG AS THE YIELD CURVE STEEPENING.
54:58 IT'S FINE.THAT SHOULD BE OK.
55:02 AT THIS POINT IT IS THE YIELD CURVE.
55:04 I THINK THE ACTIVITY WILL CONTINUE.
55:07 THOSE WHO CAN HAVE A BUSINESS MODEL, A RETURN ON INVESTMENT IS
55:14 HIGHER THAN THE COST OF CAPITAL, WILL BE ABLE TO BORROW.
55:16 YOU SEE THE PROBLEM IN THE TRIPLE-C AND HIGH-YIELD INDEX
55:22 BUT IT IS NOT SPREADING YET BECAUSE ULTIMATELY CORPORATE
55:25 AMERICA IS VERY HEALTHY WITH VERY HIGH OPERATING PROFIT.
55:29 DANI: IS THERE SOMETHING THAT COULD CAUSE IT TO SPREAD OR ARE
55:33 YOU CONVINCED IT WILL STAY WELL-CONTAINED?
55:36 ALICIA: WHEN YOU SEE WEAKNESS IN A CORNER IT'S HARD TO SAY IT
55:39 WILL STAY IN A CORNER. A HIGHER RATE WORLD IS NOT
55:43 NECESSARILY POSITIVE FOR RISK ASSETS.
55:45 THE QUESTION IS, IS IT NECESSARILY NEGATIVE?
55:49 FOR NOW, THERE IS STILL ACCESS TO CAPITAL SO WE THINK THE LARGE
55:54 FINANCIAL WILL BE FINE. JONATHAN: IT IS DISCRETIONARY
56:00 TOO AND MONEY HAS BEEN PILING INTO STAPLES.
56:02 IS THE MARKET STARTED TO SIGNAL SOME CYCLICAL SLOWDOWN?
56:04 YOU CAN PUSH BACK BUT I WONDER IF THAT'S WHAT THE MARKET IS
56:06 STARTING TO SIGNAL? ALICIA: IT WOULD BE NATURAL FOR
56:20 OVERTURNED I.E. THE TARIFFS ALL OF THE COMPANIES THAT SUITED TO
56:25 GET MONEY BACK FROM THE GOVERNMENT THAT ENDED UP BEING
56:29 ABOUT $2 TRILLION BACK INTO THE ECONOMY TO THE CORPORATE SECTOR.
56:32 WE HAVE THE I'LL RISK GIVING MONEY BACK TO HOUSEHOLDS.
56:37 WE ENDED UP WITH AN EXTRA TRILLION OF STIMULUS THIS YEAR.
56:40 WE THOUGHT THE GROWTH RATE FOR 2026 4% REAL.
56:47 IS STILL 1% HIGHER THAN WHERE TREND IS.
56:51 WE THINK NEXT YEAR WILL BE A NATURAL DECELERATION CLOSER TO
56:54 TREND, WE JUST DON'T HAVE AS MUCH STIMULUS.
56:57 IT WILL BE THERE IN FISCAL BECAUSE POLITICIANS WERE PUT ON
56:59 EARTH TO GIVE THINGS AWAY. THERE WILL BE MORE GIVING AWAY
57:02 NEXT YEAR, IT JUST MAY NOT BE THE EXTRA TRILLION.
57:07 ON TOP OF THAT THE AI CAPEX IS EXPECTED TO BE 3% OF GDP NEXT
57:10 YEAR. THAT'S A LOT.
57:12 JONATHAN: DO YOU THINK THE PRESIDENT CAN WORK WITH
57:15 DEMOCRATS ON THE GIVING AWAY POINT?
57:16 I WONDER WHERE IT IS RIGHT NOW. ALICIA: HE SAID HE WANTED.
57:21 I THINK THERE ARE AREAS ON HOUSING AND HEALTH CARE,
57:23 POSSIBLY SOME REGULATION HE WOULD BE WILLING TO WORK WITH
57:25 DEMOCRATS ON. THERE SEEMS TO BE A CONFLUENCE
57:30 OF VIEWS ON CERTAIN ISSUES ON BOTH SIDES OF THE HOUSE.
57:32 THAT'S LIKELY TO BE THE AREA WHERE THERE IS GOING TO BE SOME
57:34 AGREEMENT. DANI: MAYBE THE HORSESHOE A
57:38 POLITICS, THIS POPULIST BEEN COMING BACK IN AND OF DOING
57:40 THAT, WHAT DOES THAT MEAN GENERALLY FOR YOUR OUTLOOK OF
57:42 THE CONSUMER? NOT TO BRING IT BACK AROUND TO
57:46 EVERYTHING IS INTERCONNECTED TO AI.
57:49 THERE HAVE BEEN CRAZY STORIES OF PEOPLE IN SAN FRANCISCO BUYING
57:51 HOMES FOR ONE MILLION OVER ASKING BECAUSE OF ALL OF THIS
57:54 WEALTH COMING IN. DOES THAT AT THE MARGINS WEAKEN
57:57 THINGS IF IT IS NOT AS BIG OF A GROWTH AS WE BEEN USE TO OVER
58:00 THE PAST COUPLE OF YEARS FOR AI? ALICIA: I THINK THE CONSUMER
58:04 LOOKS TO BE FINE BECAUSE THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IS 4.1
58:06 PERCENT. IT'S ALSO NOT GETTING
58:09 INCORPORATED WHAT'S GOING ON IN THE GIG ECONOMY.
58:12 PEOPLE ARE TAKING SECOND AND THIRD JOBS.
58:14 IT'S NOT GETTING REALLY CAPTURED IN OFFICIAL STATISTICS.
58:17 I THINK THAT IS WHAT IS STABILIZING THE LABOR MARKET.
58:20 EVERYONE HATES INFLATION. REAL WAGES HAVE NOT CUT UP WITH
58:24 INFLATION SINCE THE BEGINNING 2020, STILL 3% OR 4% LOWER ON
58:27 REAL WAGES, BUT NEVERTHELESS THERE ARE OUTLETS FOR EMPLOYMENT
58:30 WHICH HOUSEHOLDS ARE DOING. IF YOU LOOK AT THE CONSUMPTION
58:33 NUMBERS IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE THERE'S A PROBLEM.
58:35 THE QUESTION IS, WHAT HAPPENS GOING FORWARD?
58:41 AND THAT'S ALL ABOUT THE ISSUE. THAT'S ALSO WHAT HAPPENS ON
58:43 ELECTION DAY. DANI: A GOOD POINT, DOES THAT
58:46 MEAN THE REAL RISK FOR THE ECONOMY IS WHAT'S HAPPENING IN
58:49 THE MIDDLE EAST, WHAT HAPPENS TO OIL, WHAT HAPPENS TO ENERGY?
58:53 ALICIA: IF YOU COULD WAVE A WAND AND STOP THE WAR THE MARKET --
58:56 THERE WOULD BE A MASSIVE RALLY IN THE MARKET BECAUSE THEN THE
58:59 FED COMES OFF AND INFLATION GO SLOWER AND YOU CAN CARRY ON,
59:01 CARRY ON. I THINK THE ISSUE FOR MARKETS
59:06 NEXT YEAR -- SO, WE ARE SHIFTING GEARS BUT GOING IN THE SAME
59:08 DIRECTION. IT IS JUST SHALLOW WORK.
59:12 WE STILL SEE A POSITIVE YEAR BUT WE THINK THE MARKET IS NOT DONE
59:16 DIGESTING THE CHANGE IN WHERE THE EARNINGS ARE GOING BECAUSE
59:19 THE GROWTH RATE IS POSITIVE BUT SLOWING, WHICH TENDS TO BE A
59:21 DIGESTION PHASE. THAT WOULD MEAN IF THE CHIP IS
59:27 GROWING SLOWER, ON THE MARGIN, NOT THE ABSOLUTE.
59:29 THAT'S WHERE YOU'RE GOING TO GET, I THINK OF THE NEXT THREE
59:32 TO SIX MONTHS OF SOME SORT OF SORTING OUT HERE.
59:35 SO WE ARE STILL STEADY AS SHE GOES.
59:37 IT WOULD JUST NOT -- WE ARE SHIFTING GEARS, IS WHAT I'D SAY.
59:40 JONATHAN: USE BUT THE WHOLE OF THE FIRST QUARTER DEBATING IF
59:44 THE SECOND DERIVATIVE MATTERS OR NOT, ULTIMATELY, THE
59:46 DECELERATION? THAT WILL BE THE STORY FOR EARLY
59:50 2020 SEVEN AT LEAST? DANI: BECAUSE OF WHAT WAS MADE
59:52 OF THE HUGE AMOUNT OF EARNINGS WE HAD, AND OFF OF THAT BASE IT
59:55 DOESN'T LOOK AS GOOD, BUT TO YOUR POINT, ALICIA, IT IS NOT
59:59 NECESSARILY THE SKY IS FALLING. CONSUMERS ARE STILL SPENDING, AI
1:00:02 IS STILL GROWING, JUST NOT AT THE RATE IT WAS.
1:00:07 ALICIA: A MIDCYCLE SLOWDOWN TO RESET.
1:00:09 BY THE WAY, IF CONSUMERS STOP SPENDING A LITTLE BIT IT'S GOOD
1:00:12 FOR KEVIN WARSH AS WELL. JONATHAN: TRUE.
1:00:15 GOOD TO SEE YOU, AS ALWAYS. ALICIA LEVINE.
1:00:17 THEY ARE NOT STOPPING SPENDING NOW FOR SURE.
1:00:20 THE LATEST RETAIL SALES NUMBERS PRETTY DECENT.
1:00:22 EQUITY FUTURES ON THE S&P HOLDING ONTO GAMES.
1:00:25 AN UPDATE ON NEWS WORLDWIDE. ISABELLE: ISABELLE LEE HAS MORE.
1:00:30 ISABELLE:NVIDIA SHARES RISING IN PREMARKET AFTER REPORTING
1:00:31 RESULTS THAT BEAT ESTIMATES. THE COMPANY REPORTING BOOSTING
1:00:36 ITS ANNUAL SALES FORECAST TO 75%.
1:00:38 THAT IS UP FROM 70%. ADDING 150 BILLION DOLLARS TO
1:00:40 ITS STOCK BUYBACKS. >> IT IS BUSINESS AS USUAL.
1:00:46 WE HAVE ENGAGED WITH OUR CUSTOMERS, ENGAGE WITH OUR
1:00:49 SUPPLIERS, OUR PARTNERS. THEY ARE ALL 100% BEHIND US.
1:00:54 ISABELLE: INVIDIOUS CHAIRMAN SHUTTING DOWN ANY TALK OF FORMER
1:00:58 CEO JENSEN HUANG'S COME BACK. PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP AND
1:01:00 RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN WILL MEET SEVERAL TIMES DURING
1:01:02 THEIR VISIT TO CHINA. THE CRIMINAL AND SAYING THE TWO
1:01:06 LEADERS WILL HAVE "FULL-FLEDGED CONVERSATIONS."
1:01:09 THEY WILL ALSO PARTICIPATE IN A TRILATERAL MEETING WITH CHINA' A
1:01:15 XI JINPING AND MAY DISCUSS A BY PUTIN TO MIAMI FOR THE G7.
1:01:19 OPENAI IS RELEASING A NEW VERSION OF ITS MOST ADVANCED
1:01:22 ASTRA AI MODEL COMING TWO MONTHS AFTER IT SCRAPPED THE PRIOR
1:01:24 UPDATE TO ESTABLISH STRONGER SAFEGUARDS FOR THE
1:01:28 TECHNOLOGY. OPENAI SAYS THE NEW MODEL
1:01:32 OUTPERFORMS FABLE FROM ANTHROPIC ON A BENCHMARK FOR PROFESSIONAL
1:01:35 WORK AT A FRACTION OF THE COST. THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
1:01:41 WRITE AHEAD OF THAT IPO FROM ANTHROPIC.
1:01:44 NEXT, NVIDIA POWERING AN AI COME BACK.
1:01:54 >> NVIDIA DID WHAT THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO DO.
1:01:54 >> THE UNCERTAINTY WILL BE FURTHER DOWN THE ROAD.
1:01:57 JONATHAN: NEXT, DAN IVES JOINING US ON THE LATEST FROM NVIDIA.
1:01:59 LIVE FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING.
1:02:24 JONATHAN: THESE ARE YOUR STORIES THIS MORNING
1:02:25 SO FAR, HOLDING ON GAINS IN THE S&P, UP .3%
1:02:31 FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY SLIDE ON THE S&P 500 THE LONGEST SINCE
1:02:34 MID-SEPTEMBER, THE NEST EGG DOWN 5%.
1:02:37 THIS MORNING UP A .8% OFF THE BACK OF THE MOVE FROM NVIDIA
1:02:41 FOLLOWING A BEAT AND A RAISE. NVIDIA IN THE PREMARKET HIGHER
1:02:44 BY ABOUT 3%. LET'S SEE IF WE HOLD ONTO THOSE
1:02:47 GAINS. SOME OF THE WORDS ON THE CALL
1:02:48 NOT CONVINCING ABOUT THE COMMITMENT TO THE OTHER PLAYERS
1:02:54 IN THE ECOSYSTEM INCLUDING THE NEO-CLOUD FIRMS.
1:02:55 THE NAMES AND EARLY TRADING ARE DOING BETTER THAN OK.
1:03:02 THAT IS ONE OF THE QUESTIONS WE DIDN'T GET A LOT OF DETAIL ON.
1:03:05 THE COMMITMENT TO FINANCING AND ANCHORING BORROWING FOR THE
1:03:08 ECOSYSTEM. DANI: COLETTE SEEMED TO FRAME IT
1:03:12 THAT THEY ARE STILL COMMITTED BUT WILL BE MORE DILIGENT WHICH
1:03:15 MANY PEOPLE HAVE CHEERED, MAYBE IT'S A GOOD TIME TO DO THAT, BUT
1:03:18 THERE IS A QUESTION OF WHAT HAPPENS TO THE SUB INVESTMENT
1:03:22 GRADE PART OF THE UNIVERSE. THERE ARE A LOT OF NEO-CLOUDS
1:03:25 THAT NOT ONLY THEMSELVES ARE SUB INVESTMENT GRADE BUT WHOSE
1:03:27 CUSTOMERS ARE. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR THE
1:03:30 ENTIRE STACK OF SMALLER AI COMPANIES THAT HAVE BEEN TURNING
1:03:34 TO THEM IN ORDER TO GET ACCESS TO NVIDIA CHIPS?
1:03:36 IT SEEMS THE WHOLE ECOSYSTEM MIGHT BE UNDER THREAT, BUT TO
1:03:38 YOUR POINT WE DON'T KNOW BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF DETAILS.
1:03:42 JONATHAN: DOING THE BEST ON THE CALL TO PROJECT CONFIDENCE WITH
1:03:45 THE BEAT AND A RAISE. WHERE THEY GET THE VISIBILITY
1:03:48 AND CONFIDENCE TO RAISE AT THIS POINT IS A DIFFICULT QUESTION.
1:03:52 NVIDIA POWERING AN AI COME BACK. >> NVIDIA DID WHAT THEY WERE
1:03:56 SUPPOSED TO DO, TRYING TO CALL ME INVESTOR NERVES.
1:03:58 >> IN MY MIND WHAT'S BEEN HAPPENING IN RECENT DAYS IS,
1:04:02 LET'S CALM DOWN, LET'S SLOW THIS DOWN, THE AI TRADE IS ALIVE AND
1:04:04 WELL. >> THE NEXT ONE TO TWO YEARS IS
1:04:08 STILL SOLID FOR NVIDIA. THE UNCERTAINTY WILL BE MUCH
1:04:11 FURTHER DOWN THE ROAD. JONATHAN: ANOTHER
1:04:14 RECORD-BREAKING QUARTER FOR NVIDIA BOOSTING ITS OUTLOOK AND
1:04:16 BETTING IT CAN THRIVE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT THE HELM.
1:04:21 DAN IVES MAINTAINING HIS TO 25 PRICE TARGET AND OUTPERFORM
1:04:25 RATING WRITING A CLEAN QUARTER AND GUY DON'T CLOSE THE QUESTION
1:04:28 IS THE 50% SPECIAL MEETING THRESHOLD ACTIVIST PRESSURE IN
1:04:32 THE EXPORT INVESTIGATION REMAIN THE NEXT STEPS IN THE SOCKET.
1:04:35 DAN JOINS US FOR MORE. DID YOU GET THE CLARITY YOU
1:04:38 NEEDED ON THE CALL? DAN: I THINK CLARITY IN TERMS OF
1:04:41 NOT JUST AMANDA BUT GUIDANCE. MANY FELT GOING AND COLETTE WAS
1:04:44 GOING TO GIVE GUIDANCE. 75 PERCENT GROWTH.
1:04:47 THAT'S ESSENTIALLY WHAT I VIEW IS NOT ZEROING OUT, BUT WHEN YOU
1:04:51 THINK ABOUT CHINA, HONG KONG, ALL THE LOOPHOLE AREAS, THEY
1:04:56 PROBABLY PUT THEIR VERY NEGATIVE VIEW IN TERMS OF WHAT THAT COULD
1:04:57 BE. YOU STILL HAVE 75%.
1:05:03 CLICK AT 12:1 DEMAND TO SUPPLY FOR NVIDIA CHIPS.
1:05:06 ARE YOU IN THE U.S. WE ORDER A CHIP, WE DON'T GET THE CHIP
1:05:10 UNTIL THE END OF 2028.
1:05:18 JONATHAN: THAT SPEAKS TO THE QUESTION WE HAVE BEEN PROBING,
1:05:21 BUT THEY FOUND THEMSELVES IN THIS POSITION HAVING A
1:05:22 RELATIONSHIP WITH COMPANIES THAT LOOK LIKE THEY ARE BACKDOOR INTO
1:05:25 CHINA WHEN U.S. DEMAND IS SO GREAT.
1:05:31 DAN: TRAVELED SO MUCH THROUGHOUT THE REGION, I THINK THE
1:05:35 LOOPHOLES, SINGAPORE, MALAYSIA, OTHERS, I THINK THAT HAS ALWAYS
1:05:39 BEEN SOMETHING THAT IS OUT THERE WITHIN THE INDUSTRY.
1:05:43 THE QUESTION IS WHERE THOSE THE SECOND AND THIRD RATE CHIPS
1:05:44 GOING TO CHINA? BLACKWELL CHIPS GO TO CHINA,
1:05:50 THESE THINGS NEED TO COME OUT IN THE INVESTIGATION.
1:05:55 ON THE CONFERENCE CALL YESTERDAY, ON ONE HAND -- WE SAY
1:05:58 ONE CHIP FUELING THE AI REVOLUTION, THAT'S NVIDIA, THAT
1:06:01 DOESN'T CHANGE TWO TO THREE YEARS OUT OF CHINA.
1:06:07 BUT THEN JENSEN CAST THE SHADOW.
1:06:09 THERE IS ESSENTIALLY AN ACTIVIST CAMPAIGN UNDERWAY.
1:06:12 THE STARTED YESTERDAY WHEN JENSEN SAID I WILL COME BACK.
1:06:18 MANY OF YOU -- HE THINKS HE IS CLEAN FROM A CHINA PERSPECTIVE
1:06:20 RELATIVE TO THE INVESTIGATIONS THAT ARE GOING TO HAPPEN,
1:06:24 RELATIVE TO SOME OF THE EXPORT CONTROLS, BUT THE 15% IS VERY
1:06:28 IMPORTANT BECAUSE THERE IS NO STAGGERED BOARD, NO MAJORITY
1:06:32 VOTING, SO THE VIEW IS ACTIVISTS ARE GOING TO GET THIS SPECIAL
1:06:35 SHAREHOLDER MEETING AND AT THAT POINT PROBABLY FEBRUARY OR MARCH
1:06:42 TRY TO OUTSTRIP BOARD THUS OUST THE BOARD AND BRING BACK JENSEN.
1:06:46 DANI: DO YOU THINK THERE'S A FAIR SHOT THEY COULD DO THAT?
1:06:51 DAN: IN THE WEEKEND, THERE'S NO HE COMES BACK.
1:06:53 THE ACTIVISM HAS SURPRISED ME JUST HOW LOUD IT IS.
1:06:57 NOW, THAT IS BECOMING SOMETHING WHERE I THINK IT IS BECOMING A
1:07:02 BIGGER PERCENTAGE THAN I EVER THOUGHT IT WOULD BE.
1:07:05 NOW WE HAVE -- OBVIOUSLY IN D.C., TRUMP, YOU COULD ARGUE
1:07:11 LUTNICK, THEY KNOW THE BIGGEST GAIN FACTOR BETWEEN CHINA AND
1:07:16 THE U.S. IS JENSEN. YOU COULD COME OUT CHINA IS
1:07:18 DOING CARTWHEELS. YOU HAVE THE CHINA HAWS, THE
1:07:23 MORAL COMPASS ISSUES, EVERYTHING ELSE THE BOARD WOULD HAVE TO
1:07:25 NAVIGATE. DANI: THE BOARD SECRETARY WAS
1:07:30 CLEAR HE WANTED A SHAKEUP WITH LEADERSHIP.
1:07:32 WOULD YOU BE MORE BULLISH NVIDIA IF HE CAME BACK?
1:07:34 WOULD THAT MAKE YOU MORE CONFIDENT ON THE COMPANY?
1:07:38 DAN: IT WOULDN'T BE THE ROCK STAR, BLACK LEATHER JACKET,
1:07:44 GODFATHER JENSEN, BUT WE SAID JENSEN IS WORTH TRILLION TO
1:07:48 THE VALUATION OF NVIDIA, AND THAT I THINK IS REFLECTED IN
1:07:54 COME BACK WITH THE ACTIVIST CAMPAIGN?
1:07:58 THAT NOW WILL BE A BIG QUESTION. THIS SAGA, THIS SOAP OPERA IS
1:08:04 JUST BEGINNING AND IT WILL BE A BATTLE IN D.C., A BATTLE IN
1:08:10 TERMS OF SHAREHOLDER, AND ON THE WALL STREET SIDE.
1:08:15 JONATHAN: THERE IS AN SEC INVESTIGATION, WHAT IS YOUR READ
1:08:16 ON THAT? DAN: THESE ARE THE THINGS THAT
1:08:21 NEED TO COME OUT FROM INVESTIGATIONS.
1:08:22 THEN THERE IS A VIEW LIKE COLETTE, WHO I'VE ALWAYS VIEWED
1:08:26 AS POTENTIALLY A BIG CEO OF A TECH COMPANY, SO I THINK SHE'S
1:08:33 IN A GREAT SPOT HERE, CAN YOU NAME AN EXTERNAL CANDIDATE WHILE
1:08:34 THIS IS ALL GOING ON? I THINK THAT'S WHAT KIND OF
1:08:39 CREATES A LOT OF THE UNCERTAINTY IN TERMS OF WHAT THE NEXT STEPS
1:08:43 ARE. FUNDAMENTALLY THIS IS WHERE A
1:08:48 LOT OF THE NEGATIVITY AND VIEWS -- EVEN IF YOU ZEROED OUT ANY
1:08:54 LOOPHOLES, I WOULD SAY 75% GROWTH IS PROBABLY CLOSER TO
1:08:56 85%, 90% WHEN ALL IS SAID AND DONE.
1:09:00 THIS NEEDS TO BE PLAYED OUT. JONATHAN: THE PROBLEM IS
1:09:04 TRAINING THE NAME, SOMEONE SAID THE NAME IS UP 3% OFF THE BACK
1:09:09 OF THESE NUMBERS, EVEN AS THEY HAD A MASSIVE DECLINE IN THE
1:09:11 PRINT YOU'RE ONLY UP 3%. IS THERE GOING TO BE A CLOUD
1:09:14 OVER THIS NAME FOR THE NEXT THREE TO SIX MONTHS UNTIL WE
1:09:16 CLEAN THIS UP? DAN: I THINK WHERE THE STOCK IS
1:09:21 TRADING WILL BE MUCH HIGHER. I THINK YOU WILL HAVE SHORT
1:09:23 COVERING FUNDAMENTALS AT 10 TIMES EARNINGS IN TERMS OF HOW
1:09:27 THIS PLAYS OUT, BUT THE BIG QUESTION WILL BE, THE
1:09:28 INVESTIGATIONS. WHAT ROLE IF ANY JENSEN PLAYS
1:09:34 THAT IF HE IS CLEARED COULD HE COME BACK FROM AN ACTIVIST
1:09:35 CAMPAIGN? THIRD, UNDERSTANDING THE D.C.
1:09:39 COMPONENT. I THINK DECEMBER 1 OR SECOND IS
1:09:44 WHEN HE WILL ULTIMATELY GO IN FRONT OF A CONGRESSIONAL
1:09:45 HEARING. THIS IS UNFORTUNATELY A SOAP
1:09:51 OPERA. IT IS A JAMES BOND MEETS TECH
1:09:58 SECTOR, WHATEVER YOU WANT TO CALL IT, NOW WE HAVE TO SEE THIS
1:10:02 ALL PLAY OUT, AS STOCK YOU BUY NVIDIA BECAUSE, JENSEN OR NO
1:10:06 JENSEN, IT IS ONE CHIP IN THE WORLD FUELING AI, AND IT'S
1:10:08 NVIDIA. DANI: AM STRUGGLING WITH THE
1:10:11 IDEA OF JENSEN COMING BACK, BECAUSE EVEN IF HE IS CLEARED IN
1:10:14 TERMS OF CHINA AND WHATEVER MAY HAVE GONE ON THERE, HE HAS AT
1:10:17 LEAST HAD AN AFFAIR WITH A CUSTOMER AND WITH A DIRECTOR
1:10:21 REPORT, AT THE VERY LEAST NVIDIA HAS A HUGE GOVERNANCE PROBLEM.
1:10:28 AN UNDERSTATEMENT, RIGHT. THAT'S WHY, THEN IT COMES DOWN
1:10:34 TO THE ACTIVIST AND THE SHAREHOLDERS.
1:10:36 CAN THEY GET TO 50%? CAN THEY GET A SPECIAL
1:10:39 SHAREHOLDER MEETING? THAT IS WHY ON THE CALL, WHEN
1:10:44 THEY ARE TALKING, COLETTA, THEY ARE WELL AWARE.
1:10:47 THIS IS NOT JUST REGULAR COMMENTS.
1:10:49 YOU ESSENTIALLY HAVE AN ACTIVIST CAMPAIGN BREWING IN THE
1:10:51 BACKGROUND. I THINK THAT ADDS TO THE
1:10:56 NERVOUSNESS AND MAYBE THE HESITANCY.
1:10:59 DANI: WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE LEADING IT?
1:11:02 NVIDIA SHAREHOLDERS? SILICON VALLEY THAT IS REALLY
1:11:05 BULLISH JENSEN FOR ALL OF THE AI ECOSYSTEM?
1:11:08 DAN: I THINK ALL OF THE ABOVE. PART OF THE ISSUE IS HE IS SO
1:11:14 IMPORTANT TO NOT JUST THE AI REVOLUTION BUT THE ECONOMY AND
1:11:16 GLOBAL ECONOMY. I VIEWED IT THERE IS NO WAY HE
1:11:23 WOULD BE ABLE TO COME BACK AND I TALKED ABOUT THAT.
1:11:28 THE LEVEL OF ACTIVISM AND GROUNDSWELL SURPRISED ME.
1:11:30 NOW IT COMES DOWN TO WHAT THE NEXT STEPS ARE.
1:11:35 JENSEN SAYING HE WOULD COME BACK YESTERDAY IT WASN'T LIKE HE WOKE
1:11:38 UP AND I WILL PUT OUT A STATEMENT TODAY.
1:11:41 THIS IS A GAME OF HIGH-STAKES POKER THAT IS BEING
1:11:42 PLAYED OUT. JONATHAN: 40 SECONDS LEFT.
1:11:47 ARE WE GOING SHOPPING? DAN: I LOST THE BET, WE WILL GO
1:11:57 SHOPPING IN TERMS OF A PHARAOH-APPROVED SPORTS JACKET.
1:12:01 JONATHAN: BEFORE CHRISTMAS, NAVY JACKET AND A WHITE SHIRT.
1:12:06 DAN: A WHITE SHIRT, I GET IT, WE CAN DEBATE THE NAVY JACKET.
1:12:10 JONATHAN: I AM BEING KIND NOT MAKING YOU WEAR A TIE.
1:12:16 WE WILL DO A CHRISTMAS SPECIAL. DAN IVES ON THE LATEST WITH
1:12:19 NVIDIA, THE NAME OF THE PREMARKET HIGHER BY 3% THIS
1:12:21 MORNING. NEXT WE WILL CATCH UP WITH LIBBY
1:12:25 CANTRILL OF PIMCO AS PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP ARRIVES IN CHINA
1:12:28 FOR THIS WEEK'S HISTORIC TRILATERAL SUMMIT.
1:12:29 FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING.
1:12:42 ♪ JONATHAN: WE WILL SEE IF IT
1:12:44 STICKS INTO THE OPENING BELL. THE CASH OPEN ABOUT TWO HOURS
1:12:46 AWAY. EQUITIES BOUNCING BACK.
1:12:50 THE NASDAQ COMING BACK OFF OF THE LONGEST LOSING STREAK SINCE
1:12:53 MID-OCTOBER. THE S&P THE LONGEST LOSING
1:12:56 STREAK SINCE MID-SEPTEMBER. CHIPS AND NVIDIA VERY MUCH IN
1:12:59 FOCUS. LET'S LOOK AT SOME OF THOSE
1:13:03 NAMES AND STORIES RIGHT NOW WITH ISABELLE LEE.
1:13:06 ISABELLE: THE STORY HERE IS STILL NVIDIA BECAUSE IT WAS A
1:13:08 FANTASTIC REPORT. A STRONG EARNINGS AND EVEN
1:13:10 STRONGER OUTLOOK. A COUPLE OF JUST YESTERDAY WERE
1:13:14 CONCERNED WHETHER NVIDIA WILL BE ABLE TO MAINTAIN A 70%
1:13:18 GROWTH TARGET NEXT YEAR. THEY INCREASED IT TO 75% TO THIS
1:13:23 AS LATE A LOT OF CONCERNS ABOUT THE FRAGILITY OF THE AI TRADE
1:13:26 FOR A FEW WEEKS NOW. START GETTING A LIFT OF 3.5% IN
1:13:30 THE PREMARKET. THE DAMAGE IS THERE SINCE THE
1:13:33 BREAKUP. IT HAS LOST .5 TRILLION SINCE.
1:13:40 NOW WE ARE TALKING ABOUT SOME CHIPMAKERS, AMD, BROADCOM,
1:13:45 MICRON, ALL HIGHER BY MORE THAN 2%.
1:13:48 MICRON HAS BEEN THE HARDEST HIT IN THE PAST DAYS BECAUSE IT SAW
1:13:50 FOUR STRAIGHT DAYS OF LOSSES. IT IS ONE OF THE BEST PERFORMERS
1:13:58 , UP BY NEARLY 120% AND TRADING CHEAP AT 9.5 TIMES PE.
1:14:01 FINALLY, I WANT TO END IT WITH TAKE-TWO.
1:14:04 WE HAVE THE ANTHROPIC IPO TOMORROW AND ALSO SOMETHING
1:14:06 ELSE. YOU SEE THE STOCK PUMPING AS
1:14:13 POSITIVE REVIEWS COME IN. BLOOMBERG'S RESIDENT GAMING
1:14:19 REPORTER HAD A WORD TO DESCRIBE IT, MASTERPIECE.
1:14:21 JONATHAN: THANK YOU. A LOT OF DUES JUST CALLED IN
1:14:22 SICK. DANI: SOMEONE DID SOME SORT OF
1:14:28 STUDY ABOUT HOW MUCH MONEY LIKE THE U.K. ECONOMY WILL LOSE
1:14:32 AUTO. JONATHAN: STAY UP ALL NIGHT AND
1:14:34 PLAY THAT GAME. NVIDIA'S SOLID EARNINGS AROUND
1:14:40 THE TECH TRADE WITH REVENUE TOPPING 00 BILLION FOR THE
1:14:41 FIRST TIME. THE COMPANY BOOSTING SALES
1:14:44 FORECAST. SOFTBANK'S FOUNDER SAYS PASSING
1:14:51 UP AN EARLY INVESTMENT IN ANTHROPIC WAS A MISTAKE.
1:14:58 ANTHROPIC SET TO PRICE TO MAKE IPO TODAY BEFORE TRADING
1:14:59 TOMORROW MORNING. A PUSHBACK THREATENING TO DERAIL
1:15:04 AMAZON'S 7 BILLION DATA CENTER BET.
1:15:08 THREE PROJECTS HAVE ALREADY FACED RESTRICTIONS SINCE VOTER
1:15:11 APPROVED 21 MEASURES TO SLOW DEVELOPMENT IN THE STATE.
1:15:16 DANI: A HUGE MAJORITY OF THINGS THAT CAME UP IN THIS MIDTERM
1:15:18 VOTE THAT WERE AGAINST DATA CENTERS PASSED, AND THERE WAS A
1:15:24 HOPE THAT AFTER THE MIDTERMS THIS WAS A CAMPAIGN ISSUE, THAT
1:15:27 A LOT OF POLITICIANS CAMPAIGN ON THIS ISSUE, YOU GET PAST THE
1:15:31 MIDTERMS, AND BUSINESS AS USUAL. THEY HAVE COME IN WITH THIS
1:15:33 MANDATE. IT IS NOT JUST A GOVERNOR LEVEL.
1:15:36 LOOK AT TEXAS. THE HOUSE IS MAJORITY DEMS.
1:15:41 THEY HAVE ALREADY STARTED TO PUT IN THE HOPPER LEGISLATION.
1:15:43 JONATHAN: I AM RIGHT THERE WITH YOU.
1:15:47 THERE IS A CONSENSUS THAT STILL EXISTS THAT ULTIMATELY THESE
1:15:52 GUYS WILL GET THE TAX REVENUE AND THE DATA CENTERS.
1:15:56 ALREADY WE ARE SEEING THE TEST OF THAT CONSENSUS A WEEK OR SO
1:15:57 LATER. DANI: THE PROBLEM IS THEY
1:16:00 CAMPAIGNED ON THIS AND HAVE A MANDATE ON IT.
1:16:03 WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE WHEN YOU DO THAT AND DO NOT PASS
1:16:04 ANYTHING? MAYBE IT IS NOT FULL SIZE
1:16:07 RESTRICTION BUT AT THE MARGIN IT IS SLOWING AND YOU ARE ALREADY
1:16:10 STARTING TO SEE THAT. JONATHAN: THE LATEST ON THE
1:16:13 PRESIDENT AND THE TECH TRADE. PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP MAKING AI
1:16:17 A KEY POINT IN CHINA. PRES. TRUMP: WE WANT TO ENSURE
1:16:23 THE FUTURE OF THIS TECHNOLOGY IS DOMINATED BY NATIONS THAT SHARE
1:16:26 OUR VALUES AND OUR COMMON INTERESTS.
1:16:28 JONATHAN:JONATHAN: HERE IS THE LATEST THIS MORNING.
1:16:31 CHINA IS ROLLING OUT THE RED CARPET WITH PRESIDENT TRUMP
1:16:32 ARRIVING. SAFETY AND REGULATION IN FOCUS
1:16:36 AHEAD OF TOMORROW'S TRILATERAL SUMMIT.
1:16:39 TYLER KENDALL JOINS US WITH MORE.
1:16:44 TYLER: GOOD MORNING. A VERY WARM WELCOME FOR
1:16:48 PRESIDENT TRUMP AS XI JINPING GAVE HIM A RARE AIRPORT GREETING
1:16:52 WHEN AIR FORCE ONE TOUCHED DOWN DESPITE WHAT HAS BEEN ESCALATING
1:16:53 TENSIONS BETWEEN THE TWO COUNTRIES.
1:16:57 WE EVEN GOT A PREVIEW OF WHAT MAY BE THE PRIVATE MESSAGE
1:16:59 TOMORROW DURING THIS TRILATERAL MEETING WITH CHINESE PRESIDENT
1:17:04 XI JINPING AND RUSSIAN PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN SAYING IN THEIR
1:17:09 SPEECHES TO THE SUMMIT THEY ARE WARNING AGAINST WHAT THEY ARE
1:17:11 CALLING ECONOMIC BARRIERS AND PROTECTIONIST MEASURES.
1:17:15 KEEPING IN MIND THAT YESTERDAY CHINA'S COMMERCE MINISTRY
1:17:19 PLEDGED MEASURES IN RESPONSE TO THE U.S. COMMERCE DEPARTMENT
1:17:21 SAYING IT WOULD PUT ON EXPORT RESTRICTIONS IN A BID TO CURB
1:17:25 CHINESE ACCESS TO ADVANCED CHIPS.
1:17:27 OUR OWN ANALYSTS AND BLOOMBERG ECONOMICS SAY WHEN IT COMES TO
1:17:31 THE BILATERAL MEETING AND TRILATERAL MEETING THAT WE
1:17:33 SHOULD EXPECT MORE HEADLINES THAN BREAKTHROUGHS ESPECIALLY
1:17:37 CONSIDERING THAT GOING INTO THIS WEEK CHINA HAD WANTED TO SEE THE
1:17:40 U.S. LOOSEN OR LIFT RESTRICTIONS ON U.S. TECH, NOT TIGHTEN IT.
1:17:45 ALL OF THE FOCUS WILL BE ON XI JINPING AND ALSO RUSSIAN
1:17:49 PRESIDENT VLADIMIR PUTIN, BUT I ALSO WANTED TO BRING YOU ONE
1:17:51 OTHER BREAKING HEADLINES WE GOT THIS MORNINGM WHICH I, WHICH IS
1:17:57 ANOTHER BILATERAL MEETING WAS ADDED THIS MORNING,
1:18:02 WHICH IS ANOTHER BILATERAL MEETING ADDED WITH MARK CARNEY.
1:18:05 BACK. JONATHAN: I SENSE THE CANADIAN
1:18:08 MIGHT BE FRUSTRATED. TYLER KENDALL WITH THE LATEST.
1:18:12 LIBBY CANTRILL FROM PIMCO CALLING THE VISIT TO CHINA A
1:18:14 PERFECT POLITICAL STORE. WHAT IS NOT INTENDED TO BE ON
1:18:22 THE AGENDA IS THE UNFOLDING SCANDAL AROUND NVIDIA WHICH
1:18:25 RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT THE ACTIONS OR LACK OF ACTION OF
1:18:26 PRESIDENT TRUMP'S OWN ADMINISTRATION.
1:18:30 TREASURY. WHAT IS BEHIND IT AND WHO
1:18:35 ULTIMATELY WAS THE BATTLE?
1:18:39 LIBBY: IT IS IMPORTANT TO POINT OUT THIS IS VERY UNUSUAL.
1:18:42 THERE IS OBVIOUSLY USUALLY INTRA-AGENCY TENSION IN ANY
1:18:48 ADMINISTRATION, BUT EFFECTIVELY WHEN THERE IS A POLICY THAT IS
1:18:49 PUT OUT, EVERYONE RALLIES AROUND IT, PROVIDES A UNITED FRONT.
1:18:54 IT IS NOT REALLY HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
1:18:56 THE COMMERCE DEPARTMENT IN THE INTERIM ROLE ISSUED ON MONDAY
1:18:59 THAT BASICALLY HELPS TO RESTRICT ACCESS TO CHINA OF U.S. CHIPS
1:19:06 EFFECTIVELY SAID THIS WAS AT THE DOING OF THE NSC, NATIONAL
1:19:10 SECURITY COUNCIL, AND THE TREASURY.
1:19:13 THEY ARE TRYING TO DISTANCE THEMSELVES FROM IT EVEN THOUGH
1:19:14 THIS WAS A COMMERCE RULE. JUST TO PUT THIS IN BROADER
1:19:18 CONTEXT, THIS IS QUITE UNUSUAL. MOST OF THIS TENSION USUALLY
1:19:23 HAPPENS BEHIND THE SCENES, NOT SORT OF FOR PUBLIC CONSUMPTION
1:19:24 IF YOU WILL. IN TERMS OF WHO WINS, I THINK
1:19:29 CONGRESS WILL HAVE A SAY IN THIS AND THAT IS WHO PROBABLY WILL
1:19:31 WIN. CONGRESS WILL MOVE TOWARDS
1:19:35 PUTTING SOME MORE RESTRICTIONS ON THESE CHIPS, POTENTIALLY ON
1:19:42 SEMICONDUCTOR EQUIPMENT AS WELL, INCREASING AUTHORIZATION THAT
1:19:45 CONGRESS HAS OVER THIS WHOLE PROCESS.
1:19:49 I THINK THAT IS LIKELY TO BE INCLUDED IN SOMETHING CALLED THE
1:19:51 NDAA. THAT HAS TO PASS BY THE END OF
1:19:54 THE YEAR MOST LIKELY. PRESIDENT TRUMP WOULD LIKELY BE
1:19:57 COMPELLED TO SIGN THAT. FOR ALL OF THE DRAMA THAT IS
1:20:04 HAPPENING BEHIND THE SCENES OR IN FRONT OF THE SCENES IN THIS
1:20:06 CASE, I THINK CONGRESS WILL HAVE THE LAST WORD ON THIS.
1:20:10 JONATHAN: HOW WOULD YOU FRAME THE ACTION THIS WEEK?
1:20:13 DO YOU CONSIDER IT A NEW FRESH RESTRICTION OR CLOSING THE LOOP
1:20:14 ALL? LIBBY: THIS IS IN SOME WAYS
1:20:21 CLOSING IN THE PAUL BUT SOMETHING THAT HAS NOT BEEN
1:20:26 COVERED AS WELL IS THIS IS GOING TO REQUIRE A LOT OF ENFORCEMENT
1:20:27 AT COMMERCE. THIS IS A DIVISION WITHIN
1:20:34 COMMERCE THAT IS NOT NECESSARILY VERY WELL-FUNDED.
1:20:36 THESE ARE OBVIOUSLY SMART PEOPLE.
1:20:38 HOWEVER, THERE ARE NOT MANY OF THEM.
1:20:44 WE CAN PUT WORDS ON PAPER, BUT IN TERMS OF WHAT THE ENFORCEMENT
1:20:47 LOOKS LIKE, WHAT THE FOLLOW-THROUGH WILL LOOK LIKE,
1:20:49 THAT I THINK IS A REAL OPEN QUESTION AND PROBABLY WILL HAVE
1:20:55 ENFORCEMENT. THE TELLER HERE IS THEY COULD
1:20:59 HAVE PUT MEGASPEED ON THE ENTITY LIST AND IT IS STILL NOT ON.
1:21:06 THAT IS SOMETHING CONGRESS COULD DO EFFECTIVELY UNILATERALLY.
1:21:10 IT IS A LITTLE CURIOUS ISSUING THIS INTERIM ROLE ON ONE HAND
1:21:13 BUT ALLOWING MEGASPEED TO EFFECTIVELY STILL TRADE WITH
1:21:18 U.S. COMPANIES IS A GET BACK. .
1:21:20 DANI: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THAT? IS IT NOT A COINCIDENCE OF
1:21:26 TIMING THEY DID NOT GO THAT FAR AS TRUMP IS SET TO MEET WITH XI
1:21:28 AND IS MEETING WITH HIM? LIBBY: THIS IS NOT A PERFECT
1:21:31 STORM OF ISSUES. AI AND CHINA ARE
1:21:39 RED MEAT FOR THE HILL, IF YOU WILL.
1:21:43 I THINK THERE IS PROBABLY TRYING TO BE WALKING THE FINE LINE IN
1:21:48 TERMS OF NOT SORT OF ALIENATING XI.
1:21:52 AGAIN, I THINK CONGRESS HAS A SAY IN THAT.
1:21:54 IF WE DO NOT SEE ACTION RELATIVELY SHORTLY AFTER THE
1:22:00 SUMMIT THIS WEEK, I THINK AGAIN THERE WILL BE A LOT OF HEARINGS,
1:22:01 A LOT OF OVERSIGHT. YOU WILL SEE THAT EVEN BEFORE
1:22:06 THE NEW CONGRESS IS SEATED IN JANUARY.
1:22:09 COMMERCE SECRETARY LUTNICK IS SUPPOSED TO TESTIFY BEFORE THE
1:22:12 SENATE BANKING COMMITTEE IN DECEMBER.
1:22:15 BUT OF COURSE WHEN THE NEW DEMOCRATS COME IN, YOU WILL SEE
1:22:17 A TON OF OVERSIGHT. TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, THE
1:22:24 TIMING HERE IS AT LEAST PARTLY A CONSIDERATION.
1:22:28 BUT IF YOU DO NOT SEE THAT MOVE IN PRETTY SHORT ORDER AFTER THE
1:22:30 SUMMIT, I THINK CONGRESS IS GOING TO USE THEIR OVERSIGHT
1:22:36 TOOLS IN ORDER TO SHINE A LIGHT ON THIS
1:22:39 ISSUE. DANI: WHAT WAS THE BIG FORCE OF
1:22:43 LOBBYING, THAT WAS JENSEN HUANG HIMSELF.
1:22:50 HE WAS SO IMPACTFUL IN HIS PRESENCE AND ADVOCACY FOR AI AND
1:22:51 GLOBAL AI. IS THERE SOMEONE THAT FEELS THAT
1:22:54 VACUUM? LIBBY: THAT IS A THING WE HAVE
1:22:58 BEEN POINTING OUT AS WELL. YOU USUALLY HAVE FULL WHO ARE
1:23:07 THE EVANGELIZERS FOR ALL OF THEIR BENEFITS.
1:23:11 YOU HAVE NOT HAD THAT WITH AI, AT LEAST NOT IN THE UNITED
1:23:12 STATES. THIS IS A PR ISSUE WITH BIG
1:23:15 TECH. THEY HAVE NOT GONE TO THE PEOPLE
1:23:19 IF YOU WILL TO TRY TO HIGHLIGHT ALL OF THE GOOD POSSIBLE THINGS
1:23:23 THAT CAN HAPPEN WITH AI. THEY ARE FOCUSED ON THE MORE
1:23:30 DYSTOPIAN AND DOWNSIDE RISKS IN TERMS OF AI IMPLICATIONS AND
1:23:34 JENSEN HUANG WAS ONE OF THOSE EVANGELIZERS.
1:23:38 ONE OF THE FEW ON THE HILL AND IN WASHINGTON AT LARGE BUT ALSO
1:23:40 JUST IN THE MEDIA. HE HAS BEEN TALKING ABOUT HOW
1:23:49 THIS IS GREAT ON THE UNITED STATES, HOW THIS SPEAKS
1:23:51 TO THE CULTURE OF INNOVATION AND RISK-TAKING AND HOW WE WILL WIN
1:23:56 THE AI RACE AND HOW THAT IS INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT.
1:24:00 WITH HIM UNDERMINED HERE, THAT WILL BE SILENCING A REALLY
1:24:04 IMPORTANT VOICE IN THIS SORT OF WHOLE LANDSCAPE.
1:24:10 YOU WILL NOT HAVE THAT VOID
1:24:16 OTHER FOLKS WHO ARE MUCH MORE FOCUSED THAT SEEM TO BE ON THE
1:24:18 RISKS. JONATHAN: IF IT WAS NOT FOR
1:24:23 NVIDIA, WE WOULD BE TALKING BUT ATTEMPTING TO END SOME WARS THIS
1:24:24 WEEK. LIBBY: YES, THERE WOULD BE A LOT
1:24:26 OF OTHER THINGS. I THINK NUCLEAR ARMS -- SOUNDS
1:24:32 LIKE THAT WILL BE ON THE AGENDA. OF COURSE, CHINA HAS INCREASED
1:24:38 THEIR NUMBER OF WARHEADS OVER THE PAST FEW YEARS, SO I THINK
1:24:40 THAT IS GOING TO BE POTENTIALLY SOMETHING.
1:24:44 MAYBE IF NOT PUBLICLY SPOKEN ABOUT, CERTAINLY PRIVATELY.
1:24:49 BUT YES, OBVIOUSLY, THE FOCUS IS MAYBE ON
1:24:58 OTHER THINGS THAN WHAT THE ADMINISTRATION WANTED IT TO BE.
1:25:03 WITH YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF. ISABELLE LEE HAS MORE.
1:25:06 ISABELLE: SECRETARY OF STATE MARCO RUBIO AFTER AC WAS OF
1:25:11 HIGH-TECH PROFILE OUTAGES. >> WE HAVE REASON TO BELIEVE
1:25:15 THESE EVENTS ARE NOT INTERRELATED.
1:25:19 NONE OF THEM WERE THE WORK OF A MALIGNED ACTOR OR CYBER
1:25:20 CRIMINAL. ISABELLE: HIS COMMENTS FOLLOW A
1:25:26 SERIES OF OUTAGES INVOLVING FAA, JP MORGAN, MICROSOFT, APPLE, AND
1:25:28 NSA OVER THE LAST FEW DAYS. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION
1:25:34 WITHDRAWING OVERTON'S NOMINATION TO LEAD THE FAA DUE TO A LACK OF
1:25:37 CONGRESSIONAL SUPPORT. SHE FACED CONCERNS FROM
1:25:45 SENATORS. IT IS UNCLEAR AT THE WHITE HOUSE
1:25:46 WILL BE ABLE TO ADVANCE ANOTHER NOMINEE FOR DEMOCRATS TAKE OVER
1:25:49 THE SENATE IN JANUARY. JENSEN HUANG WILL NOT BE
1:25:54 RETURNING AS NVIDIA'S CEO. THE NEWLY APPOINTED CHAIRMAN OF
1:25:56 THE BOARD SAY IT IS NOT CONSIDERING REINSTATING JENSEN
1:25:58 HUANG. EARLIER, HE SAID IN A STATEMENT
1:26:01 THAT HE WOULD BE HONORED TO RETURN IF THE BOARD CONSIDERED
1:26:06 IT IN THE BEST INTEREST OF SHAREHOLDERS, EMPLOYEES, AND
1:26:07 PARTNERS. THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
1:26:10 JONATHAN: THANK YOU. GETTING SOME HEADLINES FROM
1:26:14 CHRIS WALLER SPEAKING TO THE AMERICAN PRESS THIS MORNING.
1:26:20 IF WE ARE NOT SIGNALING A HIKE IN JANUARY, WE SHOULD MOVE BY 50
1:26:22 BASIS POINTS IN DECEMBER. THIS IS THE CONVERSATION WE HAD
1:26:25 YESTERDAY. THE PROBLEM WITH THE FED CHAIR
1:26:29 AND THE RELUCTANCE TO SIGNAL IS THE HAWKS WILL PUSH FOR MORE
1:26:32 BECAUSE TYPICALLY THE WAY THIS WORKS IS YOU HIKE 25 AND SIGNAL
1:26:35 THERE IS ANOTHER 25 DOWN THE ROAD.
1:26:38 IF THE FED CHAIR IS NOT DOING THAT FOR YOU, YOU WILL PUSH FOR
1:26:40 MORE IN THE MEETING. DANI: AND YOU MIGHT HAVE LESS
1:26:43 FED RATE DECISION MEETINGS IN THE FUTURE.
1:26:48 YOU DON'T HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO HIKE MORE FREQUENTLY.
1:26:52 JONATHAN: TWOS RIGHT NOW AT 4.82%.
1:26:56 UP NEXT ON THE PROGRAM, THE GROWING INFLATION DEBATE.
1:27:00 >> WE STILL HAVE WORK TO DO TO MAKE SURE THAT WE BRING
1:27:02 INFLATION BACK DOWN TO 2% IN A TIMELY WAY AND A SUSTAINED
1:27:04 MANNER. I DON'T THINK THE SITUATION
1:27:07 CALLS FOR DRAMATIC ACTION. I THINK WHAT WE HAVE BEEN DOING
1:27:10 THE PAST FEW MONTHS IS WORKING WELL.
1:27:13 JONATHAN: LOOKING FORWARD TO CATCHING UP WITH GITA GOPINATH.
1:27:16 FROM NEW YORK CITY, YOU ARE WATCHING "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE
1:27:42 JONATHAN: LOOKING TO BOUNCE BACK FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY SLIDE ON
1:27:44 THE S&P 500. THE BOUNCE IS SMALL SO FAR.
1:27:48 THE S&P 500 HIGHER BY 0.2%. THE NASDAQ UP BY 0.6%.
1:27:54 NVIDIA JUST ABOUT HOLDING ONTO GAINS FOLLOWING A BEAT AND RAISE
1:27:56 AND REALLY STRONG GUIDANCE COMING FROM THE C-SUITE.
1:27:59 THE STOCK IS ONLY UP BY 2.8%. THERE IS A CHANGE IN THE LAST
1:28:03 FEW MINUTES. TWOS UP BY TWO TO ABOUT 4.83% AT
1:28:11 THE FRONT END OF THE CURVE WITH HAWKISH FED SPEAK FROM GOVERNOR
1:28:13 WALLER MOMENTS AGO. DANI: YES, ENDORSING SOMETHING
1:28:19 OF A 50 BASIS POINT HIKE IF WE DO NOT
1:28:22 GET ONE SOON. IT IS UNCLEAR HOW HIS GUIDANCE
1:28:27 HAS BEEN AND HE HAS BEEN CLEAR WITH WHAT HE WANTS TO SEE HAPPEN
1:28:29 AS WE HAVE A FED CHAIR SAY THIS IS NOT A FED THAT WILL NOT
1:28:35 HOLD THE MARKET'S HAND. JONATHAN: UNDER SURVEILLANCE
1:28:37 THIS MORNING, THE GROWING INFLATION DEBATE.
1:28:42 >> WE STILL HAVE WORK TO DO TO MAKE SURE THAT WE BRING
1:28:44 INFLATION BACK DOWN TO 2% IN A TIMELY WAY AND A SUSTAINED
1:28:46 MANNER. I DON'T THINK THE SITUATION
1:28:50 CALLS FOR A DRAMATIC ACTION. WHAT WE HAVE BEEN DOING THE PAST
1:28:53 FEW MONTHS IS WORKING WELL. WE ARE COLLECTING THE DATA,
1:28:57 ANALYZING IT, HAVING THE DEBATE, MAKING A DECISION.
1:28:59 JONATHAN: JOHN WILLIAMS PUSHING BACK ON A JUMBO RATE HIKE AS FED
1:29:04 GOVERNOR CHRIS WALLER IS TELLING U.S. MEDIA OF OFFICIALS NOT
1:29:08 SIGNALING A HIKE IN JANUARY A 50 BASIS POINT MOVE IN DECEMBER
1:29:10 SHOULD BE ON THE TABLE. GITA GOPINATH JOINS US NOW FOR
1:29:13 MORE. GOOD MORNING AND WELCOME.
1:29:16 GITA: THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME. JONATHAN: IT IS GOOD TO SEE YOU.
1:29:22 DO YOU THINK THIS IS A SITUATION THAT CALLS FOR DRASTIC ACTION?
1:29:25 GITA: I THINK THIS IS A SITUATION WHERE THE FED HAS TO
1:29:28 WALK THE TALK, WHICH IS WARSH HAS BEEN VERY CLEAR IN HIS PRESS
1:29:33 CONFERENCES TO REMIND EVERYBODY THE FED IS COMPLETELY IN LINE
1:29:35 WITH HITTING THE 2% TARGET. THE TARGET IS TO PERCENT, NOT
1:29:39 2.5%, NOT 3%. WE ARE DOING EVERY THING WE CAN
1:29:42 TO BRING INFLATION DOWN TO TARGET.
1:29:44 LAST TIME, HE SAID WE ARE ON HOLD BECAUSE THIS IS A DATA RICH
1:29:51 ENVIRONMENT, AND THE DATA HAS SAID BASICALLY WHILE INFLATION
1:29:53 IS A PROBLEM, SO I CAN SEE WHY WALLER IS PUSHING FOR 50 BASIS
1:29:58 POINTS, BUT THERE IS CLEARLY DISAGREEMENT.
1:30:02 BUT THEY WILL HAVE TO BE MUCH MORE STRONGER SIGNALING IN
1:30:04 DECEMBER, NOT JUST ABOUT ANY RATE HIKE IN DECEMBER BUT ALSO
1:30:07 GOING FORWARD. JONATHAN: DO YOU THINK HE WILL
1:30:09 GET THE SIGNAL FROM THE FED CHAIR?
1:30:12 HE SEEMS RELUCTANT TO SIGNAL ANYTHING AT ALL.
1:30:15 GITA: I GUESS EVERYONE ELSE IS DOING THAT NOW.
1:30:16 JONATHAN: THE REST OF THE COMMITTEE.
1:30:19 GITA: EVERYONE ELSE ON THE COMMITTEE IS DOING THAT.
1:30:22 HE WILL NEED TO CONVEY MUCH MORE STRONGLY THAN HE DID IN THE LAST
1:30:25 PRESS CONFERENCE ABOUT, WHY IS IT THE FED WOULD MOVE MUCH MORE
1:30:29 SLOWLY THAN A 50 BASIS POINT HIKE?
1:30:32 JONATHAN: WHAT IS IT ABOUT THIS BACKDROP THAT MAKES IT DIFFICULT
1:30:36 TO GET BACK TO TARGET AND WHAT IS WALKING THE WALK LIKE?
1:30:39 WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO DO? GITA: WE HAVE HAD THREE MUCH OF
1:30:43 INFLATION AT 3.7%. THIS IS THREE MONTHS.
1:30:47 NOT A ONE-OFF THING. IT IS LOOKING LIKE THERE IS A
1:30:50 HEATING ECONOMY. ECONOMIC ACTIVITY HAS COME OUT
1:30:53 STRONG. THE DATA WE HAVE SEEN SO FAR HAS
1:30:55 COME OUT STRONG. EARNINGS REPORTS ARE COMING OUT
1:30:57 STRONG. ON THE ONE HAND, YOU HAVE THE
1:31:01 INFLATION, WHICH IS STRONG. YOU HAVE A VERY HEALTHY ECONOMY
1:31:05 IN TERMS OF ANY ECONOMIC ACTIVITY INDICATOR.
1:31:09 THE CONCERN IS THE RISK OFF ENVIRONMENT WE ARE IN RIGHT NOW
1:31:13 WITH THE OUTAGES AND ALL OF THESE OTHER ASPECTS.
1:31:18 IF WE ARE GOING TO DO MONETARY POLICYMAKING ON THE ASSUMPTION
1:31:22 OF WAITING FOR ALL OF THE UNCERTAINTIES TO UNWIND, YOU
1:31:24 WILL BE BEHIND THE CURVE ON THAT.
1:31:27 GIVEN ALL THE FACTS, YOU HAVE TO BE CREDIBLE AND SAY GIVEN WHAT
1:31:30 WE ARE SEEING IN THE DATA RIGHT NOW, THERE IS REASON TO BE
1:31:33 TOUGHER ON MONETARY POLICY. DANI: WALLER SPEAKING THIS
1:31:37 MORNING SEEMS TO THINK ONE OF THE PROBLEMS IS ENTRENCHMENT
1:31:39 EXPECTATIONS. 3% INFLATION MAY BE THE NORM BUT
1:31:44 THAT IS WHAT PEOPLE ARE CURRENTLY THINKING.
1:31:48 DO YOU THINK THIS IS ABOUT RAINING AND EXPECTATIONS AND IN
1:31:51 ORDER TO DO THAT YOU NEED TO HAVE A FED THAT MAY BE DOES NOT
1:31:53 HIKE BUT SIGNALS WHAT IS TO COME?
1:31:55 SOMETHING CHAIR WARSH DOES NOT WANT TO DO.
1:31:58 GITA: THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT IS NOT SHOWING UP IN MEASURES OF
1:32:02 INFLATION EXPECTATIONS AS WE ARE NOT SEEING A DRIFT AWAY FROM THE
1:32:05 FED TARGET SO THAT IS GOOD NEWS. BUT YOU DO NOT WANT TO WAIT TOO
1:32:08 LONG BEFORE THAT HAPPENS. IF INDEED 2%
1:32:14 IS THE NUMBER, THAT IS PROBLEMATIC AND YOU HAVE TO BE
1:32:15 CREDIBLE. I THINK WARSH EVEN MORE THAN
1:32:21 POWELL HAS PUT A LOT OF EMPHASIS ON THE INFLATION TARGET.
1:32:23 EITHER HE DELIVERS ON THAT OR WE HAVE TO REASSESS HOW HE TRULY
1:32:26 BELIEVES ABOUT THIS INFLATION. I KNOW HIM AND KNOW THAT HE IS A
1:32:32 HAWK AND BELIEVES IN MEETING THE INFLATION TARGET.
1:32:38 IT WOULD NOT BE SURPRISING IF HE DID NOT SAY MUCH THAN TO
1:32:46 WILLIAMS. DANI: YOU THINK THAT IS WHERE HE
1:32:50 IS ALIGNED, THAT HE MIGHT BACK A 50 BASIS POINT HIKE?
1:32:53 GITA: BASED ON EVERYTHING I HAVE KNOWN ABOUT HIM AND THE DATA
1:32:55 COMING, THAT WOULD BE WHERE I THINK HE IS, WHICH IS CLOSER TO
1:32:58 WALLER THAN WILLIAMS. BUT WE WILL SEE WHAT HE SAYS.
1:33:02 JONATHAN: WE WILL SEE WHAT WE GET IN THE COMING WEEKS OR SO.
1:33:04 I WANT YOUR ASSESSMENT ON THE ECONOMY.
1:33:07 HOW VIGILANT SHOULD THEY BE ABOUT THE PROSPECT OF THIS
1:33:09 INFLATION SPILLING INTO THE LABOR MARKET?
1:33:12 LABOR MARKET TIGHTNESS HAS NOT BEEN A BIG THEME OF THE STORY
1:33:13 THE LAST COUPLE YEARS. DO YOU THINK IT WILL BE?
1:33:22 GITA: THE LABOR MARKET WAS NOT A BIG STORY FOR THE LAST BIG
1:33:23 INFLATION SPIKE WE HAD. WHAT WE HAD THE PANDEMIC AND
1:33:31 AT THE LABOR MARKET AND SAYING WE DO NOT SEE PRESSURE IN THE
1:33:32 LABOR MARKET. AND THEN IT CAME FROM EVERYTHING
1:33:36 ELSE, THE SUPPLY CHAIN PRESSURES.
1:33:39 SO THERE IS THE SIMILAR SITUATION WE ARE IN NOW WHERE
1:33:42 INFLATION IS COMING FROM THE SUPPLY CHAIN PRESSURES INCLUDING
1:33:45 ENERGY PRICES, RESIDUAL EFFECTS OF THE TARIFFS.
1:33:48 WHETHER THAT PASSES THROUGH TO THE REST OF THE ECONOMY IS A
1:33:51 FUNCTION OF HAVE A STRONG DEMAND IS IN THE ECONOMY.
1:33:54 AT THIS POINT, WE HAVE THE INVESTMENT BOOM.
1:33:57 WE HAVE CONSUMER SPENDING STILL HOLDING UP.
1:34:00 PEOPLE ARE DIPPING INTO THEIR SAVINGS.
1:34:03 YOU CAN ALWAYS WISH FOR EVERYTHING TO GO IN THE RIGHT
1:34:06 DIRECTION AND EVERYTHING TO AUTOMATICALLY UNWIND, WHICH AS A
1:34:10 POLICYMAKER YOU DO NOT WANT TO BE RAISING RATES TOO MUCH.
1:34:12 IT IS GETTING HARDER. JONATHAN: ARE YOU WORRIED IT IS
1:34:15 GOING THE WRONG DIRECTION? GITA: I AM WORRIED WE ARE
1:34:21 GETTING TO A POINT WHERE WE ARE TRYING TO HOPE FOR THE BEST AS
1:34:23 OPPOSED TO DOING WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE IN TERMS OF TACKLING
1:34:25 INFLATION. JONATHAN: HOW DO YOU IMAGINE
1:34:30 WHAT THIS COULD LOOK LIKE IN THE NEXT YEAR?
1:34:33 WHAT DOES THIS LOOK LIKE IN 2027?
1:34:35 GITA: A TON OF UNCERTAINTY. WE COULD HAVE A SERIOUS
1:34:40 CORRECTION IN THE MARKETS, AND WE WOULD BE HAVING A COMPLETELY
1:34:43 DIFFERENT CONVERSATION WITH INTEREST-RATE HAVING TO BE
1:34:44 BROUGHT DOWN VERY RAPIDLY, BUT GIVEN THE CURRENT CONJUNCTURE
1:34:49 AND THE WORRY, YOU HAVE TO STRONGLY THAT WE ARE ON THE PATH
1:34:50 TO RAISING INFLATION. ANOTHER MARKET IS SET FOR
1:34:55 ANOTHER 80 BASIS POINTS BETWEEN NOW AND THE END OF 2027 AND
1:34:59 MAYBE THAT IS WHAT IS NEEDED. JONATHAN: IT IS GOOD TO SEE YOU
1:35:02 AS ALWAYS. THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
1:35:07 THERE IS A BIG GAP AND WE TALKED ABOUT THE GAP BETWEEN THE POLICY
1:35:09 RATE AND THE FRONT END OF THE CURVE.
1:35:11 IT SOUNDS LIKE THE GAP MIGHT CLOSE WITH WHETHER MARKET IS AT
1:35:15 THE MOMENT. DANI: AND MAYBE IT NEEDS TO COME
1:35:19 TO THE POINT THAT WALLER IS MAKING THAT STILL YOU HAVE
1:35:22 DISINFLATION ABOVE TARGET. IT HAS BEEN A PROBLEM FOR THE
1:35:24 PAST THREE MONTHS. THIS IS A FED THAT NEEDS TO WALK
1:35:26 THE WALK. JONATHAN: THERE IS A FIVE ON THE
1:35:28 BOARD RIGHT NOW. GOVERNOR WALLER IS PULLING NO
1:35:31 PUNCHES. COMMENTS LIKE THIS THIS MORNING.
1:35:36 DANI: IT IS NOT EVEN JUST THE FACT THAT HE IS CALLING FOR A
1:35:38 RATE HIKES. HE IS GIVING A SPECIFIC
1:35:44 PRESCRIPTION, SAYING IF CPI COMES THIS WAY, WE NEED TO DO 50
1:35:45 BASIS POINT. IF WE DO NOT IGNORE THIS, WE
1:35:48 NEED TO DO 50 BASIS POINT. IT IS VERY SPECIFIC AND FORWARD
1:35:51 GUIDANCE. JONATHAN: UP NEXT ON THE
1:35:54 PROGRAM, WE WILL CATCH UP WITH EMILY, CHRIS, BECKY, AND THE NEW
1:36:03 YORK CITY COMPTROLLER MARK ON THE ANTHROPIC IPO.
1:36:04 HE WANTED IT DELAYED. FROM NEW YORK CITY, THE THIRD
1:36:08 HOUR OF "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE" IS JUST AROUND THE CORNER.
1:36:32 ♪ >> THE TRENDLINE IS NO LONGER
1:36:34 THAT SORT OF HOCKEY STICK WE HAVE TAKEN FOR GRANTED IN THE AI
1:36:35 TRADE. >> IT IS AMAZING HOW THIS WHOLE
1:36:39 AREA HAS EVOLVED OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS.
1:36:45 >> REALLY HAS TO BE YOUR NORTHSTAR IS, HOW DOES THE
1:36:47 DEMAND FOR COMPUTERLIKE? >> THIS WILL BE A DIFFICULT TIME
1:36:51 FOR THE MARKETS AND HOW MUCH CAN IT TAKE?
1:36:54 >> YOU HAVE TO BE MEASURED ABOUT WHERE YOU ARE TAKING RISKS.
1:36:55 >> THIS IS "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE" WITH JONATHAN
1:36:59 FERRO, LISA ABRAMOWICZ, AND ANNMARIE HORDERN.
1:37:02 JONATHAN: LIVE FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING,
1:37:03 GOOD MORNING. THE THIRD HOUR OF "BLOOMBERG
1:37:06 SURVEILLANCE" STARTS RIGHT NOW. YOUR SCORE LOOKS LIKE THIS.
1:37:10 NVIDIA IN THE PREMARKET HOLDING ONTO GAINS.
1:37:14 THIS IS THE STOCK OF THE MOMENT, DOWN HARD ON THE MONTH, DOWN
1:37:16 HARD FROM THE HIGHS OF OCTOBER. THIS MORNING, HIGHER BY 2.8%.
1:37:21 THAT STOCK FACING SOME MAJOR QUESTIONS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS.
1:37:25 THE C-SUITE DOING THEIR BEST TO ANSWER THEM ON THE CALL.
1:37:30 WILL THEY CAN GUIDANCE, GET RID OF IT, CHANGE IT, CHANGE THE
1:37:35 APPROACH TO FINANCING IN THE ECOSYSTEM?
1:37:40 HOW MUCH REVENUE IS THERE GIVEN THE RISK?
1:37:43 THAT STOCK JUST ABOUT HOLDING ONTO GAINS.
1:37:47 THE EQUITY MARKET DOING OK BUT FADING SLOWLY AS WE APPROACHED
1:37:48 OPENING BELL. FUTURES UP BY 0.2% ON THE S&P.
1:37:55 ON THE NASDAQ, HIGHER BY 0.6% FOLLOWING A LOSING STREAK BY THE
1:37:57 S&P AND NASDAQ 100. SETTING THE TONE THE LAST 20
1:38:01 MINUTES, THIS BOND MARKET HAS COMMENTS FROM FED GOVERNOR CHRIS
1:38:02 WALLER. YIELDS PUSHING HIGHER AT THE
1:38:04 FRONT END OF THE CURVE. TWOS AT 4.83%.
1:38:11 THE MESSAGE FROM GOVERNOR WALLER CLEAR, IF YOU ARE NOT GOING TO
1:38:14 SIGNAL YOU MIGHT MOVE AGAIN IN JANUARY, I WANT A 50 BASIS POINT
1:38:18 MOVE IN DECEMBER. THE MEETING OF THE FED A FEW
1:38:20 WEEKS AWAY. COMING UP THIS HOUR, WE WILL
1:38:23 CATCH UP WITH EMILY OF JOHN HANCOCK, CHRIS OF WOLFE RESEARCH
1:38:28 CUTTING HIS PRICE TARGET ON NVIDIA, AND WE WILL SPEAK TO THE
1:38:33 NEW YORK CITY COMPTROLLER AS ANTHROPIC PREPARES TO PRICE ITS
1:38:34 MEGA IPO. AGAIN THIS HOUR WITH STOCKS
1:38:39 REBOUNDING FOLLOWING BLOCKBUSTER RESULTS FROM NVIDIA, ED LUDLOW
1:38:41 HAS THE LATEST. GOOD MORNING.
1:38:42 ED: GOOD MORNING. IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT
1:38:46 BOOSTING THE GROWTH OUTLOOK FOR 2027, DEMAND IS RUNNING AHEAD OF
1:38:52 SUPPLY BUT THERE IS IMPROVEMENT IN SUPPLY.
1:38:55 YOU WILL SEE ON THE BLOOMBERG TERMINAL A LOT OF DEBATE THIS
1:38:57 MORNING WAS AROUND THE COMMENTS THAT COLETTE KRESS MADE ABOUT
1:39:03 RIGOROUS AND DISCIPLINED
1:39:07 ABOUT WHERE NVIDIA DEPLOYS ITS BALANCE SHEET.
1:39:10 YOU USED THE WORD ECOSYSTEM A MINUTE AGO.
1:39:14 IF YOU GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE TRANSCRIPT OF WHAT SHE SAID, IT
1:39:16 IS A DEBATE ABOUT WHERE IN THE ECOSYSTEM IS THE PRIORITY.
1:39:20 THE NEO-CLOUDS ARE HIGHER THIS MORNING AND IT SEEMS LIKE THEY
1:39:24 ARE BEING MORE DISCERNING ON HOW THEY SUPPORTED THOSE KINDS OF
1:39:26 PROJECTS, BUT THE PRIORITY IS THE SUPPLIERS.
1:39:29 THE BACKLOG NUMBER OR COMMITMENTS NUMBER THAT NVIDIA
1:39:31 GREW BY 10 BILLION IS IMPORTANT.
1:39:36 THAT IS WHAT NVIDIA IS PREPARED TO PUT UP TO HELP IT SUPPLIERS
1:39:37 BOOST SUPPLY. COLETTE KRESS WAS CRYSTAL CLEAR,
1:39:41 THAT IS WHERE THEY WANT TO SEE IMPROVEMENT.
1:39:44 THAT IS WHERE THEY WILL GREASE THE WHEELS OF THEIR OWN CAPITAL.
1:39:48 AWAY FROM THAT, THE INDIRECT CHINA FACTOR IS AN OVERHANG FOR
1:39:51 CALENDAR 2027 ACCORDING TO BARCLAYS.
1:39:55 BUT AGAIN, THE GROWTH OUTLOOK REFLECTS THE IDEA THAT WHILE
1:39:58 THEY TRY TO UNDERSTAND THESE NEW COMMERCE DEPARTMENT RULES, IF
1:40:02 THEIR ABILITY TO SHIFT TO SOME OF THOSE MARKETS IN SOUTHEAST
1:40:05 ASIA WENT AWAY, DEMAND FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE WOULD MAKE UP FOR
1:40:07 IT AND THAT IS BEING DIGESTED IN THE MARKETS THIS MORNING.
1:40:11 JONATHAN: CAN WE SPENT TIME TALKING ABOUT THE PERFORMANCE ON
1:40:12 THE CALL? ED: PLEASE.
1:40:17 JONATHAN: JENSEN HUANG CAN COMMUNICATE INCREDIBLY
1:40:21 EXTREMELY NERVOUS ON THAT CALL YESTERDAY.
1:40:23 I JUST WONDER HOW SHE WILL NAVIGATE LOBBYING AND
1:40:30 INVESTIGATION IN THE COMING WEEKS AND MONTHS BECAUSE THE
1:40:35 ANALYSTS TOOK THE CUE COMING FROM THE CHAIRMAN.
1:40:39 YOU CANNOT ASK ABOUT THIS, AND ANALYSTS HATE THEMSELVES.
1:40:43 OTHER OFFICIALS IN WASHINGTON WILL NOT PLAY BY THE RULES SET
1:40:47 THEMSELVES. CAN SHE HANDLE THE MOMENT?
1:40:53 ED: THAT IS A GOOD QUESTION AND A FAIR QUESTION.
1:40:56 THERE IS THE CHRONOLOGY OF OPENING UP THE CALL AND
1:40:58 ADDRESSING THE IDEA OF BOARD WAS UNANIMOUS IN ACCEPTING JENSEN
1:41:03 HIM. THERE WAS THE MOMENT THAT
1:41:06 INVESTORS NEED TO BELIEVE WITH CONVICTION WHERE COLETTE KRESS
1:41:10 SAID THE TECHNOLOGY ROADMAP IS INTACT.
1:41:13 SHE DESCRIBES HOW THIS GENERATION OF REUBEN PLATFORM IS
1:41:16 RAMPING MORE EFFECTIVELY THAN ANY PRIOR GENERATION.
1:41:19 THERE WERE $20 BILLION OF SALES IN THE QUARTER ENDED IMPACT TO
1:41:22 MARGINS IN THE CURRENT PERIOD. BUT THAT IS NOT HER THING.
1:41:26 SHE IS NOT THE TECHNOLOGY VISIONARY.
1:41:32 SHE HAS BEEN THE CFO THAT HAS HAD THE RELATIONSHIP WITH WALL
1:41:33 STREET. ONE THING I WOULD SAY IF YOU
1:41:36 TAKE THE POLICYMAKERS OUT OF IT, THAT WAS JENSEN HUANG'S ROLE FOR
1:41:38 SURE. A LOT OF THE NEO-CLOUDS, THE
1:41:43 FRONTIER LABS THEMSELVES, I CAN TELL YOU IT WAS COLETTE KRESS
1:41:44 MAKING BUSINESS WITH THEM. YOU CAN SEE HEADLINES THIS
1:41:48 MORNING FROM EXECUTIVE FROM COREWEAVE SAYING WE SPOKE WITH
1:41:56 JENSEN THE WHOLE TIME. IT IS THE OUTLOOK ON TECHNOLOGY
1:42:01 THAT IS IMPORTANT AND WHY THE FOCUS OF THIS BOARD ON THE
1:42:04 EXTERNAL SEARCH IS LOOKING AT TECHNOLOGY LEADERS, NOT
1:42:08 NECESSARILY BUSINESS, FINANCE FOCUSED EXECUTIVES.
1:42:11 JONATHAN: GOOD TO SEE YOU WE WILL CATCH UP LATER THIS HOUR
1:42:14 AND TALK ABOUT THE ANTHROPIC IPO AND MEGA IPO IN THE COMING
1:42:18 HOURS. EMILY SAYING THERE ARE TWO
1:42:22 FORCES WERE DECLINED, THAT EARNINGS ARE NOT THE PROBLEM,
1:42:24 THE PROBLEM IS THE FED. WE HAVE A TECHNOLOGY DRIVEN
1:42:29 EARNINGS BOOM OF EPIC PROPORTIONS AND A MORE HAWKISH
1:42:30 FED THAT IS DEAFENING LIQUIDITY. WELCOME.
1:42:34 LET'S TALK ABOUT CHRIS WALLER. WAS IT THE BOOKCASE OF SLOWING
1:42:38 CAPEX AND HIGHER INTEREST RATES? EMILY: YEAH, IT IS NOTABLE THAT
1:42:43 AFTER SEEING CHRIS WALLER COME OUT WITH THIS CALL FOR
1:42:45 POTENTIALLY SEEING 50 BASIS POINT IN DECEMBER, IT MAKES
1:42:48 SENSE IN TERMS OF THE FORWARD GARLANDS A LOT OF INVESTORS ARE
1:42:50 LOOKING FOR. YOU ALSO HAD THE ST. LOUIS FED
1:42:58 PRESIDENT SUGGESTING THAT FOUR RATE HIKES MAY BE NECESSARY OVER
1:42:59 THE NEXT SEVERAL MONTHS HERE. THIS IS COMING AT A TIME WHEN
1:43:04 HYPERSCALERS ARE DEMANDING MORE LIQUIDITY THAN EVER.
1:43:07 THE AI TRADE STARTED ROLLING OVER REALLY BEFORE THE MIDTERM
1:43:11 ELECTIONS, BEFORE THE LAST WEEK OF NEWS AROUND NVIDIA WITH SOUTH
1:43:15 KOREA AND TAIWAN SEEING MEANINGFUL DOWNSIDE PRESSURE.
1:43:19 THOSE MARKETS HAD BEEN MOVING UP IN A PARABOLIC DIRECTION.
1:43:23 IT REALLY COINCIDED TO US WITH THE FED TURNING MORE HAWKISH.
1:43:25 THESE TWO FORCES ARE COLLIDING. MATT AND I HAVE BEEN TALKING
1:43:28 ABOUT THIS ON YOUR SHOW FOR THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS.
1:43:32 THIS MASSIVE NEED FOR LIQUIDITY, THE NEED FOR THE BLANK CHECKBOOK
1:43:35 AT THE SAME TIME THAT FED IS REMOVING LIQUIDITY FROM THAT
1:43:38 MARKET AT A FASTER CLIP THAN HAD BEEN ANTICIPATED.
1:43:43 WE MAY SEE MORE DOWNSIDE VOLATILITY HERE, BUT WE WOULD
1:43:46 THINK ABOUT GETTING THAT HOLIDAY SHOPPING LIST OUT.
1:43:48 JONATHAN: WHAT IS ON THE SHOPPING LIST RIGHT NOW?
1:43:52 EMILY: YEAH, SO WE ARE LOOKING TO QUALITY VALUE AS OUR MANTRA
1:43:54 HEADING INTO 2027. THESE ARE STOCKS WITH GREAT ROE,
1:44:01 RISKS. WE WANT TO PROTECT AGAINST REAL
1:44:06 EVALUATION RISKS HERE. THE NICE PART ABOUT THE VALUE
1:44:10 SIDE OF THE TRADE NOW AS IT INCLUDES TECHNOLOGY STOCKS.
1:44:14 NOW VALUE MANAGERS CAN BIOTECH WHICH WE THINK IS -- BUY TECH,
1:44:17 WHICH WE THINK IS GREAT. WE HAVE BEEN HIGHLIGHTING AREAS
1:44:20 LIKE HEALTH CARE. THEY HAVE A LOW EARNINGS BAR.
1:44:24 THEY ARE NOT AI TO THE GREATEST EXTENT WE CAN FIND.
1:44:28 WE ARE LOOKING AT SOLID BALANCE SHEETS GOOD EARNINGS ESTIMATES.
1:44:31 AREAS LIKE UTILITIES, INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTING WE
1:44:33 THINK REALLY MAKE A NICE COMPLEMENT TO PORTFOLIOS.
1:44:37 BUT TECHNOLOGY AND OF COURSE BONDS ARE STILL OVERLOOKED HERE
1:44:41 AND COULD ADD A LOT OF VALUE TO PORTFOLIOS EVEN THE ELEVATED
1:44:44 INCOME THAT IS AVAILABLE TODAY. JONATHAN: LET'S JUST GO WITH A
1:44:47 FEW THINGS. UTILITIES, HEALTH CARE, BONDS.
1:44:52 ARE YOU LOOKING FOR A CYCLICAL SLOWDOWN INTO NEXT YEAR?
1:44:54 EMILY: BY THE WAY, I LOVE SHOPPING, SO I WILL ALWAYS HAVE
1:44:57 A REALLY LONG LIST OF THINGS TO SHOP FOR.
1:44:59 BUT WE ARE. WHAT WE SAW THIS YEAR THROUGH
1:45:05 THE ONE BIG BEAUTIFUL BILL WAS A MASSIVE AMOUNT OF FISCAL
1:45:06 SPENDING. IT REALLY WAS TO THE ECONOMY.
1:45:13 WE SAW ECONOMIC GROWTH BOOMING. TWO US, IT RHYMES WITH 2018.
1:45:22 TIME WHEN THE ECONOMY WAS COMING ALONG QUITE NICELY.
1:45:25 SO IT WAS FISCAL STIMULUS THAT WAS NOT COUNTERCYCLICAL.
1:45:29 IN OTHER WORDS, NOT DESIGNED TO GET US OUT OF A RECESSION.
1:45:31 THE ECONOMY WAS BOOMING. LOW AND BEHOLD, THE FED HAD TO
1:45:33 HIKE. IF YOU FAST-FORWARD TO 2019, THE
1:45:38 FISCAL SUGAR RUSH FADED INTO THE NEXT YEAR.
1:45:40 THERE WAS A BIT OF A HANGOVER FOR IT, AND THE HIKING CYCLE
1:45:43 ENDED UP BEING SHORT AND SWEET. THE FED WAS ACTUALLY CUTTING
1:45:47 INTO 2019. WE THINK WE COULD SEE A VERY
1:45:53 SIMILAR PATTERN NOW WITH A SHORT AND SWEET HIKING CYCLE THAT IS
1:45:56 DESIGNED TO CALM DOWN THE OVERHEATING WE HAVE SEEN IN THE
1:45:59 ECONOMY AND WITH THE FED CUTTING NEXT YEAR.
1:46:02 WE DON'T THINK INFLATION IS AS BIG A PROBLEM AS WE ARE HEARING
1:46:04 FROM OTHER INVESTORS. JONATHAN: SOMETHING BAD NEEDED
1:46:07 TO HAPPEN BEFORE THE FED BACKED AWAY IN 2018.
1:46:10 WE WOULD MEMBER THE BLOWOUT IN CREDIT SPREADS WE SAW AT THE
1:46:13 BACK END OF THE YEAR. I TALK ABOUT THIS REPEATEDLY
1:46:16 BECAUSE IT WAS SUCH AN IMPORTANT MOMENT.
1:46:19 YOU DID NOT GET A SINGLE JUNK BOND ISSUED IN THIS COUNTRY IN
1:46:20 THE MONTH OF DECEMBER OF 2018. ARE YOU ANTICIPATING A MOMENT
1:46:23 LIKE THAT? EMILY: IT IS POSSIBLE, AND IT IS
1:46:28 ALWAYS HARD TO SEE WHERE THESE FINANCIAL ACCIDENTS MIGHT COME
1:46:29 FROM. LOOKING AT TRIPLE C'S, WE SAW
1:46:36 THE BLOWOUT TO 10%, 11%. THE REST OF THE HIGH-YIELD BOND
1:46:39 MARKET HAS BEEN REMARKABLY CONTAINED.
1:46:42 WE ARE AT 336 BASIS POINTS OVER TREASURIES RIGHT NOW, NOT EVEN
1:46:47 BACK TO THE HIGHS WE SAW IN THE SPRING OF THIS YEAR.
1:46:50 CREDIT IS ACTING REMARKABLY CONTAINED HERE.
1:46:55 AND SAID WE ARE NOT CLOSE TO NEUTRAL.
1:46:58 EQUITY MARKETS DID NOT LIKE THAT AT THE END OF 2018.
1:47:04 I THINK THAT THE FED IS TRENDING VERY CAREFULLY HERE IN
1:47:06 TERMS OF WHAT THEY WILL BE DOING NEXT YEAR.
1:47:10 THAT COMMUNICATION, IT ONLY TOOK A FEW WORDS FROM CHAIR WARSH TO
1:47:14 CAUSE A NEARLY 20% DRAWDOWN IN THE MARKET IN 2018.
1:47:18 IT WAS A GOOD OPPORTUNITY TO GET THE SHOPPING LIST OUT.
1:47:22 WE DO NOT EXPECT A RECESSION HERE.
1:47:23 EARNINGS ARE STILL GOOD. GAS PRICES ARE COMING DOWN.
1:47:27 WE THINK RATES REVERSE INTO NEXT YEAR.
1:47:31 HIGH-YIELD BOND SPREADS ARE STILL RELATIVELY TIGHT HERE.
1:47:35 A NON-RECESSIONARY CORRECTION, A MIDCYCLE SLOWDOWN, A LOT OF
1:47:39 PEOPLE HAVE BEEN SAYING THIS ON THE SHOW AND I COMPLETELY AGREE,
1:47:41 SLOWING BUT STILL GROWING. JONATHAN: I KNOW YOU MENTIONED
1:47:44 CHAIR WARSH, CHAIR POWELL. LET'S TALK ABOUT CHAIRMAN WARSH
1:47:47 SINCE HE IS ON YOUR MIND. CHAIRMAN WARSH IS FACING A FIGHT
1:47:50 ON HIS BOARD. HE HAS SOME REAL PUSHBACK.
1:47:55 WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE FOR THE COMING MEETING?
1:47:58 EMILY: YEAH, THE OLD FAMILY FIGHT.
1:48:01 IT IS ALL ABOUT GETTING MORE COMMUNICATION.
1:48:02 I THINK HE HAS TO BE HAWKISH. IF THIS 50 BASIS POINT HIKE
1:48:10 REALLY STARTS TO BUILD IN THE NARRATIVE ON THE STREET AND THE
1:48:12 FED DOES NOT DO IT, THAT IS THE HOLIDAY GIFT THAT EVERYBODY WILL
1:48:15 HAVE WISHED FOR. YOU SEE EQUITY MARKETS RALLY ON
1:48:22 THAT AND YOU MAY SEE SOME TYPE OF BACKUP IN BOND YIELDS ON THAT
1:48:27 AS WELL GIVEN THE FACT THAT MAYBE FINANCIAL CONDITIONS WILL
1:48:29 NOT BE AS TIGHT AS WAS FEARED. WE WILL HAVE TO SEE WHAT HAPPENS
1:48:31 HERE. IN OUR VIEW, INFLATION IS JUST
1:48:34 NOT AS BIG OF A PROBLEM. AS I MENTIONED EARLIER,
1:48:38 HOMEBUILDER SENTIMENT CAME OUT YESTERDAY AT THE LOWEST LEVEL
1:48:41 SINCE 2012. BUILDERS ARE CUTTING PRICES
1:48:43 RIGHT NOW. THE HOUSING MARKET IS THE
1:48:45 ECONOMIC CYCLE. SO THE FED WILL POTENTIALLY RISK
1:48:52 HARMING THE HOUSING MARKET, WHICH WITH MORTGAGE RATES WILL
1:49:03 SEE PRESSURE SO THEY HAVE TO BE CAREFUL HERE.
1:49:05 JONATHAN: IS THAT ABOUT A FLATTER CURVE?
1:49:08 EMILY: WE ARE SEEING THAT HAPPEN OVER THE COURSE OF THE YEAR.
1:49:12 THE MARKET KEEPS RATCHETING UP EXPECTATIONS FOR THE FED AND
1:49:13 THAT IS SHOPPING IN THE FLATTER CURVE, WHICH IS SUGGESTING
1:49:17 GROWTH IS NOT THAT GREAT. IN ADDITION, THE AI TRADE HAS
1:49:22 BEEN RESPONSIBLE FOR A LOT OF THAT GROWTH AND HAS BEEN HELPED
1:49:23 BY THE ONE BIG BEAUTIFUL BILL. THIS IS BACK TO THE 2018 AND
1:49:29 2019 ANALOGY. NOT SAYING AI CAPEX IS FALLING
1:49:34 OFF A CLIFF. IT IS PROBABLY SLOWING FROM
1:49:36 HERE. YOU WILL NOT GET THE SAME BOOST
1:49:37 GROWTH. HAVE TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT GROWTH
1:49:43 AND DECELERATION DRAWING MORE THAN THE BOND MARKET IS SNIFFING
1:49:44 OUT RIGHT NOW. SEEING MORE AT THE LONGER END.
1:49:47 JONATHAN: THANK YOU. EMILY ROLAND THERE.
1:49:54 29 BASIS POINTS, SLIGHTLY FLATTER ON THE DAY.
1:50:00 TWOS AT THE MOMENT SLIGHTLY HIGHER BY ABOUT A BASIS POINT OR
1:50:01 TWO. TENS BARELY MOVING ON THE BACK
1:50:04 OF THE COMMENTS. THAT IS THE FRONT END OF THE
1:50:06 CURVE. THE LIKES OF EMILY ROLAND
1:50:10 TALKING ABOUT OFF OF THE COMMENTS FROM FED GOVERNOR
1:50:12 WALLER. AN ADDITIONAL PUSH HIGHER, UP BY
1:50:18 TWO, HEADING INTO THE MEETING A FEW WEEKS HI.
1:50:21 WITH YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF, ISABELLE LEE HAS MORE.
1:50:24 ISABELLE: FED GOVERNOR CHRIS WALLER IS CONCERNED INFLATION IS
1:50:26 HEADED IN THE WRONG DIRECTION. SPEAKING TO AMERICAN MEDIA,
1:50:33 WALLER SAYING OFFICIALS ARE NOT SIGNALING A HIKE IN JANUARY, A
1:50:36 50 BASIS POINT HIKE SHOULD BE ON THE TABLE NEXT MONTH.
1:50:41 NVIDIA NO LONGER SHIPPING SOME TRIPS TO CHINA DESPITE U.S.
1:50:42 GOVERNMENT APPROVAL. THE COMPANY SOLD $2.4 BILLION
1:50:46 WORTH OF PRODUCTS TO CHINA IN THE THIRD QUARTER.
1:50:50 BUT ON THE ANALYST CALL LAST NIGHT, INTERIM CEO COLETTE KRESS
1:50:53 SAYING FUTURE GUIDANCE DOES NOT INCLUDE ANY LICENSED
1:50:57 DATA CENTER PRODUCTS TO CHINA. ANTHROPIC PRICING THE HIGHLY
1:51:01 ANTICIPATED IPO TODAY. SHARES WILL LIKELY PRICE AT $78
1:51:05 A PIECE OR HIGHER. THEY ARE OFFERING 820 5 MILLION
1:51:12 SHARES IN A DEAL THAT COULD VALUE THE COMPANY AT .4
1:51:14 TRILLION. AND TOPIC WILL BEGIN TRADING ON
1:51:19 THE NASDAQ TOMORROW UNDER ANT. JONATHAN: THANK YOU.
1:51:24 WE ARE ON COURSE, ON TRACK FOR A RECORD-BREAKING IPO IN THE NEXT
1:51:25 24 HOURS. UP NEXT, THE MORNING CALLS AND
1:51:32 WE WILL CATCH UP WITH CHRIS CASO CUTTING HIS PRICE TARGET ON
1:51:35 NVIDIA DUE TO EXPORT CONTROL AND LEADERSHIP UNCERTAINTY.
1:51:38 LOOKING FORWARD TO CATCH UP WITH CHRIS IN A MOMENT.
1:51:40 LIVE FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING, GOOD MORNING.
1:52:01 ♪ >> THE GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES HAVE
1:52:04 BECOME MORE CHALLENGING GIVEN THE U.S. MARKET NOT ABLE TO HAVE
1:52:08 POTENTIAL OPPORTUNITIES IN OTHER REGIONS OF THE WORLD JUST MAKES
1:52:11 IT INCREDIBLY MORE CHALLENGING FOR THAT TO CONTINUE TO GROW AT
1:52:14 A CERTAIN RATE AS WE GO INTO CALENDAR 2028.
1:52:17 JONATHAN: THAT WAS ANGELO FOLLOWING THE BEAT AND RAISE
1:52:21 FROM THE YESTERDAY. THE STOCK UP BY OVER 2% IN THE
1:52:26 PREMARKET. THERE IS AN OVERHANG ON THE
1:52:29 STOCK. WE TALKED ABOUT IT REPEATEDLY
1:52:33 THIS MORNING FROM BARCLAYS AND THE ACCESS TO SOUTHEAST ASIA
1:52:38 REMAINS AN OVERHANG INTO 2027. FOR THE STOCK AND OTHERS, THERE
1:52:42 IS AN OVERHANG ELSEWHERE TOO. THEY WERE VAGUE ON THE CALL
1:52:45 ABOUT THE COMMITMENT TO FINANCING, ANCHORING BORROWING
1:52:49 IN THE AI ECOSYSTEM. RIGOROUSLY EVALUATING
1:52:56 COMMITMENTS AND GUARANTEES COMING OUT OF THE C-SUITE THE
1:52:58 LAST 24 HOURS.COREWEAVE HIGHER.
1:53:05 NEBIUS UP BY CLOSE TO 4%. FUTURES MORE BROADLY HOLDING
1:53:08 ONTO GAINS. ON THE S&P 500, HIGHER BY 0.2%
1:53:14 FOLLOWING A FOUR-DAY LOSING STREAK.
1:53:17 OVER THE LAST FOUR SESSIONS, THE NASDAQ DOWN BY 5%.
1:53:21 ON THE NASDAQ 100 THIS MORNING, UP BY 0.6%.
1:53:26 WE HAVE LOSSES ON THE RUSSELL IN THE FACE OF THE BOND MOVE IN THE
1:53:28 MARKET. TWOS UP TO 4.82% AS GOVERNOR
1:53:41 WALLER IS PUSHING FOR A 50 BASIS POINT MOVE IN DECEMBER IF HE
1:53:44 DOES NOT SEE A SIGNAL THE FED WILL MAKE ANOTHER 25 BASIS POINT
1:53:46 MOVE IN EARLY 2027. THOSE COMMENTS FROM FED GOVERNOR
1:53:51 CHRIS WALLER A BIT EARLIER THIS MORNING ABOUT 30 MINUTES AGO.
1:53:54 SOME OF THE PRICE ACTION IN THE BOND MARKET.
1:54:01 CALLS. NVIDIA MAY BE RANGE BOUND UNTIL
1:54:06 FURTHER CEO CLARITY. A STRONGER NEAR TO MIDTERM
1:54:09 OUTLOOK. FINALLY, UBS LOWERING ITS PRICE
1:54:15 TARGET ON THE CHIPMAKER SAYING RISKS INCLUDE THE ONGOING
1:54:16 INVESTIGATION. LET'S STICK WITH THAT NAME.
1:54:21 CHRIS CASO OF WOLFE RESEARCH MAINTAINING AND OUTPERFORM,
1:54:23 CUTTING THE PRICE TARGET. "WE THINK A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT
1:54:26 OF BAD NEWS IS REFLECTED IN THE STOCK DUE TO UNCERTAINTY AROUND
1:54:30 NEW EXPORT CONTROLS AND THE CEO'S DEPARTURE."
1:54:34 WHAT DID
1:54:41 YOU MAKE OF THE CALL YESTERDAY? DID YOU GET ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
1:54:44 YOU HAD? CHRIS: SOME OF THEM.
1:54:50 AFTER ANYTHING BUT A NORMAL WEEK, IT WAS A TYPICAL NVIDIA
1:54:51 BEAT AND RAISE. OF COURSE, THEY RAISED THE
1:54:56 NUMBERS FOR FISCAL 2028, CALENDAR 2027, FROM 70% TO 75%.
1:55:03 THE MESSAGE MANAGEMENT WAS TRYING TO SEND WITHIN THAT IS
1:55:08 DESPITE ALL OF THE UNCERTAINTY AND GIVEN JENSEN HUANG'S
1:55:11 DEPARTURE, DEMAND REMAINS VERY MUCH AHEAD OF SUPPLY.
1:55:18 AS A RESULT OF THAT, EVEN IF THERE ARE CHANGES IN DEMAND BY
1:55:21 SOME OF THE THINGS THE MARKET HAS BEEN WORRIED ABOUT SUCH AS
1:55:24 AVAILABILITY OF INFRASTRUCTURE, SOME OF THE FINANCING, SOME OF
1:55:29 THE EXPORT CONTROLS, DEMAND IS SO FAR AHEAD OF SUPPLY THEY
1:55:31 COULD NOT SUPPLY IT ANYWAY SO THAT IS THE REASON WHY NUMBERS
1:55:33 WOULD NOT HAVE TO CHANGE. JONATHAN: CAN I GET YOUR
1:55:36 PERSONAL VIEWS ON WHETHER THOSE NUMBERS MIGHT HAVE TO CHANGE?
1:55:39 HOW MUCH REVENUE DO BELIEVE THERE IS A RISK OFF THE BACK OF
1:55:41 ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS THIS WEEK?
1:55:46 CHRIS: MY SENSE IS NOT VERY MUCH.
1:55:52 I THINK THAT HAVING MORE DISCLOSURE ABOUT THAT BE A GOOD
1:55:56 THING. AND ON THAT, THERE WAS NOT MUCH
1:56:00 DISCUSSION IN ITS VERY EARLY DAYS.
1:56:03 THE RULES ONLY CAME OUT MONDAY SO I UNDERSTAND WHY MANAGEMENT
1:56:05 MAY NOT HAVE EXTREME CLARITY ON THEIR OWN.
1:56:11 WITH REGARD TO CHINA ITSELF, I THINK THOSE CONCERNS ARE A
1:56:14 LITTLE BIT OVERBLOWN BECAUSE, AGAIN, NVIDIA WAS PERMITTED TO
1:56:18 SELL LOWER END CHIPS INTO CHINA AND IT WAS THE CHINESE
1:56:20 GOVERNMENT THEMSELVES THAT DID NOT WANT THOSE CHIPS BECAUSE
1:56:22 THEY WANTED TO PROMOTE THEIR INTERNAL.
1:56:27 SO I DO NOTHING CHINA ITSELF IS A BIG DEAL.
1:56:32 THESE NEW REGULATIONS ARE THAT CLOUDS WITH IN PLACES LIKE
1:56:35 SINGAPORE, INDONESIA, MALAYSIA WILL NO LONGER BE ABLE TO USE
1:56:41 NVIDIA'S CHIPS OR ANY U.S. CHIPS TO SUPPLY COMPUTE DEMAND TO
1:56:42 CHINESE CUSTOMERS. AND AGAIN, THAT PROBABLY HAS
1:56:46 SOME IMPACT ON THOSE CUSTOMERS. THE QUESTION IS, IS THAT SO
1:56:52 SMALL THAT THE CHIPS CAN BE REDIRECTED SOMEWHERE ELSE?
1:56:56 REMEMBER, SPACEX ON THE LAST EARNINGS CALL INCREASED THEIR
1:56:59 EXPECTATION FOR HOW MANY GIGAWATTS THEY SHIP NEXT YEAR,
1:57:03 AND ELON MUSK SAID I WOULD LIKE TO GET TO 20 GIGAWATTS FROM
1:57:06 INCREMENTAL 10 GIGAWATTS IN THEIR PLANS RIGHT NOW.
1:57:11 SO THERE ARE PLACES BECAUSE OF THE SHORT SUPPLY A CUSTOMER
1:57:14 WOULD VERY MUCH LIKE TO HAVE ADDITIONAL PRODUCT.
1:57:17 ELSEWHERE. JONATHAN: JUST TO FOLLOW THAT
1:57:21 ANOTHER COUPLE OF STEPS, THE SOURCE OF DEMAND, WHERE WILL IT
1:57:22 BE? WILL IT COME FROM ELSEWHERE?
1:57:26 IT COMES FROM ELSEWHERE PARTICULARLY DOMESTICALLY IN THE
1:57:28 UNITED STATES. DO THEY GO BACK TO HAVING THE
1:57:31 DOMINANT SOURCE BEING SOME OF THE HYPERSCALERS THAT MIGHT END
1:57:35 UP BEING COMPETITORS AS WELL, SOMETHING JENSEN WAS CONCERNED
1:57:38 ABOUT ACCORDING TO REPORTS THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS?
1:57:41 CHRIS: YEAH, AND THAT IS A TOUGHER QUESTION TO ANSWER.
1:57:45 LISTEN, I THINK THE WAY WE LOOK AT IT IS THE MOST IMPORTANT
1:57:51 THING IS, WHAT IS THE ROI ON THESE DATA CENTER INVESTMENTS?
1:57:54 AND SO FAR, IT HAS BEEN VERY HIGH.
1:57:59 IN FACT, GOING BACK TO SPACEX, WHAT THEY SAID WAS THE PAYBACK
1:58:01 PERIOD ON INVESTMENT IS LESS THAN A YEAR.
1:58:03 IF THAT IS THE CASE, IF THAT IS REMOTELY TRUE, YOU WANT TO
1:58:09 INSTALL AS MUCH AS YOU CAN AS QUICKLY AS YOU CAN BECAUSE YOU
1:58:10 ARE GETTING VERY HIGH RETURNS ON IT RIGHT NOW.
1:58:12 EXACTLY WHERE THE DEMAND IS COMING FROM IS LESS RELEVANT
1:58:16 THAN THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE AGGREGATE DEMAND.
1:58:27 OF COURSE, EVERYTHING WORKS ON THE BSO TO THE EXTENT
1:58:30 DEMAND CHANGES AND GOES FROM ONE PLACE TO ANOTHER, NVIDIA IS BEST
1:58:32 POSITIONED FOR THAT. JONATHAN: WE HAVE A SHOW ME
1:58:38 THE GUIDANCE. THE STOCK ONLY UP BY 2.6% ON THE
1:58:42 SCREEN THIS MORNING. HOW QUICKLY CAN WE GET THROUGH
1:58:45 SOME OF THESE OVERHANGS? HOW QUICKLY CAN WE GET THE
1:58:49 CLARITY WE NEED FOR THIS TO DEVELOP BEYOND A SHOW ME STORY
1:58:51 AND WE CAN TRUST THE GUIDANCE? CHRIS: I THINK THAT IS A VERY
1:58:54 GOOD POINT. THAT IS THE REASON WE DID NOT
1:59:00 TAKE UP OUR FISCAL 2028 NUMBERS EVEN THOUGH MANAGEMENT RAISED
1:59:01 THEIR GUIDANCE. WE LOWERED OUR PRICE TARGET.
1:59:06 IT IS ALL IN THE WAY OF CONSERVATISM.
1:59:10 RIGHT NOW, THE MULTIPLE OF STOCK IS TRADING AT ABOUT 10 TIMES THE
1:59:12 FISCAL 2028 NUMBER. IT IS A SINGLE DIGIT NUMBER FOR
1:59:16 2028. INVESTORS, EVEN BEFORE THE
1:59:22 JENSEN ISSUES DID NOT EXPECT VERY MUCH FROM THE STOCK.
1:59:26 THE STOCK WAS TELLING YOU WE, DO NOT BELIEVE WHERE THE STREET
1:59:32 NUMBERS ARE RIGHT NOW.
1:59:36 THE CATALYST IS A NEW CEO. IT IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO RESET
1:59:41 THINGS, RESET THE NARRATIVE, TO TALK ABOUT THINGS INVESTORS ARE
1:59:42 CONCERNED ABOUT. SO LONG AS THE FUNDAMENTAL
1:59:49 THEY WILL BE FINE. BUT CERTAINLY THEY NEED TO RESET
1:59:54 THE NARRATIVE, AND A NEW CEO WILL GIVE YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO
1:59:55 DO THAT. JONATHAN: IS THE NEW CEO AIN'T
1:59:59 CEO OR THE OLD CEO? CHRIS: NVIDIA'S CHAIRMAN WAS ON
2:00:06 THE CALL LAST NIGHT AND VERY CLEAR THEY WERE NOT GOING TO ASK
2:00:07 JENSEN TO COME BACK. I THINK THAT IS SUPPORTIVE
2:00:10 BECAUSE IF YOU ARE TRYING TO RECRUIT A NEW CEO, NO ONE WILL
2:00:16 TALK TO YOU IF SOMEONE IS WAITING IN THE WINGS.
2:00:18 JONATHAN: CHRIS CASO. FROM NEW YORK, YOU ARE WATCHING
2:00:21 BLOOMBERG TV. ♪
2:00:30 JONATHAN: BRAMOW DOWN IN WASHINGTON, D.C., CATCHING UP
2:00:36 WITH JANE FRASER OF CITI LATER THIS AFTERNOON.
2:00:38 DON'T MISS THAT AT 4:00 P.M. EASTERN TIME.
2:00:43 THAT CONVERSATION COMING THIS AFTERNOON ON BLOOMBERG TV.
2:00:46 THERE IS YOUR PROMOTE. LET'S GET TO PRICE ACTION.
2:00:52 EQUITY FUTURES DOING OK, UP BY A QUARTER OF 1% ON THE S&P,
2:00:56 HOLDING ONTO TECH RELATED GAINS ON THE NASDAQ AFTER A FOUR-DAY
2:00:59 SLIDE, 5% SLIDE ON THE NASDAQ 100.
2:01:02 WE ARE HIGHER BY 0.7%. THE RUSSELL SMALL CAPS
2:01:05 UNDERPERFORMING. THE FRONT END OF THE CURVE, TO
2:01:11 YEAR YIELDS ARE HIGHER OFF THE BACK OF HAWKISH FED SPEAK FROM
2:01:16 CHRIS WALLER, HIGHER BY TWO BASIS POINTS THIS MORNING TO
2:01:20 4.83% FOLLOWING A 33 BASIS POINT MOVE ON THE TWO-YEAR LAST WEEK.
2:01:24 THE CASH OPEN 60 MINUTES AWAY. LET'S GET YOU SOME MORNING
2:01:26 MOVERS, SOME SINGLE NAMES. ISABELLE: WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT
2:01:30 NVIDIA BECAUSE IT WAS A FANTASTIC EARNINGS REPORT.
2:01:33 SOLID EARNINGS AND EVEN MORE SOLID OUTLOOK.
2:01:36 THE COMPANY RAISED THEIR GROWTH DATA TO 75% FOR NEXT YEAR.
2:01:39 REMEMBER, YOUR GUEST YESTERDAY WAS TALKING ABOUT 70%, NOW 75%.
2:01:46 YOU COULD HEAR A SIGH OF RELIEF FROM INVESTORS WHO WERE JITTERY
2:01:48 WHEN IT COMES TO THE FRAGILITY OF THE AI TRADE.
2:01:52 NVIDIA SAID ONE THING:
2:01:57 THAT IT CAN SURVIVE WITHOUT JENSEN HUANG AT THE HELM.
2:02:02 HERE ARE THE CLOUD PROVIDERS. ALL HIGHER IN THE PREMARKET BY
2:02:07 AT LEAST 4%. THEIR BUSINESS MODELS RELY
2:02:12 HEAVILY ON HYPERSCALERS SPENDING AGGRESSIVELY.
2:02:15 NVIDIA SAID THE AGREEMENT WITH NEIL CLOUD PROVIDERS HAVE
2:02:17 TOTALED $32 BILLION. THIS IS ANOTHER SIGN OF THE
2:02:21 SUPPORT AND FINANCING NVIDIA IS PROVIDING
2:02:27 NEO-CLOUD PROVIDERS. THIS IS FOR ALL THE GAMERS OUT
2:02:30 THERE, FINALLY. GRAND THEFT AUTO IS OUT
2:02:32 TOMORROW. TAKE SHARES POPPING PREMARKET.
2:02:37 THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE ONE OF THE MOST SUCCESSFUL GAMES OF ALL
2:02:39 TIME. A LOT OF EXCITEMENT BUILDING UP
2:02:42 AND POSITIVE REVIEWS. OUR GAMING REPORTER DESCRIBED IT
2:02:44 AS A MASTERPIECE. JONATHAN: I AM NOT JUDGING
2:02:52 GAMERS, BUT I WILL JUDGE THOSE TAKING THE DAY OFF BECAUSE THEY
2:02:52 ARE PLAYING GRAND THEFT AUTO. NOT DOWN WITH THAT.
2:03:02 THAT IS YOUR LIST OF FED SPEAK INTO THE WEEKEND, WHICH IS
2:03:04 ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS. MICHAEL MCKEE HAS TO TRACK AT
2:03:08 ALL AND JOINS US NOW. GOOD MORNING.
2:03:12 MICHAEL: GOOD MORNING. WHEN THE FED CHAIR KEVIN WARSH
2:03:13 DOES NOT WANT TO TELL YOU WHERE THEY ARE GOING, INVESTORS LOOK
2:03:17 TO OTHER MEMBERS AND OTHER LEADERS OF THE FED FOR A PATH
2:03:19 FORWARD. WE ARE GETTING THAT THIS MORNING
2:03:24 WITH CHRIS WALLER, THE FED GOVERNOR WHO HAD CALLED FOR 50
2:03:25 BASIS POINTS EARLIER IN THE MONTH.
2:03:29 NOW HE IS BACKING THAT UP AGAIN. SPEAKING ON CNBC THIS MORNING,
2:03:34 SAYING INFLATION HAS BEEN ABOVE OUR TARGET FOR FIVE YEARS.
2:03:38 IF YOU WANT TO GET IT DOWN, YOU
2:03:40 HAVE TO TAKE MORE AGGRESSIVE ACTIONS.
2:03:44 JOHN WILLIAMS IS WHO WAS LOOKED TO FOR THE OCTOBER MEETING.
2:03:47 WILLIAMS SAID YESTERDAY, I DON'T THINK THE SITUATION CALLS FOR
2:03:48 DRAMATIC ACTION. WE WILL SEE WHOSE ADJECTIVES ARE
2:03:51 RIGHT. WALLER QUALIFIED WHAT HE IS
2:03:56 TALKING ABOUT, SAYING 25 BASIS POINTS THIS MONTH, 25 BASIS
2:04:00 POINTS IN JANUARY ARE PRETTY MUCH THE SAME THING, BUT WHAT HE
2:04:03 WANTS TO SEE IS A SIGNAL FROM THE FED CHAIR AND THE OTHER
2:04:06 MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE THAT THEY WOULD GO IN JANUARY.
2:04:10 HE SAID, IF WE DO NOT SIGNAL A JANUARY MOVE, MY VIEW IS YOU
2:04:15 HAVE TO DO 50 IN DECEMBER TO PUT IT IN PLACE AND GET IT DONE.
2:04:18 WHERE IS EVERYBODY ELSE AT THE MOMENT?
2:04:20 THEY ARE ALL PRETTY MUCH ON BOARD.
2:04:23 ALMOST ALL FOR A RATE INCREASE. WE DON'T KNOW HOW MANY THEY ARE
2:04:27 GOING TO SUPPORT AT THE MEETING NEXT MONTH.
2:04:35 BUT FOR HAVE SUGGESTED WE NEED. FOUR HAVE NOT SAID ONE WAY OR
2:04:45 ANOTHER, WE NEED TO MOVE UP, BUT NOT HOW MANY TIMES.
2:04:48 BOWMAN SAYING MAYBE WE NEED TO RAISE RATES, MAYBE WE NEED TO DO
2:04:51 IT SLOWLY, AND WE WILL SEE WHAT THE DATA SAY.
2:04:55 OF COURSE, SHE IS THE VICE CHAIR FOR SUPERVISION SO PEOPLE DO NOT
2:04:59 LOOK TO HER FOR REAL CLUES WHERE MONETARY POLICY IS GOING.
2:05:03 HAVE TO MENTION ONE ECONOMIC INDICATOR OUT THIS MORNING.
2:05:07 HOUSING STARTS UP BY 9.9% BUT REVISED DOWN TO -7% IN THE MONTH
2:05:11 OF SEPTEMBER. SO IT KIND OF IS A WASH.
2:05:16 BUILDING PERMITS FELL. OF COURSE, ALL OF THIS MATTERS
2:05:20 BECAUSE HOUSING IS TAKING IT ON THE CHIN FROM THESE RATE
2:05:21 INCREASES. IF THEY GO UP AGAIN, IT WILL BE
2:05:24 EVEN WORSE. JONATHAN: IT MIGHT GO UP EVEN
2:05:25 MORE. CAN WE SIT ON THE WALL OR QUOTE?
2:05:30 THAT DETAIL IS IN PART BECAUSE IT SOUNDS LIKE HE IS CALLING OUT
2:05:32 THE FED CHAIR BECAUSE HE HAS A FEELING HE WILL NOT SIGNAL WHAT
2:05:36 THEY WILL DO AT THE MEETING AFTER THE NEXT ONE.
2:05:39 IF THEY WILL NOT GO 25 OR 50 BECAUSE THEY WILL NOT SIGNAL 25,
2:05:42 HE WILL PUSH FOR EVEN MORE. THIS IS THE ISSUE THE LIKES OF
2:05:47 GOVERNOR CHRIS WALLER STILL HAS WITH THE CHAIRMAN'S APPROACH TO
2:05:50 FORWARD GUIDANCE. HE SEES VALUING GUIDANCE
2:05:57 SIGNALING ANOTHER 25 TO COME AND THIS FED WITH THIS LEADERSHIP,
2:05:59 YOU KNOW IF YOU ARE NOT GETTING THAT COMMITMENT TO THE NEXT
2:06:03 MOVE, WHY NOT PUSH FOR 50? MICHAEL: ANYTHING CAN BE
2:06:05 DISCUSSED. THERE HAVE NOT BEEN OTHERS THAT
2:06:10 SIGNED ON TO 50 AT THIS MEETING, BUT AS YOU KNOW, I HAVE BEEN
2:06:12 TRAVELING AROUND THE COUNTRY THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS TALKING TO FED
2:06:15 BANK PRESIDENTS EVERYWHERE AND THEY ARE UNANIMOUS SAYING THAT
2:06:21 HE CAN DO WHAT HE WANTS BUT WE WILL CONTINUE TALKING, CONTINUE
2:06:24 GIVING PEOPLE OUR OUTLOOK ON THE ECONOMY AND WHERE WE THINK
2:06:25 MONETARY POLICY IS GOING. NOT LIKE THERE WILL BE A
2:06:29 SHORTAGE OF PEOPLE SUGGESTING WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE.
2:06:33 IT IS MORE LIKE YOU HAVE TO AGGREGATE ALL OF THE SPEECHES
2:06:37 AND SEE WHERE THE MAJORITY OF THE OPEN MARKET COMMITTEE IS AT
2:06:40 ANY ONE PARTICULAR TIME. JONATHAN: MICHAEL MCKEE, THANK
2:06:44 YOU. UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES TAKING
2:06:45 PLACE AT THE FEDERAL RESERVE RIGHT NOW.
2:06:49 ATTEMPTING TO TURN DOWN THE NOISE BUT IT IS GETTING NOISIER.
2:06:53 FED CHAIR KEVIN WARSH ISSUING A STARK WARNING OVER THE IMPACT OF
2:06:55 SUPER INTELLIGENCE ON U.S. JOBS. >> SI
2:07:01 COULD DISAPPOINT. EXPECT IT RETURNS COULD TURN
2:07:05 DOWN. EQUITY VALUATIONS COULD FALL,
2:07:09 LEADING TO AN ECONOMIC SLOWDOWN AND A MORE NOTABLE RISE IN
2:07:10 UNEMPLOYMENT. IN TIME, THE ECONOMY WOULD
2:07:16 RECOVER, BUT WITHOUT THE PRODUCTIVITY GAINS.
2:07:22 JONATHAN: THE INCOMING CEO OF MANPOWERGROUP SAYS THE BIGGEST
2:07:24 LABOR MARKET IMPACT OF AI IS SHOWING UP IN THE PEOPLE NEEDED
2:07:29 TO BUILD, OPERATE, AND SUPPORT.
2:07:32 LET US JUST WORK WITH AI. FIRST OF ALL, CONGRATULATIONS ON
2:07:35 THE NEW SEAT. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
2:07:39 JONATHAN: HOW ARE YOU IMPLEMENT THIS TECHNOLOGY?
2:07:44 >> YEAH, SO FOR OUR OWN COMPANY, WE ARE IMPLEMENT AI IN OUR
2:07:45 PROCESSES. THERE IS TECH DEBT AND PROCESS
2:07:51 DEBT, AND A I HOPE TO LOOK AT THE PROCESSES AND AUTOMATE WHAT
2:07:54 SHOULD BE AUTOMATED, WHAT CAN BE AUTOMATED FOR THE BUSINESS, SO
2:07:56 FOR US, WE RUN A HUMAN CAPITAL BUSINESS AND HAVE HUMAN
2:07:59 RECRUITERS. WE ARE LOOKING AT AI HELPING
2:08:02 THEM MAKE BETTER CHOICES ON THE SOURCING OF CANDIDATES.
2:08:04 JONATHAN: DO YOU DO MORE WITH THE STAFF?
2:08:07 WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE? BECKY: IT ENABLES OUR RECRUITERS
2:08:13 TO BE MORE PRODUCTIVE SO IT TAKES BUSY WORK OFF OF THEIR
2:08:15 PLAY SO THEY CAN SPEND TIME WITH OUR CANDIDATES, GETTING TO KNOW
2:08:19 THEM, MAKING SURE OF THE RIGHT MATCH, THE RIGHT PLACEMENT SO IT
2:08:20 FREES UP SOME TIME. WE HAVE NOT SEEN A REPLACE OF
2:08:26 JOBS BUT WE HAVE SEEN IT PROVIDE PRODUCTIVITY.
2:08:28 JONATHAN: WHERE DO YOU THINK IT IS GOING?
2:08:31 WILL THE RECRUITER BE RECRUITING LESS?
2:08:34 BECKY: I THINK THEY WILL BE RECRUITING DIFFERENTLY, NOT
2:08:35 LESS. WE ARE EXPERTS IN AUTOMATION.
2:08:40 WE HAVE SEEN THE CHANGES COME SO AS LONG AS THEY ENABLE
2:08:41 RECRUITERS TO RETOOL, FIND THE RIGHT TALENT IN THE MARKET, WE
2:08:44 WILL BE ABLE TO CONTINUE RECRUITING BUT BE FOCUSED ON THE
2:08:48 SKILL IN DEMAND IN THE MARKET. JONATHAN: HOW MUCH OF A BOOM ARE
2:08:51 WE SEEING? BECKY: FIRST I WOULD SAY THE
2:08:55 WHOLE LANDSCAPE OF AI HAS CHANGED DRAMATICALLY.
2:09:00 THE CONVERSATION HAS BROADENED FROM AI TAKING JOBS TO AI
2:09:01 CHANGING SKILLS. YOU DID NOT HEAR ME SAYING
2:09:04 TAKING SKILLS. YOU HEARD ME SAYING CHANGING
2:09:06 SKILLS. HUGE DEMAND IN DATA CENTERS.
2:09:11 52% INCREASE YEAR TO DATA CENTER HIRING.
2:09:14 THAT IS INTERESTING BECAUSE IT IS CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS,
2:09:18 ENGINEERS, AND IT TRICKLED DOWN TO THE REST OF THE ECONOMY SO
2:09:21 IS GROWING. THINGS LIKE MARKETING, SALES,
2:09:27 ETC., THOSE ARE GROWING PIECES OUT OF DATA CENTERS.
2:09:30 NOT JUST IN THE WALLS BUT GROWING OUTSIDE OF THE WALLS.
2:09:33 THAT WOULD BE THE FIRST THING THE DEFINITION OF AI IS
2:09:34 CHANGING. THE SECOND IS CLIENTS ARE TRYING
2:09:40 TO FIND AI RELATED SKILLS EMBEDDED IN EVERYDAY JOBS.
2:09:44 YOU ASKED ABOUT RECRUITERS. THEIR JOBS ARE CHANGING.
2:09:46 YOU MIGHT OR MIGHT NOT THINK ABOUT THAT.
2:09:49 AI IS BEING ABETTED ACROSS THE ECONOMY.
2:09:52 JONATHAN: DO YOU SEE MOMENTUM INTO 2027 BROADENING?
2:09:55 YOU SEE SOME BREADTH TO THE STORY?
2:10:00 BECKY: WE KNOW THE LABOR MARKET IS RESILIENT.
2:10:01 IT IS NOT MOMENTUM FOR EVERYONE. IT IS MOMENTUM FOR SOME.
2:10:06 IF YOU ARE IN THE IN POCKET DEMAND SKILLS AND JOBS, YOU
2:10:07 THINK THIS LABOR MARKET IS GREAT.
2:10:10 IF NOT, IT CAN FEEL SLOW AND DIFFICULT.
2:10:12 JONATHAN: WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE IN WAGES BETWEEN THE TWO
2:10:15 STORIES? BECKY: SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENT
2:10:21 IF YOU ARE IN ENGINEERING, LOGISTICS, MANUFACTURING, JOBS
2:10:24 ARE IN DEMAND. IF YOU ARE IN OTHER PARTS OF THE
2:10:28 ECONOMY, IF YOU ARE LOOKING FOR YOUR FIRST JOB, IT IS TAKING
2:10:32 ABOUT 27 WEEKS TO FIND A JOB VERSUS 22 PRE-COVID.
2:10:35 JONATHAN: WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE FOR THE FINANCIAL SECTOR?
2:10:38 WE HAVE A LOT OF OUR AUDIENCE RIGHT NOW TRADING AROUND THE
2:10:42 COUNTRY AND THE WORLD. WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE FOR THAT
2:10:43 SECTOR? BECKY: IT IS A CHALLENGED SECTOR
2:10:48 RIGHT NOW DEPENDING ON THE POCKET YOU ARE IN.
2:10:50 SEEING PROFESSIONAL DEMAND HAPPENED BUT NOT IN THE
2:10:52 FINANCIAL SECTOR. THAT IS THE PART THAT IS
2:10:54 CHALLENGED. JONATHAN: WHAT DO YOU THINK
2:10:58 EXPLAINS THAT, THE TECHNOLOGY? BECKY: AS I SAID BEFORE, THE
2:11:02 LABOR MARKET IS ABOUT FEELINGS, EMPLOYER CONFIDENCE, SO IF WE
2:11:04 CANNOT SEE THROUGH WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE ECONOMY AND ITS
2:11:09 EMPLOYERS, THEY DO NOT SPEND IF THEY DO NOT HIRE AT THE RATE
2:11:12 THEY NEED TO FOR THEIR BUSINESS, AND AI IS GIVING CAPACITY TO DO
2:11:14 MORE WITH LESS. THAT IS HAPPENING, BUT WE NEED
2:11:17 SOMETHING TO BRING SOME STABILITY SO EMPLOYERS WILL
2:11:20 REOPEN THE SPIGOTS OF SPENDING. JONATHAN: ALWAYS GOOD TO SEE
2:11:22 YOU. CONGRATS ONCE AGAIN.
2:11:25 WE WILL CATCH UP IN DAVOS NO DOUBT.
2:11:31 THE LATEST ON THIS LABOR MARKET. THE LATEST DATA COMING TOMORROW
2:11:32 MORNING. GET YOU ON A BIT ON NEWS
2:11:36 WORLDWIDE WITH YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
2:11:37 ISABELLE LEE HAS MORE. ISABELLE: SECRETARY OF STATE
2:11:41 MARCO RUBIO LOOKING TO CALM NERVES AFTER A SERIES OF
2:11:42 HIGH-PROFILE TECH OUTAGES. >> WE HAVE REASON TO BELIEVE
2:11:47 THESE EVENTS ARE NOT INTERRELATED.
2:11:49 THESE ARE ALL DISTINCT EVENTS AND NONE OF THEM WERE THE WORK
2:11:52 OF MALIGN ACTORS OR A CYBER CRIMINAL.
2:11:55 ISABELLE: IT FOLLOWS A SERIES OF OUTAGES INVOLVING
2:12:03 THE FAA, JP MORGAN, MICROSOFT THE
2:12:05 LAST FEW DAYS. MARY PELTOLA HAS DEFEATED
2:12:10 INCUMBENT DAN SULLIVAN, GIVING DEMOCRATS A 56-44 SENATE
2:12:15 MAJORITY WHEN THE NEW CONGRESS CONVENES IN JANUARY.
2:12:19 OPENAI RELEASING A
2:12:23 NEW VERSION OF A MODEL. OPENAI SAYS THE NEW MODEL
2:12:29 OUTPERFORMS THE MOST POWERFUL FABLE MODEL FROM ANTHROPIC ON
2:12:33 COST. THAT IS YOUR BLOOMBERG BRIEF.
2:12:36 JONATHAN: THANK YOU. TAKE YOU FOR THE UPDATE AND THIS
2:12:39 MORNING. UP NEXT, WE SET YOU UP FOR THE
2:12:41 DAY AND WEEK AHEAD AND CATCH UP WITH MARK LEVINE AS ANTHROPIC
2:12:47 PREPARES TO PRICE ITS MEGA IPO LATER TODAY.
2:12:50 FROM NEW YORK CITY, YOU ARE WATCHING "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE
2:13:12 >> ONE SHIP IN THE WORLD FUELING AI REVOLUTION, THAT IS NVIDIA,
2:13:14 THAT DOES NOT CHANGE. THE BIG QUESTION WILL BE THE
2:13:22 INVESTIGATIONS, WHAT ROLE IF ANY JENSEN PLAY, AND IF HE IS
2:13:26 CLEARED, COULD HE COME BACK FROM AN ACTIVIST CAMPAIGN?
2:13:29 JONATHAN: COULD HE COME BACK?
2:13:36 DAN RAISING THE QUESTION, THE IDEA OF JENSEN HUANG COMING BACK
2:13:39 IN THE COMING MONTHS. THE QUESTION OF THE BOARD IS IN
2:13:43 THE OTHER DIRECTION. FOLLOWING FOR DAYS OF LOSSES ON
2:13:52 THE NASDAQ, HIGHER BY 0.8%. ENCOURAGED BY A PUMP AND NVIDIA
2:13:55 OFF THE BACK OF THE BEAT AND RAISE.
2:13:58 THE WEEKEND. WINK COMING UP THIS WEEK.
2:14:00 THIS IS YOUR TRADING DIARY. ANTHROPIC PRICING, BEGINS
2:14:15 TRADING IN THE NEXT 24 HOURS. LET'S GET THE LATEST ON PRICING
2:14:18 AND WHERE THINGS ARE GOING. ED LUDLOW HAS MORE FOR US THIS
2:14:19 MORNING. ED: HELLO.
2:14:23 WE ARE JUST REPORTING IN THE LAST FEW MOMENTS THAT ANTHROPIC
2:14:27 IS GUIDING PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS THEY WILL BE PRICING THIS IPO
2:14:33 ABOVE THE MARKETED RANGE $70 TO $78 A SHARE.
2:14:40 825 MILLION SHARES AT THE OFFERING.
2:14:45 YOU ARE LOOKING AT A .4 TRILLION VALUATION.
2:14:51 THE TARGET RACE, $90.4 BILLION, $26 BILLION OF WHICH IN THE
2:14:53 PRIVATE PLACEMENT FORMAT. IT WOULD TAKE IT BEYOND SPACEX.
2:15:00 I HAVE BEEN SPEAKING TO A LOT OF EXISTING INVESTORS AND THOSE
2:15:01 TRYING TO GET AN ALLOCATION IN THIS THING AND THEY BELIEVE THE
2:15:03 BANK IS THAT IT IS OVERSUBSCRIBED.
2:15:11 IN THE HERE AND NOW, THIS IS A FIRST.
2:15:12 THIS IS THE FIRST FRONTIER LAB TO GO PUBLIC.
2:15:16 ONCE YOU GET BEYOND THE MECHANICS OF THEM DOING THE
2:15:18 TRANSACTION THERE IS STILL A LONG WAY TO GO IN EXPLAINING THE
2:15:21 COMPETING BUSINESS MODEL INTERESTS OF SKIERS COMPUTE, HOW
2:15:26 DO YOU BALANCE THE TRAINING RUNS, AND THE INTERNAL RUN
2:15:30 AGAINST MAKING DEMAND FROM INFERENCE?
2:15:33 JONATHAN: WE WILL NOT DEAL WITH THE CONSPIRACY THEORIES BUT WE
2:15:35 CAN TALK ABOUT CONSEQUENCES. IS THERE A CASE TO BE MADE THAT
2:15:39 ANTHROPIC AND THE IPO HAS BENEFITED FROM THE NVIDIA
2:15:40 PROBLEMS? ED: THEY WERE ALREADY THINKING
2:15:46 ABOUT HOW THEY ARE NOT EXPOSED TO ONE SINGLE POINT OF FAILURE
2:15:48 IN THE COMPUTE SUPPLY CHAIN, RIGHT?
2:15:52 NVIDIA WILL PUT 0 BILLION INTO THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT PORTION OF
2:15:53 THIS DEAL. THAT IS REALLY INTERESTING.
2:15:57 BUT THEY ARE ALREADY TRYING TO TAKE THEIR OWN DESTINY INTO
2:15:59 THEIR OWN HANDS. I HAVE BEEN THINKING ABOUT THEY
2:16:04 COME OUT OF THIS WITH
2:16:08 $228 BILLION ON THE BALANCE SHEET.
2:16:12 NEXT YEAR, THEY WILL SPEND $200 BILLION ON DIFFERENT SHIP
2:16:15 PROGRAMS, DIFFERENT FORMATS OF HAVING COMPUTE.
2:16:20 AND WHERE NVIDIA
2:16:23 SITS IN THAT IS INTERESTING. I THINK EVERY REASONABLE
2:16:27 QUESTION THE NEXT 24 HOURS IS, HAS THAT CHANGED SOME WITH
2:16:30 JENSEN HUANG'S DEPARTURE? I TOLD YOU IN THE LAST HOUR
2:16:35 ABOUT COLETTE KRESS AND THE CALL, AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS
2:16:39 SHE HAS THAT RELATIONSHIP WITH ANTHROPIC AS WELL.
2:16:42 IT IS NOT JUST A SINGLE POINT OF CONTACT WITH JENSEN HUANG.
2:16:45 COLETTE INTERACTS WITH THE FRONTIER LABS.
2:16:49 BY THE WAY, IN THIS YEAR, THE FRONTIER LABS ACCOUNT FOR 15% OF
2:16:54 REVENUE SO THERE IS A CLOSE TIE THERE ACROSS THOSE RELATIONS.
2:16:57 JONATHAN: I AM POSING THE QUESTION FROM TWO DIFFERENT
2:16:58 ANGLES. ONE BEING LIQUIDITY FROM SELLING
2:17:03 NVIDIA ALLOCATED TO ANTHROPIC. THE SECOND ONE BEING MAYBE THE
2:17:07 MORE IMPORTANT ONE, THE REGULATORY ASPECT.
2:17:11 REGULATING THIS ENTIRE TECHNOLOGY.
2:17:15 ON THE ONE SIDE WAS JENSEN. ON THE OTHER SIDE WAS DARIO.
2:17:21 IT FEELS LIKE WITH WASHINGTON AT THE DIRECTION OF TRAVEL, IT
2:17:22 LOOKS LIKE DARIO IS WINNING THE ARGUMENT.
2:17:28 ED: DARIO'S CASE AS OUTLINED IN THE ESSAY WAS FRONTIER LABS NEED
2:17:31 THE FREEDOM TO WORK COLLABORATIVELY IN THE WAY
2:17:36 OF AN ANTITRUST WAIVER AT THAT POINT IN TIME.
2:17:39 IN PART BECAUSE HE WAS SHOULDER TO SHOULDER WITH THE PRESIDENT,
2:17:43 HE SAID WE NEED TO KEEP AMERICA AND AMERICAN COMPANIES AHEAD OF
2:17:44 CHINA IN THIS RACE. I DON'T KNOW.
2:17:50 ALL OF THE REPORT SUGGESTS EVEN IF THE BANKERS WERE SENT TO
2:17:52 ANTHROPIC, IS NOW THE TIME? DOES THE MANAGEMENT TEAM WANT TO
2:17:54 DO THIS? TO THESE PEOPLE, THE EVALUATION,
2:18:00 TIMING, THE MARKET OF THE LAST 10 DAYS, THEY HAD THE CONVICTION
2:18:03 TO GO NOW AND THE PUBLIC COMPANY IS THE ONLY MECHANISM TO RAISE
2:18:05 THE CAPITAL OF THE VOLUME THEY NEED, AND THE REGULATORY
2:18:08 OVERSIGHT OF THIS FIELD COMES AFTER THAT.
2:18:12 JONATHAN: A BIG WEEK FOR YOU AND THE "BLOOMBERG TECHNOLOGY" TEAM.
2:18:15 LOOKING FORWARD TO THE COVERAGE. TO BUILD ON THIS CONVERSATION,
2:18:21 MARK LEVINE HAS WRITTEN A LETTER LAST MONTH CALLING FOR ANTHROPIC
2:18:25 TO PAUSE ITS IPO UNTIL AI SAFETY RISKS ARE ADDRESSED.
2:18:27 THEY DID NOT LISTEN. MARK JOINS US THIS MORNING.
2:18:33 MARK: WE ARE NOT DONE FIGHTING YET.
2:18:34 IT IS DISAPPOINTING. IS THIS COGNITIVE DISSONANCE
2:18:38 RIGHT NOW BECAUSE WE HAVE HAD MONTHS OF SERIOUS AI SAFETY
2:18:40 INCIDENTS. WE HAD A WEEK OF DISRUPTIONS.
2:18:45 JONATHAN: YOU ARE LINKING THE TWO?
2:18:47 MARK: UNDOUBTEDLY. WE HAVE A COMPANY THAT
2:18:50 ACKNOWLEDGES THEIR TECHNOLOGY COULD LEAD TO "CATASTROPHIC"
2:18:54 RISKS. AND THEY CALLED THEMSELVES FOR
2:18:58 PACING THE FRONTIER. THAT IS A CONTRADICTION THAT THE
2:19:03 COMPANY IS GOING PUBLIC NOW, RAISING CAPITAL THAT WILL HELP
2:19:04 THEM ACCELERATE THEIR DEVELOPMENT, TAKING ON ALL THE
2:19:07 PRESSURE FOR GROWTH AND PROFITABILITY THAT WILL WEIGH
2:19:11 AGAINST THE SAFETY WORK. WE WILL BE A MAJOR SHAREHOLDER
2:19:16 AS YOU KNOW BECAUSE OF INDEXING, AND I FEEL THEY ARE
2:19:20 ASKING SHAREHOLDERS TO TAKE ON THE RISK WITHOUT ADEQUATE
2:19:23 TRANSPARENCY OR ACCOUNTABILITY. JONATHAN: WHAT DOES INVESTING
2:19:25 LOOK LIKE FOR YOU IN THIS COMPANY?
2:19:30 MARK: CONTINUING TRADITIONS WE HAVE SEEN NOW IN SPACEX AND META
2:19:35 AND NVIDIA REALLY DISEMPOWERS SHAREHOLDERS.
2:19:37 THEY KEEP SO MUCH POWER WITH THE FOUNDERS.
2:19:40 IN THIS CASE WITH THE LONG-TERM BENEFIT TRUST WHICH IS APPOINTED
2:19:42 BY THE FOUNDERS. WE DO NOT HAVE THE NORMAL
2:19:46 AVENUES FOR ACTIVISM. WE HAVE A TRUMP SEC WHICH HAS
2:19:50 BEEN PULLING BACK FROM ITS HISTORIC ROLE OF PLAYING A
2:19:53 NEUTRAL REFEREE BETWEEN SHAREHOLDERS AND MANAGERS.
2:19:56 ACTUALLY, THEY ARE PUSHING THE RULE NOW THAT IF IT PASSES WE
2:20:00 WILL MAKE IT VERY DIFFICULT IF NOT IMPOSSIBLE FOR SHAREHOLDERS
2:20:03 TO PUT RESOLUTIONS FORWARD. DESPITE ALL OF THAT, WE INTEND
2:20:08 TO BE VOCAL AND COMMUNICATE WITH MANAGEMENT AND RALLY WITH
2:20:12 LIKE-MINDED INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AROUND THE COUNTRY AND
2:20:15 PUSH FOR TRANSPARENCY AND GOOD SAFETY PROTOCOLS.
2:20:20 JONATHAN: LET ME SPOIL THE POTENTIAL FOR CONTRADICTION IN
2:20:21 WHAT YOU SAID. ON ONE HAND YOU SAID THEY WILL
2:20:23 TRY TO PLEASE SHAREHOLDERS AND DO THINGS BUT ON THE OTHER HAND
2:20:27 THEY WILL NOT LISTEN TO SHAREHOLDERS BECAUSE THEY HAVE
2:20:28 SO MUCH CONTROL. WHICH ONE IS IT?
2:20:32 MARK: THERE IS A TENSION BETWEEN THE DRIVE FOR SHORT-TERM PROFIT
2:20:34 AND THE NEED TO THINK ABOUT LONG-TERM RISK.
2:20:38 WHAT YOU SEE IN THE IPO IS A FRENZY BECAUSE WE HAVE FOMO THAT
2:20:43 PEOPLE ARE CONCENTRATING ON WHAT IS QUITE CONSIDERABLE POTENTIAL
2:20:47 FOR GROWTH IN THE REVENUE WHICH I SEE AS A VERY IMPORTANT PILLAR
2:20:49 OF THE AMERICAN ECONOMY RIGHT NOW.
2:20:53 WE AS A FRONT HAVE BENEFITED ENORMOUSLY FROM GROWTH IN THE AI
2:20:54 SECTOR. BUT IT IS ALSO OUR JOB REPRESENT
2:20:59 SHAREHOLDERS AND IN MY CASE PUBLIC SERVANTS AND RETIREES IN
2:21:00 NEW YORK CITY TO LOOK AT THE RISK.
2:21:05 THERE IS ABSOLUTELY RISK THAT AI COULD GO ROGUE, THAT IT COULD DO
2:21:11 HARM, THAT IT COULD BE USED BY MOTHERSHIPS ACTORS.
2:21:12 I DON'T THINK ANYONE CAN DEBATE THAT ANYMORE.
2:21:15 WE WANT TO KNOW, WHAT ARE THE PROTOCOLS FOR THIRD-PARTY
2:21:16 VALUATIONS? ARE THEY TRULY INDEPENDENT?
2:21:20 WILL IT BE TRANSPARENCY ABOUT
2:21:26 WHAT THEY REALIZE THAT
2:21:28 WILL BE CONNECTED WITH SHAREHOLDERS?
2:21:31 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE BUSINESS SIDE OF THE HOUSE WANTS TO GO
2:21:33 FORWARD WITH THE NEW MODEL AND THE SAFETY SIDE SAYS YOU NEED TO
2:21:35 WAIT, IT IS NOT SAFE? HOW IS THAT CONFLICT RESOLVED?
2:21:39 I DO THINK WE HAVE AN ANSWER TO THAT.
2:21:41 AS SHAREHOLDERS, WE DESERVE THE INFORMATION.
2:21:44 JONATHAN: I KNOW IT IS EASIER SAID THAN DONE, BUT WHY INDEX?
2:21:47 YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE SHAREHOLDERS.
2:21:48 YOU CAN STOP INDEXING. MARK: WE HAVE A THIRD OF
2:21:52 TRILLION WE HAVE TO DEPLOY IN A DIVERSE WAY.
2:21:55 WE ARE ONE OF THE LARGEST PUBLIC PENSIONS IN AMERICA.
2:21:58 THAT MEANS YOU HAVE TO BE ACROSS THE ENTIRE GLOBAL ECONOMY.
2:22:00 EVERY STRATEGY. BUT PASSIVE PUBLIC MARKET
2:22:06 INDEXING HAS BEEN VERY SUCCESSFUL FOR US.
2:22:10 WE HAVE NOW WELL OVER 00 BILLION IN THAT STRATEGY.
2:22:13 WE TRACK TO THE RUSSELL 3000. THIS IS OWNED BY THE LONDON
2:22:16 STOCK EXCHANGE. WE APPEALED TO THEM DURING THE
2:22:21 SPACEX ROLLOUT TO GIVE IT TIME. THEY DID NOT LISTEN TO US.
2:22:25 WE WERE READ THAT WOULD SET A PRECEDENT, AND IT DID.
2:22:29 IT LOOKS LIKE ANTHROPIC WILL BE BROUGHT INTO THE RUSSELL 3000
2:22:36 IN A MATTER OF WEEKS. NEED TO WATCH FOR SALES BY
2:22:39 INSIDERS. IT WILL HAPPEN.
2:22:43 TO GIVE YOU A SENSE OF WHAT THIS COULD MEAN, WE CURRENTLY OWN 25
2:22:46 MILLION SHARES AT NVIDIA. THAT IS ENTIRELY FROM PASSIVE
2:22:50 PURCHASING THROUGH INDEXING. NVIDIA IS A LARGER COMPANY AND
2:22:54 HAS BEEN PUBLIC FOR LONGER. BY THE WAY, THAT IS WORTH A
2:22:57 LITTLE LESS THAN IT WAS A MONTH AGO BUT STILL ALMOST $4 BILLION.
2:23:02 BUT ANTHROPIC COULD BE ONE DAY AS BIG OR BIGGER THAN NVIDIA AND
2:23:05 WE COULD ON MORE STOCK THERE. THIS IS A MAJOR FACTOR FOR US AT
2:23:11 A TIME WHEN WE ARE ALREADY SO HEAVILY DEPLOYED AND EXPOSED TO
2:23:15 AI IN EVERY ASSET CLASS, PRIVATE EQUITY, PRIVATE CREDIT,
2:23:17 INFRASTRUCTURE, DEVELOPING MARKETS.
2:23:20 AND I HAVE TO SAY THERE IS A CONVERSATION ACROSS EVERY PUBLIC
2:23:23 PENSION FUND IN AMERICA THAT I AM HAVING WITH PEERS RIGHT NOW.
2:23:25 WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT THIS? WE HAVE THE UPSIDE.
2:23:28 THERE IS NO DOUBT ABOUT IT, BUT THERE IS RISK.
2:23:31 THE ANTHROPIC IPO JUST ADDS TO THE STAKES.
2:23:35 JONATHAN: THAT CONVERSATION IS NOT GOING TO WAIT UNTIL NEXT
2:23:36 YEAR. IT IS GOOD TO SEE YOU.
2:23:37 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MARK LEVINE, THE NEW YORK CITY
2:23:40 COMPTROLLER. TOMORROW, WE WILL CATCH UP WITH
2:23:48 NOAH, JAY, MOMEI. WE PRICE A RECORD-BREAKING IPO
2:23:52 POTENTIALLY LATER THIS AFTERNOON.
2:23:54 TOMORROW, WE START TRADING. FROM NEW YORK CITY THIS MORNING,
2:23:56 GOOD MORNING. THIS WAS "BLOOMBERG SURVEILLANCE
2:24:00 ." ♪
Warsh Is Closer to Waller on Fed Policy, Gopinath Says full transcript
0:00 We still have our work, to do to make sure that we bring inflation back down
0:05 to 2% in a timely way and in a sustained manner. I don't think the situation
0:09 calls for, you know, dramatic action. I think what we've been doing over the last past
0:13 few months is working well. We're collecting the data, analyzing it, having the debate, and making
0:18 a decision.
0:19 So here's the latest this morning. The New York Fed president John Williams pushing back on
0:23 a jumbo rate hike as Fed governor Chris Waller is telling US media of officials are
0:27 not signaling a hike in January. A 50 basis point move in December should be on
0:32 the table. The former IMF deputy manager director, Gita Gopinath, joins us now for more. Gita,
0:37 good morning, welcome.
0:38 Thank you for having me on your show.
0:40 It's good to see you. Do you think this is a situation that calls for drastic
0:42 action?
0:44 I think this is a situation where the Fed has to walk the talk, which is,
0:48 you know, has been very clear in all its press conferences to say reminding everybody that
0:54 the Fed is completely in line with hitting the 2% target. The target is 2%. It's
0:59 not two and a half. It's not three. It's 2%, and we're doing everything we can
1:03 to bring inflation down to target. So last time, he said we're on hold because this
1:08 is a data rich environment that's coming up, and the data has basically said that, well,
1:12 inflation is a problem. And so I can see why Waller is pushing for 50 basis
1:19 points, but there's... Clearly, there's disagreement. But there's gonna have to be much more stronger signaling
1:24 in December, not just about any rate hike they do in December, but also going forward.
1:29 Do you think you will get that signal from this Fed chair? He seems reluctant to
1:32 signal anything at all.
1:34 Well, I guess everybody else is doing that now. The... He's out of state to the
1:38 rest
1:38 of the committee.
1:38 Everybody else in the committee is doing that, but, he will need to convey much more
1:44 strongly than he did in the last press conference about, you know, why is it that
1:47 the Fed would move much more slowly than, say, a 50 basis point hike.
1:51 What is it about this backdrop, Peter, this economy that makes it difficult to get inflation
1:55 back to target? And what does walking the walk actually look like? What do have to
1:58 do?
1:59 So we've had three months of inflation now at... You know, if you look at core
2:04 CPI inflation, it's, like, 3.7. So this is three months. It's not a one off thing.
2:09 It's looking like there is a a heating economy. Economic activity has come out strong. So
2:15 the data we've seen so far is coming out strong. I mean, earnings reports are coming
2:19 out strong. Right? So on the one hand, you have the inflation, which is strong. You
2:24 have a very healthy economy in terms of any economic activity indicator. The concern is the
2:29 risk off environment that we're in right now with all the air pockets and the wobbles
2:33 and the outages and all these other aspects. But if we're going to do monetary policy
2:38 making on the assumption, well, let's wait and see for all of these uncertainties to unwind,
2:44 that... You would be behind the curve on that. So given all the facts, you have
2:49 to be credible, and you have to say, well, given what we're seeing in the data
2:52 right now, there is reason to be tougher on monetary policy.
2:55 Well, Waller speaking this morning seems to think that one of the problems this time around
2:59 is the entrenchment of expectations. Him saying that 3% inflation may be the norm, that that's
3:05 what people are currently thinking. Do you think this is about reigning in expectations? And in
3:10 order to do that, you need to
3:11 have a Fed that maybe just doesn't hike but signals what's to come, something again chair
3:16 worse doesn't wanna do. The good news is that it isn't showing up in measures of
3:20 inflation expectations as we're not seeing a drift away from the Fed's target. So I think
3:26 that's good news. But but, indeed, you don't wanna wait too long before that happens. If
3:30 indeed 2% is the number, then staying at 3% for so long is problematic, and you
3:36 have to be credible. And I think, Walsh, even more than Powell, has put a lot
3:41 of emphasis on the inflation target. And so either he delivers on that or that we
3:45 have to reassess how he truly believes about this inflation. I mean, I've known him, so
3:49 I know that he is a hawk, and he does believe in the inflation, you know,
3:54 keeping... Meeting the inflation target. So it is... It would be surprising if he didn't say
3:59 much more close... Meet... Kind of closer to Waller than to, Williams. You think that's
4:04 where he is, that he is more aligned with what Waller is saying currently that maybe
4:08 he himself might back a 50 basis point hike as well?
4:11 Based on everything I know about him and based on the data that's come in, that
4:15 would be what I... That... Where I think he is, which is closer to Waller than
4:20 Williams. But we'll see what he says.
4:23 We'll see what we get in the coming weeks or so. I want your assessment on
4:26 the economy. How vigilant should they be about the prospect of this inflation spilling into the
4:30 labor market? Because labor market tightness hasn't been a big theme of the inflation story over
4:34 the last couple of years. Do you think it could be Yeah. For next year?
4:37 I think what we have to remember that the labor market was not a big part
4:40 of the story for the last big inflation spike that we had. So when when we
4:45 had the pandemic and we had all the supply chain disruptions, you know, those of us
4:49 including me, we were looking at the labor market and we were saying, well, we don't
4:52 really see pressure in the labor market. And then it came from everything else. It came
4:57 from the supply chain pressures. So there's the similar situation we're in right now where the
5:02 inflation is coming from the supply chain pressures, including the energy prices, residual effects of the
5:07 tariffs. Whether that passes through into the rest of the economy is a function of how
5:12 strong demand is in the rest of the economy. And at this point, we do have
5:16 the investment boom. We do have consumer spending that's still holding up. You know, people are
5:21 dipping into their savings. So, no. You could always wish for everything to go in the
5:26 right direction and everything to automatically unwind, which is always... You know, as a policymaker, you
5:31 don't want to be raising rates too much.
5:33 Are you worried
5:33 it's going harder?
5:34 Are you worried it's going in the wrong direction?
5:36 I think I'm worrying that we are getting to a point where we are, you know,
5:42 trying to hope for the best as opposed to doing what needs to be done in
5:46 terms of tackling inflation.
5:48 Help me imagine what this could look like next year. What do you think it could
5:51 look like in '27?
5:53 Firstly, there's ton of uncertainty. You know that I also have the view that we could
5:57 have a serious correction in markets, and then we would have a... Be having a completely
6:02 different conversation with interest rates having to be brought down very rapidly. But I think given
6:07 the current conjunction that we're in, you have to signal strongly that we're on the path
6:12 to raising inflation. I mean, I know the market's at another 80 basis points between now
6:16 and the end of twenty twenty seven. And, you know, that... Maybe that's what's needed.
6:22 Guy, it's good to see you. As always, thanks for being here. Thank you very much.
6:25 Guy Gopenhaus there, the former IMF deputy managing director. There's a big gap when we talked
6:28 about that gap between the policy rate and two is the front end of the curve.
6:32 Listening to Guy, it sounds like that gap might close by the policy rate coming up
6:35 to where the market is at the moment.
6:36 Right. And, again, maybe it needs to come up to that point to the point that
6:39 Waller is making, that Guido is making, that still you have this inflation that is above
6:43 target. It's been a problem for the past three months. This is a Fed that needs
6:47 to walk the walk.
6:47 There is a fight on that board right now, isn't there? There really is. I mean,
6:51 governor Wallace pulling no punches. Speeches like the one in the last week, comments like this
6:55 this morning.
6:56 Again, it's not even just the fact that he's calling for jumbo rate hikes. It's that
7:01 he's giving a specific prescription, saying if CPI comes in this way, we need to do
7:06 50 basis points. If we don't signal this, then we need to do 50 basis points.
7:10 It's it's it's very, very specific and is forward guidance.
Tech Outages and Failures Rattle the Nerves of Americans full transcript
0:00 Everything we have reason to believe, tells us that these events are not interrelated. These were
0:04 all distinct events and that none of them were the work of a malign actor or
0:08 a cybercriminal.
0:10 And that was secretary of state Marco Rubio speaking yesterday, seeking to ease concerns after a
0:14 string of major tech outages. And happening now on Capitol Hill, a house committee is holding
0:19 a hearing on worldwide threats to the homeland. For more on the recent outages, we're joined
0:23 by Michael Shepherd, Bloomberg's senior editor for technology and strategic industries. Mike, so many disruptions in
0:29 such a short period of time. At what point do we start treating this as something
0:33 connected rather than just isolated incidents?
0:36 Well, it's a great question, and it's one that Marco Rubio really tried to address in
0:41 his remarks from Asia where he's traveling with president Donald Trump. Look. He says this is
0:46 really not the work of cyber attackers. It is not anything coordinated. And in fact, we
0:51 also heard from the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, Mark Warner. He said that,
0:58 look. Right now, AI may be playing a role, but not in the way that you
1:01 think, Isabelle. In fact, companies may be using AI tools to sniff out vulnerabilities in their
1:07 networks and try to quickly patch them. We've talked to other experts too who said that
1:12 some of the rush to put these patches in place in old systems may not be
1:17 working, and some of the systems may not be able to take and absorb some of
1:21 the changes that are being required because AI has found gaps in network security. But still,
1:29 it is not assuaging the public much. We have seen over the past week a surge
1:34 in panic buying of everything from water to nonperishable goods to batteries, retailers like Costco, and
1:41 the discount retailer even said over the weekend that, sales of their, high end generators, were
1:48 pretty much tapped out as of Sunday.
1:50 Yeah. Costco got a... Got an upgrade by one sell side analyst because of all the
1:54 panic buying. It's been remarkable, and you would be forgiven for people again who have this
1:59 idea. We we actually had someone tell us as as well, Shep, that basically so many
2:03 patches are happening at the same time because of the advancements in technology. Homeland security secretary
2:08 Mark Wayne Mullen, though, is speaking, in front, as Isabelle mentioned, a committee in front of
2:13 congress saying that basically adversaries are targeting The US infrastructure points to Iran, points to North
2:21 Korea. Again, didn't go so far as to say that these are the reasons for the
2:24 averages we've had. Again, to your point, the government has been in pains to say that
2:28 that is not what it is. But how vulnerable are we to cybercriminals, bad state actors
2:34 trying to create more issues among our infrastructure?
2:39 Well, this is the fear and loathing, Dani, that the artificial intelligence era has brought when
2:44 it comes to cybersecurity. The idea that, cybercriminals, state sponsored hackers could use sophisticated AI tools
2:52 to wreak havoc across critical infrastructure, that's a nightmare fuel for a lot of people, especially
2:57 in the IT sector, but for the public too. And it is something that the government
3:01 has previously acknowledged and warned about. Going back to April, the administration was warning, that Iran
3:08 could be targeting critical infrastructure, including water utilities. And in fact, they have attributed, cyber attacks
3:15 on Minnesota's waterworks to Iran, and France also has more recently attributed those refrigerator system hacks
3:23 to Iran as well. So we do see this, combination of cyber criminals and hostile actors
3:29 potentially seizing on this technology to, to, wreak havoc, to cause trouble, and it's really left
3:37 government in in the difficult position of having to scramble to respond, to all of these
3:43 potential threats, which can pop up out of nowhere and target, seemingly random things such as
3:50 refrigeration or water facilities.
3:52 Hey, Shep. Thank you so much for joining us. That is Bloomberg's Michael Shepard in Washington
3:57 DC.
Nvidia's CEO Issues May Only Be the Tip of the Iceberg, Great Hill's Hayes Says full transcript
0:00 I guess for you as an investor, what do you wanna see with regards to, I
0:06 guess, the replacement of India... Of Jensen Huang, or do you actually want Jensen Huang to
0:11 come back?
0:12 Well, I think it's gonna be very difficult, if not impossible, for Jensen Wong to come
0:16 back. He lied to the board. There... He's gonna be an ongoing investigations. There's a new
0:21 SEC investigation. I will say the key number that wasn't touched on that we were focused
0:27 on was free cash flow conversion, which had really dipped last quarter to 36%. It it
0:34 came in around 66, 67% for this quarter, so that's a move in the right direction.
0:39 The one thing I would keep in mind is the inventory build a little bit on
0:45 the inventory and the days of customer outstanding moved from 60 to 64 or sixty five...
0:52 Sixty four days from 60 last quarter and from forty five days the previous quarter. So
0:57 the time that the customers are taking to pay is going up. Now from an investor
1:01 standpoint, first off, we don't own the stock here. Yeah. I think the, the real issue
1:07 is going to have a... An outsider come in with a pristine reputation to edify all
1:16 of these financing commitments because up to 25% of their revenues next year are companies that
1:21 either vendor finance or balance sheet backstop. That's a huge portion of revenues as well as
1:28 the big China rerouting question, which could be... We've seen estimates from, you know, 10% as
1:33 high as 20%, and there was a new article in the Feet just before I came
1:37 on. So you have 40% of revenues that are kind of unclear on the path forward.
1:43 Now they did say in this press release, the road map is on track.
1:47 Yeah.
1:47 So that implies they're gonna continue with the back stops and the vendor financing.
1:51 But I am curious. I I mean I mean, you sold out of this, and I
1:53 am curious about the idea
1:54 of No. No. No. We know... We did
1:56 not We love this. Yeah. What what what makes you an investor again? And start with
1:59 those financing arrangements because any new CEO... Permanent CEO that comes in, if they're not already
2:04 doing it right now, is gonna have to start evaluating those finance commitments. And I'm curious,
2:08 where do you start? Do you start off balance sheet? Do you start with a a
2:11 neo clouds? I mean, what is the first thing that as an investor, you would want
2:15 them to look at and then publicly articulate some sort of sense of what actually is
2:21 there?
2:23 Well, the big thing is the type of person who would be qualified to steward NVIDIA
2:28 is not going to take the job until they have certainty, of what they're getting into
2:33 specifically before putting their reputation on the line. So I think this process is gonna take
2:37 a little bit longer than people expect. There's gonna be an information vacuum in the meantime.
2:42 They're gonna try to edify, Colette Crest in the meantime and and make everyone feel confident
2:47 that she can steward the ship for the next three. It may take as much as
2:52 four to six months to find a new CEO by the time they vet them, by
2:56 the time they go through all the financing, by the time they agree to do it.
2:59 So that's why it's in limbo. Now the other big thing is I thought the buyback
3:03 was slightly light, 28,100,000,000. They did upsize the buyback going forward, and I think that's kinda
3:09 gonna be the salvation for the stock as we come out of this blackout period. They
3:13 can go to work in the market and kinda stabilize the stock while we're in this
3:18 information vacuum. That said, you have to keep in mind, you saw the 13 f's yesterday,
3:24 Romaine. Right. A lot of funds jumped in on this towards the top in q three
3:28 after you had that huge bounce after situational awareness was cleared out at the end of
3:33 August. And a lot of those folks that got flushed in the month of October are
3:38 probably gonna be using any bounce and any strength and any buyback liquidity to actually get
3:44 liquidity of their own moving forward. So I think we're set up for a short term
3:48 technical bounce. I think in the intermediate term, it's stand aside until we have some more
3:53 leadership clarity. That said, the numbers today, are confidence inspiring that they were able to deliver
4:00 it. They were able to guide strong. Yes. The gross margins for next quarter are gonna
4:04 be weaker on the Vera build, but that was already telegraphed.
4:07 Let's say the thing that after forty four minutes in the hour and twenty four minutes
4:11 after the earnings, we've not said. That just before those earnings hit a matter of hours,
4:16 Jensen Huang issued a statement saying he'd be willing to come back as CEO if the
4:21 board decided it was in the best interest of shareholders, employees, and of America. How much
4:27 pressure does that put on Colette Crest and this company to answer that question on the
4:33 earnings?
4:33 Well, look. I... I'd be willing to play for the New York Knicks if if James
4:38 Dolan would have me on the team. The the fact of the matter is, I think
4:41 that door has closed for the time being, and it would take an awful lot to
4:45 walk that back. I mean, in any other company, if the CEO had taken those actions
4:50 not once but twice and then lied about it, they would not be welcomed back. Now
4:54 you could say it's a national security issue. You could have some policymakers get involved, maybe
4:59 it could be... Push it across the line. But I I think at this stage, where
5:03 there's smoke, there's fire. And we we may only be at the tip of the iceberg
5:08 of what we know and what we don't know about what took place, during that leadership
5:12 period.